1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:03,000
Brussels Live
Transcribed and translated by AI

2
00:03:22,355 --> 00:03:26,762
Okay, colleagues, we are already past our
starting time, so I would be very happy to

3
00:03:26,835 --> 00:03:28,035
start.

4
00:03:29,495 --> 00:03:33,755
By the radio, so this. Excess—

5
00:03:33,995 --> 00:03:39,335
So we start with the adoption of the
agenda, and if there are no objections, then

6
00:03:39,389 --> 00:03:43,359
the agenda of the meeting
is deemed adopted.

7
00:03:43,475 --> 00:03:48,375
I see no objections, so it is adopted.
For chair's announcements, you have been

8
00:03:48,415 --> 00:03:53,131
informed via the technical note about
the interpretation provided today.

9
00:03:53,255 --> 00:03:57,151
And, dear colleagues, please be informed
that speech-to-text automatic transcription

10
00:03:57,200 --> 00:04:01,121
and translation is available
for accessibility purposes.

11
00:04:01,295 --> 00:04:10,032
Please scan the QR code on posters. And
select the channel with the language being

12
00:04:10,075 --> 00:04:13,967
spoken. For translation, you can choose
your preferred language from the available

13
00:04:14,051 --> 00:04:18,617
options on the menu. I would also like to
draw your attention to the upcoming fourth

14
00:04:18,664 --> 00:04:23,351
edition of the Disability Rights Week,
taking place on the 30th of November to 7th

15
00:04:23,477 --> 00:04:29,190
of December. The employment and social
affairs committee will host a public hearing

16
00:04:29,236 --> 00:04:34,335
on inclusive education and employment
for young persons with disabilities.

17
00:04:34,415 --> 00:04:38,751
And a workshop on EU social
funding for disability inclusion.

18
00:04:38,855 --> 00:04:42,885
A high-level event on the 2nd of December
will mark the 20th anniversary of the UN

19
00:04:42,935 --> 00:04:47,212
Convention on the Rights of Persons with
Disabilities under the theme "The EU as a

20
00:04:47,257 --> 00:04:49,078
Driver for Inclusion
and Independent Living.

21
00:04:49,115 --> 00:04:54,262
" Ample members are also invited to the
FEM hearing on women with disabilities in

22
00:04:54,317 --> 00:04:58,951
political and public life
on the 3rd of December.

23
00:04:59,075 --> 00:05:03,672
On appointment of rapporteurs, please note
that Jeroen Lenners from the EPP group

24
00:05:03,715 --> 00:05:07,217
has been appointed as rapporteur for the
report on the revision of the European

25
00:05:07,263 --> 00:05:11,840
Labour Authority's mandate. Mark Angell
from the S&D group has been appointed as

26
00:05:11,892 --> 00:05:16,135
rapporteur for the report on digitalization
of the coordination of social security

27
00:05:16,186 --> 00:05:20,175
systems and establishment of the
European Social Security Pass.

28
00:05:20,435 --> 00:05:23,873
Brigitte van den Berry from the Renew group
has been appointed as rapporteur for the

29
00:05:23,926 --> 00:05:29,057
report on skills portability act. Sara
Mathieu from the Greens EFA group has been

30
00:05:29,097 --> 00:05:33,143
appointed as rapporteur for the opinion
to the public procurement regulation.

31
00:05:33,215 --> 00:05:36,830
And Laurence Farreng from the Renew group
has been appointed as rapporteur for the

32
00:05:36,874 --> 00:05:40,175
opinion on the recognition of
qualifications of third-country nationals.

33
00:05:40,835 --> 00:05:44,338
And Irena Joveva from the Renew group
has been appointed as rapporteur for the

34
00:05:44,390 --> 00:05:47,989
opinion on digitalization of procedures
for the recognition of professional

35
00:05:48,035 --> 00:05:53,195
qualifications. And that was all
for the chair's announcements.

36
00:05:53,255 --> 00:05:55,599
Point number three is adoption of minutes.

37
00:05:55,655 --> 00:06:00,071
If there are no objections, the minutes
of the ample meetings of first and 12th of

38
00:06:00,148 --> 00:06:06,905
October 2026 are deemed
adopted. And they are adopted.

39
00:06:07,055 --> 00:06:11,735
We then move on to point number four, ample
mission to Germany and Poland to visit

40
00:06:11,780 --> 00:06:18,405
Amazon warehouses. From the 26th to the
28th of October 2026, a delegation of seven

41
00:06:18,451 --> 00:06:22,309
members of the Committee on Employment and
Social Affairs carried out a fact-finding

42
00:06:22,355 --> 00:06:26,435
mission to Amazon warehouses
in Germany and Poland.

43
00:06:26,615 --> 00:06:30,302
I had the honor of chairing this mission.
Also, very pleased that this mission took

44
00:06:30,344 --> 00:06:35,468
place. As we know, this has been a
longstanding request from the Parliament.

45
00:06:35,555 --> 00:06:40,194
And we visited three major operational
sites in Munchengladbach and Dortmund in

46
00:06:40,264 --> 00:06:44,951
Germany, and Sosnowiec
near Katowice in Poland.

47
00:06:45,095 --> 00:06:49,157
The principal objective of the mission
was to examine on-site working conditions,

48
00:06:49,210 --> 00:06:53,701
occupational health and safety standards,
the application of algorithmic management

49
00:06:53,771 --> 00:06:59,601
systems, and the extent of automated
worker monitoring across Amazon's European

50
00:06:59,681 --> 00:07:04,557
warehouses network. The visit served as a
direct follow-up to the ample committee's

51
00:07:04,600 --> 00:07:10,424
parliamentary hearing on working conditions
at Amazon held in January 2026, where

52
00:07:10,474 --> 00:07:14,739
workers and social partners raised severe
concerns regarding rising productivity

53
00:07:14,795 --> 00:07:20,512
targets, workplace surveillance, and
barriers to collective bargaining.

