1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:03,000
Brussels Live
Transcribed and translated by AI

2
00:10:20,245 --> 00:10:25,131
So good morning, colleagues.
The sitting is open.

3
00:10:25,285 --> 00:10:30,238
I have received from the Council its
position at first reading regarding the

4
00:10:30,309 --> 00:10:35,614
following two files: payment services in
the internal markets and payment services

5
00:10:35,671 --> 00:10:39,483
and electronic money services
in the internal market.

6
00:10:39,565 --> 00:10:44,250
I have also received the reasons which
led to their adoption and the Commission's

7
00:10:44,305 --> 00:10:49,083
positions. The full title will be "Titles
will be published in the minutes of

8
00:10:49,132 --> 00:10:53,707
today's sitting. " The three-month period
available to Parliament to adopt its

9
00:10:53,769 --> 00:10:59,071
positions begins tomorrow,
the 13th of November.

10
00:10:59,365 --> 00:11:05,182
The next item on the agenda is the Council
and Commission statements further EU

11
00:11:05,253 --> 00:11:10,684
sanctions against Russia in response to
this escalating attacks against Ukraine.

12
00:11:10,765 --> 00:11:15,127
Cutting off the sources
financing the Russian war.

13
00:11:15,265 --> 00:11:21,183
And as always, we will begin with
the Council and Minister Harking.

14
00:11:21,265 --> 00:11:22,465
Please, the floor is yours.

15
00:11:34,765 --> 00:11:38,909
President, Honorable
Members, Commissioner.

16
00:11:39,025 --> 00:11:45,938
Thank you for this timely debate. As we
approach the fifth anniversary of Russia's

17
00:11:46,032 --> 00:11:54,865
full-scale invasion, Ukraine continues
to stand and fight with our unwavering

18
00:11:54,985 --> 00:12:03,135
support. But we must also look—excuse
me—at the immediate challenges ahead.

19
00:12:03,265 --> 00:12:07,276
The coming months will be
very difficult for Ukraine.

20
00:12:07,405 --> 00:12:14,789
As winter approaches, Russia is intensifying
its attacks against civilians, and

21
00:12:14,891 --> 00:12:22,666
civilian infrastructure. Russia targets
energy facilities, transport networks,

22
00:12:22,765 --> 00:12:30,067
hospitals, and schools. These attacks aim
to weaken Ukraine, undermine its economy,

23
00:12:30,143 --> 00:12:38,431
and exhaust its people. They must,
however, not weaken our resolve.

24
00:12:38,605 --> 00:12:46,165
Russia's ability to wage this war
depends on its ability to finance it.

25
00:12:46,405 --> 00:12:52,819
The European Parliament has consistently
called for stronger sanctions and tougher

26
00:12:52,933 --> 00:12:59,727
actions against circumvention.
We share this objective.

27
00:12:59,845 --> 00:13:05,062
And the European Union has
already taken substantial action.

28
00:13:05,185 --> 00:13:12,175
Through 21 sanctions packages, we have
progressively restricted Russia's access to

29
00:13:12,253 --> 00:13:19,674
energy revenues, financial services,
technology, and goods needed by its military

30
00:13:19,791 --> 00:13:26,992
industry. The 21st package adopted in
July further targeted Russia's energy and

31
00:13:27,073 --> 00:13:33,512
financial sectors and extended
restrictions against the shadow fleet.

32
00:13:33,625 --> 00:13:41,624
In October, the Council went further and
adopted the largest-ever listings proposal

33
00:13:41,721 --> 00:13:49,171
targeting close to 1,600 companies
and individuals linked to Russia's

34
00:13:49,285 --> 00:13:55,188
military-industrial complex.
These measures matter.

35
00:13:55,285 --> 00:14:02,746
But their effectiveness also depends on
their implementation and enforcement.

36
00:14:02,905 --> 00:14:08,667
Russia continues to rely on intermediaries,
third countries, and complex trade

37
00:14:08,745 --> 00:14:15,738
networks to circumvent our restrictions.
We must make these channels increasingly

38
00:14:15,823 --> 00:14:23,070
difficult and costly to use. This is
where we are focusing our efforts.

39
00:14:23,185 --> 00:14:28,854
In October, the European Council called for
additional measures in coordination with

40
00:14:28,933 --> 00:14:36,808
our partners to further fight circumvention
and curb shadow fleet operations.

41
00:14:36,925 --> 00:14:43,400
As we prepare to receive the Commission's
proposal, for the 22nd sanctions package,

42
00:14:43,476 --> 00:14:43,885
the

43
00:14:43,885 --> 00:14:51,018
Irish presidency stands ready to work
with member states to make swift progress.

44
00:14:51,145 --> 00:14:54,697
Strengthened unity is not just
the motto of our presidency;

45
00:14:54,751 --> 00:15:00,609
it is also a necessity in this matter
where the adoption of sanctions requires

46
00:15:00,685 --> 00:15:07,550
unanimity in the Council. This is all the
more important as Russia continues to use

47
00:15:07,645 --> 00:15:15,642
hybrid attacks and disinformation in
an attempt to undermine our unity.

48
00:15:15,925 --> 00:15:19,121
But our response cannot stop at sanctions.

49
00:15:19,225 --> 00:15:25,336
Increasing pressure on Russia must go
hand in hand with continued support for

50
00:15:25,439 --> 00:15:31,128
Ukraine. First of all, this
support is military and material.

51
00:15:31,225 --> 00:15:38,883
We are strengthening our military support
to the extension of EU MAMS mandate, and

52
00:15:38,975 --> 00:15:47,860
the mobilization of the 6.6 billion
euro under the European Peace Facility.

53
00:15:47,965 --> 00:15:55,327
We are also helping Ukraine protect and
repair its critical infrastructure through

54
00:15:55,453 --> 00:16:03,478
the Ukraine Energy Support Fund.
Secondly, our support is financial.

55
00:16:03,625 --> 00:16:12,785
Key disbursements under the 90 billion
euro Ukraine Support Loan for 2026 and 2027

56
00:16:13,045 --> 00:16:20,354
are underway. We expect Ukraine to continue
implementing the reforms required to

57
00:16:20,442 --> 00:16:25,550
receive further disbursement
under the Ukraine Facility.

58
00:16:25,645 --> 00:16:32,161
Thirdly, our support is political. The
opening of accession negotiations clusters

59
00:16:32,233 --> 00:16:39,745
two and three on the 13th of October this
year marked another step towards Ukraine

60
00:16:39,925 --> 00:16:44,043
and European future. So
our message is clear:

61
00:16:44,125 --> 00:16:52,165
we will maintain our support and continue
to weaken Russia's capacity to finance its

62
00:16:52,301 --> 00:17:00,540
war until it ends its aggression and
engages in meaningful negotiations towards a

63
00:17:00,636 --> 00:17:03,685
lasting peace. Thank
you for your attention.

64
00:17:06,085 --> 00:17:08,314
Thank you very, very
much, Minister Harking.

65
00:17:08,365 --> 00:17:12,636
And now I will give the floor to the
Commissioner and Commissioner Albuquerque.

66
00:17:12,685 --> 00:17:13,885
Please, the floor is yours.

67
00:17:20,365 --> 00:17:27,940
President, Honorable Members, Minister.
In response to Russia's illegal and

68
00:17:28,006 --> 00:17:35,396
unprovoked full-scale invasion of Ukraine
in February 2022, the EU swiftly adopted

69
00:17:35,485 --> 00:17:40,466
unprecedentedly tough sanctions, in close
cooperation with international partners,

70
00:17:40,525 --> 00:17:45,934
including the United States, the United
Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and Japan.

71
00:17:46,105 --> 00:17:52,285
The rapid succession of the 21 packages of
EU sanctions adopted since the outset of

72
00:17:52,352 --> 00:17:57,092
the war have resulted in an
unparalleled set of measures.

73
00:17:57,205 --> 00:18:03,325
Overall, the scope of the sectoral sanctions
is immense, ranging from trade energy

74
00:18:03,397 --> 00:18:09,675
and transport to finance and media. In
addition, since last autumn, the EU has been

75
00:18:09,738 --> 00:18:15,524
adopting additional rounds of listings
at every foreign affairs council.

76
00:18:15,625 --> 00:18:22,011
The largest such listing package in October
targeted the Russian military-industrial

77
00:18:22,088 --> 00:18:27,478
complex and brought the total number
of entities and individuals listed for

78
00:18:27,549 --> 00:18:34,234
undermining Ukraine's territorial
integrity close to 4,600.

79
00:18:34,405 --> 00:18:40,051
We have heavily targeted Russia's oil and
gas sector, its main source of revenues,

80
00:18:40,101 --> 00:18:47,821
and will continue to do so. To date, the
EU has listed more than 690 shadow fleet

81
00:18:47,899 --> 00:18:52,431
vessels that are barred
from EU ports and services.

82
00:18:52,525 --> 00:18:57,820
We have cut off large parts of Russia's
financial sector, causing it to rely on

83
00:18:57,894 --> 00:19:03,781
alternative payment channels and we have
introduced measures to curb those too.

84
00:19:03,865 --> 00:19:11,409
So far, we have placed more than 100
Russian banks under an EU transaction ban.

85
00:19:11,545 --> 00:19:16,930
Through our collective work, we have banned
exports to Russia of weapons and other

86
00:19:16,988 --> 00:19:19,813
goods that could be
used in the battlefield.

87
00:19:19,885 --> 00:19:25,146
And we have suspended the broadcasting of
Russian media outlets in the EU that just

88
00:19:25,244 --> 00:19:31,111
serve to spread propaganda.
Sanctions work and Moscow knows it.

89
00:19:31,225 --> 00:19:37,598
They have caused Russia over 1 trillion
euros that it could have otherwise spent on

90
00:19:37,765 --> 00:19:45,350
the war. Honorable Members, despite all
ongoing diplomatic efforts, Russia shows no

91
00:19:45,420 --> 00:19:50,358
willingness to stop its war
of aggression against Ukraine.

92
00:19:50,545 --> 00:19:56,539
Unable to move the front line, Russia has
escalated its massive systematic missile

93
00:19:56,611 --> 00:20:02,605
and drone attacks against civilians across
Ukraine aiming to cause as much terror as

94
00:20:02,665 --> 00:20:03,865
possible.

95
00:20:04,405 --> 00:20:10,475
Moscow, as also stepped up in its hybrid
attacks on Europe, hoping to break our

96
00:20:10,564 --> 00:20:18,025
resolve. It has had the opposite effect.
The EU stands unwavering and united in our

97
00:20:18,103 --> 00:20:24,024
support for Ukraine as it defends its
independence, sovereignty, and territorial

98
00:20:24,085 --> 00:20:28,066
integrity, and its people
from the aggressor.

99
00:20:28,165 --> 00:20:32,994
At their last summit in October, European
leaders were very clear on the need to

100
00:20:33,068 --> 00:20:38,651
continue raising pressure so that Russia
engages seriously in talks to end this war

101
00:20:38,708 --> 00:20:44,169
of aggression and achieve peace.
This reflects a joint understanding:

102
00:20:44,245 --> 00:20:50,821
sanctions must be maintained and increased,
until there is just and lasting peace.

103
00:20:50,965 --> 00:20:55,505
Therefore, the European Council called
for further measures in coordination with

104
00:20:55,590 --> 00:21:01,022
partners to reduce Russia's energy
revenues close loopholes and combat the

105
00:21:01,083 --> 00:21:07,919
circumvention of sanctions. Honorable
Members, the EU will lead the way on further

106
00:21:07,976 --> 00:21:13,047
sanctions on Russia in alignment with
partners whenever possible, to maximize their

107
00:21:13,105 --> 00:21:19,686
impact and limit circumvention. Coordinated
pressure works best, strengthening both

108
00:21:19,742 --> 00:21:24,925
the political message and enforcement.
We continue working together in various

109
00:21:24,985 --> 00:21:32,528
formats, including the G7, to that end.
Honorable Members, next Monday, EU Foreign

110
00:21:32,586 --> 00:21:37,165
Ministers are poised to adopt further
listing measures on oil refineries,

111
00:21:37,225 --> 00:21:40,438
refineries, and the
shadow fleet ecosystem.

112
00:21:40,525 --> 00:21:45,477
This is yet another round of hard listings
targeting the malicious attempts of

113
00:21:45,553 --> 00:21:49,688
enablers and profiteers of
Russia's war of aggression.

114
00:21:49,765 --> 00:21:56,251
The EAS and the Commission are also
finalizing proposals for a comprehensive 22nd

115
00:21:56,365 --> 00:22:02,403
package of sanctions. We will continue using
sanctions to limit Russia's capacity to

116
00:22:02,481 --> 00:22:07,345
wage this war, to strengthen enforcement
of EU measures, and counter their

117
00:22:07,405 --> 00:22:12,445
circumvention, and to ensure accountability
for violations of international law.

118
00:22:12,505 --> 00:22:16,939
The support of this House to further
strengthen pressure on Russia is much

119
00:22:17,008 --> 00:22:18,265
appreciated. Thank you.

120
00:22:22,465 --> 00:22:26,565
Thank you very much, Commissioner. And now
we will take the first round of speakers

121
00:22:26,605 --> 00:22:29,312
on behalf of the political
groups, beginning with Mr.

122
00:22:29,425 --> 00:22:32,845
Halitsky, on behalf of EPP for
one and a half minutes, please.

123
00:22:36,745 --> 00:22:43,536
Ladies and Gentlemen, the European sanctions
policy cannot change with regard to

124
00:22:43,665 --> 00:22:50,480
Russia until the last Russian aggressor
soldier leaves the territory of Ukraine.

125
00:22:50,531 --> 00:22:55,553
We must be consistent and determined,
this time the energy sector, the financial

126
00:22:55,641 --> 00:22:59,670
sector is the one that will
be subject to sanctions.

127
00:22:59,716 --> 00:23:05,809
We demand a longer list of individual
sanctions and a very strict correction policy,

128
00:23:05,874 --> 00:23:10,867
a visa policy. But this is a package we
talk about very often and we also continue

129
00:23:10,971 --> 00:23:16,311
to call for consistent enforcement.
There is one issue that we can no longer

130
00:23:16,388 --> 00:23:19,087
debate—we must act. The frozen
Russian funds and assets.

131
00:23:19,150 --> 00:23:26,956
€185 billion in accounts, due to the
concerns of one country, Belgium, remain

132
00:23:27,092 --> 00:23:31,258
unused. But they must be put
to work in support of Ukraine.

133
00:23:31,319 --> 00:23:36,343
That is why, in writing, I would like to
thank here my colleague Ties Reuten from

134
00:23:36,411 --> 00:23:41,068
the Socialists and Democrats, but also on
behalf of the European People’s Party, we

135
00:23:41,114 --> 00:23:44,954
are calling in writing for the creation
of a trust fund that will be guaranteed by

136
00:23:45,000 --> 00:23:49,923
all Member States, which will minimise those
legal concerns, and these funds must be

137
00:23:49,988 --> 00:23:55,347
put to work to support Ukraine, to help
rebuild critical infrastructure, and also to

138
00:23:55,399 --> 00:23:57,924
provide assistance that will end this war.

139
00:23:57,989 --> 00:24:02,066
And one final thing: kidnappings
are still taking place.

140
00:24:02,155 --> 00:24:07,488
Children are being abducted to places where
they are being Russified, over 200 such

141
00:24:07,558 --> 00:24:11,847
places in Russia, 13 in Belarus.
Russia is a terrorist state.

142
00:24:11,905 --> 00:24:15,847
And we must speak out about this loudly,
supporting the International Criminal

143
00:24:15,894 --> 00:24:20,618
Court, because this is an element of a
policy that has a genocidal character.

144
00:24:20,719 --> 00:24:22,705
Putin is a war criminal.

145
00:24:24,445 --> 00:24:27,487
Thank you very much. And
on behalf of S&D, Mr.

146
00:24:27,565 --> 00:24:29,125
Reuten, for one and a
half minutes, please.

147
00:24:29,605 --> 00:24:33,844
President, Council, Commission, colleagues,
I would almost hope that Europe's

148
00:24:33,925 --> 00:24:37,753
leaders simply put off difficult decisions
on sanctions, assets, air defense, deep

149
00:24:37,801 --> 00:24:40,824
strike, travel bans, the
SkyShield, or retaliation.

150
00:24:40,885 --> 00:24:46,907
Out of hope for real results this time.
But if we are honest, expectations of Abu

151
00:24:46,974 --> 00:24:52,575
Dhabi were very low. At least with me,
simply because the entire setup is wrong with

152
00:24:52,645 --> 00:24:57,400
one consistent element from the US side,
a piecing the aggressor and pressuring the

153
00:24:57,465 --> 00:25:02,157
victim. And I acknowledge what you said and
what the European Union has done so far,

154
00:25:02,198 --> 00:25:04,918
and your personal
commitment. But we need more.

155
00:25:05,005 --> 00:25:09,677
European components still end up in Russian
drones and missiles built on machines

156
00:25:09,745 --> 00:25:14,127
running on European lubricants, carrying
explosives made with European chemical

157
00:25:14,191 --> 00:25:18,827
precursors. How can we ask from third
countries to stop circumvention if our own

158
00:25:18,883 --> 00:25:23,721
house is not in order? National
carve-outs, information not shared, too few

159
00:25:23,797 --> 00:25:29,901
prosecutions, and no real EU oversight.
The Court of Auditors stated yesterday,

160
00:25:29,965 --> 00:25:32,823
"Europe lacks the will to
implement in good faith."

161
00:25:32,905 --> 00:25:37,808
The new sanctions office could be a welcome
step, but only if it has real teeth.

162
00:25:37,885 --> 00:25:42,817
So close the loopholes and end forum
shopping, fully ban exports of alumina,

163
00:25:42,867 --> 00:25:47,525
chemical precursors, and lubricants, and
make producers' tech their high-priority

164
00:25:47,579 --> 00:25:52,281
components and make them liable when
they turn up in Russian weapons.

165
00:25:52,345 --> 00:25:56,343
There is no point in just
hoping this war will end.

166
00:25:56,425 --> 00:25:59,294
The Russians made that
very clear yesterday.

167
00:25:59,365 --> 00:26:00,565
Thank you.

168
00:26:01,405 --> 00:26:06,145
Thank you very much. And the next
speaker is on behalf of the Patriots, Ms.

169
00:26:06,385 --> 00:26:08,185
Ceccardi, for two minutes, please.

170
00:26:10,645 --> 00:26:18,894
Thank you, Mr President. Today marks the
1,723rd day since the start of Russia’s

171
00:26:18,990 --> 00:26:24,571
invasion of Ukraine. Nearly five years
of war, and in the meantime, how much has

172
00:26:24,679 --> 00:26:31,773
Europe mobilised? €235 billion, of which
almost €78 billion in military assistance.

173
00:26:31,834 --> 00:26:38,695
To these commitments is added a €90
billion loan for 2026 and 2027, already

174
00:26:38,778 --> 00:26:44,327
approved. How much has the
war cost our businesses?

175
00:26:44,464 --> 00:26:52,176
Between 2021 and 2025, European exports to
Russia have fallen by almost €69 billion.

176
00:26:52,294 --> 00:26:57,003
That’s a 69.5% contraction
in exports per year.

177
00:26:57,074 --> 00:27:02,379
A figure that testifies to how much trade
relations have changed and that requires

178
00:27:02,441 --> 00:27:07,203
us to also assess the economic consequences
of sanctions on our businesses.

179
00:27:07,254 --> 00:27:12,141
I would like to ask the Commission and
President von der Leyen what concrete results

180
00:27:12,221 --> 00:27:15,837
these 21 packages of
sanctions have produced.

181
00:27:15,915 --> 00:27:19,964
What diplomatic strategy
accompanies these measures?

182
00:27:20,040 --> 00:27:25,647
Talks between the United States, Russia
and Ukraine were held in Abu Dhabi.

183
00:27:25,721 --> 00:27:31,499
Europe is involved in the diplomatic
coordination, but not directly at the

184
00:27:31,571 --> 00:27:37,259
trilateral table. After hundreds of billions
mobilised, Europe is not even at the

185
00:27:37,331 --> 00:27:41,844
table. After almost five years, we
must acknowledge a fundamental truth:

186
00:27:41,903 --> 00:27:48,302
there can be no lasting security in Europe
without peace and with this European

187
00:27:48,408 --> 00:27:54,402
Commission unable to deliver it. Your
responsibility is not to sign endless cheques,

188
00:27:54,477 --> 00:27:58,754
but to contribute to a serious
and credible diplomatic solution.

189
00:27:58,832 --> 00:28:01,307
Our citizens demand
answers; so do businesses.

190
00:28:01,361 --> 00:28:06,578
Our businesses need stability, our economies
need investment, and European taxpayers

191
00:28:06,642 --> 00:28:11,063
deserve to know where their
money is being used responsibly.

192
00:28:11,121 --> 00:28:16,607
The time has come to stop measuring Europe’s
commitment in billions spent and start

193
00:28:16,664 --> 00:28:20,125
measuring it in the capacity
to build real peace.

194
00:28:23,005 --> 00:28:26,505
Thank you. And the next speaker
is on behalf of ECR, Mr.

195
00:28:26,605 --> 00:28:28,045
Posniaks, for one minute, please.

196
00:28:30,085 --> 00:28:30,685
Dear.

197
00:28:30,685 --> 00:28:36,655
Colleagues, since Russia is failing to break
Ukraine's armed forces on the front, it

198
00:28:36,732 --> 00:28:41,837
is trying to break Ukrainian society.
Russia is attacking hospitals, schools, and

199
00:28:41,891 --> 00:28:46,506
energy infrastructure with thousands of
drones and hundreds of missiles, killing

200
00:28:46,560 --> 00:28:49,834
hundreds and injuring
thousands of civilians.

201
00:28:49,885 --> 00:28:54,382
While Russia is blocking Ukraine's grain
exports with attacks in the Black Sea, it

202
00:28:54,439 --> 00:28:58,286
continues to export its own
grain through European ports.

203
00:28:58,343 --> 00:29:06,709
The shadow fleet is still transporting
Russian oil and fuelling its war machine.

204
00:29:06,785 --> 00:29:11,398
We are desperately looking for additional
funding to help Ukraine survive the

205
00:29:11,454 --> 00:29:15,898
winter, but Russia’s frozen state
assets remain frozen and are not being

206
00:29:15,979 --> 00:29:22,029
confiscated. And in Russian drones and
missiles we are still finding components from

207
00:29:22,094 --> 00:29:26,244
Western companies. We have long
known what needs to be done:

208
00:29:26,326 --> 00:29:31,799
it is time to act, and no less important
is to ensure that the sanctions already in

209
00:29:31,857 --> 00:29:33,505
place actually work. Thank you.

210
00:29:36,925 --> 00:29:41,169
Thank you. And the next speaker is
on behalf of Renew, and that is Mr.

211
00:29:41,245 --> 00:29:42,505
Goetze for one minute, please.

212
00:29:47,725 --> 00:29:53,548
I don’t know about you, but I, for one,
am angry with all of us – citizens and

213
00:29:53,614 --> 00:29:56,917
elected representatives
alike – in our 27 countries.

214
00:29:56,953 --> 00:30:00,377
I am not angry with ourselves for not
immediately sanctioning all those Russians who

215
00:30:00,420 --> 00:30:04,888
should have been. I do not blame all of
us, citizens and elected representatives of

216
00:30:04,955 --> 00:30:08,791
our 27 countries. I do not blame us for
not having immediately sanctioned all those

217
00:30:08,868 --> 00:30:12,547
Russians who should have been. I do not
blame us for not having already made

218
00:30:12,596 --> 00:30:16,991
available to Ukraine enough weapons
and Russian assets of which we are the

219
00:30:17,048 --> 00:30:21,657
custodians. I do not blame us for not
doing enough, because we are not doing so

220
00:30:21,704 --> 00:30:25,827
little. But I do blame us for not calling
things by their name before the world.

221
00:30:25,870 --> 00:30:28,223
Vladimir Putin would like to
reconstitute the Tsars’ Empire.

222
00:30:28,262 --> 00:30:33,308
Failing to have prevailed on the ground,
he now wants to break the Ukrainian

223
00:30:33,376 --> 00:30:39,235
civilians with cold, bombs and thirst. He
claims to want peace but continues his war

224
00:30:39,326 --> 00:30:45,274
and spreads aggression across Europe.
So let us call Putin what he is.

225
00:30:45,371 --> 00:30:48,337
You, sir, are a murderer.
A child abductor.

226
00:30:48,409 --> 00:30:53,065
A dictator. The most deranged of
liars, and the last of the colonisers.

227
00:30:56,245 --> 00:31:00,038
Thank you. And the next speaker is Mr.
Stefanucci on behalf of the Greens for one

228
00:31:00,077 --> 00:31:01,277
and a half minutes, please.

229
00:31:05,965 --> 00:31:07,842
Counsel, I want you to
pass a message to Mr.

230
00:31:07,885 --> 00:31:14,572
Bart De Waver. When will he finally lift
his veto against Russian assets seized by

231
00:31:14,633 --> 00:31:20,007
the European Union when only his own fridge
will stop because of daily aggression

232
00:31:20,065 --> 00:31:23,845
against the citizens, against the
electricity grid, against all that?

233
00:31:23,905 --> 00:31:29,982
When will we lift this
incredibly stupid thing to do?

234
00:31:30,205 --> 00:31:35,568
Secondly, I heard Ms. Ceccardi speaking
about the effects of sanctions on the

235
00:31:35,626 --> 00:31:40,285
economy. Doesn't the biggest effect on
your economy come from the fact that Russia

236
00:31:40,341 --> 00:31:46,113
started a war from the beginning? Doesn't
that, isn't that the biggest effect?

237
00:31:46,345 --> 00:31:51,301
So-called patriots, isn't that the reason
why our citizens are suffering the most?

238
00:31:51,385 --> 00:31:55,841
It's not the sanctions. Sanctions
work when they are applied correctly.

239
00:31:55,945 --> 00:32:00,161
Structurally. And not when
we leave a million loopholes.

240
00:32:00,205 --> 00:32:04,710
Because we have 100 components found
in Russian drones that were produced by

241
00:32:04,765 --> 00:32:09,725
European firms. So let's stop with the
hypocrisy, because these drones attack us,

242
00:32:09,777 --> 00:32:15,179
attack our homeland. Drones landed in
a block of flats in Galați, in Romania.

243
00:32:15,265 --> 00:32:18,679
There will be a matter of days or weeks
when there will be European victims.

244
00:32:18,745 --> 00:32:22,856
There have been victims in the Black
Sea. We just don't talk too much because

245
00:32:22,900 --> 00:32:26,981
they're not European, but there have
been victims of ships being drowned.

246
00:32:27,085 --> 00:32:32,190
By Russian drones. Member States must
implement the sanctions directive.

247
00:32:32,245 --> 00:32:35,235
It was already supposed
to be done by 2025.

248
00:32:35,425 --> 00:32:38,595
Let's push it. Because
they are pushing us.

249
00:32:38,665 --> 00:32:42,942
They are coming for us. And qualified
majority voting should be introduced in the

250
00:32:43,015 --> 00:32:48,447
Council to stop this ridiculousness where
only one Member State stops one action or

251
00:32:48,542 --> 00:32:54,682
the other. We cannot continue like this.
Because we are not being taken seriously.

252
00:32:54,745 --> 00:32:58,222
We need to be taken seriously
so to truly defend our citizens.

253
00:32:58,285 --> 00:32:59,485
Thank you.

254
00:33:00,445 --> 00:33:02,908
Thank you very much.
The next speaker is Ms.

255
00:33:02,965 --> 00:33:04,645
Demirel for one minute on behalf of.

256
00:33:06,025 --> 00:33:12,866
Thank you, Madam President! Negotiations
are taking place in Abu Dhabi, but without

257
00:33:12,950 --> 00:33:17,747
the EU. And what is the EU doing? It
is once again talking about sanctions.

258
00:33:17,804 --> 00:33:21,194
But even the next sanctions
package will not end this war.

259
00:33:21,248 --> 00:33:25,591
Especially since the European Court of
Auditors has just found that the sanctions

260
00:33:25,642 --> 00:33:31,176
are not working properly because not even
all Member States want to implement them.

261
00:33:31,243 --> 00:33:36,517
Colleagues, do you know *The Simpsons*?
There is an episode in which Lisa tests

262
00:33:36,568 --> 00:33:39,819
Bart’s intelligence against
that of his hamster.

263
00:33:39,882 --> 00:33:45,221
Despite hidden electric shocks, Bart keeps
reaching for the muffin time and time

264
00:33:45,289 --> 00:33:49,947
again. The hamster learns faster,
stops. Dear Commission, you must finally

265
00:33:50,015 --> 00:33:54,494
understand: your strategy of more weapons,
more sanctions is not achieving its goal.

266
00:33:54,551 --> 00:33:57,301
At least not if the
goal is to end the war.

267
00:33:57,356 --> 00:34:02,280
Instead, your sanctions are also
contributing to price increases worldwide.

268
00:34:02,331 --> 00:34:07,094
People are feeling this. At the petrol
pump, when heating their homes, with gas.

269
00:34:07,154 --> 00:34:10,202
Finally change your strategy,
work on an exit plan.

270
00:34:10,254 --> 00:34:14,308
Not just because of the prices, but above
all because of the human lives at stake in

271
00:34:14,355 --> 00:34:15,555
this war.

272
00:34:17,185 --> 00:34:21,949
Thank you. The next speaker is Mr. Urich
on behalf of ESN for one and a half

273
00:34:21,997 --> 00:34:23,197
minutes, please.

274
00:34:24,625 --> 00:34:28,137
Colleagues, most of you here are talking
about what Russia has done, what it should

275
00:34:28,185 --> 00:34:32,716
do, and what it should not do. But dear
progressives, hello, wake up, it is your

276
00:34:32,780 --> 00:34:37,971
favourite Chancellor Merz who is now
threatening to blackmail the whole of Europe,

277
00:34:38,036 --> 00:34:43,223
saying that if we do not also give, yes,
70 billion euros to Ukraine, he will stop

278
00:34:43,277 --> 00:34:48,156
funding for the entire European
Union. What kind of nonsense is this?

279
00:34:48,210 --> 00:34:51,932
What kind of absurdity is this? Forgive
me, have you all gone completely mad?

280
00:34:51,983 --> 00:34:55,111
What is the point of all these
consolidation efforts then?

