Speaker 2en
Hello, hello everybody. Good afternoon. We start because there are five minutes past. But for me, because I'm very tired, I speak in Romanian. Please, for to listen a.
Speaker 2ro
Have you received the agenda? I will not read it out again. If you agree, we can go straight to the agenda. Also, Members have been notified of the interpretation service we are benefiting from and I thank the interpreters. We have interpretation in many languages. I would like you to listen. If it is easy for you in your mother tongue. I remind you that our sitting is being broadcast on the internet. It is also available on tablet, laptop. The voting system will be available tomorrow. Today, we will not be voting, but voting will only be possible in the meeting room. Therefore, you will need your voting cards. I could inform you that, right at the beginning, we have a few deadlines for amendments, namely for 11 November we have the deadline for the CIPSACT report. Would Mr Paulius Sodagar be so kind as to give his opinion?
Speaker 2en
I don't know it's correctly
Speaker 2ro
whether or not, and on 12 November we also have a deadline for the multimodal booking and passenger protection report on rail transport for a single ticket; the rapporteur for opinion is Mr Cosma, Mr Cosma Zlotovski from the ECR. We have the first item on the agenda. We have the Chair of the working group for the implementation of the Digital Markets Act, Mr Andreas Schwab, who is with us. And of course, today, for the first item on the agenda, we have asked the Chair of the group to present a report on the meeting held on 4 November this year, in no more than five minutes.
Speaker 1en
Andreas, te rog.
Barry AndrewsRenewde
Yes, thank you very much, Madam Chair. I am also tired, which is why I am speaking in German. But on the matter, of course, I am happy to also summarise the points in English. If I have understood you correctly, Madam Chair, I have five minutes, and since I am currently the only Member present, I take the liberty of drawing attention to this. Of course, I am delighted that you, Madam Chair, are chairing this meeting. But also at the last meeting of the Digital Markets Act Working Group, the DMA Working Group, the number of participants was rather low despite a highly interesting discussion. And so we need to think together, certainly then also with the Chair and the coordinators, about how we can continue our work in the working groups.
Barry AndrewsRenewen
Trotzdem nonetheless, I'm very happy to report back from the meeting that we had last week. The latest DMA Working Group took place last Wednesday. It was focused on the comparison of how the EU and the US approach competition in digital markets. In a similar direction, but with different means and different tools, with a focus especially on enforcement and on remedies. The two sides, so the US and the EU, because the European Commission was present as well as representatives from the state attorneys of the United States, the two sides share one goal and that's that market have to stay contestable and users have to have a real choice. We know that the tools are different. Europe combines ex-ante regulation through the DMA with the traditional competition enforcement angle. The US relies mainly on a case-by-case litigation under antitrust law, increasingly driven by courts and state authorities. State authorities because also they have a lot of possibilities to launch proceedings that in the past have also been done at federal level, but as there is a bit of a Trump bottleneck at federal level at the moment, it seems that there is less of activity there. So let me come a bit to the details. The outcomes look different too. In Europe, the DMA has teased and the Commission has started to use them. In July, it found Google non-compliant on two counts. Google search favored its own services over those of its rivals. Which cost it 460 million euros. Google Playbook developers from steering users to better offers, which costed it another 400, 30 million. That makes 809 million euros in one go and the third DMA fine after Apple and Meta. And the message from that seemed to be clear and the Commission has also defended it in the working group. The rules of the DMA for open markets also in digital are not a pure or a mere decoration. In the US, on the contrary, money changes hands through settlements. Negotiated by a state attorney general, 700 million dollars over Google Play pricing and privacy and on
privacy, 1.3 billion dollars in one case and 391 million in another. So you see that the amount of money on the other side of the Atlantic is even higher and the president of the United States isn't saying anything on this. So maybe the European Commission can become also a bit more courageous. Meanwhile, in the US, the big federal cases on search and edtech are still in the courts. Remedies and appeals are pending. So the final word is yet to come. In this regard, we had the pleasure of gathering two representatives of state attorney generals of DG Comp and DG Connect, as well as of Google, to have also a bit an open discussion of a company that was at stake in the presentations of both the European Commission and the state attorneys from Tennessee and Colorado. And what I can say to you, Chairwoman, is that overall, enforcement does not happen in isolation. The lessons from US proceedings and from our own should inform how we apply the DMA and, where needed, improve it. And I just want to share with you the view that also our American state attorneys were very clear that they share the basic logics of the DMA that they share the fines that the Commission has been putting out and they don't share the view that this is any sort of trade instrument, but they care as we do about openness of markets, about fairness of competition, and therefore the working group will keep following these developments further. And we believe that we have a very strong cooperation also with the United States in that case rather with the state attorneys and less with the federal level. But as in politics always, things may change soon. Sooner or later. And therefore I'm just grateful that the Secretariat, Chairwoman, is always perfectly preparing these meetings taking into account the proposals of the colleagues that are participating. There are plenty of people that complain. There are plenty of companies that would like to show that the Commission is sometimes going too far. We are there holding to account the European Commission to be sure that the enforcement of the DMA is going
further. And like that, I think we should continue. Thank you so much. For those that have helped, for those that have been attending and also for you, Chairwoman, to give me the time to report on it.
Speaker 2ro
Thank you, Andreas. Yes, I also believe that this working group is important and more people need to participate and contribute. The necessary conclusions. And certainly to share them with the European Commission, to see how we can improve things. That was also the purpose of setting up the working group.
Speaker 2en
Mulțumesc. Thank you, Sean.
Speaker 2ro
The next point on our agenda today I believe is extremely important and I hope it will also be followed online. SMEs and the EU’s SME test in practice – effectiveness and gaps. We have a study and I would like to thank for the exchange of views and the presentation of the study. To those who have taken on the responsibility and have come here today and are speaking here in front of Mr. Timotei Iong, Research Fellow, is a researcher associated with the Centre for Empirical Jurisprudence at Leuven. Also present is the committee through Digi Grow, I would like to begin with a 10-minute presentation of the study. After that, the committee will have five minutes to express its point of view, and then, of course, colleagues if they wish to share their own points of view. So, I would like to thank the researcher and give him the floor for ten minutes.
Speaker 1en
Thank you, Chair.
Speaker 3en
Dear Honorable Members, my name is Timothy Iong, PhD in Economics, Research Fellow at SEPS. Today I represent my colleagues and present this study on SMEs and the EU SME test.
Speaker 1en
In practice, effectiveness and gaps. Next.
Speaker 3en
Some background information. SMEs account for more than 99% of businesses in number in the EU. It is therefore reasonable to believe or assume that most of the legislation will affect SMEs. Indeed, in EU law-making framework, SMEs have been prominent. Just to name some examples, the 2008 Commission's Communication Think Small First is one of the guiding documents. Within the better regulation framework, there are SME filter, SME test, and SME check. The SME filter is an early step to determine if a legislative proposal is relevant to SMEs. The SME test is an assimilation of the proposal's impact on SMEs. And the SME check is a template for the presentation of the SME test. Besides, there is a network of SME envoys which include national representatives and some business associations which will be consulted when needed especially about whether a proposal is relevant to SMEs. And yet there are voices saying that SMEs bear significant burdens coming from EU legislation. So the main policy research question of this study is whether the better regulation framework has done a good job in balancing good policy and regulatory burdens on SME. Next slide please. The purposes of the study. We collected the impact assessment published between 2020 and 2025 and see how they considered SME impacts especially when they had a separate session or annex of SME test. In particular, we would like to see if the better regulation toolbox published in November 2021 made any differences. Also, we have six case studies. They allow us to go deeper into the details. Learn the good and not so good practices and consult six interviewees for their perspectives and ideas. Finally, we summarize the findings into 10 recommendation ideas. Next. Next slide please. Methodology. We check 224 impact assessments and identified 172 business or SME related impact assessments. Then we design a data collection template and had a team of researchers reading the 172 impact assessments. Besides, we used machine to read those documents and
produced some statistics. We have selected six cases covering different policy areas from AI to late payments regulation. Also, we have a case study template that ensures all cases are comparable. Moreover, we conducted six interviews. Which involved business associations and national representatives associated with the SME envoys. Next slide please. So first, let me show you the partition of the 224 impact assessments. As mentioned before, there are 172 business related impact assessments. Among these 172 impact assessments, 55 were published before 2022. Which we call the pre-2021 subsample. Because the 2021 edition of the better regulation toolbox was published in November 2021. So we are quite sure that these 55 impact assessments were not under the influence of the 2021 better regulation toolbox. Then we separate 95 impact assessments published between September 2022 and December 2025. We call it the post-2021 subsample. As we are quite sure that these were draft with the 2021 toolbox in place. In between, we have 22 impact assessments we call it the mixed or transition subsample. Next slide please. A very first statistics how often SMEs are mentioned in these impact assessments. We can see from this table the trend is increasing meaning that on average SMEs are more frequently mentioned by impact assessments from the pre-2021 46 times to the post-2021 106 times per impact assessments. Next slide please. So where on the impact assessments are SMEs are mentioned? We divide one impact assessment into 10 equal portions. And see on average how many times SMEs are mentioned in different positions of an impact assessment. Blue line represents the pre-2021 results and the green line represents the post-2021 results. We can see that everywhere the post-2021 average is higher than the pre-2021 average. Besides, the first peak of the post-2021 result which is at 20 to 30 percent comes earlier than the pre-2021 results. Meaning that on average SMEs tend to appear earlier in an impact assessment.
The final jump of the post-2021 result is obviously the consequence of the presentation of the SME test as an annex. So here we conclude that the 2021 better regulation toolbox indeed influenced how the commission draft their impact assessments. And SMEs and the commission becomes more aware of the SME considerations. Now I'm going to show you some other results which may not be as positive as this. Next slide. Next slide please. So we found that SMEs are less mentioned in the section of why should you act. It suggests that the commission might fail to relate the need for you action to the SMEs. Also, SMEs are seldomly mentioned in the monitoring and evaluation section. So meanwhile we see that quantification is on an increasing trend. But very often cost estimation does not differentiate SMEs from larger business. SME contributions to public consultations were limited but business associations usually replied. But what we failed to see is if those replies were influential. So some other useful findings. SME and innovation is often discussed. 95 times out of 172. Some more than SME competitiveness. But market entry and SME monitoring measures are less discussed. So next slide please. So we have six case studies but I will not go into the details. I picked only some of them in the I mean some of the findings in the presentation. Cost, quantification is often not matched. With benefits discussion. So that means the assessment cannot tell whether the legislation can justify the cost. In some proposals such as the general product safety regulation other principles take precedence over economic concerns. And therefore the space for SME consideration is quite limited. A more general observation is that the assessment does not differentiate the economic roles of firms and therefore the SME impact discussed in the impact assessments are too general to apply to actual businesses. In other cases SME impact remain qualitative and did not affect much the design of the policy options. Finally in the case of late payment regulation while the impact
assessment report in general positive feedback from stakeholders business associations in fact ask for the withdrawal of the proposal. So I would encourage you to read the cases if you are interested in one of the cases in the list. Next slide please. So now let me summarize some findings before present to you some recommendations. First we got an impression that SME test is a box taken exercise. With little influence on the choice of the preferred option. Two we sometimes found SME test and the competitiveness check overlap and there might be a better way to integrate or separate them. Three the condition of SMEs is not well understood and their roles in the markets are not well differentiated. Four the analytical support to the SME analysis is often poor without evidence. It gives an impression that SME analysis is to justify the commission's choices. Five concerning stakeholder consultations. The number of SMEs consulted is usually small. Next slide please. Sorry that I missed number six here. Stakeholders consultations are sometimes quite detached from the rest of the assessments. And concerns are not linked to the policy options. Seven there is a lack of monitoring and evaluation framework for SME impacts. Eight the RSB is working but lacks a stronger mandate to improve the quality of the impact assessments. Nine we found that SME considerations are often lost during the negotiations between co-legislators. Ten we have not found examples where the impact assessment considers the cumulative effects of EU legislations on SMEs. Next slide please. So now I present to you some recommendations. First the think small first principle should be fully implemented. That means the legislation should be designed for small entities. The cost estimation is based on the capabilities of small firms. Two the better regulation toolbox should be designed the tools for SMEs but not to jam the analysis with another tools. Three firms should not only be differentiated by their size but their economic roles
so that the analysis can better study the indirect or downstream effects along a value chain. Four an impact assessment should be transparent with the supporting data and analytical steps made available for verification and further studies. Five each public consultation should seek an adequate SME representation on top of the replies from associations. Six an impact assessment should demonstrate how SME consultation or the SME test influence the policy options and choices. Seven a proposal should introduce SME specific monitoring and evaluation measures. Eight the institutional oversight of SME considerations and impact should be strengthened. The RSB should play a bigger role and be more independent. Nine SME considerations should be maintained throughout the legislative process. SME test should not stop being relevant at the proposal stage. It should also be relevant during the negotiation stage. Ten the commission should regularly review the cumulative burdens on SMEs and provide more support. This is all of my presentation. Thank you very much. Thank you chair. And I welcome any comments and questions.