54
00:07:20,615 --> 00:07:25,493
During the mission, we conducted walk-throughs
of operational departments, engaged

55
00:07:25,547 --> 00:07:29,889
with site general managers, and regional
corporate executives, and held extensive

56
00:07:29,946 --> 00:07:35,310
off-site consultation sessions with trade
union representatives, work councils, and

57
00:07:35,380 --> 00:07:41,615
labor inspectors. I will soon give the
floor to the members that were participating

58
00:07:41,675 --> 00:07:47,120
in this mission, but on a personal note,
I really think one of the main takeaways

59
00:07:47,184 --> 00:07:53,315
from this mission was the difficulty
also for us to get information about the

60
00:07:53,375 --> 00:07:54,695
algorithmic management

61
00:07:55,115 --> 00:08:02,020
system used to monitor workflow. And
work performance at these warehouses.

62
00:08:02,135 --> 00:08:07,484
And also the fact that workers themselves
did not either have that information or

63
00:08:07,549 --> 00:08:12,763
information about how, for example,
productivity targets are set and why

64
00:08:12,850 --> 00:08:17,903
productivity targets increase
or very rarely decrease.

65
00:08:18,035 --> 00:08:22,486
So this really, in my opinion, strengthened
the case and shows the need for rules on

66
00:08:22,551 --> 00:08:26,266
algorithmic management
and AI in working life.

67
00:08:26,375 --> 00:08:32,485
And we will, of course, also use the
evidence and testimonies gathered during this

68
00:08:32,538 --> 00:08:36,285
mission to inform this
committee's legislative work.

69
00:08:36,395 --> 00:08:40,415
In particular, on the European Commission's
upcoming quality jobs act legislative

70
00:08:40,475 --> 00:08:46,769
package expected in December 2026. The
post-mission report will be accompanied by a

71
00:08:46,828 --> 00:08:51,580
chair's letter to President Metsola and
commission executive vice president Minsatu,

72
00:08:51,635 --> 00:08:55,844
highlighting the need for robust legislation
on the use of algorithmic management in

73
00:08:55,895 --> 00:09:00,290
the world of work, to be adequately addressed
in the forthcoming commission proposal

74
00:09:00,335 --> 00:09:05,828
for a quality jobs act. So I will now
open the floors to the members who

75
00:09:05,879 --> 00:09:10,783
participated in the mission. Please indicate
if you wish to take the floor and we

76
00:09:10,844 --> 00:09:14,261
will try and keep the contributions
to one minute, please.

77
00:09:14,315 --> 00:09:15,515
Starting with Mrs. Sommer.

78
00:09:17,435 --> 00:09:20,963
Thank you, Chair, and
good afternoon, everyone.

79
00:09:21,095 --> 00:09:26,761
First of all, I would really like to
thank all of the organizers of our ample

80
00:09:26,873 --> 00:09:31,884
committee for this mission. It was really
interesting, our Amazon mission to Germany

81
00:09:31,985 --> 00:09:36,535
in Poland. It was really interesting,
but also deeply concerning.

82
00:09:36,635 --> 00:09:41,710
In what we've heard there, what we struck
me most was actually the enormous pressure

83
00:09:41,767 --> 00:09:46,843
under which Amazon employees are working.
We heard very similar testimonies from

84
00:09:46,895 --> 00:09:52,695
workers and trade unions in both
countries, which was really remarkable.

85
00:09:52,835 --> 00:09:56,964
They say that workers are constantly
monitored through scanners and algorithms, and

86
00:09:57,017 --> 00:10:02,402
every movement, every task, and every
minute of inactivity seems to be measured.

87
00:10:02,495 --> 00:10:05,970
Workers are pushed to
work faster and harder.

88
00:10:06,095 --> 00:10:11,177
And this comes, of course, with a serious
cost to their physical and mental health.

89
00:10:11,255 --> 00:10:16,395
In Poland, workers told us that they
sometimes have to walk up to 30 kilometers per

90
00:10:16,588 --> 00:10:22,062
day. In every automated warehouse, the
walking is reduced, but the work becomes

91
00:10:22,115 --> 00:10:27,682
extremely repetitive. And as one worker
put it, they have become part of the robot.

92
00:10:27,755 --> 00:10:33,809
It seems. We also heard very worrying
testimonies about pressure on sick workers,

93
00:10:33,875 --> 00:10:39,324
insufficient rest breaks, and intimidation
of trade union representatives.

94
00:10:39,395 --> 00:10:44,642
And of course, these are testimonies
that deserve further investigation.

95
00:10:44,735 --> 00:10:50,550
But the consistency of what we heard in
both countries should concern us all.

96
00:10:50,615 --> 00:10:55,005
And that is exactly what you say, Chair.
This was a fact-finding mission, and that

97
00:10:55,050 --> 00:10:58,362
is what concerns us, that the facts
didn't seem to be on the table.

98
00:10:58,415 --> 00:11:04,600
We had testimonies, we had input from
Amazon, but our questions that we asked there

99
00:11:04,645 --> 00:11:09,316
were not really answered. And it is very
difficult from a legislative point of view

100
00:11:09,389 --> 00:11:15,817
to know how to act in this
regard. But we need to act;

101
00:11:15,918 --> 00:11:19,542
that is clear. And I want to
make one thing very clear.

102
00:11:19,595 --> 00:11:22,903
I am not against technology
or automation, not at all.

103
00:11:22,955 --> 00:11:28,464
On the contrary, innovation can improve
productivity, create opportunities, and make

104
00:11:28,552 --> 00:11:34,115
work safer. But technology must always
serve people and not the other way around.

105
00:11:34,715 --> 00:11:37,951
So I look forward to the
follow-up on this mission.

