1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:03,000
Brussels Live
Tras-scríofa agus aistrithe ag IS

2
00:00:13,836 --> 00:00:18,084
Good morning, everyone, and welcome to this
morning's press briefing on next week's

3
00:00:18,156 --> 00:00:21,777
plenary session in Strasbourg. The more
observant amongst you will have noticed that

4
00:00:21,816 --> 00:00:27,151
I am not Delphine Collard, but I'm
honored to be replacing her this morning.

5
00:00:27,216 --> 00:00:31,923
So, next week, firstly on institutional
matters, which are primarily budgetary in

6
00:00:31,997 --> 00:00:36,593
nature, MEPs will be discussing the European
Council President's compromise proposal

7
00:00:36,636 --> 00:00:42,349
on the next multi-annual financial framework,
or the long-term budget, on Wednesday.

8
00:00:42,456 --> 00:00:47,039
Antonio Costa, as you may know, will be
unveiling the proposal tomorrow morning, and

9
00:00:47,106 --> 00:00:51,114
Parliament's co-rapporteurs will be
reacting shortly afterwards with a written

10
00:00:51,156 --> 00:00:55,962
statement. Parliament's position has
to be taken into account as an absolute

11
00:00:56,025 --> 00:01:00,238
majority of MEPs in is
needed to approve the MFF.

12
00:01:00,336 --> 00:01:04,173
Parliament set out its general position
back in April and is now adopting its

13
00:01:04,227 --> 00:01:08,705
mandates for negotiation on the individual
sectoral programs, many of which will be

14
00:01:08,753 --> 00:01:14,250
voted next week. In Strasbourg, such as
the Global Europe, Horizon, Competitiveness

15
00:01:14,297 --> 00:01:19,619
Fund, European Social Fund, Agora
EU, Border Management, Asylum, etc.

16
00:01:19,776 --> 00:01:25,139
There will be a press conference with the
MFF and Own Resources co-rapporteurs next

17
00:01:25,279 --> 00:01:30,870
Wednesday morning at 9:30. Again, on
a related matter, Parliament reached a

18
00:01:30,907 --> 00:01:34,671
provisional agreement with the
Council on the 2027 budget.

19
00:01:34,776 --> 00:01:39,801
The last annual budget for the current
framework earlier this month, and MEPs will

20
00:01:39,868 --> 00:01:45,474
debate it on Tuesday before it is voted
and then signed by the President the

21
00:01:45,548 --> 00:01:50,899
following day. On foreign affairs, in a
key debate on Wednesday morning from 9:00,

22
00:01:50,976 --> 00:01:54,968
MEPs will be discussing Europe's capacity
to protect the international order and

23
00:01:55,010 --> 00:01:57,396
secure a just and lasting
peace for Ukraine.

24
00:01:57,456 --> 00:02:01,877
The debate is expected to center on the
outcome of the informed summit of EU heads

25
00:02:01,933 --> 00:02:08,152
of state in Dublin, last week. On Tuesday,
MEPs will debate the impact of Europe's

26
00:02:08,196 --> 00:02:12,347
eastern border security challenges on
frontline EU countries, and on the need to

27
00:02:12,400 --> 00:02:16,220
maintain sanctions on Russia
in international sports.

28
00:02:16,296 --> 00:02:19,836
The latter will wind up with a
resolution to be put to a vote at a

29
00:02:19,836 --> 00:02:25,904
future part session. The dire humanitarian
situation in Gaza is back on the plenary

30
00:02:25,954 --> 00:02:29,885
agenda, with a debate with the Council and
the Commission on Tuesday afternoon, and

31
00:02:29,955 --> 00:02:34,299
despite the 2025 ceasefire agreement,
Israel has continued its air attacks on Gaza

32
00:02:34,351 --> 00:02:38,682
and there are still restrictions on
humanitarian access, as well as the conditions

33
00:02:38,736 --> 00:02:44,581
now deteriorate. A draft report, calling
for EU action to support the international

34
00:02:44,626 --> 00:02:48,488
court of justice system and protect
institutions and human rights defenders against

35
00:02:48,546 --> 00:02:51,934
foreign pressure, will also
be put to vote on Wednesday.

36
00:02:51,996 --> 00:02:55,284
It denounces the coercion
against the ICC, including U.S.

37
00:02:55,356 --> 00:03:00,194
sanctions. And calls for the EU to support
the ICC through legislation, politically,

38
00:03:00,256 --> 00:03:06,403
financially, and operationally. As you
know, Parliament has decided to award the

39
00:03:06,462 --> 00:03:10,704
2026 Sakharov Prize for Freedom of Thought
to the ICC and its officials, and that

40
00:03:10,765 --> 00:03:15,245
award ceremony will take place during the
December plenary session in Strasbourg.

41
00:03:15,336 --> 00:03:19,030
And then, on to the EU
protecting citizens.

42
00:03:19,116 --> 00:03:25,405
Topic: homing in on EU citizens' everyday
concerns of affordability and the cost of

43
00:03:25,460 --> 00:03:28,776
living crisis will be the
subject of a debate on Tuesday.

44
00:03:28,836 --> 00:03:32,817
MEPs will be calling on the Council and
the Commission to do more to address

45
00:03:32,872 --> 00:03:37,365
inflation, high energy prices,
and rising housing costs.

46
00:03:37,596 --> 00:03:42,257
Which we know from a Eurobarometer survey
in the spring, featured amongst the EU

47
00:03:42,338 --> 00:03:47,296
citizens' top priorities. Parliament is
expected to endorse three key laws reforming

48
00:03:47,347 --> 00:03:49,545
EU pharmaceutical
legislation on Wednesday.

49
00:03:49,596 --> 00:03:53,981
A draft regulation and directive revise
the EU's 20-year-old general pharmaceutical

50
00:03:54,036 --> 00:03:58,166
legislation to help increase access
to medicines, cut red tape, and boost

51
00:03:58,236 --> 00:04:01,796
innovation. Whilst the EU critical
medicines act is designed to enhance the

52
00:04:01,845 --> 00:04:05,550
availability and supply of critical
medicines such as vaccines.

53
00:04:05,616 --> 00:04:09,593
There will be a press conference
with the rapporteurs after.

54
00:04:09,636 --> 00:04:15,311
The votes at 2:00. Then there are new rules
to boost consumers' confidence in the EU

55
00:04:15,373 --> 00:04:19,761
organic logo and to support organic farmers
by ensuring non-EU producers apply the

56
00:04:19,814 --> 00:04:23,016
same quality standards as they do.

57
00:04:23,136 --> 00:04:27,705
It will be put to a vote on Tuesday. The
new law includes exemptions for small

58
00:04:27,756 --> 00:04:31,678
businesses selling organic products
directly to consumers, and new measures to

59
00:04:31,728 --> 00:04:34,599
tackle cross-contamination
by conventional farming.

60
00:04:34,656 --> 00:04:38,754
There will be a press conference
on that as well following the vote.

61
00:04:38,976 --> 00:04:43,587
The rapid expansion of digital technologies
and AI, in particular, is leading to new

62
00:04:43,645 --> 00:04:47,997
forms of abuse and exacerbating existing
threats, disproportionately affecting women

63
00:04:48,085 --> 00:04:52,106
and girls. EU action and progress on
combating gender-based violence in the age of

64
00:04:52,150 --> 00:04:56,346
digital technology will be assessed in a
debate with the Commission on Wednesday

65
00:04:56,429 --> 00:05:00,745
afternoon. And immediately afterwards, on
Wednesday, MEPs and the Commission will

66
00:05:00,783 --> 00:05:06,303
discuss the political and media hate speech
currently fueling racism and violence in

67
00:05:06,413 --> 00:05:11,115
Europe. On Tuesday. MEPs will discuss
reforms recently undertaken in Hungary to

68
00:05:11,157 --> 00:05:14,884
restore the rule of law in EU values, and
other changes in the country's political

69
00:05:14,920 --> 00:05:17,835
and institutional landscape
since the April 26 elections.

70
00:05:17,916 --> 00:05:22,423
And there will be a resolution, sorry, put
to the vote during the December plenary

71
00:05:22,476 --> 00:05:29,379
session. Still on similar topic, a resolution
on the state of media freedom and the

72
00:05:29,416 --> 00:05:32,565
rule of law in Czechia will,
meanwhile, be put to vote on Wednesday.