Speaker 2ro
Thank you very much. Even though it was more than 10 minutes, I believe the study is very important. And I hope we can have it for the entire committee. I am pleased that the European Commission will speak after the presentation of the study, because I personally greatly appreciate the outcome and the recommendations you have made, and I am very curious to see what the Commission has to say regarding the results of this study. Thank you. So, the Commission's representative will have five minutes. Commission, from Digi Grău, let me see the name immediately. It is Mr, madam, Mr, madam, Marie-Hélène Pradin. Pradin. Sorry.
Speaker 1fr
Thank you, Madam President. Thank you and honourable Members of the Parliament. First of all, I would like to thank you for commissioning this study. I believe we can only congratulate ourselves on the attention paid to SMEs and the way in which they are taken into account in the impact assessment. I will keep my remarks fairly general and would like to make a few points and draw your attention to the following. First of all, I believe it is important to point out that, in any case, our SME Unit and the team responsible for the SME test methodology was not at all involved or consulted for this study. We were not asked, we did not have the opportunity to express our views on the document, and that is a bit regrettable because from the outset we could also have contributed our expertise. Secondly, I believe that in light of the presentation that has been made, we can only note the progress that has been achieved over the period since 2021, since the Better Regulation Toolbox of 2021 was put in place. SMEs are mentioned more frequently in impact assessments, the quantification of costs has improved, even if it is not yet optimal, and the SME filter has been applied to all proposals since 2022. I mean, the figures speak for themselves: out of 224 impact assessments that have been published, the share of those that include an SME test has risen from 23% to 93% for initiatives that have been selected by the filter, and the mention of SMEs in impact assessment reports has also more than doubled. So this demonstrates a real progress in systematically taking into account the impact of proposals on SMEs in the context of legislation drafting. Obviously, there are still difficulties that remain. These have been highlighted by the study. To improve the quality of these impact assessments in particular, the lack of reliable data needs to be addressed by exploring, in particular, a more
targeted SMEs, recourse to proxy variables for qualitative elements where direct quantification is not possible, and finally more transparent communication on data gaps explaining why quantification was not possible. Thirdly, it is also about emphasising in the presentation, more than in the study, that the SME is merely one tool among others. It addresses one dimension, the SME dimension, at a very specific stage in the legislative cycle. We must not forget that this already begins before, at the very origin of the proposal, because as soon as an initiative is announced, there is a public consultation, there is an impact assessment, there is the drafting of the legal act, there are negotiations between the European Parliament and the Council, and then there is the implementation. So we try to intervene at all stages of this process. And that is why there is a whole series of tools that have been put in place, which have already been mentioned in the presentation: the filter, the test, the SME check, which is also recent. And today, I am pleased to announce that we want to go further and that there should be a new tool available in January 2027. It was announced in the strategy for the single market to improve the single market. In January 2027, we should publish a collection of what we call SME-friendly provisions, which are good practices, standard clauses that will be made available first to our services but also to legislators to draft legislation that. will be more favourable from the outset for SMEs. These are provisions that will cover key elements of the regulation on renewing support for SMEs at every stage, so to speak. I see that there has been feedback, so I will conclude fairly quickly. We have taken good note of the ten recommendations. Many of them have already been taken into account since 2025 and since the study. I can go into more detail if there are any questions.
Finally, I would like to recall that the simplification that is also currently being sought by the Commission, which is one of its priorities, is a bit the other half of the picture. I will mention the 12 omnibus packages that the Commission has already presented, which will bring their share of improvements for SMEs and will also ease their administrative burden. This has been estimated at €22.3 billion per year. Of which 7.7 billion euros solely for SMEs. And you all know that there is this objective to reduce the administrative burden on SMEs by 35 % by the end of this mandate. So to conclude, we are satisfied with the study. It shows the efforts, sorry, that have already been undertaken. Perhaps a quick reminder to say that for this change to be truly real, all institutions need to move in the same direction. Perhaps the best example is the regulation on packaging and packaging waste. Recently, which could have been more favourable to SMEs if it had been designed like this from the very beginning. I will stop there. So we also count on the co-legislator to take up this baton and improve the legislative provisions for SMEs. Thank you.
Speaker 1ro
Thank you very much, and now, following the presentation of the study and the committee's position, if the colleague from Renew has a point of view, I would also like to speak. I invite them to ask questions or request clarifications. Thank you.
Speaker 1nl
Ehm I will speak in Dutch. Well, thank you anyway, and yes, I certainly want to say something in the context of SMEs because, well, at the start of my mandate when I entered Parliament here, SMEs and simplifying matters for SMEs were high on my agenda. And also within Renew we have fully embraced the motto 'Think Small First'. So it is very important that we have this presentation. Thank you also for the study that has been carried out. And thank you also for the response from the Commission. Ehm the study, eh, of course, shows that there is still a lot to be done. Eh, but I also see the Commission, which indeed indicates that since 2021, and the figures from the study also show that, we have seen improvements. But not enough in my view. The eh Think Small First principle is still not being applied sufficiently, and we also see that reflected in the study. And I believe the importance of that lies particularly in the fact that entrepreneurs, especially SMEs, are confronted here with a piling up of rules. So the cumulative effect of the various rules that we make here in this House means that, ultimately, certainly the small entrepreneur does not have the capacity to review all those rules, to see them and to understand them. So what else can we do about this accumulation of rules? I see that the committee is already working on omnibus bills, you know. So what we call the simplification debate. That is of great importance. But we can, I think, also take further steps there. For the rest, it is of course important, as also recommended, to involve SMEs at an earlier stage. And it is a shame that the study notes that this is not yet happening sufficiently. In the effects, eh, the costs for SMEs and, of course, also in the way in which, eh, SMEs are considered in the regulations. And in that sense, eh, it is also important that we involve SMEs earlier, eh, so that, as the example of the Packaging Regulation was given, we do not again have to backtrack afterwards.
to row. Eh because that is double the work. So without wasting everyone’s time and first plunging SMEs into a crisis and into the stress of whatever is now being cooked up in Brussels. And that is unnecessary. Eh because I think it is important that we take that into account from the outset. So I would like to hear how we can better involve SMEs from the very beginning. Thank you, Mr President. Okay, thank you, Commissioner.
Speaker 1ro
and the distinguished researcher can respond to the issue because, from what I understand from my colleague, it seems that SMEs are not satisfied with what we are doing together here to make their lives easier. Who would like to open the debate or? I believe that research, study, if you can say something about what has been raised as an issue. How can we speed up and bring about a better effect ultimately on simplification and regulation that have an impact on SMEs?
Speaker 1en
Ъм so in my opinion or from the findings of the study uh the think for a small first principle should be fully implemented in a way that when the commission draft a legislation this they should say first think about the impacts on these small entities for example you know in some of the cases or in some impact assessment that we study the cost estimation is quite general which applies to all the businesses in the economy but in fact you know the most of the burdens would you know would be on the SMEs and usually they are the ones who lack the financial means to respond to the cost so I think there should be a change of the um of the way how the commission consider the impacts on the uh on the SMEs um so you know trying to fully implement the think small first principle and sometimes you know the SMEs are more like um additional analysis more like you know add on to the main analysis which is you know to me the opposite of the think small first principle. Thank you.
Speaker 1ro
Thank you. Commissioner, a response?
Speaker 1fr
Thank you, Madam President. Er, perhaps a small reminder and a remark on two main points. Er, on the Think Small First principle, er, so the idea of making legislation applicable for SMEs, er, I think I explained that in my previous speech. We are really trying to take it into account at all stages, er. There is first the filter. As soon as there is the idea of the proposal, then the test, er, then the SME check, which is now a mandatory annex of the impact assessment that goes not only to the Commission but also to the Council and Parliament. And soon, we hope, the development, in other words the provision of our services and the standard set of provisions for the College, which will take account of SMEs that go beyond, in fact, the impact assessment and the SMI test that we have in the impact analysis. So we are trying to have this comprehensive package right from the start to finish for SMEs. But perhaps I would like to make a second point. I mentioned this at the conclusion of my speech earlier: the proposal is indeed prepared by the Commission services, adopted by the College of Commissioners, but then it goes to the Council and Parliament. And there, if I may, there are often amendments and substantial amendments made. I am not saying whether they are justified or not, but very often they are not sufficiently assessed for SMEs. This is something we know has been acknowledged recently, and I believe the idea of working towards a method to evaluate these impacts across the three institutions would be a good thing to implement in a fully operational way. Of course, it is the collegiate work of the institutions to discuss the Commission’s proposals, make amendments and adopt them, but we would be available to also assess the impact that these amendments may have on SMEs, and not just before the proposal.
Thank you.
Speaker 1ro
Thank you very much. I will also have two questions. One for... Those who conducted the research, who carried out the study. You said in your presentation that, first and foremost, there is too little consultation of SMEs when a new legislative act is being drafted. And you spoke about late payments. My question now is, and perhaps the Commission will respond to this, SMEs are dissatisfied to a very high percentage in all 27 Member States regarding the functioning the directive on late payments, which has been in place since 2013 and is not functioning properly, and we have asked – at least I personally have asked – for a regulation rather than a directive to ensure uniform application across all 27 Member States. Because if payment is delayed for a large enterprise, the impact is smaller. If payment is delayed for a smaller company, the impact is certainly greater. What is your view, and could you explain what you meant by saying that companies should be differentiated not only by turnover and number of employees, but also by the impact they have on the economy and the sector in which they operate? Because I too tried in my country, in Romania, when I was Minister, to introduce taxation based on CAEN codes, since the profit rate and the ability to capitalise differ depending on the sector in which I operate, in construction, textiles, furniture and so on. I do not know what you meant, but perhaps you can explain. And to the Commission I will say frankly that I have not felt the functioning of the Small Business Act. I have not felt the functioning of ‘think small first’ and then we apply, and I myself say, as an SME, I do not know how you thought, oh, I do not know how you consider it works, I do not know who you consult to see whether they are satisfied or not. It is true that you said we can make amendments ourselves, but I know that I have been at the negotiator’s negotiation as rapporteur. The Commission is there in person and often opposes when we want to make a
change, and you know how difficult it is to get the Council on board, which also opposes when we, the Parliament, come forward with a proposal. But my question is, when you drew up the Packaging Regulation and the Waste Regulation, I am asking you directly, did you consult SMEs? I have held meetings with them many times on these two documents, these two regulations, and it is extremely burdensome for an SME to apply the Packaging Regulation and the Waste Regulation because I do not see here that there is any difference between a large company and a small company. They have to apply the same regulations. Thank you.
I therefore request a response.
