Brussels Live · Plenary sitting 2026-11-11 Transcribed and translated automatically from the original sound. Mistakes are possible. Machine translation. The original is authoritative. Independent service, not affiliated with the European Parliament or the European Commission. Source: © European Union. AI-generated: Transcripts, translations and summaries on this site are generated automatically by AI: speech recognition (Soniox), machine translation and summaries (Mistral AI). Not edited by humans before publication. EU AI Act, Article 50. [15:00:44] Roberta Metsola (PPE) [EN] Good afternoon, dear colleagues. Could I ask you, please, to take your seats? It's okay, it's okay. [15:01:09] Speaker 2 [EN] We'll wait for one minute for the colleagues to come in. [15:01:25] Speaker 2 [EN] It's okay. [15:01:42] Roberta Metsola (PPE) [EN] So, dear colleagues, at the 11th hour, on the 11th day of the 11th month in 1918, the guns fell silent on the western front. Today, we remember the millions whose lives were cut short, the families left waiting, and a generation forever changed. Remembrance also means honouring those who—a generation later—fought to defend and restore freedom in Europe. One of those heroines was Solange Alexandre, who passed away a few days ago at the age of 104, known as Scorlet. She led 30 resistance fighters against the Nazi occupation and helped liberate Turin in France. It is on us to carry their stories forward, to defend our freedom, and to protect the peace that they sacrificed so much to secure. [15:02:47] Roberta Metsola (PPE) [FR] To God, Ms Alexandre, we will never forget you. [15:02:52] Roberta Metsola (PPE) [EN] Now, dear colleagues, yesterday, severe weather led to a series of multi-vehicle crashes on Bulgaria's Trakia motorway. At least 11 people lost their lives, and many more were injured. On behalf of the European Parliament, we offer our deepest condolences to the families and loved ones of those who lost their lives. We thank the rescue services and medical teams who worked tirelessly at the scene, and everyone who came forward to donate blood. We were all shocked and appalled at the shooting in Kraków's main market square last Saturday afternoon. What should have been a peaceful afternoon turned into a senseless attack that left six people dead and more injured. Later, three more people were found dead in the perpetrator's home. We thank the European Parliament, and we thank the police officers at the scene, for acting quickly and bravely to stop the attacker. And the emergency services who helped bring the people to safety. [15:04:14] Roberta Metsola (PPE) [FR] Dear colleagues, this Assembly was also deeply shocked by the attack that took place in Trappes and La Verrière at the beginning of the month. One innocent man lost his life, and several other people were injured, including a 12-year-old girl. We pay tribute to the memory of Pengo Bosiovangi and express our deepest solidarity with all those whose lives have been shattered by this attack. No one should be targeted because of the colour of their skin. Of their origins, or of their religion. Racism has no place in our Europe. [15:05:13] Roberta Metsola (PPE) [EN] Now, dear colleagues, on the 28th of October, 2026, another tragedy occurred when a train collision in Urda, Spain, left 69 people dead and dozens more injured. On behalf of this House, I offer our deepest condolences to the families and friends mourning their loved ones. We share in their grief and wish all those injured a swift and full recovery. We also express our heartfelt gratitude to the emergency services who worked tirelessly at the scene of the disaster. So, dear colleagues, in memory of all those lost, I ask you to join me in observing a minute of silence. [15:06:42] Roberta Metsola (PPE) [EN] Thank you. Excuse me. Oh, sorry. Sorry. Thank you. [15:06:55] Speaker 2 [EN] If your announcements from my end, it is a pleasure to welcome Deputy Speaker of the Verhoevenaarade, Ms. Olena Kondraciuk, at the Diplomatic Gallery for this important mini. Plenary session. We're very happy to have you here, Olena. Welcome. The minutes and the texts adopted of the Sitting of the 22nd of October, 2026, are available. Are there any comments? No. Therefore, the minutes are approved. The competent authorities of Spain have notified me of the election of Antony Comini-Olivares to the European Parliament with effect from 22nd of October, 2026. I welcome our colleague and recall that he takes his seat in Parliament and his bodies in full enjoyment of his rights, pending the verification of his credentials. Parliament verifies the credentials of Balázs Orbán and of Robert Garbel with effect from 18 September, 2026. Pursuant to Rules 10 and 183 of the Rules of Procedure, and after taking into account the observations of the member concerned, I have decided to impose a penalty on Mr. Sebastian Tünkönen for disrupting the Sitting of 17 June, 2026, by engaging in improper behavior during the voting session and failing to comply with the Vice President's calls to proceed with the vote. The penalty consists of a reprimand the member concerned has been notified of this decision. He has not lodged an internal appeal with the Bureau under Rule 184. The penalty is therefore final. The competent authorities of Greece have addressed the request to me for the Parliamentary immunity of Nikos Papas to be waived. The competent authorities of Germany have addressed a request to me for the Parliamentary immunity of Arno Bausemer to be waived. The competent authorities of Poland have addressed a request to me for the Parliamentary immunity of Gregor Braun to be waived. These requests are referred to the Committee on Legal Affairs. The EPP PFE and ECR groups and the non-attached members have notified me of decisions relating to changes to appointments within committees and delegations. The decisions will be set out in the minutes of today's sitting and take effect on the date of this [15:09:15] Speaker 2 [EN] announcement. The Inter and Liber Afet and Dever Yuri and Liber and Liber committees have decided to enter inter-institutional negotiations pursuant to Rule 72, paragraph 1 of the Rules of Procedure. The reports, which constitute the mandates for the negotiations, are available on the plenary web page and the titles will be published in the minutes of the sitting. Pursuant to Rule 72, paragraph 2, members or political groups reaching at least a medium threshold may request in writing by tomorrow, Thursday, the 12th of November, at midnight, that the decisions be put to the vote. If no request for a vote in Parliament is made within the deadline, the committees may start negotiations. Tomorrow, we will proceed with the election of a Vice President of the European Parliament to replace Mr. Nicolao Stefanutsa. By the deadline of Tuesday, 10th November, at 7:00 p.m., I received the following nominations: Ms. Rada Lajková, nominated by the ESN group, and Ms. Tilly Metz, nominated by the Greens group. The candidates have confirmed to me their consent to their candidacies. As the number of candidates exceeds the number of seats, to be filled, tomorrow we shall hold a secret electronic ballot in accordance with Rule 17, paragraph 1 of the Rules of Procedure. Can I take this opportunity to thank Vice President Stefanutsa for the work that we have done together? Now, we come to the order of business. The revised final draft agenda, as adopted by the Conference of Presidents on 10th of November, pursuant to Rule 163, has been distributed. The agenda is adopted and the order of business is thus established. Mr. Buxader, if you have a point of order which is not a point of order, I ask you to make a one-minute speech, okay? Tonight, soon. We can give you the floor. One-minute speech. All right. Oh, my hand. Now, the next item on the agenda is statement by the Vice President of the Mr. Buxader, this is not a point of order. We are not going to have a point of order on the Spanish people. Okay? [15:11:44] Roberta Metsola (PPE) [EN] We are going to have one-minute speech. I will give you a one-minute speech. Give me a second. I will give you the one-minute speech. But first, I will—this has nothing to do with order of the day. The next item on the agenda is statement by the Vice President of the Commission, High Representative, for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy. Ukrainian children forcibly deported to Russia or living in Russian-occupied territories in Ukraine. I'd like to inform members that there will be only one round of political group speakers for this debate. Therefore, there's no catch-die procedure and no blue cards will be accepted. I give the floor to Ms. Kayakallas. And then we will have the one-minute speeches. Don't worry. [15:12:29] Kaja Kallas [EN] The President, Honorable Members, as we hold this debate, talks between Ukrainian and Russian officials have taken place in Abu Dhabi. These allow Ms. Kayakallas to speak. The EU has always supported efforts for a just and lasting peace in Ukraine. The only problem is that Russia shows no signs that it's ready to seriously negotiate. The treatment of Ukrainian children over the last four years is the clearest example of Russia's total disregard of life. It is Russian government policy, approved by Putin himself, to deport Ukrainian children from occupied areas of Ukraine to Russia over 20,000 children have been illegally deported. This year, the OSCE published a report detailing a state-orchestrated campaign in temporary-occupied territories to erase Ukrainian identity of children from early childhood onward. All evidence points to a crime against humanity. Back. In 2025, I welcomed the Parliament's resolution on this topic, but three MEPs voted against it, and there were 34 abstentions. If the information you have by now does not convince you, I don't know what will. In a sick and twisted turn of events, in a sick and twisted turn of events, it is likely that stolen Ukrainian children are now being sent back by Russia to fight against Ukraine. Honorable Members, Russia can only run its horrific system of child deportation indoctrination and illegal adoption thanks to the network of people and entities. That is why the European Union has sanctioned the people and entities responsible. Most recently, we have extended the list to include more children's camps, including Songda-1 International Children's Camp in North Korea, where Ukrainian children were found. Russia abducts children. North Korea, indoctrinates them. That is how dictatorships divide labor. In parallel, Europe's efforts to support Ukrainian children continue on other tracks: diplomacy, ensures the world does not lose sight of these children. In December 2025, the EU co-sponsored the UN General Assembly resolution, which called on the UN [15:15:21] Kaja Kallas [EN] Secretary-General to engage directly with Russia to locate the children, assess their health, and legal status, and secure their return. Now we need to see concrete follow-up on this. We have hosted and participated in multiple events, including the International Coalition for the Return of Ukrainian Children, and this is important for awareness-raising and sharing information on where our efforts need to focus next. The European Union remains the biggest supporter of accountability efforts, including the work of the International Criminal Court—let us not forget that there are two ICC arrest warrants for Vladimir Putin and Maria Lvova-Belova for these crimes. EU funding also supports Ukrainian children in a variety of ways. Recent examples include close to 30 million euro in humanitarian aid to support Ukrainian children and children's facilities, 10 million euro to provide education and learning support for children and teachers, 5 million euro to restore access to local education systems in war-affected communities, and 4 million euro to deported Ukrainian children, including 1. 75 million euro for accountability efforts for crimes related to deportations. The ultimate goal, of course, is to bring the kids home. International efforts are working. As of this month, 2,790 Ukrainian children have been returned, including 13 children and teenagers last week. One of them, Luka, had just reached 18, and received Russian military draft notice. But each time a child comes home with the stories of the threats they have endured, psychological pressure, and life-threatening living conditions, it is another reminder of why we must explore every window of opportunity. The Oleshky ceasefire shows that Russia can, and the suffering of Ukrainian people, if it wants to. Russia has claimed in the past to be carrying out humanitarian evacuations, but still, Russian system exists to systematically repatriate Ukrainian children. If Russia was serious about protecting Ukrainian children, it would immediately start with establishing safe regular [15:17:54] Kaja Kallas [EN] communication between children and their parents, relatives, and legal guardians. Honorable Members, a negotiated end to Russia's illegal war of aggression must mitigate the security risk Russia poses to the European continent, but it also must see the return of every Ukrainian child to their parents. Failing to do so will leave a black mark on humanity forever. Thank you. [15:18:24] Speaker 3 [DE] Thank you very much. The floor now goes to Ms colleague Kovač from the EPP Group. [15:18:35] Ewa Kopacz (PPE) [PL] Madam President, honourable Members. Behind every war lie the tragedies of people whose lives have been destroyed. However, there is something particularly cruel about a war being waged against children. Madam President, honourable Members, behind every war lie the tragedies of people whose lives have been destroyed. However, there is something particularly cruel about a war waged against children. To understand this crime, we must look at it not through the prism of war, but through the prism of our own families. Your child has a name. It has a home, a school, friends with whom it spends afternoons. It has favourite toys, its little secrets, and dreams about who it will become when it grows up. Every day you build its world. And it builds its identity. And suddenly war comes. The school he attended is destroyed. Friends flee, and home is no longer safe. Eventually, someone takes your child away from you. They give him a new first and last name, change his citizenship, forbid him to speak his native language. It ends up in a new family, which raises it as if its previous life had never existed. But you don’t know. You don’t know where it is. You don’t know whether it is safe. Does it still remember your voice? Has anyone told him that you are still waiting for him? This is exactly what the reality of Ukrainian families looks like today, whose children have been deported and forcibly displaced by Putin’s criminal actions. Ladies and Gentlemen, Europe, which recognises human dignity and children's rights as the foundation of its values, must remain true to them even when it comes to making the most difficult decisions. Thank you very much. [15:20:46] Thijs Reuten (S&D) [DE] Thank you. The floor now goes to Mr Reuten of the S&D Group. [15:20:51] Thijs Reuten (S&D) [EN] President, dear colleagues, dear High Representative, excellent to have you with us, and thank you for your commitment. Every day we witness Russia's heinous crimes against Ukraine's people, but tearing children from their families indoctrinating and abusing them by the thousands strikes anyone with empathy and human dignity. Imagine ordering such a policy or calling it humanitarian. It is cold-blooded barbarism. Our position must remain clear: there can no be any genuine peace without safe return of every Ukrainian child, and accountability for those responsible. The ICC has rightly issued arrest warrants for Putin and Lvova-Belova. We command every effort to return the children safely to their families and help them recover and integrate. The EU must continue supporting the Bring Kids Back initiative, the Ukrainian Ombudsman's cooperation with Europol and Eurojust, and Ukrainian and international civil society. Our support and sanctions, and we will talk about them tomorrow in this House, must not stop until every single child is home. [15:21:58] Speaker 3 [UK] Glory to Ukraine! [15:22:02] Speaker 3 [DE] Thank you. For the Patriots for faction, our colleague Ms Ferenc now takes the floor. [15:22:14] Viktória Ferenc (PfE) [HU] Heartbreaking news is arriving day after day from the Russian-Ukrainian war. But our hearts truly ache when a child becomes a victim of the war. Or when they lose their home, their father, when air raid sirens and rocket attacks dictate their daily lives even in the shelters where they hold classes. What kind of childhood has this been now for five years? As part of the humanitarian crisis shaking Ukraine, the forced deportation of 20,600 children and attempts to erase their Ukrainian identity have also been documented. As a Hungarian from Transcarpathia, I know what it feels like when something natural is restricted: the use of one’s mother tongue. Therefore, I firmly condemn Russia’s actions in this regard, as well as any other violations of children’s rights. We must mitigate the tragic consequences of the war. However, our most important task remains ending the war and achieving peace. Madam High Representative, you have recently questioned the purpose of peace negotiations. Difficult negotiations do not justify abandoning diplomacy. Are you truly guided by the peace and security of Ukrainian children? After all, peace would be their most important gift. [15:23:39] Rihards Kols (ECR) [DE] Thank you. The colleague Mr Kols will now speak on behalf of the ECR Group. [15:23:46] Rihards Kols (ECR) [EN] Dear colleagues, one demand comes before everything else today: return every kidnapped Ukrainian child, immediately and unconditionally. Over 20,000 Ukrainian children have been deported to Russia. In September, the Council sanctioned just 10 individuals or entities, 10, and we comfort ourselves with two ICC warrants as though naming the architects dismantled the building. It did not. Putin does not forge birth certificates himself. Thousands of clerks camped directors and occupation officials run this system, financed by Gazprom and Rosneft. Almost all remain untouched by our sanctions. These children are being renamed, re-registered, and stripped of their families. Erasure is entire point of crime. Under Article 2, subparagraph e of the Genocide Convention, this is genocide. Every member state has a binding duty to act. Sanction the entire chain of enablers, prosecute every collaborator, and fund the Ukrainian teams keeping stolen identities alive. Because right now Russia is stealing Ukraine's children, and Europe is barely answering. This is our shame. Thank you. [15:25:06] Petras Auštrevičius (Renew) [DE] Thank you. The colleague Austravicius now speaks on behalf of the Renew group. [15:25:13] Petras Auštrevičius (Renew) [EN] Madam Chair, High Representative, Council Representative, Honourable colleagues. The Russian regime conceals its crimes behind euphemisms. For example, Russia's war of aggression is referred to as "special military operation. " The occupation of foreign territories as the liberation of territories and the forced deportation of tens of thousands of children as humanitarian evacuation. These are war crimes, crimes against humanity, and an attempt to cover up genocide. Ukrainian children have only one homeland: Ukraine. Were they belong? We must constantly raise the issue of deported and abducted Ukrainian children because it is our basic human duty. Any peace agreement must include provisions for the safety of Ukrainian children and the unconditional return of those who have been deported. Without children, Ukraine has no future and no hope for a better tomorrow. On behalf of the Renew Europe Group, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to the numerous Ukrainian and international organizations and volunteers who are working tirelessly and at a great personal risk to secure and return Ukrainian children to their homeland. Thank you very much. [15:26:38] Villy Søvndal (Verts/ALE) [DE] Thank you. Danke schön. The Greens/EFA Group will now be represented by my colleague Mr Sönder. [15:26:44] Villy Søvndal (Verts/ALE) [EN] Thank you, Chair. I'll speak in Danish. [15:26:47] Villy Søvndal (Verts/ALE) [DE] Russia is waging a war because of quotes. [15:26:50] Villy Søvndal (Verts/ALE) [DA] It is about drones and bombs, but not only that. No, it is a war against Ukraine's children and their consciousness. Since Putin's invasion, Russia has taken more than 20,000 Ukrainian children away from their families. Just try to imagine that. One morning when your son is not in his bed, a day when your daughter does not come home from school, evenings when you are left with a gnawing sense of loss. Many parents never see their children again, and if the children do return, they may no longer be the same. The Russians are indeed trying, through violence and force, to erase their Ukrainian identity and memories. These are despicable war crimes that we in Europe must press hard to stop. With sanctions against Russia and full support for Ukraine, for their sake, but also for our own sake. Thank you. [15:27:46] Özlem Demirel (The Left) [DE] Thank you. The floor now goes to the Left Group’s colleague, Ms Demirel. Thank you. Madam President! Winter is just around the corner. For children, that means looking forward to snowball fights and Christmas. For children in war zones, however, it means one thing above all else: even more suffering. The fifth winter of war is now looming for Ukraine. 17,000 killed, 55,000 injured, civilians for five years. Indescribable suffering. And the Ukrainian children who have been torn from their families and abducted. The children must return, yes. But that requires more than resolutions. It requires political will and serious diplomatic efforts, also from you, Ms Kallas. Colleagues, I do not know how many times I have asked this question here, but I will not stop. Where is the EU’s strategy to truly end this war? Why is there still no dedicated peace initiative? No negotiator? Now negotiations are taking place in Abu Dhabi, but without the EU. And one thing must be clear: children are not helped by battle cries, by geopolitical interests, nor by crocodile tears. What helps them is an end to the war. Every child belongs in a home. Every child belongs in a warm home. Every child should be able to celebrate Christmas in peace, and the EU should contribute to that. Thank you. Good. The colleague Ms Vosdorf will now speak for the ESN Group. Over 20,000 Ukrainian children have been abducted to Russia during the war. Children who cannot defend themselves. Children who have been made homeless. Children who may never see their families again. This is one of the worst war crimes. Even in the Netherlands, without any war, more than 2,000 children were taken from their parents. This was exposed in the child benefit scandal by a courageous politician, families were financially ruined, and parents were subsequently branded as incapable of providing care. The Prime Minister of that country at the time was Mark Rutte, who is now NATO Secretary General. [15:30:06] Irmhild Boßdorf (ESN) [DE] He was never held accountable for this scandal. Children must never be made into prey. Neither in times of peace nor in times of war. We demand the immediate repatriation of all these children. The children have a right to their homeland and to their family. Thank you. This position. The round of group spokespersons and with that, I may now hand the floor back to Ms High Representative Kallas. Please go ahead. [15:30:43] Kaja Kallas [EN] Thank you, Honorable Members, for this debate. I absolutely agree that children have the right for their home, for their parents, also for peace. To live and grow up in peace. That's why, of course, we are supporting all diplomatic efforts. And we have also put forward our own plan for peace that I have proposed for the European Foreign Ministers. And we have also discussed with the European Foreign Ministers clearly. But the problem is that Russia is not interested in peace. Russia thinks that it can just present maximum demands and will walk away with what they have more, what they had before. So what I think the result of this debate could be when we are talking about Ukrainian children, then we can call on Russia to facilitate humanitarian corridors and practically arrangements for eventual family reunification. We can call on Russia to allow the United Nations UNICEF, the International Committee of the Red Cross, and other appropriate independent bodies to access relevant institutions and locations where Ukrainian children are held. And notably, of course, we can call on Russia to halt the attacks on schools, education facilities, kindergartens, universities, school shelters, school buses, and everywhere where the Ukrainians' children really are to show their good faith that they actually are looking into and thinking about peace. Unfortunately, this is so far not the case. Thank you. [15:32:33] Katarina Barley (S&D) [DE] Many thanks. Since the next slot is only scheduled for 15:45, I will now adjourn the meeting until then. We will resume at 15:45 with the Commission's statement on the Commission's 2027 work programme. Thank you very much. [15:42:47] Katarina Barley (S&D) [DE] So, dear colleagues, we can resume the session three minutes earlier, because both the Commissioner and the first speakers are present. The meeting is therefore resumed and the next item on the agenda is a statement by the Commission on the Commission's 2027 work programme. And once everyone is ready, I now give the floor to the Commission, Commissioner Šefčovič. [15:43:35] 99424 [EN] Madam President, honorable members, it is a pleasure to present to you the 2027 Commission Work Programme. And let me start by thanking you for the fruitful cooperation during its preparation. We had many constructive exchanges including the discussion with the Conference of Committee Chairs attended by the Executive Vice President, Commissioners Dobrowski, Seraphine, and myself. And as the President von der Leyen said in her State of the Union speech, in Europe we stand up for one another. Be it by our steadfast support for Ukraine in the face of Russian aggression, by finding common responses to drone incursions and hybrid attacks in our Member States, or by joining forces to fight the growing impacts of climate change such as unprecedented wildfires. We are dealing with high energy prices and significant cost of living pressures. While facing attacks on democracy and accelerating technological disruption through artificial intelligence. This work program is strategic, targeted, and streamlined, doubling down on our political priorities and main workstreams. It has a focus on delivery and meeting our commitment for stronger Europe. Together we need to further strengthen our competitiveness, boost our energy security, and continue simplifying our rules. We need to deliver on enhancing defense and strengthen our security. Quality of life, in the EU must remain high, including in rural areas. We will strengthen our preparedness for the effects of climate change and continue defending our democracies and values. With these priorities in mind, we are proposing a limited number of key initiatives. In addition, implementation and force man and rapid delivery of major proposals already on the table are crucial for the year ahead. To address energy security and prices as well as decarbonization, we will shape the post-2030 energy framework. It will be made simpler and more effective while keeping Europe firmly on track to meet its 2040 decarbonization objectives. Our competitiveness relies on a thriving single market, delivering on the One Europe [15:46:23] 99424 [EN] One Market roadmap by the end of next year, remains a key. Therefore, we will propose targeted additional initiatives like a measure on preventing single market barriers. We will also tackle unjustified territorial supply constraints to avoid suppliers fragmenting the single market, limiting consumer choice, and causing significant price differences. For projects in the EU strategic interest to attract additional investment, we will propose further measures to accelerate permitting. Our companies must be put in a position to thrive in an economy that is reshaped by the digital and AI transformation. Honorable members, when we talk about competitiveness, we are talking about jobs, people, and livelihoods. As next year marks the 10th anniversary of the European Pillar of Social Rights, we will come forward with important initiatives under our social priority. To help deliver on high-quality cross-border education across the EU and boost skills and innovation, we will propose the European Universities Alliances 2. 0. Care needs of aging populations are increasing. We need to promote affordable, quality care reduced staff shortages and improve careers for care workers. This will be the focus of the Care Deal. Our strategy on the right to stay. We'll identify measures needed for regions and people to thrive and succeed to counter the challenges caused by economic decline and population loss. The devastating impact of this summer's wildfires is still being felt. Successive heat waves have led to staggering impacts, including losses of agricultural production. Against this background, our European Water Initiative will help to better manage vital water resources for citizens, our food security, and our industries. Beyond adapting to climate change, we need to continue protecting our environment. The review of the Nature Protection Directive will allow us to assess where the changes are needed to the legal framework, parts of which date from the early 90s. The foundation to addressing today's challenges at European level is a thriving and resilient democracy. [15:49:05] 99424 [EN] Malign actors are putting our democratic system under pressure. Disinformation and information manipulation are spreading fast, fueled by AI. This is why we will step up our work on the European Democracy Shield. We will also address the increased threats: attacks and violence against political candidates and elected representatives with the safety in politics initiative. It is of the utmost importance that we focus the legislative work on our absolute key priorities. That is why we are proposing a targeted annex with priority pending proposals building on One Europe One Market and the 2026 Joint Declaration. In addition, it will be key to progress swiftly on the multi-annual financial framework. We need to ensure seamless continuity of funding at the start of 2028. We have closely examined all proposals on the table and listed the proposals we intend to withdraw. The Commission will carefully listen to the views of the co-legislators before taking a final decision. Lastly, in the context of our continuous efforts on regulatory deep cleaning, we also propose repealing 14 legal acts. Honorable members, I will stop here and I look forward to the debate. Thank you, Madam President. [15:50:36] Jeroen Lenaers (PPE) [DE] Thank you very much, Commissioner. I now call on Mr Lehners for the EPP Group. [15:50:50] Jeroen Lenaers (PPE) [EN] Yes, thank you, Madam President. Dear Commissioner, on behalf of the EPP group, I welcome the Commission's work program for 2027. And this program is a very important one in terms of timing. Many of the proposals presented in 2027 will shape our legislative agenda right until the elections in 2029. We have a responsibility to deliver, and this is a good start. Because the Commission sends the right message, good European policy is not simply about producing more legislation. It is also about implementing the rules we already have, simplifying or withdrawing them where necessary, and making sure they actually work in practice. People at home don't care how many directives or regulations we adopt. They care whether what we do here has an impact on their daily lives, whether they will feel that things are changing in a good way. And in that context, I would like to highlight four important initiatives. First, the review of the Birth and Habitat Directive Natura 2000. We must protect nature, of course, but at the same time, we must ensure that our legislation is workable, proportionate, and provides legal certainty. And we must bring it up to date with the challenges of today. Second, on permitting. Across Europe, essential investments in housing, infrastructure, energy, and industry face lengthy procedures. Removing unnecessary delays must be our priority. Third, on the housing simplification package. Affordable housing is a major concern for many of us citizens, including most of our young people. And Europe should help remove obstacles to building new homes rather than adding bureaucracy. And fourth, energy simplification. Affordable and reliable energy is essential, not only for households but also for industry and Europe's competitiveness. Our rules must support investment and energy security. Dear colleagues, the real test of this work program will not be how many legislative files we manage to close before 2029. The real test will be whether Europeans will see a difference, whether families can find [15:53:11] Jeroen Lenaers (PPE) [EN] affordable homes, businesses can invest in energy remains, affordable, and that our rules work in practice. And this is how we will measure the success of this program. Thank you. [15:53:24] Iratxe García Pérez (S&D) [DE] Thank you. For the S&D Group, Cathia Perth, the Chair, will now speak. [15:53:33] Iratxe García Pérez (S&D) [ES] Thank you, Madam President. There is one question that must open today’s debate, and it is this: for whom does the European Commission work? While programmes are being presented here, out there European citizens are demanding the ability to pay for a home; to make ends meet; to live without fear and to have rights. And yet, this work programme seems to have been written from another reality. Trapped in the bubble of simplification and deregulation. Lots of talk about competitiveness, and very few answers for those who can no longer wait. Have we really not understood the message in the streets? That of thousands and thousands of young people, of older people, of students, of trade unionists, of teachers who take to the streets to live, to demand to live with dignity? By the way, I would like to send from here a message of absolute respect for the trade union work, for the work that trade unions have done in the construction of Europe. Think about housing. Housing. A house must be a home, not a business for speculators. We need to curb speculative purchases, penalise empty properties in high-pressure areas, and control abusive rents. And we must ban evictions of vulnerable people; no child, no elderly person should end up on the street. Think about the bills. How can the Commission ignore the connection between Trump’s and Netanyahu’s wars and the rise in energy prices? Let’s adopt a European social bond funded by a tax on the excess profits of the big energy companies to ease the burden of electricity and heating bills for citizens. Those who profit from wars must contribute to protecting those who pay the price. In the face of climate denialism, it is time to adopt binding adaptation plans with targets. and real funding, and a European climate insurance alliance to protect citizens from the increasingly deadly risks of climate change. And the Union’s next budget must rise to the challenge of the times we are living through. [15:56:20] Iratxe García Pérez (S&D) [ES] We need own resources and fair taxation. Women's rights and fundamental freedoms also require laws, not declarations. The European law on 'only yes means yes' for rape offences is urgent, as is the ban on conversion therapies. More than a million citizens have called for action. What is the Commission waiting for? Citizens are not taking to the streets to ask us for more recommendations. They are taking to the streets to demand change. The European project will only survive with commitments. The question I asked at the beginning remains unanswered: who does the European Commission work for? The answer is clear: it works for those who live and work in Europe. And that requires less deregulation and more justice. People first. Thank you very much. [15:57:15] Harald Vilimsky (PfE) [DE] Thank you. The colleague Wilimski will now speak on behalf of the ECR Group. [15:57:19] Harald Vilimsky (PfE) [DE] Thank you, Mr President. You can’t believe your eyes, and you can’t believe your ears. At one of the most difficult hours for the continent, the Commission is presenting its programme for next year. And the President of the Commission does not even deem it fair to appear here and now. And no matter for what reason she is not here, then the debate must be postponed. And she must face this House in a democratic and parliamentary manner, first and foremost. Secondly: If, in this government agreement and the Commission's programme of activities, you seriously include the idea that Europeans must adapt to the changing population proportions in Europe, then this is the next monumental folly for which you are responsible. Since 2015, you have allowed millions of people from Arabia and Africa to enter this continent. Eighty per cent have no legal residence status whatsoever. And now we are supposed to adapt to them. I maintain that even those who have come to us legally must adapt to us, not the other way around—we do not have to adapt to them. Point number one. Point number two: the Green Deal, which you now want to push forward further. No, that is the wrong path. Don’t you see that the entire European automotive industry is going down the drain, meaning people have ever less money at their disposal? Families can no longer make ends meet and afford a decent life? That is the wrong path. You insist on it. I come to my conclusion. I didn’t think the Chocolate Juncker Commission could get any worse. The one that will go down in history as the Ischgl Commission. You will go down in history as the Titanic Commission. Shame on you and shame on this policy. [15:59:01] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. The ECR Group will now be represented by its Chair, Ms Caccini. [15:59:12] Nicola Procaccini (ECR) [IT] Thank you, Mr President. Commissioners, colleagues. I must admit that when I read the Commission's 2027 work programme, I felt a certain sense of satisfaction: competitiveness, energy independence, security, simplification, and the defence of our industries. These are exactly the words that we conservatives have been repeating for years. When... We were saying this, though, we were accused of being anti-European, sovereignists or enemies of the environment. Today those same words have become the priorities of the European Commission. Welcome to reality, I might say, better late than never. But there is a problem, because changing words is easy. Changing policies is much more difficult. You cannot invoke competitiveness or promise affordable energy and at the same time defend the ETS system by extending it even to private transport and housing. You cannot announce a revolution in simplification and then continue to churn out regulations, directives, obligations and bans. Vice-President Šefčovič, it is not enough to stop accelerating towards the precipice. We must also change direction. And yet I also want to recognise some encouraging signals: the revision of certain environmental directives, a greater attention to technological neutrality, the strengthening of external borders, the effectiveness of repatriations, and also the recognition of the right to remain in one’s own territories, defending local communities from depopulation. These are all battles that we conservatives have been waging for a long time. And if today the Commission begins to recognise some of our arguments, we cannot but be pleased. But we will be very demanding in judging the results. Because Europe does not need a Green Deal with a different name. It needs a different policy. It does not need new European taxes, but lower costs for families and businesses. It does not need more centralism, but more freedom. We want a strong Europe, but the strength of Europe is not measured by the number and power of its regulations. [16:01:39] Nicola Procaccini (ECR) [IT] It is measured by the prosperity of its citizens, the security of its borders and the freedom of its nations. [16:01:53] Billy Kelleher (Renew) [DE] The next speaker is Mr Kellerer from the Renew Group. [16:01:58] Billy Kelleher (Renew) [EN] Renew Europe has been actively engaged with the Commission in developing the work program for 2027, and we're pleased to see many of our priorities included in the program. And I know that my colleagues will expand on that later in the debate. You won't have to worry about Renew Europe being a trusted partner in implementing the work program. While we may not agree in every detail, we have our own distinct priorities. We do generally believe that the direction of travel is positive, and we support this. Vice President, the fundamental question that must be asked and answered over the next two and a half years of this electoral mandate is: who can be relied on to implement the work program? Who will resist the urge to do dirty side deals with those that may want to undermine the Commission's priorities? The work program must deliver for citizens, for businesses, for people, and implementing Draghi is a critically important component of that. Affordable housing, cheaper energy, and deepening the single market, and implementing the savings and investment union. And protecting our environment. The pro-European political groups in this House have a duty and an obligation to work together to make sure the next two and a half years is positive for our citizens. [16:03:11] Terry Reintke (Verts/ALE) [DE] Thank you. The Greens/EFA Group is now represented by its Chair, Thierry Reinke. [16:03:16] Terry Reintke (Verts/ALE) [EN] Colleagues, let me be clear. I have voted