Speaker 1en
Good morning, colleagues. Please take your seats; it's 9:30 and we can start in time. So, welcome everyone. We can start with the agenda: we have a very lively commission committee today, so we have to also take into account the time. The first item is the adoption of the agenda. If there are no comments, the agenda can be adopted. So we go immediately to the item 2. First, some announcement: as usual, today's meeting is web-streamed. Interpretation will be available in 23 languages. Now we go on with the exchange of views with Matschild Wurthofer, Deputy Director General Directorate General for Energy. European Commission on Commission delegated act as regards the establishment of a common union rating scheme for data centers. And I would like to welcome Ms. Matschild Wurthofer. I hope to, okay, the good pronunciation for the surname. So, Deputy Director General, as I said, to this exchange of views. Thank you very much. For accepting our invitation. The commission proposed a common rating scheme for data centers on 21 September 2026, which aims to make the energy and water use of data centers more transparent in the form of a delegated act. That is currently under scrutiny in the Parliament. The deadline for adopting an objection to this delegated act is during the January 2027 plenary session. Now, we have a 40 minutes for this exchange of views. After the opening remarks of our guest, we start with the first round of coordinators or their representative two minutes two minutes each, and continue with catch the eye and catch the eye will take one minute each. I invite all members who want to take the floor to put their nameplates vertically in their holders. Time permitting, I will allow members who want to ask a follow-up questions to do so. So please indicate that to me. I wanted to remind everyone, including our guest, but we have at the beginning, at the very beginning of the day, so to please stick to the allotted time. And now I invite I invite Ms. Wurthofer to take the floor for 10 minutes for her
opening statements. Please the floor is yours.
Speaker 2en
Thank you, Madam Chair, Madam Donna San. Dear members of the European Parliament, it's a pleasure to be here. Thank you very much for inviting me here to present what we call the data center energy efficiency package, which the commission adopted on the 21st of September, and in particular the delegated regulation which establishes a common union rating scheme for data center. My aim today is not to discuss or from DGNR commission side pro and cons for data centers, but it's really about energy and data center sustainability, criterias for data centers, but also we see a lot of benefits in digitalization in the transformation of our clean energy system, and AI has also in the energy sector a number of opportunities. When it comes, for examples, to smart grids, demand side flexibility, bi-directional charging of electric vehicles, or just to shift consumption to cheaper hours to digitalization and AI in the energy sector go hand in hand with affordability, competitiveness, security of supply, and decarbonization. Still, there are also challenges what we see apart from all the benefits. First, it's about energy consumption. We know that according to recent estimates, data centers account for around 2.5 to 3 percent of our total electricity demand in the EU. That varies among our EU member states. For example, Ireland, the consumption is up to 20 percent of the electricity in the country. In others, it's well below 3 percent. We have a few hubs, a few cities where data centers are mostly located, but of course the scenario also from IEA is that data centers will grow, also post-2030, and energy consumption will grow accordingly. Second challenge is that data centers can create grid congestion in areas where data centers tend to cluster. They can strain energy and water resources, and also there is a risk that new data centers can drive up energy prices and that, as I said, is our number one aim to look at affordability and energy prices. That's why we think that digital growth and high sustainable standards must go together
and most of the data centers capacity that will be on the ground in the next 20 years will be designed and constructed in the next few years. And that's why it's important to act now. And that's why we took action in September. We had the proposal on cloud and AI development act, the CADA, which is has the objective to triple data centers by 2035 to match needs. But as I said, we are committed that data centers in the EU are sustainable by promoting transparency and best available technologies and by ensuring that data centers contribute to the clean energy transition. We came out with a strategic roadmap for digitalization in energy, some time ago, and action number one is to look at the sustainable integration of data center in the system. We have chosen an approach which is practical and cooperative. We want to identify solutions and best practices from across Europe. And then bring them together as a set of voluntary commitments. In that sense, we are preparing in close cooperation with member states authorities data centers operators, grid operators, and all energy stakeholders and EU model for tripartite agreements on the integration of data centers. We hope to be ready by the end of the year. And then it's a voluntary model that can be piloted in member states and regions adapted to national circumstances and translated into local agreements signed by regional and local partners. So a blueprint on integration of data centers. But we will go step by step. So in 2024, we introduced the European database on data centers and a reporting scheme at the time to collect information and key performance indicators on the sustainability of data centers. As I said, in September this year, we adopted the data center energy efficiency package, which has a report to the European Parliament and Council it has the delegated regulation establishing a common union rating scheme for data centers. That complements the reporting scheme. And as a third element, we launched a public consultation for possible minimum performance standards
for data centers in the EU. And that would apply to new or retrofitted data centers. The open consultation is running until the 12th of December. So we invite all stakeholders to take part. So the next step, if stakeholders want it, would be MEPs minimum energy performance standard. But today we are discussion the delegated regulation which is in fact that is our package from September and the delegated regulation is in fact a label that will be generated automatically for all data centers which are reporting to the database. That is how this label would look like or is looking like. For data centers, that means zero added burden to data centers operators and public administration because it will be automatically for all data centers in the database. All labels will be publicly available as part of the existing dashboard. The main aim is to increase transparency. About the use of energy for data centers and inform better policymaking and certainly to support more sustainable procurement of digital assets and services. It can then allow comparison between data centers in a region and promote new designs or appropriate efficiency interventions. The origin is the EED, the energy efficiency directive. But it covers three dimension in our view important dimension of sustainability of data centers. You can see on the right it's the power usage effectiveness. So energy efficiency. Water use effectiveness which is equally important because data center use a lot of water. And sourcing of low emission energy sources which you can see on the left sourcing of energy renewables nuclear and others. So that are the key elements of the label it needs to be as simple as possible that what we learned from other labels for products but it gives more transparency for that. And with that I would like to conclude my first intervention thank you very much for listening we think it's an important step for transparency and sustainability as I said in the beginning of course the whole area of data centers cover many more aspects but in the energy sector this is where we are looking for looking at benefits and
challenges. Thank you very much.
Speaker 1en
Thank you for your clear explanation and now I give the floor for the EPP to Ms. Aura Salla.
Aura SallaPPEen
Thank you Chair.
Speaker 1en
Yeah please.
Speaker 2en
And thank you Deputy Director General first a general note we must stop facilitating data centers for American and Chinese companies we must reserve our electricity and natural resources for our own companies in Europe and we must start choosing European cloud as quickly and as widely as possible there is no questions we need data centers that's for Europe's AI development but we need to make sure we enable them for European users with clear rules the rules must be fair and technology neutral the labels must provide clear and reliable information that businesses public authorities and citizens can use to understand and compare the actual environmental performance of data centers here I want to acknowledge the constructive cooperation between Parliament and Commission many of the concerns we raised in spring 2026 have been addressed in adopted delegated act which we welcome of course however I would like to raise a question about how we measure and communicate sustainability. There is an important difference between a data center what the data center is ready to do and what it actually delivers I understand the need for simple rating system and that operators should not be penalized for circumstances beyond their control such as absence of a district heating networks but we should also make sure that those delivering real environmental benefits receive a proper recognition so I have three questions first why does the rating scheme focus on technical readiness rather than measuring the actual amount of waste heat reused and grid flexibility services delivered second how will the Commission ensure that these publicly available labels clearly distinguish between technical readiness and actual performance so that businesses authorities and the wider public can make informed comparisons and third will the Commission commit to addressing these gaps in the 2028 review so that the rating scheme better reflects what data centers actually deliver while taking into account circumstances beyond operators control I believe that this would
make the rating scheme more meaningful encourage genuine sustainability and support investments in Europe's data center infrastructure thank you.
Speaker 1en
Thank you and now for SND Mr. Niels Fugs Lang.
Speaker 3en
Thank you thank you so much Chair and thank you Mechthild for presenting this this proposal for a label I think it's it's a good step and and indeed indeed it as you as you mentioned it it comes from the energy efficiency directive and you were there for our clock in the morning at the negotiations when we when we adopted this when I negotiated on behalf of the Parliament so I think this this is really useful indeed to make sure that that we have more sustainable data centers I have to say I agree quite a lot with with the words from my colleague from the EPP that we need to reserve the the capacity for European data centers I don't see our interest in spending all our energy and water on data center centers from Microsoft or Apple or Google and other big tech companies from the US but at the same time we of course need data centers because we need to be independent we we cannot store all our data on foreign data centers we need our own capacity here in the European Union and so I think this this labeling will will help us have some European sustainable data centers I have two questions the one one concerns waste heat so the label only indicates whether a data center is ready to use waste heat is it does not quantify how much waste heat a data center actually reuses and so you know how how what what's your thoughts on this I think that could be improved and I know that every third year there will be a revision a chance to reform the label and is this something you will watch I think you should watch it in terms of looking at how can we how can we improve the the labeling the the waste heat because we know that data centers actually today they could they could cover you know the waste heat from data centers is equivalent to the demand of 4 million European households in Denmark we have a lot of district heating but only four out of our 54 data centers use the waste heat so I think that can be improved the other thing I would like to ask you is about flexibility you also have in the label a question on whether the data center can be flexible and
thus reduce electricity demand and peak hours but you don't measure whether it actually does use that potential and so could that be something you would consider you know thinking about how we can improve the label in the coming years thank you.
Speaker 1en
Thank you on behalf of ECR Diego Solier. Okay I'm going to speak in Spanish sorry. Thank you gracias como ponente principal de cada la verdad es que el esta iniciativa me parece una iniciativa que puede ser acertada pero me gustaría hacer unas cuantas reflexiones primero si esta iniciativa tiene en cuenta los diferentes tipos de data centers quiero decir no es lo mismo un data center de colocation que un data center de cloud que un data center de IA entonces son diferentes tipos de data center con diferentes requerimientos de tanto energéticos como de refrigeración segundo lo que comentaba el compañero de de Sandí me parece todo un acierto siempre y cuando un data center esté cerca de las zonas donde puede aportar ese ese calor hacia hacia digamos las zonas civiles que pueden ayudar me parece una cosa perfecta pero hay momentos en que la física no acompaña y estos data centers están ubicados en situaciones o en regiones que no están próximas a a centros urbanos entonces esa ese calor no puede llegar nunca a un centro urbano para para favorecerlo entonces obviamente siempre y cuando ese data center pueda estar cerca de una zona urbana y pueda aportar es un beneficio más que debe que debe de dar a la sociedad por estar instalado en esa en esa zona lo que yo quería también comentar y es una una reflexión y una casi pregunta es tiene en cuenta esta clasificación la zona geográfica no es lo mismo un data center en la región de en cualquier región de Iberia de España o de Europa del sur de Europa que un data center en el norte de Europa por qué porque obviamente sistemas de refrigeración en el sur de Europa son o tienen más consumen más energía y el sistema de refrigeraciones es diferente al norte de Europa por qué Irlanda por ejemplo es un gran hub de data centers por sus condiciones meteorológicas también que ayudan aparte de por otras cosas entonces es importante esa diferenciación o tener en cuenta esa situación geográfica de donde los data centers van a van a estar ubicados me gustaría también y quiero terminar ya porque se me va el tiempo es pedir que DG
Ener trabaje conjuntamente con DG Connect en este tipo de de normativas porque es importante que haya esa comunicación en la comisión y que esta este esta propuesta no de alguna forma menoscabe lo que se está trabajando ahora mismo en en el cloud area development a través de las zonas de aceleración porque creemos que es un mecanismo muy potente para potenciar el desarrollo de data centers y no nos gustaría que de alguna forma estas disposiciones se alguna forma se se vean Impactadas por esta buena creo opción de DG Ener. Thank you Diego.