73
00:05:32,616 --> 00:05:37,030
Winding up the plenary debate that
took place last week in Brussels.

74
00:05:37,116 --> 00:05:43,343
And to conclude, the five film shortlisted
in the 2027 Lux Audience Film Award will

75
00:05:43,389 --> 00:05:46,289
be announced at a press
conference on Wednesday.

76
00:05:46,356 --> 00:05:51,840
The winner will be chosen by citizens from
across Europe and by MEPs, and will be

77
00:05:51,924 --> 00:05:55,930
announced next spring.
It was launched in 2007.

78
00:05:56,016 --> 00:06:00,807
The award champions films that sparked
debate, reflect shared European values,

79
00:06:00,876 --> 00:06:04,371
celebrate cultural and linguistic diversity,
and explore issues at the heart of

80
00:06:04,411 --> 00:06:07,381
European Parliament
policy and legislation.

81
00:06:07,476 --> 00:06:13,093
There will also be a list of mandates to
be announced at the number of mandates to

82
00:06:13,158 --> 00:06:16,709
be announced on various files
coming to first reading.

83
00:06:16,776 --> 00:06:19,821
If you're interested, we
can—I can mention them later.

84
00:06:19,896 --> 00:06:24,165
But I think I will give the floor now to
the political groups, starting with Pedro

85
00:06:24,216 --> 00:06:25,416
for the EPP.

86
00:06:37,836 --> 00:06:38,676
Go raibh maith agat, a Neil.

87
00:06:38,676 --> 00:06:44,037
Bonjour à tous. Et comme je sais que
vous devez travailler avec les sommets

88
00:06:44,076 --> 00:06:50,976
britannique et que demain vous travaillez,
parce que au Conseil, le président Costa

89
00:06:51,069 --> 00:06:56,511
va présenter la négo box,
je vais. Être très bref.

90
00:06:56,676 --> 00:07:01,501
Et juste, même si j'ai l'habitude de que
les politiciens ne m'écoutent pas, après

91
00:07:01,554 --> 00:07:07,877
autant d'années, mais je vais passer trois
messages de la part du groupe PPE aux

92
00:07:07,956 --> 00:07:12,293
chefs de gouvernement qui vont se réunir
la semaine prochaine, et parler des cadres

93
00:07:12,360 --> 00:07:16,469
pluriannuels, des budgets
pluriannuels de l'Union européenne.

94
00:07:16,536 --> 00:07:21,251
Et je voulais leur dire trois choses. Une:

95
00:07:21,364 --> 00:07:27,533
qu'ils soient sincères. S'ils veulent
couper les budgets de l'Union européenne,

96
00:07:27,622 --> 00:07:35,803
qu'ils aient la dignité de nous dire où
et quoi l'Union européenne doit arrêter de

97
00:07:35,959 --> 00:07:43,430
faire. Première chose. Deuxième chose: Les
budgets européens ne sont pas un budget

98
00:07:43,476 --> 00:07:46,758
dépense, c'est un budget d'investissement.

99
00:07:46,836 --> 00:07:53,616
Et donc, il doit y avoir
la dignité de nous dire où.

100
00:07:53,736 --> 00:08:00,061
Il faut qu'on arrête d'investir, et de
reconnaître qu'il manque d'ambition.

101
00:08:00,156 --> 00:08:05,392
Et le troisième message: c'est qu'ils ne
doivent pas sous-estimer ce Parlement.

102
00:08:05,496 --> 00:08:11,031
Parce qu'au jour d'aujourd'hui, il n'y a
pas le vote nécessaire pour approuver ce

103
00:08:11,117 --> 00:08:16,890
cadre pluriannuel. Et donc, il doit faire
attention et pas compter comme d'habitude

104
00:08:16,956 --> 00:08:25,646
que le Parlement, il va suivre comme des
petits chiens ce qu'ils vont décider.

105
00:08:25,716 --> 00:08:29,598
Donc, qu'ils écoutent pour une
fois ces trois petits messages.

106
00:08:29,676 --> 00:08:33,141
Et c'est un conseil d'envie
routier de l'Union européenne.

107
00:08:33,216 --> 00:08:37,652
Et sinon, je suis prêt à répondre à vos
questions sur l'agenda de la session plus

108
00:08:37,716 --> 00:08:43,428
tard. Et pour rappeler qu'à 9 h 30, mardi,
le président du groupe, Manfred Weber,

109
00:08:43,476 --> 00:08:47,341
sera là. Je ne serai pas à Strasbourg
parce que je dois passer à l'atelier, mais

110
00:08:47,407 --> 00:08:50,572
arranger un petit truc. Mais
tous mes collègues, ils seront.

111
00:08:50,616 --> 00:08:51,936
Okay? Merci beaucoup.

112
00:08:53,076 --> 00:08:57,096
Thank you very much. Pedro,
now Ute for the S&D group.

113
00:09:06,996 --> 00:09:12,554
Good morning, Neil and all of
you here in the room and online.

114
00:09:12,636 --> 00:09:17,239
Great to see you. So, our
topics for the week ahead:

115
00:09:17,316 --> 00:09:21,488
affordability debate on
Tuesday, Neil mentioned it.

116
00:09:21,576 --> 00:09:27,809
It is thanks to our group that
affordability is on the plenary agenda.

117
00:09:28,056 --> 00:09:33,504
A European Union where people cannot
afford a home, earn a decent wage, access

118
00:09:33,572 --> 00:09:39,053
quality, education, or simply fill their
shopping baskets and pay their energy

119
00:09:39,126 --> 00:09:44,868
bills, is not our Europe. We as a group
put forward different proposals and have

120
00:09:44,945 --> 00:09:51,951
repeatedly insisted on the need to prioritize
the affordability crisis, calling for

121
00:09:52,024 --> 00:09:56,669
concrete measures, amongst others,
against the housing speculation.

122
00:09:56,736 --> 00:10:01,274
We must treat housing
as a fundamental right.

123
00:10:01,356 --> 00:10:08,990
Committing to end homelessness by 2030
via housing-first policies and boosting

124
00:10:09,096 --> 00:10:13,623
dedicated funding for
students and children.

125
00:10:13,716 --> 00:10:19,275
Making life affordable is the defining
challenge of this crisis, and the young

126
00:10:19,334 --> 00:10:23,050
generation will pay the
highest price for inaction.

127
00:10:23,136 --> 00:10:30,761
We must break this rent-to-wage trap. By
banning unpaid traineeships, across the EU,

128
00:10:30,864 --> 00:10:36,656
enforcing fair minimum wages, and collective
bargaining, and investing heavily in

129
00:10:36,729 --> 00:10:44,848
affordable student and social housing.
Today's international youth strike—the latest

130
00:10:44,916 --> 00:10:51,304
and biggest in month—of young mobilization
sends a clear message, which we can't

131
00:10:51,381 --> 00:10:57,313
ignore. The European project won't survive
if its citizens and especially the youth

132
00:10:57,417 --> 00:11:03,456
can't live in dignity. So we
must listen, and act, now.

133
00:11:03,756 --> 00:11:08,738
Then I would like to come to the second
point, the MFF mentioned, of course, and the

134
00:11:08,842 --> 00:11:15,102
upcoming summit. As of tomorrow and on the
agenda next week, the big elephant in the

135
00:11:15,244 --> 00:11:19,748
room, the MFF. Not big enough, not nearly.

136
00:11:19,836 --> 00:11:26,331
For us. In times of rising social uncertainty
and unbearable costs of living, it is

137
00:11:26,406 --> 00:11:32,705
impossible to do more with less. This is
not a choice between a cheap Europe and an

138
00:11:32,786 --> 00:11:38,037
expensive one. It's a choice between a
Europe that lurches from crisis to crisis and

139
00:11:38,110 --> 00:11:42,332
a Europe with the means
to shape its own future.

140
00:11:42,456 --> 00:11:48,301
The next MFF needs a well-established
European social fund plus, as the best way to

141
00:11:48,379 --> 00:11:53,651
support workers, skilled and education,
opportunities for young Europeans, and so

142
00:11:53,708 --> 00:11:54,908
much more.

143
00:11:55,116 --> 00:12:00,944
A stronger cohesion fund for tangible
results, better schools, roads, and public

144
00:12:01,011 --> 00:12:05,491
transport, in support of citizens
and businesses across the Union.

