WEBVTT

NOTE Brussels Live. Transcribed and translated automatically from the original sound. Mistakes are possible. Independent service, not affiliated with the European Parliament or the European Commission. Source: © European Union. AI-generated: Transcripts, translations and summaries on this site are generated automatically by AI: speech recognition (Soniox), machine translation and summaries (Mistral AI). Not edited by humans before publication. EU AI Act, Article 50.

00:10:06.833 --> 00:10:14.693
Good afternoon, dear colleagues. Could
I ask you, please, to take your seats?

00:10:15.413 --> 00:10:16.613
It's okay, it's okay.

00:10:31.013 --> 00:10:33.593
We'll wait for one minute for
the colleagues to come in.

00:10:47.873 --> 00:10:49.073
It's okay.

00:11:04.373 --> 00:11:12.513
So, dear colleagues, at the 11th hour, on
the 11th day of the 11th month in 1918,

00:11:12.893 --> 00:11:16.621
the guns fell silent on the western front.

00:11:16.733 --> 00:11:23.482
Today, we remember the millions whose
lives were cut short, the families left

00:11:23.573 --> 00:11:28.046
waiting, and a generation forever changed.

00:11:28.253 --> 00:11:35.311
Remembrance also means honouring those
who—a generation later—fought to defend and

00:11:35.420 --> 00:11:42.873
restore freedom in Europe. One of those
heroines was Solange Alexandre, who passed

00:11:42.966 --> 00:11:49.310
away a few days ago at the
age of 104, known as Scorlet.

00:11:49.433 --> 00:11:56.418
She led 30 resistance fighters against the
Nazi occupation and helped liberate Turin

00:11:56.513 --> 00:12:03.773
in France. It is on us to carry their stories
forward, to defend our freedom, and to

00:12:03.833 --> 00:12:08.333
protect the peace that they
sacrificed so much to secure.

00:12:09.593 --> 00:12:12.893
To God, Ms Alexandre, we
will never forget you.

00:12:14.693 --> 00:12:21.988
Now, dear colleagues, yesterday, severe
weather led to a series of multi-vehicle

00:12:22.133 --> 00:12:29.719
crashes on Bulgaria's Trakia motorway. At
least 11 people lost their lives, and many

00:12:29.816 --> 00:12:35.491
more were injured. On behalf of the
European Parliament, we offer our deepest

00:12:35.562 --> 00:12:40.607
condolences to the families and loved
ones of those who lost their lives.

00:12:40.673 --> 00:12:48.024
We thank the rescue services and medical
teams who worked tirelessly at the scene,

00:12:48.113 --> 00:12:54.974
and everyone who came
forward to donate blood.

00:12:55.253 --> 00:13:01.698
We were all shocked and appalled at the
shooting in Kraków's main market square last

00:13:01.793 --> 00:13:09.055
Saturday afternoon. What should have
been a peaceful afternoon turned into a

00:13:09.138 --> 00:13:14.876
senseless attack that left six
people dead and more injured.

00:13:14.993 --> 00:13:20.474
Later, three more people were found
dead in the perpetrator's home.

00:13:20.573 --> 00:13:25.858
We thank the European Parliament, and we
thank the police officers at the scene, for

00:13:25.920 --> 00:13:29.365
acting quickly and bravely
to stop the attacker.

00:13:29.453 --> 00:13:33.473
And the emergency services who
helped bring the people to safety.

00:13:36.053 --> 00:13:43.282
Dear colleagues, this Assembly was also
deeply shocked by the attack that took place

00:13:43.347 --> 00:13:48.306
in Trappes and La Verrière at
the beginning of the month.

00:13:48.383 --> 00:13:54.637
One innocent man lost his life, and several
other people were injured, including a

00:13:54.727 --> 00:14:01.600
12-year-old girl. We pay tribute to the
memory of Pengo Bosiovangi and express our

00:14:01.682 --> 00:14:09.677
deepest solidarity with all those whose
lives have been shattered by this attack.

00:14:09.769 --> 00:14:16.783
No one should be targeted because
of the colour of their skin.

00:14:16.873 --> 00:14:23.633
Of their origins, or of their religion.
Racism has no place in our Europe.

00:14:35.993 --> 00:14:44.448
Now, dear colleagues, on the 28th of October,
2026, another tragedy occurred when a

00:14:44.547 --> 00:14:51.797
train collision in Urda, Spain, left
69 people dead and dozens more injured.

00:14:51.893 --> 00:14:58.057
On behalf of this House, I offer our deepest
condolences to the families and friends

00:14:58.118 --> 00:15:04.355
mourning their loved ones. We share in
their grief and wish all those injured a

00:15:04.451 --> 00:15:10.870
swift and full recovery. We also express
our heartfelt gratitude to the emergency

00:15:10.928 --> 00:15:16.031
services who worked tirelessly
at the scene of the disaster.

00:15:16.133 --> 00:15:21.407
So, dear colleagues, in memory of all those
lost, I ask you to join me in observing

00:15:21.473 --> 00:15:22.793
a minute of silence.

00:16:04.433 --> 00:16:14.753
Thank you. Excuse me. Oh,
sorry. Sorry. Thank you.

00:16:17.933 --> 00:16:22.420
If your announcements from my end, it is a
pleasure to welcome Deputy Speaker of the

00:16:22.478 --> 00:16:29.609
Verhoevenaarade, Ms. Olena Kondraciuk, at
the Diplomatic Gallery for this important

00:16:29.813 --> 00:16:38.694
mini. Plenary session. We're very
happy to have you here, Olena.

00:16:38.753 --> 00:16:44.575
Welcome. The minutes and the texts adopted
of the Sitting of the 22nd of October,

00:16:44.633 --> 00:16:48.841
2026, are available.
Are there any comments?

00:16:48.953 --> 00:16:52.802
No. Therefore, the minutes are approved.
The competent authorities of Spain have

00:16:52.853 --> 00:16:58.220
notified me of the election of Antony
Comini-Olivares to the European Parliament

00:16:58.270 --> 00:17:03.447
with effect from 22nd of October, 2026. I
welcome our colleague and recall that he

00:17:03.494 --> 00:17:08.704
takes his seat in Parliament and his bodies
in full enjoyment of his rights, pending

00:17:08.782 --> 00:17:15.241
the verification of his credentials.
Parliament verifies the credentials of Balázs

00:17:15.368 --> 00:17:21.842
Orbán and of Robert Garbel with
effect from 18 September, 2026.

00:17:21.953 --> 00:17:27.628
Pursuant to Rules 10 and 183 of the
Rules of Procedure, and after taking into

00:17:27.672 --> 00:17:32.273
account the observations of the member
concerned, I have decided to impose a penalty

00:17:32.333 --> 00:17:37.898
on Mr. Sebastian Tünkönen for disrupting
the Sitting of 17 June, 2026, by engaging

00:17:37.946 --> 00:17:42.758
in improper behavior during the voting
session and failing to comply with the Vice

00:17:42.803 --> 00:17:44.819
President's calls to
proceed with the vote.

00:17:44.873 --> 00:17:49.566
The penalty consists of a reprimand the
member concerned has been notified of this

00:17:49.620 --> 00:17:55.601
decision. He has not lodged an internal
appeal with the Bureau under Rule 184.

00:17:55.673 --> 00:18:00.306
The penalty is therefore final. The competent
authorities of Greece have addressed

00:18:00.353 --> 00:18:04.776
the request to me for the Parliamentary
immunity of Nikos Papas to be waived.

00:18:04.853 --> 00:18:08.296
The competent authorities of Germany
have addressed a request to me for the

00:18:08.338 --> 00:18:11.741
Parliamentary immunity of
Arno Bausemer to be waived.

00:18:11.813 --> 00:18:15.788
The competent authorities of Poland
have addressed a request to me for the

00:18:15.831 --> 00:18:19.181
Parliamentary immunity of
Gregor Braun to be waived.

00:18:19.253 --> 00:18:23.713
These requests are referred to
the Committee on Legal Affairs.

00:18:23.873 --> 00:18:28.996
The EPP PFE and ECR groups and the
non-attached members have notified me of

00:18:29.044 --> 00:18:32.708
decisions relating to changes to appointments
within committees and delegations.

00:18:32.753 --> 00:18:36.689
The decisions will be set out in the minutes
of today's sitting and take effect on

00:18:36.730 --> 00:18:37.373
the date of this

00:18:37.373 --> 00:18:45.119
announcement. The Inter and Liber Afet and
Dever Yuri and Liber and Liber committees

00:18:45.170 --> 00:18:50.480
have decided to enter inter-institutional
negotiations pursuant to Rule 72,

00:18:50.557 --> 00:18:54.413
paragraph 1 of the Rules of Procedure.
The reports, which constitute the mandates

00:18:54.453 --> 00:18:59.264
for the negotiations, are available on the
plenary web page and the titles will be

00:18:59.315 --> 00:19:03.943
published in the minutes of the sitting.
Pursuant to Rule 72, paragraph 2, members

00:19:03.985 --> 00:19:07.987
or political groups reaching at least a
medium threshold may request in writing by

00:19:08.046 --> 00:19:12.505
tomorrow, Thursday, the 12th of November,
at midnight, that the decisions be put to

00:19:12.551 --> 00:19:16.676
the vote. If no request for a vote in
Parliament is made within the deadline, the

00:19:16.726 --> 00:19:24.086
committees may start negotiations. Tomorrow,
we will proceed with the election of a

00:19:24.140 --> 00:19:27.983
Vice President of the European
Parliament to replace Mr.

00:19:28.073 --> 00:19:34.795
Nicolao Stefanutsa. By the deadline of
Tuesday, 10th November, at 7:00 p.m., I

00:19:34.856 --> 00:19:41.036
received the following nominations: Ms.
Rada Lajková, nominated by the ESN group,

00:19:41.144 --> 00:19:45.613
and Ms. Tilly Metz, nominated
by the Greens group.

00:19:45.713 --> 00:19:50.626
The candidates have confirmed to me
their consent to their candidacies.

00:19:50.693 --> 00:19:56.695
As the number of candidates exceeds the
number of seats, to be filled, tomorrow we

00:19:56.781 --> 00:20:03.684
shall hold a secret electronic ballot in
accordance with Rule 17, paragraph 1 of the

00:20:03.773 --> 00:20:08.059
Rules of Procedure. Can I take this
opportunity to thank Vice President Stefanutsa

00:20:08.111 --> 00:20:20.575
for the work that we have done together?
Now, we come to the order of business.

00:20:20.633 --> 00:20:24.483
The revised final draft agenda, as adopted
by the Conference of Presidents on 10th

00:20:24.530 --> 00:20:28.613
of November, pursuant to Rule
163, has been distributed.

00:20:28.673 --> 00:20:37.368
The agenda is adopted and the order
of business is thus established.

00:20:37.733 --> 00:20:42.302
Mr. Buxader, if you have a point of order
which is not a point of order, I ask you

00:20:42.353 --> 00:20:45.233
to make a one-minute
speech, okay? Tonight, soon.

00:20:45.293 --> 00:20:48.732
We can give you the
floor. One-minute speech.

00:20:48.833 --> 00:20:54.154
All right. Oh, my hand. Now, the next item
on the agenda is statement by the Vice

00:20:54.245 --> 00:21:02.290
President of the Mr. Buxader,
this is not a point of order.

00:21:02.453 --> 00:21:06.016
We are not going to have a point
of order on the Spanish people.

00:21:06.113 --> 00:21:06.473
Okay?

00:21:06.473 --> 00:21:10.032
We are going to have one-minute speech.
I will give you a one-minute speech.

00:21:10.073 --> 00:21:12.313
Give me a second. I will give
you the one-minute speech.

00:21:12.353 --> 00:21:16.973
But first, I will—this has nothing
to do with order of the day.

00:21:17.033 --> 00:21:22.001
The next item on the agenda is statement
by the Vice President of the Commission,

00:21:22.053 --> 00:21:25.435
High Representative, for Foreign
Affairs and Security Policy.

00:21:25.493 --> 00:21:30.404
Ukrainian children forcibly deported
to Russia or living in Russian-occupied

00:21:30.473 --> 00:21:36.793
territories in Ukraine. I'd like to inform
members that there will be only one round

00:21:36.843 --> 00:21:38.947
of political group
speakers for this debate.

00:21:38.993 --> 00:21:43.366
Therefore, there's no catch-die procedure
and no blue cards will be accepted.

00:21:43.433 --> 00:21:48.322
I give the floor to Ms. Kayakallas. And
then we will have the one-minute speeches.

00:21:48.353 --> 00:21:49.553
Don't worry.

00:21:51.893 --> 00:21:58.217
The President, Honorable Members, as we
hold this debate, talks between Ukrainian

00:21:58.289 --> 00:22:07.131
and Russian officials have
taken place in Abu Dhabi.

00:22:07.373 --> 00:22:15.332
These allow Ms. Kayakallas to speak. The
EU has always supported efforts for a just

00:22:15.426 --> 00:22:21.845
and lasting peace in Ukraine. The only
problem is that Russia shows no signs that

00:22:21.953 --> 00:22:29.243
it's ready to seriously negotiate. The
treatment of Ukrainian children over the last

00:22:29.333 --> 00:22:36.163
four years is the clearest example
of Russia's total disregard of life.

00:22:36.293 --> 00:22:42.067
It is Russian government policy, approved
by Putin himself, to deport Ukrainian

00:22:42.144 --> 00:22:50.684
children from occupied areas of Ukraine
to Russia over 20,000 children have been

00:22:50.770 --> 00:22:57.063
illegally deported. This year, the
OSCE published a report detailing a

00:22:57.133 --> 00:23:02.774
state-orchestrated campaign in temporary-occupied territories to erase Ukrainian

00:23:02.862 --> 00:23:06.991
identity of children from
early childhood onward.

00:23:07.133 --> 00:23:12.155
All evidence points to a
crime against humanity.

00:23:12.413 --> 00:23:19.529
Back. In 2025, I welcomed the Parliament's
resolution on this topic, but three MEPs

00:23:19.613 --> 00:23:24.338
voted against it, and
there were 34 abstentions.

00:23:24.473 --> 00:23:30.523
If the information you have by now does
not convince you, I don't know what will.

00:23:30.773 --> 00:23:39.910
In a sick and twisted turn of events, in
a sick and twisted turn of events, it is

00:23:39.974 --> 00:23:46.053
likely that stolen Ukrainian children are
now being sent back by Russia to fight

00:23:46.129 --> 00:23:53.086
against Ukraine. Honorable Members, Russia
can only run its horrific system of child

00:23:53.168 --> 00:23:59.266
deportation indoctrination and illegal
adoption thanks to the network of people and

00:23:59.348 --> 00:24:04.428
entities. That is why the European Union
has sanctioned the people and entities

00:24:04.493 --> 00:24:10.296
responsible. Most recently, we have
extended the list to include more children's

00:24:10.373 --> 00:24:16.195
camps, including Songda-1 International
Children's Camp in North Korea, where

00:24:16.250 --> 00:24:20.326
Ukrainian children were found.
Russia abducts children.

00:24:20.393 --> 00:24:25.982
North Korea, indoctrinates them. That
is how dictatorships divide labor.

00:24:26.153 --> 00:24:30.470
In parallel, Europe's efforts to support
Ukrainian children continue on other

00:24:30.533 --> 00:24:36.323
tracks: diplomacy, ensures the world
does not lose sight of these children.

00:24:36.413 --> 00:24:42.157
In December 2025, the EU co-sponsored
the UN General Assembly resolution, which

00:24:42.214 --> 00:24:43.414
called on the UN

00:24:43.433 --> 00:24:48.884
Secretary-General to engage directly with
Russia to locate the children, assess

00:24:48.942 --> 00:24:53.059
their health, and legal status,
and secure their return.

00:24:53.153 --> 00:24:56.046
Now we need to see
concrete follow-up on this.

00:24:56.153 --> 00:25:00.422
We have hosted and participated in multiple
events, including the International

00:25:00.473 --> 00:25:05.006
Coalition for the Return of Ukrainian
Children, and this is important for

00:25:05.137 --> 00:25:14.348
awareness-raising and sharing information
on where our efforts need to focus next.

00:25:14.573 --> 00:25:19.113
The European Union remains the biggest
supporter of accountability efforts,

00:25:19.193 --> 00:25:24.797
including the work of the International
Criminal Court—let us not forget that there

00:25:24.886 --> 00:25:31.832
are two ICC arrest warrants for Vladimir
Putin and Maria Lvova-Belova for these

00:25:31.947 --> 00:25:37.412
crimes. EU funding also supports
Ukrainian children in a variety of ways.

00:25:37.493 --> 00:25:42.918
Recent examples include close to 30
million euro in humanitarian aid to support

00:25:42.979 --> 00:25:48.406
Ukrainian children and children's facilities,
10 million euro to provide education

00:25:48.473 --> 00:25:54.423
and learning support for children and
teachers, 5 million euro to restore access to

00:25:54.489 --> 00:26:00.475
local education systems in war-affected
communities, and 4 million euro to deported

00:26:00.542 --> 00:26:07.029
Ukrainian children, including 1. 75
million euro for accountability efforts for

00:26:07.106 --> 00:26:13.396
crimes related to deportations. The ultimate
goal, of course, is to bring the kids

00:26:13.478 --> 00:26:20.767
home. International efforts are working.
As of this month, 2,790 Ukrainian children

00:26:20.822 --> 00:26:25.292
have been returned, including 13
children and teenagers last week.

00:26:25.373 --> 00:26:33.018
One of them, Luka, had just reached 18,
and received Russian military draft notice.

00:26:33.113 --> 00:26:38.644
But each time a child comes home with the
stories of the threats they have endured,

00:26:38.711 --> 00:26:44.266
psychological pressure, and life-threatening
living conditions, it is another

00:26:44.333 --> 00:26:48.696
reminder of why we must explore
every window of opportunity.

00:26:48.773 --> 00:26:54.641
The Oleshky ceasefire shows that Russia
can, and the suffering of Ukrainian people,

00:26:54.728 --> 00:27:00.118
if it wants to. Russia has claimed in
the past to be carrying out humanitarian

00:27:00.173 --> 00:27:07.130
evacuations, but still, Russian system
exists to systematically repatriate Ukrainian

00:27:07.283 --> 00:27:12.901
children. If Russia was serious about
protecting Ukrainian children, it would

00:27:12.953 --> 00:27:15.773
immediately start with
establishing safe regular

00:27:16.073 --> 00:27:22.958
communication between children and their
parents, relatives, and legal guardians.

00:27:23.093 --> 00:27:28.171
Honorable Members, a negotiated end to
Russia's illegal war of aggression must

00:27:28.240 --> 00:27:34.238
mitigate the security risk Russia poses to
the European continent, but it also must

00:27:34.313 --> 00:27:38.498
see the return of every
Ukrainian child to their parents.

00:27:38.573 --> 00:27:43.357
Failing to do so will leave a
black mark on humanity forever.

00:27:43.433 --> 00:27:44.633
Thank you.

00:27:46.913 --> 00:27:51.833
Thank you very much. The floor now goes
to Ms colleague Kovač from the EPP Group.

00:27:57.173 --> 00:28:03.290
Madam President, honourable Members. Behind
every war lie the tragedies of people

00:28:03.347 --> 00:28:08.907
whose lives have been destroyed. However,
there is something particularly cruel

00:28:08.979 --> 00:28:14.678
about a war being waged against children.
Madam President, honourable Members,

00:28:14.743 --> 00:28:20.005
behind every war lie the tragedies of
people whose lives have been destroyed.

00:28:20.074 --> 00:28:27.890
However, there is something particularly
cruel about a war waged against children.

00:28:27.978 --> 00:28:33.698
To understand this crime, we must look
at it not through the prism of war, but

00:28:33.763 --> 00:28:38.348
through the prism of our own
families. Your child has a name.

00:28:38.426 --> 00:28:44.285
It has a home, a school, friends
with whom it spends afternoons.

00:28:44.361 --> 00:28:51.954
It has favourite toys, its little secrets,
and dreams about who it will become when

00:28:52.011 --> 00:28:54.473
it grows up. Every day
you build its world.

00:28:54.538 --> 00:28:58.023
And it builds its identity.
And suddenly war comes.

00:28:58.095 --> 00:29:06.319
The school he attended is destroyed.
Friends flee, and home is no longer safe.

00:29:06.410 --> 00:29:10.750
Eventually, someone takes
your child away from you.

00:29:10.824 --> 00:29:17.055
They give him a new first and last name,
change his citizenship, forbid him to speak

00:29:17.128 --> 00:29:24.229
his native language. It ends up in a new
family, which raises it as if its previous

00:29:24.290 --> 00:29:26.705
life had never existed.
But you don’t know.

00:29:26.757 --> 00:29:31.165
You don’t know where it is. You
don’t know whether it is safe.

00:29:31.237 --> 00:29:38.133
Does it still remember your voice? Has
anyone told him that you are still waiting

00:29:38.205 --> 00:29:44.186
for him? This is exactly what the reality
of Ukrainian families looks like today,

00:29:44.257 --> 00:29:49.995
whose children have been deported and
forcibly displaced by Putin’s criminal

00:29:50.064 --> 00:29:55.475
actions. Ladies and Gentlemen, Europe, which
recognises human dignity and children's

00:29:55.569 --> 00:30:01.544
rights as the foundation of its values,
must remain true to them even when it comes

00:30:01.617 --> 00:30:04.613
to making the most difficult
decisions. Thank you very much.

00:30:08.153 --> 00:30:12.413
Thank you. The floor now goes
to Mr Reuten of the S&D Group.

00:30:13.853 --> 00:30:16.793
President, dear colleagues, dear High
Representative, excellent to have you with us,

00:30:16.838 --> 00:30:21.191
and thank you for your commitment. Every
day we witness Russia's heinous crimes

00:30:21.243 --> 00:30:26.388
against Ukraine's people, but tearing
children from their families indoctrinating

00:30:26.453 --> 00:30:32.920
and abusing them by the thousands strikes
anyone with empathy and human dignity.

00:30:33.053 --> 00:30:38.545
Imagine ordering such a policy
or calling it humanitarian.

00:30:38.633 --> 00:30:42.827
It is cold-blooded barbarism.
Our position must remain clear:

00:30:42.893 --> 00:30:48.916
there can no be any genuine peace without
safe return of every Ukrainian child, and

00:30:48.963 --> 00:30:53.909
accountability for those responsible. The
ICC has rightly issued arrest warrants for

00:30:53.982 --> 00:30:58.493
Putin and Lvova-Belova. We command every
effort to return the children safely to

00:30:58.533 --> 00:31:01.046
their families and help
them recover and integrate.

00:31:01.133 --> 00:31:05.215
The EU must continue supporting the
Bring Kids Back initiative, the Ukrainian

00:31:05.273 --> 00:31:10.124
Ombudsman's cooperation with Europol and
Eurojust, and Ukrainian and international

00:31:10.193 --> 00:31:15.769
civil society. Our support and sanctions,
and we will talk about them tomorrow in

00:31:15.833 --> 00:31:20.753
this House, must not stop until
every single child is home.

00:31:20.933 --> 00:31:22.133
Glory to Ukraine!

00:31:24.413 --> 00:31:31.076
Thank you. For the Patriots for faction,
our colleague Ms Ferenc now takes the

00:31:31.135 --> 00:31:32.335
floor.

00:31:36.233 --> 00:31:40.920
Heartbreaking news is arriving day after
day from the Russian-Ukrainian war.

00:31:40.979 --> 00:31:44.619
But our hearts truly ache when a
child becomes a victim of the war.

00:31:44.669 --> 00:31:51.710
Or when they lose their home, their father,
when air raid sirens and rocket attacks

00:31:51.787 --> 00:31:56.466
dictate their daily lives even in
the shelters where they hold classes.

00:31:56.542 --> 00:32:00.803
What kind of childhood has
this been now for five years?

00:32:00.865 --> 00:32:07.778
As part of the humanitarian crisis shaking
Ukraine, the forced deportation of 20,600

00:32:07.845 --> 00:32:13.729
children and attempts to erase their
Ukrainian identity have also been documented.

00:32:13.781 --> 00:32:19.296
As a Hungarian from Transcarpathia, I know
what it feels like when something natural

00:32:19.365 --> 00:32:22.947
is restricted: the use
of one’s mother tongue.

00:32:23.012 --> 00:32:27.981
Therefore, I firmly condemn Russia’s
actions in this regard, as well as any other

00:32:28.104 --> 00:32:33.751
violations of children’s rights. We must
mitigate the tragic consequences of the

00:32:33.806 --> 00:32:39.338
war. However, our most important task
remains ending the war and achieving peace.

00:32:39.436 --> 00:32:44.609
Madam High Representative, you have
recently questioned the purpose of peace

00:32:44.678 --> 00:32:49.663
negotiations. Difficult negotiations
do not justify abandoning diplomacy.

00:32:49.715 --> 00:32:54.063
Are you truly guided by the peace
and security of Ukrainian children?

00:32:54.123 --> 00:32:57.173
After all, peace would be
their most important gift.

00:33:01.193 --> 00:33:04.193
Thank you. The colleague Mr Kols will
now speak on behalf of the ECR Group.

00:33:08.753 --> 00:33:13.351
Dear colleagues, one demand comes
before everything else today:

00:33:13.433 --> 00:33:18.457
return every kidnapped Ukrainian
child, immediately and unconditionally.

00:33:18.533 --> 00:33:22.409
Over 20,000 Ukrainian children
have been deported to Russia.

00:33:22.493 --> 00:33:28.401
In September, the Council sanctioned just
10 individuals or entities, 10, and we

00:33:28.518 --> 00:33:35.405
comfort ourselves with two ICC warrants
as though naming the architects dismantled

00:33:35.460 --> 00:33:40.833
the building. It did not. Putin does
not forge birth certificates himself.

00:33:40.973 --> 00:33:46.144
Thousands of clerks camped directors and
occupation officials run this system,

00:33:46.215 --> 00:33:52.275
financed by Gazprom and Rosneft. Almost
all remain untouched by our sanctions.

00:33:52.373 --> 00:33:57.278
These children are being renamed,
re-registered, and stripped of their families.

00:33:57.353 --> 00:34:03.933
Erasure is entire point of crime. Under
Article 2, subparagraph e of the Genocide

00:34:04.013 --> 00:34:09.425
Convention, this is genocide. Every
member state has a binding duty to act.

00:34:09.593 --> 00:34:14.909
Sanction the entire chain of enablers,
prosecute every collaborator, and fund the

00:34:14.974 --> 00:34:18.560
Ukrainian teams keeping
stolen identities alive.

00:34:18.653 --> 00:34:23.550
Because right now Russia is stealing
Ukraine's children, and Europe is barely

00:34:23.633 --> 00:34:26.573
answering. This is our shame. Thank you.

00:34:28.973 --> 00:34:32.873
Thank you. The colleague Austravicius
now speaks on behalf of the Renew group.

00:34:35.993 --> 00:34:40.787
Madam Chair, High Representative, Council
Representative, Honourable colleagues.

00:34:40.853 --> 00:34:45.993
The Russian regime conceals
its crimes behind euphemisms.

00:34:46.073 --> 00:34:51.812
For example, Russia's war of aggression
is referred to as "special military

00:34:51.864 --> 00:34:57.402
operation. " The occupation of foreign
territories as the liberation of territories

00:34:57.473 --> 00:35:03.269
and the forced deportation of tens of
thousands of children as humanitarian

00:35:03.377 --> 00:35:09.178
evacuation. These are war crimes, crimes
against humanity, and an attempt to cover

00:35:09.259 --> 00:35:14.510
up genocide. Ukrainian children
have only one homeland:

00:35:14.649 --> 00:35:20.781
Ukraine. Were they belong? We must
constantly raise the issue of deported and

00:35:20.836 --> 00:35:26.596
abducted Ukrainian children
because it is our basic human duty.

00:35:26.753 --> 00:35:31.798
Any peace agreement must include provisions
for the safety of Ukrainian children and

00:35:31.859 --> 00:35:36.138
the unconditional return of
those who have been deported.

00:35:36.233 --> 00:35:42.616
Without children, Ukraine has no future
and no hope for a better tomorrow.

00:35:42.713 --> 00:35:47.369
On behalf of the Renew Europe Group, I would
like to express my sincere gratitude to

00:35:47.447 --> 00:35:51.768
the numerous Ukrainian and international
organizations and volunteers who are

00:35:51.827 --> 00:35:57.012
working tirelessly and at a great personal
risk to secure and return Ukrainian

00:35:57.084 --> 00:35:59.693
children to their homeland.
Thank you very much.

00:36:00.833 --> 00:36:05.166
Thank you. Danke schön. The Greens/EFA Group
will now be represented by my colleague

00:36:05.207 --> 00:36:06.407
Mr Sönder.

00:36:06.653 --> 00:36:09.053
Thank you, Chair. I'll speak in Danish.

00:36:09.413 --> 00:36:11.753
Russia is waging a war because of quotes.

00:36:12.713 --> 00:36:16.022
It is about drones and
bombs, but not only that.

00:36:16.092 --> 00:36:21.318
No, it is a war against Ukraine's
children and their consciousness.

00:36:21.379 --> 00:36:27.126
Since Putin's invasion, Russia has taken
more than 20,000 Ukrainian children away

00:36:27.201 --> 00:36:29.739
from their families.
Just try to imagine that.

00:36:29.787 --> 00:36:33.873
One morning when your son is not in his
bed, a day when your daughter does not come

00:36:33.927 --> 00:36:38.749
home from school, evenings when you
are left with a gnawing sense of loss.

00:36:38.796 --> 00:36:43.416
Many parents never see their children again,
and if the children do return, they may

00:36:43.485 --> 00:36:48.403
no longer be the same. The Russians are
indeed trying, through violence and force,

00:36:48.477 --> 00:36:52.353
to erase their Ukrainian
identity and memories.

00:36:52.416 --> 00:36:57.317
These are despicable war crimes that
we in Europe must press hard to stop.

00:36:57.396 --> 00:37:04.144
With sanctions against Russia and full
support for Ukraine, for their sake, but also

00:37:04.203 --> 00:37:05.993
for our own sake. Thank you.

00:37:08.453 --> 00:37:14.279
Thank you. The floor now goes to the
Left Group’s colleague, Ms Demirel.

00:37:14.397 --> 00:37:19.389
Thank you. Madam President!
Winter is just around the corner.

00:37:19.463 --> 00:37:24.522
For children, that means looking forward
to snowball fights and Christmas.

00:37:24.578 --> 00:37:29.408
For children in war zones, however,
it means one thing above all else:

00:37:29.465 --> 00:37:35.109
even more suffering. The fifth winter
of war is now looming for Ukraine.

00:37:35.211 --> 00:37:40.050
17,000 killed, 55,000 injured,
civilians for five years.

00:37:40.127 --> 00:37:45.085
Indescribable suffering. And the Ukrainian
children who have been torn from their

00:37:45.138 --> 00:37:48.799
families and abducted. The
children must return, yes.

00:37:48.877 --> 00:37:54.329
But that requires more than resolutions.
It requires political will and serious

00:37:54.380 --> 00:37:56.830
diplomatic efforts, also
from you, Ms Kallas.

00:37:56.931 --> 00:38:01.429
Colleagues, I do not know how many times I
have asked this question here, but I will

00:38:01.478 --> 00:38:05.276
not stop. Where is the EU’s
strategy to truly end this war?

00:38:05.333 --> 00:38:08.651
Why is there still no
dedicated peace initiative?

00:38:08.729 --> 00:38:14.767
No negotiator? Now negotiations are taking
place in Abu Dhabi, but without the EU.

00:38:14.821 --> 00:38:20.015
And one thing must be clear: children
are not helped by battle cries, by

00:38:20.068 --> 00:38:22.678
geopolitical interests,
nor by crocodile tears.

00:38:22.738 --> 00:38:27.363
What helps them is an end to the
war. Every child belongs in a home.

00:38:27.451 --> 00:38:32.766
Every child belongs in a warm home.
Every child should be able to celebrate

00:38:32.824 --> 00:38:37.240
Christmas in peace, and the
EU should contribute to that.

00:38:37.360 --> 00:38:44.304
Thank you. Good. The colleague Ms
Vosdorf will now speak for the ESN Group.

00:38:44.542 --> 00:38:50.409
Over 20,000 Ukrainian children have
been abducted to Russia during the war.

00:38:50.453 --> 00:38:55.544
Children who cannot defend themselves.
Children who have been made homeless.

00:38:55.612 --> 00:38:58.912
Children who may never
see their families again.

00:38:58.981 --> 00:39:04.365
This is one of the worst war crimes. Even
in the Netherlands, without any war, more

00:39:04.431 --> 00:39:08.439
than 2,000 children were
taken from their parents.

00:39:08.508 --> 00:39:14.505
This was exposed in the child benefit
scandal by a courageous politician, families

00:39:14.566 --> 00:39:20.483
were financially ruined, and parents
were subsequently branded as incapable of

00:39:20.564 --> 00:39:26.546
providing care. The Prime Minister of that
country at the time was Mark Rutte, who

00:39:26.629 --> 00:39:28.613
is now NATO Secretary General.

00:39:28.913 --> 00:39:32.659
He was never held
accountable for this scandal.

00:39:32.762 --> 00:39:38.326
Children must never be made into prey.
Neither in times of peace nor in times of

00:39:38.388 --> 00:39:43.130
war. We demand the immediate
repatriation of all these children.

00:39:43.209 --> 00:39:48.206
The children have a right to their
homeland and to their family.

00:39:48.411 --> 00:39:54.381
Thank you. This position. The round of
group spokespersons and with that, I may now

00:39:54.439 --> 00:39:58.307
hand the floor back to Ms
High Representative Kallas.

00:39:58.388 --> 00:39:59.588
Please go ahead.

00:40:05.633 --> 00:40:08.338
Thank you, Honorable
Members, for this debate.

00:40:08.393 --> 00:40:14.921
I absolutely agree that children have the
right for their home, for their parents,

00:40:14.993 --> 00:40:19.955
also for peace. To live
and grow up in peace.

00:40:20.033 --> 00:40:24.061
That's why, of course, we are
supporting all diplomatic efforts.

00:40:24.113 --> 00:40:30.788
And we have also put forward our own plan
for peace that I have proposed for the

00:40:30.893 --> 00:40:34.935
European Foreign Ministers. And we have
also discussed with the European Foreign

00:40:35.024 --> 00:40:40.251
Ministers clearly. But the problem is
that Russia is not interested in peace.

00:40:40.313 --> 00:40:45.897
Russia thinks that it can just present
maximum demands and will walk away with what

00:40:45.950 --> 00:40:51.548
they have more, what they had before. So
what I think the result of this debate

00:40:51.599 --> 00:40:57.166
could be when we are talking about Ukrainian
children, then we can call on Russia to

00:40:57.253 --> 00:41:03.332
facilitate humanitarian corridors and
practically arrangements for eventual family

00:41:03.434 --> 00:41:10.179
reunification. We can call on Russia
to allow the United Nations UNICEF, the

00:41:10.235 --> 00:41:15.378
International Committee of the Red Cross,
and other appropriate independent bodies

00:41:15.443 --> 00:41:20.491
to access relevant institutions and
locations where Ukrainian children are held.

00:41:20.573 --> 00:41:27.245
And notably, of course, we can call on
Russia to halt the attacks on schools,

00:41:27.353 --> 00:41:35.343
education facilities, kindergartens,
universities, school shelters, school buses,

00:41:35.533 --> 00:41:42.133
and everywhere where the Ukrainians'
children really are to show their good faith

00:41:42.225 --> 00:41:46.870
that they actually are looking
into and thinking about peace.

00:41:46.973 --> 00:41:50.953
Unfortunately, this is
so far not the case.

00:41:51.053 --> 00:41:52.253
Thank you.

00:41:55.553 --> 00:42:02.584
Many thanks. Since the next slot is only
scheduled for 15:45, I will now adjourn the

00:42:02.679 --> 00:42:08.775
meeting until then. We will resume at 15:45
with the Commission's statement on the

00:42:08.820 --> 00:42:12.953
Commission's 2027 work
programme. Thank you very much.

00:52:09.953 --> 00:52:17.643
So, dear colleagues, we can resume the
session three minutes earlier, because both

00:52:17.735 --> 00:52:22.381
the Commissioner and the
first speakers are present.

00:52:22.564 --> 00:52:28.725
The meeting is therefore resumed and the
next item on the agenda is a statement by

00:52:28.783 --> 00:52:34.921
the Commission on the
Commission's 2027 work programme.

00:52:35.060 --> 00:52:42.883
And once everyone is ready, I now give
the floor to the Commission, Commissioner

00:52:42.980 --> 00:52:44.180
Šefčovič.

00:52:57.833 --> 00:53:04.037
Madam President, honorable members, it
is a pleasure to present to you the 2027

00:53:04.160 --> 00:53:10.760
Commission Work Programme. And let me
start by thanking you for the fruitful

00:53:10.837 --> 00:53:17.537
cooperation during its preparation. We had
many constructive exchanges including the

00:53:17.585 --> 00:53:22.433
discussion with the Conference of Committee
Chairs attended by the Executive Vice

00:53:22.503 --> 00:53:27.526
President, Commissioners
Dobrowski, Seraphine, and myself.

00:53:27.713 --> 00:53:34.687
And as the President von der Leyen said in
her State of the Union speech, in Europe

00:53:34.848 --> 00:53:41.964
we stand up for one another. Be it by our
steadfast support for Ukraine in the face

00:53:42.038 --> 00:53:47.447
of Russian aggression, by finding common
responses to drone incursions and hybrid

00:53:47.521 --> 00:53:52.853
attacks in our Member States, or by joining
forces to fight the growing impacts of

00:53:52.913 --> 00:53:58.368
climate change such as
unprecedented wildfires.

00:53:58.493 --> 00:54:05.947
We are dealing with high energy prices
and significant cost of living pressures.

00:54:06.053 --> 00:54:12.437
While facing attacks on democracy and
accelerating technological disruption through

00:54:12.505 --> 00:54:19.213
artificial intelligence. This work program
is strategic, targeted, and streamlined,

00:54:19.313 --> 00:54:24.244
doubling down on our political
priorities and main workstreams.

00:54:24.353 --> 00:54:29.941
It has a focus on delivery and meeting
our commitment for stronger Europe.

00:54:30.113 --> 00:54:35.917
Together we need to further strengthen
our competitiveness, boost our energy

00:54:35.995 --> 00:54:39.748
security, and continue
simplifying our rules.

00:54:39.833 --> 00:54:45.321
We need to deliver on enhancing
defense and strengthen our security.

00:54:45.413 --> 00:54:51.413
Quality of life, in the EU must
remain high, including in rural areas.

00:54:51.533 --> 00:54:56.019
We will strengthen our preparedness for
the effects of climate change and continue

00:54:56.093 --> 00:55:02.289
defending our democracies and values.
With these priorities in mind, we are

00:55:02.354 --> 00:55:06.007
proposing a limited
number of key initiatives.

00:55:06.113 --> 00:55:13.523
In addition, implementation and force
man and rapid delivery of major proposals

00:55:13.613 --> 00:55:17.996
already on the table are
crucial for the year ahead.

00:55:18.113 --> 00:55:24.709
To address energy security and prices as
well as decarbonization, we will shape the

00:55:24.807 --> 00:55:31.520
post-2030 energy framework. It will be made
simpler and more effective while keeping

00:55:31.592 --> 00:55:37.866
Europe firmly on track to meet its
2040 decarbonization objectives.

00:55:37.973 --> 00:55:44.693
Our competitiveness relies on a thriving
single market, delivering on the One Europe

00:55:45.413 --> 00:55:50.755
One Market roadmap by the end
of next year, remains a key.

00:55:50.873 --> 00:55:56.273
Therefore, we will propose targeted
additional initiatives like a measure on

00:55:56.333 --> 00:56:01.932
preventing single market barriers. We
will also tackle unjustified territorial

00:56:01.994 --> 00:56:06.904
supply constraints to avoid suppliers
fragmenting the single market, limiting

00:56:06.983 --> 00:56:11.966
consumer choice, and causing
significant price differences.

00:56:12.053 --> 00:56:17.946
For projects in the EU strategic interest
to attract additional investment, we will

00:56:18.008 --> 00:56:22.553
propose further measures
to accelerate permitting.

00:56:22.673 --> 00:56:28.887
Our companies must be put in a position to
thrive in an economy that is reshaped by

00:56:28.952 --> 00:56:35.385
the digital and AI transformation.
Honorable members, when we talk about

00:56:35.453 --> 00:56:41.379
competitiveness, we are talking
about jobs, people, and livelihoods.

00:56:41.513 --> 00:56:47.566
As next year marks the 10th anniversary of
the European Pillar of Social Rights, we

00:56:47.633 --> 00:56:53.330
will come forward with important
initiatives under our social priority.

00:56:53.453 --> 00:56:59.533
To help deliver on high-quality cross-border
education across the EU and boost

00:56:59.636 --> 00:57:04.973
skills and innovation, we will propose
the European Universities Alliances 2.

00:57:05.093 --> 00:57:11.116
0. Care needs of aging
populations are increasing.

00:57:11.213 --> 00:57:17.329
We need to promote affordable, quality
care reduced staff shortages and improve

00:57:17.404 --> 00:57:23.529
careers for care workers. This
will be the focus of the Care Deal.

00:57:23.693 --> 00:57:30.198
Our strategy on the right to stay. We'll
identify measures needed for regions and

00:57:30.276 --> 00:57:35.873
people to thrive and succeed to counter
the challenges caused by economic decline

00:57:35.933 --> 00:57:42.270
and population loss. The devastating
impact of this summer's wildfires is still

00:57:42.368 --> 00:57:48.607
being felt. Successive heat waves have led
to staggering impacts, including losses

00:57:48.689 --> 00:57:54.517
of agricultural production. Against this
background, our European Water Initiative

00:57:54.591 --> 00:58:00.624
will help to better manage vital water
resources for citizens, our food security,

00:58:00.713 --> 00:58:06.731
and our industries. Beyond adapting
to climate change, we need to continue

00:58:06.809 --> 00:58:11.847
protecting our environment. The review of
the Nature Protection Directive will allow

00:58:11.899 --> 00:58:17.174
us to assess where the changes are needed
to the legal framework, parts of which

00:58:17.252 --> 00:58:23.836
date from the early 90s. The foundation to
addressing today's challenges at European

00:58:23.899 --> 00:58:26.873
level is a thriving and
resilient democracy.

00:58:27.713 --> 00:58:32.056
Malign actors are putting our
democratic system under pressure.

00:58:32.153 --> 00:58:38.839
Disinformation and information manipulation
are spreading fast, fueled by AI.

00:58:38.993 --> 00:58:44.446
This is why we will step up our work
on the European Democracy Shield.

00:58:44.573 --> 00:58:47.212
We will also address
the increased threats:

00:58:47.273 --> 00:58:52.685
attacks and violence against political
candidates and elected representatives with

00:58:52.778 --> 00:58:58.889
the safety in politics initiative. It is
of the utmost importance that we focus the

00:58:58.957 --> 00:59:03.919
legislative work on our
absolute key priorities.

00:59:04.013 --> 00:59:08.745
That is why we are proposing a targeted
annex with priority pending proposals

00:59:08.813 --> 00:59:15.007
building on One Europe One Market
and the 2026 Joint Declaration.

00:59:15.113 --> 00:59:20.744
In addition, it will be key to progress
swiftly on the multi-annual financial

00:59:20.810 --> 00:59:27.115
framework. We need to ensure seamless
continuity of funding at the start of 2028.

00:59:27.233 --> 00:59:33.688
We have closely examined all proposals
on the table and listed the proposals we

00:59:33.773 --> 00:59:39.233
intend to withdraw. The Commission will
carefully listen to the views of the

00:59:39.312 --> 00:59:42.876
co-legislators before
taking a final decision.

00:59:42.953 --> 00:59:48.299
Lastly, in the context of our continuous
efforts on regulatory deep cleaning, we

00:59:48.392 --> 00:59:55.175
also propose repealing 14 legal acts.
Honorable members, I will stop here and I look

00:59:55.234 --> 00:59:57.353
forward to the debate.
Thank you, Madam President.

00:59:58.493 --> 01:00:04.193
Thank you very much, Commissioner. I now
call on Mr Lehners for the EPP Group.

01:00:12.473 --> 01:00:17.302
Yes, thank you, Madam President. Dear
Commissioner, on behalf of the EPP group, I

01:00:17.350 --> 01:00:20.473
welcome the Commission's
work program for 2027.

01:00:20.573 --> 01:00:24.383
And this program is a very
important one in terms of timing.

01:00:24.473 --> 01:00:30.165
Many of the proposals presented in 2027
will shape our legislative agenda right

01:00:30.235 --> 01:00:37.018
until the elections in 2029. We have a
responsibility to deliver, and this is a good

01:00:37.085 --> 01:00:42.646
start. Because the Commission sends the
right message, good European policy is not

01:00:42.737 --> 01:00:48.322
simply about producing more legislation.
It is also about implementing the rules we

01:00:48.396 --> 01:00:54.216
already have, simplifying or withdrawing
them where necessary, and making sure they

01:00:54.281 --> 01:01:00.035
actually work in practice. People at
home don't care how many directives or

01:01:00.116 --> 01:01:06.394
regulations we adopt. They care whether
what we do here has an impact on their daily

01:01:06.473 --> 01:01:11.786
lives, whether they will feel that
things are changing in a good way.

01:01:11.873 --> 01:01:15.488
And in that context, I would like to
highlight four important initiatives.

01:01:15.533 --> 01:01:19.248
First, the review of the Birth
and Habitat Directive Natura 2000.

01:01:19.313 --> 01:01:24.061
We must protect nature, of course, but
at the same time, we must ensure that our

01:01:24.124 --> 01:01:28.083
legislation is workable, proportionate,
and provides legal certainty.

01:01:28.133 --> 01:01:33.191
And we must bring it up to date
with the challenges of today.

01:01:33.293 --> 01:01:37.508
Second, on permitting. Across Europe,
essential investments in housing,

01:01:37.569 --> 01:01:41.624
infrastructure, energy, and
industry face lengthy procedures.

01:01:41.693 --> 01:01:46.545
Removing unnecessary delays
must be our priority.

01:01:46.673 --> 01:01:49.380
Third, on the housing
simplification package.

01:01:49.433 --> 01:01:55.491
Affordable housing is a major concern for
many of us citizens, including most of our

01:01:55.567 --> 01:02:01.119
young people. And Europe should help remove
obstacles to building new homes rather

01:02:01.193 --> 01:02:06.574
than adding bureaucracy. And
fourth, energy simplification.

01:02:06.653 --> 01:02:11.933
Affordable and reliable energy is essential,
not only for households but also for

01:02:11.993 --> 01:02:18.136
industry and Europe's competitiveness. Our
rules must support investment and energy

01:02:18.270 --> 01:02:23.749
security. Dear colleagues, the real test
of this work program will not be how many

01:02:23.813 --> 01:02:27.404
legislative files we manage
to close before 2029.

01:02:27.533 --> 01:02:32.517
The real test will be whether Europeans
will see a difference, whether families can

01:02:32.552 --> 01:02:33.353
find

01:02:33.353 --> 01:02:38.831
affordable homes, businesses can invest in
energy remains, affordable, and that our

01:02:38.897 --> 01:02:43.750
rules work in practice. And this is how we
will measure the success of this program.

01:02:43.793 --> 01:02:44.993
Thank you.

01:02:46.493 --> 01:02:51.593
Thank you. For the S&D Group, Cathia
Perth, the Chair, will now speak.

01:02:55.733 --> 01:03:03.837
Thank you, Madam President. There is one
question that must open today’s debate, and

01:03:03.930 --> 01:03:09.521
it is this: for whom does
the European Commission work?

01:03:09.669 --> 01:03:18.762
While programmes are being presented here,
out there European citizens are demanding

01:03:18.859 --> 01:03:23.323
the ability to pay for a
home; to make ends meet;

01:03:23.377 --> 01:03:29.547
to live without fear and to have rights.
And yet, this work programme seems to have

01:03:29.628 --> 01:03:36.797
been written from another reality. Trapped
in the bubble of simplification and

01:03:36.908 --> 01:03:44.290
deregulation. Lots of talk about competitiveness, and very few answers for those who

01:03:44.379 --> 01:03:51.044
can no longer wait. Have we really not
understood the message in the streets?

01:03:51.144 --> 01:03:57.389
That of thousands and thousands of young
people, of older people, of students, of

01:03:57.479 --> 01:04:04.973
trade unionists, of teachers who take to
the streets to live, to demand to live with

01:04:05.068 --> 01:04:12.596
dignity? By the way, I would like to send
from here a message of absolute respect

01:04:12.718 --> 01:04:19.229
for the trade union work, for the work
that trade unions have done in the

01:04:19.306 --> 01:04:22.987
construction of Europe.
Think about housing.

01:04:23.077 --> 01:04:27.833
Housing. A house must be a home,
not a business for speculators.

01:04:27.908 --> 01:04:34.938
We need to curb speculative purchases,
penalise empty properties in high-pressure

01:04:35.030 --> 01:04:42.405
areas, and control abusive rents. And we
must ban evictions of vulnerable people;

01:04:42.505 --> 01:04:47.942
no child, no elderly person
should end up on the street.

01:04:48.048 --> 01:04:54.519
Think about the bills. How can the Commission
ignore the connection between Trump’s

01:04:54.621 --> 01:04:58.896
and Netanyahu’s wars and
the rise in energy prices?

01:04:58.965 --> 01:05:05.378
Let’s adopt a European social bond funded
by a tax on the excess profits of the big

01:05:05.467 --> 01:05:11.967
energy companies to ease the burden of
electricity and heating bills for citizens.

01:05:12.038 --> 01:05:18.574
Those who profit from wars must contribute
to protecting those who pay the price.

01:05:18.636 --> 01:05:24.927
In the face of climate denialism, it is
time to adopt binding adaptation plans with

01:05:25.025 --> 01:05:32.219
targets. and real funding, and a European
climate insurance alliance to protect

01:05:32.291 --> 01:05:37.378
citizens from the increasingly
deadly risks of climate change.

01:05:37.504 --> 01:05:42.035
And the Union’s next budget must rise to
the challenge of the times we are living

01:05:42.084 --> 01:05:42.833
through.

01:05:42.833 --> 01:05:48.201
We need own resources and fair taxation.
Women's rights and fundamental freedoms

01:05:48.253 --> 01:05:53.506
also require laws, not declarations. The
European law on 'only yes means yes' for

01:05:53.585 --> 01:05:57.994
rape offences is urgent, as is
the ban on conversion therapies.

01:05:58.068 --> 01:06:01.627
More than a million citizens
have called for action.

01:06:01.701 --> 01:06:07.749
What is the Commission waiting for? Citizens
are not taking to the streets to ask us

01:06:07.815 --> 01:06:12.909
for more recommendations. They are
taking to the streets to demand change.

01:06:12.986 --> 01:06:17.102
The European project will
only survive with commitments.

01:06:17.171 --> 01:06:20.840
The question I asked at the
beginning remains unanswered:

01:06:20.889 --> 01:06:23.306
who does the European Commission work for?

01:06:23.364 --> 01:06:27.536
The answer is clear: it works for
those who live and work in Europe.

01:06:27.617 --> 01:06:32.521
And that requires less
deregulation and more justice.

01:06:32.613 --> 01:06:34.673
People first. Thank you very much.

01:06:37.253 --> 01:06:40.913
Thank you. The colleague Wilimski will
now speak on behalf of the ECR Group.

01:06:41.933 --> 01:06:45.578
Thank you, Mr President. You can’t believe
your eyes, and you can’t believe your

01:06:45.630 --> 01:06:49.928
ears. At one of the most difficult hours
for the continent, the Commission is

01:06:49.992 --> 01:06:54.500
presenting its programme for next year. And
the President of the Commission does not

01:06:54.552 --> 01:06:59.096
even deem it fair to appear here and now.
And no matter for what reason she is not

01:06:59.151 --> 01:07:02.868
here, then the debate must be postponed.
And she must face this House in a

01:07:02.917 --> 01:07:06.101
democratic and parliamentary
manner, first and foremost.

01:07:06.186 --> 01:07:10.929
Secondly: If, in this government agreement
and the Commission's programme of

01:07:11.003 --> 01:07:16.930
activities, you seriously include the idea
that Europeans must adapt to the changing

01:07:17.021 --> 01:07:22.641
population proportions in Europe, then
this is the next monumental folly for which

01:07:22.697 --> 01:07:28.871
you are responsible. Since 2015, you have
allowed millions of people from Arabia and

01:07:28.930 --> 01:07:33.935
Africa to enter this continent. Eighty
per cent have no legal residence status

01:07:34.000 --> 01:07:37.435
whatsoever. And now we are
supposed to adapt to them.

01:07:37.506 --> 01:07:43.032
I maintain that even those who have come
to us legally must adapt to us, not the

01:07:43.096 --> 01:07:46.365
other way around—we do
not have to adapt to them.

01:07:46.430 --> 01:07:50.811
Point number one. Point number two: the
Green Deal, which you now want to push

01:07:50.865 --> 01:07:53.321
forward further. No,
that is the wrong path.

01:07:53.378 --> 01:07:58.368
Don’t you see that the entire European
automotive industry is going down the drain,

01:07:58.428 --> 01:08:01.452
meaning people have ever
less money at their disposal?

01:08:01.518 --> 01:08:05.121
Families can no longer make ends
meet and afford a decent life?

01:08:05.182 --> 01:08:08.721
That is the wrong path. You insist
on it. I come to my conclusion.

01:08:08.780 --> 01:08:14.030
I didn’t think the Chocolate Juncker
Commission could get any worse.

01:08:14.086 --> 01:08:17.561
The one that will go down in
history as the Ischgl Commission.

01:08:17.622 --> 01:08:21.010
You will go down in history
as the Titanic Commission.

01:08:21.065 --> 01:08:22.913
Shame on you and shame on this policy.

01:08:23.273 --> 01:08:30.953
Thank you. The ECR Group will now be
represented by its Chair, Ms Caccini.

01:08:34.553 --> 01:08:39.092
Thank you, Mr President.
Commissioners, colleagues.

01:08:39.148 --> 01:08:45.324
I must admit that when I read the Commission's
2027 work programme, I felt a certain

01:08:45.438 --> 01:08:52.072
sense of satisfaction: competitiveness,
energy independence, security,

01:08:52.166 --> 01:08:56.675
simplification, and the
defence of our industries.

01:08:56.729 --> 01:09:04.107
These are exactly the words that we
conservatives have been repeating for years.

01:09:04.186 --> 01:09:10.878
When... We were saying this, though,
we were accused of being anti-European,

01:09:10.956 --> 01:09:13.848
sovereignists or enemies
of the environment.

01:09:13.905 --> 01:09:19.440
Today those same words have become the
priorities of the European Commission.

01:09:19.516 --> 01:09:22.982
Welcome to reality, I might
say, better late than never.

01:09:23.035 --> 01:09:26.850
But there is a problem,
because changing words is easy.

01:09:26.922 --> 01:09:31.983
Changing policies is much more difficult.
You cannot invoke competitiveness or

01:09:32.058 --> 01:09:37.747
promise affordable energy and at the same
time defend the ETS system by extending it

01:09:37.843 --> 01:09:43.963
even to private transport and housing.
You cannot announce a revolution in

01:09:44.028 --> 01:09:49.198
simplification and then continue to churn
out regulations, directives, obligations

01:09:49.274 --> 01:09:58.414
and bans. Vice-President Šefčovič, it is
not enough to stop accelerating towards the

01:09:58.540 --> 01:10:04.999
precipice. We must also change direction.
And yet I also want to recognise some

01:10:05.057 --> 01:10:10.100
encouraging signals: the revision of
certain environmental directives, a greater

01:10:10.157 --> 01:10:15.131
attention to technological neutrality,
the strengthening of external borders, the

01:10:15.198 --> 01:10:20.167
effectiveness of repatriations, and also
the recognition of the right to remain in

01:10:20.221 --> 01:10:23.898
one’s own territories, defending
local communities from depopulation.

01:10:23.951 --> 01:10:28.619
These are all battles that we conservatives
have been waging for a long time.

01:10:28.685 --> 01:10:33.280
And if today the Commission begins to
recognise some of our arguments, we cannot but

01:10:33.408 --> 01:10:38.268
be pleased. But we will be very
demanding in judging the results.

01:10:38.330 --> 01:10:43.211
Because Europe does not need a
Green Deal with a different name.

01:10:43.293 --> 01:10:48.333
It needs a different policy. It does not
need new European taxes, but lower costs

01:10:48.380 --> 01:10:52.753
for families and businesses. It does not
need more centralism, but more freedom.

01:10:52.841 --> 01:10:58.674
We want a strong Europe, but the strength
of Europe is not measured by the number

01:10:58.752 --> 01:11:01.433
and power of its regulations.

01:11:01.553 --> 01:11:08.188
It is measured by the prosperity of its
citizens, the security of its borders and

01:11:08.279 --> 01:11:10.313
the freedom of its nations.

01:11:15.473 --> 01:11:18.473
The next speaker is Mr
Kellerer from the Renew Group.

01:11:20.213 --> 01:11:23.605
Renew Europe has been actively engaged
with the Commission in developing the work

01:11:23.667 --> 01:11:27.758
program for 2027, and we're pleased to
see many of our priorities included in the

01:11:27.826 --> 01:11:32.304
program. And I know that my colleagues
will expand on that later in the debate.

01:11:32.393 --> 01:11:37.661
You won't have to worry about Renew Europe
being a trusted partner in implementing

01:11:37.712 --> 01:11:41.862
the work program. While we may not agree
in every detail, we have our own distinct

01:11:41.909 --> 01:11:46.461
priorities. We do generally believe that
the direction of travel is positive, and we

01:11:46.518 --> 01:11:50.563
support this. Vice President, the
fundamental question that must be asked and

01:11:50.620 --> 01:11:54.207
answered over the next two and a half
years of this electoral mandate is:

01:11:54.250 --> 01:11:57.273
who can be relied on to
implement the work program?

01:11:57.353 --> 01:12:01.564
Who will resist the urge to do dirty
side deals with those that may want to

01:12:01.613 --> 01:12:06.621
undermine the Commission's priorities? The
work program must deliver for citizens,

01:12:06.685 --> 01:12:10.959
for businesses, for people, and implementing
Draghi is a critically important

01:12:11.010 --> 01:12:15.416
component of that. Affordable housing,
cheaper energy, and deepening the single

01:12:15.471 --> 01:12:18.717
market, and implementing the
savings and investment union.

01:12:18.773 --> 01:12:23.905
And protecting our environment. The
pro-European political groups in this House have

01:12:23.984 --> 01:12:28.556
a duty and an obligation to work together
to make sure the next two and a half years

01:12:28.600 --> 01:12:29.993
is positive for our citizens.

