1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:03,000
Brussels Live
Transcribed and translated by AI

2
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:00,000
Ladies and gentlemen, I will continue.

3
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:00,000
Whenever it’s too late,
it ends up in the till.

4
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:00,000
Yes, yes, of course.

5
00:07:10,061 --> 00:07:13,923
So good afternoon, everyone. We will start
today's meeting with the adoption of the

6
00:07:13,961 --> 00:07:17,734
agenda. If there is no
objection, the agenda is adopted.

7
00:07:17,801 --> 00:07:23,392
Interpretation will be
available today in 12 languages.

8
00:07:23,501 --> 00:07:29,139
Now we will move to the adoption of the
minutes of the meeting of the 10th and 28th

9
00:07:29,266 --> 00:07:38,564
September 2026. If there is no objection,
the minutes of the meeting are adopted.

10
00:07:38,681 --> 00:07:44,674
Now, report on ongoing inter-institutional
negotiation and the single currency

11
00:07:44,746 --> 00:07:52,342
package. It was the fixed trilogue.
This. Covered the regulation on the

12
00:07:52,393 --> 00:07:57,048
establishment of digital euro, the provision
of digital euro services by payment

13
00:07:57,113 --> 00:08:02,364
services provider, incorporated in member
states whose currency is not the euro.

14
00:08:02,441 --> 00:08:05,926
And the legal tender of
Euro Banklands and coins.

15
00:08:06,041 --> 00:08:11,144
This trilogue was held on
November the 5th in the council.

16
00:08:11,261 --> 00:08:17,016
The negotiation continued on different
political points, as a result of the

17
00:08:17,104 --> 00:08:23,992
exchanges some topics were delegated to
the technical level, limited items of the

18
00:08:24,055 --> 00:08:28,762
legal tender of cash regulation, and
the relevant provision regarding the

19
00:08:28,811 --> 00:08:33,981
distribution of digital euro, whereas
others were not conclusive or not discussed

20
00:08:34,066 --> 00:08:39,374
due to time constraints. The technical
help of the Commission was requested to

21
00:08:39,433 --> 00:08:45,314
further advance on the negotiation,
especially on designated PSPs and sanctions.

22
00:08:45,401 --> 00:08:55,486
The next trilogue is scheduled for another
November 18 in the European Parliament.

23
00:08:55,661 --> 00:09:01,280
And this is a perfect transition because
I would like to welcome to the Economic

24
00:09:01,338 --> 00:09:06,817
Committee Mr. Piero Cipollane, member of
the Executive Board of the ECB, who will

25
00:09:06,906 --> 00:09:12,551
update us on the latest
developments on digital euro.

26
00:09:12,641 --> 00:09:19,123
The ECB continues working on its pilot
project on visage to kick off in the second

27
00:09:19,181 --> 00:09:26,945
half of 2027. And involving the industry
to be ready for a potential first insurance

28
00:09:27,041 --> 00:09:33,191
of the digital euro in 2029. The ECB
launched a series of calls for expression of

29
00:09:33,256 --> 00:09:36,150
interest to the industry for this purpose.

30
00:09:36,221 --> 00:09:40,949
Regarding the legislation process, the
inter-institutional negotiation with the

31
00:09:41,015 --> 00:09:44,349
Council continues as
you know. And today, Mr.

32
00:09:44,441 --> 00:09:48,101
Cipollane will update us on
the ECB's continued work on the

33
00:09:48,401 --> 00:09:53,427
digital euro project, notably the pilot
project building on the exchange we had with

34
00:09:53,493 --> 00:09:59,546
him in this committee in June.
So I will give the floor to Mr.

35
00:09:59,621 --> 00:10:05,229
Cipollane for five minutes or a little bit
more if it is needed, and then there will

36
00:10:05,284 --> 00:10:08,800
be a Q&A session with the member
of the Economic Committee.

37
00:10:08,861 --> 00:10:10,241
Again, welcome, Piero.

38
00:10:12,221 --> 00:10:20,541
Dear Chair, dear Honorable Members of the
Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee,

39
00:10:20,617 --> 00:10:26,014
it is a pleasure to be back here for the
first time since the Parliament adopted its

40
00:10:26,092 --> 00:10:33,590
position on the single currency package,
and I am very much welcome the broad

41
00:10:33,683 --> 00:10:39,454
support it received in the
plenary session of July 9.

42
00:10:39,701 --> 00:10:44,886
This gives a strong democratic
backing to the digital euro.

43
00:10:44,981 --> 00:10:51,761
Let me also thank you for the considerable
work and constructive dialogue that have

44
00:10:51,851 --> 00:10:59,547
made this progress possible. A swift
conclusion of the ongoing trilogue negotiation

45
00:10:59,621 --> 00:11:05,566
would pave the way for the adoption of the
single currency package by the end of the

46
00:11:05,651 --> 00:11:11,732
year, as foreseen in the One
Europe One Market roadmap.

47
00:11:11,861 --> 00:11:19,137
This gives us the legal certainty needed
to complete our preparation for the digital

48
00:11:19,237 --> 00:11:25,151
euro. It would also give certainty to the
market regarding the planned date for a

49
00:11:25,226 --> 00:11:32,870
possible first issuance, which can be
set only after the regulation is adopted.

50
00:11:32,981 --> 00:11:37,803
A delay in the adoption could instead
postpone the introduction of the digital euro

51
00:11:37,898 --> 00:11:43,846
further entrench Europe's dependence on
foreign providers and make it more difficult

52
00:11:43,901 --> 00:11:47,570
for European companies
to innovate and compete.

53
00:11:47,681 --> 00:11:53,323
Europe's achievements in payment innovation
go beyond progress on the digital euro,

54
00:11:53,404 --> 00:11:58,601
in September we launched Pontes, which
connects market distributed ledger

55
00:11:58,661 --> 00:12:04,039
technologies platform with the
euro system target services.

56
00:12:04,121 --> 00:12:11,240
The launch was widely welcomed by market,
with 18 market participants and DLT

57
00:12:11,321 --> 00:12:17,535
operators onboarded on day one, and
many other preparing to join soon.

58
00:12:17,681 --> 00:12:22,654
Pontes makes the settlement of tokenized
transactions in central bank money an

59
00:12:22,741 --> 00:12:28,607
operational reality and is a major milestone
in the development of digital European

60
00:12:28,687 --> 00:12:37,529
capital markets. On November 2, it settled
the issuance of the ESM-first digital

61
00:12:37,613 --> 00:12:44,850
native benchmark bond for 1 billion,
facilitating the shift in European tokenized

62
00:12:44,921 --> 00:12:50,748
finance from experimentation to adoption.
While I am happy to answer any question on

63
00:12:50,812 --> 00:12:57,625
Pontes, I would like to focus my remarks
today on the digital euro and cash.

64
00:12:57,821 --> 00:13:01,661
We are moving ahead with preparation
for the digital euro pilot.

65
00:13:02,381 --> 00:13:08,253
It will test the digital euro's technical
functionalities, operational processes,

66
00:13:08,336 --> 00:13:14,630
and user experience using a beta
version without legal tender status.

67
00:13:14,741 --> 00:13:21,390
Starting in the second half of 2027, the
pilot will involve the euro system staff,

68
00:13:21,483 --> 00:13:28,185
participating payment service providers,
and selected merchants offering everyday

69
00:13:28,260 --> 00:13:36,893
services, for example in canteen at ACB
and participating national central banks.

70
00:13:37,061 --> 00:13:42,241
We have seen strong market
interest in the pilot and in July.

71
00:13:42,401 --> 00:13:52,066
We announced the 36 PSP selected to join
the pilot from more than 50 applicants.

72
00:13:52,181 --> 00:13:58,529
They include banks of and non-banks providers,
and covers a broad range of business

73
00:13:58,598 --> 00:14:05,738
model, size, and geographical location.
We are working closely with participating

74
00:14:05,848 --> 00:14:11,528
PSPs to hear their views and
benefit from their experience.

75
00:14:11,621 --> 00:14:17,837
In September, we opened an additional call
for online and mobile merchants to join

76
00:14:17,921 --> 00:14:25,181
the pilot to test remote payments. The
final selection of merchants will be

77
00:14:25,267 --> 00:14:31,184
announced early next year. This collaboration
with the market player is essential.

78
00:14:31,241 --> 00:14:37,181
The digital euro must work on a technical
level, but also in everyday life for

79
00:14:37,253 --> 00:14:43,211
consumer merchants and PSPs. Looking further
ahead, we are planning for the digital

80
00:14:43,293 --> 00:14:50,701
euro rollout. On our side, we plan to ensure
that all relevant use cases for digital

81
00:14:50,768 --> 00:14:56,247
euro are made technically
available from first issuance.

82
00:14:56,381 --> 00:15:03,089
At the same time, feedback from market
participants showed that a gradual rollout

83
00:15:03,161 --> 00:15:10,953
would support a smooth and successful first
issuance by giving them sufficient time

84
00:15:11,101 --> 00:15:17,786
to adopt. We are glad that the college's
letter intends to provide legal certainty

85
00:15:17,861 --> 00:15:24,305
on the feasibility of such
a phase rollout in shops.

86
00:15:24,461 --> 00:15:29,344
In preparation for first issuance, we are
also working closely with the market on

87
00:15:29,401 --> 00:15:34,367
the digital euro innovation platform.
In September, we launched a new call for

88
00:15:34,421 --> 00:15:40,957
expression of interest inviting private
companies and organizations to explore how

89
00:15:41,034 --> 00:15:45,473
the digital euro can
foster market innovation.

90
00:15:45,581 --> 00:15:50,936
The next wave of activities includes
testing conditional payments and exploring

91
00:15:51,011 --> 00:15:52,211
application of

92
00:15:52,721 --> 00:15:58,891
artificial intelligence in payments
will run from January to June 2027.

93
00:15:59,201 --> 00:16:05,786
Innovation also extends to banknotes. In
July, we invited Europeans to share their

94
00:16:05,884 --> 00:16:14,559
views on 10 shortlisted design proposals
for the new euro banknotes, based on themes

95
00:16:14,681 --> 00:16:21,096
European culture and river and birds.
The surveys received almost 10 million

96
00:16:21,191 --> 00:16:27,581
responses. With the high participation
across all euro area countries, and age

97
00:16:27,681 --> 00:16:34,513
groups, this demonstrates how deeply
Europeans care about their money.

98
00:16:34,661 --> 00:16:40,037
The survey results will inform the ECB
governing council decision on the final

99
00:16:40,145 --> 00:16:45,401
design concept, expected
around the end of this year.

100
00:16:45,581 --> 00:16:50,641
At that point, we will
publish the survey result.

101
00:16:50,801 --> 00:16:55,297
First, the nomination of the new banknotes
series are expected to enter into

102
00:16:55,361 --> 00:17:04,510
circulation in the early 2030. But cash
must also remain widely available at an

103
00:17:04,601 --> 00:17:11,287
accepted in practice. We therefore support
strong legislative provision on mandatory

104
00:17:11,381 --> 00:17:17,429
cash acceptance, access to
cash across euro area and.

105
00:17:17,561 --> 00:17:22,206
Resilience of cash
infrastructure. Let me conclude.

106
00:17:22,361 --> 00:17:28,257
In today's uncertain geopolitical environment,
timely progress on the digital euro

107
00:17:28,309 --> 00:17:31,952
is essential to strengthen
Europe's autonomy in payments.

108
00:17:32,021 --> 00:17:36,631
We are doing our part by progressing
with the technical preparation, but the

109
00:17:36,689 --> 00:17:42,930
adoption of the legal framework is necessary
to finalize the digital euro design and

110
00:17:43,061 --> 00:17:47,124
rulebook, and ultimately
to issue the digital euro.

111
00:17:47,201 --> 00:17:53,959
In two months' time, we will mark the 25th
anniversary of Eurobanknotes and Coins

112
00:17:54,041 --> 00:18:01,393
entering circulation. While cash is still
widely used in shops, digital payments are

113
00:18:01,504 --> 00:18:07,977
growing. I therefore hope that by then
we will have a strong legal framework in

114
00:18:08,068 --> 00:18:15,541
place one that both safeguards the acceptance
of cash and gives European a digital

115
00:18:15,619 --> 00:18:19,241
form of cash along it. Thank you, Chair.

116
00:18:20,021 --> 00:18:20,801
Thank you.

117
00:18:20,801 --> 00:18:21,941
Thank you so much.

118
00:18:21,941 --> 00:18:26,553
Slovenian for the question, three minutes
for the answer, and I'll start with the

119
00:18:26,616 --> 00:18:27,816
EPP and Mr Avtjas.

120
00:18:29,621 --> 00:18:33,641
Thank you. Dear colleagues,
I will speak in Greek.

121
00:18:37,721 --> 00:18:43,871
because you are very experienced, I want
four quick answers so that the European

122
00:18:43,942 --> 00:18:47,878
citizen can be informed. First,
how will you block tax evasion?

123
00:18:47,942 --> 00:18:52,294
Through the digital euro. Secondly, how
much will merchants' fees be reduced?

124
00:18:52,413 --> 00:18:56,285
Thirdly, what will the
withdrawal limit be?

125
00:18:56,343 --> 00:19:02,127
And fourthly, what will the process be for
transferring cash into the digital euro?

126
00:19:02,223 --> 00:19:06,910
Four crucial questions for citizens.
If the euro does not reach the ordinary

127
00:19:06,964 --> 00:19:08,681
citizen, then we are in trouble.

128
00:19:24,341 --> 00:19:32,100
So I'm not completely sure I understood
completely the question, but let me try to

129
00:19:32,201 --> 00:19:39,534
answer. So on tax evasion, we are not
a fiscal authority, as you imagine.

130
00:19:39,581 --> 00:19:45,487
What we are doing here is
providing a means of payments for.

131
00:19:45,641 --> 00:19:54,772
People. So I'm. I have hard time to
relate this question to tax evasion.

132
00:19:54,941 --> 00:20:04,236
On the cost of the. If I understand exactly,
you are asking what is the impact on

133
00:20:04,304 --> 00:20:10,373
the merchants for the digital euro.
Now, this is the compensation.

134
00:20:10,421 --> 00:20:14,634
This is the compensation model.
This is in your own hands.

135
00:20:14,741 --> 00:20:19,121
I understand that this point in time
there are two proposals that could be

136
00:20:19,181 --> 00:20:28,029
complemented each other. One proposal is
to set a cap at the European level which is

137
00:20:28,153 --> 00:20:34,481
sort of average of what people pay now.
Which means that this is going to favor

138
00:20:34,541 --> 00:20:39,915
especially small merchants which are
the ones that now pay the highest price.

139
00:20:40,061 --> 00:20:44,905
And this is one proposal. Alongside with
this proposal, there is also this proposal

140
00:20:44,973 --> 00:20:51,199
of the no worth of solution which means
that even for those below that already pay

141
00:20:51,332 --> 00:20:57,295
below the cap, there will be a provision
to make sure that their price will not

142
00:20:57,364 --> 00:21:02,733
increase. Now, how this is going to be
implemented technically is not clear, but

143
00:21:02,801 --> 00:21:08,789
this is not for us to decide.
This has been discussed by the.

