Brussels Live · Plenary sitting 2026-11-12 Transcribed and translated automatically from the original sound. Mistakes are possible. Machine translation. The original is authoritative. Independent service, not affiliated with the European Parliament or the European Commission. Source: © European Union. AI-generated: Transcripts, translations and summaries on this site are generated automatically by AI: speech recognition (Soniox), machine translation and summaries (Mistral AI). Not edited by humans before publication. EU AI Act, Article 50. [09:01:02] Christel Schaldemose (S&D) [EN] So good morning, colleagues. The sitting is open. I have received from the Council its position at first reading regarding the following two files: payment services in the internal markets and payment services and electronic money services in the internal market. I have also received the reasons which led to their adoption and the Commission's positions. The full title will be "Titles will be published in the minutes of today's sitting. " The three-month period available to Parliament to adopt its positions begins tomorrow, the 13th of November. The next item on the agenda is the Council and Commission statements further EU sanctions against Russia in response to this escalating attacks against Ukraine. Cutting off the sources financing the Russian war. And as always, we will begin with the Council and Minister Harking. Please, the floor is yours. [09:02:16] Marian Harkin [EN] President, Honorable Members, Commissioner. Thank you for this timely debate. As we approach the fifth anniversary of Russia's full-scale invasion, Ukraine continues to stand and fight with our unwavering support. But we must also look—excuse me—at the immediate challenges ahead. The coming months will be very difficult for Ukraine. As winter approaches, Russia is intensifying its attacks against civilians, and civilian infrastructure. Russia targets energy facilities, transport networks, hospitals, and schools. These attacks aim to weaken Ukraine, undermine its economy, and exhaust its people. They must, however, not weaken our resolve. Russia's ability to wage this war depends on its ability to finance it. The European Parliament has consistently called for stronger sanctions and tougher actions against circumvention. We share this objective. And the European Union has already taken substantial action. Through 21 sanctions packages, we have progressively restricted Russia's access to energy revenues, financial services, technology, and goods needed by its military industry. The 21st package adopted in July further targeted Russia's energy and financial sectors and extended restrictions against the shadow fleet. In October, the Council went further and adopted the largest-ever listings proposal targeting close to 1,600 companies and individuals linked to Russia's military-industrial complex. These measures matter. But their effectiveness also depends on their implementation and enforcement. Russia continues to rely on intermediaries, third countries, and complex trade networks to circumvent our restrictions. We must make these channels increasingly difficult and costly to use. This is where we are focusing our efforts. In October, the European Council called for additional measures in coordination with our partners to further fight circumvention and curb shadow fleet operations. As we prepare to receive the Commission's proposal, for the 22nd sanctions package, the [09:05:25] Marian Harkin [EN] Irish presidency stands ready to work with member states to make swift progress. Strengthened unity is not just the motto of our presidency; it is also a necessity in this matter where the adoption of sanctions requires unanimity in the Council. This is all the more important as Russia continues to use hybrid attacks and disinformation in an attempt to undermine our unity. But our response cannot stop at sanctions. Increasing pressure on Russia must go hand in hand with continued support for Ukraine. First of all, this support is military and material. We are strengthening our military support to the extension of EU MAMS mandate, and the mobilization of the 6.6 billion euro under the European Peace Facility. We are also helping Ukraine protect and repair its critical infrastructure through the Ukraine Energy Support Fund. Secondly, our support is financial. Key disbursements under the 90 billion euro Ukraine Support Loan for 2026 and 2027 are underway. We expect Ukraine to continue implementing the reforms required to receive further disbursement under the Ukraine Facility. Thirdly, our support is political. The opening of accession negotiations clusters two and three on the 13th of October this year marked another step towards Ukraine and European future. So our message is clear: we will maintain our support and continue to weaken Russia's capacity to finance its war until it ends its aggression and engages in meaningful negotiations towards a lasting peace. Thank you for your attention. [09:07:48] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very, very much, Minister Harking. And now I will give the floor to the Commissioner and Commissioner Albuquerque. Please, the floor is yours. [09:08:02] 263973 [EN] President, Honorable Members, Minister. In response to Russia's illegal and unprovoked full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, the EU swiftly adopted unprecedentedly tough sanctions, in close cooperation with international partners, including the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and Japan. The rapid succession of the 21 packages of EU sanctions adopted since the outset of the war have resulted in an unparalleled set of measures. Overall, the scope of the sectoral sanctions is immense, ranging from trade energy and transport to finance and media. In addition, since last autumn, the EU has been adopting additional rounds of listings at every foreign affairs council. The largest such listing package in October targeted the Russian military-industrial complex and brought the total number of entities and individuals listed for undermining Ukraine's territorial integrity close to 4,600. We have heavily targeted Russia's oil and gas sector, its main source of revenues, and will continue to do so. To date, the EU has listed more than 690 shadow fleet vessels that are barred from EU ports and services. We have cut off large parts of Russia's financial sector, causing it to rely on alternative payment channels and we have introduced measures to curb those too. So far, we have placed more than 100 Russian banks under an EU transaction ban. Through our collective work, we have banned exports to Russia of weapons and other goods that could be used in the battlefield. And we have suspended the broadcasting of Russian media outlets in the EU that just serve to spread propaganda. Sanctions work and Moscow knows it. They have caused Russia over 1 trillion euros that it could have otherwise spent on the war. Honorable Members, despite all ongoing diplomatic efforts, Russia shows no willingness to stop its war of aggression against Ukraine. Unable to move the front line, Russia has escalated its massive systematic missile and drone attacks against civilians across Ukraine aiming to cause as much terror as possible. [09:10:46] 263973 [EN] Moscow, as also stepped up in its hybrid attacks on Europe, hoping to break our resolve. It has had the opposite effect. The EU stands unwavering and united in our support for Ukraine as it defends its independence, sovereignty, and territorial integrity, and its people from the aggressor. At their last summit in October, European leaders were very clear on the need to continue raising pressure so that Russia engages seriously in talks to end this war of aggression and achieve peace. This reflects a joint understanding: sanctions must be maintained and increased, until there is just and lasting peace. Therefore, the European Council called for further measures in coordination with partners to reduce Russia's energy revenues close loopholes and combat the circumvention of sanctions. Honorable Members, the EU will lead the way on further sanctions on Russia in alignment with partners whenever possible, to maximize their impact and limit circumvention. Coordinated pressure works best, strengthening both the political message and enforcement. We continue working together in various formats, including the G7, to that end. Honorable Members, next Monday, EU Foreign Ministers are poised to adopt further listing measures on oil refineries, refineries, and the shadow fleet ecosystem. This is yet another round of hard listings targeting the malicious attempts of enablers and profiteers of Russia's war of aggression. The EAS and the Commission are also finalizing proposals for a comprehensive 22nd package of sanctions. We will continue using sanctions to limit Russia's capacity to wage this war, to strengthen enforcement of EU measures, and counter their circumvention, and to ensure accountability for violations of international law. The support of this House to further strengthen pressure on Russia is much appreciated. Thank you. [09:13:04] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much, Commissioner. And now we will take the first round of speakers on behalf of the political groups, beginning with Mr. Halitsky, on behalf of EPP for one and a half minutes, please. [09:13:18] Andrzej Halicki (PPE) [PL] Ladies and Gentlemen, the European sanctions policy cannot change with regard to Russia until the last Russian aggressor soldier leaves the territory of Ukraine. We must be consistent and determined, this time the energy sector, the financial sector is the one that will be subject to sanctions. We demand a longer list of individual sanctions and a very strict correction policy, a visa policy. But this is a package we talk about very often and we also continue to call for consistent enforcement. There is one issue that we can no longer debate—we must act. The frozen Russian funds and assets. €185 billion in accounts, due to the concerns of one country, Belgium, remain unused. But they must be put to work in support of Ukraine. That is why, in writing, I would like to thank here my colleague Ties Reuten from the Socialists and Democrats, but also on behalf of the European People’s Party, we are calling in writing for the creation of a trust fund that will be guaranteed by all Member States, which will minimise those legal concerns, and these funds must be put to work to support Ukraine, to help rebuild critical infrastructure, and also to provide assistance that will end this war. And one final thing: kidnappings are still taking place. Children are being abducted to places where they are being Russified, over 200 such places in Russia, 13 in Belarus. Russia is a terrorist state. And we must speak out about this loudly, supporting the International Criminal Court, because this is an element of a policy that has a genocidal character. Putin is a war criminal. [09:15:06] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And on behalf of S&D, Mr. Reuten, for one and a half minutes, please. [09:15:11] Thijs Reuten (S&D) [EN] President, Council, Commission, colleagues, I would almost hope that Europe's leaders simply put off difficult decisions on sanctions, assets, air defense, deep strike, travel bans, the SkyShield, or retaliation. Out of hope for real results this time. But if we are honest, expectations of Abu Dhabi were very low. At least with me, simply because the entire setup is wrong with one consistent element from the US side, a piecing the aggressor and pressuring the victim. And I acknowledge what you said and what the European Union has done so far, and your personal commitment. But we need more. European components still end up in Russian drones and missiles built on machines running on European lubricants, carrying explosives made with European chemical precursors. How can we ask from third countries to stop circumvention if our own house is not in order? National carve-outs, information not shared, too few prosecutions, and no real EU oversight. The Court of Auditors stated yesterday, "Europe lacks the will to implement in good faith." The new sanctions office could be a welcome step, but only if it has real teeth. So close the loopholes and end forum shopping, fully ban exports of alumina, chemical precursors, and lubricants, and make producers' tech their high-priority components and make them liable when they turn up in Russian weapons. There is no point in just hoping this war will end. The Russians made that very clear yesterday. Thank you. [09:16:43] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And the next speaker is on behalf of the Patriots, Ms. Ceccardi, for two minutes, please. [09:16:52] Susanna Ceccardi (PfE) [IT] Thank you, Mr President. Today marks the 1,723rd day since the start of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Nearly five years of war, and in the meantime, how much has Europe mobilised? €235 billion, of which almost €78 billion in military assistance. To these commitments is added a €90 billion loan for 2026 and 2027, already approved. How much has the war cost our businesses? Between 2021 and 2025, European exports to Russia have fallen by almost €69 billion. That’s a 69.5% contraction in exports per year. A figure that testifies to how much trade relations have changed and that requires us to also assess the economic consequences of sanctions on our businesses. I would like to ask the Commission and President von der Leyen what concrete results these 21 packages of sanctions have produced. What diplomatic strategy accompanies these measures? Talks between the United States, Russia and Ukraine were held in Abu Dhabi. Europe is involved in the diplomatic coordination, but not directly at the trilateral table. After hundreds of billions mobilised, Europe is not even at the table. After almost five years, we must acknowledge a fundamental truth: there can be no lasting security in Europe without peace and with this European Commission unable to deliver it. Your responsibility is not to sign endless cheques, but to contribute to a serious and credible diplomatic solution. Our citizens demand answers; so do businesses. Our businesses need stability, our economies need investment, and European taxpayers deserve to know where their money is being used responsibly. The time has come to stop measuring Europe’s commitment in billions spent and start measuring it in the capacity to build real peace. [09:19:05] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. And the next speaker is on behalf of ECR, Mr. Posniaks, for one minute, please. [09:19:12] Reinis Pozņaks (ECR) [PL] Dear. [09:19:12] Reinis Pozņaks (ECR) [LV] Colleagues, since Russia is failing to break Ukraine's armed forces on the front, it is trying to break Ukrainian society. Russia is attacking hospitals, schools, and energy infrastructure with thousands of drones and hundreds of missiles, killing hundreds and injuring thousands of civilians. While Russia is blocking Ukraine's grain exports with attacks in the Black Sea, it continues to export its own grain through European ports. The shadow fleet is still transporting Russian oil and fuelling its war machine. We are desperately looking for additional funding to help Ukraine survive the winter, but Russia’s frozen state assets remain frozen and are not being confiscated. And in Russian drones and missiles we are still finding components from Western companies. We have long known what needs to be done: it is time to act, and no less important is to ensure that the sanctions already in place actually work. Thank you. [09:20:18] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. And the next speaker is on behalf of Renew, and that is Mr. Goetze for one minute, please. [09:20:29] Bernard Guetta (Renew) [FR] I don’t know about you, but I, for one, am angry with all of us – citizens and elected representatives alike – in our 27 countries. I am not angry with ourselves for not immediately sanctioning all those Russians who should have been. I do not blame all of us, citizens and elected representatives of our 27 countries. I do not blame us for not having immediately sanctioned all those Russians who should have been. I do not blame us for not having already made available to Ukraine enough weapons and Russian assets of which we are the custodians. I do not blame us for not doing enough, because we are not doing so little. But I do blame us for not calling things by their name before the world. Vladimir Putin would like to reconstitute the Tsars’ Empire. Failing to have prevailed on the ground, he now wants to break the Ukrainian civilians with cold, bombs and thirst. He claims to want peace but continues his war and spreads aggression across Europe. So let us call Putin what he is. You, sir, are a murderer. A child abductor. A dictator. The most deranged of liars, and the last of the colonisers. [09:21:38] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. And the next speaker is Mr. Stefanucci on behalf of the Greens for one and a half minutes, please. [09:21:47] Nicolae Ștefănuță (Verts/ALE) [EN] Counsel, I want you to pass a message to Mr. Bart De Waver. When will he finally lift his veto against Russian assets seized by the European Union when only his own fridge will stop because of daily aggression against the citizens, against the electricity grid, against all that? When will we lift this incredibly stupid thing to do? Secondly, I heard Ms. Ceccardi speaking about the effects of sanctions on the economy. Doesn't the biggest effect on your economy come from the fact that Russia started a war from the beginning? Doesn't that, isn't that the biggest effect? So-called patriots, isn't that the reason why our citizens are suffering the most? It's not the sanctions. Sanctions work when they are applied correctly. Structurally. And not when we leave a million loopholes. Because we have 100 components found in Russian drones that were produced by European firms. So let's stop with the hypocrisy, because these drones attack us, attack our homeland. Drones landed in a block of flats in Galați, in Romania. There will be a matter of days or weeks when there will be European victims. There have been victims in the Black Sea. We just don't talk too much because they're not European, but there have been victims of ships being drowned. By Russian drones. Member States must implement the sanctions directive. It was already supposed to be done by 2025. Let's push it. Because they are pushing us. They are coming for us. And qualified majority voting should be introduced in the Council to stop this ridiculousness where only one Member State stops one action or the other. We cannot continue like this. Because we are not being taken seriously. We need to be taken seriously so to truly defend our citizens. Thank you. [09:23:42] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is Ms. Demirel for one minute on behalf of. [09:23:48] Özlem Demirel (The Left) [DE] Thank you, Madam President! Negotiations are taking place in Abu Dhabi, but without the EU. And what is the EU doing? It is once again talking about sanctions. But