01:12:33.053 --> 01:12:37.073
Thank you. The Greens/EFA Group is now
represented by its Chair, Thierry Reinke.

01:12:38.633 --> 01:12:41.650
Colleagues, let me be clear. I have
voted for the Commission President.

01:12:41.693 --> 01:12:46.367
I have voted for the Commission, and I have
defended this Commission, even for a lot

01:12:46.413 --> 01:12:49.073
of very controversial
decisions that have been taken.

01:12:49.133 --> 01:12:54.215
But even my patience has an end. And I
must say the fact that the Commission is

01:12:54.278 --> 01:12:59.775
considering to opening up in this Commission
work program absolutely critical nature

01:12:59.838 --> 01:13:03.743
protection legislation
to me is a step too far.

01:13:03.833 --> 01:13:08.617
Because this is a field where the
European Union, over the past decades, has

01:13:08.711 --> 01:13:15.041
championed making the lives of hundreds
of millions of European citizens better.

01:13:15.113 --> 01:13:19.131
This is not a nice-to-have. This
is not about fancy green parks.

01:13:19.193 --> 01:13:22.779
This is about the health and
well-being of our citizens.

01:13:22.853 --> 01:13:29.393
And especially facing a climate emergency
where nature is our most important ally in

01:13:29.453 --> 01:13:34.137
mitigating the effects of climate change.
And if you need examples, I invite you to

01:13:34.200 --> 01:13:38.088
come to my home region. I grew
up close to the Amschel River.

01:13:38.153 --> 01:13:42.771
The Amschel used to be one of the dirtiest,
the smelliest, and the most polluted

01:13:42.833 --> 01:13:48.598
rivers in the whole of Europe. And only
because of EU regulation, this river and its

01:13:48.662 --> 01:13:52.621
riverbed were renovated.
It was re-naturalized.

01:13:52.733 --> 01:13:55.781
And now it is the joy to go to this river.

01:13:55.853 --> 01:14:01.096
And for 2.2 million citizens, this has
directly influenced their well-being and

01:14:01.154 --> 01:14:07.202
health. So to me, putting this and so
many other examples at stake is a step too

01:14:07.291 --> 01:14:11.503
far. So as Greens, we will do
everything in order to stop this.

01:14:11.573 --> 01:14:16.186
Do not endanger the health, the well-being,
and the nature that our citizens so

01:14:16.242 --> 01:14:17.442
urgently need.

01:14:20.453 --> 01:14:25.673
Thank you. Next, speaking for the
Left Group is its Chair, Aubry.

01:14:32.873 --> 01:14:36.706
Dear colleagues, the social
emergency is worsening.

01:14:36.776 --> 01:14:42.016
In France, Belgium, Italy, Portugal and
Spain, historic mobilisations against the

01:14:42.077 --> 01:14:45.236
high cost of living are
taking place every week.

01:14:45.287 --> 01:14:49.668
Prices are soaring, wages are stagnating,
and many can no longer afford to feed

01:14:49.724 --> 01:14:55.113
themselves or to live decently. And in
the face of this emergency, what is the

01:14:55.166 --> 01:14:59.524
European Commission proposing? A work
programme completely out of touch with

01:14:59.575 --> 01:15:04.863
reality. Mr Vice-President, if we wanted
to draw up a bingo of the worst possible

01:15:04.911 --> 01:15:09.004
measures in this context, I am sure your
Commission would have won hands down.

01:15:09.066 --> 01:15:12.878
To address the social emergency,
nothing. On the other hand, new omnibus

01:15:12.924 --> 01:15:17.314
deregulation texts, a series of gifts to
the largest companies and lobbyists, even

01:15:17.361 --> 01:15:21.583
if it means sacrificing all the social and
environmental progress of recent years.

01:15:21.633 --> 01:15:25.986
On taxation, while the richest have never
been richer, the few texts that hinted at

01:15:26.030 --> 01:15:30.511
a fairer tax model have simply
disappeared from the programme.

01:15:30.576 --> 01:15:34.711
On the housing crisis, the only text you
have is going to target environmental

01:15:34.786 --> 01:15:40.393
standards, as if the problem came from
there rather than from property speculation

01:15:40.474 --> 01:15:46.321
and soaring rents. Perhaps we might have
expected some progress on climate after a

01:15:46.373 --> 01:15:50.783
scorching summer. No, here too, a revision
of the nature protection law to water it

01:15:50.838 --> 01:15:54.938
down even further. On trade, at a time of
reindustrialisation, Mr Vice-President, I

01:15:54.980 --> 01:15:57.354
must say that this is
your area of expertise:

01:15:57.411 --> 01:16:01.619
free trade agreements one after another
that will cripple our producers.

01:16:01.682 --> 01:16:06.864
On fundamental rights, the rights of
LGBTI people, or even the inclusion of the

01:16:06.919 --> 01:16:10.192
concept of consent in the definition
of rape, not a single word.

01:16:10.235 --> 01:16:14.086
As if fundamental rights were not being
systematically attacked by the far right in

01:16:14.139 --> 01:16:16.730
this Chamber and daily
within the European Union.

01:16:16.774 --> 01:16:20.831
As for the thousands of people who drown
each year at Europe’s borders, you respond

01:16:20.888 --> 01:16:21.833
by strengthening

01:16:21.833 --> 01:16:26.552
Frontex, which is nonetheless responsible
for illegal pushbacks and human rights

01:16:26.688 --> 01:16:32.830
violations. I am not even mentioning
Palestine, a word you do not even utter, even

01:16:32.896 --> 01:16:36.784
though the European Union continues to
be complicit through its association

01:16:36.845 --> 01:16:42.175
agreement and even though more than a
million people are still calling on you to

01:16:42.217 --> 01:16:45.180
act, having signed a European
citizens' initiative on the matter.

01:16:45.306 --> 01:16:50.083
So, there you have it. The right and
the far right are sharing the victory.

01:16:50.126 --> 01:16:53.562
Our Left group, however, sees only the
reflection of an institution that prioritises

01:16:53.602 --> 01:16:57.688
the interests of a handful of privileged
individuals over the general interest.

01:16:57.727 --> 01:17:01.054
Unlike our colleagues, however, we are not
fooled, and you will find us in your path

01:17:01.091 --> 01:17:02.873
as we continue to defend
the interests of the many.

01:17:06.053 --> 01:17:09.593
Thank you. And now, for the ESN
Group, the Chair, Mr Aust, will speak.

01:17:14.153 --> 01:17:20.147
Europe needs an alternative, because this
Commission work programme will not be able

01:17:20.211 --> 01:17:25.189
to solve Europe’s problems – not in the
area of migration, not in the area of the

01:17:25.230 --> 01:17:29.861
economy, not in the area of energy. We
have seen all of this in the past few years

01:17:29.908 --> 01:17:32.873
already. What is needed
in the area of migration?

01:17:32.938 --> 01:17:35.766
Everything that has been
done is insufficient.

01:17:35.828 --> 01:17:39.429
We see it in the riots in Paris
or in Milan or in Brussels.

01:17:39.489 --> 01:17:43.466
And we see the current situation
today in the Canary Islands.

01:17:43.533 --> 01:17:49.462
There continues to be a major surge of
illegal mass immigration into all of Europe.

01:17:49.519 --> 01:17:54.181
That is why our solutions are clear: for
example, we need to legalise pushbacks;

01:17:54.236 --> 01:18:00.622
the external borders of the European Union
must finally be effectively and truly

01:18:00.707 --> 01:18:05.912
protected. In addition, those who have
already entered our continent illegally and

01:18:05.968 --> 01:18:10.879
are living here must be returned. That
is why we need remigration across all of

01:18:10.953 --> 01:18:14.968
Europe. Second: an end
to climate ideology.

01:18:15.070 --> 01:18:20.806
An end to the Green Deal. What
is needed is affordable energy.

01:18:20.884 --> 01:18:24.922
Especially when we look to the
future – artificial intelligence.

01:18:24.982 --> 01:18:29.506
Europe is once again in danger of
falling into new dependencies here.

01:18:29.560 --> 01:18:33.846
Look at the rest of the world, look at
the United States, where the future is

01:18:33.912 --> 01:18:39.800
currently being invented, look at China,
where the future is being built, while here

01:18:39.899 --> 01:18:44.109
in Europe we are merely
administering the past.

01:18:44.178 --> 01:18:47.253
Third: what is needed
is affordable housing.

01:18:47.331 --> 01:18:52.496
And here the two issues come together.
First, we must ensure, through affordable

01:18:52.582 --> 01:18:58.403
energy and less bureaucracy, that construction
becomes cheaper so that sufficient

01:18:58.495 --> 01:19:02.936
housing is available for our families.
Second, we must ensure that, through

01:19:02.995 --> 01:19:08.306
remigration, fewer apartments are in
demand so that rents can fall as a result.

01:19:08.375 --> 01:19:13.137
In other words: everything we need is
an alternative programme to what the

01:19:13.206 --> 01:19:17.688
Commission is presenting to us. What
is needed is an alternative for Europe.

01:19:17.746 --> 01:19:20.718
And you can find that in
all European countries.

01:19:20.776 --> 01:19:23.453
That is why you should vote
for the patriotic parties.

01:19:23.633 --> 01:19:24.833
Many thanks indeed.

01:19:27.053 --> 01:19:29.633
This concludes the round
of group chairpersons.

01:19:30.233 --> 01:19:32.171
I will become more
stricter with the time now.

01:19:32.213 --> 01:19:33.173
As you know,

01:19:33.173 --> 01:19:35.633
and now the floor goes to
my colleague Ms Montserrat.

01:19:39.653 --> 01:19:42.190
Well, thank you very
much, Madam President.

01:19:42.265 --> 01:19:46.614
Commissioner, we welcome the fact
that reindustrialisation, autonomy and

01:19:46.677 --> 01:19:50.713
competitiveness are at the heart of the
Commission's work programme to create

01:19:50.779 --> 01:19:54.764
quality jobs. But if we want a competitive
Europe, we need to complete the single

01:19:54.818 --> 01:19:59.314
market once and for all, and now. And if
we want a Europe where young people can

01:19:59.362 --> 01:20:02.182
build their future, we must
guarantee them housing.

01:20:02.236 --> 01:20:07.689
And that means building more, freeing up
land, removing obstacles, and putting an

01:20:07.739 --> 01:20:10.290
end to interventionism
and communist measures.

01:20:10.385 --> 01:20:16.504
Private property is sacred; it is the savings
of a family’s entire life, the effort,

01:20:16.568 --> 01:20:21.220
the sweat of a lifetime. Private property
belongs to citizens, not the State.

01:20:21.275 --> 01:20:25.735
And no populist government, such as
Sánchez’s, will expropriate it from us.

01:20:25.820 --> 01:20:31.011
Lastly, if we want a secure Europe, we
need greater firmness and governments that

01:20:31.066 --> 01:20:34.651
comply with the Return Directive.
If one fails, we all fall.

01:20:34.730 --> 01:20:39.834
Yesterday it was Ceuta, and today it is
once again the Canary Islands, with over

01:20:39.889 --> 01:20:44.137
7,000 irregular migrants in a week
and innocent deaths in the Atlantic.

01:20:44.199 --> 01:20:49.928
Unacceptable, Mr Sánchez, that you continue
to fail to implement the migration pact.

01:20:49.985 --> 01:20:55.163
But, Mr Commissioner, allow me to
highlight a matter of vital importance.

01:20:55.221 --> 01:21:00.907
We demand rigorous control by the Commission
over every euro of the Next Generation

01:21:00.977 --> 01:21:03.978
funds for infrastructure.
Corruption kills.

01:21:04.044 --> 01:21:09.293
We have seen it in Adamuz and Urda; we
do not want any more railway tragedies.

01:21:09.359 --> 01:21:13.703
We want to know how our European
money has been spent, Mr Sánchez.

01:21:13.761 --> 01:21:17.398
We demand respect for the victims
and safety for our citizens.

01:21:17.461 --> 01:21:20.415
And lastly, we want to
remain a fishing power.

01:21:20.477 --> 01:21:25.375
And the reforms of the Common Fisheries
Policy cannot be left out of this programme.

01:21:25.437 --> 01:21:26.637
Thank you very much.

01:21:27.053 --> 01:21:30.173
Dear colleague, may I have a blue card?

01:21:30.293 --> 01:21:34.553
No. Next, we have as the next
speaker the colleague Lauretti.

01:21:39.533 --> 01:21:41.393
Let's put people first.

01:21:41.573 --> 01:21:45.599
This is what we do not find in
the Commission's work programme.

01:21:45.663 --> 01:21:50.261
Thousands of people are taking to the
streets in European cities amid rising

01:21:50.322 --> 01:21:55.400
inflation, the cost of living reaching
unsustainable levels, and millions of

01:21:55.483 --> 01:21:58.347
Europeans struggling to
access decent housing.

01:21:58.405 --> 01:22:02.494
And economic inequalities
continue to grow, not shrink.

01:22:02.561 --> 01:22:09.471
Thirty-eight per cent of Europeans are
cutting back on food and healthcare spending,

01:22:09.554 --> 01:22:17.860
while 60 % are reducing their purchasing
power because of high energy costs.

01:22:17.969 --> 01:22:24.796
We must respond to these figures, but
above all to these citizens, men and women.

01:22:24.851 --> 01:22:30.193
Competitiveness is fine, but not if it
comes at the expense of a large part of the

01:22:30.254 --> 01:22:36.003
population. And simplification is fine,
but only if it safeguards environmental and

01:22:36.082 --> 01:22:42.853
social ambitions; not if it continues to
concentrate power in the hands of a few at

01:22:42.929 --> 01:22:45.473
the expense of the well-being of many.

01:22:48.053 --> 01:22:51.713
Dear colleague, do you accept the
blue card by colleague Mulacic?

01:22:52.253 --> 01:22:52.793
No.

01:22:52.793 --> 01:22:56.513
Right. I now give the floor
to my colleague Ms Štálová.

01:23:03.233 --> 01:23:03.773
Micro, please.

01:23:03.773 --> 01:23:09.021
An ambitious work programme for 2027. And
I would like to ask the Commissioner just

01:23:09.068 --> 01:23:13.501
one point from that work programme in a
very straightforward question about housing.

01:23:13.555 --> 01:23:18.794
When will we finally start to remove the
problems that European legislation itself

01:23:18.851 --> 01:23:23.551
has helped to create, thereby
classifying housing as unaffordable?

01:23:23.624 --> 01:23:27.946
Europeans do not need more
strategies on affordable housing.

01:23:28.003 --> 01:23:30.814
Europeans need real
housing. They need a home.

01:23:30.866 --> 01:23:33.685
And that will not be
created in Brussels offices;

01:23:33.741 --> 01:23:38.102
it is created on construction sites.
Yet while the Commission promises

01:23:38.160 --> 01:23:43.107
simplification, it is coming up with a
left-leaning 'Affordable Housing Act',

01:23:43.182 --> 01:23:48.308
instead of removing obstacles it is opening
up regulations on short-term rentals and

01:23:48.369 --> 01:23:53.484
interfering with property rights. We cannot
turn owners into culprits of the housing

01:23:53.537 --> 01:23:56.916
crisis, and we cannot turn further
regulation into a solution.

01:23:57.024 --> 01:24:01.804
The real test of this work programme will
therefore be the Housing Simplification

01:24:01.861 --> 01:24:06.745
Package, in which we want to see concrete
removal of unnecessary bureaucracy, a

01:24:06.794 --> 01:24:10.425
review of excessive requirements and
simplification of rules that drive up

01:24:10.474 --> 01:24:15.192
construction costs. This includes those in
the areas of energy, the environment and

01:24:15.249 --> 01:24:18.131
with respect for the competences
of the Member States.

01:24:18.181 --> 01:24:19.381
Thank you.

01:24:21.293 --> 01:24:25.313
Thank you. Next, I give the floor
to my colleague Ms Schidlow.

01:24:31.433 --> 01:24:34.273
Thank you, Madam President.
Commissioner, ladies and gentlemen.

01:24:34.320 --> 01:24:40.181
This Commission work programme for 2027
does not guarantee a solution to any of the

01:24:40.242 --> 01:24:45.954
problems that are currently leading to
successive crises in the European Union.

01:24:46.007 --> 01:24:51.447
The same directions are to be maintained.
Of course, the main issue here is

01:24:51.495 --> 01:24:57.612
migration policy. Listening to the speeches
of my colleagues here in this Chamber,

01:24:57.686 --> 01:25:01.644
one could almost say that everyone is
criticising and dissatisfied with this plan.

01:25:01.697 --> 01:25:04.174
So the question has
already been raised here:

01:25:04.238 --> 01:25:06.751
for whom does the
European Commission work?

01:25:06.805 --> 01:25:11.033
Or perhaps we should ask whether the
European Commission is even needed at all?

01:25:11.097 --> 01:25:18.254
Should we not finally say stop to the
continued assumption of new competences and

01:25:18.315 --> 01:25:24.925
the appropriation of further areas that
the Commission wants to bring under its

01:25:25.028 --> 01:25:29.163
control, even though this is clearly not
leading to anything good, as we cannot

01:25:29.211 --> 01:25:32.129
see—just as I mentioned earlier—a
solution to these problems.

01:25:32.176 --> 01:25:37.370
For this reason, I believe that this
Commission work programme is inadequate and

01:25:37.466 --> 01:25:42.945
does not guarantee development or a way
out of the crises in the European Union.

01:25:42.994 --> 01:25:44.194
Thank you very much.

01:25:48.413 --> 01:25:51.593
Thank you. The next speaker
is my colleague Ms Kavašová.

01:25:55.913 --> 01:26:00.933
I would like to thank the European
Commission and, in particular, Vice-President

01:26:00.984 --> 01:26:04.774
Fico for the initiative of the Right
to Stay strategy, the right to stay.

01:26:04.832 --> 01:26:09.914
It is important that our citizens do not
have to leave their homes out of necessity

01:26:09.955 --> 01:26:13.623
and need. Simply because they do not have
enough opportunities, because they lack

01:26:13.673 --> 01:26:17.936
quality services, or because they
have no prospects for the future.

01:26:17.995 --> 01:26:23.074
But one thing is crucial: this strategy
must not remain merely a shelf of good

01:26:23.136 --> 01:26:27.562
ideas. Therefore, we need concrete
measures, and above all, money.

01:26:27.634 --> 01:26:32.351
And that money is precisely what we are
discussing now in the European Parliament.

01:26:32.399 --> 01:26:36.994
We are also talking about future EU funds,
the conditions of which we are currently

01:26:37.044 --> 01:26:42.238
negotiating. And so I have a very clear
message for the leaders of the Member States

01:26:42.291 --> 01:26:47.116
of the European Union. We need an agreement
on the European budget by the end of

01:26:47.190 --> 01:26:52.144
this year. Precisely because it is about
our citizens, it is about our businesses,

01:26:52.209 --> 01:26:57.158
and it is about our regions. In the
European Parliament, we are ready and we are

01:26:57.219 --> 01:26:59.753
prepared to support
Ukraine as well. Thank you.

01:27:01.133 --> 01:27:05.153
Dear colleague, do you accept
the blue card by colleague Žonta?

01:27:07.253 --> 01:27:07.913
Yes.

01:27:07.913 --> 01:27:09.113
Okay.

01:27:09.473 --> 01:27:10.673
156, please.

01:27:11.213 --> 01:27:12.953
Just a second, you need
the mic. Yeah, now.

01:27:16.493 --> 01:27:19.648
I listened carefully to your speech,
as well as to the previous speeches.

01:27:19.691 --> 01:27:22.876
You come from a very
influential liberal group.

01:27:22.964 --> 01:27:28.520
Someone mentioned that there used to be
a dirty river, and now there is a clean

01:27:28.600 --> 01:27:33.930
river there. In my region, in Poland,
we have a problem with rivers drying up.

01:27:33.990 --> 01:27:38.071
Large water reservoirs have
emptied. And my question to you:

01:27:38.142 --> 01:27:42.897
given that the experts are directly stating
that next year will be very difficult in

01:27:42.941 --> 01:27:47.258
terms of water resources in the European
Union, will you support the idea of quickly

01:27:47.309 --> 01:27:53.057
finding funds to retain water in regions
where there are farmers, fruit growers and

01:27:53.116 --> 01:27:54.593
those who live off water?

01:28:00.713 --> 01:28:05.469
Thank you very much. This is one of the
examples of what we are all facing in our

01:28:05.531 --> 01:28:10.925
regions. Right now, the eastern region of
Slovakia, part of the eastern region in

01:28:11.010 --> 01:28:16.126
Gemer, Rimavská Sobota, has declared
an emergency situation due to a lack of

01:28:16.179 --> 01:28:21.862
drinking water. In the middle of autumn,
when we expect rain, and the reason?

01:28:21.954 --> 01:28:27.839
A long period of drought. So this is really
a challenge that we are facing in all

01:28:27.890 --> 01:28:33.613
European countries. And that is exactly
why we need European leaders to set aside

01:28:33.691 --> 01:28:39.443
their egos and start focusing on their
citizens and the needs of their citizens,

01:28:39.535 --> 01:28:44.811
including the issue of
access to drinking water.

01:28:44.936 --> 01:28:46.136
Thank you.

01:28:46.373 --> 01:28:49.193
Thank you. Next, we have a
speech by our colleague Ms Tusza.

01:28:58.733 --> 01:29:03.453
Mr Commissioner, to throw the Birds and
Habitats Directives to the wolves in the

01:29:03.519 --> 01:29:07.486
midst of the sixth mass
extinction is a historic mistake.

01:29:07.535 --> 01:29:11.827
These directives are our wetlands, our
forests, our coastlines, our protection

01:29:11.884 --> 01:29:15.526
against droughts and floods. You want
to wipe out in one stroke 40 years of

01:29:15.568 --> 01:29:21.428
protection for living things, even Mr
Macron and Ms von der Leyen tell you this is

01:29:21.482 --> 01:29:26.320
not serious. Ultimately, your programme
for the coming mandate is off the mark:

01:29:26.376 --> 01:29:30.416
heatwave plans on one side, climate
deregulation on the other, you are pouring oil

01:29:30.486 --> 01:29:35.334
on the fire, and doing nothing about
the eternal pollutants, PFAS, which are

01:29:35.407 --> 01:29:40.293
everywhere. In our blood, our bodies, our
water, our breast milk, they need to be

01:29:40.352 --> 01:29:44.137
banned, starting by protecting workers. Mr
Commissioner, across Europe, citizens are

01:29:44.192 --> 01:29:49.190
mobilising against the high cost of living,
against austerity, for young people.

01:29:49.261 --> 01:29:53.167
But you, you are feeding a
troubling obsession with lobbies.

01:29:53.225 --> 01:29:56.455
For banks, a omnibus. For
agrochemicals, an omnibus.

01:29:56.516 --> 01:29:59.790
For tenants, bulldozers. Mr Commissioner,
it is not by giving free rein to

01:29:59.828 --> 01:30:03.765
speculators that we will guarantee a
dignified life for each and every one of us on

01:30:03.809 --> 01:30:05.009
our continent.

01:30:06.233 --> 01:30:11.873
Dear colleagues, do you accept a
blue card from colleague Mulacic?

01:30:13.493 --> 01:30:14.693
The ECR.

01:30:15.173 --> 01:30:20.033
Very well. Thank you. Next, we will
hear from our colleague Ms Zacharia.

01:30:25.373 --> 01:30:30.490
Enough is enough with a Europe that
always finds solutions for bankers,

01:30:30.554 --> 01:30:35.693
industrialists, shipowners, but constantly
demands patience from its peoples.

01:30:35.756 --> 01:30:41.128
Workers cannot make ends meet, young people
cannot find a home, families are losing

01:30:41.193 --> 01:30:47.317
their homes to funds. And your answer?
Competitiveness and more market facilitation.

01:30:47.389 --> 01:30:53.946
In the Commission’s 2027 programme, you
withdraw the proposal for a common European

01:30:54.018 --> 01:30:59.204
deposit insurance, but prepare a new
competitiveness package for banks.

01:30:59.265 --> 01:31:02.308
You even want to interfere
with citizens’ lives.

01:31:02.371 --> 01:31:07.405
You withdraw the directive on controlling
environmental claims by businesses, but

01:31:07.473 --> 01:31:11.875
re-examine directives on birds,
habitats and Natura 2000 areas.

01:31:11.956 --> 01:31:18.212
You push ahead with EU Inc., the 28th
corporate regime under which all workers will

01:31:18.259 --> 01:31:22.915
be paid Bulgarian wages, and numerous
other measures for the militarisation of

01:31:22.981 --> 01:31:27.476
Europe. Profits cannot be protected by
law while people are left with promises.

01:31:27.521 --> 01:31:28.913
Your programme is unacceptable.

01:31:29.273 --> 01:31:30.473
Thank you.

01:31:30.893 --> 01:31:36.935
Dear colleague, do you colleague Zacharia,
please, do you accept the blue card by

01:31:37.002 --> 01:31:44.393
colleague Oliveira?
From the left, yes. 136.

01:31:49.493 --> 01:31:53.517
Thank you, Mr President. Ms Zacharia,
the question I want to ask is:

01:31:53.596 --> 01:32:00.691
how can we accept the complete lack of
concern for the social situation that people

01:32:00.773 --> 01:32:06.647
are facing? The European Commission's work
programme does not include any ideas for

01:32:06.716 --> 01:32:11.702
addressing the rising cost of living, the
difficulties people face in meeting basic

01:32:11.754 --> 01:32:16.438
needs due to the increase in fuel prices,
food prices and essential goods — how is

01:32:16.499 --> 01:32:21.231
it possible to support a work programme
like this that the Commission is presenting

01:32:21.281 --> 01:32:25.652
here if it is completely disconnected
from the needs and realities facing people

01:32:25.688 --> 01:32:26.888
across the European Union?

01:32:31.433 --> 01:32:36.355
Thank you very much for your question. It
is truly astonishing how this programme is

01:32:36.422 --> 01:32:43.058
considered something that citizens across
Europe will be able to accept and see a

01:32:43.151 --> 01:32:48.146
better day in their own lives. What is
really concerning the Commission, and is

01:32:48.212 --> 01:32:53.446
clearly evident through this programme,
is how it will drain the wealth of the

01:32:53.560 --> 01:33:00.069
people and how those who already have
plenty of money will live with even greater

01:33:00.126 --> 01:33:03.483
profits. That is the
essence of the matter.

01:33:03.567 --> 01:33:08.185
Because, in the end, it is lobbies
that are calling the shots here.

01:33:08.234 --> 01:33:09.434
Thank you.

01:33:11.753 --> 01:33:13.673
Thank you. The next speaker
is my colleague Tobi.

01:33:17.693 --> 01:33:25.122
President, colleagues, we are now
entering the third year of this mandate.

01:33:25.253 --> 01:33:32.267
Time flies. But we have also done a lot
of reforms to have better security, more

01:33:32.325 --> 01:33:38.071
competitiveness, of course with the goal
of getting a more prosperous Europe.

01:33:38.153 --> 01:33:44.839
But of course we need to deliver more.
Firstly, we need to strengthen Europol and

01:33:44.947 --> 01:33:53.123
develop a modern criminal law instrument
to better tackle drug-related crime.

01:33:53.213 --> 01:33:58.673
We must go after the money and the
business models of the criminal networks.

01:33:58.793 --> 01:34:02.462
Secondly, we need to do more
to protect our children.

01:34:02.573 --> 01:34:09.383
The EPP maintain our call for caucus law
at European level to effectively combat

01:34:09.473 --> 01:34:15.153
cyberbullying. And thirdly, we must do
more to take back control of migration.

01:34:15.233 --> 01:34:20.479
We need to address the weaponization
of migration like we saw in Ceuta.

01:34:20.573 --> 01:34:25.366
This is a bigger question than the lack
of response from the centrist government.

01:34:25.433 --> 01:34:28.900
Europe needs to deliver an
EPP. We'll do exactly that.

01:34:28.973 --> 01:34:30.173
Thank you.

01:34:31.433 --> 01:34:34.539
Dear colleague Tobi, there is a blue card.

01:34:34.613 --> 01:34:41.116
By colleague Wiśniewska. Monsieur
Tobi, there is a blue card.

01:34:41.213 --> 01:34:46.433
By Mrs. Wiśniewska.
Yes? Okay. 361, please.

01:34:53.453 --> 01:34:56.311
Thank you very much for
accepting the question.

01:34:56.422 --> 01:35:00.533
I agree with most of the
points raised by the gentleman.

01:35:00.598 --> 01:35:06.448
In particular, those concerning the
strengthening of Europol and the reduction of

01:35:06.521 --> 01:35:11.348
uncontrolled migration. These
are urgent and necessary matters.

01:35:11.412 --> 01:35:15.970
However, I would like to ask you, in the
context of the high cost of living and high

01:35:16.028 --> 01:35:23.127
energy prices, whether you do not think
that the proposed changes to the emissions

01:35:23.209 --> 01:35:29.449
trading system are too modest to improve
the competitiveness of the European economy

01:35:29.500 --> 01:35:31.913
and thus lower the cost
of living? Thank you.

01:35:36.293 --> 01:35:39.117
Well, thank you, colleague,
for the question.

01:35:39.173 --> 01:35:44.917
I'm good that we can at least agree that
it's important that Europe are taking steps

01:35:45.006 --> 01:35:49.539
to have a stronger Europol and that we
are taking back control of migration.

01:35:49.613 --> 01:35:54.259
Well, I would like to take an example when
it's come to ETS, and let me take my home

01:35:54.325 --> 01:36:00.620
country, Sweden, as an example. We have
the lowest emissions in Europe, and at the

01:36:00.695 --> 01:36:04.148
same time we have had
high growth in Europe.

01:36:04.253 --> 01:36:08.627
And I think the ETS has been crucial,
actually, to also create this.

01:36:08.693 --> 01:36:13.164
Of course, the basis of this is that
you need to have a good energy mix.

01:36:13.253 --> 01:36:18.344
In Sweden, we have an invested a lot in
renewables, but at the same time also

01:36:18.477 --> 01:36:23.979
nuclear. And this has also created that
we can have low energy prices and so that

01:36:24.053 --> 01:36:27.113
people also have a decent way
when it comes to cost of living.

01:36:28.853 --> 01:36:30.713
Thank you. Next redner

01:36:30.833 --> 01:36:32.033
is my colleague Wigenin.

01:36:39.653 --> 01:36:43.653
Thank you very much, Madam Chair.
Commissioner, dear colleagues.

01:36:43.730 --> 01:36:49.240
We live in a world in which international
law is increasingly being called into

01:36:49.294 --> 01:36:54.529
question. Conflicts are escalating and
economic dependencies are being used as a

01:36:54.601 --> 01:36:58.873
political weapon. The Commission is
right to speak of strategic autonomy.

01:36:58.951 --> 01:37:02.750
However, this does not only apply
to defence and competitiveness.

01:37:02.827 --> 01:37:08.513
It also encompasses Europe’s claim to
act as an independent geopolitical power.

01:37:08.605 --> 01:37:14.730
This is precisely where we encounter the
great contradiction between words and

01:37:14.794 --> 01:37:18.184
results. Today, we are
shown less and less respect.

01:37:18.264 --> 01:37:23.856
Our role in the world economy, world
politics and global security is becoming ever

01:37:23.927 --> 01:37:28.796
smaller, and the measures taken so
far are not changing this outlook.

01:37:28.861 --> 01:37:34.371
What plan do we have to ensure that our
voice is heard when negotiations on the end

01:37:34.444 --> 01:37:37.872
of Russia’s war against
Ukraine take place?

01:37:37.956 --> 01:37:42.959
What is our strategy for the Middle East
that goes beyond mere expressions of

01:37:43.070 --> 01:37:48.708
concern? How long will we continue to
allow others to determine our security?

01:37:48.805 --> 01:37:54.816
Europeans want their politicians to
show courage, wisdom and dignity.

01:37:54.907 --> 01:37:56.513
That is why people first.

01:37:58.193 --> 01:38:05.152
Dear colleague, may I have a Blue Card?
There are two, and both have already spoken,

01:38:05.201 --> 01:38:07.728
so I would take the first
one from Mr Oliveira.

01:38:07.815 --> 01:38:11.153
Is that okay? 136.

01:38:15.533 --> 01:38:21.064
Thank you, Mr President. Mr Wigenin, you
spoke about issues related to defence and

01:38:21.111 --> 01:38:23.685
security, and the
question I put to you is:

01:38:23.755 --> 01:38:28.707
how can it be justified that the Commission’s
work programme does not include a

01:38:28.794 --> 01:38:35.321
single initiative focused on peace? On
achieving a solution for peace and collective

01:38:35.376 --> 01:38:38.837
security to end the war
being waged in Ukraine.

01:38:38.912 --> 01:38:45.386
To end the war in the Middle East. To
end the genocide that Israel continues to

01:38:45.450 --> 01:38:48.950
commit against the Palestinian
people. How is this possible?

01:38:48.997 --> 01:38:53.344
The work programme speaks of defence and
security in international projection but

01:38:53.392 --> 01:38:56.873
does not have a single line on
building peace as a priority objective?

01:39:03.293 --> 01:39:07.132
Yeah, thank you for your comments. I
think I said the same, but in German.

01:39:07.193 --> 01:39:11.197
So obviously that was a
critic for the Commission.

01:39:11.273 --> 01:39:17.607
It's really important that we are able,
first, to further develop our defense

01:39:17.673 --> 01:39:22.546
capabilities, but at the same time to match
them with initiatives and a clear stance

01:39:22.608 --> 01:39:27.225
on how we deal with the big conflicts
of our time, because they affect every

01:39:27.293 --> 01:39:29.753
citizen's, every European
citizen. Thank you.

01:39:30.953 --> 01:39:35.284
Dear colleague, I made a mistake, Mr
Mulacic had not yet received a Blue Card.

01:39:35.333 --> 01:39:38.779
He had only applied for one. Would
you take a second card, a Blue Card?

01:39:38.834 --> 01:39:40.433
Yes, then please, Mr Mulacic.

01:39:42.773 --> 01:39:43.973
Okay.

01:39:48.833 --> 01:39:51.629
Thank you very much for
accepting the blue card.

01:39:51.762 --> 01:39:56.532
It was a very interesting speech. Mr Deputy
raised issues concerning the lack of a

01:39:56.591 --> 01:40:01.614
European strategic policy in foreign policy
and the priorities of the European Union

01:40:01.655 --> 01:40:04.327
when it comes to resolving
international disputes.

01:40:04.399 --> 01:40:06.513
Mr Deputy, however, the
question is crucial.

01:40:06.557 --> 01:40:11.055
Do the countries of the European
Union have a uniform strategy?

01:40:11.113 --> 01:40:15.928
When it comes to major conflicts in
the world, what about Central Europe?

01:40:15.983 --> 01:40:20.089
Does Poland have the same priorities?
Does Bulgaria, for example, like France or

01:40:20.155 --> 01:40:25.587
Germany, I fear that we do, however, have
a different perception of international

01:40:25.635 --> 01:40:29.182
reality and our relations with
America? Thank you very much.

01:40:29.277 --> 01:40:30.593
What is your opinion on this matter?

01:40:36.653 --> 01:40:40.923
Well, thank you for your comment, because
this is really an important element of the

01:40:40.973 --> 01:40:46.241
work that we need to do together. Because
when we talk about priorities, I think

01:40:46.308 --> 01:40:50.770
that we can easily achieve clear,
common, goals of the European Union.

01:40:50.873 --> 01:40:55.254
Which are definitely in favor of both
France, Bulgaria, Poland, and any other

01:40:55.308 --> 01:40:58.947
country. If we are strong in
defense, it's good for everyone, no?

01:40:59.033 --> 01:41:03.913
If we are strong at the world scene, if
we have a strong voice and we can together

01:41:03.983 --> 01:41:08.816
use this voice, it's good for France,
Bulgaria, Poland, and any other country.

01:41:08.873 --> 01:41:14.213
So working together, trying to find together
the best solution and using our power

01:41:14.313 --> 01:41:18.642
individual and common as European
Union is the way to move forward.

01:41:18.713 --> 01:41:24.869
But that means that we need to have a
really a guidance, a leadership, which can

01:41:24.942 --> 01:41:27.833
unite us. This is the main
problem we have right now.

01:41:29.333 --> 01:41:36.027
Thank you very much. Thank you. Colleague
Ehlers has now disappeared from the list,

01:41:36.069 --> 01:41:38.273
but she is still here.
Please, Ms Colleague Ehlers.

01:41:44.153 --> 01:41:51.486
Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner, for
the 2027 work programme, the Commission

01:41:51.567 --> 01:41:55.285
is announcing no fewer
than 24 new initiatives.

01:41:55.376 --> 01:42:00.357
More plans, more rules, more
interference from Brussels.

01:42:00.412 --> 01:42:06.155
At the same time, the Commission is also
announcing that it will repeal a few laws

01:42:06.256 --> 01:42:11.586
as part of its deregulation
drive. But that is pure deception.

01:42:11.639 --> 01:42:17.221
Because the laws the Commission wants to
repeal are, in fact, no longer relevant.

01:42:17.275 --> 01:42:23.693
For example, it is talking about a
regulation from 1991 on a one-off delivery of

01:42:23.766 --> 01:42:31.948
butter and milk powder to
Bulgaria. What a show of strength.

01:42:32.047 --> 01:42:37.070
This is not deregulation; it
is long-overdue maintenance.

01:42:37.137 --> 01:42:42.810
No citizen gains anything if irrelevant
legislation is scrapped administratively.

01:42:42.897 --> 01:42:47.747
What the Commission should really do
is abolish the disastrous Green Deal.

01:42:47.825 --> 01:42:54.686
Or withdraw the failing migration pact.
It would, of course, be even better if the

01:42:54.768 --> 01:42:58.193
Commission simply abolished
itself. Thank you.

01:42:59.753 --> 01:43:04.130
May I ask, Kollege Müller, as for
Blue Card, but it is withdrawn.

01:43:04.193 --> 01:43:07.839
Is that correct?
Withdrawn. Okay, thank you.

01:43:07.913 --> 01:43:09.113
It was withdrawn.

01:43:09.773 --> 01:43:11.993
I now give the floor to
my colleague Mr Weimers.

01:43:16.733 --> 01:43:22.166
Yes, thank you, Madam President. This
is the Commission’s work programme.

01:43:22.218 --> 01:43:26.965
They say they care about high electricity
prices, but here in Brussels they are

01:43:27.045 --> 01:43:34.160
talking about new rules after 2030, while
Swedish families are lying awake worrying

01:43:34.216 --> 01:43:38.882
about the bill. In my part of Skåne, for
example, there could be an extra tens of

01:43:38.940 --> 01:43:43.647
thousands of kronor to pay this winter.
That is the reality for ordinary people, a

01:43:43.697 --> 01:43:47.645
different reality from that of your
Commissioners here in Brussels.

01:43:47.741 --> 01:43:52.418
Why is it like this then? Yes, because the
red-green coalition dismantled the energy

01:43:52.463 --> 01:43:55.016
system, shut down nuclear
power that was working.

01:43:55.092 --> 01:43:58.162
Now Swedish households
are footing the bill.

01:43:58.261 --> 01:44:02.875
And it’s going to get worse. Swedish
electricity customers are subsidising German

01:44:02.939 --> 01:44:06.391
electricity after their
disastrous energy turnaround.

01:44:06.461 --> 01:44:10.634
They shut down their nuclear
power and we’re paying for it.

01:44:10.706 --> 01:44:15.773
Every new EU proposal must pass a
test. Does it lower electricity prices?

01:44:15.827 --> 01:44:20.509
If not, then it’s a legislative proposal
that belongs in the wastepaper basket.

01:44:20.570 --> 01:44:22.975
We cannot sit still while
prosperity disappears.

01:44:23.016 --> 01:44:27.392
We must turn the tide now. Because without
cheap electricity, ordinary Swedes have

01:44:27.452 --> 01:44:30.833
neither security nor a future
– that’s just how it is.

01:44:33.773 --> 01:44:35.753
Thank you. The next speaker
is our colleague, Ms Hahn.

01:44:43.193 --> 01:44:47.139
Dear colleagues, you see me
here today happier than usual.

01:44:47.193 --> 01:44:49.152
I am critical of the
Commission, but I am happy.

01:44:49.192 --> 01:44:54.173
Because finally something is happening when
it comes to cutting red tape in Europe.

01:44:54.259 --> 01:44:58.614
The Commission wants to withdraw the Green
Claims Directive and the Late Payments

01:44:58.671 --> 01:45:03.450
Regulation. Two bureaucratic monsters
that I have been warning about for years.

01:45:03.511 --> 01:45:08.567
Because European companies neither need
an expensive eco-TÜV for their advertising

01:45:08.634 --> 01:45:13.543
nor state-dictated payment deadlines. And
for many years, Commission President von

01:45:13.595 --> 01:45:16.220
der Leyen has promised the
one-in-one-out principle.

01:45:16.267 --> 01:45:20.470
So it is really good – albeit overdue –
that finally, for every new law, one is

01:45:20.527 --> 01:45:23.203
withdrawn. But this can
only be the beginning.

01:45:23.261 --> 01:45:27.702
Because if you only withdraw legislative
proposals that have not yet entered into

01:45:27.757 --> 01:45:30.792
force, you have not abolished
a single existing rule.

01:45:30.847 --> 01:45:34.886
We must have the courage to tackle the
existing stock and scrap unnecessary

01:45:34.946 --> 01:45:38.159
regulations. Because Europe will
not regulate itself into prosperity.

01:45:38.190 --> 01:45:41.564
And that is why we must measure the
Commission and its work programmes against

01:45:41.633 --> 01:45:46.062
whether they enable growth. Because growth
means good jobs, rising incomes and new

01:45:46.119 --> 01:45:51.490
opportunities for people in Europe, and
this also strengthens trust in the EU.

01:45:51.521 --> 01:45:52.373
Thank you.

01:45:52.373 --> 01:45:54.563
Colleague Ms Hahn, may I have a Blue Card?

01:45:54.667 --> 01:45:58.973
Colleague Mr Müller. Go ahead.

01:46:01.253 --> 01:46:02.093
Location.

01:46:02.093 --> 01:46:04.089
Madam Member, I am very pleased
with the words you have just spoken;

01:46:04.118 --> 01:46:07.904
moreover, in the IMCO committee we have
the opportunity to work together precisely

01:46:07.951 --> 01:46:12.632
in this area to simplify regulations
concerning the economy, and in many cases we

01:46:12.678 --> 01:46:16.388
have succeeded in doing so hand in hand.
However, I do not share your optimism for

01:46:16.433 --> 01:46:20.690
the future, unfortunately, because in recent
months we have seen that parliamentary

01:46:20.751 --> 01:46:25.784
committees and then in the plenary session
these provisions are simply removed, even

01:46:25.860 --> 01:46:29.625
if the European Commission proposes
good provisions, they are often deleted.

01:46:29.661 --> 01:46:33.772
And sometimes they are also not
ambitious enough, and the more ambitious

01:46:33.811 --> 01:46:36.753
simplifications do not come to pass. So
the question is, what is your view here:

01:46:36.794 --> 01:46:40.583
can the coming year change this, and will
the Socialists finally wake up and notice

01:46:40.638 --> 01:46:42.713
the negative effects of these provisions?

01:46:47.693 --> 01:46:52.884
Thank you for your question. Mr President,
Mr Müller, I believe that we in the

01:46:52.937 --> 01:46:57.432
European Parliament must also have this
courage, which we—or at least I—rightly

01:46:57.477 --> 01:47:01.657
expect from the Commission. We must have
the courage to put everything we have in

01:47:01.708 --> 01:47:06.089
terms of laws to the test and see what
truly defends the rights of our citizens,

01:47:06.151 --> 01:47:09.527
what defends the interests of
our citizens and our businesses.

01:47:09.586 --> 01:47:14.368
And what has accumulated as unnecessary
rules, which neither serves the defence of

01:47:14.427 --> 01:47:18.916
our interests or our prosperity but is
simply leftover bureaucracy, that must go.

01:47:18.987 --> 01:47:23.679
Because economic growth means prosperity,
means progress and means confidence in a

01:47:23.751 --> 01:47:28.452
better future. And we need this
courage here in Parliament too.

01:47:28.546 --> 01:47:32.273
Thank you. The floor now goes
to my colleague Mr Böselager.

01:47:39.473 --> 01:47:43.800
Dear Vice President, it's halftime, so
we are halfway through the von der Leyen

01:47:43.853 --> 01:47:47.473
government too, and I think above all
you promised competitiveness, which in my

01:47:47.515 --> 01:47:51.997
understanding means making business
easier in and across Europe.

01:47:52.073 --> 01:47:54.068
But what have you
actually achieved on this?

01:47:54.113 --> 01:47:57.480
Founding is still very difficult
in Europe, and the EU, Inc.

01:47:57.533 --> 01:48:00.230
is at risk of being
hollowed out right now.

01:48:00.293 --> 01:48:03.732
Hiring is really, really
difficult across the continent.

01:48:03.773 --> 01:48:08.047
It's a tax nightmare, and when we talk
about attracting international talent, the

01:48:08.092 --> 01:48:11.623
narrative that we have on
migration is scaring off people.

01:48:11.753 --> 01:48:16.829
And when it is about selling across borders,
we still have huge hidden tariffs when

01:48:16.877 --> 01:48:20.754
it comes to goods and services, and
I don't see a full and comprehensive

01:48:20.813 --> 01:48:25.502
single-market program from your side. And
when it comes to selling across the world,

01:48:25.553 --> 01:48:28.265
we don't really see the trade
deals that are necessary.

01:48:28.313 --> 01:48:33.073
We are sending them to the courts or
elsewhere, but we don't actually close them.

01:48:33.173 --> 01:48:37.604
And when it comes to raising capital I
have to say our public money is focused on

01:48:37.671 --> 01:48:43.321
farmers and not on AI and innovation, and
our private money still is invested in the

01:48:43.403 --> 01:48:47.761
US. So my question to you is, can you commit
that in the second half of your mandate

01:48:47.808 --> 01:48:50.648
you will actually deliver on
these elements of competitiveness?

01:48:50.693 --> 01:48:51.893
Thank you so much.

01:48:53.213 --> 01:48:56.033
Thank you. The floor now goes
to my colleague Ms Burkhardt.

01:49:01.073 --> 01:49:06.270
Thank you, Madam President. In my parents'
group, heating tips are being exchanged

01:49:06.322 --> 01:49:08.990
because people are worried
about the exploding prices.

01:49:09.041 --> 01:49:13.402
In my vocational school class, they ask
me how they're supposed to get to their

01:49:13.474 --> 01:49:16.579
training centre with
fuel prices like this.

01:49:16.651 --> 01:49:22.230
But competitiveness and cutting red tape
aren't exactly the answers that make people

01:49:22.303 --> 01:49:25.629
feel heard in the face
of such everyday worries.

01:49:25.684 --> 01:49:30.751
Not because you don't care about economic
policy, but because you want it to work

01:49:30.802 --> 01:49:35.687
for you too. To look ahead with optimism.
That's why we now need measures that don't

01:49:35.750 --> 01:49:40.794
just allow a few to profit from crises,
but actually bring down the costs of energy

01:49:40.867 --> 01:49:45.929
and food. But in times of crisis, we also
need to position ourselves for the future

01:49:45.997 --> 01:49:50.804
— not by selling off our environmental
and social standards, but by investing in

01:49:50.859 --> 01:49:56.015
good jobs, a future-proof industry and
clear rules for digital corporations.

01:49:56.085 --> 01:49:57.285
People first.

01:50:00.053 --> 01:50:03.113
Thank you very much. The next
speaker is my colleague Mr Borg here.

01:50:08.093 --> 01:50:14.406
Commissioner, I thank you for presenting
the work programme, but allow us to say

01:50:14.474 --> 01:50:19.462
that we are a little disappointed, because
we would have liked President von der

01:50:19.546 --> 01:50:25.783
Leyen to have put her face to it: you
have said many commendable things, but one

01:50:25.884 --> 01:50:32.010
fundamental aspect, a vital one, was
missing, the one linked to the freedom of

01:50:32.087 --> 01:50:36.971
Europeans. The freedom to choose
their own government, to begin with.

01:50:37.019 --> 01:50:42.463
Instead, in recent years, we have witnessed
the abuse of the rule of law to obstruct

01:50:42.530 --> 01:50:45.723
governments that were less
palatable to Brussels.

01:50:45.783 --> 01:50:51.199
In Poland, there was even a kind of coup,
but since Tusk is your friend, no one said

01:50:51.282 --> 01:50:56.849
anything. In Italy, they are even publishing
schoolbooks trying to convince students

01:50:56.907 --> 01:51:02.156
that there is a fascist government in
Italy, but fortunately our young people are

01:51:02.226 --> 01:51:06.503
smart enough not to be taken in
by a few left-wing blowhards.

01:51:06.573 --> 01:51:12.511
Let’s be honest: in recent years, Brussels
has taken a lot away from Europeans –

01:51:12.607 --> 01:51:17.518
industry, agriculture, sovereignty – but
what you will never be able to take away is

01:51:17.571 --> 01:51:18.953
their freedom and dignity.

01:51:21.413 --> 01:51:24.198
Thank you. We are now concluding
the Blue Card procedure.

01:51:24.237 --> 01:51:26.093
We have already received
more than we can take.

01:51:27.653 --> 01:51:28.253
Catch the eye,

01:51:28.253 --> 01:51:31.603
not the Blue Card. Sorry, we do have
the Blue Card, but there is another one,

01:51:31.675 --> 01:51:33.533
namely, oh yes, excuse me,

01:51:34.253 --> 01:51:37.257
signore Borgia, do you
accept the Bluecard?

01:51:37.313 --> 01:51:40.313
I'm sorry, aber bitte, okay, thank you.

01:51:41.213 --> 01:51:44.873
Next, we have, er, the next
speaker, our colleague Röschen.

01:51:50.573 --> 01:51:53.645
Thank you, Mr President, dear colleagues,
the work programme of the European

01:51:53.697 --> 01:51:57.657
Commission this time contains
some interesting intentions.

01:51:57.720 --> 01:52:03.120
The most striking is the announced revision
of the Birds and Habitats Directives.

01:52:03.197 --> 01:52:08.749
This revision is really badly needed. After
all, these are very outdated directives,

01:52:08.808 --> 01:52:12.030
but there is also a very
important flaw in them.

01:52:12.118 --> 01:52:17.416
Namely this: under these directives,
everything is legally subordinated to achieving

01:52:17.518 --> 01:52:23.499
the nature objectives. And that
sometimes leads to absurd situations.

01:52:23.588 --> 01:52:28.222
For example, a major construction project
that comes to a standstill for months

01:52:28.294 --> 01:52:31.784
because a single frog
is found on the site.

01:52:31.858 --> 01:52:38.173
But also major problems with permit granting,
particularly concerning Natura 2000.

01:52:38.225 --> 01:52:44.211
Permits are not being issued because
nature is allegedly not yet 100% in order.

01:52:44.324 --> 01:52:50.562
Unnecessary nitrogen rules, national rules,
certainly play a role here, but so does

01:52:50.625 --> 01:52:54.049
the flaw I mentioned.
We need to address that.

01:52:54.111 --> 01:52:59.604
A more balanced approach in European nature
policy, with greater consideration for

01:52:59.680 --> 01:53:03.214
social and economic
interests, is urgently needed.

01:53:03.257 --> 01:53:04.457
Thank you.

01:53:05.813 --> 01:53:08.273
Thank you. The next speaker
is my colleague, Mr Gozi.

01:53:13.553 --> 01:53:17.855
Thank you, President. The Commission's
decision to withdraw the Green Claims

01:53:17.933 --> 01:53:23.562
Directive is political and acceptable
and institutionally deeply troubling.

01:53:23.633 --> 01:53:29.308
Let's be clear: the Commission never
seriously tried to revive negotiations, quite

01:53:29.386 --> 01:53:34.440
the opposite. When the Polish presidency
was ready to move forward, the Commission

01:53:34.519 --> 01:53:39.280
did the opposite. And helped bring
negotiations to a standstill.

01:53:39.353 --> 01:53:45.356
This raises serious questions about its
institutional independence and its duty to

01:53:45.444 --> 01:53:51.545
act as an honest broker. The anti-hero
of this bad story were President von der

01:53:51.612 --> 01:53:56.859
Leyen and Commissioner Roosevelt. But I'm
afraid their marriage, the responsibility,

01:53:56.922 --> 01:54:02.074
reading the treaty, is collected.
And the consequences are real.

01:54:02.153 --> 01:54:08.268
Businesses still lack clear certainty,
consumers still lack clear guarantees because

01:54:08.335 --> 01:54:13.720
bending rewashing without establishing
clear rules for credible green claims is

01:54:13.833 --> 01:54:18.944
simply a joke. The Commission should
be building bridges, not burning them,

01:54:19.022 --> 01:54:24.171
defending European legislation, not giving
up under national political pressure.

01:54:24.233 --> 01:54:25.433
Thank you very much.

01:54:26.813 --> 01:54:29.393
Thank you. The next speaker
is my colleague Ms Gölemans.

01:54:33.953 --> 01:54:42.481
Good grief, I can look and look, but where
is the social dimension in your 2027 work

01:54:42.589 --> 01:54:47.696
programme? Do you seriously believe
that Europe will become stronger, more

01:54:47.772 --> 01:54:51.568
autonomous and more resilient
on a social wasteland?

01:54:51.638 --> 01:54:57.015
This work programme generously devotes a
few lines to the European Pillar of Social

01:54:57.079 --> 01:55:02.296
Rights, a few lines lost in an ocean
of competitiveness and deregulation.

01:55:02.371 --> 01:55:09.221
While the social emergency is being
expressed in the streets across Europe, there

01:55:09.279 --> 01:55:12.836
are no concrete measures on employment.
Yet the challenges are legion:

01:55:12.881 --> 01:55:18.000
European workers are today widely affected
by artificial intelligence, algorithmic

01:55:18.067 --> 01:55:22.815
management, stress, burnout and wages
that do not allow a dignified life.

01:55:22.879 --> 01:55:28.145
In the coming weeks, the Quality Jobs Act
will be a unique opportunity to address

01:55:28.208 --> 01:55:31.641
this, with binding legislation
to protect Europeans.

01:55:31.712 --> 01:55:35.873
Because competitiveness is
definitely not a societal project.

01:55:36.473 --> 01:55:38.873
So let's put people first.

01:55:41.513 --> 01:55:44.873
Thank you. Next speaker, next
speaker is our colleague Pönel.

01:55:49.733 --> 01:55:54.135
The Commission’s 2027 work programme
unfortunately confirms that it is persisting

01:55:54.181 --> 01:55:56.120
with a policy that sacrifices our farmers.

01:55:56.166 --> 01:56:00.563
First, there is even more free trade,
including the agreement with Australia, which

01:56:00.617 --> 01:56:04.859
will further intensify the unfair
competition faced by our producers.

01:56:04.913 --> 01:56:09.369
It is a paradox when, at the same time, the
Commission claims it wants to reduce our

01:56:09.416 --> 01:56:13.934
dependencies. You finally acknowledge
that our standards are penalising the

01:56:14.003 --> 01:56:18.838
competitiveness of our economy. But while
you attempt to reduce bureaucracy, you are

01:56:18.900 --> 01:56:24.229
doing nothing about the regulatory nightmare
that is suffocating our agriculture.

01:56:24.298 --> 01:56:29.417
Worse still, you are reaffirming your
decarbonisation objectives even though we are

01:56:29.476 --> 01:56:32.996
already the most virtuous region
in the world in this area.

01:56:33.059 --> 01:56:36.579
And you continue with your
policy of punitive ecology.

01:56:36.618 --> 01:56:41.385
Finally, you are preparing a drastic cut
to the CAP budget, which will deprive our

01:56:41.439 --> 01:56:43.611
farmers of the support
they desperately need.

01:56:43.656 --> 01:56:46.129
Commissioner, our farmers
are caught in a vice.

01:56:46.194 --> 01:56:50.184
Increasing unfair competition, decreasing
support, and just as many regulations.

01:56:50.242 --> 01:56:55.537
When will you understand that our agriculture
is sinking because of you, because of

01:56:55.621 --> 01:57:00.473
your regulations, because of the unfair
competition that you are orchestrating here?

01:57:04.133 --> 01:57:08.033
Thank you. And the last speaker on
the list is our colleague Ms Göring.

01:57:12.533 --> 01:57:17.231
Honourable colleagues, the committee’s work
programme for next year is nothing more

01:57:17.290 --> 01:57:20.978
than sleight of hand. It fails
to address the essential issues.

01:57:21.044 --> 01:57:25.860
They have crammed everything into it, from
permitting procedures to LGBTQ rights,

01:57:25.919 --> 01:57:30.449
while European citizens are struggling
with livelihood problems, businesses and

01:57:30.507 --> 01:57:35.209
farmers are grappling with overregulation
and unaffordable energy prices.

01:57:35.268 --> 01:57:39.934
The von der Leyen cabinet offers no
substantive solutions to these problems.

01:57:39.988 --> 01:57:44.734
It is clear that it is seeking to meet
the expectations of the Brussels grand

01:57:44.837 --> 01:57:48.279
coalition that keeps it in power.
On paper, their proposals may serve

01:57:48.337 --> 01:57:53.264
competitiveness, but they certainly do
not reduce energy prices by a single cent.

01:57:53.317 --> 01:57:58.200
The much-touted simplification packages do
not eliminate the economic damage caused

01:57:58.265 --> 01:58:03.160
by the Green Deal. Colleagues, we need
immediate deregulation across as many areas

01:58:03.222 --> 01:58:07.512
as possible. The long list of withdrawn
legislation also proves that Brussels has

01:58:07.572 --> 01:58:12.286
lost touch with reality. If, instead of
harmonisation efforts, they focused on

01:58:12.344 --> 01:58:17.039
people’s real problems, there would not
be so many pieces of legislation that die

01:58:17.098 --> 01:58:22.252
stillborn. It is high time, therefore, to
act on the basis of common sense and stand

01:58:22.314 --> 01:58:24.833
by the side of European
citizens. Thank you.

01:58:26.813 --> 01:58:28.073
My colleague Ms Göring,

01:58:28.193 --> 01:58:33.833
do you accept the blue card?
Mrs. Göring, excuse me.

01:58:34.553 --> 01:58:35.693
Hello.

01:58:35.693 --> 01:58:38.393
Hello. Do you accept the blue card?

01:58:39.413 --> 01:58:40.613
By Colleague Fritzon.

01:58:44.333 --> 01:58:45.533
Here, S&D.

01:58:49.913 --> 01:58:50.933
Thank you.

01:58:50.933 --> 01:58:51.773
And President.

01:58:51.773 --> 01:58:52.133
No.

01:58:52.133 --> 01:58:53.333
Yeah.