145
00:12:05,616 --> 00:12:11,906
And no cuts to the common agricultural
policy, as cuts would undermine food

146
00:12:11,976 --> 00:12:18,579
security, an essential part of national
security, and European sovereignty in an

147
00:12:18,653 --> 00:12:25,149
unstable world. For this purpose, but not
only, new own resources are essential:

148
00:12:25,236 --> 00:12:31,138
finance through levies on digital services,
online gambling, and crypto assets.

149
00:12:31,236 --> 00:12:37,253
We urge the European Council to consider
the European Parliament's new own resources

150
00:12:37,339 --> 00:12:41,346
proposals along with
the Commission's basket.

151
00:12:41,436 --> 00:12:45,319
It's time to reach an
agreement and a bigger one.

152
00:12:45,456 --> 00:12:49,056
Finally, let me come to
another issue on the agenda:

153
00:12:49,116 --> 00:12:50,976
digital gender-based violence.

154
00:12:51,456 --> 00:12:56,587
Let's be clear: what is illegal
offline, must be illegal online.

155
00:12:56,676 --> 00:13:01,836
Digital gender-based violence
is not just a personal attack.

156
00:13:01,956 --> 00:13:08,346
For too long, online abuse and non-consensual
deepfakes have come at zero cost to

157
00:13:08,436 --> 00:13:14,201
perpetrators, while women pay the price.
Europe must recognize gender-based violence

158
00:13:14,256 --> 00:13:20,451
as an EU crime, and hold digital platforms
legally accountable so the internet

159
00:13:20,523 --> 00:13:24,786
becomes a safe space for
every woman and girl.

160
00:13:24,936 --> 00:13:31,656
Enforcing the digital services act against
very large online gender-based violence

161
00:13:31,716 --> 00:13:39,784
will not allow big tech algorithms or
AI deepfakes to roll back our democracy.

162
00:13:39,876 --> 00:13:45,883
Digital violence is real violence, and
Europe that fails to protect women is failing

163
00:13:45,969 --> 00:13:52,258
to defend equality and democracy itself.
By concluding, I would like to invite you

164
00:13:52,365 --> 00:14:01,589
to four events next week. Of course, on
Tuesday 1st, our press conference with our

165
00:14:01,663 --> 00:14:08,014
leader, at 10 o'clock. The same day, in
solidarity with Gaza, and around the debate

166
00:14:08,076 --> 00:14:14,274
on Gaza, we will organize a photo
opportunity with our MEPs around the plenary.

167
00:14:14,376 --> 00:14:22,549
And at 4:30, the EP president, our S&D
group president, MEPs, and guests will

168
00:14:22,638 --> 00:14:28,970
inaugurate in the Salvador de
Madriaga building the meeting room S1.

169
00:14:29,076 --> 00:14:35,541
And we will, it will be dedicated to Ursula
Hirschmann, a pioneering German-Italian

170
00:14:35,639 --> 00:14:41,664
feminist anti-fascist and European federalist
whose vision of a united democratic

171
00:14:41,736 --> 00:14:47,708
and equal Europe continues to inspire.
And finally, for all those present in

172
00:14:47,814 --> 00:14:56,480
Strasbourg, among you, at 6:30 on Tuesday,
we are inviting you to a Bureau reception

173
00:14:56,554 --> 00:15:03,492
with all our vice presidents present
and our group president in Salon C31.

174
00:15:03,876 --> 00:15:05,076
Thank you very much.

175
00:15:06,096 --> 00:15:09,876
Thank you very much, Ute. And
now, Alonso, for the PFE group.

176
00:15:16,176 --> 00:15:18,991
Good morning, everyone.
Thank you for being here.

177
00:15:19,056 --> 00:15:27,636
Thank you, Nil. Next week, agenda in
Strasbourg has several interesting items.

178
00:15:27,876 --> 00:15:32,099
And as always, patriots will
follow them all closely.

179
00:15:32,256 --> 00:15:38,813
I want to stop on one. The Commission
statement on the rule of law in Hungary.

180
00:15:38,916 --> 00:15:44,630
We don't expect a legal assessment.
We expect a victory bulletin.

181
00:15:44,736 --> 00:15:51,513
We expect propaganda. Hungary is
not returning to the rule of law.

182
00:15:51,576 --> 00:15:58,169
Hungary never left the rule of law. But
the new government's first steps do give

183
00:15:58,274 --> 00:16:08,412
reason for concern. Retroactive
laws to disqualify opponents.

184
00:16:08,556 --> 00:16:16,982
Arrest staged as humiliation
rituals. Media outlets shut down.

185
00:16:17,136 --> 00:16:24,033
Pluralism under attack. The Prime Minister
is totally obsessed with the opposition.

186
00:16:24,096 --> 00:16:31,383
You just have to check his
timeline on X. It's totally crazy.

187
00:16:31,596 --> 00:16:34,236
He looks like I will not say.

188
00:16:36,096 --> 00:16:40,617
None of this happened
under Orbán's government.

189
00:16:40,725 --> 00:16:44,196
This is happening just now. And.

190
00:16:53,715 --> 00:16:58,029
Is of their right to speak in
their own parliament on EU matters.

191
00:16:58,095 --> 00:17:04,442
This is totally crazy. All of this is
happening now, and Brussels applauds.

192
00:17:04,515 --> 00:17:08,059
They will say that the rule of
law is coming back to Hungary.

193
00:17:08,115 --> 00:17:13,788
It will be a lie. Because we know
what democracy means for the Brussels

194
00:17:13,847 --> 00:17:16,743
establishment when they
win: it's democracy.

195
00:17:16,815 --> 00:17:20,509
When they lose, it's
a threat to democracy.

196
00:17:20,595 --> 00:17:27,951
We see it on the so-called cordon sanitaire,
that is, Brussels democracy, we see it

197
00:17:28,035 --> 00:17:35,498
in the debates also. I don't know if you
know, ESN's debate title was rejected a

198
00:17:35,595 --> 00:17:44,209
couple of days ago for the word
"remigration," one word, debate banned.

199
00:17:44,355 --> 00:17:51,053
That's censorship, but apparently
that's Brussels democracy.

200
00:17:51,255 --> 00:17:57,410
We see it also in the
MFF. A 7-year budget.

201
00:17:57,495 --> 00:18:02,086
They want to keep it away from the
plenary and rush it to trialogues.

202
00:18:02,175 --> 00:18:07,108
Lock it in before the French
elections just in case.

203
00:18:07,275 --> 00:18:16,321
That's Brussels democracy, a fairy tale.
Then a beautiful historic town hall, burned

204
00:18:16,419 --> 00:18:24,546
in Limoges, shops looted, shops destroyed,
cars burning, you don't need to go to

205
00:18:24,603 --> 00:18:31,390
France to watch this, you can go 500 meters
away here in Société XL, you will see

206
00:18:31,490 --> 00:18:38,691
many shops look like bunkers
now, they are barricaded, but.

207
00:18:38,775 --> 00:18:47,739
Brussels calls it "youth mobilization."
And then they do a debate called a debate

208
00:18:47,847 --> 00:18:57,064
against hate speech. Cars burned, youth
mobilization, words spoken, hate speech.

209
00:18:57,195 --> 00:19:04,385
That's Orwellian to say the least.
But we work with what we have.

210
00:19:04,635 --> 00:19:11,843
Next week we will raise all of it. Let me
finish by saying that we are very pleased

211
00:19:11,911 --> 00:19:18,593
to welcome a new MEP from Slovenija to the
Patriots group, who joined us this week.

212
00:19:18,735 --> 00:19:24,775
Patriots keep growing, Patriots keep
fighting for secure borders, for a strong

213
00:19:24,838 --> 00:19:31,589
industry, for a strong farming, for a union
that serves its member states, not the

214
00:19:31,677 --> 00:19:34,455
other way around. That's
it. Thank you very much.

215
00:19:35,715 --> 00:19:38,295
Thank you, Alonzo. Michael, for the ECR.

216
00:19:46,935 --> 00:19:49,868
Thank you, Neil, and
good morning, everyone.

217
00:19:49,935 --> 00:19:54,167
Always a pleasure to see you all again,
and especially thank you to Neil, who is

218
00:19:54,252 --> 00:19:57,423
very kindly keeping us all in order today.