106
00:11:38,015 --> 00:11:43,255
Like you say in the quality jobs act, both
regarding the specific concerns raised

107
00:11:43,318 --> 00:11:48,724
about the working conditions at Amazon and
also more broadly how we can ensure that

108
00:11:48,782 --> 00:11:53,849
AI and algorithmic management are used
responsibly in workplaces across Europe.

109
00:11:53,915 --> 00:11:55,115
Thank you.

110
00:11:56,195 --> 00:11:57,635
Thank you very much, Mrs. Kelemens.

111
00:11:59,975 --> 00:12:03,877
Thank you, Madam President. I would also
like to join in, in any case, the thanks

112
00:12:03,949 --> 00:12:09,320
that have been addressed to the Employment
Secretariat for organising this mission.

113
00:12:09,368 --> 00:12:12,999
We knew that it was going to be an
additional challenge, so it was a bit of a

114
00:12:13,046 --> 00:12:17,379
whirlwind between Germany and Poland,
but I really want to thank them for the

115
00:12:17,432 --> 00:12:22,348
quality of this organisation. So, Amazon
at least gave the impression that they were

116
00:12:22,382 --> 00:12:27,519
playing the transparency game and actually
opening their warehouses as they probably

117
00:12:27,588 --> 00:12:30,532
never do. But on the other
hand, I think we are not fooled.

118
00:12:30,597 --> 00:12:34,368
We were mainly received by an
army of communications experts.

119
00:12:34,424 --> 00:12:39,613
They prepared three or four PowerPoints,
which were pretty much always the same, in

120
00:12:39,664 --> 00:12:44,446
each of the companies we visited. And
above all, no concrete answers to our

121
00:12:44,522 --> 00:12:49,859
questions. When we actually go on a mission,
a fact-finding mission that concerns

122
00:12:49,940 --> 00:12:55,535
working conditions, the impact on health,
working hours, the status of workers, and

123
00:12:55,586 --> 00:13:00,429
we cannot even be given a precise and
exact answer as to how many workers are

124
00:13:00,514 --> 00:13:04,708
employed, with what status, what
the levels of absenteeism are.

125
00:13:04,784 --> 00:13:09,845
So, very clearly, we do not have, and
above all, no answer to a question.

126
00:13:09,904 --> 00:13:15,374
Or in any case, just a denial, even though
we were able to see that this was not the

127
00:13:15,440 --> 00:13:21,414
case. Do you also use the algorithm, not
only to organise the work and the workflow,

128
00:13:21,459 --> 00:13:26,400
but also to control the workers? Even
though they kept telling us no, it was very,

129
00:13:26,443 --> 00:13:30,029
very clear that this was the case,
particularly in terms of its impact on break

130
00:13:30,088 --> 00:13:35,880
times and other matters. So, in Germany
too, there has been a very clear refusal to

131
00:13:35,926 --> 00:13:40,535
negotiate collective agreements.
That was made very clear to us.

132
00:13:40,613 --> 00:13:45,609
In Germany too, they have used sites –
these are the sites neighbouring Poland – to

133
00:13:45,646 --> 00:13:47,990
weaken a strike movement or to
undermine a strike movement.

134
00:13:48,034 --> 00:13:50,855
So we also see the attacks
against trade union organisations.

135
00:13:51,695 --> 00:13:55,667
In Poland, there are problems even with the
organisation of the right to strike and,

136
00:13:55,707 --> 00:14:01,423
above all, clear evidence of constant
surveillance via cameras, pressure being put

137
00:14:01,466 --> 00:14:03,255
on working conditions and wage conditions.

138
00:14:03,298 --> 00:14:07,060
So, yes, I think we will also take our
responsibilities in the Employment Committee

139
00:14:07,096 --> 00:14:10,900
to follow up on this mission. You also
thank you, Madam President, and we know that

140
00:14:10,938 --> 00:14:15,548
an initiative must be taken because more
than ever, in the Quality Jobs Act, we must

141
00:14:15,622 --> 00:14:19,067
have better oversight of
algorithmic management.

142
00:14:19,124 --> 00:14:23,116
If there is one example that has shown
us this, it is indeed that of Amazon's

143
00:14:23,168 --> 00:14:24,368
warehouses. Thank you.

144
00:14:28,835 --> 00:14:30,635
Thank you very much.
And next, Mrs. Scheibe.

145
00:14:34,535 --> 00:14:39,666
Thank you. Hello to everyone. And I would
like to join in thanking the secretariat

146
00:14:39,729 --> 00:14:43,420
for organising this mission. It was
really extremely well organised, a very

147
00:14:43,470 --> 00:14:47,366
interesting mission. So, Amazon’s
management had also very well organised and

148
00:14:47,411 --> 00:14:52,105
prepared this mission. They did everything
to make us feel like we were in Amazon’s

149
00:14:52,147 --> 00:14:58,160
wonderful world, where all employees are
happy, where there are no problems at all.

150
00:14:58,250 --> 00:15:02,838
It really was a dream company. And so,
we were clearly treated to a staged

151
00:15:02,891 --> 00:15:08,061
performance, a carefully controlled tour.
And I just want to share this little

152
00:15:08,113 --> 00:15:13,589
anecdote with you. On the second day, when
we were in Poland, we were visiting the

153
00:15:13,677 --> 00:15:16,136
warehouse there. So, the
warehouse was quite empty.

154
00:15:16,171 --> 00:15:19,540
We were saying, ‘Look, look, there aren’t
many people in this warehouse.’ At one

155
00:15:19,593 --> 00:15:22,999
point, they stopped us in front of
an employee who was packing items.

156
00:15:23,144 --> 00:15:29,315
And I tell you, he was like
this. So, completely calm.

157
00:15:29,344 --> 00:15:29,975
And then they tell us:

158
00:15:29,975 --> 00:15:32,216
« There is no rush. Look,
it's always like that.