281
00:34:55,168 --> 00:35:00,082
What is the point of raising taxes and
tightening belts for hard-working European

282
00:35:00,131 --> 00:35:04,811
citizens if, in the end, all the money
saved is sent to Zelenskyy for the war in

283
00:35:04,873 --> 00:35:09,046
Ukraine? What kind of audacity is this?
Who exactly are you actually serving when

284
00:35:09,085 --> 00:35:14,307
money for Ukrainians is more important to
you than money for Europeans themselves,

285
00:35:14,362 --> 00:35:18,528
for European states? Money for schools,
for hospitals, for regions, local

286
00:35:18,589 --> 00:35:21,882
authorities, farmers. Did
we join such an Union?

287
00:35:21,927 --> 00:35:26,015
We do not want an Union where every year
we will systematically have to pay for

288
00:35:26,062 --> 00:35:28,522
Ukraine, sometimes 40,
sometimes 70 billion euros.

289
00:35:28,611 --> 00:35:33,351
If Merz wants to, let him pay;
let him pay from his own pocket.

290
00:35:33,402 --> 00:35:35,787
You also pay for Ukraine from
your own, but you have no right.

291
00:35:35,824 --> 00:35:39,227
You have no right to force us to
pay money to Ukraine compulsorily.

292
00:35:39,284 --> 00:35:43,824
I understand that you are afraid that Ms
Le Pen will win in France, that the AfD

293
00:35:43,870 --> 00:35:48,237
will succeed in Germany, that the Republika
movement will emerge in Slovakia, and

294
00:35:48,282 --> 00:35:52,353
that we will stop financing Ukraine.
That is why you want to change the voting

295
00:35:52,397 --> 00:35:56,566
system for aid to Ukraine from
unanimous to majority voting.

296
00:35:56,628 --> 00:35:59,068
Because you hope to somehow
patch it up. But no.

297
00:35:59,115 --> 00:36:03,476
We will stop you. And I am speaking on
behalf of hundreds of millions of Europeans:

298
00:36:03,519 --> 00:36:07,068
we have had enough. We do not want
to send any more money to Ukraine;

299
00:36:07,115 --> 00:36:10,600
we want peace at last, we want calm at
last, and we want the money to stay in

300
00:36:10,644 --> 00:36:11,844
Europe.

301
00:36:14,125 --> 00:36:19,373
Thank you. I will now please,
please quiet, colleagues.

302
00:36:19,465 --> 00:36:25,125
And respect each other. I will now open
up for the blue card and invite you to use

303
00:36:25,193 --> 00:36:27,925
it. And the next speaker is Mr.
Gala for one minute, please.

304
00:36:28,645 --> 00:36:34,114
Thank you very much, colleagues. Well,
the previous speaker forgot who is

305
00:36:34,179 --> 00:36:38,243
responsible for the cost that we
have. It's Putin's war of aggression.

306
00:36:38,305 --> 00:36:41,545
Why we have all these costs.
And you are his puppet.

307
00:36:41,605 --> 00:36:45,752
And I wonder what you profit from that.
You will not have a future in Europe with

308
00:36:45,805 --> 00:36:51,247
Putin winning this war. And that is why we
need to be very clear what the objective

309
00:36:51,322 --> 00:36:56,110
is. As we have seen in Abu Dhabi,
Putin does not even want a ceasefire.

310
00:36:56,185 --> 00:37:00,315
Putin wants to kick the can down the road,
wants to get over the winter because he

311
00:37:00,364 --> 00:37:08,489
doesn't, he will attack Ukrainian civilian
targets in order to get them agreeing to

312
00:37:08,620 --> 00:37:13,886
his demands. We will remain clear and with
regard to the sanctions that we have to

313
00:37:13,939 --> 00:37:19,338
apply, I think we need indeed to be
more forceful in the implementation.

314
00:37:19,405 --> 00:37:24,253
And for my specific German case, when it
comes to the shadow fleet, I call on my own

315
00:37:24,325 --> 00:37:28,565
government to be as courageous as the
Finns, the Danes, and the Swedes are in

316
00:37:28,619 --> 00:37:31,896
controlling these ships. We are
not doing enough in this regard.

317
00:37:31,945 --> 00:37:35,845
So that is one specific thing that
we could also do in this field.

318
00:37:35,905 --> 00:37:37,105
Thank you very much.

319
00:37:37,885 --> 00:37:40,293
Mr. Gala, there is a
blue card. There is a Mr.

320
00:37:40,345 --> 00:37:43,655
Gala. Mr. Gala, do you want
to take a blue card from Mr.

321
00:37:43,705 --> 00:37:46,885
Dostel? Seat 854, please.

322
00:37:52,285 --> 00:37:56,890
Mr. Gala, you asked who is
profiting. From the sanctions.

323
00:37:56,965 --> 00:38:00,019
And I answer you. It is
India and it is China.

324
00:38:00,085 --> 00:38:07,082
Because all these cheap oil and gas is going
there from our Central European states.

325
00:38:07,165 --> 00:38:14,870
Do you think it is proper to harm European
industry and benefit the Indians and the

326
00:38:14,940 --> 00:38:19,769
Chinese so our competitiveness will be
even worse than without the sanctions?

327
00:38:19,825 --> 00:38:22,225
Do you think it is the
right strategy for Europe?

328
00:38:23,005 --> 00:38:28,600
Well, we cannot demand from India or
China what they do or what they don't.

329
00:38:28,645 --> 00:38:33,987
I mean, we are currently having a scarcity
of oil because of the closure of the

330
00:38:34,038 --> 00:38:38,554
street of Hormuz. And that is why everybody
tries to grab whatever he or she can get

331
00:38:38,625 --> 00:38:42,152
hold of. I'm not happy about this
situation with India and China.

332
00:38:42,205 --> 00:38:46,239
But we cannot prevent it. But we
should not add to Russia's income.

333
00:38:46,285 --> 00:38:47,485
That is clear.

334
00:38:48,685 --> 00:38:52,008
Thank you. Thank you very much. And we
will continue with the speakers' list.

335
00:38:52,045 --> 00:38:54,745
And the next speaker is Ms. Moretti
for one and a half minutes, please.

336
00:38:57,565 --> 00:39:02,604
Thank you, Mr President. Colleagues. This
week saw the publication of the European

337
00:39:02,671 --> 00:39:08,871
Court of Auditors’ report which highlights
the continued circumvention of sanctions

338
00:39:08,947 --> 00:39:11,541
against Russia. The sanctions are working;

339
00:39:11,596 --> 00:39:17,257
they are more urgent than ever, they are
exerting significant pressure on the Putin

340
00:39:17,334 --> 00:39:22,376
regime, but their circumvention is a
huge problem for the effectiveness of the

341
00:39:22,425 --> 00:39:28,183
Union’s policy towards Moscow and for
the credibility of our institutions.

342
00:39:28,234 --> 00:39:32,809
Member States implement trade sanctions
in different ways, thus limiting their

343
00:39:32,888 --> 00:39:38,283
overall impact. This is also because the
wording of the measures is often vague,

344
00:39:38,349 --> 00:39:44,831
leaving room for interpretation. We not
only need more sanctions, more targeted

345
00:39:44,898 --> 00:39:50,601
ones, but it is also necessary for those
already in place to be more effective.

346
00:39:50,649 --> 00:39:55,722
More than four years have passed since the
start of this war, and just as four years

347
00:39:55,789 --> 00:40:01,948
ago, we continue to work for peace. A just
peace, however, that is not a surrender,

348
00:40:02,020 --> 00:40:07,260
but that respects the rights of people,
Ukraine’s territorial integrity and

349
00:40:07,347 --> 00:40:11,920
autonomy, and its independence
in deciding its own future.

350
00:40:11,992 --> 00:40:13,192
Thank you.

351
00:40:14,365 --> 00:40:16,067
Ms. Moretti, there is a blue card for you.

352
00:40:16,105 --> 00:40:19,465
Do you want to take it? It's from
Mr. Oliveira, seat 136, please.

353
00:40:23,965 --> 00:40:28,735
Thank you, Mr President. Ms Moretti, you
referred to peace, and that is exactly the

354
00:40:28,786 --> 00:40:35,820
question I want to ask you. What is, what
was the last initiative that has come from

355
00:40:35,902 --> 00:40:38,556
the European Union to
find a peace solution?

356
00:40:38,615 --> 00:40:43,356
Apart from the policy of sanctions, the
sending of weapons, and measures that in

357
00:40:43,416 --> 00:40:47,845
practice only contribute to prolonging
the war, what measures, what political and

358
00:40:47,896 --> 00:40:51,745
diplomatic initiatives, whether from the
European Council or from the European

359
00:40:51,787 --> 00:40:57,159
Commission, have been taken to discuss the
terms of building peace in Ukraine and a

360
00:40:57,220 --> 00:41:01,017
collective security solution that cannot
be just for Ukraine, it has to be for the

361
00:41:01,058 --> 00:41:04,885
entire European continent,
from Lisbon to the Urals?

362
00:41:08,005 --> 00:41:12,574
Thank you, colleague. I agree
with you. Europe is weak.

363
00:41:12,660 --> 00:41:20,552
Unfortunately, Europe does not have a
strong influence in the peace process.

364
00:41:20,657 --> 00:41:26,619
And this is because some political forces
within this Parliament want Europe not to

365
00:41:26,700 --> 00:41:32,422
have a say in this negotiation. And that
is why we must continue to find ways to

366
00:41:32,552 --> 00:41:39,384
strengthen the European Union, with a
common foreign policy and a common European

367
00:41:39,476 --> 00:41:43,504
defence. And we need to
work on multiple levels.

368
00:41:43,565 --> 00:41:48,969
On the level of strengthening our
authority and on the level of sanctions.

369
00:41:49,068 --> 00:41:56,338
Because otherwise we will continue to be
irrelevant on the international diplomacy

370
00:41:56,409 --> 00:41:57,609
stage. Thank you.

371
00:41:58,285 --> 00:42:00,410
Thank you. And we will continue
with the speakers' list.

372
00:42:00,445 --> 00:42:03,385
And the next speaker is Mr. Knotek
for one and a half minutes, please.

373
00:42:03,865 --> 00:42:08,603
Thank you, Madam Chairman. Mrs.
Commissioner, Russian war against Ukraine is

374
00:42:08,649 --> 00:42:13,351
damaging Europe and sanctions against
Russia are therefore legitimate response.

375
00:42:13,465 --> 00:42:17,670
Top priorities in sanctions should be
technologies, products, materials, and

376
00:42:17,725 --> 00:42:21,295
precursors that Russia could
use to continue the war.

377
00:42:21,385 --> 00:42:25,579
Also, sanctions should continue to
decrease our dependencies on Russia.

378
00:42:25,645 --> 00:42:31,729
We shall diversify or produce in Europe.
My message here is that our sanctions must

379
00:42:31,825 --> 00:42:35,821
be smart. And look what we
have done with natural gas.

380
00:42:36,025 --> 00:42:39,365
We have sanctions on
Russian gas imports. Okay.

381
00:42:39,565 --> 00:42:45,314
But we still import products from Russia
made from Russian gas, like ammonia,

382
00:42:45,396 --> 00:42:50,757
fertilizers, or urea. So Russia
still gets a lot of money.

383
00:42:50,845 --> 00:42:57,745
We stopped buying commodity, but instead
we buy a product with higher value.

384
00:42:57,865 --> 00:43:02,294
So also sanctions could be
considered into this direction.

385
00:43:02,365 --> 00:43:10,061
And second element, our export bans from
Europe to Russia often cover products which

386
00:43:10,127 --> 00:43:14,762
cannot be used in Russian
warfare. One example for all.

387
00:43:14,845 --> 00:43:21,669
EU-based company 115 employees basalt,
basalt tiles, or basalt severage parts.

388
00:43:21,745 --> 00:43:27,622
They cannot export to Russia despite the
market demand because basalt is considered

389
00:43:27,679 --> 00:43:32,901
as a war effort. So Madam Commissioner,
allow me to pass you from the heart of

390
00:43:32,965 --> 00:43:37,367
Europe, from the Czech Republic, a basalt
heart to demonstrate that basalt is not a

391
00:43:37,425 --> 00:43:41,079
weapon and the re-export
bans could be considered.

392
00:43:41,125 --> 00:43:42,325
Thank you very much.

393
00:43:43,885 --> 00:43:48,850
Mr. Knotek, there is a blue card. Mr.
Knotek, there is a blue card from Mr.

394
00:43:48,925 --> 00:43:51,475
Dostal. Do you want to
take it? Yeah. And please.

395
00:43:51,565 --> 00:43:54,745
Mr. Dostal, seat...

396
00:43:55,405 --> 00:43:58,283
Mr colleague, I will ask
you once again, in Czech.

397
00:43:58,367 --> 00:44:03,870
Anything that we impose sanctions on,
immediately it will disappear in India, in

398
00:44:03,942 --> 00:44:09,237
China, in the United States, in ASEAN, and
it will no longer be available to Czech

399
00:44:09,289 --> 00:44:14,292
industry, to Central European industry.
So what benefit will these sanctions bring

400
00:44:14,346 --> 00:44:18,508
to taxpayers, to industry in the Czech
Republic, if all they do is reduce their

401
00:44:18,560 --> 00:44:21,900
competitiveness compared to those
who are not imposing sanctions?

402
00:44:21,951 --> 00:44:23,151
Thank you for your answer.

403
00:44:24,865 --> 00:44:27,274
You are touching on a very
complex issue, colleague.

404
00:44:27,361 --> 00:44:33,181
The competitiveness of European industry
is primarily reduced by climate and energy

405
00:44:33,245 --> 00:44:37,899
policy, which has much greater impacts
than any potential negative effects of

406
00:44:37,950 --> 00:44:42,655
sanctions. Yes, I agree, and I have
actually been speaking about this, that the

407
00:44:42,747 --> 00:44:47,347
sanctions are not perfect and there are
cases where, for example, if we change the

408
00:44:47,399 --> 00:44:53,067
export rules for things that are not weapons,
such as basalt, we will certainly help

409
00:44:53,111 --> 00:44:56,755
industry. That is to say, sanctions
yes, but they must be smart.

410
00:44:56,841 --> 00:45:02,860
And Europe is undermining its own position
primarily through poor climate and energy

411
00:45:02,905 --> 00:45:04,105
policy. Thank you.

412
00:45:05,365 --> 00:45:08,803
Thank you very much. And Mr. Dostal, that
was the last blue card you got in this

413
00:45:08,845 --> 00:45:10,731
debate. We will continue
with the speakers' list.

414
00:45:10,765 --> 00:45:14,005
And the next speaker is Ms.
Gosievska for one minute, please.

415
00:45:15,985 --> 00:45:21,118
Ladies and Gentlemen, how many more debates
and resolutions do we need before Europe

416
00:45:21,177 --> 00:45:24,015
stops funding Russia’s
war against Ukraine?

417
00:45:24,093 --> 00:45:29,222
Russia is bombing Ukrainian cities, killing
civilians, destroying infrastructure,

418
00:45:29,283 --> 00:45:34,471
and yet European money continues to flow
to Moscow for Russian raw materials.

419
00:45:34,556 --> 00:45:37,275
Where is European
solidarity and credibility?

420
00:45:37,355 --> 00:45:41,910
You cannot simultaneously support
the victim and finance the aggressor.

421
00:45:41,998 --> 00:45:47,573
That is why I demand decisive, further
sanctions, but above all the enforcement of

422
00:45:47,646 --> 00:45:53,284
those already in place. And accountability
for those who help Russia to circumvent

423
00:45:53,390 --> 00:45:59,206
them. We must cut off revenue from raw
materials, strike at the shadow fleet, close

424
00:45:59,277 --> 00:46:05,435
the channels of war financing and freeze
the assets of those supporting the Kremlin.

425
00:46:05,485 --> 00:46:07,789
No European privileges for Putin’s allies.

426
00:46:07,909 --> 00:46:10,940
No impunity for those
who circumvent sanctions.

427
00:46:10,999 --> 00:46:16,627
Enough of double standards. It is
time to stop talking about solidarity.

428
00:46:16,696 --> 00:46:20,185
It is time to start
enforcing it in practice.

429
00:46:22,525 --> 00:46:24,931
Thank you very much. And
the next speaker is Ms.

430
00:46:24,985 --> 00:46:26,485
Karlsbro for one minute, please.

431
00:46:33,565 --> 00:46:43,108
Madam President, everyone knows Russia
will never win the war in Ukraine.

432
00:46:43,225 --> 00:46:50,718
But it's our choice how much longer
we want to sustain Putin's terror.

433
00:46:50,845 --> 00:46:55,615
Europe needs to strangle
Russia's war machine.

434
00:46:55,705 --> 00:47:03,352
With empty pockets, Putin can't buy
missiles for killing Ukrainian people.

435
00:47:03,505 --> 00:47:12,065
Everything left unsanctioned every
exemption means fresh money for Russia.

436
00:47:12,205 --> 00:47:21,023
We are funding hybrid warfare
on EU member states ourselves.

437
00:47:21,205 --> 00:47:25,675
So. Let's use the economy
as our battlefield.

438
00:47:25,765 --> 00:47:33,943
Let's stop doing business with Russia.
Let's use the frozen assets, make Russia pay

439
00:47:34,049 --> 00:47:35,785
for the war. Thank you.

440
00:47:37,765 --> 00:47:41,458
Mr. Karlsbro, there is a
blue card from Ronsard.

441
00:47:41,545 --> 00:47:43,585
Do you want to take it, seat 156, please?

442
00:47:46,525 --> 00:47:50,828
Okay. Madam, I am here.
I will speak in Polish.

443
00:47:50,905 --> 00:47:52,465
Please take the headphones.

444
00:47:53,305 --> 00:48:01,534
You mentioned an interesting issue, namely
those frozen Russian assets in Western

445
00:48:01,654 --> 00:48:08,507
Europe. We are all talking about this and
we all demand that these Russian assets be

446
00:48:08,627 --> 00:48:15,675
used to help Ukraine. You come from a very
rich country, an influential country in

447
00:48:15,739 --> 00:48:21,143
the European Union. Do you see an opportunity
to actually use these frozen Russian

448
00:48:21,216 --> 00:48:25,765
assets now, or will we just be talking
about this for the next two years?

449
00:48:34,285 --> 00:48:41,874
Thank you for this debate. I think it's
damn time to use the frozen assets.

450
00:48:41,965 --> 00:48:50,334
It's Russia's war. Russia should pay for
every damage it has caused to Ukraine.

451
00:48:50,425 --> 00:48:56,959
And it's up to the Council to deliver. We
know that there are legal possibilities

452
00:48:57,025 --> 00:49:01,460
for a decision in the Council.
There is no time to wait.

453
00:49:01,525 --> 00:49:09,547
So from this House, we expect a proposal
and I can promise you that we will not

454
00:49:09,643 --> 00:49:15,498
delay that decision. So let's use
the frozen assets, make Russia pay.

455
00:49:15,565 --> 00:49:16,765
Thank you.

456
00:49:17,725 --> 00:49:20,986
Thank you very much. Thank you very
much. And the next speaker is Mr.

457
00:49:21,025 --> 00:49:22,525
Lagodinski for one minute, please.

458
00:49:27,565 --> 00:49:33,013
Colleagues, yesterday we talked about
Ukrainian children who are being abducted.

459
00:49:33,145 --> 00:49:37,375
Today we're talking about Ukrainian
children who are being killed.

460
00:49:37,465 --> 00:49:43,525
Because this is what it is about. Every
ballistic missile launched from Russia.

461
00:49:43,645 --> 00:49:49,929
And produced in Russia. Has a blood
stain on the other end of trajectory.

462
00:49:50,065 --> 00:49:54,091
And to those colleagues
who are asking, what for?

463
00:49:54,265 --> 00:49:58,867
This is what it is for. This
is what we are investing in.

464
00:49:58,945 --> 00:50:07,838
And this is what we're sanctioning for in
order to save one, two, hundred Ukrainian

465
00:50:07,919 --> 00:50:11,526
children's lives. And
I think it is worth it.

466
00:50:11,605 --> 00:50:17,354
Alone this year, about 80 children were
already killed and 700 were demolished.

467
00:50:17,425 --> 00:50:21,733
Were traumatized. And we cannot
normalize this situation.

468
00:50:21,805 --> 00:50:24,925
We should not normalize. We
should not invite athletes.

469
00:50:24,985 --> 00:50:28,925
We should not call Kremlin
humanitarian. We should not.

470
00:50:29,005 --> 00:50:33,787
We should sanction. And by the way,
we sanction also for our own benefit.

471
00:50:33,865 --> 00:50:36,991
Russia's satellite system is
about to be launched in Russia.

472
00:50:37,045 --> 00:50:42,745
And it will be a threat to us. So let's
stop supplies for this technology.

473
00:50:42,805 --> 00:50:44,005
Thank you. Sanction. Thank you.

474
00:50:44,185 --> 00:50:44,965
Do not normalize.

475
00:50:44,965 --> 00:50:49,485
Thank you. So dear colleagues, there's a
lot of people on the speakers list and we

476
00:50:49,527 --> 00:50:52,776
have a lot of catch. And hopefully
also get more blue cards.

477
00:50:52,825 --> 00:50:55,465
So please try to stick to
speaking time. That would help us.

478
00:50:55,525 --> 00:50:58,345
And the next speaker is Mr.
Botenga for one minute, please.

479
00:51:02,185 --> 00:51:04,045
Thank you, President.

480
00:51:04,045 --> 00:51:08,408
Dear colleagues, you said it is for the
Ukrainians to decide whether to negotiate.

481
00:51:08,466 --> 00:51:10,773
Well, today the Ukrainians
are negotiating.

482
00:51:10,818 --> 00:51:14,712
You said the Russians do not want to.
Today the Russians are negotiating.

483
00:51:14,766 --> 00:51:19,232
But you, you continue to say zero
concessions, zero concessions, that is zero

484
00:51:19,316 --> 00:51:22,286
negotiation, it is
endless war. The result:

485
00:51:22,348 --> 00:51:26,745
the European Union today is not invited
to the negotiations in Abu Dhabi.

486
00:51:26,784 --> 00:51:31,377
And I tried to understand this obstinacy.
And I came across this document from the

487
00:51:31,437 --> 00:51:36,622
Council of European governments where
Ukraine is described as a strategic

488
00:51:36,696 --> 00:51:41,927
opportunity for Europe. You talk of a
strategic opportunity while people on the

489
00:51:41,976 --> 00:51:44,807
ground are dying. This is a
disgrace, I cannot accept that.

490
00:51:44,854 --> 00:51:48,699
So, are we, like the Russians and the
Americans, coveting the European Union,

491
00:51:48,759 --> 00:51:52,931
coveting Ukraine’s strategic resources?
People are fed up with the war.

492
00:51:52,976 --> 00:51:55,980
In Russia, there are
deserters against Putin’s war.

493
00:51:56,072 --> 00:52:00,660
In Ukraine, 80 % of the population want
to negotiate, and 2 million people have

494
00:52:00,713 --> 00:52:05,821
refused to join this war. And in Europe,
citizens are also fed up with paying for

495
00:52:05,900 --> 00:52:10,766
it. So name this Special
Representative and negotiate.

496
00:52:10,825 --> 00:52:12,085
Do your job. Thank you.

497
00:52:13,405 --> 00:52:18,138
Thank you. Mr. Botenga, I
have in fact three blue cards.

498
00:52:18,205 --> 00:52:20,263
I cannot allow all of
them, but I might take two.

499
00:52:20,305 --> 00:52:22,749
Do you want to take them? Okay. First, Mr.

500
00:52:22,825 --> 00:52:24,385
Lagodinski, please site.

501
00:52:29,545 --> 00:52:34,906
You're saying that Russians want
to deal and negotiate with us.

502
00:52:35,005 --> 00:52:38,668
Do you know who is blocking
participation of Europeans at the table?

503
00:52:38,725 --> 00:52:44,585
Do you know that the Americans are now
going to Moscow to beg Russia to allow

504
00:52:44,647 --> 00:52:50,656
Europeans to the table? Do you know that
Lavrov just while they were negotiating

505
00:52:50,725 --> 00:52:57,004
said that they will get back every meter
of their territory from Ukrainians?

506
00:52:57,085 --> 00:53:01,159
So who is not willing to negotiate?
These negotiations are farse.

507
00:53:01,225 --> 00:53:06,157
They are just distracting our attention
from the fight and from the murder that

508
00:53:06,190 --> 00:53:07,390
they're making.

509
00:53:08,245 --> 00:53:09,445
Mr. Botenga.

510
00:53:11,245 --> 00:53:16,417
I think there are two things.
And I will answer in English.

511
00:53:16,525 --> 00:53:21,211
First, yesterday there were
negotiations between three parties.

512
00:53:21,265 --> 00:53:29,261
United States, Russia and
Ukraine. Europeans were not there.

513
00:53:29,425 --> 00:53:32,452
I said three parties.
I said three parties.

514
00:53:32,545 --> 00:53:36,014
Europeans were not there. And I
don't see you troubled by that.

515
00:53:36,085 --> 00:53:40,527
I don't see you troubled by that. And
what I see is when I hear the high

516
00:53:40,582 --> 00:53:45,848
representative and you're not listening
to the answer, you're defending democracy

517
00:53:45,891 --> 00:53:49,285
but you got difficulty listening
to other people in this House.

518
00:53:49,345 --> 00:53:52,645
Mr. Lagodinski, I think you need
maybe a little course in democracy.

519
00:53:52,705 --> 00:53:54,265
It's conversation. It's a dialogue.

520
00:53:54,325 --> 00:53:58,645
Thank you, Mr. Botenga. I need to take
one more blue card if you allow it.

521
00:53:58,705 --> 00:54:02,353
Andrew Kaitis, please.
Mr. Andrew Kaitis, 225.

522
00:54:02,485 --> 00:54:04,225
Blue card, please stick to your time.

523
00:54:06,205 --> 00:54:10,045
Great. Mayor, you can take
from I can ask you in between.

524
00:54:16,525 --> 00:54:21,924
I would like to ask you and
receive a yes or no answer.

525
00:54:22,161 --> 00:54:29,575
My question is this: is territorial
integrity and the inviolability of borders

526
00:54:29,647 --> 00:54:33,830
confirmed in the Helsinki Final
Act and in international documents?

527
00:54:33,923 --> 00:54:39,758
My question to you. Is the inviolability
of borders and territorial integrity a

528
00:54:39,835 --> 00:54:44,290
cornerstone? Can it be
allowed to be violated?

529
00:54:44,373 --> 00:54:45,573
Yes or no?

530
00:54:52,765 --> 00:54:53,965
Mr. Botenga.

531
00:54:54,565 --> 00:54:59,661
But let us be very clear. International
law leaves no doubt that you cannot attack

532
00:54:59,709 --> 00:55:04,272
another country, you cannot occupy another
country, and you cannot violate another

533
00:55:04,323 --> 00:55:07,172
country's borders. So I
entirely agree on that point.

534
00:55:07,230 --> 00:55:11,500
And what I would ask of this European Union
is that it be as consistent in the case

535
00:55:11,558 --> 00:55:17,499
of Ukraine as it is in Lebanon when it
is Israel that is occupying in Palestine,

536
00:55:17,566 --> 00:55:22,882
when it is Israel that is occupying in
Syria, or in Iran when it is our allies, the

537
00:55:22,942 --> 00:55:27,849
United States, that are bombing.
Because it's a case of double standards.

538
00:55:27,902 --> 00:55:30,922
Territorial integrity matters
to us only in Ukraine.

539
00:55:30,962 --> 00:55:32,125
That is hypocrisy, sir.

540
00:55:32,125 --> 00:55:35,795
Thank you. Thank you very much. So we
will continue with the speakers list.

541
00:55:35,845 --> 00:55:38,125
No, no, we don't have.
Sorry, we don't have.

542
00:55:38,185 --> 00:55:40,825
Time for that. The next speaker is
Mr. Sale for one minute, please.

543
00:55:44,065 --> 00:55:47,261
The Commission says the sanctions
against Russia are working.

544
00:55:47,325 --> 00:55:51,298
The question is, for whom? Before the war,
German companies exported goods worth 27

545
00:55:51,346 --> 00:55:53,260
billion euros to Russia
in the previous year.

546
00:55:53,292 --> 00:55:56,258
Now it’s only seven. Imports
have fallen even more sharply.

547
00:55:56,303 --> 00:56:00,426
Almost 100 percent, because we Europeans
are no longer allowed to buy oil from

548
00:56:00,476 --> 00:56:05,473
Russia. And what has it achieved? Today,
Russia is not selling less oil, but more

549
00:56:05,525 --> 00:56:09,647
than before the war—just not to Europe.
While we suffer under high fuel prices, the

550
00:56:09,693 --> 00:56:13,474
Russians are doing big business
with the Chinese, Indians and Turks.

551
00:56:13,528 --> 00:56:20,444
And that is at our expense. In September,
Europe bought 44 million litres of diesel

552
00:56:20,501 --> 00:56:24,579
from India every single day, even
though India has no oil of its own.

553
00:56:24,644 --> 00:56:29,465
So the sanctions are not hurting
Russia; they are hurting us Europeans.

554
00:56:29,557 --> 00:56:34,058
We do not need a 22nd sanctions package;
we need a realistic peace plan for Ukraine,

555
00:56:34,108 --> 00:56:38,186
and that can only succeed if we are willing
to talk to both sides, as the Americans

556
00:56:38,236 --> 00:56:42,176
are doing right now in Abu Dhabi. I am
glad that the Commission was not at the

557
00:56:42,228 --> 00:56:44,665
table. Otherwise, it would
have shot us in the knee again.

558
00:56:47,725 --> 00:56:51,385
Thank you. The next speaker is Mr. Panayoutou
for one and a half minutes, please.

559
00:56:57,805 --> 00:57:04,863
The EU has failed Ukraine by refusing to
use diplomacy to put an end to this war.

560
00:57:04,945 --> 00:57:10,520
This crazy policies that you vote in
this Parliament has resulted in leaving

561
00:57:10,622 --> 00:57:15,614
Zelensky alone negotiating
with Putin and Trump.

562
00:57:15,745 --> 00:57:22,852
This means they will be the ones deciding
over the future of our continent.

563
00:57:23,005 --> 00:57:27,385
Some members of the European Parliament
have spent years trying to change this and

564
00:57:27,445 --> 00:57:33,463
we have tried to push EU to get
serious and do diplomacy with Russia.

565
00:57:33,565 --> 00:57:39,120
But in exchange for our efforts, we have
just been called Russian puppets and

566
00:57:39,205 --> 00:57:45,615
recently we even have been added to an
alleged kill list in the past few days.

