Brussels Live · Committee meeting EMPL 2026-11-09 Transcribed and translated automatically from the original sound. Mistakes are possible. Machine translation. The original is authoritative. Independent service, not affiliated with the European Parliament or the European Commission. Source: © European Union. AI-generated: Transcripts, translations and summaries on this site are generated automatically by AI: speech recognition (Soniox), machine translation and summaries (Mistral AI). Not edited by humans before publication. EU AI Act, Article 50. [15:19:50] Speaker 1 [EN] Okay, colleagues, we are already past our starting time, so I would be very happy to start. [15:19:57] Speaker 2 [EN] By the radio, so this. Excess— [15:20:01] Speaker 1 [EN] So we start with the adoption of the agenda, and if there are no objections, then the agenda of the meeting is deemed adopted. I see no objections, so it is adopted. For chair's announcements, you have been informed via the technical note about the interpretation provided today. And, dear colleagues, please be informed that speech-to-text automatic transcription and translation is available for accessibility purposes. Please scan the QR code on posters. And select the channel with the language being spoken. For translation, you can choose your preferred language from the available options on the menu. I would also like to draw your attention to the upcoming fourth edition of the Disability Rights Week, taking place on the 30th of November to 7th of December. The employment and social affairs committee will host a public hearing on inclusive education and employment for young persons with disabilities. And a workshop on EU social funding for disability inclusion. A high-level event on the 2nd of December will mark the 20th anniversary of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities under the theme "The EU as a Driver for Inclusion and Independent Living. " Ample members are also invited to the FEM hearing on women with disabilities in political and public life on the 3rd of December. On appointment of rapporteurs, please note that Jeroen Lenners from the EPP group has been appointed as rapporteur for the report on the revision of the European Labour Authority's mandate. Mark Angell from the S&D group has been appointed as rapporteur for the report on digitalization of the coordination of social security systems and establishment of the European Social Security Pass. Brigitte van den Berry from the Renew group has been appointed as rapporteur for the report on skills portability act. Sara Mathieu from the Greens EFA group has been appointed as rapporteur for the opinion to the public procurement regulation. And Laurence Farreng from the Renew group has been appointed as rapporteur for the opinion on the recognition of qualifications of third-country nationals. [15:22:08] Speaker 1 [EN] And Irena Joveva from the Renew group has been appointed as rapporteur for the opinion on digitalization of procedures for the recognition of professional qualifications. And that was all for the chair's announcements. Point number three is adoption of minutes. If there are no objections, the minutes of the ample meetings of first and 12th of October 2026 are deemed adopted. And they are adopted. We then move on to point number four, ample mission to Germany and Poland to visit Amazon warehouses. From the 26th to the 28th of October 2026, a delegation of seven members of the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs carried out a fact-finding mission to Amazon warehouses in Germany and Poland. I had the honor of chairing this mission. Also, very pleased that this mission took place. As we know, this has been a longstanding request from the Parliament. And we visited three major operational sites in Munchengladbach and Dortmund in Germany, and Sosnowiec near Katowice in Poland. The principal objective of the mission was to examine on-site working conditions, occupational health and safety standards, the application of algorithmic management systems, and the extent of automated worker monitoring across Amazon's European warehouses network. The visit served as a direct follow-up to the ample committee's parliamentary hearing on working conditions at Amazon held in January 2026, where workers and social partners raised severe concerns regarding rising productivity targets, workplace surveillance, and barriers to collective bargaining. During the mission, we conducted walk-throughs of operational departments, engaged with site general managers, and regional corporate executives, and held extensive off-site consultation sessions with trade union representatives, work councils, and labor inspectors. I will soon give the floor to the members that were participating in this mission, but on a personal note, I really think one of the main takeaways from this mission was the difficulty also for us to get information about the algorithmic management [15:24:23] Speaker 1 [EN] system used to monitor workflow. And work performance at these warehouses. And also the fact that workers themselves did not either have that information or information about how, for example, productivity targets are set and why productivity targets increase or very rarely decrease. So this really, in my opinion, strengthened the case and shows the need for rules on algorithmic management and AI in working life. And we will, of course, also use the evidence and testimonies gathered during this mission to inform this committee's legislative work. In particular, on the European Commission's upcoming quality jobs act legislative package expected in December 2026. The post-mission report will be accompanied by a chair's letter to President Metsola and commission executive vice president Minsatu, highlighting the need for robust legislation on the use of algorithmic management in the world of work, to be adequately addressed in the forthcoming commission proposal for a quality jobs act. So I will now open the floors to the members who participated in the mission. Please indicate if you wish to take the floor and we will try and keep the contributions to one minute, please. Starting with Mrs. Sommer. [15:25:45] Liesbet Sommen (PPE) [EN] Thank you, Chair, and good afternoon, everyone. First of all, I would really like to thank all of the organizers of our ample committee for this mission. It was really interesting, our Amazon mission to Germany in Poland. It was really interesting, but also deeply concerning. In what we've heard there, what we struck me most was actually the enormous pressure under which Amazon employees are working. We heard very similar testimonies from workers and trade unions in both countries, which was really remarkable. They say that workers are constantly monitored through scanners and algorithms, and every movement, every task, and every minute of inactivity seems to be measured. Workers are pushed to work faster and harder. And this comes, of course, with a serious cost to their physical and mental health. In Poland, workers told us that they sometimes have to walk up to 30 kilometers per day. In every automated warehouse, the walking is reduced, but the work becomes extremely repetitive. And as one worker put it, they have become part of the robot. It seems. We also heard very worrying testimonies about pressure on sick workers, insufficient rest breaks, and intimidation of trade union representatives. And of course, these are testimonies that deserve further investigation. But the consistency of what we heard in both countries should concern us all. And that is exactly what you say, Chair. This was a fact-finding mission, and that is what concerns us, that the facts didn't seem to be on the table. We had testimonies, we had input from Amazon, but our questions that we asked there were not really answered. And it is very difficult from a legislative point of view to know how to act in this regard. But we need to act; that is clear. And I want to make one thing very clear. I am not against technology or automation, not at all. On the contrary, innovation can improve productivity, create opportunities, and make work safer. But technology must always serve people and not the other way around. [15:28:02] Liesbet Sommen (PPE) [EN] So I look forward to the follow-up on this mission. Like you say in the quality jobs act, both regarding the specific concerns raised about the working conditions at Amazon and also more broadly how we can ensure that AI and algorithmic management are used responsibly in workplaces across Europe. Thank you. [15:28:24] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much, Mrs. Kelemens. [15:28:27] Speaker 2 [FR] Thank you, Madam President. I would also like to join in, in any case, the thanks that have been addressed to the Employment Secretariat for organising this mission. We knew that it was going to be an additional challenge, so it was a bit of a whirlwind between Germany and Poland, but I really want to thank them for the quality of this organisation. So, Amazon at least gave the impression that they were playing the transparency game and actually opening their warehouses as they probably never do. But on the other hand, I think we are not fooled. We were mainly received by an army of communications experts. They prepared three or four PowerPoints, which were pretty much always the same, in each of the companies we visited. And above all, no concrete answers to our questions. When we actually go on a mission, a fact-finding mission that concerns working conditions, the impact on health, working hours, the status of workers, and we cannot even be given a precise and exact answer as to how many workers are employed, with what status, what the levels of absenteeism are. So, very clearly, we do not have, and above all, no answer to a question. Or in any case, just a denial, even though we were able to see that this was not the case. Do you also use the algorithm, not only to organise the work and the workflow, but also to control the workers? Even though they kept telling us no, it was very, very clear that this was the case, particularly in terms of its impact on break times and other matters. So, in Germany too, there has been a very clear refusal to negotiate collective agreements. That was made very clear to us. In Germany too, they have used sites – these are the sites neighbouring Poland – to weaken a strike movement or to undermine a strike movement. So we also see the attacks against trade union organisations. [15:30:19] Speaker 2 [FR] In Poland, there are problems even with the organisation of the right to strike and, above all, clear evidence of constant surveillance via cameras, pressure being put on working conditions and wage conditions. So, yes, I think we will also take our responsibilities in the Employment Committee to follow up on this mission. You also thank you, Madam President, and we know that an initiative must be taken because more than ever, in the Quality Jobs Act, we must have better oversight of algorithmic management. If there is one example that has shown us this, it is indeed that of Amazon's warehouses. Thank you. [15:30:56] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. And next, Mrs. Scheibe. [15:31:02] Speaker 2 [FR] Thank you. Hello to everyone. And I would like to join in thanking the secretariat for organising this mission. It was really extremely well organised, a very interesting mission. So, Amazon’s management had also very well organised and prepared this mission. They did everything to make us feel like we were in Amazon’s wonderful world, where all employees are happy, where there are no problems at all. It really was a dream company. And so, we were clearly treated to a staged performance, a carefully controlled tour. And I just want to share this little anecdote with you. On the second day, when we were in Poland, we were visiting the warehouse there. So, the warehouse was quite empty. We were saying, ‘Look, look, there aren’t many people in this warehouse.’ At one point, they stopped us in front of an employee who was packing items. And I tell you, he was like this. So, completely calm. And then they tell us: [15:31:57] Speaker 2 [EN] « There is no rush. Look, it's always like that. » [15:32:00] Speaker 2 [FR] So, we say: 'Well, okay, yes, it's true, indeed, it's a bit going against what we saw the day before.' And then we learn from the employees, the workers with whom we had a meeting afterwards, the trade union representatives, that management Amazon management had offered all employees a day off for that day, and those who were present on site had received a text message telling them: 'Go to the canteen, hide in the canteen, and we will assign you another location so that you do not cross paths with the Members of the European Parliament.' So, that is quite something, hats off. When we then questioned the representatives, the armada of public relations officers, all these people who were accompanying us—there were many of them, from communications—about the issues, there were no problems. It is not even a case of saying: ‘Yes, there are problems, we will try to work on them.’ There are no problems. The noise level, no, no, no, the noise level is not high. You get used to it. You know, it is like when you live next to an airport, you get used to it. Repetitive tasks, we are told: ‘No, but there is rotation, there is rotation.’ Algorithmic management? They even told us: ‘It does not exist. No, there is no algorithmic management. It does not exist.’ So it was still quite strong stuff and very, very caricatured. The thing is, the moment we stepped outside the beaten path on the first visit, we went to see the workers, and we immediately came across a woman who was working in the picking section — that’s where you take products from the shelves, extract them, and then they’re put into packaging. And indeed, it’s a workshop that’s a robotised warehouse, and they’re proud to say that the employees no longer have to walk the 30 kilometres a day they used to when they had to go into the aisles. But what do we actually see? We see people who are at the service of, who are slaves to, the robot. [15:33:38] Speaker 2 [FR] In fact, they are trampling on a two-square-metre space at breakneck speed, in conditions that are nothing short of slavery, with truly infernal rhythms. And just to conclude, when we speak to the workers—we were fortunate enough to speak to them—they give us a very different account of the wonderful world we witnessed. In other words, the so-called rotation between posts? There isn’t any. The noise levels, the measurements were taken not where the workers are actually working. So, for me, this mission—well, I hope that the report to be drawn up by the secretariat will reflect exactly what the workers told us: what you saw was nothing but window dressing, pure and simple. Thank you. [15:34:18] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. And Mr. Andersson. [15:34:25] Li Andersson (The Left) [EN] Yeah, thanks a lot. I also want to thank our secretariat for a great job and also Yuli for her leadership of the mission. And additionally, to what colleagues mentioned, I would like to, let's say, add three topics. The first one is massive in my opinion, huge use of temporary work agencies regarding in the case of Polish factory. If I don't know if you knew, however, the Polish Amazon doesn't publish single vacancy this year. Every vacancies which are published, I mean, publicly accessible are published by temporary work agencies. So there is a huge use of temporary workers for benefit of Amazon's without let's say reasonable reasons why not to hire workers directly to the Amazon. Also seasonal workers are very questionable in Amazon. It is absolutely no clear where is really a season for the Amazon, even if they told us in Katowice that the season starts in, I don't know, November and finish in January. In fact, under the, let's say, the label of seasonal workers, they use thousands of workers throughout the year. The second topic is very visible prevention of trade unions from operations on site. We received very particular, very, very broad reports of trade unionists, how they are prevented from any single operation regarding to workers, how they are under pressure regarding to their work with the people working in Amazon. Yeah, I know. And the final different working conditions between Germany and Poland, just one example. This operational or production cycle for German workers has been set up for five seconds and for Polish workers for three seconds. I want to say that they did should be also addressed in a fair this fair jobs documents which are expected to be presented by the government. I absolutely understand that there are different remuneration across the Europe, but there is no reason why such basic working conditions like is production cycle should be so hugely different between East and West Europe. So non-fair Conditions for East Europeans has been also very clearly the result of this mission. [15:37:35] Li Andersson (The Left) [EN] Thank you. [15:37:38] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. And thank you also to all the members who participated in the mission and as was already stated, we will now prepare the written mission report. And in the meeting, we will proceed to the next point on the agenda, which is the public hearing. So I now have the pleasure to start our public hearing on the occupational exposure to pesticides among agricultural workers in the EU. The effects of pesticides on human health have been documented for a long time, linking them to an increased risk of cancers and neurodegenerative diseases. Such as Parkinson's or Alzheimer's. These are matters with which other committees in this house, such as Agri, Envy, and SANT, have also been dealing and we therefore invited them to join us today. However, our focus this afternoon will be to take an ample perspective to these hazards namely how agricultural workers are or can be protected against the risks arising from the risks of pesticides. Of course, the best cure is always prevention as such the hierarchy of measures within the Ausländerbesetzung prioritizes the avoidance or the minimization of risks mirroring in a way the principle of preventive action in EU's environmental policy, as enshrined in the treaties. Setting market rules aside, from a labor law perspective, employers are required to assess relevant risks to the safety and health of workers arising from pesticides and manage these risks in accordance with the hierarchy of controls. But how are the different rules interacting with each other in this cross-cutting fields given that agriculture is among the sectors of economic activity more exposed to cancer risk factors and other diseases linked to the use of pesticides? And above all, how can we do better? To answers to answer these questions, I'm very happy to welcome our distinguished guest speakers today. From European Agency for Safety and Health at Work, Pesticides Action Europe, the European Federation of Food, Agriculture and Tourism Trade Unions, and the Employers Group of Professional Agricultural Organizations, in the European Union. [15:39:59] Speaker 1 [EN] We will first hear from our guest speakers and then I will open the floor for ample coordinators or other group representatives and then we will do another round with catch the eye where also Envy, SANT, and Agri members are invited to take the floor. But Mr. Bogdan Zeleny from Brussels Liaison Manager at EU OSHA will be our first speakers to set the scene. Summarizing EU OSHA's findings on the topic. So please, you have the floor for the first seven to eight minutes. [15:40:28] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the Employment and Social Affairs Committee for organizing this debate. My name is Bogdan Zeleny. I'm the Brussels Liaison Manager for the European Agency for Safety and Health and as you say, we are we are tasked with protecting workers and ensuring they have safe and healthy workplaces. If we can go to the next slide, just a couple of words for our agency. How do we do this? We provide evidence, data, and research to policymakers such as yourselves. We transform it into guidance and tools for workplaces. And we try to raise awareness, conduct information campaigns, and networking to get the good practices across the Europe. And this is because we still have a high incidence of workplace fatality fatal accidents illnesses and deaths related to workplace. And beyond the human cost, still what we estimate around 3. 3% of GDP of the EU is lost due to what we call bad OSH. Before I dive into the pesticides, itself, next slide please, I want to give you an overview of the agricultural of the occupational exposures that agricultural workers face. Because the pesticide discussion has to be taken into the wider context of the risks affecting the sector. So in our workers exposure survey, where we check the probable exposure to at least one of 24 occupational cancer risk factors, we found that people working in the crop, animal production, hunting, and related services, so very much the sector, face a probable exposure to at least one cancer risk factor of 84. 4% during a normal work week, which is almost double than the average in the EU. And if we go to the next slide, we can check that this can overlap. It means that during agricultural work, there are a number of risks that are overlapping in a more severe severe manner. And this is way before we talk to about pesticides. So give an example of farmer tilling a field on a tractor is maybe exposed to diesel exhaust fumes. UV radiation crystalline respirable silica that is raised up from the soil and that is before probable [15:42:38] Speaker 2 [EN] exposure also to any eventual pesticides. That's just to give you an idea of the complexity of the discussion and the importance to take all risks into account when going forward to discussing prevention. Having said that, on pesticides themselves, if we go to the next slide, how does exposure happen? And again, here is very important to have a holistic approach. When you talk about exposure to pesticides, it happens at all points. It can happen at all points of the process, so on transportation, storage, containers, handling, mixing, loading the containers, and then of course the actual act of spraying, handling equipment where there's a high chance of exposure, but also afterwards after application when there's cleaning equipment, transportation again of the empty containers, but also people who are entering treated crops bystanders, what we call, can also be subjected to exposure. And it happens through dermal exposure, inhalation, and ingestion. The negative ill effects of the health we can see in the next slide stemming from this risks can be acute and also longer term. When you talk about acute exposure, it causes irritation, respiratory symptoms, headaches, dizziness, and in serious cases poisoning, fainting, and so on, worse worse symptoms. But also there can be longer term exposure effects. And there are associations reported with neurological outcomes such as Parkinson's disease, respiratory outcomes, certain cancers, but also endocrine or reproductive exposures. Now, EU OSHA promotes we can go to the next slide, promotes prevention and risk assessment as the cornerstone of the way that workers are prevented. When it comes to pesticides themselves, there's a product specific assessment. And I suspect a lot of my fellow panelists will dive deeper into this topic here. And then there's a workplace risk assessment that has to follow as the chair said, the hierarchy of controls where we prioritize measures at the source. So starting with anything, ideally elimination of the product, substitution, adaptation, or [15:44:44] Speaker 2 [EN] isolations