for the Commission President. I have voted for the Commission, and I have defended this Commission, even for a lot of very controversial decisions that have been taken. But even my patience has an end. And I must say the fact that the Commission is considering to opening up in this Commission work program absolutely critical nature protection legislation to me is a step too far. Because this is a field where the European Union, over the past decades, has championed making the lives of hundreds of millions of European citizens better. This is not a nice-to-have. This is not about fancy green parks. This is about the health and well-being of our citizens. And especially facing a climate emergency where nature is our most important ally in mitigating the effects of climate change. And if you need examples, I invite you to come to my home region. I grew up close to the Amschel River. The Amschel used to be one of the dirtiest, the smelliest, and the most polluted rivers in the whole of Europe. And only because of EU regulation, this river and its riverbed were renovated. It was re-naturalized. And now it is the joy to go to this river. And for 2.2 million citizens, this has directly influenced their well-being and health. So to me, putting this and so many other examples at stake is a step too far. So as Greens, we will do everything in order to stop this. Do not endanger the health, the well-being, and the nature that our citizens so urgently need. [16:04:58] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. Next, speaking for the Left Group is its Chair, Aubry. [16:05:10] Manon Aubry (The Left) [FR] Dear colleagues, the social emergency is worsening. In France, Belgium, Italy, Portugal and Spain, historic mobilisations against the high cost of living are taking place every week. Prices are soaring, wages are stagnating, and many can no longer afford to feed themselves or to live decently. And in the face of this emergency, what is the European Commission proposing? A work programme completely out of touch with reality. Mr Vice-President, if we wanted to draw up a bingo of the worst possible measures in this context, I am sure your Commission would have won hands down. To address the social emergency, nothing. On the other hand, new omnibus deregulation texts, a series of gifts to the largest companies and lobbyists, even if it means sacrificing all the social and environmental progress of recent years. On taxation, while the richest have never been richer, the few texts that hinted at a fairer tax model have simply disappeared from the programme. On the housing crisis, the only text you have is going to target environmental standards, as if the problem came from there rather than from property speculation and soaring rents. Perhaps we might have expected some progress on climate after a scorching summer. No, here too, a revision of the nature protection law to water it down even further. On trade, at a time of reindustrialisation, Mr Vice-President, I must say that this is your area of expertise: free trade agreements one after another that will cripple our producers. On fundamental rights, the rights of LGBTI people, or even the inclusion of the concept of consent in the definition of rape, not a single word. As if fundamental rights were not being systematically attacked by the far right in this Chamber and daily within the European Union. As for the thousands of people who drown each year at Europe’s borders, you respond by strengthening [16:06:59] Manon Aubry (The Left) [FR] Frontex, which is nonetheless responsible for illegal pushbacks and human rights violations. I am not even mentioning Palestine, a word you do not even utter, even though the European Union continues to be complicit through its association agreement and even though more than a million people are still calling on you to act, having signed a European citizens' initiative on the matter. So, there you have it. The right and the far right are sharing the victory. Our Left group, however, sees only the reflection of an institution that prioritises the interests of a handful of privileged individuals over the general interest. Unlike our colleagues, however, we are not fooled, and you will find us in your path as we continue to defend the interests of the many. [16:07:44] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. And now, for the ESN Group, the Chair, Mr Aust, will speak. [16:07:52] René Aust (ESN) [DE] Europe needs an alternative, because this Commission work programme will not be able to solve Europe’s problems – not in the area of migration, not in the area of the economy, not in the area of energy. We have seen all of this in the past few years already. What is needed in the area of migration? Everything that has been done is insufficient. We see it in the riots in Paris or in Milan or in Brussels. And we see the current situation today in the Canary Islands. There continues to be a major surge of illegal mass immigration into all of Europe. That is why our solutions are clear: for example, we need to legalise pushbacks; the external borders of the European Union must finally be effectively and truly protected. In addition, those who have already entered our continent illegally and are living here must be returned. That is why we need remigration across all of Europe. Second: an end to climate ideology. An end to the Green Deal. What is needed is affordable energy. Especially when we look to the future – artificial intelligence. Europe is once again in danger of falling into new dependencies here. Look at the rest of the world, look at the United States, where the future is currently being invented, look at China, where the future is being built, while here in Europe we are merely administering the past. Third: what is needed is affordable housing. And here the two issues come together. First, we must ensure, through affordable energy and less bureaucracy, that construction becomes cheaper so that sufficient housing is available for our families. Second, we must ensure that, through remigration, fewer apartments are in demand so that rents can fall as a result. In other words: everything we need is an alternative programme to what the Commission is presenting to us. What is needed is an alternative for Europe. And you can find that in all European countries. That is why you should vote for the patriotic parties. [16:10:01] Speaker 2 [DE] Many thanks indeed. [16:10:05] Speaker 1 [DE] This concludes the round of group chairpersons. [16:10:08] Speaker 1 [EN] I will become more stricter with the time now. As you know, [16:10:11] Dolors Montserrat (PPE) [DE] and now the floor goes to my colleague Ms Montserrat. [16:10:17] Dolors Montserrat (PPE) [ES] Well, thank you very much, Madam President. Commissioner, we welcome the fact that reindustrialisation, autonomy and competitiveness are at the heart of the Commission's work programme to create quality jobs. But if we want a competitive Europe, we need to complete the single market once and for all, and now. And if we want a Europe where young people can build their future, we must guarantee them housing. And that means building more, freeing up land, removing obstacles, and putting an end to interventionism and communist measures. Private property is sacred; it is the savings of a family’s entire life, the effort, the sweat of a lifetime. Private property belongs to citizens, not the State. And no populist government, such as Sánchez’s, will expropriate it from us. Lastly, if we want a secure Europe, we need greater firmness and governments that comply with the Return Directive. If one fails, we all fall. Yesterday it was Ceuta, and today it is once again the Canary Islands, with over 7,000 irregular migrants in a week and innocent deaths in the Atlantic. Unacceptable, Mr Sánchez, that you continue to fail to implement the migration pact. But, Mr Commissioner, allow me to highlight a matter of vital importance. We demand rigorous control by the Commission over every euro of the Next Generation funds for infrastructure. Corruption kills. We have seen it in Adamuz and Urda; we do not want any more railway tragedies. We want to know how our European money has been spent, Mr Sánchez. We demand respect for the victims and safety for our citizens. And lastly, we want to remain a fishing power. And the reforms of the Common Fisheries Policy cannot be left out of this programme. Thank you very much. [16:12:05] Speaker 1 [ES] Dear colleague, may I have a blue card? [16:12:08] Camilla Laureti (S&D) [DE] No. Next, we have as the next speaker the colleague Lauretti. [16:12:17] Camilla Laureti (S&D) [EN] Let's put people first. [16:12:19] Camilla Laureti (S&D) [IT] This is what we do not find in the Commission's work programme. Thousands of people are taking to the streets in European cities amid rising inflation, the cost of living reaching unsustainable levels, and millions of Europeans struggling to access decent housing. And economic inequalities continue to grow, not shrink. Thirty-eight per cent of Europeans are cutting back on food and healthcare spending, while 60 % are reducing their purchasing power because of high energy costs. We must respond to these figures, but above all to these citizens, men and women. Competitiveness is fine, but not if it comes at the expense of a large part of the population. And simplification is fine, but only if it safeguards environmental and social ambitions; not if it continues to concentrate power in the hands of a few at the expense of the well-being of many. [16:13:26] Speaker 1 [EN] Dear colleague, do you accept the blue card by colleague Mulacic? [16:13:30] Speaker 5 [EN] No. [16:13:30] Speaker 1 [DE] Right. I now give the floor to my colleague Ms Štálová. [16:13:41] Klara Dostalova (PfE) [EN] Micro, please. [16:13:41] Klara Dostalova (PfE) [CS] An ambitious work programme for 2027. And I would like to ask the Commissioner just one point from that work programme in a very straightforward question about housing. When will we finally start to remove the problems that European legislation itself has helped to create, thereby classifying housing as unaffordable? Europeans do not need more strategies on affordable housing. Europeans need real housing. They need a home. And that will not be created in Brussels offices; it is created on construction sites. Yet while the Commission promises simplification, it is coming up with a left-leaning 'Affordable Housing Act', instead of removing obstacles it is opening up regulations on short-term rentals and interfering with property rights. We cannot turn owners into culprits of the housing crisis, and we cannot turn further regulation into a solution. The real test of this work programme will therefore be the Housing Simplification Package, in which we want to see concrete removal of unnecessary bureaucracy, a review of excessive requirements and simplification of rules that drive up construction costs. This includes those in the areas of energy, the environment and with respect for the competences of the Member States. Thank you. [16:14:59] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. Next, I give the floor to my colleague Ms Schidlow. [16:15:09] Beata Szydło (ECR) [PL] Thank you, Madam President. Commissioner, ladies and gentlemen. This Commission work programme for 2027 does not guarantee a solution to any of the problems that are currently leading to successive crises in the European Union. The same directions are to be maintained. Of course, the main issue here is migration policy. Listening to the speeches of my colleagues here in this Chamber, one could almost say that everyone is criticising and dissatisfied with this plan. So the question has already been raised here: for whom does the European Commission work? Or perhaps we should ask whether the European Commission is even needed at all? Should we not finally say stop to the continued assumption of new competences and the appropriation of further areas that the Commission wants to bring under its control, even though this is clearly not leading to anything good, as we cannot see—just as I mentioned earlier—a solution to these problems. For this reason, I believe that this Commission work programme is inadequate and does not guarantee development or a way out of the crises in the European Union. Thank you very much. [16:16:26] Ľubica Karvašová (Renew) [DE] Thank you. The next speaker is my colleague Ms Kavašová. [16:16:33] Ľubica Karvašová (Renew) [SK] I would like to thank the European Commission and, in particular, Vice-President Fico for the initiative of the Right to Stay strategy, the right to stay. It is important that our citizens do not have to leave their homes out of necessity and need. Simply because they do not have enough opportunities, because they lack quality services, or because they have no prospects for the future. But one thing is crucial: this strategy must not remain merely a shelf of good ideas. Therefore, we need concrete measures, and above all, money. And that money is precisely what we are discussing now in the European Parliament. We are also talking about future EU funds, the conditions of which we are currently negotiating. And so I have a very clear message for the leaders of the Member States of the European Union. We need an agreement on the European budget by the end of this year. Precisely because it is about our citizens, it is about our businesses, and it is about our regions. In the European Parliament, we are ready and we are prepared to support Ukraine as well. Thank you. [16:17:39] Speaker 1 [EN] Dear colleague, do you accept the blue card by colleague Žonta? [16:17:45] Speaker 4 [EN] Yes. [16:17:45] Speaker 1 [EN] Okay. [16:17:47] Bogdan Rzońca (ECR) [EN] 156, please. [16:17:49] Bogdan Rzońca (ECR) [EN] Just a second, you need the mic. Yeah, now. [16:17:54] Bogdan Rzońca (ECR) [PL] I listened carefully to your speech, as well as to the previous speeches. You come from a very influential liberal group. Someone mentioned that there used to be a dirty river, and now there is a clean river there. In my region, in Poland, we have a problem with rivers drying up. Large water reservoirs have emptied. And my question to you: given that the experts are directly stating that next year will be very difficult in terms of water resources in the European Union, will you support the idea of quickly finding funds to retain water in regions where there are farmers, fruit growers and those who live off water? [16:18:38] Ľubica Karvašová (Renew) [SK] Thank you very much. This is one of the examples of what we are all facing in our regions. Right now, the eastern region of Slovakia, part of the eastern region in Gemer, Rimavská Sobota, has declared an emergency situation due to a lack of drinking water. In the middle of autumn, when we expect rain, and the reason? A long period of drought. So this is really a challenge that we are facing in all European countries. And that is exactly why we need European leaders to set aside their egos and start focusing on their citizens and the needs of their citizens, including the issue of access to drinking water. Thank you. [16:19:24] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. Next, we have a speech by our colleague Ms Tusza. [16:19:36] Marie Toussaint (Verts/ALE) [FR] Mr Commissioner, to throw the Birds and Habitats Directives to the wolves in the midst of the sixth mass extinction is a historic mistake. These directives are our wetlands, our forests, our coastlines, our protection against droughts and floods. You want to wipe out in one stroke 40 years of protection for living things, even Mr Macron and Ms von der Leyen tell you this is not serious. Ultimately, your programme for the coming mandate is off the mark: heatwave plans on one side, climate deregulation on the other, you are pouring oil on the fire, and doing nothing about the eternal pollutants, PFAS, which are everywhere. In our blood, our bodies, our water, our breast milk, they need to be banned, starting by protecting workers. Mr Commissioner, across Europe, citizens are mobilising against the high cost of living, against austerity, for young people. But you, you are feeding a troubling obsession with lobbies. For banks, a omnibus. For agrochemicals, an omnibus. For tenants, bulldozers. Mr Commissioner, it is not by giving free rein to speculators that we will guarantee a dignified life for each and every one of us on our continent. [16:20:44] Speaker 1 [FR] Dear colleagues, do you accept a blue card from colleague Mulacic? [16:20:51] Speaker 1 [EN] The ECR. [16:20:53] Speaker 1 [DE] Very well. Thank you. Next, we will hear from our colleague Ms Zacharia. [16:21:03] Maria Zacharia (NI) [EL] Enough is enough with a Europe that always finds solutions for bankers, industrialists, shipowners, but constantly demands patience from its peoples. Workers cannot make ends meet, young people cannot find a home, families are losing their homes to funds. And your answer? Competitiveness and more market facilitation. In the Commission’s 2027 programme, you withdraw the proposal for a common European deposit insurance, but prepare a new competitiveness package for banks. You even want to interfere with citizens’ lives. You withdraw the directive on controlling environmental claims by businesses, but re-examine directives on birds, habitats and Natura 2000 areas. You push ahead with EU Inc., the 28th corporate regime under which all workers will be paid Bulgarian wages, and numerous other measures for the militarisation of Europe. Profits cannot be protected by law while people are left with promises. Your programme is unacceptable. [16:22:07] Speaker 2 [EL] Thank you. [16:22:08] Speaker 1 [EN] Dear colleague, do you colleague Zacharia, please, do you accept the blue card by colleague Oliveira? From the left, yes. 136. [16:22:27] João Oliveira (The Left) [PT] Thank you, Mr President. Ms Zacharia, the question I want to ask is: how can we accept the complete lack of concern for the social situation that people are facing? The European Commission's work programme does not include any ideas for addressing the rising cost of living, the difficulties people face in meeting basic needs due to the increase in fuel prices, food prices and essential goods — how is it possible to support a work programme like this that the Commission is presenting here if it is completely disconnected from the needs and realities facing people across the European Union? [16:23:09] Maria Zacharia (NI) [EL] Thank you very much for your question. It is truly astonishing how this programme is considered something that citizens across Europe will be able to accept and see a better day in their own lives. What is really concerning the Commission, and is clearly evident through this programme, is how it will drain the wealth of the people and how those who already have plenty of money will live with even greater profits. That is the essence of the matter. Because, in the end, it is lobbies that are calling the shots here. Thank you. [16:23:49] Tomas Tobé (PPE) [DE] Thank you. The next speaker is my colleague Tobi. [16:23:55] Tomas Tobé (PPE) [EN] President, colleagues, we are now entering the third year of this mandate. Time flies. But we have also done a lot of reforms to have better security, more competitiveness, of course with the goal of getting a more prosperous Europe. But of course we need to deliver more. Firstly, we need to strengthen Europol and develop a modern criminal law instrument to better tackle drug-related crime. We must go after the money and the business models of the criminal networks. Secondly, we need to do more to protect our children. The EPP maintain our call for caucus law at European level to effectively combat cyberbullying. And thirdly, we must do more to take back control of migration. We need to address the weaponization of migration like we saw in Ceuta. This is a bigger question than the lack of response from the centrist government. Europe needs to deliver an EPP. We'll do exactly that. Thank you. [16:25:09] Speaker 1 [EN] Dear colleague Tobi, there is a blue card. By colleague Wiśniewska. Monsieur Tobi, there is a blue card. By Mrs. Wiśniewska. Yes? Okay. 361, please. [16:25:31] Jadwiga Wiśniewska (ECR) [PL] Thank you very much for accepting the question. I agree with most of the points raised by the gentleman. In particular, those concerning the strengthening of Europol and the reduction of uncontrolled migration. These are urgent and necessary matters. However, I would like to ask you, in the context of the high cost of living and high energy prices, whether you do not think that the proposed changes to the emissions trading system are too modest to improve the competitiveness of the European economy and thus lower the cost of living? Thank you. [16:26:14] Tomas Tobé (PPE) [EN] Well, thank you, colleague, for the question. I'm good that we can at least agree that it's important that Europe are taking steps to have a stronger Europol and that we are taking back control of migration. Well, I would like to take an example when it's come to ETS, and let me take my home country, Sweden, as an example. We have the lowest emissions in Europe, and at the same time we have had high growth in Europe. And I think the ETS has been crucial, actually, to also create this. Of course, the basis of this is that you need to have a good energy mix. In Sweden, we have an invested a lot in renewables, but at the same time also nuclear. And this has also created that we can have low energy prices and so that people also have a decent way when it comes to cost of living. [16:27:06] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you. Next redner [16:27:08] Kristian Vigenin (S&D) [DE] is my colleague Wigenin. [16:27:17] Kristian Vigenin (S&D) [DE] Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Commissioner, dear colleagues. We live in a world in which international law is increasingly being called into question. Conflicts are escalating and economic dependencies are being used as a political weapon. The Commission is right to speak of strategic autonomy. However, this does not only apply to defence and competitiveness. It also encompasses Europe’s claim to act as an independent geopolitical power. This is precisely where we encounter the great contradiction between words and results. Today, we are shown less and less respect. Our role in the world economy, world politics and global security is becoming ever smaller, and the measures taken so far are not changing this outlook. What plan do we have to ensure that our voice is heard when negotiations on the end of Russia’s war against Ukraine take place? What is our strategy for the Middle East that goes beyond mere expressions of concern? How long will we continue to allow others to determine our security? Europeans want their politicians to show courage, wisdom and dignity. That is why people first. [16:28:36] Speaker 1 [DE] Dear colleague, may I have a Blue Card? There are two, and both have already spoken, so I would take the first one from Mr Oliveira. Is that okay? 136. [16:28:53] João Oliveira (The Left) [PT] Thank you, Mr President. Mr Wigenin, you spoke about issues related to defence and security, and the question I put to you is: how can it be justified that the Commission’s work programme does not include a single initiative focused on peace? On achieving a solution for peace and collective security to end the war being waged in Ukraine. To end the war in the Middle East. To end the genocide that Israel continues to commit against the Palestinian people. How is this possible? The work programme speaks of defence and security in international projection but does not have a single line on building peace as a priority objective? [16:29:41] Kristian Vigenin (S&D) [EN] Yeah, thank you for your comments. I think I said the same, but in German. So obviously that was a critic for the Commission. It's really important that we are able, first, to further develop our defense capabilities, but at the same time to match them with initiatives and a clear stance on how we deal with the big conflicts of our time, because they affect every citizen's, every European citizen. Thank you. [16:30:08] Speaker 1 [DE] Dear colleague, I made a mistake, Mr Mulacic had not yet received a Blue Card. He had only applied for one. Would you take a second card, a Blue Card? Yes, then please, Mr Mulacic. [16:30:20] Speaker 4 [EN] Okay. [16:30:26] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Thank you very much for accepting the blue card. It was a very interesting speech. Mr Deputy raised issues concerning the lack of a European strategic policy in foreign policy and the priorities of the European Union when it comes to resolving international disputes. Mr Deputy, however, the question is crucial. Do the countries of the European Union have a uniform strategy? When it comes to major conflicts in the world, what about Central Europe? Does Poland have the same priorities? Does Bulgaria, for example, like France or Germany, I fear that we do, however, have a different perception of international reality and our relations with America? Thank you very much. What is your opinion on this matter? [16:31:14] Kristian Vigenin (S&D) [EN] Well, thank you for your comment, because this is really an important element of the work that we need to do together. Because when we talk about priorities, I think that we can easily achieve clear, common, goals of the European Union. Which are definitely in favor of both France, Bulgaria, Poland, and any other country. If we are strong in defense, it's good for everyone, no? If we are strong at the world scene, if we have a strong voice and we can together use this voice, it's good for France, Bulgaria, Poland, and any other country. So working together, trying to find together the best solution and using our power individual and common as European Union is the way to move forward. But that means that we need to have a really a guidance, a leadership, which can unite us. This is the main problem we have right now. [16:32:07] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you very much. Thank you. Colleague Ehlers has now disappeared from the list, but she is still here. Please, Ms Colleague Ehlers. [16:32:22] Marieke Ehlers (PfE) [NL] Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner, for the 2027 work programme, the Commission is announcing no fewer than 24 new initiatives. More plans, more rules, more interference from Brussels. At the same time, the Commission is also announcing that it will repeal a few laws as part of its deregulation drive. But that is pure deception. Because the laws the Commission wants to repeal are, in fact, no longer relevant. For example, it is talking about a regulation from 1991 on a one-off delivery of butter and milk powder to Bulgaria. What a show of strength. This is not deregulation; it is long-overdue maintenance. No citizen gains anything if irrelevant legislation is scrapped administratively. What the Commission should really do is abolish the disastrous Green Deal. Or withdraw the failing migration pact. It would, of course, be even better if the Commission simply abolished itself. Thank you. [16:33:37] Speaker 1 [EN] May I ask, Kollege Müller, as for Blue Card, but it is withdrawn. Is that correct? Withdrawn. Okay, thank you. It was withdrawn. [16:33:47] Speaker 1 [DE] I now give the floor to my colleague Mr Weimers. [16:33:54] Charlie Weimers (ECR) [SV] Yes, thank you, Madam President. This is the Commission’s work programme. They say they care about high electricity prices, but here in Brussels they are talking about new rules after 2030, while Swedish families are lying awake worrying about the bill. In my part of Skåne, for example, there could be an extra tens of thousands of kronor to pay this winter. That is the reality for ordinary people, a different reality from that of your Commissioners here in Brussels. Why is it like this then? Yes, because the red-green coalition dismantled the energy system, shut down nuclear power that was working. Now Swedish households are footing the bill. And it’s going to get worse. Swedish electricity customers are subsidising German electricity after their disastrous energy turnaround. They shut down their nuclear power and we’re paying for it. Every new EU proposal must pass a test. Does it lower electricity prices? If not, then it’s a legislative proposal that belongs in the wastepaper basket. We cannot sit still while prosperity disappears. We must turn the tide now. Because without cheap electricity, ordinary Swedes have neither security nor a future – that’s just how it is. [16:35:11] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. The next speaker is our colleague, Ms Hahn. [16:35:21] Svenja Hahn (Renew) [DE] Dear colleagues, you see me here today happier than usual. I am critical of the Commission, but I am happy. Because finally something is happening when it comes to cutting red tape in Europe. The Commission wants to withdraw the Green Claims Directive and the Late Payments Regulation. Two bureaucratic monsters that I have been warning about for years. Because European companies neither need an expensive eco-TÜV for their advertising nor state-dictated payment deadlines. And for many years, Commission President von der Leyen has promised the one-in-one-out principle. So it is really good – albeit overdue – that finally, for every new law, one is withdrawn. But this can only be the beginning. Because if you only withdraw legislative proposals that have not yet entered into force, you have not abolished a single existing rule. We must have the courage to tackle the existing stock and scrap unnecessary regulations. Because Europe will not regulate itself into prosperity. And that is why we must measure the Commission and its work programmes against whether they enable growth. Because growth means good jobs, rising incomes and new opportunities for people in Europe, and this also strengthens trust in the EU. Thank you. [16:36:30] Speaker 1 [DE] Colleague Ms Hahn, may I have a Blue Card? Colleague Mr Müller. Go ahead. [16:36:39] Piotr Müller (ECR) [DE] Location. [16:36:40] Piotr Müller (ECR) [PL] Madam Member, I am very pleased with the words you have just spoken; moreover, in the IMCO committee we have the opportunity to work together precisely in this area to simplify regulations concerning the economy, and in many cases we have succeeded in doing so hand in hand. However, I do not share your optimism for the future, unfortunately, because in recent months we have seen that parliamentary committees and then in the plenary session these provisions are simply removed, even if the European Commission proposes good provisions, they are often deleted. And sometimes they are also not ambitious enough, and the more ambitious simplifications do not come to pass. So the question is, what is your view here: can the coming year change this, and will the Socialists finally wake up and notice the negative effects of these provisions? [16:37:25] Svenja Hahn (Renew) [DE] Thank you for your question. Mr President, Mr Müller, I believe that we in the European Parliament must also have this courage, which we—or at least I—rightly expect from the Commission. We must have the courage to put everything we have in terms of laws to the test and see what truly defends the rights of our citizens, what defends the interests of our citizens and our businesses. And what has accumulated as unnecessary rules, which neither serves the defence of our interests or our prosperity but is simply leftover bureaucracy, that must go. Because economic growth means prosperity, means progress and means confidence in a better future. And we need this courage here in Parliament too. Thank you. The floor now goes to my colleague Mr Böselager. [16:38:17] Damian Boeselager (Verts/ALE) [EN] Dear Vice President, it's halftime, so we are halfway through the von der Leyen government too, and I think above all you promised competitiveness, which in my understanding means making business easier in and across Europe. But what have you actually achieved on this? Founding is still very difficult in Europe, and the EU, Inc. is at risk of being hollowed out right now. Hiring is really, really difficult across the continent. It's a tax nightmare, and when we talk about attracting international talent, the narrative that we have on migration is scaring off people. And when it is about selling across borders, we still have huge hidden tariffs when it comes to goods and services, and I don't see a full and comprehensive single-market program from your side. And when it comes to selling across the world, we don't really see the trade deals that are necessary. We are sending them to the courts or elsewhere, but we don't actually close them. And when it comes to raising capital I have to say our public money is focused on farmers and not on AI and innovation, and our private money still is invested in the US. So my question to you is, can you commit that in the second half of your mandate you will actually deliver on these elements of competitiveness? Thank you so much. [16:39:31] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. The floor now goes to my colleague Ms Burkhardt. [16:39:39] Delara Burkhardt (S&D) [DE] Thank you, Madam President. In my parents' group, heating tips are being exchanged because people are worried about the exploding prices. In my vocational school class, they ask me how they're supposed to get to their training centre with fuel prices like this. But competitiveness and cutting red tape aren't exactly the answers that make people feel heard in the face of such everyday worries. Not because you don't care about economic policy, but because you want it to work for you too. To look ahead with optimism. That's why we now need measures that don't just allow a few to profit from crises, but actually bring down the costs of energy and food. But in times of crisis, we also need to position ourselves for the future — not by selling off our environmental and social standards, but by investing in good jobs, a future-proof industry and clear rules for digital corporations. People first. [16:40:38] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you very much. The next speaker is my colleague Mr Borg here. [16:40:46] Paolo Borchia (PfE) [IT] Commissioner, I thank you for presenting the work programme, but allow us to say that we are a little disappointed, because we would have liked President von der Leyen to have put her face to it: you have said many commendable things, but one fundamental aspect, a vital one, was missing, the one linked to the freedom of Europeans. The freedom to choose their own government, to begin with. Instead, in recent years, we have witnessed the abuse of the rule of law to obstruct governments that were less palatable to Brussels. In Poland, there was even a kind of coup, but since Tusk is your friend, no one said anything. In Italy, they are even publishing schoolbooks trying to convince students that there is a fascist government in Italy, but fortunately our young people are smart enough not to be taken in by a few left-wing blowhards. Let’s be honest: in recent years, Brussels has taken a lot away from Europeans – industry, agriculture, sovereignty – but what you will never be able to take away is their freedom and dignity. [16:41:59] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. We are now concluding the Blue Card procedure. We have already received more than we can take. [16:42:05] Speaker 1 [EN] Catch the eye, [16:42:06] Speaker 1 [DE] not the Blue Card. Sorry, we do have the Blue Card, but there is another one, namely, oh yes, excuse me, [16:42:12] Speaker 1 [EN] signore Borgia, do you accept the Bluecard? I'm sorry, aber bitte, okay, thank you. [16:42:19] Speaker 1 [DE] Next, we have, er, the next speaker, our colleague Röschen. [16:42:28] Bert-Jan Ruissen (ECR) [NL] Thank you, Mr President, dear colleagues, the work programme of the European Commission this time contains some interesting intentions. The most striking is the announced revision of the Birds and Habitats Directives. This revision is really badly needed. After all, these are very outdated directives, but there is also a very important flaw in them. Namely this: under these directives, everything is legally subordinated to achieving the nature objectives. And that sometimes leads to absurd situations. For example, a major construction project that comes to a standstill for months because a single frog is found on the site. But also major problems with permit granting, particularly concerning Natura 2000. Permits are not being issued because nature is allegedly not yet 100% in order. Unnecessary nitrogen rules, national rules, certainly play a role here, but so does the flaw I mentioned. We need to address that. A more balanced approach in European nature policy, with greater consideration for social and economic interests, is urgently needed. Thank you. [16:43:43] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. The next speaker is my colleague, Mr Gozi. [16:43:51] Sandro Gozi (Renew) [EN] Thank you, President. The Commission's decision to withdraw the Green Claims Directive is political and acceptable and institutionally deeply troubling. Let's be clear: the Commission never seriously tried to revive negotiations, quite the opposite. When the Polish presidency was ready to move forward, the Commission did the opposite. And helped bring negotiations to a standstill. This raises serious questions about its institutional independence and its duty to act as an honest broker. The anti-hero of this bad story were President von der Leyen and Commissioner Roosevelt. But I'm afraid their marriage, the responsibility, reading the treaty, is collected. And the consequences are real. Businesses still lack clear certainty, consumers still lack clear guarantees because bending rewashing without establishing clear rules for credible green claims is simply a joke. The Commission should be building bridges, not burning them, defending European legislation, not giving up under national political pressure. Thank you very much. [16:45:04] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. The next speaker is my colleague Ms Gölemans. [16:45:11] Estelle Ceulemans (S&D) [FR] Good grief, I can look and look, but where is the social dimension in your 2027 work programme? Do you seriously believe that Europe will become stronger, more autonomous and more resilient on a social wasteland? This work programme generously devotes a few lines to the European Pillar of Social Rights, a few lines lost in an ocean of competitiveness and deregulation. While the social emergency is being expressed in the streets across Europe, there are no concrete measures on employment. Yet the challenges are legion: European workers are today widely affected by artificial intelligence, algorithmic management, stress, burnout and wages that do not allow a dignified life. In the coming weeks, the Quality Jobs Act will be a unique opportunity to address this, with binding legislation to protect Europeans. Because competitiveness is definitely not a societal project. [16:46:14] Speaker 4 [EN] So let's put people first. [16:46:19] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. Next speaker, next speaker is our colleague Pönel. [16:46:27] Gilles Pennelle (PfE) [FR] The Commission’s 2027 work programme unfortunately confirms that it is persisting with a policy that sacrifices our farmers. First, there is even more free trade, including the agreement with Australia, which will further intensify the unfair competition faced by our producers. It is a paradox when, at the same time, the Commission claims it wants to reduce our dependencies. You finally acknowledge that our standards are penalising the competitiveness of our economy. But while you attempt to reduce bureaucracy, you are doing nothing about the regulatory nightmare that is suffocating our agriculture. Worse still, you are reaffirming your decarbonisation objectives even though we are already the most virtuous region in the world in this area. And you continue with your policy of punitive ecology. Finally, you are preparing a drastic cut to the CAP budget, which will deprive our farmers of the support they desperately need. Commissioner, our farmers are caught in a vice. Increasing unfair competition, decreasing support, and just as many regulations. When will you understand that our agriculture is sinking because of you, because of your regulations, because of the unfair competition that you are orchestrating here? [16:47:42] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. And the last speaker on the list is our colleague Ms Göring. [16:47:50] Enikő Győri (PfE) [HU] Honourable colleagues, the committee’s work programme for next year is nothing more than sleight of hand. It fails to address the essential issues. They have crammed everything into it, from permitting procedures to LGBTQ rights, while European citizens are struggling with livelihood problems, businesses and farmers are grappling with overregulation and unaffordable energy prices. The von der Leyen cabinet offers no substantive solutions to these problems. It is clear that it is seeking to meet the expectations of the Brussels grand coalition that keeps it in power. On paper, their proposals may serve competitiveness, but they certainly do not reduce energy prices by a single cent. The much-touted simplification packages do not eliminate the economic damage caused by the Green Deal. Colleagues, we need immediate deregulation across as many areas as possible. The long list of withdrawn legislation also proves that Brussels has lost touch with reality. If, instead of harmonisation efforts, they focused on people’s real problems, there would not be so many pieces of legislation that die stillborn. It is high time, therefore, to act on the basis of common sense and stand by the side of European citizens. Thank you. [16:49:04] Speaker 1 [DE] My colleague Ms Göring, [16:49:06] Speaker 1 [EN] do you accept the blue card? Mrs. Göring, excuse me. [16:49:12] Speaker 5 [EN] Hello. [16:49:13] Speaker 1 [EN] Hello. Do you accept the blue card? [16:49:17] Speaker 5 [EN] By Colleague Fritzon. [16:49:22] Speaker 1 [EN] Here, S&D. [16:49:27] Heléne Fritzon (S&D) [EN] Thank you. [16:49:28] Heléne Fritzon (S&D) [EN] And President. [16:49:29] Heléne Fritzon (S&D) [EN] No. [16:49:30] Heléne Fritzon (S&D) [EN] Yeah. [16:49:31] Heléne Fritzon (S&D) [EN] Yes, we have a time when women's rights are under attack. We expected much greater ambition from the Commission, and we know there is a crucial debate here in the Parliament because we can see in the work program that it falls short on gender equality. So where do you see the needs for initiatives on sexual and reproductive health and rights, on gender-based violence, and women's economic independence? Because we know that in this worrying world we need to put women's rights on the top of the agenda, but you are not with us in that, and we need to be united here in the Parliament to fight for women's rights. [16:50:17] Enikő Győri (PfE) [HU] Honourable Member, I believe that the European Union has its founding treaties, it has a Charter of Fundamental Rights, and these provide appropriate legal protection, and we also have our national constitutions and national legislation. I think these are perfectly adequate, we should focus on these and not confuse which level regulates what. As for what precise further steps might be needed, I believe we should trust in the wisdom of our nations to find a solution if anything further is necessary. Thank you. [16:50:54] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. That exhausts the regular speaking list, and we have 17 Catch the Eye requests; we can’t take them all, but I think we can get through 11. Then we can start with the colleague Ms Brnjac, and Mr Lopez-Aguilar can prepare. Wait, wait, first Ms Brnjac. 