219
00:19:57,495 --> 00:20:00,935
Before turning to next week's agenda,
I must first address the very serious

220
00:20:00,980 --> 00:20:04,974
developments in Poland this morning.
We are deeply concerned by reports of

221
00:20:05,053 --> 00:20:10,215
violations of Polish airspace. We are
following the situation very closely, and are

222
00:20:10,266 --> 00:20:15,178
also concerned about reports that the
local population may have been warned very

223
00:20:15,275 --> 00:20:20,284
late. We expect the circumstances to
be clarified as quickly as possible.

224
00:20:20,355 --> 00:20:25,267
The security of Polish citizens and indeed
of NATO's entire eastern flank is of the

225
00:20:25,333 --> 00:20:31,908
utmost importance to us. Now turning to
the priorities for next week's plenary

226
00:20:31,995 --> 00:20:38,739
session. First, in the key debate on efforts
to secure a just and lasting peace in

227
00:20:38,801 --> 00:20:43,515
Ukraine, the ECR group will insist that
Russia must neither be rewarded for its

228
00:20:43,575 --> 00:20:48,869
aggression nor be allowed to escape
responsibility for the war it has unleashed.

229
00:20:48,975 --> 00:20:53,068
Any agreement must respect Ukraine's
sovereignty and provide lasting security for

230
00:20:53,115 --> 00:20:56,592
Ukraine and Europe as a
whole. One thing is clear:

231
00:20:56,648 --> 00:21:00,938
there can be no peace
without Ukraine at the table.

232
00:21:01,035 --> 00:21:04,878
We welcome the diplomatic efforts, but
European governments need to coordinate their

233
00:21:04,921 --> 00:21:09,718
positions much more closely and agree
on the clear negotiating mandate.

234
00:21:09,795 --> 00:21:13,543
Europe cannot expect to have a serious
say in negotiations if it cannot agree on

235
00:21:13,593 --> 00:21:18,608
what to say. A just and lasting peace can
only be built on strength, and Europe must

236
00:21:18,655 --> 00:21:22,489
be able to bring strength
to the negotiating table.

237
00:21:22,695 --> 00:21:27,209
Second, in the debate on the MFF, we believe
that much of the discussion is starting

238
00:21:27,255 --> 00:21:33,234
at the wrong end. For us, the European
Union must first get its priorities right.

239
00:21:33,315 --> 00:21:38,584
The EU budget should first and foremost
finance the Union's core responsibilities,

240
00:21:38,655 --> 00:21:43,828
the single market, agriculture, cohesion,
security, and the fight against illegal

241
00:21:43,890 --> 00:21:47,844
migration, and of course we must also
address Europe's urgent defense needs,

242
00:21:47,906 --> 00:21:54,106
particularly along our eastern border.
We need to cut spending at least on less

243
00:21:54,162 --> 00:21:58,035
essential programs and concentrate our
resources on the things that really matter.

244
00:21:58,635 --> 00:22:04,442
As you know, the ECR motto is "do less,
but do it better," new EU-owned resources

245
00:22:04,498 --> 00:22:09,832
remain a red line for us. Brussels has
first and foremost a spending problem, not a

246
00:22:09,906 --> 00:22:14,455
revenue problem. Third, on
Tuesday at half past 4 p.

247
00:22:14,535 --> 00:22:20,009
m., parliament scrutiny working group on
NGO financing will meet to formally adopt

248
00:22:20,065 --> 00:22:25,673
its final working document prepared by our
ECR MEP, Carlo Fidanza, and together with

249
00:22:25,737 --> 00:22:33,315
EPP's Dirk Goting. After a year of work and
the examination of a considerable number

250
00:22:33,369 --> 00:22:37,605
of contracts, the working group has
produced its findings and recommendations to

251
00:22:37,658 --> 00:22:41,085
improve transparency
and accountability. Mr.

252
00:22:41,175 --> 00:22:45,457
Goting and Mr. Fidanza will present
their findings at the press conference on

253
00:22:45,508 --> 00:22:49,685
Tuesday at 6 p. m., and you
are all very welcome to join.

254
00:22:49,935 --> 00:22:56,684
Now, on COP31, the ongoing negotiations
in Antalya, which parliament will also

255
00:22:56,763 --> 00:23:02,883
discuss next week. I once again expose
deep international divisions over climate

256
00:23:02,951 --> 00:23:07,386
policy. The EU is struggling to secure
stronger commitments from other major

257
00:23:07,472 --> 00:23:12,604
economies. Apparently, it is proving
difficult even to agree on including the word

258
00:23:12,659 --> 00:23:16,140
"clean" in the proposed
global electrification target.

259
00:23:16,275 --> 00:23:20,639
For the ECR group, climate policy
must be based on three principles:

260
00:23:20,715 --> 00:23:25,862
technological neutrality, energy
security, and industrial competitiveness.

261
00:23:25,935 --> 00:23:28,460
And one thing is becoming
increasingly clear:

262
00:23:28,540 --> 00:23:34,320
the European Union cannot save the planet
on its own, and it certainly cannot afford

263
00:23:34,376 --> 00:23:38,603
to price its own industry out
of existence in the attempt.

264
00:23:38,715 --> 00:23:43,126
That brings us to the vote on increasing
the buffer of emission allowances in the

265
00:23:43,176 --> 00:23:47,796
ETS market stability reserve that
will be taking place on Tuesday.

266
00:23:47,895 --> 00:23:50,828
700 million allowances are
better than 400 million.

267
00:23:50,895 --> 00:23:54,689
It's a step in the right direction and
better than nothing, but not enough to

268
00:23:54,754 --> 00:23:58,399
protect European industry from
future carbon price spikes.

269
00:23:58,455 --> 00:24:04,505
We therefore intend to abstain. And finally,
and on a more positive note, we welcome

270
00:24:04,579 --> 00:24:09,606
the Omnibus 4 package, which extends
regulatory exemptions, currently available to

271
00:24:09,659 --> 00:24:14,541
SMEs, to growing businesses, the so-called
small midcap enterprises with up to 1,000

272
00:24:14,638 --> 00:24:18,495
employees, our rapporteur
Maria-Theresa Vivaldini has played

273
00:24:18,795 --> 00:24:23,646
an important role in these negotiations.
It's true that businesses should not be

274
00:24:23,689 --> 00:24:28,028
punished with a mountain of new paperwork
simply because they are successful enough

275
00:24:28,075 --> 00:24:34,145
to grow. I shall leave it here. There is,
of course, plenty more to discover on our

276
00:24:34,201 --> 00:24:40,120
week ahead. Newsletter, our co-chairman's
press briefing is on Tuesday at half past

277
00:24:40,203 --> 00:24:43,803
10, and as always, you
are very warmly invited.

278
00:24:43,875 --> 00:24:46,455
Thank you very much. Have a good
weekend, and see you in Strasbourg.

279
00:24:47,355 --> 00:24:50,175
Thank you, Michael. And now
for the Renew Group, Linda.

280
00:25:05,355 --> 00:25:09,683
Thank you, Neil. And
good morning to everyone.

281
00:25:09,795 --> 00:25:15,286
The EU's next long-term budget is the first
priority for Liberals and Democrats for

282
00:25:15,358 --> 00:25:20,648
next week. We are convinced that Europe
needs a budget that matches the Union's

283
00:25:20,715 --> 00:25:26,786
ambitions. Because we cannot keep adding
responsibilities, from climate action to

284
00:25:26,863 --> 00:25:31,595
defense, without increasing
the resources to deliver.

285
00:25:31,755 --> 00:25:38,307
We also need new EU revenues, those who
profit from our single market, such as tech

286
00:25:38,383 --> 00:25:42,857
giants and major
polluters, must contribute.

287
00:25:42,975 --> 00:25:48,922
And for the sake of our citizens and
companies, competitiveness must be at the heart

288
00:25:48,985 --> 00:25:53,795
of the budget, with a properly
funded EU competitiveness fund.

289
00:25:54,015 --> 00:26:00,413
Because we want to give European businesses
the tools to grow, to create new jobs,

290
00:26:00,491 --> 00:26:05,785
and to compete globally.
The message is simple:

291
00:26:05,895 --> 00:26:13,739
Europe needs a budget ready for the future,
and Renew Europe is fighting for it.

292
00:26:13,875 --> 00:26:20,027
Moving on to Russia's full-scale invasion
of Ukraine, Europe's principles are not

293
00:26:20,093 --> 00:26:27,932
for sale. We welcome the Commission's 45
billion euro loan, but all 27 member states

294
00:26:28,035 --> 00:26:34,596
alongside Ukraine's international
partners must do more to meet their needs.