at the source. We can talk about technical measures afterwards. We can this is called a hierarchy. Some people talk call it a pyramid, but the bottom line is that there's always steps to to be taken at every level. And the next one can be organizational measures where we train workers better. We can promote segregation from the source or temporal measures. Although it must be said when it comes to pesticides, for example, temporal measures in other workplaces can mean that workers can take shifts to rotate. When it comes to pesticides, that can actually make it worse. And I'm giving you this this example just to again underline the complexity of ensuring adequate protection. And then there are of course personal protective equipment. We all think about that when we think about OSH. That's one of the components of the actual prevention when it comes to to workers. Now, this is all done in a wider ecosystem of risks. And if you go to the next slide, we have to be aware that pesticides themselves are can be subjected to a wide number of factors. So climate change itself is a shift is a change that can modify exposure. So weather, temperature, and wind influence exposure during application. And the shifting patterns of weather might see in the future and we will have probably reports coming out in the in the coming year as well on how changing pest patterns might have to change treatment patterns. And beyond that can influence pesticides themselves. Some could become volatile from extreme heat. The protective equipment of workers could be damaged. And so on and so forth. So there's a big need to understand that in this wider debate we have to it's it's a living debate. It's not something that is is finalized at any point. And adequate prevention has to continually adapt to the changing patterns. I mean, we're talking about agriculture. It's a it's a work that anyway follows a season, but due to the the wider discussion on climate change, there's an extra need for attention here. There's of course a workforce dynamics. [15:46:50] Speaker 2 [EN] There's a lot of seasonal and migrant work. Employed also in small farms or people who are self-employed. There's language and training barriers. Thinking back on the hierarchy of prevention where training is very very important to prevent risks. And also there can be unequal access to protection. And last in this discussion on transitions and shifts, we have to be aware that in risk prevention, one measure that prevents one risk can engender other risks. So lowering pesticide use in in some cases may lead for example to the need to do manual weed control tasks that can have musculoskeletal strain risk. So any measures and any discussions have to be done again in a holistic manner ideally. Now we at EU OSHA and we can go to my next slide. Promote very much part. Approach to discussion. We provide our evidence. So the workers exposure survey findings on agriculture, an article that I think was shared with you before the the hearing today. We have something called an OSH wiki which I would encourage you all to check. Beyond that, we produce practical tools and we have something called an online risk interactive risk assessment tool that we developed actually with the organization of my fellow panelists. So the trade unions and the employers in agriculture that helps assess some of the risks in agriculture and can be used by the way for free by anybody online. And we cooperate with the wide network of partners to to review such evidence and then adapt always the guidelines and the tools that we put out. And I encourage you all to check out the the rev the research that we put out and I look forward very much to your questions. I I'm very happy to see I kept to the eight minutes and I look forward to the rest of the debate. Thank you. [15:48:33] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you very much. Very interesting and very clear I think. I would now like to welcome Mrs. Christine de Champelaire whose policy officer at Pesticide Action Europe a science-based NGO on EU level working on on alternatives to pesticides to present Pan Europe's data and analysis for the next seven to eight minutes please. [15:48:55] Speaker 3 [EN] Thank you very much. Also for the invitation and for the organization of of this event on a very pressing and urgent topic. So indeed Pan Europe is a civil society organization and we focus on raising awareness on the harmful impacts of pesticides we advocate for a robust protection and phasing out dependency on harmful pesticides replacing them with sound alternatives. We can go to the next slide please. Yeah and to the third slide. Thank you. So scientific evidence has shown clear links between exposure to pesticides and a variety of diseases which include for example neurodegenerative diseases such as Parkinson's disease certain cancers cognitive disorders respiratory system disorders and then available data also show that some groups like farm workers their families but also other citizens living in rural areas are more exposed. And data show then also for example from epidemiological studies that certain diseases and health impacts are more prevalent among people who have been professionally exposed to pesticides such as farm workers. And it's also very important to emphasize that also children are particularly vulnerable because their organs are still developing they have a lot of hand mount contact and studies also show a strong presumption of a link between pesticide exposure during childhood but also during for the pregnancy with certain diseases such as certain pediatric cancers. But also development disorders for example. We can go to the next slide please. So the numbers are really alarming. We we we really can say I think we can speak here really of a major public health challenge. And the numbers for example on Parkinson's how they are have been been steeply decreasing also the projections to doubling by 2050 are very worrying. The same for cancer numbers also cancers for people under 50 years old for example with with younger people have also been increasing and they see for both of these types of conditions also a link with with pesticide exposure. Yeah we can go to the next slide. [15:51:14] Speaker 3 [EN] And of course these these numbers are alarming but it's it's good to to always think of like that behind every of these numbers there is a life there's a person and their families and every of these very serious diseases of course is really a yeah a drama for farmers. Their their families other people involved and also people beyond farmers who have also been exposed to pesticides. [15:51:38] Speaker 1 [EN] Sorry the translator are asking for a little bit of a slower pace. [15:51:41] Speaker 3 [EN] Okay I will go. Thank you. We can go to the next slide. So there are severe shortcomings in risk assessment and implementation of pesticide regulation. So while the the primary objective of these regulation is to ensure a high level of protection and is also explicitly underpinned by the precautionary principle in practice yeah this this has in many ways been failing and we see major shortcomings there and this is also very clearly shown by the fact that very regularly pesticide have had to be banned in the past because there are serious hazardous properties had not been well identified during the the authorization the risk assessment and authorization process. So we see that reprotoxic neurotoxic endocrine disrupting pesticides reach the market and often stay there also for quite a long time until they're finally again reviewed. We can go to the next slide. So these shortcomings I won't go in detail on all of them but they include the fact that mixture of pesticides combined effects are not well included in current risk assessment neither is chronic as exposure also to low level of pesticides for a long amount of time co-formulant so the additives that are added to pesticide products beyond active substance are not well assessed for their toxicity this is not taken into account and it's important that these shortcomings have also been really underlined by consortia of researchers working on this topic and we really recommend to to urgently close these loopholes. We can go to the next slide. Here I also won't go through all the the examples given here but it's important to show examples of many particularly hazardous pesticides who are still on the market. For example endocrine disrupting pesticides by law they actually have to be banned but in practice they remain on the market and and banning is taking a really long time and these are substances of which experts also say we cannot really define safe concentrations because they can already at very low concentrations have important [15:53:53] Speaker 3 [EN] effects important negative effects on health and we see for example that then the directive on CMRs to protect against CMRs at work also focuses on for example reprotox one B substances but we have also even some reprotoxic one B pesticides which are still authorized today. We can go to the next slide. Then about. Protective equipment is is really essential of course but it's important that there has been quite some research on how it's definitely not a silver bullet and and really a miracle solution for exposure. So studies show some data show also that sometimes exposure gets even higher because of the field situations farmers are in. So it's possible that in a protective equipment overall for example inside the concentration gets higher than outside. And it's also important to not lay the responsibility with individual farmers because of course we have to ensure they are not exposed during their work to particularly hazardous pesticides. We can go to the next slide. This I shortly want to mention because these are other key shortcomings in implementation we see. For example the implementation of the sustainable use of pesticides directive is lacking behind. We also have no spatially explicit digital pesticide use data while this is of course a key foundation we need otherwise we cannot well see what exposure can be expected where we cannot measure the benefits of certain policy actions so we really need this urgently. And also the common agricultural policy we find that there's really not a clear link there has been not a clear link with reducing and phasing out harmful pesticides and there's also a lack of adequate social conditionality which EFAT will also further look into I think. We can go to the next slide. There is a certainly also a lack of recognition and support for victims of pesticide exposure only a few members states have taken steps in in this regard for example especially France even in countries recognition it stays difficult and for many for many patients to get them the right compensations it's a [15:56:23] Speaker 3 [EN] very long process but so an important message is it's only in three member states and Belgium is currently working on this there is no not an EU wide recognition and also the recommended list of occupational diseases we see that pesticides is overall not included there nor is a disease as for example Parkinson's for which there's really a lot of evidence of over the links. We can go to the next slide. Then I would like to mention also the omnibus X as many of you know which would make a lot of significant changes to the authorization process. We see that that there would be really detrimental weakenings and while we need better protection we would move in the opposite direction and an example is unlimited approvals of pesticides of course it's it's very much needed and I think evident for everyone to understand that we have to regularly look again at at substances which are designed to be toxic to have toxic effects and these scientific evidence is continuously progressing if we don't do that then we really turn our back also to farm workers because