Speaker 2en
Right. So I I could give a short answer to the question by by the chair. So when so. When we study the late payments directive or regulation case, this is very interesting case because on the impact assessments the commission said that in general the feedback from stakeholder is positive. And what they want is more like a a unified rule for all the sectors in the economy. They will follow the same the same rule and then SMEs are only differentiated in terms of their size. But that actually when we look into different comments and you know like opinions from stakeholders and associations um. They said no in fact you know the late payment situation differs significantly in different sectors. So there's no way that you could have one single rule that will help all the SMEs in all the sectors. So this this is you know how we've got the fundings that you know we fund in the impact assessments often SMEs are not differentiated according to their economic roles which is important when we try to understand the actual impact on the SMEs. This is this is my short answer. Thank you.
Speaker 1ro
Thank you. And now the committee?
Speaker 3fr
Thank you, Madam President. Perhaps you have asked several questions. I will try to address the different points. Regarding the Small Business Act, in fact it was introduced in 2009 and so it was before the establishment of all the tools that we have created. Since then, in terms of better regulation, before the SME filter, before the SME test, before the SME check, so this may explain why SMEs had not been sufficiently taken into account. You are no doubt aware that we recently adopted a communication last April to further improve matters, which highlights simplicity by design right from the start of the proposals. I would also like to remind you, regarding simplification, that as I mentioned in my introduction, the Commission has called for the adoption of 12 omnibus texts to date, but only three have been adopted. So we need time for the legislative process to reach its conclusion and for the proposals to be implemented before they can concretely bear fruit. We may regret the time it takes, but this is the normal timeframe for legislation. On the issue of payment delays, I fully understand your frustration. It is, moreover, shared at the level of the committee and my unit in particular. Three years ago, we had proposed a regulation to improve things. The Parliament was very supportive, but the Council blocked it. There were quite a few discussions; we tried to unblock the situation. Faced with this blockage and this inaction, you know that the Commission chose to withdraw the proposal from the work programme that was adopted last week. That does not mean, however, that we do not want to do anything to improve things. We are currently reflecting on what we can do to better implement the directive. Well, we will see how things and the discussions can evolve subsequently. Regarding the consideration of the heterogeneity of SMEs, because it is true that we talk about SMEs, but they are
by nature very different in terms of their size, their sector, between micro-enterprises and SMEs. In fact, in our SME test, when a legislative proposal has been deemed highly relevant, we take into account differentiation by size but also by sector. So this is something that we are trying as much as possible to reflect. Finally, on the packaging and packaging waste regulation, which, as we know, is criticised for creating additional administrative burdens for businesses, and in particular for SMEs. The fact remains that we must not forget the objective of the regulation, which is to improve the functioning of the single market for packaging and to create economies of scale, ultimately with a single set of rules. The idea is still to support a circular economy that reduces dependence on raw materials and improves the security of supply. The Regulation does indeed provide for an adjustment period and exemptions with simplified requirements, including for small businesses and micro-enterprises, which are exempted from certain reuse targets. We have noted the difficulties in implementation, which is why last December the Commission proposed an environmental omnibus that aimed to suspend the obligation for Union producers to designate an authorised representative when they sell directly to users in other Member States. This was intended to remove the significant burden associated with designating such a representative, as the designation of a representative costs a great deal for an individual company. The proposal is on the table, I believe, and we are all in the Commission keen for it to be adopted as quickly as possible. There have been quite a few discussions and a blockage in the Council, I believe, but discussions have resumed, so we can hope that this will improve things.
things, it will go faster, and you probably know that, as part of the Circular Economy Act, the Commission is preparing a broader, more significant reform of mandatory representative systems. This reform will focus on simplification, harmonisation and digitalisation. So we will try to provide a more systematic solution to this difficulty. Thank you.
Speaker 1ro
Yes. Thank you very much. Of course, things can always be done better, and I hope that we are moving in that direction because, as I was saying, the burden – and, well, the expectation – of SMEs is to regulate and simplify things. Certainly without deregulating, because it is good to have a regulated market nonetheless. I would like to thank Mr researcher Timothy Young and Ms representative of the Digi Grău committee, and I hope we can achieve, as you, Madam, said, better results. I regret that the committee’s proposal was withdrawn due to the deadlock created by the Council, but I hope we can still find a solution and move forward. I would like to remind you that we now have an important debate, I would say a very important workshop, the legislative act on digital fairness, on how online consumers can be effectively protected while ensuring coherent interaction with existing legislation. We also have, and I would like to welcome here the experts, including those joining online, thank you for participating in this workshop. The purpose of the workshop is to exchange views on how the future legislative act on digital fairness can strengthen the protection of online consumers while ensuring consistency and coherence with the existing EU acquis. And I also want you to know that the workshop is organised by the thematic department for the IMCO committee; the workshop is divided into two discussion groups. The first round table, the first debate, is on rethinking consumer protection in the digital age, and here we have Professor, Doctor Emilia Miscenic, Professor at the Faculty of Law in Rijeka – she is online, if she is connected, after 10 minutes.
Speaker 2ro
16.
Speaker 1ro
Next is Professor Doctor Peter Roth, Professor of Commercial Civil Law and Information Law at the University of Oldenburg, with a maximum of 10 minutes, after which, I assume, fellow Members of Parliament can intervene. I understand that Professor Emilia Miscenic, Professor at the Faculty of Law in Rijeka, is also connected. I invite you, Professor.
Speaker 3en
Uh thank you very much can you hear me well um honorable madam chair distinguished members of the committee uh representatives of the European Parliament uh of the European Commission ladies and gentlemen uh it is an honor to present this briefing requested by IMCO committee on the horizontal issues relevant for the forthcoming digital fairness act uh the title from the average to vulnerable consumer in digital environments um uh captures the central question that I intend to discuss whether the current uh benchmarks and definition um of the EU consumer law such as average and vulnerable consumer uh remain fit for purpose in the digital uh environments um next slide please. So allow me first to shortly outline the structure of the presentation I shall begin very very short overview of the policy trajectory leading to the digital fairness act uh then I will turn to the core of the presentation where I examine the benchmarks uh in particular in the context of the Court of Justice case law and in the second step in the context of digital environments uh where we will discuss new emerging concepts of digital vulnerability and digital asymmetry and in the end I will try to to offer some policy recommendations and options regarding the possible updates of the benchmarks um next slide please. So um as we all know uh the proposal for the DFA did not emerge in vacuum uh in 2020 new consumer agenda the commission asked whether further legislation uh was needed to ensure uh equivalent level of consumer uh protection in online and offline transactions and to use later the commission launched the digital fairness fitness check followed by public consultation the result came out came out in October 2024 and then followed uh the public consultation on the future digital fairness act in 2025 as we can see on the slide the most representatives uh were consumer and uh they agreed that and supported the new rules on dark patterns addictive design personalization harmful influencer marketing and so on however uh most of the respondents
uh expressed no opinion uh on the horizontal issues of benchmarks uh that we are discussing uh today so next slide please. Uh shortly on the fitness check because more or less we are all familiar with these results so on the basis of these five examined criteria that you can see on the slide um unfair commercial practices directive uh commer uh consumer rights directive and unfair contract terms directive were questioned and the general finding was that uh the current EU legislation uh in consumer law is overall efficient but uh its effectiveness is limited due to a high level of legal fragmentation the coherence between directives the themselves is fine but the external coherence especially with the digital key DSA DMA AI act and so on um there are issues um efficiency suffers from huge discrepancy cost when it comes to uh businesses compliance cost and the um online consumer harms which were at that time approximated um at 7. 9 billion per year so the the overall diagnosis um is very clear that objectives of directive remain highly relevant but legal fragmentation uh digital vulnerability of consumers and weak enforcement um undermine their goals so uh next please uh slide. Thank you. Uh we now turn to the core of the briefing uh where uh first we need to distinguish uh consumer definition and benchmark whereby uh the definition of the consumer is used to uh determine the personal scope of the relevant act uh while the benchmark is used as an interpretive tool um to help us to determine the level uh of protection afforded to consumer um so uh on the one hand we have this legal definition of the consumer defined by two uh cumulative criteria personal and functional criteria and across different EU consumer directives uh consumer is always a natural person acting outside of uh trade business or professional um activity and once we have um defined the person as a consumer then we can speak about the benchmark and about the position of the consumer in certain legal transaction and here on the slide you can see that during 90s uh the Court of
Justice uh established today an objective standard of an average consumer who is reasonably well informed reasonably observant and circumspect and this came by relying on the doctrine of um the so-called homoeconomicus um um and information paradigm meaning observing the consumer as a person who is making um rational and informed decisions and choices based on available and transparent information um this was later codified by the UCPD unfair commercial practices directive together with the subsidiary standard for particularly vulnerable consumers and today we are questioning whether these benchmarks uh which was established long ago uh still correspond to the needs uh of consumer in digital environments which are shaped by algorithms personal recommendations data-driven personalization and so on so um next slide please. Uh the Court of Justice case law holds on strongly on these objective standard of an average consumer and its applies also when interpreting other uh EU consumer directives such as the unfair contract terms directive consumer crediting directives um consumer rights directive however as mentioned uh the level of consumer protection may vary depending upon the factual circumstances uh of the case and uh court uh and case law showed a certain level of uh flexibility by bending or adjusting this standard uh so next slide please. Uh for instance here you can see just some excerpts from different cases in the famous Oceano Groupo case where there was interpretation of unfair contract contract terms or there were line of cases when it comes to interpretation of unfair contractual terms in credit or mortgage uh credit agreements the Court of Justice concluded that this average consumer is in a weaker position uh toward traders uh regarding the the both bargaining power the level of knowledge the available information um here we can see for instance Duarte Juero's Spanish case uh related to non-compliance of goods and the Court of Justice considered that the consumer who failed to invoke one of the the rights in the civil procedure was unaware
uh of her rights so this basically showed us that the benchmark is already uh context uh sensitive in practice and uh that there is a possibility um to codify this practice of the court of justice uh by retaining the the objectives standard while incorporating um the circumstances including digital ones which may transform uh an average consumer into a weaker and even vulnerable party so next next slide please. Uh which bring us to the benchmark of the vulnerable consumer uh which is currently recognized in the UCPD consumer rights directive AI act UK act and and other legislation in a similar but inconsistent manner and is predominantly focused on personal characteristics as you can see on the slide such as mental and physical informity age credulity uh while being less focused on external factors which need special attention in particular when we talk about challenges of of digital environments uh so next slide please. Uh in this respect according to the BUC report 2021 the digital vulnerability and uh connected uh digital asymmetry in B2C relationships uh these are connected notions and the vulnerability arises directly from structural architecture of digital marketplaces and therein used uh digital techniques um unfair manipulative practices which make consumer uh digitally vulnerable and quite very often result uh in transactional decisions which are not informed uh or rational rational ones so next slide please. Uh the asymmetry in the B2C relationships and in is increasing in digital environments and this is of course also recognized as you can see from again examples and excerpt from in the Court of Justice case law um which is um recognizing um the the impact of these techniques uh on consumer choices online um here we can see several cases but maybe because of the time limit just to mention the previously um uh mentioned uh Compass Banka on the previous slide where where it was acknowledged that the benchmark of the average consumer uh does not exclude uh taking into account
uh the influence of cognitive biases uh on the average uh consumer um so next slide please. Uh so therefore in the briefing um I recommend updating of both average and vulnerable uh consumer benchmarks by by keeping the the Court of Justice uh standard but by adding criteria which will reflect uh the challenges of digital uh environments and how to do so uh by introducing new concepts uh on digital vulnerability and associated digital asymmetry since these can obviously uh affect both average and vulnerable consumers in in digital environments next slide please. Uh of course the way of regulating will depend upon upon the form of the act and in my view the initial idea of the um avoiding the legal fragmentation by systematic approach of uh updating the question directives seems to be abandoned so whatever direction it goes uh the legislator needs to be careful in achieving external coherence with the digital a key because we all know that this might affect the enforcement next slide please. And here are the main conclusions that I have already mentioned because of the time limit I will not repeat them I thank you for your attention and I also thank you for for the opportunity uh as a vulnerable consumer to to give me the floor online because of my disability issues thank you so much for for the possibility and attention.