144
00:21:08,921 --> 00:21:15,764
Colleges later. As we said always say,
we stand ready to provide technical

145
00:21:15,871 --> 00:21:21,453
assistance if it's needed,
whenever it's needed.

146
00:21:21,581 --> 00:21:28,645
So that's the situation. What we can say
for sure that given the current proposal we

147
00:21:28,721 --> 00:21:36,756
expect that the. Especially
the small merchant will.

148
00:21:36,881 --> 00:21:44,030
Pay less. But this paying less is not paid
by other people except that because what

149
00:21:44,102 --> 00:21:50,845
we are trying what we do with the system
through the digital euro we will not charge

150
00:21:50,981 --> 00:21:57,986
scheme fees which is a. Important
cost component of the actual scheme.

151
00:21:58,061 --> 00:22:03,408
By removing the scheme fees, this saving
could be distributed along the supply

152
00:22:03,474 --> 00:22:09,976
chain. So merchant could benefit but
also banks and PSP can benefit from that.

153
00:22:10,061 --> 00:22:14,441
So I'm sorry I lost your
last question. I don't know.

154
00:22:14,741 --> 00:22:16,001
It was 14 minutes, I see.

155
00:22:16,301 --> 00:22:17,201
Oh, on the old.

156
00:22:17,201 --> 00:22:18,521
I think it was 14 minutes, yeah.

157
00:22:22,121 --> 00:22:25,241
Withdrawal limits? To stop
money from leaving the banks.

158
00:22:25,721 --> 00:22:29,321
And thirdly, the process of transferring
liquid assets into digital form.

159
00:22:29,861 --> 00:22:33,817
If someone has €30,000 in the bank, how
much will they transfer to the digital

160
00:22:33,865 --> 00:22:35,065
wallet? What will that limit be?

161
00:22:35,561 --> 00:22:39,940
Bankers are afraid there will be a large
outflow of capital into the digital euro.

162
00:22:40,016 --> 00:22:44,078
How will this be prevented? But first,
on tax evasion, you have disappointed me.

163
00:22:44,127 --> 00:22:49,752
Just so you know. On the first issue
of tax evasion, you left us hanging.

164
00:22:49,814 --> 00:22:52,841
And I am very sorry about
that. You must take action.

165
00:23:02,741 --> 00:23:06,377
Let me go back to this issue.
Now I understood better.

166
00:23:06,461 --> 00:23:11,838
I don't understand why you think that
digital euro will increase the tax evasion.

167
00:23:11,921 --> 00:23:21,070
I don't see this. This will be a transaction
that will be— Will go essentially

168
00:23:21,223 --> 00:23:27,678
through. Through the current system. So
I don't see how this is going to increase

169
00:23:27,743 --> 00:23:37,529
the tax evasion. There could be a case
in which for the peer-to-peer but this is

170
00:23:37,613 --> 00:23:41,816
going to have a— I hope. I imagine
that there will be a cap on the single

171
00:23:41,861 --> 00:23:49,106
transaction for the offline solution. And
this is in any case at the merchant level

172
00:23:49,171 --> 00:23:51,944
this should be registered
in the cash register.

173
00:23:52,001 --> 00:23:57,501
So I don't really see how this
is going to increase tax evasion.

174
00:23:57,581 --> 00:24:03,046
I really don't see. Actually there is—
We have been accused by that we are doing

175
00:24:03,117 --> 00:24:09,872
this to remove to, you
know, to. Avoid tax evasion.

176
00:24:09,941 --> 00:24:16,226
So I don't see this. On the holding
limits, you know the process, right?

177
00:24:16,361 --> 00:24:22,722
There will be a proposal by the ECB if the
current legislation is approved because

178
00:24:22,770 --> 00:24:30,118
I'm still pending this. If the current
legislation is approved the ECB will make a

179
00:24:30,375 --> 00:24:37,166
proposal in agreement. Or in
consultation with the Commission.

180
00:24:37,241 --> 00:24:45,050
This will go to the Council and the Council
can approve or not this— This amount.

181
00:24:45,101 --> 00:24:53,447
This is the cap. The maximum amount.
Within this cap the ECB is free to set the

182
00:24:53,561 --> 00:24:58,611
holding limits. Depending
on how much. Now,.

183
00:24:59,081 --> 00:25:04,835
And this is for the holdings. But
there is no limits for the transaction.

184
00:25:04,901 --> 00:25:08,395
So you can spend as much money as
you want through the digital euro.

185
00:25:08,441 --> 00:25:13,581
There is no— At least in the current
legislation proposal there is no limit to the

186
00:25:13,639 --> 00:25:17,190
amount of that you can spend
through the digital euro.

187
00:25:17,261 --> 00:25:23,304
The cap is referred to the amount
that you can hold on your wallet.

188
00:25:23,381 --> 00:25:31,773
Now, whether people will transfer this—
Whether people will transfer their deposit

189
00:25:31,888 --> 00:25:39,101
from the bank account into the digital
euro we provide to this committee one year

190
00:25:39,206 --> 00:25:44,819
ago a detailed study that shows
that this is not a real concern.

191
00:25:44,921 --> 00:25:52,466
You may remember that we provide you guys
a study in which we simulated the impact

192
00:25:52,561 --> 00:25:58,361
on the banking sector of possible holding
limits starting from 500 euros up to

193
00:25:58,841 --> 00:26:07,678
3,000 with under two possible scenarios.
One scenario is business as usual and one

194
00:26:07,748 --> 00:26:14,960
scenario is, you know, a case of critical
crisis so that all people would use the—

195
00:26:15,041 --> 00:26:18,813
To move as much money they
could into the digital euro.

196
00:26:18,881 --> 00:26:25,932
So even in this extreme scenario the
simulation that is available we made available

197
00:26:25,983 --> 00:26:32,175
to this committee show that there will be
no impact on the financial stability only

198
00:26:32,364 --> 00:26:41,499
13 banks would hit the liquidity cover
ratio which is the liquidity requirements by

199
00:26:41,591 --> 00:26:50,450
the regulators. And the amount of assets
managed by these 13 banks is like zero.

200
00:26:50,681 --> 00:26:53,670
Three percent of the total
asset of the euro area.

201
00:26:53,741 --> 00:26:58,981
And we are talking about
this extreme case scenario.

202
00:26:59,081 --> 00:27:07,013
So I don't— I mean I can just reiterate
what we showed in the study that we don't

203
00:27:07,097 --> 00:27:09,761
see any concern on the
financial stability.

204
00:27:11,921 --> 00:27:15,401
Thank you. Now I give the floor
to the SND to Nikos Papamareou.

205
00:27:16,361 --> 00:27:22,788
Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Mr.
Cipollane, again for being here.

206
00:27:22,901 --> 00:27:28,391
So there has been a difficult process and
I want to just emphasize one element of

207
00:27:28,466 --> 00:27:32,830
that difficulty. The debate has too often
been shaped by the established commercial

208
00:27:32,872 --> 00:27:36,037
instruments of the large banks
and the larger member states.

209
00:27:36,101 --> 00:27:39,775
They hold the largest stakes in their
domestic card schemes and they naturally want

210
00:27:39,824 --> 00:27:44,629
to protect them. The voice has been loud.
The voice of merchants and citizens has

211
00:27:44,681 --> 00:27:49,666
not, at least of all in small countries.
In Greece we have the IRIS which is instant

212
00:27:49,712 --> 00:27:53,713
payment system and people are happy with
that but we have no domestic card scheme

213
00:27:53,769 --> 00:27:57,540
and that includes many other countries.
Neither do most euro area countries.

214
00:27:57,581 --> 00:28:00,222
We have for card payments
Visa or MasterCard.

215
00:28:00,281 --> 00:28:03,419
So the digital euro for us
is not just a nice addition.

216
00:28:03,521 --> 00:28:07,164
It is the first European payment that
our citizens and merchants could use for

217
00:28:07,207 --> 00:28:09,944
everyday purchases and that's
what sovereignty means.

218
00:28:10,001 --> 00:28:13,778
But it will really only work
if it is a real alternative.

219
00:28:13,841 --> 00:28:18,821
If the digital euro costs the same in Athens
or Tallinn as the international schemes

220
00:28:18,881 --> 00:28:22,315
no merchant has a reason to choose it.
And the banks have no reason to offer it.

221
00:28:22,361 --> 00:28:25,677
We would have done all this work to build
an instrument that changes nothing where

222
00:28:25,726 --> 00:28:28,729
it matters most. So this is
not big versus small countries.

223
00:28:28,781 --> 00:28:33,298
It is a simple question. Isn't this
project designed to protect established

224
00:28:33,349 --> 00:28:37,665
commercial interests and to give every
euro area citizen of the European choice?

225
00:28:37,721 --> 00:28:41,136
And I would like to hear again
what you said a little bit earlier.

226
00:28:41,201 --> 00:28:46,300
So the ECB supports the idea that scheme
fees which be publicly supported must be

227
00:28:46,351 --> 00:28:50,425
factored into reducing the above average
result to a fair distribution between

228
00:28:50,474 --> 00:28:53,685
payment providers and all merchants
including small merchants.

229
00:28:53,741 --> 00:28:59,021
As opposed to only the cap. So you agree
with the average but also we have the

230
00:28:59,063 --> 00:29:01,731
scheme fee which was quite a
strong position from the SND.

231
00:29:01,781 --> 00:29:07,202
Thank you. From the very beginning—
Thank you first of all for this question.

232
00:29:07,241 --> 00:29:10,361
I mean from the very beginning
these are not been a mystery, right?

233
00:29:11,501 --> 00:29:19,729
We have been saying look we are not— The
ECB is not going to charge an important

234
00:29:19,830 --> 00:29:26,590
part of the cost which is part of the cost
that are borne by the merchant is in the

235
00:29:26,653 --> 00:29:31,575
current system is going
to remunerate the scheme.

236
00:29:31,721 --> 00:29:37,978
And this is not a marginal point. This
is not a marginal— Let me be a little bit

237
00:29:38,055 --> 00:29:46,945
more explicit on this. We are talking
in absolute of a no huge numbers.

238
00:29:47,081 --> 00:29:54,898
But when you talk about merchants that run
their business on a three, four percent

239
00:29:55,015 --> 00:30:03,143
margin if you take away from that cost only
few basis points this is a huge effect.

240
00:30:03,221 --> 00:30:08,623
So it's not— If you are a small merchant
and you live out of, you know, maybe three,

241
00:30:08,708 --> 00:30:14,391
four percent your charge your— The
margin that you have on your product.

242
00:30:14,441 --> 00:30:21,020
If you can reduce any small amount no
matter how small this is a huge improvement.

243
00:30:21,101 --> 00:30:27,200
So from the very beginning we said we remove
the cost a big component of cost which

244
00:30:27,255 --> 00:30:34,123
is the scheme fee and the process fee.
And then we— And this is our role, right?

245
00:30:34,181 --> 00:30:40,216
To design a system that provides
some saving to the system.

246
00:30:40,301 --> 00:30:47,226
Now, how this saving will be distributed
along the chain it's not for us to decide

247
00:30:47,292 --> 00:30:54,759
what we have said we have said to the
legislator please guys distribute this saving

248
00:30:54,833 --> 00:31:01,781
so that everyone has something to gain
because to construct a scheme you need

249
00:31:01,901 --> 00:31:06,135
incentive to from everyone to participate.

250
00:31:06,221 --> 00:31:15,041
So a fair distribution of this scheme of
this saving would be the ideal things to

251
00:31:15,161 --> 00:31:22,211
do. So the cap is meant to protect the
small merchant because at this point you

252
00:31:22,301 --> 00:31:26,948
impose to the merchant to accept the
digital euro it's fair that you protect them

253
00:31:27,074 --> 00:31:31,238
against some possible
increase in the price.

254
00:31:31,301 --> 00:31:36,896
So what we have been recommending is a fair
distribution of this saving so that all

255
00:31:36,980 --> 00:31:40,599
the actor involved have an
incentive to participate.

256
00:31:40,661 --> 00:31:44,199
And this has been the philosophy
from the very beginning.

257
00:31:44,261 --> 00:31:47,441
And I hope this will be reflected
in the final legislation.

258
00:31:50,261 --> 00:31:52,361
Thank you for ECR Marlena Malag.

259
00:31:54,941 --> 00:32:01,150
Thank you, Mr President. I have a
question regarding forced acceptance.

260
00:32:01,228 --> 00:32:07,844
digital euro. Does the ECB really believe
in the attractiveness of this digital euro

261
00:32:07,928 --> 00:32:13,752
product? Or rather does it not believe in
it, and sees its widespread adoption as

262
00:32:13,837 --> 00:32:17,964
hinging on compulsory
acceptance? through sellers?

263
00:32:18,033 --> 00:32:23,817
If the digital euro offered real value,
there would be no need to pressure sellers

264
00:32:23,900 --> 00:32:28,888
to accept it. This, after all,
entails additional costs for them.

265
00:32:28,962 --> 00:32:33,450
Acceptance of the digital euro
should rather be entirely voluntary.

266
00:32:33,532 --> 00:32:39,431
And how do you see this matter? Should
the single currency package impose such an

267
00:32:39,510 --> 00:32:42,761
obligation or not necessarily?
Thank you very much.

268
00:32:49,961 --> 00:32:56,376
So let me take— This is an important
question and maybe often overlooked.

269
00:32:56,441 --> 00:33:02,526
So let me give— Take a little
bit of time to explain this.

270
00:33:02,621 --> 00:33:07,304
So from the very beginning we have
been asking why are we doing this?

271
00:33:07,421 --> 00:33:14,768
We are doing this because we want to provide
something that is very much like cash.

272
00:33:14,981 --> 00:33:22,552
That can be used for those use cases
that cannot where cash cannot be used.

273
00:33:22,661 --> 00:33:25,943
We are talking about a large
part of our expenditure.

274
00:33:26,021 --> 00:33:34,909
One third of our expenditure is online.
Which means that citizen do not have the

275
00:33:35,001 --> 00:33:45,041
freedom to use their money cash
to pay for important use cases.

276
00:33:45,281 --> 00:33:50,974
Our responsibility as a central bank is
to provide means of payments to people.

277
00:33:51,161 --> 00:34:00,873
So we need to complement cash with the
solution that allows them to pay with their

278
00:34:01,061 --> 00:34:06,547
money. So the digital euro is
an online version of the cash.

279
00:34:06,641 --> 00:34:15,686
And cash we have been— You are also
discussing this— Is a legal tender.

280
00:34:15,941 --> 00:34:20,125
Legal tender. All country
have a legal tender.

281
00:34:20,201 --> 00:34:28,630
So because of the digital euro
is— A digital version of cash.

282
00:34:28,721 --> 00:34:33,115
He also has to inheritage
this legal tender status.

283
00:34:33,221 --> 00:34:36,931
But this is not— This is
not something strange.