567
00:57:45,745 --> 00:57:51,488
Of course I completely condemn the Russian
invasion because a clear violation of

568
00:57:51,553 --> 00:57:58,154
international law. We must defend Ukraine's
sovereignty and territorial integrity

569
00:57:58,225 --> 00:58:05,684
while recognizing that diplomacy is essential
to achieving a just and lasting peace

570
00:58:05,775 --> 00:58:11,238
in Ukraine. Europe must get serious now
and finally have one representative to

571
00:58:11,325 --> 00:58:16,502
directly negotiate with Russia and
Ukraine to put an end to this war.

572
00:58:16,585 --> 00:58:21,025
Because this is our continent
and we must shape our future.

573
00:58:23,905 --> 00:58:28,485
So Mr. Do you want to
take a blue card? Okay.

574
00:58:28,585 --> 00:58:32,965
I had Mr. Starkis on. Do you
still want to take it, please?

575
00:58:34,105 --> 00:58:36,976
Yes. Thank you for your
speech. I'm a bit curious.

576
00:58:37,045 --> 00:58:41,078
Is Russia paying you for spreading his
propaganda or you are betraying Europe for

577
00:58:41,125 --> 00:58:48,838
free? We have the same
problem in my country, Cyprus.

578
00:58:48,925 --> 00:58:56,070
Cyprus has been invaded by Turkey and is
still illegally occupied and is still the

579
00:58:56,131 --> 00:59:01,867
same position that I hold for my country.
To solve this problem with diplomacy, not

580
00:59:01,940 --> 00:59:03,140
with war.

581
00:59:05,725 --> 00:59:09,741
Okay. Well, I did in fact have one more
but we're running a little bit out of time

582
00:59:09,777 --> 00:59:12,406
so I will continue with the speakers
list and the next speaker is Mr.

583
00:59:12,445 --> 00:59:13,645
Altsula for one minute, please.

584
00:59:20,845 --> 00:59:24,196
Mr President, Europe is now being
squeezed from two directions.

585
00:59:24,242 --> 00:59:27,734
Mr President, Russia is demanding
that its war be rewarded.

586
00:59:27,797 --> 00:59:33,162
The US administration wants a deal quickly,
and we are being offered as the one to

587
00:59:33,337 --> 00:59:36,673
pay the bill. However, the
cards are in our hands.

588
00:59:36,722 --> 00:59:40,323
The heaviest sanctions are Europe’s
frozen assets, which are in Europe.

589
00:59:40,376 --> 00:59:43,235
The markets that Russia
wants to access are ours.

590
00:59:43,325 --> 00:59:46,073
Without us, Russia will
not get what it wants.

591
00:59:46,126 --> 00:59:49,687
Without us, the United States
will not be able to secure a deal.

592
00:59:49,738 --> 00:59:54,041
We may be spoken over, but no
agreement can be reached without us.

593
00:59:54,119 --> 00:59:58,245
And Ukraine cannot be bypassed in any way.

594
00:59:58,302 --> 01:00:01,118
Good cards are not given
away in a nervous state.

595
01:00:01,187 --> 01:00:06,193
And there is no reason to do so now. Russia
strikes Ukraine every night and demands

596
01:00:06,262 --> 01:00:11,147
every inch at the table. That is
why sanctions must be tightened.

597
01:00:11,209 --> 01:00:14,282
Loopholes must be closed and banks listed.

598
01:00:14,344 --> 01:00:17,725
The cards remain in our hands
until Russia ends the war.

599
01:00:21,445 --> 01:00:23,620
Thank you very much. And
the next speaker is Mr.

600
01:00:23,665 --> 01:00:25,285
Szyman for one and a half minutes, please.

601
01:00:27,745 --> 01:00:32,051
Dear colleagues, this war is
no longer a territorial war;

602
01:00:32,119 --> 01:00:37,254
it has become a war against a people. Energy
infrastructure is being systematically

603
01:00:37,304 --> 01:00:40,452
targeted to leave Ukrainians
at the mercy of the cold.

604
01:00:40,509 --> 01:00:45,388
In parks, in schools, Russian drones
are striking women and children.

605
01:00:45,464 --> 01:00:50,843
And meanwhile, in Abu Dhabi, Russians and
Americans are discussing the security of

606
01:00:50,949 --> 01:00:56,151
our continent while we Europeans are
literally left sitting on the sidelines

607
01:00:56,212 --> 01:01:03,331
watching the negotiations. As long as it
cannot pursue its aggression, Russia will

608
01:01:03,415 --> 01:01:08,450
not negotiate in good faith. That is
why I commend the Council’s efforts to

609
01:01:08,495 --> 01:01:13,942
strengthen sanctions. We must cut off
the money that is fuelling Putin’s war.

610
01:01:14,008 --> 01:01:17,405
But what use are our sanctions
if they are not respected?

611
01:01:17,452 --> 01:01:21,222
How can European components still
be found in the missiles of Moscow?

612
01:01:21,295 --> 01:01:26,544
How can goods blocked in Poland
be sent back to Russia from Italy?

613
01:01:26,632 --> 01:01:30,613
How can those who violate our
sanctions still escape any prosecution?

614
01:01:30,691 --> 01:01:35,916
Let us finally enforce our sanctions
to urgently cut off funding for Putin.

615
01:01:35,971 --> 01:01:42,129
And let us step up support for Ukraine.
Let us provide the €70 billion it needs to

616
01:01:42,179 --> 01:01:47,627
sustain its war effort in 2027. And let
us bring back to the table the issue of

617
01:01:47,693 --> 01:01:52,247
frozen Russian assets. Many of us support
the idea of transferring them into a

618
01:01:52,308 --> 01:01:57,269
European vehicle. This is a common-sense
solution that would help to avoid any

619
01:01:57,322 --> 01:02:00,983
financial risk for the Member States
that are concerned about their financial

620
01:02:01,076 --> 01:02:06,948
stability. We can and we must act. Let
us no longer be spectators of our own

621
01:02:07,047 --> 01:02:08,247
destiny. Thank you.

622
01:02:09,025 --> 01:02:12,138
Mr. Szyman, there is a
blue card from Mr. Mulacic.

623
01:02:12,205 --> 01:02:15,145
Do you want to take it? Seat 576, please.

624
01:02:17,905 --> 01:02:21,180
Thank you, Mr Ambassador,
for accepting the blue card.

625
01:02:21,254 --> 01:02:25,781
I agree with you on the principle
that sanctions against Russia must be

626
01:02:25,857 --> 01:02:30,796
strengthened. And Russia must bear
significantly higher costs for waging this war.

627
01:02:30,835 --> 01:02:34,977
However, I was very surprised by your
statement that some elements of armaments from

628
01:02:35,043 --> 01:02:41,479
Italy are being delivered to Poland,
which are then used by Putin to wage war.

629
01:02:41,524 --> 01:02:45,186
Mr Member, please elaborate on this, because
we want to know what elements, who and

630
01:02:45,248 --> 01:02:50,086
which companies are allegedly
delivering them to Russia via Poland.

631
01:02:50,185 --> 01:02:53,547
I understand also via Ukraine. Please
elaborate, because this is a very interesting

632
01:02:53,587 --> 01:02:55,765
thread. To the European
Commission. Thank you very much.

633
01:02:56,545 --> 01:02:58,165
Thank you. Mr. Szyman.

634
01:02:58,465 --> 01:02:59,725
Very good, because I was
also curious about that.

635
01:02:59,905 --> 01:03:05,029
Thank you, dear colleague, because I think
it's really important to track any way of

636
01:03:05,143 --> 01:03:14,105
not applying the sanctions. Those ways of
going through the sanctions and the way

637
01:03:14,181 --> 01:03:18,865
for products to, when they are blocked
in Poland, for example, to go through the

638
01:03:18,925 --> 01:03:23,761
sanctions and to come back to the
country are now well documented.

639
01:03:23,845 --> 01:03:30,381
I was speaking of an example through
Italy, but there are many more of them.

640
01:03:30,445 --> 01:03:34,116
And I guess they should be
tracked much more than now.

641
01:03:34,165 --> 01:03:35,365
Thank you, dear colleague.

642
01:03:35,605 --> 01:03:38,451
Thank you very much. Thank you very
much. And the next speaker is Mr.

643
01:03:38,485 --> 01:03:39,685
Ferruga for one minute, please.

644
01:03:42,325 --> 01:03:47,522
Dear colleagues, Russia is escalating its
brutal attacks against Ukraine on a daily

645
01:03:47,587 --> 01:03:52,676
basis. Civilians are being killed,
cities are being destroyed, and energy

646
01:03:52,732 --> 01:03:58,102
infrastructure is being wiped out. And
Russia’s threat is not limited to Ukraine

647
01:03:58,160 --> 01:04:03,597
alone. Now, both the Baltic states and
other countries are facing drone incidents,

648
01:04:03,658 --> 01:04:07,242
airspace violations,
and other provocations.

649
01:04:07,331 --> 01:04:12,027
This is already a concern for Europe
as a whole, not just for Ukraine.

650
01:04:12,096 --> 01:04:18,418
And every euro we pay Russia for oil, gas
or other energy resources fuels Russia’s

651
01:04:18,502 --> 01:04:24,451
war machine. And, unfortunately, Russian
gas still accounts for around 11 per cent

652
01:04:24,516 --> 01:04:28,782
of the European Union’s gas supply. So
sanctions must not only be strict, but

653
01:04:28,841 --> 01:04:34,505
effective: we must definitively abandon
Russian energy resources and prevent

654
01:04:34,563 --> 01:04:40,034
sanctions circumvention. Lithuania proved
back in 2022 that it is possible to live

655
01:04:40,089 --> 01:04:43,535
without Russian gas. The whole
of Europe can do this too.

656
01:04:43,600 --> 01:04:44,800
Thank you.

657
01:04:46,645 --> 01:04:48,871
Thank you very much. And
the next speaker is Mr.

658
01:04:48,925 --> 01:04:50,725
Ostrowicz for one minute, please.

659
01:04:52,165 --> 01:04:57,072
Madam Chair, Commissioner, Council
Representative, Honorable Colleagues.

660
01:04:57,145 --> 01:05:05,347
In 2027, the Russian regime will allocate
44 percent of its state budget for its war

661
01:05:05,480 --> 01:05:13,791
efforts. 44 percent. This figure has
increased by 27 percent on an annual basis,

662
01:05:13,885 --> 01:05:18,449
confirming the aggressor's intention to
continue its war of aggression against

663
01:05:18,505 --> 01:05:25,085
Ukraine and its terror operations
and attacks against us, Europe.

664
01:05:25,285 --> 01:05:31,053
Fossil fuels account for around 30 percent
of the Russian budget, while value-added

665
01:05:31,124 --> 01:05:35,920
and other domestic taxes
account for another 40 percent.

666
01:05:36,025 --> 01:05:42,596
Clearly, the more fossil fuel Russia sells
and the more active its domestic economy

667
01:05:42,673 --> 01:05:50,068
is, the fuller its budget becomes, increasing
its capacity to continue the war of

668
01:05:50,149 --> 01:05:56,330
aggression against Ukraine. Colleagues,
there might have been a time when even the

669
01:05:56,400 --> 01:06:00,995
European Parliament was
heated using Russian gas.

670
01:06:01,105 --> 01:06:04,260
But those days must be
consigned to history.

671
01:06:04,345 --> 01:06:05,545
Thank you.

672
01:06:06,805 --> 01:06:09,160
Thank you very much. And
the next speaker is Mr.

673
01:06:09,205 --> 01:06:10,405
Starkis for one minute, please.

674
01:06:13,645 --> 01:06:14,845
Madam President,

675
01:06:14,905 --> 01:06:21,945
yesterday in Abu Dhabi Putin's negotiator
Medinski told the Europeans they call him

676
01:06:22,032 --> 01:06:26,737
the tourists. He told them
to sit in hotel's bar.

677
01:06:26,965 --> 01:06:31,233
Actually, colleagues, he meant us from
this side of the house to that side of the

678
01:06:31,285 --> 01:06:35,433
house to the Kremlin.
We are just tourists.

679
01:06:35,545 --> 01:06:41,413
And where is America? Inside discussing
Europe's security with Russia while Europe

680
01:06:41,478 --> 01:06:47,759
waited outside the door. And today its
envoys are in Moscow, asking Putin whether

681
01:06:47,845 --> 01:06:54,900
Europe may join talks about Europe. But
let me tell you, tourists are not sanction

682
01:06:54,985 --> 01:06:59,312
Putin's war machine. And tourists
are not arming the Ukraine.

683
01:06:59,425 --> 01:07:04,073
Europe does. Do we really
lack the pride to answer?

684
01:07:04,165 --> 01:07:07,231
Putin, you are the murderer
and Hague is waiting for you.

685
01:07:07,285 --> 01:07:11,012
And Putin, and Trump, you are
already on the Putin's side.

686
01:07:11,065 --> 01:07:14,290
And Europe is not yours
to trade. Europe is ours.

687
01:07:14,365 --> 01:07:19,272
We live here. And no one dictates
us. Not Moscow, not Washington.

688
01:07:19,345 --> 01:07:20,485
Thank you.

689
01:07:20,485 --> 01:07:22,719
Thank you. Mr. Starkis,
there is a blue card.

690
01:07:22,765 --> 01:07:27,886
There is a blue card from Ms. Konieczka. I
have two blue cards, but I will only take

691
01:07:27,932 --> 01:07:30,985
one. And Ms. Konieczka, seat 524, please.

692
01:07:32,425 --> 01:07:33,805
Thank you, Madam President.

693
01:07:35,845 --> 01:07:36,985
Mr colleague.

694
01:07:36,985 --> 01:07:41,665
Vy říkáte, can you hear me? Yeah?

695
01:07:43,105 --> 01:07:48,172
Mr colleague, you are saying that the
negotiators are claiming that we are tourists.

696
01:07:48,272 --> 01:07:50,685
What have we done to
ensure we are not tourists?

697
01:07:50,731 --> 01:07:53,736
How many peace initiatives
have you prepared?

698
01:07:53,796 --> 01:07:58,378
How many times have you tried to get Europe
to sit at any negotiating table at all?

699
01:07:58,442 --> 01:08:02,381
Yes, sanctions, more
weapons, you’re good at that.

700
01:08:02,456 --> 01:08:07,630
But how many times did you not want to
be tourists and actually wanted to play a

701
01:08:07,690 --> 01:08:12,462
part in those negotiations as such? Because
I don’t think it has happened even once.

702
01:08:12,512 --> 01:08:15,305
And that is the problem of
the entire European Union:

703
01:08:15,360 --> 01:08:20,134
you deal with sanctions, you deal with
weapons, but you are afraid to talk about

704
01:08:20,184 --> 01:08:20,545
peace.

705
01:08:20,545 --> 01:08:22,165
Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Starkis.

706
01:08:23,485 --> 01:08:24,145
Yeah, no tack.

707
01:08:24,145 --> 01:08:27,975
You asked me in your language, so
I will also answer you in Latvian.

708
01:08:28,031 --> 01:08:32,233
I do not believe that war criminals
should be negotiated with at all.

709
01:08:32,299 --> 01:08:36,811
I believe that Russia will lose this war.
If not on the battlefield, then it will

710
01:08:36,856 --> 01:08:40,339
certainly lose economically. That is
why we really must continue to do so.

711
01:08:40,395 --> 01:08:44,491
We must continue to both help Ukraine and
supply weapons, as well as continue to

712
01:08:44,538 --> 01:08:47,905
impose sanctions. This is the
way in which we can end this war.

713
01:08:50,845 --> 01:08:54,280
Thank you. Thank you very much.
And the next speaker is Mr.

714
01:08:54,325 --> 01:08:55,525
Anderson for one minute, please.

715
01:09:00,265 --> 01:09:05,533
Is it a problem as some have said that
Finnish President Alexander Stubb and

716
01:09:05,605 --> 01:09:11,411
Norwegian Prime Minister Støre in close
consultations with Ukraine made a phone call

717
01:09:11,489 --> 01:09:18,267
to Putin? I think it is not. Europe needs
to make sure that neither Ukraine nor

718
01:09:18,347 --> 01:09:24,300
Europe is sidelined in diplomacy. Especially
as the US is so clearly aligning with

719
01:09:24,367 --> 01:09:29,799
Putin and European security architecture
is one of the topics the US has mentioned

720
01:09:29,868 --> 01:09:36,567
should be discussed. Is diplomacy then
an alternative to military support and

721
01:09:36,632 --> 01:09:41,502
sanctions as many especially in
the extreme right are saying?

722
01:09:41,605 --> 01:09:48,241
Absolutely not. As Putin continues to
strike on Ukraine's energy infrastructure,

723
01:09:48,325 --> 01:09:53,612
residential areas, and even schools, Europe
needs to be ready to respond with strong

724
01:09:53,703 --> 01:09:59,699
military support, stronger sanctions, and
making sure we are not sidelined at the

725
01:09:59,790 --> 01:10:05,620
diplomatic tables. Especially important
is to finally stop financing Putin's war

726
01:10:05,695 --> 01:10:10,561
crime through gas imports. It is shameful
that some member states have accelerated

727
01:10:10,624 --> 01:10:14,725
these imports before the ban enters into
force at the beginning of next year.

728
01:10:15,085 --> 01:10:16,285
Thank you.

729
01:10:18,145 --> 01:10:21,325
Thank you. And now I would like to ask
my colleague Mr Volgin to take the floor.

730
01:10:23,365 --> 01:10:24,565
U.

731
01:10:25,345 --> 01:10:30,027
At the negotiations in Abu Dhabi, where
the United States and Russia discussed

732
01:10:30,092 --> 01:10:35,248
future global security, representatives of
the European Union wandered the corridors

733
01:10:35,305 --> 01:10:39,911
in vain, hoping that one of the major
players would pay them some attention or at

734
01:10:39,980 --> 01:10:45,307
least acknowledge them with a nod. Never
before in history have European politicians

735
01:10:45,366 --> 01:10:49,263
been so helpless and never before
have they elicited such pity.

736
01:10:49,322 --> 01:10:53,910
And never before have European leaders
embodied total intellectual helplessness.

737
01:10:53,988 --> 01:10:58,525
All these people can come up with is
yet another package of sanctions against

738
01:10:58,599 --> 01:11:04,675
Russia. With a stubbornness that defies
common sense, EU leaders continue to assure

739
01:11:04,732 --> 01:11:09,927
us that these very actions will deliver a
crushing blow to the Russian Federation.

740
01:11:09,989 --> 01:11:14,856
And this despite the fact that the thousands
of sanctions imposed so far have failed

741
01:11:14,913 --> 01:11:20,112
to achieve that. No serious political
force will negotiate with such politicians,

742
01:11:20,174 --> 01:11:25,499
with politicians bereft of common sense.
If Europe wants to take part in talks about

743
01:11:25,553 --> 01:11:30,543
the future, it must be represented by
leaders who are the complete opposite of the

744
01:11:30,610 --> 01:11:32,185
current ones, thank you.

745
01:11:33,985 --> 01:11:37,455
Will you accept the blue
card from Mr. Lagodinski?

746
01:11:37,525 --> 01:11:40,150
And I'm going to be taking
only one blue card, so Mrs.

747
01:11:40,225 --> 01:11:43,045
Sipper, I'm sorry, you
will not get it. Mr.

748
01:11:43,105 --> 01:11:44,305
Lagodinski.

749
01:11:48,625 --> 01:11:53,635
Thank you. Mr. Volgin, you were
talking about engaging with Russia.

750
01:11:53,785 --> 01:11:56,841
Haven't you been engaging
with Russia all along?

751
01:11:56,905 --> 01:12:02,883
You are doing everything in order to leave
your country, defenseless, in the face of

752
01:12:02,942 --> 01:12:06,239
attacks that are taking
place near your coast.

753
01:12:06,325 --> 01:12:11,478
You are supporting pro-Russian forces and
pro-Russian candidates during elections.

754
01:12:11,545 --> 01:12:18,431
And you and your party are bringing a
Russia-style agent, anti-agent law that would

755
01:12:18,524 --> 01:12:23,832
observe civil society, like
Moscow is doing in Kremlin.

756
01:12:23,965 --> 01:12:27,205
What is your term of
engagement with Russia?

757
01:12:29,905 --> 01:12:37,045
I mean, anyone who defends common sense
is associated with Russia is not a spectre

758
01:12:37,119 --> 01:12:43,113
of highly developed intellect. What my
party, Revival, and other normal political

759
01:12:43,198 --> 01:12:48,586
forces in this Parliament are doing is
ensuring that Europe is represented with

760
01:12:48,652 --> 01:12:54,341
dignity at the negotiating table, not like
a frightened puppy whining at the door.

761
01:12:54,413 --> 01:12:58,453
Because the Europeans have
now done that in Abu Dhabi.

762
01:12:58,522 --> 01:13:03,009
If we want to be taken seriously,
we need to speak and act seriously.

763
01:13:03,073 --> 01:13:04,273
Thank you.

764
01:13:06,385 --> 01:13:10,825
Now I would like to ask my colleague
Kalniete to take the floor.

765
01:13:15,565 --> 01:13:21,414
Colleagues, currently millions of tonnes
of grain are stuck in Ukraine’s Black Sea

766
01:13:21,487 --> 01:13:26,496
ports due to Russian attacks.
These will soon start to rot.

767
01:13:26,544 --> 01:13:30,654
Russia is regularly attacking civilian
ships, including in the exclusive economic

768
01:13:30,707 --> 01:13:35,290
zones of European Union countries
and even in their territorial waters.

769
01:13:35,359 --> 01:13:39,249
Dozens of seafarers have
been killed in these attacks.

770
01:13:39,347 --> 01:13:44,076
The Kremlin's goal is to strangle Ukraine's
economy and destabilise global food

771
01:13:44,141 --> 01:13:49,713
security, as the attacks mean grain does
not reach millions of people in Africa and

772
01:13:49,794 --> 01:13:55,715
the Middle East. Let us not be naive –
this is part of Putin's plan to destabilise

773
01:13:55,782 --> 01:14:00,447
regions around the European Union's
external borders and create new waves of

774
01:14:00,518 --> 01:14:04,343
migration. So that Europe
suffers the consequences.

775
01:14:04,414 --> 01:14:09,754
Latvia and the Baltic States call on EU
Member States to immediately ban the transit

776
01:14:09,810 --> 01:14:12,788
of Russia’s bloody grain
through their territories.

777
01:14:12,841 --> 01:14:18,156
We must stop feeding Putin’s war machine
and pressure the Kremlin to end this

778
01:14:18,240 --> 01:14:19,525
blockade. Thank you.

779
01:14:22,225 --> 01:14:25,645
Thank you. And now I would like to ask
my colleague Mr Kremer to take the floor.

780
01:14:27,565 --> 01:14:31,892
Colleagues, a new round of negotiations
is underway between Russia, America, and

781
01:14:31,945 --> 01:14:35,849
Ukraine. And that leaves us
here in Europe, with a choice.

782
01:14:35,905 --> 01:14:39,722
We can either once again politely watch
from the sidelines and hope for the best, as

783
01:14:39,762 --> 01:14:45,726
others decide about Europe without Europe,
or we can finally get our act together,

784
01:14:45,798 --> 01:14:50,605
speak with one voice, and claim from a
position of strength our rightful place at

785
01:14:50,665 --> 01:14:54,910
the negotiating table. Because, colleagues,
if Europe's security architecture is on

786
01:14:54,967 --> 01:14:58,391
the menu, then this should
be our table to begin with.

787
01:14:58,465 --> 01:15:02,695
This is our security. And we
have the strength to defend it.

788
01:15:02,785 --> 01:15:06,905
We are Ukraine's strongest supporters.
We are the second biggest economy in the

789
01:15:06,953 --> 01:15:09,865
world. And our sanctions
hit Putin where it hurts.

790
01:15:09,925 --> 01:15:15,250
But we must be honest with ourselves. The
greatest leverage is useless unless we

791
01:15:15,355 --> 01:15:21,530
decide to use it. And use it
strategically, decisively, and effectively.

792
01:15:21,625 --> 01:15:26,405
So let's act now. And close every
last loophole in the sanctions.

793
01:15:26,485 --> 01:15:29,957
Use Russia's frozen assets
as a leverage for peace.

794
01:15:30,025 --> 01:15:34,811
And take the diplomatic initiative together
with Ukraine to get real negotiations

795
01:15:34,885 --> 01:15:37,970
from a position of
strength for our Europe.

796
01:15:38,065 --> 01:15:39,265
Thank you.

797
01:15:39,865 --> 01:15:42,801
Thank you. And you have
a blue card from Mr.

798
01:15:42,865 --> 01:15:46,699
Mularchik. Mr. Sipper,
you were second again.

799
01:15:46,765 --> 01:15:51,356
But Mr. Mularchik, this is your second
blue card, so I will stick to the two blue

800
01:15:51,429 --> 01:15:55,165
cards per member. So
we are on time. Please.

801
01:15:55,225 --> 01:15:57,510
Thank you. I have a lot
of questions. Thank you.

802
01:15:57,625 --> 01:15:58,825
I will speak in Polish.

803
01:15:59,605 --> 01:16:07,401
Honourable colleague, you are expressing
regret here that Europe is not at the

804
01:16:07,455 --> 01:16:14,117
negotiating table, in the talks, while a
dialogue is taking place between America,

805
01:16:14,169 --> 01:16:17,261
Ukraine and Russia. But isn't
this actually Europe's fault?

806
01:16:17,314 --> 01:16:21,292
Is it not the fault of the current
European Commission, which adopts a

807
01:16:21,356 --> 01:16:24,193
confrontational style
towards President Trump?

808
01:16:24,253 --> 01:16:29,303
Is it not the fault of the left, which
does everything to harm EU-US relations?

809
01:16:29,366 --> 01:16:32,965
Is it not Europe’s very fault that it is
not sitting at the negotiating table today?

810
01:16:36,865 --> 01:16:41,599
I think we must be very realistic. We
support every diplomatic initiative.

811
01:16:41,665 --> 01:16:47,255
Our hand is always open. But we have
seen before what appeasement looks like.

812
01:16:47,305 --> 01:16:49,830
Trump has rolled out the
red carpet in Alaska.

813
01:16:49,885 --> 01:16:53,963
And what was the result? Nothing.
Just more bombs on Ukraine.

814
01:16:54,025 --> 01:16:59,115
We won't negotiations, but we also have
to understand that diplomacy requires not

815
01:16:59,172 --> 01:17:02,310
appeasement of the dictator,
but a position of strength.

816
01:17:02,365 --> 01:17:07,411
And the only reason Putin will ever really
come to negotiate is if we put on the

817
01:17:07,462 --> 01:17:11,432
screws with the sanctions, if we show
him, if we change his calculus, that he

818
01:17:11,476 --> 01:17:15,025
understands that he will never win
this war and that he must stop now.

819
01:17:18,505 --> 01:17:21,745
Thank you. And now I would like to
call on my colleague Ms Vrecianová.

820
01:17:26,485 --> 01:17:31,359
Good afternoon, thank you. I take the
floor, Mr President, honourable colleagues,

821
01:17:31,432 --> 01:17:36,279
ladies and gentlemen. Russia continues to
bomb Ukrainian cities every single day,

822
01:17:36,340 --> 01:17:39,884
destroying energy infrastructure
and killing civilians.

823
01:17:39,935 --> 01:17:43,455
Putin’s regime shows no real
willingness to end the war.

824
01:17:43,512 --> 01:17:46,298
Our response therefore cannot be hesitant.

825
01:17:46,356 --> 01:17:52,685
If we want fair and lasting peace in Europe,
we must not continue to send money to

826
01:17:52,755 --> 01:17:57,788
Russia to fund its war. We must definitively
end the purchase of oil and liquefied

827
01:17:57,860 --> 01:18:03,018
natural gas. And also rigorously enforce
the existing sanctions, take strong action

828
01:18:03,070 --> 01:18:08,475
against the Russian shadow fleet, and
consistently prevent circumvention through

829
01:18:08,539 --> 01:18:12,314
third countries. Supporting
Ukraine is not charity;

830
01:18:12,374 --> 01:18:15,427
it is a direct investment
in our own security.

831
01:18:15,504 --> 01:18:20,438
And if we are not united due to domestic
politicking or profiteering, and do not

832
01:18:20,501 --> 01:18:24,180
persevere, we are only
playing into Russia’s hands.

833
01:18:24,242 --> 01:18:25,765
Thank you for your attention.

834
01:18:27,385 --> 01:18:30,124
Thank you very much. And now I would
like to give the floor to my colleague Mr

835
01:18:30,156 --> 01:18:31,356
Bráška, that is, Mr Vytria.

836
01:18:33,085 --> 01:18:38,605
Thank you. Mr. President. Putin's guerre
à l'Europe, that what Nouvel Obs writes

837
01:18:38,665 --> 01:18:43,487
today, it's Putin's war against Europe.
And we have to understand that there is

838
01:18:43,536 --> 01:18:47,422
terror he wages, terror against
Ukraine, but also war against Europe.

839
01:18:47,485 --> 01:18:51,387
There are attacks in Europe,
disinformation, cyber attacks, and so on.

840
01:18:51,445 --> 01:18:54,695
So we need the sanctions also
for us, and the sanctions work.

841
01:18:54,745 --> 01:18:58,465
And of course, the right-wing extremists
are against the sanctions because they are

842
01:18:58,525 --> 01:19:01,350
Putin's poodles. And we
have to say it very clearly.

843
01:19:01,405 --> 01:19:06,577
And we have to enforce the sanctions. It's
a shame that Irish aluminium is going to

844
01:19:06,649 --> 01:19:13,501
Russia. It's a shame that we removed, or
the EU removed, people like Alisha Usmanov

845
01:19:13,585 --> 01:19:16,105
and Mikael Friedman from the EU blacklist.

846
01:19:16,165 --> 01:19:21,953
It's a shame that many components of Russian
missiles kill Ukrainians because these

847
01:19:22,029 --> 01:19:26,709
components were produced in
Europe. So we need more sanctions.

848
01:19:26,785 --> 01:19:29,015
We need stronger sanctions.
We have to control them.

849
01:19:29,065 --> 01:19:32,890
And we have to understand that
this war is also against us.

850
01:19:32,965 --> 01:19:36,091
So when we help Ukraine,
we defend also Europe.

851
01:19:36,145 --> 01:19:37,345
Thank you very much.

852
01:19:39,745 --> 01:19:43,405
Thank you. And now I would like to ask
my colleague Ms Riel to take the floor.