Speaker 1en
Thank you for
Speaker 1ro
Thank you very much, and I hope you will stay with us because there will be interventions from colleagues, as you have observed. The research by Professor Emilia Mișenici has focused on European private law, anti-discrimination law and consumer rights. It is now my pleasure to invite Professor Peter Rot, Professor of Civil, Commercial and Information Law at the University of Oldenburg. His contribution will certainly enrich this debate. His research focuses on the effects of digitalisation on private law, sustainability and ensuring compliance with consumer protection legislation. You have 10 minutes, Professor.
Speaker 1en
Thank you very much madam chair honorable members ladies and gentlemen um my task is to look at some more concrete aspects of the digital fairness act and um you probably all know that the digital fairness act or the draft has been leaked to the best possible moment which is after we have made our prepared our presentations and um I had 10 minutes to flick through it I'll try to relate to what I've seen and what I have what I am proposing next slide please so I don't uh I don't need to repeat all the um the the aims of the DFA I just wanted to to mention that most of them increasing legal certainty reducing legal fragmentation avoiding friction simplification of the legal framework is would benefit everybody consumers as much as traders who would have a a clearer framework to deal with and of course the internal market and uh of course all this should happen at a high level of consumer protection next slide please. So what I want to do is to look at three practices dark patterns influence a marketing and personalization practices and some practicalities like the burden of proof and precision of small traders and I will go through them by identifying gaps in legal uncertainties um potential frictions with other legislation and then uh give. Some possible solutions next uh slide please. So starting with dark patterns of course we have some existing legislation but it only uh covers certain aspects the DSA only covers online platforms the consumer rights directive only um the distance selling of financial services and the AI act only dark patterns produced by artificial intelligence whether or not the UCPD covers them or to what extent uh is subject to not only academic discussion but also to conflicting already conflicting case law uh in the courts uh and the same um uh applies to the uh to data protection law the GDPR where of course dark patterns could impact on free and informed consent but to what extent they actually do and what the benchmark is is again uh discussed very controversially
um so next slide please. Um everybody feels a clear need to regulate dark patterns um in particular also the consultation respondents and the possible solutions and that's the one that uh I have seen has been chosen now by the commission is a clear prohibition in the UCPD an exemplary list of dark patterns to concretize what what this broad notion actually means to give guidance to um traders in particular what they are allowed to do and what not um and to give the power to the commission um to concretize these uh these the various forms and types of dark patterns further in delegated legislation what I would add um what I haven't seen yet is um even to try and standardize certain legal requirements where there is no need to give you know creativity to traders and my prime example would be cookie banners where I can't see why everybody needs a different one next um thank you. Um next point influence a marketing um which is not explicitly covered yet at EU level but of course um the UCBD would apply to influence a marketing um because influence is are or can be traders again the question is in what circumstances are are they traders and the UCBD applies and what exactly do they have to do to flag up what um that they're using commercial communication um here we can um already see a lot of legal fragmentation within the European Union and even within member states with uh Spanish legislation that has come up um and implementing the audio visual media services directive um with the German special rule in in the German unfair commercial practices law with the most comprehensive system in France and with diverging national case law next slide please. Again there is a clear need for regu uh for regulation and um I've seen there is one in the uh in the proposal so we need a special provision clarifying who's a trader and what exactly needs to be disclosed I would also advocate standardization of disclosers so what what do you have to say and um I can I've seen that the the proposal of
the commission offers two um two notions that can be used advertisement and commercial cooperation which I think is a great idea and then there are aspects in particular from French law that deserve to be taken over which is special protection of minors when it comes to um to influences and special areas um in which influence so areas that are of particularly risky it could be health uh could be financial services where it may not be a good idea to um have influence a marketing. So there could be some prohibitions. And there are some in the proposal. Um another aspect which has come up and which I've also seen is it should be clear that traders that use influences to market their product should be liable for what they do. So they should be um they should have the the duty to maybe teach them what they are allowed to do what not and they should be liable if they if they don't comply with the rules. Next slide please. Personalized pricing my favorite one um there is some explicit legislation but it is uh tend uh usually conceived to be insufficient um because there is only mere information obligations in the consumer rights directive and the consumer credit directive saying that personal pricing is applied but not how so that consumers can't really understand what it means um otherwise when it comes to the UCBD there's legal uncertainty uh some have advocated to to deal with um personalization of prices as material information in terms of misleading omission but that has never been tested in court so we don't know um there is certainly there is um there are gaps because the CRD and the CCD don't cover everything and therefore a need for regulation possible solutions next slide please would of course the most radical one would of course be a total prohibition of personalized pricing that actually most respondents would prefer um lesser solution would be an opt-in system or an opt-out system where you could uh choose not to be subjected to personalization practices um at the very least one could um
and that's that's what I have seen in the in the proposal um one should prohibit um using sensitive data for personalization and one should not target minors with personalization practices. Um and of course if one did that one should adjust the other uh legal acts the consumer rights directive and the CCD accordingly personalized marketing next slide um. Same issue of course there is some GDPR some data protection law in the background because personalized marketing uh implies that someone has acquired personal data in the first place but that is at a time long before the marketing and everybody knows that nobody reads the data protection declarations anyway so that's not um very helpful um um otherwise to what extent it may be covered under the UCBD again is quite unclear and there could be aggressive practices dealing with that but we don't uh again that hasn't been never been tested in court again people feel that there is a need for regulation and to possible solutions next slide are pretty much the same as when it comes to personalized pricing it could be an opt-in or an opt-out system or at least the prohibition of the use of sensitive data and the prohibition of personalized marketing towards minors the last two points are I've seen in the proposal the first one unfortunately not um next slide when it comes to practicalities um everything stands and falls in this black box area with the burden of proof if you leave it to um consumer organizations or individual consumers to prove that there are dark patterns in the web design um there will be no enforcement no private enforcement and it's you you're stuck with public enforcement that may work in some member states but not in others um the current rule of article 12 UCBD is clearly insufficient for many reasons because first of all it only relates to fact but not to web designs and um it leaves the application of the rules to the discretion of the court um apart from that many different standards have developed in the member states and some are more friendly towards the claimant than others
so there is surely a need uh for regulation in particular also with regard to a level playing field in the different member states next slide please poss the the the poss the solution that I um would see the most convincing is for to follow the model of the of the the product liability directive that has just been reformed and deals with the exact same problem of the black box issue uh when it comes to smart products etc so there should be a right to disclosure where for example um a dark pattern or price personalization is made plausible by the claimant so it looks like you know you see different prices and it can't be explained so that it's quite plausible that there is something in the background um and then sanctions um if the web design is not disclosed by the trader um there's also something about to say about the standard of proof so what to what extent do you need to convince the court do you need full proof or just a probability that uh there is a dark pattern in the background again different standards in the member states next slide now we've we've uh just discussed SME so I have something on small traders as well um in the sense that many small traders don't design their websites themselves but they buy the website as it is from sellers like Shopify and they don't necessarily know what they are doing they wouldn't possibly know that there is a dark pattern in the background or a personalization practice and the question is would do do we need to protect them in some way and um possible solution and again I've seen that in the in the proposal is a redress claim against the third party who who may have sold them or or designed their website uh including a dark pattern or including a personal an unlawful personalization practice um it's a system that we find in the sale of goods directive and also in the digital content digital services directive and it makes sense to to get these third parties in to the system you could even include them um more directly like in product liability law as third persons who are responsible for the dark pattern in the first place and if
you could target them directly you could pick the problem at the root and not only at the many emanations but that's not in the proposal um apart from that one could think of a somewhat relaxed liability taking into account that the UCBD um is an objective piece of law so you only need the breach but no negligence to be liable um but that's a political decision uh last one I just uh in terms of the simplification agenda I just wanted to mention that um clear prohibitions and clear standards could also reduce the um the the confusion and um complexity and therefore reduce transaction costs would make life simpler and it also could um bring about a more level playing field between big traders and small traders because big traders can afford personalization practices and small traders may not be able to do so and um big traders may um be able to uh create dark patterns in their web designs which small traders may be unable to thank you that was
Speaker 1ro
my presentation, thank you Mr Professor. I have just listened to Professor Emilia, I hope she is with us, and to Mr Peter Ruth. Now, dear colleagues, according to the principle of 'cash di', if anyone would like to intervene, ok.
Speaker 1en
Dora David thank you chair um thank you very much for the comprehensive overviews it's very helpful to see um the outline of the problems and possible solutions um I have a question around how we can future proof um solutions because I think we already have um future proof solution we have principles based consumer laws so you mentioned the UCPD with regard to um dark patterns I think uh they clearly do cover uh dark patterns because you know dark patterns lead the consumer to take a transactional decision that they would otherwise not have made had they been aware of the the design so with the expansion of a blacklist which seems to be the solution proposed in the DFA in your view how will we ensure that the law is future proof and doesn't need to be updated every two minutes um you know I think guidelines are more flexible in this regard um and I want to make sure that we don't remove the flexibility of a principles based regime that we already have thank you
Speaker 1ro
thank you very much SND Crystal
Speaker 1en
thank you very much first and foremost thank you for your presentation today we're quite interesting and useful the upcoming work with the DFA uh first uh to uh to the question about um average versus vulnerable consumer I think uh I'm not really sure that uh also as you said professor I'm not sure that that way of looking at consumers today makes that much sense I would not count myself as being a vulnerable consumer uh I'm well educated and uh can read and write and understand the different languages uh etc etc but even I fall into uh problems sometimes when I'm online buying goods being kind of uh you know tricked uh so the question is you know honestly I maybe we should go away from that having average vulnerable consumers but just talk about consumers and make sure that we are protected no matter what uh uh that that goes you know for you know could be dark patterns but it could also be whether this web shop is is kind of you know sometimes I buy and believe that I'm buying from a Danish web shop uh of course I've learned the tricks now how to check it but uh but still I can be cheated here as well uh so so I think I would like to kind of answered it but but I think that today being a consumer being digital and buy online you don't have the same protection as you have in the offline world if you buy good and it's broken you go down to the shop where in the past you get down to the shop ask them about what you do and they would explain your rights etc you had a person you could talk to today you don't know you you cannot necessarily get into contact with anybody you don't get a reply or if you get a reply it it might be generated by a chatbot and you can use it for any purposes and you don't know where you stand if you have to uh return the goods even though we also have good used to have good protection on that as well so my question is on on average vulnerable whether we should keep on having this at all and just talk about consumers uh and uh and on on all the good suggestions uh
we just heard uh from the second uh presentation uh about uh prohibition and and personal pricing etc etc um. Here also I'm I'm considering uh well. If we put things on a list uh and and and ban it uh isn't there a risk that uh the shops uh or uh the platforms will just invent new tools that makes it even more difficult uh I. Have my I don't know honestly I'm I'm really have doubt about how to do this I want consumers to be better protected than they are when they're going online buying things but also risking if we're too precise that it will be so convenient is also something that I'm a bit scared of we have seen examples of that that once we come up with the idea and they find ways to so convenient those ideas and that's why I hesitate a little bit about banning things concretely um and and so also on the DSA when we talked about dark patterns it was more in general because it is difficult to describe it in a way where we can cover everything so it's better to have the term in and then you know all to have the courts help us deciding by ruling on the cases so I have my doubts I would like to hear your point of views on how you look at that uh but uh but just in general I do think that we are not protecting consumers enough when they're online and the thing is that it's difficult to find the right way to do it the right balances where we don't want to destroy it for those who are the good guys but we want to make sure that the bad guys are are uh stopped and then you know we also tackled some of it in the DSA but I think in general we need to make sure that some that it is possible to get into contact with somebody at a shop even though it's online thank you very much thank you very much Crystal uh Renew yeah maybe short remark uh thanks for the presentations um I'm curious to the answer also to the question why not all consumers and not make the difference uh in the presentation it said do not take a step back uh but uh I I think at this moment in time it's really all consumers are at risk if if you may call it like that