295
00:26:34,695 --> 00:26:37,615
The following key
principles must guide us:

296
00:26:37,699 --> 00:26:43,016
when it comes to peace talks beyond our
very well-known position of steadfast and

297
00:26:43,077 --> 00:26:48,461
unwavering support for Ukraine, and after
the Berlin Declaration, we call for a

298
00:26:48,538 --> 00:26:55,596
substantial place for the EU at the table,
and Kayakallas as the EU's chief diplomat

299
00:26:55,664 --> 00:27:02,597
has to play a key role in it. Let's
remember that Ukraine is fighting for its

300
00:27:02,660 --> 00:27:09,728
freedom, and for ours. And Liberals and
Democrats will stand with Ukraine for as

301
00:27:09,899 --> 00:27:18,446
long as it takes. Our final point is the
fight against impunity through sanctions.

302
00:27:18,555 --> 00:27:24,445
Liberals and Democrats successfully
secured a debate on this next week.

303
00:27:24,615 --> 00:27:29,654
And we call for corruption to be included
in the EU Global Human Rights sanctions

304
00:27:29,715 --> 00:27:37,125
regime, the so-called EU Magnitsky Act.
Today, the EU can freeze the assets of human

305
00:27:37,187 --> 00:27:42,724
rights abuses and ban them from entering
Europe, but until now, the EU cannot impose

306
00:27:42,795 --> 00:27:46,721
sanctions for corruption,
as a standalone ground.

307
00:27:46,815 --> 00:27:48,135
We must change that.

308
00:27:48,855 --> 00:27:54,478
In a letter to the Council, several Renew
MEPs are calling for serious corruption

309
00:27:54,551 --> 00:28:00,153
including bribery, misuse of public money,
and money laundering, to become grounds

310
00:28:00,250 --> 00:28:04,812
for EU sanctions. We also call
for the mechanism to be renamed.

311
00:28:04,875 --> 00:28:12,060
In honor of Sergei Magnitsky. Before I
end, please note that the press conference

312
00:28:12,118 --> 00:28:16,935
with President Valery Ayer, takes place on
Tuesday at 11 o'clock in Strasbourg, and

313
00:28:16,985 --> 00:28:20,248
you're most welcome to attend it.
And that's it from Renew Europe.

314
00:28:20,295 --> 00:28:21,495
Thank you so much.

315
00:28:21,855 --> 00:28:23,055
Thank you very much, Linda.

316
00:28:23,655 --> 00:28:26,535
Tom, for the Green Zephyr Group.

317
00:28:27,675 --> 00:28:28,875
B’fhéidir go bhfuil mé
ag dul thar mo chéile.

318
00:28:37,455 --> 00:28:40,838
Thank you so much. Good morning, everyone.

319
00:28:40,935 --> 00:28:46,841
Every 10 minutes, every 10 minutes, a
woman or a girl is killed by their intimate

320
00:28:46,924 --> 00:28:51,178
partner or family. We need
to stop these killings now.

321
00:28:51,255 --> 00:28:56,035
And protect women and girls from violence
as laid out in the Istanbul Convention, we

322
00:28:56,086 --> 00:29:00,664
also urge for every member state of the
EU who hasn't ratified yet like Czech

323
00:29:00,733 --> 00:29:04,003
Republic and Slovakia
to do so immediately.

324
00:29:04,095 --> 00:29:09,975
You might remember the recent study that
found out that 50 MEPs have been targeted

325
00:29:10,042 --> 00:29:15,195
by sexualized AI deepfakes,
one of our MEPs included.

326
00:29:15,315 --> 00:29:20,506
This digital violence is real violence.
And thanks to the Green Zephyr, sexualized

327
00:29:20,558 --> 00:29:26,389
AI deepfakes and so-called nudifier apps
need to disappear from the second of

328
00:29:26,451 --> 00:29:32,675
December on. It is high time for
platforms to finally take responsibility.

329
00:29:32,835 --> 00:29:35,847
On the occasion of the International Day
for the Elimination of Violence Against

330
00:29:35,889 --> 00:29:38,835
Women, we will, of course,
participate in the plenary debate.

331
00:29:38,895 --> 00:29:44,269
And let me also invite you to a press
conference on Tuesday at 5:30 with our

332
00:29:44,394 --> 00:29:49,845
Alexandra Geza and
representative. Of HateAid.

333
00:29:50,055 --> 00:29:55,095
Endangered media freedom in Czech
Republic, last Sunday in Prague, the world

334
00:29:55,155 --> 00:30:00,763
witnessed the largest demonstration since
the 1989 Velvet Revolution, with around

335
00:30:00,840 --> 00:30:05,595
400,000 citizens protesting against the
new media law, introduced by the Czech

336
00:30:05,655 --> 00:30:09,411
government led by patriot
ESN and motorists.

337
00:30:09,495 --> 00:30:14,125
The Green Zephyr, together with EPP,
brought the fight for medium freedom on the

338
00:30:14,175 --> 00:30:19,335
parliament's agenda. We call for the
government to withdraw the proposed funding

339
00:30:19,395 --> 00:30:25,204
reform, which clearly follows Orbán's
playbook, and for the Commission to assess the

340
00:30:25,269 --> 00:30:30,315
compatibility of the proposed reform with
a media freedom act, and the rule of law,

341
00:30:30,387 --> 00:30:36,252
and consider infringement procedures.
And ahead of UKO, still, the conflict of

342
00:30:36,311 --> 00:30:39,630
interest of the Czech
Prime Minister is obvious.

343
00:30:39,735 --> 00:30:44,068
Andrej Babiš is deciding in Brussels about
millions of European fundings that land

344
00:30:44,115 --> 00:30:49,060
in his own pockets. It is time for the
Commission and for the Council to ensure that

345
00:30:49,113 --> 00:30:52,275
Andrej Babiš is not involved in
any negotiations around the EU's

346
00:30:52,335 --> 00:30:58,005
long-term budget, which may
benefit him or his family directly.

347
00:30:58,155 --> 00:31:04,428
And one more note to flag: on international
justice, our Munir Satouri is EP

348
00:31:04,515 --> 00:31:09,073
rapporteur for the report that is urgent
for the Commission to activate the

349
00:31:09,152 --> 00:31:14,897
so-called blocking statute and protect
the ICC and its judges and human rights

350
00:31:14,962 --> 00:31:20,731
defenders from attacks by Donald Trump,
Benjamin Netanyahu, or Vladimir Putin.

351
00:31:20,835 --> 00:31:27,985
And let me stress the discussion about the
topical debate on so-called remigration

352
00:31:28,035 --> 00:31:31,285
honestly, I don't really want to use
that word, but you need to know what I'm

353
00:31:31,323 --> 00:31:34,382
referring to, and I
thought you did so as well.

354
00:31:34,455 --> 00:31:39,939
This is a disgraceful word, and a disgraceful
attack against what the EU stands for

355
00:31:40,015 --> 00:31:45,659
and what we stand for. And it means
nothing less than deportation.

356
00:31:45,735 --> 00:31:50,995
And I'm pleased that all democratic groups
did what democratic groups are supposed

357
00:31:51,083 --> 00:31:56,098
to do, not let this disgrace
happen in this honorable house.

358
00:31:56,355 --> 00:32:01,821
And what you call what you try to frame as
censorship, it's just a majority decision

359
00:32:01,878 --> 00:32:07,319
upholding fundamental rights. Let me kindly
invite you, and I hope I will see all of

360
00:32:07,402 --> 00:32:12,180
you next Tuesday at our presidential
press briefing with our presidents, Terry

361
00:32:12,237 --> 00:32:15,536
Reinker and Nicholas
Stefanutsa, from 9:00 to 9:30.

362
00:32:15,615 --> 00:32:17,055
Thank you, and have a good weekend.

363
00:32:17,955 --> 00:32:19,695
Thank you, Pia. And now, Tom.

364
00:32:21,135 --> 00:32:22,455
For the left group.

365
00:32:29,895 --> 00:32:32,428
Good morning, everyone, and
thank you very much, Neil.

366
00:32:32,475 --> 00:32:35,773
So the left has two main
priorities for this session.

367
00:32:35,835 --> 00:32:39,315
The first priority is health,
security, and the environment.