853
01:19:48,805 --> 01:19:52,308
Do you remember what
he did five years ago?

854
01:19:52,405 --> 01:19:55,005
And what has happened
in your life since then?

855
01:19:55,105 --> 01:20:01,407
Well, we were celebrating half a decade
of Christmases, of birthdays, of really

856
01:20:01,465 --> 01:20:06,911
life-changing things.
Ukrainians had air ride sirens.

857
01:20:06,985 --> 01:20:11,523
They had destroyed homes. They had
their loved ones lost on the front.

858
01:20:11,605 --> 01:20:16,993
Ukraine's paying are paying the
highest price for Russia's illegal war.

859
01:20:17,185 --> 01:20:22,074
They pay with their life. And
Russia? Russia's paying nothing.

860
01:20:22,165 --> 01:20:26,842
Why is the only one waging this illegal
war also the only one not paying for it?

861
01:20:26,905 --> 01:20:29,805
The one who causes the damage
should be the one who pays for it.

862
01:20:29,845 --> 01:20:34,281
Why is that even debatable? Of
course, Putin won't pay voluntarily.

863
01:20:34,345 --> 01:20:40,510
But we don't need him to. We already have
Russia's money here, over $200 billion of

864
01:20:40,563 --> 01:20:43,958
frozen assets, right here
in Brussels at Euroclear.

865
01:20:44,065 --> 01:20:46,578
This shouldn't be Belgium's
burden alone, of course.

866
01:20:46,645 --> 01:20:51,198
Europe can, and Europe should take the
risk and use that money for Ukraine.

867
01:20:51,265 --> 01:20:54,438
That money stopped being
Russian a long time ago.

868
01:20:54,505 --> 01:20:57,445
This is unpaid debt, and
it's time to settle the bill.

869
01:21:00,865 --> 01:21:03,625
Thank you. And now I would like
to ask my colleague Mr Sütz.

870
01:21:08,785 --> 01:21:13,720
Thank you very much, Mr President. We are
now seeing how Donald Trump is aligning

871
01:21:13,783 --> 01:21:18,842
himself with Putin and wants to
make deals with Russian oil and gas.

872
01:21:18,890 --> 01:21:24,140
This is direct support for Russia’s
brutal war of aggression against Ukraine.

873
01:21:24,194 --> 01:21:29,213
One of the proposals is to reopen the
Nord Stream gas pipeline for Russian gas

874
01:21:29,266 --> 01:21:34,611
exports. A pipeline that runs through
Sweden’s economic zone in the Baltic Sea.

875
01:21:34,711 --> 01:21:39,154
Our answer is a resounding no. The problem
with Nord Stream is not that the pipeline

876
01:21:39,207 --> 01:21:43,505
has been rendered inoperable. The
problem is that it was ever built.

877
01:21:43,554 --> 01:21:48,306
The EU’s decision to introduce a halt
on imports of Russian gas must remain in

878
01:21:48,361 --> 01:21:52,640
place. We expect the Commission also to
come forward with its promised proposal for

879
01:21:52,697 --> 01:21:58,412
a total ban on imports of Russian oil.
The sanctions need to be tightened.

880
01:21:58,454 --> 01:22:02,194
Together, we can put a stop to the Russian
shadow fleet’s export of oil and gas

881
01:22:02,250 --> 01:22:07,209
through the Baltic Sea. I welcome Germany’s
decision that Russia is not welcome to

882
01:22:07,259 --> 01:22:10,145
play ice hockey in the
country’s World Championships.

883
01:22:10,209 --> 01:22:15,220
EU countries should follow Canada’s example
and refuse to grant visas to athletes

884
01:22:15,281 --> 01:22:19,803
from a country that is committing the most
despicable atrocities against the people

885
01:22:19,854 --> 01:22:21,054
of Ukraine.

886
01:22:23,185 --> 01:22:27,505
Thank you. And now I give the
floor to Minister Kováčová, please.

887
01:22:29,065 --> 01:22:33,205
Madam President, Mr Minister, Madam
Commissioner, dear colleagues.

888
01:22:33,685 --> 01:22:37,381
The European Union and Ukraine
want peace as of today.

889
01:22:37,454 --> 01:22:43,428
If Russia truly wants peace, as its
supporters here claim, then it can end its

890
01:22:43,492 --> 01:22:49,103
aggression today. However, the outcome
of the first round of negotiations in Abu

891
01:22:49,157 --> 01:22:53,378
Dhabi shows that Russia is not
interested in a fair and lasting peace.

892
01:22:53,433 --> 01:22:58,363
That is why sanctions must be strictly
enforced and cut off funding for the Russian

893
01:22:58,433 --> 01:23:06,164
war machine, which also threatens us. In
the Black Sea, nine ships were struck, with

894
01:23:06,220 --> 01:23:10,826
over 30 sailors killed. We need unity.
Member States lobbying for the exclusion of

895
01:23:10,901 --> 01:23:16,788
certain individuals and sectors are weakening
sanctions and helping to prolong the

896
01:23:16,844 --> 01:23:21,724
war. Ukraine needs secure financing;
together, EUR 90 billion is important, but we

897
01:23:21,783 --> 01:23:25,610
must do more. Of course, we must also use
the frozen Russian assets and transfer

898
01:23:25,666 --> 01:23:30,733
these assets to the European Union's joint
instrument that will distribute the legal

899
01:23:30,797 --> 01:23:34,988
risks. Russia must pay for the destruction
it has caused, and we must reduce the

900
01:23:35,046 --> 01:23:38,365
ability to finance this
terrible war. Thank you.

901
01:23:40,465 --> 01:23:44,065
Thank you. And now I would like to ask
my colleague Mr Mixer to take the floor.

902
01:23:46,045 --> 01:23:47,005
Colleague.

903
01:23:47,005 --> 01:23:50,466
To the skeptics and doubters, I would
like to say that sanctions are having an

904
01:23:50,527 --> 01:23:53,905
effect on Russia's ability to
continue waging its murderous war.

905
01:23:54,025 --> 01:23:57,893
But obviously, they could have a much
greater effect if properly implemented and

906
01:23:57,951 --> 01:24:02,598
further strengthened. Sanctions are an
important element in our effort to help

907
01:24:02,675 --> 01:24:06,076
Ukraine win the war. But
it's just one element.

908
01:24:06,145 --> 01:24:10,708
Others include supporting or continuing
supporting Ukraine, maintaining a broad

909
01:24:10,765 --> 01:24:14,967
international coalition on the side of
Ukraine, and ensuring accountability for war

910
01:24:15,025 --> 01:24:19,898
crimes. The war will inevitably
end at the negotiating table.

911
01:24:20,005 --> 01:24:23,795
But we should stop lamenting Europe's
irrelevance because we are not irrelevant.

912
01:24:23,845 --> 01:24:26,482
We are the strongest supporter of Ukraine.

913
01:24:26,545 --> 01:24:30,739
We will play an important role
in the post-war reconstruction.

914
01:24:30,805 --> 01:24:34,734
And Ukraine will be a
full member of our union.

915
01:24:34,825 --> 01:24:39,552
And we will have a place at the table when
it comes to making sure that the war ends

916
01:24:39,623 --> 01:24:44,527
on terms favorable to Ukraine. But we
should be very careful and not rush to

917
01:24:44,610 --> 01:24:49,641
negotiating table without a clear strategy
in a situation where this might grant

918
01:24:49,707 --> 01:24:55,388
legitimacy to Russia's totally illegitimate
imperial aspirations and their efforts

919
01:24:55,452 --> 01:24:58,405
to demolish the foundations of
European security architecture.

920
01:24:59,965 --> 01:25:05,965
You have a blue card from Mr.
Sieper. I guess you take it.

921
01:25:08,005 --> 01:25:13,420
Final. Thank you. President. Thank you,
colleagues, for accepting the blue card.

922
01:25:13,465 --> 01:25:18,066
I have a very simple question. Do you think
it is efficient that the member states

923
01:25:18,129 --> 01:25:21,554
implement the sanctions
instead of the EU directly?

924
01:25:21,625 --> 01:25:29,091
Thank you. Well, obviously,
we should follow the rules.

925
01:25:29,185 --> 01:25:33,454
Of the treaty base, of the European Union.

926
01:25:33,565 --> 01:25:44,605
There is a procedure for ensuring. The
proper implementation of the sanctions.

927
01:25:44,725 --> 01:25:47,959
I do think that the member states
have the tools at their disposal.

928
01:25:48,025 --> 01:25:54,129
Obviously, it's a political decision.
Consensus decision to apply sanctions.

929
01:25:54,265 --> 01:25:58,209
And we should trust our member states to
be in a position to implement the sanctions

930
01:25:58,262 --> 01:26:02,845
that they have voted for
at the council table.

931
01:26:07,645 --> 01:26:11,608
Ďakujem. And just let me inform you before
giving the floor to the next speaker that

932
01:26:11,663 --> 01:26:17,563
I'm closing HDI. There are 13 requests
we'll see how we're doing with the time.

933
01:26:17,605 --> 01:26:22,573
I will try to take everybody, but I
cannot guarantee it's going to be tight.

934
01:26:22,645 --> 01:26:34,786
Please Europa aplică sancțiuni dure Rusiei
în timp ce importă direct sau indirect

935
01:26:34,843 --> 01:26:37,923
mereu mai multe produse
energetice din Rusia.

936
01:26:38,005 --> 01:26:43,177
Permițându-i lui Putin să continue un
război distrugător pentru Ucraina și

937
01:26:43,243 --> 01:26:48,869
falimentar pentru Uniunea Europeană. Totodată,
Uniunea Europeană le cere cetățenilor

938
01:26:48,940 --> 01:26:53,766
și întreprinderilor mici și mijlocii să
strângă și mai mult șurubul precum și

939
01:26:53,818 --> 01:26:57,125
solidaritate în suportarea
costurilor acestei politici.

940
01:26:57,205 --> 01:27:01,723
În capitalele europene, oamenii ies în
stradă, strângându-și disperarea față de

941
01:27:01,791 --> 01:27:06,813
creșterea aberantă a costului vieții. În
acest timp, autoritățile reacționează sever

942
01:27:06,865 --> 01:27:12,222
și le cer oamenilor să respecte valori
pe care ele însele le aplică selectiv.

943
01:27:12,325 --> 01:27:16,405
Protecția drepturilor omului nu se poate
invoca selectiv fără a pica în ipocrizie.

944
01:27:16,465 --> 01:27:21,365
Există rapoarte ale ONU care au
documentat acuzații de încălcări grave ale

945
01:27:21,429 --> 01:27:26,957
drepturilor omului în Ucraina. Copilul de
14 ani, Olexei, a fost torturat de unități

946
01:27:27,007 --> 01:27:32,167
ale batalionului Azov. Liste negre cu
europeni, inclusiv europarlamentari, sunt

947
01:27:32,218 --> 01:27:36,265
ținute de aceste entități. Eu zic
că este timpul să ne cam trezim.

948
01:27:39,805 --> 01:27:43,285
Thank you. And now I give the
floor to Ms colleague Jar, please.

949
01:27:46,765 --> 01:27:51,310
Colleagues, this year is the deadliest
year for Ukrainian civilians since the

950
01:27:51,366 --> 01:27:53,941
beginning of Russia's full-scale invasion.

951
01:27:54,025 --> 01:28:00,127
And in Europe, we know perfectly well
how Russia finances its killing machine.

952
01:28:00,205 --> 01:28:09,973
First, fossil fuels. Russia's steel earns
625 million euro of it every single day.

953
01:28:10,165 --> 01:28:17,651
Secondly, shadow fleets. A huge amount of
Russian oil is still transported by ships

954
01:28:17,725 --> 01:28:24,020
that are either owned or insured by many
of the EU countries that even proclaim

955
01:28:24,107 --> 01:28:29,188
their support for Ukraine. So that
is not an effective sanctions policy.

956
01:28:29,245 --> 01:28:34,917
It is clearly a loophole. And it
undermines our collective impact.

957
01:28:35,005 --> 01:28:40,009
But you know who is even worse?
Those who do not even try.

958
01:28:40,105 --> 01:28:44,886
Those who cynically lie that
Russia is merely defending itself.

959
01:28:44,965 --> 01:28:48,807
And that we, in the EU, are
actually the aggressors.

960
01:28:48,865 --> 01:28:51,562
And we've heard it
today. They are among us.

961
01:28:51,625 --> 01:28:54,550
They are sitting in the
governments of the member states.

962
01:28:54,625 --> 01:29:00,598
They are even speaking here. So to those
who want to repeat Putin's lies, go and

963
01:29:00,660 --> 01:29:01,645
stay in Moscow.

964
01:29:01,645 --> 01:29:03,685
Thank you very much. Thank you very much.

965
01:29:04,105 --> 01:29:07,165
Now I would like to give the floor
to my colleague Mr Anschütz, please.

966
01:29:12,445 --> 01:29:16,269
It's not that hard. Can we
be honest for one second?

967
01:29:16,345 --> 01:29:21,165
While negotiation attempts to end Russia's
war are happening, we're not even at the

968
01:29:21,230 --> 01:29:25,234
table. Putin is setting the terms. Trump
and his cronies are more focused on the

969
01:29:25,276 --> 01:29:28,748
money they can make than
making a lasting peace.

970
01:29:28,825 --> 01:29:33,483
Unless Europeans learn to speak with
one voice, it'll never be heard.

971
01:29:33,565 --> 01:29:36,949
And Ukrainians and Europeans
will pay the price.

972
01:29:37,045 --> 01:29:41,456
We've been calling for this for
years, and it's never been so urgent.

973
01:29:41,545 --> 01:29:47,099
Zelensky also asked us to hurry up and
appoint someone to help negotiate peace.

974
01:29:47,245 --> 01:29:52,758
If the U.S. can be represented by corrupt
businessmen and Russia can be represented

975
01:29:52,820 --> 01:29:57,742
by war criminals, surely we can find
someone and give them a mandate.

976
01:29:57,805 --> 01:30:04,296
Anyone, stoop, call us, Pavel, you. The
Russians want nothing more than to exclude

977
01:30:04,345 --> 01:30:08,159
us from these talks and right
now they have an easy excuse.

978
01:30:08,245 --> 01:30:14,193
Europe can't agree on who to send. So
national leaders, get into a room, lock the

979
01:30:14,260 --> 01:30:18,198
door, and don't come out
until you pick someone.

980
01:30:18,325 --> 01:30:19,525
Thank you.

981
01:30:20,785 --> 01:30:23,245
Thank you. And now a blue card.

982
01:30:23,365 --> 01:30:25,665
Sorry, I forgot almost. You
have a blue card from Mr.

983
01:30:25,705 --> 01:30:26,905
Sieper.

984
01:30:31,765 --> 01:30:33,985
Thank you. Dear colleagues,

985
01:30:34,045 --> 01:30:37,798
I why do you think we
haven't picked someone yet?

986
01:30:37,885 --> 01:30:45,639
Thank you. Oh, yes. That's
a very good question.

987
01:30:45,685 --> 01:30:51,959
So why haven't we picked anyone yet? I think
a lot of our national leaders are stuck

988
01:30:52,043 --> 01:30:57,575
in a 20th-century mindset where nationalism
dictates what they think is the right

989
01:30:57,617 --> 01:31:02,372
thing to do. But nationalism for European
countries right now is an illusion.

990
01:31:02,425 --> 01:31:08,715
The only real sovereignty we can create,
we can have, is sovereignty that is truly

991
01:31:08,785 --> 01:31:14,042
European. And until our national leaders
realize that, they will not step over their

992
01:31:14,085 --> 01:31:15,884
own shadow. They will
not find the courage.

993
01:31:15,925 --> 01:31:20,873
But Europeans know this, and that's an
interesting thing because Europeans want us

994
01:31:20,928 --> 01:31:23,739
to speak with one voice as
all the European polls show.

995
01:31:23,785 --> 01:31:24,985
Thank you.

996
01:31:26,185 --> 01:31:29,605
Thank you. And now I would like to call
on my colleague Mr Klausen, please.

997
01:31:35,485 --> 01:31:41,244
When Russia sends suicide drones and cruise
missiles against Ukraine, one thing is

998
01:31:41,332 --> 01:31:47,486
absolutely certain: their killing machines
only work because they are filled with

999
01:31:47,565 --> 01:31:53,137
Western components. Components that, despite
sanctions, they apparently have little

1000
01:31:53,241 --> 01:31:58,222
trouble getting their hands on. So what
we are talking about here is support.

1001
01:31:58,271 --> 01:32:03,368
But if we really want to protect Ukraine’s
civilians, there are two things we should

1002
01:32:03,441 --> 01:32:06,386
ensure, preferably today
rather than tomorrow.

1003
01:32:06,442 --> 01:32:11,299
First, we must ensure that Russia can no
longer obtain Western microchips and other

1004
01:32:11,354 --> 01:32:15,882
electronics for its arms factories. And
second, we need to become much better at

1005
01:32:15,939 --> 01:32:19,686
curbing Russia’s ability to wage
war by hitting it in the pocket.

1006
01:32:19,746 --> 01:32:24,952
And unfortunately, we don’t need to go
back further than October, when the EU

1007
01:32:25,017 --> 01:32:26,701
actually removed sanctions against Russia.

1008
01:32:26,736 --> 01:32:29,388
That is not what we need. We
need to tighten sanctions.

1009
01:32:29,464 --> 01:32:34,714
What we are doing when we remove sanctions
and allow Russia to use parts from us to

1010
01:32:34,778 --> 01:32:39,738
produce weapons against Ukraine is this:
we are sending the bill to Ukraine’s

1011
01:32:39,792 --> 01:32:41,665
population, and we must stop doing that.

1012
01:32:44,965 --> 01:32:49,593
Ďakujem. And let me inform you, I'll have
to be more strict because we're really

1013
01:32:49,628 --> 01:32:54,805
tight on time. And let me give the
floor to Madam Vice Lima, please.

1014
01:32:56,845 --> 01:32:58,045
Madam.

1015
01:33:00,805 --> 01:33:05,205
Last winter, Russia deliberately plunged
Ukrainian civilians into darkness and

1016
01:33:05,284 --> 01:33:10,535
freezing cold. It is doing so again this
year, going so far as to target substations

1017
01:33:10,579 --> 01:33:14,828
connected to nuclear power plants. And
just last night, mere hours after the

1018
01:33:14,886 --> 01:33:19,723
conclusion of the talks in Abu Dhabi, Russian
ballistic missiles were striking Kiev.

1019
01:33:19,780 --> 01:33:25,763
Is this what Moscow means by dialogue? Let
us therefore cut off the resources that

1020
01:33:25,802 --> 01:33:27,649
still enable the Kremlin
to finance this war.

1021
01:33:27,720 --> 01:33:34,001
Every barrel sold by the shadow fleet,
every component transiting through a third

1022
01:33:34,079 --> 01:33:38,499
country, every transaction in
crypto-assets finances the next strike.

1023
01:33:38,581 --> 01:33:43,872
Let us plug the loopholes. Let us
sanction the intermediaries facilitating

1024
01:33:43,925 --> 01:33:47,110
circumvention. Let's actually
control the ghost fleet at sea.

1025
01:33:47,161 --> 01:33:50,071
Let's adopt the next
package without delay.

1026
01:33:50,138 --> 01:33:55,485
This war is already costing Moscow
far more than it is bringing in.

1027
01:33:55,543 --> 01:34:01,337
But Putin will only stop it the day when
pursuing it threatens his own power.

1028
01:34:01,435 --> 01:34:06,484
It is up to us to corner him into making
that choice, from the outside through our

1029
01:34:06,536 --> 01:34:10,310
sanctions, so that the pressure
also builds from within.

1030
01:34:10,389 --> 01:34:11,589
Thank you.

1031
01:34:13,045 --> 01:34:13,585
Mr.

1032
01:34:13,585 --> 01:34:17,845
Thank you. Thank you. And now I give the
floor to Ms Colleague Fricon, please.

1033
01:34:21,745 --> 01:34:24,265
Mr Talmann, Putin's brutal

1034
01:34:24,565 --> 01:34:31,490
the war against Ukraine continues, the
bombs are falling, here and now, on homes,

1035
01:34:31,587 --> 01:34:37,834
hospitals, schools, and families
live in constant terror.

1036
01:34:37,957 --> 01:34:47,120
Today, Europe is buying more oil and gas
for more money than we are providing in

1037
01:34:47,227 --> 01:34:52,314
support to Ukraine. This is
nothing short of hypocrisy.

1038
01:34:52,390 --> 01:34:57,754
We must, once and for all, free
ourselves from Russian fossil energy.

1039
01:34:57,833 --> 01:35:04,212
We have indeed taken that decision.
Europe must never contribute to financing

1040
01:35:04,301 --> 01:35:08,734
Putin’s war. We Social Democrats
demand stricter sanctions.

1041
01:35:08,806 --> 01:35:14,001
We must stop the Russian shadow fleet.
Plug the loopholes and ensure that the

1042
01:35:14,064 --> 01:35:18,704
sanctions are actually complied
with. We must be clear:

1043
01:35:18,774 --> 01:35:24,401
Ukraine’s struggle is also our struggle.
We must stand up for the people of Ukraine

1044
01:35:24,462 --> 01:35:28,225
and we must do so together;
the EU must show the way.

1045
01:35:32,905 --> 01:35:35,725
Thank you. I would now like to give
the floor to my colleague, please.

1046
01:35:36,805 --> 01:35:42,481
Ladies and Gentlemen, you are looking for
the guilty parties in the wrong place.

1047
01:35:42,558 --> 01:35:45,325
All you need to do is
look around this Chamber.

1048
01:35:45,379 --> 01:35:50,661
Especially the Left and the liberals. Show
me one person who has effectively been

1049
01:35:50,712 --> 01:35:55,115
subject to personal sanctions and has been
banned from entering the European Union

1050
01:35:55,167 --> 01:35:59,015
for collaborating with the
criminals under Vladimir Putin.

1051
01:35:59,096 --> 01:36:03,215
How is it possible that several months
ago I submitted a request for Gerhard

1052
01:36:03,275 --> 01:36:06,203
Schröder to be subject
to personal sanctions?

1053
01:36:06,271 --> 01:36:11,406
The Left and the European People's
Party are partly standing up.

1054
01:36:11,454 --> 01:36:14,767
So start imposing sanctions
on those who are standing up.

1055
01:36:14,827 --> 01:36:19,505
Throw them out of the groups. You are
responsible for the fact that a man

1056
01:36:19,568 --> 01:36:24,715
responsible for Nord Stream was celebrating
Vladimir Putin’s birthday a month ago.

1057
01:36:24,800 --> 01:36:28,004
And this is something you
must take to heart today.

1058
01:36:28,046 --> 01:36:31,384
It is you who are to blame.
The previous term and earlier.

1059
01:36:31,438 --> 01:36:33,837
You are responsible for
everything you are saying today.

1060
01:36:33,878 --> 01:36:38,210
And history will judge you. Though of
course, independent prosecutorial action

1061
01:36:38,260 --> 01:36:41,863
should be taken. Because you are acting
as if you were acting on Vladimir Putin’s

1062
01:36:41,905 --> 01:36:43,105
orders. Thank you.

1063
01:36:45,385 --> 01:36:48,797
Thank you. Thank you. And now I would like
to ask my colleague Mr Koboška to take

1064
01:36:48,831 --> 01:36:50,031
the floor, please, Michal.

1065
01:36:55,885 --> 01:37:01,085
Colleagues, the balance sheet of five years
of war on the Russian side is over one

1066
01:37:01,146 --> 01:37:05,954
and a half million killed and
wounded. Over one and a half million.

1067
01:37:06,032 --> 01:37:08,459
In October alone, 54,000
killed and wounded.

1068
01:37:08,530 --> 01:37:13,847
In one month, Russia has lost as many
people as the Soviet Union did over 10 years

1069
01:37:13,918 --> 01:37:19,056
of war in Afghanistan. And yet Putin is
bringing in more of his people for the

1070
01:37:19,129 --> 01:37:22,848
slaughter. He is bombing Ukrainian
cities, murdering civilians.

1071
01:37:22,900 --> 01:37:27,115
And the Russian negotiator in Abu Dhabi
is offering similar, quote-unquote,

1072
01:37:27,211 --> 01:37:32,375
'treatment' to the whole of Europe. And
that is why our pressure on Russia must

1073
01:37:32,438 --> 01:37:37,206
increase, not weaken. In the 2022 sanctions
package, we must target the sectors that

1074
01:37:37,263 --> 01:37:40,656
bring Russia the highest
revenues: finance and energy.

1075
01:37:40,703 --> 01:37:44,659
We must also effectively close the
loopholes for circumventing sanctions.

1076
01:37:44,710 --> 01:37:47,713
Above all, however, the
frozen Russian assets.

1077
01:37:47,775 --> 01:37:52,026
I appeal to the European Commission:
do not postpone this issue.

1078
01:37:52,103 --> 01:37:56,151
Do not be afraid. In cooperation with
experts, a solution based on solid legal

1079
01:37:56,213 --> 01:38:01,329
grounds has been found. The aggressor must
pay for this war from its own money, not

1080
01:38:01,376 --> 01:38:02,576
from ours. Thank you.

1081
01:38:06,145 --> 01:38:10,105
Thank you. And now I would like to ask
Ms Colleague Zofka to take the floor.

1082
01:38:12,085 --> 01:38:17,858
Your. Colleagues, not one cent of European
money should finance Russia's illegal war

1083
01:38:17,909 --> 01:38:23,534
of aggression against Ukraine. Our next
sanctions package must hit Russia where it

1084
01:38:23,603 --> 01:38:31,655
hurts. It's energy revenues, financial
sector, and networks enabling circumvention.

1085
01:38:31,765 --> 01:38:38,178
Russia weaponized supply, attacks Ukraine's
energy infrastructures, and circumvents

1086
01:38:38,241 --> 01:38:44,404
sanctions to keep its revenue flowing.
Croatia offers alternative energy supply

1087
01:38:44,481 --> 01:38:50,902
through YANAF and the Kirk LNG terminal.
We must support investment that allows

1088
01:38:50,965 --> 01:38:57,214
Europe to cut its independence on Russia.
We must also dismantle the shadow fleets

1089
01:38:57,276 --> 01:39:01,744
business model by targeting the
companies managing its vessels.

1090
01:39:01,825 --> 01:39:05,591
Alongside coordinating
maritime enforcement.

1091
01:39:05,725 --> 01:39:09,030
Russia must pay for the
destruction it has caused.

1092
01:39:09,145 --> 01:39:14,515
We must advance legally sound solutions
to use frozen Russian assets to support

1093
01:39:14,614 --> 01:39:21,085
Ukraine. Every loophole we close reduces
Russia's capacity to fund the next attack.

1094
01:39:21,145 --> 01:39:23,606
That must be the measure of our sanctions.

1095
01:39:23,665 --> 01:39:24,865
Thank you.

1096
01:39:25,585 --> 01:39:29,845
Thank you. Thank you. And now I give the
floor to Mr colleague Picula, please.

1097
01:39:31,945 --> 01:39:33,145
Thank you.

1098
01:39:33,385 --> 01:39:37,819
In these days when unacceptable conditions
for ending the war are being imposed on

1099
01:39:37,878 --> 01:39:42,466
Ukraine, conditions that neither guarantee
future peace and in fact reward the

1100
01:39:42,529 --> 01:39:45,460
aggressor, we in this House must be clear.

1101
01:39:45,533 --> 01:39:48,198
The European Union must
further sanction the Kremlin.

1102
01:39:48,244 --> 01:39:52,203
With a greater focus on preventing
the circumvention of sanctions through

1103
01:39:52,262 --> 01:39:55,612
intermediaries and trade
channels of third countries.

1104
01:39:55,683 --> 01:39:58,977
The current sanctions have
had a significant impact.

1105
01:39:59,070 --> 01:40:03,263
They have reduced Russia’s access to the
European market, foreign investment and

1106
01:40:03,313 --> 01:40:06,029
technology, and increased
costs for its economy.

1107
01:40:06,088 --> 01:40:10,284
Russia is increasingly dependent on Beijing,
which dictates the rules of the game to

1108
01:40:10,356 --> 01:40:14,379
it. It is crucial that the European Union
continues to act in a coordinated manner.

1109
01:40:14,427 --> 01:40:18,999
It is closing the loopholes in the
existing sanctions system and maintaining

1110
01:40:19,052 --> 01:40:23,134
pressure. Despite demands from pro-Russian
options in some Member States, and even

1111
01:40:23,182 --> 01:40:27,583
in this Parliament, returning to energy
dependence on Russia would be a strategic

1112
01:40:27,642 --> 01:40:32,224
mistake. Even once the aggression ends,
full normalisation of relations, especially

1113
01:40:32,291 --> 01:40:36,780
under Putin’s regime, is not realistic.
Trust has been destroyed, and this Russia

1114
01:40:36,839 --> 01:40:41,141
will remain a security threat to Europe.
A threat to our freedom, our way of life

1115
01:40:41,190 --> 01:40:42,390
and our values. Thank you.

1116
01:40:45,085 --> 01:40:48,685
Thank you. And now I would like to ask
my colleague Mr Tereš to take the floor.

1117
01:40:54,925 --> 01:41:02,040
Thank you. Dear Commissioner, if the EU is
fully committed to imposing sanctions on

1118
01:41:02,090 --> 01:41:07,361
Russia that will cut off the source's
financing its illegal war, it needs to take

1119
01:41:07,465 --> 01:41:13,238
two major steps. First, close the Northern
Corridor crossing Russia and territory to

1120
01:41:13,304 --> 01:41:19,412
European trade. And second, actively
redirect commercial flows between Europe and

1121
01:41:19,481 --> 01:41:24,755
Asia towards the Middle Corridor. As long
as goods traveling between Europe and Asia

1122
01:41:24,812 --> 01:41:30,136
continue to transit through Russia, we
continue directly or indirectly to Russia's

1123
01:41:30,203 --> 01:41:34,844
economic resilience generates transit
revenues for Moscow and maintains strategic

1124
01:41:34,903 --> 01:41:39,095
dependencies on a country that
has chosen aggression over peace.

1125
01:41:39,205 --> 01:41:43,525
The Middle Corridor connecting Europe and
Asia through the Black Sea region and the

1126
01:41:43,585 --> 01:41:48,303
South Caucasus and Central Asia offers a
viable strategic alternative that would

1127
01:41:48,355 --> 01:41:53,179
strengthen regional connectivity while
reducing Russia's geopolitical leverage over

1128
01:41:53,257 --> 01:41:58,822
both Europe and China. Let's turn
sanctions into a geopolitical strategic

1129
01:41:58,895 --> 01:42:02,814
opportunity. Close the Northern Corridor,
strengthen the Middle Corridor, and stop

1130
01:42:02,866 --> 01:42:04,765
financing the Russians' war. Thank you.