159
00:15:32,255 --> 00:15:32,315
»

160
00:15:32,315 --> 00:15:35,410
So, we say: 'Well, okay, yes, it's true,
indeed, it's a bit going against what we

161
00:15:35,449 --> 00:15:39,509
saw the day before.' And then we learn from
the employees, the workers with whom we

162
00:15:39,548 --> 00:15:43,410
had a meeting afterwards, the trade union
representatives, that management Amazon

163
00:15:43,460 --> 00:15:47,353
management had offered all employees a
day off for that day, and those who were

164
00:15:47,405 --> 00:15:50,725
present on site had received
a text message telling them:

165
00:15:50,791 --> 00:15:54,330
'Go to the canteen, hide in the canteen,
and we will assign you another location so

166
00:15:54,367 --> 00:15:58,473
that you do not cross paths with the Members
of the European Parliament.' So, that

167
00:15:58,553 --> 00:16:03,705
is quite something, hats off. When we
then questioned the representatives, the

168
00:16:03,760 --> 00:16:07,942
armada of public relations officers, all
these people who were accompanying us—there

169
00:16:07,999 --> 00:16:11,356
were many of them, from communications—about
the issues, there were no problems.

170
00:16:11,393 --> 00:16:14,920
It is not even a case of saying: ‘Yes,
there are problems, we will try to work on

171
00:16:14,971 --> 00:16:18,489
them.’ There are no problems. The noise
level, no, no, no, the noise level is not

172
00:16:18,527 --> 00:16:23,266
high. You get used to it. You know, it is
like when you live next to an airport, you

173
00:16:23,306 --> 00:16:25,172
get used to it. Repetitive
tasks, we are told:

174
00:16:25,212 --> 00:16:28,203
‘No, but there is rotation, there is
rotation.’ Algorithmic management?

175
00:16:28,253 --> 00:16:31,736
They even told us: ‘It does not exist.
No, there is no algorithmic management.

176
00:16:31,792 --> 00:16:36,323
It does not exist.’ So it was still quite
strong stuff and very, very caricatured.

177
00:16:36,374 --> 00:16:40,976
The thing is, the moment we stepped outside
the beaten path on the first visit, we

178
00:16:41,045 --> 00:16:46,770
went to see the workers, and we immediately
came across a woman who was working in

179
00:16:46,894 --> 00:16:51,955
the picking section — that’s where you take
products from the shelves, extract them,

180
00:16:52,027 --> 00:16:56,728
and then they’re put into packaging. And
indeed, it’s a workshop that’s a robotised

181
00:16:56,792 --> 00:17:01,333
warehouse, and they’re proud to say that
the employees no longer have to walk the 30

182
00:17:01,387 --> 00:17:04,692
kilometres a day they used to when
they had to go into the aisles.

183
00:17:04,768 --> 00:17:09,113
But what do we actually see? We see people
who are at the service of, who are slaves

184
00:17:09,164 --> 00:17:10,055
to, the robot.

185
00:17:10,055 --> 00:17:15,785
In fact, they are trampling on a
two-square-metre space at breakneck speed, in

186
00:17:15,899 --> 00:17:20,665
conditions that are nothing short of
slavery, with truly infernal rhythms.

187
00:17:20,730 --> 00:17:24,764
And just to conclude, when we speak to the
workers—we were fortunate enough to speak

188
00:17:24,800 --> 00:17:29,300
to them—they give us a very different
account of the wonderful world we witnessed.

189
00:17:29,356 --> 00:17:32,180
In other words, the so-called
rotation between posts?

190
00:17:32,220 --> 00:17:37,250
There isn’t any. The noise levels, the
measurements were taken not where the workers

191
00:17:37,317 --> 00:17:41,131
are actually working. So, for me, this
mission—well, I hope that the report to be

192
00:17:41,179 --> 00:17:44,287
drawn up by the secretariat will reflect
exactly what the workers told us:

193
00:17:44,325 --> 00:17:46,942
what you saw was nothing but
window dressing, pure and simple.

194
00:17:47,067 --> 00:17:48,267
Thank you.

195
00:17:50,435 --> 00:17:53,315
Thank you very much. And Mr. Andersson.

196
00:17:57,755 --> 00:18:02,891
Yeah, thanks a lot. I also want to thank
our secretariat for a great job and also

197
00:18:02,975 --> 00:18:10,513
Yuli for her leadership of the mission.
And additionally, to what colleagues

198
00:18:10,595 --> 00:18:15,922
mentioned, I would like to,
let's say, add three topics.

199
00:18:15,995 --> 00:18:23,305
The first one is massive in my opinion,
huge use of temporary work agencies

200
00:18:23,375 --> 00:18:34,041
regarding in the case of Polish factory.
If I don't know if you knew, however, the

201
00:18:34,115 --> 00:18:39,063
Polish Amazon doesn't publish
single vacancy this year.

202
00:18:39,155 --> 00:18:47,957
Every vacancies which are published, I
mean, publicly accessible are published by

203
00:18:48,095 --> 00:18:55,920
temporary work agencies. So there is a huge
use of temporary workers for benefit of

204
00:18:56,008 --> 00:19:05,063
Amazon's without let's say reasonable
reasons why not to hire workers directly to

205
00:19:05,147 --> 00:19:09,930
the Amazon. Also seasonal workers
are very questionable in Amazon.

206
00:19:09,995 --> 00:19:17,543
It is absolutely no clear where is really
a season for the Amazon, even if they told

207
00:19:17,660 --> 00:19:23,617
us in Katowice that the season starts
in, I don't know, November and finish in

208
00:19:23,675 --> 00:19:30,447
January. In fact, under the, let's say,
the label of seasonal workers, they use

209
00:19:30,521 --> 00:19:39,187
thousands of workers throughout the
year. The second topic is very visible

210
00:19:39,395 --> 00:19:44,306
prevention of trade unions
from operations on site.