01:58:53.393 --> 01:58:56.570
Yes, we have a time when
women's rights are under attack.

01:58:56.633 --> 01:59:01.079
We expected much greater ambition from
the Commission, and we know there is a

01:59:01.145 --> 01:59:06.585
crucial debate here in the Parliament because
we can see in the work program that it

01:59:06.661 --> 01:59:13.448
falls short on gender equality. So where
do you see the needs for initiatives on

01:59:13.521 --> 01:59:18.175
sexual and reproductive health and rights,
on gender-based violence, and women's

01:59:18.233 --> 01:59:24.127
economic independence? Because we know
that in this worrying world we need to put

01:59:24.186 --> 01:59:30.263
women's rights on the top of the agenda,
but you are not with us in that, and we

01:59:30.366 --> 01:59:34.673
need to be united here in the
Parliament to fight for women's rights.

01:59:39.593 --> 01:59:44.930
Honourable Member, I believe that the
European Union has its founding treaties, it

01:59:45.006 --> 01:59:51.356
has a Charter of Fundamental Rights, and
these provide appropriate legal protection,

01:59:51.415 --> 01:59:56.042
and we also have our national
constitutions and national legislation.

01:59:56.104 --> 02:00:01.096
I think these are perfectly adequate, we
should focus on these and not confuse which

02:00:01.150 --> 02:00:06.964
level regulates what. As for what precise
further steps might be needed, I believe

02:00:07.026 --> 02:00:11.809
we should trust in the wisdom of our nations
to find a solution if anything further

02:00:11.875 --> 02:00:13.193
is necessary. Thank you.

02:00:16.373 --> 02:00:22.661
Thank you. That exhausts the regular
speaking list, and we have 17 Catch the Eye

02:00:22.750 --> 02:00:29.066
requests; we can’t take them all,
but I think we can get through 11.

02:00:29.149 --> 02:00:39.463
Then we can start with the colleague Ms
Brnjac, and Mr Lopez-Aguilar can prepare.

02:00:39.559 --> 02:00:43.073
Wait, wait, first Ms Brnjac. 3, 4, 8.

02:00:46.373 --> 02:00:50.938
Commissioner, the European Commission's
work programme places emphasis on

02:00:50.993 --> 02:00:53.948
competitiveness and the
simplification of legislation.

02:00:53.991 --> 02:00:57.773
However, simplification must be felt
in the everyday lives of our citizens.

02:00:57.845 --> 02:01:02.594
As coordinator in the Committee on the
Housing Crisis, I particularly highlight the

02:01:02.660 --> 02:01:05.956
announced package for simplification
in the area of housing.

02:01:05.995 --> 02:01:09.388
The European Parliament already adopted
concrete recommendations in March of this

02:01:09.434 --> 02:01:13.802
year: the digitalisation of procedures,
faster issuance of building permits, and the

02:01:13.860 --> 02:01:17.691
activation of unused land. From the
European Commission, we now expect real

02:01:17.738 --> 02:01:20.397
regulatory reform, not just
simplification on paper.

02:01:20.472 --> 02:01:24.655
If construction projects continue to
wait for permits for years, if existing

02:01:24.700 --> 02:01:28.396
buildings cannot be repurposed more easily,
and if administrative costs continue to

02:01:28.446 --> 02:01:30.764
rise, then we have not solved the problem.

02:01:30.824 --> 02:01:33.425
Simplification must mean
more homes being built.

02:01:33.476 --> 02:01:38.011
This must be the yardstick for measuring
the success of the Commission's work

02:01:38.055 --> 02:01:39.255
programme. Thank you.

02:01:41.933 --> 02:01:45.658
Thank you. The floor now goes to our
colleague Mr Lopez-Aguilar, and our colleague

02:01:45.701 --> 02:01:47.033
Mr Smits is preparing to speak.

02:01:52.553 --> 02:01:54.833
We need a micro. 3, 3,
8, 1, please, micro.

02:01:55.313 --> 02:01:56.513
Yeah.

02:01:57.653 --> 02:02:01.460
Thank you, Madam President. Commissioner
Šešković, the Commission's work programme

02:02:01.504 --> 02:02:02.693
for 2027,

02:02:02.693 --> 02:02:07.903
I stand by the commitment to implement the
Migration Pact with obligatory solidarity

02:02:07.970 --> 02:02:12.825
under pressure, which admits no flexibility
whatsoever nor any omnibus bill, but

02:02:12.889 --> 02:02:16.203
rather the full rigour of
the European commitment.

02:02:16.272 --> 02:02:22.434
Within the framework of the rule of law,
as set out in the treaties and through

02:02:22.479 --> 02:02:25.911
reform, because the Conference on the
Future of Europe, with experts, must produce

02:02:25.949 --> 02:02:29.006
institutional reforms
prior to any enlargement.

02:02:29.083 --> 02:02:35.632
And the shield of democracy in Europe also
includes the prohibition of conversion

02:02:35.695 --> 02:02:39.633
practices. In accordance with the
European Citizens' Initiative.

02:02:39.704 --> 02:02:44.734
And finally, the recovery of the social
pillar and the funding of affordable housing

02:02:44.812 --> 02:02:49.378
require own resources. Within the multiannual
financial framework, windfall profits

02:02:49.427 --> 02:02:53.425
from major energy companies, crypto-assets
and, of course, the large profits of

02:02:53.467 --> 02:02:56.825
major tech companies must be used to finance
a robust recovery of the social pillar,

02:02:56.890 --> 02:03:01.352
which is absolutely urgent in order to
be able to respond to the social anger

02:03:01.404 --> 02:03:02.993
sweeping across Europe.
Thank you, Madam President.

02:03:04.673 --> 02:03:08.557
Thank you. The floor now goes to our
colleague Mr Smits, and our colleague Mr

02:03:08.606 --> 02:03:10.073
Oliveira is preparing to speak.

02:03:12.953 --> 02:03:16.328
Mr President, Commissioner,
stand up for each other.

02:03:16.378 --> 02:03:21.668
The Commission wants to review the next
habitat directives and Natura 2000.

02:03:21.751 --> 02:03:26.656
Positive, but not enough. The countryside
does not need a review, but a genuine

02:03:26.725 --> 02:03:31.716
overhaul of these laws. Stand
up for our countryside in 2027.

02:03:31.986 --> 02:03:37.365
The deterioration ban and the case law are
putting the Netherlands and Europe in a

02:03:37.499 --> 02:03:43.294
tight spot. Make it possible to revise
designated Natura 2000 areas and objectives

02:03:43.358 --> 02:03:46.244
where they are unfeasible or unscientific.

02:03:46.304 --> 02:03:50.934
Problem wolves that are terrorising our
countryside must be able to be culled.

02:03:50.994 --> 02:03:54.312
The same applies to
cormorants and other species.

02:03:54.400 --> 02:03:58.974
Management by hunters is necessary,
for nature and for people.

02:03:59.044 --> 02:04:04.150
The absurd nitrogen crisis in The Hague,
caused by national targets on top of

02:04:04.211 --> 02:04:07.916
European legislation, is a
textbook example of gold-plating:

02:04:07.997 --> 02:04:14.901
so get rid of those national heads.
Maintain in the MFF targeted support for our

02:04:14.980 --> 02:04:20.551
farmers and fishermen. Commissioner, less
regulatory burden and more simplification.

02:04:20.620 --> 02:04:24.587
The space for innovation that
our AI sector needs and no rules.

02:04:24.647 --> 02:04:28.973
Only in this way can we protect
our socio-economic future.

02:04:31.493 --> 02:04:36.425
The floor now goes to my colleague Mr
Oliveira, and my colleague Ms Jovanović-Šešuka

02:04:36.482 --> 02:04:37.682
may prepare herself.

02:04:39.533 --> 02:04:45.249
Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner
Šešković, between declarations of intent and

02:04:45.342 --> 02:04:51.683
deregulation packages, from the Commission’s
work programme for 2027, what stands

02:04:51.783 --> 02:04:57.353
out are nine initiatives to multiply the
privileges and benefits of multinationals

02:04:57.417 --> 02:05:02.675
under the pretext of competitiveness.
Nine more initiatives to keep arming the

02:05:02.733 --> 02:05:08.822
European Union to the teeth and to take
the political project of confrontation and

02:05:08.887 --> 02:05:14.381
war even further. Three initiatives to
favour those who speculate in housing instead

02:05:14.435 --> 02:05:18.721
of addressing the problem affecting the
people, who cannot find a home they can

02:05:18.778 --> 02:05:23.310
afford. And a birthday party for the ten-year
anniversary of the European Pillar of

02:05:23.376 --> 02:05:26.744
Social Rights, to pretend
there is concern for people.

02:05:26.803 --> 02:05:32.132
Not a single word about initiatives to
build peace in Ukraine or end the genocides

02:05:32.206 --> 02:05:36.920
in Palestine. Not a word about the rising
cost of living, the need to increase wages

02:05:36.980 --> 02:05:42.378
and pensions, combating poverty after
presenting a strategy to eradicate poverty, a

02:05:42.435 --> 02:05:47.175
word to increase public housing, to invest
in public services or support productive

02:05:47.227 --> 02:05:51.593
sectors. This work programme does not serve
the peoples of the European Union area.

02:05:54.893 --> 02:06:00.007
Thank you. Now the floor goes to our
colleague Jovanović-Šešuka, and our colleague

02:06:00.063 --> 02:06:01.263
Mian Mon can prepare.

02:06:04.013 --> 02:06:05.273
Thank you. I will speak Romanian.

02:06:06.293 --> 02:06:10.293
Two days ago, Ms Ursula von
der Leyen visited Romania.

02:06:10.353 --> 02:06:15.721
In fact, the so-called President of Romania,
illegal and unconstitutional, following

02:06:15.782 --> 02:06:19.332
elections annulled by the
European Commission in Romania.

02:06:19.415 --> 02:06:24.954
What did she ask for? She asked us to give
all our Patriot missiles to Ukraine for

02:06:25.043 --> 02:06:30.713
free. Ms Ursula von der Leyen did not
inquire about the pensioners living on 200

02:06:30.819 --> 02:06:37.029
euros a month. Meanwhile, prices in
Romania are higher than in Brussels.

02:06:37.099 --> 02:06:41.924
We have Brussels prices and salaries
from the former Soviet gulag.

02:06:42.033 --> 02:06:47.421
You are not interested in peace either,
because you have not understood:

02:06:47.529 --> 02:06:53.506
you are arming, taking all our money,
destroying all our savings, and Mr Zelensky is

02:06:53.579 --> 02:06:57.484
killing both Ukrainians and
Russians, and Romanians.

02:06:57.538 --> 02:07:02.807
And you are not interested in the fact
that now the three major powers, the United

02:07:02.856 --> 02:07:07.585
States of America, Russia and China,
are making peace because you have not

02:07:07.637 --> 02:07:11.906
understood that the Russian-Ukrainian war
is being waged so that Russia no longer

02:07:11.958 --> 02:07:14.993
cooperates with the European
Union. So, maximum poverty.

02:07:17.213 --> 02:07:21.977
Thank you. The next speaker is my colleague
Mian Mon, and my colleague Baiana is

02:07:22.027 --> 02:07:23.227
preparing to speak.

02:07:23.333 --> 02:07:27.665
Thank you, Madam President. I regret that
the Commission's work programme for 2027

02:07:27.752 --> 02:07:31.719
once again leaves fisheries
outside its priorities.

02:07:31.792 --> 02:07:36.302
In the list of legislative initiatives for
next year, there are no specific measures

02:07:36.367 --> 02:07:41.032
included for the fisheries sector. I am
particularly pained by the absence of the

02:07:41.077 --> 02:07:43.865
much-needed reform of the
Common Fisheries Policy.

02:07:43.923 --> 02:07:49.215
In September, this Parliament called for
an urgent reform of the CFP in a resolution

02:07:49.282 --> 02:07:54.254
that was widely supported. Moreover, from
the EPP Group we have repeatedly urged the

02:07:54.306 --> 02:07:58.901
Commission to take action, most recently
a couple of weeks ago with a letter signed

02:07:58.960 --> 02:08:03.873
by more than 60 EPP MEPs. That is why I
cannot understand the European Commission’s

02:08:03.929 --> 02:08:08.615
stubbornness in avoiding this reform.
The evaluation of the CFP has shown the

02:08:08.686 --> 02:08:13.500
decline of the fishing fleet. Every
year there are fewer and older boats.

02:08:13.564 --> 02:08:16.688
Fewer fishermen, and those
who remain are also older.

02:08:16.743 --> 02:08:22.352
Lower catches of fish and of lower value.
And profitability that barely reaches 1%.

02:08:22.405 --> 02:08:26.096
In this situation, what is
your response, Mr Šešković?

02:08:26.225 --> 02:08:30.329
To do nothing legislatively.
It is disappointing.

02:08:30.427 --> 02:08:34.347
Commissioner, fishing cannot continue
to be the great forgotten sector of the

02:08:34.403 --> 02:08:39.485
Commission. We urgently need concrete
legislative measures and a clear timetable.

02:08:39.564 --> 02:08:40.764
Thank you.

02:08:42.173 --> 02:08:45.904
Thank you. The floor now goes to the
colleague Baiana, and colleague Dünkenen may

02:08:45.950 --> 02:08:47.150
prepare.

02:08:49.073 --> 02:08:55.830
Thank you. What's this obsession and
temptation to reopen the waterframe directive?

02:08:55.913 --> 02:09:01.126
First, it was critical raw materials;
now it's the European Water Initiative.

02:09:01.193 --> 02:09:05.209
We have already had this debate, and I
was the rapporteur of that initiative.

02:09:05.273 --> 02:09:10.429
You do not solve problems by reopening a
legislation that your own assessments say

02:09:10.508 --> 02:09:14.902
that it is fit for purpose. When
you rightly said that the problem is

02:09:14.976 --> 02:09:20.861
implementation, so I tell you, if the
problem is leakage invest in infrastructure.

02:09:20.933 --> 02:09:24.669
If it is scarcity, improve
efficiency and reuse.

02:09:24.773 --> 02:09:31.025
If it is pollution and force, the rules.
Enough with excuses in order to help the

02:09:31.109 --> 02:09:35.412
companies. Vice President, in your work
program, it looks that you are still

02:09:35.480 --> 02:09:41.836
hesitating. So I tell you, we know where
the gap is, so let's work together and work

02:09:41.921 --> 02:09:51.219
to implement it. Do not reopen. Protect
the water that unites us and the water that

02:09:51.299 --> 02:09:53.753
makes us continue to live and prosper.

02:09:59.933 --> 02:10:01.133
It's 2-0.

02:10:01.853 --> 02:10:14.684
Four. Sorry. Dear President, how has
Europe done with migration this year?

02:10:14.813 --> 02:10:20.465
We have seen gangs of people with
migrant backgrounds destroying Europe.

02:10:20.573 --> 02:10:27.082
Europe has a problem with segregation.
Between summer 25 and summer 26, the EU

02:10:27.168 --> 02:10:33.366
failed to return 321,000 illegal migrants.

02:10:33.473 --> 02:10:40.114
Europe has a problem with returns. In
August, we saw 80,000 Moroccans crossing the

02:10:40.168 --> 02:10:45.740
Spanish border in Ceuta. Europe
has a problem with border control.

02:10:45.833 --> 02:10:51.353
But when I look at the European Commission's
program for the next year, I see a lack

02:10:51.473 --> 02:10:57.875
of solutions. Where is the initiative to
outsource asylum processes outside Europe?

02:10:57.953 --> 02:11:02.474
Where are the projects to
build fences along our borders?

02:11:02.573 --> 02:11:06.757
When will we stop destroying
Europe with migration?

02:11:06.833 --> 02:11:08.033
Thank you.

02:11:11.453 --> 02:11:19.193
Seat 110. Mr. Lopatka, Mr.

02:11:21.413 --> 02:11:23.688
Let me begin by saying
something fundamental.

02:11:23.825 --> 02:11:29.615
In the end, every work programme is
only as good as its implementation.

02:11:29.672 --> 02:11:34.285
The Commission is setting the right priorities
here, but we need to pick up the pace

02:11:34.338 --> 02:11:39.070
when it comes to implementation.
We cannot afford to lose any time.

02:11:39.117 --> 02:11:45.521
In times of war – and I do not understand
many of the Members who have taken the

02:11:45.660 --> 02:11:50.875
floor and still see the solution at
national level and want to give so little

02:11:50.954 --> 02:11:54.555
support to the Commission.
We must not be spectators.

02:11:54.613 --> 02:12:00.889
It is really a shame if we are sitting
in the next room while negotiations are

02:12:00.974 --> 02:12:04.937
taking place about the future of Ukraine
and the fate of the people there.

02:12:05.005 --> 02:12:11.111
We need to become stronger in areas that
concern us – our security, our foreign

02:12:11.181 --> 02:12:15.385
policy, our defence. And that is only
possible if we simultaneously strengthen our

02:12:15.449 --> 02:12:20.463
economic base. The Commission is setting
the right priorities, but the crucial thing

02:12:20.531 --> 02:12:22.553
is to speed up implementation.

02:12:24.653 --> 02:12:29.033
Thank you. Their colleague,
Madame Jurkovic, seat 541.

02:12:33.533 --> 02:12:40.298
Thank you, Chair. Dear Commissioner, the
Commissioner's work program promises a

02:12:40.356 --> 02:12:46.598
stronger and more resilient Europe, but
there is a—where is the health in that

02:12:46.703 --> 02:12:52.320
ambition? You didn't say a word about it.
In parliamentary report on cardiovascular

02:12:52.373 --> 02:12:57.956
health, we explicitly called on the
Commission to present a dedicated European

02:12:58.013 --> 02:13:02.389
prevention strategy, because investing
in prevention delivers twice:

02:13:02.457 --> 02:13:07.416
it saves lives and reduces the
pressure on our healthcare systems.

02:13:07.493 --> 02:13:11.378
And without a comprehensive strategy, we
will continue addressing prevention in

02:13:11.428 --> 02:13:16.516
fragments through isolated initiatives and
campaigns telling people to eat better,

02:13:16.579 --> 02:13:19.837
to exercise more, and
make healthier choices.

02:13:19.913 --> 02:13:24.587
But prevention is not simply a
matter of individual responsibility.

02:13:24.653 --> 02:13:29.150
We cannot ask citizens to make healthy
choices while ignoring the environment that

02:13:29.213 --> 02:13:33.479
shaped those choices. And we need to
tackle all the determinants of health,

02:13:33.548 --> 02:13:37.125
including environmental and
commercial determinants.

02:13:37.193 --> 02:13:42.539
So Commissioner, health and prevention
must become a strategic EU priority.

02:13:42.593 --> 02:13:44.873
So you should listen,
European citizens. Thank you.

02:13:45.773 --> 02:13:49.793
Thank you. Their colleague,
and last, Mr. Tonin, seat 113.

02:13:55.493 --> 02:14:00.749
Honourable Commissioner Šefčovič, the
European Commission has announced in the 2027

02:14:00.869 --> 02:14:06.936
programme that it will begin implementing
what it has long been promising.

02:14:07.034 --> 02:14:13.847
In the field of energy, we have pledged to
ensure people a reliable energy supply at

02:14:13.919 --> 02:14:20.546
affordable prices. The President of the
Commission has repeatedly stressed in her

02:14:20.606 --> 02:14:26.311
speeches that the future hinges on a mix
of renewable energy sources on the one hand

02:14:26.361 --> 02:14:32.057
and nuclear energy on the other. Politically,
a number of statements have been made

02:14:32.126 --> 02:14:39.269
that are heading in the right direction.
However, I have the impression that the

02:14:39.374 --> 02:14:44.187
administration is not following
these political announcements.

02:14:44.283 --> 02:14:50.091
And that, by far, the treatment of nuclear
energy is not nearly as favourable as

02:14:50.159 --> 02:14:55.391
that of renewable energy sources. And if
we want to ensure a secure future, then

02:14:55.443 --> 02:15:00.233
these things need to change. And it
should start with your administration.

02:15:02.093 --> 02:15:07.913
Thank you. Their colleague, Mr. Šefčovič.
It's your chance to close the debate.

02:15:15.113 --> 02:15:17.472
Thank you very much.
Thank you very much, Mr.

02:15:17.513 --> 02:15:24.571
President. Honorable members, I would like
to thank all those honorable members who

02:15:24.633 --> 02:15:30.713
encouraged the Commission, who supported
the program, but let me focus my answer on

02:15:30.818 --> 02:15:41.162
the questions, on some critiques, and on
some clarifications where I think we need

02:15:41.333 --> 02:15:47.269
to react. First and foremost, and I hope
for your indulgence with one or two more

02:15:47.313 --> 02:15:50.770
minutes of the speaking time so I can
answer to most of the questions which have

02:15:50.813 --> 02:15:55.196
been proposed by the honorable members.
First, I would like to absolutely underscore

02:15:55.253 --> 02:16:00.821
and highlight that I totally agree with
the statement of Madame Iratxe Garcia,

02:16:00.965 --> 02:16:06.248
Pérez, that people's
are first. Absolutely.

02:16:06.353 --> 02:16:12.146
That's our key guiding principle. That
was our motto in this and all previous

02:16:12.214 --> 02:16:19.531
commissions' work program. And therefore,
we included in the Commission's work

02:16:19.615 --> 02:16:25.144
program very strong social dimension. And
if you allow, I would just list some of

02:16:25.193 --> 02:16:31.001
the planned key proposals that would
showcase this just to highlight how much we

02:16:31.066 --> 02:16:36.053
want also to mark the 10th anniversary
of the European Pillar of Social Rights,

02:16:36.113 --> 02:16:39.193
which we are going to celebrate next year.

02:16:39.353 --> 02:16:44.765
So in the Commission's work program, you
will find the European Care Deal, you will

02:16:44.834 --> 02:16:49.047
find the proposal for European
University Alliance 2.0.

02:16:49.133 --> 02:16:54.037
Just to make sure that we would deliver
high-quality cross-border education.

02:16:54.113 --> 02:16:59.179
We will work very hard on the skill guarantee,
which is so important for many of the

02:16:59.224 --> 02:17:03.930
young people you've been referring to.
And of course, together with the Vice

02:17:03.984 --> 02:17:09.430
President Fico, we'll be working on making
sure that we will guarantee to the people

02:17:09.533 --> 02:17:13.563
right to stay where they
want to work and live.

02:17:13.673 --> 02:17:17.513
And on top of it, we are going to organize,
and I'm sure that many of you will

02:17:17.573 --> 02:17:23.564
participate, the summit to restate the
commitments to the principles of the European

02:17:23.646 --> 02:17:31.292
Social Pillar next year. If you allow me
just the shorter part to Madame Kelemen's

02:17:31.433 --> 02:17:40.392
on the quality jobs roadmap. We adopted
it in December 2025, and indeed it focused

02:17:40.465 --> 02:17:45.113
on creating and maintaining quality
jobs in Europe and ensuring fairness and

02:17:45.173 --> 02:17:47.393
modernization in the world of work.

02:17:47.573 --> 02:17:52.825
It will also support workers, employers
in the green digital and demographic

02:17:52.888 --> 02:17:57.713
transition, and as announced in their
roadmap and confirmed by the President's 2026

02:17:57.773 --> 02:18:02.609
State of the Union address, Commission
will propose a quality jobs act still this

02:18:02.693 --> 02:18:08.336
year in the first quarter and this proposal
will be based on very thorough two-stage

02:18:08.390 --> 02:18:12.226
social partner consultation that
closed by the end of December.

02:18:12.293 --> 02:18:17.085
And the new law, as Madame Kelemen
was suggesting, will update EU minimum

02:18:17.138 --> 02:18:21.833
requirements protecting workers' health
and safety as well as their rights while

02:18:21.893 --> 02:18:25.733
supporting productivity
and competitiveness.

02:18:25.853 --> 02:18:32.315
Secondly, let me also highlight that when
we talk about competitiveness, we are

02:18:32.382 --> 02:18:36.267
indeed talking about jobs,
people, and livelihoods.

02:18:36.353 --> 02:18:44.340
And therefore, if you are also referring
to the other very important issues like

02:18:44.386 --> 02:18:48.293
several honorable members, I think
last one was my very good colleague Mr.

02:18:48.353 --> 02:18:53.824
López, Aguilar, the conversion
practices, this is announced.

02:18:53.933 --> 02:18:59.729
In the Commission's work program, as
a flagship initiative in annexed one.

02:18:59.993 --> 02:19:07.894
Honorable members, I also would like to
underline and to kind of call upon all of us

02:19:07.973 --> 02:19:13.879
that we shouldn't look at the word
simplification as something toxic.

02:19:14.153 --> 02:19:19.718
Simplification proposals do not change the
EU's environment, climate, or food safety

02:19:19.775 --> 02:19:22.976
objective as some of you have
been concerned or worried.

02:19:23.033 --> 02:19:29.939
They would simply allow stakeholders to
meet, I would say, these new criteria in a

02:19:30.009 --> 02:19:34.682
simple way by removing duplication
and the complex requirement.

02:19:34.733 --> 02:19:38.901
And this is exactly what we hear from our
stakeholders' meetings from the citizens,

02:19:38.948 --> 02:19:44.889
first and foremost, from SMEs,
but also from the big businesses.

02:19:44.993 --> 02:19:50.433
As regards the concerns which you're
presenting by Madame Reitke, Madame Toussaint

02:19:50.518 --> 02:19:57.829
on the birds and habitat reviews, I would
like to underscore once again that for us

02:19:57.883 --> 02:20:02.836
it's very clear that quality of life in
Europe will increasingly depend on our

02:20:02.935 --> 02:20:08.396
ability to adapt to and mitigate
the effects of changing climate.

02:20:08.453 --> 02:20:12.703
And the Commission will stay the
course on our climate targets.

02:20:12.773 --> 02:20:15.477
And we are committed to
protect the environment.

02:20:15.533 --> 02:20:19.613
The review of the nature protection
directives as you referred to, the

02:20:19.733 --> 02:20:27.256
habitat directives, dates back from
1992 and birds directive from 2009.

02:20:27.353 --> 02:20:33.065
So it's the directive
which is 34 years old.

02:20:33.233 --> 02:20:38.387
And therefore, I think that we are doing
the right thing because this review will

02:20:38.468 --> 02:20:43.857
allow us to assess whether, I would underline
the word whether, changes to the legal

02:20:43.914 --> 02:20:48.550
framework are needed. And this would allow
us to continue to effectively achieve the

02:20:48.622 --> 02:20:52.949
objectives which have been
set together in a simple way.

02:20:53.213 --> 02:20:58.441
On climate, mitigation, just give me
some examples because there was a lot of

02:20:58.493 --> 02:21:02.988
references made to the heat
wave and to the heat wave plan.

02:21:03.053 --> 02:21:08.676
I would like again to reassure the honorable
members that the heat wave plan will

02:21:08.747 --> 02:21:13.844
ensure stronger early warning systems,
better health preparedness, and support to

02:21:13.906 --> 02:21:19.677
the people vulnerable to extreme heat. It
will also look at the adaptation of the

02:21:19.741 --> 02:21:24.835
cities to the effect of climate change and
how the climate resilience urban spaces

02:21:24.919 --> 02:21:32.380
are created. And if you allow me one word
on the water initiative, because here this

02:21:32.466 --> 02:21:38.603
initiative will cover measures to address
water scarcity, which adversely affects

02:21:38.672 --> 02:21:41.513
farmers' energy production,
or supply chains.

02:21:41.573 --> 02:21:46.534
For example, through limited availability
of waterways during the drought periods.

02:21:46.613 --> 02:21:50.160
If you allow, Mr. President, a lot of
honorable members have been also making very

02:21:50.222 --> 02:21:55.759
important references to the housing. So
I just would like to recall that this

02:21:55.832 --> 02:22:01.461
Commission is the first one which has
a dedicated commissioner for housing.

02:22:01.553 --> 02:22:06.861
And that this remit was also
enlarged to the specific DG.

02:22:06.953 --> 02:22:12.683
And I know that my colleagues' commissioner,
Jørgensen, is working very hard on this

02:22:12.807 --> 02:22:19.707
file. And therefore, if you look in the
housing simplification package, this package

02:22:19.780 --> 02:22:25.028
will precisely aim at facilitating the
supply of affordable, sustainable, and

02:22:25.086 --> 02:22:30.010
quality housing. And we'll also support
effective implementation of relevant

02:22:30.104 --> 02:22:35.236
European rules. This should happen by
reducing administrative burden, accelerating

02:22:35.309 --> 02:22:40.661
processes, and improving cost efficiency
while respecting the policy goals such as

02:22:40.733 --> 02:22:43.313
climate and environmental protection.

02:22:44.333 --> 02:22:49.435
Madame Toussaint was also
concerned about the PFAS.

02:22:49.553 --> 02:22:56.129
The European Chemical Agency is currently
finalizing a socioeconomic assessment of

02:22:56.213 --> 02:23:00.893
PFAS, or as they are known, forever
chemicals, under which they expect to be

02:23:00.965 --> 02:23:06.603
completed by the end of 2026. And on that
basis, on the basis of this very thorough

02:23:06.653 --> 02:23:11.458
analysis, the Commission, as a risk manager,
will prepare a draft restriction and

02:23:11.510 --> 02:23:15.833
submit it to the vote to the member states'
committee with a view to adopting and

02:23:15.893 --> 02:23:22.085
implementation regulation. As it is derived
as a tertiary legislation, and therefore

02:23:22.157 --> 02:23:26.080
it is not, of course, listed in
the Commission's work program.

02:23:26.153 --> 02:23:31.950
If you allow to react very shortly
to Mr. Buuselager, statement.

02:23:32.033 --> 02:23:35.858
I mean, the big part of that
can absolutely agree with.

02:23:35.933 --> 02:23:41.158
But I also would like to highlight that
under One Europe, One Market, that for us,

02:23:41.262 --> 02:23:48.809
this is clear roadmap for single market
completion by the end of 2027, where most of

02:23:48.881 --> 02:23:54.838
the initiatives are on the table and
the co-legislator will need to find the

02:23:54.913 --> 02:24:01.269
agreements on them. And if you allow me,
I know that you are already very generous

02:24:01.313 --> 02:24:03.731
with the time. The last point,
but it's very crucial, Mr.

02:24:03.773 --> 02:24:11.462
President, on withdrawals. For the
withdrawal annex of 2027, we did an honest

02:24:11.541 --> 02:24:16.611
assessment of all files that had been
pending with co-legislator for a long time.

02:24:16.673 --> 02:24:22.346
Very often, many, many years. Co-legislator
now have the opportunity to react in the

02:24:22.414 --> 02:24:27.644
months to come as stipulated in the
institutional agreement, like every year.

02:24:27.713 --> 02:24:32.697
Your views, we'll be taking into account.
If you can move with this proposals on the

02:24:32.748 --> 02:24:38.171
table, if you can move I can reassure
you, there will be very happy to see that.

02:24:38.273 --> 02:24:44.758
And therefore, I look at the withdrawal
list as a political momentum, as a political

02:24:44.831 --> 02:24:50.879
push to clearly work with the co-legislator
on this file and to see if there is a

02:24:50.929 --> 02:24:55.030
political will to deliver. So, Mr. President,
once again, I would like to thank you

02:24:55.073 --> 02:24:57.813
for your generosity
with the speaking time.

02:24:57.893 --> 02:25:02.282
I hope that I addressed most of
the concerns raised in this room.

02:25:02.333 --> 02:25:06.386
And we are very much looking forward to
work with the European Parliament as a

02:25:06.436 --> 02:25:09.353
co-legislator on delivering the
Commission's work program for the next year.

02:25:09.353 --> 02:25:10.553
Thank you very much, Mr. President.

02:25:10.913 --> 02:25:12.113
Thank you.

02:25:12.533 --> 02:25:16.483
Thank you very much, Mr. Commissioner.
It is a very important debate.

02:25:16.553 --> 02:25:22.447
So it is justified. The
debate now is closed.

02:25:22.553 --> 02:25:31.702
Our next issue is next item on the agenda
is the report by Madame la Señora Pajín

02:25:31.793 --> 02:25:37.714
and Madame Veriga Union Civil Protection
Mechanism and Union Support for Health

02:25:37.803 --> 02:25:40.673
Emergence and Preparedness and Response.

02:25:42.173 --> 02:25:46.553
The floor is now given to my
friend, the rapporteur, Ms Pajín.

02:25:51.713 --> 02:25:56.488
Thank you very much, dear
President. Commissioner, welcome.

02:25:56.597 --> 02:26:04.571
Just a few days ago marked two years
since the most devastating tragedy in our

02:26:04.637 --> 02:26:08.630
country in the region where
I grew up. In Valencia.

02:26:08.706 --> 02:26:13.903
234 people lost their lives in
an absolutely devastating flood.

02:26:13.998 --> 02:26:19.370
And they lost everything. Their homes,
their memories, their loved ones.

02:26:19.461 --> 02:26:24.286
I would like to dedicate, Your
Honour, this debate to those victims.

02:26:24.353 --> 02:26:29.277
They were listened to here. And I pledged
to them that we would work to improve the

02:26:29.326 --> 02:26:32.874
mechanisms for responding
to such disasters.

02:26:32.976 --> 02:26:37.236
And I also want to remember the victims
of the wildfires that have ravaged our

02:26:37.297 --> 02:26:42.532
countries this summer. Spain too. And,
of course, the emergency services, the

02:26:42.591 --> 02:26:47.464
firefighters. To the volunteers. To all
those who come to the rescue in the most

02:26:47.514 --> 02:26:52.598
difficult moments. Because we are
living through times of climate crises.

02:26:52.655 --> 02:26:57.243
And today, other DANAs are once
again striking the Mediterranean.

02:26:57.310 --> 02:27:00.882
Every summer, forest fires will
start earlier and last longer.

02:27:00.962 --> 02:27:04.583
They are more virulent and
more difficult to extinguish.

02:27:04.647 --> 02:27:10.068
And with the pandemic, moreover, we
learned in a very costly way that epidemic

02:27:10.193 --> 02:27:17.358
outbreaks come and spread in the time it
takes a person to travel from one place to

02:27:17.445 --> 02:27:21.111
another. And therefore, that global
health crises are also important.

02:27:21.148 --> 02:27:23.224
The climate emergency is now
the new normal on our planet.

02:27:23.260 --> 02:27:28.594
And at the same time, there are new
hybrid risks that are drawing ever closer.

02:27:28.710 --> 02:27:32.993
That is why, to tackle these risks, the
European Union has equipped itself with a

02:27:33.031 --> 02:27:36.668
European civil protection mechanism,
which is now 25 years old.

02:27:36.790 --> 02:27:42.957
This is surely the clearest and most
concrete expression of the solidarity of the

02:27:43.060 --> 02:27:46.524
European people, of
the European countries.

02:27:46.573 --> 02:27:51.094
Parliament has welcomed the Commission's
new proposal to improve this mechanism,

02:27:51.149 --> 02:27:54.494
above all in its anticipation
and prevention phase.

02:27:54.577 --> 02:27:58.387
And we must do this first and
foremost by providing more resources.

02:27:58.457 --> 02:28:03.525
We cannot respond better to new crises,
which we say are more virulent and more

02:28:03.589 --> 02:28:05.513
complex, with fewer resources.

02:28:05.933 --> 02:28:09.986
We need more. We also have
to improve our coordination.

02:28:10.045 --> 02:28:15.106
In times of crisis, we must cooperate
and we must share information.

02:28:15.171 --> 02:28:21.582
And we must deploy the best mechanisms
and the best capabilities for everyone.

02:28:21.639 --> 02:28:26.080
But we must also put the best scientific
evidence at the service of public policies.

02:28:26.136 --> 02:28:29.743
We must gather the best knowledge
and turn it into real solutions.

02:28:29.815 --> 02:28:34.117
We must strengthen the capacities and
resources available to respond better to

02:28:34.165 --> 02:28:36.831
crises. But above all,
we need to anticipate.

02:28:36.887 --> 02:28:40.687
To prevent better. To be able to
get there before what happens.

02:28:40.753 --> 02:28:45.908
The shared objective of almost all the
groups in this House is precisely to achieve

02:28:45.970 --> 02:28:50.140
a resilient society. One that has
a true culture of preparedness.

02:28:50.195 --> 02:28:55.030
Inclusive, supportive, to face all risks.
That is why our message is very clear.

02:28:55.088 --> 02:28:58.074
We cannot do more with less.
We need more resources.

02:28:58.132 --> 02:29:03.428
But we also need to have a greater capacity
for prevention and, above all, to make

02:29:03.507 --> 02:29:06.912
citizens understand what
their role is in these crises.

02:29:06.975 --> 02:29:10.984
Knowing when to act, how to
act, with what resources to act.

02:29:11.041 --> 02:29:15.003
We must educate that population.
Lastly, we also have to fight against

02:29:15.089 --> 02:29:20.140
disinformation. Against falsehoods. Which
cause so much damage in these crises.

02:29:20.195 --> 02:29:24.289
But for that, we also need tools. Tools
that will fight against that disinformation.

02:29:24.328 --> 02:29:29.619
We have woven a high level of consensus
and we understand that the proposal that

02:29:29.698 --> 02:29:32.537
that we will debate today
is a better proposal.

02:29:32.606 --> 02:29:37.590
That is why we hope that tomorrow’s vote,
all that technical work, that political

02:29:37.659 --> 02:29:41.733
capacity, will translate into a
resounding political consensus.

02:29:41.793 --> 02:29:46.454
So that we can have a mechanism that
protects lives, that anticipates crises and

02:29:46.507 --> 02:29:48.833
that is more effective.
Thank you very much.

02:29:51.173 --> 02:29:53.273
Thank you very much, Ms Pajín.

02:29:53.993 --> 02:29:58.073
Mr. Veriga, you have the
floor. As reporter as well.

02:29:59.153 --> 02:30:04.719
Thank you. President, Commissioner,
first I would like to sincerely thank

02:30:04.793 --> 02:30:10.961
Corrapporteur Leire Pajín for her constructive
cooperation throughout this process.

02:30:11.033 --> 02:30:16.133
I would also like to thank all the shadow
reporters and all members of Parliament

02:30:16.193 --> 02:30:21.293
who contributed with their proposals and
all the technical stuff for their expertise

02:30:21.353 --> 02:30:28.725
and excellent work together. Today Europe
is faced with a fundamentally different

02:30:28.793 --> 02:30:32.936
environment from the one
we knew just a decade ago.

02:30:33.053 --> 02:30:38.072
The report prepared by former Finnish
President Sauli Niinistö clearly identifies

02:30:38.148 --> 02:30:44.284
the challenges we must be ready to face.
Military aggression, hybrid attacks, cyber

02:30:44.358 --> 02:30:50.239
threats, disruption to critical infrastructure,
pandemics, and increasingly severe

02:30:50.297 --> 02:30:55.521
climate-related disasters. Building on
the recommendations of this report, the

02:30:55.589 --> 02:31:00.131
strategy promotes a whole-of-society
and whole-of-government approach.

02:31:00.233 --> 02:31:05.795
We cannot limit ourselves to responding
to disasters after they have happened.

02:31:05.873 --> 02:31:13.570
We must invest in preparing our institutions
and professionals and societies before

02:31:13.673 --> 02:31:20.001
emergencies occur. The COVID-19 pandemic
thought as a very important lesson.

02:31:20.093 --> 02:31:24.662
Even the wealthiest and most developed
European countries were not sufficiently

02:31:24.713 --> 02:31:30.962
prepared for a major health emergency.
Health preparedness must become a clearly

02:31:31.013 --> 02:31:35.734
defined and properly financed part
of the European Civil Protection.

02:31:35.813 --> 02:31:42.475
We need strategic reserves, trained
professionals, sufficient emergency capacity,

02:31:42.551 --> 02:31:47.624
and effective cross-border cooperation.
At the same time, we are witnessing

02:31:47.681 --> 02:31:52.087
increasingly severe
climate-related emergencies.

02:31:52.193 --> 02:31:59.219
These events threaten lives, destroy
infrastructure, disrupt essential services.

02:31:59.333 --> 02:32:05.949
South and East European countries are
particularly exposed to wildfires, droughts,

02:32:06.031 --> 02:32:13.130
and extreme heat. Other regions face
serious flooding and severe storms.

02:32:13.253 --> 02:32:19.193
For countries along the European Union's
eastern border, including my own country

02:32:19.283 --> 02:32:24.193
Lithuania, the situation
is even more complicated.

02:32:24.293 --> 02:32:30.171
We face not only natural disasters but
also the very real possibility of military

02:32:30.263 --> 02:32:34.133
aggression, hybrid
attacks, sabotage, cyber

02:32:34.433 --> 02:32:39.638
operations, and the deliberate
disruption of critical infrastructure.

02:32:39.713 --> 02:32:44.993
We must prepare not only for natural
disasters but also for situations where civil

02:32:45.053 --> 02:32:50.757
military cooperation is essential to
support society during military or hybrid

02:32:50.841 --> 02:32:56.734
threats, while respecting Member States'
competences and preserving the UCPM's

02:32:56.813 --> 02:33:04.649
civilian nature. This means strengthening
emergency services, evacuation capacities,

02:33:04.733 --> 02:33:10.393
shelters, communications, and the ability
of public institutions to maintain

02:33:10.515 --> 02:33:16.313
essential functions. European solidarity
must be based on a common level of

02:33:16.373 --> 02:33:22.240
ambition, but it must also recognize the
specific risks faced by different Member

02:33:22.297 --> 02:33:27.082
States and regions. Finally, none of
these ambitions can be achieved without

02:33:27.151 --> 02:33:32.125
adequate financing. And I would like to
thank my colleagues for their support in our

02:33:32.190 --> 02:33:37.975
efforts to secure a larger budget for the
UCPM and a clearer allocation of resources

02:33:38.033 --> 02:33:44.282
to different areas of preparedness,
particularly health emergency preparedness.

02:33:44.393 --> 02:33:49.913
Dear colleagues, the cost of
preparedness might seem significant.

02:33:50.033 --> 02:33:58.821
But the cost of not being unprepared is
always much higher measured not only in

02:33:58.895 --> 02:34:02.546
financial losses but
above all in human lives.

02:34:02.633 --> 02:34:06.584
So therefore, I call all of
you to support this document.

02:34:06.653 --> 02:34:07.853
Thank you.

02:34:08.573 --> 02:34:10.433
Thank you very much, Mr. Veriga.

02:34:12.053 --> 02:34:18.064
Thank you very much, Mr. Veriga.
My next speaker is Madame La Rive.

02:34:18.173 --> 02:34:19.373
On behalf of the Commission.

02:34:24.473 --> 02:34:29.715
Honorable Members, thank you first of
all for this opportunity to discuss the

02:34:29.842 --> 02:34:37.038
proposal on the UCPM and I would like first
of all to thank you, the Parliament and

02:34:37.106 --> 02:34:42.471
especially the two rapporteurs. You know
that indeed last week we celebrated the

02:34:42.535 --> 02:34:47.540
25th anniversary of the Union Civil
Protection Mechanism here in Brussels.

02:34:47.633 --> 02:34:53.846
2,500 fighters rescuers, young people,
social partners, and businesses from 80

02:34:53.928 --> 02:35:00.116
nationalities came to Brussels to exchange
on and brainstorming on the way we

02:35:00.227 --> 02:35:06.110
prepare for and respond to emergencies.
And this was indeed an occasion to

02:35:06.173 --> 02:35:11.863
acknowledge the contribution of the
UCPM in the last quarter of century.

02:35:11.993 --> 02:35:20.476
And since its creation, the UCPM has
been activated more than 900 times by 160

02:35:20.753 --> 02:35:26.375
countries. For wildfires, floods,
earthquakes, population displacement,

02:35:26.444 --> 02:35:31.639
repatriation, medical evacuations,
and many, many other operations.

02:35:31.733 --> 02:35:36.354
Our UCPM is an operational tool that
makes a difference on the ground.

02:35:36.413 --> 02:35:42.567
And in recent years, it has been
activated 10 times more than at its start.

02:35:42.713 --> 02:35:49.911
The UCPM is what Europe can do best when
we stand together but we need to update and

02:35:49.990 --> 02:35:55.183
enhance it for the future. And I would
like again to thank the European Parliament

02:35:55.233 --> 02:36:00.143
for your constructive cooperation and for
the report that you will be putting to the

02:36:00.218 --> 02:36:06.223
vote tomorrow. Your report reflects the
Parliament's strong engagement with this

02:36:06.296 --> 02:36:11.265
proposal and our shared recognition that
Europe must be better prepared and capable

02:36:11.333 --> 02:36:18.345
of anticipating and effectively
managing future disasters and crises.

02:36:18.473 --> 02:36:25.981
The proposals draws from recent lessons.
Climate-related events, COVID-19 pandemic,

02:36:26.044 --> 02:36:31.518
and Russia's war of aggression against
Ukraine expose critical vulnerabilities in

02:36:31.590 --> 02:36:37.865
our collective system and show that
preparedness requires collective action at EU

02:36:38.021 --> 02:36:43.923
level. Recent developments such as the
Ebola outbreak in Central Africa are

02:36:43.986 --> 02:36:48.667
reminders of the health threats
we must be ready to face.

02:36:48.773 --> 02:36:55.331
These complex risks require stronger
systemic preparedness and proactive and

02:36:55.390 --> 02:36:59.007
coordinated approach
across different sectors.

02:36:59.093 --> 02:37:04.433
And to look at risk and threat
with 360-degree approach.

02:37:05.093 --> 02:37:11.653
Crises are increasingly interconnected
across multiple sectors and regions.

02:37:11.753 --> 02:37:18.214
This is precisely why the Commission proposed
a single instrument bringing together

02:37:18.293 --> 02:37:23.597
civil protection and funding for health
emergency preparedness and response.

02:37:23.693 --> 02:37:29.031
And this is also why we have proposed
establishing a crisis coordination hub and

02:37:29.108 --> 02:37:33.072
strengthening the civil
military cooperation.

02:37:33.173 --> 02:37:40.679
Our goal is simple. We must equip the
Union with an integrated all-hazards and

02:37:40.761 --> 02:37:46.656
cross-sectoral framework. By breaking
down silos, we can act faster and more

02:37:46.741 --> 02:37:54.100
effectively when the next crisis comes
to support our Member States or other in

02:37:54.213 --> 02:37:59.121
need. I therefore welcome the Parliament's
report which strongly backs the core

02:37:59.178 --> 02:38:05.986
pillars of our proposals. Let me now turn
to the budget, where I appreciate your

02:38:06.053 --> 02:38:10.433
support for an expanded
financial envelope.

02:38:10.613 --> 02:38:14.468
We have put forward an
instrument with a budget of 10.

02:38:14.573 --> 02:38:19.282
7 billion reflecting the scale
of the challenges we face.

02:38:19.373 --> 02:38:27.046
In today's unpredictable world, this
level of ambition is really essential.

02:38:27.173 --> 02:38:32.838
In this slide, the discussions in
the Council are really concerning.

02:38:32.933 --> 02:38:40.203
Some capitals still see preparedness as a
cost, but past crises have shown that the

02:38:40.286 --> 02:38:47.899
cost of not being prepared is much higher
for our lives, for our societies, but also

02:38:47.969 --> 02:38:51.859
for our economies.
Preparedness is not a cost.

02:38:51.953 --> 02:38:58.836
It is an investment in building a stronger
and more resilient Union and protecting

02:38:58.913 --> 02:39:05.031
our citizens. At the same time, this
instrument must remain operationally agile and

02:39:05.093 --> 02:39:11.132
financially flexible. We cannot predict
what will happen in the next seven years.

02:39:11.213 --> 02:39:17.603
Therefore, earmarking would limit our
ability to move resources rapidly where they

02:39:17.691 --> 02:39:23.516
are most needed. I count on your continued
cooperation and you can count on mine to

02:39:23.570 --> 02:39:28.729
continue to support this House and the
Council towards a timely agreement on that

02:39:28.833 --> 02:39:36.893
proposal. This is essential to ensure the
necessary preparations in 2027 and allow

02:39:37.013 --> 02:39:41.453
the program to start strongly
in 2028 without delay.

02:39:41.573 --> 02:39:42.773
Thank you.

02:39:44.093 --> 02:39:47.624
Thank you, very much, Madame Commissioner.

02:39:47.693 --> 02:39:51.833
On behalf of the City
Committee, Mr. Terrebes.

02:39:55.493 --> 02:40:00.487
Thank you. Dear colleagues, on behalf of
many peoples in AXA and the City Committee,

02:40:00.528 --> 02:40:04.682
it is my pleasure to inform you that the
Civil Protection Mechanism represents one

02:40:04.754 --> 02:40:11.128
of the most comprehensive files for
crisis responses written in recent years.

02:40:11.213 --> 02:40:15.833
The core of CPM is resilience, our ability
to withstand or recover quickly from

02:40:15.923 --> 02:40:21.413
threats we face. It covers a range of
responsible capabilities, tools, and resources

02:40:21.473 --> 02:40:27.245
the EU needs to assist Member States
coping with the mounting challenges we are

02:40:27.327 --> 02:40:33.131
faced with every year. This includes
installing in our leadership the tools needed

02:40:33.189 --> 02:40:36.800
to overcome the ever-expanding
threats of hybrid warfare.

02:40:36.893 --> 02:40:41.739
We were able to ensure key pillars were
added into the CPM so that Member States

02:40:41.787 --> 02:40:46.152
were given the much-needed resources
and force multipliers to enhance our

02:40:46.238 --> 02:40:51.901
resilience. The five key points are
shelters, and protective spaces, critical

02:40:51.953 --> 02:40:57.962
infrastructure, protection, civilian and
military cooperation, volunteers, and joint

02:40:58.043 --> 02:41:03.638
training. We must be realistic about the
challenges we face and the fact that they

02:41:03.703 --> 02:41:09.206
will grow in the upcoming years. Yet,
we must remain optimistic that with

02:41:09.276 --> 02:41:14.854
initiatives such as CPM, we will get stronger
and move faster than the situation can

02:41:14.929 --> 02:41:16.129
worsen. Thank you.

02:41:16.733 --> 02:41:17.933
Thank you very much.

02:41:18.353 --> 02:41:19.313
Thank you.

02:41:19.313 --> 02:41:26.288
Thank you very much, dear colleague.
On behalf of the DFEC Committee, Mr.

02:41:26.393 --> 02:41:27.413
Schornstedt.

02:41:27.413 --> 02:41:27.893
No.

02:41:27.893 --> 02:41:29.093
Mr. Andrews.

02:41:29.813 --> 02:41:31.013
It's okay.

02:41:31.493 --> 02:41:34.305
Mr. Schornstedt is over
there. Thank you, Mr.

02:41:34.373 --> 02:41:38.750
President. Commissioner, colleagues,
obviously like everybody else, I very much

02:41:38.789 --> 02:41:41.460
welcome the expansion of the
Civil Protection Mechanism.

02:41:41.513 --> 02:41:44.931
I think it's one of the most successful
programs under your leadership,

02:41:44.971 --> 02:41:49.964
Commissioner, that we have had as an
expression of our influence across the

02:41:50.033 --> 02:41:52.858
neighborhood, and that's
been very much welcome.

02:41:52.913 --> 02:41:57.538
It's like an insurance policy, an effectively
we're expanding our insurance cover by

02:41:57.593 --> 02:42:01.469
moving into health resilience. And I think
it's really important that we recognize

02:42:01.505 --> 02:42:05.371
that we cannot construct that
resilience just within our EU borders.

02:42:05.453 --> 02:42:10.603
And that's why the development committee
insists that we extend the remit to fragile

02:42:10.648 --> 02:42:14.873
and conflict-affected countries, particularly
around the Mediterranean, the Sahel,

02:42:14.921 --> 02:42:18.538
and the Horn of Africa. Their health
security is our health security.

02:42:18.593 --> 02:42:21.173
Their strength is our
strength. There are no silos.

02:42:21.233 --> 02:42:25.157
And I know we can rely on you, Commissioner,
to ensure that what we are developing

02:42:25.202 --> 02:42:30.206
here aligns with the EU Global Health
Strategy, but also the EU framework on one

02:42:30.293 --> 02:42:34.865
health. I know that you will also ensure
that the crisis coordination hub engages

02:42:34.933 --> 02:42:39.338
with fragile and conflict-affected countries,
to make sure that we have protocols

02:42:39.392 --> 02:42:42.354
around reporting and
frameworks around information.

02:42:42.413 --> 02:42:46.393
And finally, I recommend that we extend
this to the overseas countries and

02:42:46.443 --> 02:42:48.739
territories. And that's contained
in the development opinion.

02:42:48.773 --> 02:42:51.907
Thank you very much.
Thank you very much, Mr.

02:42:51.953 --> 02:42:58.724
Andrews. On behalf of the budget
committee of the committee, the real Mr.

02:42:58.793 --> 02:42:59.993
Schornstedt.

02:43:02.153 --> 02:43:07.569
Thank you very much, Mr President. The
European Civil Protection Mechanism is a very

02:43:07.632 --> 02:43:12.714
good example of concrete European
cooperation, and the proposal is welcome.

02:43:12.765 --> 02:43:17.567
However, when we examined it in the Committee
on Budgetary Control, it is also clear

02:43:17.633 --> 02:43:22.521
that there are significant risks
from a budgetary control perspective.

02:43:22.577 --> 02:43:28.566
And this is something that is confirmed
by a recent report from the European Court

02:43:28.613 --> 02:43:33.096
of Auditors. Here we have a mix of funding
sources, with the main responsibility

02:43:33.167 --> 02:43:38.624
lying with the participating countries.
The EU’s role in this area is increasing,

02:43:38.679 --> 02:43:43.359
and there is a significant risk of double
funding, both in terms of national and EU

02:43:43.472 --> 02:43:47.779
funding, as well as between
different EU programmes.

02:43:47.826 --> 02:43:52.215
We want to address this by increasing
transparency and traceability, by taking

02:43:52.270 --> 02:43:56.750
concrete measures to prevent double
financing, and by defining what the EU’s added

02:43:56.805 --> 02:44:01.738
value actually consists of. It is also
necessary to clarify the explicit audit

02:44:01.802 --> 02:44:05.429
rights of the EU’s relevant
bodies in this area.

02:44:05.508 --> 02:44:07.557
Some of our proposals
have been taken on board.

02:44:07.604 --> 02:44:10.193
There could have been a few
more, but we welcome it anyway.

02:44:10.613 --> 02:44:11.813
Thank you, Mr President.

02:44:12.893 --> 02:44:16.496
Thank you very much, dear colleague.
On behalf of the Reggie Committee, Mr.

02:44:16.553 --> 02:44:17.753
Preblich.

02:44:23.573 --> 02:44:29.720
I will speak in Slovenian. Honourable
colleagues, my report on this topic was

02:44:29.800 --> 02:44:33.828
adopted in the REGGIE
committee six months ago.

02:44:33.904 --> 02:44:39.696
Since then, more than 35,000 Europeans
have died as a result of climate change,

02:44:39.786 --> 02:44:46.438
direct damage amounting to more than €13
billion has been caused, and our economy

02:44:46.486 --> 02:44:49.823
has suffered a loss of more
than €100 billion in revenue.

02:44:49.902 --> 02:44:56.952
And Europe, every time a crisis strikes,
just chases the damage after the fact.

02:44:57.036 --> 02:45:01.813
This is largely a failure of policy
and is completely unacceptable.

02:45:01.866 --> 02:45:06.496
I myself maintain that we do not need
just minor fixes, but we must be more

02:45:06.567 --> 02:45:13.464
ambitious. We need RescEU 2.0, a permanently
ready European reserve aircraft, health

02:45:13.541 --> 02:45:18.009
teams and rescue units that will be
available within a matter of hours.

02:45:18.092 --> 02:45:23.808
Investing in this security is currently
the most important investment, more so than

02:45:23.868 --> 02:45:29.269
is the case for conventional defence. Above
all, however, we need a common European

02:45:29.333 --> 02:45:33.799
responsiveness. In crises, European
action must be an unconditional duty;

02:45:33.871 --> 02:45:37.504
let us stop creating tragedies
and start preventing them.

02:45:37.541 --> 02:45:38.741
Thank you.

02:45:38.933 --> 02:45:43.208
Thank you very much, dear colleague.
Thank you very much, dear colleague.

02:45:43.253 --> 02:45:49.866
We already have enough cuts that I
request, so I'm going to close the option.

02:45:49.973 --> 02:45:53.273
Now, on behalf of the
EPP group, Mr. Armond.

02:45:54.653 --> 02:45:56.412
Thank you very much, Mr
President, Commissioner.

02:45:56.449 --> 02:46:02.399
This is about European civil protection,
the Civil Protection Mechanism, which we

02:46:02.509 --> 02:46:05.699
have been working on together
here over the past few months.

02:46:05.745 --> 02:46:09.814
I could now say something about every article
here, but instead I would like to tell

02:46:09.861 --> 02:46:13.021
you a story that happened while
we were negotiating this text.

02:46:13.060 --> 02:46:19.500
At the time, I was in my homeland in East
Belgium, in a 3,000-hectare forest that

02:46:19.586 --> 02:46:25.494
was on fire. And during this fire, we
activated this civil protection mechanism.

02:46:25.581 --> 02:46:30.015
This means that firefighting aircraft
came from two other countries, helicopters

02:46:30.059 --> 02:46:34.600
from six other countries, the fire was
really bad, but the help that arrived was

02:46:34.670 --> 02:46:40.231
good. That was European solidarity. We all
know that these disasters are increasing,

02:46:40.297 --> 02:46:46.583
they are increasing exponentially. The
fires, the droughts, the storms, the

02:46:46.680 --> 02:46:49.784
pandemics – this will increase.
So we need to be better prepared.

02:46:49.850 --> 02:46:54.847
That means we need to build a small
civil protection army, buy firefighting

02:46:54.918 --> 02:47:00.586
aircraft, have them built here, we need
to expand this crisis centre in Brussels,

02:47:00.649 --> 02:47:07.479
which has been coordinating these fires,
and turn it into a hub that can coordinate

02:47:07.584 --> 02:47:11.771
when multiple pandemics or
environmental disasters occur.

02:47:11.827 --> 02:47:15.447
And above all, we need to think about the
people who are there when nature strikes,

02:47:15.499 --> 02:47:18.492
and that is the firefighters,
the volunteer firefighters.

02:47:18.545 --> 02:47:22.462
We need to remove administrative hurdles
for them so they can continue this

02:47:22.510 --> 02:47:27.047
voluntary work. But we also need to involve
farmers and contractors who voluntarily

02:47:27.106 --> 02:47:30.735
drive to the scene with their water
tankers in the event of a fire.

02:47:30.802 --> 02:47:36.140
We need to integrate them into our crisis
plans, and that will improve our disaster

02:47:36.206 --> 02:47:41.649
protection. Disaster protection means not
having to improvise when nature strikes;

02:47:41.728 --> 02:47:46.016
disaster protection means being well
prepared so that we can protect what is

02:47:46.069 --> 02:47:48.839
important to us. That is
our people and our homeland.