1131
01:42:06,805 --> 01:42:10,585
Thank you. And now I would like to
call on Vice-President Pičerna, please.

1132
01:42:13,165 --> 01:42:19,443
Yes, thank you. Mr President, on 3 November
Russia launched the largest attack this

1133
01:42:19,533 --> 01:42:25,834
year against Ukraine’s energy system. And
at the same time it continues to export

1134
01:42:25,923 --> 01:42:30,046
its oil, even using European
ships and insurance.

1135
01:42:30,123 --> 01:42:37,068
Why, as we know, the ban on maritime
services has been on hold since April pending

1136
01:42:37,162 --> 01:42:41,715
the G7. And we want to reiterate here
in this Chamber that this ban must be

1137
01:42:41,793 --> 01:42:48,027
reinstated immediately, because every time
an oligarch is removed from the sanctions

1138
01:42:48,099 --> 01:42:53,969
lists, every time Member States turn a blind
eye to European companies that continue

1139
01:42:54,023 --> 01:43:00,466
to do illegal business with Russia, in this
way Putin’s imperialism is being aided.

1140
01:43:00,544 --> 01:43:09,306
And we must reiterate this: the era of
the fake trade-off between human rights,

1141
01:43:09,407 --> 01:43:16,898
peace and trade is over. Andrej
Sakharov warned us of this in 1975:

1142
01:43:17,081 --> 01:43:24,449
peace, progress and human rights are
three objectives indissolubly linked.

1143
01:43:24,533 --> 01:43:28,405
If you trade one off, you
lose them all. Thank you.

1144
01:43:29,725 --> 01:43:33,210
Thank you. And now I would like to give
the floor to my colleague Pascal Della

1145
01:43:33,235 --> 01:43:34,435
Parte.

1146
01:43:38,965 --> 01:43:44,751
Thank you very much, Mr President. As we
approach the fifth year of war in Ukraine,

1147
01:43:44,823 --> 01:43:50,904
proposals are beginning to emerge to
confuse us, to divide us, to weaken us.

1148
01:43:50,980 --> 01:43:55,970
The latest is to mix up and confuse
negotiations on a future peace in Ukraine with

1149
01:43:56,027 --> 01:43:58,888
the creation of a security
structure in Europe.

1150
01:43:58,959 --> 01:44:03,566
Let us not fall into that trap. We
must clearly maintain our objectives:

1151
01:44:03,627 --> 01:44:08,960
our objective is to achieve as soon as
possible a real ceasefire in Ukraine and for

1152
01:44:09,009 --> 01:44:12,211
negotiations to begin on
the current line of contact.

1153
01:44:12,287 --> 01:44:17,270
Secondly, we must make it clear that
our firm support for Ukraine — military,

1154
01:44:17,359 --> 01:44:23,390
political and financial — will be maintained
and increased for as long as necessary.

1155
01:44:23,461 --> 01:44:28,980
Secondly, we will tell Russia that we will
maintain and also increase our sanctions

1156
01:44:29,049 --> 01:44:35,264
and that we will use the funds from
assets in European banks to finance the

1157
01:44:35,323 --> 01:44:41,326
reconstruction of Ukraine. And thirdly, we
will open negotiations from a position of

1158
01:44:41,383 --> 01:44:45,850
strength. This means that Europe must be
at the negotiating table because, among

1159
01:44:45,907 --> 01:44:51,305
other things, a part of that negotiation
will be Ukraine’s future membership of the

1160
01:44:51,373 --> 01:44:54,745
European Union. Thank you. Let us
not let the Ukrainians down, because.

1161
01:44:54,985 --> 01:44:59,433
Thank you. I'm sorry, I really have to be
strict on time because we are running out

1162
01:44:59,492 --> 01:45:01,765
and we're running really
seriously late. I'm sorry.

1163
01:45:04,885 --> 01:45:07,585
And now I give the floor to
Ms colleague Schöring-Villus.

1164
01:45:08,425 --> 01:45:13,541
Mr President, Commissioner. The ongoing
peace talks in Abu Dhabi so far give no hope

1165
01:45:13,595 --> 01:45:16,973
of ending the war in Ukraine.
Mr President, Commissioner.

1166
01:45:17,029 --> 01:45:20,792
Despite our desire for this, we
cannot forget who we are dealing with.

1167
01:45:20,843 --> 01:45:27,127
Since the beginning of its attack on
Ukraine, Russia has been killing civilians,

1168
01:45:27,202 --> 01:45:32,111
abducting children, violating international
law and showing that it is not at all

1169
01:45:32,173 --> 01:45:37,653
interested in peace. That is why it is so
important for Europe to maintain sanctions

1170
01:45:37,724 --> 01:45:43,178
against the Kremlin and not give in to
pressure from Trump, who wants to end this

1171
01:45:43,249 --> 01:45:48,098
war at all costs, even at the expense
of a free Ukraine, and probably also at

1172
01:45:48,150 --> 01:45:53,239
Europe’s expense. We must also remember
that Russian money is financing not only

1173
01:45:53,306 --> 01:45:57,955
missiles and ammunition. It is also
financing the information war being waged

1174
01:45:58,010 --> 01:46:02,932
against our societies. Bot farms,
thousands of fake accounts and organised

1175
01:46:03,008 --> 01:46:08,319
disinformation campaigns are being used
to destabilise our states, undermine trust

1176
01:46:08,382 --> 01:46:11,091
in institutions and weaken European unity.

1177
01:46:11,160 --> 01:46:16,047
That is why we must cut off all Russian
sources of funding for the war – both that

1178
01:46:16,103 --> 01:46:19,998
on the Ukrainian front and that being
waged on the screens of our phones.

1179
01:46:20,043 --> 01:46:21,243
Thank you.

1180
01:46:22,585 --> 01:46:26,245
Thank you. And now I would like to ask
my colleague Mr Buda to take the floor.

1181
01:46:29,845 --> 01:46:30,985
With you, colleague. We've

1182
01:46:30,985 --> 01:46:33,505
done Churchill in 1940, avertiza.

1183
01:46:33,865 --> 01:46:40,904
If we do not succeed, then the entire world
will be plunged into the abyss of a dark

1184
01:46:41,003 --> 01:46:46,059
age. Europe cannot afford to fail. Russia’s
war is not just a war against Ukraine,

1185
01:46:46,125 --> 01:46:50,189
it is an attack on the security
order of our entire continent.

1186
01:46:50,254 --> 01:46:56,526
Look at the Black Sea. Commercial vessels
are being hit, maritime routes are under

1187
01:46:56,629 --> 01:47:01,811
threat, drones are falling on the territory
of the European Union, including Romania

1188
01:47:01,861 --> 01:47:06,755
and Bulgaria, and beyond. And the freedom
of navigation, international trade and the

1189
01:47:06,835 --> 01:47:13,960
safety of our citizens are put at risk.
That is precisely why European funds must

1190
01:47:14,055 --> 01:47:20,310
not be used to fuel Russia’s war machine.
Sanctions must target energy revenues, the

1191
01:47:20,376 --> 01:47:24,938
shadow fleet and the supply chains
of the Russian military industry.

1192
01:47:25,011 --> 01:47:31,815
And these must be applied in earnest.
Because every loophole left open turns into a

1193
01:47:31,869 --> 01:47:36,343
rocket, into a drone, into a new attack.
Ukraine's security is our security.

1194
01:47:36,422 --> 01:47:39,805
Today's firmness is
tomorrow's peace. Thank you.

1195
01:47:42,565 --> 01:47:46,471
Thank you. And now I would like to give the
floor to Ms Vice-President Schalldemose,

1196
01:47:46,508 --> 01:47:47,485
please.

1197
01:47:47,485 --> 01:47:53,240
Thank you for that. Putin speaks of
peace, but his bombs tell a very different

1198
01:47:53,300 --> 01:47:58,704
story. While we stand here, Russia is
attacking Ukrainian families and their homes.

1199
01:47:58,765 --> 01:48:04,813
And at the same time, Putin wants to
negotiate about Ukraine's future and Europe's

1200
01:48:04,891 --> 01:48:09,087
security behind Europe's back.
That is completely unacceptable.

1201
01:48:09,143 --> 01:48:12,971
Because the war in Ukraine is not
just about Ukraine's security.

1202
01:48:13,038 --> 01:48:17,761
It is also about all of Europe. It is
our democracy, our freedom and our shared

1203
01:48:17,819 --> 01:48:24,625
future that are at stake. That is why
Denmark has just provided its 32nd donation

1204
01:48:24,788 --> 01:48:28,542
package to Ukraine. That
amounts to 642 million euros.

1205
01:48:28,582 --> 01:48:32,131
I hope that more people will join in
and contribute more funds to Ukraine.

1206
01:48:32,182 --> 01:48:36,587
But we must also hit Russia where it hurts
– specifically by targeting the money

1207
01:48:36,626 --> 01:48:40,103
that is financing the war. That is
why we must tighten the sanctions.

1208
01:48:40,152 --> 01:48:44,415
We must close the loopholes and stop
those who help Russia to circumvent them.

1209
01:48:44,460 --> 01:48:47,960
We need to do more, because the war
in Ukraine is not only Ukraine’s war.

1210
01:48:48,018 --> 01:48:50,665
War is also about our
security. Slaver Ukraine.

1211
01:48:53,485 --> 01:48:56,545
Thank you. And now I would like to invite
my colleague Mr Kely to take the floor.

1212
01:49:01,405 --> 01:49:08,168
Faulty rotorash, Maren Harken. You
reached your own talk against Kara Zulum.

1213
01:49:08,245 --> 01:49:11,579
How do you bring a dictator
like Putin to the table?

1214
01:49:11,785 --> 01:49:15,412
Donald Trump thinks it's by
offering vast concessions.

1215
01:49:15,505 --> 01:49:21,799
Ukrainian land, sanctions relief, and
the say in Europe's future security.

1216
01:49:21,985 --> 01:49:27,363
This is not the way. Resistance
and sanctions are the answer.

1217
01:49:27,505 --> 01:49:32,560
Ukraine is doing the first part, but the
European Union and our partners must do

1218
01:49:32,656 --> 01:49:40,133
more on the second. Before the Iranian
War, Russia's vital aisle and gas revenues

1219
01:49:40,206 --> 01:49:46,469
had fallen by almost half. However, the
supply shock resulting from the Iran War has

1220
01:49:46,544 --> 01:49:49,782
handed massive energy
windfall profits to Putin.

1221
01:49:49,885 --> 01:49:55,173
Which, alongside the U.S. sanction waivers,
has been worth tens of billions for his

1222
01:49:55,244 --> 01:50:02,778
war effort. We have no excuse; we need to
ban Russian oil imports to build on our

1223
01:50:02,865 --> 01:50:10,771
walk to phase out gas. Neel Nandara
Raoging, Matami Darira, Shasev Leshanukhran.

1224
01:50:10,885 --> 01:50:13,165
Slaver Ukraine. Remarkable Trump.

1225
01:50:14,545 --> 01:50:18,025
Thank you. And now I would like to give
the floor to Ms colleague Tarlák, please.

1226
01:50:21,805 --> 01:50:28,167
Mr President, distinguished colleagues,
negotiating with Putin is like playing poker

1227
01:50:28,223 --> 01:50:33,986
with someone who is constantly cheating.
And it looks as though we have a chair at

1228
01:50:34,054 --> 01:50:39,723
the negotiating table. But without
strengthening our hand, we cannot.

1229
01:50:39,823 --> 01:50:44,783
Ukraine has already been defending itself
against Russian aggression for 12 years.

1230
01:50:44,836 --> 01:50:47,862
There have been endless talks and summits.

1231
01:50:47,962 --> 01:50:52,655
Without result. And yet: Europe
cannot afford to lose heart.

1232
01:50:52,744 --> 01:50:56,457
We too are bearing the
consequences of this war.

1233
01:50:56,618 --> 01:51:00,815
For a long time, we have had to
fight for this seat at the table.

1234
01:51:00,861 --> 01:51:07,315
Now is the time to play our cards right:
sanctions, frozen assets, security

1235
01:51:07,382 --> 01:51:12,860
guarantees, and smart moves. The stakes
are not just about the future of Ukraine.

1236
01:51:12,928 --> 01:51:15,865
It is about the security
of Europe. Thank you.

1237
01:51:17,605 --> 01:51:27,625
Except the blue card
from Mr. Roncha. Button.

1238
01:51:30,565 --> 01:51:32,910
Thank you very much for
accepting the question.

1239
01:51:32,986 --> 01:51:38,853
And I wanted to ask you, as you come from
the Netherlands, about Putin's payroll.

1240
01:51:38,933 --> 01:51:42,700
On that Putin payroll,
there is not a single Pole.

1241
01:51:42,783 --> 01:51:48,593
I do not know whether you are aware of this,
but there are politicians from Germany,

1242
01:51:48,684 --> 01:51:56,889
the Netherlands, Italy and Austria. Is
it discussed in your country in what way

1243
01:51:56,981 --> 01:52:01,104
these politicians from Western
Europe ended up on this payroll?

1244
01:52:01,174 --> 01:52:06,271
Because, of course, sanctions are one
thing, and the history and truth about how

1245
01:52:06,335 --> 01:52:10,645
Putin was promoted and respected by
Western Europe is quite another matter.

1246
01:52:19,705 --> 01:52:25,655
Thank you. Colleague, for your question.
From the Netherlands, support for Ukraine

1247
01:52:25,713 --> 01:52:29,459
remains unwavering. And we will continue
to do so at all times, because the war in

1248
01:52:29,520 --> 01:52:31,765
Ukraine is also our security. Thank you.

1249
01:52:35,125 --> 01:52:38,665
Thank you. And now I would like to ask
my colleague Mr Kohút to take the floor.

1250
01:52:41,965 --> 01:52:44,687
The enemy is to the east.
Let’s face the truth.

1251
01:52:44,747 --> 01:52:48,842
Russia is waging an open hybrid
war against all of Europe.

1252
01:52:48,922 --> 01:52:54,224
On the internet, at the borders, at
airports, and even in supermarkets.

1253
01:52:54,294 --> 01:52:59,270
Acts of sabotage have become everyday
occurrences from the Bug to the Rhine.

1254
01:52:59,329 --> 01:53:03,039
Moscow’s actions are affecting
the daily lives of Europeans.

1255
01:53:03,098 --> 01:53:07,455
That is precisely why we should
continue to impose further sanctions.

1256
01:53:07,528 --> 01:53:11,756
We must defend ourselves. The Kremlin
understands only the language of force.

1257
01:53:11,799 --> 01:53:16,853
We need cross-party unity on this matter.
MEPs from the Left, the Right and the

1258
01:53:16,912 --> 01:53:20,055
Centre should speak with
one voice on this matter.

1259
01:53:20,107 --> 01:53:24,208
They should not spout nonsense about
reparations from Germany, but demand that

1260
01:53:24,281 --> 01:53:27,696
frozen Russian assets be
transferred to Ukraine.

1261
01:53:27,764 --> 01:53:30,912
More weapons for Kyiv,
less anti-EU propaganda.

1262
01:53:30,971 --> 01:53:34,606
All this is to avoid war on
the territory of the Union.

1263
01:53:34,674 --> 01:53:38,709
A strong United Europe speaking
with one voice is invincible.

1264
01:53:38,774 --> 01:53:43,118
So I just remind you: the enemy is
in the east and its name is Russia.

1265
01:53:43,177 --> 01:53:44,377
Thank you very much.

1266
01:53:46,045 --> 01:53:49,321
Will you. Accept the blue
card from Mr. Grazulis?

1267
01:53:49,465 --> 01:53:53,233
No. Sorry, the blue card was not accepted.

1268
01:53:53,305 --> 01:53:54,685
Let me give the floor to Mr.

1269
01:53:54,985 --> 01:53:56,185
Now.

1270
01:54:02,065 --> 01:54:07,318
Honourable Chair, the European Union's
sanctions against Russia have significantly

1271
01:54:07,390 --> 01:54:12,538
affected the aggressor country's economy.
At the same time, the imposition of

1272
01:54:12,581 --> 01:54:17,335
sanctions has from the very beginning
been too episodic, too half-hearted.

1273
01:54:17,391 --> 01:54:22,398
If sanctions are the hammer with which we
are to strike Russia, then in reality we

1274
01:54:22,464 --> 01:54:25,366
have rather used it to
pat Russia on the back.

1275
01:54:25,425 --> 01:54:31,038
This has allowed Russia to find various
ways to circumvent sanctions and continue to

1276
01:54:31,120 --> 01:54:35,528
fill its war chest through
trade with third countries.

1277
01:54:35,595 --> 01:54:40,818
We need to target Russia’s shadow fleet
and the infrastructure supporting it much

1278
01:54:40,900 --> 01:54:45,154
more sharply. Impose stricter sanctions
against companies that facilitate the

1279
01:54:45,208 --> 01:54:50,681
circumvention of sanctions in Russia. All
dependence of EU Member States on Russian

1280
01:54:50,759 --> 01:54:53,524
energy carriers must be brought to an end.

1281
01:54:53,579 --> 01:54:58,193
It is deeply schizophrenic for Member
States to pay hundreds of millions to Russia

1282
01:54:58,256 --> 01:55:04,802
so that it can kill Ukrainians and
prepare for war with the rest of Europe.

1283
01:55:05,125 --> 01:55:05,845
Thank you.

1284
01:55:05,845 --> 01:55:09,465
Will you accept the blue
card from... No. Okay.

1285
01:55:09,625 --> 01:55:16,551
So, that concludes this part of the
debate, and we move to catch the eye.

1286
01:55:16,645 --> 01:55:22,285
Looking at the time, I will be able to
only take one round of speakers per group.

1287
01:55:22,345 --> 01:55:25,873
I'm afraid because you don't want all
the colleagues coming for the vote to be

1288
01:55:25,949 --> 01:55:29,014
disturbing the debate, and
being angry that we're late.

1289
01:55:29,065 --> 01:55:32,305
So, let me start with colleague Jonski.

1290
01:55:38,065 --> 01:55:43,928
Thank you very much, Mr President. Ukraine
should sit down at the table and come to

1291
01:55:44,007 --> 01:55:49,872
an agreement with Russia. That is what
Ms Herning-Zajączkowska says, and that is

1292
01:55:49,984 --> 01:55:52,923
what politicians from
the far right are saying.

1293
01:55:52,980 --> 01:55:57,470
So let us imagine a situation in which
someone enters our home, takes our child,

1294
01:55:57,540 --> 01:56:02,305
holds them for 5 years, and after those 5
years comes and says that they may sign an

1295
01:56:02,358 --> 01:56:06,311
agreement with the parents. But on the
condition that he does not return the child.

1296
01:56:06,362 --> 01:56:09,897
Would anyone in this Chamber, would
anyone in this Chamber say that this is an

1297
01:56:09,937 --> 01:56:14,533
agreement, that this is peace? No,
we cannot accept this in any way.

1298
01:56:14,600 --> 01:56:18,558
We cannot reward the aggressor
for attacking a neighbour.

1299
01:56:18,662 --> 01:56:22,638
The aggressor must be
punished. And every single day.

1300
01:56:22,716 --> 01:56:26,319
With sanctions, economic
and political pressure.

1301
01:56:26,416 --> 01:56:33,234
Because peace begins when the aggressor
understands that they will pay for their

1302
01:56:33,298 --> 01:56:34,885
aggression. Thank you very much.

1303
01:56:35,125 --> 01:56:37,885
Thank you. Ďakujem.

1304
01:56:38,185 --> 01:56:41,425
Now I would like to call on my
colleague Ms Rajdov, please.

1305
01:56:49,645 --> 01:56:54,340
It works. Since February 2022, Vladimir
Putin has been striving to prevent the

1306
01:56:54,389 --> 01:56:57,328
ceasefire in Ukraine. Sixteen times
precisely, I have counted them.

1307
01:56:57,370 --> 01:57:00,248
Sixteen times, he has
claimed to want to negotiate.

1308
01:57:00,296 --> 01:57:04,598
Sixteen times, he has refused a condition
that is nonetheless fundamental for anyone

1309
01:57:04,650 --> 01:57:07,672
who truly wants peace: the
cessation of strikes, a ceasefire.

1310
01:57:07,714 --> 01:57:11,003
On the infrastructures, the cities and
the civilian populations in Ukraine that

1311
01:57:11,044 --> 01:57:14,641
Russia continues to attack every
day. I remind you of an obvious fact:

1312
01:57:14,681 --> 01:57:18,026
it is Russia that started this war and
it is Ukraine that has suffered it.

1313
01:57:18,079 --> 01:57:22,276
So today, the priority is a ceasefire.
But Russia has no intention of ending this

1314
01:57:22,324 --> 01:57:26,476
war. Every time Mr Putin claims to negotiate,
it is to push his advantage and extend

1315
01:57:26,530 --> 01:57:30,890
his aggression. Right now, in Abu Dhabi,
the Russians are not prepared to give up

1316
01:57:30,935 --> 01:57:35,337
any territory they have seized from Ukraine,
and while the Europeans are absent from

1317
01:57:35,394 --> 01:57:39,609
the table, they are demanding from the
Russians a new security order in Europe,

1318
01:57:39,666 --> 01:57:44,108
because the current one is not working.
That is interesting, coming from the sole

1319
01:57:44,169 --> 01:57:48,269
aggressor in 75 years. Let us
not be naive and take action.

1320
01:57:48,323 --> 01:57:52,154
We must maintain pressure on Putin and
his band of murderers to bring him to the

1321
01:57:52,207 --> 01:57:56,023
negotiating table. We should not play into
his hands by weakening Ukraine, as Trump

1322
01:57:56,068 --> 01:57:59,317
is doing, or by calling for
colonial-style referendums in the Donbas.

1323
01:57:59,360 --> 01:58:02,954
It is not for the two thugs, Trump and
Putin, to decide the security of our

1324
01:58:03,004 --> 01:58:04,204
continent.

1325
01:58:04,285 --> 01:58:08,005
Thank you. And now I would ask the
honourable Member to conclude, please.

1326
01:58:12,085 --> 01:58:16,003
Thank you, Mr President. Colleagues, it is
hard to believe that more than four years

1327
01:58:16,043 --> 01:58:20,040
after the invasion of Ukraine, we are
still discussing the same thing in this

1328
01:58:20,100 --> 01:58:24,517
Chamber. More and more sanctions against
Russia, more weapons for Ukraine, and this

1329
01:58:24,565 --> 01:58:28,444
is the very reason why any peace effort
to resolve the conflict is doomed.

1330
01:58:28,502 --> 01:58:32,161
There was hope of ending the conflict
as early as 2022, but European states

1331
01:58:32,256 --> 01:58:37,484
torpedoed those hopes in favour of a prolonged
conflict, and since then we have been

1332
01:58:37,532 --> 01:58:41,736
doing the same thing over and over again.
Even though the United States has already

1333
01:58:41,777 --> 01:58:45,519
started negotiating with Russia, even
though there have been efforts to isolate

1334
01:58:45,573 --> 01:58:50,713
Russia, this country is deepening its
relations with states in Asia, Africa and even

1335
01:58:50,774 --> 01:58:52,834
in the Americas, and is profiting from it.

1336
01:58:52,880 --> 01:58:57,326
How many people had to die just so someone
could profit from the war, when we could

1337
01:58:57,393 --> 01:59:01,465
have already had a ceasefire and not
keep repeating the same old phrases about

1338
01:59:01,509 --> 01:59:06,091
sanctions, which we have all known for
many years do not work and only make life

1339
01:59:06,153 --> 01:59:09,847
more expensive for every European
and destroy Europe's competitiveness?

1340
01:59:09,887 --> 01:59:11,485
We should reflect on this, colleagues.

1341
01:59:15,265 --> 01:59:17,845
Now I would like to call
on my colleague Tinkl.

1342
01:59:21,265 --> 01:59:29,053
Dear President, over 200 billion euros—that
is how much European money has flooded

1343
01:59:29,111 --> 01:59:34,782
into Russia through energy purchases
since the full-scale invasion began.

1344
01:59:35,005 --> 01:59:40,385
Think about it. It's more than the EU
and its and all its member states have

1345
01:59:40,442 --> 01:59:45,033
provided in aid to Ukraine
in its fight against Russia.

1346
01:59:45,205 --> 01:59:51,330
Every single one of those euros has held
by the missiles and drones that rained down

1347
01:59:51,411 --> 01:59:57,239
on Ukrainian cities. It's time
to show what Europe is about.

1348
01:59:57,445 --> 02:00:01,576
No more loopholes. No more
getting around sanctions.

1349
02:00:01,645 --> 02:00:08,870
Not one single euro to Putin's war chest.
War ends when it is no longer profitable.

1350
02:00:08,965 --> 02:00:14,063
So let's make the charts look different.
Let's make them show that we support

1351
02:00:14,125 --> 02:00:19,253
Ukraine rather than Russia. And let's
make the charts coming from the front show

1352
02:00:19,333 --> 02:00:22,525
that Russia is losing the war. Thank you.

1353
02:00:27,685 --> 02:00:32,035
Sorry. Thank you. And now I would like to
give the floor to Ms colleague Henriksson,

1354
02:00:32,068 --> 02:00:33,268
please.

1355
02:00:34,285 --> 02:00:41,091
Thank you very much, Mr President. Russia
continues its brutal war in Ukraine every

1356
02:00:41,181 --> 02:00:45,334
day. And unfortunately,
civilians are dying every day.

1357
02:00:45,398 --> 02:00:49,289
It is strange that the far right
here does not understand that.

1358
02:00:49,348 --> 02:00:53,570
It is also Putin who could
end this war immediately.

1359
02:00:53,657 --> 02:00:58,275
Europe now needs to show strength.
We need to tighten the sanctions.

1360
02:00:58,345 --> 02:01:03,748
We need to ensure that Russian gas
and oil do not flow into Europe.

1361
02:01:03,819 --> 02:01:08,641
We also need to ensure that we
use the frozen Russian assets.

1362
02:01:08,713 --> 02:01:14,827
And we also need to ensure that neither
Putin nor Russia can claim any propaganda

1363
02:01:14,900 --> 02:01:19,953
victory when it comes to the Ice
Hockey World Championship next year.

1364
02:01:20,006 --> 02:01:23,634
Finland has shown here that it
will not play against Russia.

1365
02:01:23,711 --> 02:01:27,216
Sweden, Denmark, Norway and other
countries have fallen behind.

1366
02:01:27,260 --> 02:01:30,023
But now we also need to
tighten the visa rules.

1367
02:01:30,086 --> 02:01:33,957
We should not grant visas
to tourists from Russia.

1368
02:01:34,025 --> 02:01:38,764
Nor to athletes, for example at
the Ice Hockey World Championship.

1369
02:01:38,832 --> 02:01:41,305
This is in the interests of all of Europe.

1370
02:01:44,665 --> 02:01:48,279
Thank you. And as the last one, I
would also ask colleague Olivérie.

1371
02:01:48,330 --> 02:01:49,530
Please.

1372
02:01:52,525 --> 02:01:56,118
Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner Maria
Luísa Albuquerque, the path is not one

1373
02:01:56,179 --> 02:02:00,575
of sanctions and war. It has to be about
building peace and collective security,

1374
02:02:00,640 --> 02:02:04,495
with corresponding political
and diplomatic measures.

1375
02:02:04,575 --> 02:02:09,643
We insist that the principles enshrined in
the Final Act of the Helsinki Conference

1376
02:02:09,708 --> 02:02:14,979
provide a solid foundation for the political
and diplomatic action that is needed.

1377
02:02:15,036 --> 02:02:20,290
You do not end war with more war. Insisting
on sanctions is insisting on prolonging

1378
02:02:20,352 --> 02:02:25,347
confrontation and war. And it is the peoples
who pay the costs of sanctions and war

1379
02:02:25,395 --> 02:02:29,054
with rising prices and the cost of raw
materials, with the closure of factories and

1380
02:02:29,099 --> 02:02:33,070
the loss of jobs and industrial production
capacity, with the diversion of budgetary

1381
02:02:33,131 --> 02:02:37,857
resources to war that are sorely needed
for housing, health, education and social

1382
02:02:37,923 --> 02:02:42,336
protection. The European Union’s policy is
driven by the billion-euro arms business

1383
02:02:42,380 --> 02:02:46,468
and by a war-mongering discourse
that turns a blind eye.

1384
02:02:46,548 --> 02:02:51,217
And the EU is willing to sacrifice the
last Ukrainian to promote that billion-euro

1385
02:02:51,275 --> 02:02:56,167
business and that policy, while also
sacrificing the rights of the rest of the

1386
02:02:56,216 --> 02:03:00,782
European peoples. Insisting on sanctions,
confrontation and escalating the war is

1387
02:03:00,826 --> 02:03:01,825
not the way forward.

1388
02:03:01,825 --> 02:03:07,476
Ďakujem. And now for the Commission, I
would like to give the floor to Commissioner

1389
02:03:07,522 --> 02:03:09,085
Albuquerque. Please, the floor is yours.

1390
02:03:20,725 --> 02:03:28,368
Mr. President, Honorable Members, Minister,
thank you for this important and timely

1391
02:03:28,472 --> 02:03:34,269
debate. The Court of Auditors report has
confirmed that the impact of our sanctions

1392
02:03:34,345 --> 02:03:39,487
is clear. Trade sanctions together
with anti-circumvention measures have

1393
02:03:39,568 --> 02:03:45,313
significantly reduced the trade between
the EU and Russia, in particular for the

1394
02:03:45,375 --> 02:03:50,402
goods that Russia's military needs
most to fight its illegal war.

1395
02:03:50,485 --> 02:03:55,501
And that the Commission has established
extensive coordination tools to support the

1396
02:03:55,555 --> 02:03:58,843
effective implementation
of trade sanctions.

1397
02:03:58,945 --> 02:04:02,936
The Commission has announced the
creation of a sanctions office.

1398
02:04:03,025 --> 02:04:09,035
It will allow us to step up on enforcement
and coordination on implementation of

1399
02:04:09,110 --> 02:04:14,749
sanctions also within the broader
context of our full sanctions policy.

1400
02:04:14,845 --> 02:04:20,642
On the topic of the Russian immobilized
assets, which many of you mentioned, the

1401
02:04:20,714 --> 02:04:24,671
Ukraine loan is guaranteed
by this immobilized assets.