3, 4, 8. [16:51:24] Nikolina Brnjac (PPE) [HR] Commissioner, the European Commission's work programme places emphasis on competitiveness and the simplification of legislation. However, simplification must be felt in the everyday lives of our citizens. As coordinator in the Committee on the Housing Crisis, I particularly highlight the announced package for simplification in the area of housing. The European Parliament already adopted concrete recommendations in March of this year: the digitalisation of procedures, faster issuance of building permits, and the activation of unused land. From the European Commission, we now expect real regulatory reform, not just simplification on paper. If construction projects continue to wait for permits for years, if existing buildings cannot be repurposed more easily, and if administrative costs continue to rise, then we have not solved the problem. Simplification must mean more homes being built. This must be the yardstick for measuring the success of the Commission's work programme. Thank you. [16:52:19] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. The floor now goes to our colleague Mr Lopez-Aguilar, and our colleague Mr Smits is preparing to speak. [16:52:30] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [EN] We need a micro. 3, 3, 8, 1, please, micro. [16:52:33] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [EN] Yeah. [16:52:35] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [DE] Thank you, Madam President. Commissioner Šešković, the Commission's work programme for 2027, [16:52:40] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [ES] I stand by the commitment to implement the Migration Pact with obligatory solidarity under pressure, which admits no flexibility whatsoever nor any omnibus bill, but rather the full rigour of the European commitment. Within the framework of the rule of law, as set out in the treaties and through reform, because the Conference on the Future of Europe, with experts, must produce institutional reforms prior to any enlargement. And the shield of democracy in Europe also includes the prohibition of conversion practices. In accordance with the European Citizens' Initiative. And finally, the recovery of the social pillar and the funding of affordable housing require own resources. Within the multiannual financial framework, windfall profits from major energy companies, crypto-assets and, of course, the large profits of major tech companies must be used to finance a robust recovery of the social pillar, which is absolutely urgent in order to be able to respond to the social anger sweeping across Europe. Thank you, Madam President. [16:53:42] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. The floor now goes to our colleague Mr Smits, and our colleague Mr Oliveira is preparing to speak. [16:53:50] Sander Smit (ECR) [NL] Mr President, Commissioner, stand up for each other. The Commission wants to review the next habitat directives and Natura 2000. Positive, but not enough. The countryside does not need a review, but a genuine overhaul of these laws. Stand up for our countryside in 2027. The deterioration ban and the case law are putting the Netherlands and Europe in a tight spot. Make it possible to revise designated Natura 2000 areas and objectives where they are unfeasible or unscientific. Problem wolves that are terrorising our countryside must be able to be culled. The same applies to cormorants and other species. Management by hunters is necessary, for nature and for people. The absurd nitrogen crisis in The Hague, caused by national targets on top of European legislation, is a textbook example of gold-plating: so get rid of those national heads. Maintain in the MFF targeted support for our farmers and fishermen. Commissioner, less regulatory burden and more simplification. The space for innovation that our AI sector needs and no rules. Only in this way can we protect our socio-economic future. [16:55:09] Speaker 1 [DE] The floor now goes to my colleague Mr Oliveira, and my colleague Ms Jovanović-Šešuka may prepare herself. [16:55:17] João Oliveira (The Left) [PT] Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner Šešković, between declarations of intent and deregulation packages, from the Commission’s work programme for 2027, what stands out are nine initiatives to multiply the privileges and benefits of multinationals under the pretext of competitiveness. Nine more initiatives to keep arming the European Union to the teeth and to take the political project of confrontation and war even further. Three initiatives to favour those who speculate in housing instead of addressing the problem affecting the people, who cannot find a home they can afford. And a birthday party for the ten-year anniversary of the European Pillar of Social Rights, to pretend there is concern for people. Not a single word about initiatives to build peace in Ukraine or end the genocides in Palestine. Not a word about the rising cost of living, the need to increase wages and pensions, combating poverty after presenting a strategy to eradicate poverty, a word to increase public housing, to invest in public services or support productive sectors. This work programme does not serve the peoples of the European Union area. [16:56:32] Speaker 1 [DE] Thank you. Now the floor goes to our colleague Jovanović-Šešuka, and our colleague Mian Mon can prepare. [16:56:42] Diana Iovanovici Şoşoacă (NI) [EN] Thank you. I will speak Romanian. [16:56:44] Diana Iovanovici Şoşoacă (NI) [RO] Two days ago, Ms Ursula von der Leyen visited Romania. In fact, the so-called President of Romania, illegal and unconstitutional, following elections annulled by the European Commission in Romania. What did she ask for? She asked us to give all our Patriot missiles to Ukraine for free. Ms Ursula von der Leyen did not inquire about the pensioners living on 200 euros a month. Meanwhile, prices in Romania are higher than in Brussels. We have Brussels prices and salaries from the former Soviet gulag. You are not interested in peace either, because you have not understood: you are arming, taking all our money, destroying all our savings, and Mr Zelensky is killing both Ukrainians and Russians, and Romanians. And you are not interested in the fact that now the three major powers, the United States of America, Russia and China, are making peace because you have not understood that the Russian-Ukrainian war is being waged so that Russia no longer cooperates with the European Union. So, maximum poverty. [16:57:55] Francisco José Millán Mon (PPE) [DE] Thank you. The next speaker is my colleague Mian Mon, and my colleague Baiana is preparing to speak. [16:58:01] Francisco José Millán Mon (PPE) [ES] Thank you, Madam President. I regret that the Commission's work programme for 2027 once again leaves fisheries outside its priorities. In the list of legislative initiatives for next year, there are no specific measures included for the fisheries sector. I am particularly pained by the absence of the much-needed reform of the Common Fisheries Policy. In September, this Parliament called for an urgent reform of the CFP in a resolution that was widely supported. Moreover, from the EPP Group we have repeatedly urged the Commission to take action, most recently a couple of weeks ago with a letter signed by more than 60 EPP MEPs. That is why I cannot understand the European Commission’s stubbornness in avoiding this reform. The evaluation of the CFP has shown the decline of the fishing fleet. Every year there are fewer and older boats. Fewer fishermen, and those who remain are also older. Lower catches of fish and of lower value. And profitability that barely reaches 1%. In this situation, what is your response, Mr Šešković? To do nothing legislatively. It is disappointing. Commissioner, fishing cannot continue to be the great forgotten sector of the Commission. We urgently need concrete legislative measures and a clear timetable. Thank you. [16:59:20] Thomas Bajada (S&D) [DE] Thank you. The floor now goes to the colleague Baiana, and colleague Dünkenen may prepare. [16:59:27] Thomas Bajada (S&D) [EN] Thank you. What's this obsession and temptation to reopen the waterframe directive? First, it was critical raw materials; now it's the European Water Initiative. We have already had this debate, and I was the rapporteur of that initiative. You do not solve problems by reopening a legislation that your own assessments say that it is fit for purpose. When you rightly said that the problem is implementation, so I tell you, if the problem is leakage invest in infrastructure. If it is scarcity, improve efficiency and reuse. If it is pollution and force, the rules. Enough with excuses in order to help the companies. Vice President, in your work program, it looks that you are still hesitating. So I tell you, we know where the gap is, so let's work together and work to implement it. Do not reopen. Protect the water that unites us and the water that makes us continue to live and prosper. [17:00:37] Speaker 4 [FR] It's 2-0. [17:00:39] Sebastian Tynkkynen (ECR) [EN] Four. Sorry. Dear President, how has Europe done with migration this year? We have seen gangs of people with migrant backgrounds destroying Europe. Europe has a problem with segregation. Between summer 25 and summer 26, the EU failed to return 321,000 illegal migrants. Europe has a problem with returns. In August, we saw 80,000 Moroccans crossing the Spanish border in Ceuta. Europe has a problem with border control. But when I look at the European Commission's program for the next year, I see a lack of solutions. Where is the initiative to outsource asylum processes outside Europe? Where are the projects to build fences along our borders? When will we stop destroying Europe with migration? Thank you. [17:01:49] Speaker 3 [EN] Seat 110. Mr. Lopatka, Mr. [17:01:59] Reinhold Lopatka (PPE) [DE] Let me begin by saying something fundamental. In the end, every work programme is only as good as its implementation. The Commission is setting the right priorities here, but we need to pick up the pace when it comes to implementation. We cannot afford to lose any time. In times of war – and I do not understand many of the Members who have taken the floor and still see the solution at national level and want to give so little support to the Commission. We must not be spectators. It is really a shame if we are sitting in the next room while negotiations are taking place about the future of Ukraine and the fate of the people there. We need to become stronger in areas that concern us – our security, our foreign policy, our defence. And that is only possible if we simultaneously strengthen our economic base. The Commission is setting the right priorities, but the crucial thing is to speed up implementation. [17:03:02] Speaker 3 [EN] Thank you. Their colleague, Madame Jurkovic, seat 541. [17:03:11] Romana Jerković (S&D) [EN] Thank you, Chair. Dear Commissioner, the Commissioner's work program promises a stronger and more resilient Europe, but there is a—where is the health in that ambition? You didn't say a word about it. In parliamentary report on cardiovascular health, we explicitly called on the Commission to present a dedicated European prevention strategy, because investing in prevention delivers twice: it saves lives and reduces the pressure on our healthcare systems. And without a comprehensive strategy, we will continue addressing prevention in fragments through isolated initiatives and campaigns telling people to eat better, to exercise more, and make healthier choices. But prevention is not simply a matter of individual responsibility. We cannot ask citizens to make healthy choices while ignoring the environment that shaped those choices. And we need to tackle all the determinants of health, including environmental and commercial determinants. So Commissioner, health and prevention must become a strategic EU priority. So you should listen, European citizens. Thank you. [17:04:23] Speaker 3 [EN] Thank you. Their colleague, and last, Mr. Tonin, seat 113. [17:04:33] Matej Tonin (PPE) [SL] Honourable Commissioner Šefčovič, the European Commission has announced in the 2027 programme that it will begin implementing what it has long been promising. In the field of energy, we have pledged to ensure people a reliable energy supply at affordable prices. The President of the Commission has repeatedly stressed in her speeches that the future hinges on a mix of renewable energy sources on the one hand and nuclear energy on the other. Politically, a number of statements have been made that are heading in the right direction. However, I have the impression that the administration is not following these political announcements. And that, by far, the treatment of nuclear energy is not nearly as favourable as that of renewable energy sources. And if we want to ensure a secure future, then these things need to change. And it should start with your administration. [17:05:40] Speaker 3 [EN] Thank you. Their colleague, Mr. Šefčovič. It's your chance to close the debate. [17:05:53] 99424 [EN] Thank you very much. Thank you very much, Mr. President. Honorable members, I would like to thank all those honorable members who encouraged the Commission, who supported the program, but let me focus my answer on the questions, on some critiques, and on some clarifications where I think we need to react. First and foremost, and I hope for your indulgence with one or two more minutes of the speaking time so I can answer to most of the questions which have been proposed by the honorable members. First, I would like to absolutely underscore and highlight that I totally agree with the statement of Madame Iratxe Garcia, Pérez, that people's are first. Absolutely. That's our key guiding principle. That was our motto in this and all previous commissions' work program. And therefore, we included in the Commission's work program very strong social dimension. And if you allow, I would just list some of the planned key proposals that would showcase this just to highlight how much we want also to mark the 10th anniversary of the European Pillar of Social Rights, which we are going to celebrate next year. So in the Commission's work program, you will find the European Care Deal, you will find the proposal for European University Alliance 2.0. Just to make sure that we would deliver high-quality cross-border education. We will work very hard on the skill guarantee, which is so important for many of the young people you've been referring to. And of course, together with the Vice President Fico, we'll be working on making sure that we will guarantee to the people right to stay where they want to work and live. And on top of it, we are going to organize, and I'm sure that many of you will participate, the summit to restate the commitments to the principles of the European Social Pillar next year. If you allow me just the shorter part to Madame Kelemen's on the quality jobs roadmap. We adopted it in December 2025, and indeed it focused on creating and maintaining quality jobs in Europe and ensuring fairness and modernization in the world of work. [17:08:25] 99424 [EN] It will also support workers, employers in the green digital and demographic transition, and as announced in their roadmap and confirmed by the President's 2026 State of the Union address, Commission will propose a quality jobs act still this year in the first quarter and this proposal will be based on very thorough two-stage social partner consultation that closed by the end of December. And the new law, as Madame Kelemen was suggesting, will update EU minimum requirements protecting workers' health and safety as well as their rights while supporting productivity and competitiveness. Secondly, let me also highlight that when we talk about competitiveness, we are indeed talking about jobs, people, and livelihoods. And therefore, if you are also referring to the other very important issues like several honorable members, I think last one was my very good colleague Mr. López, Aguilar, the conversion practices, this is announced. In the Commission's work program, as a flagship initiative in annexed one. Honorable members, I also would like to underline and to kind of call upon all of us that we shouldn't look at the word simplification as something toxic. Simplification proposals do not change the EU's environment, climate, or food safety objective as some of you have been concerned or worried. They would simply allow stakeholders to meet, I would say, these new criteria in a simple way by removing duplication and the complex requirement. And this is exactly what we hear from our stakeholders' meetings from the citizens, first and foremost, from SMEs, but also from the big businesses. As regards the concerns which you're presenting by Madame Reitke, Madame Toussaint on the birds and habitat reviews, I would like to underscore once again that for us it's very clear that quality of life in Europe will increasingly depend on our ability to adapt to and mitigate the effects of changing climate. And the Commission will stay the course on our climate targets. And we are committed to protect the environment. The review of the nature protection directives as you referred to, the [17:10:57] 99424 [EN] habitat directives, dates back from 1992 and birds directive from 2009. So it's the directive which is 34 years old. And therefore, I think that we are doing the right thing because this review will allow us to assess whether, I would underline the word whether, changes to the legal framework are needed. And this would allow us to continue to effectively achieve the objectives which have been set together in a simple way. On climate, mitigation, just give me some examples because there was a lot of references made to the heat wave and to the heat wave plan. I would like again to reassure the honorable members that the heat wave plan will ensure stronger early warning systems, better health preparedness, and support to the people vulnerable to extreme heat. It will also look at the adaptation of the cities to the effect of climate change and how the climate resilience urban spaces are created. And if you allow me one word on the water initiative, because here this initiative will cover measures to address water scarcity, which adversely affects farmers' energy production, or supply chains. For example, through limited availability of waterways during the drought periods. If you allow, Mr. President, a lot of honorable members have been also making very important references to the housing. So I just would like to recall that this Commission is the first one which has a dedicated commissioner for housing. And that this remit was also enlarged to the specific DG. And I know that my colleagues' commissioner, Jørgensen, is working very hard on this file. And therefore, if you look in the housing simplification package, this package will precisely aim at facilitating the supply of affordable, sustainable, and quality housing. And we'll also support effective implementation of relevant European rules. This should happen by reducing administrative burden, accelerating processes, and improving cost efficiency while respecting the policy goals such as climate and environmental protection. [17:13:22] 99424 [EN] Madame Toussaint was also concerned about the PFAS. The European Chemical Agency is currently finalizing a socioeconomic assessment of PFAS, or as they are known, forever chemicals, under which they expect to be completed by the end of 2026. And on that basis, on the basis of this very thorough analysis, the Commission, as a risk manager, will prepare a draft restriction and submit it to the vote to the member states' committee with a view to adopting and implementation regulation. As it is derived as a tertiary legislation, and therefore it is not, of course, listed in the Commission's work program. If you allow to react very shortly to Mr. Buuselager, statement. I mean, the big part of that can absolutely agree with. But I also would like to highlight that under One Europe, One Market, that for us, this is clear roadmap for single market completion by the end of 2027, where most of the initiatives are on the table and the co-legislator will need to find the agreements on them. And if you allow me, I know that you are already very generous with the time. The last point, but it's very crucial, Mr. President, on withdrawals. For the withdrawal annex of 2027, we did an honest assessment of all files that had been pending with co-legislator for a long time. Very often, many, many years. Co-legislator now have the opportunity to react in the months to come as stipulated in the institutional agreement, like every year. Your views, we'll be taking into account. If you can move with this proposals on the table, if you can move I can reassure you, there will be very happy to see that. And therefore, I look at the withdrawal list as a political momentum, as a political push to clearly work with the co-legislator on this file and to see if there is a political will to deliver. So, Mr. President, once again, I would like to thank you for your generosity with the speaking time. I hope that I addressed most of the concerns raised in this room. And we are very much looking forward to work with the European Parliament as a co-legislator on delivering the Commission's work program for the next year. [17:15:47] Esteban González Pons (PPE) [EN] Thank you very much, Mr. President. [17:15:48] Esteban González Pons (PPE) [EN] Thank you. [17:15:50] Esteban González Pons (PPE) [EN] Thank you very much, Mr. Commissioner. It is a very important debate. So it is justified. The debate now is closed. Our next issue is next item on the agenda is the report by Madame la Señora Pajín and Madame Veriga Union Civil Protection Mechanism and Union Support for Health Emergence and Preparedness and Response. [17:16:20] Esteban González Pons (PPE) [ES] The floor is now given to my friend, the rapporteur, Ms Pajín. [17:16:29] Leire Pajín (S&D) [ES] Thank you very much, dear President. Commissioner, welcome. Just a few days ago marked two years since the most devastating tragedy in our country in the region where I grew up. In Valencia. 234 people lost their lives in an absolutely devastating flood. And they lost everything. Their homes, their memories, their loved ones. I would like to dedicate, Your Honour, this debate to those victims. They were listened to here. And I pledged to them that we would work to improve the mechanisms for responding to such disasters. And I also want to remember the victims of the wildfires that have ravaged our countries this summer. Spain too. And, of course, the emergency services, the firefighters. To the volunteers. To all those who come to the rescue in the most difficult moments. Because we are living through times of climate crises. And today, other DANAs are once again striking the Mediterranean. Every summer, forest fires will start earlier and last longer. They are more virulent and more difficult to extinguish. And with the pandemic, moreover, we learned in a very costly way that epidemic outbreaks come and spread in the time it takes a person to travel from one place to another. And therefore, that global health crises are also important. The climate emergency is now the new normal on our planet. And at the same time, there are new hybrid risks that are drawing ever closer. That is why, to tackle these risks, the European Union has equipped itself with a European civil protection mechanism, which is now 25 years old. This is surely the clearest and most concrete expression of the solidarity of the European people, of the European countries. Parliament has welcomed the Commission's new proposal to improve this mechanism, above all in its anticipation and prevention phase. And we must do this first and foremost by providing more resources. We cannot respond better to new crises, which we say are more virulent and more complex, with fewer resources. [17:18:43] Leire Pajín (S&D) [ES] We need more. We also have to improve our coordination. In times of crisis, we must cooperate and we must share information. And we must deploy the best mechanisms and the best capabilities for everyone. But we must also put the best scientific evidence at the service of public policies. We must gather the best knowledge and turn it into real solutions. We must strengthen the capacities and resources available to respond better to crises. But above all, we need to anticipate. To prevent better. To be able to get there before what happens. The shared objective of almost all the groups in this House is precisely to achieve a resilient society. One that has a true culture of preparedness. Inclusive, supportive, to face all risks. That is why our message is very clear. We cannot do more with less. We need more resources. But we also need to have a greater capacity for prevention and, above all, to make citizens understand what their role is in these crises. Knowing when to act, how to act, with what resources to act. We must educate that population. Lastly, we also have to fight against disinformation. Against falsehoods. Which cause so much damage in these crises. But for that, we also need tools. Tools that will fight against that disinformation. We have woven a high level of consensus and we understand that the proposal that that we will debate today is a better proposal. That is why we hope that tomorrow’s vote, all that technical work, that political capacity, will translate into a resounding political consensus. So that we can have a mechanism that protects lives, that anticipates crises and that is more effective. Thank you very much. [17:20:29] Speaker 2 [ES] Thank you very much, Ms Pajín. [17:20:31] Aurelijus Veryga (ECR) [EN] Mr. Veriga, you have the floor. As reporter as well. [17:20:37] Aurelijus Veryga (ECR) [EN] Thank you. President, Commissioner, first I would like to sincerely thank Corrapporteur Leire Pajín for her constructive cooperation throughout this process. I would also like to thank all the shadow reporters and all members of Parliament who contributed with their proposals and all the technical stuff for their expertise and excellent work together. Today Europe is faced with a fundamentally different environment from the one we knew just a decade ago. The report prepared by former Finnish President Sauli Niinistö clearly identifies the challenges we must be ready to face. Military aggression, hybrid attacks, cyber threats, disruption to critical infrastructure, pandemics, and increasingly severe climate-related disasters. Building on the recommendations of this report, the strategy promotes a whole-of-society and whole-of-government approach. We cannot limit ourselves to responding to disasters after they have happened. We must invest in preparing our institutions and professionals and societies before emergencies occur. The COVID-19 pandemic thought as a very important lesson. Even the wealthiest and most developed European countries were not sufficiently prepared for a major health emergency. Health preparedness must become a clearly defined and properly financed part of the European Civil Protection. We need strategic reserves, trained professionals, sufficient emergency capacity, and effective cross-border cooperation. At the same time, we are witnessing increasingly severe climate-related emergencies. These events threaten lives, destroy infrastructure, disrupt essential services. South and East European countries are particularly exposed to wildfires, droughts, and extreme heat. Other regions face serious flooding and severe storms. For countries along the European Union's eastern border, including my own country Lithuania, the situation is even more complicated. We face not only natural disasters but also the very real possibility of military aggression, hybrid attacks, sabotage, cyber [17:23:12] Aurelijus Veryga (ECR) [EN] operations, and the deliberate disruption of critical infrastructure. We must prepare not only for natural disasters but also for situations where civil military cooperation is essential to support society during military or hybrid threats, while respecting Member States' competences and preserving the UCPM's civilian nature. This means strengthening emergency services, evacuation capacities, shelters, communications, and the ability of public institutions to maintain essential functions. European solidarity must be based on a common level of ambition, but it must also recognize the specific risks faced by different Member States and regions. Finally, none of these ambitions can be achieved without adequate financing. And I would like to thank my colleagues for their support in our efforts to secure a larger budget for the UCPM and a clearer allocation of resources to different areas of preparedness, particularly health emergency preparedness. Dear colleagues, the cost of preparedness might seem significant. But the cost of not being unprepared is always much higher measured not only in financial losses but above all in human lives. So therefore, I call all of you to support this document. Thank you. [17:24:46] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much, Mr. Veriga. [17:24:50] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, Mr. Veriga. My next speaker is Madame La Rive. On behalf of the Commission. [17:25:02] 251198 [EN] Honorable Members, thank you first of all for this opportunity to discuss the proposal on the UCPM and I would like first of all to thank you, the Parliament and especially the two rapporteurs. You know that indeed last week we celebrated the 25th anniversary of the Union Civil Protection Mechanism here in Brussels. 2,500 fighters rescuers, young people, social partners, and businesses from 80 nationalities came to Brussels to exchange on and brainstorming on the way we prepare for and respond to emergencies. And this was indeed an occasion to acknowledge the contribution of the UCPM in the last quarter of century. And since its creation, the UCPM has been activated more than 900 times by 160 countries. For wildfires, floods, earthquakes, population displacement, repatriation, medical evacuations, and many, many other operations. Our UCPM is an operational tool that makes a difference on the ground. And in recent years, it has been activated 10 times more than at its start. The UCPM is what Europe can do best when we stand together but we need to update and enhance it for the future. And I would like again to thank the European Parliament for your constructive cooperation and for the report that you will be putting to the vote tomorrow. Your report reflects the Parliament's strong engagement with this proposal and our shared recognition that Europe must be better prepared and capable of anticipating and effectively managing future disasters and crises. The proposals draws from recent lessons. Climate-related events, COVID-19 pandemic, and Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine expose critical vulnerabilities in our collective system and show that preparedness requires collective action at EU level. Recent developments such as the Ebola outbreak in Central Africa are reminders of the health threats we must be ready to face. These complex risks require stronger systemic preparedness and proactive and coordinated approach across different sectors. And to look at risk and threat with 360-degree approach. [17:27:43] 251198 [EN] Crises are increasingly interconnected across multiple sectors and regions. This is precisely why the Commission proposed a single instrument bringing together civil protection and funding for health emergency preparedness and response. And this is also why we have proposed establishing a crisis coordination hub and strengthening the civil military cooperation. Our goal is simple. We must equip the Union with an integrated all-hazards and cross-sectoral framework. By breaking down silos, we can act faster and more effectively when the next crisis comes to support our Member States or other in need. I therefore welcome the Parliament's report which strongly backs the core pillars of our proposals. Let me now turn to the budget, where I appreciate your support for an expanded financial envelope. We have put forward an instrument with a budget of 10. 7 billion reflecting the scale of the challenges we face. In today's unpredictable world, this level of ambition is really essential. In this slide, the discussions in the Council are really concerning. Some capitals still see preparedness as a cost, but past crises have shown that the cost of not being prepared is much higher for our lives, for our societies, but also for our economies. Preparedness is not a cost. It is an investment in building a stronger and more resilient Union and protecting our citizens. At the same time, this instrument must remain operationally agile and financially flexible. We cannot predict what will happen in the next seven years. Therefore, earmarking would limit our ability to move resources rapidly where they are most needed. I count on your continued cooperation and you can count on mine to continue to support this House and the Council towards a timely agreement on that proposal. This is essential to ensure the necessary preparations in 2027 and allow the program to start strongly in 2028 without delay. Thank you. [17:30:22] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you, very much, Madame Commissioner. On behalf of the City Committee, Mr. Terrebes. [17:30:33] Cristian Terheş (ECR) [EN] Thank you. Dear colleagues, on behalf of many peoples in AXA and the City Committee, it is my pleasure to inform you that the Civil Protection Mechanism represents one of the most comprehensive files for crisis responses written in recent years. The core of CPM is resilience, our ability to withstand or recover quickly from threats we face. It covers a range of responsible capabilities, tools, and resources the EU needs to assist Member States coping with the mounting challenges we are faced with every year. This includes installing in our leadership the tools needed to overcome the ever-expanding threats of hybrid warfare. We were able to ensure key pillars were added into the CPM so that Member States were given the much-needed resources and force multipliers to enhance our resilience. The five key points are shelters, and protective spaces, critical infrastructure, protection, civilian and military cooperation, volunteers, and joint training. We must be realistic about the challenges we face and the fact that they will grow in the upcoming years. Yet, we must remain optimistic that with initiatives such as CPM, we will get stronger and move faster than the situation can worsen. Thank you. [17:31:54] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. [17:31:56] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. [17:31:57] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, dear colleague. On behalf of the DFEC Committee, Mr. Schornstedt. [17:32:05] Barry Andrews (Renew) [EN] No. [17:32:05] Barry Andrews (Renew) [EN] Mr. Andrews. [17:32:07] Barry Andrews (Renew) [EN] It's okay. [17:32:09] Barry Andrews (Renew) [EN] Mr. Schornstedt is over there. Thank you, Mr. President. Commissioner, colleagues, obviously like everybody else, I very much welcome the expansion of the Civil Protection Mechanism. I think it's one of the most successful programs under your leadership, Commissioner, that we have had as an expression of our influence across the neighborhood, and that's been very much welcome. It's like an insurance policy, an effectively we're expanding our insurance cover by moving into health resilience. And I think it's really important that we recognize that we cannot construct that resilience just within our EU borders. And that's why the development committee insists that we extend the remit to fragile and conflict-affected countries, particularly around the Mediterranean, the Sahel, and the Horn of Africa. Their health security is our health security. Their strength is our strength. There are no silos. And I know we can rely on you, Commissioner, to ensure that what we are developing here aligns with the EU Global Health Strategy, but also the EU framework on one health. I know that you will also ensure that the crisis coordination hub engages with fragile and conflict-affected countries, to make sure that we have protocols around reporting and frameworks around information. And finally, I recommend that we extend this to the overseas countries and territories. And that's contained in the development opinion. Thank you very much. Thank you very much, Mr. Andrews. On behalf of the budget committee of the committee, the real Mr. Schornstedt. [17:33:40] Jonas Sjöstedt (The Left) [SV] Thank you very much, Mr President. The European Civil Protection Mechanism is a very good example of concrete European cooperation, and the proposal is welcome. However, when we examined it in the Committee on Budgetary Control, it is also clear that there are significant risks from a budgetary control perspective. And this is something that is confirmed by a recent report from the European Court of Auditors. Here we have a mix of funding sources, with the main responsibility lying with the participating countries. The EU’s role in this area is increasing, and there is a significant risk of double funding, both in terms of national and EU funding, as well as between different EU programmes. We want to address this by increasing transparency and traceability, by taking concrete measures to prevent double financing, and by defining what the EU’s added value actually consists of. It is also necessary to clarify the explicit audit rights of the EU’s relevant bodies in this area. Some of our proposals have been taken on board. There could have been a few more, but we welcome it anyway. [17:34:48] Jonas Sjöstedt (The Left) [SV] Thank you, Mr President. [17:34:50] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, dear colleague. On behalf of the Reggie Committee, Mr. Preblich. [17:35:01] Vladimir Prebilič (Verts/ALE) [SL] I will speak in Slovenian. Honourable colleagues, my report on this topic was adopted in the REGGIE committee six months ago. Since then, more than 35,000 Europeans have died as a result of climate change, direct damage amounting to more than €13 billion has been caused, and our economy has suffered a loss of more than €100 billion in revenue. And Europe, every time a crisis strikes, just chases the damage after the fact. This is largely a failure of policy and is completely unacceptable. I myself maintain that we do not need just minor fixes, but we must be more ambitious. We need RescEU 2.0, a permanently ready European reserve aircraft, health teams and rescue units that will be available within a matter of hours. Investing in this security is currently the most important investment, more so than is the case for conventional defence. Above all, however, we need a common European responsiveness. In crises, European action must be an unconditional duty; let us stop creating tragedies and start preventing them. Thank you. [17:36:16] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, dear colleague. Thank you very much, dear colleague. We already have enough cuts that I request, so I'm going to close the option. Now, on behalf of the EPP group, Mr. Armond. [17:36:32] Pascal Arimont (PPE) [DE] Thank you very much, Mr President, Commissioner. This is about European civil protection, the Civil Protection Mechanism, which we have been working on together here over the past few months. I could now say something about every article here, but instead I would like to tell you a story that happened while we were negotiating this text. At the time, I was in my homeland in East Belgium, in a 3,000-hectare forest that was on fire. And during this fire, we activated this civil protection mechanism. This means that firefighting aircraft came from two other countries, helicopters from six other countries, the fire was really bad, but the help that arrived was good. That was European solidarity. We all know that these disasters are increasing, they are increasing exponentially. The fires, the droughts, the storms, the pandemics – this will increase. So we need to be better prepared. That means we need to build a small civil protection army, buy firefighting aircraft, have them built here, we need to expand this crisis centre in Brussels, which has been coordinating these fires, and turn it