284
00:34:37,001 --> 00:34:42,566
This is the money of the sovereign. And by
definition the money of the sovereign is

285
00:34:42,709 --> 00:34:49,841
able to free you from obligation. So
this is not a commercial— This is not a

286
00:34:49,961 --> 00:34:56,983
commercial product. This has to do with
the possibility of people to retain the

287
00:34:57,056 --> 00:35:04,950
freedom to pay with the
money of their— Sovereign.

288
00:35:05,141 --> 00:35:14,734
Now, the fact that this might imply
some small cost for merchant it may.

289
00:35:14,801 --> 00:35:24,445
Be but if we look at the reality merchants
small and large from any corner of Europe

290
00:35:24,537 --> 00:35:32,329
have been supporting this idea. Which
means that the saving that they can make by

291
00:35:32,453 --> 00:35:39,830
accepting the digital euro are far larger
than the small adoption cost that they

292
00:35:39,889 --> 00:35:48,607
will incur. I mean if the digital euro
were a drug on the profitability of small

293
00:35:48,672 --> 00:35:53,360
merchant we would have heard
them. We had exactly the opposite.

294
00:35:53,441 --> 00:35:57,841
Whenever we meet them
they say us do it quickly.

295
00:35:57,941 --> 00:36:03,866
Do it quickly. Because this is essential
for us to save money and gain transparency

296
00:36:03,941 --> 00:36:07,841
from the fees that other player
are bringing to the table.

297
00:36:09,701 --> 00:36:10,901
Thank you.

298
00:36:11,921 --> 00:36:14,081
Thank you. Ludovic Todor for renew.

299
00:36:15,521 --> 00:36:18,174
Thank you and thank you for
this interesting discussion.

300
00:36:18,221 --> 00:36:24,926
I'm not really afraid of the merchants
because they should gain from the digital

301
00:36:25,022 --> 00:36:30,774
euro. My question is about two other
things which are really important.

302
00:36:30,881 --> 00:36:36,858
One thing is public acceptance and there
you need a kind of a user experience

303
00:36:36,915 --> 00:36:44,525
comparable to other solutions. And if the
banking sector is not supporting enough

304
00:36:44,621 --> 00:36:52,282
the project then of course they can you
know make sure that the user experience with

305
00:36:52,337 --> 00:36:56,801
electronic money is a little bit different
than the user experience with digital

306
00:36:56,870 --> 00:37:02,507
euro. So can you comment on this? And the
second one is related to the debate we had

307
00:37:02,558 --> 00:37:09,790
in the European Parliament whether to
introduce the digital euro or to support

308
00:37:09,897 --> 00:37:15,446
private sector solutions. So my
question is right now how do you see it?

309
00:37:15,701 --> 00:37:22,657
Is there a chance to have a complementary
system where you have a kind of a digital

310
00:37:22,730 --> 00:37:25,366
euro backbone and private solutions on it?

311
00:37:25,421 --> 00:37:33,521
Or the banking sector will try to come out
with their own solution to this problem?

312
00:37:36,341 --> 00:37:46,327
Thank you. These are two questions but in
some sense they point to the same issue.

313
00:37:46,601 --> 00:37:55,159
Now, definitely the public acceptance
depends on the user experience.

314
00:37:55,241 --> 00:38:03,147
So we are working hard to design
user experience that is top class.

315
00:38:03,221 --> 00:38:08,835
As you can imagine we
are running Focus Group.

316
00:38:09,401 --> 00:38:15,076
But in doing so we don't
want to leave anyone out.

317
00:38:15,221 --> 00:38:18,994
We are not a commercial— We
are not a commercial product.

318
00:38:19,061 --> 00:38:26,013
So inclusiveness for us is a very, very
important— Very, very important feature.

319
00:38:26,081 --> 00:38:33,256
So we are trying to build this feature
in the rulebook so that easy access, easy

320
00:38:33,378 --> 00:38:42,041
usability— Easy to understand are— We are
trying to build in the rulebook and in

321
00:38:42,101 --> 00:38:47,615
order to give a physical representation of
that we are developing our own app which

322
00:38:47,693 --> 00:38:53,655
would embed all these feature. And
that's why we have been asking for making

323
00:38:53,767 --> 00:39:04,946
mandatory the distribution of the app.
Now, the discussion will go— I mean— So in.

324
00:39:05,081 --> 00:39:12,583
To make sure that everyone will be in.
Some sense encouraged to distribute the

325
00:39:12,684 --> 00:39:18,413
digital euro and not to
keep the project you.

326
00:39:18,521 --> 00:39:23,988
Need to work on the incentives. So we have
been working with the private sector from

327
00:39:24,050 --> 00:39:31,301
the very beginning to try to construct a
product that would be— Would encourage them

328
00:39:31,391 --> 00:39:36,407
to distribute. We have already talked
about the compensation model but there is

329
00:39:36,455 --> 00:39:45,162
something more. We said to the private
solution— The private solution reach at this

330
00:39:45,214 --> 00:39:50,237
point in time in Europe is limited. Is
limited at the national level or the use

331
00:39:50,345 --> 00:39:57,634
cases. So in order for them to provide a
full coverage throughout the euro area and

332
00:39:57,761 --> 00:40:03,974
for all use cases normally the domestic
solution coverage with the international

333
00:40:04,028 --> 00:40:09,585
card scheme. But any time that the client
uses the international card scheme they

334
00:40:09,676 --> 00:40:16,619
would lose fees and data. So if they could
coverage with the digital euro instead of

335
00:40:16,721 --> 00:40:22,988
the international card scheme this
would improve their financial result.

336
00:40:23,081 --> 00:40:31,231
And we think this is an efficient incentive
for them to not to hide too much the

337
00:40:31,308 --> 00:40:38,357
digital euro. At the same
time— At the same time the.

338
00:40:38,741 --> 00:40:44,522
Possibility to coverage with the digital
euro and the fact that the private scheme

339
00:40:44,596 --> 00:40:45,761
can reuse our

340
00:40:45,761 --> 00:40:55,610
acceptance network. Should favor their
ability to expand their reach beyond the

341
00:40:55,693 --> 00:41:01,159
current reach that they have. Let me
make an example so that everyone can

342
00:41:01,331 --> 00:41:09,972
understand. Today if a private sector
solution wants to expand in a market that is

343
00:41:10,038 --> 00:41:15,881
not covered this private solution has to
go and convince merchant by merchant to

344
00:41:15,941 --> 00:41:19,995
adopt the standard that this
private solution adopts.

345
00:41:20,081 --> 00:41:24,048
And this is very costly
and timely consuming.

346
00:41:24,161 --> 00:41:29,579
With the digital euro the acceptance network
will be already there because of what

347
00:41:29,634 --> 00:41:37,220
we were saying before
about the. Legal tender.

348
00:41:37,301 --> 00:41:43,126
So the private sector can leverage already
the acceptance network that is there

349
00:41:43,194 --> 00:41:49,481
because of the digital euro so I expect
that there will be a composition of

350
00:41:49,601 --> 00:41:56,545
solution. The digital euro could provide—
Would provide a backbone and certainly on

351
00:41:56,659 --> 00:42:03,124
which private sector can
develop new solution and.

352
00:42:03,341 --> 00:42:08,586
Provide their services. This is particularly
important though because for the time

353
00:42:08,654 --> 00:42:16,680
that we are living we know that a little
bit of resilience and redundance in the

354
00:42:16,781 --> 00:42:20,478
system is essential because
anything can happen.

355
00:42:20,561 --> 00:42:28,131
So if we have different way to allow our
people to pay regardless possible accident

356
00:42:28,241 --> 00:42:34,048
outages I think it's especially considering
the time we are living in I think that

357
00:42:34,103 --> 00:42:35,441
is a smart things to do.

358
00:42:38,981 --> 00:42:40,961
Thank you for the green Damian Bazleger.

359
00:42:42,041 --> 00:42:45,965
Yes. It's nice to see you here again.
As you know we are in the middle of the

360
00:42:46,001 --> 00:42:49,688
negotiations on the digital euro and there
are some of the negotiating team here.

361
00:42:49,781 --> 00:42:54,805
I want to ask on the sanctions. You call
the digital euro sovereign cash a couple of

362
00:42:54,875 --> 00:42:58,784
times. And I understand that we have seen
recently the European Commission underline

363
00:42:58,822 --> 00:43:04,425
that under the payments accounts directive
third country like nation sanctions that

364
00:43:04,501 --> 00:43:09,461
come here do not deprive citizens of
the right to the basic bank account.

365
00:43:09,521 --> 00:43:12,754
So this is already for
commercial bank accounts.

366
00:43:12,821 --> 00:43:17,672
But still we had heard from the ICC judges
and maybe some others that they have

367
00:43:17,719 --> 00:43:20,965
issues accepting even their
basic bank account services.

368
00:43:21,041 --> 00:43:24,701
Which they have— Which they are
entitled to under our rules.

369
00:43:24,821 --> 00:43:30,050
So if you think that the digital euro is
supposed to be sovereign cash shouldn't it

370
00:43:30,125 --> 00:43:35,229
be made extra clear that for example people
who are unbanked because of any other

371
00:43:35,298 --> 00:43:40,534
reasons that may be unfair that the digital
euro at least should be fully and in its

372
00:43:40,648 --> 00:43:43,734
audits entirety preserved.
That's the first question.

373
00:43:43,781 --> 00:43:49,296
And the second one would be shouldn't we
also use the digital euro with potentially

374
00:43:49,345 --> 00:43:53,656
a specific regime for these people which
could be triggered in multiple ways in

375
00:43:53,733 --> 00:43:58,974
order to allow institutions entities and
individuals who are affected by these

376
00:43:59,031 --> 00:44:03,779
sanctions to potentially have additional
holding higher holding limits higher

377
00:44:03,819 --> 00:44:07,511
transaction limits and so on. This is one
question and because this was easy I'll

378
00:44:07,624 --> 00:44:14,128
just give you a second one and it's
about the access to mobile devices.

379
00:44:14,201 --> 00:44:21,566
I mean in the text it says that basically
yeah mobile phone providers should make

380
00:44:21,641 --> 00:44:27,068
deals with commercial banks when it comes
to you know the digital euro apps on their

381
00:44:27,112 --> 00:44:31,098
phones and the functionality. This is not
true for those falling under the DMA where

382
00:44:31,141 --> 00:44:34,838
basically full functionality needs to
be provided but they also mobile phone

383
00:44:34,893 --> 00:44:39,188
providers or producers which do not fall
under the DMA and so I was just wondering

384
00:44:39,230 --> 00:44:41,964
do you have any views on whether this
should potentially also be free of charge

385
00:44:41,995 --> 00:44:42,941
rather than

386
00:44:42,941 --> 00:44:44,201
subject to negotiation. Thank you.

387
00:44:46,361 --> 00:44:59,050
So— I'm trying to find a simple answer
to your first very long question and

388
00:44:59,138 --> 00:45:05,362
complicated question. So let me step
back a little bit on this right.

389
00:45:05,441 --> 00:45:11,553
From the very beginning and I already said
that we designed the digital euro to be

390
00:45:11,642 --> 00:45:18,454
as inclusive as possible.
And for everyone to use.

391
00:45:18,641 --> 00:45:24,401
So in order to implement this we have built
an infrastructure that doesn't depend on

392
00:45:24,461 --> 00:45:36,148
anybody else but on us. On Europeans.
Now I think this is a sufficient base to

393
00:45:36,341 --> 00:45:42,481
provide. Some solution that can be found
possibly at the technical level to make

394
00:45:42,578 --> 00:45:49,392
sure that no one is cut out of
a basic services like payment.

395
00:45:49,541 --> 00:45:55,283
So this is my answer to your first question
and to your second question obviously

396
00:45:55,428 --> 00:46:03,298
for us having the all the providers under
the article 33 would be the best thing.

397
00:46:03,341 --> 00:46:09,086
If we can— If we can implement that in a
direct way this is a straightforward— A

398
00:46:09,144 --> 00:46:15,281
straightforward way to implement this
solution this would be the best way forward.

399
00:46:21,341 --> 00:46:24,521
Thank you. I give the floor to
Pasquale Tredico for the left.

400
00:46:25,541 --> 00:46:28,797
Thank you. Thank you to you Mr. Cipollone.

401
00:46:28,841 --> 00:46:34,324
Thank you to Damian because he just made
a question which I wanted to do but I want

402
00:46:34,376 --> 00:46:37,627
to go a little bit deeper
on this question Mr.

403
00:46:37,721 --> 00:46:42,708
Cipollone. Because actually there is an
issue which is very sensitive in Italy right

404
00:46:42,779 --> 00:46:47,970
now and apart from the perspective of getting
a solution on that through the digital

405
00:46:48,028 --> 00:46:51,575
euro I would like to have if
possible an answer from you.

406
00:46:51,641 --> 00:46:57,866
I'm referring to the sanction that
Banca Etica is receiving from US.

407
00:46:58,361 --> 00:47:07,035
Which basically does. Not allow to an
association called Autistici Immaginari to get

408
00:47:07,121 --> 00:47:13,438
their services and their money with the
condition if Banca Etica provides services

409
00:47:13,510 --> 00:47:21,546
to Autistici Immaginari that actually
130,000 client of Banca Etica would be

410
00:47:21,619 --> 00:47:30,861
basically sanctioned as well. It's an
issue which concerns as well doctors from.

411
00:47:31,061 --> 00:47:35,295
Cuba working in a region that you know
very well which is Calabria which is

412
00:47:35,343 --> 00:47:38,526
basically getting the same sanction
because actually they are working there.

413
00:47:38,561 --> 00:47:42,996
So this situation is basically
unsustainable right now.

414
00:47:43,181 --> 00:47:50,185
I wonder whether the ECB is trying to
fix or to create an umbrella for those

415
00:47:50,250 --> 00:47:57,232
institution which actually have apart
from those associations Cuban doctors or

416
00:47:57,305 --> 00:48:02,993
Autistici Immaginari they have thousand
and thousand of clients which risk as well

417
00:48:03,077 --> 00:48:11,446
their services. Being sanctioned by.
US. Sanction which are of course not

418
00:48:11,486 --> 00:48:12,686
recognized.

419
00:48:13,421 --> 00:48:25,337
Now. This is a very complicated
question for one fundamental reason.

420
00:48:25,601 --> 00:48:32,311
The source of this issue has to
do with the fact that the dollar.

421
00:48:32,381 --> 00:48:36,234
Is the dominant currency around the world.

422
00:48:36,341 --> 00:48:45,581
So banks will even if you solve the individual
problem point is that even receiving

423
00:48:45,641 --> 00:48:52,090
a payments from a bank that has been
sanctioned could be a risk for the receiving

424
00:48:52,161 --> 00:48:59,591
banks because the Americans can prevent
you to have access to the dollar system.

425
00:48:59,681 --> 00:49:06,512
So if you do any transaction in dollar
and you do business with someone that has

426
00:49:06,573 --> 00:49:11,672
been sanctioned you could
be subject to sanction.