02:47:48.860 --> 02:47:50.060
Thank you.

02:47:50.633 --> 02:47:53.995
Thank you very much, dear colleague.
On behalf of the S&D group, Mr.

02:47:54.053 --> 02:47:55.253
Andrew Cattis.

02:47:57.893 --> 02:48:03.299
Thank you. Dear colleagues, in front of
simultaneously occurring wildfires, floods,

02:48:03.364 --> 02:48:09.660
pandemics, and hybrid threats, funding for
union civil protection mechanism must not

02:48:09.826 --> 02:48:15.997
be cut. With no financial envelope,
with 100 flexibility is problematic.

02:48:16.073 --> 02:48:21.722
With no floor for either civil protection
or health preparedness, there is no legal

02:48:21.836 --> 02:48:28.802
guarantee what share either will get. We
must have untouchable reserves, 30% of

02:48:28.964 --> 02:48:34.886
which is for health emergencies. Health
preparedness cannot be whatever funding

02:48:34.952 --> 02:48:38.895
remains after everything
else has been allocated.

02:48:38.993 --> 02:48:43.833
We should invest in our healthcare
workforce, firefighters, and volunteers.

02:48:43.913 --> 02:48:49.388
Preparedness plans for climate-related
risks, including anticipation, prevention,

02:48:49.461 --> 02:48:55.095
and regional vulnerability mapping, creation
of recovery readiness frameworks, and

02:48:55.149 --> 02:49:02.622
stockpiling medical countermeasures, must
be urgently implemented at union level.

02:49:02.753 --> 02:49:07.642
To the council, I say this:
35% cut is not a saving.

02:49:07.733 --> 02:49:12.943
It only pushes the cost forward. There
are not just tangible costs, but also the

02:49:13.009 --> 02:49:16.322
cost of human life. Preparedness
is never a waste of money.

02:49:16.373 --> 02:49:19.073
Being unprepared always costs more.

02:49:21.413 --> 02:49:25.673
Thank you very much, dear colleague. On
behalf of the PFE group, Madame Connexta.

02:49:28.013 --> 02:49:30.953
Dear colleagues, Mr
President, Commissioner.

02:49:31.193 --> 02:49:35.452
Wherever floods or any other natural disaster
strike in the European Union, European

02:49:35.499 --> 02:49:39.830
assistance must be swift and effective.
But, for example, decisions on the

02:49:39.883 --> 02:49:43.986
deployment of Czech firefighters, our
hospitals and crisis plans must be made in the

02:49:44.036 --> 02:49:48.769
Czech Republic, not in Brussels. This
proposal links civil protection with health

02:49:48.819 --> 02:49:53.136
crises. It expands European coordination
and envisages more than €12 billion.

02:49:53.191 --> 02:49:58.410
However, the French Senate has already
questioned whether the proposal sufficiently

02:49:58.459 --> 02:50:00.843
respects the competences
of the Member States.

02:50:00.895 --> 02:50:04.111
This is already becoming
something of a classic.

02:50:04.169 --> 02:50:08.384
Every time something is reformed, greater
centralisation is introduced and Brussels

02:50:08.442 --> 02:50:12.955
usurps more powers. So where does
assistance end and interference in the

02:50:13.009 --> 02:50:17.776
decision-making of Member States begin?
I support the sharing of equipment,

02:50:17.832 --> 02:50:20.759
supplies, information and
an increase in resources.

02:50:20.819 --> 02:50:25.108
However, I will not support a proposal
that does not provide sufficiently clear

02:50:25.167 --> 02:50:29.860
guarantees that the final say in resolving
crises in a given Member State will rest

02:50:29.935 --> 02:50:31.313
with that Member State.

02:50:33.653 --> 02:50:38.044
Thank you very much, dear colleague. On
behalf of the ECR group, Vice President

02:50:38.088 --> 02:50:39.288
Sverna.

02:50:43.193 --> 02:50:49.448
Commissioner, colleagues, we have now reached
the voting stage on this mechanism for

02:50:49.508 --> 02:50:54.464
the revision of the Union civil protection
mechanism and I would first of all like

02:50:54.528 --> 02:50:58.598
to thank the rapporteurs, Ms Pagini and Ms
Veriga, for their excellent work and all

02:50:58.645 --> 02:51:03.055
the colleagues, and for their commitment
and efforts to create a synthesis and to

02:51:03.106 --> 02:51:09.356
collaborate during these negotiations. We
know how complex it is precisely because

02:51:09.418 --> 02:51:14.910
it involves finding a compromise on
mechanisms that affect Member States, directly

02:51:14.958 --> 02:51:18.933
touching each one in terms of their
specificities, whether technical or

02:51:18.999 --> 02:51:23.679
geographical, with different traditions,
and above all with first-instance

02:51:23.734 --> 02:51:28.147
intervention. For Italy, as you know,
ensuring the effectiveness of the Union

02:51:28.210 --> 02:51:31.930
mechanism is fundamental. Our country has
a consolidated system and therefore we

02:51:31.980 --> 02:51:35.117
have contributed; we hope
to improve this proposal.

02:51:35.171 --> 02:51:39.651
We are aware of the need for strengthening,
precisely because situations—including

02:51:39.706 --> 02:51:44.274
geopolitical ones—demand it. I hope that
the vote in this plenary session and the

02:51:44.311 --> 02:51:47.719
discussion we are holding today, the vote
that will take place in the coming days,

02:51:47.769 --> 02:51:51.895
will help to improve it even further and
make it truly useful for our national

02:51:51.958 --> 02:51:56.122
systems, the European mechanism in general
and, above all, to provide concrete and

02:51:56.176 --> 02:51:58.828
immediate responses to
all European citizens.

02:51:58.892 --> 02:52:00.092
Thank you.

02:52:00.533 --> 02:52:04.988
Grazie, onorevole. On behalf
of the Renew group, Mr.

02:52:05.093 --> 02:52:06.293
Alion.

02:52:07.853 --> 02:52:12.769
Mr President, Commissioner, dear colleagues,
here in this Assembly we are defending

02:52:12.823 --> 02:52:15.537
an ambitious budget
alongside the Commission.

02:52:15.608 --> 02:52:20.953
We are calling for more than €12.4 billion
for the benefit of the European Union

02:52:20.995 --> 02:52:25.304
Civil Protection Mechanism, while some
Member States are trying to cut it by more

02:52:25.391 --> 02:52:28.591
than a third. Why are we
defending this position?

02:52:28.646 --> 02:52:34.576
Because this mechanism is indispensable.
More than 900 activations since 2001, more

02:52:34.673 --> 02:52:38.980
than 12 mobilisations in 2026, and
civil protection must not be a budgetary

02:52:39.040 --> 02:52:44.275
adjustment variable. Some have said
it: we need to move from reaction to

02:52:44.332 --> 02:52:48.700
anticipation, to prevent and prepare
populations, but above all by relying on

02:52:48.766 --> 02:52:53.917
elected representatives and our local
areas, which are at the heart of resilience.

02:52:53.971 --> 02:52:58.350
We must also promote local engagement,
through firefighters, farmers and volunteers

02:52:58.411 --> 02:53:03.317
who are involved, and establish a European
Resilience Day and, above all, a European

02:53:03.378 --> 02:53:07.692
Resilience Label to highlight what
our local authorities are doing.

02:53:07.762 --> 02:53:12.108
Finally, to strengthen European sovereignty,
Commissioner, with the need to have

02:53:12.169 --> 02:53:16.807
European air capabilities, a European
civil protection industry to reduce our

02:53:16.856 --> 02:53:22.457
dependence on the outside. Because our
ability to protect Europeans must be in our

02:53:22.515 --> 02:53:24.713
hands and not in those
of others. Thank you.

02:53:26.093 --> 02:53:28.433
Thank you. On behalf.

02:53:28.973 --> 02:53:31.073
Of the Greens and Madame Merz.

02:53:35.813 --> 02:53:42.101
Thank you, dear President. Wildfires
flood heatwaves, pandemics, and health

02:53:42.175 --> 02:53:48.415
emergencies. The crisis Europe faces are
becoming increasingly frequent, complex,

02:53:48.498 --> 02:53:53.615
and interconnected. They all
remind us of one simple fact:

02:53:53.704 --> 02:53:57.593
disasters do not stop at national borders.

02:53:57.713 --> 02:54:04.348
Neither should our response. The text we
are voting takes an important step towards

02:54:04.411 --> 02:54:08.115
a more coordinated European
civil protection mechanism.

02:54:08.213 --> 02:54:14.780
Because protecting people means addressing
climate risk, strengthening the health

02:54:14.844 --> 02:54:19.415
system, and ensuring
no one is left behind.

02:54:19.553 --> 02:54:26.153
We often say that Europe grows stronger in
times of crisis, but this does not happen

02:54:26.228 --> 02:54:34.313
by itself. It takes political will,
solidarity, and courage to act together.

02:54:34.433 --> 02:54:41.589
And that means acting before disaster
strikes, not just reacting when it does.

02:54:41.693 --> 02:54:47.096
So let us take that responsibility. Let
us build a Europe that is better prepared,

02:54:47.153 --> 02:54:50.846
more resilient, and ready
to protect everyone.

02:54:50.933 --> 02:54:52.133
Thank you.

02:54:52.253 --> 02:54:56.513
Thank you, dear colleagues. On behalf
of the Left, La Signora Martins.

02:55:03.353 --> 02:55:07.126
Mr President, Commissioner, the question
is not whether we will spend more on civil

02:55:07.180 --> 02:55:11.457
protection, because we will. The question
is whether we are spending it well.

02:55:11.499 --> 02:55:15.533
Today, in Portugal, civil protection is
asking the population to stay at home, which

02:55:15.577 --> 02:55:19.315
is easier for those who have a safe home
than for those who have no roof over their

02:55:19.365 --> 02:55:23.333
heads or are still waiting for a
roof since last winter's storms.

02:55:23.389 --> 02:55:28.218
And even before the storm arrived, floods,
thousands of people without electricity

02:55:28.302 --> 02:55:33.489
due to heavy rainfall. Extreme weather
events are becoming more frequent, and the

02:55:33.548 --> 02:55:39.225
infrastructure is not prepared. A European
Union budget that cuts spending on

02:55:39.287 --> 02:55:44.593
transition and adaptation to invest in
weapons is, for that very reason, a tragedy.

02:55:44.670 --> 02:55:49.746
And the same applies to civil protection.
Fighter jets and military frigates do not

02:55:49.804 --> 02:55:55.284
put out fires or rescue flood victims. Civil
aid needs its own budget, a robust one,

02:55:55.354 --> 02:56:00.408
exclusively civilian, that does not live
off scraps nor serve as a shortcut to

02:56:00.463 --> 02:56:04.807
finance the war machine under
the pretext of dual use.

02:56:04.874 --> 02:56:10.756
We support Parliament’s proposal in calling
for support for countries on the front

02:56:10.836 --> 02:56:16.367
line, health reserves, rights for
firefighters, and rapid recovery mechanisms.

02:56:16.431 --> 02:56:22.210
But all of this requires a budget
that military rhetoric is undermining.

02:56:22.258 --> 02:56:26.289
When disaster strikes in Portugal or
Poland, in France or Greece, Europe must

02:56:26.348 --> 02:56:31.431
respond with solidarity. That means rescue
means, equipped firefighters, support for

02:56:31.504 --> 02:56:36.575
those who have lost everything.
Civil protection cannot be dual use.

02:56:36.660 --> 02:56:39.953
Civil protection is for peace,
for life and for the climate.

02:56:41.693 --> 02:56:45.833
Obrigado. On behalf of
the ESN group, Mr. Jongen.

02:56:50.993 --> 02:56:55.870
Ms Commissioner Labib, you are recommending
that citizens stockpile 72 hours' worth

02:56:55.919 --> 02:56:57.953
of supplies of water, food and medication.

02:56:58.193 --> 02:56:59.393
Ready for anything.

02:56:59.813 --> 02:57:04.614
This campaign is driving people into a
panic and suggesting an imminent collapse.

02:57:04.664 --> 02:57:08.898
In doing so, it conceals the fact that
the crises being lamented are almost all

02:57:08.955 --> 02:57:13.487
man-made. The NATO’s drive eastwards,
complete with war drums, mass migration,

02:57:13.550 --> 02:57:18.801
ideological energy policy, and astronomical
levels of debt—only the weather is not

02:57:18.851 --> 02:57:23.642
man-made, contrary to your claim. A permanent
state of emergency logic is driving a

02:57:23.704 --> 02:57:27.419
dangerous military-civilian
fusion towards totalitarianism.

02:57:27.486 --> 02:57:32.601
The UCBM proposal today follows precisely
this pattern, with the new Crisis

02:57:32.686 --> 02:57:37.221
Coordination Hub set to be rammed through
despite existing disaster protection

02:57:37.277 --> 02:57:42.601
structures, and to become immediately
effective in the event of a health emergency

02:57:42.681 --> 02:57:43.977
declared by the WHO.

02:58:07.253 --> 02:58:11.873
Thank you very much, dear colleague.
The Commissioner can take the floor now.

02:58:19.553 --> 02:58:25.013
Thank you, Mr. President, and I will speak
French, so take your headset if needed.

02:58:26.273 --> 02:58:32.896
Je voudrais tout d'abord remercier le
Parlement européen pour son large support et

02:58:32.993 --> 02:58:36.738
pour cette première
discussion très fructueuse.

02:58:36.893 --> 02:58:42.892
Tout d'abord, le risque de duplication
: il n'y a pas de risque de financement

02:58:42.953 --> 02:58:49.412
double. Et je dois dire qu'entendre cet
argument me semble totalement déconnecté de

02:58:49.470 --> 02:58:54.322
la réalité de terrain. Cet été, par
exemple, durant la saison des feux de forêt,

02:58:54.380 --> 02:59:00.692
nous avons fait appel à tous les moyens
européens, donc ceux qui sont dans le pool

02:59:00.749 --> 02:59:05.822
européen, certifiés par l'Union européenne,
et ceux, évidemment, qui sont dans notre

02:59:05.876 --> 02:59:10.323
réserve stratégique. Nous avons dû
aussi voir des États membres qui sont

02:59:10.402 --> 02:59:13.378
spontanésment venus à
l'aide des uns des autres.

02:59:13.433 --> 02:59:18.814
Donc, c'était... on était vraiment
au point maximum de nos réserves.

02:59:18.893 --> 02:59:20.806
On a tout utilisé. Venir dire maintenant :

02:59:20.842 --> 02:59:25.037
« Il y aurait peut-être un risque de
double financement » me semble totalement

02:59:25.130 --> 02:59:30.646
déconnecté de la réalité. Pour la nature,
du désastre, merci de prendre tout en

02:59:30.699 --> 02:59:35.569
considération. Aujourd'hui, on a
soudainement des frigos dans nos magasins qui

02:59:35.633 --> 02:59:40.291
cessent de fonctionner. On a des alertes
à la bombe dans des écoles, des centaines

02:59:40.358 --> 02:59:43.728
en Italie qui ont poussé
à l'évacuation d'enfants.

02:59:43.793 --> 02:59:48.708
Donc, les menaces sont de plus
en plus hybrides, imprévues.

02:59:48.773 --> 02:59:55.557
Il faut absolument que l'on se prépare
à toute cette imprévisibilité, avec une

02:59:55.625 --> 02:59:59.756
longueur d'avance et
avant qu'elle n'arrive.

02:59:59.873 --> 03:00:04.608
Pour ce qui est de la coopération civile
au militaire, bien sûr, c'est sensible.

03:00:04.673 --> 03:00:08.485
Mais aujourd'hui, quelle est la réalité ?
Quand il y a des feux de forêt, est-ce que

03:00:08.522 --> 03:00:11.219
vous demandez à quel corps
de métier appartenez-vous ?

03:00:11.273 --> 03:00:14.473
Est-ce que vous êtes militaire ? Est-ce
que vous êtes de la protection civile ?

03:00:14.513 --> 03:00:18.233
Est-ce que vous êtes agriculteur ?
Est-ce que vous êtes citoyen bénévole ?

03:00:18.353 --> 03:00:23.263
Non. On vient, on y va,
on répond à l'urgence.

03:00:23.333 --> 03:00:26.698
C'est ça, la réalité de terrain.
Mais il faut qu'on soit coordonnés.

03:00:26.753 --> 03:00:31.028
Cet été, j'ai vu des opérations qui étaient
extrêmement compliquées sur le terrain

03:00:31.073 --> 03:00:33.998
parce qu'on ne savait
pas comment coordonner.

03:00:34.073 --> 03:00:37.308
Quelle architecture ?
À quel ordre répondre ?

03:00:37.373 --> 03:00:40.373
Et donc, tout ça, il faut le
savoir avant que l'urgence arrive.

03:00:40.613 --> 03:00:45.897
Donc, s'il vous plaît, soyez flexibles,
faites un petit peu preuve d'imagination,

03:00:45.953 --> 03:00:50.285
parce que ce qui nous tombera demain dessus,
eh bien, est totalement imprévisible.

03:00:50.333 --> 03:00:51.533
Je vous remercie.

03:00:53.333 --> 03:00:54.533
Thank you, Madam.

03:00:54.773 --> 03:00:57.556
We jump now in the next
part of the debate.

03:00:57.653 --> 03:00:59.993
First, my first speaker is
going to be Madame Pitikainen.

03:01:09.653 --> 03:01:15.065
We need coordinated action, as
our Commissioner just stated, out.

03:01:15.293 --> 03:01:22.248
And we know we are going to have more
crises, different kinds of crises in the

03:01:22.335 --> 03:01:29.033
future. They are derived from the climate,
from cyberattacks, from pandemics, and

03:01:29.213 --> 03:01:37.913
the unsecure safety environment. And these
crises are going to be interlinked and

03:01:38.003 --> 03:01:43.457
multiplying, and they are going to
be in the future much more systemic.

03:01:43.613 --> 03:01:50.693
So we owe it to our citizens that we have
a proper preparation mechanism and action

03:01:50.753 --> 03:01:54.676
mechanism. And you can't do it
on the side when the crisis hits.

03:01:54.773 --> 03:01:59.731
You have to have it, and you
have to plan it in before.

03:01:59.873 --> 03:02:07.015
And then another point, and this is the
fact that the Member States can't do it

03:02:07.082 --> 03:02:11.793
alone. Like the volunteers,
firefighters, they can't do it alone.

03:02:11.873 --> 03:02:17.232
Someone needs to be the
actor and the coordinator.

03:02:17.333 --> 03:02:25.457
And as we know, the role is in the Council
to set up the situation when this sets on

03:02:25.589 --> 03:02:29.843
force. Then it is the
European Coordination.

03:02:29.933 --> 03:02:35.113
And we need not only better
coordination, we need better finance.

03:02:35.213 --> 03:02:43.903
And I urge everybody to contact the own
ministers and the Council members because it

03:02:43.973 --> 03:02:52.153
is duly unresponsible to try to cut the
finance what we have preserved here to save

03:02:52.233 --> 03:02:53.433
our citizens.

03:02:55.193 --> 03:03:00.757
Madame Pitikainen, you have a blue
card from Madame Binieska from ECR.

03:03:00.833 --> 03:03:04.553
Do you accept it? Yes, seat 361.

03:03:07.733 --> 03:03:09.053
I will speak Polish.

03:03:10.433 --> 03:03:18.311
Dziękuję Pani za przyjęcie pytania.
Chciałabym odnieść się do Ochotniczych Straży

03:03:18.404 --> 03:03:22.709
Pożarnych. Bardzo się cieszę,
że docenia Pani ich znaczenie.

03:03:22.793 --> 03:03:29.182
W Polsce do Ochotniczych Straży Pożarnych
należy ponad 700 000 wolontariuszy.

03:03:29.273 --> 03:03:33.576
To jest ogromna armia ludzi,
którzy niosą pomoc w potrzebie.

03:03:33.653 --> 03:03:40.619
Czy nie obawia się Pani, że proponowane
regulacje nałożą biurokrację na te właśnie

03:03:40.699 --> 03:03:45.713
ochotnicze organizacje, które są
pierwsze, jeśli chodzi o niesienie pomocy?

03:03:45.773 --> 03:03:46.973
Dziękuję.

03:03:50.453 --> 03:03:53.201
Thank you for the question.
It's very relevant.

03:03:53.273 --> 03:03:58.533
No, I do not fear it. I'm quite certain
this is going to cut down the bureaucracy

03:03:58.580 --> 03:04:02.631
because if you have the bureaucracy and
Member State level, then you will need to

03:04:02.695 --> 03:04:07.656
coordinate with some other Member State.
You need to coordinate with Red Cross, you

03:04:07.714 --> 03:04:15.548
need to coordinate with medical staff, you
need to figure out on ICU doctors whether

03:04:15.653 --> 03:04:21.685
you have the permits and licenses to work
in Germany if you are friends or vice

03:04:21.801 --> 03:04:30.717
versa. This is the bureaucracy. EU means
one rulebook, one action, pre-planned

03:04:30.788 --> 03:04:34.243
systems what to do. And
this is less bureaucracy.

03:04:34.313 --> 03:04:38.405
This kind of a chaotic way of
doing things on my opinion.

03:04:38.513 --> 03:04:39.953
Is more bureaucracy. Thank you.

03:04:40.553 --> 03:04:45.356
Thank you very much, Madame
Pitikainen. My next speaker is Mr.

03:04:45.413 --> 03:04:46.613
Maren.

03:04:48.653 --> 03:04:54.113
Grazie, Presidente. Colleghi, vogliamo che
i cittadini sentano l'Europa più vicina?

03:04:54.173 --> 03:04:58.033
Beh, allora dobbiamo esserci
quando hanno bisogno.

03:04:58.133 --> 03:05:02.463
Le alluvioni, gli incendi di quest'estate
ci ricordano quanto siamo vulnerabili di

03:05:02.513 --> 03:05:06.725
fronte ai cambiamenti climatici. Che negli
ultimi quattro anni hanno causato oltre

03:05:06.773 --> 03:05:11.719
200 miliardi di danni. Dobbiamo contrastare
i cambiamenti climatici, ma è anche

03:05:11.783 --> 03:05:15.092
essere pronti quando le
catastrofi colpiscono.

03:05:15.173 --> 03:05:19.438
Per questo la Commissione Ambiente, che
presiedo, ha chiesto con forza una vera

03:05:19.493 --> 03:05:24.377
protezione civile europea.
Pronta ad affrontare ogni crisi.

03:05:24.473 --> 03:05:28.586
Una protezione civile che dica ai
cittadini e alle comunità locali:

03:05:28.673 --> 03:05:33.488
non siete soli. L'Europa
c'è ed è al vostro fianco.

03:05:33.653 --> 03:05:37.056
Ma per farla servono
investimenti e risorse adeguate.

03:05:37.133 --> 03:05:42.448
Per questo chiediamo che i 27 Stati membri
sostengano davvero che non riducano le

03:05:42.514 --> 03:05:46.522
ambizioni prospettate da
Parlamento e Commissione.

03:05:46.613 --> 03:05:52.176
L'Europa si fonda sulla solidarietà. Facciamo
sì che la protezione civile europea ne

03:05:52.227 --> 03:05:55.064
diventi un simbolo dell'Europa
di oggi e di domani.

03:05:55.133 --> 03:05:56.333
Grazie.

03:05:56.453 --> 03:06:01.120
Sorry. Thank you very much.
My next speaker is Mr.

03:06:01.193 --> 03:06:02.393
Chastle.

03:06:03.833 --> 03:06:06.598
Merci, Monsieur le Président, Madame
la Commissaire, chers collègues.

03:06:06.653 --> 03:06:11.052
Quand on pense aux réussites européennes,
on évoque souvent Erasmus, Schengen ou la

03:06:11.121 --> 03:06:16.569
fin du roaming. Eh bien, il existe. Il
existe une autre success story, peu connue du

03:06:16.635 --> 03:06:20.039
grand public: le mécanisme
européen de protection civile.

03:06:20.093 --> 03:06:25.083
Depuis 25 ans, ce mécanisme est
l'illustration de la solidarité européenne en

03:06:25.139 --> 03:06:29.393
mobilisant rapidement les moyens de
plusieurs pays face aux catastrophes.

03:06:29.453 --> 03:06:34.442
Mais face à des crises de plus en plus
complexes, nous devons mieux anticiper, mieux

03:06:34.515 --> 03:06:39.410
nous préparer, mieux réagir. Et c'est
tout le sens de la proposition de la

03:06:39.458 --> 03:06:44.320
Commissaire Hadjalabib qui a fait de la
préparation des citoyens en crise une

03:06:44.436 --> 03:06:47.826
priorité. Une autre avancée
majeure pour la première fois:

03:06:47.873 --> 03:06:51.297
la santé sera pleinement
intégrée au mécanisme.

03:06:51.353 --> 03:06:56.961
Une évolution essentielle pour tirer
les leçons de la pandémie de Covid-19.

03:06:57.053 --> 03:07:00.708
La position du Parlement est
ambitieuse et équilibrée.

03:07:00.773 --> 03:07:05.456
J'espère que les États membres partageront
cette vision, celle d'une Europe qui

03:07:05.513 --> 03:07:11.273
anticipe, qui agit et qui protège. Une
Europe concrète au service de ses citoyens.

03:07:11.333 --> 03:07:12.533
Je vous remercie.

03:07:13.913 --> 03:07:17.123
Merci, Monsieur. You
have a blue card from Mr.

03:07:17.213 --> 03:07:20.333
Tannin. Do you accept
it? From the EPP group.

03:07:20.393 --> 03:07:24.077
Do you accept it? Mr.
Tannin, you have the floor.

03:07:24.113 --> 03:07:25.313
Seat 113.

03:07:29.873 --> 03:07:35.436
Collega Strinjam se z vami, da je
evropski mehanizem civilne zaščite uspeh.

03:07:35.633 --> 03:07:41.616
Pa se vam ne zdi, da bi pa veljalo kljub
temu ga nadgraditi v smislu, da bi ta

03:07:41.689 --> 03:07:47.565
mehanizem tudi ponujal skupne
zmogljivosti, na primer letala za gašenje?

03:07:47.633 --> 03:07:52.581
Da bi več pozornosti posvečal interoperabilnosti, kar pomeni, da slovenski gasilci

03:07:52.636 --> 03:07:55.556
lahko sodelujejo s francoskimi
in podobnimi stvarmi.

03:07:55.613 --> 03:08:01.373
Ali vidite priložnost, da se mehanizem
nadgradi v še močnejšega, še boljšega?

03:08:01.433 --> 03:08:10.585
Ker so naravne nesreče
vedno bolj brutalne.

03:08:11.093 --> 03:08:17.751
Seveda, évidemment, il faut développer de
plus en plus cette solidarité européenne.

03:08:17.813 --> 03:08:21.801
Mais d'autres l'ont évoqué avant moi: il
faudra pour cela que les États membres se

03:08:21.851 --> 03:08:26.050
mettent d'accord sur un budget adapté
aux ambitions que nous avons pour le

03:08:26.092 --> 03:08:27.292
mécanisme.

03:08:29.393 --> 03:08:32.513
Merci, Monsieur. My next
speaker is Madame Safko.

03:08:35.033 --> 03:08:41.905
Thank you very much. Mr. President, Madame
Commissioner, I agree absolutely with you

03:08:41.993 --> 03:08:47.778
that we in a case of fire, in a case of
hybrid threats, and in the case of big

03:08:47.828 --> 03:08:53.162
floods, no one will ask from which part
the army comes from because we will need

03:08:53.213 --> 03:09:00.028
also the army. I remember in 2018 when I
did this first renewed rescue mechanism,

03:09:00.097 --> 03:09:05.137
the journalist asked me when we presented
it in Split, "Why do you need this field

03:09:05.188 --> 03:09:09.506
hospital? " and stuff that was
presented in the first rescue mechanism.

03:09:09.593 --> 03:09:13.613
And they were laughing when we mentioned
that they might be big pandemic.

03:09:13.673 --> 03:09:19.124
And 2020, we understood what
this rescue mechanism meant.

03:09:19.253 --> 03:09:25.215
And that's why I agree that we need 11
billion for this because this is the only

03:09:25.274 --> 03:09:29.686
helping hand in a case of need, in
a case of threats that are coming.

03:09:29.753 --> 03:09:34.943
And coming from Croatia, it's a golden
boy and I mean golden lady or whatever.

03:09:35.033 --> 03:09:40.115
Of civil protection, we have a good
place, we have good firefighters, we have

03:09:40.198 --> 03:09:45.353
excellent people, but we need much more
money for preparedness, we need much more

03:09:45.413 --> 03:09:52.042
money for our firefighters, we need also
to facilitate their work and also to

03:09:52.133 --> 03:09:57.284
anticipate how to prepare ourselves, how
to prepare how to educate our children to

03:09:57.340 --> 03:10:01.774
prepare for the catastrophes because
we cannot lie to our citizens.

03:10:01.853 --> 03:10:05.877
Catastrophes are going to come
and we are still not prepared.

03:10:05.933 --> 03:10:07.133
So keep good work.

03:10:08.573 --> 03:10:12.902
Thank you. Thank you very
much. Thank you very much.

03:10:12.953 --> 03:10:15.833
Dear colleagues, my next
speaker is Mr. Clérigou.

03:10:21.113 --> 03:10:24.431
Monsieur le Président, Madame la
Commissaire, si nous voulons protéger les

03:10:24.477 --> 03:10:30.349
Européens, il va falloir s'attaquer aux
vulnérabilités sociales, environnementales

03:10:30.416 --> 03:10:35.197
et territoriales. Parce que oui, il faut
se préparer, mais être très bien préparé ne

03:10:35.259 --> 03:10:39.611
suffira pas. Le même phénomène climatique,
la même tempête, la même inondation

03:10:39.662 --> 03:10:44.033
n'aura pas les mêmes conséquences sur un
territoire très vulnérable que sur un autre

03:10:44.093 --> 03:10:49.397
territoire mieux organisé. Alors oui,
pour faire cela, il faut des politiques de

03:10:49.469 --> 03:10:54.479
solidarité, des politiques d'aménagement
du territoire, et de solutions basées sur

03:10:54.544 --> 03:10:57.526
la nature qui soient
extrêmement ambitieuses.

03:10:57.593 --> 03:11:01.570
Et je ne sais pas si le budget que nous
avons suffira à le faire, ça doit devenir

03:11:01.620 --> 03:11:04.614
une ambition transversale
des politiques européennes.

03:11:04.673 --> 03:11:08.899
Et ensuite, si nous voulons réellement
défendre les citoyens, leur permettre d'avoir

03:11:08.956 --> 03:11:13.363
un futur il va falloir réparer
les territoires, les plus frappés.

03:11:13.433 --> 03:11:18.042
Quand la question d'habiter encore des
territoires se pose en France, dans l'Aude,

03:11:18.113 --> 03:11:22.253
après les feux, ou dans la
Gironde, après les feux de cet été.

03:11:22.313 --> 03:11:24.720
Et là, ces territoires
se sentent abandonnés.

03:11:24.773 --> 03:11:28.151
Et ce sont des centaines de millions
ou des milliards d'euros qui vont être

03:11:28.204 --> 03:11:31.897
nécessaires pour redonner
un avenir à ces territoires.

03:11:31.973 --> 03:11:35.933
En Europe continentale et dans les
outre-mer qui sont aussi très exposés.

03:11:35.993 --> 03:11:39.961
Et là, dans le budget européen, je ne
vois pas les solutions qui sont proposées.

03:11:40.013 --> 03:11:42.363
J'ai besoin encore de
réponses supplémentaires.

03:11:42.413 --> 03:11:43.373
Merci.

03:11:43.373 --> 03:11:48.811
Dear colleagues, you have two blue cards.
Do you accept at least the first one?

03:11:48.893 --> 03:11:52.242
Dear colleagues, sorry.
Do you accept a blue card?

03:11:52.313 --> 03:11:58.778
From Mr. Mularczyk from ECR, seat 576. Mr.

03:11:58.853 --> 03:12:01.193
Mularczyk, Mr. Mularczyk from ECR.

03:12:01.793 --> 03:12:04.553
Yes, thank you. Thank you very
much. I will speak in Polish.

03:12:05.813 --> 03:12:08.553
Bardzo dziękuję za wystąpienie
i przyjęcie pytania.

03:12:08.633 --> 03:12:13.897
Chcę zwrócić uwagę, że pan poseł podkreślił,
że tych środków rzeczywiście może być

03:12:13.948 --> 03:12:16.376
za mało dla wszystkich
potrzebujących krajów.

03:12:16.433 --> 03:12:20.128
Ale ja chcę zwrócić szczególną uwagę
na kraje wschodniej flanki NATO, w

03:12:20.174 --> 03:12:25.606
szczególności na mój kraj, Polskę, który
wydaje 5% PKB na bezpieczeństwo, dając

03:12:25.665 --> 03:12:31.693
bezpieczeństwo całej Unii Europejskiej.
A jednocześnie musi ponosić wydatki na

03:12:31.833 --> 03:12:36.299
bezpieczeństwo dotyczące
Klęsk żywiołowych.

03:12:36.353 --> 03:12:40.735
Czy uważa pan, że właśnie takie kraje powinny
mieć specjalny status w tym programie?

03:12:40.793 --> 03:12:41.993
Dziękuję bardzo.

03:12:54.713 --> 03:12:57.871
Moi, je crois que le principe de
l'Union européenne, c'est un principe de

03:12:57.946 --> 03:13:03.104
solidarité. Les budgets qui sont prévus
pour les politiques de préparation aux

03:13:03.161 --> 03:13:07.913
crises, côté protection civile, et côté
santé, sont sûrement suffisants pour la

03:13:08.007 --> 03:13:10.977
préparation. Et encore,
il faut le vérifier.

03:13:11.033 --> 03:13:14.597
Par contre, vous avez raison, les
territoires vulnérables, c'est aussi la

03:13:14.642 --> 03:13:19.978
vulnérabilité en matière de défense. Mais
c'est ensemble au niveau européen qu'il

03:13:20.026 --> 03:13:23.002
faut accompagner les territoires les
plus vulnérables d'un point de vue

03:13:23.040 --> 03:13:27.273
environnemental ou social, et les
territoires les plus exposés aux questions de

03:13:27.324 --> 03:13:31.623
sécurité et de défense. Et pour cela,
il faut des fonds mutualisés à l'échelle

03:13:31.673 --> 03:13:32.873
européenne. Merci.

03:13:34.733 --> 03:13:35.633
Merci.

03:13:35.633 --> 03:13:38.393
Merci, Monsieur. My next
speaker is Madame Wessler.

03:13:42.173 --> 03:13:46.431
Sehr geehrter Herr Präsident, sehr geehrte
Frau Kommissarin, oft hören wir Politiker

03:13:46.493 --> 03:13:51.421
von Bürgerinnen und Bürgern, dass sie von
Europa im Alltag viel zu wenig spüren.

03:13:51.533 --> 03:13:56.350
Und manchmal ist das genau die beste
Nachricht, wenn alles einfach läuft.

03:13:56.453 --> 03:14:00.370
Wenn die Feuerwehr rechtzeitig kommt, wenn
das Krankenhaus vorbereitet ist, und wenn

03:14:00.433 --> 03:14:04.989
im Ernstfall Hilfe bereitsteht. Und
genau darum geht es in dieser Woche.

03:14:05.033 --> 03:14:09.013
Wir beraten über ein neues Gesetz für den
Katastrophenschutz und die Vorbereitung

03:14:09.060 --> 03:14:15.605
auf Gesundheitsrisiken 2028. Denn ob
Hochwasser, Waldbrand oder Pandemie, kein Land

03:14:15.699 --> 03:14:21.117
kann jede Krise alleine bewältigen. Und
wir kümmern uns deshalb um den Zivilschutz,

03:14:21.173 --> 03:14:25.514
bevor es ernst wird. Deshalb haben wir als
Europäisches Parlament den ursprünglichen

03:14:25.553 --> 03:14:28.598
Vorschlag der Kommission
konkret verbessert.

03:14:28.673 --> 03:14:31.733
Mit besserem Schutz für unsere
freiwilligen Feuerwehren und ehrenamtlichen

03:14:31.783 --> 03:14:35.253
Rettungskräfte, mit Expertenteams, die
nach Katastrophen helfen, mit Strom und

03:14:35.293 --> 03:14:40.028
Wasser schnell wiederherzustellen, und mit
besserer Zusammenarbeit der bestehenden

03:14:40.099 --> 03:14:44.782
Stellen. Denn manchmal ist das Beste an
Europa, dass die Bürgerinnen und Bürger gar

03:14:44.831 --> 03:14:49.073
nichts davon spüren, weil wir
vorgesorgt haben, bevor es ernst wird.

03:14:51.653 --> 03:14:55.483
Thank you very much. Dear colleagues,
now we begin with the Cats de Ai.

03:14:55.553 --> 03:15:01.640
I have to tell you that I have lots of
requests, so not everybody is going to be

03:15:01.702 --> 03:15:05.501
able to get it. I will try
to give as much as possible.

03:15:05.573 --> 03:15:11.033
My first speaker is going
to be Mr. Sokol, seat 347.

03:15:12.833 --> 03:15:18.483
Hvala lijepa. Od uspostavljanja 2001.
godine, mehanizam Unije za civilnu zaštitu

03:15:18.533 --> 03:15:23.493
aktiviran je više od 900 puta. To pokazuje
koliko europska solidarnost važna kada

03:15:23.563 --> 03:15:27.335
katastrofe ugroze živote
i sigurnost naših građana.

03:15:27.413 --> 03:15:32.159
Za Hrvatsku, ali i ostale mediteranske
države, ovaj mehanizam iznimno važan zbog

03:15:32.221 --> 03:15:35.678
šumskih požara koji svake
godine čine ogromnu štetu.

03:15:35.753 --> 03:15:40.368
Zahvaljujući europskoj suradnji, možemo
računati na dodatne protupožarne zrakoplove,

03:15:40.433 --> 03:15:44.790
opremu i stručnjake kada nacionalni
kapaciteti nisu dovoljni.

03:15:44.873 --> 03:15:48.794
Zato podržavam jačanje mehanizma kroz
ulaganja u prevenciju, sustav ranog

03:15:48.853 --> 03:15:51.527
upozoravanja i brži odgovor na katastrofe.

03:15:51.593 --> 03:15:55.800
Moramo bolje povezati europske,
nacionalne i lokalne službe kako bi pomoć

03:15:55.853 --> 03:15:58.968
pravovremeno stigla ondje
gdje je najpotrebnija.

03:15:59.033 --> 03:16:02.958
Pozdravno pozdravljam snažnije povezivanje
civilne zaštite sa zdravstvenom

03:16:03.025 --> 03:16:08.199
pripravnošću. Pandemija nam je pokazala da
zdravstvene prijetnje ne poznaju granice.

03:16:08.273 --> 03:16:12.885
Potrebna nam je stoga pravodobna razmjena
informacija i učinkovita koordinacija među

03:16:12.953 --> 03:16:17.638
državama članicama. Kolegice i kolege,
ulaganje u pripravnost nije trošak, nego

03:16:17.695 --> 03:16:20.755
ulaganje u živote, sigurnost
zajednice, gospodarstvo.

03:16:20.813 --> 03:16:24.617
Naš cilj mora biti Europa koja ne čeka
da katastrofa nastupi, nego unaprijed

03:16:24.673 --> 03:16:27.773
prepoznaje rizike, priprema
odgovore i štiti građane.

03:16:27.833 --> 03:16:28.973
Hvala lijepa.

03:16:28.973 --> 03:16:32.873
Thank you very much.
Madame Glavac, seat 500.

03:16:36.413 --> 03:16:42.426
Hvala vam lijepa. Kolegice i kolege,
ne slažem se s uštedama kada govorimo o

03:16:42.498 --> 03:16:46.805
životima ljudi i kada
govorimo o spašavanju ljudi.

03:16:46.913 --> 03:16:52.043
Ono što je bitno, da nacionalne službe
zadržavaju odgovornost za zaštitu građana, i

03:16:52.094 --> 03:16:57.571
to jasno želim istaknuti jer mislim da smo
pomalo danas čuli krive informacije ili

03:16:57.650 --> 03:17:02.618
dezinformacije. Snažnije uključivanje
lokalnih i regionalnih vlasti, ali i jasnu

03:17:02.693 --> 03:17:10.313
podjelu odgovornosti. Ovime se nadopunjavaju
nacionalni kapaciteti, a ne zamjenjuju

03:17:10.397 --> 03:17:18.253
se nacionalni kapaciteti. Hrvatska je ne
samo primateljica pomoći, već je Hrvatska

03:17:18.353 --> 03:17:23.758
uvijek tu kada treba. Naši vatrogasci i
pripadnici civilne zaštite gorske službe

03:17:23.833 --> 03:17:27.274
spašavanja naše zračne
snage pomažu drugima.

03:17:27.353 --> 03:17:31.487
Imamo 65 godina iskustva
u civilnoj zaštiti.

03:17:31.553 --> 03:17:37.709
Ja mislim najduže u Europskoj uniji, stoga
treba poslušati one koji to iskustvo mogu

03:17:37.782 --> 03:17:42.399
pretočiti u stvarnu pomoć našim
ljudima i našim sugrađanima.

03:17:42.473 --> 03:17:47.098
I na kraju, ako nam svaka nova katastrofa
pokazuje da nemamo dovoljno opreme i

03:17:47.153 --> 03:17:51.520
kapaciteta, onda nije dovoljno
samo bolje organizirati odgovor.

03:17:51.593 --> 03:17:52.793
Hvala lijepa.

03:17:53.213 --> 03:17:54.353
Thank you very much.

03:17:54.353 --> 03:17:57.233
El señor López Aguilar, sitio 381.

03:17:58.493 --> 03:18:04.282
Gracias, presidente Pons. Comisaria Laviv,
oportuna iniciativa la de un mecanismo

03:18:04.344 --> 03:18:09.932
europeo unificado de protección civil y
respuesta ante emergencias sanitarias.

03:18:10.013 --> 03:18:14.876
Y excelente, el informe de nuestra compañera
Leire Pajín, que no solamente asegura

03:18:14.933 --> 03:18:19.318
una amplia mayoría para su aprobación,
sino una financiación histórica en el marco

03:18:19.373 --> 03:18:23.589
financiero plurianual de 11. 000 millones
de euros que en ningún caso puede ser

03:18:23.651 --> 03:18:27.822
rebajada por el Consejo como
propone la presidencia irlandesa.

03:18:27.893 --> 03:18:33.473
Prevención y anticipación antes que reacción,
y un centro europeo de coordinación de

03:18:33.533 --> 03:18:40.124
crisis que no solamente transmita alerta
y combata bulos que tanto daño hacen ante

03:18:40.190 --> 03:18:44.658
ese tipo de emergencias imponiendo
obligaciones de coordinación a las autoridades

03:18:44.712 --> 03:18:48.726
regionales y locales, sino sobre todo
impida que pueda volver a repetirse la

03:18:48.793 --> 03:18:53.621
cacofonía de medidas de emergencia,
adoptadas por los Estados miembros

03:18:53.693 --> 03:18:57.416
unilateralmente, como sucedió
en la crisis del COVID.

03:18:57.473 --> 03:19:01.433
En aquel momento la Unión Europea
reaccionó a tiempo, pero reaccionó.

03:19:01.493 --> 03:19:05.477
Es el momento de la anticipación y de la
prevención, como propone el informe de

03:19:05.531 --> 03:19:06.953
Leire Pajín. Por tanto, enhorabuena.

03:19:09.113 --> 03:19:14.393
Muchas gracias. Mr. Besliga, seat 719.

03:19:16.733 --> 03:19:18.233
Thank you, Chair. I'll speak on Croatian.

03:19:19.373 --> 03:19:23.995
Novi europski mehanizam civilne zaštite
prilika je koja se ne smije propustiti.

03:19:24.053 --> 03:19:29.325
Prilika za jačanje spremnosti i odgovora
na sve učestalije krize i katastrofe.

03:19:29.393 --> 03:19:34.381
No u središtu svakog sustava, pa tako
i ovoga, su dakako ljudi na terenu.

03:19:34.493 --> 03:19:39.627
Nas u Hrvatskoj događanje ovoga ljeta u
prvom redu požar na Omičkom području u kojem

03:19:39.675 --> 03:19:43.760
je, nažalost, 6 osoba izgubilo svoj život,
podsjetila još jednom koliko su važni

03:19:43.813 --> 03:19:46.681
pravodobno upozoravanje
i koordinacija službi.

03:19:46.793 --> 03:19:49.973
Sustav ranoga upozoravanja
tada je, nažalost, zakazao.

03:19:50.033 --> 03:19:55.325
I to u trenutku kad su se naši vatrogasci
borili s požarom katastrofalnih razmjera.

03:19:55.433 --> 03:19:59.940
Zato novi mehanizam mora u prvom redu
prepoznati i vrednovati ulogu profesionalnih i

03:20:00.007 --> 03:20:05.351
dobrovoljnih vatrogasaca gorske službe
spašavanja i svih drugih službi civilne

03:20:05.406 --> 03:20:11.290
zaštite koje u ovakvim situacijama
riskiraju svoje živote kako bi spasili naše.

03:20:11.393 --> 03:20:17.612
Civilna zaštita zato nije samo pitanje
opreme i koordinacija, nego je pitanje ljudi.

03:20:17.693 --> 03:20:22.673
A njihova sigurnost i priznanje njihova
doprinosa moraju biti europski prioritet.

03:20:25.493 --> 03:20:27.953
Madame Bisnieska, seat 361.

03:20:29.213 --> 03:20:33.584
Thank you very much, Mr President. The
protection of the population and the

03:20:33.655 --> 03:20:38.755
organisation of healthcare are fundamental
competences of the Member States.

03:20:38.815 --> 03:20:44.952
The EU mechanism should therefore constitute
an efficient safety net and support at

03:20:45.031 --> 03:20:51.482
the request of a Member State, rather than
becoming a tool for top-down control or

03:20:51.568 --> 03:20:56.674
centralisation. Poland and the Central
and Eastern European region are located in

03:20:56.740 --> 03:21:03.253
the immediate vicinity of the war in Ukraine,
and these areas are exposed to hybrid

03:21:03.354 --> 03:21:08.265
attacks, sabotage and the
spillover effects of the conflict.

03:21:08.343 --> 03:21:14.218
Therefore, EU support, with full respect
for sovereignty and the principle of

03:21:14.319 --> 03:21:17.846
subsidiarity, must
support bordering states.

03:21:17.922 --> 03:21:24.108
It is also worth highlighting the role
of volunteer fire brigades and protecting

03:21:24.198 --> 03:21:26.513
them from Brussels bureaucracy.

03:21:26.873 --> 03:21:28.073
Dziękuję.

03:21:30.053 --> 03:21:35.273
Thank you very much.
Madame Vaucier, seat 104.

03:21:37.313 --> 03:21:41.813
Thank you very much. And thank you
for the excellent work you're doing.

03:21:41.873 --> 03:21:48.526
I want to concentrate on one crisis,
perhaps the largest crisis that we will ever

03:21:48.593 --> 03:21:55.882
face: one which is now spiraling out of
our control, namely the climate crisis.

03:21:55.973 --> 03:22:00.109
Europe is, as you know well, the continent
that is warming the fastest, but it's

03:22:00.173 --> 03:22:04.930
also the continent with the
highest concentration of wealth.

03:22:05.033 --> 03:22:14.527
Heating threatens health and wealth.
Buildings, homes, businesses, and lives we

03:22:14.693 --> 03:22:21.762
still need to fight the warming.
We need to lower our CO2 emissions.

03:22:21.893 --> 03:22:27.757
We need to work with our resilience, as you
are very well doing, we need to know how

03:22:27.851 --> 03:22:34.217
to build buildings, we need
how to know how to plan.

03:22:34.313 --> 03:22:39.053
And then, of course, at the end, also crisis
management, as we're talking about this

03:22:39.113 --> 03:22:45.457
evening. But we need to see the three levels
of defense because if we do not invest

03:22:45.549 --> 03:22:50.291
now, the budgets that we're
talking about will be small.

03:22:50.513 --> 03:22:55.279
Then it will be huge costs. So let's
also get the other things right.

03:22:55.313 --> 03:22:56.513
Thank you very much.

03:22:57.353 --> 03:22:58.553
Thank you very much.

03:22:59.033 --> 03:23:01.793
La señora Miranda en el escaño 234.

03:23:04.973 --> 03:23:09.848
Thank you very much, Mr President. Commissioner,
you know as well as I do—because we

03:23:09.930 --> 03:23:15.256
have spoken about this many times—that we
need a more comprehensive civil protection

03:23:15.323 --> 03:23:18.813
mechanism that can respond to serious
situations such as the wildfires we are

03:23:18.880 --> 03:23:22.791
experiencing, and my colleague Leire
Pajín knows this too, as we are also

03:23:22.836 --> 03:23:25.515
collaborating on this
dossier within our group.

03:23:25.566 --> 03:23:28.411
We also need to listen, for
example, to the firefighters.

03:23:28.461 --> 03:23:34.119
Just a week ago, firefighters from all
over Europe came here to tell us about the

03:23:34.198 --> 03:23:39.831
problems they face, from Belgium to Galicia,
from Croatia to Italy and from Finland

03:23:39.886 --> 03:23:44.455
to Romania. Therefore, these coordination
and anticipation mechanisms must be based

03:23:44.518 --> 03:23:48.969
on solidarity and coordination. Unfortunately,
crises—whether climate-related or

03:23:49.025 --> 03:23:51.614
natural disasters—no
longer respect borders.

03:23:51.662 --> 03:23:56.375
And if we do not tackle this from a coordinated
perspective, while also highlighting

03:23:56.436 --> 03:24:00.797
the need for prevention and anticipation,
we must invest more resources.

03:24:00.861 --> 03:24:05.156
It cannot be that firefighters are working
in precarious conditions, and it cannot

03:24:05.206 --> 03:24:08.538
be that we wait for European assistance
when there is not even support in our own

03:24:08.577 --> 03:24:14.706
territories. That is why it is so important,
as I always say, to increase support

03:24:14.770 --> 03:24:16.673
for civil protection and not tanks.

03:24:18.473 --> 03:24:24.111
Thank you very much, Ms Miranda. To
conclude, the rapporteur, Ms Pajín, has the

03:24:24.163 --> 03:24:25.363
floor.

03:24:29.573 --> 03:24:32.393
I would like my final words to be, first
and foremost, to express my gratitude.

03:24:33.413 --> 03:24:38.643
I would like to thank my colleague Aurelio
Esberiga for his excellent work and

03:24:38.694 --> 03:24:42.978
cooperation. I would also like to thank
all the shadow rapporteurs from the

03:24:43.038 --> 03:24:48.765
different parliamentary groups, because
we have shown that in this House we are

03:24:48.825 --> 03:24:55.916
capable of doing outstanding political
work by pooling our efforts and reaching

03:24:55.965 --> 03:24:58.772
consensus on a necessity, on
a tool that will save lives.

03:24:58.815 --> 03:25:01.737
I also want to express my gratitude
to the experts we have heard.

03:25:01.789 --> 03:25:05.563
To carry out this work, we have listened
to experts, international bodies,

03:25:05.648 --> 03:25:09.504
professionals, firefighters,
volunteers, who are a fundamental part.

03:25:09.549 --> 03:25:15.104
We have listened to the victims, and we
have committed ourselves to them to prevent

03:25:15.162 --> 03:25:18.140
these crises from having
the same impact again.

03:25:18.217 --> 03:25:21.161
We have also listened to
different professional sectors.

03:25:21.229 --> 03:25:25.381
But I also want to acknowledge the
excellent work of our technical teams.

03:25:25.428 --> 03:25:29.240
Behind the proposal we are debating today,
there are many hours of work, of course,

03:25:29.277 --> 03:25:34.306
by the MEPs, but especially by our
technical teams, who have done a great job.

03:25:34.377 --> 03:25:36.713
And I would like to
send two final messages.

03:25:36.758 --> 03:25:41.603
The first concerns the need for this
mechanism to be properly financially endowed.

03:25:41.652 --> 03:25:45.845
The crises we are facing today are very
complex and of an unprecedented scale.

03:25:45.888 --> 03:25:49.428
Therefore, we need far more resources.
And our work does not end here.

03:25:49.483 --> 03:25:53.569
It will continue in the trilogues,
aiming, of course, to secure sufficient

03:25:53.624 --> 03:25:57.955
resources. The second message concerns
the climate emergency context.

03:25:58.019 --> 03:26:02.716
Denying scientific evidence and the climate
emergency is exposing us to ever greater

03:26:02.782 --> 03:26:07.683
risks. That is why we cannot allow this
to continue to be a reality, even in the

03:26:07.765 --> 03:26:12.474
seats of this Chamber. We must especially
reach out to the most vulnerable, which is

03:26:12.528 --> 03:26:17.264
why we also talk about vulnerability maps,
and prevent elderly people from dying in

03:26:17.307 --> 03:26:21.139
care homes, as happened, for example,
in my country during the pandemic.

03:26:21.194 --> 03:26:25.576
And finally, we must be able to
anticipate and prevent the impact we have

03:26:25.620 --> 03:26:27.533
experienced, which has cost so many lives.

03:26:27.773 --> 03:26:32.438
happens again. That is why our work today
is to improve that mechanism here, to

03:26:32.501 --> 03:26:34.673
prevent, to anticipate and to save lives.

03:26:35.093 --> 03:26:36.293
Thank you very much.

03:26:36.773 --> 03:26:37.973
Thank you very much, Your Honour.

03:26:39.113 --> 03:26:40.673
Mr. Esberiga, you have the floor.

03:26:43.673 --> 03:26:48.584
Dear colleagues, first I would like to
thank all of you for your contributions.

03:26:48.653 --> 03:26:55.928
You have clearly demonstrated just how
important and necessary this mechanism is,

03:26:55.994 --> 03:27:00.617
especially as we celebrate its
25th anniversary this year.

03:27:00.713 --> 03:27:08.250
I would like to underline that between
2020 and 2024 alone, this mechanism has

03:27:08.333 --> 03:27:15.163
activated more than 650 times, four times
as often as during the previous five

03:27:15.255 --> 03:27:20.361
years. These figures clearly demonstrate
the growing need for this mechanism and

03:27:20.431 --> 03:27:24.373
importance of strengthening
of our preparedness.

03:27:24.473 --> 03:27:29.136
Preparedness requires investment,
effort, and political will.

03:27:29.213 --> 03:27:35.068
But we must remember one simple truth:
when disasters strike, it is often too late

03:27:35.155 --> 03:27:41.363
to start preparing. At that moment, we
are no longer counting the money we could

03:27:41.453 --> 03:27:49.669
have saved, we are counting lifes lost,
homes destroyed, and families whose lives

03:27:49.801 --> 03:27:57.675
have been changed forever. That is why we
have responsibility to act today, so that

03:27:57.773 --> 03:28:02.715
tomorrow we do not have to
regret that what we failed to do.

03:28:02.813 --> 03:28:07.505
Because preparedness is
not simply an investment.

03:28:07.673 --> 03:28:13.087
In security, it is above all
an investment in human lives.

03:28:13.193 --> 03:28:20.663
Our citizens are counting on us. They expect
us as policymakers to do everything in

03:28:20.753 --> 03:28:28.373
our power to ensure that Europe is better
prepared for whatever challenge lie ahead.

03:28:28.493 --> 03:28:29.693
Thank you so much.

03:28:31.133 --> 03:28:35.419
Thank you very much, dear
colleagues. The debate is close.

03:28:35.513 --> 03:28:43.836
The vote will be held tomorrow. The next
item on the agenda is the report by Mr.

03:28:43.913 --> 03:28:48.599
Vasily Voisulescu, Europe's
bidding cancer plan.

03:28:48.713 --> 03:28:53.753
And the reporter is my first
speaker. Mr. Vasily Voisulescu.

03:28:57.173 --> 03:29:03.833
Vice President, Commissioner, colleagues,
I will be brief, but by the time I will be

03:29:03.893 --> 03:29:09.248
I will stop speaking. Two people
in Europe will have died of cancer.

03:29:09.353 --> 03:29:14.873
Cancer is one of the worst things that
can happen to each and every one of us in

03:29:14.978 --> 03:29:21.403
peacetime. Cancer shatters dreams, it tears
families apart, it takes away children,

03:29:21.488 --> 03:29:25.498
mothers, fathers, sisters,
the people we love most.

03:29:25.613 --> 03:29:31.350
But cancer is not just a personal tragedy,
it's a challenge for our entire society.

03:29:31.433 --> 03:29:34.416
A challenge that no member
state can tackle alone.

03:29:34.553 --> 03:29:40.142
Five years ago, Europe made a promise:
4 billion euro for a plan covering

03:29:40.196 --> 03:29:44.330
prevention, early detection, better
treatments, and life after cancer.

03:29:44.393 --> 03:29:49.378
It was the right plan, it delivered results,
but too many Europeans have yet to feel

03:29:49.433 --> 03:29:56.648
its benefits. This report looks at what
has changed and what we must change.

03:29:56.813 --> 03:29:59.864
Three realities make
it particularly urgent.

03:29:59.933 --> 03:30:06.572
First, we live longer. Sixty percent
of cancers appear after the age of 65.

03:30:06.653 --> 03:30:11.618
This means that if nothing else changes,
more Europeans will develop cancer.

03:30:11.693 --> 03:30:17.277
Second, science is advancing. Treatments
are more targeted, more personalized, but

03:30:17.341 --> 03:30:23.513
also far more expensive. Third, our
social systems are under strain.

03:30:23.573 --> 03:30:28.237
Our healthcare systems as well. The
pressure is only getting heavier.

03:30:28.313 --> 03:30:32.324
After months of negotiation, this report
sets priorities, how we finance research,

03:30:32.374 --> 03:30:36.544
how we connect scientists, hospitals, and
patients, and how we reduce inequalities

03:30:36.590 --> 03:30:43.409
in access to treatment. But beyond funding
projects, business as usual, we must

03:30:43.465 --> 03:30:46.613
recognize that this is not
a feasible option anymore.

03:30:46.673 --> 03:30:50.969
We must tackle the risk factors that
cause cancer in the first place.

03:30:51.053 --> 03:30:58.097
We need to make some choices here in the
European Parliament, and we cannot pretend

03:30:58.167 --> 03:31:03.893
to be naive or show shortsighted. Tobacco
is the best documented risk factor for

03:31:03.953 --> 03:31:08.679
cancer, and it is one of the areas where
we know exactly which measures work to

03:31:08.750 --> 03:31:14.564
prevent it. Tobacco makes political and
indeed moral choices painfully clear.

03:31:14.693 --> 03:31:19.332
In the Union, one in five cancer
deaths is caused by tobacco.