Speaker 1fr
Now for Renew, Mr Christophe Grudler.
Christophe GrudlerRenewfr
Thank you, Madam President, I will speak in French. Thank you, Madam Deputy Director-General, for your presentation. I very clearly want to commend the evolution in this final version of the Alliance Act; they are truly heading in the right direction. We have come a long way, if I may say so, because in the first version that you circulated, nuclear energy was quite simply excluded, which was somewhat of a paradox at a time when Ursula von der Leyen herself, at the World Nuclear Exhibition near Paris, had said that she had made a strategic error in blocking nuclear energy everywhere and that she had now understood, and only a few days later a new version emerged. version of the delegated act in which, in fact, nuclear was actually prohibited. So, in fact, a data centre powered by nuclear had no recognition, whereas a data centre powered by natural gas with a small wind power contract alongside it was recognised and valued. This was truly a strategic error, a climate and industrial nonsense. Together with several colleagues from different groups, we alerted the President and the DGNR, and the text presented today is an important advance and a victory for this cross-party mobilisation. The issue is a strategic one because Europe wants to triple its data centre capacities within seven years; there will be no European digital sovereignty or artificial intelligence without abundant, decarbonised and controllable energy. I therefore have two very brief questions. Firstly, can you guarantee that, as from summer 2027, the use of nuclear energy can be included in this label with the same visibility as renewable energies? And secondly, the additionality rule as it was set out in the first version raised serious concerns. Can you confirm that the 10-year rule will not penalise existing production capacities, I am thinking in particular of nuclear power plants and dams? hydroelectric dams built several decades ago that still produce decarbonised electricity
will the installations really be able to be valued under this label? Thank you. Thank you.
Speaker 1en
And now we go on with Greens Miss Utah Paulus.
Jutta PaulusVerts/ALEen
Thank you very much chair and thank you Mechteld for being here I was also with Niels in the same room when we negotiated the EED of course and I must say I'm quite I find it very reassuring that parliament is quite united on the need to end the dependency on foreign operators and also on reserving precious space and grid capacity for European operators I have a question which on the very first question is on the reporting because we know that about 30% of the operators did do the reporting which they were obliged to so my question is what kind of consequences will the commission draw from this how will we well coax the remaining 70% into actually giving their data I think the name data center efficiency package including nuclear is kind of an oxymoron because nuclear is of course never efficient this is thermodynamics I know that you Mr. Grudler would like to change that but unfortunately physical laws cannot be changed but my question is rather how would nuclear certificates from legacy plants like Katamam like you know all the plants that are running already how would those certificates actually help the transition because nothing would have to be changed no new capacity would have to be built so I for me it's not really clear what's the the sense behind that label on the waste heat ready thing I have the same impression as Ms. Salah and Mr. Fuglesang and Mr. Sollier the whole point is that the operator should choose a location where the heat can be used instead of choosing the location and then saying oh I'm sorry no use for my heat here but I do agree with your question how the differentiation between for example hyperscalers and co-locators could be made is the commission thinking about a type related benchmark here or what are the ideas thank you.
Speaker 1en
Thank you and now for the left Mr. Per Clausen.
Per ClausenThe Leften
Thank you very much and I will speak in Danish.
Per ClausenThe Leftda
I would like to start by thanking the Deputy Director for being here today so that we can have this important discussion. It is true that the EU largely lacks transparent sustainability assessments that can be compared across the EU's Member States. This is an overview we should have had long before large American data centres began to overwhelm our countries. I also believe we strongly need to have some common minimum standards. as it stands now, EU citizens are paying the price for American tech oligarchs exploiting our shared resources. Citizens are seeing how noisy data centres are popping up next to their homes, which once stood in scenic surroundings but are now suddenly located in an industrial area with noise pollution in Finland. We have seen how badly it can go wrong when Google illegally felled 250,000 trees and destroyed precious forest and biodiversity, but also the European the water supply warns that data centres risk negatively affecting water resources, and we have also seen how working conditions at a number of these data centres, both during construction and subsequently during operation, are deeply problematic, and they threaten the green transition. So there is no doubt that we need an overview of the consequences of data centres in the EU, but we also quite simply need restrictions on their over-exploitation of our resources. And even though the Commission plans to present minimum standards in mid-2027, it is still then many US-owned data centres could reach Europe before then, and the consequences could become unmanageable, so my question is essentially what the Commission plans to do in the meantime to counteract the environmental and climate-related consequences of the new data centres, and isn’t it here that having a temporary halt could be a model for ensuring that we actually get European data centres – European-owned and -controlled data centres in the future.
Speaker 1en
Thank you now we have ended the turn of the colleague and now I give back the floor to the to the commission please. For your answers.
Speaker 3en
Yeah so first of all many thanks and I can see indeed that the parliament has a lot of support to our initiative to look at data center from a sustainable ET aspect and definitely include energy efficiency include water efficiency and clean energy resources so in that sense I think we we are on the right way and thank you very much for your support coming back to to the questions now. Waste heat is of course a very important element and we should use as much as possible and where available waste heat that is definitely part of our energy policy but the label will only provide information about data center which are ready to offer waste heat to any potential offtaker and the actual use or reuse of waste heat has not been included not to penalize data centers who have not that opportunity it's as simple as such so in some occasions you have the opportunity then of course we very much welcome it but we shouldn't penalize the data center as such when they are no possibility for waste heat or any other sourcing so that's why we have established a neutral approach if I may say so whatever it's available at the location we put it in the label if it's not unfortunately it's not the fault of the data center of course our general energy policy approach is to use as much waste heat as possible that is in our papers accelerate EU and others but not to penalize that was a little bit the question I I got it and another aspect here is I mentioned that we will work with all the stakeholders member states data centers providers on a kind of tripartite contract and we'll have kind of models by the end of the year best practice and that will then be included in the review we are planning for 2028 which is already part of our proposal so if we have in the next two years more evidence that this is possible in one way or the other we are very happy that was the third question from the member of parliament to include that in the review and then improve eventually what we are. And I think Niels you started very well the basis is the energy efficiency directive which as
rapporteur with your turn others you you negotiated and that's why the starting point and also to come to Mr. Krügler was energy efficiency it's part of our obligation on energy efficiency that was the driving force we are technology neutral we wanted the energy efficiency but with our work in the last two years with the reports the database we were aware that water is an issue as you know and that's why we included water but also we included nuclear as technology neutral renewables and nuclear as clean energy resources this is now part of our label there is no whatever intention it was the basis energy efficiency and the last we started with renewables but we are very happy to include all low carbon energy sources and we start with renewables and nuclear as you clearly can see and there is a category non-specified sources for now maybe in two years we will be more specific but there's also a balance to be made between being clear and easy to read and then not overburdened but it's clearly the basis is the energy efficiency directive but we evolved and that was welcomed as I understood also from the parliament to have these three main sustainable criteria the clean energy resourcing which is covered here I think waste heat I covered flexibility is a bit the same of course we want data center to contribute to demand side flexibility as well as much as they can but it's also not to penalize those who cannot do it but that might be also something we will dig more into it in two years when we review the label I think we want more flexibility certainly it's also a key policy objective which we follow in energy and it's a bit the same reasoning with waste heat we want it but we don't want to penalize data centers who have not yet the opportunity then we got a question from the Spanish MEP about where we are when the location and climate variation and their impact on energy and water consumption our main aim is to increase transparency so the data center is assessed based on their objective
on energy and water consumption and clean energy resources that seems to us the most straightforward approach and that can make different assessment and allow for comparison but to add we have also in the label the obligation or an accompanying document which is part of our delegated act to provide explanations and a methodology to assess the potential impact of climate on energy and water consumption which is called PUE and WUE if someone wants to compare data centers across Europe so there is this possibility and this obligation in the accompanying document to assess also where the location is and what is the potential impact of climate on energy water consumption which might be different in Spain and Finland in Poland or in other parts so there is a hook to the the location via via that I think. I replied to Mr. Krügler on nuclear merci beaucoup and we won't change on the question of asset age condition the guarantees of origins and the PPAs need to relate to generation asset that have been commissioned or that have undergone substantial refurbishment extending their operative life not more than 10 years prior to the reporting year that's also part to reply to Mr. Krügler to Jutta Paulus thank you very much I think I replied a little bit already the origin and also the reporting obligation it's it's part of the member states market surveillance so member states need to act it's a market instrument so we really want to push member states to act via the market surveillance institutions I think the other elements which were touched upon location working conditions are important but this label is really mainly about sustainability as I said in the beginning there are other criteria for the location of data centers but this captured the energy resourcing and working condition is of course of the bigger picture and it's our proposal of the label is part of this CADA of this cloud and AI package which we as the commission provided which is a bit broader about data sovereignty and other aspects but maybe I didn't reply fully yeah the question was rather that what Mr.