368
00:32:39,375 --> 00:32:43,770
So let me set the scene for this plenary.
We vote on Tuesday, and we're going to

369
00:32:43,819 --> 00:32:47,771
speed up environmental assessments.
So far, I'm okay with that.

370
00:32:47,835 --> 00:32:51,761
It sounds good. Until you actually see
what's going on there, because you see that

371
00:32:51,808 --> 00:32:55,892
the right and the far right, they
redefine killing in this law.

372
00:32:55,995 --> 00:33:00,331
So the idea is they don't want profits
to be harmed just because we're murdering

373
00:33:00,384 --> 00:33:04,262
wildlife. So the left is going to
propose a rejection amendment on that.

374
00:33:04,395 --> 00:33:08,186
And you saw Israel once again
breaks the so-called ceasefire.

375
00:33:08,295 --> 00:33:11,960
And we must at least, at
least, stop trading with them.

376
00:33:12,015 --> 00:33:15,428
We're voting on Wednesday to protect funds
for the reconstruction of Gaza, and we

377
00:33:15,471 --> 00:33:19,635
have two reports on the agenda that we
brought, one which recognizes the Israeli

378
00:33:19,695 --> 00:33:25,244
occupation of Syria and Lebanon, and one
which specifically defends the work of the

379
00:33:25,298 --> 00:33:31,164
ICC and ICJ in stopping genocide. So on
Wednesday, you have seen that the left

380
00:33:31,218 --> 00:33:35,656
secured a debate on media hate speech
that fuels racism and violence in Europe,

381
00:33:35,715 --> 00:33:40,924
because insidious far-right narratives
are building in the media international

382
00:33:40,970 --> 00:33:45,165
politics and even here in this house.
And it's emboldened racists and white

383
00:33:45,243 --> 00:33:51,817
supremacists. You know, a far-right terrorist
attack in Trapp in France, it killed

384
00:33:51,915 --> 00:33:54,515
it targeted Black and Arab citizens,
it killed a 12-year-old girl.

385
00:33:54,555 --> 00:33:57,664
It's terrible. We had a
copycat terrorist in Poland.

386
00:33:57,735 --> 00:34:01,679
We need an immediate remedy to the
growing hate speech in the media.

387
00:34:01,755 --> 00:34:05,483
And on another remedy, Wednesday's
vote on the critical medicines act.

388
00:34:05,535 --> 00:34:10,093
So we secured provisions to protect
against shortages of critical medicines in

389
00:34:10,155 --> 00:34:14,841
smaller countries that don't have big
pharmaceutical manufacturing infrastructure.

390
00:34:14,895 --> 00:34:18,728
But also keep on the lookout for our
amendment to take money away from defense

391
00:34:18,800 --> 00:34:23,458
spending and to use it to actually defend
people by giving them critical medicine.

392
00:34:23,535 --> 00:34:26,775
So this brings us to the second priority.
It's the final priority, really.

393
00:34:27,195 --> 00:34:31,259
It's workers in the economy. So we debate
the budget on Tuesday afternoon, and then

394
00:34:31,315 --> 00:34:35,608
we have a key debate on the multi-annual
financial framework, the MFF, on Wednesday

395
00:34:35,655 --> 00:34:40,461
morning. And the latest proposals, as you
see, are cuts to social funds and regional

396
00:34:40,515 --> 00:34:43,262
support, and a rise in
money for arms dealers.

397
00:34:43,335 --> 00:34:48,308
So we are asking for smart, targeted, own
resources that raise the budget, yes, but

398
00:34:48,345 --> 00:34:52,160
raise the budget for what? For people. I
mean, the MFF debate is going to be held on

399
00:34:52,202 --> 00:34:56,068
the same day as the International Day for
the Illuminating Violence Against Women.

400
00:34:56,115 --> 00:35:00,145
And I'm not going to repeat what we've
heard from the Greens and the socialists

401
00:35:00,195 --> 00:35:02,318
here, but I'll just I'll just
add one more point on this.

402
00:35:02,355 --> 00:35:06,604
I mean, just one example of the
importance of the economy for people.

403
00:35:06,675 --> 00:35:11,195
I mean, a woman who has the resources and
the opportunities to be able to move out

404
00:35:11,239 --> 00:35:16,108
and rent her own flat will be more likely
to be able to leave her husband and

405
00:35:16,179 --> 00:35:20,605
recover. So the latest polling shows the
top priority of European citizens is the

406
00:35:20,660 --> 00:35:23,962
cost of living. And we have the
debate. You see it on the title.

407
00:35:24,015 --> 00:35:28,665
Our name is there. On the cost of living.
So we need a social emergency to tackle

408
00:35:28,715 --> 00:35:32,656
poverty and end the housing crisis. And we
have invited, and we've sent the request

409
00:35:32,701 --> 00:35:38,106
to Ursula von der Leyen to come and
hear how we are intending to do it.

410
00:35:38,295 --> 00:35:43,898
So I end with that people will, and are,
you see it in the streets, people are

411
00:35:43,940 --> 00:35:48,570
fighting back against this commission, this
parliament, continuing to make it easier

412
00:35:48,628 --> 00:35:51,432
to wipe out animal and
plant life for profit.

413
00:35:51,495 --> 00:35:54,902
And cut social spending to
fund weapons designed to kill.

414
00:35:54,975 --> 00:35:59,337
People will reject these policies. It won't
be long before it's election time, and

415
00:35:59,390 --> 00:36:03,835
the European people sweep the left
group into politics, into power.

416
00:36:03,915 --> 00:36:06,324
We're working people can
finally take a breath.

417
00:36:06,375 --> 00:36:11,285
And if you want to hear more, please come
to our co-chairs, press conference at

418
00:36:11,370 --> 00:36:14,374
11:30 a. m. with Manolo Brie and
Martin Cherdovan in Strasbourg.

419
00:36:14,415 --> 00:36:15,615
Thank you very much.

420
00:36:15,915 --> 00:36:17,115
Thank you very much, Tom.

421
00:36:17,415 --> 00:36:22,830
Creidim go bhfuil Vijay
ar líne. Ón ngrúpa ESN.

422
00:36:22,923 --> 00:36:24,855
Vijay, is leat an focal anois.

423
00:36:31,095 --> 00:36:36,015
Hi. Hello. Sorry to connect
remotely. I hope you hear me well.

424
00:36:41,595 --> 00:36:45,201
Je vais dire quelques mots sur les votes.
Concernant les différents textes des

425
00:36:45,239 --> 00:36:49,517
paquets Omnibus 4 et Omnibus 8,
notre position sera assez simple.

426
00:36:49,575 --> 00:36:53,372
Nous soutiendrons toutes les dispositions
qui permettent de réduire réellement les

427
00:36:53,440 --> 00:36:57,133
contraintes administratives et
réglementaires pesant sur les entreprises

428
00:36:57,189 --> 00:37:00,717
européennes. Mais nous rappellerons aussi
que ces mesures de simplification visent

429
00:37:00,773 --> 00:37:05,420
pour l'essentiel à corriger les effets
de réglementation que les institutions

430
00:37:05,466 --> 00:37:09,935
européennes ont elles-mêmes adoptées. Et
il y a quelque chose d'assez paradoxal dans

431
00:37:09,985 --> 00:37:13,887
cette situation, puisqu'on impose de
nouvelles obligations aux entreprises, puis

432
00:37:13,935 --> 00:37:18,064
quelques années plus tard, on constate
qu'elles sont trop lourdes et l'on décide

433
00:37:18,126 --> 00:37:22,205
alors de les alléger. Mais entre-temps,
les entreprises ont dû en supporter les

434
00:37:22,262 --> 00:37:27,409
conséquences. Certaines ont dû renoncer
à investir, d'autres ont perdu en

435
00:37:27,471 --> 00:37:30,543
compétitivité, et
certaines ont même disparu.

436
00:37:30,615 --> 00:37:35,158
Nous soutiendrons donc les véritables
mesures de simplification et, en revanche,

437
00:37:35,235 --> 00:37:38,592
nous nous opposerons aux textes qui
sous-couvertent de simplification

438
00:37:38,658 --> 00:37:42,645
réintroduiraient des obligations
précédemment écartées.

439
00:37:42,735 --> 00:37:46,926
Et je voudrais maintenant revenir sur
trois débats politiques qui étaient

440
00:37:46,974 --> 00:37:51,009
initialement prévus à l'agenda
de la session plénière.