even the next sanctions package will not end this war. Especially since the European Court of Auditors has just found that the sanctions are not working properly because not even all Member States want to implement them. Colleagues, do you know *The Simpsons*? There is an episode in which Lisa tests Bart’s intelligence against that of his hamster. Despite hidden electric shocks, Bart keeps reaching for the muffin time and time again. The hamster learns faster, stops. Dear Commission, you must finally understand: your strategy of more weapons, more sanctions is not achieving its goal. At least not if the goal is to end the war. Instead, your sanctions are also contributing to price increases worldwide. People are feeling this. At the petrol pump, when heating their homes, with gas. Finally change your strategy, work on an exit plan. Not just because of the prices, but above all because of the human lives at stake in this war. [09:24:59] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Mr. Urich on behalf of ESN for one and a half minutes, please. [09:25:06] Milan Uhrík (ESN) [SK] Colleagues, most of you here are talking about what Russia has done, what it should do, and what it should not do. But dear progressives, hello, wake up, it is your favourite Chancellor Merz who is now threatening to blackmail the whole of Europe, saying that if we do not also give, yes, 70 billion euros to Ukraine, he will stop funding for the entire European Union. What kind of nonsense is this? What kind of absurdity is this? Forgive me, have you all gone completely mad? What is the point of all these consolidation efforts then? What is the point of raising taxes and tightening belts for hard-working European citizens if, in the end, all the money saved is sent to Zelenskyy for the war in Ukraine? What kind of audacity is this? Who exactly are you actually serving when money for Ukrainians is more important to you than money for Europeans themselves, for European states? Money for schools, for hospitals, for regions, local authorities, farmers. Did we join such an Union? We do not want an Union where every year we will systematically have to pay for Ukraine, sometimes 40, sometimes 70 billion euros. If Merz wants to, let him pay; let him pay from his own pocket. You also pay for Ukraine from your own, but you have no right. You have no right to force us to pay money to Ukraine compulsorily. I understand that you are afraid that Ms Le Pen will win in France, that the AfD will succeed in Germany, that the Republika movement will emerge in Slovakia, and that we will stop financing Ukraine. That is why you want to change the voting system for aid to Ukraine from unanimous to majority voting. Because you hope to somehow patch it up. But no. We will stop you. And I am speaking on behalf of hundreds of millions of Europeans: we have had enough. We do not want to send any more money to Ukraine; we want peace at last, we want calm at last, and we want the money to stay in Europe. [09:26:56] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. I will now please, please quiet, colleagues. And respect each other. I will now open up for the blue card and invite you to use it. And the next speaker is Mr. Gala for one minute, please. [09:27:10] Michael Gahler (PPE) [EN] Thank you very much, colleagues. Well, the previous speaker forgot who is responsible for the cost that we have. It's Putin's war of aggression. Why we have all these costs. And you are his puppet. And I wonder what you profit from that. You will not have a future in Europe with Putin winning this war. And that is why we need to be very clear what the objective is. As we have seen in Abu Dhabi, Putin does not even want a ceasefire. Putin wants to kick the can down the road, wants to get over the winter because he doesn't, he will attack Ukrainian civilian targets in order to get them agreeing to his demands. We will remain clear and with regard to the sanctions that we have to apply, I think we need indeed to be more forceful in the implementation. And for my specific German case, when it comes to the shadow fleet, I call on my own government to be as courageous as the Finns, the Danes, and the Swedes are in controlling these ships. We are not doing enough in this regard. So that is one specific thing that we could also do in this field. Thank you very much. [09:28:19] Speaker 2 [EN] Mr. Gala, there is a blue card. There is a Mr. Gala. Mr. Gala, do you want to take a blue card from Mr. Dostel? Seat 854, please. [09:28:34] Ondřej Dostál (NI) [EN] Mr. Gala, you asked who is profiting. From the sanctions. And I answer you. It is India and it is China. Because all these cheap oil and gas is going there from our Central European states. Do you think it is proper to harm European industry and benefit the Indians and the Chinese so our competitiveness will be even worse than without the sanctions? Do you think it is the right strategy for Europe? [09:29:05] Michael Gahler (PPE) [EN] Well, we cannot demand from India or China what they do or what they don't. I mean, we are currently having a scarcity of oil because of the closure of the street of Hormuz. And that is why everybody tries to grab whatever he or she can get hold of. I'm not happy about this situation with India and China. But we cannot prevent it. But we should not add to Russia's income. That is clear. [09:29:30] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Thank you very much. And we will continue with the speakers' list. And the next speaker is Ms. Moretti for one and a half minutes, please. [09:29:39] Alessandra Moretti (S&D) [IT] Thank you, Mr President. Colleagues. This week saw the publication of the European Court of Auditors’ report which highlights the continued circumvention of sanctions against Russia. The sanctions are working; they are more urgent than ever, they are exerting significant pressure on the Putin regime, but their circumvention is a huge problem for the effectiveness of the Union’s policy towards Moscow and for the credibility of our institutions. Member States implement trade sanctions in different ways, thus limiting their overall impact. This is also because the wording of the measures is often vague, leaving room for interpretation. We not only need more sanctions, more targeted ones, but it is also necessary for those already in place to be more effective. More than four years have passed since the start of this war, and just as four years ago, we continue to work for peace. A just peace, however, that is not a surrender, but that respects the rights of people, Ukraine’s territorial integrity and autonomy, and its independence in deciding its own future. Thank you. [09:30:56] Speaker 2 [EN] Ms. Moretti, there is a blue card for you. Do you want to take it? It's from Mr. Oliveira, seat 136, please. [09:31:05] João Oliveira (The Left) [PT] Thank you, Mr President. Ms Moretti, you referred to peace, and that is exactly the question I want to ask you. What is, what was the last initiative that has come from the European Union to find a peace solution? Apart from the policy of sanctions, the sending of weapons, and measures that in practice only contribute to prolonging the war, what measures, what political and diplomatic initiatives, whether from the European Council or from the European Commission, have been taken to discuss the terms of building peace in Ukraine and a collective security solution that cannot be just for Ukraine, it has to be for the entire European continent, from Lisbon to the Urals? [09:31:50] Alessandra Moretti (S&D) [IT] Thank you, colleague. I agree with you. Europe is weak. Unfortunately, Europe does not have a strong influence in the peace process. And this is because some political forces within this Parliament want Europe not to have a say in this negotiation. And that is why we must continue to find ways to strengthen the European Union, with a common foreign policy and a common European defence. And we need to work on multiple levels. On the level of strengthening our authority and on the level of sanctions. Because otherwise we will continue to be irrelevant on the international diplomacy stage. Thank you. [09:32:40] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. And we will continue with the speakers' list. And the next speaker is Mr. Knotek for one and a half minutes, please. [09:32:45] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] Thank you, Madam Chairman. Mrs. Commissioner, Russian war against Ukraine is damaging Europe and sanctions against Russia are therefore legitimate response. Top priorities in sanctions should be technologies, products, materials, and precursors that Russia could use to continue the war. Also, sanctions should continue to decrease our dependencies on Russia. We shall diversify or produce in Europe. My message here is that our sanctions must be smart. And look what we have done with natural gas. We have sanctions on Russian gas imports. Okay. But we still import products from Russia made from Russian gas, like ammonia, fertilizers, or urea. So Russia still gets a lot of money. We stopped buying commodity, but instead we buy a product with higher value. So also sanctions could be considered into this direction. And second element, our export bans from Europe to Russia often cover products which cannot be used in Russian warfare. One example for all. EU-based company 115 employees basalt, basalt tiles, or basalt severage parts. They cannot export to Russia despite the market demand because basalt is considered as a war effort. So Madam Commissioner, allow me to pass you from the heart of Europe, from the Czech Republic, a basalt heart to demonstrate that basalt is not a weapon and the re-export bans could be considered. Thank you very much. [09:34:25] Speaker 2 [EN] Mr. Knotek, there is a blue card. Mr. Knotek, there is a blue card from Mr. Dostal. Do you want to take it? Yeah. And please. Mr. Dostal, seat... [09:34:37] Ondřej Dostál (NI) [CS] Mr colleague, I will ask you once again, in Czech. Anything that we impose sanctions on, immediately it will disappear in India, in China, in the United States, in ASEAN, and it will no longer be available to Czech industry, to Central European industry. So what benefit will these sanctions bring to taxpayers, to industry in the Czech Republic, if all they do is reduce their competitiveness compared to those who are not imposing sanctions? Thank you for your answer. [09:35:06] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [CS] You are touching on a very complex issue, colleague. The competitiveness of European industry is primarily reduced by climate and energy policy, which has much greater impacts than any potential negative effects of sanctions. Yes, I agree, and I have actually been speaking about this, that the sanctions are not perfect and there are cases where, for example, if we change the export rules for things that are not weapons, such as basalt, we will certainly help industry. That is to say, sanctions yes, but they must be smart. And Europe is undermining its own position primarily through poor climate and energy policy. Thank you. [09:35:47] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And Mr. Dostal, that was the last blue card you got in this debate. We will continue with the speakers' list. And the next speaker is Ms. Gosievska for one minute, please. [09:35:57] Małgorzata Gosiewska (ECR) [PL] Ladies and Gentlemen, how many more debates and resolutions do we need before Europe stops funding Russia’s war against Ukraine? Russia is bombing Ukrainian cities, killing civilians, destroying infrastructure, and yet European money continues to flow to Moscow for Russian raw materials. Where is European solidarity and credibility? You cannot simultaneously support the victim and finance the aggressor. That is why I demand decisive, further sanctions, but above all the enforcement of those already in place. And accountability for those who help Russia to circumvent them. We must cut off revenue from raw materials, strike at the shadow fleet, close the channels of war financing and freeze the assets of those supporting the Kremlin. No European privileges for Putin’s allies. No impunity for those who circumvent sanctions. Enough of double standards. It is time to stop talking about solidarity. It is time to start enforcing it in practice. [09:37:04] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And the next speaker is Ms. Karlsbro for one minute, please. [09:37:15] Karin Karlsbro (Renew) [EN] Madam President, everyone knows Russia will never win the war in Ukraine. But it's our choice how much longer we want to sustain Putin's terror. Europe needs to strangle Russia's war machine. With empty pockets, Putin can't buy missiles for killing Ukrainian people. Everything left unsanctioned every exemption means fresh money for Russia. We are funding hybrid warfare on EU member states ourselves. So. Let's use the economy as our battlefield. Let's stop doing business with Russia. Let's use the frozen assets, make Russia pay for the war. Thank you. [09:38:19] Speaker 2 [EN] Mr. Karlsbro, there is a blue card from Ronsard. Do you want to take it, seat 156, please? [09:38:28] Bogdan Rzońca (ECR) [EN] Okay. Madam, I am here. I will speak in Polish. Please take the headphones. [09:38:35] Bogdan Rzońca (ECR) [PL] You mentioned an interesting issue, namely those frozen Russian assets in Western Europe. We are all talking about this and we all demand that these Russian assets be used to help Ukraine. You come from a very rich country, an influential country in the European Union. Do you see an opportunity to actually use these frozen Russian assets now, or will we just be talking about this for the next two years? [09:39:16] Karin Karlsbro (Renew) [EN] Thank you for this debate. I think it's damn time to use the frozen assets. It's Russia's war. Russia should pay for every damage it has caused to Ukraine. And it's up to the Council to deliver. We know that there are legal possibilities for a decision in the Council. There is no time to wait. So from this House, we expect a proposal and I can promise you that we will not delay that decision. So let's use the frozen assets, make Russia pay. Thank you. [09:39:59] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. Thank you very much. And the next speaker is Mr. Lagodinski for one minute, please. [09:40:09] Sergey Lagodinsky (Verts/ALE) [EN] Colleagues, yesterday we talked about Ukrainian children who are being abducted. Today we're talking about Ukrainian children who are being killed. Because this is what it is about. Every ballistic missile launched from Russia. And produced in Russia. Has a blood stain on the other end of trajectory. And to those colleagues who are asking, what for? This is what it is for. This is what we are investing in. And this is what we're sanctioning for in order to save one, two, hundred Ukrainian children's lives. And I think it is worth it. Alone this year, about 80 children were already killed and 700 were demolished. Were traumatized. And we cannot normalize this situation. We should not normalize. We should not invite athletes. We should not call Kremlin humanitarian. We should not. We should sanction. And by the way, we sanction also for our own benefit. Russia's satellite system is about to be launched in Russia. And it will be a threat to us. So let's stop supplies for this technology. [09:41:24] Sergey Lagodinsky (Verts/ALE) [EN] Thank you. Sanction. Thank you. [09:41:26] Sergey Lagodinsky (Verts/ALE) [EN] Do not normalize. [09:41:26] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. So dear colleagues, there's a lot of people on the speakers list and we have a lot of catch. And hopefully also get more blue cards. So please try to stick to speaking time. That would help us. And the next speaker is Mr. Botenga for one minute, please. [09:41:44] Marc Botenga (The Left) [EN] Thank you, President. [09:41:46] Marc Botenga (The Left) [FR] Dear colleagues, you said it is for the Ukrainians to decide whether to negotiate. Well, today the Ukrainians are negotiating. You said the Russians do not want to. Today the Russians are negotiating. But you, you continue to say zero concessions, zero concessions, that is zero negotiation, it is endless war. The result: the European Union today is not invited to the negotiations in Abu Dhabi. And I tried to understand this obstinacy. And I came across this document from the Council of European governments where Ukraine is described as a strategic opportunity for Europe. You talk of a strategic opportunity while people on the ground are dying. This is a disgrace, I cannot accept that. So, are we, like the Russians and the Americans, coveting the European Union, coveting Ukraine’s strategic resources? People are fed up with the war. In Russia, there are deserters against Putin’s war. In Ukraine, 80 % of the population want to negotiate, and 2 million people have refused to join this war. And in Europe, citizens are also fed up with paying for it. So name this Special Representative and negotiate. Do your job. Thank you. [09:42:55] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Mr. Botenga, I have in fact three blue cards. I cannot allow all of them, but I might take two. Do you want to take them? Okay. First, Mr. Lagodinski, please site. [09:43:11] Sergey Lagodinsky (Verts/ALE) [EN] You're saying that Russians want to deal and negotiate with us. Do you know who is blocking participation of Europeans at the table? Do you know that the Americans are now going to Moscow to beg Russia to allow Europeans to the table? Do you know that Lavrov just while they were negotiating said that they will get back every meter of their territory from Ukrainians? So who is not willing to negotiate? These negotiations are farse. They are just distracting our attention from the fight and from the murder that they're making. [09:43:50] Speaker 2 [EN] Mr. Botenga. [09:43:53] Marc Botenga (The Left) [EN] I think there are two things. And I will answer in English. First, yesterday there were negotiations between three parties. United States, Russia and Ukraine. Europeans were not there. I said three parties. I said three parties. Europeans were not there. And I don't see you troubled by that. I don't see you troubled by that. And what I see is when I hear the high representative and you're not listening to the answer, you're defending democracy but you got difficulty listening to other people in this House. Mr. Lagodinski, I think you need maybe a little course in democracy. It's conversation. It's a dialogue. [09:44:36] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you, Mr. Botenga. I need to take one more blue card if you allow it. Andrew Kaitis, please. Mr. Andrew Kaitis, 225. Blue card, please stick to your time. [09:44:48] Vytenis Povilas Andriukaitis (S&D) [EN] Great. Mayor, you can take from I can ask you in between. [09:44:58] Vytenis Povilas Andriukaitis (S&D) [LT] I would like to ask you and receive a yes or no answer. My question is this: is territorial integrity and the inviolability of borders confirmed in the Helsinki Final Act and in international documents? My question to you. Is the inviolability of borders and