Sawyer had already said that co-location is different from hyperscaler they ask. For request another another round so please have you finished yeah okay so thank you for the answers and we go back to another round of yes of speech just one minute for EPP known but S&D Mr. Nico Gonzalez Casares Gracias sorry sorry colleague I didn't look sorry so first the colleague Salla please thank you but they're not the round you just said another round right yeah yeah yeah. Senators has two rounds. Both follow up question oh yes just for follow up question yeah just a follow up question right yeah okay so one additional point the commission has indicated indeed that this rating scheme could also inform future legislation as you just mentioned cloud and AI act for example this makes it particularly important that we get the indications right from the beginning the new low emission energy factor recognizes both renewable and nuclear energy right which is welcome development can the commission confirm that future requirements will also recognize all low emission electricity resources including nuclear energy rather than relying primarily on renewable only indicators and importantly how will the commission ensure that these labels do not automatically become binding requirements without proper impact assessment and parliament's scrutiny thank you so follow up now the turn is no. Hablaré en español Quería recalcar la la pregunta que acaba de hacer la compañía de Salas del PP creo que es importante reconocer lo que ha dicho de low carbon porque como sabemos el mix de cada país en la Unión Europea es diferente y hay países los cuales no tienen ahora mismo energía nuclear y dependen de otras fuentes de energía diferentes que son o no son consideradas aún como con etiqueta verde entonces es importante esa reconocimiento ese reconocimiento de low carbon energy y después quería a la parte de los verdes y nos simplemente por los comentarios el 80. % de la carga de de datos y servicios en Europa están obviamente en mano de los
hiperescaladores extranjeros lo que propone cada es mejorar y distanciarnos de ese de esa dependencia que tenemos ahora mismo pero con sentido común no podemos movernos en dos días de donde estamos a donde queremos llegar hay que hacerlo con sentido común y con buenas prácticas por tanto lo de la moratoria lo veo un poco complicado porque la tecnología no espera si nosotros cortamos ahora mismo el desarrollo de centro de datos no. Me parece a mí que vamos a perder otra carrera más que es la carrera de tecnología thank you Okay I didn't understand there was a follow up round here but since there is I would like to ask Data center that draws on coal or gas power during the night can still receive a green label as far as I read this this label that you present the way the label accounts for renewable energy is based on guarantees of origin and power purchase agreements which allow data centers to document that they have purchased enough renewable electricity to cover their annual consumption however this does not necessarily reflect the actual source of the electricity they consume at the time they use it how will the commission prevent the sustainability label from becoming greenwashing exercise where the label senders where the label the. Data center the data centers can look green on the paper while they're still relying heavily on fossil fuels in practice thank you Paul. Yes thank you very much Mr. Sawyer I did not ask for a moratorium it was the left right but you make it maybe I wasn't I wasn't clear enough my question was we have different types of data centers as Mr. Sawyer has said we have the co-locators we have the hyperscalers we have the AI training facilities and all these data centers or these types of data centers have different characteristics so I think his question and it is mine actually also is the commission already thinking about assigning a benchmark system that is related to the type of data center because that would actually make sense because you cannot really
compare them it's a bit like we have in the eco design regulation we differentiate between small cars and big cars obviously because a big car will always use more energy than a small car so basically that would be my question and what is from from your explanations I haven't quite understood why a a. Are you listening I haven't yet understood why a data center operator has no influence on the use of waste heat because he can choose a location where waste heat can be used that is within his possibilities and I certainly agree very much with my colleagues that we should really push for European owned European controlled data centers because we are dependent on them and we can see what the US can do within a few days okay so the last yes the closing please thank you and I will still speak in Danish two. Spørgsmål det første er hvis vi ikke stiller krav om at overskudsvarmen skal genanvendes ved datacentre hvordan forhindrer vi så at datacentrene systematisk placeres steder hvor man kan henvise til at det ikke er muligt at genanvende overskudsvarmen så det synes jeg jo er et vigtigt spørgsmål her fordi så risikerer vi jo hvis vi datacentre bliver placeret sådan et sted altså får vi et massivt spild af energi og det kan næppe være eneste vores ønsker om energieffektivitet og det andet spørgsmål det er hvis man ikke vil have et moratorium hvordan vil man så sikre at vi ikke i løbet af de næste års tid får etableret et utal af amerikansk ejede datacentre som ikke tager hensyn til energieffektiviteten det er jo den situation vi står i. Please now the floor is your 40 answer the following question many thanks I think as I said this proposal is part of CADA and I see there are rapporteur or co-rapporteur of CADA so I'm I'm focusing on on the energy side the location of a data center has definitely different criteria one is waste heat but there might be others that's why we decided on a label we cannot penalize it's a plus definitely but some member states might decide or some data center provider to go somewhere else where
grid connection is there which is also an important factor or labor force I I mean there are many criteria on location what we did to in the commission we had already one and we will have other round tables where we put the digital if I may say so and the energy side together so the TSOs the data center providers the companies and so on and the member states of course so that the criteria of location that they talk to each other before they locate and they know that the waste heat for example is some important criteria but more than that we are not deciding where the data center is but we are reflecting it in the label I think that's one point on the different types of data that's true different types of data centers there is on the label under our European flag data center operator and type of data center with x x x x x that is where the type will be there we decided and cannot do different labels for different types of data center but it's transparent what kind of data center it is and you mentioned a few so that is reflected in the label so people can see transparency where it is there was also a question yeah on the future on the energy sourcing for now as I said before renewables and nuclear are are mentioned there is also non-specified which can be any other source if we see in the review in two years we need to rework that and be maybe a bit more specific or do it differently we will do so in the report in the review but for now this is the simplest way and that refers also to the question of Niels it's the efforts to to source from energy it's not the actual energy mix so the data center the GOPPAs as you rightly said and asked is really the effort from the data center to provide and get clean energy it's not the energy mix which is the basis for for for that source of energy labeling it's based on GO and PPAs which is how we do it in in in in general to provide clarity and transparency I think I covered most of the questions so many thanks we are very much looking
forward to your reaction and yes we have a lot okay okay sorry no please some some more colleague asked to interview so Mr. Nico Gonzalez Casares first a question of order please don't don't run my one minute this is a very important debate it's on the top of the agenda and you see this is one of the biggest committee of this parliament and few men members he has why if we dedicate 80% of the time of the debate to rounds and rounds of coordinators the other members cannot speak and they are not here so we had to reflect about it's it's for the for for ourselves it's a debate for ourselves nothing nothing related with mercy but this is the reality today is Tuesday in the morning high peak of affluence in the parliament and this is the reality we want this kind of debates we had to reflect ourselves what is really happening with this second round and round and round with not other members with the possibility to to speak you see in EPP one or two is the biggest group of the camera I'm not blaming them it's because other members cannot speak go to my minute Está claro que necesitamos un debate más amplio sobre el despliegue de centros de datos en Europa los centros de datos se desplieguen necesita primero soberanía no la vamos a lograr contra esta etiqueta con esta etiqueta no es el objetivo de ella pero necesitamos soberanía que nadie nos pueda pagar el servicio que presta nuestros centros de datos y nosotros ponemos la energía el agua el territorio y otros pueden apagarnos cuando quieran eso tenemos que evitarlo pero este no es el lugar y por otro lado sostenibilidad esto lo que pretendía esta etiqueta y está superada por el debate créanme es un ejercicio de buena voluntad pero esto está completamente superado por qué porque no nos asegura un impacto real saber el impacto real de los centros de datos con esta etiqueta no podemos saber ni los megavatios totales consumidos por un centro de datos ni los litros de agua ni los megavatios hora renovables no podemos saber ni las emisiones de CO2 que provoca cada centro de datos por lo tanto está completamente
superada y necesitamos avanzar en algo yo creo que la comisión tiene una una una oportunidad en los los mínimum standards en mínimum performance standards la propuesta legislativa y cree o entiende la comisión que es el momento ahí de poner pues objetivos europeos vinculantes para que haya soberanía y sostenibilidad de verdad perdone presidenta muchas gracias thank you colleague and now for a new Mrs. Miss Katri Kurmuni Thank you chair while listening this discussion I've noticed that there is a huge overruns that we we see it somewhat similarly and there's no question that we wouldn't be supportive with new technologies and with data centers but what the majority of us is concerned that now in the front line are the Americans and Chinese and we will give lots of our energy energy grids water resources for them and then when they will finally hopefully in some point be Europeans to come on these markets we're nothing to offer anymore at least I and I I assume my colleagues as well have been receiving lots of feedback also from the citizens and especially they've been worried about the article five paragraph five about the exact same theme that's the previous speaker mentioned that these statistics aren't visible many of the consumption numbers are hidden with business secrets so why did you decide to reframe the article five paragraph five in this this sense and not in a public manner where everything should be public in public issues thank you thank you Miss Sophie Erickson Thank you chair thank you deputy director general we're talking about some of the world's absolute rigid tech companies and they must pay the actual price for their own electricity when they build these enormous data centers they must also take responsibility for the new electricity generation needed to power them otherwise households risk facing higher electricity bills and European industry risks being crowd out but I cannot find any initiative on this in the work program for next year why you have already launched a call for evidence so you recognize the issue and are already gathering
input so when will you put forward binding requirements to ensure that data centers take responsibility for their growing electricity demand we need a clear answer here the technology giants are expanding rapidly households should not have to pay the price because policymakers act too late and I also want to say that you we cannot call a data center sustainable if people building it are working without basic rights and sometimes close to slave-like conditions thank you thank you and at the last Miss Benedetta Scuderi Grazie presidente ringrazio la commissione per questo importante dibattito sui data center allora guardando l'etichetta mi sembra un po' però incoerente parlare di un'etichetta sulla sostenibilità se poi è proprio la commissione come abbiamo detto come hanno detto anche molti colleghi che ha detto che i dati sui data center sono coperti da segreto e allora quindi le comunità locali le amministrazioni devono sapere soltanto che c'è un'efficienza energetica di senza sapere quanta energia utilizzata quanta acqua utilizzata qual è l'impatto reale per quella comunità e io penso che questa cosa si deve su questa cosa si debba far chiarezza un'altra cosa come questa etichetta va a informare tutti quei comuni quelle città quelle regioni che hanno bisogno di informazioni vere per prendere delle decisioni su quali data center poter poter dare l'ok e l'altra cosa è mi sembra che siamo un po' in ritardo perché arrivare a un'etichetta adesso quando ci sono migliaia e migliaia e migliaia di richieste da parte di data center per lo più americani e non mettere delle regole chiare e dire che la classe G in Europa non si fa che la classe F in Europa non si fa abbiamo bisogno di data center sostenibili europei e con regole chiare e un'etichetta mi sembra un passo molto molto lento con l'accelerazione che invece le big tech hanno grazie grazie collega for your answer please take your fraud just to take some time it's important having short answer please okay I will be short thank you very much first of all as I said in the beginning we act now because we
have 3% 2.5 to 3% of our electricity in the EU on average going to data center it will grow certainly post 2030 so we act now with this label our plan and the current open consultation is about the next step minimum energy performance standard I think Casaras was referring to it we encourage everyone to reply to that stakeholder consultation which is running until 12th of December and then next year beginning of next year first half we are ready to make a proposal on minimum energy performance standard for data centers we hear already that there is a huge interest so we are ready to take the next step and and make a proposal on it but today it's about the delegated act on the label which is a first step but as I said we are ready we are working on it public consultation is running we will analyze all the replies and make a proposal next year and as we see of course the next couple of years I fully agree are hugely important because of of of the estimated scenario that data centers will the number of data center will increase so it's really important you. Were referring to article five paragraph five which is about the data so it's all based as I said on energy efficiency directive which we all know and that directive requires the commission to publish aggregated data and we are making such information available through two means a public dashboard where we share summarized data as soon as it's ready and secondly we share data through annual reports which provide detailed analysis of the reported figures so as much as we can from the commission side based on the ED we will publish the data aggregated and then member states decide which specific data their data center must publish so it's the compromised member states will decide on that and but we are checking from the commission side the member states if they have applied the rules correctly and if they don't we act so there is an obligation based on the ED to publish member states are in charge to decide if there are specific data which needs to be published but we are