211
00:19:44,435 --> 00:19:53,420
We received very particular, very, very
broad reports of trade unionists, how they

212
00:19:53,489 --> 00:20:00,845
are prevented from any single operation
regarding to workers, how they are under

213
00:20:00,920 --> 00:20:05,735
pressure regarding to their work
with the people working in Amazon.

214
00:20:05,795 --> 00:20:13,985
Yeah, I know. And the final different working
conditions between Germany and Poland,

215
00:20:14,107 --> 00:20:22,007
just one example. This operational or
production cycle for German workers has been

216
00:20:22,091 --> 00:20:26,789
set up for five seconds and for
Polish workers for three seconds.

217
00:20:26,855 --> 00:20:35,713
I want to say that they did should be
also addressed in a fair this fair jobs

218
00:20:35,819 --> 00:20:40,004
documents which are expected to
be presented by the government.

219
00:20:40,055 --> 00:20:44,782
I absolutely understand that there are
different remuneration across the Europe, but

220
00:20:44,857 --> 00:20:51,875
there is no reason why such basic working
conditions like is production cycle should

221
00:20:51,965 --> 00:20:55,717
be so hugely different
between East and West Europe.

222
00:20:55,775 --> 00:21:06,057
So non-fair Conditions for East Europeans
has been also very clearly the result of

223
00:21:06,133 --> 00:21:07,235
this mission.

224
00:21:07,235 --> 00:21:08,435
Thank you.

225
00:21:10,115 --> 00:21:15,156
Thank you very much. And thank you also
to all the members who participated in the

226
00:21:15,210 --> 00:21:21,755
mission and as was already stated, we will
now prepare the written mission report.

227
00:21:21,875 --> 00:21:26,217
And in the meeting, we will proceed to
the next point on the agenda, which is the

228
00:21:26,267 --> 00:21:38,365
public hearing. So I now have the pleasure
to start our public hearing on the

229
00:21:38,415 --> 00:21:43,601
occupational exposure to pesticides
among agricultural workers in the EU.

230
00:21:43,715 --> 00:21:47,548
The effects of pesticides on human health
have been documented for a long time,

231
00:21:47,602 --> 00:21:53,321
linking them to an increased risk of
cancers and neurodegenerative diseases.

232
00:21:53,435 --> 00:21:58,988
Such as Parkinson's or Alzheimer's. These
are matters with which other committees in

233
00:21:59,065 --> 00:22:04,289
this house, such as Agri, Envy, and SANT,
have also been dealing and we therefore

234
00:22:04,339 --> 00:22:10,022
invited them to join us today. However,
our focus this afternoon will be to take an

235
00:22:10,103 --> 00:22:16,082
ample perspective to these hazards namely
how agricultural workers are or can be

236
00:22:16,136 --> 00:22:21,111
protected against the risks arising
from the risks of pesticides.

237
00:22:21,215 --> 00:22:25,797
Of course, the best cure is always
prevention as such the hierarchy of measures

238
00:22:25,847 --> 00:22:31,220
within the Ausländerbesetzung prioritizes
the avoidance or the minimization of risks

239
00:22:31,286 --> 00:22:36,131
mirroring in a way the principle of preventive
action in EU's environmental policy,

240
00:22:36,193 --> 00:22:42,108
as enshrined in the treaties. Setting
market rules aside, from a labor law

241
00:22:42,155 --> 00:22:46,013
perspective, employers are required to
assess relevant risks to the safety and

242
00:22:46,061 --> 00:22:51,177
health of workers arising from pesticides
and manage these risks in accordance with

243
00:22:51,272 --> 00:22:56,771
the hierarchy of controls. But how are
the different rules interacting with each

244
00:22:56,825 --> 00:23:01,009
other in this cross-cutting fields given
that agriculture is among the sectors of

245
00:23:01,076 --> 00:23:05,980
economic activity more exposed to cancer
risk factors and other diseases linked to

246
00:23:06,048 --> 00:23:10,514
the use of pesticides? And
above all, how can we do better?

247
00:23:10,595 --> 00:23:14,741
To answers to answer these questions, I'm
very happy to welcome our distinguished

248
00:23:14,783 --> 00:23:20,095
guest speakers today. From European Agency
for Safety and Health at Work, Pesticides

249
00:23:20,183 --> 00:23:23,886
Action Europe, the European Federation
of Food, Agriculture and Tourism Trade

250
00:23:23,934 --> 00:23:28,682
Unions, and the Employers Group of
Professional Agricultural Organizations, in the

251
00:23:28,767 --> 00:23:30,035
European Union.

252
00:23:31,235 --> 00:23:34,977
We will first hear from our guest speakers
and then I will open the floor for ample

253
00:23:35,022 --> 00:23:39,221
coordinators or other group representatives
and then we will do another round with

254
00:23:39,275 --> 00:23:45,306
catch the eye where also Envy, SANT, and
Agri members are invited to take the floor.

255
00:23:45,395 --> 00:23:49,649
But Mr. Bogdan Zeleny from Brussels Liaison
Manager at EU OSHA will be our first

256
00:23:49,700 --> 00:23:53,867
speakers to set the scene. Summarizing
EU OSHA's findings on the topic.

257
00:23:53,915 --> 00:23:57,515
So please, you have the floor for
the first seven to eight minutes.

258
00:24:00,155 --> 00:24:04,802
Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the
Employment and Social Affairs Committee for

259
00:24:04,864 --> 00:24:07,373
organizing this debate.
My name is Bogdan Zeleny.

260
00:24:07,415 --> 00:24:11,106
I'm the Brussels Liaison Manager for the
European Agency for Safety and Health and

261
00:24:11,170 --> 00:24:15,875
as you say, we are we are tasked with
protecting workers and ensuring they have safe

262
00:24:15,935 --> 00:24:21,475
and healthy workplaces. If we can go to
the next slide, just a couple of words for

263
00:24:21,524 --> 00:24:24,946
our agency. How do we do this? We
provide evidence, data, and research to

264
00:24:24,995 --> 00:24:29,206
policymakers such as yourselves. We
transform it into guidance and tools for

265
00:24:29,255 --> 00:24:33,773
workplaces. And we try to raise awareness,
conduct information campaigns, and

266
00:24:33,852 --> 00:24:37,003
networking to get the good
practices across the Europe.