427
00:49:11,741 --> 00:49:15,449
This is a decision a
unilateral decision by the US.

428
00:49:15,521 --> 00:49:24,890
There is no much the ECB can do. What the
ECB is doing on this general front is to

429
00:49:24,952 --> 00:49:27,814
reinforce the international
role of the euro.

430
00:49:27,881 --> 00:49:34,134
When we talk about you know international
role of the euro we also talked about

431
00:49:34,235 --> 00:49:37,901
this. So this is the we
need to understand the game.

432
00:49:37,961 --> 00:49:45,810
So it's not you can if you are afraid that
to do business with someone that has been

433
00:49:45,869 --> 00:49:50,701
sanctioned you could be sanctioned as well
which means that you don't fund yourself

434
00:49:50,786 --> 00:49:56,023
in dollar this is a huge risk.
So people will not enter to that.

435
00:49:56,081 --> 00:50:01,860
There is no much you can do unless you
know you slowly move into an environment

436
00:50:01,925 --> 00:50:12,832
where you can do business and. You know
finance your client even if they you know

437
00:50:12,941 --> 00:50:17,195
because they don't need any longer
dollars because they do other things.

438
00:50:17,261 --> 00:50:24,457
On the specific though what the
digital euro can do on that.

439
00:50:24,641 --> 00:50:28,347
Starting from the point you are saying I
mean the infrastructure the digital euro

440
00:50:28,393 --> 00:50:32,019
infrastructure is independent.
Depend on us on the ECB.

441
00:50:32,081 --> 00:50:42,454
So we can allow anyone to transact. The
point is— You need to find within the euro

442
00:50:42,557 --> 00:50:51,296
the digital euro ecosystem an entity that
doesn't need to fund itself in dollars.

443
00:50:51,401 --> 00:50:55,177
Because then this entity
can provide the services.

444
00:50:55,301 --> 00:51:01,665
And especially through the offline solution
people could pay because the offline

445
00:51:01,748 --> 00:51:06,411
solution is not it's like exchanging cash.

446
00:51:06,701 --> 00:51:13,455
So I that's why I was answering
before that the setting is there.

447
00:51:13,781 --> 00:51:20,561
We need to find fine tune solution that
would allow us to provide for specific

448
00:51:21,221 --> 00:51:28,418
case and. Because the
contest is what it is.

449
00:51:28,481 --> 00:51:37,684
So we need to the I repeat that the
technical infrastructure is there that would

450
00:51:37,821 --> 00:51:46,198
allow us to in some sense
overcome this problem.

451
00:51:46,541 --> 00:51:51,519
But there is no as far as I can understand
and I've been thinking about that for a

452
00:51:51,637 --> 00:51:56,133
while I couldn't find
any overarching solution.

453
00:51:56,201 --> 00:52:02,804
So we need to look into the specifics and
see if we can do something at the specific

454
00:52:02,861 --> 00:52:12,569
level. The advantage again is this that the
infrastructure is depends essentially on

455
00:52:12,701 --> 00:52:18,593
the ECB and therefore we can
allow anyone to transact.

456
00:52:18,641 --> 00:52:21,511
The problem is the at the
local level at the bank level.

457
00:52:21,581 --> 00:52:28,961
So you need to find an entity that it's
not conditioned by its need to fund itself

458
00:52:29,021 --> 00:52:35,725
in dollar. If you find an. Network of
those entity we would have overcome the

459
00:52:35,773 --> 00:52:36,973
problem.

460
00:52:38,981 --> 00:52:42,161
Thank you. I know give the
floor to Regina Duarte for EPP.

461
00:52:43,361 --> 00:52:45,790
Thanks chair. And Mr.
Cipollone you're very welcome.

462
00:52:45,821 --> 00:52:49,250
It's a very interesting conversation and
where you're rightly point out that the

463
00:52:49,327 --> 00:52:52,974
delivery of the digital euro obviously
is a key commitment for all of the

464
00:52:53,031 --> 00:52:56,058
co-legislators under
One Europe One Market.

465
00:52:56,141 --> 00:53:01,005
And we see now that the plan is to reach
an agreement at the open-ended trilogue on

466
00:53:01,071 --> 00:53:05,117
November the 18th. So I'm really sure that
everybody will be constructive flexible

467
00:53:05,189 --> 00:53:10,394
and obviously engage very meaningfully
because we know that the strategic importance

468
00:53:10,441 --> 00:53:14,319
of the project if there's any further
delay it will obviously impact the first

469
00:53:14,383 --> 00:53:19,383
issuance by the ECB. And I think from our
perspective delivery on this project is

470
00:53:19,427 --> 00:53:22,262
something that we all should
obviously be thinking it's a priority.

471
00:53:22,301 --> 00:53:26,681
So I have two questions there. Number one
is if the negotiations are prolonged what

472
00:53:26,741 --> 00:53:31,400
impact do you think this will have on the
digital euro's launch and what impact do

473
00:53:31,457 --> 00:53:36,016
you expect that to have on Europe's
strategic autonomy as a result.

474
00:53:36,101 --> 00:53:39,479
And secondly more briefly I want to ask
you about the discussion on costs with the

475
00:53:39,525 --> 00:53:45,341
merchants within the overall cap. What is
the ECB's view on whether there should be

476
00:53:45,401 --> 00:53:50,231
still room for negotiation within the
overall cap and do you think that this will

477
00:53:50,287 --> 00:53:52,901
impact the success
ultimately of the project.

478
00:53:52,961 --> 00:53:54,161
Thank you.

479
00:53:57,341 --> 00:54:06,791
So um. So from the very
beginning we have been saying um.

480
00:54:07,961 --> 00:54:14,096
We need more or less
two and a half year to.

481
00:54:14,321 --> 00:54:19,361
Roll out the digital euro from the moment
in which we have the legislation in place.

482
00:54:19,421 --> 00:54:22,984
When I say the legislation in
place I mean on the journal.

483
00:54:23,081 --> 00:54:28,831
On the official journal. Why
are we so formal if you want?

484
00:54:29,141 --> 00:54:35,413
I'll just give you an example. I need to
give to an instruction to the people that

485
00:54:35,475 --> 00:54:41,563
are developing the software how
many accounts people can have.

486
00:54:41,681 --> 00:54:50,831
This is you know as a trivial issue but
they need to write the code in such a way

487
00:54:51,032 --> 00:54:57,054
that would. Provide for the specific
request that is in the legislation.

488
00:54:57,101 --> 00:55:03,223
Now this is an extreme example but
there are many many dimension like that.

489
00:55:03,341 --> 00:55:09,784
So the finalization of the finalization
of the code will require to have a

490
00:55:09,843 --> 00:55:12,689
legislation. But think about the rulebook.

491
00:55:12,761 --> 00:55:16,887
The rulebook are the rule of the
game. How are payments is processed.

492
00:55:16,961 --> 00:55:24,027
This has to be spelled out step by step.
So we always said there are these two and a

493
00:55:24,106 --> 00:55:30,401
half years that are needed because then you
have to roll out all the scheme so you'd

494
00:55:30,454 --> 00:55:35,375
need these two and a half year from the
moment you have the legislation in place.

495
00:55:35,501 --> 00:55:43,073
Obviously you know if we delay the end
game the moment in which we will be able to

496
00:55:43,135 --> 00:55:46,503
roll out the digital
euro will be postponed.

497
00:55:46,601 --> 00:55:56,513
So the damage would be that we. Cannot
address the urgent problem that we have in

498
00:55:56,578 --> 00:56:04,061
terms of strategic autonomy and the time
goes I mean if not if we delay things get

499
00:56:04,151 --> 00:56:10,608
worse. Because we know that non-European
players are gaining market share in Europe.

500
00:56:10,661 --> 00:56:18,110
So the more we delay the worse the
situation the more entrenched will be our

501
00:56:18,581 --> 00:56:26,874
dependency. That's why we have been advocating
from the very beginning to be quick.

502
00:56:27,101 --> 00:56:35,102
So internally at the ECB we are forcing we
are running really running to squeeze as

503
00:56:35,178 --> 00:56:43,136
much as possible the technical time
in order to be able to deliver and to.

504
00:56:43,421 --> 00:56:47,884
Roll out the digital
euro as soon as possible.

505
00:56:47,981 --> 00:56:55,381
On the cap I mean this is
really this is really I.

506
00:56:55,901 --> 00:56:59,631
A little bit an easy to talk about that
because you know I am a central bank.

507
00:56:59,681 --> 00:57:05,141
A central bank do central bank issue.
This is a fiscal decision if you want.

508
00:57:05,681 --> 00:57:12,110
It's how you distribute resources across
the your constituency and citizen.

509
00:57:12,221 --> 00:57:19,112
So we think that we are taking out of
the system a lot of cost and therefore

510
00:57:19,241 --> 00:57:27,731
providing to the system enough saving
that could incentivize everyone to to

511
00:57:27,806 --> 00:57:32,882
participate. So my recommendation
is to everyone don't be greedy.

512
00:57:32,981 --> 00:57:38,286
Understand that everyone need to
have some incentive to participate.

513
00:57:38,381 --> 00:57:42,954
Because if we roll out
this everyone will benefit.

514
00:57:43,061 --> 00:57:49,601
Not just will benefit definitely from
a financial point of view but also as a

515
00:57:49,781 --> 00:57:56,801
citizen and in terms of our own freedom
and ability to master our own destiny.

516
00:57:58,241 --> 00:58:00,179
Thank you so much and
you're absolutely right.

517
00:58:00,221 --> 00:58:05,485
Time is running again. So this is why
we need the council to be open-minded to

518
00:58:05,621 --> 00:58:07,841
negotiate and I give the
floor to Matias Ecke.

519
00:58:09,401 --> 00:58:14,958
Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr
Cipollone, let me ask you a question.

520
00:58:15,010 --> 00:58:19,560
It is about the obligation to adopt
and possible exceptions to it.

521
00:58:19,629 --> 00:58:24,168
We all want the digital euro to become
a successful model, a successful digital

522
00:58:24,230 --> 00:58:27,307
central bank currency and
a public means of payment.

523
00:58:27,365 --> 00:58:31,057
I think that is extremely important. But
of course, it must not lead to absurd

524
00:58:31,111 --> 00:58:35,545
situations either. And that is why the
European Parliament has indeed laid down

525
00:58:35,603 --> 00:58:39,932
exceptions, going even further than the
Commission's proposal, for small and

526
00:58:39,978 --> 00:58:42,131
micro-enterprises and
private transactions.

527
00:58:42,203 --> 00:58:46,758
I would say that it would certainly not be
helpful for the acceptance of the digital

528
00:58:46,825 --> 00:58:51,616
euro if the police were to storm a school
flea market because digital euros are not

529
00:58:51,667 --> 00:58:55,561
accepted there. But at the same time, and
this is a bit of my concern now in the

530
00:58:55,604 --> 00:58:58,042
negotiations, the exception
must not go too far.

531
00:58:58,122 --> 00:59:03,759
Where would you say is the limit at which
the digital euro still actually has the

532
00:59:03,815 --> 00:59:07,536
status of legal tender, that it
is still a legal means of payment?

533
00:59:07,594 --> 00:59:13,679
Where is the limit of the exceptions that
the co-legislators are now setting, where

534
00:59:13,757 --> 00:59:17,538
we risk losing the status as a digital
means of payment, as a legal means of

535
00:59:17,567 --> 00:59:18,767
payment?

536
00:59:24,221 --> 00:59:30,453
So thank you for this question. So I
think that our initial proposal was a

537
00:59:30,559 --> 00:59:38,561
reasonable one. We said if you are a
merchant you already accept some digital

538
00:59:38,621 --> 00:59:45,014
payments you could add the digital euro.
It seems to me and this was more or less

539
00:59:45,122 --> 00:59:49,282
our initial proposal I
think it's reasonable.

540
00:59:49,361 --> 00:59:57,211
So but again I mean I'm not so I can
reiterate this because it comply is it simple

541
00:59:57,281 --> 01:00:07,539
and doesn't add much cost. To if you have
already you know you already have your.

542
01:00:07,721 --> 01:00:13,430
Your backend connected to the front end
where you receive digital payments it's not

543
01:00:13,514 --> 01:00:20,661
going to add much cost. Actually our
estimate is that 80% of the machine to accept

544
01:00:20,759 --> 01:00:29,379
digital payments can be updated via
software to accept the digital euro.

545
01:00:29,441 --> 01:00:34,342
So the marginal cost is very small. So we
thought that from the very beginning that

546
01:00:34,413 --> 01:00:39,641
was this would could be a reasonable
a reasonable a reasonable solution.

547
01:00:42,041 --> 01:00:44,441
Thank you for ESN. Mr. Droze.

548
01:00:45,101 --> 01:00:45,941
Yeah.

549
01:00:45,941 --> 01:00:48,881
Thank you Chair. I speak
German. Herr Cipollone

550
01:00:48,941 --> 01:00:52,911
Thank you very much for your report.
Indeed, Europeans love their money.

551
01:00:52,959 --> 01:00:57,641
I am one of them. Of course, I would most
of all like to have the German mark back

552
01:00:57,714 --> 01:01:03,116
again. They do love it, but outside of
these discussion rounds and probably outside

553
01:01:03,180 --> 01:01:07,800
their ECB headquarters, there are indeed
significant reservations in society about

554
01:01:07,915 --> 01:01:12,058
the digital euro. And I think you
will have to do a lot of work on that.

555
01:01:12,112 --> 01:01:16,781
The question I have is that, as you know,
Ms Lagarde has effectively announced her

556
01:01:16,840 --> 01:01:22,952
early resignation from her mandate. She
has made the digital euro one of her

557
01:01:22,993 --> 01:01:26,885
priorities. The wording suggests that
the digital euro would be one of her

558
01:01:26,962 --> 01:01:31,762
priorities. So are there now any
impacts on the digital euro project?

559
01:01:31,818 --> 01:01:38,197
I mean, are there any delays? And does the
change in leadership within the ECB not

560
01:01:38,259 --> 01:01:42,516
provide grounds for reassessing the cost
risks and benefits of the digital euro

561
01:01:42,565 --> 01:01:46,415
independently before entering into further
significant financial and organisational

562
01:01:46,473 --> 01:01:50,559
commitments? And would it not be sensible
to conclude the parliamentary negotiations

563
01:01:50,599 --> 01:01:54,102
and then allow the new ECB leadership
to decide on the next steps?

564
01:01:54,191 --> 01:01:59,267
And a concrete question: what would
happen if a large Member State, let’s say

565
01:01:59,357 --> 01:02:04,505
Germany in 2029, were led by other political
forces and wanted to withdraw from the

566
01:02:04,564 --> 01:02:07,399
project? So what would then
be the consequence of that?

567
01:02:07,445 --> 01:02:09,041
That is what I would be
interested in. Thank you.

568
01:02:17,261 --> 01:02:24,491
So let me answer for the department
that has to do with the with the ECB.

569
01:02:24,701 --> 01:02:33,049
So ECB governance is a robust one. The
decision so far about the development of the

570
01:02:33,115 --> 01:02:37,683
digital euro has been supported
by the governing council.