controlling if the rules are apply applied and the label itself will already increase transparency on the sustainability of individual data center and that as I said is the first step and the aim of this proposal thank you thank you thank you for being here for your answer it was a very interesting topic and very sensitive that's why we have a so lively debate so I just we we move on the item four and I kido scusa al collega Stancanelli per il ritardo and please we have five minutes for the mission to India from 21 to 25 September 2026 I give the floor to Rafael Stancanelli as a head of delegation for a short report on the mission please grazie presidente onorevoli colleghi e con grande piacere che intervengo oggi per riferire Sul risultati della missione della nostra commissione Nuova Deli svolta dal 21 al 25 settembre che ho avuto l'onore di guidare desidero innanzitutto ringraziare i colleghi dei diversi gruppi politici che hanno preso parte alla missione contribuendo a un confronto costruttivo e approfondito con i nostri interlocutori indiani un sincero ringraziamento va inoltre al segretariato e alla commissione ITRE ai funzionari e agli interpreti nonché alla delegazione dell'Unione Europea Nuova Deli per l'eccellente organizzazione del prezioso supporto garantito durante l'intera visita la missione ci ha offerto l'opportunità di incontrare importanti rappresentanti delle istituzioni indiane tra cui i ministri responsabili per la scienza e la tecnologia le industrie pesanti e l'energia nonché il consigliere scientifico principale del governo abbiamo inoltre avuto un confronto diretto coi rappresentanti della stilla authority of India dell'Indian Institute of Technology della federazione delle imprese europee in India e di Airbus da questi incontri è emerso un dato che ritengo particolarmente significativo l'India guarda all'Unione Europea con interesse si tratta di un mercato in fortissima espansione nel quale sono già presenti circa 6000 imprese europee si tratta di una presenza economica
importante che testimonia il potenziale della nostra relazioni e le prospettive di ulteriore cooperazione anche alla luce dell'accordo libero scambio in corso di formalizzazione per quanto riguarda l'energia e la sicurezza degli approvvigionamenti abbiamo approfondito la priorità della politica energetica indiana e le possibili aree di collaborazione con l'Unione Europea dal confronto emersa una lezione molto chiara la diversificazione delle fonti e indispensabile e la transizione energetica non può prescindere da tre elementi fondamentali ovvero sostenibilità economica sicurezza e l'approvvigionamenti e competitività in questo contesto la neutralità tecnologica deve rappresentare un principio imprescindibile abbiamo inoltre discusso di idrogeno un settore nel quale l'India sta investendo con grande ambizione di SIBAM un tema che continua a suscitare preoccupazione tra i partner industriali indiani con il ministro delle industrie pesanti dell'acciaio abbiamo affrontato anche le prospettive della mobilità elettrica delle batterie del riciclaggio e dell'accesso alle materie prime critiche la cooperazione con l'India anche alla luce dell'accordo commerciale concluso rappresenta un'opportunità per entrambe le parti affinché possa produrre benefici effettivi dovrà tuttavia fondarsi su condizioni di reciprocità parità di trattamento e tutela delle rispettive capacità produttive un altro importante ambito di confronto ha riguardato la ricerca l'innovazione e le tecnologie strategiche è emerso un significativo potenziale di collaborazione in settori quali le tecnologie quantistiche il supercalcolo i semiconduttori l'intelligenza artificiale le biotecnologie e lo spazio particolarmente interessante è stato anche il confronto sull'approccio indiano all'intelligenza artificiale una strategia che pone al centro l'innovazione prevede una valutazione progressiva dei rischi e valorizza ove possibile il ricorso al quadro normativo già esistente evitando restrizioni preventive eccessive credo che anche in Europa dovremmo guardare con attenzione a questo approccio infine gli incontri con
la federazione delle imprese europee in India e con Airbus ci hanno permesso di approfondire le opportunità offerte al mercato indiano e le prospettive di espansione del settore dell'aviazione anche per quanto riguarda lo sviluppo e l'impiego di carburanti sostenibili in conclusione la missione ha confermato che le opportunità di cooperazione tra l'Unione Europea e l'India sono concrete e significative per coglierle tuttavia è necessario che nel lungo periodo l'Unione Europea sappia esprimere una visione una strategia industriale chiara e pragmatica vi ringrazio per l'ascolto grazie Raffaele and now I take the floor to Gonzalez Casares gracias creo che la mission fu una buona mission gracias all'organizzazione del segretariato e los grupos y está claro che in India Europa e India tendremos opportunidades e ellos tendran opportunidades y de acuerdo puede ser importante y hay que agradecer también las autoridades indias su buena disposición creo que hay muchísimas oportunidades en diferentes sectores tecnológicos industriales en la energía pero también hemos visto algunas barreras no por ejemplo en el ámbito de la movilidad de los automóviles creo que existe pues barreras muy proteccionistas en lo que tiene que ver en la India no con la posibilidad de de introducirse en ese mercado en ámbito de energía sí que hemos visto una preocupación más que energía diplomacia climática y y comercio hemos visto una preocupación con el CIBAM por parte de las autoridades indias y ellos están creando un sistema de comercio emisiones parecido a nuestro TS un poco más digamos más blando de inicio pero nos llama la atención una cosa crean un sistema de mercado. De carbono para las industrias que emiten pero no lo crean para sus fuentes de energía lo que nos hace sospechar que ese sistema de mercado de emisiones de carbono está simplemente creado para actuar contra el CIBAM no como un objetivo real de cumplir con los acuerdos de París en lo que tiene que ver con el artículo 6.3 y los mercados de carbono y reducir emisiones gracias
thank. You very much I'm very interested in position so. We end the the item and we move to the item five mission. To acer. Slovenia in Lubiana 21 to 22 September 2026 we have a five minutes for its for this item I will give the floor to Jens Geier from S&D as head of delegation for a short report on the mission ciao please thank you president um dear colleagues from the 21st to the 22nd September the committee conducted a mission to Lubiana to visit ASA the European Union Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulation Regulators ASA was established in 2011 to coordinate the work of national regulators at union level it supports the development of EU wide network and market rules promotes competition and market integration and monitors the market for abuse in recent years it take its tasks have grown with the transition of our energy system the European Parliament has always been a strong supporter of ASA making this visit an excellent opportunity to exchange on current legislative work and see up close how ASA promotes further integration of the energy market and carries out its monitoring and investigatory mandate during the visit the agency gave us an update on the state of play of the energy market integration and on recent developments improving its functioning the benefits of market integration integration such as stronger resilience and socioeconomic welfare can already be seen today however challenges remain further implementation of EU wide and regional projects is crucial to fully exploit the potential of market integration enhance efficiency and performance of electricity markets and support shared goals such as energy affordability sustainability goals and security of supply an important aim of the mission was to inform our current and upcoming legislative work to this end we had insightful exchanges about the grids package the proposal for network charges the upcoming energy security package we also discussed the monitoring of the Russian gas phase out and ASA's hydrogen monitoring we were also updated on the state of play of the remit
two implementation the EU framework to detect and deter against wholesale market abuse the 2024 revision not only broadened the scope of the regulation but also granted ASA investigatory powers and cross-border cases these powers allow ASA to establish relevant facts regarding potential breaches of remit and effectively support the enforcement activities of national regulatory authorities in conclusion the visit showed that ASA's role is growing and that the agency is central to an integrated transparent and trusted energy market I believe this house should continue to support ASA including with the resources it needs to for to carry out its mandate finally I would like to thank ASA for the insightful presentations and exchanges and the ETA secretariat for the excellent organization thank you thank you very much and now we move to yes uh to mission to Enisa Greece in Athens 20 from 21 to 23 September 2026. Oh. Sorry colleague we have a five minutes for this item I will give the floor to Marketa Gregorova from Greens as head of delegation of a short report for a short report for the mission please thank you very much chair and dear colleagues uh so the committee conducted a mission to Athens from 21st to 23rd September 2026 as you already mentioned and we focus on union's cyber security activities and the work of European Union Agency for cyber security and ISA and the mission was timed to coincide with our ITRA work on both the CSA2 and NIS2 revision for which I am coincidentally the rapporteur uh before turning to uh our findings I would really like to thank the ITRA secretariat for the excellent organization of the mission uh during the fruitful discussions we had we looked at Enisa's mandate and its contribution to implementing the EU cyber security framework it was clear to the delegation that Enisa provides expertise develops guidance and supports key cooperation between member states EU institutions and of course the broader cyber security community however Enisa also
has around 130 staff under its staff plan NIS2 the CRA and the cyber solidarity act each added tasks CSA2 adds more and the commission's financial statement foresees 118 additional posts by 2031 so this definitely needs to be addressed in the future discussions also addressed changes and evolutions in the cyber threat environment ransomware distributed denial of service attacks supply chain vulnerabilities and the exploitation of software vulnerabilities continue to create significant risks the growing use of AI adds whole another dimension on Tuesday we discussed AI as a tool for attackers and as a target Enisa published its threat landscape 2026 that day it reports malware written with AI in active use and an AI assisted intrusion that gained administrator rights in a cloud environment within 8 minutes Enisa's July paper gives the figures for one organization it found about 80 vulnerabilities in the first quarter of 2025 and about 500 in the first quarter of 2026 and with frontier tools it now finds about 500 a day since August the commission can enforce its power under the AI act to evaluate the general purpose AI models with systemic risk the union has no staff able to carry out such an evaluation though the scientific panel only gives advice the action plan of 7th of July assigns Enisa five of its nine key actions but none of them is a legal task Enisa's work program has no separate budget line for AI and I hope we can rectify that all in the CSA2 file this mission confirmed several through truths to me cyber security is undergoing a monumental change as we speak and this change requires us to fund and to develop Enisa's scale and tasks likewise the CSA2 is the place to do so right now and I hope my colleagues after this mission see this in a similar way thank you yes we. Be more aware thank you very much and now we move to the item seven amending regulation critical raw material act um we have a five minutes but the our colleague uh Mr. Chahim cannot be here so ask me to uh give the the the the information to the
to the committee so the first trilog on the targeted revision of the critical raw material act took place under the Irish presidency with Ambassador Kate Moran representing the council executive vice presidence representing the commission and Mr. Chahim leading parliaments and negotiation team rapporteur welcomed the constructive approach of the council and highlighted that differences on the targeted amendments appear relatively limited allowing substantial progress at the technical level he stressed that the file has two pillars the targeted amendments and the establishment of the European critical raw material center parliament aims to reach an agreement on the entire revision targeted amendments and the EU CRM center by the end of the year with no further delays justified on the CRM center parliament reiterated its support for a standalone decentralized decentralized agency arguing that this is the most appropriate structure to ensure operational stability funding and democratic accountability particularly for market and intervention activities the rapporteur also highlighted the proposed governing board urgency steering committee stakeholder involvement and the indicate dedicated to billion critical raw materials fund the council confirmed its commitment to the revision but underlined that it still needs to develop its mandate on the CRMM center it requested a more detailed assessment of the costs benefits and possible governance arrangements and asked the commission to provide more information as soon as possible the commission welcomed the swift start of negotiations and stressed the importance of maintaining flexibility avoiding additional administrative burdens and ensuring effective tools for diversification and crisis response on the CRM center it expressed willingness to work towards a solution while respecting institutional competencies and the upcoming MFF negotiations next steps are technical meeting are confirmed for 11 18th and 20th November with the with the next politic political trilog
envisaged for 9 the 9th of December so that's all any. Other question so we can move to item eight exchange of views with Marco Mishmash Barack chair 2026 Alejandra the eaga Gandini Barack chair 2027 and Dr. Verena Weber director of the agency for support for Barack the body of European regulators for electronic communication another very sensitive topic so thank you welcome uh and uh I would like so to welcome this important guests uh thank you very much for accepting our invitation we have approximate approximately one hour for this annual exchange of views after the opening remarks of our guests we start with the first round of coordinator or their representatives two minute two minutes each and continue with catch the aisle one minute each I invite all the members who wanted to take the floor to put their nameplates as usually time permitting I will allow members who wanted to ask a follow-up question to do so I wanted to remind everyone including our guests to please stick to the allocated time and now I invite Mr. Mism followed by Miss the Turiaga Gandini and Dr. Weber to take the floor for seven minutes each for their opening statements please the floor is yours thank you chair so next slide so let me briefly go through today's agenda first a few words uh about Barack uh and Barack office then Alejandra our incoming chair will present uh Barack uh work in 2027 after that Verena Weber uh Barack office director and I will present our DNA assessment next slide please so Barack and Barack office next slide why Barack is so important our work is about making the digital single market function in practice and ensuring that European rules translating to the real benefits for end users and businesses this means affordable connectivity roam like at home kept EU cost and text prices it means choice and fair treatment open internet access and strong consumer rights it means reliable modern networks supporting fiber deployment a smooth transition from copper and finally a secure digital