into a hub that can coordinate when multiple pandemics or environmental disasters occur. And above all, we need to think about the people who are there when nature strikes, and that is the firefighters, the volunteer firefighters. We need to remove administrative hurdles for them so they can continue this voluntary work. But we also need to involve farmers and contractors who voluntarily drive to the scene with their water tankers in the event of a fire. We need to integrate them into our crisis plans, and that will improve our disaster protection. Disaster protection means not having to improvise when nature strikes; disaster protection means being well prepared so that we can protect what is important to us. That is our people and our homeland. Thank you. [17:38:28] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, dear colleague. On behalf of the S&D group, Mr. Andrew Cattis. [17:38:35] Vytenis Povilas Andriukaitis (S&D) [EN] Thank you. Dear colleagues, in front of simultaneously occurring wildfires, floods, pandemics, and hybrid threats, funding for union civil protection mechanism must not be cut. With no financial envelope, with 100 flexibility is problematic. With no floor for either civil protection or health preparedness, there is no legal guarantee what share either will get. We must have untouchable reserves, 30% of which is for health emergencies. Health preparedness cannot be whatever funding remains after everything else has been allocated. We should invest in our healthcare workforce, firefighters, and volunteers. Preparedness plans for climate-related risks, including anticipation, prevention, and regional vulnerability mapping, creation of recovery readiness frameworks, and stockpiling medical countermeasures, must be urgently implemented at union level. To the council, I say this: 35% cut is not a saving. It only pushes the cost forward. There are not just tangible costs, but also the cost of human life. Preparedness is never a waste of money. Being unprepared always costs more. [17:39:59] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [EN] Thank you very much, dear colleague. On behalf of the PFE group, Madame Connexta. [17:40:06] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [SK] Dear colleagues, Mr President, Commissioner. [17:40:09] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [CS] Wherever floods or any other natural disaster strike in the European Union, European assistance must be swift and effective. But, for example, decisions on the deployment of Czech firefighters, our hospitals and crisis plans must be made in the Czech Republic, not in Brussels. This proposal links civil protection with health crises. It expands European coordination and envisages more than €12 billion. However, the French Senate has already questioned whether the proposal sufficiently respects the competences of the Member States. This is already becoming something of a classic. Every time something is reformed, greater centralisation is introduced and Brussels usurps more powers. So where does assistance end and interference in the decision-making of Member States begin? I support the sharing of equipment, supplies, information and an increase in resources. However, I will not support a proposal that does not provide sufficiently clear guarantees that the final say in resolving crises in a given Member State will rest with that Member State. [17:41:11] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, dear colleague. On behalf of the ECR group, Vice President Sverna. [17:41:21] Antonella Sberna (ECR) [IT] Commissioner, colleagues, we have now reached the voting stage on this mechanism for the revision of the Union civil protection mechanism and I would first of all like to thank the rapporteurs, Ms Pagini and Ms Veriga, for their excellent work and all the colleagues, and for their commitment and efforts to create a synthesis and to collaborate during these negotiations. We know how complex it is precisely because it involves finding a compromise on mechanisms that affect Member States, directly touching each one in terms of their specificities, whether technical or geographical, with different traditions, and above all with first-instance intervention. For Italy, as you know, ensuring the effectiveness of the Union mechanism is fundamental. Our country has a consolidated system and therefore we have contributed; we hope to improve this proposal. We are aware of the need for strengthening, precisely because situations—including geopolitical ones—demand it. I hope that the vote in this plenary session and the discussion we are holding today, the vote that will take place in the coming days, will help to improve it even further and make it truly useful for our national systems, the European mechanism in general and, above all, to provide concrete and immediate responses to all European citizens. Thank you. [17:42:38] Speaker 1 [EN] Grazie, onorevole. On behalf of the Renew group, Mr. Alion. [17:42:45] Grégory Allione (Renew) [FR] Mr President, Commissioner, dear colleagues, here in this Assembly we are defending an ambitious budget alongside the Commission. We are calling for more than €12.4 billion for the benefit of the European Union Civil Protection Mechanism, while some Member States are trying to cut it by more than a third. Why are we defending this position? Because this mechanism is indispensable. More than 900 activations since 2001, more than 12 mobilisations in 2026, and civil protection must not be a budgetary adjustment variable. Some have said it: we need to move from reaction to anticipation, to prevent and prepare populations, but above all by relying on elected representatives and our local areas, which are at the heart of resilience. We must also promote local engagement, through firefighters, farmers and volunteers who are involved, and establish a European Resilience Day and, above all, a European Resilience Label to highlight what our local authorities are doing. Finally, to strengthen European sovereignty, Commissioner, with the need to have European air capabilities, a European civil protection industry to reduce our dependence on the outside. Because our ability to protect Europeans must be in our hands and not in those of others. Thank you. [17:44:04] Speaker 1 [FR] Thank you. On behalf. [17:44:06] Speaker 1 [EN] Of the Greens and Madame Merz. [17:44:13] Tilly Metz (Verts/ALE) [EN] Thank you, dear President. Wildfires flood heatwaves, pandemics, and health emergencies. The crisis Europe faces are becoming increasingly frequent, complex, and interconnected. They all remind us of one simple fact: disasters do not stop at national borders. Neither should our response. The text we are voting takes an important step towards a more coordinated European civil protection mechanism. Because protecting people means addressing climate risk, strengthening the health system, and ensuring no one is left behind. We often say that Europe grows stronger in times of crisis, but this does not happen by itself. It takes political will, solidarity, and courage to act together. And that means acting before disaster strikes, not just reacting when it does. So let us take that responsibility. Let us build a Europe that is better prepared, more resilient, and ready to protect everyone. Thank you. [17:45:30] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you, dear colleagues. On behalf of the Left, La Signora Martins. [17:45:41] Catarina Martins (The Left) [PT] Mr President, Commissioner, the question is not whether we will spend more on civil protection, because we will. The question is whether we are spending it well. Today, in Portugal, civil protection is asking the population to stay at home, which is easier for those who have a safe home than for those who have no roof over their heads or are still waiting for a roof since last winter's storms. And even before the storm arrived, floods, thousands of people without electricity due to heavy rainfall. Extreme weather events are becoming more frequent, and the infrastructure is not prepared. A European Union budget that cuts spending on transition and adaptation to invest in weapons is, for that very reason, a tragedy. And the same applies to civil protection. Fighter jets and military frigates do not put out fires or rescue flood victims. Civil aid needs its own budget, a robust one, exclusively civilian, that does not live off scraps nor serve as a shortcut to finance the war machine under the pretext of dual use. We support Parliament’s proposal in calling for support for countries on the front line, health reserves, rights for firefighters, and rapid recovery mechanisms. But all of this requires a budget that military rhetoric is undermining. When disaster strikes in Portugal or Poland, in France or Greece, Europe must respond with solidarity. That means rescue means, equipped firefighters, support for those who have lost everything. Civil protection cannot be dual use. Civil protection is for peace, for life and for the climate. [17:47:19] Speaker 1 [EN] Obrigado. On behalf of the ESN group, Mr. Jongen. [17:47:28] Marc Jongen (ESN) [DE] Ms Commissioner Labib, you are recommending that citizens stockpile 72 hours' worth of supplies of water, food and medication. [17:47:36] Marc Jongen (ESN) [EN] Ready for anything. [17:47:37] Marc Jongen (ESN) [DE] This campaign is driving people into a panic and suggesting an imminent collapse. In doing so, it conceals the fact that the crises being lamented are almost all man-made. The NATO’s drive eastwards, complete with war drums, mass migration, ideological energy policy, and astronomical levels of debt—only the weather is not man-made, contrary to your claim. A permanent state of emergency logic is driving a dangerous military-civilian fusion towards totalitarianism. The UCBM proposal today follows precisely this pattern, with the new Crisis Coordination Hub set to be rammed through despite existing disaster protection structures, and to become immediately effective in the event of a health emergency declared by the WHO. [17:48:45] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, dear colleague. The Commissioner can take the floor now. [17:48:57] 251198 [EN] Thank you, Mr. President, and I will speak French, so take your headset if needed. [17:49:04] 251198 [FR] Je voudrais tout d'abord remercier le Parlement européen pour son large support et pour cette première discussion très fructueuse. Tout d'abord, le risque de duplication : il n'y a pas de risque de financement double. Et je dois dire qu'entendre cet argument me semble totalement déconnecté de la réalité de terrain. Cet été, par exemple, durant la saison des feux de forêt, nous avons fait appel à tous les moyens européens, donc ceux qui sont dans le pool européen, certifiés par l'Union européenne, et ceux, évidemment, qui sont dans notre réserve stratégique. Nous avons dû aussi voir des États membres qui sont spontanésment venus à l'aide des uns des autres. Donc, c'était... on était vraiment au point maximum de nos réserves. On a tout utilisé. Venir dire maintenant : « Il y aurait peut-être un risque de double financement » me semble totalement déconnecté de la réalité. Pour la nature, du désastre, merci de prendre tout en considération. Aujourd'hui, on a soudainement des frigos dans nos magasins qui cessent de fonctionner. On a des alertes à la bombe dans des écoles, des centaines en Italie qui ont poussé à l'évacuation d'enfants. Donc, les menaces sont de plus en plus hybrides, imprévues. Il faut absolument que l'on se prépare à toute cette imprévisibilité, avec une longueur d'avance et avant qu'elle n'arrive. Pour ce qui est de la coopération civile au militaire, bien sûr, c'est sensible. Mais aujourd'hui, quelle est la réalité ? Quand il y a des feux de forêt, est-ce que vous demandez à quel corps de métier appartenez-vous ? Est-ce que vous êtes militaire ? Est-ce que vous êtes de la protection civile ? Est-ce que vous êtes agriculteur ? Est-ce que vous êtes citoyen bénévole ? Non. On vient, on y va, on répond à l'urgence. C'est ça, la réalité de terrain. Mais il faut qu'on soit coordonnés. Cet été, j'ai vu des opérations qui étaient extrêmement compliquées sur le terrain parce qu'on ne savait pas comment coordonner. Quelle architecture ? À quel ordre répondre ? Et donc, tout ça, il faut le savoir avant que l'urgence arrive. [17:51:18] 251198 [FR] Donc, s'il vous plaît, soyez flexibles, faites un petit peu preuve d'imagination, parce que ce qui nous tombera demain dessus, eh bien, est totalement imprévisible. Je vous remercie. [17:51:31] Speaker 1 [FR] Thank you, Madam. [17:51:32] Speaker 1 [EN] We jump now in the next part of the debate. First, my first speaker is going to be Madame Pitikainen. [17:51:47] Sirpa Pietikäinen (PPE) [EN] We need coordinated action, as our Commissioner just stated, out. And we know we are going to have more crises, different kinds of crises in the future. They are derived from the climate, from cyberattacks, from pandemics, and the unsecure safety environment. And these crises are going to be interlinked and multiplying, and they are going to be in the future much more systemic. So we owe it to our citizens that we have a proper preparation mechanism and action mechanism. And you can't do it on the side when the crisis hits. You have to have it, and you have to plan it in before. And then another point, and this is the fact that the Member States can't do it alone. Like the volunteers, firefighters, they can't do it alone. Someone needs to be the actor and the coordinator. And as we know, the role is in the Council to set up the situation when this sets on force. Then it is the European Coordination. And we need not only better coordination, we need better finance. And I urge everybody to contact the own ministers and the Council members because it is duly unresponsible to try to cut the finance what we have preserved here to save our citizens. [17:53:33] Speaker 1 [EN] Madame Pitikainen, you have a blue card from Madame Binieska from ECR. Do you accept it? Yes, seat 361. [17:53:45] Jadwiga Wiśniewska (ECR) [EN] I will speak Polish. [17:53:48] Jadwiga Wiśniewska (ECR) [PL] Dziękuję Pani za przyjęcie pytania. Chciałabym odnieść się do Ochotniczych Straży Pożarnych. Bardzo się cieszę, że docenia Pani ich znaczenie. W Polsce do Ochotniczych Straży Pożarnych należy ponad 700 000 wolontariuszy. To jest ogromna armia ludzi, którzy niosą pomoc w potrzebie. Czy nie obawia się Pani, że proponowane regulacje nałożą biurokrację na te właśnie ochotnicze organizacje, które są pierwsze, jeśli chodzi o niesienie pomocy? Dziękuję. [17:54:28] Sirpa Pietikäinen (PPE) [EN] Thank you for the question. It's very relevant. No, I do not fear it. I'm quite certain this is going to cut down the bureaucracy because if you have the bureaucracy and Member State level, then you will need to coordinate with some other Member State. You need to coordinate with Red Cross, you need to coordinate with medical staff, you need to figure out on ICU doctors whether you have the permits and licenses to work in Germany if you are friends or vice versa. This is the bureaucracy. EU means one rulebook, one action, pre-planned systems what to do. And this is less bureaucracy. This kind of a chaotic way of doing things on my opinion. Is more bureaucracy. Thank you. [17:55:18] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, Madame Pitikainen. My next speaker is Mr. Maren. [17:55:26] Pierfrancesco Maran (S&D) [IT] Grazie, Presidente. Colleghi, vogliamo che i cittadini sentano l'Europa più vicina? Beh, allora dobbiamo esserci quando hanno bisogno. Le alluvioni, gli incendi di quest'estate ci ricordano quanto siamo vulnerabili di fronte ai cambiamenti climatici. Che negli ultimi quattro anni hanno causato oltre 200 miliardi di danni. Dobbiamo contrastare i cambiamenti climatici, ma è anche essere pronti quando le catastrofi colpiscono. Per questo la Commissione Ambiente, che presiedo, ha chiesto con forza una vera protezione civile europea. Pronta ad affrontare ogni crisi. Una protezione civile che dica ai cittadini e alle comunità locali: non siete soli. L'Europa c'è ed è al vostro fianco. Ma per farla servono investimenti e risorse adeguate. Per questo chiediamo che i 27 Stati membri sostengano davvero che non riducano le ambizioni prospettate da Parlamento e Commissione. L'Europa si fonda sulla solidarietà. Facciamo sì che la protezione civile europea ne diventi un simbolo dell'Europa di oggi e di domani. Grazie. [17:56:34] Olivier Chastel (Renew) [EN] Sorry. Thank you very much. My next speaker is Mr. Chastle. [17:56:41] Olivier Chastel (Renew) [FR] Merci, Monsieur le Président, Madame la Commissaire, chers collègues. Quand on pense aux réussites européennes, on évoque souvent Erasmus, Schengen ou la fin du roaming. Eh bien, il existe. Il existe une autre success story, peu connue du grand public: le mécanisme européen de protection civile. Depuis 25 ans, ce mécanisme est l'illustration de la solidarité européenne en mobilisant rapidement les moyens de plusieurs pays face aux catastrophes. Mais face à des crises de plus en plus complexes, nous devons mieux anticiper, mieux nous préparer, mieux réagir. Et c'est tout le sens de la proposition de la Commissaire Hadjalabib qui a fait de la préparation des citoyens en crise une priorité. Une autre avancée majeure pour la première fois: la santé sera pleinement intégrée au mécanisme. Une évolution essentielle pour tirer les leçons de la pandémie de Covid-19. La position du Parlement est ambitieuse et équilibrée. J'espère que les États membres partageront cette vision, celle d'une Europe qui anticipe, qui agit et qui protège. Une Europe concrète au service de ses citoyens. Je vous remercie. [17:57:51] Speaker 1 [EN] Merci, Monsieur. You have a blue card from Mr. Tannin. Do you accept it? From the EPP group. Do you accept it? Mr. Tannin, you have the floor. Seat 113. [17:58:07] Matej Tonin (PPE) [SL] Collega Strinjam se z vami, da je evropski mehanizem civilne zaščite uspeh. Pa se vam ne zdi, da bi pa veljalo kljub temu ga nadgraditi v smislu, da bi ta mehanizem tudi ponujal skupne zmogljivosti, na primer letala za gašenje? Da bi več pozornosti posvečal interoperabilnosti, kar pomeni, da slovenski gasilci lahko sodelujejo s francoskimi in podobnimi stvarmi. Ali vidite priložnost, da se mehanizem nadgradi v še močnejšega, še boljšega? Ker so naravne nesreče vedno bolj brutalne. Seveda, évidemment, il faut développer de plus en plus cette solidarité européenne. Mais d'autres l'ont évoqué avant moi: il faudra pour cela que les États membres se mettent d'accord sur un budget adapté aux ambitions que nous avons pour le mécanisme. [17:59:07] Željana Zovko (PPE) [EN] Merci, Monsieur. My next speaker is Madame Safko. [17:59:13] Željana Zovko (PPE) [EN] Thank you very much. Mr. President, Madame Commissioner, I agree absolutely with you that we in a case of fire, in a case of hybrid threats, and in the case of big floods, no one will ask from which part the army comes from because we will need also the army. I remember in 2018 when I did this first renewed rescue mechanism, the journalist asked me when we presented it in Split, "Why do you need this field hospital? " and stuff that was presented in the first rescue mechanism. And they were laughing when we mentioned that they might be big pandemic. And 2020, we understood what this rescue mechanism meant. And that's why I agree that we need 11 billion for this because this is the only helping hand in a case of need, in a case of threats that are coming. And coming from Croatia, it's a golden boy and I mean golden lady or whatever. Of civil protection, we have a good place, we have good firefighters, we have excellent people, but we need much more money for preparedness, we need much more money for our firefighters, we need also to facilitate their work and also to anticipate how to prepare ourselves, how to prepare how to educate our children to prepare for the catastrophes because we cannot lie to our citizens. Catastrophes are going to come and we are still not prepared. So keep good work. [18:00:46] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Dear colleagues, my next speaker is Mr. Clérigou. [18:00:59] Christophe Clergeau (S&D) [FR] Monsieur le Président, Madame la Commissaire, si nous voulons protéger les Européens, il va falloir s'attaquer aux vulnérabilités sociales, environnementales et territoriales. Parce que oui, il faut se préparer, mais être très bien préparé ne suffira pas. Le même phénomène climatique, la même tempête, la même inondation n'aura pas les mêmes conséquences sur un territoire très vulnérable que sur un autre territoire mieux organisé. Alors oui, pour faire cela, il faut des politiques de solidarité, des politiques d'aménagement du territoire, et de solutions basées sur la nature qui soient extrêmement ambitieuses. Et je ne sais pas si le budget que nous avons suffira à le faire, ça doit devenir une ambition transversale des politiques européennes. Et ensuite, si nous voulons réellement défendre les citoyens, leur permettre d'avoir un futur il va falloir réparer les territoires, les plus frappés. Quand la question d'habiter encore des territoires se pose en France, dans l'Aude, après les feux, ou dans la Gironde, après les feux de cet été. Et là, ces territoires se sentent abandonnés. Et ce sont des centaines de millions ou des milliards d'euros qui vont être nécessaires pour redonner un avenir à ces territoires. En Europe continentale et dans les outre-mer qui sont aussi très exposés. Et là, dans le budget européen, je ne vois pas les solutions qui sont proposées. J'ai besoin encore de réponses supplémentaires. Merci. [18:02:21] Speaker 1 [EN] Dear colleagues, you have two blue cards. Do you accept at least the first one? Dear colleagues, sorry. Do you accept a blue card? From Mr. Mularczyk from ECR, seat 576. Mr. Mularczyk, Mr. Mularczyk from ECR. [18:02:39] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [EN] Yes, thank you. Thank you very much. I will speak in Polish. [18:02:43] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Bardzo dziękuję za wystąpienie i przyjęcie pytania. Chcę zwrócić uwagę, że pan poseł podkreślił, że tych środków rzeczywiście może być za mało dla wszystkich potrzebujących krajów. Ale ja chcę zwrócić szczególną uwagę na kraje wschodniej flanki NATO, w szczególności na mój kraj, Polskę, który wydaje 5% PKB na bezpieczeństwo, dając bezpieczeństwo całej Unii Europejskiej. A jednocześnie musi ponosić wydatki na bezpieczeństwo dotyczące Klęsk żywiołowych. Czy uważa pan, że właśnie takie kraje powinny mieć specjalny status w tym programie? Dziękuję bardzo. [18:03:32] Christophe Clergeau (S&D) [FR] Moi, je crois que le principe de l'Union européenne, c'est un principe de solidarité. Les budgets qui sont prévus pour les politiques de préparation aux crises, côté protection civile, et côté santé, sont sûrement suffisants pour la préparation. Et encore, il faut le vérifier. Par contre, vous avez raison, les territoires vulnérables, c'est aussi la vulnérabilité en matière de défense. Mais c'est ensemble au niveau européen qu'il faut accompagner les territoires les plus vulnérables d'un point de vue environnemental ou social, et les territoires les plus exposés aux questions de sécurité et de défense. Et pour cela, il faut des fonds mutualisés à l'échelle européenne. Merci. [18:04:12] Speaker 1 [EN] Merci. [18:04:13] Speaker 2 [EN] Merci, Monsieur. My next speaker is Madame Wessler. [18:04:20] Andrea Wechsler (PPE) [DE] Sehr geehrter Herr Präsident, sehr geehrte Frau Kommissarin, oft hören wir Politiker von Bürgerinnen und Bürgern, dass sie von Europa im Alltag viel zu wenig spüren. Und manchmal ist das genau die beste Nachricht, wenn alles einfach läuft. Wenn die Feuerwehr rechtzeitig kommt, wenn das Krankenhaus vorbereitet ist, und wenn im Ernstfall Hilfe bereitsteht. Und genau darum geht es in dieser Woche. Wir beraten über ein neues Gesetz für den Katastrophenschutz und die Vorbereitung auf Gesundheitsrisiken 2028. Denn ob Hochwasser, Waldbrand oder Pandemie, kein Land kann jede Krise alleine bewältigen. Und wir kümmern uns deshalb um den Zivilschutz, bevor es ernst wird. Deshalb haben wir als Europäisches Parlament den ursprünglichen Vorschlag der Kommission konkret verbessert. Mit besserem Schutz für unsere freiwilligen Feuerwehren und ehrenamtlichen Rettungskräfte, mit Expertenteams, die nach Katastrophen helfen, mit Strom und Wasser schnell wiederherzustellen, und mit besserer Zusammenarbeit der bestehenden Stellen. Denn manchmal ist das Beste an Europa, dass die Bürgerinnen und Bürger gar nichts davon spüren, weil wir vorgesorgt haben, bevor es ernst wird. [18:05:29] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. Dear colleagues, now we begin with the Cats de Ai. I have to tell you that I have lots of requests, so not everybody is going to be able to get it. I will try to give as much as possible. My first speaker is going to be Mr. Sokol, seat 347. [18:05:50] Tomislav Sokol (PPE) [HR] Hvala lijepa. Od uspostavljanja 2001. godine, mehanizam Unije za civilnu zaštitu aktiviran je više od 900 puta. To pokazuje koliko europska solidarnost važna kada katastrofe ugroze živote i sigurnost naših građana. Za Hrvatsku, ali i ostale mediteranske države, ovaj mehanizam iznimno važan zbog šumskih požara koji svake godine čine ogromnu štetu. Zahvaljujući europskoj suradnji, možemo računati na dodatne protupožarne zrakoplove, opremu i stručnjake kada nacionalni kapaciteti nisu dovoljni. Zato podržavam jačanje mehanizma kroz ulaganja u prevenciju, sustav ranog upozoravanja i brži odgovor na katastrofe. Moramo bolje povezati europske, nacionalne i lokalne službe kako bi pomoć pravovremeno stigla ondje gdje je najpotrebnija. Pozdravno pozdravljam snažnije povezivanje civilne zaštite sa zdravstvenom pripravnošću. Pandemija nam je pokazala da zdravstvene prijetnje ne poznaju granice. Potrebna nam je stoga pravodobna razmjena informacija i učinkovita koordinacija među državama članicama. Kolegice i kolege, ulaganje u pripravnost nije trošak, nego ulaganje u živote, sigurnost zajednice, gospodarstvo. Naš cilj mora biti Europa koja ne čeka da katastrofa nastupi, nego unaprijed prepoznaje rizike, priprema odgovore i štiti građane. Hvala lijepa. [18:07:06] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. Madame Glavac, seat 500. [18:07:14] Sunčana Glavak (PPE) [HR] Hvala vam lijepa. Kolegice i kolege, ne slažem se s uštedama kada govorimo o životima ljudi i kada govorimo o spašavanju ljudi. Ono što je bitno, da nacionalne službe zadržavaju odgovornost za zaštitu građana, i to jasno želim istaknuti jer mislim da smo pomalo danas čuli krive informacije ili dezinformacije. Snažnije uključivanje lokalnih i regionalnih vlasti, ali i jasnu podjelu odgovornosti. Ovime se nadopunjavaju nacionalni kapaciteti, a ne zamjenjuju se nacionalni kapaciteti. Hrvatska je ne samo primateljica pomoći, već je Hrvatska uvijek tu kada treba. Naši vatrogasci i pripadnici civilne zaštite gorske službe spašavanja naše zračne snage pomažu drugima. Imamo 65 godina iskustva u civilnoj zaštiti. Ja mislim najduže u Europskoj uniji, stoga treba poslušati one koji to iskustvo mogu pretočiti u stvarnu pomoć našim ljudima i našim sugrađanima. I na kraju, ako nam svaka nova katastrofa pokazuje da nemamo dovoljno opreme i kapaciteta, onda nije dovoljno samo bolje organizirati odgovor. Hvala lijepa. [18:08:31] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. [18:08:32] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [ES] El señor López Aguilar, sitio 381. [18:08:36] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [ES] Gracias, presidente Pons. Comisaria Laviv, oportuna iniciativa la de un mecanismo europeo unificado de protección civil y respuesta ante emergencias sanitarias. Y excelente, el informe de nuestra compañera Leire Pajín, que no solamente asegura una amplia mayoría para su aprobación, sino una financiación histórica en el marco financiero plurianual de 11. 000 millones de euros que en ningún caso puede ser rebajada por el Consejo como propone la presidencia irlandesa. Prevención y anticipación antes que reacción, y un centro europeo de coordinación de crisis que no solamente transmita alerta y combata bulos que tanto daño hacen ante ese tipo de emergencias imponiendo obligaciones de coordinación a las autoridades regionales y locales, sino sobre todo impida que pueda volver a repetirse la cacofonía de medidas de emergencia, adoptadas por los Estados miembros unilateralmente, como sucedió en la crisis del COVID. En aquel momento la Unión Europea reaccionó a tiempo, pero reaccionó. Es el momento de la anticipación y de la prevención, como propone el informe de Leire Pajín. Por tanto, enhorabuena. [18:09:47] Speaker 1 [EN] Muchas gracias. Mr. Besliga, seat 719. [18:09:54] Marko Vešligaj (S&D) [EN] Thank you, Chair. I'll speak on Croatian. [18:09:57] Marko Vešligaj (S&D) [HR] Novi europski mehanizam civilne zaštite prilika je koja se ne smije propustiti. Prilika za jačanje spremnosti i odgovora na sve učestalije krize i katastrofe. No u središtu svakog sustava, pa tako i ovoga, su dakako ljudi na terenu. Nas u Hrvatskoj događanje ovoga ljeta u prvom redu požar na Omičkom području u kojem je, nažalost, 6 osoba izgubilo svoj život, podsjetila još jednom koliko su važni pravodobno upozoravanje i koordinacija službi. Sustav ranoga upozoravanja tada je, nažalost, zakazao. I to u trenutku kad su se naši vatrogasci borili s požarom katastrofalnih razmjera. Zato novi mehanizam mora u prvom redu prepoznati i vrednovati ulogu profesionalnih i dobrovoljnih vatrogasaca gorske službe spašavanja i svih drugih službi civilne zaštite koje u ovakvim situacijama riskiraju svoje živote kako bi spasili naše. Civilna zaštita zato nije samo pitanje opreme i koordinacija, nego je pitanje ljudi. A njihova sigurnost i priznanje njihova doprinosa moraju biti europski prioritet. [18:11:03] Jadwiga Wiśniewska (ECR) [EN] Madame Bisnieska, seat 361. [18:11:07] Jadwiga Wiśniewska (ECR) [PL] Thank you very much, Mr President. The protection of the population and the organisation of healthcare are fundamental competences of the Member States. The EU mechanism should therefore constitute an efficient safety net and support at the request of a Member State, rather than becoming a tool for top-down control or centralisation. Poland and the Central and Eastern European region are located in the immediate vicinity of the war in Ukraine, and these areas are exposed to hybrid attacks, sabotage and the spillover effects of the conflict. Therefore, EU support, with full respect for sovereignty and the principle of subsidiarity, must support bordering states. It is also worth highlighting the role of volunteer fire brigades and protecting them from Brussels bureaucracy. [18:12:04] Speaker 2 [PL] Dziękuję. [18:12:08] Stine Bosse (Renew) [EN] Thank you very much. Madame Vaucier, seat 104. [18:12:15] Stine Bosse (Renew) [EN] Thank you very much. And thank you for the excellent work you're doing. I want to concentrate on one crisis, perhaps the largest crisis that we will ever face: one which is now spiraling out of our control, namely the climate crisis. Europe is, as you know well, the continent that is warming the fastest, but it's also the continent with the highest concentration of wealth. Heating threatens health and wealth. Buildings, homes, businesses, and lives we still need to fight the warming. We need to lower our CO2 emissions. We need to work with our resilience, as you are very well doing, we need to know how to build buildings, we need how to know how to plan. And then, of course, at the end, also crisis management, as we're talking about this evening. But we need to see the three levels of defense because if we do not invest now, the budgets that we're talking about will be small. Then it will be huge costs. So let's also get the other things right. Thank you very much. [18:13:35] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. [18:13:37] Speaker 1 [ES] La señora Miranda en el escaño 234. [18:13:42] Ana Miranda Paz (Verts/ALE) [ES] Thank you very much, Mr President. Commissioner, you know as well as I do—because we have spoken about this many times—that we need a more comprehensive civil protection mechanism that can respond to serious situations such as the wildfires we are experiencing, and my colleague Leire Pajín knows this too, as we are also collaborating on this dossier within our group. We also need to listen, for example, to the firefighters. Just a week ago, firefighters from all over Europe came here to tell us about the problems they face, from Belgium to Galicia, from Croatia to Italy and from Finland to Romania. Therefore, these coordination and anticipation mechanisms must be based on solidarity and coordination. Unfortunately, crises—whether climate-related or natural disasters—no longer respect borders. And if we do not tackle this from a coordinated perspective, while also highlighting the need for prevention and anticipation, we must invest more resources. It cannot be that firefighters are working in precarious conditions, and it cannot be that we wait for European assistance when there is not even support in our own territories. That is why it is so important, as I always say, to increase support for civil protection and not tanks. [18:14:56] Speaker 1 [ES] Thank you very much, Ms Miranda. To conclude, the rapporteur, Ms Pajín, has the floor. [18:15:07] Leire Pajín (S&D) [ES] I would like my final words to be, first and foremost, to express my gratitude. [18:15:11] Leire Pajín (S&D) [ES] I would like to thank my colleague Aurelio Esberiga for his excellent work and cooperation. I would also like to thank all the shadow rapporteurs from the different parliamentary groups, because we have shown that in this House we are capable of doing outstanding political work by pooling our efforts and reaching consensus on a necessity, on a tool that will save lives. I also want to express my gratitude to the experts we have heard. To carry out this work, we have listened to experts, international bodies, professionals, firefighters, volunteers, who are a fundamental part. We have listened to the victims, and we have committed ourselves to them to prevent these crises from having the same impact again. We have also listened to different professional sectors. But I also want to acknowledge the excellent work of our technical teams. Behind the proposal we are debating today, there are many hours of work, of course, by the MEPs, but especially by our technical teams, who have done a great job. And I would like to send two final messages. The first concerns the need for this mechanism to be properly financially endowed. The crises we are facing today are very complex and of an unprecedented scale. Therefore, we need far more resources. And our work does not end here. It will continue in the trilogues, aiming, of course, to secure sufficient resources. The second message concerns the climate emergency context. Denying scientific evidence and the climate emergency is exposing us to ever greater risks. That is why we cannot allow this to continue to be a reality, even in the seats of this Chamber. We must especially reach out to the most vulnerable, which is why we also talk about vulnerability maps, and prevent elderly people from dying in care homes, as happened, for example, in my country during the pandemic. And finally, we must be able to anticipate and prevent the impact we have experienced, which has cost so many lives. [18:17:05] Leire Pajín (S&D) [ES] happens again. That is why our work today is to improve that mechanism here, to prevent, to anticipate and to save lives. [18:17:13] Speaker 3 [ES] Thank you very much. [18:17:14] Speaker 1 [ES] Thank you very much, Your Honour. [18:17:17] Aurelijus Veryga (ECR) [EN] Mr. Esberiga, you have the floor. [18:17:21] Aurelijus Veryga (ECR) [EN] Dear colleagues, first I would like to thank all of you for your contributions. You have clearly demonstrated just how important and necessary this mechanism is, especially as we celebrate its 25th anniversary this year. I would like to underline that between 2020 and 2024 alone, this mechanism has activated more than 650 times, four times as often as during the previous five years. These figures clearly demonstrate the growing need for this mechanism and importance of strengthening of our preparedness. Preparedness requires investment, effort, and political will. But we must remember one simple truth: when disasters strike, it is often too late to start preparing. At that moment, we are no longer counting the money we could have saved, we are counting lifes lost, homes destroyed, and families whose lives have been changed forever. That is why we have responsibility to act today, so that tomorrow we do not have to regret that what we failed to do. Because preparedness is not simply an investment. In security, it is above all an investment in human lives. Our citizens are counting on us. They expect us as policymakers to do everything in our power to ensure that Europe is better prepared for whatever challenge lie ahead. Thank you so much. [18:19:09] Esteban González Pons (PPE) [EN] Thank you very much, dear colleagues. The debate is close. The vote will be held tomorrow. The next item on the agenda is the report by Mr. Vasily Voisulescu, Europe's bidding cancer plan. And the reporter is my first speaker. Mr. Vasily Voisulescu. [18:19:35] Vlad Vasile-Voiculescu (Renew) [EN] Vice President, Commissioner, colleagues, I will be brief, but by the time I will be I will stop speaking. Two people in Europe will have died of cancer. Cancer is one of the worst things that can happen to each and every one of us in peacetime. Cancer shatters dreams, it tears families apart, it takes away children, mothers, fathers, sisters, the people we love most. But cancer is not just a personal tragedy, it's a challenge for our entire society. A challenge that no member state can tackle alone. Five years ago, Europe made a promise: 4 billion euro for a plan covering prevention, early detection, better treatments, and life after cancer. It was the right plan, it delivered results, but too many Europeans have yet to feel its benefits. This report looks at what has changed and what we must change. Three realities make it particularly urgent. First, we live longer. Sixty percent of cancers appear after the age of 65. This means that if nothing else changes, more Europeans will develop cancer. Second, science is advancing. Treatments are more targeted, more personalized, but also far more expensive. Third, our social systems are under strain. Our healthcare systems as well. The pressure is only getting heavier. After months of negotiation, this report sets priorities, how we finance research, how we connect scientists, hospitals, and patients, and how we reduce inequalities in access to treatment. But beyond funding projects, business as usual, we must recognize that this is not a feasible option anymore. We must tackle the risk factors that cause cancer in the first place. We need to make some choices here in the European Parliament, and we cannot pretend to be naive or show shortsighted. Tobacco is the best documented risk factor for cancer, and it is one of the areas where we know exactly which measures work to prevent it. Tobacco makes political and indeed moral choices painfully clear. In the Union, one in five cancer deaths is caused by tobacco. I will repeat this: one in five. Tobacco makes not only nine out of ten lung [18:22:04] Vlad Vasile-Voiculescu (Renew) [EN] cancers, but also causes at least 20 other types of cancer: voice box cancers, mouth cancer, bladder pancreas, and it doubles the risk of cervical cancer for women. Among 15 and 16-year-olds in Europe, e-cigarettes use rose from 14 to 22 percent in five years. And this is, by the way, the highest rate in the world. We know what works: higher tobacco taxes, plain packaging, removing tobacco from shop displays, and banning advertising. And our rules must also address e-cigarettes, heated tobacco, and nicotine pouches. On the basis of independent science. I want to thank my colleagues who share my concerns and recognize also the courage that they have shown, especially in the face of intense lobbying pressure, that they have faced in real in recent weeks. I would also like to thank the shadow reporters and the technical teams and more so my team for their work and for their commitment. The proposed text is balanced, it recognizes the limits of political compromise, but still leaves room for moral courage. For doing what is right, for saving lives. And make no mistake, our vote here today and tomorrow will count. So please support the report as adopted in SANT and support the final text as it stands. Thank you. [18:23:30] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you, thank you very much, dear colleagues. Commissioner Várhelyi, Commissioner Várhelyi, Commissioner, you have the floor. [18:23:48] 201944 [EN] The President, Honorable Members, Europe's bidding cancer plan is a key pillar in our public health policy. It is already making a real difference for patients across Europe. Since we launched the plan back in 2021, the Commission has allocated 2. 