um and on the other hand on uh you need to call somebody of course within the uh um customs uh regulation with the uh the responsible person discussion uh what difficult do you see now within the implementation Mulțumesc. Green thank you so much uh for your very interesting presentations um I uh guess um looking at uh the DFA um from our group's perspective or the league that we saw uh we can say that we're quite disappointed uh on some of the things that we've seen um I think especially when it comes to dark patterns and specifically addictive design um we have many times also in this committee acknowledged that that is one of the biggest challenges we have for both our health and democracy not only for kids not only for vulnerable consumers but every consumer there's no one who uh can uh actually go against these manipulative tricks um so uh this in my view would be historic mistake if it stays this way um but now I'm very very curious actually how our experts uh see it because what now is uh what we've seen now in the league is that uh as the tech companies wanted there will be an opt-out instead of an opt-in um I don't see any other way that did this will turn out in practice as another stupid cookie banner where you have to before you enter any website or any app have to click which kind of addictive features should do or do not want uh we already know what that's going to look like in practice and I think it's going to be horrible but if you have any other ways that you see this turning out very curious to hear um and also uh how do you see uh the fact that uh probably the most extreme social media algorithms that are the most addictive uh things that we are seeing are most probably exempted uh or at least not covered by the latest league um and then when it comes to um the mention of um you know unfair practices um it seems that the commission chose to go mainly for transparency uh rather than actually um you know trying to uh limit uh some of these dynamic pricing uh practices um are there
any studies that you know of that transparency will actually support consumers uh uh and whether that's uh that's a good idea um once again I think if we if we don't uh take these steps right now we're making a historical mistake as uh as Europe uh both in uh failing to protect our consumers but also protecting our democracy so curious what will actually come out on Wednesday thank you very much mulțumesc
Speaker 1ro
și acum dacă doamna profesor Emilia Mișcenic este încă conectată o rog să dea răspuns și după aceea domnul profesor Peter Rut
Translating…
Speaker 1en
uh thank you very much um thank you for your questions uh which are uh not only interesting but they are really to the point I actually agree with the with your uh statements and um maybe this was misunderstood in the presentation because as I said in the briefing I I actually do recommend that this average consumer benchmark which needs to be updated and which was created by the court of justice uh needs to be updated in the sense of uh acknowledging that we are as you said and explain uh all vulnerable uh digitally uh but when it comes to vulnerability um and um I was of course thinking a lot about it reading a lot about it this distinction as you said between um vulnerable and average consumer which um exists in the from unfair commercial practices directive um I wrote about it years ago that we have to make this distinction between digital vulnerability and uh consumer vulnerability as um prescribed by the uh unfair commercial practices directive because um under commercial practices directives um consumer vulnerability is uh focused on these certain certain personal characteristics uh where we look as I said informative we look at the age and usually what is meant of course under consumer which are particularly vulnerable are children are elderly people and there are studies actually studies from the European Commission um years ago um um covering uh practices online and showing that um there is actually a distinction between average and and vulnerable consumer and that digital techniques unfair um commercial practices affect vulnerable consumer more than than average consumer although uh this is very very interesting discussion and we should really think about as you said whether we should change the legislation uh to to merge to merge it all on Thursday I don't know whether you have noticed there was a orcla case uh the the judgment came after our briefing uh where the court of justice uh which I said said um explained the benchmarks came up with the interpretation of the notion of the definition of the consumer and
uh the image was again distinction there was average consumer but then it was interpreted that this average consumer can also encompass as you mentioned vulnerable consumers such as kids although it was a case about design of detergent uh that can mislead by the packaging the the kids uh we can by analogy use it also for digital vulnerabilities and say that there are categories as as the court mentioned the risk of confusion in these by these categories is heightened uh when it comes to to to to these categories so I'm not sure whether I have managed to to to explain but I think that basically we agree on these points uh that that as you said both are we are all vulnerable uh digitally and exposed in certain cases of course it depends from case to case thank you thank you very much now Mr. Professor Rot well yeah thank you for these um challenging questions um let me start by saying um. I think I I I indicated in my short presentation that I could have imagined a higher level of protection in certain areas and the question is always do you want to wait for the perfect solution or get nothing and and get nothing in the meantime or do you want to get some progress I think there is some progress in the proposal um and I think there are some gaps as well um transparency I'm very skeptical uh I have two boys of 17 and 22 and I'm very worried that they would get anything out of this um in particular that generation is I think is lost for for transparency so I can't see that uh that this is very helpful um as to the questions of future proof regulation well of course consumer law has always been like the fairy tale of the hair and the hedgehog um once once the legislator comes up with something the the hedgehog is has already on the other at the end of the of the lane so comes up but again that cannot be a reason to do nothing about the existing problems um so I think well you can tackle what you what you have and um you need to remain flexible and of course nobody wants to give up the principle based approach as
a fallback option where you don't have specific rules um you of you of course you need them um but otherwise I think this layered solution of having the principle having um concrete examples and then even a a description or a concretization of what these examples like or dark patterns actually are is um a re and plus the flexibility uh that comes in with um delegated legislation uh in that area that the the the draft provides for an article 103 um is sort of the best you can do at the moment if you instead wait for the court system to solve the problems you wait for a long long time because I mean I'm from Germany and um at least in Germany we have a lot of case law and if there is case case law anywhere in the EU it's in Germany because we are a litigious society and everybody wants to sue everybody um but if if we look at other member states you will have nothing for the next five or 10 years and that that can't be the way forward so I think um concrete examples in that in the legislation plus some flexibility with delegated legislation or or if there is no delegated legislation at least guidelines um but forward looking guidelines not guidelines that only summarize what has already been decided by the courts because that that we know already um is the best you can do at the moment um opt in opt out yes I totally agree I mean opt in is so um uh opt out is so far less efficient than opt in um that is has always been the preferred option of traders because they know nothing will happen um it's a political decision
Speaker 1ro
thank you very much to Professor Emilia Misenici and Professor Peter Rot and to the colleagues who, through the questions they asked, supplemented the information that the professors provided us with, and I hope that the committee will also take into account what the specialists recommend. Thank you very much. We now move on to the next equally interesting legislative act on digital fairness. Here we have Assistant Professor at the Faculty of Law and Administration, University of Kraków, Mr. Palca – the other name is difficult to pronounce – you have up to 10 minutes to make your presentation, and we thank you for being here.
Speaker 1en
madam chairman honorable members of the committee ladies and gentlemen thank you very much it's a great honor to be here with you next slide please in my written contribution I was asked to address two questions first of all how one could understand addictive design in the digital furnace act and what are the regulatory options on the table and second what are the pros and cons of thinking of the digital furnace act as a regulation or a directive and if a directive whether what are the arguments for or against minimum or maximum harmonization this questions will structure also my presentation oral presentation today next slide please we've been talking about addictive design in official union documents for more than half a decade now it was prominently mentioned in the UCPD 2021 interpretative guidance by the commission since then we have two binding instruments DSA which only mentions addictive design in its recitals but has certain obligations directed at vlops which might be used to combat addictive design and the AI act similarly article 5 there are certain ways in which one could imagine being used against addictive design and in the interpretative guidance we also here see it mentioned there was obviously in the meantime the 2023 resolution by the European Parliament which called on the commission to do something about the addictive design and in September of this year we've seen addictive design the proposition. To regulate addictive design in the proposal for the EU Kids Act and today we have seen leaked the unofficial still yet proposal for the digital fairness act next slide please in this sense one needs to remember that there are instruments already binding on the table and the DFA obviously needs to be compatible with all those we don't want this to be in any way incompatible but at the same time one can learn from the limitations of the existing documents we have seen in the leaked proposal that the idea for the DFA is to repeal the UCPD so we will be replacing the UCPDD if it gets adopted in the way that it was proposed other than that
we have DSA and AI act already binding and the EU cuts EU Kids Act being discussed in the meantime next slide please when discussing if I could please ask for the next slide when. Discussing the notion of addictive design what needs to remember that the very word addictive brings into mind the association with health unhealthy lifestyles adult things that are addictive like alcohol like tobacco like gambling and in some situations when it comes to specifically excessive use those are correct intuitions however one also should remember that from the medical from the psychological perspective not every engagement in behavior more than one would like to or more than someone else thinks that one should counts as an addiction from the psychiatric perspective behavior. Addictions are recognized very seldomly in the DSM-5 which is one of the two reference points only gambling disorder is considered addiction in the psychiatric sense in ICD-11 there's also gaming disorder however all those other behaviors one engages in more than one would like to are not really recognized by the medical community yet of course there are psychiatrists that have proposed that we also recognize social media addiction however there are certain criteria that if this becomes a disorder would need to be met in order for someone to be considered addicted these criteria include salience mood modification tolerance withdrawal conflict and relapse just like with many other addictions next slide please in this sense the fact that certain consumers believe themselves to be addicted or certain consumers think they have some type of problem does not necessarily match how many people are actually exhibiting the symptoms even if one accepted the currently proposed criteria in the literature I've cited some studies in the contribution which show that it is about 10% of people in the population that can be said to suffer from those criteria while at the same time people who claim to be addicted in various studies that are also cited the number there is much higher this is
important because if it is health that is being presented as the primary reason to regulate addictive design this will also be the primary way primary field in which the traders will defend themselves by saying that look not everyone using our service more than they would like to is actually addicted it's called addictive design this will be one of the possible avenues. For defense one can imagine next time next slide please of course the union legislature is absolutely free to give the notion of addictive design an autonomous meaning we can define it the union can define it in in isolation from how psychiatrists psychologists think about addiction and then one faces the question of how exactly the addictive design should be defined what we've seen in the proposal the leaked proposal of the DFA is that there is a list of certain features that should be count should be counted as examples of a trader using addictive design however this is not the only possibility one could also imagine a general clause and one could also imagine some sort of general ban on based on the general clause however again all those solutions have pros and cons what I think one should bear in mind is that the root cause of the provider's using those features is the business model which is ad driven the more time consumers spend online the more money the providers make as was already mentioned by the honorable member in the discussion about the previous presentation next slide please another. Thing I would like to point out is that it is. Not necessarily the case that the problem of addictive design needs to be addressed in the DFA in one horizontal manner against all possible traders one could imagine various measures being used ranging from flat prohibition through some type of risk management like for example we have in the DSA against vlogs or the information obligations which is the least intrusive way for traders and possibly least helpful for consumers but one could imagine that there would be certain types of services that need to abide by certain measures other types would be abiding
and others we could imagine a world in which social media have different regulation here than for example providers of video streaming services or shops etc etc so right now in the in in the leak draft we have this one general article addressed at all the traders that is the opt out from the features that are listed in the regulation which can be amended by the commission however one could imagine that there could be more nuance here next slide please ultimately what choice is being taken will be dictated by what exactly is the goal that the DFA is supposed to achieve a goal of better consumer protection or easier compliance is the kind of goal that everybody can agree on but it's about the question of how exactly do we operationalize better consumer protection what exactly do we want to achieve that would dictate the choices here there is a possibility of a world in which we can imagine that in certain types of services or for certain types of consumers we don't want exposure to addictive design whatever we choose to it to mean at all in certain types of services we want the consumers to be able to switch it on and off but we could also imagine that in certain types of services or certain types of consumer. We just want to inform them just like for example we do with cigarettes no they're really bad everybody knows they're really bad but we put the sign so that the adults can make that decision next slide please when it comes to the second question of whether it should be regulation or directive we've seen that the proposal is for regulation there are obvious and known reasons to all of us why regulation provides most uniformity most legal certainty at least on paper as I think we have seen over the last five years where almost all the acts took the form of regulation however there are certain problems with various national versions of the regulations when they are to be applied in practice it is one thing to properly translate. The regulation which our translation service does amazingly but then those regulations need to be applied by the lawyers in the