it's actually saying we don't really care about new scientific evidence and this has been met with severe critique from scientists civil society farmers also victims of pesticide exposure and health organizations as Parkinson's Europe we can go to the next slide. Then to finalize the recommendations we we see three major lines of actions so first to prevent the use of an exposure to toxic pesticides so this means addressing these key shortcomings in the pesticide regulation and in the implementation of the pesticides use directive this it's also key that member states ensure enough staff to meet these regulatory deadlines and adequate fees we need spatial accessible digital pesticide use data second point is that there is really a need for an EU wide framework for recognition recognition sorry and compensations of compensation of victims of pesticide exposure and here we think it's key that financial compensation is also carried by manufacturers according [15:58:41] Speaker 3 [EN] to to the polluters space principle and then a third point is that we recommend to reject the omnibus as we need much better protection not less against harmful pesticides and we think this would be a historical retreat of protection thank you very much for your time. [15:58:59] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much and next I give the floor to Mr. Ivan Ivanov who's a general secretary of European Federation of Food Agriculture and Tourism Trade Union who will give us the views of workers organizations in the agricultural sector on relevant data collected from their member organizations as well as on relevant rules notably occupational health and safety ones as well as the perspective on the future so please you have the floor for the next seven to eight minutes. [15:59:25] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you. [15:59:25] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you very much chair and thank you very much for the invitation to talk about this important topic maybe we go to the next slide I mean the I think the first two slides are basically representing EFAT just to say that we are the European umbrella organization of trade unions in the sectors food agriculture tourism and domestic work we have 120 national trade unions affiliated to our federation from 40 different countries and I think I'm not going to spend much of my time on presenting EFAT but I think the presentation you have it already maybe we go two slides further and to the topic of of today's hearing and this is exposure to pesticides of farm workers I would like to start start my presentation with outlining few sector specificities which inter interacts with with exposure of to pesticides among farm workers first of all we speak about agricultural sector we speak about the sector where we still encounter over 30% of share of undeclared work this is estimate by the platform for undeclared work which is under the umbrella of the European labor authority and you can imagine that being let's say in a employed in an informal setting I think that this also the occupation of healthy and safe framework is is usually not applied so 30% of the workforce we can we can assume does not benefit let's say from from the European OSH framework which which which we have in in place then secondly estimate by the European Economic and Social Committee we have a sector where we have a high a significant share of migrant and seasonal workforce we have different estimates here but I think the European Economic and Social Committee speaking of 2. 4 million seasonal workers in the European agriculture and we know that seasonal and migrant workers they are more vulnerable usually they are less aware of their rights as as workers and in that respect they are also more prone to to non-compliance with labor provisions and exploitation and less likely to report any any violations and any disrespect of their of their of their [16:01:50] Speaker 2 [EN] rights. Then talking still about agriculture we we spoke about very fragmented sector with let's say family farms being the most predominant form and and. Subsequently also low frequency and of inspections which take place in in agricultural sector we have a figure for one particular member state I'm not knowing to disclose which one but they are we have find out that only 0.024% of the companies in agricultural sector have been expect inspected on on annual basis so we have also because of that many gaps when it comes to implementation and enforcement of labor provisions. So when it comes to yeah to the exposure to pesticides and the direct causes we don't have very reliable data from from the European from the European statistics but some some good estimates which point out to 1. 6 million cases of unintentional pesticides poisoning in Europe each year this is an estimate which was done by by Pan Germany but also by Heinrich Böll Foundation in Germany which is a significant number and still the authors of the study also point out that they assume that there'll be also high share of underreporting also within this within this figure as my colleague from Pan Europe said quite often when it comes about when we talk about the direct exposure we always refer to the protective equipment as let's say as the most widespread widespread protective measure but actually this is this the last resort when it when we take let's say the hierarchy of risk controls under the occupational safety and health framework and as my previous speaker said we have also evidence there that let's say the the mitigating effect of personal protective equipment might be also heavily over overestimated and so far we have spoken a lot about the direct impacts the direct effect of pesticides exposure but what about the long term effects like diseases like Parkinson Alzheimer but also cancer we also heard Parkinson is also recognized in only three member states in the European in the European country which is far from from enough so we go maybe to the next slide which goes a bit to the [16:04:17] Speaker 2 [EN] what what needs to be done from our perspective to enhance the protection of farm workers first of all surely we need to improve the implementation implementation of both of pesticides legislation and I think my previous speaker touch upon it but also of the occupational safety and health framework and for that we have been also engaging also with EU OSHA and but also with our social partner from the employers in developing an online risk assessment tool to facilitate conducting a risk assessment in the workplace so we need to such tools to be adapted to the national level but also widely promoted and I think this is also part of our work program of the European sector of social dialogue which we are having also with our social partners but secondly I think it's out of question that we we can also the existing pesticides rules which we have at at the moment so that's why also EFAT is firmly against adopting the the omnibus 10 package and in particular the provisions which concern the pesticides regulation I was referring also to the hierarchy of risk controls and actually as I said the protective equipment comes as the last but actually the elimination of substitution of the risk is actually the has the highest the highest priority even before protective and prevention preventive measures and I think for that reason also EFAT has been very active and collaborating with civil society organizations also from an environmental spectrum to argue for policies for just transition away from hazardous pesticides second. We also see and know that let's say this preventive and protective measures they might come to too late for some some workers which have been for long been exposed to pesticides and for that reason we need also to better recognize and compensate also occupational diseases linked to pesticides exposure that would be the case for instance with with with Parkinson which needs to be also from our perspective recognized as occupational disease not only three countries but in in in in entire Europe Germany was let's say the [16:06:25] Speaker 2 [EN] last from the three countries which recently introduced and formalized the recognition of Parkinson as occupational disease and we already have indications of 300 potential cases in the first year of application and I think we have an instrument at the European level that will be the European semester for occupational diseases which needs to to be updated but also turn into a binding instrument to provide for a harmonized list of occupational diseases at European level we also think that we need to facilitate the recognition of occupational diseases at the moment it's also also in the countries where we have Parkinson for instance recognized occupational disease for workers is particular burdensome to to prove this as and for that we have having also arguing for workers for farm workers to have a right to a document which outlines also the chemicals and pesticides used during their professional activity so that it facilitates also the recognition of occupational diseases and another point which we also believe it's essential is that we need to leverage the different policy fields to enhance the protection of farm workers from pesticides exposure we talked about a lot of pesticides pesticides regulations about occupational safety and health regulations but I think we also need to leverage the common agricultural policy and to strengthen also the social conditionality which we managed to introduce in the last revision of the common agricultural policy as it has also an important occupational safety and health pillar in it and as a last point I think we need also to assume our responsibility at the global level and pesticides which are produced here but banned in Europe we need yeah we should stop exporting them also to to third countries and I end here and I'm at your disposal for any questions and comments thank you very much and I now turn to Mrs. Claudia Melino who is remotely connected and as the president of employers group of professional agricultural organizations in the European Union she will give us the views of employers organizations in the [16:08:28] Speaker 2 [EN] agriculture sector on relevant data and relevant rules notably the occupational health and safety ones and also perspectives for the future so please you have the floor for the next seven to eight minutes grazie buon buon pomeriggio Claudia Merlino presidente Geopa il Geopa è il gruppo europeo dei datori di lavoro delle organizzazioni professionali agricole e ha l'incarico della commissione riconosciuto dalla commissione per il dialogo sociale settoriale che svolgiamo ogni giorno praticamente con i nostri amici dell'EFAT io vorrei iniziare questa questa audizione ringraziando per l'occasione con una affermazione molto chiara da parte nostra ed è la seguente per i datori di lavoro agricoli europei la salute e la sicurezza dei lavoratori agricoli e degli agricoltori rappresenta una priorità assoluta è stato detto va detto che l'agricoltura è un settore estremamente diversificato è un settore caratterizzato da presenza di lavoratori autonomi di lavoratori familiari manodopera stagionale manodopera dei paesi terzi aziende con dimensioni molto diverse con sistemi produttivi molto diversi riteniamo che queste caratteristiche debbano essere considerate anche nella prevenzione dell'esposizione ai pesticidi e ai prodotti fitosanitari ed è per questo che vorrei concentrarmi su quattro messaggi principali il primo messaggio riguarda a nostro avviso il ruolo della prevenzione sappiamo. Sapete come gli agricoltori e i lavoratori agricoli affrontano quotidianamente tanti rischi i parassiti le malattie delle piante le erbe infestanti e sono quotidianamente impegnati nella produzione di alimenti che siano sufficienti e che siano sicuri ecco il primo aspetto è questo la modalità di utilizzo dei