03:31:19.433 --> 03:31:26.213
I will repeat this: one in five. Tobacco
makes not only nine out of ten lung

03:31:26.393 --> 03:31:30.400
cancers, but also causes at
least 20 other types of cancer:

03:31:30.466 --> 03:31:36.578
voice box cancers, mouth cancer, bladder
pancreas, and it doubles the risk of

03:31:36.631 --> 03:31:43.454
cervical cancer for women. Among 15 and
16-year-olds in Europe, e-cigarettes use

03:31:43.561 --> 03:31:49.774
rose from 14 to 22 percent in five years.
And this is, by the way, the highest rate

03:31:49.859 --> 03:31:56.475
in the world. We know what works: higher
tobacco taxes, plain packaging, removing

03:31:56.553 --> 03:32:00.751
tobacco from shop displays,
and banning advertising.

03:32:00.833 --> 03:32:05.402
And our rules must also address e-cigarettes,
heated tobacco, and nicotine pouches.

03:32:05.453 --> 03:32:11.063
On the basis of independent science. I
want to thank my colleagues who share my

03:32:11.108 --> 03:32:15.508
concerns and recognize also the courage
that they have shown, especially in the face

03:32:15.555 --> 03:32:20.830
of intense lobbying pressure, that they
have faced in real in recent weeks.

03:32:20.933 --> 03:32:25.015
I would also like to thank the shadow
reporters and the technical teams and more so

03:32:25.073 --> 03:32:27.718
my team for their work
and for their commitment.

03:32:27.773 --> 03:32:32.455
The proposed text is balanced, it recognizes
the limits of political compromise, but

03:32:32.536 --> 03:32:39.447
still leaves room for moral courage. For
doing what is right, for saving lives.

03:32:39.533 --> 03:32:44.973
And make no mistake, our vote here
today and tomorrow will count.

03:32:45.053 --> 03:32:50.384
So please support the report as adopted
in SANT and support the final text as it

03:32:50.479 --> 03:32:51.679
stands. Thank you.

03:32:52.853 --> 03:32:58.818
Thank you, thank you very
much, dear colleagues.

03:32:58.973 --> 03:33:03.473
Commissioner Várhelyi, Commissioner
Várhelyi, Commissioner, you have the floor.

03:33:10.973 --> 03:33:16.958
The President, Honorable Members, Europe's
bidding cancer plan is a key pillar in

03:33:17.043 --> 03:33:22.643
our public health policy. It is already
making a real difference for patients across

03:33:22.733 --> 03:33:29.327
Europe. Since we launched the plan back
in 2021, the Commission has allocated 2.

03:33:29.393 --> 03:33:35.930
7 billion euros to its actions through
EU4Health program, as well as through Horizon

03:33:35.993 --> 03:33:40.017
Europe program, including
the EU Cancer Mission.

03:33:40.133 --> 03:33:48.344
With this support, we have funded more than
70 projects, and worked with almost 630

03:33:48.473 --> 03:33:52.885
organizations. And the
results are very clear.

03:33:52.973 --> 03:33:58.088
The review of the cancer plan back in
February last year and the European Court of

03:33:58.149 --> 03:34:05.090
Auditors both confirmed that the
plan is delivering real added value.

03:34:05.213 --> 03:34:12.904
Prevention is at the heart of this work.
Around 40 percent, four zero, of cancers

03:34:13.013 --> 03:34:20.273
are preventable. It is for this reason
that 45 percent of the plans supporting

03:34:20.333 --> 03:34:27.113
actions are dedicated to prevention. And
we have reached important milestones on

03:34:27.215 --> 03:34:33.881
prevention. The 2024 Cancer Recommendations
on Vaccine Preventable Cancers and on

03:34:33.959 --> 03:34:40.647
Smoke and Aerosol-Free Environments. The
fifth edition of the European Code Against

03:34:40.750 --> 03:34:46.498
Cancer. And better protection for
workers from carcinogens and asbestos.

03:34:46.613 --> 03:34:51.164
On tobacco, the Commission has proposed
a revision of the Tobacco Taxation

03:34:51.233 --> 03:34:56.960
Directive, to also reflect the
health risks of novel products.

03:34:57.053 --> 03:35:02.704
And we intend to propose a revision
of the EU Tobacco Control Framework.

03:35:02.813 --> 03:35:08.751
And this will address novel products as
they pose the same risks with those of

03:35:08.821 --> 03:35:14.737
traditional tobacco products and, in
particular, pose very high concerns for the

03:35:14.851 --> 03:35:21.314
young generation. But cancer
does not exist in isolation.

03:35:21.473 --> 03:35:27.025
The same risk factors drive other
major non-communicable diseases.

03:35:27.113 --> 03:35:32.783
This is why last December the Commission
adopted the Safe Hearts Plan, addressing

03:35:32.856 --> 03:35:37.886
cardiovascular disease,
diabetes, and obesity.

03:35:38.093 --> 03:35:43.922
The two plans reinforce each
other, and share the same logic.

03:35:44.153 --> 03:35:51.600
Earlier action, healthier lifestyles,
stronger public health policies, and better

03:35:51.731 --> 03:35:57.713
outcome for people. Prevention
is only part of the answer.

03:35:57.893 --> 03:36:01.313
Diagnosis and treatment
matter just as much and both

03:36:01.673 --> 03:36:07.810
depend on innovation. The proposed
biotech act will help turn scientific

03:36:07.889 --> 03:36:12.556
breakthroughs into
state-of-the-art treatments faster.

03:36:12.773 --> 03:36:18.978
Personalized mRNA cancer vaccines
show what this means in practice.

03:36:19.073 --> 03:36:25.085
Biotechnology that trains each patient's
immune system to recognize and attack their

03:36:25.154 --> 03:36:32.853
own tumor. Moreover, the biotech act will
streamline clinical trials and facilitate

03:36:32.933 --> 03:36:38.962
complex technologies combining pharmaceuticals
and medical devices and artificial

03:36:39.056 --> 03:36:44.503
intelligence. The medical devices
reform will bring the next generation of

03:36:44.573 --> 03:36:52.143
diagnostics, from advanced imaging to new
cancer tests, to patients' faster so that

03:36:52.229 --> 03:36:57.226
cancer is detected earlier
when it is most treatable.

03:36:57.353 --> 03:37:02.741
It will also create a coherent
framework for AI-enabled devices.

03:37:02.873 --> 03:37:08.539
I count on your cooperation to conclude
these two important files swiftly.

03:37:08.633 --> 03:37:14.275
The revised EU Pharmaceutical Legislation,
which will soon enter into force, creates

03:37:14.344 --> 03:37:21.299
new incentives to develop medicines for
unmet medical needs including especially

03:37:21.399 --> 03:37:27.381
cancer. And the critical medicines act
will also help cancer patients get timely

03:37:27.476 --> 03:37:33.593
access to medicines they need. Breakthrough
diagnostics and therapies depend on high

03:37:33.674 --> 03:37:39.713
quality, and interconnected data. This is
why we're working on a swift rollout of

03:37:39.773 --> 03:37:46.334
the European Health Dataspace. With the
ambitious AI agenda, the President set out

03:37:46.406 --> 03:37:52.122
in the State of the Union speech, we aim
to bring its benefits to patients even

03:37:52.239 --> 03:38:00.738
before the 2029 application date. Honorable
Members, the right to be forgotten has

03:38:00.804 --> 03:38:04.562
been highlighted by this House many times.

03:38:04.793 --> 03:38:10.673
In response, the Commission held a public
consultation on this autumn, and is

03:38:10.733 --> 03:38:15.200
working to prepare guidance on fair
access to financial services for cancer

03:38:15.274 --> 03:38:22.013
survivors as a matter of priority. Looking
ahead, the Commission's proposal for the

03:38:22.081 --> 03:38:27.434
next long-term EU budget offers a coherent
funding framework for cancer-related

03:38:27.498 --> 03:38:33.775
actions. This reflects our commitment
to prevention, early detection, better

03:38:33.845 --> 03:38:38.033
treatment, and to our quality of life.
Thank you very much for your attention.

03:38:39.773 --> 03:38:45.122
Thank you very much, dear Commissioner. On
behalf, we jump into the second part, and

03:38:45.205 --> 03:38:48.593
on behalf of the EPP, has
the floor Mr. Arlosovic.

03:38:51.653 --> 03:38:56.542
Ladies and Gentlemen, this
will probably not be...

03:38:56.588 --> 03:39:01.028
the most popular speech in
the European Parliament.

03:39:01.092 --> 03:39:07.819
For months, we have been drafting yet
another report on how Europe should fight

03:39:07.883 --> 03:39:15.095
cancer. Dozens, hundreds of hours of
negotiations, meetings, discussions,

03:39:15.195 --> 03:39:22.083
persuasion, negotiating compromises –
you might think we were discussing how to

03:39:22.134 --> 03:39:27.092
secure affordable access to the most
advanced cancer therapies, for instance?

03:39:27.160 --> 03:39:31.072
For the most seriously ill
patients? No, Ladies and Gentlemen.

03:39:31.113 --> 03:39:35.328
Did you think we were discussing, for
example, how to improve the lot of women in

03:39:35.372 --> 03:39:38.635
Eastern Europe who die from cancers that
patients in Western Europe can survive?

03:39:38.673 --> 03:39:45.764
No. Did you think we were discussing
the fate of children in hospices?

03:39:46.071 --> 03:39:53.582
No. We have produced yet another report in
which, alongside cancer, we discussed the

03:39:53.654 --> 03:39:58.554
condition of companies
producing wine and cigarettes.

03:39:58.631 --> 03:40:02.531
And that is what the
negotiations were about.

03:40:02.580 --> 03:40:07.250
Weeks and months spent on this report,
just to make sure we do not harm those who

03:40:07.317 --> 03:40:12.036
produce alcohol and cigarettes. I do not
want to come across here as someone taking

03:40:12.106 --> 03:40:16.778
up a position of fighting
them. That is not the point.

03:40:16.824 --> 03:40:20.633
But I know that today, after the Europe’s
Beating Cancer Plan, which has never

03:40:20.686 --> 03:40:26.148
really been implemented, Europe is today
kneeling before cancer and surrendering.

03:40:26.197 --> 03:40:32.531
I know that it is far more spectacular to
build motorways, far more spectacular to

03:40:32.597 --> 03:40:35.472
launch programmes such
as Future for Europe.

03:40:35.537 --> 03:40:42.194
Ladies and Gentlemen, there will be no
Future until we all get our act together and

03:40:42.239 --> 03:40:47.118
remember why people sent us here. They
sent us here to help them survive.

03:40:47.193 --> 03:40:50.993
To help them fight cancer.
That is why we are here.

03:40:53.813 --> 03:40:58.493
Thank you very much, dear colleague.
On behalf of the S&D Group,

03:40:59.333 --> 03:41:00.533
Ms Moretti.

03:41:05.333 --> 03:41:10.139
Thank you, Mr President,
colleagues, fellow Members.

03:41:10.250 --> 03:41:16.709
Commissioner, tomorrow we will be called
upon to vote on a sensitive issue:

03:41:16.761 --> 03:41:21.846
the fight against cancer. Over the years,
this Parliament has repeatedly reaffirmed

03:41:21.908 --> 03:41:27.416
its closeness to patients and their
families, its support for research, doctors,

03:41:27.482 --> 03:41:31.308
nurses, in favour of prevention
and against risk factors.

03:41:31.359 --> 03:41:36.008
The text that emerged from the Committee
is balanced and reflects the Parliament’s

03:41:36.085 --> 03:41:40.558
consolidated positions. However, I am
very concerned about the attempts by

03:41:40.623 --> 03:41:44.159
right-wing groups to
weaken prevention measures.

03:41:44.218 --> 03:41:47.743
I address my fellow Members
who will be voting tomorrow:

03:41:47.811 --> 03:41:53.839
patients, their families, doctors,
associations fighting cancer, they are watching

03:41:53.909 --> 03:41:59.306
you. Do not put economic interests,
powerful lobbies, before health.

03:41:59.416 --> 03:42:04.765
Do not do it. Reject the dangerous
amendments on tobacco and alcohol.

03:42:04.842 --> 03:42:10.018
Put the fight against cancer at the heart
of this Parliament’s political action.

03:42:10.097 --> 03:42:13.388
Do not compromise at
the expense of people.

03:42:13.459 --> 03:42:14.659
Thank you.

03:42:16.733 --> 03:42:20.560
Grazie, Onorevole. On
behalf of the PFE Group, Mr.

03:42:20.633 --> 03:42:21.833
Hauser.

03:42:26.213 --> 03:42:28.940
Thank you, Mr Chair. Mr
President, thank you very much.

03:42:28.992 --> 03:42:32.874
Commissioner, the most important thing,
and this has already been mentioned today,

03:42:32.910 --> 03:42:37.514
is that we help cancer patients. And we
know, and unfortunately, this is being

03:42:37.561 --> 03:42:43.524
overlooked not only in this House but
everywhere, including in the Committee on the

03:42:43.635 --> 03:42:49.598
Environment, Public Health and Food
Safety, that since the introduction of the

03:42:49.677 --> 03:42:53.761
COVID-19 vaccination in 2020,
cancer numbers have exploded.

03:42:53.816 --> 03:42:59.676
Why is this being overlooked? Commissioner,
you are also aware of the figures for

03:42:59.730 --> 03:43:03.537
deaths and severe side effects linked
to COVID-19 vaccinations that have been

03:43:03.566 --> 03:43:06.845
reported to the European Medicines Agency.

03:43:06.982 --> 03:43:13.744
I currently have the figures here. As of
26 October, around 30,000 deaths linked to

03:43:13.797 --> 03:43:18.579
COVID-19 vaccinations have been reported.
With an estimated reporting rate of 5,000

03:43:18.649 --> 03:43:24.116
to 6,000 percent, the total number of
all side effects is around 3 million.

03:43:24.168 --> 03:43:28.939
If you extrapolate that, you get
over 40 million people affected.

03:43:29.008 --> 03:43:33.513
And this is being ignored. And among
those affected are many people who have

03:43:33.564 --> 03:43:37.858
developed cancer. And that is why,
Commissioner, I urge you to look at what is

03:43:37.921 --> 03:43:43.243
happening in America. We finally need a
clinic for vaccine victims here in Europe

03:43:43.318 --> 03:43:47.414
too, as has been introduced in
America since October of this year.

03:43:47.486 --> 03:43:50.033
Let us finally help
those harmed by vaccines.

03:43:51.053 --> 03:43:52.313
Thank you very much.

03:43:53.093 --> 03:43:54.293
Mr Fiocchi.

03:44:00.173 --> 03:44:05.469
Mr President, dear colleagues, the text
that emerged from the Sente Commission in

03:44:05.518 --> 03:44:11.281
the section on prevention remains
ideological, paternalistic, does not take into

03:44:11.348 --> 03:44:17.299
account scientific evidence, including
the different levels of risk between

03:44:17.374 --> 03:44:24.991
traditional smoking and alternatives.
Furthermore, failing to align the wording on

03:44:25.097 --> 03:44:30.761
'harmful alcohol consumption' with the
initiative on cardiovascular diseases

03:44:30.858 --> 03:44:34.465
contradicts the principles
of Better Regulation.

03:44:34.529 --> 03:44:41.044
I would have liked to see a document more
aligned between cardiovascular and bacon.

03:44:41.102 --> 03:44:45.779
This is a real shame, because the European
cancer plan contains many important

03:44:45.870 --> 03:44:52.525
elements, in particular the push on the
database, especially for rare diseases and

03:44:52.586 --> 03:44:57.251
paediatric cancers, which should have been
a little bolder and more aggressive, but

03:44:57.364 --> 03:45:03.568
also the reference to prevention screening
and so on, which is a bit weak, though

03:45:03.625 --> 03:45:08.688
heading in the right direction. I would
have liked to see something more aggressive.

03:45:08.731 --> 03:45:13.608
We certainly welcome the sharing of knowledge
at European level, thanks also to the

03:45:13.660 --> 03:45:19.529
European reference networks, but overall
more could have been done to share data and

03:45:19.602 --> 03:45:28.523
experiences more quickly for fairer and
more equitable treatment for citizens.

03:45:28.678 --> 03:45:35.299
Let us remember that, indeed, raising
taxes on tobacco and alcohol only favours

03:45:35.351 --> 03:45:41.820
criminal organisations, so we need a much
more delicate approach to this, and again

03:45:41.912 --> 03:45:47.150
I would really like to see a more aggressive
approach, especially on oncological

03:45:47.270 --> 03:45:50.633
screening and rare diseases. Thank you.

03:45:53.693 --> 03:45:58.130
Thank you very much, but I really beg
you to stick to the time because we are

03:45:58.230 --> 03:46:03.328
already out of our time schedule, so the
next speaker is Vice President Sophie

03:46:03.378 --> 03:46:08.398
Wilmitz on behalf of the Renew Group.
Please, for one minute, and I really beg to

03:46:08.448 --> 03:46:10.193
stick to the time. Thank you, Chair.

03:46:10.313 --> 03:46:15.880
Dear colleagues, tonight I want to talk
to you about rare cancers with a poor

03:46:15.936 --> 03:46:22.077
prognosis, because while rare cancers are
indeed mentioned in this text, those with

03:46:22.149 --> 03:46:25.927
a poor prognosis are not. And yet,
I believe we need to address this.

03:46:25.987 --> 03:46:31.254
We need to address it because these
cancers, such as certain brain tumours, face

03:46:31.308 --> 03:46:36.363
multiple obstacles that a global strategy,
however useful it may be, is not enough

03:46:36.441 --> 03:46:42.140
to overcome. The major issue with rare
cancers with a poor prognosis is that we have

03:46:42.196 --> 03:46:46.030
too few patients and too few experts
in each country taken separately.

03:46:46.093 --> 03:46:51.061
And so, without a real European ecosystem
to connect them, there are few clinical

03:46:51.110 --> 03:46:55.770
trials, little incentive to invest in
treatments, and consequently, little progress

03:46:55.842 --> 03:47:01.333
in research – even though this progress
would directly benefit the fight against all

03:47:01.380 --> 03:47:05.633
cancers. This situation, dear colleagues,
for most patients with a rare cancer with

03:47:05.689 --> 03:47:09.180
a poor prognosis, is a death
sentence within five years.

03:47:09.254 --> 03:47:14.289
So, while the resolution lays the
foundations for this ecosystem, and I welcome

03:47:14.342 --> 03:47:18.843
that, and I would also like to thank our
rapporteur, for these patients, for these

03:47:18.900 --> 03:47:23.441
families too, we must do more. We must
ensure that the next European budget includes

03:47:23.507 --> 03:47:27.408
dedicated funding for research
into these particular cancers;

03:47:27.470 --> 03:47:31.008
this funding must be guaranteed
and commensurate with the needs.

03:47:31.066 --> 03:47:32.266
Thank you.

03:47:33.773 --> 03:47:36.953
The next speaker is Billy
Metz on behalf of the Greens.

03:47:39.713 --> 03:47:40.913
Thank you, President.

03:47:41.873 --> 03:47:47.979
Colleagues, by 2040, cancer is projected
to become the leading cause of death in the

03:47:48.035 --> 03:47:54.305
European Union, and mortality
rates are expected to rise by 30%.

03:47:54.653 --> 03:48:00.306
These figures are a wake-up call. They
remind us why the work we are discussing

03:48:00.385 --> 03:48:06.106
today matters so much, but they also
remind us that we must look ahead.

03:48:06.173 --> 03:48:11.243
We cannot afford to lose
ambition of Europe's cancer plan.

03:48:11.393 --> 03:48:17.420
That means also taking prevention seriously,
and it starts with one fundamental

03:48:17.497 --> 03:48:23.740
principle: economic interest must never
become come before the precautionary

03:48:23.795 --> 03:48:26.846
principle and the
protection of public health.

03:48:26.933 --> 03:48:32.563
Because reducing our exposure to risk
factors, from tobacco and alcohol to

03:48:32.643 --> 03:48:38.595
environmental pollution, is not just
about reducing numbers, it's about saving

03:48:38.693 --> 03:48:44.737
lives. And reducing the enormous social
and economic burden of cancer, we have the

03:48:44.796 --> 03:48:50.096
knowledge, we have the tools, what we need
now is the political act, the political

03:48:50.163 --> 03:48:54.233
courage to act. For a healthier
Europe and for a better future.

03:48:54.293 --> 03:48:55.193
Thank you.

03:48:55.193 --> 03:48:59.273
Thank you very much. The next speaker
is Robert Gabel on behalf of the Left.

03:49:05.033 --> 03:49:09.540
When we talk here and today about the fight
against cancer, we must also discuss the

03:49:09.633 --> 03:49:15.894
fact that many cancer cases can be
prevented through environmental and animal

03:49:15.970 --> 03:49:22.346
protection. Because many cases are caused
by environmental toxins, air pollution or

03:49:22.413 --> 03:49:25.806
meat consumption.
Particularly processed meat.

03:49:25.884 --> 03:49:28.326
And we can no longer
ignore these connections.

03:49:28.382 --> 03:49:34.724
There is one health, and it consists of
the health of people, animals and the

03:49:34.784 --> 03:49:41.451
environment. If we want to take cancer
prevention seriously, we must take this into

03:49:41.539 --> 03:49:46.518
account. And health is
not an economic burden;

03:49:46.614 --> 03:49:52.778
rather, if we do it right, it is a benefit
for the environment, animals and people.

03:49:52.834 --> 03:49:58.137
And I would like a European Union that
takes this into account and heeds it.

03:49:58.181 --> 03:50:00.344
And thank you for being
here today, Commissioner.

03:50:00.388 --> 03:50:04.555
I hope for a Commissioner who also
takes this into account and heeds it.

03:50:04.587 --> 03:50:05.787
Thank you.

03:50:06.413 --> 03:50:09.220
Thank you. The next
speaker is Tomislav Sokol.

03:50:09.282 --> 03:50:11.873
Please, the floor is yours for one minute.

03:50:15.173 --> 03:50:20.310
Vice-President, Commissioner, honourable
colleagues, every 24 seconds one person in

03:50:20.373 --> 03:50:25.418
the European Union dies from cancer.
Knowing that 40% of cancer cases can be

03:50:25.478 --> 03:50:30.251
prevented, we must invest more in prevention,
raising awareness and early detection

03:50:30.333 --> 03:50:35.228
programmes. At the same time, we must
strongly invest in research, development and

03:50:35.273 --> 03:50:39.237
innovative therapies. That is precisely
why, in the next multiannual financial

03:50:39.282 --> 03:50:44.174
framework, we must secure a fixed budget
for health and continue to implement the

03:50:44.238 --> 03:50:49.095
European Cancer Plan excellently. In doing
so, access to the best possible treatment

03:50:49.147 --> 03:50:52.096
must not depend on the Member
State in which someone lives.

03:50:52.144 --> 03:50:56.666
Joint public procurement, which we are
introducing through the Critical Medicines

03:50:56.719 --> 03:51:01.025
Act, will enable medicines to be available
to patients from smaller Member States

03:51:01.094 --> 03:51:04.650
much earlier and on more
favourable terms than before.

03:51:04.713 --> 03:51:08.839
Lastly, I would like to highlight in
particular the right to be forgotten.

03:51:08.887 --> 03:51:12.987
People who have survived cancer must not
be discriminated against when accessing

03:51:13.044 --> 03:51:17.254
credit, insurance or other financial
services because of the disease they have

03:51:17.303 --> 03:51:21.339
overcome. We have clearly laid this down
in the Consumer Credit Directive, and I

03:51:21.392 --> 03:51:24.888
hope that the same will apply in
other laws that we will adopt.

03:51:24.927 --> 03:51:25.973
Thank you.

03:51:25.973 --> 03:51:28.793
Thank you. The next speaker
is Alexander Nikolić.

03:51:32.213 --> 03:51:36.809
In this report on cancers, you mention the
issue of sedentary lifestyles, that is,

03:51:36.866 --> 03:51:41.248
the lack of physical activity, and
yes, it is true, it is a real scourge.

03:51:41.295 --> 03:51:45.651
You also mention junk food, and here too,
it is true, it is a major risk factor.

03:51:45.702 --> 03:51:50.506
So, it would be logical to combat sedentary
lifestyles and junk food in order to

03:51:50.591 --> 03:51:53.202
fight cancer. Well,
look how clever we are.

03:51:53.249 --> 03:51:57.749
In Emmanuel Macron’s France, we have
taken this observation and done the exact

03:51:57.825 --> 03:52:02.463
opposite. Yes, we give fine speeches and
produce nice ad campaigns encouraging

03:52:02.517 --> 03:52:06.307
people to take up sport and
adopt a healthy, balanced diet.

03:52:06.344 --> 03:52:09.894
But in reality, in everyday life, if you
want to pay for a gym membership or sign up

03:52:09.949 --> 03:52:15.820
for paddle tennis, you will pay 20% VAT.
Likewise, if you want to play tennis in an

03:52:15.870 --> 03:52:18.414
association, you will pay
20% VAT on your racket.

03:52:18.467 --> 03:52:24.145
If your child plays football, well, you
will also pay 20% VAT on their boots.

03:52:24.203 --> 03:52:30.116
On the other hand, if you want to buy a
large, extra-large, jumbo, greasy Big Mac

03:52:30.185 --> 03:52:34.035
meal at McDonald’s, you will
pay 10% VAT, half as much.

03:52:34.127 --> 03:52:39.021
It’s a fact. Macron’s France uses taxation
to encourage people to eat a Big Mac

03:52:39.078 --> 03:52:43.607
rather than do sport. We might laugh at
this inversion of values, but unfortunately,

03:52:43.649 --> 03:52:44.849
it costs lives.

03:52:45.053 --> 03:52:47.273
Thank you. The next
speaker is Monika Benyova.

03:52:50.573 --> 03:52:54.620
Mr Commissioner, colleagues, ladies and
gentlemen, when we talk about the risks of

03:52:54.665 --> 03:52:59.448
developing oncological diseases in connection
with products, that risk depends on

03:52:59.500 --> 03:53:04.622
the nature of the product, its composition,
the degree of processing, as well as the

03:53:04.668 --> 03:53:09.236
manner and extent of its consumption. Not
all products pose the same level of health

03:53:09.292 --> 03:53:13.853
risk. Processed red meat does not, after
all, carry the same health risk as lean

03:53:13.915 --> 03:53:17.896
unprocessed red meat. Similarly,
different types of alcoholic beverages are

03:53:17.962 --> 03:53:22.115
associated with different patterns
of consumption and health risks.

03:53:22.168 --> 03:53:27.746
And differences in health consequences
also exist, for example, between individual

03:53:27.803 --> 03:53:31.696
tobacco and nicotine products. Recognising
these differences is simply a matter of

03:53:31.747 --> 03:53:34.597
scientific objectivity and
responsible policymaking.

03:53:34.649 --> 03:53:38.858
And it is precisely this approach that
allows us to adopt more targeted and

03:53:38.918 --> 03:53:43.665
effective measures instead of blanket bans
and restrictions, which may ultimately do

03:53:43.721 --> 03:53:48.674
more harm than good. That is why I
urge you to recognise the principle of

03:53:48.729 --> 03:53:53.035
distinguishing between products according
to the level of health risk they pose.

03:53:53.080 --> 03:53:57.228
I am convinced that this is the right path
that will enable us to fight cancer more

03:53:57.283 --> 03:54:02.210
effectively and, at the same time, build
a truly functional European Health Union.

03:54:02.263 --> 03:54:02.753
Thank you.

03:54:02.753 --> 03:54:05.993
Thank you very much. The
next speaker is András Kulya.

03:54:10.253 --> 03:54:14.366
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen,
Commissioner, dear colleagues.

03:54:14.418 --> 03:54:19.483
As a doctor, I have seen how a cancer
diagnosis can change an entire family's life

03:54:19.546 --> 03:54:24.759
in a single moment. The future becomes
uncertain, and no amount of time can be

03:54:24.840 --> 03:54:29.797
regained that was lost due to
delayed diagnosis or late treatment.

03:54:29.862 --> 03:54:35.477
Tomorrow, we will vote on the report on
the implementation of the Europe's Beating

03:54:35.568 --> 03:54:42.095
Cancer Plan. Ensuring access to prevention,
screening, and modern treatments is our

03:54:42.183 --> 03:54:48.361
shared European responsibility. For Tisza,
the goal was clear both before and after

03:54:48.441 --> 03:54:53.883
the change of government: healthcare
must serve prevention and recovery.

03:54:53.963 --> 03:55:00.568
This requires functional screening programmes,
sufficient healthcare professionals,

03:55:00.631 --> 03:55:04.201
timely diagnostics, and
care accessible to society.

03:55:04.261 --> 03:55:08.908
Health cannot be a privilege,
neither in Hungary nor in Europe.

03:55:08.970 --> 03:55:14.272
Every life lost is a warning we cannot
ignore in silence, so I ask you to support

03:55:14.355 --> 03:55:16.433
the report tomorrow. Thank you.

03:55:17.213 --> 03:55:21.773
Thank you very much. And now the last
speaker on the speakers' list is Jessica

03:55:21.833 --> 03:55:23.033
Pohl-Fiat.

03:55:28.673 --> 03:55:35.462
Madam President, Commissioner. Mr President,
Commissioner, in Sweden, around 10

03:55:35.634 --> 03:55:40.983
million people live in the world. The
same number of people die of cancer every

03:55:41.040 --> 03:55:47.523
year. A Sweden lost to cancer every year.
In Europe, around 1.2 million people die

03:55:47.602 --> 03:55:50.546
of cancer. Every Member
State must do more.

03:55:50.610 --> 03:55:55.280
Where you live should not determine when
you receive your diagnosis or how you

03:55:55.356 --> 03:56:00.141
receive your treatment. That is why there
is a great responsibility on the Member

03:56:00.202 --> 03:56:06.142
States to develop and implement national
cancer plans with clear and measurable

03:56:06.257 --> 03:56:10.833
targets. Within the EU, we must
continue the work that has begun:

03:56:10.913 --> 03:56:16.530
investing in research and cooperation
by sharing data and reducing disparities

03:56:16.594 --> 03:56:18.897
between regions and between women and men.

03:56:19.002 --> 03:56:24.523
The fight against cancer continues, for all
those who have fought, for those who are

03:56:24.586 --> 03:56:28.946
fighting, and for all those
who will fight in the future.

03:56:29.019 --> 03:56:30.233
Thank you, Mr President.

03:56:30.893 --> 03:56:33.735
Thank you very much. And now
we come to the catch the eye.

03:56:33.773 --> 03:56:37.655
And the first speaker on catch the eye
is Esther Herranz-García, for one minute

03:56:37.710 --> 03:56:42.183
please, and I beg the colleagues to stick
to the one minute because then we can take

03:56:42.241 --> 03:56:44.153
more colleagues under
catch the eye. Thank you.

03:56:49.013 --> 03:56:55.363
With this text, which affects us all. But
after carefully reading your amendments to

03:56:55.448 --> 03:56:59.600
the text, I have to tell you that this is
as serious a matter as cancer, and that we

03:56:59.651 --> 03:57:04.796
must be guided by scientific rigour and
not attack or demonise, for ideological

03:57:04.851 --> 03:57:08.828
reasons, food sectors such as
the meat or wine industries.

03:57:08.908 --> 03:57:13.674
This is not scientific and only threatens
the way of life and livelihoods of

03:57:13.725 --> 03:57:18.791
thousands of families who are the backbone
of Europe and rural areas, and who

03:57:18.907 --> 03:57:23.091
maintain our heritage. It is very far
removed from the fight against cancer, which

03:57:23.153 --> 03:57:28.417
is what truly matters. Wine, when consumed
in a moderate and responsible manner, is

03:57:28.475 --> 03:57:33.180
a natural foodstuff and is recognised
by numerous studies as a pillar of the

03:57:33.236 --> 03:57:38.301
Mediterranean diet, which is also
recognised as being balanced, complete and

03:57:38.366 --> 03:57:43.593
sufficient. Linked to a healthy lifestyle,
with a lower incidence of various

03:57:43.674 --> 03:57:49.652
diseases. It is not acceptable to link all
alcohol or meat consumption with cancer.

03:57:49.736 --> 03:57:55.108
That is ideology, not science. We cannot
confuse the public or criminalise our

03:57:55.170 --> 03:58:00.387
culture. We must protect health, but let
us do so with common sense, education and

03:58:00.457 --> 03:58:03.579
science, not with ideology
and indoctrination.

03:58:03.644 --> 03:58:04.373
Thank you.

03:58:04.373 --> 03:58:07.433
Thank you very much. The next
speaker is Christian Vigenin.

03:58:12.413 --> 03:58:17.748
The fight against cancer should not depend
on the country you live in or how much

03:58:17.842 --> 03:58:23.172
you earn. But reality is different. In
Bulgaria, the five-year survival rate for

03:58:23.255 --> 03:58:29.300
colorectal cancer is 52%, compared to
an average of 60% in the European Union.

03:58:29.355 --> 03:58:33.938
For lung cancer, the difference
is even more alarming:

03:58:34.007 --> 03:58:37.413
8% versus 15%. Behind these
figures lie human lives.

03:58:37.473 --> 03:58:42.906
The causes include late diagnosis,
insufficient prevention, and unequal access to

03:58:42.976 --> 03:58:47.895
modern technologies. That is why the
European Cancer Plan must be backed by real

03:58:47.959 --> 03:58:52.394
resources. We insist that the next
multiannual financial framework guarantees at

03:58:52.456 --> 03:58:56.762
least two and a half billion euros
for the fight against cancer.

03:58:56.811 --> 03:59:01.020
And national health systems should align
their priorities with the common European

03:59:01.088 --> 03:59:06.176
goals so as to strengthen the exchange of
experience and best practices and improve

03:59:06.229 --> 03:59:09.765
outcomes in cross-border
treatment of cancer patients.

03:59:09.825 --> 03:59:14.275
Healthcare and the fight against cancer
are not charity, nor an expense at the

03:59:14.343 --> 03:59:17.462
expense of competitiveness.
Healthy people work.

03:59:17.523 --> 03:59:20.371
They create. They
contribute to the economy.

03:59:20.434 --> 03:59:24.126
Investment in healthcare is an
investment in Europe’s future.

03:59:24.181 --> 03:59:25.381
Thank you.

03:59:25.433 --> 03:59:28.433
Thank you very much. The next
speaker is Sebastian Tynkenen.

03:59:32.933 --> 03:59:38.094
Mr President. Who should be
responsible for promoting non-smoking?

03:59:38.182 --> 03:59:45.361
For many, the first thought is the family,
loved ones and the individual smoker

03:59:45.470 --> 03:59:53.404
themselves. After that, the state –
everyone understands that the state taxes

03:59:53.478 --> 03:59:56.556
tobacco in order to combat
its harms, such as cancer.

03:59:56.607 --> 04:00:02.865
But does the spouse coughing from second-hand
smoke think that the EU needs to step

04:00:02.956 --> 04:00:07.317
in? In Brussels, however,
this is how it is thought.

04:00:07.395 --> 04:00:11.653
At EU level, for example, calls have
been made to ban smoking on terraces.

04:00:11.745 --> 04:00:17.686
Have we really forgotten that some things
are entirely a matter for the national

04:00:17.766 --> 04:00:22.623
level? It seems so. The European Commission,
for its part, came out with a proposal

04:00:22.675 --> 04:00:27.948
in which it would start collecting over
€11 billion a year from Member States’

04:00:28.043 --> 04:00:31.992
tobacco taxes for its own
budget. There must be a limit.

04:00:32.051 --> 04:00:37.373
Combating smoking is a worthwhile
cause, but this constant EU grab is not.

04:00:40.373 --> 04:00:42.113
The next speaker is Helmut Brandstetter.

04:00:45.413 --> 04:00:51.417
Thank you. Madam President, I would like
to use this important report on combating

04:00:51.471 --> 04:00:55.855
cancer in Europe to thank all the researchers
who have done outstanding work over

04:00:55.909 --> 04:01:01.166
the past years and again this year. We know
that there are medicines that have only

04:01:01.240 --> 04:01:05.820
just been newly developed this year to
treat various forms of cancer, such as

04:01:05.878 --> 04:01:09.112
bladder cancer, lung
cancer and breast cancer.

04:01:09.175 --> 04:01:13.231
We know that excellent progress
is being made on cancer vaccines.

04:01:13.286 --> 04:01:19.024
There are already some, and new mRNA
vaccines are also being developed, and these

04:01:19.080 --> 04:01:23.554
will help us too. We must be grateful to
these researchers, and we can see just how

04:01:23.610 --> 04:01:27.919
great Europe is when we look at the
collaborations they are engaged in.

04:01:27.977 --> 04:01:31.927
I am familiar with the work being done at
Austrian universities, but I also know—and

04:01:31.974 --> 04:01:35.679
they have told me this—that
they are working with others.

04:01:35.723 --> 04:01:38.687
Thank you also to the many people
who care for cancer patients.

04:01:38.740 --> 04:01:43.924
And finally, a word because America was
praised from the right side of the House.

04:01:43.988 --> 04:01:49.369
Well, there they have abolished vaccinations,
which has led to many preventable

04:01:49.435 --> 04:01:55.609
deaths there. That is dangerous. Europe
is doing better, and that is a good thing.

04:01:55.639 --> 04:01:56.839
Thank you.

04:01:59.993 --> 04:02:02.033
Next speaker is Ana Miranda Paz.

04:02:05.213 --> 04:02:13.000
Thank you very much. Cancer is the leading
cause of death in my country, Galicia.

04:02:13.062 --> 04:02:19.378
Delays in the waiting lists for appointments,
delays in diagnosis, failing health

04:02:19.446 --> 04:02:24.707
platforms, and rulings against
the Galician health service.

04:02:24.839 --> 04:02:29.831
Waits of more than a year to receive
treatment, to have mammograms, MRIs,

04:02:29.905 --> 04:02:37.199
endoscopies, I stress, delays in diagnoses,
delays in follow-up consultations, and

04:02:37.267 --> 04:02:42.772
in reviewing people treated for cancer.
Difficulty in securing primary care

04:02:42.858 --> 04:02:49.163
appointments. There needs to be more
preventive policies and more public policies,

04:02:49.227 --> 04:02:54.539
such as support for public health, which
we have always called for, and not closing

04:02:54.607 --> 04:02:59.962
health centres, as well as policies to
support those who have been waiting for more

04:03:00.010 --> 04:03:05.139
than a year for cancer treatment or
diagnosis, and policies that also support

04:03:05.219 --> 04:03:08.393
psychological treatment and
research. Thank you very much.

04:03:10.133 --> 04:03:13.793
Thank you. The next speaker
is Lefteris Nikolaou Alvanos.

04:03:18.173 --> 04:03:22.595
The report places the blame for the problem
on the aging population while taking

04:03:22.640 --> 04:03:25.479
measures to strengthen
pharmaceutical giants and monopolies.

04:03:25.541 --> 04:03:29.698
It brazenly conceals the root causes, such
as the deterioration of workers' living

04:03:29.735 --> 04:03:32.893
conditions, the degradation of the natural
environment by monopolies, exposure to

04:03:32.937 --> 04:03:36.485
hazardous substances at work, the
commodification and privatisation of healthcare,

04:03:36.548 --> 04:03:41.035
which deprives the people of prevention.
It shifts individual responsibility onto

04:03:41.086 --> 04:03:45.341
the people, perceives cancer as lost working
hours and a cost for corporate groups.

04:03:45.387 --> 04:03:48.956
It erects obstacles to therapeutic treatment,
stifling research which is squeezed by

04:03:48.996 --> 04:03:52.979
the competition between pharmaceutical
monopolies, the European Union, the United

04:03:53.032 --> 04:03:57.898
States, and China, and in this race,
European corporate groups are being rewarded.

04:03:57.949 --> 04:04:01.412
In line with the dismantling and
commodification of the public healthcare system,

04:04:01.454 --> 04:04:05.271
and the continuous increase in the cost
of medication for the people, workers and

04:04:05.326 --> 04:04:08.739
healthcare professionals are fighting for
a unified, exclusively public and free

04:04:08.782 --> 04:04:12.403
healthcare system, research, and treatment
for cancer, free from any business

04:04:12.463 --> 04:04:16.639
activity. Strong primary care, free prevention
and medication, fully staffed public

04:04:16.688 --> 04:04:20.441
healthcare structures, and healthcare
professionals employed on a full-time and

04:04:20.480 --> 04:04:21.680
exclusive basis.

04:04:23.153 --> 04:04:25.913
Thank you. And the last speaker,
undercatch the ice, Ochana Glavak.

04:04:31.133 --> 04:04:34.684
Thank you very much, esteemed
Vice-President, Commissioner, colleagues.

04:04:34.740 --> 04:04:40.435
Five years after its launch, we need to
assess the success or failure in terms of

04:04:40.508 --> 04:04:44.257
prevention, early detection
and access to treatment.

04:04:44.328 --> 04:04:50.845
Since 2021, we have allocated 4 billion
euros for the fight against cancer.

04:04:50.944 --> 04:04:56.756
Therefore, Commissioner, continuity of
funding must not be a budgetary compromise,

04:04:56.818 --> 04:04:59.957
and I believe you will
agree with me on this.

04:05:00.023 --> 04:05:03.727
It is not enough merely to report
on the number of projects launched;

04:05:03.773 --> 04:05:08.321
we must, of course, continue to invest
in innovation and new technologies.

04:05:08.384 --> 04:05:13.783
We need to know how many diseases were
detected in time, how survival rates have

04:05:13.841 --> 04:05:18.992
improved and whether we have reduced risks
and disparities between Member States.

04:05:19.065 --> 04:05:25.167
The ultimate outcome of this plan must not
be the number of funded projects, but the

04:05:25.226 --> 04:05:30.014
number of timely detected diseases,
successful treatments and lives saved.

04:05:30.081 --> 04:05:35.300
Where you live must not
determine whether you will live.

04:05:35.383 --> 04:05:38.583
We have heard this said
several times today.

04:05:38.649 --> 04:05:39.849
Thank you very much.

04:05:40.373 --> 04:05:44.633
Thank you. And now I pass the floor for
one minute to Commissioner Várhelyi.

04:05:54.353 --> 04:05:59.049
Dear President, Honorable Members, I think
that from the debate it's very clear that

04:05:59.093 --> 04:06:03.653
the Europe's beating cancer plan has
already started to change the landscape of

04:06:03.743 --> 04:06:09.917
cancer policy in Europe. Across the
whole cancer pathway, from prevention to

04:06:09.985 --> 04:06:15.771
detection, treatment, and quality of life,
of survivors and also their families.

04:06:15.833 --> 04:06:21.540
So now we must build on that progress, and
this should mean that we will prioritize

04:06:21.606 --> 04:06:26.744
even further prevention, we should strengthen
the synergies between the two plans,

04:06:26.798 --> 04:06:31.349
so the safe house plan and the Europe
beating cancer plan, and also finalizing the

04:06:31.397 --> 04:06:38.180
health package without delay. To Mrs.
Glavac, it follows from this debate that of

04:06:38.248 --> 04:06:43.368
course our commitment is long-term, and
this is why the Europe beating cancer plan

04:06:43.433 --> 04:06:47.093
must continue into the
next MFF. And to Mr.

04:06:47.153 --> 04:06:50.318
Hauser, this is not
the first time that Mr.

04:06:50.393 --> 04:06:56.213
Hauser raises this point, and several times
I have explained to him that the EMA is

04:06:56.309 --> 04:07:02.223
carrying out all the studies when it comes
to side effects of COVID vaccines, and it

04:07:02.304 --> 04:07:06.953
has not confirmed any of the
findings or allegations, Mr.

04:07:07.013 --> 04:07:12.067
Hauser claims. And I also want to
reiterate here that the European Cancer

04:07:12.122 --> 04:07:19.298
Information System or the European Cancer
Inequality Registry which are our sources

04:07:19.433 --> 04:07:29.113
of information do not, I underline, do
not, do not give any credible data of any

04:07:29.213 --> 04:07:33.596
explosion when it comes to cancer
related to the use of COVID vaccines.

04:07:33.653 --> 04:07:34.733
Thank you very much.

04:07:34.733 --> 04:07:41.076
Thank you very much. And now I pass the
floor to our rapporteur, Vlad Vasile

04:07:41.193 --> 04:07:43.433
Voiculescu. For two minutes, please.

04:07:44.453 --> 04:07:49.435
Thank you. I would like to thank everyone
for your contributions and to this debate

04:07:49.491 --> 04:07:53.721
and in particular I would like to thank the
Commissioner for his remarks and for the

04:07:53.780 --> 04:07:59.516
commitment made here today. There was also
something that I would like to draw your

04:07:59.573 --> 04:08:03.464
attention to, and that's especially
after analyzing the amendments that were

04:08:03.530 --> 04:08:08.508
submitted. I count on your sharp memory
to remember that this report is about

04:08:08.573 --> 04:08:13.913
fighting cancer, and this report is a
trajectory correction or of the plan to

04:08:13.973 --> 04:08:17.204
prevent and stop cancer
for millions of Europeans.

04:08:17.273 --> 04:08:22.263
One in five cancers are attributed to
tobacco, nevertheless this is exactly where

04:08:22.325 --> 04:08:28.709
amendments were tabled. Amendment 12 swaps
without further delay for in a timely

04:08:28.785 --> 04:08:33.529
manner. What is in a timely manner? For
me that was at least five years ago.

04:08:33.593 --> 04:08:38.826
Amendment 5 kills the health assessment
of a new product before it reaches the

04:08:38.891 --> 04:08:44.493
market. Because we should just throw
novel products, novel tobacco products or

04:08:44.603 --> 04:08:50.539
vaping at our kids, right? We're told a
health assessment is not necessary and to

04:08:50.583 --> 04:08:55.691
protect and that we should protect
the growing tobacco agriculture.

04:08:55.793 --> 04:09:02.333
A tobacco costs member states 80. 7, 80.7
billion euros a year, and in a report on

04:09:02.393 --> 04:09:07.519
beating cancer, defending the product
that causes cancer is just shameful.

04:09:07.613 --> 04:09:12.836
Imagine you had a magic wand. You could
bring a child's mother back who died from

04:09:12.882 --> 04:09:17.261
breast cancer, you could lift a child
out of a hospital bed where she or he can

04:09:17.339 --> 04:09:22.695
barely breathe for popcorn lungs, would
you look at that child and say we have a

04:09:22.752 --> 04:09:25.083
rural industry to
protect? I don't think so.

04:09:25.133 --> 04:09:30.501
We have no magic wand, we just have our
vote and thus it's strongly I strongly

04:09:30.557 --> 04:09:35.399
encourage you to exercise your moral
virtue and vote against diluting the text.

04:09:35.453 --> 04:09:40.149
Vote the reports as in the sand
as adopted in the sand committee.

04:09:40.193 --> 04:09:41.393
Thank you.

04:09:43.553 --> 04:09:47.056
The debate is now closed.
Voting will take place tomorrow.

04:09:47.135 --> 04:09:50.736
We now move on to the
next item on the agenda.

04:09:50.781 --> 04:09:54.181
This concerns the Council and Commission
declaration on resilience against

04:09:54.235 --> 04:09:59.008
cyber-attacks and other hybrid threats
to protect critical infrastructure and

04:09:59.088 --> 04:10:04.282
essential supply chains. And I now give
the floor, first of all in the name of the

04:10:04.345 --> 04:10:05.545
Council, to

04:10:06.113 --> 04:10:10.405
the Minister of State for Further
Education, Apprenticeship, Construction and

04:10:10.455 --> 04:10:15.353
Climate Skills, Marianne Harkin. The
floor is yours for five minutes, please.

04:10:22.373 --> 04:10:30.667
President, Honorable Members, and
Executive Vice President of the Commission.

04:10:30.773 --> 04:10:36.773
Cyber resilience, of critical infrastructure
supply chains, is becoming more and

04:10:36.863 --> 04:10:43.778
more essential as digitalization impacts
all sectors and as the threats to our

04:10:43.906 --> 04:10:49.708
security evolve. Indeed, that is something
every one of us here today in this

04:10:49.774 --> 04:10:54.073
Parliament and across the
EU are concerned with.

04:10:54.293 --> 04:11:00.673
Particularly due to recent and perhaps
not so recent events, back in May this

04:11:00.753 --> 04:11:08.191
Parliament debated advanced AI systems
and how they can be used to combat cyber

04:11:08.319 --> 04:11:14.270
attacks. Now we see attacks on our supermarkets
that threaten our supply chains and

04:11:14.333 --> 04:11:18.224
impact the everyday lives of our citizens.

04:11:18.353 --> 04:11:24.056
Indeed, just today and in previous days
we see threats issued to schools in my own

04:11:24.122 --> 04:11:28.486
country, Ireland, and in
other EU member states.

04:11:28.613 --> 04:11:36.141
These threats are designed to cause real
anxiety, huge uncertainty, and fear among

04:11:36.293 --> 04:11:42.743
parents, school communities, and
indeed our population, in general.

04:11:42.953 --> 04:11:49.341
So our challenges as a European Union is
that we need to be prepared and we're at

04:11:49.419 --> 04:11:57.433
all possible anticipate such threats. Today's
debate is very timely because it shows

04:11:57.513 --> 04:12:03.836
once more the importance of maintaining
our efforts to continuously strengthen our

04:12:03.977 --> 04:12:11.834
cyber security. And that is why at
European level our institutions have passed

04:12:11.933 --> 04:12:18.093
landmark legislations during the previous
parliamentary term, in particular the NIS2

04:12:18.171 --> 04:12:25.088
directive and the Cyber Resilience Act.
The implementation of these instruments is

04:12:25.186 --> 04:12:32.016
essential to further increase our collective
capacity to protect our citizens and

04:12:32.093 --> 04:12:38.521
our economies against a
multiplication of malicious actors.

04:12:38.753 --> 04:12:45.353
As the Irish Presidency, we are fully
committed to advancing negotiations on the

04:12:45.473 --> 04:12:53.118
cyber security package covering both the
revision of the Cyber Security Act and the

04:12:53.224 --> 04:13:00.698
amending NIS2 directive. In that context,
I can say we've made real progress on the

04:13:00.773 --> 04:13:04.377
three main parts of
the Cyber Security Act.

04:13:04.493 --> 04:13:08.769
That is, first of all, the
strengthening of an ESA.

04:13:08.933 --> 04:13:15.773
Secondly, making certification frameworks
more efficient and effective and thirdly,

04:13:16.553 --> 04:13:23.025
improving protection of our
critical ICT supply chains.

04:13:23.153 --> 04:13:31.368
So can I conclude by saying we still aim
to reach agreement in the Council before

04:13:31.462 --> 04:13:38.521
the end of our presidency. So that our
Lithuanian colleagues can start the trialogue

04:13:38.600 --> 04:13:45.149
when the Parliament is ready. We are
convinced that this legislation will

04:13:45.233 --> 04:13:51.293
significantly contribute to the
strengthening of our cyber security.

04:13:51.413 --> 04:13:58.720
Because preventing successful attacks by
better protecting our networks and the

04:13:58.793 --> 04:14:03.593
whole ICT supply system is key. Thank you.

04:14:04.133 --> 04:14:05.513
So much for your attention.

04:14:06.473 --> 04:14:11.866
Thank you very much, Minister Harkin. And
now I pass the floor to the Commission

04:14:11.933 --> 04:14:15.658
Executive Vice President Hannah Wirkonen.
The floor is yours for five minutes,

04:14:15.695 --> 04:14:16.895
please.

04:14:17.813 --> 04:14:22.287
Thank you very much, Honorable
President, Honorable Members, Council.

04:14:22.373 --> 04:14:27.519
Cyber security is very essential part
of European preparedness and defense.

04:14:27.593 --> 04:14:32.614
Cyber resilience is not only about preventing
attacks but about ensuring that our

04:14:32.679 --> 04:14:37.780
societies, our economies, and our defense
capabilities can continue to function

04:14:37.893 --> 04:14:43.616
during crises. The risk of disruption to
the Union's critical infrastructure by

04:14:43.669 --> 04:14:50.371
foreign actors is real. Just last week we
saw refrigeration systems in supermarkets

04:14:50.425 --> 04:14:55.385
and blue banks throughout Europe
switched off because of cyber incidents.

04:14:55.493 --> 04:15:00.092
And the estimated cost was in the
tens and hundreds of millions.

04:15:00.173 --> 04:15:06.198
But it's not only about financial
impact. It's also about social impact.

04:15:06.293 --> 04:15:11.367
Although the attacks did not cause any
significant impact on food security and

04:15:11.440 --> 04:15:16.108
public health, it should be
a wake-up call for everybody.

04:15:16.193 --> 04:15:21.236
Europe cannot afford to have dependencies
or strategic weaknesses that expose our

04:15:21.302 --> 04:15:24.793
critical infrastructure
to unexpected risks.

04:15:24.893 --> 04:15:29.213
For instance, we cannot allow risks
of foreign interference, espionage, or

04:15:29.273 --> 04:15:33.353
disruption in our most
critical ICT supply chains.

04:15:33.473 --> 04:15:38.499
And this is particularly relevant in our
communications infrastructure such as 5G

04:15:38.642 --> 04:15:44.564
networks. They are increasingly relevant
for reliable ultra-fast connectivity, data,

04:15:44.626 --> 04:15:49.080
and information sharing, drone
detection, and also real-time operational

04:15:49.133 --> 04:15:54.824
coordination. And this is why supply chain
security is at the core of the proposal

04:15:54.886 --> 04:16:01.230
for the revision of Cyber Security Act,
which is now on the table of this House.

04:16:01.313 --> 04:16:07.293
We need a strong pragmatic and proportionate
approach to de-risking our essential

04:16:07.360 --> 04:16:13.426
ICT supply chains. And we need to
act now to de-risk our 5G networks.

04:16:13.553 --> 04:16:19.766
It has been almost seven years since the
EU adopted the 5G Cyber Security Toolbox.

04:16:19.853 --> 04:16:25.647
The time for hesitation is over. We need
to be much more decisive and ambitious,

04:16:25.701 --> 04:16:31.220
including when it comes to setting clear
timelines for phasing out high-risk

04:16:31.313 --> 04:16:37.898
suppliers. If we fail to act decisively
now, we are not only putting our 5G networks

04:16:37.993 --> 04:16:43.486
at risk but also will carry these
dependencies into 6G, the next generation of

04:16:43.542 --> 04:16:44.742
connectivity.

04:16:46.313 --> 04:16:51.436
A strong and cyber resilient Europe also
needs a strong European Cyber Security

04:16:51.521 --> 04:16:56.439
Agency where the resources match
the mandate and the challenges.

04:16:56.513 --> 04:17:02.010
In the Commission's action plan on cyber
security and AI, an ESA is playing an

04:17:02.075 --> 04:17:06.725
important role, by strengthening the
resilience of our critical and other vital

04:17:06.788 --> 04:17:12.075
infrastructure against AI-driven cyber
attacks and by testing and assessing the

04:17:12.131 --> 04:17:16.335
cyber security capabilities
of frontier AI models.

04:17:16.493 --> 04:17:20.284
All these clearly demonstrate
the potential of an ESA.

04:17:20.453 --> 04:17:25.717
This is also a very concrete example
of European solidarity and cooperation.

04:17:25.793 --> 04:17:30.961
Through an ESA, we can ensure that all
our 27 member states benefit from shared

04:17:31.016 --> 04:17:36.394
expertise, knowledge, and capabilities
rather than each having to develop them

04:17:36.478 --> 04:17:41.537
independently. And this is why I urge the
European Parliament to support our efforts

04:17:41.588 --> 04:17:46.198
to equip an ESA with the mandate, resources,
and capabilities it needs to support

04:17:46.253 --> 04:17:50.333
our member states and protect
Europe's critical infrastructure.

04:17:50.393 --> 04:17:56.393
Not only against the threats we face today
but also against those that are emerging

04:17:56.495 --> 04:18:02.576
on the horizon. Honorable Members, in
recent months we have witnessed a wave of

04:18:02.633 --> 04:18:06.147
high-profile cyber incidents
and other hybrid attacks.

04:18:06.233 --> 04:18:11.093
From attacks on public administrations
and personal data breaches to attacks on

04:18:11.153 --> 04:18:16.373
health, telecommunications, and energy
infrastructure, including subsea cables and,

04:18:16.433 --> 04:18:20.847
as I mentioned earlier, on
supermarkets and blue banks.

04:18:21.053 --> 04:18:25.472
These incidents underlined the importance
of the regulatory framework we have put in

04:18:25.551 --> 04:18:30.613
place at European level. We can already see
the difference that the cyber resilience

04:18:30.663 --> 04:18:35.243
act will make by strengthening the security
of digital products placed on the EU

04:18:35.346 --> 04:18:42.334
market. And in many cases, industrial
devices such as refrigeration systems are

04:18:42.407 --> 04:18:48.274
unnecessary exposed to the internet or
they are configured with the weak passwords

04:18:48.351 --> 04:18:54.023
or run outdated software. And these are
low-hanging fruits, because many of these

04:18:54.073 --> 04:18:58.821
incidents therefore demonstrate the
importance of the basic cyber security

04:18:58.901 --> 04:19:01.673
requirements set out
in the NIS2 directive.

04:19:02.513 --> 04:19:07.815
Had these requirements been fully transposed
and effectively implemented, some of

04:19:07.861 --> 04:19:13.350
these incidents could potentially have been
prevented or their impact significantly

04:19:13.454 --> 04:19:19.024
reduced. The challenge before us is therefore
not only to develop new policies and

04:19:19.087 --> 04:19:24.353
new instruments but to ensure that the
rules we have already agreed are translated

04:19:24.413 --> 04:19:30.248
into real security on the ground. Because
ultimately cyber security is not only

04:19:30.332 --> 04:19:34.652
about legislation, institutions,
or about technology.

04:19:34.733 --> 04:19:39.982
It is about protecting our economies,
safeguarding the essential services on which

04:19:40.048 --> 04:19:45.328
our citizens depend, and ensuring that
Europe has the resilience and capacity to act

04:19:45.408 --> 04:19:51.575
in an increasingly uncertain world. And
that is responsibility we must now deliver

04:19:51.641 --> 04:19:52.841
on together.

04:19:56.333 --> 04:20:01.088
Thank you very much, Commissioner. And now
we proceed with the speakers on behalf of

04:20:01.135 --> 04:20:05.297
the political groups. And the first speaker
on behalf of EPP is Thomas Dubé for one

04:20:05.344 --> 04:20:07.193
and a half minutes.
Please, the floor is yours.

04:20:09.173 --> 04:20:17.153
President, Minister, Commissioner, in
recent weeks cyber attacks on grocery stores

04:20:17.213 --> 04:20:20.734
across Europe have destroyed
food worth millions.

04:20:20.813 --> 04:20:25.988
of euros. This time the
target was our food supply.