1402
02:04:24,745 --> 02:04:29,641
So we are already using them,
productively, in a legally sound manner.

1403
02:04:29,725 --> 02:04:35,704
And we continue to explore the
possibility for their further use.

1404
02:04:35,845 --> 02:04:39,969
This is not the time to
stray from our course.

1405
02:04:40,045 --> 02:04:45,835
As Russia continues its aggression, we
have no choice but to respond strongly.

1406
02:04:45,985 --> 02:04:52,116
By keeping our unwavering support to Ukraine,
be it political, diplomatic, military,

1407
02:04:52,185 --> 02:04:57,559
financial, or humanitarian. And by
maintaining an increasing pressure on Russia,

1408
02:04:57,635 --> 02:05:02,861
including through sanctions.
We intend to do exactly that.

1409
02:05:02,965 --> 02:05:07,881
The Foreign Affairs Council will adopt
new sanctions on Russia next week, further

1410
02:05:07,957 --> 02:05:14,060
curbing its sources of revenue. The 22nd
package with a broad set of measures is in

1411
02:05:14,125 --> 02:05:19,614
the making and should be tabled
shortly. Let me also emphasize:

1412
02:05:19,705 --> 02:05:23,528
EU sanctions are not directed
against Russian people.

1413
02:05:23,605 --> 02:05:28,918
They are carefully targeted, designed to
be proportionate, and temporary in nature.

1414
02:05:29,005 --> 02:05:34,101
Yet they are a necessary tool to
bring this atrocious war to an end.

1415
02:05:34,165 --> 02:05:35,365
Thank you.

1416
02:05:37,825 --> 02:05:42,133
Thank you, Commissioner. And before
giving the floor to the Minister of State,

1417
02:05:42,182 --> 02:05:47,119
please, colleague, try to protect the
dignity of this House and be silent while the

1418
02:05:47,197 --> 02:05:49,405
Minister is speaking. Please.

1419
02:05:57,625 --> 02:06:01,403
Thank you, President, Honorable
Members, and Commissioner.

1420
02:06:01,465 --> 02:06:06,721
And I have to say, as a former member
of this House, I fully understand the

1421
02:06:06,793 --> 02:06:09,979
disturbance that's taking
place at the moment.

1422
02:06:10,045 --> 02:06:15,265
But however, we've had an important
discussion here this morning, and I think once

1423
02:06:15,333 --> 02:06:21,561
again it shows that despite sometimes
difficult but very necessary debates, the

1424
02:06:21,640 --> 02:06:25,525
overall political direction remains clear.

1425
02:06:25,645 --> 02:06:30,261
That direction has been
reaffirmed at every level.

1426
02:06:30,385 --> 02:06:36,008
In the state of the Union address, President
von der Leyen has called for further

1427
02:06:36,078 --> 02:06:42,129
pressure on Russia, with particular
focus on enforcing existing sanctions and

1428
02:06:42,244 --> 02:06:48,150
closing loopholes. The European Council
has called for additional revenues and

1429
02:06:48,216 --> 02:06:53,737
measures to efficiently cut
Russia's energy revenues.

1430
02:06:53,845 --> 02:07:00,193
And this Parliament has repeatedly
called for stronger sanctions and tougher

1431
02:07:00,301 --> 02:07:06,064
enforcement, including this morning,
which I am really pleased to hear.

1432
02:07:06,205 --> 02:07:12,983
On this central issue, for the future of
Ukraine and the EU, our institutions are

1433
02:07:13,070 --> 02:07:20,589
sending a very consistent message. We
will maintain pressure on Russia and stand

1434
02:07:20,674 --> 02:07:27,596
firmly by Ukraine. Just one question raised
during the debate referred to the use of

1435
02:07:27,685 --> 02:07:34,080
Russian frozen assets. As you know, any
decision on the usage of Russian frozen

1436
02:07:34,165 --> 02:07:41,309
assets requires unanimity in the Council.
Currently, the EU collects windfall

1437
02:07:41,385 --> 02:07:48,048
profits generated by these assets and
channels them into military assistance, budget

1438
02:07:48,141 --> 02:07:52,973
support, and the Ukraine
loan cooperation mechanism.

1439
02:07:53,065 --> 02:07:59,562
So there is real benefit to Ukraine.
Colleagues, can I conclude by saying that you

1440
02:07:59,632 --> 02:08:06,462
can be assured, until the very end of our
presidency, Ireland will stand ready, with

1441
02:08:06,531 --> 02:08:13,098
the Council, to deliver further measures
in the months ahead to support our

1442
02:08:13,213 --> 02:08:15,265
Ukrainian colleagues? Thank you.

1443
02:08:19,645 --> 02:08:23,365
Thank you, Minister of State.
And this concludes the debate.

1444
02:08:23,605 --> 02:08:25,865
The debate is suspended for a short while.

1445
02:08:25,945 --> 02:08:28,825
We will resume at 11
o'clock with the vote.

1446
02:10:09,865 --> 02:10:15,625
Dear colleagues, please take your seats.
We would like to start with the meeting.

1447
02:10:37,165 --> 02:10:43,825
The sitting is resumed. Dear colleagues,
before we begin, let me welcome six members

1448
02:10:43,885 --> 02:10:46,645
of the Canadian Parliament
who are with us today.

1449
02:11:13,405 --> 02:11:19,015
Thank you, colleagues. Your presence
here is a testament to the ever-growing

1450
02:11:19,068 --> 02:11:24,313
partnership between Europe and Canada.
It also reflects the important role our

1451
02:11:24,369 --> 02:11:27,405
Parliaments play in
strengthening those ties.

1452
02:11:27,565 --> 02:11:33,190
As was confirmed during the EU-Canada
summit, it is a pleasure to have you here;

1453
02:11:33,322 --> 02:11:40,212
thank you for being here. And the next
item is the election of a Vice President of

1454
02:11:40,268 --> 02:11:44,936
the European Parliament to
replace Mr. Nicholas Stefanutsa.

1455
02:11:45,025 --> 02:11:50,147
I would like to remind you that pursuant
to Rule 20 of the Rules of Procedure, the

1456
02:11:50,214 --> 02:11:55,936
newly elected Vice President shall
take the place of her predecessor.

1457
02:11:56,065 --> 02:12:00,920
In the order of procedure,
of precedence, sorry.

1458
02:12:01,045 --> 02:12:06,655
For the elections to be held for the Vice
President, please colleagues, those who

1459
02:12:06,712 --> 02:12:13,723
are not seated yet should take their seat,
but silently, so that we can proceed with

1460
02:12:13,825 --> 02:12:22,657
our meeting. And stop the talks. Again,
for the election of to be held for a Vice

1461
02:12:22,711 --> 02:12:30,141
President to replace Mr. Nicholas
Stefanutsa, I have received the nomination—

1462
02:12:30,385 --> 02:12:31,585
Colleagues, please.

1463
02:12:37,885 --> 02:12:39,805
Should Mr Liebsen say
we're in kindergarten?

1464
02:12:48,865 --> 02:12:54,317
I have received the nomination of Mrs. Rada
Lajková, nominated by the ESN Group, and

1465
02:12:54,398 --> 02:12:58,679
of Mrs. Tilly Metz, nominated
by the Greens Group.

1466
02:12:58,765 --> 02:13:03,724
The candidates have confirmed to me
their consent to their candidacys.

1467
02:13:03,805 --> 02:13:08,889
And as the number of candidates exceeds
the number of seats to be filled, we shall

1468
02:13:08,939 --> 02:13:14,412
hold a secret ballot in accordance with
Rule 17, paragraph 1 of the Rules of

1469
02:13:14,503 --> 02:13:19,645
Procedure. Blank and void ballots, as well
as abstention, will not be regarded as

1470
02:13:19,705 --> 02:13:26,498
votes cast. We shall then move to
the secret ballot electronic ballot.

1471
02:13:26,605 --> 02:13:33,780
Please insert your voting cards. And we
shall first hold a dummy vote to ensure that

1472
02:13:33,837 --> 02:13:37,960
everybody is familiar with
the electronic voting system.

1473
02:13:38,125 --> 02:13:45,362
Once the vote has been— We can
also say a test vote or whatever.

1474
02:13:45,445 --> 02:13:54,852
So once the vote— Once the vote has been
declared open, you will see on your screen

1475
02:13:54,904 --> 02:13:59,361
the subject of the vote. The list
of candidates, in this case two.

1476
02:13:59,425 --> 02:14:02,941
The number of seats to be
filled, in this case one.

1477
02:14:03,085 --> 02:14:07,735
Then select your chosen candidate by using
the buttons at the bottom right of the

1478
02:14:07,865 --> 02:14:11,368
screen. Cast your vote by
pressing the plus button.

1479
02:14:11,425 --> 02:14:15,363
It's the left-hand button on the
terminal, like with normal votes.

1480
02:14:15,445 --> 02:14:20,485
The blue voting light will come
on, and the asterisk will appear.

1481
02:14:20,545 --> 02:14:25,802
Next to the name, to safeguard voting
confidentially, move the cursor to make the

1482
02:14:25,865 --> 02:14:32,462
asterisk disappear from the screen. If
you wish to abstain, use the zero button.

1483
02:14:32,545 --> 02:14:37,610
It's the center button on the terminal.
You can change your vote until the vote has

1484
02:14:37,719 --> 02:14:44,007
been declared closed. To do so, reselect
the name of the candidate you originally

1485
02:14:44,073 --> 02:14:48,401
choose, and use the plus
button to cancel your vote.

1486
02:14:48,565 --> 02:14:53,567
The asterisk, again, it's
the name will disappear.

1487
02:14:53,665 --> 02:14:59,441
You can then select another candidate and
vote by using the plus button or use the

1488
02:14:59,502 --> 02:15:06,074
zero button if you wish to abstain. You
can vote one for one candidate or abstain.

1489
02:15:06,145 --> 02:15:10,691
You cannot vote against a
candidate. That's not in the rules.

1490
02:15:10,765 --> 02:15:15,205
To see the candidate, you have already
voted for, press the button at the bottom

1491
02:15:15,265 --> 02:15:20,259
left of the screen. And now that we're long
explanations, but we want don't want to

1492
02:15:20,308 --> 02:15:23,485
risk that there are mistakes or invalid

1493
02:15:23,605 --> 02:15:28,976
votes in the end. Please. For this test
vote, I invite you to proceed to the vote

1494
02:15:29,037 --> 02:15:34,437
for the election of the singers
Phil Collins or Jennifer Lopez.

1495
02:15:34,525 --> 02:15:37,585
The vote is open.

1496
02:15:52,225 --> 02:16:13,512
Has everyone voted? The vote is closed. And
the winner, very clear, is Phil Collins.

1497
02:16:14,005 --> 02:16:17,785
There is no check. It was
electronically. Sorry.

1498
02:16:18,025 --> 02:16:20,314
Was there a problem with
the voting machines?

1499
02:16:20,365 --> 02:16:24,521
Please I beg the technician
stop. Sorry, colleagues.

1500
02:16:24,565 --> 02:16:27,506
If everyone is shouting
around, we cannot proceed.

1501
02:16:27,565 --> 02:16:33,342
Is there a technical problem? Yes. Then I
please I beg the technicians to check if

1502
02:16:33,419 --> 02:16:39,094
it was possible to shift to the other
votes or not, because we had already we had

1503
02:16:39,162 --> 02:16:45,669
also votes for Mrs. Lopez. So take. Your
microphone if you want to come in, because

1504
02:16:45,711 --> 02:16:51,565
I don't hear otherwise.
Mr. Stefanutsa, please.

1505
02:16:55,045 --> 02:16:56,245
We can do another test.

1506
02:16:56,365 --> 02:17:00,788
We can do another test.
We can repeat the test.

1507
02:17:00,925 --> 02:17:04,045
Okay. Let's repeat the test,
because there was a problem.

1508
02:17:04,285 --> 02:17:05,605
To go up and down in the—

1509
02:17:05,665 --> 02:17:09,328
The up and down was not working, I
think. But we I can give the floor to Mr.

1510
02:17:09,385 --> 02:17:11,185
Stefanutsa, seat number eight, please.

1511
02:17:12,385 --> 02:17:16,707
Madam President, with the all respect, I
think members didn't quite get the cursor.

1512
02:17:16,765 --> 02:17:20,914
It happened to several people here. So
can you repeat the information on cursor?

1513
02:17:20,965 --> 02:17:25,045
How to switch between Collins?

1514
02:17:25,105 --> 02:17:28,710
So again, if you would have listened at
the beginning, I explained everything very

1515
02:17:28,760 --> 02:17:35,269
everything very detailed. Sorry. It
is on the right side, on the bottom.

1516
02:17:35,365 --> 02:17:42,128
You have the different small
black buttons under the screen.

1517
02:17:42,265 --> 02:17:48,660
And there you see the cursors. That are
also the buttons you have to press when you

1518
02:17:48,717 --> 02:17:51,433
want a blue card or
catch the eye or others.

1519
02:17:51,505 --> 02:17:55,461
But that are those on the right
side at the bottom of the screen.

1520
02:17:55,525 --> 02:18:03,135
Not the plus minus and and and against
button in the in the in the hole.

1521
02:18:03,205 --> 02:18:07,806
It's on the screen down on the
screen. So please let's check again.

1522
02:18:07,885 --> 02:18:17,658
I again open the test
vote. Does it work now?

1523
02:18:17,785 --> 02:18:27,742
Wonderful. So has. Everybody
had the possibility to choose?

1524
02:18:27,805 --> 02:18:38,686
It's candidate. And has everybody
voted? Then I close the vote.

1525
02:18:38,965 --> 02:18:46,694
And this time the result is
different. Jennifer Lopez.

1526
02:18:47,005 --> 02:18:58,969
Won the. Election with 379 votes.
And Phil Collins just said 126.

1527
02:18:59,245 --> 02:19:07,995
So then I think we are ready to come
to the real vote on our candidates.

1528
02:19:08,185 --> 02:19:19,689
And I open to the vote. I open the vote
for the real election of our candidate.

1529
02:19:19,765 --> 02:19:33,145
Please. The upload loans.

1530
02:19:49,465 --> 02:19:50,725
Has everybody voted?

1531
02:19:57,625 --> 02:20:00,745
They're asking to wait a second.
They're asking to answer.

1532
02:20:03,865 --> 02:20:12,085
Is there a technical problem? So
now again, has everybody voted?

1533
02:20:12,145 --> 02:20:25,400
Had everybody the chance to vote?
Is the technical problem solved?

1534
02:20:25,465 --> 02:20:29,721
Was it was there a technical problem?
No. So the problems are solved.

1535
02:20:29,785 --> 02:20:35,136
And then I close the vote.
And we have a result.

1536
02:20:35,185 --> 02:20:41,250
We have 579 members voting.
We had blank votes, 42.

1537
02:20:41,365 --> 02:20:51,916
We had votes that cast, 537.
Tilly Metz got 423 votes.

1538
02:20:52,525 --> 02:21:07,045
And Mrs. Rada, Lykova,
Mrs. Rada Lykova had 114.

1539
02:21:22,345 --> 02:21:30,484
Tilly Metz— Tilly Metz has obtained an
absolute majority of the votes cast.

1540
02:21:30,565 --> 02:21:35,955
And I declare Tilly Metz elected Vice
President of the European Parliament.

1541
02:21:36,025 --> 02:21:40,090
And should like to congratulate
her warmly on the election.

1542
02:21:40,165 --> 02:21:44,700
In accordance with Rule 20 of the Rules
of Procedure, the newly elected Vice

1543
02:21:44,754 --> 02:21:52,319
President shall take the place of her
predecessor in the order of precedent.

1544
02:21:52,585 --> 02:21:56,767
Now we come to the votes
on the report by Mr.

1545
02:21:56,845 --> 02:22:02,418
Marcin Zbigniewski. On the request of
the waiver of the immunity of Andraž

1546
02:22:02,510 --> 02:22:03,805
Tivadar-Kulya.

1547
02:22:04,645 --> 02:22:06,205
Can you just a second from the—

1548
02:22:06,325 --> 02:22:11,785
The machine has to reload the other
system, but I think that's done now, or?

1549
02:22:11,965 --> 02:22:12,445
Not yet.

1550
02:22:12,445 --> 02:22:14,005
Not yet. Not yet.

1551
02:22:14,305 --> 02:22:15,685
Or from election mode.

1552
02:22:16,345 --> 02:22:22,387
But that's not a roll call
vote. So who is in favor?

1553
02:22:22,525 --> 02:22:29,614
Who is against? Abstentions adopted.
Then we come to the report by Mr.

1554
02:22:29,785 --> 02:22:34,945
Dainius Zalimas on the request of the
waiver of the immunity of Aphrodite

1555
02:22:35,045 --> 02:22:40,851
Latinopoulou. And I ask who
is in favor? Who is against?

1556
02:22:40,945 --> 02:22:45,973
Abstentions adopted. Now we
come to the report by Mrs.

1557
02:22:46,045 --> 02:22:51,265
Lara Walters. On amendments of the statute
of members of the European Parliament as

1558
02:22:51,325 --> 02:22:56,125
regards proxy voting. And I give the
floor to the rapporteur for two minutes.

1559
02:23:01,585 --> 02:23:03,925
Thank you, very much. Is this working?

1560
02:23:04,465 --> 02:23:05,665
Yeah, yeah.

1561
02:23:06,025 --> 02:23:13,452
Colleagues, I am proud that we as the
European Parliament, over the years, have

1562
02:23:13,525 --> 02:23:18,773
improved the rights of Europeans when it
comes to maternity leave, paternity leave,

1563
02:23:18,846 --> 02:23:24,812
and parental leave. But at the same time,
we have not given some of those same

1564
02:23:24,874 --> 02:23:30,025
rights and possibilities to our
own members of Parliament yet.

1565
02:23:30,325 --> 02:23:35,422
Indeed, I have sometimes wondered whether
Europe's founding fathers ever thought

1566
02:23:35,485 --> 02:23:41,515
that a member of the European Parliament
could also be a young woman having a baby.

1567
02:23:41,725 --> 02:23:46,411
But those young women
exist. They are here now.

1568
02:23:46,525 --> 02:23:51,205
Myself included. And I know that
over the years they have struggled.

1569
02:23:51,325 --> 02:23:55,855
And why is that? Because those young
women, they don't take their parliamentary

1570
02:23:55,945 --> 02:24:00,852
duties lightly. They want to do
right by those who elected them.

1571
02:24:00,925 --> 02:24:06,614
But of course, naturally at the same time,
they want to be there for their newborns.

1572
02:24:06,685 --> 02:24:11,329
So today we're voting about
giving those young women options.

1573
02:24:11,425 --> 02:24:15,007
So that colleagues can vote for
them when they are not there.

1574
02:24:15,085 --> 02:24:19,345
And that's something that of course is a
given already in many national parliaments.

1575
02:24:19,405 --> 02:24:22,923
After all, this is a
question of democracy.

1576
02:24:23,005 --> 02:24:25,834
Am I glad that we're
taking this step today?

1577
02:24:25,945 --> 02:24:31,625
Yes, absolutely. Do I wish that today we
would be doing the same for young fathers

1578
02:24:31,682 --> 02:24:36,515
in the same position? Or maybe
those adopting children also?

1579
02:24:36,625 --> 02:24:50,212
Yes. Unfortunately, unfortunately, that
is something where member states are still

1580
02:24:50,275 --> 02:24:54,439
blocking. And that's a fight
that will need to keep fighting.

1581
02:24:54,565 --> 02:25:01,176
But in the meantime, today is a good day.
And I'd like to ask you to join me in

1582
02:25:01,242 --> 02:25:07,371
taking a step towards making this European
Parliament more modern, more fair, and

1583
02:25:07,465 --> 02:25:09,505
more representative. Thank you very much.

1584
02:25:16,405 --> 02:25:22,395
Voters. Thank you, Mrs. Walters.
And now we come to the vote.

1585
02:25:22,465 --> 02:25:26,788
We vote on Article 1, paragraph 1,
point B, original text in two parts.

1586
02:25:26,845 --> 02:25:31,608
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1587
02:25:31,705 --> 02:25:35,081
Second part, who's in
favor? Who's against?

1588
02:25:35,185 --> 02:25:40,956
Abstentions. We have to
check. I open the vote.

1589
02:25:41,125 --> 02:25:51,219
I. Close the vote. And it is adopted. Now
we come to Article 1, paragraph 1, point

1590
02:25:51,280 --> 02:25:56,979
E, original text in three parts.
First part, I who is in favor?

1591
02:25:57,085 --> 02:26:02,706
Who's against? Abstentions adopted.
Second part, who's in favor?

1592
02:26:02,785 --> 02:26:06,857
Who's against? Abstentions
again, I have to check.

1593
02:26:06,925 --> 02:26:19,307
I open the vote. I close
the vote. And it is adopted.

1594
02:26:19,405 --> 02:26:23,437
Third part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1595
02:26:23,545 --> 02:26:29,518
Abstention. That's the same majority.
So we now so it's reject adopted.

1596
02:26:29,605 --> 02:26:33,496
Now we come to a recital 5,
original text in three parts.

1597
02:26:33,565 --> 02:26:37,125
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1598
02:26:37,225 --> 02:26:40,401
Abstentions adopted. Second
part, who's in favor?

1599
02:26:40,465 --> 02:26:48,496
Who's against? Abstentions adopted.
Third part, who's in okay, we can check.

1600
02:26:48,685 --> 02:26:58,381
I open the vote. And
I close the vote. And.

1601
02:26:58,465 --> 02:27:01,174
It is adopted. It's the
same majority as before.

1602
02:27:01,225 --> 02:27:04,559
Now we come to the third
part, who's in favor?

1603
02:27:04,645 --> 02:27:10,887
Who's against? Abstentions. Adopted.
We come to recital 6 in two parts.

1604
02:27:10,945 --> 02:27:14,782
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1605
02:27:14,845 --> 02:27:19,962
Second part, who's in favor?
Against. Abstentions adopted.

1606
02:27:20,065 --> 02:27:23,789
Now we vote on the draft
legislative act as a whole.

1607
02:27:23,845 --> 02:27:28,017
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions.

1608
02:27:28,105 --> 02:27:32,494
Adopted. Now we come for
the motion of a resolution.

1609
02:27:32,605 --> 02:27:36,637
Amendment 1, who's in
favor? Who's against?

1610
02:27:36,745 --> 02:27:47,265
Abstentions. I have to check
that. I. Open the vote.

1611
02:27:47,665 --> 02:27:55,965
I close the vote. And it is rejected.
Now we come to the vote as a whole.

1612
02:27:56,065 --> 02:28:05,622
By roll call vote, I open
the vote. I close the vote.

1613
02:28:05,905 --> 02:28:16,345
And it is clearly adopted. Now
we come to the report by Mrs.

1614
02:28:16,405 --> 02:28:22,959
Leary Pagin and by Mr. Aurelius Veriga. On
the union civil protection mechanism and

1615
02:28:23,023 --> 02:28:27,943
union support for health emergency
preparedness and response.

1616
02:28:28,045 --> 02:28:32,761
The there is a proposal to
reject the commission proposal.

1617
02:28:32,845 --> 02:28:39,902
Amendment 339. By roll
call vote, I open the vote.

1618
02:28:40,045 --> 02:28:47,809
I close the vote. And it is rejected.
Now we come to the draft legislative act.

1619
02:28:47,965 --> 02:28:50,905
Amendments by the committee
responsible in a block vote.

1620
02:28:51,565 --> 02:28:55,922
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1621
02:28:56,005 --> 02:28:59,952
Amendment 9 in two parts.
First part, who's in favor?

1622
02:29:00,025 --> 02:29:07,381
Who's against? Abstentions adopted. Second
part, by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1623
02:29:07,705 --> 02:29:15,427
I close the vote. And. It is adopted.
Amendment 12, by roll call vote, I open the

1624
02:29:15,721 --> 02:29:23,302
vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted.

1625
02:29:23,365 --> 02:29:27,013
Amendment 14, who's in
favor? Who's against?

1626
02:29:27,085 --> 02:29:30,494
Abstentions adopted.
Amendment 38 in two parts.

1627
02:29:30,565 --> 02:29:34,384
First part, by roll call
vote, I open the vote.

1628
02:29:34,465 --> 02:29:40,071
And I close the vote. And.
It is clearly adopted.

1629
02:29:40,165 --> 02:29:44,479
Second part, also by roll
call vote, I open the vote.

1630
02:29:44,725 --> 02:29:55,068
I. Close the vote. And it is adopted.
Amendment 53, by roll call vote, I open the

1631
02:29:55,254 --> 02:30:01,579
vote. I close the vote. And it is adopted.

1632
02:30:01,645 --> 02:30:08,146
Amendment 138, by roll
call vote, I open the vote.

1633
02:30:08,305 --> 02:30:16,669
I close the vote. And it is adopted.
Amendment 314, by roll call 14, by roll call

1634
02:30:16,806 --> 02:30:22,751
vote, I open the vote.
And I close the vote.

1635
02:30:22,885 --> 02:30:27,662
And. It is clearly rejected.
We come to Amendment 341.

1636
02:30:27,745 --> 02:30:30,930
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions.

1637
02:30:30,985 --> 02:30:34,852
Rejected. Amendment 342.
Who's in favor? Against.

1638
02:30:34,945 --> 02:30:39,970
Abstentions. Rejected.
Amendment 343. Who's in favor?

1639
02:30:40,045 --> 02:30:45,397
Against. Abstentions.
Rejected. Amendment 353.

1640
02:30:45,505 --> 02:30:48,934
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions.

1641
02:30:48,985 --> 02:30:53,703
Rejected. We come to
Amendment 93. Who's in favor?

1642
02:30:53,785 --> 02:30:59,770
Who's against? Abstentions adopted.
Article 4, paragraph 1, Amendment 354.

1643
02:30:59,845 --> 02:31:05,311
Who's in favor? Against.
Abstentions. Rejected.

1644
02:31:05,485 --> 02:31:09,793
We come to Amendment 355.
Who's in favor? Who's against?

1645
02:31:09,865 --> 02:31:13,804
Abstentions. Rejected.
We come to Amendment 125.

1646
02:31:13,885 --> 02:31:17,528
Who's in favor? Against.
Abstentions adopted.

1647
02:31:17,605 --> 02:31:22,856
Amendment 337. By roll
call vote, who's in favor?

1648
02:31:22,945 --> 02:31:30,092
I open the vote. Sorry.
Yeah. I close the vote.

1649
02:31:30,205 --> 02:31:35,040
And it is clearly rejected.
We come to Amendment 344.

1650
02:31:35,125 --> 02:31:41,586
By roll call vote, I open the
vote. And I close the vote.

1651
02:31:41,725 --> 02:31:46,320
And it. Is rejected. We
come to Amendment 134.

1652
02:31:46,405 --> 02:31:50,108
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1653
02:31:50,185 --> 02:31:55,423
Amendment 345. By roll
call vote, I open the vote.

1654
02:31:55,525 --> 02:32:02,729
I. Close the vote. And it
is rejected. Amendment 135.

1655
02:32:02,845 --> 02:32:07,036
I who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1656
02:32:07,105 --> 02:32:13,369
100 300 356. Who's in
favor? Who's against?

1657
02:32:13,465 --> 02:32:14,305
Abstentions.

1658
02:32:14,305 --> 02:32:19,389
Rejected. Amendment 357.
Who's in favor? Who's against?

1659
02:32:19,465 --> 02:32:26,088
Abstentions. Rejected. 346. By
roll call vote, I open the vote.

1660
02:32:26,185 --> 02:32:34,181
I close the vote. And it
is rejected. Amendment 136.

1661
02:32:34,345 --> 02:32:38,231
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1662
02:32:38,305 --> 02:32:43,094
137. Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1663
02:32:43,165 --> 02:32:48,225
Amendment 333. By roll
call vote, I open the vote.

1664
02:32:48,325 --> 02:32:55,985
I. Close the vote. And it
is rejected. Amendment 347.

1665
02:32:56,125 --> 02:32:59,379
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions.

1666
02:32:59,425 --> 02:33:04,953
Rejected. Amendment 141.
Who's in favor? Who's against?

1667
02:33:05,065 --> 02:33:09,299
Abstentions adopted.
Amendment 348. Who's in favor?

1668
02:33:09,385 --> 02:33:13,881
Who's against? Abstentions.
Rejected. Amendment 202.

1669
02:33:14,005 --> 02:33:17,945
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1670
02:33:18,025 --> 02:33:22,110
358. Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions.

1671
02:33:22,165 --> 02:33:25,949
Rejected. 224. Who's in
favor? Who's against?

1672
02:33:26,005 --> 02:33:31,089
Abstentions adopted. 359.
Who's in favor? Who's against?

1673
02:33:31,165 --> 02:33:34,979
Abstentions. Rejected.
349. Who's in favor?

1674
02:33:35,065 --> 02:33:39,177
Who's against? Abstentions.
Rejected. Amendment 360.

1675
02:33:39,265 --> 02:33:42,311
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions.

1676
02:33:42,385 --> 02:33:46,797
Rejected. 231. Who's in
favor? Who's against?

1677
02:33:46,885 --> 02:33:51,603
Abstentions adopted.
35 350. Who's in favor?

1678
02:33:51,685 --> 02:33:55,369
Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 249.

1679
02:33:55,585 --> 02:33:59,051
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions.

1680
02:33:59,125 --> 02:34:03,665
Adopted. 351. Who's in
favor? Who's against?

1681
02:34:03,745 --> 02:34:10,137
Abstentions. Rejected.
338. And Amendment 352.

1682
02:34:10,285 --> 02:34:18,465
By roll call vote, I open the
vote. And. I close the vote.

1683
02:34:18,685 --> 02:34:29,175
And it is rejected. Amendments 255 to
261 and the Amendments 263 to 264 by the

1684
02:34:29,276 --> 02:34:33,916
committee. Who's in favor?
Who's against? Abstentions.

1685
02:34:33,985 --> 02:34:38,889
Adopted. Amendment 361. Who's
in favor? Who's against?

1686
02:34:38,965 --> 02:34:42,790
Abstentions. Rejected.
362. Who's in favor?

1687
02:34:42,865 --> 02:34:47,173
Who's against? Abstentions. Rejected. 262.

1688
02:34:47,305 --> 02:34:52,565
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1689
02:34:52,705 --> 02:34:57,775
So 363 falls, and we go
to 364. Who's in favor?