7 billion euros to its actions through EU4Health program, as well as through Horizon Europe program, including the EU Cancer Mission. With this support, we have funded more than 70 projects, and worked with almost 630 organizations. And the results are very clear. The review of the cancer plan back in February last year and the European Court of Auditors both confirmed that the plan is delivering real added value. Prevention is at the heart of this work. Around 40 percent, four zero, of cancers are preventable. It is for this reason that 45 percent of the plans supporting actions are dedicated to prevention. And we have reached important milestones on prevention. The 2024 Cancer Recommendations on Vaccine Preventable Cancers and on Smoke and Aerosol-Free Environments. The fifth edition of the European Code Against Cancer. And better protection for workers from carcinogens and asbestos. On tobacco, the Commission has proposed a revision of the Tobacco Taxation Directive, to also reflect the health risks of novel products. And we intend to propose a revision of the EU Tobacco Control Framework. And this will address novel products as they pose the same risks with those of traditional tobacco products and, in particular, pose very high concerns for the young generation. But cancer does not exist in isolation. The same risk factors drive other major non-communicable diseases. This is why last December the Commission adopted the Safe Hearts Plan, addressing cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and obesity. The two plans reinforce each other, and share the same logic. Earlier action, healthier lifestyles, stronger public health policies, and better outcome for people. Prevention is only part of the answer. Diagnosis and treatment matter just as much and both [18:26:39] 201944 [EN] depend on innovation. The proposed biotech act will help turn scientific breakthroughs into state-of-the-art treatments faster. Personalized mRNA cancer vaccines show what this means in practice. Biotechnology that trains each patient's immune system to recognize and attack their own tumor. Moreover, the biotech act will streamline clinical trials and facilitate complex technologies combining pharmaceuticals and medical devices and artificial intelligence. The medical devices reform will bring the next generation of diagnostics, from advanced imaging to new cancer tests, to patients' faster so that cancer is detected earlier when it is most treatable. It will also create a coherent framework for AI-enabled devices. I count on your cooperation to conclude these two important files swiftly. The revised EU Pharmaceutical Legislation, which will soon enter into force, creates new incentives to develop medicines for unmet medical needs including especially cancer. And the critical medicines act will also help cancer patients get timely access to medicines they need. Breakthrough diagnostics and therapies depend on high quality, and interconnected data. This is why we're working on a swift rollout of the European Health Dataspace. With the ambitious AI agenda, the President set out in the State of the Union speech, we aim to bring its benefits to patients even before the 2029 application date. Honorable Members, the right to be forgotten has been highlighted by this House many times. In response, the Commission held a public consultation on this autumn, and is working to prepare guidance on fair access to financial services for cancer survivors as a matter of priority. Looking ahead, the Commission's proposal for the next long-term EU budget offers a coherent funding framework for cancer-related actions. This reflects our commitment to prevention, early detection, better treatment, and to our quality of life. Thank you very much for your attention. [18:29:17] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, dear Commissioner. On behalf, we jump into the second part, and on behalf of the EPP, has the floor Mr. Arlosovic. [18:29:29] Bartosz Arłukowicz (PPE) [PL] Ladies and Gentlemen, this will probably not be... the most popular speech in the European Parliament. For months, we have been drafting yet another report on how Europe should fight cancer. Dozens, hundreds of hours of negotiations, meetings, discussions, persuasion, negotiating compromises – you might think we were discussing how to secure affordable access to the most advanced cancer therapies, for instance? For the most seriously ill patients? No, Ladies and Gentlemen. Did you think we were discussing, for example, how to improve the lot of women in Eastern Europe who die from cancers that patients in Western Europe can survive? No. Did you think we were discussing the fate of children in hospices? No. We have produced yet another report in which, alongside cancer, we discussed the condition of companies producing wine and cigarettes. And that is what the negotiations were about. Weeks and months spent on this report, just to make sure we do not harm those who produce alcohol and cigarettes. I do not want to come across here as someone taking up a position of fighting them. That is not the point. But I know that today, after the Europe’s Beating Cancer Plan, which has never really been implemented, Europe is today kneeling before cancer and surrendering. I know that it is far more spectacular to build motorways, far more spectacular to launch programmes such as Future for Europe. Ladies and Gentlemen, there will be no Future until we all get our act together and remember why people sent us here. They sent us here to help them survive. To help them fight cancer. That is why we are here. [18:31:31] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, dear colleague. On behalf of the S&D Group, [18:31:37] Alessandra Moretti (S&D) [ES] Ms Moretti. [18:31:43] Alessandra Moretti (S&D) [IT] Thank you, Mr President, colleagues, fellow Members. Commissioner, tomorrow we will be called upon to vote on a sensitive issue: the fight against cancer. Over the years, this Parliament has repeatedly reaffirmed its closeness to patients and their families, its support for research, doctors, nurses, in favour of prevention and against risk factors. The text that emerged from the Committee is balanced and reflects the Parliament’s consolidated positions. However, I am very concerned about the attempts by right-wing groups to weaken prevention measures. I address my fellow Members who will be voting tomorrow: patients, their families, doctors, associations fighting cancer, they are watching you. Do not put economic interests, powerful lobbies, before health. Do not do it. Reject the dangerous amendments on tobacco and alcohol. Put the fight against cancer at the heart of this Parliament’s political action. Do not compromise at the expense of people. Thank you. [18:32:54] Speaker 1 [EN] Grazie, Onorevole. On behalf of the PFE Group, Mr. Hauser. [18:33:04] Gerald Hauser (PfE) [DE] Thank you, Mr Chair. Mr President, thank you very much. Commissioner, the most important thing, and this has already been mentioned today, is that we help cancer patients. And we know, and unfortunately, this is being overlooked not only in this House but everywhere, including in the Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety, that since the introduction of the COVID-19 vaccination in 2020, cancer numbers have exploded. Why is this being overlooked? Commissioner, you are also aware of the figures for deaths and severe side effects linked to COVID-19 vaccinations that have been reported to the European Medicines Agency. I currently have the figures here. As of 26 October, around 30,000 deaths linked to COVID-19 vaccinations have been reported. With an estimated reporting rate of 5,000 to 6,000 percent, the total number of all side effects is around 3 million. If you extrapolate that, you get over 40 million people affected. And this is being ignored. And among those affected are many people who have developed cancer. And that is why, Commissioner, I urge you to look at what is happening in America. We finally need a clinic for vaccine victims here in Europe too, as has been introduced in America since October of this year. Let us finally help those harmed by vaccines. [18:34:29] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. [18:34:31] Speaker 1 [ES] Mr Fiocchi. [18:34:38] Pietro Fiocchi (ECR) [IT] Mr President, dear colleagues, the text that emerged from the Sente Commission in the section on prevention remains ideological, paternalistic, does not take into account scientific evidence, including the different levels of risk between traditional smoking and alternatives. Furthermore, failing to align the wording on 'harmful alcohol consumption' with the initiative on cardiovascular diseases contradicts the principles of Better Regulation. I would have liked to see a document more aligned between cardiovascular and bacon. This is a real shame, because the European cancer plan contains many important elements, in particular the push on the database, especially for rare diseases and paediatric cancers, which should have been a little bolder and more aggressive, but also the reference to prevention screening and so on, which is a bit weak, though heading in the right direction. I would have liked to see something more aggressive. We certainly welcome the sharing of knowledge at European level, thanks also to the European reference networks, but overall more could have been done to share data and experiences more quickly for fairer and more equitable treatment for citizens. Let us remember that, indeed, raising taxes on tobacco and alcohol only favours criminal organisations, so we need a much more delicate approach to this, and again I would really like to see a more aggressive approach, especially on oncological screening and rare diseases. Thank you. [18:36:31] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much, but I really beg you to stick to the time because we are already out of our time schedule, so the next speaker is Vice President Sophie Wilmitz on behalf of the Renew Group. Please, for one minute, and I really beg to stick to the time. Thank you, Chair. [18:36:48] Sophie Wilmès (Renew) [FR] Dear colleagues, tonight I want to talk to you about rare cancers with a poor prognosis, because while rare cancers are indeed mentioned in this text, those with a poor prognosis are not. And yet, I believe we need to address this. We need to address it because these cancers, such as certain brain tumours, face multiple obstacles that a global strategy, however useful it may be, is not enough to overcome. The major issue with rare cancers with a poor prognosis is that we have too few patients and too few experts in each country taken separately. And so, without a real European ecosystem to connect them, there are few clinical trials, little incentive to invest in treatments, and consequently, little progress in research – even though this progress would directly benefit the fight against all cancers. This situation, dear colleagues, for most patients with a rare cancer with a poor prognosis, is a death sentence within five years. So, while the resolution lays the foundations for this ecosystem, and I welcome that, and I would also like to thank our rapporteur, for these patients, for these families too, we must do more. We must ensure that the next European budget includes dedicated funding for research into these particular cancers; this funding must be guaranteed and commensurate with the needs. Thank you. [18:38:11] Speaker 2 [EN] The next speaker is Billy Metz on behalf of the Greens. [18:38:17] Tilly Metz (Verts/ALE) [EN] Thank you, President. [18:38:19] Tilly Metz (Verts/ALE) [EN] Colleagues, by 2040, cancer is projected to become the leading cause of death in the European Union, and mortality rates are expected to rise by 30%. These figures are a wake-up call. They remind us why the work we are discussing today matters so much, but they also remind us that we must look ahead. We cannot afford to lose ambition of Europe's cancer plan. That means also taking prevention seriously, and it starts with one fundamental principle: economic interest must never become come before the precautionary principle and the protection of public health. Because reducing our exposure to risk factors, from tobacco and alcohol to environmental pollution, is not just about reducing numbers, it's about saving lives. And reducing the enormous social and economic burden of cancer, we have the knowledge, we have the tools, what we need now is the political act, the political courage to act. For a healthier Europe and for a better future. Thank you. [18:39:33] Speaker 3 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is Robert Gabel on behalf of the Left. [18:39:43] Robert Gabel (The Left) [DE] When we talk here and today about the fight against cancer, we must also discuss the fact that many cancer cases can be prevented through environmental and animal protection. Because many cases are caused by environmental toxins, air pollution or meat consumption. Particularly processed meat. And we can no longer ignore these connections. There is one health, and it consists of the health of people, animals and the environment. If we want to take cancer prevention seriously, we must take this into account. And health is not an economic burden; rather, if we do it right, it is a benefit for the environment, animals and people. And I would like a European Union that takes this into account and heeds it. And thank you for being here today, Commissioner. I hope for a Commissioner who also takes this into account and heeds it. Thank you. [18:40:44] Speaker 2 [DE] Thank you. The next speaker is Tomislav Sokol. Please, the floor is yours for one minute. [18:40:53] Tomislav Sokol (PPE) [HR] Vice-President, Commissioner, honourable colleagues, every 24 seconds one person in the European Union dies from cancer. Knowing that 40% of cancer cases can be prevented, we must invest more in prevention, raising awareness and early detection programmes. At the same time, we must strongly invest in research, development and innovative therapies. That is precisely why, in the next multiannual financial framework, we must secure a fixed budget for health and continue to implement the European Cancer Plan excellently. In doing so, access to the best possible treatment must not depend on the Member State in which someone lives. Joint public procurement, which we are introducing through the Critical Medicines Act, will enable medicines to be available to patients from smaller Member States much earlier and on more favourable terms than before. Lastly, I would like to highlight in particular the right to be forgotten. People who have survived cancer must not be discriminated against when accessing credit, insurance or other financial services because of the disease they have overcome. We have clearly laid this down in the Consumer Credit Directive, and I hope that the same will apply in other laws that we will adopt. Thank you. [18:42:03] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Alexander Nikolić. [18:42:10] Aleksandar Nikolic (PfE) [FR] In this report on cancers, you mention the issue of sedentary lifestyles, that is, the lack of physical activity, and yes, it is true, it is a real scourge. You also mention junk food, and here too, it is true, it is a major risk factor. So, it would be logical to combat sedentary lifestyles and junk food in order to fight cancer. Well, look how clever we are. In Emmanuel Macron’s France, we have taken this observation and done the exact opposite. Yes, we give fine speeches and produce nice ad campaigns encouraging people to take up sport and adopt a healthy, balanced diet. But in reality, in everyday life, if you want to pay for a gym membership or sign up for paddle tennis, you will pay 20% VAT. Likewise, if you want to play tennis in an association, you will pay 20% VAT on your racket. If your child plays football, well, you will also pay 20% VAT on their boots. On the other hand, if you want to buy a large, extra-large, jumbo, greasy Big Mac meal at McDonald’s, you will pay 10% VAT, half as much. It’s a fact. Macron’s France uses taxation to encourage people to eat a Big Mac rather than do sport. We might laugh at this inversion of values, but unfortunately, it costs lives. [18:43:23] Monika Beňová (NI) [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Monika Benyova. [18:43:28] Monika Beňová (NI) [SK] Mr Commissioner, colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, when we talk about the risks of developing oncological diseases in connection with products, that risk depends on the nature of the product, its composition, the degree of processing, as well as the manner and extent of its consumption. Not all products pose the same level of health risk. Processed red meat does not, after all, carry the same health risk as lean unprocessed red meat. Similarly, different types of alcoholic beverages are associated with different patterns of consumption and health risks. And differences in health consequences also exist, for example, between individual tobacco and nicotine products. Recognising these differences is simply a matter of scientific objectivity and responsible policymaking. And it is precisely this approach that allows us to adopt more targeted and effective measures instead of blanket bans and restrictions, which may ultimately do more harm than good. That is why I urge you to recognise the principle of distinguishing between products according to the level of health risk they pose. I am convinced that this is the right path that will enable us to fight cancer more effectively and, at the same time, build a truly functional European Health Union. Thank you. [18:44:40] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is András Kulya. [18:44:48] András Tivadar Kulja (PPE) [HU] Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, Commissioner, dear colleagues. As a doctor, I have seen how a cancer diagnosis can change an entire family's life in a single moment. The future becomes uncertain, and no amount of time can be regained that was lost due to delayed diagnosis or late treatment. Tomorrow, we will vote on the report on the implementation of the Europe's Beating Cancer Plan. Ensuring access to prevention, screening, and modern treatments is our shared European responsibility. For Tisza, the goal was clear both before and after the change of government: healthcare must serve prevention and recovery. This requires functional screening programmes, sufficient healthcare professionals, timely diagnostics, and care accessible to society. Health cannot be a privilege, neither in Hungary nor in Europe. Every life lost is a warning we cannot ignore in silence, so I ask you to support the report tomorrow. Thank you. [18:45:55] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And now the last speaker on the speakers' list is Jessica Pohl-Fiat. [18:46:06] Jessica Polfjärd (PPE) [SV] Madam President, Commissioner. Mr President, Commissioner, in Sweden, around 10 million people live in the world. The same number of people die of cancer every year. A Sweden lost to cancer every year. In Europe, around 1.2 million people die of cancer. Every Member State must do more. Where you live should not determine when you receive your diagnosis or how you receive your treatment. That is why there is a great responsibility on the Member States to develop and implement national cancer plans with clear and measurable targets. Within the EU, we must continue the work that has begun: investing in research and cooperation by sharing data and reducing disparities between regions and between women and men. The fight against cancer continues, for all those who have fought, for those who are fighting, and for all those who will fight in the future. Thank you, Mr President. [18:47:08] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And now we come to the catch the eye. And the first speaker on catch the eye is Esther Herranz-García, for one minute please, and I beg the colleagues to stick to the one minute because then we can take more colleagues under catch the eye. Thank you. [18:47:27] Esther Herranz García (PPE) [ES] With this text, which affects us all. But after carefully reading your amendments to the text, I have to tell you that this is as serious a matter as cancer, and that we must be guided by scientific rigour and not attack or demonise, for ideological reasons, food sectors such as the meat or wine industries. This is not scientific and only threatens the way of life and livelihoods of thousands of families who are the backbone of Europe and rural areas, and who maintain our heritage. It is very far removed from the fight against cancer, which is what truly matters. Wine, when consumed in a moderate and responsible manner, is a natural foodstuff and is recognised by numerous studies as a pillar of the Mediterranean diet, which is also recognised as being balanced, complete and sufficient. Linked to a healthy lifestyle, with a lower incidence of various diseases. It is not acceptable to link all alcohol or meat consumption with cancer. That is ideology, not science. We cannot confuse the public or criminalise our culture. We must protect health, but let us do so with common sense, education and science, not with ideology and indoctrination. Thank you. [18:48:42] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is Christian Vigenin. [18:48:50] Kristian Vigenin (S&D) [BG] The fight against cancer should not depend on the country you live in or how much you earn. But reality is different. In Bulgaria, the five-year survival rate for colorectal cancer is 52%, compared to an average of 60% in the European Union. For lung cancer, the difference is even more alarming: 8% versus 15%. Behind these figures lie human lives. The causes include late diagnosis, insufficient prevention, and unequal access to modern technologies. That is why the European Cancer Plan must be backed by real resources. We insist that the next multiannual financial framework guarantees at least two and a half billion euros for the fight against cancer. And national health systems should align their priorities with the common European goals so as to strengthen the exchange of experience and best practices and improve outcomes in cross-border treatment of cancer patients. Healthcare and the fight against cancer are not charity, nor an expense at the expense of competitiveness. Healthy people work. They create. They contribute to the economy. Investment in healthcare is an investment in Europe’s future. Thank you. [18:50:03] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is Sebastian Tynkenen. [18:50:10] Sebastian Tynkkynen (ECR) [FI] Mr President. Who should be responsible for promoting non-smoking? For many, the first thought is the family, loved ones and the individual smoker themselves. After that, the state – everyone understands that the state taxes tobacco in order to combat its harms, such as cancer. But does the spouse coughing from second-hand smoke think that the EU needs to step in? In Brussels, however, this is how it is thought. At EU level, for example, calls have been made to ban smoking on terraces. Have we really forgotten that some things are entirely a matter for the national level? It seems so. The European Commission, for its part, came out with a proposal in which it would start collecting over €11 billion a year from Member States’ tobacco taxes for its own budget. There must be a limit. Combating smoking is a worthwhile cause, but this constant EU grab is not. [18:51:18] Helmut Brandstätter (Renew) [EN] The next speaker is Helmut Brandstetter. [18:51:23] Helmut Brandstätter (Renew) [DE] Thank you. Madam President, I would like to use this important report on combating cancer in Europe to thank all the researchers who have done outstanding work over the past years and again this year. We know that there are medicines that have only just been newly developed this year to treat various forms of cancer, such as bladder cancer, lung cancer and breast cancer. We know that excellent progress is being made on cancer vaccines. There are already some, and new mRNA vaccines are also being developed, and these will help us too. We must be grateful to these researchers, and we can see just how great Europe is when we look at the collaborations they are engaged in. I am familiar with the work being done at Austrian universities, but I also know—and they have told me this—that they are working with others. Thank you also to the many people who care for cancer patients. And finally, a word because America was praised from the right side of the House. Well, there they have abolished vaccinations, which has led to many preventable deaths there. That is dangerous. Europe is doing better, and that is a good thing. Thank you. [18:52:37] Ana Miranda Paz (Verts/ALE) [EN] Next speaker is Ana Miranda Paz. [18:52:43] Ana Miranda Paz (Verts/ALE) [PT] Thank you very much. Cancer is the leading cause of death in my country, Galicia. Delays in the waiting lists for appointments, delays in diagnosis, failing health platforms, and rulings against the Galician health service. Waits of more than a year to receive treatment, to have mammograms, MRIs, endoscopies, I stress, delays in diagnoses, delays in follow-up consultations, and in reviewing people treated for cancer. Difficulty in securing primary care appointments. There needs to be more preventive policies and more public policies, such as support for public health, which we have always called for, and not closing health centres, as well as policies to support those who have been waiting for more than a year for cancer treatment or diagnosis, and policies that also support psychological treatment and research. Thank you very much. [18:53:48] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Lefteris Nikolaou Alvanos. [18:53:56] Lefteris Nikolaou-Alavanos (NI) [EL] The report places the blame for the problem on the aging population while taking measures to strengthen pharmaceutical giants and monopolies. It brazenly conceals the root causes, such as the deterioration of workers' living conditions, the degradation of the natural environment by monopolies, exposure to hazardous substances at work, the commodification and privatisation of healthcare, which deprives the people of prevention. It shifts individual responsibility onto the people, perceives cancer as lost working hours and a cost for corporate groups. It erects obstacles to therapeutic treatment, stifling research which is squeezed by the competition between pharmaceutical monopolies, the European Union, the United States, and China, and in this race, European corporate groups are being rewarded. In line with the dismantling and commodification of the public healthcare system, and the continuous increase in the cost of medication for the people, workers and healthcare professionals are fighting for a unified, exclusively public and free healthcare system, research, and treatment for cancer, free from any business activity. Strong primary care, free prevention and medication, fully staffed public healthcare structures, and healthcare professionals employed on a full-time and exclusive basis. [18:55:01] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. And the last speaker, undercatch the ice, Ochana Glavak. [18:55:09] Sunčana Glavak (PPE) [HR] Thank you very much, esteemed Vice-President, Commissioner, colleagues. Five years after its launch, we need to assess the success or failure in terms of prevention, early detection and access to treatment. Since 2021, we have allocated 4 billion euros for the fight against cancer. Therefore, Commissioner, continuity of funding must not be a budgetary compromise, and I believe you will agree with me on this. It is not enough merely to report on the number of projects launched; we must, of course, continue to invest in innovation and new technologies. We need to know how many diseases were detected in time, how survival rates have improved and whether we have reduced risks and disparities between Member States. The ultimate outcome of this plan must not be the number of funded projects, but the number of timely detected diseases, successful treatments and lives saved. Where you live must not determine whether you will live. We have heard this said several times today. Thank you very much. [18:56:18] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. And now I pass the floor for one minute to Commissioner Várhelyi. [18:56:32] 201944 [EN] Dear President, Honorable Members, I think that from the debate it's very clear that the Europe's beating cancer plan has already started to change the landscape of cancer policy in Europe. Across the whole cancer pathway, from prevention to detection, treatment, and quality of life, of survivors and also their families. So now we must build on that progress, and this should mean that we will prioritize even further prevention, we should strengthen the synergies between the two plans, so the safe house plan and the Europe beating cancer plan, and also finalizing the health package without delay. To Mrs. Glavac, it follows from this debate that of course our commitment is long-term, and this is why the Europe beating cancer plan must continue into the next MFF. And to Mr. Hauser, this is not the first time that Mr. Hauser raises this point, and several times I have explained to him that the EMA is carrying out all the studies when it comes to side effects of COVID vaccines, and it has not confirmed any of the findings or allegations, Mr. Hauser claims. And I also want to reiterate here that the European Cancer Information System or the European Cancer Inequality Registry which are our sources of information do not, I underline, do not, do not give any credible data of any explosion when it comes to cancer related to the use of COVID vaccines. Thank you very much. [18:58:12] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And now I pass the floor to our rapporteur, Vlad Vasile Voiculescu. For two minutes, please. [18:58:22] Vlad Vasile-Voiculescu (Renew) [EN] Thank you. I would like to thank everyone for your contributions and to this debate and in particular I would like to thank the Commissioner for his remarks and for the commitment made here today. There was also something that I would like to draw your attention to, and that's especially after analyzing the amendments that were submitted. I count on your sharp memory to remember that this report is about fighting cancer, and this report is a trajectory correction or of the plan to prevent and stop cancer for millions of Europeans. One in five cancers are attributed to tobacco, nevertheless this is exactly where amendments were tabled. Amendment 12 swaps without further delay for in a timely manner. What is in a timely manner? For me that was at least five years ago. Amendment 5 kills the health assessment of a new product before it reaches the market. Because we should just throw novel products, novel tobacco products or vaping at our kids, right? We're told a health assessment is not necessary and to protect and that we should protect the growing tobacco agriculture. A tobacco costs member states 80. 7, 80.7 billion euros a year, and in a report on beating cancer, defending the product that causes cancer is just shameful. Imagine you had a magic wand. You could bring a child's mother back who died from breast cancer, you could lift a child out of a hospital bed where she or he can barely breathe for popcorn lungs, would you look at that child and say we have a rural industry to protect? I don't think so. We have no magic wand, we just have our vote and thus it's strongly I strongly encourage you to exercise your moral virtue and vote against diluting the text. Vote the reports as in the sand as adopted in the sand committee. Thank you. [19:00:21] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [DE] The debate is now closed. Voting will take place tomorrow. We now move on to the next item on the agenda. This concerns the Council and Commission declaration on resilience against cyber-attacks and other hybrid threats to protect critical infrastructure and essential supply chains. And I now give the floor, first of all in the name of the Council, to [19:00:44] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] the Minister of State for Further Education, Apprenticeship, Construction and Climate Skills, Marianne Harkin. The floor is yours for five minutes, please. [19:01:00] Marian Harkin [EN] President, Honorable Members, and Executive Vice President of the Commission. Cyber resilience, of critical infrastructure supply chains, is becoming more and more essential as digitalization impacts all sectors and as the threats to our security evolve. Indeed, that is something every one of us here today in this Parliament and across the EU are concerned with. Particularly due to recent and perhaps not so recent events, back in May this Parliament debated advanced AI systems and how they can be used to combat cyber attacks. Now we see attacks on our supermarkets that threaten our supply chains and impact the everyday lives of our citizens. Indeed, just today and in previous days we see threats issued to schools in my own country, Ireland, and in other EU member states. These threats are designed to cause real anxiety, huge uncertainty, and fear among parents, school communities, and indeed our population, in general. So our challenges as a European Union is that we need to be prepared and we're at all possible anticipate such threats. Today's debate is very timely because it shows once more the importance of maintaining our efforts to continuously strengthen our cyber security. And that is why at European level our institutions have passed landmark legislations during the previous parliamentary term, in particular the NIS2 directive and the Cyber Resilience Act. The implementation of these instruments is essential to further increase our collective capacity to protect our citizens and our economies against a multiplication of malicious actors. As the Irish Presidency, we are fully committed to advancing negotiations on the cyber security package covering both the revision of the Cyber Security Act and the amending NIS2 directive. In that context, I can say we've made real progress on the three main parts of the Cyber Security Act. That is, first of all, the strengthening of an ESA. Secondly, making certification frameworks more efficient and effective and thirdly, [19:03:54] Marian Harkin [EN] improving protection of our critical ICT supply chains. So can I conclude by saying we still aim to reach agreement in the Council before the end of our presidency. So that our Lithuanian colleagues can start the trialogue when the Parliament is ready. We are convinced that this legislation will significantly contribute to the strengthening of our cyber security. Because preventing successful attacks by better protecting our networks and the whole ICT supply system is key. Thank you. [19:04:42] Speaker 2 [EN] So much for your attention. [19:04:44] Speaker 3 [EN] Thank you very much, Minister Harkin. And now I pass the floor to the Commission Executive Vice President Hannah Wirkonen. The floor is yours for five minutes, please. [19:04:55] Henna Virkkunen [EN] Thank you very much, Honorable President, Honorable Members, Council. Cyber security is very essential part of European preparedness and defense. Cyber resilience is not only about preventing attacks but about ensuring that our societies, our economies, and our defense capabilities can continue to function during crises. The risk of disruption to the Union's critical infrastructure by foreign actors is real. Just last week we saw refrigeration systems in supermarkets and blue banks throughout Europe switched off because of cyber incidents. And the estimated cost was in the tens and hundreds of millions. But it's not only about financial impact. It's also about social impact. Although the attacks did not cause any significant impact on food security and public health, it should be a wake-up call for everybody. Europe cannot afford to have dependencies or strategic weaknesses that expose our critical infrastructure to unexpected risks. For instance, we cannot allow risks of foreign interference, espionage, or disruption in our most critical ICT supply chains. And this is particularly relevant in our communications infrastructure such as 5G networks. They are increasingly relevant for reliable ultra-fast connectivity, data, and information sharing, drone detection, and also real-time operational coordination. And this is why supply chain security is at the core of the proposal for the revision of Cyber Security Act, which is now on the table of this House. We need a strong pragmatic and proportionate approach to de-risking our essential ICT supply chains. And we need to act now to de-risk our 5G networks. It has been almost seven years since the EU adopted the 5G Cyber Security Toolbox. The time for hesitation is over. We need to be much more decisive and ambitious, including when it comes to setting clear timelines for phasing out high-risk suppliers. If we fail to act decisively now, we are not only putting our 5G networks at risk but also will carry these dependencies into 6G, the next generation of connectivity. [19:07:24] Henna Virkkunen [EN] A strong and cyber resilient Europe also needs a strong European Cyber Security Agency where the resources match the mandate and the challenges. In the Commission's action plan on cyber security and AI, an ESA is playing an important role, by strengthening the resilience of our critical and other vital infrastructure against AI-driven cyber attacks and by testing and assessing the cyber security capabilities of frontier AI models. All these clearly demonstrate the potential of an ESA. This is also a very concrete example of European solidarity and cooperation. Through an ESA, we can ensure that all our 27 member states benefit from shared expertise, knowledge, and capabilities rather than each having to develop them independently. And this is why I urge the European Parliament to support our efforts to equip an ESA with the mandate, resources, and capabilities it needs to support our member states and protect Europe's critical infrastructure. Not only against the threats we face today but also against those that are emerging on the horizon. Honorable Members, in recent months we have witnessed a wave of high-profile cyber incidents and other hybrid attacks. From attacks on public administrations and personal data breaches to attacks on health, telecommunications, and energy infrastructure, including subsea cables and, as I mentioned earlier, on supermarkets and blue banks. These incidents underlined the importance of the regulatory framework we have put in place at European level. We can already see the difference that the cyber resilience act will make by strengthening the security of digital products placed on the EU market. And in many cases, industrial devices such as refrigeration systems are unnecessary exposed to the internet or they are configured with the weak passwords or run outdated software. And these are low-hanging fruits, because many of these incidents therefore demonstrate the importance of the basic cyber security requirements set out in the NIS2 directive. [19:09:40] Henna Virkkunen [EN] Had these requirements been fully transposed and effectively implemented, some of these incidents could potentially have been prevented or their impact significantly reduced. The challenge before us is therefore not only to develop new policies and new instruments but to ensure that the rules we have already agreed are translated into real security on the ground. Because ultimately cyber security is not only about legislation, institutions, or about technology. It is about protecting our economies, safeguarding the essential services on which our citizens depend, and ensuring that Europe has the resilience and capacity to act in an increasingly uncertain world. And that is responsibility we must now deliver on together. [19:10:34] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much, Commissioner. And now we proceed with the speakers on behalf of the political groups. And the first speaker on behalf of EPP is Thomas Dubé for one and a half minutes. Please, the floor is yours. [19:10:47] Tomas Tobé (PPE) [EN] President, Minister, Commissioner, in recent weeks cyber attacks on grocery stores across Europe have destroyed food worth millions. of euros. This time the target was our food supply. What will they target tomorrow? These hackers are often state-sponsored and will exploit every vulnerability that they can found, from food on our tables to energy instruction, even our elections. Last week in France, they even targeted freezers used to store blood, plasma, in blood banks. This is just terrible. I think it's important now that we quickly try to adapt the cyber security act without delay. Establishing a strong framework to face out high-risk suppliers from our critical supply chains. I also think it's important that member states they need to call them out. We know that Iran, China, Russia, systematically target Europe in cyberspace. We need to establish a credible deterrence deterrence only works when our enemies knows that hostile actions will have consequences. With powerful new AI models, cyber attacks will unfortunately become more frequent, more sophisticated, and harder to defend against. But our enemies should be under no illusion: if you mess with Europe, we will mess with you. Thank you. [19:12:38] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker on behalf of SNT is Jens Geyer. [19:12:45] Jens Geier (S&D) [DE] Thank you, Madam President. Madam Vice-President, Madam Minister, severe cyberattacks seem to be occurring more frequently in recent weeks. Therefore, we need not only a strong cybersecurity strategy in the European Union, but also a policy that systematically minimises risks. Ms Virkkunen, you have kindly presented us with the Cybersecurity Act 2, which is intended to systematically reduce the risk of the ICT sector being influenced or even shut down from outside the EU. This risk is real, not only in the ICT sector but also in wind turbines and other technologies used to operate our energy networks. That is why I am advocating for the scope of the CSA 2 to be extended to energy networks as well. The Cybersecurity Act 2 is an opportunity to increase resilience. Because two things must apply in future: first, no kill switch mechanism that can be activated from outside the EU, and second, no data stored on servers that are not subject to EU legislation. Thank you. [19:13:53] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Jorge Bouchadé Villalba on behalf of PFI. [19:14:00] Jorge Buxadé Villalba (PfE) [ES] The good fortune that all of you here in Brussels have, most of you, Ms von der Leyen, is that most people do not know what goes on here. They are making up a new debate about cyber resilience and hybrid attacks, but when Spain suffers a hybrid attack from Morocco with 100,000 invaders in Ceuta, the Socialist People’s Group blocks the creation of a special committee with