04:20:26.153 --> 04:20:33.271
What will they target tomorrow? These
hackers are often state-sponsored and will

04:20:33.353 --> 04:20:39.651
exploit every vulnerability that they can
found, from food on our tables to energy

04:20:39.724 --> 04:20:47.894
instruction, even our elections. Last week
in France, they even targeted freezers

04:20:47.993 --> 04:20:52.317
used to store blood,
plasma, in blood banks.

04:20:52.433 --> 04:21:00.043
This is just terrible. I think it's important
now that we quickly try to adapt the

04:21:00.139 --> 04:21:06.878
cyber security act without delay.
Establishing a strong framework to face out

04:21:06.953 --> 04:21:11.858
high-risk suppliers from
our critical supply chains.

04:21:12.053 --> 04:21:19.169
I also think it's important that member
states they need to call them out.

04:21:19.373 --> 04:21:27.976
We know that Iran, China, Russia,
systematically target Europe in cyberspace.

04:21:28.073 --> 04:21:34.572
We need to establish a credible deterrence
deterrence only works when our enemies

04:21:34.646 --> 04:21:39.764
knows that hostile actions
will have consequences.

04:21:39.893 --> 04:21:47.081
With powerful new AI models, cyber attacks
will unfortunately become more frequent,

04:21:47.153 --> 04:21:51.482
more sophisticated, and
harder to defend against.

04:21:51.593 --> 04:21:55.531
But our enemies should
be under no illusion:

04:21:55.627 --> 04:21:59.093
if you mess with Europe,
we will mess with you.

04:21:59.153 --> 04:22:00.353
Thank you.

04:22:00.413 --> 04:22:04.433
Thank you very much. The next speaker
on behalf of SNT is Jens Geyer.

04:22:07.793 --> 04:22:13.217
Thank you, Madam President. Madam
Vice-President, Madam Minister, severe

04:22:13.279 --> 04:22:18.290
cyberattacks seem to be occurring
more frequently in recent weeks.

04:22:18.340 --> 04:22:23.163
Therefore, we need not only a strong
cybersecurity strategy in the European Union,

04:22:23.230 --> 04:22:27.231
but also a policy that
systematically minimises risks.

04:22:27.313 --> 04:22:32.854
Ms Virkkunen, you have kindly presented
us with the Cybersecurity Act 2, which is

04:22:32.935 --> 04:22:38.738
intended to systematically reduce the
risk of the ICT sector being influenced or

04:22:38.795 --> 04:22:44.393
even shut down from outside the EU. This
risk is real, not only in the ICT sector

04:22:44.467 --> 04:22:49.864
but also in wind turbines and other
technologies used to operate our energy

04:22:49.928 --> 04:22:54.941
networks. That is why I am advocating for
the scope of the CSA 2 to be extended to

04:22:55.049 --> 04:23:00.861
energy networks as well. The Cybersecurity
Act 2 is an opportunity to increase

04:23:00.937 --> 04:23:04.418
resilience. Because two
things must apply in future:

04:23:04.481 --> 04:23:09.645
first, no kill switch mechanism that can
be activated from outside the EU, and

04:23:09.707 --> 04:23:13.911
second, no data stored on servers that
are not subject to EU legislation.

04:23:13.934 --> 04:23:15.134
Thank you.

04:23:15.833 --> 04:23:20.153
Thank you. The next speaker is Jorge
Bouchadé Villalba on behalf of PFI.

04:23:22.493 --> 04:23:27.035
The good fortune that all of you here in
Brussels have, most of you, Ms von der

04:23:27.073 --> 04:23:30.021
Leyen, is that most people do
not know what goes on here.

04:23:30.111 --> 04:23:35.765
They are making up a new debate about cyber
resilience and hybrid attacks, but when

04:23:35.812 --> 04:23:41.213
Spain suffers a hybrid attack from Morocco
with 100,000 invaders in Ceuta, the

04:23:41.334 --> 04:23:46.312
Socialist People’s Group blocks the creation
of a special committee with its vote

04:23:46.368 --> 04:23:50.999
and the European Commission continues
to shower money on the neighbour.

04:23:51.050 --> 04:23:55.897
What is more, it is a scandal that they
talk about cyber-attacks on infrastructure

04:23:55.956 --> 04:24:00.412
while this very week they have censored
a debate on the collapse of Spain’s rail

04:24:00.471 --> 04:24:04.508
infrastructure, which has
claimed the lives of 69 people.

04:24:04.569 --> 04:24:08.754
There was incompetence, a failure
of due care and corruption.

04:24:08.825 --> 04:24:12.693
When the European Commission hands out
billions from Brussels and governments like

04:24:12.754 --> 04:24:17.378
Mr Sánchez’s give them to countries like
Morocco and Uzbekistan to improve rail

04:24:17.433 --> 04:24:20.296
safety, the Spanish people demand justice.

04:24:20.391 --> 04:24:25.197
The 115 victims of Adamuz and Urdah
are not the result of bad luck;

04:24:25.257 --> 04:24:30.298
they are the result of corruption. And
that is what happens when you put the lives

04:24:30.351 --> 04:24:33.064
of Europeans in the
hands of corrupt people.

04:24:33.127 --> 04:24:36.833
The real threat is corrupt
politicians and corruption kills.

04:24:38.693 --> 04:24:43.193
Thank you. The next speaker is
Francesco Torselli on behalf of ECR.

04:24:49.193 --> 04:24:56.727
6,000 Italian schools received threats
today, intimidation, bomb threats via email.

04:24:56.791 --> 04:25:03.308
As Prime Minister Meloni has clarified, no
concrete dangers have emerged, but even a

04:25:03.398 --> 04:25:07.729
false alarm can sow fear and
disrupt a public service.

04:25:07.824 --> 04:25:12.694
Today it was the schools, last week
it was the refrigeration systems of

04:25:12.762 --> 04:25:16.747
supermarkets, and before
that, the alarms on flights.

04:25:16.810 --> 04:25:20.398
Cyberattacks that affect
all of us and all of Europe.

04:25:20.450 --> 04:25:25.057
This is why Europe must do its part,
investing in prevention, in rapid information

04:25:25.146 --> 04:25:30.093
sharing, and in the cyberdefence
of strategic infrastructure.

04:25:30.149 --> 04:25:35.130
When we talk about defending our freedom,
we do not mean doing so only with rifles

04:25:35.199 --> 04:25:40.026
and tanks. We must protect schools,
hospitals, transport, businesses.

04:25:40.106 --> 04:25:47.351
Our daily lives. And to those who think
they can intimidate us, we say that we will

04:25:47.440 --> 04:25:53.608
not give up even one of the services
on which our free daily life depends.

04:25:53.682 --> 04:25:54.882
Thank you.

04:25:57.113 --> 04:26:00.113
The next speaker on behalf
of Renew is Bart Rothuis.

04:26:02.573 --> 04:26:07.862
Thank you, Chair. Dear Commissioner,
Minister, cool custom in all the supermarkets

04:26:07.908 --> 04:26:09.108
and actually all the other

04:26:09.233 --> 04:26:12.110
digital products are becoming
increasingly secure in Europe.

04:26:12.149 --> 04:26:15.496
And if you follow the news, you might
not say that quickly, but with the Cyber

04:26:15.548 --> 04:26:20.483
Resilience Act and NIS 2, we are setting
the bar for cybersecurity particularly high

04:26:20.545 --> 04:26:24.945
here. That is the good news. The bad news
is that there are still an incredible

04:26:24.992 --> 04:26:27.924
number of outdated devices
connected to the internet.

04:26:27.994 --> 04:26:32.564
Often with software that is 10 or 20 years
old, full of vulnerabilities that can

04:26:32.611 --> 04:26:36.850
sometimes no longer even be fixed.
And now AI is coming along, so one old

04:26:36.904 --> 04:26:41.100
refrigerator can suddenly become, for
hackers, the gateway to your company's

04:26:41.153 --> 04:26:44.970
network. So my message is very simple:
take another good look at what is all

04:26:45.018 --> 04:26:48.454
connected to your network, ask yourself
whether all of that really needs to be

04:26:48.503 --> 04:26:52.192
connected to the internet.
Usually, that is not a good idea.

04:26:52.247 --> 04:26:56.907
Take action yourselves as well. The government
is not going to solve everything for

04:26:56.953 --> 04:27:00.533
you. We are creating the best cybersecurity
laws in the world here, but cyber

04:27:00.580 --> 04:27:02.513
responsibility lies with you. Thank you.

04:27:04.253 --> 04:27:05.333
Thank you.

04:27:05.333 --> 04:27:08.380
The next speaker is Reinier van Landschot.

04:27:08.453 --> 04:27:09.653
For one minute.

04:27:13.313 --> 04:27:16.421
Cyber resilience is
also about sovereignty.

04:27:16.493 --> 04:27:21.042
In China, American software is
purged from state companies.

04:27:21.113 --> 04:27:26.933
That's sovereignty made in China. In
America, no Chinese tech gets near the

04:27:26.993 --> 04:27:30.451
Pentagon. That's
sovereignty made in the USA.

04:27:30.533 --> 04:27:36.053
In Europe, Washington switches off the
email cloud and banking of the International

04:27:36.113 --> 04:27:43.066
Criminal Court and Chancellor Merz says
for the German intelligence agency a Google

04:27:43.163 --> 04:27:49.110
Cloud is sovereign enough. The USA and
China understand it, but our digital

04:27:49.185 --> 04:27:54.471
sovereignty? It's not made in Europe.
This makes us vulnerable to espionage,

04:27:54.533 --> 04:27:58.693
cybercrime, and somebody
could just switch us off.

04:27:58.793 --> 04:28:03.686
It's time to change that. We have to
protect our critical infrastructure with

04:28:03.747 --> 04:28:09.266
European cloud and AI. That's what the
cloud and AI development act must deliver,

04:28:09.331 --> 04:28:12.944
with sovereign cloud for
all critical infrastructure.

04:28:13.013 --> 04:28:18.438
A united Europe can make it happen. So stop
the inferiority complex and let's create

04:28:18.500 --> 04:28:22.793
a resilient European tech stack.
That's a future made in Europe.

04:28:23.213 --> 04:28:23.933
Thank you.

04:28:23.933 --> 04:28:28.673
Thank you very much. The next speaker is
Dario Tamburano on behalf of the Left.

04:28:30.893 --> 04:28:35.005
Colleagues, I have written to my car
manufacturer asking how to disconnect and

04:28:35.063 --> 04:28:40.123
reconnect it from the internet. I received
responses about privacy but no clear and

04:28:40.169 --> 04:28:44.524
immediate procedure to manage incoming data
independently and thus prevent possible

04:28:44.578 --> 04:28:49.485
network-based attacks. And what if tomorrow
the IT systems managing connected cars

04:28:49.546 --> 04:28:52.496
and controlling their
activity were compromised?

04:28:52.561 --> 04:28:57.385
What rights do we have to rule out this
possibility and protect ourselves from the

04:28:57.447 --> 04:29:02.416
risk of individual cars being blocked and
going haywire, or in the extreme scenario

04:29:02.478 --> 04:29:07.013
of millions of vehicles out of
control with no attackers on board?

04:29:07.106 --> 04:29:12.882
We have filled the web with tedious
disclaimers for theoretical privacy, but where

04:29:12.935 --> 04:29:16.562
is the right to disconnect our
objects from the internet of things?

04:29:16.617 --> 04:29:21.891
To go offline in a simple and reversible
way, like the airplane mode on mobile

04:29:21.966 --> 04:29:25.616
phones? I believe this
is a reasonable request.

04:29:25.678 --> 04:29:30.860
It will be even more so tomorrow. We already
have this by law for work tools and in

04:29:30.907 --> 04:29:36.068
hazardous environments: a physical button,
prominently placed, with a mandatory red

04:29:36.151 --> 04:29:41.622
colour. We want this on the dashboard,
a simple gesture, a single word:

04:29:41.703 --> 04:29:42.713
stop.

04:29:42.713 --> 04:29:43.913
Thank you.

04:29:44.453 --> 04:29:48.353
Thank you. The next speaker on
behalf of ESN is Markus Buchheit.

04:29:51.893 --> 04:29:56.478
Thank you, Madam Chair. Dear colleagues,
in October, Mr Bresser paralysed the town

04:29:56.518 --> 04:30:01.287
hall of my home town of Eichstätt and
extracted 1.4 terabytes of data, including

04:30:01.343 --> 04:30:06.307
citizens’ tax and account data. At the
same time, in hundreds of supermarkets,

04:30:06.365 --> 04:30:10.828
refrigerated shelves were heating up to 50
degrees, and last week criminals diverted

04:30:10.871 --> 04:30:14.524
more than €100 million from a
French bank via a service provider.

04:30:14.603 --> 04:30:19.694
After town halls and supermarkets, now
savings accounts are also under attack.

04:30:19.767 --> 04:30:24.318
Banks, however, have been subject to their
own EU regulation on digital resilience

04:30:24.376 --> 04:30:28.045
for almost two years now. Yet
it did not prevent this attack.

04:30:28.097 --> 04:30:31.732
The vulnerability of IT systems has
been demonstrated time and again.

04:30:31.778 --> 04:30:34.445
So has the toothlessness
of our authorities.

04:30:34.510 --> 04:30:38.418
Yet the Commission now wants more money
and staff for ENISA, a central reporting

04:30:38.465 --> 04:30:43.022
office and new certificates. Please do
not centralise yet another competence in

04:30:43.068 --> 04:30:47.211
Brussels. Incidentally, it was not agencies
that saved Eichstätt, but a backup.

04:30:47.276 --> 04:30:50.873
A small town cannot defend itself alone
against professional extortionists.

04:30:50.911 --> 04:30:54.444
That is something the Member States
must ultimately provide, close to their

04:30:54.496 --> 04:30:59.436
municipalities. With experts, with money
for backups and network segmentation, with

04:30:59.492 --> 04:31:04.068
a firewall around every town hall. And many
of my German colleagues, after all, know

04:31:04.120 --> 04:31:06.442
a thing or two about
firewalls and firewalls.

04:31:06.477 --> 04:31:07.677
Thank you.

04:31:09.053 --> 04:31:13.480
Next speaker is again the
Commission, Hannah Virkunen.

04:31:13.553 --> 04:31:17.153
You have the floor for four
and a half minutes, please.

04:31:22.793 --> 04:31:28.414
Thank you very much, Honorable Chair.
Members, Council, thank you very much for your

04:31:28.487 --> 04:31:32.936
interventions. The points raised today
demonstrate very clearly that cyber

04:31:33.003 --> 04:31:38.141
resilience must be treated as a strategic
security imperative, not merely a

04:31:38.213 --> 04:31:43.373
technical challenge. It's also very clear
that we have to be prepared for many

04:31:43.433 --> 04:31:48.890
different kinds of hybrid attacks. The
recent wave of bomb threats targeting

04:31:48.953 --> 04:31:54.448
European aviation, schools, and media is
a very stark reminder that the security of

04:31:54.510 --> 04:31:59.532
our critical infrastructure and
societies cannot be taken for granted.

04:31:59.633 --> 04:32:04.876
Whether through cyberattacks, physical
sabotage, or other forms of disruption, our

04:32:04.943 --> 04:32:10.272
adversaries seek to exploit vulnerabilities,
disrupt, essential services, and

04:32:10.328 --> 04:32:17.174
undermine public confidence. Any threats
against civilians are unacceptable.

04:32:17.273 --> 04:32:22.335
Ensuring the safety and security of
our citizens is our top priority.

04:32:22.433 --> 04:32:27.523
We are closely coordinating
with the affected member states.

04:32:27.653 --> 04:32:32.457
It's also clear that Europe must be able
to protect our critical infrastructures and

04:32:32.598 --> 04:32:38.687
our society; our essential supply chains,
against an increasingly complex threat

04:32:38.753 --> 04:32:44.716
landscape. This includes foreign
interference, strategic dependencies, and

04:32:44.799 --> 04:32:50.252
AI-enabled cyberattacks. We have already
established a strong European framework,

04:32:50.307 --> 04:32:55.549
but legislation alone is not enough. We
must ensure effective implementation,

04:32:55.613 --> 04:33:00.364
strengthen our operational preparedness,
improve cooperation between member states,

04:33:00.413 --> 04:33:05.747
and address the risks arising from
high-risk suppliers in essential ICT supply

04:33:05.854 --> 04:33:11.104
chains. And this also means reinforcing
cybersecurity at every level.

04:33:11.213 --> 04:33:16.187
Strengthening risk management and supply
chain security, building security into

04:33:16.261 --> 04:33:21.337
products from the outset, ensuring effective
vulnerability management, and securing

04:33:21.391 --> 04:33:26.153
the digital products and services that
provide remote access to key operational

04:33:26.237 --> 04:33:31.118
systems. And this is precisely why the
revision of the Cybersecurity Act is so

04:33:31.193 --> 04:33:35.924
important. It is an opportunity to
translate our ambitions into concrete

04:33:35.996 --> 04:33:40.556
capabilities, strengthening Europe's
collective preparedness, reducing critical

04:33:40.613 --> 04:33:45.113
dependencies, and also equipping ENISA
with the mandate and resources to support

04:33:45.773 --> 04:33:46.973
member states.

04:33:52.013 --> 04:33:56.393
Thank you very much, Commissioner. And
now I pass the floor to Dariusz Jonski.

04:34:01.373 --> 04:34:03.909
Thank you very much, Madam
President, Commissioner.

04:34:03.959 --> 04:34:10.941
Today, 11 November, today my country,
Poland, is celebrating Independence Day.

04:34:11.005 --> 04:34:15.976
This is a day that reminds us that freedom,
sovereignty and security are not given

04:34:16.077 --> 04:34:23.360
once and for all. Poland had to
fight for them for 123 years.

04:34:23.438 --> 04:34:27.962
And Poland knows how important freedom
is, and it is our shared duty to do

04:34:28.017 --> 04:34:32.222
everything to ensure that
Europe is ready to defend it.

04:34:32.280 --> 04:34:36.858
And we must understand that modern
warfare is not just tanks, it is not just

04:34:36.929 --> 04:34:42.467
missiles. It is also cyberattacks, sabotage,
disinformation, and attacks on energy,

04:34:42.533 --> 04:34:48.623
rail, ports, critical infrastructure. It
is an attempt to weaken the state without

04:34:48.664 --> 04:34:52.672
firing a single shot. We must remember that
Europe’s security begins at its eastern

04:34:52.758 --> 04:34:57.720
border. Poland and the countries in our
region perfectly understand the scale of the

04:34:57.773 --> 04:35:02.402
threats, as for years we have been
facing hybrid pressure, cyberattacks, and

04:35:02.454 --> 04:35:06.760
attempts at destabilisation. That is why
protecting critical infrastructure cannot

04:35:06.810 --> 04:35:09.212
be the sole responsibility
of individual states.

04:35:09.258 --> 04:35:14.649
We need a common European strategy, real
investments, and rapid information exchange

04:35:14.702 --> 04:35:18.446
on threats. Europe’s security must
also be built through transport.

04:35:18.488 --> 04:35:23.417
We need resilient rail, road, and port
infrastructure that will enable the rapid

04:35:23.487 --> 04:35:27.615
movement of troops and equipment. We
cannot allow bureaucracy and infrastructure

04:35:27.660 --> 04:35:31.763
gaps to weaken our defence capabilities.
I hope that this year we will adopt

04:35:31.817 --> 04:35:35.385
military Schengen, so vital,
so necessary for all of Europe.

04:35:35.455 --> 04:35:36.655
Thank you very much.

04:35:37.253 --> 04:35:40.673
Thank you very much. The next
speaker is Johann Danielson.

04:35:45.413 --> 04:35:52.741
Madam President, on one day, 18
aircraft were bombed across Europe.

04:35:52.806 --> 04:35:59.080
In Sweden and the rest of Europe,
refrigerators and freezers failed, and today

04:35:59.157 --> 04:36:03.669
schools have been forced to
evacuate across our continent.

04:36:03.738 --> 04:36:09.752
It must not be so easy for hostile actors
to remotely cause such major disruptions

04:36:09.829 --> 04:36:13.127
to businesses and ordinary
people’s daily lives.

04:36:13.187 --> 04:36:18.164
Hybrid attacks will continue. Next time,
it could be our trains, our hospitals or

04:36:18.234 --> 04:36:23.570
our energy systems. That is why we must
urgently put in place at least three things:

04:36:23.625 --> 04:36:28.867
first, preventive work to ensure that the
application of new technology does not

04:36:28.948 --> 04:36:34.750
create unnecessary vulnerabilities. Second,
active defence that can prevent attacks

04:36:34.825 --> 04:36:39.323
and, if it fails, identify
the responsible perpetrator.

04:36:39.393 --> 04:36:45.231
And finally, we need a common structure
to ensure responses that increase the cost

04:36:45.302 --> 04:36:49.552
for the actors responsible. Because
if you attack Europe, there must be

04:36:49.607 --> 04:36:52.193
consequences. Thank
you for your attention.

04:36:53.033 --> 04:36:56.153
Thank you very much. The next
speaker is Jessica van Leeuwen.

04:37:00.833 --> 04:37:05.251
Thank you very much, Chair. Minister,
Commissioner, in October cyberattack hit

04:37:05.293 --> 04:37:07.705
supermarkets in the
Netherlands and Belgium.

04:37:07.793 --> 04:37:10.901
Shelves were left empty and
home deliveries were canceled.

04:37:10.973 --> 04:37:15.525
In France, supermarkets had to throw food
away after a separate attack on cooling

04:37:15.592 --> 04:37:19.733
systems. Three weeks later, cyberattacks
hit food businesses in the Netherlands,

04:37:19.793 --> 04:37:23.740
Germany, Italy, Belgium,
Sweden, and other member states.

04:37:23.813 --> 04:37:29.079
And these are not isolated incidents, but
a systematic attack on our food security.

04:37:29.153 --> 04:37:34.458
Food waste and empty shelves will affect
both producers and consumers in the food

04:37:34.521 --> 04:37:39.946
supply chain. And it clearly demonstrates
how vulnerable our food security is.

04:37:40.013 --> 04:37:44.597
We have to make sure to produce enough
food inside the European Union so we do not

04:37:44.665 --> 04:37:50.896
depend on imports, but we also need to
protect the entire chain from farmer to

04:37:50.981 --> 04:37:55.268
consumer. So Commissioner, are you
acknowledging the seriousness of this

04:37:55.339 --> 04:37:59.743
vulnerability? Are you looking into
strengthening the cyber resilience of our food

04:37:59.792 --> 04:38:04.307
supply chain? And will you work with the
member states to protect the whole chain?

04:38:04.373 --> 04:38:07.943
Food security means keeping
food on every table.

04:38:08.033 --> 04:38:11.278
So support our farmers and
protect the food supply chain.

04:38:11.333 --> 04:38:12.533
Thank you.

04:38:13.133 --> 04:38:17.873
Thank you. Is Oierane
Agiregoitia Martinez.

04:38:23.813 --> 04:38:27.106
European security is also at
stake in our everyday lives.

04:38:27.158 --> 04:38:31.863
We have seen this in recent days: attacks
on refrigeration chains in France, threats

04:38:31.952 --> 04:38:36.297
to European flights, and threats
to media outlets in Ireland.

04:38:36.347 --> 04:38:39.485
Just today, there were
incidents in Italian schools.

04:38:39.555 --> 04:38:44.064
Our transport infrastructure — ports,
airports, railways, logistics centres — is

04:38:44.126 --> 04:38:49.609
increasingly vulnerable. Hybrid attacks
are taking place, and we are seeing that

04:38:49.676 --> 04:38:55.129
even without a single explosion or
conventional military strike, there is fear,

04:38:55.196 --> 04:38:59.249
there is a certain level of chaos,
and services are being paralysed.

04:38:59.295 --> 04:39:04.224
The European Union Agency for Cybersecurity
also stated in its latest report that we

04:39:04.284 --> 04:39:06.754
are not sufficiently
prepared or coordinated.

04:39:06.813 --> 04:39:11.752
Moreover, artificial intelligence is
making these threats increasingly complex.

04:39:11.834 --> 04:39:15.884
That is why we are proposing
two concrete measures.

04:39:15.961 --> 04:39:20.705
First, to strengthen the European early
warning system and coordinated response to

04:39:20.774 --> 04:39:23.785
share real-time information
and act jointly.

04:39:23.850 --> 04:39:28.540
Second, European-wide drills. Because a
response to protect our essential services

04:39:28.587 --> 04:39:31.362
cannot be improvised on
the day of an attack;

04:39:31.423 --> 04:39:35.488
it must be prepared in advance.
Protecting Europe means ensuring that our

04:39:35.539 --> 04:39:40.007
infrastructure, our economy and our society
continue to function even when attempts

04:39:40.066 --> 04:39:41.393
are made to destabilise us.

04:39:42.293 --> 04:39:44.993
Thank you. The next speaker is Yuri Ratas.

04:39:47.912 --> 04:39:51.994
This is honest today, Mr President
and Commissioner, dear colleagues.

04:39:52.044 --> 04:39:56.958
In recent days, we have witnessed targeted
attacks on our critical supply chains:

04:39:57.034 --> 04:40:02.776
cyberattacks have hit supermarkets,
refrigeration systems in more than 10 European

04:40:02.850 --> 04:40:08.239
countries, and even France’s blood bank
cold storage systems have been targeted.

04:40:08.306 --> 04:40:13.578
The aim of these attacks is to sow panic:
to disrupt essential services for people

04:40:13.639 --> 04:40:19.231
and create insecurity. We do not yet know
who is behind these specific attacks, but

04:40:19.281 --> 04:40:23.653
we do know for certain that we must
address our vulnerabilities immediately and

04:40:23.728 --> 04:40:29.633
decisively. Protecting critical infrastructure
requires significantly strengthening

04:40:29.706 --> 04:40:36.118
systems, faster information sharing, and
real resilience to ensure backup solutions

04:40:36.190 --> 04:40:41.445
and the functioning of supply chains
even in the event of an attack.

04:40:41.523 --> 04:40:47.065
Resilience means that no attack should
be able to paralyse the day-to-day

04:40:47.116 --> 04:40:48.932
functioning of our society. Thank you.

04:40:51.452 --> 04:40:54.932
Thank you very much. The next
speaker is Alex Andrew Saliba.

04:40:56.912 --> 04:41:04.265
Thank you, Mr President. The cybersecurity
test of the Twister call or the collapses

04:41:04.356 --> 04:41:09.263
for security at the kelp fields. Raina,
are you aware that supermarkets and young

04:41:09.328 --> 04:41:13.833
people are being hacked? I ask you
whether Europe is with the chess pieces or

04:41:13.877 --> 04:41:15.077
against the chess pieces.

04:41:15.572 --> 04:41:19.429
And we do not have a digital infrastructure
that is failing us, with dire concrete

04:41:19.492 --> 04:41:22.352
consequences, and this is
the fault of the Commission.

04:41:22.472 --> 04:41:26.370
Thank you, Mr President. The online
platform is now operational and provides

04:41:26.435 --> 04:41:30.632
essential services in at least two
official languages of the Member States.

04:41:30.992 --> 04:41:36.805
Within the framework of one economic meltdown
and austerity, citizens are exposed to

04:41:36.870 --> 04:41:38.070
real risks.

04:41:38.072 --> 04:41:44.613
This also depends on Malta, as we rely on
transport for complex supply chains that

04:41:44.684 --> 04:41:47.432
bring essential products to our shores.

04:41:48.212 --> 04:41:52.540
Anna bzone infrastruttura digitale le
tappoggia il provvista tale che le cittadine

04:41:52.592 --> 04:41:57.152
tana din tritcum protetta
o sicura me cyber attacks.

04:41:57.692 --> 04:42:02.252
In the quest for security, we cannot
accept an integrated fascist ideology.

04:42:02.372 --> 04:42:07.446
Mr President. The technology companies and
the two have greater responsibility for

04:42:07.497 --> 04:42:08.552
safer products.

04:42:08.552 --> 04:42:12.913
Or the European Union has, for the first
time, coordinated at the external borders,

04:42:12.970 --> 04:42:15.332
the Schengen frontiers,
and also the airports.

04:42:16.712 --> 04:42:19.292
Thank you. The next speaker
is Ana Miguel Pedro.

04:42:25.712 --> 04:42:30.870
Commissioner, today it is no longer
necessary to move a border to threaten a

04:42:30.950 --> 04:42:35.935
country's security. All it takes is
exploiting a cyber vulnerability.

04:42:35.997 --> 04:42:40.620
When it is possible to remotely manipulate
cooling systems, compromise blood banks

04:42:40.681 --> 04:42:45.224
or disrupt civil aviation, we are faced
with a direct threat to the security of

04:42:45.302 --> 04:42:48.740
European citizens. This is
the reality of hybrid threats.

04:42:48.793 --> 04:42:52.336
They do not need tanks on the
streets or a declaration of war.

04:42:52.396 --> 04:42:56.986
They can paralyse essential services,
compromise supply chains and sow fear and

04:42:57.037 --> 04:43:01.966
mistrust in our societies. Hostile regimes
know our vulnerabilities, seek to exploit

04:43:02.020 --> 04:43:07.110
them, and artificial intelligence will
increase the scale and sophistication of

04:43:07.179 --> 04:43:12.055
these threats. Commissioner, we need a
firm and coordinated European response, a

04:43:12.113 --> 04:43:16.582
response that does not merely coordinate
attacks but identifies those responsible,

04:43:16.636 --> 04:43:21.247
imposes sanctions and strengthens the
protection of our essential infrastructures

04:43:21.292 --> 04:43:24.364
and supply chains. This
is only the beginning.

04:43:24.394 --> 04:43:25.594
Thank you.

04:43:26.192 --> 04:43:29.012
Thank you very much. The
next speaker is José Cepeda.

04:43:35.072 --> 04:43:41.709
Madam President, Vice-President Vilkunen,
the truth is that when one analyses how

04:43:41.784 --> 04:43:45.195
Europe stands today, we
have no other clear answer.

04:43:45.255 --> 04:43:49.799
Europe is at war, and it is directly
affecting the lives of its citizens.

04:43:49.868 --> 04:43:54.390
When they attack water distribution,
sanitation and food refrigeration

04:43:54.451 --> 04:44:00.800
infrastructures, what is clear is that
we can talk at great length about all the

04:44:00.863 --> 04:44:05.980
initiatives being implemented through ENISA
or the European Agency itself, that is,

04:44:06.041 --> 04:44:11.273
cybersecurity, but it is not enough. We
feel that, for months now, I have been

04:44:11.347 --> 04:44:16.785
calling for the need not only to design
patterns, not only to identify the

04:44:16.847 --> 04:44:23.599
authorship, we also need, in addition
to developing a cybersecurity shield, to

04:44:23.654 --> 04:44:27.891
promote a sword, and for that we
need a European cyber command.

04:44:27.966 --> 04:44:33.900
We really need to take much further a
single European intelligence model that we

04:44:33.974 --> 04:44:39.134
currently lack. So, good luck, keep your
spirits up, but above all, let us be

04:44:39.185 --> 04:44:42.939
resolute in the response we must
give to protect 450 million people.

04:44:42.971 --> 04:44:44.171
Thank you.

04:44:44.312 --> 04:44:46.851
Thank you very much. And now we
proceed to the catch the eye.

04:44:46.892 --> 04:44:48.812
And first I give the
floor to Santana Glavac.

04:44:53.252 --> 04:44:57.375
Thank you very much. Vice-Presidents,
Commissioners, colleagues, ladies and

04:44:57.440 --> 04:45:02.456
gentlemen, it is clear to everyone that a
war against Europe does not have to begin

04:45:02.527 --> 04:45:05.145
with tanks entering a
European Union Member State.

04:45:05.197 --> 04:45:10.066
It can begin precisely in this way: by
shutting down the electricity grid, blocking

04:45:10.145 --> 04:45:14.530
banks or cutting off food supplies.
Imagine not being able to buy medicine,

04:45:14.637 --> 04:45:21.021
groceries or withdraw cash. As many as
73% of the organisations affected by the

04:45:21.079 --> 04:45:25.679
incidents analysed were key or important
entities under the NIS2 Directive.

04:45:25.732 --> 04:45:30.091
In other words, it is precisely the systems
on which the daily lives of our citizens

04:45:30.180 --> 04:45:34.994
depend that are under threat:
transport, energy, food and healthcare.

04:45:35.049 --> 04:45:38.395
That is why I welcome the proposal,
but I have several questions.

04:45:38.443 --> 04:45:42.615
How will we ensure that the equipment and
software used by our hospitals, energy

04:45:42.672 --> 04:45:47.264
grids and telecommunications systems
meet the highest security standards?

04:45:47.322 --> 04:45:52.197
How will we ensure the continuity of
essential services when an attack occurs?

04:45:52.268 --> 04:45:57.268
And how will we provide the resources to
implement the new obligations, particularly

04:45:57.333 --> 04:46:00.101
for smaller providers
of essential services?

04:46:00.160 --> 04:46:01.360
Thank you very much.

04:46:03.692 --> 04:46:06.812
Thank you very much. The next speaker
is Juan Fernando López Aguilar.

04:46:09.092 --> 04:46:10.772
Thank you for president and commissaria.

04:46:11.492 --> 04:46:18.074
The last legislature consumed a great deal
of energy and time regulating artificial

04:46:18.151 --> 04:46:22.593
intelligence. And in this legislature,
we have turned the periscope towards

04:46:22.648 --> 04:46:27.996
cybersecurity, but in reality, both
debates are connected, because the dizzying

04:46:28.064 --> 04:46:31.955
multiplication of artificial intelligence
tools to exploit the vulnerabilities of

04:46:32.019 --> 04:46:36.463
the European Union and its Member
States requires a common response.

04:46:36.519 --> 04:46:41.529
The embryo is in the European
Cybersecurity Agency, but more is needed.

04:46:41.624 --> 04:46:48.040
In the short term, prevention and anticipation
are better than reaction, and that

04:46:48.107 --> 04:46:52.771
requires shared intelligence, that
Member States are capable of pooling all

04:46:52.835 --> 04:46:57.759
available intelligence regarding cyberattacks
targeting our critical infrastructure.

04:46:57.815 --> 04:47:02.116
But in the long term, what we need to
do is reduce the toxic and pathological

04:47:02.214 --> 04:47:06.791
dependence of the European Union on major
providers of artificial intelligence,

04:47:06.847 --> 04:47:12.226
which make us vulnerable to cyberattacks.
Therefore, investments in cybersecurity

04:47:12.290 --> 04:47:15.679
and a firm commitment to a European
model of artificial intelligence.

04:47:15.724 --> 04:47:16.924
Thank you, Madam President.

04:47:17.492 --> 04:47:20.252
Thank you. The next
speaker is Romana Jarković.

04:47:22.592 --> 04:47:27.270
Thank you, Madam President. Almost every
week we witness a new cyberattack, whether

04:47:27.324 --> 04:47:32.632
it is attacks on supermarkets, the theft
of cryptocurrencies or, worst of all,

04:47:32.693 --> 04:47:38.629
attacks on hospital systems. In 2024, in
one such attack in Croatia, the personal

04:47:38.678 --> 04:47:42.991
data of hundreds of thousands of
citizens were stolen for ransom.

04:47:43.067 --> 04:47:47.700
That same year, a cyberattack on
London hospital laboratories led to the

04:47:47.759 --> 04:47:51.548
postponement of thousands of
examinations and operations.

04:47:51.626 --> 04:47:56.416
These examples clearly show just
how vulnerable our systems are.

04:47:56.487 --> 04:48:01.140
But they also show that cybersecurity
is not just a matter of technology;

04:48:01.213 --> 04:48:06.519
it is a matter of safeguarding our citizens,
protecting their data and even their

04:48:06.632 --> 04:48:11.630
lives. Cyberattacks are a serious problem
that requires serious, joint and ambitious

04:48:11.693 --> 04:48:16.455
responses. That is why Europe must invest
more in its own technologies, in joint

04:48:16.505 --> 04:48:19.664
cyber defence and in the
resilience of our health systems.

04:48:19.720 --> 04:48:23.306
In the digital world, the security
of our citizens must be a priority.

04:48:23.334 --> 04:48:24.534
Thank you.

04:48:25.472 --> 04:48:27.692
Thank you. The next speaker
is Sebastián Tinquinen.

04:48:33.872 --> 04:48:38.074
Mr President, deep freezers
are melting in shops.

04:48:38.145 --> 04:48:41.789
A large number of false bomb
threats on European flights.

04:48:41.861 --> 04:48:46.753
Arsonists. This is just some of the hostile
activity that has taken place in Europe

04:48:46.808 --> 04:48:51.639
over a short period of time. As we can
see, hostile actors are coming up with all

04:48:51.694 --> 04:48:57.094
sorts of ways to exert influence. The origins
of individual acts of harassment often

04:48:57.143 --> 04:49:02.158
remain shrouded in mystery, but everyone
needs to consider the bigger picture.

04:49:02.218 --> 04:49:06.579
During Russia’s war of aggression, far too
many unexpected events have occurred in

04:49:06.647 --> 04:49:12.495
Europe for each incident to be a matter
of coincidence or some other factor.

04:49:12.577 --> 04:49:17.296
The bigger picture is that Russia is
engaging in hybrid influence operations in

04:49:17.351 --> 04:49:21.154
Europe and continuing its war
of aggression against Ukraine.

04:49:21.202 --> 04:49:25.920
The more we can weaken Russia in Ukraine,
the fewer resources it will have to exert

04:49:25.980 --> 04:49:30.632
influence elsewhere in Europe. That is
why Europe’s objective must be clear:

04:49:30.716 --> 04:49:34.412
Russia must be driven out
of Ukraine. Thank you.

04:49:36.092 --> 04:49:40.172
Thank you. The next speaker is
Vitenis Povilas Andriukaitis.

04:49:43.172 --> 04:49:48.283
Thank you, Ms President, Commissioner.
I really want to speak on this.

04:49:48.365 --> 04:49:56.018
We must definitely help you to strengthen
ENISA, we must definitely contribute to

04:49:56.086 --> 04:50:02.914
efforts for all Member States to finally
agree on coordinated cybersecurity actions

04:50:03.017 --> 04:50:09.013
– this Cyber Resilience Act is special
in that it can help to better harmonise,

04:50:09.101 --> 04:50:14.200
coordinate and accelerate
investment in cybersecurity.

04:50:14.263 --> 04:50:19.822
We also need to train specialists; we
need a European cyber training centre that

04:50:19.939 --> 04:50:26.925
could actually help Member States train
specialists and identify those sectors as

04:50:26.984 --> 04:50:35.234
strategic – namely food, pharmaceuticals,
water, electricity – because attacks on

04:50:35.316 --> 04:50:39.519
these can paralyse many systems
and claim thousands of lives.

04:50:39.582 --> 04:50:44.328
We really must strengthen ENISA and
reinforce the Commission’s efforts and

04:50:44.396 --> 04:50:45.596
instruments.

04:50:47.912 --> 04:50:50.612
And the last speaker under
catch the eyes Bruno Gonçalves.

04:50:53.852 --> 04:51:00.121
Ms Commissioner, honourable Members,
food refrigeration plants, blood banks,

04:51:00.185 --> 04:51:07.845
civilian targets. This is the new reality
of a hybrid threat initiative that knows

04:51:07.913 --> 04:51:13.678
no borders in Europe. But what do the
European data tell us about the capacity of

04:51:13.741 --> 04:51:18.776
European public and private systems and
companies to respond to these threats?

04:51:18.842 --> 04:51:24.022
The latest report from ENISA, the European
Cybersecurity Agency, tells us that only

04:51:24.081 --> 04:51:30.066
16% of European SMEs are equipped to respond
to these threats and that only 4% have

04:51:30.124 --> 04:51:35.449
implemented all the security
measures to address external risks.

04:51:35.502 --> 04:51:40.925
This week, we had the Director-General of
ENISA here in this Parliament, calling for

04:51:40.974 --> 04:51:43.738
the simplification of
processes and reporting.

04:51:43.802 --> 04:51:48.898
But is what is lacking not rather more
investment, a uniform European model and,

04:51:48.961 --> 04:51:54.978
while we are at it, responsible public
systems and companies capable of meeting the

04:51:55.036 --> 04:51:58.313
expectations of this Parliament
and of this Commission?

04:51:58.373 --> 04:52:03.472
What is lacking is investment, what is
lacking is strategy, and Ms Commissioner, do

04:52:03.545 --> 04:52:07.442
not give up on a sovereign Europe
and a digitally capable Europe.

04:52:07.472 --> 04:52:08.672
Thank you.

04:52:09.872 --> 04:52:15.932
Thank you. Now I pass the floor to Executive
Vice President Hena Virkunen, please.

04:52:22.952 --> 04:52:26.525
Thank you very much. Honorable
President, members, Council.

04:52:26.612 --> 04:52:30.398
Thank you everybody for your
very important contributions.

04:52:30.452 --> 04:52:35.224
I have listened carefully to the
different views expressed today here.

04:52:35.312 --> 04:52:39.565
And I think that today's debate has shown
very clearly that protecting critical

04:52:39.632 --> 04:52:45.932
infrastructures and essential supply chains
requires not only sound rules but also

04:52:46.010 --> 04:52:52.370
stronger capabilities. Secure technologies,
trusted suppliers, and effective

04:52:52.469 --> 04:52:57.891
European cooperation. The Commission
will continue to work to reduce strategic

04:52:57.963 --> 04:53:02.961
weaknesses, strengthen our collective cyber
preparedness, and ensure that Europe is

04:53:03.018 --> 04:53:08.293
better equipped to prevent, withstand,
and respond to major cyber and hybrid

04:53:08.385 --> 04:53:14.396
threats. I count on this House to work
with us to be successful in this effort.

04:53:14.492 --> 04:53:20.318
In the age of ever-evolving technologies
and geopolitical tensions, Europe must be

04:53:20.383 --> 04:53:26.224
ready for all kinds of hybrid threats,
including those from sophisticated actors

04:53:26.312 --> 04:53:32.649
posing advanced capabilities. And let
me assure you, by fully implementing our

04:53:32.713 --> 04:53:37.172
ambitious agenda, we can ensure
that Europe is up to this challenge.

04:53:39.632 --> 04:53:45.380
Thank you very much. Commissioner Virkunen,
and now I pass the floor to the Minister

04:53:45.471 --> 04:53:46.671
Marianne Harkin.

04:53:51.212 --> 04:53:57.558
President, Honorable Members, Executive
Vice President of the Commission.

04:53:57.632 --> 04:54:03.346
This is indeed a very timely
and a very important debate.

04:54:03.452 --> 04:54:08.765
We all acknowledge the importance of
strengthening our cyber resilience.

04:54:08.852 --> 04:54:15.120
Whether it's protecting our blood banks,
our schools, our food supply, or our

04:54:15.212 --> 04:54:20.129
aviation systems, indeed
all of our systems.

04:54:20.252 --> 04:54:27.980
When our citizens' lives are adversely
impacted, the EU has a responsibility to act.

04:54:28.232 --> 04:54:34.210
The new cybersecurity act will
undoubtedly contribute to this objective.

04:54:34.292 --> 04:54:41.942
By strengthening our ICT supply
chain, and our European economies.

04:54:42.092 --> 04:54:49.635
The Irish presidency remains ambitious.
To finalize the discussions on the

04:54:49.752 --> 04:54:55.497
cybersecurity act in the Council
before the end of this year.

04:54:55.592 --> 04:55:02.775
So that the negotiations between the
co-legislators can start as soon as possible in

04:55:02.889 --> 04:55:08.514
2027. I think we all agree in this
Parliament there is no time to waste.

04:55:08.612 --> 04:55:16.078
But unfortunately, one thing is clear.
Attacks will continue and will increase in

04:55:16.172 --> 04:55:25.006
number and sophistication. And we also
have to be prepared for an event that some

04:55:25.114 --> 04:55:31.712
attacks will succeed and sometimes
unfortunately at large scale.

04:55:31.832 --> 04:55:40.416
That's why the presidency will continue
to work on the implementation of the EU

04:55:40.570 --> 04:55:48.268
cyber blueprint. This is a critical tool
to help us to prepare and to react to

04:55:48.416 --> 04:55:53.785
large-scale cyber
attacks when they happen.

04:55:53.972 --> 04:56:00.704
Can I finally say I note and appreciate
the good cooperation within the Parliament

04:56:00.776 --> 04:56:08.041
on this issue? And I hope this will result
in a strong Parliament position and good

04:56:08.127 --> 04:56:13.878
outcomes in our negotiations? Can I
also say I agree with the Commission?

04:56:13.952 --> 04:56:19.440
Any threats against civilians are unacceptable
and indeed would many colleagues here

04:56:19.499 --> 04:56:27.512
this evening who emphasize that we need
full European cooperation to protect our

04:56:27.632 --> 04:56:33.512
citizens. And on that note, can I thank
all of you for your contributions and your

04:56:33.572 --> 04:56:34.772
attention.

04:56:37.112 --> 04:56:38.972
Thank you very much, Minister Harkin.

04:56:39.212 --> 04:56:44.337
The debate is now closed. We now move
on to the next item on the agenda.

04:56:44.408 --> 04:56:49.049
This concerns a statement by the Commission
on media freedom and the rule of law in

04:56:49.098 --> 04:56:53.972
the Czech Republic, including threats to
the independence of public broadcasters.

04:56:54.452 --> 04:56:59.048
And I pass the first pass the floor on
behalf of the Commission to Commissioner

04:56:59.090 --> 04:57:00.290
Michael McGrath.

04:57:08.132 --> 04:57:15.522
Dear President, dear Minister Harkin, on
behalf of the Council presidency, dear

04:57:15.569 --> 04:57:20.560
Honorable Members, thank you for this
opportunity to discuss with you today the

04:57:20.623 --> 04:57:24.822
situation of media freedom
and pluralism in Czechia.

04:57:24.932 --> 04:57:30.315
With special attention given to the
independence of public broadcasters.

04:57:30.452 --> 04:57:36.122
Media freedom and media pluralism are
core elements of the rule of law in any

04:57:36.221 --> 04:57:41.441
country. For this reason, since 2020,
there have been a key pillar of the

04:57:41.496 --> 04:57:46.140
Commission's annual rule of law
report, alongside the Justice Sector,

04:57:46.199 --> 04:57:51.426
Anti-Corruption Frameworks, and
other democratic checks and balances.

04:57:51.512 --> 04:57:56.114
In addition, over the past five years, the
Commission has also adopted a number of

04:57:56.224 --> 04:58:02.286
important instruments. Which now provide
an EU-level framework geared at protecting

04:58:02.348 --> 04:58:07.123
media freedom and pluralism
across the European Union.

04:58:07.232 --> 04:58:11.994
This ranges from recommendations to
ensure a safe and enabling environment for

04:58:12.061 --> 04:58:17.748
journalists, and other media professionals
in Europe, to anti-slap legislation and

04:58:17.829 --> 04:58:23.649
finally a regulation the European Media
Freedom Act, which is largely applicable

04:58:23.747 --> 04:58:29.166
since 2025, that introduces
important safeguards in this area.

04:58:29.312 --> 04:58:33.795
Media freedom and pluralism are also
essential for democratic accountability.

04:58:33.872 --> 04:58:39.297
Enabling citizens to access reliable
information, to scrutinize public power, and to

04:58:39.365 --> 04:58:42.785
participate meaningfully in public debate.

04:58:42.872 --> 04:58:50.240
The 2026 rule of law report, adopted in
July of this year, as you know, noted that

04:58:50.322 --> 04:58:55.199
draft legislation which would confer new
powers on the media regulator and provide

04:58:55.257 --> 04:59:01.431
media companies with additional rights and
additional responsibilities is pending.

04:59:01.532 --> 04:59:07.369
It also pointed out that no further steps
have been taken on reforms relating to the

04:59:07.442 --> 04:59:13.532
transparency of media ownership. In relation
to public service media, the rule of

04:59:13.587 --> 04:59:17.951
law report noted that the draft law presented
by the Government, which would abolish

04:59:18.017 --> 04:59:23.150
license fees for public service
media, has raised concerns.

04:59:23.252 --> 04:59:28.570
Public service media play a special role
in ensuring that citizens have access to

04:59:28.645 --> 04:59:32.772
information and a
diverse range of content.

04:59:32.912 --> 04:59:38.492
For this reason, the European Media Freedom
Act contains safeguards in relation to

04:59:38.552 --> 04:59:39.752
the governance and

04:59:40.352 --> 04:59:44.397
financing independence
of public service media.

04:59:44.492 --> 04:59:49.202
The implementation and enforcement of the
European Media Freedom Act is a priority

04:59:49.266 --> 04:59:53.425
for me as Commissioner and a
priority for the wider Commission.

04:59:53.492 --> 04:59:58.108
In line with the broad commitment to
safeguard media independence and pluralism

04:59:58.172 --> 05:00:03.652
across the European Union. The Commission
has closely engaged with all Member States

05:00:03.732 --> 05:00:07.859
including Czechia, to ensure that the
European Media Freedom Act safeguards

05:00:07.915 --> 05:00:14.126
including those relating to public service
media are in place as soon as possible in

05:00:14.207 --> 05:00:20.185
each national legal framework. We continue
to closely monitor and analyze national

05:00:20.279 --> 05:00:26.080
law as it develops in doing so we must
take into account national specificities

05:00:26.146 --> 05:00:31.230
bearing in mind that the EMFA does not
prescribe any specific governance of funding

05:00:31.292 --> 05:00:37.302
model but rather requires checks
and balances in national systems.

05:00:37.412 --> 05:00:41.833
When it comes to the crucial issue of
funding, for public service media in

05:00:41.894 --> 05:00:47.312
particular, national legislation must ensure
that public service media can rely on a

05:00:47.387 --> 05:00:52.760
funding system that is based on
transparent and objective criteria and that

05:00:52.851 --> 05:00:59.037
guarantees adequate sustainable and
predictable financial resources.

05:00:59.132 --> 05:01:02.552
Engagement with the Czech
authorities is ongoing.

05:01:02.672 --> 05:01:07.306
I would also like to stress that any
legislative proposal should proceed through a

05:01:07.381 --> 05:01:13.017
duly conducted legislative process
ensuring full respect for the applicable

05:01:13.079 --> 05:01:17.766
institutional framework and allowing
for meaningful consultation of relevant

05:01:17.835 --> 05:01:24.387
stakeholders before adoption. This is
important in that respect it is noted that the

05:01:24.452 --> 05:01:29.930
2026 rule of law report has recommended
to Czechia to take measures to improve

05:01:29.997 --> 05:01:35.954
transparency in the legislative process
and meaningful consultation of stakeholders

05:01:36.032 --> 05:01:41.021
including by addressing the frequent
use of fast track procedures.

05:01:41.132 --> 05:01:47.065
More broadly as regards the situation of
media freedom and pluralism the 2026 rule

05:01:47.157 --> 05:01:52.765
of law report notes that in Czechia
journalists continue to face serious verbal

05:01:52.832 --> 05:01:58.535
threats and harassment. A draft amendment
to the Code of Criminal Procedure which

05:01:58.583 --> 05:02:02.432
would provide additional protection
in terms of journalistic sources and

05:02:02.912 --> 05:02:06.892
confidential communications
remains pending.

05:02:07.052 --> 05:02:11.666
The report also noted that stakeholders
point to the use of strategic lawsuits

05:02:11.732 --> 05:02:18.882
against public participation or slaps by
politicians as an ongoing issue of concern.

05:02:19.052 --> 05:02:23.561
A draft law transposing the anti-slap
directive which would cover both cross-border

05:02:23.612 --> 05:02:27.973
and domestic slap cases is
currently before Parliament.

05:02:28.052 --> 05:02:31.454
The report also points
to some good practice.

05:02:31.592 --> 05:02:36.790
The safe journalism platform was set up in
the second half of 2025 and establishes a

05:02:36.844 --> 05:02:42.185
non-governmental online environment
for journalists to report attacks.

05:02:42.392 --> 05:02:47.144
Finally, in relation to media ownership,
the rule of law report notes that pending

05:02:47.189 --> 05:02:52.035
the adoption of draft legislation
significant challenges persist in relation to

05:02:52.117 --> 05:02:58.179
transparency of media ownership. No progress
has been made under recommendation of

05:02:58.303 --> 05:03:02.645
the 2025 rule of law
report in this respect.

05:03:02.732 --> 05:03:06.887
The Commission will continue to closely
follow developments on media freedom and

05:03:06.940 --> 05:03:10.567
pluralism in all Member
States including in Czechia.

05:03:10.652 --> 05:03:15.092
We will engage constructively with national
authorities and we will use all relevant

05:03:15.152 --> 05:03:21.682
tools at our disposal to uphold media
freedom media pluralism and the rule of law

05:03:21.752 --> 05:03:26.891
across the Union. Thank you for giving me
the opportunity to set out those initial

05:03:26.953 --> 05:03:31.826
remarks and I'm very much looking forward
to hearing the contributions of Honorable

05:03:31.892 --> 05:03:34.892
Members on this important
topic before us this evening.

05:03:36.092 --> 05:03:40.658
Thank you very much. Commissioner, I know
I pass the floor to the speakers on behalf

05:03:40.701 --> 05:03:43.652
of the political groups
for EPP. Danuša Nerudová.

05:03:48.812 --> 05:03:54.751
Dear colleagues, at 4:36 a.m. the government
of Andrej Babiš ended the parliamentary

05:03:54.822 --> 05:04:00.049
debate and pushed through a proposal that
threatens the independence of Czech public

05:04:00.116 --> 05:04:05.606
service media. At this moment, there is
no guarantee that the funds for the media

05:04:05.678 --> 05:04:09.496
will not become a tool of
political pressure on journalists.

05:04:09.587 --> 05:04:12.060
Czech Television is
not Babiš’s television.

05:04:12.112 --> 05:04:17.865
Czech Radio is not Babiš’s radio. The
media must hold politicians to account, not

05:04:17.941 --> 05:04:23.674
the other way around. I therefore call
on the European Commission to act.

05:04:23.732 --> 05:04:26.602
The European Media Freedom
Act must apply to all.

05:04:26.661 --> 05:04:31.967
This Sunday, hundreds of thousands of people
are expected in Prague’s Letná Square,

05:04:32.038 --> 05:04:37.873
who believe in European values, and they
will also be waiting for your response.

05:04:37.953 --> 05:04:43.139
Show them that Europe can not only
promise freedom but also defend it.

05:04:43.198 --> 05:04:48.339
So, Mr Commissioner, can you tell us
what specific steps you plan to take?

05:04:48.430 --> 05:04:54.494
And let me be clear: the mere phrase 'we
will closely monitor and observe' will no

05:04:54.564 --> 05:04:59.400
longer resolve this situation and will
not be enough for the people in those

05:04:59.462 --> 05:05:03.977
squares. I would also like to thank
everyone who has stood up for freedom.

05:05:04.044 --> 05:05:09.532
Journalists, universities, people in the
squares, theatres, and everyone else.

05:05:09.596 --> 05:05:13.216
Special thanks also go to
students and young people.

05:05:13.282 --> 05:05:18.642
As a former rector, I am immensely proud
of you, and as an MEP, I tell you that your

05:05:18.715 --> 05:05:22.816
voice is heard here in Brussels,
in the European Parliament.

05:05:22.890 --> 05:05:26.852
Freedom is not a given, and
together we will defend it.

05:05:28.472 --> 05:05:31.772
Thank you very much. The next speaker
on behalf of SNT is Hannes Heide.

05:05:34.112 --> 05:05:40.230
Mr Commissioner, media freedom, pluralism
and the rule of law are the foundation of

05:05:40.286 --> 05:05:44.228
our liberal democracy and must
be defended every single day.

05:05:44.284 --> 05:05:47.717
And public service broadcasting
plays a key role in this.

05:05:47.787 --> 05:05:52.401
It ensures independent information,
scrutiny of power and trust in democratic

05:05:52.455 --> 05:05:57.815
institutions. But this task can only be
fulfilled if editorial and institutional

05:05:57.886 --> 05:06:01.167
independence are guaranteed
without restriction.

05:06:01.227 --> 05:06:05.645
And developments in the Czech Republic
give serious cause for concern.

05:06:05.695 --> 05:06:09.720
For years, Prime Minister Babiš controlled
one of the country’s largest media

05:06:09.790 --> 05:06:15.525
groups. Added to this are massive conflicts
of interest in EU funding and plans to

05:06:15.580 --> 05:06:18.569
expose the civil service
to political influence.

05:06:18.623 --> 05:06:21.662
What exactly are they trying
to sell to the people?

05:06:21.726 --> 05:06:26.484
Abolishing licence fees and financing
from the clear state budget means nothing

05:06:26.547 --> 05:06:29.951
other than that taxpayers will
continue to pay for broadcasting.

05:06:30.001 --> 05:06:34.788
However, this increases the possibility
of influencing the content and work of

05:06:34.844 --> 05:06:39.857
journalists. And all of this follows the
autocrats' playbook and the dangerous,

05:06:39.922 --> 05:06:45.720
albeit familiar, pattern of weakening
independent oversight bodies and concentrating

05:06:45.786 --> 05:06:49.763
political power. The rule of
law thus comes under pressure.

05:06:49.821 --> 05:06:54.588
And that is precisely why we have the
European Media Freedom Act, which obliges all

05:06:54.648 --> 05:07:00.195
Member States to reliably ensure the
independence of public service media and their

05:07:00.280 --> 05:07:05.921
financing. This applies in the Czech Republic
just as it does in all other countries

05:07:05.975 --> 05:07:07.175
of the European Union.

05:07:09.152 --> 05:07:10.232
Thank you very much, Mr Heide.

05:07:10.232 --> 05:07:13.172
The next speaker on behalf
of PFE is Ondřej Knotek.

05:07:14.312 --> 05:07:16.817
Thank you, Madam Chairman, and
thank you for your remarks, Mr.

05:07:16.892 --> 05:07:21.812
Commissioner. With seven years in this
House, it's not for the first time I see this

05:07:21.884 --> 05:07:26.968
pattern. If democratic national elections
deliver government which is in opposition

05:07:27.032 --> 05:07:32.719
to the European Parliament mainstream, very
soon you guys come with plenary debates

05:07:32.790 --> 05:07:37.939
and resolutions questioning rule of law,
media freedom, and democracy in the various

05:07:38.000 --> 05:07:43.631
Member States. Often with unnecessary
escalation and often strong statements far

05:07:43.684 --> 05:07:47.782
from real situations. And let's be honest,
it's obvious that with ongoing media

05:07:47.832 --> 05:07:50.539
reform in Czech Republic
it is the same story.

05:07:50.612 --> 05:07:57.134
You talk, about risks, but media councils
and editorial independents remain

05:07:57.212 --> 05:08:03.867
unchanged. We just changed the financing
model to the one that is mostly used in the

05:08:03.965 --> 05:08:08.315
EU to enhance the financial
transparency of these institutions.

05:08:08.372 --> 05:08:11.671
Not to govern them, but to
make them more transparent.