1690
02:34:57,865 --> 02:35:02,929
Who's against? Abstentions.
Rejected. Amendment 265.

1691
02:35:03,025 --> 02:35:06,979
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions adopted.

1692
02:35:07,045 --> 02:35:12,085
So Amendment 365 falls.
We go to Amendment 267.

1693
02:35:12,205 --> 02:35:19,263
2 sorry. Amendment 276
to 279. Who's in favor?

1694
02:35:19,345 --> 02:35:24,661
Who's against? Abstentions adopted.
So the original text falls.

1695
02:35:24,745 --> 02:35:30,237
We go to Amendment 334. By roll
call vote, I open the vote.

1696
02:35:30,325 --> 02:35:38,365
And I close the vote. And it is
rejected. Now we go to Amendment 366.

1697
02:35:38,485 --> 02:35:41,596
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions.

1698
02:35:41,665 --> 02:35:46,560
Rejected. 335. By roll
call vote, I open the vote.

1699
02:35:46,645 --> 02:35:55,922
I close the vote. And it is
rejected. Now we go to Amendment 8.

1700
02:35:56,005 --> 02:36:00,008
Who's in favor? Against.
Abstentions adopted.

1701
02:36:00,085 --> 02:36:04,500
Amendment 336. By roll
call vote, I open the vote.

1702
02:36:04,585 --> 02:36:13,495
And I close the vote. And it is rejected.
Now we come to the Commission proposal as

1703
02:36:13,600 --> 02:36:25,112
a whole. By roll call
vote, I open the vote.

1704
02:36:25,645 --> 02:36:31,569
And I close the vote. And it is adopted.
And now I give the floor to the rapporteur,

1705
02:36:31,620 --> 02:36:33,205
Mr. Mrs. Parin, please.

1706
02:36:34,885 --> 02:36:38,703
I would like to request referral back
to committee's responsibility for

1707
02:36:38,762 --> 02:36:42,205
interinstitutional negotiation
according to Rule 64.

1708
02:36:45,205 --> 02:36:48,528
We now vote on the referral
back. Who's in favor?

1709
02:36:48,625 --> 02:36:54,495
Who's against? Abstentions adopted. The
report is referred back to the committee for

1710
02:36:54,572 --> 02:36:59,224
interinstitutional negotiations
in accordance with Rule 60.

1711
02:36:59,305 --> 02:37:08,526
4. And now. We come to the report
by Madame Stéphanie Joncourtin.

1712
02:37:08,665 --> 02:37:13,846
On modernization, Stéphanie Joncourtin.
I think on modernization of the key

1713
02:37:13,900 --> 02:37:18,248
information document. And
we vote on Amendment 2.

1714
02:37:18,325 --> 02:37:24,707
By roll call vote, and I
open the vote. Stéphanie.

1715
02:37:24,985 --> 02:37:34,063
And I close the vote. And it is adopted.
Now we vote on the draft resolution

1716
02:37:34,165 --> 02:37:38,569
Amendment 3. Who's in
favor? Who's against?

1717
02:37:38,665 --> 02:37:43,152
Abstentions. Adopted. The first
reading of Parliament is closed.

1718
02:37:43,225 --> 02:37:48,410
Then we come to the report again by Madame
Stéphanie Joncourtin on union retail

1719
02:37:48,472 --> 02:37:54,582
investor protection rules. Amendment 2.
We vote on the provisional agreement.

1720
02:37:54,625 --> 02:37:59,487
Amendment 2. By roll call
vote, I open the vote.

1721
02:37:59,605 --> 02:38:13,454
And I close the vote. And it is rejected.
So the first reading is closed with the

1722
02:38:13,540 --> 02:38:17,164
rejection. Now. We come
to the report by Mr.

1723
02:38:17,245 --> 02:38:24,370
Christoph Clergeau on the European
Chemicals Agency and amending regulation.

1724
02:38:24,565 --> 02:38:30,301
So we vote on the provisional agreement.
By roll call vote, and I open the vote.

1725
02:38:30,385 --> 02:38:41,851
It's Amendment 117. And I close
the vote. And it is adopted.

1726
02:38:41,905 --> 02:38:45,588
So the first reading of
Parliament is closed.

1727
02:38:45,805 --> 02:38:53,205
Then we go to the report by Mr. Dainius
Salimas on geographical indications aligning

1728
02:38:53,290 --> 02:38:57,017
EU rules with changes to the
provisions under the Lisbon Agreement.

1729
02:38:57,085 --> 02:38:59,785
And I give the floor to the
rapporteur for two minutes.

1730
02:39:01,765 --> 02:39:07,025
Thank you. Chair. Dear colleagues, geographical
indications are an important part of

1731
02:39:07,099 --> 02:39:12,409
Europe's cultural and economic heritage.
They protect the reputation of regional

1732
02:39:12,467 --> 02:39:17,770
products support local producers and ensure
that consumers can trust the origin and

1733
02:39:17,823 --> 02:39:23,566
quality of the products they buy. But for
this protection to be effective, our rules

1734
02:39:23,655 --> 02:39:27,483
must be aligned with an
international system.

1735
02:39:27,565 --> 02:39:30,588
Therefore, the purpose of this
proposal is straightforward:

1736
02:39:30,650 --> 02:39:35,160
to align EU legislation with the updated
rules of the World Intellectual Property

1737
02:39:35,217 --> 02:39:39,994
Organization's Lisbon system to
which the European Union is a party.

1738
02:39:40,165 --> 02:39:44,427
This updated international rules allow
changes to existing registrations of

1739
02:39:44,485 --> 02:39:50,346
geographical indications, including changes
to product names, types, geographical

1740
02:39:50,417 --> 02:39:56,869
areas, and product characteristics. Our
task was to ensure that EU legislation was

1741
02:39:56,977 --> 02:40:02,083
can accommodate these changes while
maintaining legal certainty and avoiding

1742
02:40:02,145 --> 02:40:08,316
unnecessary administrative burdens. The
agreement we have reached strikes this

1743
02:40:08,417 --> 02:40:13,416
balance. Changes to product names or
classifications will continue to trigger

1744
02:40:13,481 --> 02:40:18,508
updates at international level while purely
administrative changes to geographical

1745
02:40:18,565 --> 02:40:24,751
areas will not. Where changes are substantial,
member states will be able to request

1746
02:40:24,805 --> 02:40:29,134
an international update. This makes the
system more practical, proportionate,

1747
02:40:29,185 --> 02:40:32,757
without weakening the protection
of geographical indications.

1748
02:40:32,845 --> 02:40:35,938
We achieved broad political
consensus on this file.

1749
02:40:36,025 --> 02:40:40,063
Therefore, I would like to thank my colleagues,
the shadow rapporteurs, and everyone

1750
02:40:40,115 --> 02:40:43,385
involved for their
constructive cooperation.

1751
02:40:43,465 --> 02:40:45,505
I invite you to support
this report. Thank you.

1752
02:40:47,665 --> 02:40:52,388
Thank you very much. Now we vote on the
provisional agreement Amendment 36 by the

1753
02:40:52,459 --> 02:40:58,612
committee. By roll call
vote, I open the vote.

1754
02:40:58,765 --> 02:41:03,508
I close the vote. And.
It is clearly adopted.

1755
02:41:03,565 --> 02:41:06,723
So the first reading of
Parliament is closed.

1756
02:41:06,865 --> 02:41:11,961
Now we come to the report by Mr. Barry
Andrews on the Association of the Overseas

1757
02:41:12,016 --> 02:41:17,603
Countries and Territories with the EU,
including EU, Greenland, Denmark relations.

1758
02:41:17,665 --> 02:41:20,125
And I give the floor to the
rapporteur for two minutes.

1759
02:41:23,305 --> 02:41:27,810
President, colleagues, strategic rivalry
is reaching the places where Europe's

1760
02:41:27,865 --> 02:41:30,626
overseas countries and
territories are located.

1761
02:41:30,685 --> 02:41:33,697
They are not peripheral to our
interests. They are central to them.

1762
02:41:33,745 --> 02:41:37,764
They are political partners in renewable
energy, critical raw materials, research,

1763
02:41:37,812 --> 02:41:41,731
and climate. And these countries and
territories are also economic partners.

1764
02:41:41,785 --> 02:41:46,029
And that is why the Parliament is pushing
for increased EU financial support.

1765
02:41:46,105 --> 02:41:49,989
However, funding on paper is not enough.
Many of these territories have limited

1766
02:41:50,032 --> 02:41:54,756
administrative resources. And EU
programs can be complex to access.

1767
02:41:54,865 --> 02:41:59,368
So this report calls for simplified access
to EU programs and for practical help in

1768
02:41:59,430 --> 02:42:03,640
navigating complex financial tools. I
welcome the Global Gateway Investments now

1769
02:42:03,685 --> 02:42:08,265
being made in these territories. But
investments must produce results in education,

1770
02:42:08,345 --> 02:42:12,800
skills, health, connectivity, and
jobs for people who live there.

1771
02:42:12,865 --> 02:42:17,500
In an age of great power rivalry, Europe
will not win friends by outspending others.

1772
02:42:17,545 --> 02:42:21,718
We will win them by being the partner that
listens, a partner that arrives not with

1773
02:42:21,776 --> 02:42:26,049
a flagship project and a photo opportunity,
but with respect, patience, and a

1774
02:42:26,110 --> 02:42:29,435
genuine commitment to the people
who call these places home.

1775
02:42:29,545 --> 02:42:33,428
That is the difference between a sphere
of influence and genuine partnership.

1776
02:42:33,505 --> 02:42:37,025
As many of you know, colleagues, this
file has overlapped with an extremely

1777
02:42:37,087 --> 02:42:42,224
stressful time for Greenlanders. The
resolution of that issue for now is a testament

1778
02:42:42,289 --> 02:42:47,516
to Greenlanders' patience and wisdom,
to the steadfast and quiet diplomacy of

1779
02:42:47,579 --> 02:42:51,246
Denmark, and to unequivocal
European solidarity.

1780
02:42:51,325 --> 02:42:55,194
Greenlanders have a guiding principle and
it should be ours too, nothing about us

1781
02:42:55,258 --> 02:43:00,079
without us. I thank the shadows and the
Denver Secretariat and commend the report to

1782
02:43:00,119 --> 02:43:01,319
the House. Thank you.

1783
02:43:02,845 --> 02:43:08,570
Thank. You very much. We now come to the
votes on the amendments by the committee

1784
02:43:08,628 --> 02:43:11,704
responsible on the block
vote. Who is in favor?

1785
02:43:11,785 --> 02:43:16,647
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted.
We come to amendments by the committee

1786
02:43:16,698 --> 02:43:19,469
responsible in separate vote.
Amendment 15 in two parts.

1787
02:43:19,525 --> 02:43:22,517
First part, who is in
favor? Who's against?

1788
02:43:22,585 --> 02:43:25,293
Abstentions? Adopted. Second
part, who is in favor?

1789
02:43:25,345 --> 02:43:29,473
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted.
Amendment 20, who is in favor?

1790
02:43:29,545 --> 02:43:33,856
Who's against? Abstentions?
Adopted. Amendment 24 in two parts.

1791
02:43:33,925 --> 02:43:36,377
First part, who is in
favor? Who's against?

1792
02:43:36,445 --> 02:43:39,097
Abstentions? Adopted. Second
part, who is in favor?

1793
02:43:39,145 --> 02:43:43,854
Who's against? Abstentions?
Adopted. Amendment 27 in two parts.

1794
02:43:43,945 --> 02:43:46,397
First part, who is in
favor? Who's against?

1795
02:43:46,465 --> 02:43:49,175
Abstentions? Adopted. Second
part, who is in favor?

1796
02:43:49,225 --> 02:43:53,647
Who's against? Abstentions?
Adopted. Amendment 50 in two parts.

1797
02:43:53,725 --> 02:43:56,177
First part, who is in
favor? Who's against?

1798
02:43:56,245 --> 02:43:58,837
Abstentions? Adopted. Second
part, who is in favor?

1799
02:43:58,885 --> 02:44:03,014
Who's against? Abstentions?
Adopted. Amendment 51 in two parts.

1800
02:44:03,085 --> 02:44:05,309
First part, who is in
favor? Who's against?

1801
02:44:05,365 --> 02:44:07,897
Abstentions? Adopted. Second
part, who is in favor?

1802
02:44:07,945 --> 02:44:13,641
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted.
Amendment 83 by roll call vote, I open the

1803
02:44:13,813 --> 02:44:25,747
vote. And. I close the
vote. And it is rejected.

1804
02:44:25,885 --> 02:44:31,973
Now we come to Amendment
89, who is in favor?

1805
02:44:32,065 --> 02:44:38,575
Who's against? Abstentions?
Sorry. Who's in favor?

1806
02:44:38,665 --> 02:44:43,687
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. We
come to Amendment 52, who is in favor?

1807
02:44:43,765 --> 02:44:48,861
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted.
Amendment 66, who is in favor?

1808
02:44:48,925 --> 02:44:54,188
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted.
Amendment 87, who is in favor?

1809
02:44:54,265 --> 02:44:57,875
Who's against? Abstentions?
Sorry, it failed.

1810
02:44:57,925 --> 02:45:02,793
Sorry, we wouldn't have to vote
on this. So Amendment 87 falls.

1811
02:45:02,905 --> 02:45:07,157
We come to Amendment 88, who
is in favor? Who's against?

1812
02:45:07,225 --> 02:45:11,381
Abstentions? Rejected. Now we vote on the
commission proposal by roll call vote.

1813
02:45:11,425 --> 02:45:21,571
I open the vote. And. I close
the vote. And it is adopted.

1814
02:45:21,685 --> 02:45:29,838
Now we come to the report by Mr. Vlad
Vasile Voiculescu on Europe's Beating Cancer

1815
02:45:29,916 --> 02:45:32,977
Plan. We vote on the original
text of paragraph two.

1816
02:45:33,025 --> 02:45:36,394
Who's in favor? Who's
against? Abstentions?

1817
02:45:36,445 --> 02:45:40,465
Adopted. We vote on paragraph
17, original text in three parts.

1818
02:45:40,645 --> 02:45:43,389
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1819
02:45:43,465 --> 02:45:48,663
Abstentions? Adopted. Second part,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1820
02:45:48,745 --> 02:45:57,000
And I close the vote. And it is adopted.
Third part, who also by roll call vote, I

1821
02:45:57,156 --> 02:46:06,465
open the vote. I close the
vote. And it is adopted.

1822
02:46:06,625 --> 02:46:13,108
Now we come to Amendment 2, paragraph
19, by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1823
02:46:13,225 --> 02:46:22,910
I close the vote. And it is rejected.
Amendment 14, by roll call vote, I open the

1824
02:46:23,146 --> 02:46:29,968
vote. I close the vote.
And it is rejected.

1825
02:46:30,025 --> 02:46:36,583
Amendment 12, by roll call
vote, I open the vote.

1826
02:46:36,865 --> 02:46:45,634
I close the vote. And it is rejected. Now
we vote on the original text in two parts.

1827
02:46:45,685 --> 02:46:50,738
First part, by roll call
vote, I open the vote.

1828
02:46:50,845 --> 02:46:58,789
I close the vote. It is adopted. And the
second part, also by roll call vote, I open

1829
02:46:59,005 --> 02:47:06,333
the vote. And I close the
vote. And it is also adopted.

1830
02:47:06,385 --> 02:47:09,996
Now we come to paragraph 22,
original text in two parts.

1831
02:47:10,045 --> 02:47:12,729
First part, who is in
favor? Who's against?

1832
02:47:12,805 --> 02:47:18,352
Abstentions? Adopted. Second part,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1833
02:47:18,445 --> 02:47:27,232
I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now
we come to Amendment 3, by roll call vote,

1834
02:47:27,374 --> 02:47:34,684
I open the vote. I close the
vote. And it is rejected.

1835
02:47:34,765 --> 02:47:37,055
We come now to the
original text in two parts.

1836
02:47:37,105 --> 02:47:39,501
First part, who is in
favor? Who's against?

1837
02:47:39,565 --> 02:47:45,113
Abstentions? Adopted. Second part,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1838
02:47:45,205 --> 02:47:50,796
And I close the vote. And
it is clearly adopted.

1839
02:47:50,845 --> 02:47:57,907
Now we come to Amendment 4, by
roll call vote, I open the vote.

1840
02:47:58,045 --> 02:48:05,014
I close the vote. It is rejected. Now we
vote on the original text in three parts.

1841
02:48:05,065 --> 02:48:07,945
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1842
02:48:08,005 --> 02:48:12,849
Abstentions? Adopted. Second part,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1843
02:48:12,925 --> 02:48:25,394
I close the vote. And it is adopted. Third
part, by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1844
02:48:25,525 --> 02:48:29,365
And I close the vote.
And it is also adopted.

1845
02:48:29,425 --> 02:48:34,534
Now we vote on Amendment 15, by
roll call vote, I open the vote.

1846
02:48:34,645 --> 02:48:40,522
And. I close the vote. And it is rejected.

1847
02:48:40,585 --> 02:48:42,875
Now we vote on the
original text in two parts.

1848
02:48:42,925 --> 02:48:48,272
First part, also by roll
call vote. I open the vote.

1849
02:48:48,325 --> 02:48:54,843
Sorry. And I close it. It's. Adopted. The
second part, also by roll call vote, I

1850
02:48:54,886 --> 02:49:00,025
open the vote. I close the vote.

1851
02:49:02,965 --> 02:49:08,616
And it is adopted. Now we come to Amendment
16, also by roll call vote, I open the

1852
02:49:08,709 --> 02:49:15,322
vote. And I close the
vote. And it is rejected.

1853
02:49:15,385 --> 02:49:20,083
We come to Amendment 5, by
roll call. I open the vote.

1854
02:49:20,245 --> 02:49:26,782
And I. Close the vote. And it is rejected.

1855
02:49:26,845 --> 02:49:29,076
Now we vote on the
original text in two parts.

1856
02:49:29,125 --> 02:49:34,141
First part, by roll call
vote. I. Open the vote.

1857
02:49:34,225 --> 02:49:44,075
And I close the vote. It's adopted. Second
part, by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1858
02:49:44,185 --> 02:49:48,335
And I close the vote.
And it's also adopted.

1859
02:49:48,385 --> 02:49:53,355
Now we come to Amendment 17, by
roll call vote, I open the vote.

1860
02:49:53,485 --> 02:50:01,023
I. Close the vote. And it is rejected.
We come now to the original text in three

1861
02:50:01,071 --> 02:50:05,870
parts, all by roll call vote.
The first part, I open the vote.

1862
02:50:05,965 --> 02:50:14,941
I close the vote. It's adopted.
Second part, I open the vote.

1863
02:50:15,085 --> 02:50:22,230
I close the vote. And it is
adopted. Third part, by roll call.

1864
02:50:22,285 --> 02:50:30,112
Again, I open the vote.
And I close the vote.

1865
02:50:30,265 --> 02:50:35,972
And it is adopted. Now we come to Amendment
18, also by roll call vote, I open the

1866
02:50:36,074 --> 02:50:42,433
vote. And. I close the
vote. And it is rejected.

1867
02:50:42,505 --> 02:50:46,505
Amendment 6, by roll call
vote, I open the vote.

1868
02:50:46,885 --> 02:50:53,290
And. I close the vote. And it is rejected.

1869
02:50:53,365 --> 02:50:56,537
Now we come to the original
text in four parts.

1870
02:50:56,605 --> 02:51:00,977
First part, I who's in
favor? Who's against?

1871
02:51:01,045 --> 02:51:03,343
Abstentions? Adopted.
Second part, by roll call.

1872
02:51:03,385 --> 02:51:10,838
Who's in favor? Sorry. I open the
vote. Yeah, I wanted to make it fixed.

1873
02:51:10,945 --> 02:51:21,913
I close the vote. It's adopted.
Third part, I open the vote.

1874
02:51:22,045 --> 02:51:34,003
I. Close the vote. And it is adopted.
Fourth part, I open the vote.

1875
02:51:34,165 --> 02:51:43,127
And I close the vote. And it is adopted.
Now we come to Amendment 7, also by roll

1876
02:51:43,234 --> 02:51:49,719
call vote, I open the
vote. And I close the vote.

1877
02:51:49,885 --> 02:51:53,375
And it is rejected. Now we come
to the original text in two parts.

1878
02:51:53,425 --> 02:51:56,293
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1879
02:51:56,365 --> 02:52:01,030
Abstentions? Adopted. Second part,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1880
02:52:01,105 --> 02:52:10,548
And I close the vote. And it is adopted.
Now we come to paragraph 31, original text

1881
02:52:10,614 --> 02:52:16,049
in two parts, by roll call vote.
First part, I open the vote.

1882
02:52:16,165 --> 02:52:21,725
And. I close the vote. And. It is adopted.

1883
02:52:21,865 --> 02:52:25,685
Second part, by roll call
vote, I open the vote.

1884
02:52:25,765 --> 02:52:35,675
And I close the vote. It is adopted. Now
we come to paragraph 32, original text in

1885
02:52:35,745 --> 02:52:38,665
two parts, also both parts,
by roll call vote, I open

1886
02:52:38,785 --> 02:52:46,135
the vote for the first
part. And. I close the vote.

1887
02:52:46,345 --> 02:52:52,753
It's adopted. Second
part, I open the vote.

1888
02:52:52,945 --> 02:53:00,781
And I close the vote. And it is adopted.
Now we come to Amendment 19, by roll call

1889
02:53:00,828 --> 02:53:10,384
vote, I open the vote. I close
the vote. And it is rejected.

1890
02:53:10,465 --> 02:53:14,239
Amendment 8, by roll call
vote, I open the vote.

1891
02:53:14,425 --> 02:53:24,589
I close the vote. And it is rejected.
Amendment 20, by roll call vote, I open the

1892
02:53:24,757 --> 02:53:32,527
vote. I close the vote.
And it is rejected.

1893
02:53:32,605 --> 02:53:35,916
Now we come to the original
text in three parts.

1894
02:53:35,965 --> 02:53:38,537
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1895
02:53:38,605 --> 02:53:43,213
Abstentions? Adopted. Second part,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1896
02:53:43,285 --> 02:53:53,404
I close the vote. And it is adopted. Third
part, by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1897
02:53:53,485 --> 02:54:02,405
I close the vote. And it is adopted. Now
we come to paragraph 36, original text in

1898
02:54:02,475 --> 02:54:08,861
three parts, all parts, by roll call
vote, I open the vote for the first part.

1899
02:54:08,965 --> 02:54:23,322
I close the vote. And it is adopted. I
open the vote for the second part, who's— I

1900
02:54:23,518 --> 02:54:33,015
close the vote. It's adopted. The third
part, by roll call, I open the vote.

1901
02:54:33,565 --> 02:54:40,226
I close the vote. It's adopted. Now we
come to Amendment 9, who's in favor?

1902
02:54:40,285 --> 02:54:44,369
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Amendment 10, who's in favor?

1903
02:54:44,425 --> 02:54:50,321
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Paragraph 107, original text in two parts,

1904
02:54:50,368 --> 02:54:54,575
both by roll call vote.
First part, I open the vote.

1905
02:54:54,685 --> 02:55:02,681
I close the vote. It's adopted.
Second part, I open the vote.

1906
02:55:02,785 --> 02:55:15,407
I close the vote. It's adopted. Paragraph
113, original text by roll call vote, I

1907
02:55:15,492 --> 02:55:21,921
open the vote. I close
the vote. It's adopted.

1908
02:55:21,985 --> 02:55:24,801
Now we come to Amendment
11, who's in favor?

1909
02:55:24,865 --> 02:55:30,381
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Recital U, original text, who's in favor?

1910
02:55:30,445 --> 02:55:37,319
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted.
Recital Z, Amendment 1, by roll call vote, I

1911
02:55:37,422 --> 02:55:44,665
open the vote. I close the
vote. And it is rejected.

1912
02:55:44,725 --> 02:55:48,006
Now we come to Amendment
13, who's in favor?

1913
02:55:48,085 --> 02:55:52,720
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. Now
we come to the resolution as a whole, by

1914
02:55:52,765 --> 02:56:01,468
roll call vote, I open the
vote. And I close the vote.

1915
02:56:01,765 --> 02:56:07,799
And it is adopted. Now we
come. To the report by Mr.

1916
02:56:07,885 --> 02:56:12,805
Salvatore De Meo on the EU Agri-food
promotion policy—and I give the floor to the

1917
02:56:12,985 --> 02:56:14,485
rapporteur for two minutes.

1918
02:56:17,245 --> 02:56:22,865
Grazie. Grazie, Presidente. Cari colleghi,
la relazione che stiamo per votare parte

1919
02:56:22,950 --> 02:56:27,599
da una semplice convinzione: se vogliamo
che la nostra agricoltura europea resti

1920
02:56:27,657 --> 02:56:31,672
competitiva, dobbiamo dare ai nostri
produttori gli strumenti per competere.

1921
02:56:31,765 --> 02:56:34,539
La politica europea di promozione
è uno di questi strumenti.

1922
02:56:34,585 --> 02:56:38,955
Aiuta le nostre imprese a raggiungere nuovi
mercati, a valorizzare e a far conoscere

1923
02:56:39,005 --> 02:56:41,899
nel mondo le nostre
eccellenze agroalimentari.

1924
02:56:41,965 --> 02:56:46,045
Non possiamo chiedere ai nostri agricoltori
di affrontare una concorrenza globale

1925
02:56:46,105 --> 02:56:50,985
sempre più aggressiva e non sempre corretta
e, allo stesso tempo, ridurre le risorse

1926
02:56:51,035 --> 02:56:54,135
e indebolire gli strumenti
che dovrebbero sostenerli.

1927
02:56:54,205 --> 02:56:59,903
Oggi servono regole più semplici e flessibili,
meno burocrazia e risorse finanziarie

1928
02:56:59,969 --> 02:57:03,749
adeguate. Questa relazione chiede alla
Commissione una politica di promozione più

1929
02:57:03,813 --> 02:57:07,445
efficace, più accessibile e, soprattutto,
alle piccole e medie imprese.

1930
02:57:07,525 --> 02:57:12,505
E, soprattutto, senza discriminazioni
ideologiche nei confronti di alcuni prodotti.

1931
02:57:12,565 --> 02:57:16,941
Investire nella promozione significa
sostenere il lavoro dei nostri agricoltori,

1932
02:57:17,005 --> 02:57:21,325
rafforzare la competitività delle nostre
imprese e creare nuove opportunità sui

1933
02:57:21,385 --> 02:57:25,884
mercati internazionali. Voglio ringraziare
tutti i relatori ombra per il contributo

1934
02:57:25,933 --> 02:57:30,155
che hanno dato e vi invito a sostenere
questa relazione, confermando la nostra

1935
02:57:30,222 --> 02:57:34,814
vicinanza a chi ogni giorno, con il suo
lavoro, garantisce la nostra sicurezza

1936
02:57:34,870 --> 02:57:36,070
alimentare. Grazie.

1937
02:57:37,885 --> 02:57:41,172
Thank you. Very much. Now
we proceed to the vote.

1938
02:57:41,245 --> 02:57:45,438
We vote on Amendment 13, by
roll call vote, I open the vote.

1939
02:57:45,505 --> 02:57:54,658
I close the vote. And it is rejected.
Amendment 3, who's in favor?

1940
02:57:54,745 --> 02:57:59,828
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Amendment 9, by roll call vote, I open the

1941
02:57:59,890 --> 02:58:08,341
vote. I close the vote.
And it is rejected.

1942
02:58:08,425 --> 02:58:11,932
We come to Amendment 4,
who's in favor? Against?

1943
02:58:12,025 --> 02:58:15,124
Abstentions? Rejected.
Amendment 5, in favor?

1944
02:58:15,205 --> 02:58:19,579
Against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Amendment 10, who's in favor?

1945
02:58:19,645 --> 02:58:24,274
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. We
come to the original text in six parts.

1946
02:58:24,325 --> 02:58:27,069
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1947
02:58:27,145 --> 02:58:31,285
Abstentions? Adopted. Second part,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1948
02:58:31,345 --> 02:58:43,345
I close the vote. It is adopted. Third
part, by roll call, I open the vote.

1949
02:58:43,405 --> 02:58:55,221
I close the vote. It's adopted. Fourth
part, by roll call, I open the vote.

1950
02:58:55,285 --> 02:59:07,190
I close the vote. And it's adopted. Fifth
part, by roll call, I open the vote.

1951
02:59:07,285 --> 02:59:17,785
I close the vote. It's adopted.
Sixth part, who's in favor?

1952
02:59:17,845 --> 02:59:22,600
Who's against? Please
show hand. Who's in favor?

1953
02:59:22,705 --> 02:59:30,126
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted.
Amendment 6 and Amendment 11, who's in favor?

1954
02:59:30,205 --> 02:59:34,898
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Amendment 7, by roll call vote, I open the

1955
02:59:34,945 --> 02:59:46,071
vote. I close. The vote. It's rejected. Now
we come to Amendment 14, who's in favor?

1956
02:59:46,165 --> 02:59:51,023
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Amendment 8, who's in favor?

1957
02:59:51,085 --> 02:59:55,645
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Amendment 1, who's in favor?

1958
02:59:55,705 --> 02:59:59,549
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Amendment 2, who's in favor?

1959
02:59:59,605 --> 03:00:03,867
Who's against? Abstentions?
Rejected. Original text in two parts.

1960
03:00:03,925 --> 03:00:06,493
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1961
03:00:06,565 --> 03:00:10,764
Abstentions? Adopted. Second part,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1962
03:00:10,825 --> 03:00:21,845
I close the vote. And it is adopted.
Amendment 12, by roll call vote, I open the

1963
03:00:21,985 --> 03:00:32,350
vote. I close the vote.
And it is rejected.

1964
03:00:32,425 --> 03:00:37,901
Now we come to the resolution as a whole,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

1965
03:00:38,005 --> 03:00:46,163
I. Close the vote. And
it is clearly adopted.

1966
03:00:46,225 --> 03:00:51,870
Now we come to the report
by—now. Come to the report by Mr.

1967
03:00:51,925 --> 03:00:57,445
Emanuele Cefalogiannis, on the
institutional aspects of artificial

1968
03:00:57,625 --> 03:01:01,675
intelligence in the context
of European integration.

1969
03:01:01,765 --> 03:01:05,580
We vote on the original text
of paragraph 27 in two parts.

1970
03:01:05,665 --> 03:01:08,009
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1971
03:01:08,065 --> 03:01:10,771
Abstentions? Adopted.
Second part, who's in favor?