infrastructure with resilient networks and emerging technologies that is how Barack actually delivers for European citizens and businesses but none of this happens automatically it requires independent regulatory expertise strong cooperation between national regulators and consistent regulatory practices across Europe so and this is why we work in a two-tier structure um so Barack is providing as our chair was saying the independent regulatory expertise and um the Barack office um is the EU agency that provides um professional and administrative support to Barack as well as the operational continuity for Barack and so together we make sure um to turn regulation into better connect connectivity and does um everyday life benefits for the European citizens next slide please so Barack working 2027 Alejandra please thank you very much uh thank you all of you for coming here um I will address how will some topics some some ideas on how and what will be our direct work in 2027 next slide please so the digital sector is critical is critical to Europe competitiveness innovation security and digital sovereignty also for single market for and in the end for well-being of our our citizens so by bringing together the knowledge and experience of all the expertise of hundreds of hundreds any race in Barack will uh we are contributing to understand how digital market evolves and how technologies also evolves also we will identificate we are identificating the element the emerging challenges and where at are what are the measures well adopted uh in a benefit-based policies so Barack also as you know is tasked by being an advisory group uh for the European institutions so that's the reason we are here and open to help you so let me highlight some of the areas in which Barack work in 2027 will be particularly relevant to the priorities and legislative activities for this committee so first Barack has analyzed and put forward its proposal for the digital network act this will be outlined by Barack chair later on secondly we have the digital omnibus and
the digital fitness act fitness digital digital fitness check that provides an opportunity to examine how the different elements of the EU digital rulebook interact also identify duplication eliminate the the and reduce the tape and simplify the rules so Barack supports the objective subconsistency and harmonization to safeguard regulatory coherence and facilitate compliance Barack can interalia support the analysis of consistency across the digital rulebook for example with regard to definitions and governance these are most important topics that will uh we are checking in the digital fitness check digital omnibus and also in the DNA is also worth noting as you may know perfectly that discussions and the digital network act and the digital omnibus rule in parallel so in this regard I'm have to highlight that Barack has provided an input on cloud switching and portability provisions we therefore are asking that the digital omnibus should formally acknowledge the role in coordinating and supported national authorities in the implementation of these two elements so the switching and disability provision that are currently in the data act and should be also included in the digital omnibus so apart from that Barack is currently contributing to the commission's evaluation of the regulation of roaming and cross-border communication within the EU both reviews are due by June 2027 it is an opportunity to examine how these regulation is working in practice and whether it requires to be updated Barack will provide its technical expertise to inform the commission's assessment and any future policy decisions and finally another important sectoral regulation and sectoral dossier is the cyber security act 2 Barack supports the objective of reinforcing the security and resilience of Europe's digital infrastructure cyber security measures have direct implications for electronic communications network and services including network deployment supplier choice investment and operational resilience is therefore important that the framework strikes appropriate balance
between the need of security objectives and what are the condition under which networks and will be deployed and operators in particular this measure should be proportionate and risk-based take account of the industrial realities and avoid creating unnecessary dependencies on a limited number of suppliers next slide please now I will highlight briefly some topics that Barack will address next year so Barack is monitoring the evolution of the digital market connectivity and also including all the developments in this regard satellite communications are one of the example in 2027 Barack will examine the regulatory and harmonization challenges associated to with satellite satellite connectivity special especially regarding to the direct to device services which are very important now not only for to arrive to the the areas where they are not coverage by fiber but also in emergency cases at the same time the expansion the expansion of this kind of services raise regulatory questions such as authorization condition spectrum management competition resilience and the integration of satellite and terrestrial networks Barack's work will help to clarify these issues secondly Barack will also launch a broad reflection on the single market for electronic communications through exchanges with stakeholders and institution we will examine what a functioning single market should deliver in practice whether there is unmet demand for pan-European services and what incentives and barriers influence their provision and finally slide eight please end users is end users welfare is the core priority for Barack in 2027 Barack will provide a comprehensive assessment of the functioning of sectoral end users rights take into into account all the market evaluation and technical technological developments Barack is also aware of the growing concerns related to fraudulent activities online we will continue our work in this field bringing together public authorities institutions stakeholders and providers with in order to identify share good and
share with practices for combating button fraudulent activities and we will monitor of course the phase out legacy of technologies technologies such as 2G and 3G these transitions will face up spectrum and enable more efficient networks but must be managed carefully the process should be transferred for new users and include appropriate subwords the continuity of services shall consider users may still depend on legacy technologies and in in the event emerging communication shall not be this this disrupted to conclude Barack can support this committee in several complementary ways by contributing with technical evidence to legislative reviews by helping improve coherence across the EU digital rubric and identifying emerging challenges in connectivity and digital markets thank you very much thank you Alejandra next slide please so. European electronic communication code is a valid legislation for regulation of electronic communication markets for a little bit less than 10 years in between digital networks evolved the entire ecosystem evolved and you are all aware of a new digital network act proposed by the commission at the beginning of this year in the next few slides I will share Barack's view on the proposed legislation next slide please so the single market is a shared objective but harmonization is not an end in itself it should reduce unnecessary fragmentation while preserving effective enforcement where services are provided and users are affected so Barack has raised concerns about the single passport model that concentrates enforcement in the member state of notification destination regulators must remain able to act next slide please for Barack a well-functioning digital single market means stronger competition more investment and tangible benefits for European consumers and businesses the transition from copper to fiber shall not harm the end users users need safeguards and national flexibility the open internet framework is an important European achievement now we need to ensure
clarity on its application to emerging services and technologies next slide please so competition and investment should not be presented as opposing goals Barack sees effective competition as a central driver of investment innovation and consumer welfare in fixed next networks the framework must retain the ability to address bottlenecks in spectrum Barack has expressed concerns about indefinite licenses and automatic renewal next slide please to. Conclude Barack supports the ambition of the DNA and stands ready to assist the parliament and council we ask for a proportionate and evidence-based reform genuine single market gains strong end user protection continued competition and independent regulators with the resources to fulfill their tasks DNA should respect the independence of the national regulators and any new task should come with the required resources here I will turn to the Barack office director Verena please thank you and now moving to our last slide please so in this slide actually comes back to the beginning of our presentation so the role of Barack and the office is to secure our future connectivity and this for all European citizens and for all European businesses given that connectivity is actually the essential platform we need for the digital world we live in we need for AI systems etc now but in order to do this we need to have a sustainable budget for Barack and the Barack office just to be able to deliver efficiently so at the moment we face the challenge that we have a disproportionate small budget when we compare it to other agencies of similar sizes so we are now at a moment in time where the budget currently does not finance our core mandate anymore and where we cannot continue to stretch the limited resources simply to maintain basic operational capacity and I would also like to thank all of you and the parliament for the support for the 2027 budget where you are proposing a slight increase for much needed work on physical security and cyber security of the office actually now how can we address this
challenge the DNA is really the one and unique opportunity to put the budget of Barack and the office on a more stable footing together obviously with the next MFF and for this reason there is one part of the DNA that is also very important which is the legislative financial and digital statement so what we highly suggest is to make changes to this current draft legislative financial and digital statement to have adequate resources for the titles one two and three and this financed through a general EU subsidy rather than a fee finance structure which is which produces a lot of uncertainty so we would kindly so we heard and learned from the parliament that this committee the ITRA committee can request to the budget committee to give its opinion on the legislative financial and digital statement so we would highly appreciate if you could ask your colleague to draft such an opinion because this hasn't been done so far given that the overall size of the budget is is quite small so typically the budget committee only looks at files over 100 million so we have the problem that the overall file is only 20 million so but there your help would be very much appreciated and to let me conclude so and to be very clear this increased subsidy is really not about a huge institutional growth but it is to basically be able to execute the provisions of the DNA once they are agreed obviously by the co-legislators in an effective way so we want you know to take our mandate seriously and to get things done thank you very much thank you grab something that's finished back to chair okay thank you thank you so we go we move to the colleague and on behalf of EPP Miss Pilar de Castillo thank you thank you very much chair and thank you to the this prominent Barack's representation the current chair the one becoming for 2027 congratulations Alexandra Alexandra and so as well the presence of the director is really important for us having said that regarding the digital network act which we are going to debate today in the in the afternoon
here in in this committee one. Our priorities must be to ensurance a governance framework that is both both at the same time effective and independence in this regard the commission's proposal introduces changes to the current institutional framework notably as you know by creating the office of digital networks the ODN with broader competences I believe we should you know approach this reform this specific point taking into account simplification the new governance framework must avoid institutional duplications in that sense we need a clear division of responsibilities with Barack retaining is regulatory advisory and coordination role and the ODN providing the necessary operational and administrative support having said that let me focus my question in one specific point which is different to what I've been commenting but that was not much debate on this aspect an. Other specific topic as I said that I would like to hear your views is on the number in provisions of the digital networks act as you know article 46 said that the European numbering strategy articles 46 of the commission regulatory proposal the commission proposes an EU numbering strategy an EU numbering plan with advice from Barack and support from ODN this continuity article 50 with different provisions on this specific point I would like really to to listen to you I mean what you think about this because it's the kind of area which has not been really very much debated you know in previous debates thank you so much thank you colleague and now the floor for Mr. Matthias Ecke thank you chair thank you to to Barack to Marco Mischmasch to Alexandra the Gandini and to Verena Weber it's great that you're here and I really value the exchange that we have on the DNA and all the other subjects that you mentioned and it's very good that we have this exchange today in ITRA because it goes it's about the DNA but it goes beyond of course and I would like to stress a few ideas on where the electronic communications market is heading and what it means for your work because on the one hand
we move on a terrestrial level to fiber world where the market structure changes and legacy infrastructure becomes less and less important with the copper switch off we even have a like regulatory incentive to do that the fiber world will improve quality for end users of fixed network in a DNA can also push for this development and on the other hand in a mobile world we have the direct to device satellite connectivity you mentioned satellite as a challenge in the next years it is no longer future scenario and it comes with a certain market structure as well we know that Starlink is moving fast in Europe and is signing partnerships with major mobile operators across the union and at the same time they are also working with hardware makers so that ordinary phones could just directly connect to satellite services so they will increasingly become part of the value chain and so from from your perspective when we see this massive changes in the coming years what challenges do arise for national regulators and is there also opportunity for stronger European enforcement that we can make more use of the single market because single market we we all know that it comes down to what is the actual use of it and not just the abstract concept and it's the second question would be how you assess the importance of sovereignty criteria to take these into account we now discuss this especially with regard to satellite communication but I think it might go beyond yeah it can apply in many areas like the allocations of spectrum wholesale access and so on what is your opinion of that because this is the changing communications environment that we are heading to and I think national regulators are the ones that look on it from a customer perspective which I think is very valuable insight thank you thank you for the moment that we don't have any other coordinators Angelica if you want I give you the floor now so that's the Barack can do the answers altogether thank you vielen Dank Frau Vorsitzende das
Speaker 3de
I am, of course, happy to take up this offer and I would like to join the two previous speakers.