05:08:11.732 --> 05:08:17.584
By the way, identical change of media
financing happened quite recently in Denmark,

05:08:17.663 --> 05:08:22.981
France, Sweden, Finland, and the
European Parliament was silent.

05:08:23.072 --> 05:08:27.844
But with patriotic government
in place, you see a problem.

05:08:27.932 --> 05:08:34.292
Are you serious? So let's conclude.
Regarding public media in Czech Republic, the

05:08:34.352 --> 05:08:39.433
checks and balances are in place.
Freedom, medium act is respected.

05:08:39.512 --> 05:08:42.503
The majority of citizens
are in favor of this change.

05:08:42.572 --> 05:08:48.750
So please respect this and don't be useful
idiots of Czech activistic opposition.

05:08:48.812 --> 05:08:50.012
Thank you very much.

05:08:52.232 --> 05:08:57.212
The next speaker on behalf of
ECR is Veronica Vrecionova.

05:09:01.352 --> 05:09:03.798
Thank you, Madam Chair,
Commissioner, colleagues.

05:09:03.880 --> 05:09:10.439
I would like today to share with you and
tell you about the alarming developments in

05:09:10.543 --> 05:09:16.046
the Czech Republic. The government of
Andrej Babiš has decided in an unprecedented

05:09:16.094 --> 05:09:20.645
way to attack the very foundations of
freedom and independence of public service

05:09:20.703 --> 05:09:26.120
media in our country. Its real goal is
not any savings, but the subjugation and

05:09:26.174 --> 05:09:28.768
control of Czech
Television and Czech Radio.

05:09:28.832 --> 05:09:33.359
In the Czech Republic, this independence
is today protected by a proven system of

05:09:33.409 --> 05:09:37.922
television and radio licence fees, similar
to, for example, in Germany or Austria.

05:09:37.971 --> 05:09:42.989
The current government, however, wants to
abolish this system and transfer funding

05:09:43.048 --> 05:09:48.093
directly into the state budget and drastically
cut the budgets of both institutions.

05:09:48.152 --> 05:09:52.775
By more than one billion Czech crowns
compared to the current situation.

05:09:52.836 --> 05:09:58.421
This would mean one thing for both media:
the elimination of quality investigative

05:09:58.493 --> 05:10:02.441
journalism, regional reporting
and original productions.

05:10:02.497 --> 05:10:06.365
Moreover, this step makes
no sense even economically.

05:10:06.425 --> 05:10:09.529
The state will not save
anything by doing this;

05:10:09.611 --> 05:10:15.140
it will merely transfer almost 8 billion
Czech crowns onto the shoulders of the

05:10:15.203 --> 05:10:18.258
state budget, which already
shows huge deficits.

05:10:18.322 --> 05:10:23.950
The government will have to continue
borrowing to cover this and taxpayers will pay

05:10:24.021 --> 05:10:27.886
for it anyway, this time
with hefty interest.

05:10:28.005 --> 05:10:33.646
Proponents of this proposal argue that in
Europe there are countries that finance

05:10:33.709 --> 05:10:39.224
public service media in a different way
than through a licence fee, whether via

05:10:39.279 --> 05:10:44.148
electricity bills as in Italy, a dedicated
tax as in Sweden or directly from the

05:10:44.207 --> 05:10:49.379
budget as in France. All these countries,
however, have established strong

05:10:49.446 --> 05:10:55.092
safeguards that prevent the ruling elite
from interfering in editorial independence.

05:10:55.182 --> 05:10:58.994
The Czech proposal, however, does
not include any such protection.

05:10:59.057 --> 05:11:05.770
The government could change the allocation
of the majority of the television and

05:11:05.825 --> 05:11:10.708
radio budgets at any time and thus keep
both media in constant check under the

05:11:10.786 --> 05:11:15.946
threat of financial starvation. And if Prime
Minister Babiš insists that he will not

05:11:16.003 --> 05:11:21.418
interfere in the content of broadcasts,
it is enough to look at the recent past,

05:11:21.475 --> 05:11:26.516
when years ago he entered politics and
bought the two most influential Czech daily

05:11:26.572 --> 05:11:29.857
newspapers, Mladá fronta
dnes and Lidové noviny.

05:11:29.918 --> 05:11:33.512
All criticism of him disappeared
from their pages overnight.

05:11:34.712 --> 05:11:39.723
The government's true intentions are also
revealed by the way in which it pushed

05:11:39.791 --> 05:11:44.475
through this change in the first reading.
Without any debate with the expert

05:11:44.560 --> 05:11:50.810
community, the opposition or civil society,
it arrogantly used force after closing

05:11:50.881 --> 05:11:55.608
the debate, when dozens of MPs were not
even given the floor, and during the

05:11:55.669 --> 05:12:00.331
overnight vote at four thirty-six
on Friday morning into Saturday.

05:12:00.443 --> 05:12:05.782
Such a procedure is more reminiscent of
the practices of authoritarian regimes

05:12:05.851 --> 05:12:08.132
outside Europe. Thank
you for your attention.

05:12:10.232 --> 05:12:13.772
Thank you. The next speaker on
behalf of Renew is Laurence Ferrand.

05:12:16.892 --> 05:12:21.506
Thank you, Madam President. Commissioner,
dear colleagues, public service media play

05:12:21.559 --> 05:12:27.512
a key role in European democracy. By
providing citizens with verified information

05:12:27.607 --> 05:12:32.997
and original audiovisual creations, their
independence is crucial, and I therefore

05:12:33.053 --> 05:12:38.617
wish, like thousands of citizens, to express
the support of my political group for

05:12:38.673 --> 05:12:41.688
all the staff of Czech
radio and television.

05:12:41.768 --> 05:12:46.435
The Czech government’s plan to abolish the
television licence fee is not a mistake;

05:12:46.491 --> 05:12:51.448
it is a clear attempt by Mr Babiš to
undermine the independence of its public

05:12:51.517 --> 05:12:55.342
broadcasters and subject
them to political control.

05:12:55.423 --> 05:13:00.458
Yet one of the conditions for quality
journalism is stable, transparent and

05:13:00.535 --> 05:13:05.744
predictable funding. We have set this out
in black and white in the Media Freedom

05:13:05.793 --> 05:13:09.426
Act, which has been in
force since August 2025.

05:13:09.539 --> 05:13:13.843
But the far right, whether it be the
Czech government, Donald Trump or the

05:13:13.896 --> 05:13:20.865
Rassemblement National, stigmatises public
audiovisual media in order to distort

05:13:20.955 --> 05:13:26.788
public debate by leaving the field open to
government-aligned media, as Viktor Orbán

05:13:26.880 --> 05:13:31.789
has done in Hungary. Commissioner,
our compass is the Media Freedom Act.

05:13:31.842 --> 05:13:36.753
It must guarantee all citizens the right
to receive pluralistic and high-quality

05:13:36.808 --> 05:13:42.198
information, including via public media.
I therefore call on all our Member States

05:13:42.268 --> 05:13:46.574
to transpose this text without delay.
This is all the more important as we are

05:13:46.622 --> 05:13:52.662
facing increasingly organised disinformation
intended to disrupt our democracy

05:13:52.746 --> 05:13:58.793
before every election. We must also ensure
proper funding of the media through the

05:13:58.854 --> 05:14:03.782
future Agora You programme, in the
face of social networks and artificial

05:14:03.837 --> 05:14:07.183
intelligence that are swallowing
up the work of real journalists.

05:14:07.226 --> 05:14:12.584
On funding too, we expect the Commission
to urgently reform the SMA Directive to

05:14:12.645 --> 05:14:16.832
establish fair competition in
the field of advertising revenue.

05:14:17.312 --> 05:14:21.338
Without this arsenal, the European
Democratic Shield project will remain a dead

05:14:21.388 --> 05:14:24.458
letter and that will be
a serious responsibility.

05:14:24.523 --> 05:14:25.723
Thank you.

05:14:26.792 --> 05:14:32.612
Thank you. Speaker. The next speaker on
behalf of the Greens is Markéta Gregorová.

05:14:40.052 --> 05:14:44.572
Dear colleagues, Mr President, Prime
Minister Andrej Babiš used to call newsrooms

05:14:44.621 --> 05:14:48.305
when something displeased him. But those
who hold their budget in their hands no

05:14:48.352 --> 05:14:52.681
longer need to make such calls. A wave of
civic resistance is rising in the Czech

05:14:52.732 --> 05:14:57.517
Republic. Thousands of students, journalists
and female journalists are defending

05:14:57.567 --> 05:15:02.095
the independence of the media. After all,
the media are not there to serve the Prime

05:15:02.148 --> 05:15:05.915
Minister or other politicians; they
are there to hold them to account.

05:15:05.965 --> 05:15:09.585
And what is Andrej Babiš’s response?
He claims that the students have been

05:15:09.634 --> 05:15:13.132
manipulated. Mr Prime Minister, you
must be confusing them with your own

05:15:13.181 --> 05:15:17.226
parliamentary group. Students do not need
instructions from headquarters to know

05:15:17.284 --> 05:15:21.613
when to raise their hands. Public-service
media are neither government nor

05:15:21.689 --> 05:15:24.816
opposition media; they
belong to the public.

05:15:24.861 --> 05:15:28.257
And it is the public’s voice that I
am bringing here today to the European

05:15:28.328 --> 05:15:33.046
Parliament. And I am therefore
calling on the European Commission:

05:15:33.142 --> 05:15:37.318
there are no safeguards in the proposal.
Stand up for Czech citizens and use the

05:15:37.372 --> 05:15:41.372
European Media Freedom Act to defend
independent media in the Czech Republic.

05:15:45.092 --> 05:15:50.588
Grazie mille. Please, it's not possible
to make signs or everything, so thank you,

05:15:50.642 --> 05:15:52.532
Mrs. Gregorová. Please, Ms.

05:15:54.992 --> 05:15:56.192
It's ahead.

05:15:56.552 --> 05:16:02.372
It's not possible. Thank
you. Please, Mr. Arvanitis.

05:16:10.772 --> 05:16:15.240
Madam President, Commissioner, we thank
you very much for the opportunity you are

05:16:15.277 --> 05:16:19.928
giving us to discuss this issue, and I would
like to say to my younger colleagues—my

05:16:19.980 --> 05:16:22.417
older ones already know
this—I am a journalist;

05:16:22.465 --> 05:16:25.290
I used to be a journalist and
I served public television.

05:16:25.352 --> 05:16:28.219
And I have a particular
sensitivity to this.

05:16:28.293 --> 05:16:31.107
And I agree with the
Commissioner’s proposal.

05:16:31.147 --> 05:16:35.802
And I want to tell you that in Greece
we experienced this very intensely.

05:16:35.888 --> 05:16:41.358
It was 11 June 2013 when the then right-wing
government imposed a blackout and shut

05:16:41.406 --> 05:16:45.866
it down. And the independence of public
media is a fundamental prerequisite for the

05:16:45.913 --> 05:16:49.932
functioning of any democracy and for
the protection of the rule of law.

05:16:49.987 --> 05:16:55.081
And I, both as a professional and as a
journalist and as a citizen, cannot close my

05:16:55.133 --> 05:16:59.235
eyes and say: ‘This blackout is a sympathetic
blackout because the party is friendly

05:16:59.274 --> 05:17:01.951
to me, and this is
negative.’ I see it overall;

05:17:02.022 --> 05:17:07.235
it is a matter of democracy. And this is,
therefore, a refrain that we constantly

05:17:07.296 --> 05:17:11.934
highlight both in the LIBE Committee and
in our reports, particularly in the most

05:17:11.982 --> 05:17:15.655
recent one, for which I had the
honour of being the rapporteur.

05:17:15.723 --> 05:17:20.403
Unfortunately, the recent government
initiative in Czech television and Czech radio

05:17:20.454 --> 05:17:24.463
is raising serious concerns about the future
of this independence we are discussing

05:17:24.520 --> 05:17:28.675
today. Of course, there is also the issue
of transparency regarding private media,

05:17:28.727 --> 05:17:33.833
but I do not want to open that topic
now. I want to raise three key issues.

05:17:33.918 --> 05:17:39.498
First, financial dependence. The government
is pushing for the abolition of the

05:17:39.560 --> 05:17:43.988
licence fee and the transfer of
funding for public radio and television

05:17:44.042 --> 05:17:46.240
organisations directly
to the state budget.

05:17:46.286 --> 05:17:50.976
Someone might say: ‘Where is the problem?’
The problem is that we are effectively

05:17:51.058 --> 05:17:57.034
looking at a reduction in the
financial capacity of the medium.

05:17:57.103 --> 05:18:03.584
Because here we calculated that it is at
least close to, or rather below, 15% of

05:18:03.679 --> 05:18:09.249
revenue. Without, therefore, stable multi-year
and legally guaranteed guarantees, it

05:18:09.290 --> 05:18:13.606
is a given that the political majority
will acquire a powerful lever of economic

05:18:13.680 --> 05:18:14.672
pressure.

05:18:14.672 --> 05:18:21.744
in public information, and this constitutes,
Mr Commissioner, a slide backwards.

05:18:21.818 --> 05:18:25.737
Second, the weakening
of the public mission.

05:18:25.818 --> 05:18:31.158
The proposed cuts threaten the quality
of journalism and regional information,

05:18:31.216 --> 05:18:35.137
cultural production and investment
in new digital services.

05:18:35.200 --> 05:18:39.940
Public broadcasting is not simply
a business, it is not a business;

05:18:40.013 --> 05:18:45.951
it is a public good, and I stress this,
which must serve all citizens, regardless of

05:18:46.016 --> 05:18:48.307
income or political and religious beliefs.

05:18:48.357 --> 05:18:53.787
Third, the democratic process. The resort
to the urgent parliamentary procedure for

05:18:53.835 --> 05:18:59.604
the relevant bill and the absence of prior
consultation with the public broadcasters

05:18:59.664 --> 05:19:04.819
themselves rightly raise questions about
the transparency and quality of the

05:19:04.882 --> 05:19:10.370
legislative process. It is no coincidence
that on 3 November, the workers in public

05:19:10.438 --> 05:19:16.041
media, my former colleagues, held a major
strike with thousands of citizens taking

05:19:16.124 --> 05:19:21.042
to the streets to support them. We
experienced this in Athens in 2013.

05:19:21.143 --> 05:19:26.452
For all these reasons, therefore, defending
public information for us is not a

05:19:26.526 --> 05:19:29.803
corporatist issue, nor a
partisan confrontation.

05:19:29.866 --> 05:19:31.066
Thank you very much.

05:19:31.292 --> 05:19:34.772
Thank you. Honourable Member, please.
Honourable Member Mazurek, please.

05:19:37.952 --> 05:19:39.152
Here in this amendment

05:19:39.212 --> 05:19:41.751
some people must have gone completely mad.

05:19:41.828 --> 05:19:45.966
When in Germany people are having their
doors kicked in for writing something on

05:19:46.007 --> 05:19:50.675
social media, magazines are being banned,
channels are being shut down, everyone

05:19:50.733 --> 05:19:56.440
here is silent. When in Poland Donald Tusk
and his government massacred the public

05:19:56.510 --> 05:20:01.091
broadcaster, you were all silent. When
we see that the Spanish progressive

05:20:01.140 --> 05:20:06.462
government is flooding all of Europe with
illegal migrants, you are all perfectly

05:20:06.523 --> 05:20:11.389
fine with that. But when you see that in
the Czech Republic a government of patriots

05:20:11.455 --> 05:20:15.689
and a Europe of sovereign nations is in
power, you are all rushing to outdo each

05:20:15.746 --> 05:20:20.525
other in putting on the biggest circus
act about how freedom and democracy are

05:20:20.593 --> 05:20:25.014
supposedly suffering. Where is this freedom
and democracy when people in Europe are

05:20:25.074 --> 05:20:27.279
actually being locked
up for their opinions?

05:20:27.323 --> 05:20:31.510
Where is this freedom and democracy when
media are truly being silenced across

05:20:31.573 --> 05:20:35.179
Western Europe? Where is this freedom and
democracy when the German government is

05:20:35.229 --> 05:20:38.741
banning its own citizens from travelling
to conferences on re-emigration?

05:20:38.791 --> 05:20:41.718
Then you are not laughing
like half-wits, Ms Nerudová.

05:20:41.775 --> 05:20:44.079
Then you are silent.
Then everything is fine.

05:20:44.133 --> 05:20:46.848
And now we see the true
face of these people.

05:20:46.901 --> 05:20:50.765
They lost the elections, they lost the
elections in the Czech Republic and cannot

05:20:50.809 --> 05:20:55.227
accept it. They cannot accept it. That is
why they are putting on acts like clowns

05:20:55.287 --> 05:21:00.322
in a circus. Finally, respect democracy.
Respect the people of the Czech Republic,

05:21:00.375 --> 05:21:04.696
who have chosen their own government and
that government consists of patriots and a

05:21:04.747 --> 05:21:08.452
Europe of sovereign nations. You cannot
accept democracy like rabid dogs;

05:21:08.508 --> 05:21:12.812
you are calling for totalitarianism. You
yourself represent real totalitarianism.

05:21:15.512 --> 05:21:21.272
Thank you, honourable Member. Please,
honourable Member Wieselar Lima.

05:21:21.302 --> 05:21:22.532
Let us hear from our colleagues, please.

05:21:23.252 --> 05:21:24.452
Please proceed.

05:21:27.152 --> 05:21:33.552
On 24 October, at 4.36 a.m., in the middle
of the night, the majority of the Czech

05:21:33.605 --> 05:21:38.135
Parliament adopted at first reading the
removal of the television and radio public

05:21:38.201 --> 05:21:43.132
licence fee. If this goes ahead,
that means around 15 % less funding.

05:21:43.218 --> 05:21:47.976
But above all, it means direct
dependence on the State budget.

05:21:48.028 --> 05:21:52.070
This is not a budgetary dispute. A
public medium needs independence.

05:21:52.135 --> 05:21:56.605
It must not have to negotiate its funding
with a government every year, a government

05:21:56.659 --> 05:22:00.207
on which it must be able
to cast a critical eye.

05:22:00.262 --> 05:22:05.074
That is why, on 3 November, public media
employees went on strike and thousands of

05:22:05.116 --> 05:22:11.178
citizens took to the streets. The President
himself, Mr Pavel, called for a genuine

05:22:11.231 --> 05:22:16.058
debate. Without media independence, it is
democracy and the rule of law that are in

05:22:16.125 --> 05:22:21.253
danger. And this attack on the media, just
like the law targeting NGOs financed from

05:22:21.312 --> 05:22:26.263
abroad, follows a dangerous pattern
already seen elsewhere in Europe.

05:22:26.312 --> 05:22:29.747
The European regulation
on media freedom is clear.

05:22:29.803 --> 05:22:35.151
Public media funding must be
adequate, stable and predictable.

05:22:35.278 --> 05:22:40.657
Commissioner, you have said that the
Commission has already started a dialogue with

05:22:40.729 --> 05:22:45.568
Prague. We need positive results for
the rule of law before the final vote.

05:22:45.778 --> 05:22:51.877
This November, when the Czechs are
commemorating 1989, the conquest of freedom and

05:22:51.936 --> 05:22:56.100
democracy, let us defend what they
won through their Velvet Revolution.

05:22:56.218 --> 05:22:57.418
Thank you.

05:22:58.712 --> 05:23:00.812
Thank you, honourable Member.
Please, honourable Member Insir.

05:23:01.592 --> 05:23:02.792
Please proceed.

05:23:07.832 --> 05:23:12.497
Collègues, there is no democracy without
free and independent media, and there is no

05:23:12.549 --> 05:23:16.649
rule of law without accountability. The
development in the Czech Republic reminds us

05:23:16.707 --> 05:23:21.453
that the media freedom and judicial
independence must never be taken for granted.

05:23:21.512 --> 05:23:26.242
When political power threatens the independence
of public broadcast, it is not only

05:23:26.312 --> 05:23:30.929
journalists who are at risk. It is the
citizens' right to know the truth and hold

05:23:31.003 --> 05:23:37.475
those in power accountable. When we, at
least, sell at last were able to celebrate

05:23:37.532 --> 05:23:42.301
that Orbán departed from power in Hungary,
and when Kaczyński departed from power in

05:23:42.405 --> 05:23:46.406
Poland, well, Babiš stepped
up and replaced them.

05:23:46.472 --> 05:23:51.125
The European Union must stand firm in
defending media freedom and freedom,

05:23:51.212 --> 05:23:54.879
independent institutions, and
rule of law in every member state.

05:23:54.932 --> 05:23:57.932
Because democracy does
not die over one night.

05:23:57.992 --> 05:24:04.194
It is weakened step by step when those in
power's silence those who dare to question

05:24:04.285 --> 05:24:08.150
them. Collègues, notez: you talked about
my country Sweden, and you're right.

05:24:08.192 --> 05:24:12.385
What happened in Sweden is scandalous.
But you failed to mention that the biggest

05:24:12.452 --> 05:24:17.701
party in the government coalition are
your like-minded, Sweden Democrats, and

05:24:17.760 --> 05:24:22.410
finally, colleague Mazurek. There is
only one clown here, and that is you, who

05:24:22.477 --> 05:24:24.932
always blame everything at migrants.

05:24:26.852 --> 05:24:30.536
Grazie, onorevole. There
is a blue card for you.

05:24:30.632 --> 05:24:36.105
Mrs. Insir, there is a blue
card for you. If you accept it.

05:24:36.272 --> 05:24:37.472
Please, Mrs. Knotek.

05:24:37.952 --> 05:24:39.152
Mr. Knotek, please.

05:24:41.852 --> 05:24:43.052
For 30 seconds.

05:24:44.132 --> 05:24:48.007
Yes. Thank you, Madam Chairman, and thank
you, honorable colleagues, for accepting

05:24:48.084 --> 05:24:51.048
the blue card. I have carefully
listened to your speech.

05:24:51.092 --> 05:24:56.270
Could you please be more in detail able to
explain how concretely we break the media

05:24:56.327 --> 05:25:01.320
freedom with the proposal? And secondly,
you said that you have this same system in

05:25:01.379 --> 05:25:04.772
Sweden as well, so it is the
most common system in the EU.

05:25:04.892 --> 05:25:08.639
Why should we not have a right to have the
same model of financing that is as well

05:25:08.695 --> 05:25:10.172
in the EU? Thank you very much.

05:25:12.752 --> 05:25:13.952
Please.

05:25:14.192 --> 05:25:14.732
Please.

05:25:14.732 --> 05:25:19.500
I didn't hear the— it was echoing quite a
lot, but I— can you just repeat it so that

05:25:19.557 --> 05:25:21.332
I am able to really answer your—

05:25:21.512 --> 05:25:21.752
Yes.

05:25:21.752 --> 05:25:22.952
I didn't hear it, so it's—

05:25:23.192 --> 05:25:24.932
If you were, madam, so kind to explain—

05:25:25.232 --> 05:25:25.592
It's—

05:25:25.592 --> 05:25:32.873
—in detail, how concretely the proposal
of the Czech government is putting risk in

05:25:32.958 --> 05:25:37.244
the media freedom, and why we are not
allowed to have the same way of financing as

05:25:37.292 --> 05:25:38.732
majority in Europe. Thank you so much.

05:25:39.452 --> 05:25:45.620
Well, of course, everybody has the right
to financing the same way as others do, but

05:25:45.658 --> 05:25:48.398
what you are doing, you are actually
attacking the media freedom.

05:25:48.452 --> 05:25:53.260
You are cutting the funds to free and
independent media and journalists.

05:25:53.312 --> 05:25:58.459
And that is— and that's actually, in the
same line, I should say, as the Sweden

05:25:58.532 --> 05:26:03.933
Democrats has made the government in Sweden
the center-right government in Sweden do

05:26:03.992 --> 05:26:08.748
when you cut constantly. You don't always
need to directly attack, even though, of

05:26:08.797 --> 05:26:12.825
course, Babiš does it, like your friend
Orbán has done it before, like your friend

05:26:12.881 --> 05:26:17.009
Kaczyński did it also before. But
you can also do it in a subtle way.

05:26:17.072 --> 05:26:20.132
Through cutting funding of
the funding of the funding.

05:26:21.032 --> 05:26:23.012
Thank you. Please, for
your reply, if you want.

05:26:26.132 --> 05:26:30.390
Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chairman.
Yes, we are in a difficult time.

05:26:30.452 --> 05:26:34.480
Of course, everybody must save the cost.
But Czech broadcasting is responsible not

05:26:34.521 --> 05:26:39.708
only for the news, but also for a very wide
field of activities that have nothing to

05:26:39.764 --> 05:26:44.317
do with politics. And my question is:
where have you been where New Hungarian

05:26:44.381 --> 05:26:48.147
government cut the funds for
the broadcasting by 50 percent?

05:26:48.212 --> 05:26:50.386
You have been silent.
Again, double standards.

05:26:50.432 --> 05:26:52.532
Please read more before
you talk. Thank you.

05:26:54.032 --> 05:26:55.772
One thing that I have
learned from the far right—

05:26:56.132 --> 05:26:56.912
Please.

05:26:56.912 --> 05:27:00.684
—one thing that I have learned from the
far right is that there is never ever a

05:27:00.755 --> 05:27:04.824
responsibility. Everything is
always somebody else's fault.

05:27:04.892 --> 05:27:06.943
And it's always pointing at somebody else.

05:27:06.992 --> 05:27:10.341
When are you going to be able to
take responsibility for God's sake?

05:27:10.412 --> 05:27:13.924
Take responsibility for what's happening
in your country instead of saying what's

05:27:13.965 --> 05:27:18.812
happening in other countries? We have
raised the problems in Czech Republic.

05:27:18.932 --> 05:27:23.293
See it and do something
against the development.

05:27:23.372 --> 05:27:25.898
Stop talking about others.
Talk about yourself.

05:27:25.952 --> 05:27:30.475
If you care about your country, your people,
and the access to free and independent

05:27:30.525 --> 05:27:33.452
media, ensure that they reach
free and independent media.

05:27:33.512 --> 05:27:34.712
Don't attack them.

05:27:34.832 --> 05:27:40.292
Thank you. Please, Ms.
Pokorná Jermanová. Please.

05:27:42.392 --> 05:27:46.254
I would like to begin by saying that a lot
of half-truths and falsehoods have been

05:27:46.310 --> 05:27:50.909
heard here, because the approval of
the law is currently underway and the

05:27:50.975 --> 05:27:55.283
parliamentary debate is now topical.
The law is now being worked on.

05:27:55.338 --> 05:27:58.897
I would like to state that the Government
of the Czech Republic has every right to

05:27:58.948 --> 05:28:02.858
change the method of funding, because
it emerged from democratic elections.

05:28:02.911 --> 05:28:07.672
The significance and independence of public
service media does not lie in the method

05:28:07.739 --> 05:28:11.772
of funding. What matters are clear
rules and protection against political

05:28:11.829 --> 05:28:17.232
interference, and that is not changing.
What is important is strict control over the

05:28:17.288 --> 05:28:21.705
use of financial resources, but the
current system does not allow for that.

05:28:21.758 --> 05:28:26.685
If some Members of the European Parliament
or the European Commission want to turn

05:28:26.728 --> 05:28:30.459
concepts such as the protection of democracy
and the rule of law into a political

05:28:30.508 --> 05:28:33.683
cudgel against governments they
do not like, then know this:

05:28:33.747 --> 05:28:39.091
the Czech Republic is not a colony that
needs to be lectured at every step by its

05:28:39.144 --> 05:28:43.975
democratically elected parliament. And
Mr Commissioner, if you are brandishing a

05:28:44.025 --> 05:28:49.216
report from 2026, that report monitors
the period of 2025, and that was not our

05:28:49.283 --> 05:28:52.964
government, but Mr Fiala’s government,
which was represented here by my female

05:28:53.009 --> 05:28:54.332
colleagues. From the opposition.

05:28:56.012 --> 05:29:01.945
Thank you. Please, Mrs. Jarr.
I ask you to stay in time.

05:29:02.012 --> 05:29:03.212
Thank you.

05:29:04.412 --> 05:29:05.972
We are with you. Stay with us.

05:29:06.572 --> 05:29:11.749
With these words, in August 1968, Czechoslovak
Radio addressed the people when the

05:29:11.822 --> 05:29:15.002
occupation came to
silence free broadcasting.

05:29:15.071 --> 05:29:19.288
But today, tanks are not
needed. A vote at 4:36 a.m.

05:29:19.394 --> 05:29:24.531
on Saturday is enough, through which
politicians will limit the funding of public

05:29:24.585 --> 05:29:30.437
service television and radio. And then
they will also limit truthful information.

05:29:30.496 --> 05:29:33.004
This is no progressive-liberal fairy tale;

05:29:33.072 --> 05:29:36.877
it is reality in our Slovakia,
it is a warning from Slovakia.

05:29:36.935 --> 05:29:40.347
Even Babiš’s government was
clearly inspired by Slovakia.

05:29:40.419 --> 05:29:45.025
Even here it started with lies, such as
that the media spread disinformation, that

05:29:45.087 --> 05:29:49.634
Soros pays journalists, and that this
needs to be dealt with immediately.

05:29:49.685 --> 05:29:54.721
First, they cut public-service media off
from stable funding, strangled them, got

05:29:54.787 --> 05:30:00.885
rid of inconvenient employees, and then
built a loud government propaganda machine

05:30:00.963 --> 05:30:11.493
on the ruins. And we are
paying a high price for it.

05:30:11.571 --> 05:30:17.376
Today, in your streets, a struggle is taking
place for freedom and the rule of law,

05:30:17.439 --> 05:30:22.623
because the autocratic ambitions that are
simply unfolding here will never stop just

05:30:22.675 --> 05:30:25.810
at the media. Other
institutions will follow.

05:30:25.897 --> 05:30:31.927
You stand in the squares and fight for
Europe, for Slovakia, for those of us who

05:30:31.984 --> 05:30:36.072
have not yet lost hope. You
are an inspiration to us;

05:30:36.145 --> 05:30:38.872
do not stop, thank you,
and we stand with you.

05:30:41.572 --> 05:30:44.270
Thank you. Please,
honourable Member Estrich.

05:30:44.301 --> 05:30:45.501
Please.

05:30:46.852 --> 05:30:51.952
Mr. Chair, the Commissioner, Babiš and
his far-right allies have taken a page

05:30:52.012 --> 05:30:57.472
straight from the autocrats' playbook:
make the public media dependent on state

05:30:57.542 --> 05:31:03.772
funding so you can control what they say.
This is exactly what Orbán and Fico did

05:31:03.932 --> 05:31:07.951
before. Babiš calls it a financial reform;

05:31:08.032 --> 05:31:13.181
I call it an attack on the rule of law,
because there is no democratic society

05:31:13.274 --> 05:31:19.425
without media freedom. The immediate
broad and massive protests in Prague are

05:31:19.499 --> 05:31:25.074
encouraging, people know exactly what
is at stake, their right to information,

05:31:25.138 --> 05:31:30.904
expression, debate, and ultimately their
right to democracy and the rule of law.

05:31:31.012 --> 05:31:36.089
I call upon the Commission to act
just as swiftly as the protesters did.

05:31:36.172 --> 05:31:41.970
Reject the bill and make clear to Babiš
that being part of the EU requires full

05:31:42.039 --> 05:31:47.552
respect for the European values. And
take determined action if necessary.

05:31:47.632 --> 05:31:52.419
Let us not make the same mistakes from
the past, because undoing and encaptured

05:31:52.492 --> 05:31:55.192
system is so much harder
than preventing it.

05:31:55.732 --> 05:31:58.974
Thank you. This is a
blue card for you, Mr.

05:31:59.032 --> 05:32:02.752
Estrich. Ms. Estrich, there
is a blue card if you want.

05:32:04.012 --> 05:32:04.552
Yeah, okay.

05:32:04.552 --> 05:32:06.712
Okay. Please, Mr.
Mularczyk, for 30 seconds.

05:32:15.292 --> 05:32:17.032
Thank you. I will speak in Polish.

05:32:19.732 --> 05:32:23.024
Honourable Member, thank you
for accepting the blue card.

05:32:23.062 --> 05:32:27.273
Today, you are speaking about threats to
democracy due to the ongoing legislative

05:32:27.319 --> 05:32:32.138
process in the Czech Parliament. Honourable
Member, where do you stand when we see

05:32:32.217 --> 05:32:36.519
and hear what is happening in Poland?
Not long ago, Donald Tusk, without any

05:32:36.569 --> 05:32:40.161
legislation, with the help of the
police, took over the public television.

05:32:40.211 --> 05:32:43.665
He took over Polish radio and he
took over the Polish Press Agency.

05:32:43.713 --> 05:32:47.893
Later, he took over the prosecution service
with the help of the police, and now he

05:32:47.940 --> 05:32:50.861
has taken over the Constitutional
Tribunal with the help of the police.

05:32:50.906 --> 05:32:54.261
Where is the European Union? Where are
the defenders of the rule of law in the

05:32:54.304 --> 05:32:55.504
European Union?

05:32:59.692 --> 05:33:00.892
Ms. Estrich.

05:33:01.612 --> 05:33:06.756
I mean, if a legislation is being
adopted, it's not necessarily democratic.

05:33:06.832 --> 05:33:11.887
It's not necessarily under
supporting the rule of law.

05:33:11.992 --> 05:33:17.003
We saw it in Hungary. A lot of legislation
has passed under the Fidesz regime, but

05:33:17.070 --> 05:33:22.531
that wasn't democratic. That required an
Article 7 procedure and freezing of the

05:33:22.593 --> 05:33:28.677
funding. What Tusk is doing in Poland, he
is trying to rebuild the rule of law, and

05:33:28.740 --> 05:33:31.724
this is exactly my
message to the Commission:

05:33:31.792 --> 05:33:37.382
make sure you don't need to rebuild it,
but foster it as long as you have it.

05:33:37.432 --> 05:33:38.632
Thank you.

05:33:43.672 --> 05:33:44.872
Please, the chambers.

05:33:46.852 --> 05:33:50.729
Thank you, Mr President. If someone had
suggested this topic to me during my active

05:33:50.785 --> 05:33:55.000
time as an editor, I would have sent them
away, because it doesn’t fit the format.

05:33:55.048 --> 05:33:59.669
What on earth is prompting the Commission
to interfere in the media policy of a

05:33:59.721 --> 05:34:03.862
Member State? The Czech government is
planning to switch from a fee-based to a

05:34:03.910 --> 05:34:07.864
tax-funded broadcasting system, which
is exactly what has already happened in

05:34:07.909 --> 05:34:12.428
France, Denmark and Sweden. So why is the
Commission concerned about media freedom

05:34:12.485 --> 05:34:17.140
when it is doing everything in its power
to exert ever greater control over the

05:34:17.192 --> 05:34:21.704
media? When the new Polish government simply
shut down and unlawfully liquidated the

05:34:21.772 --> 05:34:24.884
state broadcaster, no
protest was raised here.

05:34:24.949 --> 05:34:30.543
Because Donald Tusk is compliant with
the EU, whereas Andrej Babiš thinks

05:34:30.602 --> 05:34:35.116
independently and wants to restructure the
finances of Czech Television – something

05:34:35.172 --> 05:34:39.971
we urgently need in Germany too. This
broadcasting system does not require nine

05:34:40.034 --> 05:34:44.968
billion euros a year. This topic does
not belong in this Parliament, and the

05:34:45.024 --> 05:34:48.765
Commission should please refrain from
interfering in the internal affairs of

05:34:48.808 --> 05:34:50.008
sovereign states.

05:34:52.912 --> 05:34:56.572
Mr. Chambres, there is a
blue card. Okay. Please, Mr.

05:34:56.632 --> 05:34:58.552
Heide. For 30 seconds.

05:34:59.212 --> 05:35:03.051
I would like to know from you what you
have to say about the fact that in two

05:35:03.105 --> 05:35:08.623
European countries, Switzerland and
Slovenia, the population has voted in

05:35:08.672 --> 05:35:13.251
referendums to maintain the licence fee,
and what do you have to say about the fact

05:35:13.312 --> 05:35:18.307
that, in a self-proclaimed patriotic
government, officials responsible for

05:35:18.382 --> 05:35:23.060
broadcasting have apologised for what
they have done for years in public-service

05:35:23.107 --> 05:35:24.232
broadcasting?

05:35:24.232 --> 05:35:27.740
Also, I also have the principle that I
do not interfere in the affairs of other

05:35:27.788 --> 05:35:33.196
states. I naturally followed the referendum
in Switzerland very closely, because it

05:35:33.273 --> 05:35:39.499
is part of our DNA. You know, my party
holds direct democracy in very high regard;

05:35:39.555 --> 05:35:43.194
we consider it very important. And I admired
that the Swiss carried it out, and of

05:35:43.233 --> 05:35:47.742
course the result must be respected. Every
country and every people should decide

05:35:47.795 --> 05:35:52.587
this for themselves. There are advantages
and disadvantages to both systems, no

05:35:52.630 --> 05:35:56.900
question about it. But now to latch onto
funding and say that suddenly it becomes

05:35:56.956 --> 05:35:59.392
dangerous – that is
nonsense, quite honestly.

05:36:02.512 --> 05:36:05.188
Thank you. Honourable Member,
please, Vice-President Verain.

05:36:05.222 --> 05:36:06.422
Please.

05:36:08.152 --> 05:36:14.226
Thank you, Madam President. Whoever controls
the money also controls the media and

05:36:14.291 --> 05:36:19.379
has influence over the editorial process.
The Czech Television and Czech Radio are

05:36:19.434 --> 05:36:22.680
to be financed directly from
the state budget in future.

05:36:22.728 --> 05:36:25.641
This is certainly also the
case in other countries.

05:36:25.701 --> 05:36:30.487
But the fact that this is happening at
the same time as a 15 per cent cut is

05:36:30.543 --> 05:36:34.496
introduced clearly shows that the
pressure and influence on the media is

05:36:34.564 --> 05:36:38.418
intentional. And this is a
serious problem for independence.

05:36:38.469 --> 05:36:43.598
Commissioner, the European Media Freedom
Act has been in force since August last

05:36:43.659 --> 05:36:46.267
year. That is now a
year and a half, almost.

05:36:46.318 --> 05:36:50.359
Its implementation is still not
complete, even though the deadline for

05:36:50.424 --> 05:36:56.813
implementation was last August. And
this case shows why this is a problem.

05:36:56.884 --> 05:37:02.526
The EMFA requires adequate, sustainable,
predictable funding that is also clearly

05:37:02.602 --> 05:37:07.732
regulated by law and not a system that
is re-established with every change of

05:37:07.793 --> 05:37:12.469
government. And that was the reason why
we created the EMFA, because we wanted to

05:37:12.563 --> 05:37:18.718
eliminate precisely these uncertainties.
Public service broadcasting should be free

05:37:18.784 --> 05:37:23.582
from political influence. And honest
budget negotiations are actually having the

05:37:23.642 --> 05:37:28.259
opposite effect. They give the government
a lever over the editorial teams and the

05:37:28.316 --> 05:37:32.685
management of public service broadcasters,
who constantly have to deal with the

05:37:32.733 --> 05:37:35.619
reality they find themselves
in after budget negotiations.

05:37:35.694 --> 05:37:39.184
The Commission says it is
observing the situation.

05:37:39.255 --> 05:37:44.238
Observation is not enough. It must act
and ensure the full implementation of the

05:37:44.296 --> 05:37:48.792
EMFA in all its aspects. And the people
in Prague are telling us exactly what they

05:37:48.833 --> 05:37:54.506
want. And Mr Schnurbusch, if you say
that you hold the plebiscite in very high

05:37:54.553 --> 05:37:58.954
regard and want the population to be able
to decide, then I ask myself why you are

05:37:59.003 --> 05:38:03.984
not listening to the thousands of people
in Prague who have taken to the streets to

05:38:04.043 --> 05:38:07.132
fight for their public
service broadcaster.

05:38:07.312 --> 05:38:10.572
and defend it. Show us that you want this.

05:38:10.648 --> 05:38:13.511
And please implement
the law, Commissioner.

05:38:13.578 --> 05:38:17.743
The EMFA must finally be fully
implemented in all Member States.

05:38:17.799 --> 05:38:18.172
Thank you.

05:38:18.172 --> 05:38:19.372
Thank you.

05:38:19.732 --> 05:38:24.422
There is a, there are two blue
cards. We can accept only one.

05:38:24.532 --> 05:38:28.507
Do you accept the, okay.
Please, Mr. László.

05:38:28.672 --> 05:38:30.472
For 30 seconds. Please stay on time.

05:38:33.712 --> 05:38:34.912
I'll be talking Hungarian.

05:38:37.372 --> 05:38:41.490
You spoke about the financing of public
service media and editorial freedom in the

05:38:41.538 --> 05:38:45.580
Czech public service media. But how is it
possible that when, in Hungary, the new

05:38:45.644 --> 05:38:51.177
Prime Minister from the governing party —
which belongs to your political family —

05:38:51.250 --> 05:38:57.372
personally intervened and publicly kicked
out, essentially, the new editor-in-chief

05:38:57.433 --> 05:39:00.256
of the new public service
media, you did not worry?

05:39:00.292 --> 05:39:03.444
How is it possible that when the financing
of public service media was reduced, you

05:39:03.486 --> 05:39:07.788
did not worry because of Hungary? How is
it possible that when the Media Council,

05:39:07.847 --> 05:39:14.507
the heads of the media authority, were
replaced by the new parliament, you did not

05:39:14.558 --> 05:39:16.809
worry? How can this double
standard be explained?

05:39:16.851 --> 05:39:18.051
Please tell us. Thank you.

05:39:18.352 --> 05:39:20.032
Thank you. You're welcome.

05:39:21.292 --> 05:39:24.152
Yes, thank you very much. We do
not need to apply double standards;

05:39:24.195 --> 05:39:28.113
what happened in Hungary is what we actually
wanted, namely – at least so far – a

05:39:28.180 --> 05:39:33.614
good implementation of the EMFA in terms
of how an independent media authority can

05:39:33.665 --> 05:39:37.432
be structured. Unlike before, there are
now representatives of the governing

05:39:37.487 --> 05:39:42.289
parties, representatives of the opposition
and representatives of civil society,

05:39:42.375 --> 05:39:45.497
which has not been the case
under Orbán in Hungary.

05:39:45.543 --> 05:39:50.215
Previously, there were three from the
governing party and one from the opposition

05:39:50.260 --> 05:39:53.836
party, ensuring that a three-quarters
majority and a corresponding position were

05:39:53.881 --> 05:39:58.063
always guaranteed. That has nothing to do
with the independence of media oversight.

05:39:58.113 --> 05:40:01.926
And that is why the step taken in Hungary
is now the right one, because what has

05:40:02.010 --> 05:40:04.932
been established fully
complies with the EMFA.

05:40:04.963 --> 05:40:06.112
Thank you.

05:40:06.112 --> 05:40:09.177
Thank you. Honourable Member, please.
Honourable Member López-Aguilar.

05:40:09.199 --> 05:40:10.399
Please.

05:40:15.532 --> 05:40:17.452
Thank you, Mr President.
Commissioner McGrath.

05:40:17.752 --> 05:40:23.501
When Anders Babiš, who is not coincidentally
a media magnate, became Prime Minister

05:40:23.556 --> 05:40:29.710
of the Czech Republic, many of us in this
Chamber foresaw a follower of Hungary’s

05:40:29.804 --> 05:40:33.554
Viktor Orbán’s illiberal path.
But we had to wait and see.

05:40:33.600 --> 05:40:39.341
And here we are again, with yet another
reform of media funding that has sparked

05:40:39.413 --> 05:40:45.113
protests in his own country, but above
all, concern—from our perspective, rightly

05:40:45.197 --> 05:40:51.585
so—about its compatibility with European
standards, as affirmed in the annual

05:40:51.665 --> 05:40:56.515
rule-of-law reports. These reports do
not only analyse the state of judicial

05:40:56.559 --> 05:41:02.066
independence, the separation of powers, the
fight against corruption, but also press

05:41:02.145 --> 05:41:05.537
freedom and its corollary,
which is media pluralism.

05:41:05.624 --> 05:41:12.161
This European Parliament has not only
adopted a law to protect journalists from

05:41:12.215 --> 05:41:17.613
strategic litigation, but also a whole
media regulation with a European centre, a

05:41:17.666 --> 05:41:21.571
European body that safeguards
freedom and media pluralism.

05:41:21.643 --> 05:41:27.148
Therefore, we must state clearly that
transparency in media funding is an essential

05:41:27.201 --> 05:41:33.701
component of media freedom and of informational
pluralism, because it is very easy

05:41:33.769 --> 05:41:37.852
to colonise freedom of expression
through invasive media funding.

05:41:37.911 --> 05:41:39.052
Thank you, President.

05:41:39.052 --> 05:41:41.872
Thank you. Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Stanek.

05:41:51.172 --> 05:41:57.731
Madam President, to all those who today
confuse the defence of media freedom with

05:41:57.816 --> 05:42:03.112
support for the Czech opposition without
knowledge of Czech legislation, I remind

05:42:03.189 --> 05:42:07.787
you that the European Parliament should
not be a tool of domestic strategic and

05:42:07.847 --> 05:42:13.134
partisan struggle. If you have evidence
of interference in editorial independence,

05:42:13.197 --> 05:42:16.506
present it. Political
disagreement is not evidence.

05:42:16.590 --> 05:42:21.011
And what are we talking about?
About the method of payment.

05:42:21.064 --> 05:42:23.573
The licence fee is not a
certificate of freedom.

05:42:23.626 --> 05:42:27.759
And funding from the budget is
not automatically censorship.

05:42:27.831 --> 05:42:31.366
The method of payment does not
guarantee media independence.

05:42:31.436 --> 05:42:33.680
What matters are the
rules that protect it.

05:42:33.727 --> 05:42:38.456
And those are guaranteed in the proposal.
I respect the right to protest as much as

05:42:38.506 --> 05:42:43.266
the right to scrutinise public money. After
all, public service media do not belong

05:42:43.316 --> 05:42:49.058
to the government. They do not belong to
the opposition, nor to any one ideological

05:42:49.135 --> 05:42:53.633
camp. Czech colleagues, do not laugh and
do not turn a domestic political dispute

05:42:53.696 --> 05:42:57.768
into an indictment of your own
country. It does not deserve that.

05:42:57.810 --> 05:42:59.010
Ms Nerudová.

05:43:03.532 --> 05:43:05.872
Thank you. Honourable Member, please.
Honourable Member Freund, please.

05:43:08.332 --> 05:43:12.460
Dear colleagues, dear Commissioner, Andrej
Babiš, the Prime Minister of the Czech

05:43:12.510 --> 05:43:16.559
Republic, has a conflict of interest.
And it's not just me saying that.

05:43:16.612 --> 05:43:21.122
It's the European Commission that said
this, and also not for the first time.

05:43:21.172 --> 05:43:24.834
This is the second time now already
that we have certified this.

05:43:24.892 --> 05:43:30.626
So making sure that he doesn't get a cent
of EU funds is the bare minimum that we

05:43:30.671 --> 05:43:35.064
need to make sure. But I actually don't
really understand how someone that has a

05:43:35.122 --> 05:43:40.192
certified conflict of interest, the Financial
Rules say it needs to be resolved, how

05:43:40.252 --> 05:43:45.451
can he still sit at the negotiation
table and negotiate the EU budget?

05:43:45.532 --> 05:43:52.024
How is this possible? Mr. Konotnik, you
said that we're only criticizing this

05:43:52.116 --> 05:43:55.852
because he's part of the
fascist political family here.

05:43:55.912 --> 05:44:00.883
But if you remember, actually, just two
years ago, you used to sit there in the

05:44:00.938 --> 05:44:04.772
middle. With the liberals.
Before you changed groups.

05:44:04.852 --> 05:44:09.597
And actually, back then, when you were
still part of what you call the political

05:44:09.650 --> 05:44:14.539
mainstream, well, this House was still
criticizing the corruption, the conflict of

05:44:14.589 --> 05:44:17.280
interest, and all the problems
in the Czech Republic.

05:44:17.332 --> 05:44:19.442
So this has nothing to do with your group.

05:44:19.492 --> 05:44:22.192
This has to do with conflict
of interest and corruption.

05:44:22.612 --> 05:44:22.972
Thank you.

05:44:22.972 --> 05:44:24.172
Thank you very much.

05:44:24.532 --> 05:44:27.424
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Kolar.

05:44:27.445 --> 05:44:28.645
Please.

05:44:39.652 --> 05:44:46.352
For personal statement,
not because of blue card.

05:44:47.272 --> 05:44:51.252
You don't push for blue card. If you want
to intervene for personal statement, you

05:44:51.459 --> 05:44:52.672
can. Please.

05:44:57.772 --> 05:45:02.500
Thank you very much. Mr. Freund, we have
a nice debate in the budgetary control

05:45:02.542 --> 05:45:07.404
committee, but this is a different topic.
By the way, are you aware that your

05:45:07.442 --> 05:45:10.925
colleague from your political group, from
the Pirates, which is part of the Greens,

05:45:10.975 --> 05:45:17.444
had exactly the same idea of change of the
financing in their parliamentary program?

05:45:17.512 --> 05:45:21.926
So your colleagues had it as a program,
and you are now criticizing us for doing

05:45:21.970 --> 05:45:24.760
what your colleagues wanted
to do eight years ago?

05:45:24.892 --> 05:45:26.632
You are not serious. You are silly.

05:45:28.792 --> 05:45:33.228
Grazie, Onorevole. It's a personal
statement, so it's not possible to reply.

05:45:33.292 --> 05:45:36.117
It's not possible to reply because
it was a personal statement.

05:45:36.172 --> 05:45:47.326
It's not a blue card.
Please, Mr. Konotnik.

05:45:47.992 --> 05:45:49.192
Mr. Kolar, sorry.

05:45:50.332 --> 05:45:55.642
Good evening. Thank you very much. And
it is terribly sad that, thanks to the

05:45:55.692 --> 05:46:00.044
populist-nationalist governing coalition,
the Czech Republic is being pushed to the

05:46:00.089 --> 05:46:02.833
sidelines and that we have
to witness this debate.

05:46:02.897 --> 05:46:07.498
How can I trust a government that is
actively decimating our own army to have good

05:46:07.552 --> 05:46:11.761
intentions towards public-service media?
Which, doubtless, many politicians in the

05:46:11.809 --> 05:46:16.535
coalition dislike because it adheres to the
principles and standards of objectivity,

05:46:16.596 --> 05:46:20.804
balance and professional journalism? I
am not saying we should not discuss how

05:46:20.855 --> 05:46:23.060
public-service media are
financed and operate.

05:46:23.108 --> 05:46:26.895
The problem, however, is that
this debate is not happening.

05:46:26.956 --> 05:46:30.223
What we are witnessing is
bullying by the government.

05:46:30.275 --> 05:46:34.658
This is not a standard political debate.
We do not see expert consultations.

05:46:34.718 --> 05:46:38.984
There is no transparent process. Instead,
we are seeing a rape of morality.

05:46:39.039 --> 05:46:41.404
We are witnessing a degradation of values.

05:46:41.463 --> 05:46:47.214
We see contempt for ideological pluralism
and for rules—both written and unwritten.

05:46:47.288 --> 05:46:52.309
And those who do this and call themselves
democrats then frenetically applaud a

05:46:52.380 --> 05:46:55.192
thoroughbred Slovak neo-Nazi. That hurts.

05:46:57.292 --> 05:47:02.756
There is a blue card from Mrs. Dostálová.
Please, for 30 seconds, and please stay on

05:47:02.803 --> 05:47:04.003
the time.

05:47:05.332 --> 05:47:08.071
Good afternoon, Mr Member
of the European Parliament.

05:47:08.118 --> 05:47:11.756
I sincerely apologise for this falling to
you, because I tried to submit a blue card

05:47:11.797 --> 05:47:15.688
for Ms Nerudová, Ms Gregorová or Ms
Vrecienová, but my fellow heroines have hidden

05:47:15.745 --> 05:47:17.788
themselves in the group
where it is not possible.

05:47:17.835 --> 05:47:20.915
So I will ask you instead whether
you read European studies.

05:47:20.963 --> 05:47:24.113
I assume you do, as a proper
Member of the European Parliament.

05:47:24.163 --> 05:47:28.213
So you certainly know that they point to
the injustice of concession fees, their

05:47:28.257 --> 05:47:31.062
administrative complexity
and problems with collection.

05:47:31.118 --> 05:47:35.744
And so I ask you why, in your view,
Czech citizens must face this?

05:47:35.795 --> 05:47:40.019
Or why must this system be maintained when
the European Commission itself points out

05:47:40.072 --> 05:47:43.971
its unsuitability? And why do you not
consider it appropriate to switch to a

05:47:44.019 --> 05:47:46.912
different method of financing,
as 14 countries have done?

05:47:52.132 --> 05:47:52.732
Please.

05:47:52.732 --> 05:47:57.068
Thank you for the question. It's a shame
you weren't listening to what I was saying.

05:47:57.196 --> 05:48:01.820
I said that it is necessary, or in other
words, it is necessary to hold this debate

05:48:01.862 --> 05:48:04.143
on the funding and functioning
of public service media.

05:48:04.186 --> 05:48:08.262
And I said that the problem is that this
debate is not taking place in the Czech

05:48:08.324 --> 05:48:11.356
Republic. You have raped
the parliamentary process.

05:48:11.412 --> 05:48:16.006
You have refused to debate
and the debate does not exist.

05:48:16.054 --> 05:48:18.774
We do not know what your government
coalition actually plans.

05:48:18.815 --> 05:48:22.477
No one knows. Frankly, I honestly think
that your Prime Minister doesn’t even know,

05:48:22.520 --> 05:48:27.080
that you yourselves don’t know. You are
just cobbling something together on the fly,

05:48:27.130 --> 05:48:32.758
no one knows what is actually
happening, and then at 4:36 a.m.

05:48:32.915 --> 05:48:35.641
on Saturday, you rape
the Chamber of Deputies.

05:48:35.687 --> 05:48:36.887
That is not done. Sorry.

05:48:39.412 --> 05:48:42.832
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Rafović.

05:48:44.092 --> 05:48:45.292
We are very late.

05:48:55.072 --> 05:48:59.474
Madam President, Commissioner, the Czech
government is directly attacking the

05:48:59.536 --> 05:49:04.210
independence of public broadcasting. By
abolishing the licence fee and announcing

05:49:04.271 --> 05:49:08.714
cuts to news budgets, they are striking
at a true pillar of our democracies.

05:49:08.773 --> 05:49:12.028
In France, we know this
story all too well.

05:49:12.097 --> 05:49:17.060
Since Emmanuel Macron abolished the
licence fee, public broadcasting has been

05:49:17.110 --> 05:49:23.080
weakened. On the far right, both here and
in France, they are rejoicing, they are

05:49:23.142 --> 05:49:28.362
rejoicing at these repeated mistakes. They
are exploiting every loophole opened up

05:49:28.413 --> 05:49:32.486
by the right-wing government. Charles
Lalonque in the French National Assembly,

05:49:32.533 --> 05:49:35.668
Sarah Knafo here – their project is clear:

05:49:35.730 --> 05:49:40.826
to do everything possible to privatise
public broadcasting and serve the media

05:49:40.890 --> 05:49:45.552
concentration agenda of their friends. We
cannot tolerate this auctioning off of our

05:49:45.613 --> 05:49:50.430
imaginations to a few oligarchs. The freedom
of our continent, the strength of our

05:49:50.492 --> 05:49:53.685
democracies, also depends on
this first line of defence.

05:49:53.750 --> 05:49:57.123
Here, information is free culture. So,
Commissioner, I say this to you very

05:49:57.160 --> 05:50:01.408
solemnly: we must ensure that the Media
Freedom Act is applied and fully transposed

05:50:01.456 --> 05:50:05.705
across Europe. We must strengthen the
protection and the capacity for action of our

05:50:05.761 --> 05:50:09.731
regulators. We must strengthen the
funding of our public broadcasting.

05:50:09.787 --> 05:50:14.366
We must establish a genuine European
preference to protect ourselves against foreign

05:50:14.419 --> 05:50:15.052
interference.

05:50:15.052 --> 05:50:15.472
Thank you.

05:50:15.472 --> 05:50:19.068
And protect our public audiovisual
media. And I will conclude here:

05:50:19.135 --> 05:50:23.541
we must finally massively
decentralise our media and culture.

05:50:23.629 --> 05:50:25.912
The oligarchy is the enemy of democracy.

05:50:26.092 --> 05:50:27.292
Thank you, Honourable Member.

05:50:27.412 --> 05:50:28.192
Thank you.

05:50:28.192 --> 05:50:32.127
We have concluded the debate. We have
six speakers registered under the written

05:50:32.235 --> 05:50:35.975
procedure CACHE-DI. We can accept them
all, but I ask you to be precise with the

05:50:36.030 --> 05:50:40.093
timing. We will begin.
Please, Honourable Grappini.

05:50:40.187 --> 05:50:41.387
Please.

05:50:42.772 --> 05:50:47.130
Thank you, Madam President. Commissioner,
dear colleagues, I believe that if

05:50:47.187 --> 05:50:52.186
citizens listened to tonight’s debate,
they will no longer have any trust in us.

05:50:52.261 --> 05:50:56.695
We must understand—having listened to
both sides—matters that could lead to

05:50:56.760 --> 05:51:01.838
disinformation. We must understand that
once states join the European Union, they

05:51:01.887 --> 05:51:04.899
must comply with European
regulations. Not à la carte.

05:51:04.959 --> 05:51:09.151
We do not pick and choose what we
like. The media is very important.

05:51:09.202 --> 05:51:12.339
These rules must be implemented
in all Member States.

05:51:12.393 --> 05:51:17.216
On the other hand, the Commission—Commissioner—you must see how you are not fuelling

05:51:17.277 --> 05:51:22.088
euroscepticism. Because if you want to
intervene, as you did in my country, Romania,

05:51:22.154 --> 05:51:28.465
to challenge a law passed by Parliament and
approved by the Constitutional Court, we

05:51:28.537 --> 05:51:33.520
lose credibility. That is why I believe
that, yes, we must know the sources of

05:51:33.611 --> 05:51:38.541
funding. Radio is the easiest means of
informing citizens, and that is why we must

05:51:38.597 --> 05:51:40.912
protect the media and
press freedom. Thank you.

05:51:42.892 --> 05:51:45.352
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Konecka.

05:51:48.172 --> 05:51:50.810
Madam President, distinguished
colleagues, ladies and gentlemen.

05:51:50.854 --> 05:51:54.853
What we are seeing and engaging in here
today is a political debate of those who

05:51:54.912 --> 05:51:58.869
were unsuccessful in last year's
elections to the Chamber of Deputies.

05:51:58.929 --> 05:52:03.022
Unsuccessful people who—it really saddens
me that neither Ms Vrecienová nor Ms

05:52:03.067 --> 05:52:07.250
Gregorová are here today; they were the
ones who kept saying how things should be

05:52:07.302 --> 05:52:11.365
different. Their political parties
proposed that the fees be abolished.