571
01:02:37,781 --> 01:02:46,145
Which is constituted by all governors of
the euro area central banks plus the six

572
01:02:46,247 --> 01:02:52,378
member of the governing council.
Now of. The executive order.

573
01:02:52,421 --> 01:02:58,937
Sorry. So so far the decision has been
unanimous on all the direction and all

574
01:02:58,985 --> 01:03:04,303
members of the governing council
are being supporting this process.

575
01:03:04,421 --> 01:03:10,274
Now from what I hear I do not
expect any change in the direction.

576
01:03:10,361 --> 01:03:19,816
Because the two names that have been you
know put forward as a presidency they both

577
01:03:19,913 --> 01:03:25,927
in public occasion supported the digital
euro and they were part of the governing

578
01:03:26,004 --> 01:03:36,296
council until few years ago. So they will
I expect that they will keep supporting on

579
01:03:36,664 --> 01:03:47,256
the. Additionally the. Council that is
the member states have agreed last year on

580
01:03:47,344 --> 01:03:54,833
the 18th of December to support
their proposal with the unanimity.

581
01:03:54,941 --> 01:03:59,249
So I also hear a strong
support from the member state.

582
01:03:59,321 --> 01:04:06,826
And also the parliament has voted with a
large majority the proposal that you have

583
01:04:06,926 --> 01:04:09,994
reached the text that you have reached to.

584
01:04:10,061 --> 01:04:16,797
So so far I see a strong democratic
backing for the digital euro.

585
01:04:16,901 --> 01:04:22,965
Then for the future I can I mean you
know there is nothing more difficult than

586
01:04:23,016 --> 01:04:29,029
making predictions. So let me let
me avoid too enter this difficult.

587
01:04:29,141 --> 01:04:30,341
Green.

588
01:04:30,701 --> 01:04:32,921
Thank you for EPP. Ludek Nidamäe.

589
01:04:33,941 --> 01:04:36,234
Thank you very much. And
it's good to have you here.

590
01:04:36,281 --> 01:04:39,939
I have two simple questions.
Each is a little bit different.

591
01:04:40,001 --> 01:04:48,256
The first concern. Retail digital euro.
How it would help with the problem of US

592
01:04:48,351 --> 01:04:53,278
sanctions to ICC court. You know
that we have discussion about it.

593
01:04:53,321 --> 01:04:57,043
But if you can summarize how
we would benefit from that one.

594
01:04:57,101 --> 01:05:01,538
And the second you know that European
parliament often called for wholesale digital

595
01:05:01,601 --> 01:05:07,811
euro. I am pleased that in September you
started the project Pontes if I am not

596
01:05:07,874 --> 01:05:13,993
mistaken. So do you have
some kind of first first.

597
01:05:14,261 --> 01:05:17,441
Things that you learned during
the first months of the operation.

598
01:05:19,961 --> 01:05:24,649
So thank you for thank you this question.
On the on the sanction I can reiterate

599
01:05:24,701 --> 01:05:32,091
what I said to to Mr.
Trivigo in both lines.

600
01:05:32,321 --> 01:05:36,074
We are building a platform
that depends only on us.

601
01:05:36,161 --> 01:05:49,883
So This per se per se just an additional
layer that increase our strategic autonomy.

602
01:05:50,141 --> 01:05:56,417
In terms of how this can help whether the
the how the digital euro infrastructure

603
01:05:56,501 --> 01:06:05,261
can help. It can help us as. Long as we
found within the PSP that distribute the

604
01:06:05,334 --> 01:06:14,363
digital euro a network that. Are
resilient to the sanction from the US.

605
01:06:14,441 --> 01:06:17,066
Because they don't need to
fund themselves in dollar.

606
01:06:17,141 --> 01:06:22,846
The real problem is that our banking sector
you know has to fund in dollar for many

607
01:06:22,901 --> 01:06:29,814
activities. And so people are people that
conduct normal business banking business

608
01:06:30,041 --> 01:06:36,008
may be concerned not to have
access to to to US dollars.

609
01:06:36,101 --> 01:06:42,521
So as long as we can find a set of PSP that
do only the distribution of the digital

610
01:06:42,581 --> 01:06:48,502
euro and do not need to to fund in dollars
I think that we can construct something

611
01:06:48,573 --> 01:06:55,384
that would be independent of the the
of the specific sanction of the US.

612
01:06:55,661 --> 01:07:06,170
So we need to stay flexible and and and.
Have the space to address case by case.

613
01:07:06,281 --> 01:07:09,649
On the whole sale yes indeed
has been a big success.

614
01:07:09,701 --> 01:07:16,646
On the 21st we launched the digital
euro. So what we learned Pontes.

615
01:07:16,781 --> 01:07:24,084
Pontes. What we we learned from Pontes.
So you know that there has been this

616
01:07:24,162 --> 01:07:31,399
important important first transaction
which was one billion euro issued by ESM.

617
01:07:31,661 --> 01:07:41,028
And. The most important I would say the
most serious point that we learned is the

618
01:07:41,169 --> 01:07:46,898
fact that we can build a
unified a unified framework.

619
01:07:46,961 --> 01:07:54,933
We can build an integrated platform in
Europe but we will not achieve a full

620
01:07:55,001 --> 01:08:00,574
integration of our capital market especially
on the tokenization part unless we

621
01:08:00,626 --> 01:08:03,650
don't do something at
the legislative level.

622
01:08:03,821 --> 01:08:09,461
We could reproduce what we are seeing
is that in the absence of a solution a

623
01:08:09,557 --> 01:08:17,393
European regulation for digital asset member
states are already developing their own

624
01:08:17,621 --> 01:08:25,022
the. Own legislative their own domestic
regulation which might not be compatible the

625
01:08:25,089 --> 01:08:31,101
next door regulation. So we could be in
a situation in which we could be able to

626
01:08:31,181 --> 01:08:32,261
construct an

627
01:08:32,261 --> 01:08:37,744
integrated financial market but at the
legislative level reproduce the fragmentation

628
01:08:37,806 --> 01:08:43,961
that we have today. This would be a pity
because that would be a loss opportunity.

629
01:08:44,081 --> 01:08:49,914
So I think that we need to seriously
start to think on how to avoid this

630
01:08:49,993 --> 01:08:52,959
fragmentation at the
at the national level.

631
01:08:53,021 --> 01:08:57,669
The second things we learned is that the
uptight for the for the tokenization is

632
01:08:57,744 --> 01:09:04,348
large and that we we could expect. So
we are seeing a kind of snowball effect.

633
01:09:04,421 --> 01:09:12,005
And many people coming to us and see
and say how can we import and and and.

634
01:09:12,101 --> 01:09:15,747
Use this technology. Just
just to give you an example.

635
01:09:15,821 --> 01:09:22,163
France is thinking to tokenize all the
commercial paper and distribute on DLT.

636
01:09:22,241 --> 01:09:25,706
We are talking about a
market of 300 billion a year.

637
01:09:25,781 --> 01:09:31,767
Not not a small feat. And other and other
institution are thinking to use to use the

638
01:09:31,829 --> 01:09:35,431
digital euro. Sorry
the wholesale solution.

639
01:09:35,501 --> 01:09:41,908
For us. For example I was in Bangkok for
the annual meeting and many international

640
01:09:41,973 --> 01:09:48,862
supernational institution came to me
to understand how how they can use this

641
01:09:48,960 --> 01:09:56,321
solution to provide the cash leg to
their transaction in of tokenized asset.

642
01:09:59,021 --> 01:10:04,574
Thank you. Any catchy
eyes. Yes Eveline Ragner.

643
01:10:04,721 --> 01:10:08,363
Thank you very much for all
your answers and for being here.

644
01:10:08,441 --> 01:10:14,097
Mr. Cipollone a very simple question but
I think it's a difficult to deal with that

645
01:10:14,163 --> 01:10:22,958
in in the outside world. There is tons and
lots of disinformation and misinformation

646
01:10:23,081 --> 01:10:26,696
and of course it helps very much when
you're right now here and answering very

647
01:10:26,744 --> 01:10:33,944
patiently to all those questions. But this
especially disinformation I mean just has

648
01:10:34,036 --> 01:10:40,584
the purpose to tell lies about the digital
euro and the implications and there's a

649
01:10:40,669 --> 01:10:47,679
lot of absurdistan out there. Do you pick
up some of them and just I mean though it

650
01:10:47,744 --> 01:10:53,174
might sound ridiculous sometimes with
these arguments like okay the digital euro

651
01:10:53,261 --> 01:10:58,136
will create a fee to pay the commission
and finance it and all these things of

652
01:10:58,204 --> 01:11:01,601
course that have nothing
to do with reality.

653
01:11:01,721 --> 01:11:06,582
Is there something that you pick up even
if it's very absurd if it's completely

654
01:11:06,641 --> 01:11:13,121
wrong in order to face those lies that
are in the digital world so much present.

655
01:11:14,861 --> 01:11:20,841
Oh as you can imagine we we face
constantly this kind of problem.

656
01:11:20,981 --> 01:11:26,134
And we try to answer in
a we are an institution.

657
01:11:26,261 --> 01:11:30,910
And we we have an institutional
language as you can imagine.

658
01:11:31,001 --> 01:11:39,139
So we provide information. And we try
to to make it as simple as possible to

659
01:11:39,221 --> 01:11:44,185
distribute this this information
as much as much as possible.

660
01:11:44,261 --> 01:11:51,124
So our you know the website that
we try to be on the on the social.

661
01:11:51,401 --> 01:12:02,120
But so far we have a huge impediment. We
cannot make an a proactive communication

662
01:12:02,201 --> 01:12:07,950
why. Because we cannot
be ahead of ourself.

663
01:12:08,081 --> 01:12:16,472
How can we communicate on a product
or on a solution that does not exist.

664
01:12:16,721 --> 01:12:21,012
That's why it's so important
that you guys reach an agreement.

665
01:12:21,101 --> 01:12:30,055
Because you will give birth to this baby.
Then we will be in a condition to make it

666
01:12:30,122 --> 01:12:36,299
grow fast and robust. But we
cannot be give them it birth.

667
01:12:36,401 --> 01:12:43,527
It's to you. So I cannot go around telling
the virtues of the digital euro because

668
01:12:43,581 --> 01:12:48,976
the digital euro does not exist. Then you
guys could be legitimately asking me why

669
01:12:49,057 --> 01:12:54,766
are you publicizing something that does
not exist and you are not being authorized

670
01:12:54,837 --> 01:13:02,455
to. To issue. That is why it's important.
Obviously we are planning to have strong

671
01:13:02,585 --> 01:13:09,606
campaign. But we can roll out this campaign
only when we will have the legitimacy of

672
01:13:09,709 --> 01:13:17,912
the of the college's leader because thanks
to God we live in a democracy and as

673
01:13:18,021 --> 01:13:25,141
where rule of law is. You
know govern our behavior.

674
01:13:25,241 --> 01:13:35,711
So please help us to you
know to fight this um.

675
01:13:36,821 --> 01:13:41,950
Fake news I would say you know. And there
are many actors that we will see and we

676
01:13:42,075 --> 01:13:45,641
see it every day. Can I
can I have one more second.

677
01:13:45,821 --> 01:13:46,241
No.

678
01:13:46,241 --> 01:13:55,566
Sure. You know three. Years ago four
years ago when we started to talk about

679
01:13:55,661 --> 01:14:02,470
strategic autonomy independent of Europe
it looked and that we were exposed to many

680
01:14:02,527 --> 01:14:09,681
external threat. It seemed
an esoteric discussion.

681
01:14:09,881 --> 01:14:16,687
Four years later we are suffering
this on our own skin every day.

682
01:14:16,781 --> 01:14:23,775
Not just for payments. So it's about
time that we wake up and we try to build

683
01:14:23,878 --> 01:14:31,091
something that make. Us wake up in the
morning and be a little bit reassured that we

684
01:14:31,181 --> 01:14:34,961
at least in part are are
master our own destiny.

685
01:14:38,081 --> 01:14:45,646
Thank you. Any request for the floor?
No. So thank you my dear Piero Cipollone.

686
01:14:45,701 --> 01:14:49,961
It may be that the next time you you come
in the committee we will have a deal.

687
01:14:50,441 --> 01:14:51,281
Absolutely.

688
01:14:51,281 --> 01:14:52,421
On digital euro.

689
01:14:52,421 --> 01:14:53,621
I will bring a champagne.

690
01:14:54,221 --> 01:14:59,381
I hope. At least champagne. Thank you so
much for your time and thank you for the

691
01:14:59,501 --> 01:15:01,001
exchange of you.

692
01:18:37,241 --> 01:18:48,215
Okay. So we can now turn to the point six
of the agenda on the competitiveness of

693
01:18:48,285 --> 01:18:53,498
the banking sector as in European
Union own initiative report.

694
01:18:53,561 --> 01:18:59,767
The purpose of this initiative report is
to present the position of the European

695
01:18:59,818 --> 01:19:05,512
Parliament on various issues
ahead of the 2027 banking package.

696
01:19:05,621 --> 01:19:11,499
So it can be considered by
the European Commission.

697
01:19:11,621 --> 01:19:18,595
More than 500 amendments were tabled. I
will give the floor not to the rapporteur

698
01:19:18,641 --> 01:19:23,921
but to Marco Sverber who will speak on
behalf of the rapporteur Isabelle Benjumea.

699
01:19:25,541 --> 01:19:28,181
Thank you very much
President. I will read Ms.

700
01:19:28,241 --> 01:19:31,849
Benjumea's message because she
cannot be here today with us.

701
01:19:31,961 --> 01:19:36,695
So I start quoting. Over the past few
years European competitiveness has been

702
01:19:36,770 --> 01:19:41,554
undermined by an ever-increasing
bureaucratic and regulatory burden.

703
01:19:41,621 --> 01:19:44,891
Our banking sector is
suffering. The consequences.

704
01:19:44,981 --> 01:19:51,547
The European regulatory framework governing
EU banks now exceeds 95,000 pages.

705
01:19:51,701 --> 01:19:56,883
Today we have more resilient banks but we
also have banks that are at a competitive

706
01:19:56,936 --> 01:20:00,627
disadvantage compared with
those in other jurisdictions.

707
01:20:00,701 --> 01:20:05,027
They continue to operate in a fragmented
market with national barriers excessively

708
01:20:05,081 --> 01:20:10,967
complex rules and high compliance costs.
All this limits their ability to invest to

709
01:20:11,041 --> 01:20:15,509
grow and to finance our economy.
And this affects us all.

710
01:20:15,581 --> 01:20:20,357
This is why reviewing this legislative
framework is an urgent priority.

711
01:20:20,441 --> 01:20:25,035
552 amendments have been
tabled to the draft report.

712
01:20:25,121 --> 01:20:29,359
As the European Parliament's rapporteur
she is working with the rest of political

713
01:20:29,407 --> 01:20:34,347
groups to deliver an ambitious
text with around five priorities.