territorial integrity a cornerstone? Can it be allowed to be violated? Yes or no? [09:45:34] Vytenis Povilas Andriukaitis (S&D) [EN] Mr. Botenga. [09:45:36] Marc Botenga (The Left) [FR] But let us be very clear. International law leaves no doubt that you cannot attack another country, you cannot occupy another country, and you cannot violate another country's borders. So I entirely agree on that point. And what I would ask of this European Union is that it be as consistent in the case of Ukraine as it is in Lebanon when it is Israel that is occupying in Palestine, when it is Israel that is occupying in Syria, or in Iran when it is our allies, the United States, that are bombing. Because it's a case of double standards. Territorial integrity matters to us only in Ukraine. That is hypocrisy, sir. [09:46:14] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Thank you very much. So we will continue with the speakers list. No, no, we don't have. Sorry, we don't have. Time for that. The next speaker is Mr. Sale for one minute, please. [09:46:26] Alexander Sell (ESN) [DE] The Commission says the sanctions against Russia are working. The question is, for whom? Before the war, German companies exported goods worth 27 billion euros to Russia in the previous year. Now it’s only seven. Imports have fallen even more sharply. Almost 100 percent, because we Europeans are no longer allowed to buy oil from Russia. And what has it achieved? Today, Russia is not selling less oil, but more than before the war—just not to Europe. While we suffer under high fuel prices, the Russians are doing big business with the Chinese, Indians and Turks. And that is at our expense. In September, Europe bought 44 million litres of diesel from India every single day, even though India has no oil of its own. So the sanctions are not hurting Russia; they are hurting us Europeans. We do not need a 22nd sanctions package; we need a realistic peace plan for Ukraine, and that can only succeed if we are willing to talk to both sides, as the Americans are doing right now in Abu Dhabi. I am glad that the Commission was not at the table. Otherwise, it would have shot us in the knee again. [09:47:29] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Mr. Panayoutou for one and a half minutes, please. [09:47:39] Fidias Panayiotou (NI) [EN] The EU has failed Ukraine by refusing to use diplomacy to put an end to this war. This crazy policies that you vote in this Parliament has resulted in leaving Zelensky alone negotiating with Putin and Trump. This means they will be the ones deciding over the future of our continent. Some members of the European Parliament have spent years trying to change this and we have tried to push EU to get serious and do diplomacy with Russia. But in exchange for our efforts, we have just been called Russian puppets and recently we even have been added to an alleged kill list in the past few days. Of course I completely condemn the Russian invasion because a clear violation of international law. We must defend Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity while recognizing that diplomacy is essential to achieving a just and lasting peace in Ukraine. Europe must get serious now and finally have one representative to directly negotiate with Russia and Ukraine to put an end to this war. Because this is our continent and we must shape our future. [09:49:05] Speaker 2 [EN] So Mr. Do you want to take a blue card? Okay. I had Mr. Starkis on. Do you still want to take it, please? [09:49:16] Fidias Panayiotou (NI) [EN] Yes. Thank you for your speech. I'm a bit curious. Is Russia paying you for spreading his propaganda or you are betraying Europe for free? We have the same problem in my country, Cyprus. Cyprus has been invaded by Turkey and is still illegally occupied and is still the same position that I hold for my country. To solve this problem with diplomacy, not with war. [09:49:47] Speaker 2 [EN] Okay. Well, I did in fact have one more but we're running a little bit out of time so I will continue with the speakers list and the next speaker is Mr. Altsula for one minute, please. [09:50:02] Mika Aaltola (PPE) [FI] Mr President, Europe is now being squeezed from two directions. Mr President, Russia is demanding that its war be rewarded. The US administration wants a deal quickly, and we are being offered as the one to pay the bill. However, the cards are in our hands. The heaviest sanctions are Europe’s frozen assets, which are in Europe. The markets that Russia wants to access are ours. Without us, Russia will not get what it wants. Without us, the United States will not be able to secure a deal. We may be spoken over, but no agreement can be reached without us. And Ukraine cannot be bypassed in any way. Good cards are not given away in a nervous state. And there is no reason to do so now. Russia strikes Ukraine every night and demands every inch at the table. That is why sanctions must be tightened. Loopholes must be closed and banks listed. The cards remain in our hands until Russia ends the war. [09:51:03] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And the next speaker is Mr. Szyman for one and a half minutes, please. [09:51:09] Jean-Marc Germain (S&D) [FR] Dear colleagues, this war is no longer a territorial war; it has become a war against a people. Energy infrastructure is being systematically targeted to leave Ukrainians at the mercy of the cold. In parks, in schools, Russian drones are striking women and children. And meanwhile, in Abu Dhabi, Russians and Americans are discussing the security of our continent while we Europeans are literally left sitting on the sidelines watching the negotiations. As long as it cannot pursue its aggression, Russia will not negotiate in good faith. That is why I commend the Council’s efforts to strengthen sanctions. We must cut off the money that is fuelling Putin’s war. But what use are our sanctions if they are not respected? How can European components still be found in the missiles of Moscow? How can goods blocked in Poland be sent back to Russia from Italy? How can those who violate our sanctions still escape any prosecution? Let us finally enforce our sanctions to urgently cut off funding for Putin. And let us step up support for Ukraine. Let us provide the €70 billion it needs to sustain its war effort in 2027. And let us bring back to the table the issue of frozen Russian assets. Many of us support the idea of transferring them into a European vehicle. This is a common-sense solution that would help to avoid any financial risk for the Member States that are concerned about their financial stability. We can and we must act. Let us no longer be spectators of our own destiny. Thank you. [09:52:51] Speaker 2 [EN] Mr. Szyman, there is a blue card from Mr. Mulacic. Do you want to take it? Seat 576, please. [09:52:59] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Thank you, Mr Ambassador, for accepting the blue card. I agree with you on the principle that sanctions against Russia must be strengthened. And Russia must bear significantly higher costs for waging this war. However, I was very surprised by your statement that some elements of armaments from Italy are being delivered to Poland, which are then used by Putin to wage war. Mr Member, please elaborate on this, because we want to know what elements, who and which companies are allegedly delivering them to Russia via Poland. I understand also via Ukraine. Please elaborate, because this is a very interesting thread. To the European Commission. Thank you very much. [09:53:38] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [EN] Thank you. Mr. Szyman. [09:53:40] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Very good, because I was also curious about that. [09:53:41] Jean-Marc Germain (S&D) [EN] Thank you, dear colleague, because I think it's really important to track any way of not applying the sanctions. Those ways of going through the sanctions and the way for products to, when they are blocked in Poland, for example, to go through the sanctions and to come back to the country are now well documented. I was speaking of an example through Italy, but there are many more of them. And I guess they should be tracked much more than now. Thank you, dear colleague. [09:54:17] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. Thank you very much. And the next speaker is Mr. Ferruga for one minute, please. [09:54:24] Aurelijus Veryga (ECR) [LT] Dear colleagues, Russia is escalating its brutal attacks against Ukraine on a daily basis. Civilians are being killed, cities are being destroyed, and energy infrastructure is being wiped out. And Russia’s threat is not limited to Ukraine alone. Now, both the Baltic states and other countries are facing drone incidents, airspace violations, and other provocations. This is already a concern for Europe as a whole, not just for Ukraine. And every euro we pay Russia for oil, gas or other energy resources fuels Russia’s war machine. And, unfortunately, Russian gas still accounts for around 11 per cent of the European Union’s gas supply. So sanctions must not only be strict, but effective: we must definitively abandon Russian energy resources and prevent sanctions circumvention. Lithuania proved back in 2022 that it is possible to live without Russian gas. The whole of Europe can do this too. Thank you. [09:55:28] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And the next speaker is Mr. Ostrowicz for one minute, please. [09:55:34] Petras Auštrevičius (Renew) [EN] Madam Chair, Commissioner, Council Representative, Honorable Colleagues. In 2027, the Russian regime will allocate 44 percent of its state budget for its war efforts. 44 percent. This figure has increased by 27 percent on an annual basis, confirming the aggressor's intention to continue its war of aggression against Ukraine and its terror operations and attacks against us, Europe. Fossil fuels account for around 30 percent of the Russian budget, while value-added and other domestic taxes account for another 40 percent. Clearly, the more fossil fuel Russia sells and the more active its domestic economy is, the fuller its budget becomes, increasing its capacity to continue the war of aggression against Ukraine. Colleagues, there might have been a time when even the European Parliament was heated using Russian gas. But those days must be consigned to history. Thank you. [09:56:48] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And the next speaker is Mr. Starkis for one minute, please. [09:56:55] Mārtiņš Staķis (Verts/ALE) [FR] Madam President, [09:56:56] Mārtiņš Staķis (Verts/ALE) [EN] yesterday in Abu Dhabi Putin's negotiator Medinski told the Europeans they call him the tourists. He told them to sit in hotel's bar. Actually, colleagues, he meant us from this side of the house to that side of the house to the Kremlin. We are just tourists. And where is America? Inside discussing Europe's security with Russia while Europe waited outside the door. And today its envoys are in Moscow, asking Putin whether Europe may join talks about Europe. But let me tell you, tourists are not sanction Putin's war machine. And tourists are not arming the Ukraine. Europe does. Do we really lack the pride to answer? Putin, you are the murderer and Hague is waiting for you. And Putin, and Trump, you are already on the Putin's side. And Europe is not yours to trade. Europe is ours. We live here. And no one dictates us. Not Moscow, not Washington. Thank you. [09:58:02] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Mr. Starkis, there is a blue card. There is a blue card from Ms. Konieczka. I have two blue cards, but I will only take one. And Ms. Konieczka, seat 524, please. [09:58:14] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [PL] Thank you, Madam President. [09:58:17] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [CS] Mr colleague. [09:58:18] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [EN] Vy říkáte, can you hear me? Yeah? [09:58:25] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [CS] Mr colleague, you are saying that the negotiators are claiming that we are tourists. What have we done to ensure we are not tourists? How many peace initiatives have you prepared? How many times have you tried to get Europe to sit at any negotiating table at all? Yes, sanctions, more weapons, you’re good at that. But how many times did you not want to be tourists and actually wanted to play a part in those negotiations as such? Because I don’t think it has happened even once. And that is the problem of the entire European Union: you deal with sanctions, you deal with weapons, but you are afraid to talk about peace. [09:59:02] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Starkis. [09:59:05] Mārtiņš Staķis (Verts/ALE) [EN] Yeah, no tack. [09:59:06] Mārtiņš Staķis (Verts/ALE) [LV] You asked me in your language, so I will also answer you in Latvian. I do not believe that war criminals should be negotiated with at all. I believe that Russia will lose this war. If not on the battlefield, then it will certainly lose economically. That is why we really must continue to do so. We must continue to both help Ukraine and supply weapons, as well as continue to impose sanctions. This is the way in which we can end this war. [09:59:32] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Thank you very much. And the next speaker is Mr. Anderson for one minute, please. [09:59:42] Li Andersson (The Left) [EN] Is it a problem as some have said that Finnish President Alexander Stubb and Norwegian Prime Minister Støre in close consultations with Ukraine made a phone call to Putin? I think it is not. Europe needs to make sure that neither Ukraine nor Europe is sidelined in diplomacy. Especially as the US is so clearly aligning with Putin and European security architecture is one of the topics the US has mentioned should be discussed. Is diplomacy then an alternative to military support and sanctions as many especially in the extreme right are saying? Absolutely not. As Putin continues to strike on Ukraine's energy infrastructure, residential areas, and even schools, Europe needs to be ready to respond with strong military support, stronger sanctions, and making sure we are not sidelined at the diplomatic tables. Especially important is to finally stop financing Putin's war crime through gas imports. It is shameful that some member states have accelerated these imports before the ban enters into force at the beginning of next year. [10:00:57] Li Andersson (The Left) [EN] Thank you. [10:01:00] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to ask my colleague Mr Volgin to take the floor. [10:01:05] Petar Volgin (ESN) [HR] U. [10:01:07] Petar Volgin (ESN) [BG] At the negotiations in Abu Dhabi, where the United States and Russia discussed future global security, representatives of the European Union wandered the corridors in vain, hoping that one of the major players would pay them some attention or at least acknowledge them with a nod. Never before in history have European politicians been so helpless and never before have they elicited such pity. And never before have European leaders embodied total intellectual helplessness. All these people can come up with is yet another package of sanctions against Russia. With a stubbornness that defies common sense, EU leaders continue to assure us that these very actions will deliver a crushing blow to the Russian Federation. And this despite the fact that the thousands of sanctions imposed so far have failed to achieve that. No serious political force will negotiate with such politicians, with politicians bereft of common sense. If Europe wants to take part in talks about the future, it must be represented by leaders who are the complete opposite of the current ones, thank you. [10:02:15] Speaker 7 [EN] Will you accept the blue card from Mr. Lagodinski? And I'm going to be taking only one blue card, so Mrs. Sipper, I'm sorry, you will not get it. Mr. Lagodinski. [10:02:30] Sergey Lagodinsky (Verts/ALE) [EN] Thank you. Mr. Volgin, you were talking about engaging with Russia. Haven't you been engaging with Russia all along? You are doing everything in order to leave your country, defenseless, in the face of attacks that are taking place near your coast. You are supporting pro-Russian forces and pro-Russian candidates during elections. And you and your party are bringing a Russia-style agent, anti-agent law that would observe civil society, like Moscow is doing in Kremlin. What is your term of engagement with Russia? [10:03:11] Petar Volgin (ESN) [BG] I mean, anyone who defends common sense is associated with Russia is not a spectre of highly developed intellect. What my party, Revival, and other normal political forces in this Parliament are doing is ensuring that Europe is represented with dignity at the negotiating table, not like a frightened puppy whining at the door. Because the Europeans have now done that in Abu Dhabi. If we want to be taken seriously, we need to speak and act seriously. Thank you. [10:03:48] Speaker 7 [SK] Now I would like to ask my colleague Kalniete to take the floor. [10:03:57] Sandra Kalniete (PPE) [LV] Colleagues, currently millions of tonnes of grain are stuck in Ukraine’s Black Sea ports due to Russian attacks. These will soon start to rot. Russia is regularly attacking civilian ships, including in the exclusive economic zones of European Union countries and even in their territorial waters. Dozens of seafarers have been killed in these attacks. The Kremlin's goal is to strangle Ukraine's economy and destabilise global food security, as the attacks mean grain does not reach millions of people in Africa and the Middle East. Let us not be naive – this is part of Putin's plan to destabilise regions around the European Union's external borders and create new waves of migration. So that Europe suffers the consequences. Latvia and the Baltic States call on EU Member States to immediately ban the transit of Russia’s bloody grain through their territories. We must stop feeding Putin’s war machine and pressure the Kremlin to end this blockade. Thank you. [10:05:04] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to ask my colleague Mr Kremer to take the floor. [10:05:09] Tobias Cremer (S&D) [EN] Colleagues, a new round of negotiations is underway between Russia, America, and Ukraine. And that leaves us here in Europe, with a choice. We can either once again politely watch from the sidelines and hope for the best, as others decide about Europe without Europe, or we can finally get our act together, speak with one voice, and claim from a position of strength our rightful place at the negotiating table. Because, colleagues, if Europe's security architecture is on the menu, then this should be our table to begin with. This is our security. And we have the strength to defend it. We are Ukraine's strongest supporters. We are the second biggest economy in the world. And our sanctions hit Putin where it hurts. But we must be honest with ourselves. The greatest leverage is useless unless we decide to use it. And use it strategically, decisively, and effectively. So let's act now. And close every last loophole in the sanctions. Use