05:52:11.434 --> 05:52:16.093
When they were not in opposition and had
the chance, they proposed that the fees be

05:52:16.163 --> 05:52:20.839
abolished. Do you, colleagues, ladies and
gentlemen, really think it is democratic

05:52:20.882 --> 05:52:25.477
that in the Czech Republic we have reached
the point where public-service media fees

05:52:25.538 --> 05:52:29.822
are paid by people who do not
even own a television or radio?

05:52:29.939 --> 05:52:34.209
Does that seem fair to you? And do
they have any chance of control?

05:52:34.272 --> 05:52:37.306
Today, they have no chance
of control whatsoever.

05:52:37.356 --> 05:52:42.094
And what is undemocratic about that, or
are countries like France, Malta and others

05:52:42.154 --> 05:52:46.961
undemocratic, where public-service media
are also funded from the state budget?

05:52:47.020 --> 05:52:51.136
And just a few final figures, colleagues,
ladies and gentlemen, so that it does not

05:52:51.184 --> 05:52:55.057
look as though the entire
Czech Republic is protesting.

05:52:55.120 --> 05:52:59.973
According to surveys, only 19 % of people
would voluntarily pay the fee to Czech

05:53:00.068 --> 05:53:03.621
Television, and only a third
of people wish to keep it.

05:53:03.670 --> 05:53:05.893
So do not believe what
you see on television;

05:53:05.934 --> 05:53:07.134
look at the data instead.

05:53:07.372 --> 05:53:07.732
Thank you.

05:53:07.732 --> 05:53:11.272
The Czechs want the fees to be
abolished, so grant them that.

05:53:11.632 --> 05:53:12.532
Thank you, Honourable Member.

05:53:12.532 --> 05:53:13.132
Let's get to it.

05:53:13.132 --> 05:53:14.332
Please, Honourable Tinkynen.

05:53:22.012 --> 05:53:27.572
Dear colleagues, I want you
to listen to me carefully.

05:53:27.712 --> 05:53:35.179
The media model you're criticizing
that Czech Republic is trying to build.

05:53:35.332 --> 05:53:43.582
That is the model we have in
Finland. What are we doing here in.

05:53:43.732 --> 05:53:50.092
Finland? We used to have TV licenses
for our citizens for funding the public

05:53:50.146 --> 05:53:55.848
broadcast company. We took them away.
Then we introduced the public broadcasting

05:53:55.912 --> 05:54:00.028
tax, and now politicians
control the system.

05:54:00.112 --> 05:54:06.624
And this government term we made the
biggest cuts for this public broadcasting

05:54:06.723 --> 05:54:10.827
company. There were no
protests in our country.

05:54:10.912 --> 05:54:15.931
EU didn't attack us. The
commissioner didn't attack us.

05:54:16.012 --> 05:54:21.377
We have EPP Prime Minister at
the moment. I hate the hypocrisy.

05:54:21.472 --> 05:54:26.934
And this happens again and again.
EU, you're losing your credibility.

05:54:26.992 --> 05:54:28.192
Thank you.

05:54:29.452 --> 05:54:31.672
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Mr László.

05:54:36.352 --> 05:54:41.009
Thank you, Madam President. This debate
on media freedom in the Czech Republic is

05:54:41.087 --> 05:54:47.465
obviously nothing more than a pathetic
and dishonest political attack.

05:54:47.572 --> 05:54:53.787
The law hasn't even been approved yet.
The new financing model exists in several

05:54:53.862 --> 05:54:58.240
other EU countries. Yet those
countries were not criticized.

05:54:58.312 --> 05:55:03.960
Why is that? Why is it that when other
parties had similar policy plans, no one was

05:55:04.043 --> 05:55:10.207
concerned in this House? The double
standards is absolutely obvious.

05:55:10.312 --> 05:55:14.911
The hypocrisy must end. The
double standards must end.

05:55:14.992 --> 05:55:21.243
Media freedom—European values—rule of law
can only be credible if they are applied

05:55:21.298 --> 05:55:26.575
with the same measure to everyone, and not
on a political basis like it is happening

05:55:26.632 --> 05:55:29.152
today with the Czech
Republic. Thank you very much.

05:55:30.772 --> 05:55:33.112
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Mularczyk.

05:55:39.472 --> 05:55:42.989
Are there different standards of the
rule of law in the European Union?

05:55:43.046 --> 05:55:48.755
Undoubtedly, yes. Because today we are
discussing a change that is being processed

05:55:48.800 --> 05:55:53.545
in the Czech Parliament. However, ladies
and gentlemen, over the past three years of

05:55:53.597 --> 05:55:58.553
Donald Tusk’s government in Poland, all
institutions—starting with public media,

05:55:58.614 --> 05:56:03.590
television, public radio, the Polish Press
Agency, the prosecution service, and most

05:56:03.643 --> 05:56:07.546
recently the Constitutional
Tribunal—have been forcibly taken over.

05:56:07.606 --> 05:56:12.128
Donald Tusk does not need any law. He
does not need any parliamentary procedure.

05:56:12.182 --> 05:56:17.142
He sends in the police, he sends in batons,
and he forcibly seizes institutions.

05:56:17.195 --> 05:56:21.710
Ladies and gentlemen, that is the current
state of the rule of law in Poland.

05:56:21.763 --> 05:56:25.415
And where is Commissioner Graff?
There is no Commissioner Graff.

05:56:25.475 --> 05:56:28.846
He is silent, he is hiding.
Where is President von der Leyen?

05:56:28.887 --> 05:56:34.004
She is not here. Because they accept it,
because in Poland a German liberal lapdog,

05:56:34.071 --> 05:56:38.014
Donald Tusk, is in power. Ladies and
gentlemen, and this is a scandal.

05:56:38.082 --> 05:56:40.912
This is not the Union we
want. Thank you very much.

05:56:43.072 --> 05:56:44.992
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Tereš.

05:56:48.472 --> 05:56:55.729
Thank you, esteemed Mr Commissioner.
When will you stop this hypocrisy?

05:56:55.912 --> 05:57:01.029
I have listened carefully to what has been
said here and I see this double standard

05:57:01.085 --> 05:57:06.752
being promoted by Ursula von der Leyen. If
the leadership of a Member State pleases

05:57:06.817 --> 05:57:12.996
Ursula von der Leyen, no matter what
that representative does, it is fine.

05:57:13.062 --> 05:57:18.145
If, however, the leadership of that State
questions European policies, whether they

05:57:18.198 --> 05:57:23.450
are good or less good, that is secondary.
No matter what the leadership of that

05:57:23.532 --> 05:57:26.505
State does, this kind
of criticism appears.

05:57:26.581 --> 05:57:32.374
I ask you: is the European Commission
the most suitable institution to lecture

05:57:32.447 --> 05:57:37.851
Member States on press freedom? Especially
when the European Commission has still

05:57:37.902 --> 05:57:43.218
not published the contracts signed
with the vaccine companies to this day?

05:57:43.284 --> 05:57:50.915
How can it preach, speak, and give lessons
on press freedom when it itself violates

05:57:51.005 --> 05:57:55.806
the freedom and the right of citizens to
access information of public interest?

05:57:55.856 --> 05:58:00.854
Mr Commissioner, please tell Ursula von
der Leyen to publish the contracts signed

05:58:00.920 --> 05:58:02.992
with Pfizer and Moderna. Thank you.

05:58:03.652 --> 05:58:08.079
Thank you, Honourable Member. We have
concluded the catch-the-eye procedure.

05:58:08.191 --> 05:58:11.992
Please, Commissioner McGrath. Thank you.

05:58:15.532 --> 05:58:17.839
Thank you very much,
President, Honorable Members.

05:58:17.872 --> 05:58:22.180
Thank you all for your contributions
to this debate this evening.

05:58:22.252 --> 05:58:27.302
And I believe that this evening's discussion
has again shown that media freedom and

05:58:27.385 --> 05:58:31.067
pluralism is certainly
not an abstract principle.

05:58:31.132 --> 05:58:37.279
It is a necessary condition for democracy,
accountability, and public trust.

05:58:37.372 --> 05:58:41.801
And this is especially true when we
speak about public service media.

05:58:41.872 --> 05:58:47.722
Whose independence and long-term sustainability
are essential for democratic life.

05:58:47.812 --> 05:58:52.856
They are a key pillar. In Czechia, as
elsewhere, and Euroform affecting the

05:58:52.912 --> 05:58:58.587
governance are financing of public
broadcasters, must be assessed with due care.

05:58:58.672 --> 05:59:03.674
Public service media needs stable, adequate,
and predictable funding to be able to

05:59:03.735 --> 05:59:06.932
fulfill their mission
in the public interest.

05:59:07.012 --> 05:59:11.210
What is at stake today goes
beyond any one financing model.

05:59:11.272 --> 05:59:15.896
Are indeed any one member state. It's
about whether public service media can

05:59:15.952 --> 05:59:21.880
continue to serve citizens, free from
political or economic pressure, at a time when

05:59:21.943 --> 05:59:26.397
trusted independent information
is more essential than ever.

05:59:26.512 --> 05:59:32.196
And this is precisely why the European
Media Freedom Act matters, not only as a

05:59:32.264 --> 05:59:38.607
shared standard on paper as EU law, but as
a framework that must now be applied and

05:59:38.692 --> 05:59:44.408
implemented in practice. But the independence
of public service media is only one

05:59:44.476 --> 05:59:49.810
part of the picture. Media freedom also
depends on the people who do the work.

05:59:49.912 --> 05:59:53.645
Journalists, must be able
to report without fear.

05:59:53.752 --> 05:59:58.130
And the truth is, across the EU,
journalists continue to face threats:

05:59:58.192 --> 06:00:00.892
online harassment, and
even physical attacks.

06:00:00.952 --> 06:00:05.090
We assess their safety every year,
in the annual Rule of Law report.

06:00:05.152 --> 06:00:09.368
And this is also why the Commission
adopted a recommendation on the safety of

06:00:09.417 --> 06:00:15.389
journalists back in 2021. And as committed
in the European Democracy Shield, the we

06:00:15.448 --> 06:00:20.614
published a year ago, we will update this
recommendation to reflect the changing

06:00:20.681 --> 06:00:24.752
realities that journalists
face in their day-to-day work.

06:00:24.952 --> 06:00:29.148
Journalists are also increasingly
targeted, as we know, by abuse of lawsuits.

06:00:29.212 --> 06:00:34.072
Known as slaps, which aim to silence
them, rather than to obtain justice.

06:00:34.552 --> 06:00:39.406
The anti-slap directive, which member
states had to transpose by May of this year,

06:00:39.472 --> 06:00:44.640
allows courts to dismiss manifestly
unfounded claims early and protects those

06:00:44.713 --> 06:00:49.660
targeted in cross-border cases. We've
recommended that member states apply the same

06:00:49.732 --> 06:00:55.558
safeguards indeed to domestic slap cases.
So let me underline one fundamental point

06:00:55.612 --> 06:01:02.194
in conclusion. Independent media including
public service media providers are not a

06:01:02.272 --> 06:01:07.601
nice-to-have in a democratic society;
they are in truth a democratic necessity.

06:01:07.672 --> 06:01:11.882
The Commission will therefore continue to
engage with the Czech authorities and, in

06:01:11.932 --> 06:01:17.288
doing so, our objective is clear: to ensure
full respect for the principles of media

06:01:17.337 --> 06:01:22.162
freedom editorial independence and transparent
and sustainable funding in line with

06:01:22.221 --> 06:01:27.343
European standards and in line with European
law in the form of the European Media

06:01:27.398 --> 06:01:32.371
Freedom Act. The Commission will remain
vigilant and committed to defending media

06:01:32.446 --> 06:01:38.479
freedom and pluralism, as well as the Rule
of Law in all member states including in

06:01:38.537 --> 06:01:41.032
Czechia. Thank you, colleagues, for
your contributions this evening.

06:01:42.712 --> 06:01:48.092
Thank you, Commissioner. The discussion
is closed and the vote will take place

06:01:48.145 --> 06:01:54.083
during a future sitting. The agenda now
includes the one-minute speeches under

06:01:54.153 --> 06:01:58.489
Article 179 of the Rules of Procedure.
I inform you that for the one-minute

06:01:58.531 --> 06:02:01.552
speeches, colleagues are invited
to take the floor from their seats.

06:02:01.599 --> 06:02:05.152
We shall begin: please,
Honourable Member Kohut.

06:02:08.092 --> 06:02:12.447
And I stand here today, even though in
Warsaw they say that the Silesians do not

06:02:12.501 --> 06:02:16.877
exist. I said this several years ago,
precisely in this hall of the European

06:02:16.937 --> 06:02:21.362
Parliament. The census: over half a
million Polish citizens declared a Silesian

06:02:21.420 --> 06:02:24.297
identity and the use of
the Silesian language.

06:02:24.387 --> 06:02:28.231
The bill on recognising Silesian as a
language twice passed through the Polish

06:02:28.284 --> 06:02:32.849
parliament. Unfortunately, twice right-wing
Polish presidents vetoed our cause.

06:02:32.905 --> 06:02:36.912
And that is precisely why we have
embarked on a different journey.

06:02:36.974 --> 06:02:41.072
We want international recognition and
respect for the Silesian language.

06:02:41.124 --> 06:02:45.500
We want to inscribe the Silesian language
as a bearer of culture in the UNESCO

06:02:45.553 --> 06:02:49.910
Intangible Cultural Heritage list. We are
currently conducting public consultations.

06:02:49.957 --> 06:02:54.056
From Opole Silesia to Cieszyn Silesia.
The entire Upper Silesia, with its various

06:02:54.113 --> 06:02:58.101
dialects, speaks one language, a carrier
of our Silesian culture and identity.

06:02:58.172 --> 06:03:02.003
We will not deviate from this path.
Let us protect regional languages.

06:03:02.061 --> 06:03:06.327
Let us jointly protect the Silesian
language, the heritage of our old ancestors.

06:03:06.381 --> 06:03:08.152
Multiculturalism is our strength.

06:03:11.032 --> 06:03:19.299
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Kristea.

06:03:19.475 --> 06:03:23.632
She is not here. Please, Ms.

06:03:23.992 --> 06:03:29.752
Disdier. 707.

06:03:31.912 --> 06:03:35.970
There you go. We're going
to fuck your mothers.

06:03:36.081 --> 06:03:41.438
Dirty whites. Dirty fascists. These are
the insults that young Catholics in Rouen

06:03:41.527 --> 06:03:46.186
received last week before
being violently attacked.

06:03:46.283 --> 06:03:50.472
Punches, a broken nose, a disfigured face.

06:03:50.541 --> 06:03:56.109
And all for no reason. But since when,
in France, would being white, French or

06:03:56.218 --> 06:04:02.199
Catholic justify becoming a target? I
welcome the upcoming creation of a European

06:04:02.262 --> 06:04:07.688
coordinator responsible for combating
anti-Christian hatred within the European

06:04:07.764 --> 06:04:11.242
Union. This is a truly
necessary step forward.

06:04:11.318 --> 06:04:14.177
But they will need to get to work quickly.

06:04:14.238 --> 06:04:17.984
Christians in Europe are not
asking for any privileges.

06:04:18.038 --> 06:04:24.745
They are simply asking to be able to
live their faith freely and safely.

06:04:24.831 --> 06:04:28.873
Anti-white racism exists.
Anti-Christian hatred exists.

06:04:28.935 --> 06:04:34.520
It is time to stop turning a blind eye.
There cannot be double standards in the

06:04:34.573 --> 06:04:37.635
fight against racism and religious hatred.

06:04:37.681 --> 06:04:43.812
As our President Metsola so rightly said
earlier, racism has no place in Europe or

06:04:43.900 --> 06:04:50.099
anywhere else. Every victim deserves
justice, whatever their origins and beliefs.

06:04:50.126 --> 06:04:50.932
Thank you.

06:04:50.932 --> 06:04:53.272
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Teodorescu.

06:04:57.292 --> 06:04:58.492
Thank you, Chair.

06:04:58.492 --> 06:05:02.036
From here, from Brussels, from the comfort
of the Parliament and the Commission, you

06:05:02.078 --> 06:05:05.614
believe you understand the needs and the
desperation of those who have filled the

06:05:05.671 --> 06:05:09.188
streets across Europe. Do you think you
can understand the pain of a mother who has

06:05:09.234 --> 06:05:12.837
nothing with which to feed her children
or the tears of an elderly person who must

06:05:12.879 --> 06:05:16.793
give up food in order to afford their
medication or their electricity bill?

06:05:16.847 --> 06:05:20.535
Your ideological, ruinous policies,
such as the Green Deal, have bankrupted

06:05:20.580 --> 06:05:24.680
businesses, suffocated the agricultural
sector, and driven production out of Europe.

06:05:24.732 --> 06:05:28.819
So that you can pat yourselves on the
back for being noble and wanting a cleaner

06:05:28.876 --> 06:05:31.021
planet, you have starved
an entire continent.

06:05:31.067 --> 06:05:33.909
There is no true democracy
without prosperity for citizens.

06:05:33.953 --> 06:05:38.348
Just as there is no real democracy with
annulled elections, political police, and

06:05:38.408 --> 06:05:42.510
banned protests. On the 14th, Romania
will rise from its knees and, like other

06:05:42.556 --> 06:05:45.137
European countries, will
demand justice in the streets.

06:05:45.178 --> 06:05:48.934
The Government in Bucharest is preparing
to crush any form of legitimate protest,

06:05:48.985 --> 06:05:53.685
believing, as they do, that it is democratic
to annul ongoing elections, to ban snap

06:05:53.733 --> 06:05:56.966
elections and, in general, to
trample the Constitution underfoot.

06:05:57.014 --> 06:06:01.002
Watch closely the news from Romania and
the abuses being prepared against Romanian

06:06:01.051 --> 06:06:02.251
citizens.

06:06:03.532 --> 06:06:05.752
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Cohen.

06:06:10.372 --> 06:06:15.386
Thank you, President. Like many at home, I
woke up this morning to welcome news of a

06:06:15.463 --> 06:06:19.224
public sector pay deal in Ireland. A
balanced agreement delivering meaningful

06:06:19.264 --> 06:06:23.830
increases for over 400,000 workers. But
there's a broader point I wanted to make.

06:06:23.872 --> 06:06:28.085
Increasingly, in Ireland and indeed in
Europe, we see competing interests all making

06:06:28.132 --> 06:06:32.142
their own demands, all insisting
their priorities come first.

06:06:32.212 --> 06:06:35.944
Here in Brussels, every committee, including
my own, demanding more from an already

06:06:35.988 --> 06:06:40.033
stretched European budget. But in
Ireland, I will remind you, it was fiscal

06:06:40.075 --> 06:06:43.601
prudence, not reckless spending on the
back of uncertain revenues, that built an

06:06:43.646 --> 06:06:47.371
economy that was capable of delivering pay
increases and supporting households and

06:06:47.416 --> 06:06:52.204
investing billions in infrastructure.
Likewise, in Brussels, it's unity and

06:06:52.253 --> 06:06:56.203
solidarity and a willingness to compromise
that have brought us to where we are.

06:06:56.272 --> 06:07:00.244
Because ultimately, the politics that I
believe in is about more than satisfying the

06:07:00.296 --> 06:07:04.237
demands of individual interests. It's
about having the courage to make difficult

06:07:04.287 --> 06:07:08.239
choices, the discipline to look beyond the
next election, and the responsibility to

06:07:08.288 --> 06:07:12.986
put the long-term interests of those we
represent and expect this Parliament and the

06:07:13.038 --> 06:07:16.774
Commission and the Council will have
that in mind when agreeing a budget that

06:07:16.825 --> 06:07:19.980
accommodates all sectoral
interests fairly and appropriately.

06:07:20.032 --> 06:07:21.232
Thank you.

06:07:26.692 --> 06:07:31.132
Thank you, Honourable Member. Please,
Honourable Member Miranda Paz.

06:07:31.211 --> 06:07:33.352
She is not here. Honourable Member Bojlan.

06:07:37.432 --> 06:07:41.433
Thank you, Chair. This week, I and my
colleague Kathleen Vonchen were proud to

06:07:41.478 --> 06:07:46.172
welcome activists from the north of Ireland
to Brussels for an Irish Unity Week.

06:07:46.252 --> 06:07:50.445
And their message was inspiring, and
it was clear that Ireland is ready for

06:07:50.512 --> 06:07:54.532
reunification and the north
is ready to rejoin the EU.

06:07:54.652 --> 06:07:58.863
Some delegates were too young to even vote
when English voters decided that these

06:07:58.912 --> 06:08:02.800
young people's futures lay
outside the European Union.

06:08:02.872 --> 06:08:06.955
But they know there is a way back through
the Good Friday Agreement, and they are

06:08:07.012 --> 06:08:11.310
determined to exercise that
option to unite Ireland in the EU.

06:08:11.392 --> 06:08:15.655
And the Parliament also heard this week
of thorough new research from Professor

06:08:15.712 --> 06:08:21.011
Colin Harvey and Barrister Mark Bassett,
pointing out at how Brussels, too, must

06:08:21.107 --> 06:08:27.099
prepare for a united Ireland. Delicate
political and legal issues can no longer be

06:08:27.165 --> 06:08:32.850
ignored by anybody here in Brussels. In
Brussels, in Belfast, in Derry, Nuri, and

06:08:32.901 --> 06:08:37.596
Dublin, the message from the people is that
it is time to get serious about a united

06:08:37.661 --> 06:08:39.352
Ireland in the European Union.

06:08:40.612 --> 06:08:42.712
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Bozdorf.

06:08:43.972 --> 06:08:45.232
Please. Thank you.

06:08:47.332 --> 06:08:52.364
100,000 young people took to the streets
in France and Italy in October to protest

06:08:52.433 --> 06:08:58.541
against failings in the education sector.
Their concerns are more than justified.

06:08:58.579 --> 06:09:03.064
Public coffers are empty, educational
institutions are falling into disrepair, and

06:09:03.144 --> 06:09:06.617
future prospects are
virtually non-existent.

06:09:06.694 --> 06:09:11.675
Dystopian images emerged when part of
these protests was hijacked by Antifa and

06:09:11.752 --> 06:09:16.436
migrants. Things spiralled completely
out of control and the anger erupted

06:09:16.522 --> 06:09:22.541
violently. Thousands of shops were looted,
cars and buildings burned, and millions

06:09:22.601 --> 06:09:27.017
of euros in damage were caused. Who
is going to compensate this damage?

06:09:27.121 --> 06:09:32.800
Good question. At the same time, billions
of euros in European Union funds flow into

06:09:32.873 --> 06:09:36.102
left-wing and opaque
structures every year.

06:09:36.186 --> 06:09:41.081
Organisations from the environment of the
protests have also benefited from this.

06:09:41.139 --> 06:09:46.335
We demand a thorough and transparent
investigation to ensure that not a single euro

06:09:46.400 --> 06:09:49.794
of our tax money has been
misused for violent protests.

06:09:49.854 --> 06:09:54.865
We also demand that, in future, our money
should be spent on the education and

06:09:54.912 --> 06:09:57.561
future of our children rather
than on left-wing propaganda.

06:09:57.585 --> 06:09:58.785
Thank you.

06:09:59.752 --> 06:10:02.759
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Lazarus.

06:10:02.773 --> 06:10:03.973
Please.

06:10:05.332 --> 06:10:08.823
Madam President, dear
colleagues, democracy in action.

06:10:08.887 --> 06:10:13.681
Madam President, dear colleagues, I see
that this important principle of the

06:10:13.721 --> 06:10:17.164
European Union is even displayed on
a banner in front of the Parliament.

06:10:17.229 --> 06:10:22.363
But let us consider how this democracy
in action operates in our countries.

06:10:22.468 --> 06:10:28.896
Actually, in Romania, in 2024, you
practically banned certain people from running

06:10:28.951 --> 06:10:31.410
for the presidency of
Romania. Which is absurd.

06:10:31.466 --> 06:10:38.093
It resembles what is happening in Iran.
Furthermore, I have also learned that in

06:10:38.153 --> 06:10:42.214
Romania someone else won the
elections than who you were expecting.

06:10:42.263 --> 06:10:46.998
If someone other than the one you wanted
won the elections, you would have annulled

06:10:47.051 --> 06:10:52.157
the elections. After you cancelled the
elections, you again banned those who wanted

06:10:52.219 --> 06:10:57.362
to run, including the election winner,
Mr Călin Georgescu, from running again.

06:10:57.436 --> 06:11:02.322
Today he has five criminal cases and
is being held in prison in Romania.

06:11:02.391 --> 06:11:07.743
And now we want to hold a rally on
Saturday, and we are not given permission.

06:11:07.810 --> 06:11:13.078
So, in what country do we live and
in what European Union do we live?

06:11:13.149 --> 06:11:18.247
I mean, aren’t you even ashamed? Ursula von
der Leyen was in Romania just a few days

06:11:18.322 --> 06:11:19.312
ago and...

06:11:19.312 --> 06:11:19.972
Thank you.

06:11:19.972 --> 06:11:21.172
Yes, I have.

06:11:21.172 --> 06:11:26.392
Thank you. Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Aftias.

06:11:30.052 --> 06:11:31.192
Please.

06:11:31.192 --> 06:11:38.412
Honourable colleagues, the support of our
islands is support for islandness through

06:11:38.534 --> 06:11:44.347
the new multiannual financial
framework must be our top priority.

06:11:44.458 --> 06:11:48.666
The islands are not just for
tourism; they have needs.

06:11:48.792 --> 06:11:55.491
They have many needs. As a member of the
Economic Committee, and as a Greek MEP,

06:11:55.560 --> 06:12:02.405
with many islands in my homeland, there
are far too many of them—227 are inhabited.

06:12:02.486 --> 06:12:08.523
They need transport, they need energy,
they need healthcare and education.

06:12:08.599 --> 06:12:12.393
Development must not
stop where the sea ends.

06:12:12.493 --> 06:12:19.365
It must continue. I therefore ask for your
full support, and I believe we will all

06:12:19.447 --> 06:12:22.432
move in this direction.
Thank you very much.

06:12:26.812 --> 06:12:30.725
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Vigenin.

06:12:30.754 --> 06:12:31.954
Please.

06:12:32.692 --> 06:12:34.072
Nikos Nebihmepous, Member of Parliament,

06:12:34.072 --> 06:12:38.060
that a company deliberately distributes
a product that leads to addiction in

06:12:38.116 --> 06:12:41.912
children. So why are we allowing
this in the digital world?

06:12:42.052 --> 06:12:46.594
The algorithms of social media platforms
are designed to keep children glued to

06:12:46.648 --> 06:12:50.323
screens for as long as possible.
The consequences can be serious:

06:12:50.371 --> 06:12:54.944
anxiety, sleep disorders, cyberbullying,
exposure to harmful content.

06:12:55.014 --> 06:12:59.169
The health and well-being of children
must be more important than the profits of

06:12:59.220 --> 06:13:03.715
digital platforms. We need stricter
measures against practices that lead to

06:13:03.776 --> 06:13:08.572
addiction, effective enforcement of existing
legislation, and new ambitious rules,

06:13:08.650 --> 06:13:13.920
including a future European legislative
act for the protection of children online

06:13:13.991 --> 06:13:18.685
and the YouKids Act, as well as the
Digital Justice Act presented today.

06:13:18.744 --> 06:13:24.076
That is why, on 21 November, I am organising
a public discussion in the city of

06:13:24.138 --> 06:13:28.818
Varna with representatives of institutions,
experts, parents and teachers to discuss

06:13:28.876 --> 06:13:33.819
European policies and specific solutions.
Parents are doing everything they can to

06:13:33.873 --> 06:13:38.614
protect their children, but they are up
against some of the most powerful tech

06:13:38.680 --> 06:13:43.824
companies in the world. It is time for us,
as legislators, to take our share of the

06:13:43.882 --> 06:13:45.352
responsibility too. Thank you.

06:13:48.952 --> 06:13:52.928
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Brica.

06:13:52.956 --> 06:13:54.156
Please.

06:13:54.172 --> 06:13:57.692
Dear colleagues, we, Poles, today
are celebrating our independence.

06:13:57.741 --> 06:14:03.706
11 November is a joyful memory of the day
when, after 123 years of captivity, Poland

06:14:03.764 --> 06:14:08.661
returned to the map of Europe as a
sovereign, strong and independent state.

06:14:08.714 --> 06:14:12.993
We have been and remain a proud and free
nation, which is why we want decisions made

06:14:13.043 --> 06:14:18.231
in Poland to be fully Polish decisions,
without yielding to any form of blackmail.

06:14:18.294 --> 06:14:22.601
Neither the European Commission, nor
Parliament, nor any external body has the right

06:14:22.656 --> 06:14:27.352
to interfere in Polish affairs. We do not
need EU resolutions, lectures, or CJEU

06:14:27.427 --> 06:14:32.057
rulings. We want the Polish economy to
grow, and that means there must be less and

06:14:32.115 --> 06:14:36.042
less EU legislation. It is Poles
who are the hosts in Poland.

06:14:36.104 --> 06:14:40.702
We will organise the system ourselves,
the judiciary ourselves, and we ourselves

06:14:40.761 --> 06:14:44.779
will hold to account those responsible
for the recent assassination attempt,

06:14:44.830 --> 06:14:48.722
including Prime Minister Tusk. The
Commissioner is supposed to have said:

06:14:48.769 --> 06:14:52.582
the Polish Constitutional Tribunal must
be allowed to function in accordance with

06:14:52.638 --> 06:14:55.447
the Polish Constitution
and the CJEU’s case law.

06:14:55.491 --> 06:14:57.850
No, Mr Commissioner, we
do not need your tribunal.

06:14:57.917 --> 06:15:00.934
We need less and less of the
Union and more and more of Poland.

06:15:00.968 --> 06:15:02.168
Long live Poland.

06:15:04.852 --> 06:15:06.959
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Reussen.

06:15:06.973 --> 06:15:08.173
Please.

06:15:12.832 --> 06:15:15.978
Thank you, Mr President. In the Netherlands,
it is the Week of Life this week.

06:15:16.019 --> 06:15:20.949
I wish to take this opportunity to
reflect on this this evening as well.

06:15:20.994 --> 06:15:22.965
Because the situation
is extremely worrying.

06:15:23.058 --> 06:15:26.975
Mr President, in the Netherlands
this week is the Week of Life.

06:15:27.054 --> 06:15:31.620
I felt it important to address
this again this evening.

06:15:31.699 --> 06:15:34.803
Because the situation
is extremely worrying.

06:15:34.850 --> 06:15:38.440
In the Netherlands alone, more than
100 abortions take place every day.

06:15:38.493 --> 06:15:44.041
Over 40,000 a year. Appalling. During the
Week of Life, many in my country reflect

06:15:44.111 --> 06:15:49.802
on the fact that life is given by God.
And so it is worthy of protection from the

06:15:49.863 --> 06:15:54.521
very beginning. I think of what David
confessed about this in Psalm 139:

06:15:54.559 --> 06:15:58.518
'You knit me together in my mother’s
womb.' And in the meantime, Mr President,

06:15:58.573 --> 06:16:02.474
Europe is only pushing for a further
expansion of abortion legislation.

06:16:02.545 --> 06:16:05.761
Mr President, the EU really
needs to stop doing that.

06:16:05.851 --> 06:16:10.036
And certainly also stop
funding abortions from the ESF.

06:16:10.095 --> 06:16:14.015
Let us protect life and focus
on care for mother and child.

06:16:14.038 --> 06:16:15.238
Thank you.

06:16:15.532 --> 06:16:16.732
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Gabel.

06:16:16.684 --> 06:16:17.884
Please go ahead. Thank
you, Honourable Member.

06:16:17.819 --> 06:16:19.019
Please, Honourable Member Gabel.

06:16:22.132 --> 06:16:26.895
The gladiatorial combats in ancient Rome,
those are thankfully history, but there

06:16:26.983 --> 06:16:31.358
are still bullfights in
some parts of Europe today.

06:16:31.412 --> 06:16:36.198
In these events, the poor animals are
tortured and tormented for so long that they

06:16:36.264 --> 06:16:41.638
ultimately die a particularly
protracted and agonising death.

06:16:41.697 --> 06:16:46.464
A particularly horrific way to
amuse and entertain certain people.

06:16:46.522 --> 06:16:52.419
However, the majority of people are
against it, even in Spain, by the way.

06:16:52.498 --> 06:16:58.293
We now have a unique opportunity to put
an end to this, to realign the Common

06:16:58.365 --> 06:17:05.553
Agricultural Policy and, in doing so,
to end EU funding for bullfighting.

06:17:05.622 --> 06:17:12.148
After all, the EU is violating its own
values and rules if it financially supports

06:17:12.245 --> 06:17:19.175
bullfighting. So let us seize this opportunity
together now and put an end to this

06:17:19.273 --> 06:17:23.752
bloody stain on the
European Union. Thank you.

06:17:26.812 --> 06:17:28.672
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Grappini.

06:17:31.372 --> 06:17:35.655
Madam President, Commissioner, the proposal
that the Commission has made for the new

06:17:35.704 --> 06:17:41.611
budget for the next seven years you know
full well that it is not well received by

06:17:41.665 --> 06:17:45.630
farmers, by the Common Agricultural
Policy, as the proposal stands:

06:17:45.691 --> 06:17:50.077
the budget is being cut. And not only does
it decrease, I am also a member of the

06:17:50.118 --> 06:17:53.010
Agriculture Committee and
Vice-President for the internal market.

06:17:53.063 --> 06:17:57.444
We cannot fail to allocate funds to
farmers who are subsidising farmers who are

06:17:57.489 --> 06:18:02.013
pensioners. We know full well that we
have a generational change problem.

06:18:02.070 --> 06:18:07.932
Then there are, no, we cannot accept – and
farmers are saying this, and the majority

06:18:07.988 --> 06:18:12.739
of Parliament is saying this – that costs
on salaries should not be reduced or

06:18:12.782 --> 06:18:15.549
excluded when capping is applied.
And there are many other things.

06:18:15.588 --> 06:18:19.270
But the most serious is that livestock
farming is on the ground, that the budget is

06:18:19.320 --> 06:18:23.885
decreasing, it is smaller than in the
previous financial exercise, and yet they are

06:18:23.947 --> 06:18:28.833
asking the Commission to consider whether,
if Parliament, if farmers do not support

06:18:28.889 --> 06:18:32.445
this budget and we will no longer have a
common agricultural policy, the Commission

06:18:32.488 --> 06:18:36.967
should change its position. And perhaps
after 20 years, when my country, since my

06:18:37.003 --> 06:18:40.495
country joined the European Union, and the
farmers in my country will have the same

06:18:40.529 --> 06:18:41.729
subsidy as the other farmers.

06:18:41.812 --> 06:18:43.012
Thank you, Honourable Member.

06:18:43.252 --> 06:18:44.992
Please, Honourable Member Moreira de Sá.

06:18:45.532 --> 06:18:46.732
Please.

06:18:47.752 --> 06:18:52.482
Madam President, when Robespierre's head
rolled for you, we had Sanson, the terror

06:18:52.542 --> 06:18:57.953
ended. Robespierre was dead. But with him
did not die his most dangerous legacy, the

06:18:58.004 --> 06:19:01.866
seduction of the idea that violence is
a legitimate instrument of political

06:19:01.929 --> 06:19:06.429
transformation. Robespierre’s guillotine
has disappeared from the squares, but not

06:19:06.478 --> 06:19:09.742
his descendants, who still
draw inspiration from him.

06:19:09.839 --> 06:19:14.073
Today, the far left is the heir to the
tyrant of Paris, seeking to hijack noble and

06:19:14.124 --> 06:19:18.326
urgent causes, such as education and
housing, not to find solutions, but to set

06:19:18.380 --> 06:19:23.062
Europe ablaze. And that is why, when they
cannot silence the ballot boxes, they seek

06:19:23.104 --> 06:19:27.715
to impose their will in the tumult
of the ballot boxes, in the streets.

06:19:27.877 --> 06:19:31.858
It is for us to draw a line in the
sand. There are those who prefer fire to

06:19:31.896 --> 06:19:35.525
dialogue. We will respond
with the strength of our laws.

06:19:35.581 --> 06:19:39.560
Terror met its end in a basket of wine.
We will not allow it to be reborn in our

06:19:39.603 --> 06:19:43.157
shop windows and stalls, in
our squares and institutions.

06:19:43.193 --> 06:19:44.393
Thank you.

06:19:45.712 --> 06:19:48.487
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Müller.

06:19:48.515 --> 06:19:49.715
Please.

06:19:51.952 --> 06:19:56.449
Ladies and Gentlemen, today Europe is even
handing over its own kitchen and bathroom

06:19:56.507 --> 06:20:00.552
to Asia. In recent years, the share of
European factories in our market for washing

06:20:00.606 --> 06:20:06.821
machines, refrigerators and
dishwashers has fallen from 81% to 71%.

06:20:06.878 --> 06:20:12.185
And at the same time, Asian products
have doubled in terms of quantity.

06:20:12.231 --> 06:20:16.412
From 15 to 28%. This is further evidence
of how we are surrendering yet another area

06:20:16.484 --> 06:20:21.458
of industrial production in Europe. And
the stakes are around one million jobs on

06:20:21.519 --> 06:20:25.569
our continent. Poland stands to lose the
most in this regard, because 39% of large

06:20:25.616 --> 06:20:30.894
household appliances produced in the
European Union are made in our country.

06:20:30.937 --> 06:20:34.517
And we in Europe are not losing this
competition to Asia because we have worse

06:20:34.567 --> 06:20:38.350
products, but because in the European Union
we have more expensive energy, greater

06:20:38.401 --> 06:20:43.069
regulations and stricter requirements,
which result in lower competitiveness, while

06:20:43.124 --> 06:20:46.527
at the same time products from
Asia are not adequately controlled.

06:20:46.577 --> 06:20:50.098
Ladies and Gentlemen, several Member States
of the European Union have called for

06:20:50.142 --> 06:20:53.822
the preparation of a special strategy
for the household appliances sector.

06:20:53.870 --> 06:20:57.686
We must do this, otherwise this sector will
end up the same way as car production in

06:20:57.719 --> 06:20:58.919
Europe.

06:20:59.932 --> 06:21:02.344
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Smith.

06:21:02.365 --> 06:21:03.565
Please.

06:21:04.972 --> 06:21:08.528
Thank you, Madam President. For several
months now, young generations have been

06:21:08.583 --> 06:21:13.089
mobilising across our continent, despite
police repression, to demand improvements

06:21:13.134 --> 06:21:15.323
in their living, working
and study conditions.

06:21:15.382 --> 06:21:20.086
And rightly so, as poverty and unemployment
rates are reaching record levels and

06:21:20.142 --> 06:21:22.501
study spaces are rapidly
falling into disrepair.

06:21:22.551 --> 06:21:25.705
Young people are being
pauperised and exploited.

06:21:25.754 --> 06:21:29.335
Their legitimate anger must be
able to find political expression.

06:21:29.384 --> 06:21:33.614
Establishment of an autonomy guarantee
at the level of the poverty threshold.

06:21:33.670 --> 06:21:38.302
Increase in the minimum wage and in the
remuneration of apprentices and trainees.

06:21:38.367 --> 06:21:41.661
Freezing of prices for
essential goods and energy.

06:21:41.718 --> 06:21:44.417
Abolition in France of
Parcoursup, in particular.

06:21:44.457 --> 06:21:47.169
Plan for modernising and adapting
buildings to climate change.

06:21:47.220 --> 06:21:51.275
All these proposals are found in the
presidential programme of Jean-Luc Mélenchon,

06:21:51.332 --> 06:21:53.762
L'Avenir en Commun, and
we are defending them.

06:21:53.814 --> 06:21:57.660
The professional sector must also regain
a coherent and efficient structure through

06:21:57.718 --> 06:22:01.156
the creation of polytechnic
centres and maritime high schools.

06:22:01.235 --> 06:22:06.512
Without a trained and emancipated youth,
national sovereignty is simply not

06:22:06.569 --> 06:22:07.769
possible. Thank you.

06:22:08.932 --> 06:22:11.638
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Jerković.

06:22:11.652 --> 06:22:12.852
Please.

06:22:13.612 --> 06:22:19.612
Thank you, Chair. Dear colleagues, we often
speak about childhood obesity as if we

06:22:19.672 --> 06:22:23.624
were simply a matter of personal
responsibility, but it's not.

06:22:23.692 --> 06:22:28.166
Children are not responsible for the
environment in which they grow up.

06:22:28.252 --> 06:22:33.746
Children do not decide what food is
advertised to them, what is served in their

06:22:33.817 --> 06:22:37.728
schools or whether their families
can afford healthy meals.

06:22:37.792 --> 06:22:43.139
These are choices shaped by policies and
food industry and markets and the society

06:22:43.203 --> 06:22:49.291
we create. We cannot expect children to
make healthy choices if we do not give them

06:22:49.365 --> 06:22:54.802
a healthy option. And that is why we need
stronger European action on prevention and

06:22:54.859 --> 06:23:00.005
healthier school environments and
protection from harmful marketing.

06:23:00.112 --> 06:23:05.152
Every child deserves the chance to grow
up healthy, regardless of their family's

06:23:05.212 --> 06:23:08.608
income or where they live.
This is not just about health;

06:23:08.665 --> 06:23:11.510
it is about equality and
about Europe's future.

06:23:11.572 --> 06:23:12.772
Thank you.

06:23:15.592 --> 06:23:16.612
Good.

06:23:16.612 --> 06:23:19.742
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Domotor.

06:23:19.763 --> 06:23:20.963
Please.

06:23:23.992 --> 06:23:27.889
In recent weeks, several delegations have
visited Hungary to assess the state of

06:23:27.936 --> 06:23:32.156
democracy, and they have concluded that
now everything is fine, there’s nothing to

06:23:32.207 --> 06:23:35.991
see here. They said this despite the fact
that a significant portion of opposition

06:23:36.044 --> 06:23:40.711
MPs are barred from political life, cannot
run in the next election, and this only

06:23:40.779 --> 06:23:45.966
affects the opposition. They have also
removed the President of the Republic,

06:23:46.026 --> 06:23:48.849
constitutional judges,
and the Chief Prosecutor.

06:23:48.927 --> 06:23:52.888
The largest opposition party’s
servers have been unlawfully seized.

06:23:52.936 --> 06:23:57.196
According to the self-proclaimed champions
of the rule of law, this is perfectly

06:23:57.260 --> 06:24:02.012
acceptable. And why is that? Because the
new government is doing everything that the

06:24:02.095 --> 06:24:05.906
previous one was unwilling to do. Green
light for war financing, accelerated

06:24:05.960 --> 06:24:10.301
expansion, they loosened the child protection
law, abolished the protected pricing

06:24:10.361 --> 06:24:14.546
of fuels, and also started to
narrow the family support system.

06:24:14.588 --> 06:24:18.768
This only proves one thing: that all
this harassment was only about having a

06:24:18.814 --> 06:24:21.829
government that would finally nod
along. Well, now there is one.

06:24:21.886 --> 06:24:26.915
All we ask now is that you kindly throw
your hypocritical rule-of-law reports into

06:24:26.991 --> 06:24:28.191
the bin. Thank you.

06:24:28.672 --> 06:24:30.592
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Tinkinen.

06:24:38.512 --> 06:24:43.853
Mr President. Welcome to the Union of
Soviet Socialist Republics of Europe.

06:24:43.916 --> 06:24:46.765
Here, a new migration
management model is now in use.

06:24:46.813 --> 06:24:51.891
We are talking about burden-sharing. Mr
President, even if you keep your own borders

06:24:51.942 --> 06:24:54.858
closed, you are in practice
left with two options:

06:24:54.935 --> 06:25:00.829
either you take on your share of the
burden of the overflowing migration belt at

06:25:00.886 --> 06:25:04.531
Europe's borders, or you end
up digging your own grave.

06:25:04.603 --> 06:25:08.970
So either you take in migrants or you pay
the receiving country 20 000 euros per

06:25:09.028 --> 06:25:14.179
migrant. Now, several Mediterranean countries
have been designated by the European

06:25:14.230 --> 06:25:19.164
Commission as countries under migration
pressure, and then the duty of solidarity is

06:25:19.211 --> 06:25:24.799
triggered for other countries, meaning
the doors or purse strings are opened.

06:25:24.861 --> 06:25:28.804
This is a problem that European
migration policy does not address;

06:25:28.860 --> 06:25:31.630
instead, it is being
shifted around Europe.

06:25:31.686 --> 06:25:34.493
Could this House finally
tackle the root cause:

06:25:34.559 --> 06:25:39.530
close the external borders and send those
residing in the EU illegally packing?

06:25:39.589 --> 06:25:40.789
Thank you.

06:25:42.232 --> 06:25:44.638
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Oliveira.

06:25:44.652 --> 06:25:45.852
Please.

06:25:49.012 --> 06:25:52.585
Thank you, Mr President.
Commissioner, thank you very much.

06:25:52.650 --> 06:25:57.735
Send the European Commission the message
that it is necessary to stop the closure of

06:25:57.795 --> 06:26:00.863
the Eco factory in Santa
Maria da Feira, Portugal.

06:26:00.931 --> 06:26:06.016
It is necessary to defend the jobs of the
632 workers who are at risk of being laid

06:26:06.104 --> 06:26:10.453
off, and it is necessary to
defend industrial production.

06:26:10.503 --> 06:26:15.137
The Danish multinational Eco, in the
footwear sector, has been established in

06:26:15.216 --> 06:26:18.829
Portugal for 40 years and has now announced,
after several collective redundancies

06:26:18.873 --> 06:26:23.067
over time, its intention to close the
factory in Portugal as part of a broader

06:26:23.143 --> 06:26:28.192
restructuring process involving thousands
of redundancies in various countries and

06:26:28.283 --> 06:26:31.867
the relocation of all production
to the Asian continent.

06:26:31.955 --> 06:26:39.482
If this situation is confirmed, 632 Portuguese
workers and their families will, from

06:26:39.538 --> 06:26:44.854
one day to the next, be left without job
prospects and plunged into uncertainty and

06:26:44.913 --> 06:26:50.509
instability. We need to put an end to the
policy that allows multinationals to set

06:26:50.577 --> 06:26:54.468
up shop, benefit from public support and
European funds, and then pull up stakes

06:26:54.515 --> 06:26:58.148
when they decide they no longer
have the profits they wanted.

06:26:58.213 --> 06:27:01.672
This policy serves neither industrial
production nor workers' rights.

06:27:03.712 --> 06:27:06.592
Thank you, Honourable Member. Please,
Honourable Member López-Aguilar.

06:27:09.472 --> 06:27:14.080
Thank you, Mr President. Commissioner
McGrath, the Canary Island of El Hierro is

06:27:14.129 --> 06:27:19.241
experiencing a sudden surge in the Atlantic
migration route to the European Union,

06:27:19.302 --> 06:27:25.190
which is the deadliest. And that is why
the European solidarity coordinator,

06:27:25.243 --> 06:27:29.949
envisaged in the Migration and Asylum Pact,
has declared, in light of El Hierro and

06:27:30.001 --> 06:27:34.322
what happened in Ceuta, Spain, under
migratory pressure, the need for mandatory

06:27:34.384 --> 06:27:38.875
solidarity envisaged in the pact for the
redistribution of people rescued at sea.

06:27:38.926 --> 06:27:42.527
That is why it is all the more regrettable
when we ask the European Union for

06:27:42.569 --> 06:27:46.379
solidarity and it is being denied by the
autonomous communities, the Spanish regions

06:27:46.436 --> 06:27:50.548
governed by the Partido Popular. As if
they were trying to make iron a permanent

06:27:50.626 --> 06:27:56.035
temporary focal point for foreigners. Without
any solidarity from the rest of Spain,

06:27:56.085 --> 06:27:58.524
it is difficult to ask for
it from the European Union.

06:27:58.594 --> 06:28:01.587
And yet, it is envisaged by the
Pact on Migration and Asylum.

06:28:01.623 --> 06:28:06.138
Therefore, it must be remembered that
solidarity is an essential component and

06:28:06.203 --> 06:28:10.301
requires assistance through financial
contributions or redistributions to uphold the

06:28:10.336 --> 06:28:12.537
fundamental rights of people
who have been rescued at sea.

06:28:12.586 --> 06:28:16.248
And there is no more insufferable hypocrisy
than lamenting the loss of lives at sea

06:28:16.285 --> 06:28:19.792
while at the same time rejecting those
who survive, having been rescued at sea.

06:28:19.972 --> 06:28:20.332
Thank you.

06:28:20.332 --> 06:28:21.922
And solidarity is being
denied in its redistribution.

06:28:21.952 --> 06:28:22.612
Thank you, Mr President.

06:28:22.612 --> 06:28:25.742
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Sánchez.

06:28:25.763 --> 06:28:26.963
Please.

06:28:28.192 --> 06:28:31.076
The concerns of the French people about the
cost of living and the state of our high

06:28:31.114 --> 06:28:33.867
schools are legitimate and
call for concrete responses.

06:28:33.898 --> 06:28:36.533
But let us nevertheless recall that the
French people voted for those who mistreat

06:28:36.569 --> 06:28:40.270
them, for those who do not solve their
problems and who drive up the cost of living.

06:28:40.320 --> 06:28:43.569
For example, the maintenance of high schools
falls under the responsibility of the

06:28:43.610 --> 06:28:46.882
regions, as in Occitania, where the left
has been in charge for decades and whose

06:28:46.923 --> 06:28:50.343
elected representatives are now marching
shamefacedly in the processions.

06:28:50.378 --> 06:28:53.680
Like in my own city of Nîmes, where
they are accountable for this record.

06:28:53.722 --> 06:28:57.610
While the only way to change this is
through voting, for the past few weeks the

06:28:57.668 --> 06:29:00.788
communist sect has been showing
its true face in France.

06:29:00.841 --> 06:29:04.968
Political exploitation, constant
chaos-mongering, total irresponsibility, talking

06:29:05.017 --> 06:29:08.713
about legitimate violence when the
facts are serious and inexcusable.

06:29:08.753 --> 06:29:13.037
Thousands of shops vandalised, over a
billion euros in damage, a town hall set on

06:29:13.075 --> 06:29:16.378
fire. And nearly 1,000 police officers
injured under the complacent gaze of the far

06:29:16.423 --> 06:29:19.725
left, the laughter of the anti-fascists
and the government’s impotence.

06:29:19.757 --> 06:29:22.605
At the same time, they are systematically
attacking anyone who does not think like

06:29:22.636 --> 06:29:25.520
them. As soon as you are no longer to the
right of their guru, you are a fascist.

06:29:25.570 --> 06:29:29.560
They deny people the right to speak out,
even want to shut down media outlets—the

06:29:29.609 --> 06:29:32.818
inquisition has begun. This is what France
would be like if they were in charge:

06:29:32.873 --> 06:29:36.549
sectarianism, hatred, pettiness,
vulgarity, ugliness, witch hunts, violence.

06:29:36.580 --> 06:29:38.272
The silent majority does not
want this new inquisition.

06:29:38.452 --> 06:29:38.992
Thank you, Honourable Member.

06:29:38.992 --> 06:29:40.552
Let us all say it together
before it is too late.

06:29:41.092 --> 06:29:43.072
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Timgren.

06:29:43.552 --> 06:29:47.512
I ask.

06:29:47.632 --> 06:29:55.430
Thank you. So here we are again. COP31.
New promises, but honestly, have these

06:29:55.499 --> 06:29:59.199
meetings actually led to
any emissions reductions?

06:29:59.283 --> 06:30:05.589
No. At the same time, Europe is under
pressure from high energy prices and

06:30:05.661 --> 06:30:09.853
overregulation. This means that jobs are
moving abroad, but it also means that

06:30:09.917 --> 06:30:14.565
emissions are shifting – to
countries such as China, for example.

06:30:14.663 --> 06:30:20.135
And speaking of China, China is still
classified as a developing country.

06:30:20.207 --> 06:30:25.053
This means that it does not have
the same obligations at all.

06:30:25.179 --> 06:30:31.446
Like Europe. And at the same time, the
so-called rich countries are supposed to

06:30:31.587 --> 06:30:40.514
finance, together, 300 billion
dollars a year in climate financing.

06:30:40.622 --> 06:30:47.002
Yet another huge meeting, thousands of
participants, and billion-dollar pledges.

06:30:47.067 --> 06:30:51.966
Is this really the best solution? No,
we need more affordable energy, we need

06:30:52.040 --> 06:30:57.255
nuclear power so that we can genuinely
reduce emissions, but also safeguard our

06:30:57.319 --> 06:30:58.912
competitiveness. Thank you.

06:30:59.872 --> 06:31:02.637
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Mularczyk.

06:31:02.652 --> 06:31:03.852
Please.

06:31:08.392 --> 06:31:13.402
Ladies and Gentlemen, in the face of the
tragic attack in Kraków, in which six

06:31:13.473 --> 06:31:18.688
people died and 15 were injured, here in
the European Parliament I would like to

06:31:18.764 --> 06:31:23.800
thank two heroes: Polish police
officers Jakub Kulik and Artur Morański.

06:31:23.869 --> 06:31:28.332
It was their courage and dedication that
saved many innocent lives in Kraków.

06:31:28.387 --> 06:31:31.861
But Ladies and Gentlemen, equally
important are also the words and the

06:31:31.919 --> 06:31:36.432
responsibility for those words. Many of
you, colleagues, men and women from across

06:31:36.470 --> 06:31:39.787
Europe, heard in global media that the
attacker was a far-right extremist.

06:31:39.849 --> 06:31:42.757
Today, we must state clearly:
that was disinformation.

06:31:42.807 --> 06:31:48.278
And its source was the Polish government
minister Marcin Kierwiński, who linked the

06:31:48.354 --> 06:31:53.930
perpetrator to the right without any
evidence, and his words immediately spread

06:31:53.989 --> 06:31:58.057
around the world. Meanwhile, the perpetrator’s
social media profiles indicate views

06:31:58.114 --> 06:32:02.836
closer to the left side of this Chamber.
But the disinformation-spreading minister

06:32:02.884 --> 06:32:05.423
has to this day not withdrawn
his words nor apologised.

06:32:05.469 --> 06:32:09.440
That is why I will say it plainly: we must
fight disinformation, but with doubled

06:32:09.484 --> 06:32:13.531
intensity we must fight the disinformation
produced by the irresponsible government

06:32:13.589 --> 06:32:15.472
in my country, in Poland. Thank you.

06:32:16.912 --> 06:32:20.397
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Gonçalves.

06:32:20.412 --> 06:32:21.612
Please.

06:32:24.652 --> 06:32:26.812
First of all, thank you, Madam
Chair, for your kindness.

06:32:27.892 --> 06:32:33.007
Today we turn on our mobile phone and
within a second we receive Today we turn on

06:32:33.084 --> 06:32:36.837
our phones and within a second we
receive online betting advertisements.

06:32:36.884 --> 06:32:41.288
They are on social media, through paid
content and influencers, on news websites and

06:32:41.341 --> 06:32:46.232
even when we watch a football match. They
offer easy money to create an account and

06:32:46.284 --> 06:32:49.587
place the first bet, with promises
of profits that never materialise.

06:32:49.631 --> 06:32:53.135
But we know that is not true, and we
also know that the gap between initial

06:32:53.202 --> 06:32:55.487
temptation and addiction
is not a long one.

06:32:55.529 --> 06:32:59.702
The digital world is increasingly drawing
people into betting, particularly younger

06:32:59.753 --> 06:33:04.494
people who are more exposed. And it is
only if we talk about irregular and illegal

06:33:04.550 --> 06:33:09.784
gambling in Europe, that by 2025 there
will be more than €90 billion in gross

06:33:09.837 --> 06:33:12.235
revenue. This is not
an individual failure;

06:33:12.291 --> 06:33:16.946
it is a political and regulatory failure.
It is the duty of the institutions to

06:33:16.991 --> 06:33:21.654
prevent predatory practices from reaching
our lives through online channels.

06:33:21.731 --> 06:33:26.818
As Henri Lacordère, French theologian
of the 19th century, warned in the

06:33:26.867 --> 06:33:30.457
relationship between the weak and the
strong, the elite must free and its absence

06:33:30.498 --> 06:33:32.392
oppresses. Let online
gambling regulation come.

06:33:32.752 --> 06:33:34.672
Thank you, Honourable Member.
Please, Honourable Member Tereš.

06:33:39.172 --> 06:33:43.402
Thank you, esteemed Commissioner for
the Danube Delta, a UNESCO World Natural

06:33:43.460 --> 06:33:47.752
Heritage Site. It is not just about
spectacular landscapes, biodiversity and

06:33:47.817 --> 06:33:51.979
tourism, but also about people. These people
are facing risks posed by drones, which

06:33:52.035 --> 06:33:56.465
has reduced tourism and, implicitly, an
important source of income for the local

06:33:56.581 --> 06:34:00.230
economy. Many communities are isolated,
infrastructure is poor, and access to

06:34:00.275 --> 06:34:03.400
medical services, education and
economic opportunities is limited.

06:34:03.516 --> 06:34:07.648
The local economy in the Danube Delta is
in decline, fishermen are losing their

06:34:07.698 --> 06:34:11.893
sources of income, young people are
leaving, and communities are depopulating.

06:34:11.938 --> 06:34:16.044
The EU is increasingly discussing
environmental restrictions and bans without any

06:34:16.091 --> 06:34:19.371
real analysis of the impact of
these decisions on the people.

06:34:19.413 --> 06:34:23.012
Protecting the Danube Delta must not
mean condemning those who live there to

06:34:23.064 --> 06:34:27.071
poverty. We need a balance between nature
conservation and economic development

06:34:27.127 --> 06:34:30.867
through investments in infrastructure,
fishing, tourism and jobs.

06:34:30.933 --> 06:34:35.475
The Danube Delta can only be saved
if the people of the Delta are lost.

06:34:35.545 --> 06:34:39.476
I therefore call on the European Union
to support the Danube Delta concretely

06:34:39.530 --> 06:34:43.890
through dedicated funding, investments in
infrastructure and safety, and economic

06:34:43.953 --> 06:34:49.114
development. Nature cannot be saved by
abandoning the communities of the Danube

06:34:49.178 --> 06:34:52.464
Delta who have lived there and
protected this heritage for generations.

06:34:52.502 --> 06:34:53.702
Thank you.

06:34:54.112 --> 06:34:57.582
Thank you, Honourable Member. We have
concluded the one-minute speeches.

06:34:57.640 --> 06:35:02.348
The next sitting will be held tomorrow,
Thursday 12 November 2026, at 09:00.

06:35:02.413 --> 06:35:07.803
The agenda has been published and is available
on the European Parliament’s website.

06:35:07.868 --> 06:35:09.472
The sitting is adjourned.