prodotti fitosanitari a nostro avviso è fondamentale il modo in cui il prodotto viene manipolato le attrezzature vengono impiegate e le pratiche di lavoro adottate sono tutti elementi per noi rilevanti per ridurre l'esposizione e questo è il motivo è stato già detto per cui abbiamo una essenziale bisogno di formazione adeguata [16:11:03] Speaker 2 [EN] sull'applicazione sicura di questi prodotti è altresì chiaro che noi riconosciamo in modo molto molto evidente il ruolo fondamentale che ha in questa difesa la difesa integrata delle culture combiniamo pratiche agricole per il controllo degli organismi nocivi e ci basiamo naturalmente sul principio che il prodotto chimico deve venire come un come ultima soluzione questo per noi è chiaro è stato detto abbiamo la possibilità di ruotare le culture l'impiego di varietà che sono resistenti la gestione del suolo sono tutti elementi che contribuiscono questo è indubbio a ridurre la dipendenza dai trattamenti chimici va detto anche però che la difesa integrata deve rimanere concretamente applicabile e praticabile per i datori di lavoro il che significa devono essere disponibili i prodotti devono esserci una sostenibilità economica degli stessi prodotti e anche un'efficacia che va misurata nelle condizioni che siano reali il secondo aspetto riguarda l'esposizione ecco noi riteniamo che per valutare il rischio il rischio effettivo per i lavoratori è necessario considerare ovviamente la pericolosità dei prodotti e delle sostanze ma anche le condizioni di esposizione e e le misure che sono disponibili per ridurre questa esposizione ci sono le stesse linee guida dell'EFSA che per esempio confermano l'importanza di valutare l'esposizione dei lavoratori che rientrano nelle culture dopo i trattamenti e qui si evidenzia la necessità di misure che siano adeguate di prevenzione ed è anche in questa prospettiva che gli agricoltori europei nel l'anno scorso nel 2025 hanno chiesto di attribuire maggiore centralità alla valutazione dell'esposizione poi è naturale che occorre concentrarsi su ciò che può ridurre l'esposizione abbiamo tecnologie molto utili i sistemi per esempio antideriva la robotica possono contribuire in modo molto concreto a ridurre l'esposizione dei lavoratori e i risultati sono misurabili vorrei citare due risultati importanti a nostro avviso come un orientamento da seguire una strada da seguire lo studio dell'anno scorso [16:13:24] Speaker 2 [EN] dell'università di Torino ha per esempio confrontato una irrorazione di tipo convenzionale con quella ottimizzata nei vigneti e nei frutteti e si sono rilevate delle riduzioni di esposizione per inalazione fino all'85% e dell'esposizione della pelle quindi cutanea fino al 91% un altro esempio una ricerca europea sul sul campo con i sistemi di trasferimento cosiddetto chiuso dei prodotti fitosanitari ha dimostrato che durante la preparazione e il caricamento di questi prodotti è possibile ridurre drasticamente l'esposizione del 90% o addirittura quasi del 100% utilizzando dei sistemi particolari contenitori capovolti sistemi con estrazione mediante sonda ecco questi sono degli esempi per dimostrare di come l'esposizione da una parte sia un fattore da considerare determinante e dall'altra parte ci possano essere misure molto concrete molto pratiche che la possono ridurre il terzo punto riguarda l'accesso ad alternative efficaci vorrei citarlo sappiamo tutti bene come l'agricoltura europea stia oggi attraversando una transizione molto importante verso cosa verso una protezione delle culture che sia più sostenibile prodotti per il controllo biologico sostanze a basso rischio tecnologie digitali ecco la nostra cautela è quella di essere realistici sui tempi di questa transizione perché i prodotti alternativi possono richiedere molto tempo prima di arrivare sul mercato e diventare delle soluzioni da una parte competitive e dall'altra parte effettivamente praticabili e non è un caso che lo stesso parlamento europeo ha adottato una risoluzione lo scorso anno nel quale evidenzia per esempio per le soluzioni biologiche che le autorizzazioni possono richiedere fino a 10-15 anni e questo è un problema sebbene l'omnibus che è stato citato punti a semplificare l'autorizzazione delle sostanze a basso rischio è fondamentale che gli agricoltori possano continuare a mantenere strumenti che siano efficaci per proteggere le culture perché questo ha se no conseguenze sulla produzione agricola e direi [16:15:37] Speaker 2 [EN] anche sull'occupazione l'ultimo punto riguarda le due istanze protezione dei lavoratori e produttività agricola non possono e non devono andare in conflitto questo avviene costantemente questa cautela che non vadano in conflitto avviene costantemente nel dialogo sociale europeo abbiamo tanti buoni esempi come il progetto sei fabitus a cui abbiamo partecipato insieme ad effat ma abbiamo tanti esempi di dialogo sociale europeo nazionale e contrattazione collettiva che funzionano cito un caso di un rischio nuovo cosiddette le estreme temperature in cui a livello nazionale paesi come l'italia la francia la spagna hanno adottato delle misure che sono misure concrete e misure effettivamente spendibili ecco io vorrei dare con questo una testimonianza concreta di come questa collaborazione tra datori di lavoro lavoratori istituzioni scientifiche e ovviamente istituzioni sia un perno della nostra attività sul quale il geopa si investe e si impegna già da subito ad essere disponibile e a contribuire con proposte concrete grazie thank you very much we then move on to the ample coordinators or representatives for questions and. Please if the questions could be two minutes and also the answers no more than two minutes so you can either address it to a specific expert or if you want everyone to answer then it will just take a bit more time but let's keep it to two minutes not more starting with mrs. Kelemens from the S&D merci merci madame la présidente merci effectivement pour les participants c'est important hearings on l'entend voilà les pesticides le phytosanitaire attaque. Lourdement la santé de celles et de ceux qui nous nourrissent alors qu'il soit travailleur indépendant qu'il soit saisonnier on voit le risque auquel ils sont exposés tous les jours il faut pas m'en vouloir mais quelque part j'ai envie de faire le lien avec l'amiante on nous vendait aussi cette technologie de l'amiante comme étant quelque chose d'incontournable comme étant quelque chose dont on ne pouvait pas se passer et bien [16:17:47] Speaker 2 [EN] finalement les pesticides c'est un peu la même chose et ici on le voit des travailleurs enfin moi j'entends tout à l'heure 1,6 millions d'exposition problématique et de en tout cas d'accident d'exposition avec immédiatement des risques directs d'irritation mais surtout des risques à long terme c'est pour ça que je fais lien vraiment avec l'amiante sur la santé avec des décès avec des maladies d'Alzheimer avec des problèmes neurodégénératifs voilà mais donc à un moment donné l'Europe ici aujourd'hui on sait qu'elle marche sur sa tête et qu'elle va permettre via ce fameux omnibus 10 de déréguler et de permettre l'autorisation de mise sur le marché de ces substances nocives pour notre santé celle des travailleurs mais aussi celle des enfants celle de toute la famille de et aussi des consommateurs donc voilà moi j'ai envie de poser deux questions c'est la représentante effectivement de la geopa copa mais aussi à celui au représentant de eu osha sur effectivement leur position sur une autorisation sans plus aucune limite de temps de pesticides qui risque après de se d'être extrêmement problématique pour la santé des travailleurs et des travailleuses puisqu'on sait qu'il y a l'effet cocktail il y a l'effet exposition chronique et le fait est que cette autorisation sans plus aucune condition après d'évaluation des risques et vous voilà voir quelle est leur position par rapport à ça merci thank you very much so i open up for our experts starting with mr mr from eurosha thank you i do have to say that our agency is not the entity that task is assessing the we're promoting the good practices and we're doing the research gathering from the workplaces we're not assessing the substances themselves in the ecosystem we promote the getting the evidence on and there's no one size fits all approach for for this kind of thing i will defer this question also to to the colleagues i think also we have colleagues in the commission present who might complete here the debate but beyond that i can say that we will be having more research coming out on the specific types of cancer [16:20:06] Speaker 2 [EN] exposures on or risks we deal very much with risks ourselves as a category not with individual substances thank you and then it was from mrs melino grazie rispondo alla domanda in due punti veloci il primo è un invito anche a distinguere relativamente al tema delle autorizzazioni il la semplificazione delle procedure su cui credo tutti quanti siamo concordi nel nell'idea di evitare almeno procedure che possano essere ritenute ridondanti ecco di distinguere questo elemento della semplificazione dalla qualità della valutazione scientifica e dalla qualità dei controlli effettivi questa è la prima diciamo considerazione che vorrei fare rispetto alla domanda vorrei anche ricordare brevemente che rispetto all'omnibus la posizione del della parte agricola e dei produttori agricoli è anche più articolata rispetto a questo tema si parla di garantire strumenti efficaci per la difesa delle colture accelerare l'accesso al biocontrollo veniva ricordato prima quanto tempo richiedono questo tipo di soluzioni e garantire una soluzione una transizione che sia praticabile ecco questo è un elemento che dobbiamo considerare tutti il venir meno di soluzioni efficaci nell'immediato senza possibilità di essere sostituite avrebbero delle ricadute sulla sostenibilità economica delle imprese agricole ciò significa anche sull'occupazione ciò significa in termini ancora più generali sulla disponibilità di un cibo che sia sicuro e che sia sufficiente grazie thank you next speaker is mrs from the patrons oui mesdames messieurs chers collègues merci tout d'abord à nos à tous nos intervenants nous sommes tous réunis ici autour d'un objectif commun protéger la santé des travailleurs agricoles mais je voudrais d'abord rappeler une réalité nos agriculteurs sont déjà confrontés à un enfer réglementaire à une réduction constante du nombre de substances phytodisponibles à une concurrence internationale qui envahit nos étals et qui ne respecte en rien les exigences que nous imposons à nos propres producteurs européens dans ce contexte comment pouvons-nous garantir une protection efficace à nos travailleurs [16:22:40] Speaker 2 [EN] sans pénaliser davantage ceux qui nous nourrissent je pense notamment à la nécessité de distinguer le danger intrinsèque d'une substance à celui du risque réel lié à son utilisation le risque peut être maîtrisé grâce à des équipements de protection adaptés à la formation et au respect de bonnes pratiques et sur ce point j'ai pleinement confiance en nos agriculteurs qui sont des gens honnêtes et amoureux de leur terre je pense également qu'il est grand temps de briser certaines chaînes idéologiques et de redonner à nos paysans les moyens de travailler d'innover de protéger efficacement leurs récoltes notre agriculture est déjà la plus propre la plus performante et la plus exigeante au monde préservons cette richesse immense car elle est le cœur de cette souveraineté alimentaire alors j'ai écouté tous nos intervenants mais j'avoue que je reste un peu dubitative parce que je n'ai pas entendu beaucoup de propositions concrètes à part retirer les pesticides considérés comme les plus dangereux pas de proposition pas d'alternative efficace rapide comme l'a souligné madame merlino donc je souhaiterais m'adresser à madame christine je voudrais pas écorcher votre nom mais vous qui souhaitez tout supprimer quel avenir envisagez-vous