its vote and the European Commission continues to shower money on the neighbour. What is more, it is a scandal that they talk about cyber-attacks on infrastructure while this very week they have censored a debate on the collapse of Spain’s rail infrastructure, which has claimed the lives of 69 people. There was incompetence, a failure of due care and corruption. When the European Commission hands out billions from Brussels and governments like Mr Sánchez’s give them to countries like Morocco and Uzbekistan to improve rail safety, the Spanish people demand justice. The 115 victims of Adamuz and Urdah are not the result of bad luck; they are the result of corruption. And that is what happens when you put the lives of Europeans in the hands of corrupt people. The real threat is corrupt politicians and corruption kills. [19:15:16] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Francesco Torselli on behalf of ECR. [19:15:27] Francesco Torselli (ECR) [IT] 6,000 Italian schools received threats today, intimidation, bomb threats via email. As Prime Minister Meloni has clarified, no concrete dangers have emerged, but even a false alarm can sow fear and disrupt a public service. Today it was the schools, last week it was the refrigeration systems of supermarkets, and before that, the alarms on flights. Cyberattacks that affect all of us and all of Europe. This is why Europe must do its part, investing in prevention, in rapid information sharing, and in the cyberdefence of strategic infrastructure. When we talk about defending our freedom, we do not mean doing so only with rifles and tanks. We must protect schools, hospitals, transport, businesses. Our daily lives. And to those who think they can intimidate us, we say that we will not give up even one of the services on which our free daily life depends. Thank you. [19:16:35] Speaker 2 [EN] The next speaker on behalf of Renew is Bart Rothuis. [19:16:40] Bart Groothuis (Renew) [EN] Thank you, Chair. Dear Commissioner, Minister, cool custom in all the supermarkets and actually all the other [19:16:47] Bart Groothuis (Renew) [NL] digital products are becoming increasingly secure in Europe. And if you follow the news, you might not say that quickly, but with the Cyber Resilience Act and NIS 2, we are setting the bar for cybersecurity particularly high here. That is the good news. The bad news is that there are still an incredible number of outdated devices connected to the internet. Often with software that is 10 or 20 years old, full of vulnerabilities that can sometimes no longer even be fixed. And now AI is coming along, so one old refrigerator can suddenly become, for hackers, the gateway to your company's network. So my message is very simple: take another good look at what is all connected to your network, ask yourself whether all of that really needs to be connected to the internet. Usually, that is not a good idea. Take action yourselves as well. The government is not going to solve everything for you. We are creating the best cybersecurity laws in the world here, but cyber responsibility lies with you. Thank you. [19:17:42] Speaker 2 [NL] Thank you. [19:17:43] Speaker 2 [EN] The next speaker is Reinier van Landschot. For one minute. [19:17:51] Reinier Van Lanschot (Verts/ALE) [EN] Cyber resilience is also about sovereignty. In China, American software is purged from state companies. That's sovereignty made in China. In America, no Chinese tech gets near the Pentagon. That's sovereignty made in the USA. In Europe, Washington switches off the email cloud and banking of the International Criminal Court and Chancellor Merz says for the German intelligence agency a Google Cloud is sovereign enough. The USA and China understand it, but our digital sovereignty? It's not made in Europe. This makes us vulnerable to espionage, cybercrime, and somebody could just switch us off. It's time to change that. We have to protect our critical infrastructure with European cloud and AI. That's what the cloud and AI development act must deliver, with sovereign cloud for all critical infrastructure. A united Europe can make it happen. So stop the inferiority complex and let's create a resilient European tech stack. That's a future made in Europe. [19:19:01] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you. [19:19:01] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is Dario Tamburano on behalf of the Left. [19:19:08] Dario Tamburrano (The Left) [IT] Colleagues, I have written to my car manufacturer asking how to disconnect and reconnect it from the internet. I received responses about privacy but no clear and immediate procedure to manage incoming data independently and thus prevent possible network-based attacks. And what if tomorrow the IT systems managing connected cars and controlling their activity were compromised? What rights do we have to rule out this possibility and protect ourselves from the risk of individual cars being blocked and going haywire, or in the extreme scenario of millions of vehicles out of control with no attackers on board? We have filled the web with tedious disclaimers for theoretical privacy, but where is the right to disconnect our objects from the internet of things? To go offline in a simple and reversible way, like the airplane mode on mobile phones? I believe this is a reasonable request. It will be even more so tomorrow. We already have this by law for work tools and in hazardous environments: a physical button, prominently placed, with a mandatory red colour. We want this on the dashboard, a simple gesture, a single word: stop. [19:20:20] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you. [19:20:22] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker on behalf of ESN is Markus Buchheit. [19:20:29] Markus Buchheit (ESN) [DE] Thank you, Madam Chair. Dear colleagues, in October, Mr Bresser paralysed the town hall of my home town of Eichstätt and extracted 1.4 terabytes of data, including citizens’ tax and account data. At the same time, in hundreds of supermarkets, refrigerated shelves were heating up to 50 degrees, and last week criminals diverted more than €100 million from a French bank via a service provider. After town halls and supermarkets, now savings accounts are also under attack. Banks, however, have been subject to their own EU regulation on digital resilience for almost two years now. Yet it did not prevent this attack. The vulnerability of IT systems has been demonstrated time and again. So has the toothlessness of our authorities. Yet the Commission now wants more money and staff for ENISA, a central reporting office and new certificates. Please do not centralise yet another competence in Brussels. Incidentally, it was not agencies that saved Eichstätt, but a backup. A small town cannot defend itself alone against professional extortionists. That is something the Member States must ultimately provide, close to their municipalities. With experts, with money for backups and network segmentation, with a firewall around every town hall. And many of my German colleagues, after all, know a thing or two about firewalls and firewalls. Thank you. [19:21:47] Speaker 2 [EN] Next speaker is again the Commission, Hannah Virkunen. You have the floor for four and a half minutes, please. [19:22:00] Henna Virkkunen [EN] Thank you very much, Honorable Chair. Members, Council, thank you very much for your interventions. The points raised today demonstrate very clearly that cyber resilience must be treated as a strategic security imperative, not merely a technical challenge. It's also very clear that we have to be prepared for many different kinds of hybrid attacks. The recent wave of bomb threats targeting European aviation, schools, and media is a very stark reminder that the security of our critical infrastructure and societies cannot be taken for granted. Whether through cyberattacks, physical sabotage, or other forms of disruption, our adversaries seek to exploit vulnerabilities, disrupt, essential services, and undermine public confidence. Any threats against civilians are unacceptable. Ensuring the safety and security of our citizens is our top priority. We are closely coordinating with the affected member states. It's also clear that Europe must be able to protect our critical infrastructures and our society; our essential supply chains, against an increasingly complex threat landscape. This includes foreign interference, strategic dependencies, and AI-enabled cyberattacks. We have already established a strong European framework, but legislation alone is not enough. We must ensure effective implementation, strengthen our operational preparedness, improve cooperation between member states, and address the risks arising from high-risk suppliers in essential ICT supply chains. And this also means reinforcing cybersecurity at every level. Strengthening risk management and supply chain security, building security into products from the outset, ensuring effective vulnerability management, and securing the digital products and services that provide remote access to key operational systems. And this is precisely why the revision of the Cybersecurity Act is so important. It is an opportunity to translate our ambitions into concrete capabilities, strengthening Europe's collective preparedness, reducing critical dependencies, and also equipping ENISA with the mandate and resources to support [19:24:23] Henna Virkkunen [EN] member states. [19:24:30] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much, Commissioner. And now I pass the floor to Dariusz Jonski. [19:24:39] Dariusz Joński (PPE) [PL] Thank you very much, Madam President, Commissioner. Today, 11 November, today my country, Poland, is celebrating Independence Day. This is a day that reminds us that freedom, sovereignty and security are not given once and for all. Poland had to fight for them for 123 years. And Poland knows how important freedom is, and it is our shared duty to do everything to ensure that Europe is ready to defend it. And we must understand that modern warfare is not just tanks, it is not just missiles. It is also cyberattacks, sabotage, disinformation, and attacks on energy, rail, ports, critical infrastructure. It is an attempt to weaken the state without firing a single shot. We must remember that Europe’s security begins at its eastern border. Poland and the countries in our region perfectly understand the scale of the threats, as for years we have been facing hybrid pressure, cyberattacks, and attempts at destabilisation. That is why protecting critical infrastructure cannot be the sole responsibility of individual states. We need a common European strategy, real investments, and rapid information exchange on threats. Europe’s security must also be built through transport. We need resilient rail, road, and port infrastructure that will enable the rapid movement of troops and equipment. We cannot allow bureaucracy and infrastructure gaps to weaken our defence capabilities. I hope that this year we will adopt military Schengen, so vital, so necessary for all of Europe. Thank you very much. [19:26:15] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is Johann Danielson. [19:26:23] Johan Danielsson (S&D) [SV] Madam President, on one day, 18 aircraft were bombed across Europe. In Sweden and the rest of Europe, refrigerators and freezers failed, and today schools have been forced to evacuate across our continent. It must not be so easy for hostile actors to remotely cause such major disruptions to businesses and ordinary people’s daily lives. Hybrid attacks will continue. Next time, it could be our trains, our hospitals or our energy systems. That is why we must urgently put in place at least three things: first, preventive work to ensure that the application of new technology does not create unnecessary vulnerabilities. Second, active defence that can prevent attacks and, if it fails, identify the responsible perpetrator. And finally, we need a common structure to ensure responses that increase the cost for the actors responsible. Because if you attack Europe, there must be consequences. Thank you for your attention. [19:27:31] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is Jessica van Leeuwen. [19:27:38] Jessika van Leeuwen (ECR) [EN] Thank you very much, Chair. Minister, Commissioner, in October cyberattack hit supermarkets in the Netherlands and Belgium. Shelves were left empty and home deliveries were canceled. In France, supermarkets had to throw food away after a separate attack on cooling systems. Three weeks later, cyberattacks hit food businesses in the Netherlands, Germany, Italy, Belgium, Sweden, and other member states. And these are not isolated incidents, but a systematic attack on our food security. Food waste and empty shelves will affect both producers and consumers in the food supply chain. And it clearly demonstrates how vulnerable our food security is. We have to make sure to produce enough food inside the European Union so we do not depend on imports, but we also need to protect the entire chain from farmer to consumer. So Commissioner, are you acknowledging the seriousness of this vulnerability? Are you looking into strengthening the cyber resilience of our food supply chain? And will you work with the member states to protect the whole chain? Food security means keeping food on every table. So support our farmers and protect the food supply chain. Thank you. [19:28:51] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Is Oierane Agiregoitia Martinez. [19:29:01] Oihane Agirregoitia Martínez (Renew) [ES] European security is also at stake in our everyday lives. We have seen this in recent days: attacks on refrigeration chains in France, threats to European flights, and threats to media outlets in Ireland. Just today, there were incidents in Italian schools. Our transport infrastructure — ports, airports, railways, logistics centres — is increasingly vulnerable. Hybrid attacks are taking place, and we are seeing that even without a single explosion or conventional military strike, there is fear, there is a certain level of chaos, and services are being paralysed. The European Union Agency for Cybersecurity also stated in its latest report that we are not sufficiently prepared or coordinated. Moreover, artificial intelligence is making these threats increasingly complex. That is why we are proposing two concrete measures. First, to strengthen the European early warning system and coordinated response to share real-time information and act jointly. Second, European-wide drills. Because a response to protect our essential services cannot be improvised on the day of an attack; it must be prepared in advance. Protecting Europe means ensuring that our infrastructure, our economy and our society continue to function even when attempts are made to destabilise us. [19:30:20] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Yuri Ratas. [19:30:25] Jüri Ratas (PPE) [ET] This is honest today, Mr President and Commissioner, dear colleagues. In recent days, we have witnessed targeted attacks on our critical supply chains: cyberattacks have hit supermarkets, refrigeration systems in more than 10 European countries, and even France’s blood bank cold storage systems have been targeted. The aim of these attacks is to sow panic: to disrupt essential services for people and create insecurity. We do not yet know who is behind these specific attacks, but we do know for certain that we must address our vulnerabilities immediately and decisively. Protecting critical infrastructure requires significantly strengthening systems, faster information sharing, and real resilience to ensure backup solutions and the functioning of supply chains even in the event of an attack. Resilience means that no attack should be able to paralyse the day-to-day functioning of our society. Thank you. [19:31:29] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is Alex Andrew Saliba. [19:31:34] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [IT] Thank you, Mr President. The cybersecurity test of the Twister call or the collapses for security at the kelp fields. Raina, are you aware that supermarkets and young people are being hacked? I ask you whether Europe is with the chess pieces or against the chess pieces. [19:31:53] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [RO] And we do not have a digital infrastructure that is failing us, with dire concrete consequences, and this is the fault of the Commission. [19:32:00] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [IT] Thank you, Mr President. The online platform is now operational and provides essential services in at least two official languages of the Member States. [19:32:08] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [FR] Within the framework of one economic meltdown and austerity, citizens are exposed to real risks. [19:32:16] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [IT] This also depends on Malta, as we rely on transport for complex supply chains that bring essential products to our shores. [19:32:26] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [EN] Anna bzone infrastruttura digitale le tappoggia il provvista tale che le cittadine tana din tritcum protetta o sicura me cyber attacks. [19:32:35] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [FR] In the quest for security, we cannot accept an integrated fascist ideology. [19:32:40] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [IT] Mr President. The technology companies and the two have greater responsibility for safer products. [19:32:46] Alex Agius Saliba (S&D) [FR] Or the European Union has, for the first time, coordinated at the external borders, the Schengen frontiers, and also the airports. [19:32:54] Ana Miguel Pedro (PPE) [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Ana Miguel Pedro. [19:33:03] Ana Miguel Pedro (PPE) [PT] Commissioner, today it is no longer necessary to move a border to threaten a country's security. All it takes is exploiting a cyber vulnerability. When it is possible to remotely manipulate cooling systems, compromise blood banks or disrupt civil aviation, we are faced with a direct threat to the security of European citizens. This is the reality of hybrid threats. They do not need tanks on the streets or a declaration of war. They can paralyse essential services, compromise supply chains and sow fear and mistrust in our societies. Hostile regimes know our vulnerabilities, seek to exploit them, and artificial intelligence will increase the scale and sophistication of these threats. Commissioner, we need a firm and coordinated European response, a response that does not merely coordinate attacks but identifies those responsible, imposes sanctions and strengthens the protection of our essential infrastructures and supply chains. This is only the beginning. Thank you. [19:34:04] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is José Cepeda. [19:34:13] José Cepeda (S&D) [ES] Madam President, Vice-President Vilkunen, the truth is that when one analyses how Europe stands today, we have no other clear answer. Europe is at war, and it is directly affecting the lives of its citizens. When they attack water distribution, sanitation and food refrigeration infrastructures, what is clear is that we can talk at great length about all the initiatives being implemented through ENISA or the European Agency itself, that is, cybersecurity, but it is not enough. We feel that, for months now, I have been calling for the need not only to design patterns, not only to identify the authorship, we also need, in addition to developing a cybersecurity shield, to promote a sword, and for that we need a European cyber command. We really need to take much further a single European intelligence model that we currently lack. So, good luck, keep your spirits up, but above all, let us be resolute in the response we must give to protect 450 million people. Thank you. [19:35:22] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. And now we proceed to the catch the eye. And first I give the floor to Santana Glavac. [19:35:31] Sunčana Glavak (PPE) [HR] Thank you very much. Vice-Presidents, Commissioners, colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, it is clear to everyone that a war against Europe does not have to begin with tanks entering a European Union Member State. It can begin precisely in this way: by shutting down the electricity grid, blocking banks or cutting off food supplies. Imagine not being able to buy medicine, groceries or withdraw cash. As many as 73% of the organisations affected by the incidents analysed were key or important entities under the NIS2 Directive. In other words, it is precisely the systems on which the daily lives of our citizens depend that are under threat: transport, energy, food and healthcare. That is why I welcome the proposal, but I have several questions. How will we ensure that the equipment and software used by our hospitals, energy grids and telecommunications systems meet the highest security standards? How will we ensure the continuity of essential services when an attack occurs? And how will we provide the resources to implement the new obligations, particularly for smaller providers of essential services? Thank you very much. [19:36:41] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker is Juan Fernando López Aguilar. [19:36:47] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [EN] Thank you for president and commissaria. [19:36:49] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [ES] The last legislature consumed a great deal of energy and time regulating artificial intelligence. And in this legislature, we have turned the periscope towards cybersecurity, but in reality, both debates are connected, because the dizzying multiplication of artificial intelligence tools to exploit the vulnerabilities of the European Union and its Member States requires a common response. The embryo is in the European Cybersecurity Agency, but more is needed. In the short term, prevention and anticipation are better than reaction, and that requires shared intelligence, that Member States are capable of pooling all available intelligence regarding cyberattacks targeting our critical infrastructure. But in the long term, what we need to do is reduce the toxic and pathological dependence of the European Union on major providers of artificial intelligence, which make us vulnerable to cyberattacks. Therefore, investments in cybersecurity and a firm commitment to a European model of artificial intelligence. Thank you, Madam President. [19:37:55] Romana Jerković (S&D) [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Romana Jarković. [19:38:00] Romana Jerković (S&D) [HR] Thank you, Madam President. Almost every week we witness a new cyberattack, whether it is attacks on supermarkets, the theft of cryptocurrencies or, worst of all, attacks on hospital systems. In 2024, in one such attack in Croatia, the personal data of hundreds of thousands of citizens were stolen for ransom. That same year, a cyberattack on London hospital laboratories led to the postponement of thousands of examinations and operations. These examples clearly show just how vulnerable our systems are. But they also show that cybersecurity is not just a matter of technology; it is a matter of safeguarding our citizens, protecting their data and even their lives. Cyberattacks are a serious problem that requires serious, joint and ambitious responses. That is why Europe must invest more in its own technologies, in joint cyber defence and in the resilience of our health systems. In the digital world, the security of our citizens must be a priority. Thank you. [19:39:03] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Sebastián Tinquinen. [19:39:11] Sebastian Tynkkynen (ECR) [FI] Mr President, deep freezers are melting in shops. A large number of false bomb threats on European flights. Arsonists. This is just some of the hostile activity that has taken place in Europe over a short period of time. As we can see, hostile actors are coming up with all sorts of ways to exert influence. The origins of individual acts of harassment often remain shrouded in mystery, but everyone needs to consider the bigger picture. During Russia’s war of aggression, far too many unexpected events have occurred in Europe for each incident to be a matter of coincidence or some other factor. The bigger picture is that Russia is engaging in hybrid influence operations in Europe and continuing its war of aggression against Ukraine. The more we can weaken Russia in Ukraine, the fewer resources it will have to exert influence elsewhere in Europe. That is why Europe’s objective must be clear: Russia must be driven out of Ukraine. Thank you. [19:40:14] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. The next speaker is Vitenis Povilas Andriukaitis. [19:40:21] Vytenis Povilas Andriukaitis (S&D) [LT] Thank you, Ms President, Commissioner. I really want to speak on this. We must definitely help you to strengthen ENISA, we must definitely contribute to efforts for all Member States to finally agree on coordinated cybersecurity actions – this Cyber Resilience Act is special in that it can help to better harmonise, coordinate and accelerate investment in cybersecurity. We also need to train specialists; we need a European cyber training centre that could actually help Member States train specialists and identify those sectors as strategic – namely food, pharmaceuticals, water, electricity – because attacks on these can paralyse many systems and claim thousands of lives. We really must strengthen ENISA and reinforce the Commission’s efforts and instruments. [19:41:25] Bruno Gonçalves (S&D) [EN] And the last speaker under catch the eyes Bruno Gonçalves. [19:41:31] Bruno Gonçalves (S&D) [PT] Ms Commissioner, honourable Members, food refrigeration plants, blood banks, civilian targets. This is the new reality of a hybrid threat initiative that knows no borders in Europe. But what do the European data tell us about the capacity of European public and private systems and companies to respond to these threats? The latest report from ENISA, the European Cybersecurity Agency, tells us that only 16% of European SMEs are equipped to respond to these threats and that only 4% have implemented all the security measures to address external risks. This week, we had the Director-General of ENISA here in this Parliament, calling for the simplification of processes and reporting. But is what is lacking not rather more investment, a uniform European model and, while we are at it, responsible public systems and companies capable of meeting the expectations of this Parliament and of this Commission? What is lacking is investment, what is lacking is strategy, and Ms Commissioner, do not give up on a sovereign Europe and a digitally capable Europe. Thank you. [19:42:47] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Now I pass the floor to Executive Vice President Hena Virkunen, please. [19:43:00] Henna Virkkunen [EN] Thank you very much. Honorable President, members, Council. Thank you everybody for your very important contributions. I have listened carefully to the different views expressed today here. And I think that today's debate has shown very clearly that protecting critical infrastructures and essential supply chains requires not only sound rules but also stronger capabilities. Secure technologies, trusted suppliers, and effective European cooperation. The Commission will continue to work to reduce strategic weaknesses, strengthen our collective cyber preparedness, and ensure that Europe is better equipped to prevent, withstand, and respond to major cyber and hybrid threats. I count on this House to work with us to be successful in this effort. In the age of ever-evolving technologies and geopolitical tensions, Europe must be ready for all kinds of hybrid threats, including those from sophisticated actors posing advanced capabilities. And let me assure you, by fully implementing our ambitious agenda, we can ensure that Europe is up to this challenge. [19:44:17] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. Commissioner Virkunen, and now I pass the floor to the Minister Marianne Harkin. [19:44:29] Marian Harkin [EN] President, Honorable Members, Executive Vice President of the Commission. This is indeed a very timely and a very important debate. We all acknowledge the importance of strengthening our cyber resilience. Whether it's protecting our blood banks, our schools, our food supply, or our aviation systems, indeed all of our systems. When our citizens' lives are adversely impacted, the EU has a responsibility to act. The new cybersecurity act will undoubtedly contribute to this objective. By strengthening our ICT supply chain, and our European economies. The Irish presidency remains ambitious. To finalize the discussions on the cybersecurity act in the Council before the end of this year. So that the negotiations between the co-legislators can start as soon as possible in 2027. I think we all agree in this Parliament there is no time to waste. But unfortunately, one thing is clear. Attacks will continue and will increase in number and sophistication. And we also have to be prepared for an event that some attacks will succeed and sometimes unfortunately at large scale. That's why the presidency will continue to work on the implementation of the EU cyber blueprint. This is a critical tool to help us to prepare and to react to large-scale cyber attacks when they happen. Can I finally say I note and appreciate the good cooperation within the Parliament on this issue? And I hope this will result in a strong Parliament position and good outcomes in our negotiations? Can I also say I agree with the Commission? Any threats against civilians are unacceptable and indeed would many colleagues here this evening who emphasize that we need full European cooperation to protect our citizens. And on that note, can I thank all of you for your contributions and your attention. [19:47:15] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] Thank you very much, Minister Harkin. [19:47:17] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [DE] The debate is now closed. We now move on to the next item on the agenda. This concerns a statement by the Commission on media freedom and the rule of law in the Czech Republic, including threats to the independence of public broadcasters. [19:47:32] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [EN] And I pass the first pass the floor on behalf of the Commission to Commissioner Michael McGrath. [19:47:46] 263979 [EN] Dear President, dear Minister Harkin, on behalf of the Council presidency, dear Honorable Members, thank you for this opportunity to discuss with you today the situation of media freedom and pluralism in Czechia. With special attention given to the independence of public broadcasters. Media freedom and media pluralism are core elements of the rule of law in any country. For this reason, since 2020, there have been a key pillar of the Commission's annual rule of law report, alongside the Justice Sector, Anti-Corruption Frameworks, and other democratic checks and balances. In addition, over the past five years, the Commission has also adopted a number of important instruments. Which now provide an EU-level framework geared at protecting media freedom and pluralism across the European Union. This ranges from recommendations to ensure a safe and enabling environment for journalists, and other media professionals in Europe, to anti-slap legislation and finally a regulation the European Media Freedom Act, which is largely applicable since 2025, that introduces important safeguards in this area. Media freedom and pluralism are also essential for democratic accountability. Enabling citizens to access reliable information, to scrutinize public power, and to participate meaningfully in public debate. The 2026 rule of law report, adopted in July of this year, as you know, noted that draft legislation which would confer new powers on the media regulator and provide media companies with additional rights and additional responsibilities is pending. It also pointed out that no further steps have been taken on reforms relating to the transparency of media ownership. In relation to public service media, the rule of law report noted that the draft law presented by the Government, which would abolish license fees for public service media, has raised concerns. Public service media play a special role in ensuring that citizens have access to information and a diverse range of content. For this reason, the European Media Freedom Act contains safeguards in relation to the governance and [19:50:18] 263979 [EN] financing independence of public service media. The implementation and enforcement of the European Media Freedom Act is a priority for me as Commissioner and a priority for the wider Commission. In line with the broad commitment to safeguard media independence and pluralism across the European Union. The Commission has closely engaged with all Member States including Czechia, to ensure that the European Media Freedom Act safeguards including those relating to public service media are in place as soon as possible in each national legal framework. We continue to closely monitor and analyze national law as it develops in doing so we must take into account national specificities bearing in mind that the EMFA does not prescribe any specific governance of funding model but rather requires checks and balances in national systems. When it comes to the crucial issue of funding, for public service media in particular, national legislation must ensure that public service media can rely on a funding system that is based on transparent and objective criteria and that guarantees adequate sustainable and predictable financial resources. Engagement with the Czech authorities is ongoing. I would also like to stress that any legislative proposal should proceed through a duly conducted legislative process ensuring full respect for the applicable institutional framework and allowing for meaningful consultation of relevant stakeholders before adoption. This is important in that respect it is noted that the 2026 rule of law report has recommended to Czechia to take measures to improve transparency in the legislative process and meaningful consultation of stakeholders including by addressing the frequent use of fast track procedures. More broadly as regards the situation of media freedom and pluralism the 2026 rule of law report notes that in Czechia journalists continue to face serious verbal threats and harassment. A draft amendment to the Code of Criminal Procedure which would provide additional protection in terms of journalistic sources and [19:52:40] 263979 [EN] confidential communications remains pending. The report also noted that stakeholders point to the use of strategic lawsuits against public participation or slaps by politicians as an ongoing issue of concern. A draft law transposing the anti-slap directive which would cover both cross-border and domestic slap cases is currently before Parliament. The report also points to some good practice. The safe journalism platform was set up in the second half of 2025 and establishes a non-governmental online environment for journalists to report attacks. Finally, in relation to media ownership, the rule of law report notes that pending the adoption of draft legislation significant challenges persist in relation to transparency of media ownership. No progress has been made under recommendation of the 2025 rule of law report in this respect. The Commission will continue to closely follow developments on media freedom and pluralism in all Member States including in Czechia. We will engage constructively with national authorities and we will use all relevant tools at our disposal to uphold media freedom media pluralism and the rule of law across the Union. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to set out those initial remarks and I'm very much looking forward to hearing the contributions of Honorable Members on this important topic before us this evening. [19:54:14] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much. Commissioner, I know I pass the floor to the speakers on behalf of the political groups for EPP. Danuša Nerudová. [19:54:26] Danuše Nerudová (PPE) [SK] Dear colleagues, at 4:36 a.m. the government of Andrej Babiš ended the parliamentary debate and pushed through a proposal that threatens the independence of Czech public service media. At this moment, there is no guarantee that the funds for the media will not become a tool of political pressure on journalists. Czech Television is not Babiš’s television. Czech Radio is not Babiš’s radio. The media must hold politicians to account, not the other way around. I therefore call on the European Commission to act. The European Media Freedom Act must apply to all. This Sunday, hundreds of thousands of people are expected in Prague’s Letná Square, who believe in European values, and they will also be waiting for your response. Show them that Europe can not only promise freedom but also defend it. So, Mr Commissioner, can you tell us what specific steps you plan to take? And let me be clear: the mere phrase 'we will closely monitor and observe' will no longer resolve this situation and will not be enough for the people in those squares. I would also like to thank everyone who has stood up for freedom. Journalists, universities, people in the squares, theatres, and everyone else. Special thanks also go to students and young people. As a former rector, I am immensely proud of you, and as an MEP, I tell you that your voice is heard here in Brussels, in the European Parliament. Freedom is not a given, and together we will defend it. [19:56:06] Hannes Heide (S&D) [EN] Thank you very much. The next speaker on behalf of SNT is Hannes Heide. [19:56:12] Hannes Heide (S&D) [DE] Mr Commissioner, media freedom, pluralism and the rule of law are the foundation of our liberal democracy and must be defended every single day. And public service broadcasting plays a key role in this. It ensures independent information, scrutiny of power and trust in democratic institutions. But this task can only be fulfilled if editorial and institutional independence are guaranteed without restriction. And developments in the Czech Republic give serious cause for concern. For years, Prime Minister Babiš controlled one of the country’s largest media groups. Added to this are massive conflicts of interest in EU funding and plans to expose the civil service to political influence. What exactly are they trying to sell to the people? Abolishing licence fees and financing from the clear state budget means nothing other than that taxpayers will continue to pay for broadcasting. However, this increases the possibility of influencing the content and work of journalists. And all of this follows the autocrats' playbook and the dangerous, albeit familiar, pattern of weakening independent oversight bodies and concentrating political power. The rule of law thus comes under pressure. And that is precisely why we have the European Media Freedom Act, which obliges all Member States to reliably ensure the independence of public service media and their financing. This applies in the Czech Republic just as it does in all other countries of the European Union. [19:57:47] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [DE] Thank you very much, Mr Heide. [19:57:48] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] The next speaker on behalf of PFE is Ondřej Knotek. [19:57:52] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] Thank you, Madam Chairman, and thank you for your remarks, Mr. Commissioner. With seven years in this House, it's not for the first time I see this pattern. If democratic national elections deliver government which is in opposition to the European Parliament mainstream, very soon you guys come with plenary debates and resolutions questioning rule of law, media freedom, and democracy in the various Member States. Often with unnecessary escalation and often strong statements far from real situations. And let's be honest, it's obvious that with ongoing media reform in Czech Republic it is the same story. You talk, about risks, but media councils and editorial independents remain unchanged. We just changed the financing model to the one that is mostly used in the EU to enhance the financial transparency of these institutions. Not to govern them, but to make them more transparent. By the way, identical change of media financing happened quite recently in Denmark, France, Sweden, Finland, and the European Parliament was silent. But with patriotic government in place, you see a problem. Are you serious? So let's conclude. Regarding public media in Czech Republic, the checks and balances are in place. Freedom, medium act is respected. The majority of citizens are in favor of this change. So please respect this and don't be useful idiots of Czech activistic opposition. Thank you very much. [19:59:30] Speaker 2 [EN] The next speaker on behalf of ECR is Veronica Vrecionova. [19:59:39] Veronika Vrecionová (ECR) [CS] Thank you, Madam Chair, Commissioner, colleagues. I would like today to share with you and tell you about the alarming developments in the Czech Republic. The government of Andrej Babiš has decided in an unprecedented way to attack the very foundations of freedom and independence of public service media in our country. Its real goal is not any savings, but the subjugation and control of Czech Television and Czech Radio. In the Czech Republic, this independence is today protected by a proven system of television and radio licence fees, similar to, for example, in Germany or Austria. The current government, however, wants to abolish this system and transfer funding directly into the state budget and drastically cut the budgets of both institutions. By more than one billion Czech crowns compared to the current situation. This would mean one thing for both media: the elimination of quality investigative journalism, regional reporting and original productions. Moreover, this step makes no sense even economically. The state will not save anything by doing this; it will merely transfer almost 8 billion Czech crowns onto the shoulders of the state budget, which already shows huge deficits. The government will have to continue borrowing to cover this and taxpayers will pay for it anyway, this time with hefty interest. Proponents of this proposal argue that in Europe there are countries that finance public service media in a different way than through a licence fee, whether via electricity bills as in Italy, a dedicated tax as in Sweden or directly from the budget as in France. All these countries, however, have established strong safeguards that prevent the ruling elite from interfering in editorial independence. The Czech proposal, however, does not include any such protection. The government could change the allocation of the majority of the television and radio budgets at any time and thus keep both media in constant check under the threat of financial starvation. And if Prime Minister Babiš insists that he will not interfere in the content of broadcasts, it is enough to look at the recent past, when years ago he entered politics and bought the two most influential Czech daily newspapers, Mladá fronta dnes and Lidové noviny. All criticism of him disappeared from their pages overnight. [20:02:12] Veronika Vrecionová (ECR) [CS] The government's true intentions are also revealed by the way in which it pushed through this change in the first reading. Without any debate with the expert community, the opposition or civil society, it arrogantly used force after closing the debate, when dozens of MPs were not even given the floor, and during the overnight vote at four thirty-six on Friday morning into Saturday. Such a procedure is more reminiscent of the practices of authoritarian regimes outside Europe. Thank you for your attention. [20:02:48] Laurence Farreng (Renew) [EN] Thank you. The next speaker on behalf of Renew is Laurence Ferrand. [20:02:54] Laurence Farreng (Renew) [FR] Thank you, Madam President. Commissioner, dear colleagues, public service media play a key role in European democracy. By providing citizens with verified information and original audiovisual creations, their independence is crucial, and I therefore wish, like thousands of citizens, to express the support of my political group for all the staff of Czech radio and television. The Czech government’s plan to abolish the television licence fee is not a mistake; it is a clear attempt by Mr Babiš to undermine the independence of its public broadcasters and subject them to political control. Yet one of the conditions for quality journalism is stable, transparent and predictable funding. We have set this out in black and white in the Media Freedom Act, which has been in force since August 2025. But the far right, whether it be the Czech government, Donald Trump or the Rassemblement National, stigmatises public audiovisual media in order to distort public debate by leaving the field open to government-aligned media, as Viktor Orbán has done in Hungary. Commissioner, our compass is the Media Freedom Act. It must guarantee all citizens the right to receive pluralistic and high-quality information, including via public media. I therefore call on all our Member States to transpose this text without delay. This is all the more important as we are facing increasingly organised disinformation intended to disrupt our democracy before every election. We must also ensure proper funding of the media through the future Agora You programme, in the face of social networks and artificial intelligence that are swallowing up the work of real journalists. On funding too, we expect the Commission to urgently reform the SMA Directive to establish fair competition in the field of advertising revenue. [20:04:55] Laurence Farreng (Renew) [FR] Without this arsenal, the European Democratic Shield project will remain a dead letter and that will be a serious responsibility. Thank you. [20:05:04] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Speaker. The next speaker on behalf of the Greens is Markéta Gregorová. [20:05:18] Markéta Gregorová (Verts/ALE) [CS] Dear colleagues, Mr President, Prime Minister Andrej Babiš used to call newsrooms when something displeased him. But those who hold their budget in their hands no longer need to make such calls. A wave of civic resistance is rising in the Czech Republic. Thousands of students, journalists and female journalists are defending the independence of the media. After all, the media are not there to serve the Prime Minister or other politicians; they are there to hold them to account. And what is Andrej Babiš’s response? He claims that the students have been manipulated. Mr Prime Minister, you must be confusing them with your own parliamentary group. Students do not need instructions from headquarters to know when to raise their hands. Public-service media are neither government nor opposition media; they belong to the public. And it is the public’s voice that I am bringing here today to the European Parliament. And I am therefore calling on the European Commission: there are no safeguards in the proposal. Stand up for Czech citizens and use the European Media Freedom Act to defend independent media in the Czech Republic. [20:06:23] Antonella Sberna (ECR) [EN] Grazie mille. Please, it's not possible to make signs or everything, so thank you, Mrs. Gregorová. Please, Ms. [20:06:32] Antonella Sberna (ECR) [EN] It's ahead. [20:06:34] Antonella Sberna (ECR) [EN] It's not possible. Thank you. Please, Mr. Arvanitis. [20:06:48] Konstantinos Arvanitis (The Left) [EL] Madam President, Commissioner, we thank you very much for the opportunity you are giving us to discuss this issue, and I would like to say to my younger colleagues—my older ones already know this—I am a journalist; I used to be a journalist and I served public television. And I have a particular sensitivity to this. And I agree with the Commissioner’s proposal. And I want to tell you that in Greece we experienced this very intensely. It was 11 June 2013 when the then right-wing government imposed a blackout and shut it down. And the independence of public media is a fundamental prerequisite for the functioning of any democracy and for the protection of the rule of law. And I, both as a professional and as a journalist and as a citizen, cannot close my eyes and say: ‘This blackout is a sympathetic blackout because the party is friendly to me, and this is negative.’ I see it overall; it is a matter of democracy. And this is, therefore, a refrain that we constantly highlight both in the LIBE Committee and in our reports, particularly in the most recent one, for which I had the honour of being the rapporteur. Unfortunately, the recent government initiative in Czech television and Czech radio is raising serious concerns about the future of this independence we are discussing today. Of course, there is also the issue of transparency regarding private media, but I do not want to open that topic now. I want to raise three key issues. First, financial dependence. The government is pushing for the abolition of the licence fee and the transfer of funding for public radio and television organisations directly to the state budget. Someone might say: ‘Where is the problem?’ The problem is that we are effectively looking at a reduction in the financial capacity of the medium. Because here we calculated that it is at least close to, or rather below, 15% of revenue. Without, therefore, stable multi-year and legally guaranteed guarantees, it is a given that the political majority will acquire a powerful lever of economic pressure. [20:08:52] Konstantinos Arvanitis (The Left) [EL] in public information, and this constitutes, Mr Commissioner, a slide backwards. Second, the weakening of the public mission. The proposed cuts threaten the quality of journalism and regional information, cultural production and investment in new digital services. Public broadcasting is not simply a business, it is not a business; it is a public good, and I stress this, which must serve all citizens, regardless of income or political and religious beliefs. Third, the democratic process. The resort to the urgent parliamentary procedure for the relevant bill and the absence of prior consultation with the public broadcasters themselves rightly raise questions about the transparency and quality of the legislative process. It is no coincidence that on 3 November, the workers in public media, my former colleagues, held a major strike with thousands of citizens taking to the streets to support them. We experienced this in Athens in 2013. For all these reasons, therefore, defending public information for us is not a corporatist issue, nor a partisan confrontation. Thank you very much. [20:10:09] Milan Mazurek (ESN) [IT] Thank you. Honourable Member, please. Honourable Member Mazurek, please. [20:10:15] Milan Mazurek (ESN) [PL] Here in this amendment [20:10:17] Milan Mazurek (ESN) [SK] some people must have gone completely mad. When in Germany people are having their doors kicked in for writing something on social media, magazines are being banned, channels are being shut down, everyone here is silent. When in Poland Donald Tusk and his government massacred the public broadcaster, you were all silent. When we see that the Spanish progressive government is flooding all of Europe with illegal migrants, you are all perfectly fine with that. But when you see that in the Czech Republic a government of patriots and a Europe of sovereign nations is in power, you are all rushing to outdo each other in putting on the biggest circus act about how freedom and democracy are supposedly suffering. Where is this freedom and democracy when people in Europe are actually being locked up for their opinions? Where is this freedom and democracy when media are truly being silenced across Western Europe? Where is this freedom and democracy when the German government is banning its own citizens from travelling to conferences on re-emigration? Then you are not laughing like half-wits, Ms Nerudová. Then you are silent. Then everything is fine. And now we see the true face of these people. They lost the elections, they lost the elections in the Czech Republic and cannot accept it. They cannot accept it. That is why they are putting on acts like clowns in a circus. Finally, respect democracy. Respect the people of the Czech Republic, who have chosen their own government and that government consists of patriots and a Europe of sovereign nations. You cannot accept democracy like rabid dogs; you are calling for totalitarianism. You yourself represent real totalitarianism. [20:11:53] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, honourable Member. Please, honourable Member Wieselar Lima. Let us hear from our colleagues, please. [20:12:01] Isabel Wiseler-Lima (PPE) [IT] Please proceed. [20:12:05] Isabel Wiseler-Lima (PPE) [FR] On 24 October, at 4.36 a.m., in the middle of the night, the majority of the Czech Parliament adopted at first reading the removal of the television and radio public licence fee. If this goes ahead, that means around 15 % less funding. But above all, it means direct dependence on the State budget. This is not a budgetary dispute. A public medium needs independence. It must not have to negotiate its funding with a government every year, a government on which it must be able to cast a critical eye. That is why, on 3 November, public media employees went on strike and thousands of citizens took to the streets. The President himself, Mr Pavel, called for a genuine debate. Without media independence, it is democracy and the rule of law that are in danger. And this attack on the media, just like the law targeting NGOs financed from abroad, follows a dangerous pattern already seen elsewhere in Europe. The European regulation on media freedom is clear. Public media funding must be adequate, stable and predictable. Commissioner, you have said that the Commission has already started a dialogue with Prague. We need positive results for the rule of law before the final vote. This November, when the Czechs are commemorating 1989, the conquest of freedom and democracy, let us defend what they won through their Velvet Revolution. Thank you. [20:13:36] Evin Incir (S&D) [IT] Thank you, honourable Member. Please, honourable Member Insir. [20:13:39] Evin Incir (S&D) [IT] Please proceed. [20:13:45] Evin Incir (S&D) [EN] Collègues, there is no democracy without free and independent media, and there is no rule of law without accountability. The development in the Czech Republic reminds us that the media freedom and judicial independence must never be taken for granted. When political power threatens the independence of public broadcast, it is not only journalists who are at risk. It is the citizens' right to know the truth and hold those in power accountable. When we, at least, sell at last were able to celebrate that Orbán departed from power in Hungary, and when Kaczyński departed from power in Poland, well, Babiš stepped up and replaced them. The European Union must stand firm in defending media freedom and freedom, independent institutions, and rule of law in every member state. Because democracy does not die over one night. It is weakened step by step when those in power's silence those who dare to question them. Collègues, notez: you talked about my country Sweden, and you're right. What happened in Sweden is scandalous. But you failed to mention that the biggest party in the government coalition are your like-minded, Sweden Democrats, and finally, colleague Mazurek. There is only one clown here, and that is you, who always blame everything at migrants. [20:15:04] Speaker 1 [EN] Grazie, onorevole. There is a blue card for you. Mrs. Insir, there is a blue card for you. If you accept it. Please, Mrs. Knotek. [20:15:15] Speaker 2 [EN] Mr. Knotek, please. [20:15:19] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] For 30 seconds. [20:15:22] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] Yes. Thank you, Madam Chairman, and thank you, honorable colleagues, for accepting the blue card. I have carefully listened to your speech. Could you please be more in detail able to explain how concretely we break the media freedom with the proposal? And secondly, you said that you have this same system in Sweden as well, so it is the most common system in the EU. Why should we not have a right to have the same model of financing that is as well in the EU? Thank you very much. [20:15:50] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [IT] Please. [20:15:52] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] Please. [20:15:52] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] I didn't hear the— it was echoing quite a lot, but I— can you just repeat it so that I am able to really answer your— [20:15:59] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] Yes. [20:15:59] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] I didn't hear it, so it's— [20:16:01] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] If you were, madam, so kind to explain— [20:16:03] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] It's— [20:16:03] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] —in detail, how concretely the proposal of the Czech government is putting risk in the media freedom, and why we are not allowed to have the same way of financing as majority in Europe. Thank you so much. [20:16:17] Evin Incir (S&D) [EN] Well, of course, everybody has the right to financing the same way as others do, but what you are doing, you are actually attacking the media freedom. You are cutting the funds to free and independent media and journalists. And that is— and that's actually, in the same line, I should say, as the Sweden Democrats has made the government in Sweden the center-right government in Sweden do when you cut constantly. You don't always need to directly attack, even though, of course, Babiš does it, like your friend Orbán has done it before, like your friend Kaczyński did it also before. But you can also do it in a subtle way. Through cutting funding of the funding of the funding. [20:16:59] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] Thank you. Please, for your reply, if you want. [20:17:04] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chairman. Yes, we are in a difficult time. Of course, everybody must save the cost. But Czech broadcasting is responsible not only for the news, but also for a very wide field of activities that have nothing to do with politics. And my question is: where have you been where New Hungarian government cut the funds for the broadcasting by 50 percent? You have been silent. Again, double standards. Please read more before you talk. Thank you. [20:17:32] Evin Incir (S&D) [EN] One thing that I have learned from the far right— [20:17:34] Evin Incir (S&D) [EN] Please. [20:17:34] Evin Incir (S&D) [EN] —one thing that I have learned from the far right is that there is never ever a responsibility. Everything is always somebody else's fault. And it's always pointing at somebody else. When are you going to be able to take responsibility for God's sake? Take responsibility for what's happening in your country instead of saying what's happening in other countries? We have raised the problems in Czech Republic. See it and do something against the development. Stop talking about others. Talk about yourself. If you care about your country, your people, and the access to free and independent media, ensure that they reach free and independent media. Don't attack them. [20:18:12] Jaroslava Pokorná Jermanová (PfE) [EN] Thank you. Please, Ms. Pokorná Jermanová. Please. [20:18:20] Jaroslava Pokorná Jermanová (PfE) [CS] I would like to begin by saying that a lot of half-truths and falsehoods have been heard here, because the approval of the law is currently underway and the parliamentary debate is now topical. The law is now being worked on. I would like to state that the Government of the Czech Republic has every right to change the method of funding, because it emerged from democratic elections. The significance and independence of public service media does not lie in the method of funding. What matters are clear rules and protection against political interference, and that is not changing. What is important is strict control over the use of financial resources, but the current system does not allow for that. If some Members of the European Parliament or the European Commission want to turn concepts such as the protection of democracy and the rule of law into a political cudgel against governments they do not like, then know this: the Czech Republic is not a colony that needs to be lectured at every step by its democratically elected parliament. And Mr Commissioner, if you are brandishing a report from 2026, that report monitors the period of 2025, and that was not our government, but Mr Fiala’s government, which was represented here by my female colleagues. From the opposition. [20:19:34] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you. Please, Mrs. Jarr. I ask you to stay in time. Thank you. [20:19:42] Lucia Yar (Renew) [CS] We are with you. Stay with us. [20:19:44] Lucia Yar (Renew) [SK] With these words, in August 1968, Czechoslovak Radio addressed the people when the occupation came to silence free broadcasting. But today, tanks are not needed. A vote at 4:36 a.m. on Saturday is enough, through which politicians will limit the funding of public service television and radio. And then they will also limit truthful information. This is no progressive-liberal fairy tale; it is reality in our Slovakia, it is a warning from Slovakia. Even Babiš’s government was clearly inspired by Slovakia. Even here it started with lies, such as that the media spread disinformation, that Soros pays journalists, and that this needs to be dealt with immediately. First, they cut public-service media off from stable funding, strangled them, got rid of inconvenient employees, and then built a loud government propaganda machine on the ruins. And we are paying a high price for it. Today, in your streets, a struggle is taking place for freedom and the rule of law, because the autocratic ambitions that are simply unfolding here will never stop just at the media. Other institutions will follow. You stand in the squares and fight for Europe, for Slovakia, for those of us who have not yet lost hope. You are an inspiration to us; do not stop, thank you, and we stand with you. [20:21:19] Tineke Strik (Verts/ALE) [IT] Thank you. Please, honourable Member Estrich. Please. [20:21:24] Tineke Strik (Verts/ALE) [EN] Mr. Chair, the Commissioner, Babiš and his far-right allies have taken a page straight from the autocrats' playbook: make the public media dependent on state funding so you can control what they say. This is exactly what Orbán and Fico did before. Babiš calls it a financial reform; I call it an attack on the rule of law, because there is no democratic society without media freedom. The immediate broad and massive protests in Prague are encouraging, people know exactly what is at stake, their right to information, expression, debate, and ultimately their right to democracy and the rule of law. I call upon the Commission to act just as swiftly as the protesters did. Reject the bill and make clear to Babiš that being part of the EU requires full respect for the European values. And take determined action if necessary. Let us not make the same mistakes from the past, because undoing and encaptured system is so much harder than preventing it. [20:22:33] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. This is a blue card for you, Mr. Estrich. Ms. Estrich, there is a blue card if you want. [20:22:42] Speaker 3 [EN] Yeah, okay. [20:22:42] Speaker 2 [EN] Okay. Please, Mr. Mularczyk, for 30 seconds. [20:22:53] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [EN] Thank you. I will speak in Polish. [20:22:57] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Honourable Member, thank you for accepting the blue card. Today, you are speaking about threats to democracy due to the ongoing legislative process in the Czech Parliament. Honourable Member, where do you stand when we see and hear what is happening in Poland? Not long ago, Donald Tusk, without any legislation, with the help of the police, took over the public television. He took over Polish radio and he took over the Polish Press Agency. Later, he took over the prosecution service with the help of the police, and now he has taken over the Constitutional Tribunal with the help of the police. Where is the European Union? Where are the defenders of the rule of law in the European Union? [20:23:37] Tineke Strik (Verts/ALE) [EN] Ms. Estrich. [20:23:39] Tineke Strik (Verts/ALE) [EN] I mean, if a legislation is being adopted, it's not necessarily democratic. It's not necessarily under supporting the rule of law. We saw it in Hungary. A lot of legislation has passed under the Fidesz regime, but that wasn't democratic. That required an Article 7 procedure and freezing of the funding. What Tusk is doing in Poland, he is trying to rebuild the rule of law, and this is exactly my message to the Commission: make sure you don't need to rebuild it, but foster it as long as you have it. Thank you. [20:24:21] Volker Schnurrbusch (ESN) [IT] Please, the chambers. [20:24:24] Volker Schnurrbusch (ESN) [DE] Thank you, Mr President. If someone had suggested this topic to me during my active time as an editor, I would have sent them away, because it doesn’t fit the format. What on earth is prompting the Commission to interfere in the media policy of a Member State? The Czech government is planning to switch from a fee-based to a tax-funded broadcasting system, which is exactly what has already happened in France, Denmark and Sweden. So why is the Commission concerned about media freedom when it is doing everything in its power to exert ever greater control over the media? When the new Polish government simply shut down and unlawfully liquidated the state broadcaster, no protest was raised here. Because Donald Tusk is compliant with the EU, whereas Andrej Babiš thinks independently and wants to restructure the finances of Czech Television – something we urgently need in Germany too. This broadcasting system does not require nine billion euros a year. This topic does not belong in this Parliament, and the Commission should please refrain from interfering in the internal affairs of sovereign states. [20:25:30] Hannes Heide (S&D) [EN] Mr. Chambres, there is a blue card. Okay. Please, Mr. Heide. For 30 seconds. [20:25:37] Hannes Heide (S&D) [DE] I would like to know from you what you have to say about the fact that in two European countries, Switzerland and Slovenia, the population has voted in referendums to maintain the licence fee, and what do you have to say about the fact that, in a self-proclaimed patriotic government, officials responsible for broadcasting have apologised for what they have done for years in public-service broadcasting? [20:26:02] Volker Schnurrbusch (ESN) [DE] Also, I also have the principle that I do not interfere in the affairs of other states. I naturally followed the referendum in Switzerland very closely, because it is part of our DNA. You know, my party holds direct democracy in very high regard; we consider it very important. And I admired that the Swiss carried it out, and of course the result must be respected. Every country and every people should decide this for themselves. There are advantages and disadvantages to both systems, no question about it. But now to latch onto funding and say that suddenly it becomes dangerous – that is nonsense, quite honestly. [20:26:40] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [IT] Thank you. Honourable Member, please, Vice-President Verain. Please. [20:26:46] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [DE] Thank you, Madam President. Whoever controls the money also controls the media and has influence over the editorial process. The Czech Television and Czech Radio are to be financed directly from the state budget in future. This is certainly also the case in other countries. But the fact that this is happening at the same time as a 15 per cent cut is introduced clearly shows that the pressure and influence on the media is intentional. And this is a serious problem for independence. Commissioner, the European Media Freedom Act has been in force since August last year. That is now a year and a half, almost. Its implementation is still not complete, even though the deadline for implementation was last August. And this case shows why this is a problem. The EMFA requires adequate, sustainable, predictable funding that is also clearly regulated by law and not a system that is re-established with every change of government. And that was the reason why we created the EMFA, because we wanted to eliminate precisely these uncertainties. Public service broadcasting should be free from political influence. And honest budget negotiations are actually having the opposite effect. They give the government a lever over the editorial teams and the management of public service broadcasters, who constantly have to deal with the reality they find themselves in after budget negotiations. The Commission says it is observing the situation. Observation is not enough. It must act and ensure the full implementation of the EMFA in all its aspects. And the people in Prague are telling us exactly what they want. And Mr Schnurbusch, if you say that you hold the plebiscite in very high regard and want the population to be able to decide, then I ask myself why you are not listening to the thousands of people in Prague who have taken to the streets to fight for their public service broadcaster. [20:28:45] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [DE] and defend it. Show us that you want this. And please implement the law, Commissioner. The EMFA must finally be fully implemented in all Member States. Thank you. [20:28:56] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you. [20:28:57] Speaker 2 [EN] There is a, there are two blue cards. We can accept only one. Do you accept the, okay. Please, Mr. László. For 30 seconds. Please stay on time. [20:29:11] András László (PfE) [EN] I'll be talking Hungarian. [20:29:15] András László (PfE) [HU] You spoke about the financing of public service media and editorial freedom in the Czech public service media. But how is it possible that when, in Hungary, the new Prime Minister from the governing party — which belongs to your political family — personally intervened and publicly kicked out, essentially, the new editor-in-chief of the new public service media, you did not worry? How is it possible that when the financing of public service media was reduced, you did not worry because of Hungary? How is it possible that when the Media Council, the heads of the media authority, were replaced by the new parliament, you did not worry? How can this double standard be explained? Please tell us. Thank you. [20:29:56] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [IT] Thank you. You're welcome. [20:29:59] Sabine Verheyen (PPE) [DE] Yes, thank you very much. We do not need to apply double standards; what happened in Hungary is what we actually wanted, namely – at least so far – a good implementation of the EMFA in terms of how an independent media authority can be structured. Unlike before, there are now representatives of the governing parties, representatives of the opposition and representatives of civil society, which has not been the case under Orbán in Hungary. Previously, there were three from the governing party and one from the opposition party, ensuring that a three-quarters majority and a corresponding position were always guaranteed. That has nothing to do with the independence of media oversight. And that is why the step taken in Hungary is now the right one, because what has been established fully complies with the EMFA. Thank you. [20:30:44] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [IT] Thank you. Honourable Member, please. Honourable Member López-Aguilar. Please. [20:30:53] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [IT] Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner McGrath. [20:30:55] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [ES] When Anders Babiš, who is not coincidentally a media magnate, became Prime Minister of the Czech Republic, many of us in this Chamber foresaw a follower of Hungary’s Viktor Orbán’s illiberal path. But we had to wait and see. And here we are again, with yet another reform of media funding that has sparked protests in his own country, but above all, concern—from our perspective, rightly so—about its compatibility with European standards, as affirmed in the annual rule-of-law reports. These reports do not only analyse the state of judicial independence, the separation of powers, the fight against corruption, but also press freedom and its corollary, which is media pluralism. This European Parliament has not only adopted a law to protect journalists from strategic litigation, but also a whole media regulation with a European centre, a European body that safeguards freedom and media pluralism. Therefore, we must state clearly that transparency in media funding is an essential component of media freedom and of informational pluralism, because it is very easy to colonise freedom of expression through invasive media funding. Thank you, President. [20:32:17] Antonín Staněk (PfE) [IT] Thank you. Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Stanek. [20:32:29] Antonín Staněk (PfE) [CS] Madam President, to all those who today confuse the defence of media freedom with support for the Czech opposition without knowledge of Czech legislation, I remind you that the European Parliament should not be a tool of domestic strategic and partisan struggle. If you have evidence of interference in editorial independence, present it. Political disagreement is not evidence. And what are we talking about? About the method of payment. The licence fee is not a certificate of freedom. And funding from the budget is not automatically censorship. The method of payment does not guarantee media independence. What matters are the rules that protect it. And those are guaranteed in the proposal. I respect the right to protest as much as the right to scrutinise public money. After all, public service media do not belong to the government. They do not belong to the opposition, nor to any one ideological camp. Czech colleagues, do not laugh and do not turn a domestic political dispute into an indictment of your own country. It does not deserve that. Ms Nerudová. [20:33:41] Daniel Freund (Verts/ALE) [IT] Thank you. Honourable Member, please. Honourable Member Freund, please. [20:33:46] Daniel Freund (Verts/ALE) [EN] Dear colleagues, dear Commissioner, Andrej Babiš, the Prime Minister of the Czech Republic, has a conflict of interest. And it's not just me saying that. It's the European Commission that said this, and also not for the first time. This is the second time now already that we have certified this. So making sure that he doesn't get a cent of EU funds is the bare minimum that we need to make sure. But I actually don't really understand how someone that has a certified conflict of interest, the Financial Rules say it needs to be resolved, how can he still sit at the negotiation table and negotiate the EU budget? How is this possible? Mr. Konotnik, you said that we're only criticizing this because he's part of the fascist political family here. But if you remember, actually, just two years ago, you used to sit there in the middle. With the liberals. Before you changed groups. And actually, back then, when you were still part of what you call the political mainstream, well, this House was still criticizing the corruption, the conflict of interest, and all the problems in the Czech Republic. So this has nothing to do with your group. This has to do with conflict of interest and corruption. [20:35:00] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you. [20:35:00] Speaker 4 [EN] Thank you very much. [20:35:02] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Kolar. Please. [20:35:17] Speaker 2 [EN] For personal statement, not because of blue card. You don't push for blue card. If you want to intervene for personal statement, you can. Please. [20:35:35] Ondřej Knotek (PfE) [EN] Thank you very much. Mr. Freund, we have a nice debate in the budgetary control committee, but this is a different topic. By the way, are you aware that your colleague from your political group, from the Pirates, which is part of the Greens, had exactly the same idea of change of the financing in their parliamentary program? So your colleagues had it as a program, and you are now criticizing us for doing what your colleagues wanted to do eight years ago? You are not serious. You are silly. [20:36:06] Speaker 2 [EN] Grazie, Onorevole. It's a personal statement, so it's not possible to reply. It's not possible to reply because it was a personal statement. It's not a blue card. Please, Mr. Konotnik. Mr. Kolar, sorry. [20:36:28] Ondřej Kolář (PPE) [CS] Good evening. Thank you very much. And it is terribly sad that, thanks to the populist-nationalist governing coalition, the Czech Republic is being pushed to the sidelines and that we have to witness this debate. How can I trust a government that is actively decimating our own army to have good intentions towards public-service media? Which, doubtless, many politicians in the coalition dislike because it adheres to the principles and standards of objectivity, balance and professional journalism? I am not saying we should not discuss how public-service media are financed and operate. The problem, however, is that this debate is not happening. What we are witnessing is bullying by the government. This is not a standard political debate. We do not see expert consultations. There is no transparent process. Instead, we are seeing a rape of morality. We are witnessing a degradation of values. We see contempt for ideological pluralism and for rules—both written and unwritten. And those who do this and call themselves democrats then frenetically applaud a thoroughbred Slovak neo-Nazi. That hurts. [20:37:35] Speaker 2 [EN] There is a blue card from Mrs. Dostálová. Please, for 30 seconds, and please stay on the time. [20:37:43] Klara Dostalova (PfE) [CS] Good afternoon, Mr Member of the European Parliament. I sincerely apologise for this falling to you, because I tried to submit a blue card for Ms Nerudová, Ms Gregorová or Ms Vrecienová, but my fellow heroines have hidden themselves in the group where it is not possible. So I will ask you instead whether you read European studies. I assume you do, as a proper Member of the European Parliament. So you certainly know that they point to the injustice of concession fees, their administrative complexity and problems with collection. And so I ask you why, in your view, Czech citizens must face this? Or why must this system be maintained when the European Commission itself points out its unsuitability? And why do you not consider it appropriate to switch to a different method of financing, as 14 countries have done? [20:38:30] Ondřej Kolář (PPE) [EN] Please. [20:38:30] Ondřej Kolář (PPE) [CS] Thank you for the question. It's a shame you weren't listening to what I was saying. I said that it is necessary, or in other words, it is necessary to hold this debate on the funding and functioning of public service media. And I said that the problem is that this debate is not taking place in the Czech Republic. You have raped the parliamentary process. You have refused to debate and the debate does not exist. We do not know what your government coalition actually plans. No one knows. Frankly, I honestly think that your Prime Minister doesn’t even know, that you yourselves don’t know. You are just cobbling something together on the fly, no one knows what is actually happening, and then at 4:36 a.m. on Saturday, you rape the Chamber of Deputies. That is not done. Sorry. [20:39:17] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Rafović. [20:39:22] Speaker 2 [EN] We are very late. [20:39:33] Emma Rafowicz (S&D) [FR] Madam President, Commissioner, the Czech government is directly attacking the independence of public broadcasting. By abolishing the licence fee and announcing cuts to news budgets, they are striking at a true pillar of our democracies. In France, we know this story all too well. Since Emmanuel Macron abolished the licence fee, public broadcasting has been weakened. On the far right, both here and in France, they are rejoicing, they are rejoicing at these repeated mistakes. They are exploiting every loophole opened up by the right-wing government. Charles Lalonque in the French National Assembly, Sarah Knafo here – their project is clear: to do everything possible to privatise public broadcasting and serve the media concentration agenda of their friends. We cannot tolerate this auctioning off of our imaginations to a few oligarchs. The freedom of our continent, the strength of our democracies, also depends on this first line of defence. Here, information is free culture. So, Commissioner, I say this to you very solemnly: we must ensure that the Media Freedom Act is applied and fully transposed across Europe. We must strengthen the protection and the capacity for action of our regulators. We must strengthen the funding of our public broadcasting. We must establish a genuine European preference to protect ourselves against foreign interference. [20:40:53] Emma Rafowicz (S&D) [IT] Thank you. [20:40:53] Emma Rafowicz (S&D) [FR] And protect our public audiovisual media. And I will conclude here: we must finally massively decentralise our media and culture. The oligarchy is the enemy of democracy. [20:41:04] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. [20:41:05] Speaker 3 [FR] Thank you. [20:41:06] Speaker 2 [IT] We have concluded the debate. We have six speakers registered under the written procedure CACHE-DI. We can accept them all, but I ask you to be precise with the timing. We will begin. Please, Honourable Grappini. Please. [20:41:20] Maria Grapini (S&D) [RO] Thank you, Madam President. Commissioner, dear colleagues, I believe that if citizens listened to tonight’s debate, they will no longer have any trust in us. We must understand—having listened to both sides—matters that could lead to disinformation. We must understand that once states join the European Union, they must comply with European regulations. Not à la carte. We do not pick and choose what we like. The media is very important. These rules must be implemented in all Member States. On the other hand, the Commission—Commissioner—you must see how you are not fuelling euroscepticism. Because if you want to intervene, as you did in my country, Romania, to challenge a law passed by Parliament and approved by the Constitutional Court, we lose credibility. That is why I believe that, yes, we must know the sources of funding. Radio is the easiest means of informing citizens, and that is why we must protect the media and press freedom. Thank you. [20:42:20] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Konecka. [20:42:26] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [CS] Madam President, distinguished colleagues, ladies and gentlemen. What we are seeing and engaging in here today is a political debate of those who were unsuccessful in last year's elections to the Chamber of Deputies. Unsuccessful people who—it really saddens me that neither Ms Vrecienová nor Ms Gregorová are here today; they were the ones who kept saying how things should be different. Their political parties proposed that the fees be abolished. When they were not in opposition and had the chance, they proposed that the fees be abolished. Do you, colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, really think it is democratic that in the Czech Republic we have reached the point where public-service media fees are paid by people who do not even own a television or radio? Does that seem fair to you? And do they have any chance of control? Today, they have no chance of control whatsoever. And what is undemocratic about