267
00:24:37,055 --> 00:24:42,913
And this is because we still have a high
incidence of workplace fatality fatal

268
00:24:43,019 --> 00:24:47,628
accidents illnesses and
deaths related to workplace.

269
00:24:47,735 --> 00:24:51,877
And beyond the human cost,
still what we estimate around 3.

270
00:24:51,935 --> 00:24:56,987
3% of GDP of the EU is lost
due to what we call bad OSH.

271
00:24:57,095 --> 00:25:02,242
Before I dive into the pesticides, itself,
next slide please, I want to give you an

272
00:25:02,370 --> 00:25:09,404
overview of the agricultural of the
occupational exposures that agricultural workers

273
00:25:09,455 --> 00:25:14,088
face. Because the pesticide discussion has
to be taken into the wider context of the

274
00:25:14,155 --> 00:25:19,073
risks affecting the sector. So in our
workers exposure survey, where we check the

275
00:25:19,124 --> 00:25:23,929
probable exposure to at least one of 24
occupational cancer risk factors, we found

276
00:25:23,984 --> 00:25:28,181
that people working in the crop, animal
production, hunting, and related services,

277
00:25:28,239 --> 00:25:33,255
so very much the sector, face a probable
exposure to at least one cancer risk factor

278
00:25:33,325 --> 00:25:39,253
of 84. 4% during a normal work week, which
is almost double than the average in the

279
00:25:39,341 --> 00:25:44,807
EU. And if we go to the next slide,
we can check that this can overlap.

280
00:25:44,915 --> 00:25:50,768
It means that during agricultural work,
there are a number of risks that are

281
00:25:50,840 --> 00:25:53,847
overlapping in a more
severe severe manner.

282
00:25:53,915 --> 00:25:56,928
And this is way before we
talk to about pesticides.

283
00:25:56,975 --> 00:26:02,344
So give an example of farmer tilling a field
on a tractor is maybe exposed to diesel

284
00:26:02,402 --> 00:26:08,208
exhaust fumes. UV radiation crystalline
respirable silica that is raised up from the

285
00:26:08,275 --> 00:26:10,175
soil and that is before probable

286
00:26:10,895 --> 00:26:15,673
exposure also to any eventual pesticides.
That's just to give you an idea of the

287
00:26:15,720 --> 00:26:19,693
complexity of the discussion and the
importance to take all risks into account when

288
00:26:19,744 --> 00:26:24,047
going forward to discussing prevention.
Having said that, on pesticides themselves,

289
00:26:24,095 --> 00:26:27,688
if we go to the next slide,
how does exposure happen?

290
00:26:27,755 --> 00:26:30,803
And again, here is very important
to have a holistic approach.

291
00:26:30,875 --> 00:26:34,279
When you talk about exposure to
pesticides, it happens at all points.

292
00:26:34,355 --> 00:26:38,830
It can happen at all points of the
process, so on transportation, storage,

293
00:26:38,901 --> 00:26:45,029
containers, handling, mixing, loading the
containers, and then of course the actual

294
00:26:45,082 --> 00:26:49,233
act of spraying, handling equipment where
there's a high chance of exposure, but

295
00:26:49,283 --> 00:26:53,991
also afterwards after application when
there's cleaning equipment, transportation

296
00:26:54,035 --> 00:26:59,028
again of the empty containers, but also
people who are entering treated crops

297
00:26:59,175 --> 00:27:03,839
bystanders, what we call, can
also be subjected to exposure.

298
00:27:03,935 --> 00:27:08,406
And it happens through dermal
exposure, inhalation, and ingestion.

299
00:27:08,495 --> 00:27:13,003
The negative ill effects of the health we
can see in the next slide stemming from

300
00:27:13,055 --> 00:27:17,879
this risks can be acute
and also longer term.

301
00:27:17,975 --> 00:27:22,359
When you talk about acute exposure, it
causes irritation, respiratory symptoms,

302
00:27:22,415 --> 00:27:26,740
headaches, dizziness, and in serious cases
poisoning, fainting, and so on, worse

303
00:27:26,795 --> 00:27:31,688
worse symptoms. But also there can
be longer term exposure effects.

304
00:27:31,775 --> 00:27:35,985
And there are associations reported with
neurological outcomes such as Parkinson's

305
00:27:36,035 --> 00:27:42,162
disease, respiratory outcomes, certain
cancers, but also endocrine or reproductive

306
00:27:42,246 --> 00:27:48,453
exposures. Now, EU OSHA promotes we can
go to the next slide, promotes prevention

307
00:27:48,519 --> 00:27:53,138
and risk assessment as the cornerstone
of the way that workers are prevented.

308
00:27:53,195 --> 00:27:57,866
When it comes to pesticides themselves,
there's a product specific assessment.

309
00:27:57,935 --> 00:28:03,257
And I suspect a lot of my fellow panelists
will dive deeper into this topic here.

310
00:28:03,335 --> 00:28:07,777
And then there's a workplace risk assessment
that has to follow as the chair said,

311
00:28:07,835 --> 00:28:11,555
the hierarchy of controls where we
prioritize measures at the source.

312
00:28:11,615 --> 00:28:15,939
So starting with anything, ideally
elimination of the product, substitution,

313
00:28:16,004 --> 00:28:16,895
adaptation, or

314
00:28:16,895 --> 00:28:20,857
isolations at the source. We can talk
about technical measures afterwards.

315
00:28:20,915 --> 00:28:25,227
We can this is called a hierarchy. Some
people talk call it a pyramid, but the

316
00:28:25,277 --> 00:28:30,406
bottom line is that there's always
steps to to be taken at every level.