pour notre agriculture quel avenir envisagez-vous pour notre souveraineté alimentaire si vous interdisez tous les pesticides et que rien n'est proposé pour les substituer comment tenez-vous compte des réalités économiques de nos exploitations face à la concurrence internationale qui eux importent des produits utilisant des pesticides ultra dangereux des ogm et là il y a un risque sanitaire réel pour nos consommateurs européens je vous remercie so the question was for mrs please thank you very much i would like to maybe first yeah say something about indeed this narrative that there's not alternatives and we need all this these pesticides and i also want to to emphasize that the omnibus is not about banning all pesticides the omnibus is a question of do we regularly look at scientific evidence on toxic substances or not or do we tell [16:24:59] Speaker 2 [EN] farmers like yeah okay this was reviewed we looked at the evidence 2025 years longer ago and it seemed fine then no and i have to say i'm a bit surprised or we are often surprised that occupational health for farm workers is not much more a priority for farming unions for example in in belgium it's now been under discussion there is a study been done to look at potentially recognizing neurodegenerative diseases but this is because of farmers in more individual farmers civil society asking for these citizens asking for this to protect farmers better but it's not a strong voice coming from the main farming unions which is difficult to understand on the alternatives i think we lack here a correct view on the current scientific evidence for example in the research institute on agriculture in france i've been also to many of their events we we always read their scientific research and they emphasize that what you exactly need for food security is a paradigm shift in which pesticide use much more than now the case than now is the case becomes the last alternative so we really have to go to systems who are much more robust much more resilient against pests this is often knowledge intensive so farmers need indeed to write support via cap via independent scientific advice but this is what is needed and exactly also to for example address issues as pest resistance which has exactly been caused by the intensive use of pesticides we've been doing in the past so there are well alternatives and studies that show this are also very varied studies that show if m ipm is very well implemented it it really ensures also stable yields and decreases pesticide use and risk dramatically without also undermining profitability so i i think the narrative of that we would go hungry or there would be the problem for our farmers if we if we yeah if we reject this omnibus is not is not correct and it's exactly of course in the farmers interest to not to not allow and to ban particularly hazardous pesticides and maybe [16:27:22] Speaker 2 [EN] to conclude of course we very much agree that there should be a level playing field and that we should also not export pesticides which have been banned here or import have residues in our food of banned pesticides this is very clear and i think we fully agree on that point thank you very much thank you and next speaker that i have on my list is mrs ohisala from the greens thank you very much chair and thank you to the speakers experts i agriculture workers face daily exposure to pesticides linked to cancer as we heard parkinson's disease and reproductive harm and seasonal and migrant workers carry the heaviest burden we've just finished the sixth revision of the carcinogens directive yet pesticides and farm workers were largely absent from it and for us greens the hierarchy of controls must start with substitution and reduce dependence on hazardous pesticides not with ppe protection must not depend on your contract or your nationality and the disease is farm workers develop much must be recognized as occupational diseases everywhere in the eu and i have to comment my colleague here before i i heard you saying that this is about penalizing the ones who feed us this is about protecting the health and the lives of the ones who feed us i think this is something that we really need to stress as a european parliament and my question also a bit similar than the colleague but you were asking about the concrete measures so if you could once more maybe effort and pan europe elaborate to one max two of the most important measures you would now put in place in order to protect the workers because we already saw huge list but where should we start thank you all right mr van ivanov yes thanks thanks a lot i think let's say the most important measures indeed i think we need to start with implementing legislation i mean we have already a good legislation osh framework but also pesticides regulation but they are not effectively effectively implemented i think we we when we look at the reality in the [16:29:57] Speaker 2 [EN] agricultural sector because of the sector specificities which i mentioned in the in in the beginning we see that. We quite often risk assessment are not not conducted at the workplace when we have migrant and seasonal seasonal workers they are not properly informed and trained in in in a language understandable to them and this is quite important as we see that they build up a significant share of the workforce in in the sector we need to see how to ensure also an effective labor protection also for the one which are not cover. Let's say by by by a formal formal employment which is as i said is widespread in agricultural in agricultural sector it's it's quite often that people are hired against their will and without being let's say and without employment being formally formally formally registered and recorded but they're still have to enjoy also the the same workers rights as as workers who are let's say in a formalized in a formalized employment and i think the same goes with the pesticides regulation we have let's say a low in in place which the sustainable use of pesticides directly which actually mandates that chemicals pesticides should be used as a last as the last alternative but we see that the implementation when it comes to the implementation that this is this is not this is not this is not respected and if we start let's say with with this proper lamentation and prevent any weakening of the current framework what's the case with the omnibus 10 i think we have already done a very important significant step in enhancing protection of farm workers thank you very much and next speaker is mr alvin it is from the left σας ευχαριστώ as my sorry there was also for mrs de champelle yes sorry no problem thank you very much yes i i agree in many points with with ivan from effort indeed a very a key point is to implement the current legislation much better to enforce it also much better and for example regarding the 1107 regulation there has been the best committee the [16:32:18] Speaker 2 [EN] the report of the best committee in 2019 which has a very important recommendations on how to to better implement and close these loopholes in implementation and so to further implement these recommendations would be an important step because my colleagues have done an analysis of this and a very small percentage of these recommendations have been implemented then about the recognition yes so i think this first point is about prevention and and this has to do with really implementing regulation much better i would also want to stress the directive as i could only do it shortly in my presentation the sustainable use of pesticides directive it really mandates only using pesticides as a very last resort but this is far from reality right now and we hear from many farmers across across different countries in the eu that's what they really miss is independent scientific advice on how they can make their cropping system more resilient and really reduce the the use of pesticides and yeah this is key to really implement ipm to reduce exposure as well about the recognition of occupational diseases linked to pesticides i think here the parliament could could maybe think of an own initiative for example to really ask also the eo commission to to really make that a priority because now we have only a list of recommended occupational diseases in which pesticides parkinson's disease are not represented as i said so i think this could be a very important step concrete step the parliament could take and then indeed about the omnibus we already said it definitely not weakening not. Current authorization and risk assessment as has really also been stressed by many scientists across europe but what that has to happen is indeed we we we we can and should really increase accessibility and implementation of alternatives and this should be among more done by by working through the delays by increased capacity of size also stated that which we through experts extra per member states they can actually [16:34:33] Speaker 2 [EN] in three year yeah handle the delays and and process them so these things are very important and i've also been described for example in the refit report it has also been described what can be done to implement regulation 1107 much better and to and to ensure increased capacity and less delays thank you very much thank you very much and now mr alvin it's please ευχαριστώ χρήσιμη όμως παρέμβαση πραγματικά και για μας και πολύ χρήσιμη είναι και η σημερινή μας συνάντηση και συζήτηση και ελπίζω να την ακούνε και οι συμπολίτες μας τα κράτη μέλη κοιτάξτε η επαγγελματική έκθεση ορισμένα φυτοφάρμακα έχει συσχετιστεί με συγκεκριμένους καρκίνους όπως ακούσαμε σήμερα και με τη νόσο του πάρκινσον και όπως ακούσαμε αυτές οι συνέπειες μπορούν να εμφανιστούν μετά από πολλά χρόνια και από τη συλλογή της eurostat από τις αναγνωρισμένες επαγγελματικές ασθένειες ορισμένα κράτη μέλη έχουν την φοβερή τακτική του πονηρού στριφοκάμουλου δεν το αναγνωρίζω ότι υπάρχει θέμα δεν υπάρχει πρόβλημα δεν την αναγνωρίζω την ασθένεια δεν υπάρχει ασθένεια έξυπνο σε κάθε κράτος μέλος νομίζω ότι χρειαζόμαστε ουσιαστικούς ελέγχους δυνατότητα καταγγελίας χωρίς αντίποινα πρόσβαση σε κατάλληλη ιατρική παρακολούθηση για όλους όσους εργάζονται στη γεωργία εμείς στην ελλάδα παραδείγματος χάρη έχουμε μικρούς κλήρους δηλαδή είναι και αγρότες και εργάτες ο ίδιος αλλά βεβαίως έχουμε και εργάτες γης συμπεριλαμβανομένων λοιπόν των αυτοαπασχολούμενων χρειαζόμαστε αντιπροσωπευτική καταγραφή της έκθεσης αναγνώριση και αποζημίωση των επαγγελματικών ασθενειών και ο εργάτης γης πρέπει να ενημερώνεται στη γλώσσα που κατανοεί και γνωρίζει πότε μπορεί να επιστρέψει με ασφάλεια στην καλλιέργεια τώρα θέλω να πω ακόμα ότι η μικρή παραγωγή χρειάζονται γεωπονική υποστήριξη και εκπαίδευση πρόληψης όμως το ξέρετε σε πολλά κράτη μέλη και στη δικιά μου έχουμε σκάνδαλα τα τα ποσά τα χρήματα δεν πάνε σε αυτούς που πρέπει να πάνε οι πόροι πάνε αλλού ρωτώ ρωτώ πώς σκέφτεστε να αντιμετωπιστεί η υποκαταγραφή των επαγγελματικών ασθενειών και [16:36:53] Speaker 2 [EN] ειδικά όσων εργάζονται με την έκθεση σε φυτοφάρμακα πώς θα διασφαλιστεί η δυνατότητα πρόσβασης των εργατών γης στα δεδομένα τους στα data τους μετά την αποχώρηση από το χώρο εργασίας τους ώστε να μπορούν ενδεχομένως να να ανασυνθέσουν το ιστορικό έκθεσής τους σε επικίνδυνες ουσίες και σε περίπτωση ασθένειας και ένα τελευταίο μήπως πάμε πάλι στην εοκ εδώ πάμε για ένωση μήπως χρειαζόμαστε κοινά ευρωπαϊκά εργαλεία επιτέλους και τα κράτη μέλη οι κυβερνήσεις να συμμορφώνονται ουσιαστικά και να μην θέτουν σε κίνδυνο εργάτες και αγρότες θα στηρίζαμε θα υποστηρίζαμε ακόμα και αυστηρότερες κυρώσεις στα παρα στα παρανομούντα κράτη μέλη ευχαριστώ κύριε άντερσον [16:37:52] Speaker 2 [EN] so not specified question do you all want wish to answer then i'll start with mr delano thank you it's a very difficult topic because indeed member states as you know follow the directives on this so they have different criteria so it's quite difficult