Speaker 3en
wanna join my colleagues already having taken the floor
Speaker 3de
Thank you very much for being here today in a trio – it’s wonderful to see how outgoing and incoming figures are working together here at the Commission; it gives hope that the work will continue very efficiently. Thank you. I have two very specific questions. The first one is something that has been occupying me for months, just like our Chair, because we have been working on the Space Act. Connectivity is absolutely central, as you also mentioned the satellite connectivity. I would be interested to know whether you have also been involved in the Space Act, what your opinion on it is. It’s not just about satellite operators; the scope is very broad – it also includes those who primarily use space data, the providers, who fall under the scope of the Space Act and are part of this major infrastructure. So have you been involved in this, and how do you view this proposal, especially since we are hearing a lot of criticism from the Member States? And the second question I think is also important: we are discussing here in the European Parliament, across various dossiers, the topic of ‘Made in Europe’ and ‘Made with Europe’. This particularly concerns digital infrastructure. Our question is: how independent, how sovereign are we already? How independent, how sovereign would we like to be? I would also be interested in your assessment. After all, you are our advisory body, so to speak. Do you have an opinion on this, and in which direction is this heading? Thank you very much.
Speaker 3en
Thank. You Angelica for your question for your question please the floor is on behalf of you thank you chair for the floor so first two questions from Pilar de Castillo first was regarding the DNA and governance how do we see let's say the proposed governance model can affect on our independence so actually one was the proposed governance model from the DNA the second already what repertoire proposed proposes the changes so that the proposed changes in the governance include the reconfiguration of the ODN management board and changes to decision making arrangements within the Barack governance structure and actually we do not agree with with the proposal why because our institutional model is built on the equal participation of the independent national regulators collective expertise and bottom up decision making so changing the composition of the management board or weakening establishing voting safeguards could undermine this balance and. Create risk for regulatory independence actually what we are proposing so we are proposing to preserve the equal participation of NRAs maintain the independence character of Barack's decision making and retain the proposed two thirds voting safeguards for the relevant bodies and also the new responsibilities as was also mentioned by Barack office director must also be accompanied by adequate financial and human resources this is actually our view regarding the governance regarding the the numbering um. On the numbering so the commission proposes a new union numbering strategy and numbering plan additional harmonization of numbering management and more restrictive conditions for granting and using numbering resources and Barack considers that the proposed centralized framework would introduce actually unnecessary administrative complexity without actually demonstrating a clear added value it could also limit the flexibility of the NRAs to manage scarce numbering resources respond to national market conditions and address emerging fraud risks so our proposal is remove the proposed union numbering strategy and numbering plan
these are articles 46 to and 47 preserve NRI discretion when granting numbering rights particularly to undertaking other than electronic communication providers and also maintain the flexibility in setting conditions for numbering rights including consumer protection and fraud prevention measures and ensure effective cross-border cooperation and enforcements without unnecessary central centralized procedures and the last one is preserve national powers to combat fraud and misuse including the possibility of maintaining higher levels of protection thank you. Thank you so so much I will I will take the the questions regarding switch off indeed switch off procedure that is included in the proposal of the DNA it's quite a challenge procedure we see it in Barack as something that has to be analyzed carefully we of course are in favor. Of promoting this switch off the migration from copper to fiber as we did in in Spain you know with the the first and only country that has completed this switch off procedure and from the Barack perspective we have analyzed the procedure included in the DNA saying that highlighting the need of more flexibility there are part areas in the different member states where fiber would not arrive and so a couple of job will not possible there is a need first of all for state aids in some cases to arrive to remote areas that's very important for Barack as the welfare of a user as I said is is the core and also it would mean satellite as you mentioned also which is one of the most important technologies so far that can can reach the areas that are not achieved by a commercial basis so that's to to things take into account state aid and also fix wireless access which is another technology that can be used for for for access to this remote areas and also we we need the transparency for end users in the copper switch off procedure and in this in this side we had the example of Spain we were pretty much transparent for to all stakeholders to all end users in order to understand which were the steps which were
the the in our web page it was announced all the locally changes that were going to be closed and so far all alternative operators would know exactly when was the time that the copper switch off would arrive so this is the the two key ideas that Barack opinion includes are first of all flexibility and second secondly transparent transparent for all the the all the stakeholders and also end users included in the in the in the in the chain in the value chain so this is one thing regarding your you mentioned I would love also from satellite the exchange satellite developments we are working pretty much in in the satellite technologies because they are also they are it's important as I said for arriving to this remote areas but also as you mentioned they are increasing agreements between local operator mobile operators and satellite we will of course be monitoring this agreements in the of course with the idea that competition is the the core principle that we have to preserve we are very happy with the proposal of opening the opening the the band spectrum band for satellite in order to include European providers for satellite services of course as you know that's a 2g band is is going to be open and related to direct to device is a special service that is included and has been used in very important cases so far in in Spain we had the case of the fires last last summer we had also the dana two years ago and that in that way agreements between operators and satellite was working on so as you mentioned we are in working in this and also we will monitor these agreements in order to maintain the competition and in order to preserve European operators from the operators from all over the the world thank you thank you very much we have some more time so I will I would like to give the floor to the commission but since I have a member of the secretary that has a very oh and Erica please yes for the following I just wanted to yeah sure as to whether my questions are going to be answered as well on the space act and on the made in Europe issues
okay okay. Thank you. Very much for the questions first one so made in Europe made for Europe critical suppliers so in Barack we we are aware that modern telecommunication network is the base for for the whole business environment and from that point of view it must work 24 hours a day it must it must be reliable it must be resilient to to all potential influences from outside and and also because of that it must be built from from equipment which is let's say it's reliable it has reliable supply chains must be maintained and from that point of view the risk should be as low as possible so we are aware that. Nothing can be done just within the Europe so what become a global but. It's very important that that all the elements in modern network in in European networks must be let's say built from. As possible low low risk supply chains so we are in favor in favor of that but what is also in favor that the high risk vendor should be removed but what is also important it is important that this from the market this shouldn't affect market as it is so it means that it should be done appropriate appropriate way then then investments already done should be preserved so it should go in hand in hand with the amortization periods that's market effects should be as less as possible. If I may add something following what Miss Nibbler asked we are we are at the end of important discussion debate on space act and the connectivity on one side and on the other side based security the following item is we are asking to Anisa what's the state of the union in cyber security are linked and there are something that is a backbone for our space act not just for we we we discussed a lot about manufacturing and autonomy for Europe but we have not we we will not join the the goal to be strong and autonomous if we don't have a connectivity and cyber security as a field so to so it could be also interesting for us to put it together you and the other colleague so the two agency but Barack and also cyber
security because we needed to understand better how we could go on with our space act in this topic so thank you Angelica I asked to Mr. Mishmash to to have another a focus on it so we will take our time for this in another in another moment and now we have some more some more time but as I said I would like to pronounce incorrect way please we will give the floor to it's Przemysław Kordasiewicz Digiconnect European Commission thank you chair my name was pronounced very correctly dear ladies and gentlemen dear honorable members of the European Parliament and dear representatives of the Barack and the Barack office the European Commission works very closely with Barack and the Barack office we supported in its daily operations as well as contribute to the works on substance recognize the Barack sectoral experience and expertise the European Commission has proposed to significantly strengthen the Barack and the Barack office while maintaining its independence also the independence from the European Commission therefore in the proposal for the DNA the European Commission proposed to equip Barack and the Barack office with new responsibilities where its works at the EU level would be most beneficial for the EU single market such as authorizations spectrum preparedness security resilience satellite communications we. Have also proposed the simplifications and the avoidance of duplication both between the works of the NRAs at the national level Barack and also the ODN having said that it is crucial to ensure that Barack and the Barack office have sufficient resources to fulfill all those tasks this applies equally to the works on the DNA as well as any other budgetary discussions which are currently ongoing between the co-legislators and ultimately the decision remains in the hands of this house so the European Parliament and the council thank you very much thank you very much and we we yeah I wanted to thank you very much for your presence for the also yes the the the fact that that you you are here all
together and it is a good sign for us thank you very much we will have a lot of things to to understand better and also deal with the MFF and the competitiveness fund because of the the question about how to support Europe agency thank you very much and we have and the this item so I would like to thank you for your presence thank you thank you thank you thank you. Thank you very much
hello hello
thank you so we can go to the next item presentation by European Union Agency for Cyber Security ENISA of a Cyber Security State of the Union report it's very very sensitive topic now in all Europe so I would like to welcome Mr. Johan Lepassar Executive Director for ENISA thank you for accepting our invitation to present the Cyber Security State of the Union report we have approximately 45 minutes for this debate after the opening presentation we start with the first round of question by Coordinators and their representatives the author is the then given the floor for his replies time permitting we will continue with catch the eyes I remind everyone about to to take but we have time so please take your time now give the I give the floor to Mr. Lepassar for 10 minutes to make his presentation the floor is yours please thank you very much Madam President it's a great honor to be back in the committee to give you the second report of the State of Cyber Security in the Union this report was drawn up by ENISA in collaboration with member states and the European Commission and I would like to highlight also that it is not just a collection of thoughts and reflections but it's based on quantitative and qualitative data along which also the EU Cyber Security Index which is around an index. Which we compiled together with member states focusing on 33 different areas so the report is an synthesis of of work done and it consists of a number of recommendation. But also looks at the overall State of Cyber Security and I will not bore you with with too many details but I would like to concentrate on on three areas and first is when we look at European Cyber Security Ecosystem where are we today so what is the EU Cyber Security posture and the posture is something that we measure on the basis of the EU Cyber Security Index we measure it across the three 33 different areas and we make a assumption on the basis of the facts and attach a number to this and we say today in 2026 the EU Cyber Security
posture from 0 to 100 is 71.53 what does it mean it means that in our assessments EU is mature when it comes to its Cyber Security posture I think that's something which we need to actually celebrate EU is one of the most mature regions in the world when it comes to Cyber Security we measure the maturity across its member states and we can say 22 member states are mature which means that their index results is a lot around 70 two member states are advanced and three member states are established which means it's it's a bit a layer below the the mature level so the highest result of a member state is 81 and the lowest result is 57 so that's the the the scope of maturity in the Union. Since 2024 what we have observed since the last report of Cyber Security in the Union is of course that there are there is an increased maturity of sectors overall on average again something to celebrate a lot of these investments are driven by regulatory demands by the framework that the Union has put in place we do regular service of the critical entities and they tell us this is the major driver why they invest in Cyber Security so without the legislative work of the Parliament these investments would not have happened the maturity of the Union would not have been there and I think that's something to celebrate on there is more focus on ICT ICT supply chain security and product security also thanks to the new legislative frameworks which have been put in force put in place by the Parliament and we have tried to define better also cyber crisis management processes within the Union now where we also see issues emerging of course is within this ecosystem there are a lot of disruptors and one of the major disruptor in the recent year has been the advance of the frontier AI capabilities which have really impacted regarding the ability of the critical entities and member states to to ensure resilience of the Cyber Security posture so when we look at the EU threat landscape 2026 the level of cyber threats to the Union is assessed as