1972
03:01:10,825 --> 03:01:14,695
Who's against? Abstentions?
I have to check that.

1973
03:01:14,785 --> 03:01:26,353
I open the vote. I close the
vote. And it is rejected.

1974
03:01:26,425 --> 03:01:30,799
Now we come to paragraph 28 in two
parts. First part, who's in favor?

1975
03:01:30,865 --> 03:01:35,481
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Second part, who's in favor?

1976
03:01:35,545 --> 03:01:41,249
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted.
Paragraph 40, original text in two parts.

1977
03:01:41,305 --> 03:01:44,237
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1978
03:01:44,305 --> 03:01:47,067
Abstentions? Adopted.
Second part, who's in favor?

1979
03:01:47,125 --> 03:01:52,926
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected. We
come to paragraph 44, original text in two

1980
03:01:52,973 --> 03:01:55,657
parts. First part, who's
in favor? Who's against?

1981
03:01:55,705 --> 03:01:58,291
Abstentions? Adopted.
Second part, who's in favor?

1982
03:01:58,345 --> 03:02:01,479
Who's against? Abstentions?
That I have to check.

1983
03:02:01,525 --> 03:02:11,058
That was quite close. I open
the vote. I close the vote.

1984
03:02:11,365 --> 03:02:17,197
And it was clearly adopted. Please show
your hands clearly when I'm too quick.

1985
03:02:17,245 --> 03:02:22,643
Please tell me. Paragraph 58,
original text, who's in favor?

1986
03:02:22,705 --> 03:02:27,788
Who's against? Abstentions?
Rejected. Paragraph 59, in two parts.

1987
03:02:27,865 --> 03:02:31,049
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1988
03:02:31,165 --> 03:02:34,939
Abstentions? Adopted.
Second part, who's in favor?

1989
03:02:35,005 --> 03:02:42,514
Who's against? Abstentions? Rejected.
Paragraph 63, original text in two parts.

1990
03:02:42,565 --> 03:02:45,265
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

1991
03:02:45,325 --> 03:02:48,203
Abstentions? Adopted.
Second part, who's in favor?

1992
03:02:48,265 --> 03:02:51,691
Who's against? Abstentions?
That is again close.

1993
03:02:51,745 --> 03:03:03,153
We have to check. I open the
vote. And I close the vote.

1994
03:03:03,445 --> 03:03:09,537
And it is adopted. We come. To
Amendment 1, who's in favor?

1995
03:03:09,625 --> 03:03:15,773
Who's against? Abstentions?
Adopted. Original text in two parts.

1996
03:03:15,865 --> 03:03:18,829
From recital O, first
part, who's in favor?

1997
03:03:18,925 --> 03:03:22,413
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted.
Second part, who's in favor?

1998
03:03:22,465 --> 03:03:25,590
Who's against? Abstentions?
I have to check that.

1999
03:03:25,645 --> 03:03:34,600
Second part, I open the
vote. I. Close the vote.

2000
03:03:34,945 --> 03:03:40,169
And it is adopted. Now we come to
recital S, original text in two parts.

2001
03:03:40,225 --> 03:03:42,965
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

2002
03:03:43,045 --> 03:03:45,747
Abstentions? Adopted.
Second part, who's in favor?

2003
03:03:45,805 --> 03:03:47,005
Who's against?

2004
03:03:47,125 --> 03:03:53,841
Abstentions? Seems to be
rejected, but I have to check.

2005
03:03:53,965 --> 03:04:03,184
No, it's not rejected.
It's adopted. It's adopted.

2006
03:04:03,265 --> 03:04:08,100
Now we come to the resolution as a whole,
by roll call vote, I open the vote.

2007
03:04:08,185 --> 03:04:17,836
I close the vote. I close
the vote. It's adopted.

2008
03:04:17,905 --> 03:04:23,460
Now we come to the report by Mr. Martin
Starkis, from prototypes to capabilities

2009
03:04:23,531 --> 03:04:28,431
enabling new defense actors to scale up.
We vote on the resolution as a whole, by

2010
03:04:28,477 --> 03:04:38,182
roll call vote, I open the
vote. I close the vote.

2011
03:04:38,605 --> 03:04:43,191
And it is adopted. Now we come to the joint
motion for a resolution tabled by five

2012
03:04:43,257 --> 03:04:48,917
groups on the Ukrainian children forcibly
deported to Russia or living in Russian

2013
03:04:48,985 --> 03:04:54,705
occupied territories in Ukraine. We vote
on paragraph 1, original text by roll call

2014
03:04:54,782 --> 03:05:03,586
vote, I open the vote. I
close the vote. It's adopted.

2015
03:05:03,685 --> 03:05:07,619
Paragraph 2, original text by
roll call vote, I open the vote.

2016
03:05:07,705 --> 03:05:19,519
I close the vote. It's adopted. Amendment
1, by roll call vote, I open the vote.

2017
03:05:19,765 --> 03:05:28,579
I. Close the vote. And it is rejected. Now
we come to paragraph 3, original text in

2018
03:05:28,629 --> 03:05:32,297
two parts. First part, who's
in favor? Who's against?

2019
03:05:32,365 --> 03:05:34,953
Abstentions? Adopted.
Second part, who's in favor?

2020
03:05:35,005 --> 03:05:39,625
Who's against? Abstentions? Adopted. Paragraph
4, original text by roll call vote, I

2021
03:05:39,745 --> 03:05:48,692
open the vote. I close the
vote. And it's clearly adopted.

2022
03:05:48,745 --> 03:05:53,361
Now we come to paragraph 5, original
text by roll call vote, I open the vote.

2023
03:05:53,425 --> 03:06:02,439
And I close the vote.
It's clearly adopted.

2024
03:06:02,485 --> 03:06:07,859
Now we come to Amendment 2, by
roll call vote, I open the vote.

2025
03:06:08,005 --> 03:06:16,532
And. I close the vote. It's rejected. Now
we come to original text in two parts.

2026
03:06:16,585 --> 03:06:18,921
First part, who's in favor? Who's against?

2027
03:06:18,985 --> 03:06:24,043
Abstentions? Adopted. Second
part, by roll call vote, I open.

2028
03:06:24,145 --> 03:06:33,188
And I close the vote. And it is adopted.
Now we come to Amendment 3, by roll call, I

2029
03:06:33,231 --> 03:06:42,271
open the vote. I. Close the
vote. And it is rejected.

2030
03:06:42,325 --> 03:06:50,685
Now we come to the resolution as a whole,
by roll call vote, and I open the vote.

2031
03:06:50,845 --> 03:06:57,565
And I close the vote. So it is adopted.
Thank you very much, colleagues.

2032
03:07:03,985 --> 03:07:05,845
Zügig. Zumindest.

2033
03:07:52,945 --> 03:07:57,776
Dear colleagues, I beg those who want to
leave the room now, do it quietly and quick

2034
03:07:57,833 --> 03:08:02,005
because we want to proceed with
the declaration of votes and

2035
03:08:02,305 --> 03:08:06,985
wir kommen nun zu den
Erklärungen, zu den Abstimmungen.

2036
03:08:08,365 --> 03:08:18,134
Please, colleagues, leave
the room quiet and quick.

2037
03:08:18,865 --> 03:08:21,025
I would like to come to the report.

2038
03:08:21,265 --> 03:08:27,051
Ich weiß, das ist in Deutsch jetzt. Ja.
Wir kommen nun zu den Erklärungen zur

2039
03:08:27,160 --> 03:08:32,163
Abstimmung. Und zunächst zum Bericht
Leire Pajin und Aurelio Ferriga,

2040
03:08:32,228 --> 03:08:36,158
Katastrophenschutzverfahren der Union
und Unterstützung der Union für die

2041
03:08:36,205 --> 03:08:39,576
Krisenvorsorge und Reaktion
bei gesundheitlichen Notlagen.

2042
03:08:39,625 --> 03:08:43,945
Und ich gebe das Wort an den Kollegen
Arkadiusz Mularczyk für eine Minute.

2043
03:08:44,485 --> 03:08:48,826
Please, colleagues, I beg you to have a
little bit of respect for those who want to

2044
03:08:48,865 --> 03:08:52,413
make a declaration of votes. Please
leave the room without talking.

2045
03:08:52,465 --> 03:08:57,415
You can walk without
talking. Please. So. Mr.

2046
03:08:57,505 --> 03:08:58,705
Mularczyk.

2047
03:08:59,425 --> 03:09:05,489
Dziękuję bardzo. Głosowałem przeciwko
rozporządzeniu w sprawie unijnego mechanizmu

2048
03:09:05,562 --> 03:09:08,906
ochrony ludności w brzmieniu
przyjętym przez parlament.

2049
03:09:08,965 --> 03:09:12,614
Popieram praktyczną współpracę państw
członkowskich w sytuacjach kryzysowych,

2050
03:09:12,671 --> 03:09:17,995
wymianę sprzętu ratowniczego, koordynację
ewakuacji medycznej, wspólne ćwiczenia i

2051
03:09:18,052 --> 03:09:20,916
wsparcie krajów, w których
zdolności zostały przeciążone.

2052
03:09:20,965 --> 03:09:24,636
Tak rozumiana solidarność
ma realną wartość dodaną.

2053
03:09:24,745 --> 03:09:29,803
Niestety tekst wykracza daleko poza ten cel
i instrumenty ochrony ludności stają się

2054
03:09:29,845 --> 03:09:32,515
narzędziem rozwijania
europejskiej Unii zdrowotnej.

2055
03:09:32,605 --> 03:09:37,427
Wprowadza szeroki katalog działań obejmujący
wspólne zamówienia leków, gromadzenie

2056
03:09:37,478 --> 03:09:42,560
strategicznych zapasów medycznych,
monitorowanie systemów krajowych oraz elementy

2057
03:09:42,609 --> 03:09:47,504
edukacji zdrowotnej. Brakuje jasnych zasad
własności zapasów i odpowiedzialności za

2058
03:09:47,557 --> 03:09:52,185
decyzje, oraz ich uwalnianie i ochrony
kompetencji państw członkowskich.

2059
03:09:52,285 --> 03:09:55,662
Rozporządzenie wyłącza też elementy
agendy klimatycznej i środowiskowej oraz

2060
03:09:55,714 --> 03:09:59,850
zacieśnia współpracę cywilno-wojskową
w tym poprzez uwzględnienie scenariuszy

2061
03:09:59,905 --> 03:10:05,321
obronnych i ocen wywiadowczych. Zamiast
usprawniać reagowanie na katastrofy, zaciera

2062
03:10:05,376 --> 03:10:10,265
granice między ochroną cywilną a polityką
zdrowotną i kwestiami obronności.

2063
03:10:10,345 --> 03:10:11,545
Dziękuję bardzo.

2064
03:10:16,585 --> 03:10:20,065
So the next speaker is Margo
Zata-Gorzkiewska for one minute.

2065
03:10:23,125 --> 03:10:27,862
Szanowni Państwo, debatowaliśmy o
gotowości Europy na zagrożenia zdrowotne.

2066
03:10:27,925 --> 03:10:32,893
Tymczasem polski system ochrony zdrowia
już dziś zmaga się z poważnym kryzysem.

2067
03:10:32,965 --> 03:10:37,815
Zobowiązania publicznych zakładów opieki
zdrowotnej przekroczyły 32 miliardy

2068
03:10:37,885 --> 03:10:42,482
złotych, z czego blisko 6
miliardów to długi przeterminowane.

2069
03:10:42,565 --> 03:10:45,380
Zamykane są porodówki
i oddziały szpitalne.

2070
03:10:45,445 --> 03:10:54,143
W 2025 roku zlikwidowano 27 oddziałów
położniczych, a od 2026 roku nie ma ich już w

2071
03:10:54,251 --> 03:10:59,330
136 powiatach. Pytam więc: jak państwo,
które ma problem z zapewnieniem obywatelom

2072
03:10:59,383 --> 03:11:04,107
podstawowej opieki zdrowotnej, przygotuje
się na epidemię, katastrofę czy zagrożenia

2073
03:11:04,165 --> 03:11:09,224
wojenne? Unijny mechanizm ochrony
ludności jest niezbędny, ale nie zastąpi

2074
03:11:09,289 --> 03:11:13,960
odpowiedzialności rządów krajowych.
Nie można mówić o gotowości na przyszłe

2075
03:11:14,014 --> 03:11:18,728
katastrofy, kiedy nie potrafi się
rozwiązać kryzysu, który trwa już dziś.

2076
03:11:18,805 --> 03:11:20,005
Dziękuję.

2077
03:11:21,685 --> 03:11:25,225
Thank you. The next speaker is
Piotr Müller, also for one minute.

2078
03:11:28,525 --> 03:11:32,356
Szanowni Państwo, wielokrotnie na tej
sali mamy do czynienia z dyskusją na temat

2079
03:11:32,399 --> 03:11:35,901
mechanizmów, które wspomagałyby
koordynację państw członkowskich.

2080
03:11:35,965 --> 03:11:40,447
Ja jestem za takimi mechanizmami, które
faktycznie tę współpracę wspomagają,

2081
03:11:40,525 --> 03:11:45,440
koordynują. Ale w tym mechanizmie, który
dzisiaj też głosowaliśmy i dyskutowaliśmy,

2082
03:11:45,505 --> 03:11:51,338
pojawiają się narzędzia, które centralizują
funkcjonowanie Unii Europejskiej.

2083
03:11:51,385 --> 03:11:54,405
Po raz kolejny zresztą. Szanowni
Państwo, ja apeluję o to, aby w kolejnych

2084
03:11:54,445 --> 03:11:58,825
dokumentach mówić o koordynacji, mówić
o współpracy, ale nie budować kolejnych

2085
03:11:58,885 --> 03:12:02,128
organów, które będą przejmowały
kompetencje państw członkowskich.

2086
03:12:02,185 --> 03:12:05,729
Naprawdę, my wszyscy jesteśmy w Unii
Europejskiej po to, żeby współpracować.

2087
03:12:05,785 --> 03:12:10,545
Żeby współpracować, koordynować swoją
działalność również właśnie w sytuacjach

2088
03:12:10,595 --> 03:12:14,098
kryzysowych. Ale nie starajmy
się budować centralnego państwa.

2089
03:12:14,185 --> 03:12:16,790
Nie możemy budować państwa
pod nazwą Unia Europejska.

2090
03:12:16,825 --> 03:12:21,619
Budujmy organizację, która się nazywa
Unia Europejska, złożona z niezależnych,

2091
03:12:21,685 --> 03:12:25,165
niepodległych państw, które chcą po
prostu razem wspólnie współpracować.

2092
03:12:26,965 --> 03:12:29,065
The next speaker is Jadwiga Wiżniewska.

2093
03:12:30,505 --> 03:12:35,952
Bardzo pani przewodnicząca. Szanowni
Państwo, bezpieczeństwo naszych obywateli i

2094
03:12:36,018 --> 03:12:40,910
ochrona ich życia to najbardziej
podstawowy obowiązek każdego państwa.

2095
03:12:41,005 --> 03:12:47,284
Działania Unii powinny polegać na koordynacji
i wspieraniu państw członkowskich tam,

2096
03:12:47,359 --> 03:12:52,978
gdzie skala kryzysu przekracza
możliwości pojedynczego państwa.

2097
03:12:53,065 --> 03:12:58,803
Unijny mechanizm ochrony ludności nie
może więc służyć przejmowaniu kompetencji

2098
03:12:58,866 --> 03:13:02,363
państw członkowskich i
zwiększaniu przy tym biurokracji.

2099
03:13:02,425 --> 03:13:07,830
Musimy zadbać, by środki unijne trafiały
na szkolenia ratowników, budowę rezerw

2100
03:13:07,895 --> 03:13:14,065
sprzętowych i wymianę doświadczeń, a nie
na ideologiczne projekty czy zawłaszczanie

2101
03:13:14,130 --> 03:13:18,724
kompetencji przez państw członkowskich
przez Komisję Europejską.

2102
03:13:18,805 --> 03:13:24,244
Potrzebujemy Europy silnych, bezpiecznych,
dobrze zorganizowanych i dobrze

2103
03:13:24,316 --> 03:13:27,773
współpracujących ze
sobą państw narodowych.

2104
03:13:27,865 --> 03:13:29,065
Dziękuję.

2105
03:13:30,445 --> 03:13:40,320
The. Bericht Vlad Vasile Voiculescu: Europas
Plan gegen Krebs und zunächst habe ich

2106
03:13:40,385 --> 03:13:42,985
für eine Minute Herrn Arkadiusz Mularczyk.

2107
03:13:50,245 --> 03:13:53,688
Wstrzymałem się od głosu w sprawie sprawozdania
dotyczącego wdrażania europejskiego

2108
03:13:53,733 --> 03:13:57,028
planu walki z rakiem w kształcie
proponowanym przez parlament.

2109
03:13:57,085 --> 03:14:00,645
Podzielam ogólne cele dokumentu, wzmocnienie
profilaktyki badań przesiewowych,

2110
03:14:00,691 --> 03:14:05,469
wczesnej diagnostyki, dostępu do innowacyjnych
terapii oraz poprawy jakości życia

2111
03:14:05,536 --> 03:14:09,640
pacjentów. Nie mogę jednak poprzeć zapisów,
które wprowadzają nieproporcjonalne

2112
03:14:09,694 --> 03:14:14,678
regulacje obciążenia fiskalne. W tym wyższe
akcyzy na tytoń, nikotynę, możliwości

2113
03:14:14,733 --> 03:14:19,197
jednolitych opakowań, nowe przepisy
dotyczące etykietowania alkoholu, oraz

2114
03:14:19,250 --> 03:14:22,708
obowiązkowe oznaczenie wartości
odżywczej z przodu opakowania.

2115
03:14:22,765 --> 03:14:26,701
Takie rozwiązania uderzają w tradycyjne
produkty europejskie, w tym wino,

2116
03:14:26,767 --> 03:14:30,925
ograniczają kompetencje państw członkowskich
i nie są w pełni oparte na dowodach

2117
03:14:30,985 --> 03:14:34,728
naukowych. Brakuje też wystarczającego
rozróżnienia produktów tytoniowych i

2118
03:14:34,790 --> 03:14:37,765
nikotynowych według
rzeczywistego profilu ryzyka.

2119
03:14:37,825 --> 03:14:46,031
Można odnieść wrażenie, że ta rezolucja
dotyczy częściowo dobrych założeń, ale nie

2120
03:14:46,126 --> 03:14:49,829
proponuje właściwego
kierunku walki z rakiem.

2121
03:14:49,885 --> 03:14:52,412
Z tych powodów nie mogłem
poprzeć tego projektu.

2122
03:14:52,465 --> 03:14:53,665
Dziękuję.

2123
03:14:54,745 --> 03:14:58,225
Die nächste Rednerin ist Margo
Zata-Gorzkiewska, auch für eine Minute, bitte.

2124
03:14:59,485 --> 03:15:04,099
Szanowni Państwo, europejska walka
z rakiem miała być priorytetem.

2125
03:15:04,165 --> 03:15:07,879
Tymczasem europejski Trybunał
Obrachunkowy alarmuje.

2126
03:15:08,005 --> 03:15:11,875
Z budżetu EU for Health
przesunięto miliard euro.

2127
03:15:11,965 --> 03:15:15,601
Przyszłość finansowania po
2027 roku jest niepewna.

2128
03:15:15,685 --> 03:15:21,189
Inicjatywy częściowo się dublują, a
Komisja nie stworzyła skutecznych ram

2129
03:15:21,252 --> 03:15:27,917
monitorowania rezultatów planu. Miliardy
euro strategie wielkie, a brakuje gwarancji

2130
03:15:27,993 --> 03:15:33,479
ciągłości działań. W Polsce również
deklaracje rozmijają się z rzeczywistością.

2131
03:15:33,565 --> 03:15:38,437
W Łodzi pacjentkę onkologiczną poinformowano
o niemożności rozpoczęcia terapii z

2132
03:15:38,510 --> 03:15:43,326
powodu braku finansowania. A termin leczenia
wskazano dopiero na pierwszy kwartał

2133
03:15:43,400 --> 03:15:48,531
przyszłego roku. Szpitale alarmują o
problemach finansowych i o zadłużeniu.

2134
03:15:48,625 --> 03:15:54,118
Jednocześnie media publiczne w likwidacji
otrzymały w pierwszym półroczu 2026 roku

2135
03:15:54,232 --> 03:16:00,733
1,2 miliarda złotych z budżetu państwa.
Kto odpowie za bezpieczeństwo pacjentów?

2136
03:16:00,805 --> 03:16:04,105
Rak nie czeka na decyzję
polityków. Rak zabija.

2137
03:16:07,405 --> 03:16:08,605
The need is

2138
03:16:08,905 --> 03:16:10,765
Rednerin ist Jadwiga Wiżniewska.

2139
03:16:12,145 --> 03:16:18,361
Dziękuję bardzo. Co roku w Unii Europejskiej
chorobę nowotworową diagnozuje się u

2140
03:16:18,577 --> 03:16:26,562
około 2 miliony 700 tysięcy ludzi. Bez
zdecydowanych i skoordynowanych działań na

2141
03:16:26,636 --> 03:16:35,138
poziomie unijnym liczba zachorowań w Europie
może rosnąć o blisko 1/4 do roku 2035.

2142
03:16:35,305 --> 03:16:41,275
Priorytetem Unii musi być efektywne wspieranie
państw członkowskich w profilaktyce,

2143
03:16:41,365 --> 03:16:47,138
badaniach przesiewowych, wczesnej diagnostyce
i innowacyjnych metodach leczenia i

2144
03:16:47,272 --> 03:16:55,143
poprawy jakości życia. Szczególną uwagę
musimy poświęcić także rzadkim nowotworom i

2145
03:16:55,240 --> 03:17:01,448
nowotworom wieku dziecięcego. Niestety
obecnie w Polsce sytuacja, jeśli chodzi o

2146
03:17:01,520 --> 03:17:09,288
choroby nowotworowe, jest dramatyczna.
Pacjenci są odsyłani bez koniecznej pomocy i

2147
03:17:09,365 --> 03:17:17,061
koniecznych procedur leczenia. Rząd nie
finansuje w sposób wystarczający leczenia

2148
03:17:17,159 --> 03:17:19,885
chorób nowotworowych.

2149
03:17:20,005 --> 03:17:20,845
Thank you very much.

2150
03:17:20,845 --> 03:17:22,045
I inne obszary.

2151
03:17:23,005 --> 03:17:26,605
And now we come to the
next report, Ukrainische

2152
03:17:26,785 --> 03:17:31,050
Kinder, die nach Russland deportiert wurden,
oder in von Russland besetzten Gebieten

2153
03:17:31,105 --> 03:17:36,085
in der Ukraine leben. Hier auch
zunächst Arkadiusz Mularczyk.

2154
03:17:36,205 --> 03:17:40,216
Dziękuję bardzo. Głosowałem za przyjęciem
rezolucji w sprawie deportacji i

2155
03:17:40,291 --> 03:17:44,305
przymusowego przemieszczania
ukraińskich dzieci przez Rosję.

2156
03:17:44,365 --> 03:17:50,588
Od 2014 roku na masową skalę od pełnoskalowej
agresji w 2022 roku rosyjskie władze

2157
03:17:50,642 --> 03:17:55,086
systematycznie porywają ukraińskie
dzieci celem ich rusyfikacji.

2158
03:17:55,165 --> 03:18:00,632
Indoktrynacji i militaryzacji. Według
ukraińskich władz zweryfikowano ponad 20

2159
03:18:00,700 --> 03:18:05,320
tysięcy takich przypadków, a rzeczywista
liczba jest prawdopodobnie znacznie wyższa.

2160
03:18:05,425 --> 03:18:10,084
Dzieci są pozbawiane tożsamości, poddawane
przymusowej adaptacji i przygotowane do

2161
03:18:10,163 --> 03:18:14,323
służby rosyjskiej armii. Takie działania
stanowią zbrodnię wojenną i zbrodnię

2162
03:18:14,365 --> 03:18:18,498
przeciwko ludzkości. W świetle konwencji
o zapobieganiu i karaniu zbrodni

2163
03:18:18,550 --> 03:18:22,795
ludobójstwa spełniają także znamiona
ludobójstwa poprzez przymusowe przenoszenie

2164
03:18:22,841 --> 03:18:25,850
dzieci z jednej grupy
narodowej do drugiej.

2165
03:18:25,945 --> 03:18:30,223
Rezolucja słusznie żąda natychmiastowego
wydania i zwrotu tych dzieci potępia udział

2166
03:18:30,271 --> 03:18:34,558
Białorusi, Korei Północnej oraz wzywa do
rozszerzenia sankcji, w tym wobec firm

2167
03:18:34,600 --> 03:18:36,895
państwowych takich jak Gazprom i Rosnieft.

2168
03:18:36,985 --> 03:18:40,525
Podkreśla też, że powrót dzieci musi
pozostać priorytetem w każdej przyszłej

2169
03:18:40,575 --> 03:18:43,725
negocjacji pokojowej. Z tych powodów
głosowałem za przyjęciem rezolucji.

2170
03:18:43,765 --> 03:18:44,965
Dziękuję bardzo.

2171
03:18:47,605 --> 03:18:48,925
Is Margo Zata-Gorzkiewska.

2172
03:18:50,485 --> 03:18:55,810
Szanowni Państwo, Rosja nie tylko
zabija ukraińskie dzieci, ona kradnie im

2173
03:18:55,874 --> 03:18:59,988
dzieciństwo, rodziny,
język, tożsamość i ojczyznę.

2174
03:19:00,085 --> 03:19:04,657
Ponad 20 tysięcy przypadków deportacji i
przymusowych przesiedleń ukraińskich dzieci

2175
03:19:04,705 --> 03:19:09,661
zostało już potwierdzonych. Dzieci
trafiają do rosyjskich rodzin i instytucji,

2176
03:19:09,736 --> 03:19:14,162
poddawane są rusyfikacji,
indoktrynacji i militaryzacji.

2177
03:19:14,245 --> 03:19:18,801
Uczy się je posłuszeństwa wobec reżimu
Putina, obsługi broni i przygotowuje do

2178
03:19:18,889 --> 03:19:22,958
służby w rosyjskiej armii. Polska
wie, czym jest taki proceder.

2179
03:19:23,005 --> 03:19:28,454
Niemieccy okupanci uprowadzili ponad 200
tysięcy polskich dzieci celem germanizacji.

2180
03:19:28,525 --> 03:19:33,470
Według szacunków IPN zaledwie
30 tysięcy udało się odzyskać.

2181
03:19:33,565 --> 03:19:38,654
W 2023 roku Międzynarodowy Trybunał Karny
wydał nakaz aresztowania dla Putina, a

2182
03:19:38,703 --> 03:19:41,528
dzieci nadal nie wróciły
do rodziców, do domów.

2183
03:19:41,665 --> 03:19:45,799
Żądamy ich powrotu, sankcji,
bezwzględnej odpowiedzialności sprawców.

2184
03:19:45,865 --> 03:19:50,694
Nie może być sprawiedliwego pokoju dopóki
ukraińskie dzieci nie wrócą do swoich

2185
03:19:50,749 --> 03:19:52,765
rodzin, do swojej ojczyzny. Dziękuję.

2186
03:19:54,565 --> 03:19:57,265
And the last speaker
is Jadwiga Wiżniewska.

2187
03:19:57,985 --> 03:20:04,597
Dziękuję bardzo. Pani Przewodnicząca,
ukraińskie dzieci są przymusowo deportowane do

2188
03:20:04,783 --> 03:20:10,382
Rosji. To te przymusowe deportacje
są absolutnie nielegalne.

2189
03:20:10,465 --> 03:20:13,927
Następuje rusyfikacja tych
dzieci i indoktrynacja.

2190
03:20:14,005 --> 03:20:19,717
To są elementy systemowej polityki Kremla,
której celem jest wymazanie ukraińskiej

2191
03:20:19,800 --> 03:20:24,934
tożsamości narodowej. Niestety jest
to znany modus operandi Rosji, która

2192
03:20:25,034 --> 03:20:28,633
doświadczała w przeszłości
również i Polska.

2193
03:20:28,705 --> 03:20:31,825
Której doświadczała w
przeszłości również i Polska.

2194
03:20:31,945 --> 03:20:37,441
Rosja odbiera dzieciom rodziny, domy,
język, historię i prawo do własnej ojczyzny.

2195
03:20:37,525 --> 03:20:40,872
To zbrodnia wojenna.
Stawiamy sprawę jasno.

2196
03:20:40,945 --> 03:20:45,323
Wzywamy Rosję do natychmiastowego
zaprzestania przesiedleń dzieci.

2197
03:20:45,385 --> 03:20:48,317
Ujawnienia ich miejsca
pobytu i tożsamości.

2198
03:20:48,385 --> 03:20:52,482
Unieważnienia procedur nadania
rosyjskiego obywatelstwa.

2199
03:20:52,585 --> 03:20:57,740
Domagamy się także pociągnięcia do
odpowiedzialności przed międzynarodowymi

2200
03:20:57,805 --> 03:21:01,615
trybunałami osób
odpowiedzialnych za te zbrodnie.

2201
03:21:01,705 --> 03:21:07,525
Żaden sprawiedliwy pokój z Rosją nie może
być zawarty kosztem ukraińskich dzieci.

2202
03:21:09,925 --> 03:21:14,165
Vielen Dank. Wir kommen nun zum Ende der
Erklärungen der persönlichen Erklärungen

2203
03:21:14,205 --> 03:21:18,334
zur Abstimmung. Die Protokolle der heutigen
und der gestrigen Sitzung werden im

2204
03:21:18,388 --> 03:21:21,963
Parlament zu Beginn seiner nächsten
Tagung zur Genehmigung vorgelegt.

2205
03:21:22,045 --> 03:21:26,118
Wenn es keine Einwände gibt, werde ich
in der heutigen Sitzung angenommenen

2206
03:21:26,168 --> 03:21:30,011
Entschließungen den in diesen Entschließungen
genannten Personen und Gremien

2207
03:21:30,080 --> 03:21:33,198
übermitteln. Die nächste
Tagung findet vom 23.

2208
03:21:33,265 --> 03:21:37,960
bis zum 26. November in Straßburg statt.
Die Sitzungsperiode des Europäischen

2209
03:21:38,009 --> 03:21:41,620
Parlaments ist unterbrochen. Die
heutige Sitzung ist hiermit geschlossen.

2210
03:21:41,670 --> 03:21:42,870
Vielen Dank.