in our field to link certain long term illnesses where especially where exposure is staggered where the latency of the disease is very long term to link them to workplaces we have a descriptive study in the works in yosha to understand already at this point we what criteria each country uses for cancer as is member state has a very different approach or can have varying degrees of approach due to this long latency how many years of exposure that it takes what were the work conditions what do they require that the workers meet what criteria they require that the workers meet so that the disease is eventually treated as an occupational disease and we're aim to have this study out by november 2027 so this is one answer i can give you on our side beyond indeed acknowledging and and saying that it's a very difficult topic also because we're we're looking at very varying varying degrees of criteria across member states and mrs yes thank you very much yes so as i showed in my slides there is only three countries up until now who have officially recognized it but indeed in other countries there can sometimes be a system in place in which individual case per case basis per case per case basis sorry individuals can try to ask for a compensation but from what we hear this is very difficult for example in belgium it is also possible in a way to to ask for compensation if you expect you have been exposed and your disease has a link with pesticide exposure but then we hear that even doctors right now don't necessarily make the link so why would then and then patients of course themselves not even make the link neither and then when they have a doctor who can really guide them it's still extremely difficult but then we see in the countries where they have made steps to recognize parkinson's disease or others there's still big [16:40:19] Speaker 2 [EN] differences in indeed the criteria for example in france if i'm correct you have to be 10 years exposed in germany that's much less so we really see this also as a key gap to work on an eu level framework and of course to make any any person who has been exposed and has a disease which can potentially be linked to to pesticides should be able to to get recognized and receive compensation there was also a question on data and i i i want to stress that already now so it's mandatory for professional users of pesticides to register pesticide use data but it was not yet mandatory to do this digitally and from next year's next year member states will have to gather this digitally and this will be very important because it it's very important that this is a user friendly system in which different people different actors can really reach these data and certainly also for victims of pesticide exposure that they can easily access them even if it's from exposure that happened many years ago so yeah thank you very much thank you mr ivano yes maybe very very brief not to repeat also what i already said i think it's important first of all that we achieve also a certain grad of harmonization at the european level and i think as i said at the moment it's up to the each member state to decide if they recognize particular diseases occupational disease linked to pesticides or not and within the case with parkinsons we have only three member states and i think we have appropriate eastern rate instrument also the european level with the european semester for occupational diseases which was also meant to be turned into a directive at at certain point so this this is something which maybe can be taken up taken up again and at least efforts together with if pw has been mandating and advocating advocating for that surely when it comes to the criteria it's still we need to see what what can the european level can do in terms of also harmonizing let's say the framework and the criteria what we have been arguing from point of view of effort is that also let's say the [16:42:26] Speaker 2 [EN] let's say the barriers for workers to prove this quite often disclosure link between the professional activity and the recognition as occupational disease it's quite it's quite high in many cases and for that for instance one of our let's say main demands has been to have every worker every farm worker to have to be entitled to a document which proves the chemicals and pesticides used during their professional activity this is something which has been discussed within which has been taken up also in the draft report on the sustainable use of pesticides regulation which was unfortunately not dropped voted down in in the parliament but this is i think a very important practical tool which can facilitate also the recognition of of occupational diseases and ensure also access to this important information for for workers thank you and then mrs melino mrs melino do you wish to take the floor si grazie solo per due precisazioni che mi sono state offerte da alcuni interventi precedenti il primo è una diciamo un accenno relativo alla alla all'omnibus e e al cosiddetto far west che si immagina come scenario vorrei solo ricordare che la proposta della commissione dice chiaramente che se emergono nuove evidenze scientifiche queste devono essere valutate a discapito di ogni altra disposizione ecco vorrei ricordare che non siamo in un ambito in cui tutto è possibile tutto è libero ma credo che sia una una un accenno opportuno da fare il secondo riguarda cosa fanno cosa si fa concretamente per la protezione dei lavoratori e per la protezione anche dell'agricoltori ricordiamo che gli agricoltori non sono datori di lavoro che stanno nei loro uffici al chiuso ma sono figure sono persone che condividono con i lavoratori ovviamente ne hanno la responsabilità ma condividono gli stessi rischi la stessa esposizione ecco vorrei ricordare non ho fatto in tempo nel mio intervento che l'efat il geopa sono impegnate o c'è uno strumento interessante vi invito anche a consultarlo si chiama oira online interactive risk assessment ed è una strumento [16:44:50] Speaker 2 [EN] interattivo che consente in modo molto semplice molto intuitivo di fare una prima valutazione dei rischi professionali anche non in presenza di diciamo conoscenze particolarmente approfondite ma da diciamo degli allarmi importanti e questi sono degli strumenti concreti praticabili che ovviamente non esulano dal rispetto della legislazione sul lavoro e della sicurezza sul lavoro quello che noi il messaggio che volevamo e vorremmo che oggi passasse è che la sicurezza non si garantisce soltanto rispettando le norme sulla carta è evidente che queste vadano rispettate ed è evidente che gli agricoltori vogliono che si rispettino perché si innescano fenomeni di concorrenza sleale a cui non vogliamo prestarci però la sicurezza si garantisce anche facendo in modo che ogni misura di prevenzione si possa tradurre in una protezione che sia reale e che sia effettiva per chi lavora nei campi grazie thank you very much we didn't move on to the second round of questions under catch the eye and as i said before if there are envisant or agri members present please you are welcome to take the floor we will take all the questions in one block and then give the floor back to the experts for answers and for possible concluding remarks and please limit for the questions please limit them to around one minute starting with mr danielson from the snd thank you also thank you to all the speakers i think it's clear from the hearing today that workers in agriculture have a high risk of exposure to cancergenic risk factors we also know that it's a high risk sector in terms of risk of labor exploitation and today we have heard about the principles such as the hierarchy of controls precautionary principles and that exposure can be limited with correct preventive measures but let's assume that the precautionary principle preventive measures and risk assessments are less likely to occur when you have labor exploitation at the worksite if this is true which i hold to be quite obvious isn't that the fact [16:47:04] Speaker 2 [EN] that the taking away the social conditionality as proposed by the agri council would mean that more workers get exposed to pesticides and other cancergenic substances at the workplace and in the end we will have more workers get in cancer and in the end miss lose their life because they get exposed at the workplace that's the question thank you thank you very much i now have mrs saharia and mr andrush on my speakers list is there anyone else who is to take the floor if not mrs saharia please ευχαριστώ κυρία πρόεδρε κάθε τόσο ερχόμαστε στην ολομέλεια και ψηφίζουμε για φυτοφάρμακα και ζιζανιοκτόνα και βλέπουμε ξανά και ξανά να προωθείται η χαλάρωση των περιορισμών στο όνομα της ανταγωνιστικότητας ποια συμφέροντα κρύβονται πίσω από αυτές τις αποφάσεις τα λόμπι των χημικών βιομηχανιών μόνο αυτοί ποιοι πίσω από αυτές τις αποφάσεις είναι άνθρωποι ένας εργάτης γης ας πούμε ένας αγρότης δουλεύει χρόνια μέσα στα φυτοφάρμακα τα εισπνέει έρχεται σε επαφή μαζί τους πολλές φορές χωρίς την απαραίτητη προστασία και μετά από 10-15 χρόνια αρρωσταίνει σοβαρά πώς θα αποδείξει ότι αρρώστησε από τη δουλειά του ποιος θα αναλάβει την ευθύνη ποιο επίσημο έγγραφο γράφει ότι αυτός ο άνθρωπος από αυτές τις ουσίες που εκτέθηκε έχει αρρωστήσει είναι απαίτηση των εργατών η υποχρεωτική καταγραφή της έκθεσής τους στα χημικά η δωρεάν ιατρική παρακολούθηση εφόρου ζωής και η ουσιαστική προστασία των εργαζομένων όχι δεν μπορεί η ανταγωνιστικότητα να περάσει πάνω από τα πτώματα των εργαζομένων δεν γίνεται και αυτό πρέπει να το αποφασίσουμε πλέον και να μην χαλαρώνουμε τα μέτρα ευχαριστώ πολύ and mr andrush thanks a lot well this discussion is maybe unexpectedly timely and i will follow up johan's intervention because 10 days ago agriculture ministers adopted their position to the legislation on common agriculture policy for post 28 period and majority of european ministers refused refused commissions proposal for binding the access to agri subsidies with social conditionality even weakening compared to to current situation so [16:49:35] Speaker 2 [EN] social conditionality covers two particular topics working conditions as regulated by national and and european legislation and occupational and safety and health rules today if national labor inspectorate uncovers violation of ocean rules agri companies are penalized by cutting zoom of subsidies since 2028 this rule should no longer be applied and access to agri subsidies should be guaranteed also for companies that demonstrably violate ocean rules contrary colleagues ministers confirmed that animal welfare and plant health will remain as conditionalities for access to agri subsidies so dear colleagues i know that this legis this particular legislation doesn't fall under competencies of this of this committee however contrary to me you are members of different groups so i would like finally i would like to to ask you to do your best to overturning this this minister's decision in the parliament once we will vote on this legislation thank you thank you very much and we then move back to our experts in the same order so starting with mr de leon thank you very much and thank you for for the the lively debate and interesting questions they're not easy questions not the least because from you osha i do have to say as you well know that this is outside of our scope what i can tell you is that there we are tripartite agency so we have as you know the employers the employees and governments on our board and there's a consensus that the osh legal framework with that we advise with our research not influence or propose in any way is generally seen as the gold standard and at the same time we we we try to promote measures and and guidelines to protect workers and the motto for that i i i have to remind everybody it's good for you good for business so we do see that when there's investment in good prevention we actually have studies that show there's