317
00:28:30,455 --> 00:28:35,432
And the next one can be organizational
measures where we train workers better.

318
00:28:35,495 --> 00:28:40,608
We can promote segregation from
the source or temporal measures.

319
00:28:40,655 --> 00:28:45,402
Although it must be said when it comes to
pesticides, for example, temporal measures

320
00:28:45,450 --> 00:28:49,558
in other workplaces can mean that
workers can take shifts to rotate.

321
00:28:49,655 --> 00:28:52,241
When it comes to pesticides,
that can actually make it worse.

322
00:28:52,295 --> 00:28:57,321
And I'm giving you this this example
just to again underline the complexity of

323
00:28:57,395 --> 00:29:01,426
ensuring adequate protection. And then
there are of course personal protective

324
00:29:01,475 --> 00:29:04,130
equipment. We all think about
that when we think about OSH.

325
00:29:04,175 --> 00:29:09,930
That's one of the components of the actual
prevention when it comes to to workers.

326
00:29:10,055 --> 00:29:14,009
Now, this is all done in a
wider ecosystem of risks.

327
00:29:14,075 --> 00:29:19,250
And if you go to the next slide, we have
to be aware that pesticides themselves are

328
00:29:19,306 --> 00:29:22,223
can be subjected to a
wide number of factors.

329
00:29:22,295 --> 00:29:28,149
So climate change itself is a shift
is a change that can modify exposure.

330
00:29:28,235 --> 00:29:32,843
So weather, temperature, and wind
influence exposure during application.

331
00:29:32,915 --> 00:29:38,813
And the shifting patterns of weather
might see in the future and we will have

332
00:29:38,920 --> 00:29:45,001
probably reports coming out in the in the
coming year as well on how changing pest

333
00:29:45,095 --> 00:29:48,005
patterns might have to
change treatment patterns.

334
00:29:48,095 --> 00:29:50,935
And beyond that can influence
pesticides themselves.

335
00:29:50,975 --> 00:29:53,264
Some could become volatile
from extreme heat.

336
00:29:53,315 --> 00:29:56,108
The protective equipment of
workers could be damaged.

337
00:29:56,195 --> 00:30:01,717
And so on and so forth. So there's a big
need to understand that in this wider

338
00:30:01,775 --> 00:30:04,431
debate we have to it's
it's a living debate.

339
00:30:04,475 --> 00:30:06,951
It's not something that is
is finalized at any point.

340
00:30:06,995 --> 00:30:10,713
And adequate prevention has to continually
adapt to the changing patterns.

341
00:30:10,775 --> 00:30:14,147
I mean, we're talking about agriculture.
It's a it's a work that anyway follows a

342
00:30:14,193 --> 00:30:18,695
season, but due to the the wider discussion
on climate change, there's an extra need

343
00:30:18,743 --> 00:30:22,595
for attention here. There's of
course a workforce dynamics.

344
00:30:22,835 --> 00:30:25,122
There's a lot of seasonal
and migrant work.

345
00:30:25,175 --> 00:30:28,238
Employed also in small farms or
people who are self-employed.

346
00:30:28,295 --> 00:30:31,707
There's language and training barriers.
Thinking back on the hierarchy of prevention

347
00:30:31,745 --> 00:30:34,656
where training is very very
important to prevent risks.

348
00:30:34,715 --> 00:30:38,055
And also there can be
unequal access to protection.

349
00:30:38,135 --> 00:30:42,763
And last in this discussion on transitions
and shifts, we have to be aware that in

350
00:30:42,833 --> 00:30:47,675
risk prevention, one measure that prevents
one risk can engender other risks.

351
00:30:47,735 --> 00:30:52,215
So lowering pesticide use in in some cases
may lead for example to the need to do

352
00:30:52,272 --> 00:30:56,601
manual weed control tasks that can
have musculoskeletal strain risk.

353
00:30:56,675 --> 00:31:00,873
So any measures and any discussions have
to be done again in a holistic manner

354
00:31:00,935 --> 00:31:05,839
ideally. Now we at EU OSHA and
we can go to my next slide.

355
00:31:05,975 --> 00:31:10,973
Promote very much part.
Approach to discussion.

356
00:31:11,015 --> 00:31:17,075
We provide our evidence. So the workers
exposure survey findings on agriculture, an

357
00:31:17,135 --> 00:31:20,516
article that I think was shared with
you before the the hearing today.

358
00:31:20,555 --> 00:31:23,868
We have something called an OSH wiki
which I would encourage you all to check.

359
00:31:23,915 --> 00:31:28,543
Beyond that, we produce practical tools
and we have something called an online risk

360
00:31:28,595 --> 00:31:32,687
interactive risk assessment tool that we
developed actually with the organization of

361
00:31:32,735 --> 00:31:37,075
my fellow panelists. So the trade unions
and the employers in agriculture that helps

362
00:31:37,143 --> 00:31:41,640
assess some of the risks in agriculture
and can be used by the way for free by

363
00:31:41,755 --> 00:31:47,099
anybody online. And we cooperate with the
wide network of partners to to review such

364
00:31:47,175 --> 00:31:51,821
evidence and then adapt always the
guidelines and the tools that we put out.

365
00:31:51,875 --> 00:31:55,685
And I encourage you all to check out the
the rev the research that we put out and I

366
00:31:55,730 --> 00:31:59,077
look forward very much to your questions.
I I'm very happy to see I kept to the

367
00:31:59,121 --> 00:32:01,613
eight minutes and I look forward
to the rest of the debate.

368
00:32:01,655 --> 00:32:02,855
Thank you.

369
00:32:05,135 --> 00:32:09,866
Thank you very much. Very
interesting and very clear I think.