substantial which means that intrusion activity by threat actors remains significant and diverse throughout 25 and 26 and the threat landscape itself is also becoming very much more complex and partially that's also because of the AI and the what we've seen as well the ability of the threat actors to utilize AI capability for their offensive operations when we look at the policy landscape on the other hand it's maturing I think there are three concurring trends at the same time implementation which means implementing the Union legislation that has been put in place mainly that means the NIS2 the CRA consolidation as well which means looking at how we can consolidate the legislative framework and the Commission has of course proposed there a number of initiatives including the review of the Cyber Security Act which is the mandate of the agency and simplification of course looking at ways how we can potentially simplify the legislative processes try to put the next slides next slide okay thank you next slide so where are the gaps and now I'm unfortunately the story will not be as rosy. I would like to start with the skills Cyber Security. Is underpinned by people and the capability of Cyber Security experts to to foster the community and what we've observed of course is a growing gap between what we need in terms of expertise and what we have in terms of expertise the 8% that you show you you see in the slide is an increase of skills gap which was measured from 24 to 25 by by the World Economic Forum and it's a global skills gap it's not only about the EU and why it's important that we understand that it's a global skills gap because Cyber Security is a global business it's not only happening in the Union itself so a widening skills gap globally also affects the Union and moreover what we have is of course the AI disrupting this the AI demanding more and different skills from from from the Cyber Security expertise and quite often sometimes skills that we yet don't have at the same time
there is also an opportunity and a threat of AI replacing some of the layers of of the skills with with with AI agents the second issue I want to focus on is vulnerabilities looking at the ICT and supply chain issues the the AI disruption has caused a huge exponential growth in in discovery and exploitation in vulnerability so compared to the last year the same quarter there has been an increase of 315% of vulnerabilities so these are weaknesses which are found in in in software and of course this capability of the AI to speed up the the discovery and the exploitation is is worrisome and it puts further strain on the Cyber Security defenders in particular so that what we see from the technology side on the other hand when you when I look at the national strategies one of the big issues there is the misalignments or miscoordination between the coordinated vulnerability disclosure policies that member states have in the strategies that is another issue which links back to the the two topics that I mentioned before because if the coordinated coordinated vulnerability disclosure policies in the national level do not align we will not be able to handle vulnerability disclosure in in seamless fashion at the Union level either finally and also linked is is the the the level of maturity when it comes to incident response teams of the member states there. The again we we rely on index that I referred before the the index result is 54 which is around the middle but that's the average doesn't tell you much in reality the maturity of member states is very dispersed and there are those who have very high level of maturity but also quite a lot of member states with lower maturity when it comes to incident response teams and this is an issue when it comes to then operationalizing the vulnerability management at the EU level so all of these little problems compound in a bigger problem in in the Union which lowers the ability of the Union to respond and the resilience of the Union to respond in in in big crisis finally regarding
sectors I said in my first slide that we observed a growth in maturity of critical sectors and that's true but at the same time when we look deeper there is a difference between big companies and small companies within the sector and 27% of SMEs struggle to find resources to invest in Cyber Security 27% of SMEs who actually are critical from the point of view of NIS2 directive in particular I would like to highlight. Some of the sectors which are in from our point of view in the risk zone which is the rail maritime public administration and space where where actors which have lower level of maturity struggle to maintain their Cyber Security posture and that in my last slide how. To address this gap I'm going to went too far okay we call it Cyber Security Compass so where can we go knowing what the gaps are knowing what our maturity level is together with member states in the Commission we put forward some recommendations looking at really focusing and shifting the implementation towards cross-border supervision and information sharing pursuing higher level of maturity for crisis management communities and networks enforcing Cyber Security across the supply chain and investing in support of AI upskilling when it comes to skills so I will leave this slide here and I'm very happy to answer all your questions and sorry if I lose a bit of time no perfect the the topic is very sensitive and so we we we can't and it's a pity that's a no much colleague are here because we are talking about this topic in all our state member state in every time we we have to comment what is happening in the in our Europe and in the world so it's very it's very pity so I give the floor to my colleague Angelica Nibbler for the first round yeah erstmal der Bericht ist eigentlich schon ernüchternd ja wenn man die die Lücken aufgezeigt bekommt mit denen wir es hier zu tun haben ich würde mal gerne beginnen mit zwei Fragen zum einen haben wir ja gerade aktuell erlebt dass in den Supermärkten hier die die Kühlschränke hier die Temperaturen der Kühlschränke hochgefahren wurden mit dem großen Schaden das war ja auch
übergreifend also in Schweden in Finnland in Frankreich glaube ich bei uns in Deutschland in viele Staaten waren ja betroffen vielleicht können Sie uns mal aufzeigen wenn so ein Fall eintritt ganz ein konkreter Incident bei dem mehrere Mitgliedstaaten betroffen sind wie läuft denn dann die Maschinerie an und wie ist da ihre wie wie wie operativ wie wie wie funktioniert es denn bei Ihnen und ist es gut gelaufen oder oder gibt's da noch haben Sie aus gerade ganz konkret an dem Beispiel gelernt da und da müssen wir einfach noch nachlegen und der zweite das zweite Thema das ich gerne noch etwas ausgeleuchteter haben möchte Sie haben ja zurecht drauf hingewiesen dass durch AI durch künstliche Intelligenz sich die die die Möglichkeiten hier auch Cyber Sicherheit oder Cyber Sicherheitsattacken zu fahren exponentiell erhöht hat was heißt denn das konkret dann auch für unsere Politik was müssen wir denn noch mehr veranlassen was sind denn so die Vorschläge die Überlegungen wie können wir denn da weitergehen und vor allen Dingen Sie haben es angesprochen wie können wir denn unsere kleinen mittelständischen Unternehmen hier noch unterstützen also ich glaube das ist wirklich ein ein Kernbereich in dem Sie jetzt arbeiten und insofern wäre ich dankbar wenn Sie da noch mal das Thema AI etwas ausleuchten könnten und vielleicht noch eine Überlegung mit Blick auf die Debatte die wir gerade vorher mit den Kolleginnen Kollegen von Ihnen von Berg hatten made in Europe hilft das um unsere Cyber Sicherheitslücken zu schließen oder sagen Sie das spielt aber keine Rolle danke thank you Angelica and now the floor to Mr. Geyer I'm sorry I have to pull out okay and Van der Leij ja thank you very much chair so this week our national leaders are finally meeting to discuss AI I saw in your report that the rise in artificial intelligence is also showing an increase in vulnerabilities in our Cyber Security and I noticed that more than 10 I think countries have not started with the implementation of the security officers that they need to appoint according to the
AI Act could you expand a bit on what vulnerabilities are increased by the lack of delivery of these national governments to implement the AI Act okay and I'll give the floor to myself. Per un paio di altre considerazioni sempre sulla linea anche di Angelica io e l'onorevole Nibbler siamo molto coinvolte nello Space Act e anche discutendo con il il Berek prima di lei connettività e Cyber sicurezza sono strettamente legati come renderlo ancora più forte questo legame perché il rischio di questa Europa in termini di architetture di avere tantissime agenzie tanti spazi di intervento e alcuni problemi che invece oggi devono essere non solo guardati a livello di stati membri ma anche di Europa stessa nella sua governance interna la seconda c'è la revisione della direttiva NIS 2 e. Nella discussione dello Space Act noi non abbiamo deciso di intervenire con una lex specialis perché non volevamo che ci fosse una sovrapposizione di normative ma questo riguarda evidentemente il tema quindi qual è la vostra di richiesta rispetto a questa a questa direttiva infine terzo punto lei ha sottolineato il gap di competenze in Europa e il divario anche qualche stato è molto basso qualche altro è molto consapevole della della pericolosità ma quali strumenti per rendere più legato sul tema ovviamente sto sul tema Cyber sicurezza e basta il rapporto. Tra stati membri e autorità europea e come andare a costruire competenze uniformi perché è un modo quello di diventare cittadini europei che passa attraverso la formazione grazie I'll give you the floor now thank you Madam President so I will start with the honor remember Madam Nibbler with a question I think it's very pertinent what can we learn from these let's say wave of targeted um. Incidents when it comes to refrigerators and their misuse I think there are a number of layers that we can potentially dig into and I'll start with let's say there are still investigations ongoing but I will start with with the technical layer and say okay what was really the
cause through which the threat actors then were able to exploit um. And there were two sides first it's the credential management the manufacturer gave a default password to all of the products which. Is in blatant violation of security by default security by design principle which is something that of course the union has tackled by the cyber resilience act which comes into force the 1st of December but these products are already in the market and the second was vulnerability which was then exploited so these two things combine and of course again vulnerability management is super critical when it comes to resilience of the products that are placed in the internal market so the CRA I would say is 20 years late but better late than never and in this sense we believe in the cyber security community that this framework will at least in the future ensure that we will have a much more secure and resilient products circulating in the internal market the problem of course there is the legacy so how do we ensure that we also and the manufacturers they take the necessary steps in order to tackle legacy products which or products which are not longer no longer supported so that's one hand of of what we observed where we where we see that there was a an issue the way that the manufacturer designed and maintained the security of its product the second issue there of course is the operational situation of when so how quickly the information was exchanged and shared between the member states and the the responsible authorities which is essentially the national see certain this national sea and then the sea network now there was a very strong. Level of exchange of knowledge between the different member states so I can't say that the member states did not share the information they did now the question of course is once the member states authorities share this this information how does it get picked up by the relevant entities in the critical sectors themselves what measures do they
take in order to raise their resilience and also do they do it only visavi the national authorities or are there eu-wide information sharing networks in place for different sectors which they can utilize and use and there we saw gaps emerging so indeed when it comes to common situational awareness this is an area where there could be efforts made in order to ensure that information is exchanged faster not only via national routes but also at the eu level throughout different sectors in particular this case was important because it shows how one single product which was mainly used in of course in in in the business of of you know supermarkets and and food distribution but this product was also used by hospitals and and by medical service providers so it's a different sector so cross-sectorial information exchange is also critical factor which I think we need to examine to see how we can ensure faster and quicker pickup of this again I mean the commission has proposed within their review of the mandate of any mechanism whereby in particular for ransomware attacks when that wasn't a ransomware attack but we could have imagined that's a similar methods could have used by ransomware related threat access which is a mechanism of early alerts where NISA could potentially push out to the community and to to to the critical service providers this kind of vital information how to protect themselves and again in collaboration in coordination with national authorities so I think these kind of mechanisms the commission has proposed would be essential to prevent and protect europe in the repeat of such crisis in the future the question about ai is of course also very pertinent one of the reasons why why the commission puts in place of course the ai action plan is the the. Yeah the the importance
Speaker 1en
Highlight three areas in particular. First, utilizing—of course, also in relation to the other question of the Right Honorable Member—what is the problem there, the problem, of course, is that when utilizing the AI capabilities, threat actors are managing to find vulnerabilities, weaknesses within our systems very easily, quickly, they can exploit these weaknesses easily and quickly, and thus gain an advantage. Vis-à-vis the defenders, it will not be as easy for the defenders to just deploy AI agents in order to defend their networks, because they need to also ensure the security and resilience of the service that they provide. So just applying a patch quickly and also basically will not, or might not, solve your problems. It might create a bigger problem. So the defender is always at the disadvantage in this particular game. And an AI is, in this, in the long run, we believe that the AI can be also, of course, an opportunity, also for the defender, because AI can help the manufacturers, for example, to screen and validate that their products do not have vulnerabilities before they put them on the market. But in the short run, it is clearly more playing at the offensive field. So where the criticality lies, first of all, we need to utilize these capabilities in order to secure the common public goods in the digital ecosystem, which is the open source software. There are millions of libraries of open source; that's all products or product manufacturers are using, which service providers are using. And not all of them are taken care of. So the orphan libraries, the libraries which are used but not taken care of, these are the critical ones. We need to make an effort in order to secure them. The Commission has put in place a specific action plan in this area. We are following it, and this is coordinating together with the member states in order to secure the critical open source assets on the time window that we have. But we can't secure everything. And it takes money, and it takes people, and this is something that we all lack.