441
00:37:51,075 --> 00:37:56,198
Le premier concerne la situation de
l'État de droit en Hongrie et la procédure

442
00:37:56,260 --> 00:38:00,675
engagée contre ce pays au titre
de l'article 7 du traité de l'UE.

443
00:38:00,795 --> 00:38:04,076
Et je voudrais dire qu'à cet égard,
notre position n'a pas changé.

444
00:38:04,155 --> 00:38:09,740
Elle était la même avant et après les
élections hongroises d'avril 2026, puisque

445
00:38:09,805 --> 00:38:13,793
c'est une position de principe. En effet,
nous considérons que les institutions

446
00:38:13,827 --> 00:38:18,067
européennes doivent respecter les choix
politiques exprimés démocratiquement par les

447
00:38:18,111 --> 00:38:22,107
citoyens des États membres. Et nous
contestons que l'utilisation des financements

448
00:38:22,155 --> 00:38:27,620
européens soit conçue comme un moyen de
pression sur les gouvernements nationaux.

449
00:38:27,675 --> 00:38:31,963
En effet, lorsque des fonds sont suspendus
pour contraindre un État membre à

450
00:38:32,020 --> 00:38:36,259
modifier ses choix politiques, nous considérons
qu'il s'agit d'une forme de chantage

451
00:38:36,314 --> 00:38:37,335
politique.

452
00:38:37,335 --> 00:38:40,841
Bien entendu, les États membres ont des
obligations qui découlent des traités, mais

453
00:38:40,884 --> 00:38:43,856
les procédures destinées à garantir
leur respect ne doivent pas devenir des

454
00:38:43,910 --> 00:38:48,615
instruments qui permettent aux institutions
européennes d'imposer leurs préférences

455
00:38:48,675 --> 00:38:51,751
politiques. Le deuxième débat
concerne le coût de la vie.

456
00:38:51,795 --> 00:38:55,791
C'est le débat dont il vient d'être question
et qui est porté par le groupe de la

457
00:38:55,834 --> 00:38:59,915
gauche. Il se tiendra mercredi. Nous y
participerons bien volontiers, car nous avons

458
00:38:59,955 --> 00:39:04,645
des propositions à formuler sur ce sujet.
Et notre conviction là-dessus est très

459
00:39:04,692 --> 00:39:08,547
simple : c'est que le pouvoir d'achat ce
n'est pas ce que l'État vous donne, mais

460
00:39:08,595 --> 00:39:12,524
c'est ce qu'il ne vous prend pas. Et
c'est une différence fondamentale avec

461
00:39:12,572 --> 00:39:16,644
l'approche qui consiste à répondre
systématiquement aux difficultés économiques par

462
00:39:16,698 --> 00:39:20,401
davantage de dépenses
publiques et de redistribution.

463
00:39:20,475 --> 00:39:24,519
La députée Sarah Knafo a d'ailleurs consacré
un ouvrage à cette question, « Le casse

464
00:39:24,573 --> 00:39:28,226
du siècle », qui a eu un
retentissement considérable en France.

465
00:39:28,275 --> 00:39:32,110
Elle y décrit comment une part considérable
des revenus des salariés est absorbée

466
00:39:32,156 --> 00:39:37,057
par les impôts et les cotisations sociales
pour financer un État devenu obèse qui

467
00:39:37,155 --> 00:39:42,219
coûte toujours plus cher. Mais surtout, je
voudrais évoquer un dernier débat, celui

468
00:39:42,272 --> 00:39:46,215
qui était inscrit à l'ordre du jour
et qui finalement n'aura pas lieu.

469
00:39:46,275 --> 00:39:49,464
Pour cette session de novembre, en effet,
notre groupe devait proposer un débat.

470
00:39:49,515 --> 00:39:53,609
C'était notre droit le plus absolu. Nous
avions le droit d'en choisir le sujet.

471
00:39:53,655 --> 00:39:56,700
Nous avions le droit d'en définir la
portée et d'en choisir les termes.

472
00:39:56,775 --> 00:40:02,435
Et ce débat devrait être présenté lors de
la dernière conférence des présidents qui

473
00:40:02,535 --> 00:40:09,111
s'est tenue mercredi. Et on nous a
refusé le droit de tenir ce débat.

474
00:40:09,195 --> 00:40:12,011
Nous considérons cette
décision scandaleuse.

475
00:40:12,075 --> 00:40:15,855
Nous voulions parler d'immigration,
probablement le sujet de préoccupation le plus

476
00:40:15,904 --> 00:40:19,506
important du débat politique européen.
On a le droit d'être, pour certaines

477
00:40:19,543 --> 00:40:22,232
propositions, à la matière.
On a le droit d'être contre.

478
00:40:22,275 --> 00:40:26,415
On a même le droit d'être profondément
choqué par certaines propositions.

479
00:40:26,475 --> 00:40:30,910
Mais la démocratie consiste précisément à
pouvoir défendre ses idées, à avancer ses

480
00:40:30,968 --> 00:40:36,002
arguments et à les confronter à ceux
des autres sans craindre d'être censuré.

481
00:40:36,135 --> 00:40:40,261
Notre parlement européen se présente
volontiers comme le temple de la démocratie,

482
00:40:40,313 --> 00:40:44,095
mais il n'y a pas de démocratie si des
représentants élus ne peuvent même plus

483
00:40:44,147 --> 00:40:48,420
choisir les sujets dont ils souhaitent
débattre et s'ils ne peuvent plus en choisir

484
00:40:48,495 --> 00:40:51,600
les termes. Je vous rappelle à tous,
chers collègues, que si nous devons tous

485
00:40:51,641 --> 00:40:55,205
employer les mêmes mots, alors nous ne
sommes plus libres d'exprimer des idées

486
00:40:55,257 --> 00:40:59,681
différentes. Et si nous ne débattons que
lorsque nous sommes d'accord sur tout,

487
00:40:59,734 --> 00:41:02,241
alors cela signifie que
nous ne débattons plus.

488
00:41:02,295 --> 00:41:05,936
Je voudrais vraiment que chacun
à cet égard se ressaisisse.

489
00:41:06,015 --> 00:41:07,215
Je vous remercie.

490
00:41:07,995 --> 00:41:09,195
Merci, Vijay.

491
00:41:10,155 --> 00:41:15,424
Right, now to some of your questions.
To the group, so myself, please.

492
00:41:15,495 --> 00:41:18,495
Introduce yourself and ask your
question to whomever you wish.

493
00:41:20,895 --> 00:41:23,886
Hello, Blaž Mohorčič with
the Slovenian Press Agency.

494
00:41:23,955 --> 00:41:30,585
I have a question for the EPP.
This week your former member, Mr.

495
00:41:30,675 --> 00:41:36,332
Grims, joined Patriots. So I would like and
other members of the Slovenian party, as

496
00:41:36,390 --> 00:41:42,358
they are staying in your group, I would
like to know is it acceptable for you that,

497
00:41:42,435 --> 00:41:49,035
as they have members in two different
groups, one is Euroskeptical, how do you see

498
00:41:49,095 --> 00:41:53,745
that? And do you expect
that, as they would expel Mr.

499
00:41:53,835 --> 00:41:55,095
Grims from the party? Thank you.

500
00:42:00,135 --> 00:42:05,840
As I told another Slovenian
journalist yesterday, we expel Mr.

501
00:42:05,955 --> 00:42:11,492
Grims on July. And since then,
he can do whatever he wants.

502
00:42:11,715 --> 00:42:18,124
And regarding his membership of
SDS, it's up to SDS to decide.

503
00:42:18,195 --> 00:42:19,695
It's not up to us.

504
00:42:23,715 --> 00:42:26,655
Okay. Thank you. And any
other questions? David.

505
00:42:28,755 --> 00:42:35,235
Hi. David Abioko from Argus Media. I
had a question for the ESN ECR and the

506
00:42:35,399 --> 00:42:42,010
Patriots. At the beginning of the month,
the lead, the reporter for the ETS, was

507
00:42:42,068 --> 00:42:47,357
saying it was, I don't want to quote him
because I forget the exact words, but the

508
00:42:47,398 --> 00:42:51,248
question was, you know, how
can you work with the ECR?

509
00:42:51,495 --> 00:42:53,371
The negotiations have
been a bit difficult.