a return on that investment in the in the lower cost down the line so while the the specific questions which were very directly addressed is is outside of our [16:52:01] Speaker 2 [EN] scope to to answer in general the wash framework is seen as quite healthy also because it's the product of long debates and agreement between the three partite partners and we hope that this dialogue can continue again in the future hopefully relying on the data that we provide thank you and mrs champion thank you very much yeah regarding the social conditionality indeed we have been very surprised to see this change in the the general approach of the of the council of course this is key it's it's difficult to believe that this was that this was removed as were other key key provisions we think for example the that the transition payments which was we think a good proposal of the commission which made which were made voluntarily while this kind of schemes are exactly what is needed to for example support farmers in phasing out harmful pesticides so and yes i think the questions are correct it would indeed lead probably to more exposure for workers and to more risk for workers given that the social conditionality is is when this conditionality would be removed because yeah this criteria would just not be there anymore to receive public funding and the cap overall should not fund and support harmful practices but should of course only support practices which are healthy for farmers for civil society overall and for the environment regarding the question on data how can someone prove i want again repeat so this is why this digital pesticide use data are key otherwise it's indeed becomes very difficult for someone to to prove to what they have been exposed or what they have been using which might have been a factor in the development of their disease i maybe if i if i quickly want to respond to the comment made on the omnibus and that it would keep targeted revision just as it's important to to to specify this there is already now in the regulation an option to ad hoc revise based on latest scientific evidence in article 21 but in practice this has proven to be very difficult and also you transfer the burden of proof now it's it's very logical [16:54:29] Speaker 2 [EN] that producers have to every 10 15 years again provide the dossier pay for this show that as a certain pesticide is not particularly hazardous and if you remove this then all the burden comes on authorities on civil society to try to fight for a certain pesticides to be reviewed and from experience this would in practice be very difficult and really not comparable to to periodic review we have now maybe to conclude yes i would like to just emphasize again that much better protection is needed not less it's really about the major human health crisis the numbers are are very yeah alarming and the evidence that is there also on the links with pest with pesticides and certain diseases are are very strong for certainly for a serious of diseases so more than enough is needed is known to really act and to use this to apply the precautionary principle while also really supporting farmers to phase out hazardous pesticides and and implement sound alternatives thank you very much thank you and mr ivanov yes thank you thank you very much no i cannot agree more that the decision which was taken by by the agrifish council few few weeks ago it's it stands in stark contradiction to the objective to to reduce exposure to to pesticides among farm workers and from our point of view it's a it's a very big political political mistake as or has been already said the social conditionality it's currently contains three directives two on occupation of safety and health one on predictable and working conditions and let me say that one of the directives from from the osh framework it's the framework directive which also contains the main instrument which we have in the osh framework the risk assessment which is also important to ensure that the exposure to to pesticides is is reduced given. Let's say the sector specificities which i mentioned also the implementation gaps i think it's really important that we leverage any possible policy fields to improve and to reduce the the exposure to pesticides and i think [16:56:52] Speaker 2 [EN] the common agricultural policy it's it's one policy field which needs to be needs to be leveraged it's also quite disappointing that the arguments which led also to this decision by the agrifish council were also quite quite misleading and false if you're interested we have also engaged with this arguments and try to debunk them so if you if you need some some some arguments some some additional information on that we're happy happy to provide this and again we rely very much on the parliament but also on your important role as employment committee as even if let's say it's the competence lies with another committee of of the parliament i think it's it's an aspect which concerns very much also the and interact with the competencies of this committee i think it's it would be important also to to talk to your colleagues in agri committee and to reiterate again the importance of this of this mechanism so it remains preserved and and eventually also secured in the in the in the subsequent interinstitutional negotiations and secondly on on the comment that health and lives are more important than competitiveness i cannot also agree more i mean health and lives of people have has to have always a priority and i always we always tend to say from the trade union movement that actually good health environmental standards are not obstacle to the competitiveness of the european economy they are actually an essential part a trademark trademark of the european competitiveness and this is how it should be seen thank you very much and mrs merlino grazie un accenno sulla condizionalità sociale non voglio esimermi ma solo per ecco fare un appello a non a non confondere lo strumento con l'obiettivo per noi è fondamentale la legislazione europea le legislazioni nazionali europee prevedono già sanzioni molto severe molto severe per chi viola le norme sulla salute e sulla sicurezza dei lavoratori nonché tutte le altre norme relative alla legislazione sul lavoro quindi non stiamo parlando di una norma che va ad intervenire [16:59:10] Speaker 2 [EN] su un vuoto su una lacuna normativa ma stiamo parlando di una norma che va a intervenire su un elemento addizionale noi siamo assolutamente convinti l'invito è anche a tutti voi a ragionare su quanto il nostro impianto legislativo rispetto a paesi diversi dai nostri e a regioni del mondo diverse dalle nostre siano tra i più maturi e tra i più evoluti e a cercare di preservare questo grado di evoluzione normativa di rispetto delle norme sul lavoro e facendosi che gli agricoltori e con essi i lavoratori che sono nelle loro aziende possano essere accompagnati in questa transizione è una transizione complessa ciò che si chiede ciò che chiedono gli agricoltori non è di essere esenti da responsabilità non è quello di attenuare le loro responsabilità ne siamo perfettamente coscienti lo viviamo tutti i giorni nelle nostre vite l'invito è quello ad accompagnare l'agricoltura in questa transizione attraverso strumenti attraverso risorse attraverso anche la collaborazione interistituzionale e anche con i sindacati agricoli dei lavoratori attraverso delle misure che siano misure che pensino anche al lato ad azioni positive io sto pensando al agli investimenti in competenze agli investimenti in tecnologie sono tutti elementi che vanno da ultima istanza a beneficio anche di un miglioramento complessivo delle condizioni di salute e di sicurezza della nostra agricoltura grazie thank you very much and after all of these questions and answers where a lot of topics and points have been raised made a short list implementation of existing legislation omnibus x occupational diseases list and recognition cmrd six the right to information from the point of view of workers the social conditionalities i will also give the floor to the commission representatives for comments mr fabio faraula from from from the employment sector in the commission please you have the floor for a round three minutes thank you chair good afternoon everybody everyone first of all let me say that the commission is happy to participate in this exchange of such an important topic [17:01:26] Speaker 2 [EN] also allow me to remind that in the eu agricultural workers are protected from the risks of exposure to pesticides through three main paths product approval rules occupational safety and health legislation and third enforcement by member states on the first point the eu legal framework establishes that pesticides can only be placed on the market and used if they are authorized following a scientific assessment of the risks to human health and environment in addition when a product is authorized specific conditions may be imposed to reduce worker exposure such as training limits to application methods buffer zones and use of pp as specifically regards the occupational safety and health legislation allow me to underline that the uwash framework directive which applies to all activity sectors with the exception of course of those sectors that have been recalled in previous interventions also covers agricultural workers this legislation defines general principles sets minimum requirements and allows member states to adopt stricter national measures importantly the commission is focused on protecting workers from the risks of exposure to hazardous chemical substances this is mainly done through supporting effective implementation and continuous update of the relevant eu regulatory framework in particular by setting occupational exposure limit values in the framework of the chemical agents directive and the carcinogens mutagens and reprotoxic substances directive the process relies on scientific evidence and is based on a well-established procedure with the involvement of the tripartite working party on chemicals of the advisory committee on safety and health at work in this context experts representing workers employers and national authorities address health concerns relating to the exposure of workers to chemicals hazardous chemicals for possible action at the eu level concrete examples of these action include the recently adopted sixth revision of the cmrd the five updates of the chemical agents directives the update of the asbestos at work directive the [17:03:54] Speaker 2 [EN] publication of guidelines for example the one on asbestos and the one on hazardous medicinal products as well as the establishment of an indicative list of hazardous medicinal products and finally the already mentioned agricultural eu osha oira and oshwiki to conclude let me remind that while the eu sets the legal framework national authorities are responsible for implementation and enforcement of the rules and for checking compliance and inspections well the senior labor inspectors committee supports member states in doing that thank you thank you very much and that brings us to the end of this public hearing i think it's been a very interesting hearing and discussion so also showing that there is clearly rule for room for improvement and of course we have to ensure that workers and farmers alike in agriculture are properly protected against the risks arising from the use of pesticides so i'd like to thank once again our speakers for the insights you have provided and also the other committees and especially the agri committee for good cooperation in the organization of this hearing and as i mentioned i think we have gotten a long list of topics to address and to follow up on so this hearing really provided with i think substantial food for thought and also points for follow-up work so thank you very much and to the members we will see each other tomorrow [17:09:20] Speaker 2 [EN] .