So obviously, we need to make some tough choices there. But we try to do our best in order to make sure that European service providers that are public administration are better footed to handle this storm. The second issue, of course, is capabilities. And again, I will follow the AI action plan in saying the Commission has foreseen that there needs to, together with the joint research center, is putting in place a testing lab for European entities and companies and critical service providers so that they can utilize these capabilities in the future in order to test. Their products, services, make sure that they have access to these capabilities when time is necessary. And then, of course, there are issues which are beyond the action plan, which are more concerning the industrial policy and the capability of Europe to create the ecosystem where the European developers can step in and provide these types of capabilities in the future. So I hope that I not only answered the question of Madam Niebler, but also the Right Honorable Gentleman who left. Now, when it comes to the questions posed by the President, very good. I mean, we have some time, so I will take a bit of time. To develop on it, first of all, in the cybersecurity committee, it is true that we have many platforms networks communities. And cybersecurity is not a simple or, let's say, straight way street. It is, because of the fact that it spans very many different sectors, product manufacturers, research community, educators, etc., we need the different communities to play the same game, which is cybersecurity game from our point of view. So that takes a lot of coordination and collaboration efforts. It takes also a mindset of creating a cybersecurity culture across these things. I'm not a big fan of unifying everything, because I don't think that that's an answer. But I do believe that talking finding a common vision and a common strategy is something that definitely helps. And that's where the Union Cybersecurity Strategy, of course, becomes very handy.
On the NIS2 and the review of this, I don't want to comment too much. I can just disclose one thing: that my constituents, which are the National Cybersecurity Authorities, once the directive was adopted, they came to me mostly complaining about why the directive is not a regulation. Which was quite interesting, I found. But I think there is a drive to find ways how to implement the EU cybersecurity framework in a much more efficient way, in a much more uniform, and much more coherent way. Now, is there a need for a specific cybersecurity legislation on top of the horizontal layer? I am doubtful. And I'll just bring you a couple of examples. Is there a difference between an incident report that happens in energy sector when it comes to cybersecurity, or when it comes to hospital, for example? The incident should reported in the similar fashion. The vulnerability should be managed in a similar fashion. Taken, of course, account the different context of the sectors. So the principles of cybersecurity do not change from sector to sector. The application might change, but the principles stay the same. So there, from the cybersecurity point of view, we would advocate for a horizontal approach for cybersecurity, for a simplified uniform approach on the grid, on how to implement the key principles and cybersecurity, whether it's an incident report, for example, or vulnerability management. And the Commission indeed has followed the same approach with the single entry point proposal within the digital omnibus, for example. Finally, the skills. What tools can we offer? If I would know the answer to this, I probably wouldn't sit in this bench. I would make a startup, and I would utilize this knowledge. For what we've seen so far is, again, it requires effort at different levels. So one of the tools that we need to apply is coordination and understanding where we are going so that different levels and different authorities can make pertinent decisions within the same framework or within the common vision.
What we have seen so far is that though more and more critical entities in critical sectors they rather than employing cybersecurity professionals, they engage with managed cybersecurity service providers to provide cybersecurity services for them. But these managed cybersecurity service providers do need skilled cybersecurity experts then in order to provide these services. So there is a need for more harmonization more consolidation, perhaps as well, so that there are similar levels of trust within the markets, so that we can trust different cybersecurity service providers. We can also trust different skill certification attestation schemes. So that there is a better movement of services across border, better provision of services, and a higher level of trust. Because again, no member state can do it alone. No sector can do it alone. There needs to be a cross-sectoral, cross-national collaboration on this. And skills is actually the domain where this collaboration happens. So if we don't understand what is the level of skill sets of a service provider, from a different member states, then there is a hesitancy from the part of the economy to engage into these services. Thus. The resilience will decrease. So I would say, yeah, trust frameworks, that's one of the toolbox within the skills area. Common attestations, certification frameworks, perhaps that would help.
Speaker 2en
Thank you also for the considerations. That could open a new debate in effect. Some other colleagues wanted to take the floor. Yes, please. Gonçalves, the floor is yours.
Speaker 1en
Thank you, Chair, and best wishes. Thank you also Mr. Lapassart for the work that ANIS is doing. I hope you don't need a startup to figure out also what tools we will need in the future for public institutions. And I think that in this matter we need to address what has happened in Europe over the past weeks. This is something that we recurrently speak at this Parliament. But these hybrid disruptions have been affecting different countries and different member states. Supermarkets, and I think even more importantly, blood banks have been subject to external manipulation that caused significant stock losses. And not to forget the phantom bomb threats on multiple flights in the European Union. All these events navigate a gray zone of causing harm without crossing a threshold of conventional conflict, and all warrant a serious consideration of our cyber preparedness. This is something that we have spoken over the past year on how companies are actually adapted to these scenarios. But I would have probably three questions for you. First, given the specific vulnerabilities, what would ANIS's highest priority be and recommendation to improve the European Union resilience? Second, do you think that we are facing a shortcoming of legislation, or is it just a matter of operational technology implementation? And third, but not least, on lead and high hand cybersecurity services, does Europe mostly rely on external contractors, or is our ecosystem sufficiently developed? Thank you.
Speaker 3en
Thank you. So I try to answer the questions as they came. Perhaps maybe there are different angles where you can look at the same problem. I already explained to Madam Niebler also the view of the agency when it comes to, you know, secure by design, secure by default in products that are circulating with the internal market. A question which I think the cyber resilience act puts fairly and squarely within the remit of the product manufacturers to fix. Of course, there are areas. Where public authorities like ANISA can help with putting in place specific guidelines for product manufacturers, how can they ensure that their products will be also designed in a secure manner. We just recently published a playbook for product manufacturers, specifically SME product manufacturers, for product engineers who are not security engineers, how can they engineer their products in the most secure fashion and maintain this security over this life cycle. So if you apply these steps, and it's not super hard, you can ensure a reasonable level of security of your products. At least reasonably from the point of view of self-attestation that the CRA demands. Now, that is a critical element, because we are all depending on the product manufacturers to actually implement secure by design concepts, not just tell that we like security by design, but actually do it in practice. And this is the key that will determine whether in the future the internal market will be more trustworthy and resilient or not. So we put a lot of efforts in helping the product manufacturers, European product manufacturers, of course, at first, but our guidelines are free for everybody, and they can be applied globally. We are also there to help with technical specifications with the help of technical specification is a kind of a mini standard essentially. Also standardization authorities to ensure that the standards are there and I know that there is a great effort now which is put in place in order to ensure that all the standards for the product
manufacturers will be delivered on time. When the CRA will kick in in first of December 2027. So there are things that we can do in order to help them, but ultimately the owners must lie on the manufacturers. The ones who deploy and maintain and circulate. Products in the markets. And there are, of course, the critical component for us is software when we talk about cybersecurity. So there is a digital element in the product. It's governed by a software, and this software needs to be also designed in a secure manner. There, again, the AI, and we know already, well, majority of software, majority of code which is written nowadays is written by AI. So the code developers, they use AI capabilities on to write code. They take components from other and it's super important as well that we know how to securely utilize the AI agency in order to write secure code. So that's again an area where the agency can help and has put in place guidelines. So I'm doing an advertisement campaign right now, but really look into the ANISA webpage if you are a code writer or a product manufacturer. What is, are we missing legislation or are we missing implementation? From my point of view, when it comes to legislation, it looks and we also observe that within the state of cybersecurity report, the legislative, the policy framework is more or less complete. There are no clear holes. Of course, as ecosystems change and are in flux, you need to plug from time to time, come with a specific element. Where we can do is consolidation and simplification. I think I can't say it enough, but I do believe that there is no a. Different way of reporting an incident or a vulnerability compared to the sectors. So we do not need 20, 30, 40 different ways of doing it. There is a simple way of doing it, and the simple way should work. And I would refer back also to the report of the Court of Auditors which was issued a couple of weeks ago where it said, the incident reporting framework, the situational awareness framework, the engine in Europe that has been put in place it has a lot of
sand in it. So it cannot work smoothly. And part of the sand, of course, is the different ways how things are implemented, the different notions. So simplification of the legislative framework is a very important drive. Consolidation as well, so that we have a better understanding who is responsible, who should take care of it. But the main effort should go to implementing what we have already put in place. Making sure that it does move the needle on the ground. And that's where ANISA will step in and I'm happy to step in as an agency as well to support member states to implement the framework, support the product manufacturers to implement the legislative framework, but also support the critical entities and critical sectors, the under the NS2. So that they implement the legislative framework in an efficient manner. I've scribbled something on the last, but I can't write I can't read my own writing, so external apologies.
Speaker 2en
Yeah, sorry, cybersecurity services on lead and a high hand if you think that we have already developed our own network or if we rely mainly on an external contractor.
Speaker 3en
It is, so there are two ways looking at it. I mean, it depends on the services as well, but ANISA is also on behalf of the European Commission running the cyber reserve. And the way that we run the cyber reserve is essentially that we engage with the trusted managed cybersecurity service providers so that when member states feel that they need support to respond to specific incidents or they need support in order to raise resilience of critical entities which under their own threat and risk assessments are targets we engage with private service providers so that they will help these member states. Now, all these private service providers that we engage with are European owned and controlled. So we spend European taxpayers' money to European businesses to help European companies. And we haven't seen that there is a significant market gap, that there is no provision of a specific service with European capabilities. So on this basis, I can say I can't see that there is an observable gap on this particular area. Now, of course, we know that there are perhaps other areas where we need to make sure that Europe has sufficient capacities, whether it's a, you know, having sufficient compute to actually utilize the. Frontier AI models or having the models themselves being developed in Europe. So that's another layer of services which so far, as ANISA, we are not meddling so much. But of course, through the AI action plan, we of course now together with the joint research center are putting in place a testing lab which would give us some information regarding whether the capabilities and how far the European market needs to go.
Speaker 1en
Thank you very much. For this interesting exchange of views, we if nobody wanted to add something else, we have finished our committee for the morning and let's see in the afternoon. Thank you very much.
Speaker 2en
Thank you.