member state that have been trained in a particular member state and sometimes those notions just have different meaning even if it's properly translated there might be some divergence unexpected there legislators in the national context also see are like sort of the second layer of possibly controlling for that at the same time a directive would fit the consumer a key and that would be a solved problem next slide please and. The question of whether it should be maximum or minimum we've it's been a long time since we did minimum harmonization in consumer law and there are all the known reasons why we should not do that however I would kindly point to the fact that when it comes to addictive design at least the prime offenders are not European companies they come from United States they come from China and so the question of whether the trade-off between high level of consumer protection and easy compliance is the same I think is out in the open on the table whether we want to make it cheaper for Meta or for Bidens to comply with our laws I I don't think there is an obvious answer to that moreover it's possible that we don't really know what the best way to address addictive design is and there is some gain to be had when member states can experiment you all know ladies and gentlemen better than me how difficult it is to legislate in the European Union how long it takes for a law to be enacted how long it takes for a law to be reformed so maybe if there's a member state that can master political will at home to pass some legislation whether it's enforceable or not it's another question but that could be elaboratory in which we can sort of allow other entities to come up with solutions because it might be the case that today we don't know the best the commission leaves the door open through the through through the possibility to update the list however where the ideas will come from I think is an open question this is everything I wanted to say thank you very much for your attention and I look forward to your comments and questions
Speaker 1ro
Mulțumesc foarte mult și acum am plăcerea să îi invit pe șefa de unitate de la Digi Just doamna Maria Mio a Canel Canelopulu
Translating…
Speaker 1en
It's correctly that is excellent okay thank you very much chair thank you honorable members and also a big thank you from the side of the commission to the experts who intervened in today's workshop indeed you touched upon some of the key aspects that we have been examining in preparation of our proposals for additional fairness act that the commission is expected to examine on the 11th of November so in a couple of days time today's workshop for us is very timely not only for us as commission but also for the co-legislators it will it can inform the interinstitutional process that still lies ahead of us and help us arrive collectively hopefully to a very solid legal text that makes rules clear simpler and more effectively enforceable in practice this has been a key consideration for us I'm sure you will all understand that a that we are not able to comment in detail today on the upcoming proposals I would like however to reiterate three key elements also in reaction to the presentations that we heard today first of all to remind everyone that the digital fairness act is the result of a very long journey which which started already in 2024 with the publication of the findings of our digital fairness fitness check of horizontal consumer protection rules we have since consulted very broadly to prepare the impact assessment for the DFA we had a call for evidence and a public consultation that received over 7,000 responses we had several surveys with targeted service with consumers businesses civil society we of course liaised with academia looked into behavioral research had a youth dialogue and implementation dialogue on simplification all this is to say of course that we have to take into account of into account various elements when formulating our proposals we paid particular attention as was signaled today also to recent case law by the court of justice and I would like to thank again the European Parliament and the IMCO committee for keeping the topic of digital fairness very high up on the agenda throughout you will not be surprised
to see that the resolutions the debates that this committee has had have informed the proposals that the commission will be examining on on Wednesday secondly in terms of content indeed we have touched upon and assessed the full range of issues that have been highlighted today in line with the mandate that was given to Commissioner McGrath together with Vice President Virkunen to combat unethical techniques online such as dark patterns marketing by social media influencers the addictive design of digital products and online profiling when consumer vulnerabilities are exploited for commercial purposes we also looked in indeed at some horizontal questions such as the benchmarks of average and vulnerable consumer when calibrating our proposals our objective has been to stay targeted and proportionate in our intervention to provide a meaningful digital update to EU consumer production rules that already apply horizontally to all business to consumer practices to all companies that are active in the single market and work as a safety net on issues such as pricing advertising selling contracting and other commercial practices we tried to reconcile indeed and this was a topic that was highlighted I think in couple of interventions what currently works really well with our horizontal consumer protection rules which is this flexible principle based nature of the rules reconcile that with the clarifications that we think are necessary to make these rules implementable and enforceable in the complex digital environment we have also given thought to how we can integrate elements in the proposals to make these rules future proof and able to be updated to keep pace with technological developments final points we have recent listened very carefully to the strong cause for ensuring coherence and complementarity between the digital fairness act and the existing digital rulebook which we are actively implementing and enforcing in practice I'm sure you have seen the latest the latest announcements on the implementation of the DSA the DFA will not affect the
current relationship between horizontal consumer protection rules and sectoral legislation our intention is not to duplicate rules such as the DSA the audio visual media services directive and the AI act but to update indeed the baseline horizontal protections in a targeted manner that keeps them fully coherent and complementary with the digital rulebook our proposals on the DFA should of course also be read in conjunction with the upcoming EU kids with a recent proposal of for an EU kids act there the commission put forward very concrete rules for the protection of children who are indeed particularly vulnerable as online consumers for example on key aspects such as addictive design on the commission side we will continue to work very closely digi just and our colleagues in digi connect as we have done for the preparation of the proposals also throughout the negotiation process to make sure that the legal text develop in a manner that is both clear mutually reinforcing and coherent thank you very much
Speaker 1ro
Mulțumesc foarte mult iată avem și poziția comisiei vreau să vă informez că serviciul. De cercetare a Parlamentului European a făcut un briefing foarte interesant și vi l recomand legat de ceea ce se va întâmpla peste câteva zile și acum întrebări din partea colegilor la. Te rog din partea SND
Translating…
Speaker 1en
Thank you chair and thank you to to the experts for this very interesting presentations thank you Mithos we have been working for the last two years and it's not a surprise that from the SND IMCO we have been calling for an ambitious and strong legislation that will imply a DFA that would tackle the vulnerabilities that exploit consumers online especially those of children the leak that we have seen now it's too early to to make an assessment from my side but obviously we consider there's an opportunity to finally address what the existing legislation has not sufficiently tackled addictive design dark patterns manipulative advertising and unfair personalization but I want to make three points first we need to move from consumer responsibility to corporate responsibility and from my point of view it's not enough to allow users to switch off addictive features with this opt out why should the burden fall on the consumers again rather than on the companies that deliberately designed this mechanism safety and fairness must be by default not an option so this is to the commission secondly obviously we consider that children must be at the center of the legislation and we need to ensure the DFA and Kids Act work together without loopholes and gaps in protection we will make sure from this parliament that this is the case and finally we must address economic manipulation especially also with addictive sorry dynamic pricing and ensure strong European enforcement transparency is not enough rights without enforcement are simply promises so let me conclude with one message Europe should not accept a digital economy where profits depend on exploitation on exploiting people's vulnerability thank you so much thank you very much now EPP Dora thank you thank you for the presentations as well Note that consumers don't read regulations they feel them or they don't so once I've had a chance to digest the leak I haven't had the chance either yet I will read the DFA with one question in mind
will it actually change what people experience online the goal is of course better consumer protection but I worry that more rules will not necessarily lead to that outcome so to make sure that we have or maximize the chances of better consumer protection the DFA has to be very precise the commission's own fitness check identified where the current rules fall short and that's where the DFA should act not on what the digital services act the AI act or the unfair commercial practices directive already cover because overlapping obligations do not protect consumers they only create legal uncertainty and I worry that the complexity as counterproductive and leads to higher rates of non-compliance which is basically where we are now because consumers don't understand their rights and businesses don't understand their obligations and as the professor said the DFA is entering a crowded crowded field so I I don't know how consumers and businesses will understand which rules apply to them when we already have these obligations especially if they now need to look at an additional set of rules to have the full picture and then secondly rules have to be the same everywhere it's welcome I think that the commission proposes a regulation but it must leave no room for divergent national rules because we see that's another issue towards legal uncertainty a consumer in Budapest deserves the same protection as a consumer in Amsterdam and a business should face one set of rules not 27 the commission has committed to simplifying consumer protection consumer information requirements and I would like to see that commitment in the text text and not new reporting obligations I have a question to the commission for every new obligation in the DFA DFA will you show us which gap it closes and why existing law does not yet cover it and then final one final comment like my colleague I think already mentioned it's essential that we make sure the DFA and the Kids Act work together and I find it a bit confusing that some parts of the DFA touch on
specifically on minors and I think wouldn't it make more sense to keep that in the Kids Act which is going to be about kids thank you thank you very much now Renew um. Yes on the the issue of well psychology or maybe it's neurology I don't know I spoke to a neurologist who also gave a lot of information on what is happening in the brain of the of youth um with all the social media but just out of curiosity we see a lot of negative negative framing. On social media because people like to click on some kind of a negative framework is this something that with advertisement and and product selling should be reckoned with or should we frame that in another way is there any from a psychology point of view maybe an answer to that thank you Crystal thank you very much first and foremost thank you for a very soon presenting the proposal of the digital fairness act I think we really need it because we still have some loopholes we need to to cover I also think that we have been quite we have learned quite a lot since for instance the DSA and one of the things is for instance about addictive designs I mean things are developing quite fast in the digital environment and and here I think it really makes sense to to look into what we can can do to to make sure that consumers are better protected so in my opinion it really makes sense to to do more but of course also being aware of not having double legislation but I I hope that the commission is taking care of that it's your task anyway so but but one thing as Laura also said I I really think that it is extremely important to remember in this environment today when you're online most of us can be cheated we are kind of vulnerable everyone so we need to do something to reverse the burden of proof or anything something that really can help consumers I don't think that people feel that they are protected well enough today and hopefully we can use the DFA and the Kids Act to to cover up for that so not to cover up to to cover those gaps so thank you very much for that I'm looking very much forward
forward to the coming month on that.
Speaker 1ro
Thank you. If there are no further interventions, I would like to ask the Commission a single question: are you already prepared to launch it in a few days? Have you discussed with all the relevant stakeholders? What is the position of the Member States? What are the Member States saying? Because the professor here was telling us that it is difficult, as lawyers in the 27 Member States will interpret it differently, and once again we will have fragmentation and, once again, we will not have protection. Do you have a response from the Member States? Can you tell us what their position is? Thank you.
Speaker 1en
thank you very much chair and thank you to the honorable members I can start by confirming what I said also in my previous intervention that we are indeed very mindful of the interplay between our horizontal consumer protection rules to which the upcoming proposal on the digital fairness act belongs and sectoral legislation on digital services we have taken atmos care to avoid duplication our starting point indeed has been the findings of our digital fairness fitness check but also the wealth of inputs that we received through a very broad consultation process that I tried to highlight indeed with the proposals you will see in the accompanying impact assessment exactly how we tried to first of all establish clarify the gaps and areas of illegal uncertainty and how we have calibrated the preferred policy response to each of those when it comes to the discussions with stakeholders academia and the member states indeed that is something we paid particular attention to throughout the process of formulating the digital fairness act beyond the consultation activities that I enumerated we have of course as we did with the parliament we have been in I think nearly every IMCO committee meeting in the last two years giving updates on the on the preparation of the digital fairness act we have done the same for the relevant council working party formations and we received several responses from member states to the consultation process as well as a. Inputs over the past days so we have tried to take everything into account and calibrate the proposals in a balanced manner that takes into account the various points of view thank you very much domnule profesor thank you very much for the comments and the questions regarding the one question that was addressed specifically to me that is negative framing I think this is clearly a political and regulatory problem that needs to be addressed that is we do have empirical studies suggesting that negative content toxic content content giving rise to
negative emotions leads to more time being spent online to more engagement and that is very much in line with the business model of many of the social media platforms when those become the main tools through which consumers get news and information about the world this starts becoming very problematic now whether this problem should be reckoned with through consumer law or on a basis of a union act based on article 114 I think the answer to that is is not obvious right I think here there are arguments to be given for and against I could imagine a world in which it is the member states that start thinking about this problem and start regulating this problem in one way or another and once there is proof that this distorts the internal market we do something about it but as we know we are not living in that world so I think it's it's it's a difficult difficult question and other than that I I think I agree with with with everything that was said so I think we're we're we're closing so I will not be taking more of your time thank you very much Mulțumesc.