714
01:20:34,421 --> 01:20:39,556
First completing the banking union and
removing the remaining barriers in the single

715
01:20:39,619 --> 01:20:44,501
market. Second making competitiveness a
secondary objective for European supervisory

716
01:20:44,561 --> 01:20:50,831
authorities. Third reducing duplication
and unnecessary regulatory burdens.

717
01:20:50,921 --> 01:20:53,441
Fourth facilitating banking consolidation.

718
01:20:53,501 --> 01:20:58,124
And fifth promoting the use of technologies
such as artificial intelligence and

719
01:20:58,181 --> 01:21:04,456
tokenization. She's confident that with
the contributions of the shadow rapporteurs

720
01:21:04,541 --> 01:21:07,891
they can reach an agreement
on an ambitious report.

721
01:21:07,961 --> 01:21:12,850
This will enable the European Parliament
to enter the debate on the major regulatory

722
01:21:12,907 --> 01:21:19,140
package that the Commission plans to
present in 2027 with a strong and coherent

723
01:21:19,215 --> 01:21:22,819
position. Europe needs bank
that can compete and invest.

724
01:21:22,901 --> 01:21:27,328
Banks that finance the growth of our
businesses and support entrepreneurs.

725
01:21:27,401 --> 01:21:32,565
We have an opportunity to provide them with
a framework that enables them to do so.

726
01:21:32,621 --> 01:21:38,330
We must therefore act with ambition.
That's what I have to say in the name of

727
01:21:38,381 --> 01:21:39,581
Isabelle.

728
01:21:40,781 --> 01:21:46,532
Thank you so much. I give the floor to the
shadow and we'll start with SND and Ronas

729
01:21:46,571 --> 01:21:47,771
Fernandez.

730
01:21:47,921 --> 01:21:49,961
Thank you Chair. I will speak in Spanish.

731
01:21:52,361 --> 01:21:59,250
First of all, I would like to thank Isabelle
Benjumea and her entire team and send a

732
01:21:59,341 --> 01:22:05,558
big hug to her APA, who has had a small
accident that seems it might have some

733
01:22:05,622 --> 01:22:08,351
consequences; let's hope
it gets resolved quickly.

734
01:22:08,402 --> 01:22:12,548
In any case, first of all, as I say, I
would like to thank Benjumea for the draft

735
01:22:12,604 --> 01:22:19,103
report and the work of these last few
weeks in which we have tried, in short, to

736
01:22:19,194 --> 01:22:24,825
find areas of agreement, due among other
things to the large number of amendments

737
01:22:24,885 --> 01:22:30,356
that we have all submitted. SANDI's
position on this matter is quite clear.

738
01:22:30,418 --> 01:22:37,443
And we could summarise it as follows: we
hope that this INI will help ensure that

739
01:22:37,500 --> 01:22:42,571
the legislative proposal the Commission
presents next year helps to reduce the

740
01:22:42,644 --> 01:22:47,162
fragmentation of the single market,
particularly within the Union.

741
01:22:47,217 --> 01:22:52,280
Banking, because behind fragmentation lie
the serious competitiveness problems that

742
01:22:52,332 --> 01:22:55,743
in some cases we can find
in our banking sector.

743
01:22:55,843 --> 01:23:01,783
This fragmentation affects first and
foremost the consolidation of the Banking

744
01:23:02,061 --> 01:23:09,175
Union. We face significant national barriers
that prevent us from taking advantage

745
01:23:09,262 --> 01:23:15,033
of the efficiencies of the banking union.
The management of liquidity or capital

746
01:23:15,106 --> 01:23:18,972
cannot be handled efficiently
across the entire Banking Union.

747
01:23:19,043 --> 01:23:25,860
This fragmentation also explains part of
the additional buffers that, in short,

748
01:23:25,961 --> 01:23:30,765
national supervisors impose to protect
themselves from risks in other jurisdictions

749
01:23:30,829 --> 01:23:36,036
even within the Banking Union. and
all of them are supervised by the SSM.

750
01:23:36,104 --> 01:23:42,608
And these fragmentation problems, as I
say, generate cost increases, loss of

751
01:23:42,672 --> 01:23:47,777
opportunities and, as I say, losses of
efficiency in the consolidation of the single

752
01:23:47,839 --> 01:23:52,010
market. These fragmentation problems
also affect capital requirements;

753
01:23:52,064 --> 01:23:57,508
for example, at the time, Parliament sought
to apply the output flow at consolidated

754
01:23:57,558 --> 01:24:02,586
level only, but to the extent that we have
a fragmented market, we ended up applying

755
01:24:02,647 --> 01:24:07,219
the output flow at both levels, and
when we talk about the complexity of the

756
01:24:07,274 --> 01:24:08,474
supervisory framework

757
01:24:09,221 --> 01:24:13,404
certainly, we are facing a complex
framework because once again we have a

758
01:24:13,465 --> 01:24:18,960
fragmentation problem. Therefore, we must
consolidate the banking union, we must

759
01:24:19,077 --> 01:24:24,570
liberalise or facilitate the use of capital
and liquidity waivers, we need to review

760
01:24:24,611 --> 01:24:28,474
some of those buffers that are imposed as
a result of fragmentation, and to resolve

761
01:24:28,528 --> 01:24:32,768
all of this, having a European
deposit system is essential.

762
01:24:32,844 --> 01:24:37,495
It is not the only instrument; we also need
other types of safeguards, but a future

763
01:24:37,580 --> 01:24:40,791
EDIS or a future European
deposit framework is central.

764
01:24:40,839 --> 01:24:46,048
And one final message: the competitiveness
of the European banking sector will not

765
01:24:46,135 --> 01:24:49,847
be resolved by reviewing
prudential treatments.

766
01:24:49,917 --> 01:24:54,936
This resilience of the current European
banking sector is the result of a very

767
01:24:55,028 --> 01:25:01,039
significant prudential effort, and thanks
to that prudential effort, the financing

768
01:25:01,080 --> 01:25:05,415
costs, for example, of banking institutions
are substantially lower than in another

769
01:25:05,500 --> 01:25:09,788
environment where prudential
frameworks were relaxed.

770
01:25:09,869 --> 01:25:13,688
Therefore, we believe that banking
competitiveness depends on the consolidation of

771
01:25:13,735 --> 01:25:17,420
the single market and not on the revision
of prudential frameworks, which contribute

772
01:25:17,468 --> 01:25:19,241
greatly to that
competitiveness. Thank you.

773
01:25:24,161 --> 01:25:26,921
Thank you. For PFI, Tomás Cubín.

774
01:25:27,821 --> 01:25:30,641
Thank you Madam Chair. I'll
speak in Czech language.

775
01:25:33,821 --> 01:25:39,666
Just like my predecessors, I would also
like to thank the rapporteur and her team,

776
01:25:39,719 --> 01:25:45,683
because the work they have done, given the
large number of amendments and the very

777
01:25:45,731 --> 01:25:50,622
diverse positions on the individual topics
covered in the report, is truly not to

778
01:25:50,688 --> 01:25:55,863
draft a joint parliamentary position, and
the entire negotiating team led by the

779
01:25:55,929 --> 01:26:00,645
rapporteur has been working on this for
a month now, and I believe we are not far

780
01:26:00,696 --> 01:26:03,235
from a text that we will
all be able to support.

781
01:26:03,293 --> 01:26:06,943
But I would also like to thank the
other shadow rapporteurs, because the

782
01:26:06,990 --> 01:26:12,600
communication and the work on this text
is truly constructive, and I must say it

783
01:26:12,658 --> 01:26:18,238
really pleases me personally. Last week
we had a meeting of the shadow rapporteurs

784
01:26:18,300 --> 01:26:25,089
after which there was a technical-level
meeting where our assistants really put in a

785
01:26:25,152 --> 01:26:28,452
lot of work. And I personally
must say that I am very pleased.

786
01:26:28,494 --> 01:26:32,345
Last week we had a meeting of the shadow
rapporteurs, followed by technical-level

787
01:26:32,417 --> 01:26:36,067
negotiations where our assistants
really put in a lot of work.

788
01:26:36,156 --> 01:26:40,208
On many points, we largely agree: we do
not want duplicate regulatory burdens for

789
01:26:40,263 --> 01:26:46,685
banks, we want to simplify complex processes,
but this must not come at the expense

790
01:26:46,746 --> 01:26:51,248
of resilience and financial stability—not
only of the European Union as a whole, but

791
01:26:51,319 --> 01:26:56,821
also of all individual Member States. This
is also related to another point that is

792
01:26:56,870 --> 01:27:01,045
being widely discussed in the context of
the upcoming banking package, if we may

793
01:27:01,110 --> 01:27:06,425
call it that, and that is the efficient
allocation of capital and liquidity in

794
01:27:06,493 --> 01:27:12,661
cross-border banking groups. We understand
that for large banks, their dream would

795
01:27:12,730 --> 01:27:20,012
come true if what we might call the
dissolution of capital within the entire group

796
01:27:20,105 --> 01:27:25,998
were to be implemented, rather than having
to take proper account of the individual

797
01:27:26,062 --> 01:27:30,366
affiliations in each country. However, we
must also be aware of the impact on the

798
01:27:30,448 --> 01:27:36,255
host countries where these large foreign
banks operate through their the so-called

799
01:27:36,334 --> 01:27:42,298
ring-fencing of capital and liquidity has
entirely rational reasons and objectives,

800
01:27:42,349 --> 01:27:48,234
the purpose of which is nothing other than
the financial stability of the country in

801
01:27:48,342 --> 01:27:52,696
question. The reports under discussion
therefore, together with other colleagues, we

802
01:27:52,743 --> 01:27:56,787
are seeking balanced formulations that will
not merely highlight the benefits of the

803
01:27:56,838 --> 01:28:03,054
release of capital and liquidity, as has
already been mentioned here, but also any

804
01:28:03,105 --> 01:28:07,609
potential risks. Last but not least, it
is crucial for us that in the upcoming

805
01:28:07,674 --> 01:28:09,461
banking package we have sufficient

806
01:28:09,641 --> 01:28:14,597
the specificities of the countries outside
the euro area and therefore also outside

807
01:28:14,652 --> 01:28:17,867
the banking union have
been taken into account.

808
01:28:17,920 --> 01:28:23,052
These countries face different risks and
have different powers than the euro area

809
01:28:23,104 --> 01:28:28,461
countries. And we also appreciate that the
rapporteur, in her report, does address

810
01:28:28,523 --> 01:28:35,568
this issue, albeit briefly, and we hope
that these mentions will remain in the text

811
01:28:35,643 --> 01:28:39,627
going forward. So once again, thank you,
and as I say, I believe we will soon be

812
01:28:39,659 --> 01:28:40,859
able to agree on that final text.

813
01:28:45,701 --> 01:28:47,801
Thank you for ACR, Giovanni Corsetto.

814
01:28:48,581 --> 01:28:57,523
Thank you, Mr President. I would also like
to begin by thanking the rapporteur and

815
01:28:57,625 --> 01:29:01,320
my colleagues for the
work carried out so far.

816
01:29:01,393 --> 01:29:10,642
We welcome the amendments aimed at
strengthening the need for European investments

817
01:29:10,688 --> 01:29:17,540
and we must therefore be ambitious in
addressing the structural constraints that

818
01:29:17,729 --> 01:29:25,111
penalise competitiveness.
However, I would like to be clear:

819
01:29:25,222 --> 01:29:31,928
this is not about deregulation nor
about weakening prudential requirements.

820
01:29:31,993 --> 01:29:36,245
Financial stability must remain the
foundation of our banking system.

821
01:29:36,308 --> 01:29:41,642
However, this must not prevent us from
improving the regulatory framework by

822
01:29:41,716 --> 01:29:47,793
removing unjustified constraints and making
it more effective in supporting the real

823
01:29:47,854 --> 01:29:53,652
economy. In this context, we support the
amendments that call for a prudential

824
01:29:53,745 --> 01:29:58,141
framework that is more
proportionate to the actual risk.

825
01:29:58,209 --> 01:30:04,000
Simplification must make it possible to
overcome regulatory overlaps and introduce

826
01:30:04,062 --> 01:30:09,120
targeted measures where the existing
requirements are not justified by the

827
01:30:09,193 --> 01:30:16,141
underlying risks. This also means ensuring
that the implementation of Basel 3 does

828
01:30:16,237 --> 01:30:21,127
not create competitive
disadvantages for European banks.

829
01:30:21,189 --> 01:30:26,934
As regards sovereign exposures, we remain
firmly opposed to the introduction of new

830
01:30:27,002 --> 01:30:30,612
constraints, including new
risk weighting factors.

831
01:30:30,694 --> 01:30:38,018
Diversification must be market-driven, not
imposed through regulatory interventions.

832
01:30:38,078 --> 01:30:42,698
Just as any possible revision of the
prudential treatment of sovereign exposures

833
01:30:42,761 --> 01:30:47,532
should not become a condition for
the completion of the banking union.

834
01:30:47,597 --> 01:30:50,551
As also recently stated by
the European Central Bank.

835
01:30:50,601 --> 01:30:56,376
These are distinct objectives and the
completion of the banking union must remain a

836
01:30:56,440 --> 01:31:02,277
priority. We also support a calibrated
regime for small and non-complex institutions

837
01:31:02,333 --> 01:31:07,640
that allows banks individually classified
as such to benefit from proportionate

838
01:31:07,699 --> 01:31:12,243
requirements. Eligibility should be
assessed on the basis of the size of the

839
01:31:12,315 --> 01:31:17,424
business model, the complexity and the risk
profile of each institution, regardless

840
01:31:17,480 --> 01:31:19,961
of its legal or organisational form.

841
01:31:20,261 --> 01:31:25,464
As, among other things, highlighted by the
European Commission in its report of 17

842
01:31:25,554 --> 01:31:30,761
July. We also welcome the proposals
aimed at strengthening banks' capacity to

843
01:31:30,832 --> 01:31:36,583
finance SMEs and families, as well as
those aimed at a prudential framework that

844
01:31:36,642 --> 01:31:41,715
better reflects the actual risk profile
of secured credit and mortgage credit.

845
01:31:41,790 --> 01:31:46,611
In particular, we would like to explore
a prudential treatment that takes greater

846
01:31:46,678 --> 01:31:52,953
account of the stability of income and
the repayment capacity of borrowers.

847
01:31:53,016 --> 01:31:57,949
We also consider it appropriate to
promote a more consistent and homogeneous

848
01:31:58,042 --> 01:32:02,838
prudential treatment for insurance
groups, as this could further facilitate

849
01:32:02,907 --> 01:32:07,857
consolidation operations that help channel
savings towards productive investment.

850
01:32:07,923 --> 01:32:11,508
In line with the objectives of
the Saving Investment Union.

851
01:32:11,573 --> 01:32:12,773
Thank you, Mr President.

852
01:32:16,541 --> 01:32:19,121
Thank you for a new now I look from Brook.