that, or are countries like France, Malta and others undemocratic, where public-service media are also funded from the state budget? And just a few final figures, colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, so that it does not look as though the entire Czech Republic is protesting. According to surveys, only 19 % of people would voluntarily pay the fee to Czech Television, and only a third of people wish to keep it. So do not believe what you see on television; look at the data instead. [20:43:45] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [IT] Thank you. [20:43:45] Kateřina Konečná (PfE) [CS] The Czechs want the fees to be abolished, so grant them that. [20:43:49] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. [20:43:50] Speaker 3 [CS] Let's get to it. [20:43:51] Speaker 2 [IT] Please, Honourable Tinkynen. [20:44:00] Sebastian Tynkkynen (ECR) [EN] Dear colleagues, I want you to listen to me carefully. The media model you're criticizing that Czech Republic is trying to build. That is the model we have in Finland. What are we doing here in. Finland? We used to have TV licenses for our citizens for funding the public broadcast company. We took them away. Then we introduced the public broadcasting tax, and now politicians control the system. And this government term we made the biggest cuts for this public broadcasting company. There were no protests in our country. EU didn't attack us. The commissioner didn't attack us. We have EPP Prime Minister at the moment. I hate the hypocrisy. And this happens again and again. EU, you're losing your credibility. Thank you. [20:45:07] András László (PfE) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Mr László. [20:45:14] András László (PfE) [EN] Thank you, Madam President. This debate on media freedom in the Czech Republic is obviously nothing more than a pathetic and dishonest political attack. The law hasn't even been approved yet. The new financing model exists in several other EU countries. Yet those countries were not criticized. Why is that? Why is it that when other parties had similar policy plans, no one was concerned in this House? The double standards is absolutely obvious. The hypocrisy must end. The double standards must end. Media freedom—European values—rule of law can only be credible if they are applied with the same measure to everyone, and not on a political basis like it is happening today with the Czech Republic. Thank you very much. [20:46:08] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Mularczyk. [20:46:17] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Are there different standards of the rule of law in the European Union? Undoubtedly, yes. Because today we are discussing a change that is being processed in the Czech Parliament. However, ladies and gentlemen, over the past three years of Donald Tusk’s government in Poland, all institutions—starting with public media, television, public radio, the Polish Press Agency, the prosecution service, and most recently the Constitutional Tribunal—have been forcibly taken over. Donald Tusk does not need any law. He does not need any parliamentary procedure. He sends in the police, he sends in batons, and he forcibly seizes institutions. Ladies and gentlemen, that is the current state of the rule of law in Poland. And where is Commissioner Graff? There is no Commissioner Graff. He is silent, he is hiding. Where is President von der Leyen? She is not here. Because they accept it, because in Poland a German liberal lapdog, Donald Tusk, is in power. Ladies and gentlemen, and this is a scandal. This is not the Union we want. Thank you very much. [20:47:21] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Tereš. [20:47:26] Cristian Terheş (ECR) [RO] Thank you, esteemed Mr Commissioner. When will you stop this hypocrisy? I have listened carefully to what has been said here and I see this double standard being promoted by Ursula von der Leyen. If the leadership of a Member State pleases Ursula von der Leyen, no matter what that representative does, it is fine. If, however, the leadership of that State questions European policies, whether they are good or less good, that is secondary. No matter what the leadership of that State does, this kind of criticism appears. I ask you: is the European Commission the most suitable institution to lecture Member States on press freedom? Especially when the European Commission has still not published the contracts signed with the vaccine companies to this day? How can it preach, speak, and give lessons on press freedom when it itself violates the freedom and the right of citizens to access information of public interest? Mr Commissioner, please tell Ursula von der Leyen to publish the contracts signed with Pfizer and Moderna. Thank you. [20:48:41] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. We have concluded the catch-the-eye procedure. Please, Commissioner McGrath. Thank you. [20:48:53] 263979 [EN] Thank you very much, President, Honorable Members. Thank you all for your contributions to this debate this evening. And I believe that this evening's discussion has again shown that media freedom and pluralism is certainly not an abstract principle. It is a necessary condition for democracy, accountability, and public trust. And this is especially true when we speak about public service media. Whose independence and long-term sustainability are essential for democratic life. They are a key pillar. In Czechia, as elsewhere, and Euroform affecting the governance are financing of public broadcasters, must be assessed with due care. Public service media needs stable, adequate, and predictable funding to be able to fulfill their mission in the public interest. What is at stake today goes beyond any one financing model. Are indeed any one member state. It's about whether public service media can continue to serve citizens, free from political or economic pressure, at a time when trusted independent information is more essential than ever. And this is precisely why the European Media Freedom Act matters, not only as a shared standard on paper as EU law, but as a framework that must now be applied and implemented in practice. But the independence of public service media is only one part of the picture. Media freedom also depends on the people who do the work. Journalists, must be able to report without fear. And the truth is, across the EU, journalists continue to face threats: online harassment, and even physical attacks. We assess their safety every year, in the annual Rule of Law report. And this is also why the Commission adopted a recommendation on the safety of journalists back in 2021. And as committed in the European Democracy Shield, the we published a year ago, we will update this recommendation to reflect the changing realities that journalists face in their day-to-day work. Journalists are also increasingly targeted, as we know, by abuse of lawsuits. Known as slaps, which aim to silence them, rather than to obtain justice. [20:51:12] 263979 [EN] The anti-slap directive, which member states had to transpose by May of this year, allows courts to dismiss manifestly unfounded claims early and protects those targeted in cross-border cases. We've recommended that member states apply the same safeguards indeed to domestic slap cases. So let me underline one fundamental point in conclusion. Independent media including public service media providers are not a nice-to-have in a democratic society; they are in truth a democratic necessity. The Commission will therefore continue to engage with the Czech authorities and, in doing so, our objective is clear: to ensure full respect for the principles of media freedom editorial independence and transparent and sustainable funding in line with European standards and in line with European law in the form of the European Media Freedom Act. The Commission will remain vigilant and committed to defending media freedom and pluralism, as well as the Rule of Law in all member states including in Czechia. Thank you, colleagues, for your contributions this evening. [20:52:20] Antonella Sberna (ECR) [IT] Thank you, Commissioner. The discussion is closed and the vote will take place during a future sitting. The agenda now includes the one-minute speeches under Article 179 of the Rules of Procedure. I inform you that for the one-minute speeches, colleagues are invited to take the floor from their seats. We shall begin: please, Honourable Member Kohut. [20:52:46] Łukasz Kohut (PPE) [PL] And I stand here today, even though in Warsaw they say that the Silesians do not exist. I said this several years ago, precisely in this hall of the European Parliament. The census: over half a million Polish citizens declared a Silesian identity and the use of the Silesian language. The bill on recognising Silesian as a language twice passed through the Polish parliament. Unfortunately, twice right-wing Polish presidents vetoed our cause. And that is precisely why we have embarked on a different journey. We want international recognition and respect for the Silesian language. We want to inscribe the Silesian language as a bearer of culture in the UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage list. We are currently conducting public consultations. From Opole Silesia to Cieszyn Silesia. The entire Upper Silesia, with its various dialects, speaks one language, a carrier of our Silesian culture and identity. We will not deviate from this path. Let us protect regional languages. Let us jointly protect the Silesian language, the heritage of our old ancestors. Multiculturalism is our strength. [20:53:49] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Kristea. She is not here. Please, Ms. [20:54:01] Speaker 2 [EN] Disdier. 707. [20:54:09] Mélanie Disdier (PfE) [FR] There you go. We're going to fuck your mothers. Dirty whites. Dirty fascists. These are the insults that young Catholics in Rouen received last week before being violently attacked. Punches, a broken nose, a disfigured face. And all for no reason. But since when, in France, would being white, French or Catholic justify becoming a target? I welcome the upcoming creation of a European coordinator responsible for combating anti-Christian hatred within the European Union. This is a truly necessary step forward. But they will need to get to work quickly. Christians in Europe are not asking for any privileges. They are simply asking to be able to live their faith freely and safely. Anti-white racism exists. Anti-Christian hatred exists. It is time to stop turning a blind eye. There cannot be double standards in the fight against racism and religious hatred. As our President Metsola so rightly said earlier, racism has no place in Europe or anywhere else. Every victim deserves justice, whatever their origins and beliefs. Thank you. [20:55:28] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Teodorescu. [20:55:35] Georgiana Teodorescu (ECR) [EN] Thank you, Chair. [20:55:36] Georgiana Teodorescu (ECR) [RO] From here, from Brussels, from the comfort of the Parliament and the Commission, you believe you understand the needs and the desperation of those who have filled the streets across Europe. Do you think you can understand the pain of a mother who has nothing with which to feed her children or the tears of an elderly person who must give up food in order to afford their medication or their electricity bill? Your ideological, ruinous policies, such as the Green Deal, have bankrupted businesses, suffocated the agricultural sector, and driven production out of Europe. So that you can pat yourselves on the back for being noble and wanting a cleaner planet, you have starved an entire continent. There is no true democracy without prosperity for citizens. Just as there is no real democracy with annulled elections, political police, and banned protests. On the 14th, Romania will rise from its knees and, like other European countries, will demand justice in the streets. The Government in Bucharest is preparing to crush any form of legitimate protest, believing, as they do, that it is democratic to annul ongoing elections, to ban snap elections and, in general, to trample the Constitution underfoot. Watch closely the news from Romania and the abuses being prepared against Romanian citizens. [20:56:41] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Cohen. [20:56:48] Barry Cowen (Renew) [EN] Thank you, President. Like many at home, I woke up this morning to welcome news of a public sector pay deal in Ireland. A balanced agreement delivering meaningful increases for over 400,000 workers. But there's a broader point I wanted to make. Increasingly, in Ireland and indeed in Europe, we see competing interests all making their own demands, all insisting their priorities come first. Here in Brussels, every committee, including my own, demanding more from an already stretched European budget. But in Ireland, I will remind you, it was fiscal prudence, not reckless spending on the back of uncertain revenues, that built an economy that was capable of delivering pay increases and supporting households and investing billions in infrastructure. Likewise, in Brussels, it's unity and solidarity and a willingness to compromise that have brought us to where we are. Because ultimately, the politics that I believe in is about more than satisfying the demands of individual interests. It's about having the courage to make difficult choices, the discipline to look beyond the next election, and the responsibility to put the long-term interests of those we represent and expect this Parliament and the Commission and the Council will have that in mind when agreeing a budget that accommodates all sectoral interests fairly and appropriately. Thank you. [20:58:04] Speaker 2 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Miranda Paz. She is not here. Honourable Member Bojlan. [20:58:15] Lynn Boylan (The Left) [EN] Thank you, Chair. This week, I and my colleague Kathleen Vonchen were proud to welcome activists from the north of Ireland to Brussels for an Irish Unity Week. And their message was inspiring, and it was clear that Ireland is ready for reunification and the north is ready to rejoin the EU. Some delegates were too young to even vote when English voters decided that these young people's futures lay outside the European Union. But they know there is a way back through the Good Friday Agreement, and they are determined to exercise that option to unite Ireland in the EU. And the Parliament also heard this week of thorough new research from Professor Colin Harvey and Barrister Mark Bassett, pointing out at how Brussels, too, must prepare for a united Ireland. Delicate political and legal issues can no longer be ignored by anybody here in Brussels. In Brussels, in Belfast, in Derry, Nuri, and Dublin, the message from the people is that it is time to get serious about a united Ireland in the European Union. [20:59:18] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Bozdorf. [20:59:21] Irmhild Boßdorf (ESN) [EN] Please. Thank you. [20:59:25] Irmhild Boßdorf (ESN) [DE] 100,000 young people took to the streets in France and Italy in October to protest against failings in the education sector. Their concerns are more than justified. Public coffers are empty, educational institutions are falling into disrepair, and future prospects are virtually non-existent. Dystopian images emerged when part of these protests was hijacked by Antifa and migrants. Things spiralled completely out of control and the anger erupted violently. Thousands of shops were looted, cars and buildings burned, and millions of euros in damage were caused. Who is going to compensate this damage? Good question. At the same time, billions of euros in European Union funds flow into left-wing and opaque structures every year. Organisations from the environment of the protests have also benefited from this. We demand a thorough and transparent investigation to ensure that not a single euro of our tax money has been misused for violent protests. We also demand that, in future, our money should be spent on the education and future of our children rather than on left-wing propaganda. Thank you. [21:00:37] Luis-Vicențiu Lazarus (NI) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Lazarus. Please. [21:00:43] Luis-Vicențiu Lazarus (NI) [RO] Madam President, dear colleagues, democracy in action. Madam President, dear colleagues, I see that this important principle of the European Union is even displayed on a banner in front of the Parliament. But let us consider how this democracy in action operates in our countries. Actually, in Romania, in 2024, you practically banned certain people from running for the presidency of Romania. Which is absurd. It resembles what is happening in Iran. Furthermore, I have also learned that in Romania someone else won the elections than who you were expecting. If someone other than the one you wanted won the elections, you would have annulled the elections. After you cancelled the elections, you again banned those who wanted to run, including the election winner, Mr Călin Georgescu, from running again. Today he has five criminal cases and is being held in prison in Romania. And now we want to hold a rally on Saturday, and we are not given permission. So, in what country do we live and in what European Union do we live? I mean, aren’t you even ashamed? Ursula von der Leyen was in Romania just a few days ago and... [21:01:57] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you. [21:01:57] Speaker 4 [RO] Yes, I have. [21:01:59] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you. Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Aftias. [21:02:08] Georgios Aftias (PPE) [EN] Please. [21:02:09] Georgios Aftias (PPE) [EL] Honourable colleagues, the support of our islands is support for islandness through the new multiannual financial framework must be our top priority. The islands are not just for tourism; they have needs. They have many needs. As a member of the Economic Committee, and as a Greek MEP, with many islands in my homeland, there are far too many of them—227 are inhabited. They need transport, they need energy, they need healthcare and education. Development must not stop where the sea ends. It must continue. I therefore ask for your full support, and I believe we will all move in this direction. Thank you very much. [21:03:04] Kristian Vigenin (S&D) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Vigenin. Please. [21:03:10] Kristian Vigenin (S&D) [EL] Nikos Nebihmepous, Member of Parliament, [21:03:12] Kristian Vigenin (S&D) [BG] that a company deliberately distributes a product that leads to addiction in children. So why are we allowing this in the digital world? The algorithms of social media platforms are designed to keep children glued to screens for as long as possible. The consequences can be serious: anxiety, sleep disorders, cyberbullying, exposure to harmful content. The health and well-being of children must be more important than the profits of digital platforms. We need stricter measures against practices that lead to addiction, effective enforcement of existing legislation, and new ambitious rules, including a future European legislative act for the protection of children online and the YouKids Act, as well as the Digital Justice Act presented today. That is why, on 21 November, I am organising a public discussion in the city of Varna with representatives of institutions, experts, parents and teachers to discuss European policies and specific solutions. Parents are doing everything they can to protect their children, but they are up against some of the most powerful tech companies in the world. It is time for us, as legislators, to take our share of the responsibility too. Thank you. [21:04:26] Anna Bryłka (PfE) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Brica. Please. [21:04:32] Anna Bryłka (PfE) [PL] Dear colleagues, we, Poles, today are celebrating our independence. 11 November is a joyful memory of the day when, after 123 years of captivity, Poland returned to the map of Europe as a sovereign, strong and independent state. We have been and remain a proud and free nation, which is why we want decisions made in Poland to be fully Polish decisions, without yielding to any form of blackmail. Neither the European Commission, nor Parliament, nor any external body has the right to interfere in Polish affairs. We do not need EU resolutions, lectures, or CJEU rulings. We want the Polish economy to grow, and that means there must be less and less EU legislation. It is Poles who are the hosts in Poland. We will organise the system ourselves, the judiciary ourselves, and we ourselves will hold to account those responsible for the recent assassination attempt, including Prime Minister Tusk. The Commissioner is supposed to have said: the Polish Constitutional Tribunal must be allowed to function in accordance with the Polish Constitution and the CJEU’s case law. No, Mr Commissioner, we do not need your tribunal. We need less and less of the Union and more and more of Poland. Long live Poland. [21:05:42] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Reussen. Please. [21:05:50] Bert-Jan Ruissen (ECR) [NL] Thank you, Mr President. In the Netherlands, it is the Week of Life this week. I wish to take this opportunity to reflect on this this evening as well. Because the situation is extremely worrying. Mr President, in the Netherlands this week is the Week of Life. I felt it important to address this again this evening. Because the situation is extremely worrying. In the Netherlands alone, more than 100 abortions take place every day. Over 40,000 a year. Appalling. During the Week of Life, many in my country reflect on the fact that life is given by God. And so it is worthy of protection from the very beginning. I think of what David confessed about this in Psalm 139: 'You knit me together in my mother’s womb.' And in the meantime, Mr President, Europe is only pushing for a further expansion of abortion legislation. Mr President, the EU really needs to stop doing that. And certainly also stop funding abortions from the ESF. Let us protect life and focus on care for mother and child. Thank you. [21:06:53] Robert Gabel (The Left) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Gabel. Please go ahead. Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Gabel. [21:07:00] Robert Gabel (The Left) [DE] The gladiatorial combats in ancient Rome, those are thankfully history, but there are still bullfights in some parts of Europe today. In these events, the poor animals are tortured and tormented for so long that they ultimately die a particularly protracted and agonising death. A particularly horrific way to amuse and entertain certain people. However, the majority of people are against it, even in Spain, by the way. We now have a unique opportunity to put an end to this, to realign the Common Agricultural Policy and, in doing so, to end EU funding for bullfighting. After all, the EU is violating its own values and rules if it financially supports bullfighting. So let us seize this opportunity together now and put an end to this bloody stain on the European Union. Thank you. [21:08:04] Maria Grapini (S&D) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Grappini. [21:08:09] Maria Grapini (S&D) [RO] Madam President, Commissioner, the proposal that the Commission has made for the new budget for the next seven years you know full well that it is not well received by farmers, by the Common Agricultural Policy, as the proposal stands: the budget is being cut. And not only does it decrease, I am also a member of the Agriculture Committee and Vice-President for the internal market. We cannot fail to allocate funds to farmers who are subsidising farmers who are pensioners. We know full well that we have a generational change problem. Then there are, no, we cannot accept – and farmers are saying this, and the majority of Parliament is saying this – that costs on salaries should not be reduced or excluded when capping is applied. And there are many other things. But the most serious is that livestock farming is on the ground, that the budget is decreasing, it is smaller than in the previous financial exercise, and yet they are asking the Commission to consider whether, if Parliament, if farmers do not support this budget and we will no longer have a common agricultural policy, the Commission should change its position. And perhaps after 20 years, when my country, since my country joined the European Union, and the farmers in my country will have the same subsidy as the other farmers. [21:09:19] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. [21:09:21] Tiago Moreira de Sá (PfE) [IT] Please, Honourable Member Moreira de Sá. [21:09:23] Tiago Moreira de Sá (PfE) [IT] Please. [21:09:25] Tiago Moreira de Sá (PfE) [PT] Madam President, when Robespierre's head rolled for you, we had Sanson, the terror ended. Robespierre was dead. But with him did not die his most dangerous legacy, the seduction of the idea that violence is a legitimate instrument of political transformation. Robespierre’s guillotine has disappeared from the squares, but not his descendants, who still draw inspiration from him. Today, the far left is the heir to the tyrant of Paris, seeking to hijack noble and urgent causes, such as education and housing, not to find solutions, but to set Europe ablaze. And that is why, when they cannot silence the ballot boxes, they seek to impose their will in the tumult of the ballot boxes, in the streets. It is for us to draw a line in the sand. There are those who prefer fire to dialogue. We will respond with the strength of our laws. Terror met its end in a basket of wine. We will not allow it to be reborn in our shop windows and stalls, in our squares and institutions. Thank you. [21:10:23] Piotr Müller (ECR) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Müller. Please. [21:10:29] Piotr Müller (ECR) [PL] Ladies and Gentlemen, today Europe is even handing over its own kitchen and bathroom to Asia. In recent years, the share of European factories in our market for washing machines, refrigerators and dishwashers has fallen from 81% to 71%. And at the same time, Asian products have doubled in terms of quantity. From 15 to 28%. This is further evidence of how we are surrendering yet another area of industrial production in Europe. And the stakes are around one million jobs on our continent. Poland stands to lose the most in this regard, because 39% of large household appliances produced in the European Union are made in our country. And we in Europe are not losing this competition to Asia because we have worse products, but because in the European Union we have more expensive energy, greater regulations and stricter requirements, which result in lower competitiveness, while at the same time products from Asia are not adequately controlled. Ladies and Gentlemen, several Member States of the European Union have called for the preparation of a special strategy for the household appliances sector. We must do this, otherwise this sector will end up the same way as car production in Europe. [21:11:37] Anthony Smith (The Left) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Smith. Please. [21:11:42] Anthony Smith (The Left) [FR] Thank you, Madam President. For several months now, young generations have been mobilising across our continent, despite police repression, to demand improvements in their living, working and study conditions. And rightly so, as poverty and unemployment rates are reaching record levels and study spaces are rapidly falling into disrepair. Young people are being pauperised and exploited. Their legitimate anger must be able to find political expression. Establishment of an autonomy guarantee at the level of the poverty threshold. Increase in the minimum wage and in the remuneration of apprentices and trainees. Freezing of prices for essential goods and energy. Abolition in France of Parcoursup, in particular. Plan for modernising and adapting buildings to climate change. All these proposals are found in the presidential programme of Jean-Luc Mélenchon, L'Avenir en Commun, and we are defending them. The professional sector must also regain a coherent and efficient structure through the creation of polytechnic centres and maritime high schools. Without a trained and emancipated youth, national sovereignty is simply not possible. Thank you. [21:12:46] Romana Jerković (S&D) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Jerković. Please. [21:12:51] Romana Jerković (S&D) [EN] Thank you, Chair. Dear colleagues, we often speak about childhood obesity as if we were simply a matter of personal responsibility, but it's not. Children are not responsible for the environment in which they grow up. Children do not decide what food is advertised to them, what is served in their schools or whether their families can afford healthy meals. These are choices shaped by policies and food industry and markets and the society we create. We cannot expect children to make healthy choices if we do not give them a healthy option. And that is why we need stronger European action on prevention and healthier school environments and protection from harmful marketing. Every child deserves the chance to grow up healthy, regardless of their family's income or where they live. This is not just about health; it is about equality and about Europe's future. Thank you. [21:13:53] Speaker 4 [SK] Good. [21:13:54] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Domotor. Please. [21:14:01] Csaba Dömötör (PfE) [HU] In recent weeks, several delegations have visited Hungary to assess the state of democracy, and they have concluded that now everything is fine, there’s nothing to see here. They said this despite the fact that a significant portion of opposition MPs are barred from political life, cannot run in the next election, and this only affects the opposition. They have also removed the President of the Republic, constitutional judges, and the Chief Prosecutor. The largest opposition party’s servers have been unlawfully seized. According to the self-proclaimed champions of the rule of law, this is perfectly acceptable. And why is that? Because the new government is doing everything that the previous one was unwilling to do. Green light for war financing, accelerated expansion, they loosened the child protection law, abolished the protected pricing of fuels, and also started to narrow the family support system. This only proves one thing: that all this harassment was only about having a government that would finally nod along. Well, now there is one. All we ask now is that you kindly throw your hypocritical rule-of-law reports into the bin. Thank you. [21:15:06] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Tinkinen. [21:15:16] Sebastian Tynkkynen (ECR) [FI] Mr President. Welcome to the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics of Europe. Here, a new migration management model is now in use. We are talking about burden-sharing. Mr President, even if you keep your own borders closed, you are in practice left with two options: either you take on your share of the burden of the overflowing migration belt at Europe's borders, or you end up digging your own grave. So either you take in migrants or you pay the receiving country 20 000 euros per migrant. Now, several Mediterranean countries have been designated by the European Commission as countries under migration pressure, and then the duty of solidarity is triggered for other countries, meaning the doors or purse strings are opened. This is a problem that European migration policy does not address; instead, it is being shifted around Europe. Could this House finally tackle the root cause: close the external borders and send those residing in the EU illegally packing? Thank you. [21:16:20] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Oliveira. Please. [21:16:27] João Oliveira (The Left) [PT] Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner, thank you very much. Send the European Commission the message that it is necessary to stop the closure of the Eco factory in Santa Maria da Feira, Portugal. It is necessary to defend the jobs of the 632 workers who are at risk of being laid off, and it is necessary to defend industrial production. The Danish multinational Eco, in the footwear sector, has been established in Portugal for 40 years and has now announced, after several collective redundancies over time, its intention to close the factory in Portugal as part of a broader restructuring process involving thousands of redundancies in various countries and the relocation of all production to the Asian continent. If this situation is confirmed, 632 Portuguese workers and their families will, from one day to the next, be left without job prospects and plunged into uncertainty and instability. We need to put an end to the policy that allows multinationals to set up shop, benefit from public support and European funds, and then pull up stakes when they decide they no longer have the profits they wanted. This policy serves neither industrial production nor workers' rights. [21:17:41] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member López-Aguilar. [21:17:47] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [IT] Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner McGrath, the Canary Island of El Hierro is experiencing a sudden surge in the Atlantic migration route to the European Union, which is the deadliest. And that is why the European solidarity coordinator, envisaged in the Migration and Asylum Pact, has declared, in light of El Hierro and what happened in Ceuta, Spain, under migratory pressure, the need for mandatory solidarity envisaged in the pact for the redistribution of people rescued at sea. That is why it is all the more regrettable when we ask the European Union for solidarity and it is being denied by the autonomous communities, the Spanish regions governed by the Partido Popular. As if they were trying to make iron a permanent temporary focal point for foreigners. Without any solidarity from the rest of Spain, it is difficult to ask for it from the European Union. And yet, it is envisaged by the Pact on Migration and Asylum. Therefore, it must be remembered that solidarity is an essential component and requires assistance through financial contributions or redistributions to uphold the fundamental rights of people who have been rescued at sea. And there is no more insufferable hypocrisy than lamenting the loss of lives at sea while at the same time rejecting those who survive, having been rescued at sea. [21:18:57] Juan Fernando López Aguilar (S&D) [IT] Thank you. [21:18:58] Speaker 3 [ES] And solidarity is being denied in its redistribution. Thank you, Mr President. [21:19:00] Julien Sanchez (PfE) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Sánchez. Please. [21:19:06] Julien Sanchez (PfE) [FR] The concerns of the French people about the cost of living and the state of our high schools are legitimate and call for concrete responses. But let us nevertheless recall that the French people voted for those who mistreat them, for those who do not solve their problems and who drive up the cost of living. For example, the maintenance of high schools falls under the responsibility of the regions, as in Occitania, where the left has been in charge for decades and whose elected representatives are now marching shamefacedly in the processions. Like in my own city of Nîmes, where they are accountable for this record. While the only way to change this is through voting, for the past few weeks the communist sect has been showing its true face in France. Political exploitation, constant chaos-mongering, total irresponsibility, talking about legitimate violence when the facts are serious and inexcusable. Thousands of shops vandalised, over a billion euros in damage, a town hall set on fire. And nearly 1,000 police officers injured under the complacent gaze of the far left, the laughter of the anti-fascists and the government’s impotence. At the same time, they are systematically attacking anyone who does not think like them. As soon as you are no longer to the right of their guru, you are a fascist. They deny people the right to speak out, even want to shut down media outlets—the inquisition has begun. This is what France would be like if they were in charge: sectarianism, hatred, pettiness, vulgarity, ugliness, witch hunts, violence. The silent majority does not want this new inquisition. [21:20:16] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. [21:20:16] Speaker 4 [FR] Let us all say it together before it is too late. [21:20:19] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Timgren. [21:20:21] Beatrice Timgren (ECR) [IT] I ask. [21:20:25] Beatrice Timgren (ECR) [SV] Thank you. So here we are again. COP31. New promises, but honestly, have these meetings actually led to any emissions reductions? No. At the same time, Europe is under pressure from high energy prices and overregulation. This means that jobs are moving abroad, but it also means that emissions are shifting – to countries such as China, for example. And speaking of China, China is still classified as a developing country. This means that it does not have the same obligations at all. Like Europe. And at the same time, the so-called rich countries are supposed to finance, together, 300 billion dollars a year in climate financing. Yet another huge meeting, thousands of participants, and billion-dollar pledges. Is this really the best solution? No, we need more affordable energy, we need nuclear power so that we can genuinely reduce emissions, but also safeguard our competitiveness. Thank you. [21:21:37] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Mularczyk. Please. [21:21:46] Arkadiusz Mularczyk (ECR) [PL] Ladies and Gentlemen, in the face of the tragic attack in Kraków, in which six people died and 15 were injured, here in the European Parliament I would like to thank two heroes: Polish police officers Jakub Kulik and Artur Morański. It was their courage and dedication that saved many innocent lives in Kraków. But Ladies and Gentlemen, equally important are also the words and the responsibility for those words. Many of you, colleagues, men and women from across Europe, heard in global media that the attacker was a far-right extremist. Today, we must state clearly: that was disinformation. And its source was the Polish government minister Marcin Kierwiński, who linked the perpetrator to the right without any evidence, and his words immediately spread around the world. Meanwhile, the perpetrator’s social media profiles indicate views closer to the left side of this Chamber. But the disinformation-spreading minister has to this day not withdrawn his words nor apologised. That is why I will say it plainly: we must fight disinformation, but with doubled intensity we must fight the disinformation produced by the irresponsible government in my country, in Poland. Thank you. [21:22:54] Speaker 1 [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Gonçalves. Please. [21:23:02] Bruno Gonçalves (S&D) [EN] First of all, thank you, Madam Chair, for your kindness. [21:23:05] Bruno Gonçalves (S&D) [PT] Today we turn on our mobile phone and within a second we receive Today we turn on our phones and within a second we receive online betting advertisements. They are on social media, through paid content and influencers, on news websites and even when we watch a football match. They offer easy money to create an account and place the first bet, with promises of profits that never materialise. But we know that is not true, and we also know that the gap between initial temptation and addiction is not a long one. The digital world is increasingly drawing people into betting, particularly younger people who are more exposed. And it is only if we talk about irregular and illegal gambling in Europe, that by 2025 there will be more than €90 billion in gross revenue. This is not an individual failure; it is a political and regulatory failure. It is the duty of the institutions to prevent predatory practices from reaching our lives through online channels. As Henri Lacordère, French theologian of the 19th century, warned in the relationship between the weak and the strong, the elite must free and its absence oppresses. Let online gambling regulation come. [21:24:10] Cristian Terheş (ECR) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. Please, Honourable Member Tereš. [21:24:17] Cristian Terheş (ECR) [RO] Thank you, esteemed Commissioner for the Danube Delta, a UNESCO World Natural Heritage Site. It is not just about spectacular landscapes, biodiversity and tourism, but also about people. These people are facing risks posed by drones, which has reduced tourism and, implicitly, an important source of income for the local economy. Many communities are isolated, infrastructure is poor, and access to medical services, education and economic opportunities is limited. The local economy in the Danube Delta is in decline, fishermen are losing their sources of income, young people are leaving, and communities are depopulating. The EU is increasingly discussing environmental restrictions and bans without any real analysis of the impact of these decisions on the people. Protecting the Danube Delta must not mean condemning those who live there to poverty. We need a balance between nature conservation and economic development through investments in infrastructure, fishing, tourism and jobs. The Danube Delta can only be saved if the people of the Delta are lost. I therefore call on the European Union to support the Danube Delta concretely through dedicated funding, investments in infrastructure and safety, and economic development. Nature cannot be saved by abandoning the communities of the Danube Delta who have lived there and protected this heritage for generations. Thank you. [21:25:32] Antonella Sberna (ECR) [IT] Thank you, Honourable Member. We have concluded the one-minute speeches. The next sitting will be held tomorrow, Thursday 12 November 2026, at 09:00. The agenda has been published and is available on the European Parliament’s website. The sitting is adjourned.