Speaker 1ro
Thank you very much, and to the professors and the representative of the committee, please allow me to inform you that all the PowerPoint presentations and information will be published online on our committee’s website, so you can study them in more detail here. They were presented within the time limit. Thank you very much, and we will move on. The last item on today’s agenda is — regarding women, the last point: women as consumers — combating gender stereotypes and unfair commercial practices. I remind you that we had Gender Equality Week in Parliament, and we were pleased to include an item in our programme: women as consumers — combating gender stereotypes and unfair commercial practices. To begin with, a two-minute video message from Ms President Roberta Metsola, which will provide a good introduction to our discussion today. I would like to welcome the speakers at this event and thank them for their participation. I regret that, despite our efforts to ensure representation from the business sector, unfortunately none were able to accept our invitation. I consider myself to be from the business world, so I have worked extensively in this area, and I will certainly invite my colleagues, after we have discussed the matter, to share their views. Let us now listen to our President, Roberta Metsola.
Speaker 1en
Europe moves forward when people decide to step up and take the lead as president I see this in action every day I have met incredible women leaders throughout our society and across our continent who are blazing trails building success stories and changing our societies but these brave women are still too often held back by pressures that may leaders rarely face from pay disparities and invisible labor to outdated stereotypes and online abuse in this house we are taking steps to smash these glass ceilings and make the path to leadership more accessible including making space on corporate boards and closing employment pay and pension gaps this parliament can also be proud of our electoral reform on proxy voting rights so that no member is forced to choose between hair democratic responsibilities and starting a family we will maintain the pressure for ratification by all member states and the national parliaments so that no woman is left behind but opening doors at the top is only part of the task we need to do more to help women succeed from day one leadership is cultivated throughout childhood education and careers it needs a strong role models and systems of support that is why this house must continue to build a more equal and representative democracy that makes leadership a real possibility for women in every field from STEM to sports getting to that point takes political will and sustained action this is what gender equality week is all about my thanks I'll go to my colleague vice president Antonella Zberna and chair Lina Galvez Munoz and thanks to all of you who work tirelessly for gender equality this week every week and every day keep up the good work because when women rise all of Europe rises with us
Speaker 1ro
We must apply this beautiful message, thank you, Roberta, even if you are not here right now. We have three speakers, and now we have the intervention from the Deputy Director of the Directorate for Equality and Non-Discrimination at Digi Just, Ms Pinuccia Contino. You have seven minutes, thank you.
Speaker 1en
Thank you very much honorable chair and committee members it is a pleasure to come back to this distinguished committee after being responsible for product safety has head of gender equality in Digi Just let me first recall the fundamentals EU consumer protection is enshrined in article 169 of the treaty and article 38 of the chart of fundamental rights of the European Union that protection is based on the premise that consumers are in a weaker position in relation to sellers or suppliers in that they have generally less information less economic power and less experience than sellers or suppliers consumer law aims therefore to compensate for this structural imbalance for example the unfair commercial practice directive protects consumers against unfair commercial practices including misleading actions and omissions and aggressive practices gender related advertising such as advertising that exploits insecurities relating to appearance body image aging or motherhood may fall within the UCPD the unfair commercial practices directive if they are unfair in any way leading to consumers in this specific case women to take a transactional decision they would not take otherwise the unfair commercial practice directive also provides for a higher level of protection for a clearly identifiable group of consumers who are particularly vulnerable to a commercial practice or the underlying product because of mental or physical infirmity age or credulity where the trader could reasonably foresee that vulnerability in such cases the practice is assessed from the perspective of the average member of the group gender as such here's however not one of the listed vulnerability grounds in UCPD that being said the unfair commercial practices directive requires a case by case assessment of the particular practice taking into account the circumstances surrounding the specific practice or contract this makes this directive a flexible instrument to tackle different types of practices and contracts for example a higher price for a product marketed to women
than for a comparable product marketed to men the so-called pink tax is not automatically an infringement of the UCPD the UCPD does not establish general prohibition on price differences between consumers or product variants it may nevertheless apply where for example the trader misleads consumers about the price or its calculation omits material information or uses an aggressive practice as many of you know and we have just heard all the discussions the commission will propose the DFA in a couple of days the DFA aims is to strengthen consumer protection online and we have seen how much the DFA is conceived to protect the interests of all consumers men or women in all their diversity its rules are intended to address practices that can harm consumers generally while taking account also of vulnerable consumers for sure certain forms of influencer marketing or personalized advertising or pricing might disproportionately affect women for example influencers promoting beauty anti-aging or weight loss products makes exploit gender specific insecurities relating to appearance and body image while failing to make sufficiently clear the commercial nature of their endorsements the DFA could strengthen protection in this area including by requiring sale and disclosures to ensure that consumers are made aware of the commercial nature of such content the work on the DFA also looked at addressing unfair personalized advertising practices for example for instance where traders use consumers personal data including sensitive information revealing health conditions or other characteristics protected under the GPDR the GDPR to target them with advertising that exploits their vulnerabilities and here we know how certain health conditions only affect women as we have stressed in the gender equality strategy minors are particularly vulnerable to influencer marketing often perceiving influencers as their friends influencers sometimes exploit minor's trust for example by blurring the commercial
purposes of their activities or exploiting gender stereotypes and gender specific vulnerabilities pushing minor to buy products or otherwise distorting their transactional decisions there is also evidence that girls can be particularly affected online also specifically with respect to video games because even though loot boxes and problem gambling was shown in a 2020 study to be stronger among among girls than boys although boys were considerably more likely to engage with loot boxes in the first place the DFA work has looked specifically into this matter and more broadly into the matter of spending maximizing practices if we look at financial services now there is of course a big risk of algorithmic biases traditional credit scoring models for instance often fail to account for women's different career partners patterns including breaks for caregiving to children or older parents when AI systems are trained on historical data reflecting decades of gender inequality they can perpetuate and scale these biases the revised consumer credit directive which will come into application on 20th November 26 strengthens protection against discriminatory automated decision making looking forward implementation will be key to ensure that algorithms are regularly tested for gender bias and deliver fair outcomes the gender equality strategy also explicitly covers the angle of women as consumers i can go deeper into this because i see that my seven minutes are almost there and i really hope that we can continue working together with all of you to address gender equality issues in the field of consumer rights
Speaker 1ro
Mulțumesc foarte mult da de decenii este inegalitate să sperăm că ajungem să trăim și noi egalitatea de de șanse acuma am să invit pentru patru minute pe doamna Mary Collins secretar general pentru lobby european al femeilor please
Translating…
Speaker 1en
Thank you very much Madam Chair and thank you to the MCO committee it's um very honored to be here on behalf of the European Women's Lobby and I think your this is very timely event as um the cost of living is soaring and we can hear out cry and in the streets I just want to first of all reiterate that women are more than 50% of the population they are not a vulnerable group they are not a footnote they're not a minority but however there are many different characteristics that impact their spending power one of them being that there is still a persistent gender pay up between 11 and 12% for decades and that has lifelong consequences because it leads to a gap in lifelong earnings and pension gap and it means poverty in older age so this obviously has a huge impact on the capacity of women in terms of their spending power also we should not overlook the entrenched gender stereotypes that impact on consumer and commercial practices there are gender biases that are ingrained so I wanted to quickly if I may in my four minutes look at the so-called pink tax which we can also call a sexist tax secondly menstrual products and thirdly the commodification of women's bodies so it was pointed out that this so-called pink tax is what we would call a sexist tax it shows that products that are aimed at women that target women are much more expensive even if the equivalent exists for male consumers so for example um healthcare and particularly products like the deodorant which is far more expensive when targeted woman but the studies show and there are not that many studies to be honest show that um even impacts on toys children's toys children's clothes the different color of products as well so we can see that gender stereotypes are ingrained and some studies show that actually it is against um gender equality laws as well in different countries so we would like to see MCO and FAM do a joint um own initiative report to really trace the differentiation of prices um with between women
and men in throughout the European Union quickly move on to menstrual products and it's more about a tampon tax it's often referred to as a tampon tax but it's more about that it's about inclusion it's part of the union of equality and it's access to women's sexual and reproductive health and rights throughout Europe today girls still drop out of school while they have their periods homeless women lack access to sanitary facilities and it's difficult to manage in terms of their dignity and their safety so we would again like to see more studies done in relation to this there are some good practices in different parts of throughout the European Union these need to be scaled up because this is a really you know very important issue for girls in terms of VAT just to say that the revision of the VAT directive gave the possibility of to member states to actually be more flexible in terms of classifying sanitary products from being luxury items to ordinary items however today there are only three countries in Europe um Malta Cyprus and Ireland where there's a zero VAT on sanitary products thirdly I want to the commodification of women's bodies so women are not for sale and this includes prostitution pornography as well as accelerating exploitive digital exploitation think it was spoken about a little bit earlier they aim to hurt alienate violate women and girls bodies minds and fundamental rights so it's an issue of violence against women and needs to be addressed as such however what we do see is that the so-called mainstream media and advertising they also use the sexualization of women's bodies to lure um customers and clients into practices and consumer practices so these need to be um called out for what it is it's exploitation of women so the DSA covers some issues for example big platforms uh such as porn um porn pornhub but it doesn't go far enough so we really need to have a we need really need to call out against the um sexualization of women through media through
advertising which have an impact in terms of consumer preferences and choices I'll leave it at that thank you very much
Speaker 1ro
Mulțumesc foarte mult și mulțumesc și pentru că ați fost și la celelalte prezentări apreciez foarte mult că ați fost aici în sală așa cum apreciez că domnul profesor stă acum să asculte și problema noastră a femeilor acum pentru patru minute am s o rog pe doamna Silvia Maurer director advocacy beuc patru minute să din perspectiva beuc acum
Translating…
Speaker 1en
Good afternoon uh Madam Chair honorable members thank you very much for inviting the European Consumers Organization B to this workshop so that we can also maybe share a little bit of the research of our member organizations because indeed uh I think that um very often uh women do uh continue to face practices that undermine their ability to participate in markets on equal terms with men um we have heard about the so-called pink tax and that is something that our members have also uh confirmed uh and it's not only anecdotal so our Slovak member SOS has for example analyzed 200 products that were sold by online retailers and they found that around 10% of those products were more expensive in their pink version and according to their research the most significant differences appeared in health supplements footwear and sporting goods but also our UK member which found out that one of the latest trends is to relabel uh uh products for uh menopa with menopause and to make price premiums even though there's very often no added value of these products compared to other ones um I will try um not to be too repetitive because a lot of points that have already been made I would also have raised the exact same issues um on the pricing what is maybe also interesting is that uh sometimes it's like very obvious what was referred to by the pink tax meaning it is almost the same product it's just that the price is higher when it's packaged differently or the color is different but there is also more subtle uh misleading uh where women are paying more because that can be that for example the quantity is lower and the price is the same so that's an indirect way on how to mislead about the pricing um and uh we have already also heard about uh the issue about um algorithms uh that they uh increasingly determine which products we see which advertisements reach us and uh sometimes even different prices that we pay and that there uh these systems rely very often on biased data uh or reinforce existing stereotypes so that's why discrimination can
occur also at the level that is very much invisible to consumers and very difficult to challenge uh I think be would agree that we should uh pay very close attention actually to influencer marketing because women and girls are among the uh the primary targets um so uh young women are encouraged to pursue unrealistic beauty standards to through endless product recommendations and they are very often also pushed towards excessive consumption for example of fast fashion uh and that's I think also where we would like to make a link to your previous workshop on the digital fairness act because obviously we need to discuss a little bit on the solutions as well what we can do um because many of these practices are very subtle and they and the market for too long um I think that also refers to the fact uh as Gigi justice some uh how pointed out before the pink tax may be an unfair commercial practices but it's also not so clear in in the law that uh that you can uh act on everything there um so on the digital fairness act uh actually I think we have uh uh here a possibility on how we can improve the legislation um but maybe we also need at the EU level to see a little bit how we can on a on a strategic alignment better align for example the implementation of the consumer agenda together with uh the strategy on gender uh maybe there are some ideas that we can can also develop and I would also say whenever there is very practical legislation that we indeed need to see if there are specific requirements that we need to make on the general product safety regulation for example in the past there was a notion that technical standards uh for safety testing very often never look at female bodies for example and it was the parliament that had made the addition I think to the text that was finally being agreed uh and it's just like this thinking that we need to apply very often on where uh improvements are possible I think I would leave it here um I think also maybe one last comment is that on some of the practices um
maybe we need a good tools for European and enforcement where we have cases of common interest and if we want to advance on the uh fairness agenda in relation to women maybe there are also some projects and and joint enforcement actions that we can be looking for together also the the evidence but also the experience on what practices are really um not uh not allowed in the market thank you
Speaker 1ro
Thank you very much before giving the floor to my colleagues, I regret that efforts have been made and representatives of the business sector have been invited, and unfortunately they have not accepted our invitation. I hope that next time they will be able to attend. I just want you to know that efforts have been made, we have invited them, and they did not come to this debate, which I believe is important. As someone mentioned here, women are not cowards; we have over 51% women, and I believe that any legislation must be considered from the perspective of its impact on women. Dora IPP
Speaker 1en
Yes thank you for coming today and thank you for the presentations um indeed as you and also um our colleague has just reiterated women are more than 50% of the population so we need to raise more awareness uh of the impacts of unfair uh commercial practices or that unfair commercial practices have on them uh so I'm also a bit disappointed to see uh the low turnout today um I would like to ask you um about the pink tax um because I I was looking and I couldn't find any recent studies on it so I I would be interested in whether you have data on the prevalence of it um and how big a a problem or how widespread a problem this is and um and how you propose tackling it I mean we said uh and and I do think there is a case where existing legislation covering this um as a misleading uh practice um so I I come back to enforcement and enforcement priorities um and there that my my key question is um how will we ensure that uh the commission and the national enforcement authorities actually take action and how we can raise awareness that they they should take action in in these um in these unfair um practices situations and then um just another question on on the I know the commission has done the digital fitness fairness check um and has come out with a figure of a staggering 7.9 billion per year of losses consumer losses um given the the shortcomings of the existing a key um and they break this down by age but not by gender so I wonder whether there's there are plans for the commission to collect data uh on such breakdown thank you
Speaker 1ro
Thank you very much Georgia S&D. Thank you.