Russia's frozen assets as a leverage for peace. And take the diplomatic initiative together with Ukraine to get real negotiations from a position of strength for our Europe. Thank you. [10:06:21] Speaker 7 [EN] Thank you. And you have a blue card from Mr. Mularchik. Mr. Sipper, you were second again. But Mr. Mularchik, this is your second blue card, so I will stick to the two blue cards per member. So we are on time. Please. [10:06:37] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [EN] Thank you. I have a lot of questions. Thank you. I will speak in Polish. [10:06:41] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Honourable colleague, you are expressing regret here that Europe is not at the negotiating table, in the talks, while a dialogue is taking place between America, Ukraine and Russia. But isn't this actually Europe's fault? Is it not the fault of the current European Commission, which adopts a confrontational style towards President Trump? Is it not the fault of the left, which does everything to harm EU-US relations? Is it not Europe’s very fault that it is not sitting at the negotiating table today? [10:07:18] Tobias Cremer (S&D) [EN] I think we must be very realistic. We support every diplomatic initiative. Our hand is always open. But we have seen before what appeasement looks like. Trump has rolled out the red carpet in Alaska. And what was the result? Nothing. Just more bombs on Ukraine. We won't negotiations, but we also have to understand that diplomacy requires not appeasement of the dictator, but a position of strength. And the only reason Putin will ever really come to negotiate is if we put on the screws with the sanctions, if we show him, if we change his calculus, that he understands that he will never win this war and that he must stop now. [10:08:00] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to call on my colleague Ms Vrecianová. [10:08:08] Veronika Vrecionová (ECR) [CS] Good afternoon, thank you. I take the floor, Mr President, honourable colleagues, ladies and gentlemen. Russia continues to bomb Ukrainian cities every single day, destroying energy infrastructure and killing civilians. Putin’s regime shows no real willingness to end the war. Our response therefore cannot be hesitant. If we want fair and lasting peace in Europe, we must not continue to send money to Russia to fund its war. We must definitively end the purchase of oil and liquefied natural gas. And also rigorously enforce the existing sanctions, take strong action against the Russian shadow fleet, and consistently prevent circumvention through third countries. Supporting Ukraine is not charity; it is a direct investment in our own security. And if we are not united due to domestic politicking or profiteering, and do not persevere, we are only playing into Russia’s hands. Thank you for your attention. [10:09:09] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you very much. And now I would like to give the floor to my colleague Mr Bráška, that is, Mr Vytria. [10:09:15] Helmut Brandstätter (Renew) [EN] Thank you. Mr. President. Putin's guerre à l'Europe, that what Nouvel Obs writes today, it's Putin's war against Europe. And we have to understand that there is terror he wages, terror against Ukraine, but also war against Europe. There are attacks in Europe, disinformation, cyber attacks, and so on. So we need the sanctions also for us, and the sanctions work. And of course, the right-wing extremists are against the sanctions because they are Putin's poodles. And we have to say it very clearly. And we have to enforce the sanctions. It's a shame that Irish aluminium is going to Russia. It's a shame that we removed, or the EU removed, people like Alisha Usmanov and Mikael Friedman from the EU blacklist. It's a shame that many components of Russian missiles kill Ukrainians because these components were produced in Europe. So we need more sanctions. We need stronger sanctions. We have to control them. And we have to understand that this war is also against us. So when we help Ukraine, we defend also Europe. Thank you very much. [10:10:21] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to ask my colleague Ms Riel to take the floor. [10:10:30] Nela Riehl (Verts/ALE) [EN] Do you remember what he did five years ago? And what has happened in your life since then? Well, we were celebrating half a decade of Christmases, of birthdays, of really life-changing things. Ukrainians had air ride sirens. They had destroyed homes. They had their loved ones lost on the front. Ukraine's paying are paying the highest price for Russia's illegal war. They pay with their life. And Russia? Russia's paying nothing. Why is the only one waging this illegal war also the only one not paying for it? The one who causes the damage should be the one who pays for it. Why is that even debatable? Of course, Putin won't pay voluntarily. But we don't need him to. We already have Russia's money here, over $200 billion of frozen assets, right here in Brussels at Euroclear. This shouldn't be Belgium's burden alone, of course. Europe can, and Europe should take the risk and use that money for Ukraine. That money stopped being Russian a long time ago. This is unpaid debt, and it's time to settle the bill. [10:11:42] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to ask my colleague Mr Sütz. [10:11:50] Jonas Sjöstedt (The Left) [SV] Thank you very much, Mr President. We are now seeing how Donald Trump is aligning himself with Putin and wants to make deals with Russian oil and gas. This is direct support for Russia’s brutal war of aggression against Ukraine. One of the proposals is to reopen the Nord Stream gas pipeline for Russian gas exports. A pipeline that runs through Sweden’s economic zone in the Baltic Sea. Our answer is a resounding no. The problem with Nord Stream is not that the pipeline has been rendered inoperable. The problem is that it was ever built. The EU’s decision to introduce a halt on imports of Russian gas must remain in place. We expect the Commission also to come forward with its promised proposal for a total ban on imports of Russian oil. The sanctions need to be tightened. Together, we can put a stop to the Russian shadow fleet’s export of oil and gas through the Baltic Sea. I welcome Germany’s decision that Russia is not welcome to play ice hockey in the country’s World Championships. EU countries should follow Canada’s example and refuse to grant visas to athletes from a country that is committing the most despicable atrocities against the people of Ukraine. [10:13:05] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I give the floor to Minister Kováčová, please. [10:13:11] Andrey Kovatchev (PPE) [SK] Madam President, Mr Minister, Madam Commissioner, dear colleagues. [10:13:15] Andrey Kovatchev (PPE) [BG] The European Union and Ukraine want peace as of today. If Russia truly wants peace, as its supporters here claim, then it can end its aggression today. However, the outcome of the first round of negotiations in Abu Dhabi shows that Russia is not interested in a fair and lasting peace. That is why sanctions must be strictly enforced and cut off funding for the Russian war machine, which also threatens us. In the Black Sea, nine ships were struck, with over 30 sailors killed. We need unity. Member States lobbying for the exclusion of certain individuals and sectors are weakening sanctions and helping to prolong the war. Ukraine needs secure financing; together, EUR 90 billion is important, but we must do more. Of course, we must also use the frozen Russian assets and transfer these assets to the European Union's joint instrument that will distribute the legal risks. Russia must pay for the destruction it has caused, and we must reduce the ability to finance this terrible war. Thank you. [10:14:22] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to ask my colleague Mr Mixer to take the floor. [10:14:28] Sven Mikser (S&D) [SK] Colleague. [10:14:29] Sven Mikser (S&D) [EN] To the skeptics and doubters, I would like to say that sanctions are having an effect on Russia's ability to continue waging its murderous war. But obviously, they could have a much greater effect if properly implemented and further strengthened. Sanctions are an important element in our effort to help Ukraine win the war. But it's just one element. Others include supporting or continuing supporting Ukraine, maintaining a broad international coalition on the side of Ukraine, and ensuring accountability for war crimes. The war will inevitably end at the negotiating table. But we should stop lamenting Europe's irrelevance because we are not irrelevant. We are the strongest supporter of Ukraine. We will play an important role in the post-war reconstruction. And Ukraine will be a full member of our union. And we will have a place at the table when it comes to making sure that the war ends on terms favorable to Ukraine. But we should be very careful and not rush to negotiating table without a clear strategy in a situation where this might grant legitimacy to Russia's totally illegitimate imperial aspirations and their efforts to demolish the foundations of European security architecture. [10:15:41] Speaker 7 [EN] You have a blue card from Mr. Sieper. I guess you take it. [10:15:50] Sven Mikser (S&D) [EN] Final. Thank you. President. Thank you, colleagues, for accepting the blue card. I have a very simple question. Do you think it is efficient that the member states implement the sanctions instead of the EU directly? Thank you. Well, obviously, we should follow the rules. Of the treaty base, of the European Union. There is a procedure for ensuring. The proper implementation of the sanctions. I do think that the member states have the tools at their disposal. Obviously, it's a political decision. Consensus decision to apply sanctions. And we should trust our member states to be in a position to implement the sanctions that they have voted for at the council table. [10:16:49] Gheorghe Piperea (ECR) [EN] Ďakujem. And just let me inform you before giving the floor to the next speaker that I'm closing HDI. There are 13 requests we'll see how we're doing with the time. I will try to take everybody, but I cannot guarantee it's going to be tight. Please Europa aplică sancțiuni dure Rusiei în timp ce importă direct sau indirect mereu mai multe produse energetice din Rusia. Permițându-i lui Putin să continue un război distrugător pentru Ucraina și falimentar pentru Uniunea Europeană. Totodată, Uniunea Europeană le cere cetățenilor și întreprinderilor mici și mijlocii să strângă și mai mult șurubul precum și solidaritate în suportarea costurilor acestei politici. În capitalele europene, oamenii ies în stradă, strângându-și disperarea față de creșterea aberantă a costului vieții. În acest timp, autoritățile reacționează sever și le cer oamenilor să respecte valori pe care ele însele le aplică selectiv. Protecția drepturilor omului nu se poate invoca selectiv fără a pica în ipocrizie. Există rapoarte ale ONU care au documentat acuzații de încălcări grave ale drepturilor omului în Ucraina. Copilul de 14 ani, Olexei, a fost torturat de unități ale batalionului Azov. Liste negre cu europeni, inclusiv europarlamentari, sunt ținute de aceste entități. Eu zic că este timpul să ne cam trezim. [10:18:21] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I give the floor to Ms colleague Jar, please. [10:18:28] Lucia Yar (Renew) [EN] Colleagues, this year is the deadliest year for Ukrainian civilians since the beginning of Russia's full-scale invasion. And in Europe, we know perfectly well how Russia finances its killing machine. First, fossil fuels. Russia's steel earns 625 million euro of it every single day. Secondly, shadow fleets. A huge amount of Russian oil is still transported by ships that are either owned or insured by many of the EU countries that even proclaim their support for Ukraine. So that is not an effective sanctions policy. It is clearly a loophole. And it undermines our collective impact. But you know who is even worse? Those who do not even try. Those who cynically lie that Russia is merely defending itself. And that we, in the EU, are actually the aggressors. And we've heard it today. They are among us. They are sitting in the governments of the member states. They are even speaking here. So to those who want to repeat Putin's lies, go and stay in Moscow. [10:19:43] Lucia Yar (Renew) [EN] Thank you very much. Thank you very much. [10:19:46] Speaker 7 [SK] Now I would like to give the floor to my colleague Mr Anschütz, please. [10:19:54] Reinier Van Lanschot (Verts/ALE) [EN] It's not that hard. Can we be honest for one second? While negotiation attempts to end Russia's war are happening, we're not even at the table. Putin is setting the terms. Trump and his cronies are more focused on the money they can make than making a lasting peace. Unless Europeans learn to speak with one voice, it'll never be heard. And Ukrainians and Europeans will pay the price. We've been calling for this for years, and it's never been so urgent. Zelensky also asked us to hurry up and appoint someone to help negotiate peace. If the U.S. can be represented by corrupt businessmen and Russia can be represented by war criminals, surely we can find someone and give them a mandate. Anyone, stoop, call us, Pavel, you. The Russians want nothing more than to exclude us from these talks and right now they have an easy excuse. Europe can't agree on who to send. So national leaders, get into a room, lock the door, and don't come out until you pick someone. Thank you. [10:21:02] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now a blue card. [10:21:05] Speaker 7 [EN] Sorry, I forgot almost. You have a blue card from Mr. Sieper. [10:21:13] Lukas Sieper (Renew) [NL] Thank you. Dear colleagues, [10:21:16] Reinier Van Lanschot (Verts/ALE) [EN] I why do you think we haven't picked someone yet? Thank you. Oh, yes. That's a very good question. So why haven't we picked anyone yet? I think a lot of our national leaders are stuck in a 20th-century mindset where nationalism dictates what they think is the right thing to do. But nationalism for European countries right now is an illusion. The only real sovereignty we can create, we can have, is sovereignty that is truly European. And until our national leaders realize that, they will not step over their own shadow. They will not find the courage. But Europeans know this, and that's an interesting thing because Europeans want us to speak with one voice as all the European polls show. Thank you. [10:22:08] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to call on my colleague Mr Klausen, please. [10:22:17] Per Clausen (The Left) [DA] When Russia sends suicide drones and cruise missiles against Ukraine, one thing is absolutely certain: their killing machines only work because they are filled with Western components. Components that, despite sanctions, they apparently have little trouble getting their hands on. So what we are talking about here is support. But if we really want to protect Ukraine’s civilians, there are two things we should ensure, preferably today rather than tomorrow. First, we must ensure that Russia can no longer obtain Western microchips and other electronics for its arms factories. And second, we need to become much better at curbing Russia’s ability to wage war by hitting it in the pocket. And unfortunately, we don’t need to go back further than October, when the EU actually removed sanctions against Russia. That is not what we need. We need to tighten sanctions. What we are doing when we remove sanctions and allow Russia to use parts from us to produce weapons against Ukraine is this: we are sending the bill to Ukraine’s population, and we must stop doing that. [10:23:26] Speaker 7 [EN] Ďakujem. And let me inform you, I'll have to be more strict because we're really tight on time. And let me give the floor to Madam Vice Lima, please. [10:23:38] Isabel Wiseler-Lima (PPE) [EN] Madam. [10:23:42] Isabel Wiseler-Lima (PPE) [FR] Last winter, Russia deliberately plunged Ukrainian civilians into darkness and freezing cold. It is doing so again this year, going so far as to target substations connected to nuclear power plants. And just last night, mere hours after the conclusion of the talks in Abu Dhabi, Russian ballistic missiles were striking Kiev. Is this what Moscow means by dialogue? Let us therefore cut off the resources that still enable the Kremlin to finance this war. Every barrel sold by the shadow fleet, every component transiting through a third country, every transaction in crypto-assets finances the next strike. Let us plug the loopholes. Let us sanction the intermediaries facilitating circumvention. Let's actually control the ghost fleet at sea. Let's adopt the next package without delay. This war is already costing Moscow far more than it is bringing in. But Putin will only stop it the day when pursuing it threatens his own power. It is up to us to corner him into making that choice, from the outside through our sanctions, so that the pressure also builds from within. Thank you. [10:24:55] Isabel Wiseler-Lima (PPE) [EN] Mr. [10:24:55] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. Thank you. And now I give the floor to Ms Colleague Fricon, please. [10:25:03] Heléne Fritzon (S&D) [DE] Mr Talmann, Putin's brutal [10:25:06] Heléne Fritzon (S&D) [SV] the war against Ukraine continues, the bombs are falling, here and now, on homes, hospitals, schools, and families live in constant terror. Today, Europe is buying more oil and gas for more money than we are providing in support to Ukraine. This is nothing short of hypocrisy. We must, once and for all, free ourselves from Russian fossil energy. We have indeed taken that decision. Europe must never contribute to financing Putin’s war. We Social Democrats demand stricter sanctions. We must stop the Russian shadow fleet. Plug the loopholes and ensure that the sanctions are actually complied with. We must be clear: Ukraine’s struggle is also our struggle. We must stand up for the people of Ukraine and we must do so together; the EU must show the way. [10:26:14] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. I would now like to give the floor to my colleague, please. [10:26:18] Jacek Ozdoba (ECR) [PL] Ladies and Gentlemen, you are looking for the guilty parties in the wrong place. All you need to do is look around this Chamber. Especially the Left and the liberals. Show me one person who has effectively been subject to personal sanctions and has been banned from entering the European Union for collaborating with the criminals under Vladimir Putin. How is it possible that several months ago I submitted a request for Gerhard Schröder to be subject to personal sanctions? The Left and the European People's Party are partly standing up. So start imposing sanctions on those who are standing up. Throw them out of the groups. You are responsible for the fact that a man responsible for Nord Stream was celebrating Vladimir Putin’s birthday a month ago. And this is something you must take to heart today. It is you who are to blame. The previous term and earlier. You are responsible for everything you are saying today. And history