853
01:32:20,621 --> 01:32:23,363
Yes. Thank you Chair and I also would
like to thank the rapporteur for the

854
01:32:23,412 --> 01:32:29,438
constructive discussions we had so far.
For us it's a safe sound a stable banking

855
01:32:29,506 --> 01:32:34,137
system is absolutely essential. At the
same time we must address the fragmentation

856
01:32:34,181 --> 01:32:39,461
of our banking market promote greater
integration and ensure that competitive

857
01:32:39,525 --> 01:32:43,855
European banks can effectively
finance our economy.

858
01:32:43,961 --> 01:32:48,189
Where rules and regulations can be
simplified without compromising financial

859
01:32:48,252 --> 01:32:52,904
stability they should be simplified and
renew stands ready to work constructively

860
01:32:52,950 --> 01:32:58,071
towards a banking system that is not safe
not only safe and resilient but also more

861
01:32:58,121 --> 01:33:00,161
integrated and competitive.
Thank you very much.

862
01:33:02,921 --> 01:33:05,321
Thank you. For the left.

863
01:33:06,341 --> 01:33:07,541
Thank you, Sarah Mo.

864
01:33:08,921 --> 01:33:13,893
Thank you Madam Chair. I also would
like to thank the rapporteur for her

865
01:33:14,004 --> 01:33:21,615
constructive approach. Unfortunately we
do not share commissions and reports main

866
01:33:21,744 --> 01:33:26,854
premise. Banks they are making huge
profits and there is no problem with

867
01:33:26,908 --> 01:33:32,999
competitiveness of the banks. So the
commission's concern really lies with the

868
01:33:33,041 --> 01:33:35,562
bank's ability to
finance the real economy.

869
01:33:35,621 --> 01:33:41,188
However even now the banks could finance
more vital investments but they focus on

870
01:33:41,255 --> 01:33:47,698
the more profitable areas. You can't push
on a rope the more banking regulation is

871
01:33:47,757 --> 01:33:53,138
dismantled the more certain it is that
money will flow into speculation rather than

872
01:33:53,243 --> 01:34:00,027
the real economy. It is a genuine problem
for Europe that in the US risk financing

873
01:34:00,101 --> 01:34:06,341
for scale-ups is significantly higher.
But the difference is not on the banks but

874
01:34:06,401 --> 01:34:13,101
with the rest of the financial market. So
briefly of our amendments the mandates of

875
01:34:13,159 --> 01:34:17,097
the supervisory authorities
should not be blurred.

876
01:34:17,201 --> 01:34:22,916
History shows that the strong prudential
safeguards are necessary and then they

877
01:34:22,985 --> 01:34:26,766
improve stability and
eventually competitiveness.

878
01:34:26,861 --> 01:34:33,080
Of course when there are overlapping
requirements or unnecessary burdens there is a

879
01:34:33,129 --> 01:34:38,519
room for rethinking and simplification.
But the aggregate level of required capital

880
01:34:38,616 --> 01:34:44,302
buffers should not be reduced. While focusing
too narrowly on certain aspects raised

881
01:34:44,349 --> 01:34:48,524
by the banking sector the draft is missing
an opportunity to address the problems

882
01:34:48,581 --> 01:34:54,202
that lie ahead. There are
multiple risks on the horizon.

883
01:34:54,281 --> 01:34:59,171
AI financing geopolitical
climate and nature related.

884
01:34:59,261 --> 01:35:04,531
Many of the prudential risks remain
unaddressed in the current framework due to the

885
01:35:04,596 --> 01:35:10,562
lack of access to proper data or
a lack of appropriate treatment.

886
01:35:10,661 --> 01:35:16,738
And to address these problems there would
be a need for EU regulation that improves

887
01:35:16,794 --> 01:35:21,485
the robust prudential rules and that
acknowledges the importance and different

888
01:35:21,536 --> 01:35:27,465
aspects of the diverse banking sector.
Better ways to identify measure and manage

889
01:35:27,521 --> 01:35:32,803
geopolitical climate and nature related
risks should be a priority at the moment not

890
01:35:32,905 --> 01:35:37,241
a short-sighted focus on an
international race to the bottom.

891
01:35:37,601 --> 01:35:38,801
Thank you.

892
01:35:39,581 --> 01:35:44,428
Thank you. Thank you to all of you. I
can add give the floor back to the to the

893
01:35:44,517 --> 01:35:51,837
rapporteur. So the voting icon has been
postponed for information from this

894
01:35:51,901 --> 01:35:55,721
afternoon. To the icon
meeting on December the 1st.

895
01:35:55,781 --> 01:36:00,761
Thank you to all of you. We know.

896
01:36:40,961 --> 01:36:47,215
Okay. We now turn to the consideration of
amendments to the icon committee yearly

897
01:36:47,367 --> 01:36:53,475
report on the ECB. The presentation of
the rapporteur draft report in the icon

898
01:36:53,533 --> 01:37:00,787
committee on November 3rd as already led
to an very rich debate on the governance

899
01:37:00,835 --> 01:37:04,415
and independence of the
central bank monetary policies.

900
01:37:04,481 --> 01:37:14,381
The digital euro and other aspects.
Almost 300 amendment were tabled.

901
01:37:14,501 --> 01:37:20,464
And we will now listen to the group views
on these amendments and I will give the

902
01:37:20,520 --> 01:37:22,361
floor first to the rapporteur Mr. Aftias.

903
01:37:26,501 --> 01:37:29,081
Dear colleagues I will speak Greek

904
01:37:30,941 --> 01:37:37,706
first of all, I would like to thank
most sincerely all my colleagues, Madam

905
01:37:37,784 --> 01:37:42,989
President, for their interest in
this matter of the European Bank.

906
01:37:43,057 --> 01:37:48,785
I also hope for a constructive cooperation
on the annual report for 2026 and I wish

907
01:37:48,838 --> 01:37:52,238
for it to serve as the
basis for that of 2027.

908
01:37:52,323 --> 01:37:58,924
Ladies and gentlemen colleagues, I will
repeat what I said from the very beginning:

909
01:37:58,992 --> 01:38:02,094
as the ancient Greeks
used to say, *hekaston*.

910
01:38:02,162 --> 01:38:07,842
you will judge the one before existence,
and the final outcome will be the

911
01:38:07,915 --> 01:38:13,095
agreement, and it will be the
work of all, not of one person.

912
01:38:13,176 --> 01:38:17,974
Our societies need us
united and determined.

913
01:38:18,088 --> 01:38:24,749
Therefore, examining all these amendments,
I have identified thematic axes, and I

914
01:38:24,838 --> 01:38:29,795
mean axes of interest. it is not
a common interest for Europe;

915
01:38:29,906 --> 01:38:33,511
the energy crisis is not an
interest for all of Europe;

916
01:38:33,601 --> 01:38:37,778
the digital euro is not an
interest for all of Europe;

917
01:38:37,887 --> 01:38:44,730
monetary policy—these elements do not
distinguish between left, right, centre,

918
01:38:44,815 --> 01:38:52,741
liberal, or anything else. All households,
all businesses—Mr President—are affected.

919
01:38:52,832 --> 01:38:59,256
Any differences that may exist, I believe,
Madam President, and I thank you warmly

920
01:38:59,351 --> 01:39:05,167
because the your benevolent stance has
helped us greatly, I think we can agree,

921
01:39:05,251 --> 01:39:09,197
because the problems in Europe are common;

922
01:39:09,361 --> 01:39:15,332
I would also like to point out
that I would like to stress this:

923
01:39:15,402 --> 01:39:21,166
the European Central Bank should first
and foremost be a social institution.

924
01:39:21,243 --> 01:39:26,379
it must support societies, it must support
businesses, it must support the common

925
01:39:26,460 --> 01:39:33,817
good the interests of societies and,
above all, its independence, because an

926
01:39:33,897 --> 01:39:42,078
independent European Central Bank means
greater trust for the European citizen.

927
01:39:42,333 --> 01:39:48,148
also, the more reliable we are in our
proposals, the more social and objective we

928
01:39:48,223 --> 01:39:53,643
are, the better we will serve the European
citizen, and I thank you warmly and await

929
01:39:53,698 --> 01:39:54,898
your observations

930
01:40:00,881 --> 01:40:05,081
Thank you. On behalf of Matthias Ecker
I give the floor to Jonas Fernandes.

931
01:40:06,221 --> 01:40:12,961
Thank you. Thank you Chair. Our shadow
Matthias Ecker cannot attend to this first

932
01:40:13,061 --> 01:40:18,134
and state of views but he
asked me for reading a note.

933
01:40:18,281 --> 01:40:26,830
So I'm going to to read. You have presented
a concise and focused report and it

934
01:40:26,905 --> 01:40:34,439
provides a good basis for our work. There
is mass in it that we as SND can support.

935
01:40:34,541 --> 01:40:37,834
Congratulations and thank
you to to the reporter.

936
01:40:37,901 --> 01:40:42,604
It's clear on the ECB independence and
the rightly so at a time when central bank

937
01:40:42,670 --> 01:40:46,945
independence has been openly
called into questions elsewhere.

938
01:40:47,021 --> 01:40:51,315
Europe must live no doubt that it
stands by its own central bank.

939
01:40:51,401 --> 01:40:54,225
We welcome the report's
position on the digital euro.

940
01:40:54,281 --> 01:40:59,899
It's a clear and ambitious commitment. At
the same time a concise report leaves room

941
01:40:59,962 --> 01:41:04,879
to develop some points further
and we see this as an opportunity.

942
01:41:04,961 --> 01:41:10,238
First the mandate. The treaty centralized
the ECB with two legally binding

943
01:41:10,303 --> 01:41:14,357
objectives. Maintaining process stability
and supporting the general economic

944
01:41:14,423 --> 01:41:19,986
policies of the union. Both form an integral
part of its mandate and we would like

945
01:41:20,036 --> 01:41:24,319
to see more transparency on how
this second objective is reflected.

946
01:41:24,401 --> 01:41:29,150
In the ECB decisions. Second
the current inflation episode.

947
01:41:29,201 --> 01:41:35,321
We are facing another energy price shock
driven largely by imported fossil energy.

948
01:41:35,441 --> 01:41:41,943
Monetary tightening may weigh on investment
and employment without addressing the

949
01:41:42,002 --> 01:41:48,627
root causes of price increases. We
therefore welcome the ECB's global approach.

950
01:41:48,701 --> 01:41:54,077
Note that long-term inflation
expectations remain broadly anchored.

951
01:41:54,161 --> 01:41:59,252
And ask the ECB to take due account of the
impact on investments and employment when

952
01:41:59,340 --> 01:42:04,809
considering further rate increases. Third
the interaction between monetary and

953
01:42:04,879 --> 01:42:07,957
fiscal policy. We see
the two as complementary.

954
01:42:08,021 --> 01:42:11,997
Investment in renewable
energy and energy efficiency.

955
01:42:12,101 --> 01:42:16,754
Strengthens our resilience to
future energy price shocks.

956
01:42:16,841 --> 01:42:22,781
And we will welcome the ECB paying close
attention to how financing conditions

957
01:42:22,871 --> 01:42:26,149
affect it. The SND has traveled
a number of amendments.

958
01:42:26,201 --> 01:42:28,897
Our intention is to complement your draft.

959
01:42:28,961 --> 01:42:34,841
And in particularly by reflecting some of
the recent developments that the euro area

960
01:42:34,901 --> 01:42:36,101
is currently facing.

961
01:42:37,181 --> 01:42:41,962
These include for example the growing
importance of artificial intelligence both for

962
01:42:42,027 --> 01:42:45,872
the economy and for cyber
security in the banking sector.

963
01:42:45,941 --> 01:42:51,264
The rapid growth of stable coins and
the risk may they may pose to monetary

964
01:42:51,355 --> 01:42:55,136
sovereignty. Once again
thank you so much Mr.

965
01:42:55,241 --> 01:42:59,897
Raftias for your work on this
report and for your openings so far.

966
01:42:59,981 --> 01:43:04,356
We are convinced that together we can find
good compromises and make this report a

967
01:43:04,412 --> 01:43:09,010
strong and balanced statement of the
parliament's position on the ECB.

968
01:43:09,101 --> 01:43:14,681
On behalf of Matthias Ecker and the SND
group I look forward to our cooperation in

969
01:43:14,741 --> 01:43:16,481
the coming weeks. Thank you so much.

970
01:43:19,541 --> 01:43:27,051
For PFI, Ms. Pokorna, Germanova.
Thank you for the floor.

971
01:43:27,101 --> 01:43:28,361
I will continue Czech.

972
01:43:31,421 --> 01:43:37,516
The draft report provides an overall
balanced assessment of the European Central

973
01:43:37,592 --> 01:43:43,196
Bank's activities. We welcome the emphasis
on price stability and on the ECB’s

974
01:43:43,265 --> 01:43:48,028
responsibility to explain its decisions
to the European Parliament and to the

975
01:43:48,084 --> 01:43:52,360
public. With our amendments, we are
seeking a more thorough assessment of the

976
01:43:52,415 --> 01:43:57,595
development of purchasing power. Even
though inflation is slowing down, households

977
01:43:57,647 --> 01:44:01,024
may still feel the effects
of earlier price increases.

978
01:44:01,078 --> 01:44:07,854
We therefore want the report to assess
whether wages, pensions and savings returns

979
01:44:07,936 --> 01:44:10,960
have kept pace with
price growth since 2021.

980
01:44:11,012 --> 01:44:15,645
We also welcome the proposal to assess the
errors in the forecasts and we want the

981
01:44:15,692 --> 01:44:20,080
ECB to explain how these errors have
affected the timing of its decisions.

982
01:44:20,129 --> 01:44:25,471
The costs and risks associated with bond
purchases also deserve the same attention.

983
01:44:25,529 --> 01:44:30,447
For us, paragraph 6 is very important, as
prudent budgetary policy on the part of

984
01:44:30,496 --> 01:44:35,267
the Member States can contribute to price
stability and give governments the space

985
01:44:35,318 --> 01:44:40,319
to help households during a crisis. In
paragraph 7, we support the mention of

986
01:44:40,368 --> 01:44:45,587
purchasing power and propose removing the
specific requirement for the ECB to report

987
01:44:45,655 --> 01:44:49,197
on expenditure on food, energy
and housing by income groups.

988
01:44:49,253 --> 01:44:53,821
The annual report can assess the broader
impacts of inflation, while decisions on

989
01:44:53,877 --> 01:44:58,685
support for households remain in
the hands of elected governments.

990
01:44:58,747 --> 01:45:04,079
On the issue of the digital euro, paragraph
12 calls for a swift agreement to be

991
01:45:04,173 --> 01:45:09,794
reached. In paragraphs 12a and 13, it is
emphasised that the use of the digital euro

992
01:45:09,857 --> 01:45:13,991
should be voluntary and that people should
continue to have access to cash and the

993
01:45:14,040 --> 01:45:18,531
ability to pay with it, including
in less densely populated areas.