Speaker 1it
Mr President, thank you for this very important debate, thank you to all the guests who have provided us with some very interesting insights, because digital transformation has certainly opened up new opportunities but has also given rise to many critical issues that we are trying to address, particularly with regard to unfair commercial practices and forms of consumer manipulation. In this sense, the initiative on the Digital Fairness Act represents a very important opportunity that we must not let slip away, so that the gender perspective can also be integrated into the new rules and in the assessment of their impact. We are obviously thinking of algorithms that can amplify those unrealistic beauty models, those targeted advertisements that predominantly exploit insecurities linked to the body, age or those marketing strategies that reproduce or further reinforce the gender stereotypes that we unfortunately know all too well. These practices do not only affect consumer choices; they can have very concrete consequences on economic autonomy, well-being and, above all, women’s freedom of choice. We are not simply faced with isolated instances of discrimination; these are not isolated episodes, we know this well: gender stereotypes and prejudices are truly embedded in algorithmic systems and in business models. They reproduce and amplify inequalities that already exist, and we see this happening continuously. It is clear that this is not a new concern. I recall a 2023 study by the European Parliament, which was requested by the FEM Committee on the impact of the gender gap in consumer protection data. The study highlights how the lack of disaggregated data also has an impact on women as consumers in the digital market. This is why I believe it is absolutely necessary for the gender perspective not to remain merely a general principle but to be
really a concrete criterion within the European legislation on consumer protection right from the GDPR. But I wonder, well, what are the criteria that are being defined in ever greater detail? Thank you.
Speaker 1ro
Thank you very much. And now I would like answers from all three of you. Before that, I want to tell you that yes, you are right, you said that cosmetics for women are more expensive, but so is lingerie. I am the one who does the shopping in the family and I know this, and I do not think it is normal. But what is even worse, the fact that women, who have lower pay compared to men, have to pay more to purchase cosmetics or other products. What is very serious, however, is what you said in your presentation, that young girls are being misled, especially young girls, to look good. I have seen so many cases where there is false information, fake news, where they are sent to various clinics and are simply mutilated. So we really need to be very careful here. Thank you, and I expect a response and conclusions from each of you.
Speaker 1en
Thank you very much, uh, for this, uh, really important debate and for all the points that have been raised. Um, as we know, when we come to gender equality, unfortunately, there are no easy, uh, responses because gender inequalities are so much ingrained in every aspect of life. So definitely I, uh, the commission can only agree with all the points that have been raised. And I would maybe here, uh, first of all, um, uh, call on hopefully, uh, gathering more data in the future. We have, uh, our, uh, agency that, uh, does a lot on this, uh, on this area and definitely, uh, we can, uh, bring also to to the attention of EGE, um, the angle of women as consumers that maybe has, um, not necessarily been the most, uh, uh, addressed, um, um, aspect because of course there is so much to do on on on the side of fighting violence against women. There is so much to do on the side of understanding better all the gaps, all all the gender gaps, gender pay gap, gender work gap, gender pension gap, and, um, uh, the, and of course there is a lot, uh, to do, uh, to fight against stereotypes that unfortunately cannot change just by law. So they really require a very, uh, multifaceted and complex action that, uh, the commission has addressed in all its gender equality strategies and in particular in the latest that the commission adopted on, uh, 5th of March 2026 and that covers until 2030 where, uh, all of the problems that have been raised today, uh, get attention and, uh, are, uh, the object of many, many, many different actions, initiatives, uh, sometimes it's studies, sometimes it's, uh, legal measures, sometimes it's initiatives or funding. So, uh, what I can assure, uh, this, uh, um, honorable, uh, committee and members is that we will do all that we can to use all the tools we have at our disposal to improve the situation. But we definitely also need you and all your work, passion, and, uh, stress on this. Thank you very much.
Speaker 1ro
I want to reiterate that our entire debate was broadcast online, um, and certainly many more people were connected online. Um, but I believe the quality of the presentations and the quality of the questions was, um, of a high standard, and I would like to thank those who delivered presentations, my colleagues who asked questions, and those who listened online, because it is important to discuss openly, frankly, and without reservations in order to find solutions. Um, I now invite the representative of the lobby and then BEUC to speak, each for two minutes.
Speaker 1en
Thank you very much and thank you very much for your questions and comments and feedback as well. Um, so the first question was asked how big is the problem in terms of the pink tax? It's probably huge. Uh, the problem is we don't have massive studies but where there are studies we can see that it's very high. And sometimes the distinction is made between the basket of goods so the kind of ordinary basket of goods that everybody uses and services. So when you, for example, there was a study done in Germany in 2017 so it's going back a number of years so when it came to the basket of goods the differentiation of prices weren't huge. So some of the products that would be, you know, aimed at women wasn't massive. But however when it came to the services and particularly hairdressing, dry cleaning, tailoring, cosmetics, etc., it was 37% difference. So it's massive. So we can only imagine that it was huge. It is huge. So we do need data and absolutely join the commission by saying that we're very fortunate in the European Union. We have the European Institute for Gender Equality who collect data and on a yearly basis who present, um, the gender equality index showing where we're at. Actually it'll be the the 26th one will be launched on the end of this month. So we're very fortunate to have that. And yes this is, uh, something that the the institute could do is collect the data so that we can see, uh, visibly the differentiation of, um, of prices because there's absolutely no objective justification for it. So that's why we call it a sexist tax as well. So what else can be done? Um, so industry has to come on board. That's absolutely necessary. Um, and also in terms of representation of women in the sector. We know that the representation of women is still very low in a lot of sectors. We do have the directive on women on boards. But we would like to see it going much further and to have parity on boards. Because, and parity means 50/50 representation to really strive for that
because we believe that that is a way of cracking some of these, uh, issues and also having a different perspective especially when it comes to using the use of women's bodies and girls' bodies. Um, that we really need to have a very different approach around that. And as the commission says there are many, um, tools that we do have and we need to make sure they talk to each other. So, um, you know, the digital services act, uh, the DFA, the AI act, the, you know, the gender equality strategy, um, they all need to talk to each other because there is no, you know, one solution. It is part of a global, uh, set of standards in our in our societies and particularly gender stereotypes and you would imagine that today in 2026 that we've gone beyond that. But no, we have not. It's still very, very much entrenched. Then I would like to say something as well about, um, funding. So we do need funding. We do need resources because we do need to tackle it on all different levels. And I just really want to point out that, um, for the next, um, MFF, they proposal by the council to, uh, reduce the Agora EU instrument which is an instrument that covers, uh, fundamental rights, gender equality, equality for all, the media and culture. All of the actors that play in it really an important role in, um, bringing these issues to the forefront and really being able to address them. That that fund is proposed to be cut by 30%, 3. 0, which is the highest cut in the whole of the EU budget. So I'd like to appeal to you here today as well to really make sure that that doesn't happen. And to go back to what the commission proposed, and, uh, to actually go beyond that too. Because this is crucial. This is about democracy as well. And especially a long-term budget. We're looking at the next seven years. Even if today the situation might feel a little bit grim. But in seven years' time we would hope that we have a more positive, and a more hopeful world. Thank you.
Speaker 1ro
Thank you very much. And I believe that to eliminate stereotypes, we also need to address education. From school, in families, from when children are very young in kindergarten, the car is only for boys, for girls it's something else, this colour is for boys, the other one is for girls. So these things need to be tackled at the grassroots level and through education, not just when we are adults. And not only through laws. So education has a very important role. Now, the representative of BEUC, please.
Speaker 1en
Thank you. Um, I think indeed that we might need, uh, more evidence collection and also connected very different areas of where we want to look for the evidence. Um, because I think, uh, in in principle the problem here I think is systemic to a certain extent because um, women are told we are advertisement that they're not quite good enough yet. And that, um, the next purchase will bring them much closer to an ideal. And that creates a constant cycle of this satisfaction that drives then again consumption. Not because consumers need a product but because they have been persuaded that they need to fix something about themselves. And, um, I think there are always unfortunately new new forms on how that feeling is being used for marketing techniques and new sales channels and everything. So it's a little bit of a self-repeating cycle whenever you found out something there are more subtle techniques on how you continue the selling techniques to the women. At worst terms because as we heard before I mean uh, women first of all often on average um, earn less and then they pay more. Uh, so they are punished twice to be consumers in in a in a single market. And that needs indeed our our attention. Um, I would agree to some of the proposals that have been made for the way forward and we would also be happy to stay in a discussion on the data. It's true that we have not much but I can make available maybe this one or two consumer surveys from the members that we have uh, in case those would be of interest.
Speaker 1ro
Thank you very much. Thank you for the answers. Thank you for the questions. Thank you to the secretariat who helped me. Thank you to the interpreters because without them, how would we have managed? It’s very good. We have 24 languages. Official languages. Today, almost all booths are full. Thank you. And I hope we don’t stop here. I will discuss in the IMCO committee to continue and perhaps bring here what we didn’t have today, namely the industry side to participate in the discussions. Of course, it is very important not only to regulate but also to implement. Because we can have a very good document but apply it poorly. And to apply it well, I believe all stakeholders must get involved and report issues. We must educate consumers to complain when their rights are violated, and especially women, because women are more hesitant, let’s say, to speak up when their rights are infringed upon. We must work a lot on this. Personally, I work in my country, you should know I lead a women’s association that has been active for 30 years, and I work very well with them, and this education has emerged to give them the courage to value their qualities and not be manipulated by all the false information. Thank you very much, and let’s meet again another time. Thank you.
Speaker 1en
Thank you very much. Congratulations.
Thank you very much.
Thank you. I have one. Thank you. Thank you.
Tomorrow. Tomorrow. Tomorrow. Yes. Thank you.
Speaker 1it
Good evening. Good evening. Yes, yes, but