will judge you. Though of course, independent prosecutorial action should be taken. Because you are acting as if you were acting on Vladimir Putin’s orders. Thank you. [10:27:27] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. Thank you. And now I would like to ask my colleague Mr Koboška to take the floor, please, Michal. [10:27:37] Michał Kobosko (Renew) [PL] Colleagues, the balance sheet of five years of war on the Russian side is over one and a half million killed and wounded. Over one and a half million. In October alone, 54,000 killed and wounded. In one month, Russia has lost as many people as the Soviet Union did over 10 years of war in Afghanistan. And yet Putin is bringing in more of his people for the slaughter. He is bombing Ukrainian cities, murdering civilians. And the Russian negotiator in Abu Dhabi is offering similar, quote-unquote, 'treatment' to the whole of Europe. And that is why our pressure on Russia must increase, not weaken. In the 2022 sanctions package, we must target the sectors that bring Russia the highest revenues: finance and energy. We must also effectively close the loopholes for circumventing sanctions. Above all, however, the frozen Russian assets. I appeal to the European Commission: do not postpone this issue. Do not be afraid. In cooperation with experts, a solution based on solid legal grounds has been found. The aggressor must pay for this war from its own money, not from ours. Thank you. [10:28:48] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to ask Ms Colleague Zofka to take the floor. [10:28:54] Željana Zovko (PPE) [EN] Your. Colleagues, not one cent of European money should finance Russia's illegal war of aggression against Ukraine. Our next sanctions package must hit Russia where it hurts. It's energy revenues, financial sector, and networks enabling circumvention. Russia weaponized supply, attacks Ukraine's energy infrastructures, and circumvents sanctions to keep its revenue flowing. Croatia offers alternative energy supply through YANAF and the Kirk LNG terminal. We must support investment that allows Europe to cut its independence on Russia. We must also dismantle the shadow fleets business model by targeting the companies managing its vessels. Alongside coordinating maritime enforcement. Russia must pay for the destruction it has caused. We must advance legally sound solutions to use frozen Russian assets to support Ukraine. Every loophole we close reduces Russia's capacity to fund the next attack. That must be the measure of our sanctions. Thank you. [10:30:07] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. Thank you. And now I give the floor to Mr colleague Picula, please. [10:30:13] Speaker 8 [SK] Thank you. [10:30:15] Tonino Picula (S&D) [HR] In these days when unacceptable conditions for ending the war are being imposed on Ukraine, conditions that neither guarantee future peace and in fact reward the aggressor, we in this House must be clear. The European Union must further sanction the Kremlin. With a greater focus on preventing the circumvention of sanctions through intermediaries and trade channels of third countries. The current sanctions have had a significant impact. They have reduced Russia’s access to the European market, foreign investment and technology, and increased costs for its economy. Russia is increasingly dependent on Beijing, which dictates the rules of the game to it. It is crucial that the European Union continues to act in a coordinated manner. It is closing the loopholes in the existing sanctions system and maintaining pressure. Despite demands from pro-Russian options in some Member States, and even in this Parliament, returning to energy dependence on Russia would be a strategic mistake. Even once the aggression ends, full normalisation of relations, especially under Putin’s regime, is not realistic. Trust has been destroyed, and this Russia will remain a security threat to Europe. A threat to our freedom, our way of life and our values. Thank you. [10:31:27] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to ask my colleague Mr Tereš to take the floor. [10:31:36] Cristian Terheş (ECR) [EN] Thank you. Dear Commissioner, if the EU is fully committed to imposing sanctions on Russia that will cut off the source's financing its illegal war, it needs to take two major steps. First, close the Northern Corridor crossing Russia and territory to European trade. And second, actively redirect commercial flows between Europe and Asia towards the Middle Corridor. As long as goods traveling between Europe and Asia continue to transit through Russia, we continue directly or indirectly to Russia's economic resilience generates transit revenues for Moscow and maintains strategic dependencies on a country that has chosen aggression over peace. The Middle Corridor connecting Europe and Asia through the Black Sea region and the South Caucasus and Central Asia offers a viable strategic alternative that would strengthen regional connectivity while reducing Russia's geopolitical leverage over both Europe and China. Let's turn sanctions into a geopolitical strategic opportunity. Close the Northern Corridor, strengthen the Middle Corridor, and stop financing the Russians' war. Thank you. [10:32:48] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to call on Vice-President Pičerna, please. [10:32:55] Pina Picierno (Renew) [IT] Yes, thank you. Mr President, on 3 November Russia launched the largest attack this year against Ukraine’s energy system. And at the same time it continues to export its oil, even using European ships and insurance. Why, as we know, the ban on maritime services has been on hold since April pending the G7. And we want to reiterate here in this Chamber that this ban must be reinstated immediately, because every time an oligarch is removed from the sanctions lists, every time Member States turn a blind eye to European companies that continue to do illegal business with Russia, in this way Putin’s imperialism is being aided. And we must reiterate this: the era of the fake trade-off between human rights, peace and trade is over. Andrej Sakharov warned us of this in 1975: peace, progress and human rights are three objectives indissolubly linked. If you trade one off, you lose them all. Thank you. [10:34:11] Pina Picierno (Renew) [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to give the floor to my colleague Pascal Della Parte. [10:34:20] Nicolás Pascual de la Parte (PPE) [ES] Thank you very much, Mr President. As we approach the fifth year of war in Ukraine, proposals are beginning to emerge to confuse us, to divide us, to weaken us. The latest is to mix up and confuse negotiations on a future peace in Ukraine with the creation of a security structure in Europe. Let us not fall into that trap. We must clearly maintain our objectives: our objective is to achieve as soon as possible a real ceasefire in Ukraine and for negotiations to begin on the current line of contact. Secondly, we must make it clear that our firm support for Ukraine — military, political and financial — will be maintained and increased for as long as necessary. Secondly, we will tell Russia that we will maintain and also increase our sanctions and that we will use the funds from assets in European banks to finance the reconstruction of Ukraine. And thirdly, we will open negotiations from a position of strength. This means that Europe must be at the negotiating table because, among other things, a part of that negotiation will be Ukraine’s future membership of the European Union. Thank you. Let us not let the Ukrainians down, because. [10:35:36] Speaker 8 [EN] Thank you. I'm sorry, I really have to be strict on time because we are running out and we're running really seriously late. I'm sorry. [10:35:46] Speaker 7 [SK] And now I give the floor to Ms colleague Schöring-Villus. [10:35:50] Joanna Scheuring-Wielgus (S&D) [PL] Mr President, Commissioner. The ongoing peace talks in Abu Dhabi so far give no hope of ending the war in Ukraine. Mr President, Commissioner. Despite our desire for this, we cannot forget who we are dealing with. Since the beginning of its attack on Ukraine, Russia has been killing civilians, abducting children, violating international law and showing that it is not at all interested in peace. That is why it is so important for Europe to maintain sanctions against the Kremlin and not give in to pressure from Trump, who wants to end this war at all costs, even at the expense of a free Ukraine, and probably also at Europe’s expense. We must also remember that Russian money is financing not only missiles and ammunition. It is also financing the information war being waged against our societies. Bot farms, thousands of fake accounts and organised disinformation campaigns are being used to destabilise our states, undermine trust in institutions and weaken European unity. That is why we must cut off all Russian sources of funding for the war – both that on the Ukrainian front and that being waged on the screens of our phones. Thank you. [10:37:04] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to ask my colleague Mr Buda to take the floor. [10:37:11] Daniel Buda (PPE) [SK] With you, colleague. We've [10:37:12] Daniel Buda (PPE) [EN] done Churchill in 1940, avertiza. [10:37:15] Daniel Buda (PPE) [RO] If we do not succeed, then the entire world will be plunged into the abyss of a dark age. Europe cannot afford to fail. Russia’s war is not just a war against Ukraine, it is an attack on the security order of our entire continent. Look at the Black Sea. Commercial vessels are being hit, maritime routes are under threat, drones are falling on the territory of the European Union, including Romania and Bulgaria, and beyond. And the freedom of navigation, international trade and the safety of our citizens are put at risk. That is precisely why European funds must not be used to fuel Russia’s war machine. Sanctions must target energy revenues, the shadow fleet and the supply chains of the Russian military industry. And these must be applied in earnest. Because every loophole left open turns into a rocket, into a drone, into a new attack. Ukraine's security is our security. Today's firmness is tomorrow's peace. Thank you. [10:38:24] Speaker 8 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to give the floor to Ms Vice-President Schalldemose, please. [10:38:29] Christel Schaldemose (S&D) [DA] Thank you for that. Putin speaks of peace, but his bombs tell a very different story. While we stand here, Russia is attacking Ukrainian families and their homes. And at the same time, Putin wants to negotiate about Ukraine's future and Europe's security behind Europe's back. That is completely unacceptable. Because the war in Ukraine is not just about Ukraine's security. It is also about all of Europe. It is our democracy, our freedom and our shared future that are at stake. That is why Denmark has just provided its 32nd donation package to Ukraine. That amounts to 642 million euros. I hope that more people will join in and contribute more funds to Ukraine. But we must also hit Russia where it hurts – specifically by targeting the money that is financing the war. That is why we must tighten the sanctions. We must close the loopholes and stop those who help Russia to circumvent them. We need to do more, because the war in Ukraine is not only Ukraine’s war. War is also about our security. Slaver Ukraine. [10:39:35] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to invite my colleague Mr Kely to take the floor. [10:39:43] Seán Kelly (PPE) [EN] Faulty rotorash, Maren Harken. You reached your own talk against Kara Zulum. How do you bring a dictator like Putin to the table? Donald Trump thinks it's by offering vast concessions. Ukrainian land, sanctions relief, and the say in Europe's future security. This is not the way. Resistance and sanctions are the answer. Ukraine is doing the first part, but the European Union and our partners must do more on the second. Before the Iranian War, Russia's vital aisle and gas revenues had fallen by almost half. However, the supply shock resulting from the Iran War has handed massive energy windfall profits to Putin. Which, alongside the U.S. sanction waivers, has been worth tens of billions for his war effort. We have no excuse; we need to ban Russian oil imports to build on our walk to phase out gas. Neel Nandara Raoging, Matami Darira, Shasev Leshanukhran. Slaver Ukraine. Remarkable Trump. [10:40:56] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to give the floor to Ms colleague Tarlák, please. [10:41:03] Ingeborg Ter Laak (PPE) [NL] Mr President, distinguished colleagues, negotiating with Putin is like playing poker with someone who is constantly cheating. And it looks as though we have a chair at the negotiating table. But without strengthening our hand, we cannot. Ukraine has already been defending itself against Russian aggression for 12 years. There have been endless talks and summits. Without result. And yet: Europe cannot afford to lose heart. We too are bearing the consequences of this war. For a long time, we have had to fight for this seat at the table. Now is the time to play our cards right: sanctions, frozen assets, security guarantees, and smart moves. The stakes are not just about the future of Ukraine. It is about the security of Europe. Thank you. [10:41:59] Speaker 8 [EN] Except the blue card from Mr. Roncha. Button. [10:42:12] Bogdan Rzońca (ECR) [PL] Thank you very much for accepting the question. And I wanted to ask you, as you come from the Netherlands, about Putin's payroll. On that Putin payroll, there is not a single Pole. I do not know whether you are aware of this, but there are politicians from Germany, the Netherlands, Italy and Austria. Is it discussed in your country in what way these politicians from Western Europe ended up on this payroll? Because, of course, sanctions are one thing, and the history and truth about how Putin was promoted and respected by Western Europe is quite another matter. [10:43:01] Ingeborg Ter Laak (PPE) [NL] Thank you. Colleague, for your question. From the Netherlands, support for Ukraine remains unwavering. And we will continue to do so at all times, because the war in Ukraine is also our security. Thank you. [10:43:17] Speaker 7 [SK] Thank you. And now I would like to ask my colleague Mr Kohút to take the floor. [10:43:23] Łukasz Kohut (PPE) [PL] The enemy is to the east. Let’s face the truth. Russia is waging an open hybrid war against all of Europe. On the internet, at the borders, at airports, and even in supermarkets. Acts of sabotage have become everyday occurrences from the Bug to the Rhine. Moscow’s actions are affecting the daily lives of Europeans. That is precisely why we should continue to impose further sanctions. We must defend ourselves. The Kremlin understands only the language of force. We need cross-party unity on this matter. MEPs from the Left, the Right and the Centre should speak with one voice on this matter. They should not spout nonsense about reparations from Germany, but demand that frozen Russian assets be transferred to Ukraine. More weapons for Kyiv, less anti-EU propaganda. All this is to avoid war on the territory of the Union. A strong United Europe speaking with one voice is invincible. So I just remind you: the enemy is in the east and its name is Russia. Thank you very much. [10:44:28] Speaker 8 [EN] Will you. Accept the blue card from Mr. Grazulis? No. Sorry, the blue card was not accepted. Let me give the floor to Mr. [10:44:36] Speaker 2 [PL] Now. [10:44:44] Riho Terras (PPE) [ET] Honourable Chair, the European Union's sanctions against Russia have significantly affected the aggressor country's economy. At the same time, the imposition of sanctions has from the very beginning been too episodic, too half-hearted. If sanctions are the hammer with which we are to strike Russia, then in reality we have rather used it to pat Russia on the back. This has allowed Russia to find various ways to circumvent sanctions and continue to fill its war chest through trade with third countries. We need to target Russia’s shadow fleet and the infrastructure supporting it much more sharply. Impose stricter sanctions against companies that facilitate the circumvention of sanctions in Russia. All dependence of EU Member States on Russian energy carriers must be brought to an end. It is deeply schizophrenic for Member States to pay hundreds of millions to Russia so that it can kill Ukrainians and prepare for war with the rest of Europe. Thank you. [10:45:47] Martin Hojsík (Renew) [EN] Will you accept the blue card from... No. Okay. So, that concludes this part of the debate, and we move to catch the eye. Looking at the time, I will be able to only take one round of speakers per group. I'm afraid because you don't want all the colleagues coming for the vote to be disturbing the debate, and being angry that we're late. So, let me start with colleague Jonski. [10:46:20] Dariusz Joński (PPE) [PL] Thank you very much, Mr President. Ukraine should sit down at the table and come to an agreement with Russia. That is what Ms Herning-Zajączkowska says, and that is what politicians from the far right are saying. So let us imagine a situation in which someone enters our home, takes our child, holds them for 5 years, and after those 5 years comes and says that they may sign an agreement with the parents. But on the condition that he does not return the child. Would anyone in this Chamber, would anyone in this Chamber say that this is an agreement, that this is peace? No, we cannot accept this in any way. We cannot reward the aggressor for attacking a neighbour. The aggressor must be punished. And every single day. With sanctions, economic and political pressure. Because peace begins when the aggressor understands that they will pay for their aggression. Thank you very much. [10:47:17] Speaker 8 [EN] Thank you. Ďakujem. [10:47:20] Speaker 8 [SK] Now I would like to call on my colleague Ms Rajdov, please. [10:47:31] Chloé Ridel (S&D) [FR] It works. Since February 2022, Vladimir Putin has been striving to prevent the ceasefire in Ukraine. Sixteen times precisely, I have counted them. Sixteen times, he has claimed to want to negotiate. Sixteen times, he has refused a condition that is nonetheless fundamental for anyone who truly wants peace: the cessation of strikes, a ceasefire. On the infrastructures, the cities and the civilian populations in Ukraine that Russia continues to attack every day. I remind you of an obvious fact: it is Russia that started this war and it is Ukraine that has suffered it. So today, the priority is a ceasefire. But Russia has no intention of ending this war. Every time Mr Putin claims to negotiate, it is to push his advantage and extend his aggression. Right now, in Abu Dhabi, the Russians are not prepared to give up any territory they have seized from Ukraine, and while the Europeans are absent from the table, they are demanding from the Russians a new security order in Europe, because the current one is not working. That is interesting, coming from the sole aggressor in 75 years. Let us not be naive and take action. We must maintain pressure on Putin and his band