510
00:42:53,415 --> 00:42:58,140
On the other side of the political
spectrum, in terms of the reform, I was

511
00:42:58,192 --> 00:43:05,706
wondering, do you see an opportunity
there that you could form a right-wing or

512
00:43:05,895 --> 00:43:11,379
majority in terms of ETS reform? I mean,
some of you are calling for it to be

513
00:43:11,425 --> 00:43:16,482
scrapped totally. We had a slight statement
there that, you know, other countries

514
00:43:16,540 --> 00:43:19,681
need to do more on climate
before the EU does.

515
00:43:19,755 --> 00:43:24,738
So I was wondering for you three groups,
how do you see working together there?

516
00:43:24,795 --> 00:43:25,995
Thanks.

517
00:43:28,575 --> 00:43:29,775
Alonso.

518
00:43:37,544 --> 00:43:42,764
Ähm, und dieses "Cooperations we
always work on a case by case"—

519
00:43:44,204 --> 00:43:49,088
Basis, and of course there's sometimes
cooperation with the right majority, but if

520
00:43:49,152 --> 00:43:54,052
we form a majority it also depends on other
groups, like EPP and Renew sometimes, on

521
00:43:54,085 --> 00:43:55,285
these things.

522
00:43:56,084 --> 00:43:58,004
And Vijay? You want to contribute?

523
00:43:59,144 --> 00:44:03,316
Oui, exactement la même réponse. Nous
sommes toujours favorables à des majorités

524
00:44:03,366 --> 00:44:08,641
alternatives, évidemment pour le coup ça
dépend toujours du groupe PPE, mais nous y

525
00:44:08,704 --> 00:44:12,774
sommes déjà parvenus, nous y sommes parvenus
sur la directive retour, nous y sommes

526
00:44:12,844 --> 00:44:17,498
parvenus sur la directive sur la déforestation,
et en la matière je crois que nous

527
00:44:17,542 --> 00:44:24,335
sommes tous d'accord pour révoquer les
éléments contraignants du Green Deal qui

528
00:44:24,391 --> 00:44:28,737
s'imposent de manière malheureuse à
nos entreprises et à nos États membres.

529
00:44:28,784 --> 00:44:31,484
Donc oui, un grand oui
pour former des coalitions.

530
00:44:34,304 --> 00:44:36,644
Right. Any other questions? Max?

531
00:44:39,044 --> 00:44:42,344
Hi, I'm Max Gilera for Politico.
I have several questions.

532
00:44:42,404 --> 00:44:46,825
I'll start with the most important one.
The Greens did drinks with the Bureau, S&D,

533
00:44:46,880 --> 00:44:52,901
they're doing it next week when our Renew
and EPP are going to follow with Bureau

534
00:44:52,966 --> 00:44:56,492
drinks with the press, so
that we can talk to them.

535
00:44:56,564 --> 00:45:02,961
In terms of actual content, I want to
ask about the Hungarian resolution.

536
00:45:03,044 --> 00:45:09,186
That will be voted in December. For S&D,
Greens, and Renew, can you indicate already

537
00:45:09,257 --> 00:45:16,806
whether you're ready to support
awarding that says to lift article 7?

538
00:45:17,084 --> 00:45:21,466
And then on MFF, I'm curious
about some self-reflection.

539
00:45:21,524 --> 00:45:25,555
We're talking about
cutting costs. Yesterday.

540
00:45:25,604 --> 00:45:31,073
The COP approved 12 million euros in
travel costs for the next 6 years.

541
00:45:31,244 --> 00:45:38,523
Including 4 missions to Australia, which
will cost a million euros to the taxpayers.

542
00:45:38,624 --> 00:45:42,061
Is there any intention
to perhaps rain this in?

543
00:45:42,164 --> 00:45:45,659
Jeroen Lanners, the chief whip of EPP,
made that suggestion yesterday in the COP.

544
00:45:45,704 --> 00:45:49,004
Perhaps EPP Pedro could you
give us your view on that too?

545
00:45:49,364 --> 00:45:55,724
Thank you. Who's? Pedro,
you're going to go first?

546
00:45:58,604 --> 00:46:02,635
Max, as I told you yesterday, the EPP
made the comment in the conference of

547
00:46:02,684 --> 00:46:09,806
presidents that we need to pay attention
on the extent and the length of these

548
00:46:09,868 --> 00:46:14,067
missions and that was a general
call to the other groups.

549
00:46:14,144 --> 00:46:19,690
To really focus on the missions
that are really worth it.

550
00:46:19,844 --> 00:46:27,771
Regarding further cost, let's the heads of
government decide on what is the overall

551
00:46:27,875 --> 00:46:37,087
of the budget and what is decided to. Be
attributed to the EU institutions and then

552
00:46:37,157 --> 00:46:43,278
the EU institutions we will adapt because
as we have always done in the past we

553
00:46:43,355 --> 00:46:48,998
always take the measures necessary to adapt
ourselves to the budget we need to cut

554
00:46:49,075 --> 00:46:54,272
emissions of the staff or whatever it is
or salaries or pensions so like any other

555
00:46:54,344 --> 00:46:58,124
public administration we will
act once there is an agreement.

556
00:47:00,464 --> 00:47:03,308
Anybody want to react on the
either of those questions?

557
00:47:03,344 --> 00:47:06,404
There was another one on rule
of law resolution in December.

558
00:47:10,424 --> 00:47:15,944
Regarding your question on Hungary, we
as group continued to develop to follow

559
00:47:16,004 --> 00:47:22,708
developments of course in Hungary very
closely the steps announced by the government

560
00:47:22,784 --> 00:47:28,687
by the new government are welcome but we
think that further reforms are needed in

561
00:47:28,729 --> 00:47:34,654
particular on fundamental rights and the
rule of law given the damage done by the

562
00:47:34,724 --> 00:47:40,754
urban regime which was mentioned this
morning also restoring the rule of law and

563
00:47:40,844 --> 00:47:47,780
fundamental values in Hungary will take
time the parliament here must keep a very

564
00:47:47,842 --> 00:47:54,565
close eye on progress while respecting
the processes and procedures that is says

565
00:47:54,629 --> 00:47:58,244
developments and thus including
the article 7 procedure thank you.

566
00:48:00,344 --> 00:48:02,444
Thank you very much. Pia and Linda?

567
00:48:07,544 --> 00:48:12,593
So on Hungary, Renew Europe welcome the
clear political will to restore the rule of

568
00:48:12,638 --> 00:48:17,684
law and build a more inclusive Hungarian
society we have always called for EU funds

569
00:48:17,744 --> 00:48:22,613
to be released only when real reforms
are made and Hungary proves that EU

570
00:48:22,668 --> 00:48:26,084
conditionality works on the
drinks we take later or now?

571
00:48:27,884 --> 00:48:29,924
You can. No, it's all right. Pia?

572
00:48:31,124 --> 00:48:35,266
Thanks. Yeah, I can add on there has been
achieved already a lot in Hungary but

573
00:48:35,313 --> 00:48:39,364
there's still a lot to be done and we are
discussing within the group so can get

574
00:48:39,408 --> 00:48:40,608
back to that later.

575
00:48:42,584 --> 00:48:47,371
Yeah. On the issue of delegation visits,
obviously the committees and delegations of

576
00:48:47,418 --> 00:48:52,362
parliaments undertake visits to third
countries or even capitals cities and cities

577
00:48:52,424 --> 00:48:57,644
around Europe as part of their mission to
inform themselves on policy issues make

578
00:48:57,764 --> 00:49:04,494
context and work as part of a parliamentary
diplomacy initiatives the decisions to

579
00:49:04,534 --> 00:49:07,844
travel are taken by the coordinators of
the various committees and the delegations

580
00:49:07,884 --> 00:49:13,011
as such and then collectively decide decide
about the Bureau on the drinks question

581
00:49:13,057 --> 00:49:17,032
I think I'll leave it up to the groups at
in and whenever it's occasion to invite

582
00:49:17,084 --> 00:49:22,207
the journalists for the drinks you don't
need to answer that first question now or

583
00:49:22,249 --> 00:49:28,724
you can do it bilaterally and invite Max
to your secret party afterwards any other

584
00:49:28,924 --> 00:49:35,944
questions? If not none online I'll let
you get back to following Andy Burnum with

585
00:49:35,979 --> 00:49:38,849
the over he is at the moment and thank you
for attending this session and I'll see

586
00:49:38,884 --> 00:49:40,084
you all next week in Strasbourg.