994
01:45:18,617 --> 01:45:23,170
We welcome these guarantees. Before the
report designates the digital euro as

995
01:45:23,228 --> 01:45:27,527
necessary, it should assess what advantages
it offers compared to existing payment

996
01:45:27,575 --> 01:45:31,922
options and how its proposed form would
protect citizens' financial privacy and

997
01:45:31,970 --> 01:45:35,160
maintain banks' ability to provide credit.

998
01:45:35,226 --> 01:45:39,941
And finally, I would like to thank the
rapporteur and my shadow rapporteurs for

999
01:45:39,985 --> 01:45:42,281
their cooperation and look
forward to its continuation.

1000
01:45:45,581 --> 01:45:50,834
Thank you so much. On behalf of Gilles
Boyer, I give the floor to Ludovic Tordor for

1001
01:45:50,881 --> 01:45:52,081
Renew.

1002
01:45:52,781 --> 01:46:01,864
Thank you very much. And I will also read
the points Gilles wanted to make for this

1003
01:46:01,920 --> 01:46:05,245
file, but unfortunately he
cannot be here right now.

1004
01:46:05,321 --> 01:46:09,350
So first of all, I would like to thank the
rapporteur for the quality of the draft

1005
01:46:09,401 --> 01:46:15,341
report, as well as all my colleagues for
the constructive exchanges we have had on

1006
01:46:15,418 --> 01:46:22,139
the basis of our respective amendments. I
believe many of us share the assessments

1007
01:46:22,194 --> 01:46:27,834
set out in the draft report. Our union is
facing a succession of shocks, including

1008
01:46:27,897 --> 01:46:33,310
the ongoing crisis in the Middle East,
whose consequences are waging heavily on

1009
01:46:33,384 --> 01:46:39,699
households and businesses alike. Mainly
through rising costs and persistent

1010
01:46:39,777 --> 01:46:45,148
uncertainty, in this context our dependence
on imported fossil fuels leaves our

1011
01:46:45,209 --> 01:46:51,108
economy exposed to external shocks. This
is precisely why Renew would like the

1012
01:46:51,181 --> 01:46:56,276
report to explicitly recognize the role
of the decarbonization transition in

1013
01:46:56,351 --> 01:47:01,924
reducing this vulnerability and helping
to ensure more stable energy costs.

1014
01:47:02,021 --> 01:47:07,511
Delivering this transition requires deeper
and better integrated capital markets,

1015
01:47:07,577 --> 01:47:13,982
completing the savings and investment union
must therefore remain a priority both to

1016
01:47:14,054 --> 01:47:19,939
mobilize the necessary financing for the
transition and to strengthen our economic

1017
01:47:20,021 --> 01:47:25,707
resilience. We will continue to advocate
for this throughout our negotiations.

1018
01:47:25,781 --> 01:47:32,236
Our amendments also reiterate the need to
give greater consolidation consideration

1019
01:47:32,313 --> 01:47:38,010
to the broader dimensions of the ECB's
mandate beyond its primary objective of

1020
01:47:38,081 --> 01:47:43,775
maintaining price stability. The ECB has
repeatedly acknowledged the importance of

1021
01:47:43,845 --> 01:47:47,714
supporting the union's
general economic policies.

1022
01:47:47,801 --> 01:47:53,102
At the same time, I would like to stress
that monetary policy must be conducted in

1023
01:47:53,171 --> 01:47:59,330
full respect of the ECB's independence,
including its freedom to choose its

1024
01:47:59,402 --> 01:48:06,311
instruments, its considers appropriate.
ECB's independence must indeed be understood

1025
01:48:06,401 --> 01:48:12,156
in its entirety and unconventional monetary
policy instrument must remain part of

1026
01:48:12,244 --> 01:48:18,773
its available toolkit. Finally, I would
once again like to thank the rapporteur for

1027
01:48:18,857 --> 01:48:23,621
this work. I remain fully available to
continue our constructive exchanges.

1028
01:48:24,221 --> 01:48:28,975
Our priority must remain clear: safeguarding
price stability and ensuring the

1029
01:48:29,040 --> 01:48:34,313
soundness of our financial system as both
are essential pillars of the European

1030
01:48:34,382 --> 01:48:38,591
Union's long-term prosperity
and strategic autonomy.

1031
01:48:38,681 --> 01:48:40,721
So this is on behalf of Gilles Boyer.

1032
01:48:42,341 --> 01:48:46,241
Thank you so much. I give the floor
to Rasmus Andreessen for the Greens.

1033
01:48:47,381 --> 01:48:52,988
Thank you so much. And also from our side,
thanks to the rapporteur for the draft

1034
01:48:53,041 --> 01:49:00,699
report and also for the first meeting. We
already had on the on the ECB report and

1035
01:49:00,777 --> 01:49:07,071
the different amendments. I
think this year the report will.

1036
01:49:07,121 --> 01:49:12,323
Be negotiated in an interesting time because
of the changes we will see at the top

1037
01:49:12,405 --> 01:49:19,312
of the ECB, but also on some of the other
posts which the ECB now has to or the

1038
01:49:19,384 --> 01:49:23,956
member states and the parliament
has to has to reflect on.

1039
01:49:24,041 --> 01:49:29,227
And I mean the report is not about
that, but I still think it gives us the

1040
01:49:29,304 --> 01:49:35,132
opportunity to reflect some of the recent
developments in monetary policy and

1041
01:49:35,210 --> 01:49:40,726
central banking. And that's also what had
been part of the amendments or is part of

1042
01:49:40,781 --> 01:49:47,156
the amendments we tabled. First of
all, on price stability, I want to.

1043
01:49:47,861 --> 01:49:51,895
I want to mention that especially for the
colleagues here who are concerned about

1044
01:49:51,941 --> 01:49:56,205
the issue on price stability
and I'm that as well.

1045
01:49:56,321 --> 01:50:01,725
I think it will be more and more important
also to reflect secondary objectives and

1046
01:50:01,787 --> 01:50:09,513
especially the role of our dependency on
fossil fuel energy and energy policy which

1047
01:50:09,572 --> 01:50:14,399
goes far beyond monetary policy but clearly
has an effect here and that's why we

1048
01:50:14,456 --> 01:50:17,933
tabled some amendments also on the
climate factor and climate risks.

1049
01:50:17,981 --> 01:50:25,436
We would like to see included in the
compromises secondly on I think we need further

1050
01:50:25,487 --> 01:50:35,659
reflections on the question on monetary
policy and fiscal coordination and thirdly

1051
01:50:35,751 --> 01:50:41,425
as one important priority for us also the
distributional impact of monetary policy

1052
01:50:41,496 --> 01:50:46,427
operations for example on housing and the
role of institutional investors and the

1053
01:50:46,481 --> 01:50:51,281
real estate markets is something where we
tabled amendments and where I think this

1054
01:50:51,371 --> 01:50:57,041
year's report should move forward and
should not stick to like some of the reports

1055
01:50:57,101 --> 01:51:02,681
we voted on but we should reflect further
and develop our position when it comes to

1056
01:51:02,741 --> 01:51:05,746
those aspects. I'm looking
forward to the next steps.

1057
01:51:05,801 --> 01:51:12,291
To see the compromises the rapporteur now
has to write and I'm looking forward also

1058
01:51:12,356 --> 01:51:14,981
to find find good and
stable compromises. Thanks.

1059
01:51:15,041 --> 01:51:16,241
Thank you so much.

1060
01:51:16,361 --> 01:51:18,881
Thank you so much. And I give
the floor back to the rapporteur.

1061
01:51:21,941 --> 01:51:27,370
Thank you to my colleagues. All the
proposals that were heard will be included in

1062
01:51:27,470 --> 01:51:31,135
this final text, which I believe
will be the guide for the '27.

1063
01:51:31,203 --> 01:51:32,403
Thank you very much.

1064
01:51:36,941 --> 01:51:41,734
Thank you. And the vote in the account
committee is planned for January 14.

1065
01:51:41,861 --> 01:51:48,721
Thank you to all of you. And the voting
session will take place at at 5 p.

1066
01:51:48,761 --> 01:51:49,961
m. in seven minutes.

1067
02:00:06,341 --> 02:00:13,001
Okay, colleagues, you can go back to your
seats so that we can proceed to the vote.

1068
02:00:18,941 --> 02:00:20,741
I will start with a test vote. Yes.

1069
02:00:22,361 --> 02:00:29,081
Okay, we will proceed to. A test vote.

1070
02:00:32,021 --> 02:00:36,641
Hi. Will. Proceed to a test vote.

1071
02:00:46,841 --> 02:00:54,814
I'm waiting for you. I'm waiting for
you. So I open the vote for a test vote.

1072
02:00:54,881 --> 02:00:56,141
The vote is opened.

1073
02:00:59,681 --> 02:01:00,881
Yes, yes, let's keep it.

1074
02:01:10,181 --> 02:01:16,402
A test vote, colleagues. Shh.
Okay, and I close the vote.

1075
02:01:16,481 --> 02:01:25,981
Okay, everything is working
well. Okay, we know.

1076
02:01:26,381 --> 02:01:38,467
Turn to the agenda. Item 8, amending
directive as regards the strengthening of the

1077
02:01:38,519 --> 02:01:43,075
framework for occupational
retirement provision.

1078
02:01:43,181 --> 02:01:49,690
We. Will start by showing off N of with
compromise A, who's in favor, who is

1079
02:01:49,789 --> 02:01:56,366
against, who abstain, adopted compromise
B, who is in favor, who is against, who

1080
02:01:56,441 --> 02:02:08,768
abstain, adopted compromise C, who is in
favor, who is against, levée, c'est pas

1081
02:02:08,826 --> 02:02:12,485
très grave. Mais pour le dernier
vote, attention, il y a...

1082
02:02:12,581 --> 02:02:16,869
Ah, maintenant il y a
trois PPE. On peut pas...

1083
02:02:17,021 --> 02:02:18,221
Il faut qu'ils enlèvent leur carte.

1084
02:02:18,461 --> 02:02:23,801
Il f yes, yes.

1085
02:02:45,221 --> 02:02:49,769
Okay, we begin one more time.
Compromise C, who is in favor?

1086
02:02:49,841 --> 02:02:54,933
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted
compromise D, who is in favor?

1087
02:02:55,001 --> 02:02:59,435
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted
compromise E, who is in favor?

1088
02:02:59,501 --> 02:03:04,053
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted
compromise F, who is in favor?

1089
02:03:04,121 --> 02:03:09,857
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted
compromise G, who is in favor?

1090
02:03:10,001 --> 02:03:16,315
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted
compromise H, who is in favor?

1091
02:03:16,421 --> 02:03:23,179
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted
compromise A, I, sorry, who is in favor?

1092
02:03:23,261 --> 02:03:36,037
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted and.
So we have a problem here, I'm sorry.

1093
02:03:36,161 --> 02:03:41,441
We have three EPP members.

1094
02:03:42,461 --> 02:03:43,121
Too many.

1095
02:03:43,121 --> 02:03:46,361
Too many. Actually,.

1096
02:03:47,081 --> 02:03:48,701
So they have to remove their cards.

1097
02:03:49,001 --> 02:03:51,641
So three members have
to remove their cards.

1098
02:03:55,181 --> 02:03:55,901
It's okay.

1099
02:03:55,901 --> 02:04:01,866
It's okay, thank you. So now, my dear
friends, we can proceed to the final vote, and

1100
02:04:01,923 --> 02:04:10,144
I open the vote by roll
call. The vote is open.

1101
02:04:10,541 --> 02:04:18,578
Vote is closed. And it is adopted.
Congratulations to the reporters, I mean,

1102
02:04:18,635 --> 02:04:26,765
Buzzliger, with 33 in favor. No vote. Now.

1103
02:04:26,861 --> 02:04:30,281
We vote on the mandate by
roll call. The vote is open.

1104
02:04:35,081 --> 02:04:36,281
31 members at least.

1105
02:04:38,261 --> 02:04:46,224
The vote. Is closed. And
the mandate is adopted.

1106
02:04:46,301 --> 02:05:02,883
Congratulations to the reporters. Now. We
now turn to the agenda item 9, the vote on

1107
02:05:02,928 --> 02:05:07,778
the draft report on the implementation
of the VAT reverse charge mechanism.

1108
02:05:07,841 --> 02:05:11,115
And before the vote, I give
the floor to the reporter, Mr.

1109
02:05:11,201 --> 02:05:14,501
Pierre Pompi. For one
minute. The floor is yours.

1110
02:05:17,021 --> 02:05:21,132
Very well. So, I will
express myself in French.

1111
02:05:21,232 --> 02:05:29,344
I just wanted to express one great regret,
because I think this is a simple subject.

1112
02:05:29,460 --> 02:05:37,093
So, as you know, this concerns VAT fraud,
so I think this is a subject that is

1113
02:05:37,187 --> 02:05:43,328
supposed to bring us together. It is
not a left-wing or right-wing issue or

1114
02:05:43,377 --> 02:05:50,017
whatever. And in fact, I regret that we
did not simply come up with a simple text.

1115
02:05:50,102 --> 02:05:58,369
Well, that’s part of the game, I
suppose. So, these are pretences.

1116
02:05:58,499 --> 02:06:08,013
It’s still the C. Still the body
where Sani Terre is against my group.

1117
02:06:08,109 --> 02:06:18,094
And so, here I am, regretting that we
did not prioritise the interests of the

1118
02:06:18,186 --> 02:06:19,841
people. That's all.

1119
02:06:21,581 --> 02:06:27,818
Thank you. The reporter. So we will start
the vote, and we will proceed by showing

1120
02:06:27,862 --> 02:06:32,453
off adds. Compromise
alternative A, who is in favor?

1121
02:06:32,561 --> 02:06:39,799
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted.
So we move directly to the compromise

1122
02:06:39,868 --> 02:06:43,170
alternative B, who is in
favor? Who is against?

1123
02:06:43,241 --> 02:06:49,775
Who abstain? Adopted. We move to
compromise alternative C, who is in favor?

1124
02:06:49,841 --> 02:06:54,885
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted.
Compromise alternative D, who is in favor?

1125
02:06:54,941 --> 02:07:01,346
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted.
Compromise alternative E, who is in favor?

1126
02:07:01,421 --> 02:07:07,010
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted.
Compromise alternative F, who is in favor?

1127
02:07:07,181 --> 02:07:12,460
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted.
Compromise alternative G, who is in favor?

1128
02:07:12,521 --> 02:07:19,615
Who is against? Who abstain? Adopted. And
we move to the final vote by roll call

1129
02:07:19,673 --> 02:07:33,499
vote. I open the vote.
And I close the vote.

1130
02:07:33,701 --> 02:07:38,295
And it is adopted.
Thank you to all of you.

1131
02:07:38,381 --> 02:07:44,096
The next second committee meeting
will take place on November 13.

1132
02:07:44,441 --> 02:07:48,221
And December 1st, 2026, in Brussels.

1133
02:11:45,341 --> 02:11:48,161
I don't think that.

1134
02:16:57,360 --> 02:16:58,560
I really wanted to say,

1135
02:17:16,500 --> 02:17:19,260
All right, the committee meeting of
the panel for the European Parliament.