of murderers to bring him to the negotiating table. We should not play into his hands by weakening Ukraine, as Trump is doing, or by calling for colonial-style referendums in the Donbas. It is not for the two thugs, Trump and Putin, to decide the security of our continent. [10:48:46] Speaker 8 [SK] Thank you. And now I would ask the honourable Member to conclude, please. [10:48:54] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [CS] Thank you, Mr President. Colleagues, it is hard to believe that more than four years after the invasion of Ukraine, we are still discussing the same thing in this Chamber. More and more sanctions against Russia, more weapons for Ukraine, and this is the very reason why any peace effort to resolve the conflict is doomed. There was hope of ending the conflict as early as 2022, but European states torpedoed those hopes in favour of a prolonged conflict, and since then we have been doing the same thing over and over again. Even though the United States has already started negotiating with Russia, even though there have been efforts to isolate Russia, this country is deepening its relations with states in Asia, Africa and even in the Americas, and is profiting from it. How many people had to die just so someone could profit from the war, when we could have already had a ceasefire and not keep repeating the same old phrases about sanctions, which we have all known for many years do not work and only make life more expensive for every European and destroy Europe's competitiveness? We should reflect on this, colleagues. [10:49:57] Speaker 8 [SK] Now I would like to call on my colleague Tinkl. [10:50:03] Sebastian Tynkkynen (ECR) [EN] Dear President, over 200 billion euros—that is how much European money has flooded into Russia through energy purchases since the full-scale invasion began. Think about it. It's more than the EU and its and all its member states have provided in aid to Ukraine in its fight against Russia. Every single one of those euros has held by the missiles and drones that rained down on Ukrainian cities. It's time to show what Europe is about. No more loopholes. No more getting around sanctions. Not one single euro to Putin's war chest. War ends when it is no longer profitable. So let's make the charts look different. Let's make them show that we support Ukraine rather than Russia. And let's make the charts coming from the front show that Russia is losing the war. Thank you. [10:51:09] Speaker 8 [SK] Sorry. Thank you. And now I would like to give the floor to Ms colleague Henriksson, please. [10:51:16] Anna-Maja Henriksson (Renew) [SV] Thank you very much, Mr President. Russia continues its brutal war in Ukraine every day. And unfortunately, civilians are dying every day. It is strange that the far right here does not understand that. It is also Putin who could end this war immediately. Europe now needs to show strength. We need to tighten the sanctions. We need to ensure that Russian gas and oil do not flow into Europe. We also need to ensure that we use the frozen Russian assets. And we also need to ensure that neither Putin nor Russia can claim any propaganda victory when it comes to the Ice Hockey World Championship next year. Finland has shown here that it will not play against Russia. Sweden, Denmark, Norway and other countries have fallen behind. But now we also need to tighten the visa rules. We should not grant visas to tourists from Russia. Nor to athletes, for example at the Ice Hockey World Championship. This is in the interests of all of Europe. [10:52:26] Speaker 8 [SK] Thank you. And as the last one, I would also ask colleague Olivérie. Please. [10:52:34] João Oliveira (The Left) [PT] Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner Maria Luísa Albuquerque, the path is not one of sanctions and war. It has to be about building peace and collective security, with corresponding political and diplomatic measures. We insist that the principles enshrined in the Final Act of the Helsinki Conference provide a solid foundation for the political and diplomatic action that is needed. You do not end war with more war. Insisting on sanctions is insisting on prolonging confrontation and war. And it is the peoples who pay the costs of sanctions and war with rising prices and the cost of raw materials, with the closure of factories and the loss of jobs and industrial production capacity, with the diversion of budgetary resources to war that are sorely needed for housing, health, education and social protection. The European Union’s policy is driven by the billion-euro arms business and by a war-mongering discourse that turns a blind eye. And the EU is willing to sacrifice the last Ukrainian to promote that billion-euro business and that policy, while also sacrificing the rights of the rest of the European peoples. Insisting on sanctions, confrontation and escalating the war is not the way forward. [10:53:43] Speaker 8 [EN] Ďakujem. And now for the Commission, I would like to give the floor to Commissioner Albuquerque. Please, the floor is yours. [10:54:02] 263973 [EN] Mr. President, Honorable Members, Minister, thank you for this important and timely debate. The Court of Auditors report has confirmed that the impact of our sanctions is clear. Trade sanctions together with anti-circumvention measures have significantly reduced the trade between the EU and Russia, in particular for the goods that Russia's military needs most to fight its illegal war. And that the Commission has established extensive coordination tools to support the effective implementation of trade sanctions. The Commission has announced the creation of a sanctions office. It will allow us to step up on enforcement and coordination on implementation of sanctions also within the broader context of our full sanctions policy. On the topic of the Russian immobilized assets, which many of you mentioned, the Ukraine loan is guaranteed by this immobilized assets. So we are already using them, productively, in a legally sound manner. And we continue to explore the possibility for their further use. This is not the time to stray from our course. As Russia continues its aggression, we have no choice but to respond strongly. By keeping our unwavering support to Ukraine, be it political, diplomatic, military, financial, or humanitarian. And by maintaining an increasing pressure on Russia, including through sanctions. We intend to do exactly that. The Foreign Affairs Council will adopt new sanctions on Russia next week, further curbing its sources of revenue. The 22nd package with a broad set of measures is in the making and should be tabled shortly. Let me also emphasize: EU sanctions are not directed against Russian people. They are carefully targeted, designed to be proportionate, and temporary in nature. Yet they are a necessary tool to bring this atrocious war to an end. Thank you. [10:56:19] Speaker 8 [EN] Thank you, Commissioner. And before giving the floor to the Minister of State, please, colleague, try to protect the dignity of this House and be silent while the Minister is speaking. Please. [10:56:39] Marian Harkin [EN] Thank you, President, Honorable Members, and Commissioner. And I have to say, as a former member of this House, I fully understand the disturbance that's taking place at the moment. But however, we've had an important discussion here this morning, and I think once again it shows that despite sometimes difficult but very necessary debates, the overall political direction remains clear. That direction has been reaffirmed at every level. In the state of the Union address, President von der Leyen has called for further pressure on Russia, with particular focus on enforcing existing sanctions and closing loopholes. The European Council has called for additional revenues and measures to efficiently cut Russia's energy revenues. And this Parliament has repeatedly called for stronger sanctions and tougher enforcement, including this morning, which I am really pleased to hear. On this central issue, for the future of Ukraine and the EU, our institutions are sending a very consistent message. We will maintain pressure on Russia and stand firmly by Ukraine. Just one question raised during the debate referred to the use of Russian frozen assets. As you know, any decision on the usage of Russian frozen assets requires unanimity in the Council. Currently, the EU collects windfall profits generated by these assets and channels them into military assistance, budget support, and the Ukraine loan cooperation mechanism. So there is real benefit to Ukraine. Colleagues, can I conclude by saying that you can be assured, until the very end of our presidency, Ireland will stand ready, with the Council, to deliver further measures in the months ahead to support our Ukrainian colleagues? Thank you. [10:59:01] Martin Hojsík (Renew) [EN] Thank you, Minister of State. And this concludes the debate. [10:59:05] Martin Hojsík (Renew) [SK] The debate is suspended for a short while. We will resume at 11 o'clock with the vote. [11:00:51] Speaker 1 [EN] Dear colleagues, please take your seats. We would like to start with the meeting. [11:01:19] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] The sitting is resumed. Dear colleagues, before we begin, let me welcome six members of the Canadian Parliament who are with us today. [11:01:55] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Thank you, colleagues. Your presence here is a testament to the ever-growing partnership between Europe and Canada. It also reflects the important role our Parliaments play in strengthening those ties. As was confirmed during the EU-Canada summit, it is a pleasure to have you here; thank you for being here. And the next item is the election of a Vice President of the European Parliament to replace Mr. Nicholas Stefanutsa. I would like to remind you that pursuant to Rule 20 of the Rules of Procedure, the newly elected Vice President shall take the place of her predecessor. In the order of procedure, of precedence, sorry. For the elections to be held for the Vice President, please colleagues, those who are not seated yet should take their seat, but silently, so that we can proceed with our meeting. And stop the talks. Again, for the election of to be held for a Vice President to replace Mr. Nicholas Stefanutsa, I have received the nomination— Colleagues, please. [11:03:19] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [DE] Should Mr Liebsen say we're in kindergarten? [11:03:30] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] I have received the nomination of Mrs. Rada Lajková, nominated by the ESN Group, and of Mrs. Tilly Metz, nominated by the Greens Group. The candidates have confirmed to me their consent to their candidacys. And as the number of candidates exceeds the number of seats to be filled, we shall hold a secret ballot in accordance with Rule 17, paragraph 1 of the Rules of Procedure. Blank and void ballots, as well as abstention, will not be regarded as votes cast. We shall then move to the secret ballot electronic ballot. Please insert your voting cards. And we shall first hold a dummy vote to ensure that everybody is familiar with the electronic voting system. Once the vote has been— We can also say a test vote or whatever. So once the vote— Once the vote has been declared open, you will see on your screen the subject of the vote. The list of candidates, in this case two. The number of seats to be filled, in this case one. Then select your chosen candidate by using the buttons at the bottom right of the screen. Cast your vote by pressing the plus button. It's the left-hand button on the terminal, like with normal votes. The blue voting light will come on, and the asterisk will appear. Next to the name, to safeguard voting confidentially, move the cursor to make the asterisk disappear from the screen. If you wish to abstain, use the zero button. It's the center button on the terminal. You can change your vote until the vote has been declared closed. To do so, reselect the name of the candidate you originally choose, and use the plus button to cancel your vote. The asterisk, again, it's the name will disappear. You can then select another candidate and vote by using the plus button or use the zero button if you wish to abstain. You can vote one for one candidate or abstain. You cannot vote against a candidate. That's not in the rules. To see the candidate, you have already voted for, press the button at the bottom left of the screen. And now that we're long explanations, but we want don't want to risk that there are mistakes or invalid [11:06:05] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] votes in the end. Please. For this test vote, I invite you to proceed to the vote for the election of the singers Phil Collins or Jennifer Lopez. The vote is open. [11:06:34] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Has everyone voted? The vote is closed. And the winner, very clear, is Phil Collins. There is no check. It was electronically. Sorry. Was there a problem with the voting machines? Please I beg the technician stop. Sorry, colleagues. If everyone is shouting around, we cannot proceed. Is there a technical problem? Yes. Then I please I beg the technicians to check if it was possible to shift to the other votes or not, because we had already we had also votes for Mrs. Lopez. So take. Your microphone if you want to come in, because I don't hear otherwise. Mr. Stefanutsa, please. [11:07:37] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] We can do another test. [11:07:38] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] We can do another test. We can repeat the test. Okay. Let's repeat the test, because there was a problem. [11:07:46] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] To go up and down in the— [11:07:47] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] The up and down was not working, I think. But we I can give the floor to Mr. Stefanutsa, seat number eight, please. [11:07:54] Nicolae Ștefănuță (Verts/ALE) [EN] Madam President, with the all respect, I think members didn't quite get the cursor. It happened to several people here. So can you repeat the information on cursor? How to switch between Collins? [11:08:07] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] So again, if you would have listened at the beginning, I explained everything very everything very detailed. Sorry. It is on the right side, on the bottom. You have the different small black buttons under the screen. And there you see the cursors. That are also the buttons you have to press when you want a blue card or catch the eye or others. But that are those on the right side at the bottom of the screen. Not the plus minus and and and against button in the in the in the hole. It's on the screen down on the screen. So please let's check again. I again open the test vote. Does it work now? Wonderful. So has. Everybody had the possibility to choose? It's candidate. And has everybody voted? Then I close the vote. And this time the result is different. Jennifer Lopez. Won the. Election with 379 votes. And Phil Collins just said 126. So then I think we are ready to come to the real vote on our candidates. And I open to the vote. I open the vote for the real election of our candidate. Please. The upload loans. [11:10:31] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Has everybody voted? [11:10:39] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] They're asking to wait a second. They're asking to answer. [11:10:45] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Is there a technical problem? So now again, has everybody voted? Had everybody the chance to vote? Is the technical problem solved? Was it was there a technical problem? No. So the problems are solved. And then I close the vote. And we have a result. We have 579 members voting. We had blank votes, 42. We had votes that cast, 537. Tilly Metz got 423 votes. And Mrs. Rada, Lykova, Mrs. Rada Lykova had 114. [11:12:04] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Tilly Metz— Tilly Metz has obtained an absolute majority of the votes cast. And I declare Tilly Metz elected Vice President of the European Parliament. And should like to congratulate her warmly on the election. In accordance with Rule 20 of the Rules of Procedure, the newly elected Vice President shall take the place of her predecessor in the order of precedent. Now we come to the votes on the report by Mr. Marcin Zbigniewski. On the request of the waiver of the immunity of Andraž Tivadar-Kulya. [11:12:46] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Can you just a second from the— [11:12:48] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] The machine has to reload the other system, but I think that's done now, or? [11:12:53] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Not yet. [11:12:54] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Not yet. Not yet. [11:12:56] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Or from election mode. [11:12:58] Speaker 1 [EN] But that's not a roll call vote. So who is in favor? Who is against? Abstentions adopted. Then we come to the report by Mr. Dainius Zalimas on the request of the waiver of the immunity of Aphrodite Latinopoulou. And I ask who is in favor? Who is against? Abstentions adopted. Now we come to the report by Mrs. Lara Walters. On amendments of the statute of members of the European Parliament as regards proxy voting. And I give the floor to the rapporteur for two minutes. [11:13:43] Lara Wolters (S&D) [EN] Thank you, very much. Is this working? [11:13:46] Lara Wolters (S&D) [EN] Yeah, yeah. [11:13:48] Lara Wolters (S&D) [EN] Colleagues, I am proud that we as the European Parliament, over the years, have improved the rights of Europeans when it comes to maternity leave, paternity leave, and parental leave. But at the same time, we have not given some of those same rights and possibilities to our own members of Parliament yet. Indeed, I have sometimes wondered whether Europe's founding fathers ever thought that a member of the European Parliament could also be a young woman having a baby. But those young women exist. They are here now. Myself included. And I know that over the years they have struggled. And why is that? Because those young women, they don't take their parliamentary duties lightly. They want to do right by those who elected them. But of course, naturally at the same time, they want to be there for their newborns. So today we're voting about giving those young women options. So that colleagues can vote for them when they are not there. And that's something that of course is a given already in many national parliaments. After all, this is a question of democracy. Am I glad that we're taking this step today? Yes, absolutely. Do I wish that today we would be doing the same for young fathers in the same position? Or maybe those adopting children also? Yes. Unfortunately, unfortunately, that is something where member states are still blocking. And that's a fight that will need to keep fighting. But in the meantime, today is a good day. And I'd like to ask you to join me in taking a step towards making this European Parliament more modern, more fair, and more representative. Thank you very much. [11:15:58] Speaker 1 [EN] Voters. Thank you, Mrs. Walters. And now we come to the vote. We vote on Article 1, paragraph 1, point B, original text in two parts. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. We have to check. I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to Article 1, paragraph 1, point E, original text in three parts. First part, I who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions again, I have to check. I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Third part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstention. That's the same majority. So we now so it's reject adopted. Now we come to a recital 5, original text in three parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Third part, who's in okay, we can check. I open the vote. And I close the vote. And. It is adopted. It's the same majority as before. Now we come to the third part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Adopted. We come to recital 6 in two parts. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Against. Abstentions adopted. Now we vote on the draft legislative act as a whole. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Adopted. Now we come for the motion of a resolution. Amendment 1, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. I have to check that. I. Open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to the vote as a whole. By roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is clearly adopted. Now we come to the report by Mrs. Leary Pagin and by Mr. Aurelius Veriga. On the union civil protection mechanism and union support for health emergency preparedness and response. The there is a proposal to reject the commission proposal. Amendment 339. By roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to the draft legislative act. Amendments by the committee responsible in a block vote. [11:19:33] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Amendment 9 in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And. It is adopted. Amendment 12, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Amendment 14, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Amendment 38 in two parts. First part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And. It is clearly adopted. Second part, also by roll call vote, I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is adopted. Amendment 53, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Amendment 138, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Amendment 314, by roll call 14, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And. It is clearly rejected. We come to Amendment 341. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. Amendment 342. Who's in favor? Against. Abstentions. Rejected. Amendment 343. Who's in favor? Against. Abstentions. Rejected. Amendment 353. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. We come to Amendment 93. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Article 4, paragraph 1, Amendment 354. Who's in favor? Against. Abstentions. Rejected. We come to Amendment 355. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. We come to Amendment 125. Who's in favor? Against. Abstentions adopted. Amendment 337. By roll call vote, who's in favor? I open the vote. Sorry. Yeah. I close the vote. And it is clearly rejected. We come to Amendment 344. By roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it. Is rejected. We come to Amendment 134. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Amendment 345. By roll call vote, I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendment 135. I who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. 100 300 356. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. [11:22:56] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Rejected. Amendment 357. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 346. By roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendment 136. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. 137. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Amendment 333. By roll call vote, I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendment 347. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. Amendment 141. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Amendment 348. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. Amendment 202. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. 358. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 224. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. 359. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 349. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. Amendment 360. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 231. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. 35 350. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 249. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Adopted. 351. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 338. And Amendment 352. By roll call vote, I open the vote. And. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendments 255 to 261 and the Amendments 263 to 264 by the committee. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Adopted. Amendment 361. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 362. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 262. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. So 363 falls, and we go to 364. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. Amendment 265. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. So Amendment 365 falls. We go to Amendment 267. 2 sorry. Amendment 276 to 279. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. So the original text falls. We go to Amendment 334. By roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we go to Amendment 366. [11:26:20] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 335. By roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we go to Amendment 8. Who's in favor? Against. Abstentions adopted. Amendment 336. By roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to the Commission proposal as a whole. By roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. And now I give the floor to the rapporteur, Mr. Mrs. Parin, please. [11:27:16] Leire Pajín (S&D) [EN] I would like to request referral back to committee's responsibility for interinstitutional negotiation according to Rule 64. [11:27:27] Speaker 1 [EN] We now vote on the referral back. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions adopted. The report is referred back to the committee for interinstitutional negotiations in accordance with Rule 60. 4. And now. We come to the report by Madame Stéphanie Joncourtin. On modernization, Stéphanie Joncourtin. I think on modernization of the key information document. And we vote on Amendment 2. By roll call vote, and I open the vote. Stéphanie. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we vote on the draft resolution Amendment 3. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions. Adopted. The first reading of Parliament is closed. Then we come to the report again by Madame Stéphanie Joncourtin on union retail investor protection rules. Amendment 2. We vote on the provisional agreement. Amendment 2. By roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is rejected. So the first reading is closed with the rejection. Now. We come to the report by Mr. Christoph Clergeau on the European Chemicals Agency and amending regulation. So we vote on the provisional agreement. By roll call vote, and I open the vote. It's Amendment 117. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. So the first reading of Parliament is closed. Then we go to the report by Mr. Dainius Salimas on geographical indications aligning EU rules with changes to the provisions under the Lisbon Agreement. And I give the floor to the rapporteur for two minutes. [11:29:43] Dainius Žalimas (Renew) [EN] Thank you. Chair. Dear colleagues, geographical indications are an important part of Europe's cultural and economic heritage. They protect the reputation of regional products support local producers and ensure that consumers can trust the origin and quality of the products they buy. But for this protection to be effective, our rules must be aligned with an international system. Therefore, the purpose of this proposal is straightforward: to align EU legislation with the updated rules of the World Intellectual Property Organization's Lisbon system to which the European Union is a party. This updated international rules allow changes to existing registrations of geographical indications, including changes to product names, types, geographical areas, and product characteristics. Our task was to ensure that EU legislation was can accommodate these changes while maintaining legal certainty and avoiding unnecessary administrative burdens. The agreement we have reached strikes this balance. Changes to product names or classifications will continue to trigger updates at international level while purely administrative changes to geographical areas will not. Where changes are substantial, member states will be able to request an international update. This makes the system more practical, proportionate, without weakening the protection of geographical indications. We achieved broad political consensus on this file. Therefore, I would like to thank my colleagues, the shadow rapporteurs, and everyone involved for their constructive cooperation. I invite you to support this report. Thank you. [11:31:29] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. Now we vote on the provisional agreement Amendment 36 by the committee. By roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And. It is clearly adopted. So the first reading of Parliament is closed. Now we come to the report by Mr. Barry Andrews on the Association of the Overseas Countries and Territories with the EU, including EU, Greenland, Denmark relations. And I give the floor to the rapporteur for two minutes. [11:32:05] Barry Andrews (Renew) [EN] President, colleagues, strategic rivalry is reaching the places where Europe's overseas countries and territories are located. They are not peripheral to our interests. They are central to them. They are political partners in renewable energy, critical raw materials, research, and climate. And these countries and territories are also economic partners. And that is why the Parliament is pushing for increased EU financial support. However, funding on paper is not enough. Many of these territories have limited administrative resources. And EU programs can be complex to access. So this report calls for simplified access to EU programs and for practical help in navigating complex financial tools. I welcome the Global Gateway Investments now being made in these territories. But investments must produce results in education, skills, health, connectivity, and jobs for people who live there. In an age of great power rivalry, Europe will not win friends by outspending others. We will win them by being the partner that listens, a partner that arrives not with a flagship project and a photo opportunity, but with respect, patience, and a genuine commitment to the people who call these places home. That is the difference between a sphere of influence and genuine partnership. As many of you know, colleagues, this file has overlapped with an extremely stressful time for Greenlanders. The resolution of that issue for now is a testament to Greenlanders' patience and wisdom, to the steadfast and quiet diplomacy of Denmark, and to unequivocal European solidarity. Greenlanders have a guiding principle and it should be ours too, nothing about us without us. I thank the shadows and the Denver Secretariat and commend the report to the House. Thank you. [11:33:44] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank. You very much. We now come to the votes on the amendments by the committee responsible on the block vote. Who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. We come to amendments by the committee responsible in separate vote. Amendment 15 in two parts. First part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Amendment 20, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Amendment 24 in two parts. First part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Amendment 27 in two parts. First part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Amendment 50 in two parts. First part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Amendment 51 in two parts. First part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Amendment 83 by roll call vote, I open the vote. And. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to Amendment 89, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Sorry. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. We come to Amendment 52, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Amendment 66, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Amendment 87, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Sorry, it failed. Sorry, we wouldn't have to vote on this. So Amendment 87 falls. We come to Amendment 88, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Now we vote on the commission proposal by roll call vote. I open the vote. And. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to the report by Mr. Vlad Vasile Voiculescu on Europe's Beating Cancer Plan. We vote on the original text of paragraph two. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. We vote on paragraph 17, original text in three parts. [11:36:22] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. Third part, who also by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to Amendment 2, paragraph 19, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendment 14, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendment 12, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we vote on the original text in two parts. First part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. It is adopted. And the second part, also by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is also adopted. Now we come to paragraph 22, original text in two parts. First part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to Amendment 3, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. We come now to the original text in two parts. First part, who is in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is clearly adopted. Now we come to Amendment 4, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. It is rejected. Now we vote on the original text in three parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Third part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is also adopted. Now we vote on Amendment 15, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we vote on the original text in two parts. First part, also by roll call vote. I open the vote. Sorry. And I close it. It's. Adopted. The second part, also by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. [11:39:44] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] And it is adopted. Now we come to Amendment 16, also by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is rejected. We come to Amendment 5, by roll call. I open the vote. And I. Close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we vote on the original text in two parts. First part, by roll call vote. I. Open the vote. And I close the vote. It's adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it's also adopted. Now we come to Amendment 17, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is rejected. We come now to the original text in three parts, all by roll call vote. The first part, I open the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Second part, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Third part, by roll call. Again, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to Amendment 18, also by roll call vote, I open the vote. And. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendment 6, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to the original text in four parts. First part, I who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call. Who's in favor? Sorry. I open the vote. Yeah, I wanted to make it fixed. I close the vote. It's adopted. Third part, I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is adopted. Fourth part, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to Amendment 7, also by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to the original text in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to paragraph 31, original text in two parts, by roll call vote. First part, I open the vote. And. I close the vote. And. It is adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. It is adopted. Now we come to paragraph 32, original text in two parts, also both parts, by roll call vote, I open [11:43:20] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] the vote for the first part. And. I close the vote. It's adopted. Second part, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to Amendment 19, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendment 8, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendment 20, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to the original text in three parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Third part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to paragraph 36, original text in three parts, all parts, by roll call vote, I open the vote for the first part. I close the vote. And it is adopted. I open the vote for the second part, who's— I close the vote. It's adopted. The third part, by roll call, I open the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Now we come to Amendment 9, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Amendment 10, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Paragraph 107, original text in two parts, both by roll call vote. First part, I open the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Second part, I open the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Paragraph 113, original text by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Now we come to Amendment 11, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Recital U, original text, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Recital Z, Amendment 1, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to Amendment 13, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Now we come to the resolution as a whole, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come. To the report by Mr. Salvatore De Meo on the EU Agri-food promotion policy—and I give the floor to the [11:46:54] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] rapporteur for two minutes. [11:46:59] Salvatore De Meo (PPE) [IT] Grazie. Grazie, Presidente. Cari colleghi, la relazione che stiamo per votare parte da una semplice convinzione: se vogliamo che la nostra agricoltura europea resti competitiva, dobbiamo dare ai nostri produttori gli strumenti per competere. La politica europea di promozione è uno di questi strumenti. Aiuta le nostre imprese a raggiungere nuovi mercati, a valorizzare e a far conoscere nel mondo le nostre eccellenze agroalimentari. Non possiamo chiedere ai nostri agricoltori di affrontare una concorrenza globale sempre più aggressiva e non sempre corretta e, allo stesso tempo, ridurre le risorse e indebolire gli strumenti che dovrebbero sostenerli. Oggi servono regole più semplici e flessibili, meno burocrazia e risorse finanziarie adeguate. Questa relazione chiede alla Commissione una politica di promozione più efficace, più accessibile e, soprattutto, alle piccole e medie imprese. E, soprattutto, senza discriminazioni ideologiche nei confronti di alcuni prodotti. Investire nella promozione significa sostenere il lavoro dei nostri agricoltori, rafforzare la competitività delle nostre imprese e creare nuove opportunità sui mercati internazionali. Voglio ringraziare tutti i relatori ombra per il contributo che hanno dato e vi invito a sostenere questa relazione, confermando la nostra vicinanza a chi ogni giorno, con il suo lavoro, garantisce la nostra sicurezza alimentare. Grazie. [11:48:19] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you. Very much. Now we proceed to the vote. We vote on Amendment 13, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Amendment 3, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Amendment 9, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. We come to Amendment 4, who's in favor? Against? Abstentions? Rejected. Amendment 5, in favor? Against? Abstentions? Rejected. Amendment 10, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. We come to the original text in six parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. It is adopted. Third part, by roll call, I open the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Fourth part, by roll call, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it's adopted. Fifth part, by roll call, I open the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Sixth part, who's in favor? Who's against? Please show hand. Who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Amendment 6 and Amendment 11, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Amendment 7, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close. The vote. It's rejected. Now we come to Amendment 14, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Amendment 8, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Amendment 1, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Amendment 2, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Original text in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Amendment 12, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to the resolution as a whole, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is clearly adopted. Now we come to the report by—now. Come to the report by Mr. Emanuele Cefalogiannis, on the institutional aspects of artificial [11:51:39] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] intelligence in the context of European integration. We vote on the original text of paragraph 27 in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? I have to check that. I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to paragraph 28 in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Paragraph 40, original text in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. We come to paragraph 44, original text in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? That I have to check. That was quite close. I open the vote. I close the vote. And it was clearly adopted. Please show your hands clearly when I'm too quick. Please tell me. Paragraph 58, original text, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Paragraph 59, in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Paragraph 63, original text in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? That is again close. We have to check. I open the vote. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. We come. To Amendment 1, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Original text in two parts. From recital O, first part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? I have to check that. Second part, I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to recital S, original text in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? [11:54:29] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Abstentions? Seems to be rejected, but I have to check. No, it's not rejected. It's adopted. It's adopted. Now we come to the resolution as a whole, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Now we come to the report by Mr. Martin Starkis, from prototypes to capabilities enabling new defense actors to scale up. We vote on the resolution as a whole, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to the joint motion for a resolution tabled by five groups on the Ukrainian children forcibly deported to Russia or living in Russian occupied territories in Ukraine. We vote on paragraph 1, original text by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Paragraph 2, original text by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. It's adopted. Amendment 1, by roll call vote, I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to paragraph 3, original text in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Paragraph 4, original text by roll call vote, I open the vote. I close the vote. And it's clearly adopted. Now we come to paragraph 5, original text by roll call vote, I open the vote. And I close the vote. It's clearly adopted. Now we come to Amendment 2, by roll call vote, I open the vote. And. I close the vote. It's rejected. Now we come to original text in two parts. First part, who's in favor? Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Second part, by roll call vote, I open. And I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now we come to Amendment 3, by roll call, I open the vote. I. Close the vote. And it is rejected. Now we come to the resolution as a whole, by roll call vote, and I open the vote. And I close the vote. So it is adopted. Thank you very much, colleagues. [11:57:45] Speaker 1 [DE] Zügig. Zumindest. [11:58:34] Speaker 1 [EN] Dear colleagues, I beg those who want to leave the room now, do it quietly and quick because we want to proceed with the declaration of votes and [11:58:44] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [DE] wir kommen nun zu den Erklärungen, zu den Abstimmungen. [11:58:50] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Please, colleagues, leave the room quiet and quick. I would like to come to the report. [11:59:03] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [DE] Ich weiß, das ist in Deutsch jetzt. Ja. Wir kommen nun zu den Erklärungen zur Abstimmung. Und zunächst zum Bericht Leire Pajin und Aurelio Ferriga, Katastrophenschutzverfahren der Union und Unterstützung der Union für die Krisenvorsorge und Reaktion bei gesundheitlichen Notlagen. Und ich gebe das Wort an den Kollegen Arkadiusz Mularczyk für eine Minute. [11:59:26] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Please, colleagues, I beg you to have a little bit of respect for those who want to make a declaration of votes. Please leave the room without talking. You can walk without talking. Please. So. Mr. Mularczyk. [11:59:41] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Dziękuję bardzo. Głosowałem przeciwko rozporządzeniu w sprawie unijnego mechanizmu ochrony ludności w brzmieniu przyjętym przez parlament. Popieram praktyczną współpracę państw członkowskich w sytuacjach kryzysowych, wymianę sprzętu ratowniczego, koordynację ewakuacji medycznej, wspólne ćwiczenia i wsparcie krajów, w których zdolności zostały przeciążone. Tak rozumiana solidarność ma realną wartość dodaną. Niestety tekst wykracza daleko poza ten cel i instrumenty ochrony ludności stają się narzędziem rozwijania europejskiej Unii zdrowotnej. Wprowadza szeroki katalog działań obejmujący wspólne zamówienia leków, gromadzenie strategicznych zapasów medycznych, monitorowanie systemów krajowych oraz elementy edukacji zdrowotnej. Brakuje jasnych zasad własności zapasów i odpowiedzialności za decyzje, oraz ich uwalnianie i ochrony kompetencji państw członkowskich. Rozporządzenie wyłącza też elementy agendy klimatycznej i środowiskowej oraz zacieśnia współpracę cywilno-wojskową w tym poprzez uwzględnienie scenariuszy obronnych i ocen wywiadowczych. Zamiast usprawniać reagowanie na katastrofy, zaciera granice między ochroną cywilną a polityką zdrowotną i kwestiami obronności. Dziękuję bardzo. [12:00:58] Speaker 1 [EN] So the next speaker is Margo Zata-Gorzkiewska for one minute. [12:01:05] Małgorzata Gosiewska (ECR) [PL] Szanowni Państwo, debatowaliśmy o gotowości Europy na zagrożenia zdrowotne. Tymczasem polski system ochrony zdrowia już dziś zmaga się z poważnym kryzysem. Zobowiązania publicznych zakładów opieki zdrowotnej przekroczyły 32 miliardy złotych, z czego blisko 6 miliardów to długi przeterminowane. Zamykane są porodówki i oddziały szpitalne. W 2025 roku zlikwidowano 27 oddziałów położniczych, a od 2026 roku nie ma ich już w 136 powiatach. Pytam więc: jak państwo, które ma problem z zapewnieniem obywatelom podstawowej opieki zdrowotnej, przygotuje się na epidemię, katastrofę czy zagrożenia wojenne? Unijny mechanizm ochrony ludności jest niezbędny, ale nie zastąpi odpowiedzialności rządów krajowych. Nie można mówić o gotowości na przyszłe katastrofy, kiedy nie potrafi się rozwiązać kryzysu, który trwa już dziś. Dziękuję. [12:02:03] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Piotr Müller, also for one minute. [12:02:10] Piotr Müller (ECR) [PL] Szanowni Państwo, wielokrotnie na tej sali mamy do czynienia z dyskusją na temat mechanizmów, które wspomagałyby koordynację państw członkowskich. Ja jestem za takimi mechanizmami, które faktycznie tę współpracę wspomagają, koordynują. Ale w tym mechanizmie, który dzisiaj też głosowaliśmy i dyskutowaliśmy, pojawiają się narzędzia, które centralizują funkcjonowanie Unii Europejskiej. Po raz kolejny zresztą. Szanowni Państwo, ja apeluję o to, aby w kolejnych dokumentach mówić o koordynacji, mówić o współpracy, ale nie budować kolejnych organów, które będą przejmowały kompetencje państw członkowskich. Naprawdę, my wszyscy jesteśmy w Unii Europejskiej po to, żeby współpracować. Żeby współpracować, koordynować swoją działalność również właśnie w sytuacjach kryzysowych. Ale nie starajmy się budować centralnego państwa. Nie możemy budować państwa pod nazwą Unia Europejska. Budujmy organizację, która się nazywa Unia Europejska, złożona z niezależnych, niepodległych państw, które chcą po prostu razem wspólnie współpracować. [12:03:08] Speaker 1 [EN] The next speaker is Jadwiga Wiżniewska. [12:03:12] Jadwiga Wiśniewska (ECR) [PL] Bardzo pani przewodnicząca. Szanowni Państwo, bezpieczeństwo naszych obywateli i ochrona ich życia to najbardziej podstawowy obowiązek każdego państwa. Działania Unii powinny polegać na koordynacji i wspieraniu państw członkowskich tam, gdzie skala kryzysu przekracza możliwości pojedynczego państwa. Unijny mechanizm ochrony ludności nie może więc służyć przejmowaniu kompetencji państw członkowskich i zwiększaniu przy tym biurokracji. Musimy zadbać, by środki unijne trafiały na szkolenia ratowników, budowę rezerw sprzętowych i wymianę doświadczeń, a nie na ideologiczne projekty czy zawłaszczanie kompetencji przez państw członkowskich przez Komisję Europejską. Potrzebujemy Europy silnych, bezpiecznych, dobrze zorganizowanych i dobrze współpracujących ze sobą państw narodowych. Dziękuję. [12:04:12] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] The. Bericht Vlad Vasile Voiculescu: Europas Plan gegen Krebs und zunächst habe ich für eine Minute Herrn Arkadiusz Mularczyk. [12:04:32] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Wstrzymałem się od głosu w sprawie sprawozdania dotyczącego wdrażania europejskiego planu walki z rakiem w kształcie proponowanym przez parlament. Podzielam ogólne cele dokumentu, wzmocnienie profilaktyki badań przesiewowych, wczesnej diagnostyki, dostępu do innowacyjnych terapii oraz poprawy jakości życia pacjentów. Nie mogę jednak poprzeć zapisów, które wprowadzają nieproporcjonalne regulacje obciążenia fiskalne. W tym wyższe akcyzy na tytoń, nikotynę, możliwości jednolitych opakowań, nowe przepisy dotyczące etykietowania alkoholu, oraz obowiązkowe oznaczenie wartości odżywczej z przodu opakowania. Takie rozwiązania uderzają w tradycyjne produkty europejskie, w tym wino, ograniczają kompetencje państw członkowskich i nie są w pełni oparte na dowodach naukowych. Brakuje też wystarczającego rozróżnienia produktów tytoniowych i nikotynowych według rzeczywistego profilu ryzyka. Można odnieść wrażenie, że ta rezolucja dotyczy częściowo dobrych założeń, ale nie proponuje właściwego kierunku walki z rakiem. Z tych powodów nie mogłem poprzeć tego projektu. Dziękuję. [12:05:36] Speaker 1 [DE] Die nächste Rednerin ist Margo Zata-Gorzkiewska, auch für eine Minute, bitte. [12:05:41] Małgorzata Gosiewska (ECR) [PL] Szanowni Państwo, europejska walka z rakiem miała być priorytetem. Tymczasem europejski Trybunał Obrachunkowy alarmuje. Z budżetu EU for Health przesunięto miliard euro. Przyszłość finansowania po 2027 roku jest niepewna. Inicjatywy częściowo się dublują, a Komisja nie stworzyła skutecznych ram monitorowania rezultatów planu. Miliardy euro strategie wielkie, a brakuje gwarancji ciągłości działań. W Polsce również deklaracje rozmijają się z rzeczywistością. W Łodzi pacjentkę onkologiczną poinformowano o niemożności rozpoczęcia terapii z powodu braku finansowania. A termin leczenia wskazano dopiero na pierwszy kwartał przyszłego roku. Szpitale alarmują o problemach finansowych i o zadłużeniu. Jednocześnie media publiczne w likwidacji otrzymały w pierwszym półroczu 2026 roku 1,2 miliarda złotych z budżetu państwa. Kto odpowie za bezpieczeństwo pacjentów? Rak nie czeka na decyzję polityków. Rak zabija. [12:06:49] Małgorzata Gosiewska (ECR) [EN] The need is [12:06:50] Speaker 1 [DE] Rednerin ist Jadwiga Wiżniewska. [12:06:54] Jadwiga Wiśniewska (ECR) [PL] Dziękuję bardzo. Co roku w Unii Europejskiej chorobę nowotworową diagnozuje się u około 2 miliony 700 tysięcy ludzi. Bez zdecydowanych i skoordynowanych działań na poziomie unijnym liczba zachorowań w Europie może rosnąć o blisko 1/4 do roku 2035. Priorytetem Unii musi być efektywne wspieranie państw członkowskich w profilaktyce, badaniach przesiewowych, wczesnej diagnostyce i innowacyjnych metodach leczenia i poprawy jakości życia. Szczególną uwagę musimy poświęcić także rzadkim nowotworom i nowotworom wieku dziecięcego. Niestety obecnie w Polsce sytuacja, jeśli chodzi o choroby nowotworowe, jest dramatyczna. Pacjenci są odsyłani bez koniecznej pomocy i koniecznych procedur leczenia. Rząd nie finansuje w sposób wystarczający leczenia chorób nowotworowych. [12:08:02] Jadwiga Wiśniewska (ECR) [EN] Thank you very much. [12:08:02] Speaker 3 [PL] I inne obszary. [12:08:05] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] And now we come to the next report, Ukrainische [12:08:08] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [DE] Kinder, die nach Russland deportiert wurden, oder in von Russland besetzten Gebieten in der Ukraine leben. Hier auch zunächst Arkadiusz Mularczyk. [12:08:18] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Dziękuję bardzo. Głosowałem za przyjęciem rezolucji w sprawie deportacji i przymusowego przemieszczania ukraińskich dzieci przez Rosję. Od 2014 roku na masową skalę od pełnoskalowej agresji w 2022 roku rosyjskie władze systematycznie porywają ukraińskie dzieci celem ich rusyfikacji. Indoktrynacji i militaryzacji. Według ukraińskich władz zweryfikowano ponad 20 tysięcy takich przypadków, a rzeczywista liczba jest prawdopodobnie znacznie wyższa. Dzieci są pozbawiane tożsamości, poddawane przymusowej adaptacji i przygotowane do służby rosyjskiej armii. Takie działania stanowią zbrodnię wojenną i zbrodnię przeciwko ludzkości. W świetle konwencji o zapobieganiu i karaniu zbrodni ludobójstwa spełniają także znamiona ludobójstwa poprzez przymusowe przenoszenie dzieci z jednej grupy narodowej do drugiej. Rezolucja słusznie żąda natychmiastowego wydania i zwrotu tych dzieci potępia udział Białorusi, Korei Północnej oraz wzywa do rozszerzenia sankcji, w tym wobec firm państwowych takich jak Gazprom i Rosnieft. Podkreśla też, że powrót dzieci musi pozostać priorytetem w każdej przyszłej negocjacji pokojowej. Z tych powodów głosowałem za przyjęciem rezolucji. Dziękuję bardzo. [12:09:29] Speaker 1 [EN] Is Margo Zata-Gorzkiewska. [12:09:32] Małgorzata Gosiewska (ECR) [PL] Szanowni Państwo, Rosja nie tylko zabija ukraińskie dzieci, ona kradnie im dzieciństwo, rodziny, język, tożsamość i ojczyznę. Ponad 20 tysięcy przypadków deportacji i przymusowych przesiedleń ukraińskich dzieci zostało już potwierdzonych. Dzieci trafiają do rosyjskich rodzin i instytucji, poddawane są rusyfikacji, indoktrynacji i militaryzacji. Uczy się je posłuszeństwa wobec reżimu Putina, obsługi broni i przygotowuje do służby w rosyjskiej armii. Polska wie, czym jest taki proceder. Niemieccy okupanci uprowadzili ponad 200 tysięcy polskich dzieci celem germanizacji. Według szacunków IPN zaledwie 30 tysięcy udało się odzyskać. W 2023 roku Międzynarodowy Trybunał Karny wydał nakaz aresztowania dla Putina, a dzieci nadal nie wróciły do rodziców, do domów. Żądamy ich powrotu, sankcji, bezwzględnej odpowiedzialności sprawców. Nie może być sprawiedliwego pokoju dopóki ukraińskie dzieci nie wrócą do swoich rodzin, do swojej ojczyzny. Dziękuję. [12:10:36] Speaker 1 [EN] And the last speaker is Jadwiga Wiżniewska. [12:10:39] Jadwiga Wiśniewska (ECR) [PL] Dziękuję bardzo. Pani Przewodnicząca, ukraińskie dzieci są przymusowo deportowane do Rosji. To te przymusowe deportacje są absolutnie nielegalne. Następuje rusyfikacja tych dzieci i indoktrynacja. To są elementy systemowej polityki Kremla, której celem jest wymazanie ukraińskiej tożsamości narodowej. Niestety jest to znany modus operandi Rosji, która doświadczała w przeszłości również i Polska. Której doświadczała w przeszłości również i Polska. Rosja odbiera dzieciom rodziny, domy, język, historię i prawo do własnej ojczyzny. To zbrodnia wojenna. Stawiamy sprawę jasno. Wzywamy Rosję do natychmiastowego zaprzestania przesiedleń dzieci. Ujawnienia ich miejsca pobytu i tożsamości. Unieważnienia procedur nadania rosyjskiego obywatelstwa. Domagamy się także pociągnięcia do odpowiedzialności przed międzynarodowymi trybunałami osób odpowiedzialnych za te zbrodnie. Żaden sprawiedliwy pokój z Rosją nie może być zawarty kosztem ukraińskich dzieci. [12:11:51] Speaker 1 [DE] Vielen Dank. Wir kommen nun zum Ende der Erklärungen der persönlichen Erklärungen zur Abstimmung. Die Protokolle der heutigen und der gestrigen Sitzung werden im Parlament zu Beginn seiner nächsten Tagung zur Genehmigung vorgelegt. Wenn es keine Einwände gibt, werde ich in der heutigen Sitzung angenommenen Entschließungen den in diesen Entschließungen genannten Personen und Gremien übermitteln. Die nächste Tagung findet vom 23. bis zum 26. November in Straßburg statt. Die Sitzungsperiode des Europäischen Parlaments ist unterbrochen. Die heutige Sitzung ist hiermit geschlossen. Vielen Dank.