370
00:32:09,935 --> 00:32:14,435
I would now like to welcome Mrs. Christine
de Champelaire whose policy officer at

371
00:32:14,495 --> 00:32:19,770
Pesticide Action Europe a science-based
NGO on EU level working on on alternatives

372
00:32:19,866 --> 00:32:24,858
to pesticides to present Pan Europe's data
and analysis for the next seven to eight

373
00:32:24,904 --> 00:32:26,104
minutes please.

374
00:32:27,815 --> 00:32:31,698
Thank you very much. Also for the invitation
and for the organization of of this

375
00:32:31,757 --> 00:32:34,575
event on a very pressing and urgent topic.

376
00:32:34,655 --> 00:32:38,837
So indeed Pan Europe is a civil society
organization and we focus on raising

377
00:32:38,893 --> 00:32:44,075
awareness on the harmful impacts of
pesticides we advocate for a robust protection

378
00:32:44,135 --> 00:32:49,403
and phasing out dependency on harmful
pesticides replacing them with sound

379
00:32:49,480 --> 00:32:53,355
alternatives. We can go
to the next slide please.

380
00:32:53,435 --> 00:32:59,855
Yeah and to the third slide. Thank you. So
scientific evidence has shown clear links

381
00:32:59,915 --> 00:33:05,195
between exposure to pesticides and a variety
of diseases which include for example

382
00:33:05,255 --> 00:33:10,545
neurodegenerative diseases such as
Parkinson's disease certain cancers cognitive

383
00:33:10,615 --> 00:33:16,138
disorders respiratory system disorders and
then available data also show that some

384
00:33:16,188 --> 00:33:20,204
groups like farm workers their families
but also other citizens living in rural

385
00:33:20,255 --> 00:33:27,043
areas are more exposed. And data show
then also for example from epidemiological

386
00:33:27,116 --> 00:33:32,324
studies that certain diseases and health
impacts are more prevalent among people who

387
00:33:32,372 --> 00:33:37,322
have been professionally exposed
to pesticides such as farm workers.

388
00:33:37,415 --> 00:33:41,084
And it's also very important to emphasize
that also children are particularly

389
00:33:41,138 --> 00:33:45,889
vulnerable because their organs are still
developing they have a lot of hand mount

390
00:33:45,948 --> 00:33:50,419
contact and studies also show a strong
presumption of a link between pesticide

391
00:33:50,480 --> 00:33:57,155
exposure during childhood but also during
for the pregnancy with certain diseases

392
00:33:57,215 --> 00:34:04,266
such as certain pediatric cancers. But
also development disorders for example.

393
00:34:04,355 --> 00:34:09,407
We can go to the next slide please.
So the numbers are really alarming.

394
00:34:09,455 --> 00:34:14,335
We we we really can say I think we can
speak here really of a major public health

395
00:34:14,418 --> 00:34:19,601
challenge. And the numbers for example on
Parkinson's how they are have been been

396
00:34:19,646 --> 00:34:26,536
steeply decreasing also the projections
to doubling by 2050 are very worrying.

397
00:34:26,615 --> 00:34:32,038
The same for cancer numbers also cancers
for people under 50 years old for example

398
00:34:32,090 --> 00:34:38,123
with with younger people have also been
increasing and they see for both of these

399
00:34:38,193 --> 00:34:43,905
types of conditions also a link
with with pesticide exposure.

400
00:34:44,015 --> 00:34:45,395
Yeah we can go to the next slide.

401
00:34:46,235 --> 00:34:50,693
And of course these these numbers are
alarming but it's it's good to to always think

402
00:34:50,748 --> 00:34:54,394
of like that behind every of these numbers
there is a life there's a person and

403
00:34:54,442 --> 00:35:01,460
their families and every of these very
serious diseases of course is really a yeah a

404
00:35:01,595 --> 00:35:07,289
drama for farmers. Their their families
other people involved and also people beyond

405
00:35:07,355 --> 00:35:09,755
farmers who have also been
exposed to pesticides.

406
00:35:10,295 --> 00:35:13,475
Sorry the translator are asking
for a little bit of a slower pace.

407
00:35:13,775 --> 00:35:18,416
Okay I will go. Thank you.
We can go to the next slide.

408
00:35:18,515 --> 00:35:23,326
So there are severe shortcomings in risk
assessment and implementation of pesticide

409
00:35:23,375 --> 00:35:29,308
regulation. So while the the primary
objective of these regulation is to ensure a

410
00:35:29,375 --> 00:35:33,885
high level of protection and is also
explicitly underpinned by the precautionary

411
00:35:33,935 --> 00:35:40,262
principle in practice yeah this this has
in many ways been failing and we see major

412
00:35:40,323 --> 00:35:45,391
shortcomings there and this is also
very clearly shown by the fact that very

413
00:35:45,463 --> 00:35:50,075
regularly pesticide have had to be banned
in the past because there are serious

414
00:35:50,135 --> 00:35:55,364
hazardous properties had not been well
identified during the the authorization the

415
00:35:55,423 --> 00:35:58,402
risk assessment and authorization process.

416
00:35:58,475 --> 00:36:03,986
So we see that reprotoxic neurotoxic
endocrine disrupting pesticides reach the

417
00:36:04,051 --> 00:36:09,288
market and often stay there also for quite
a long time until they're finally again

418
00:36:09,369 --> 00:36:15,349
reviewed. We can go to the next slide. So
these shortcomings I won't go in detail on

419
00:36:15,395 --> 00:36:20,722
all of them but they include the fact that
mixture of pesticides combined effects

420
00:36:20,772 --> 00:36:25,951
are not well included in current risk
assessment neither is chronic as exposure also

421
00:36:26,019 --> 00:36:31,715
to low level of pesticides for a long
amount of time co-formulant so the additives

422
00:36:31,762 --> 00:36:36,400
that are added to pesticide products beyond
active substance are not well assessed

423
00:36:36,446 --> 00:36:40,618
for their toxicity this is not taken into
account and it's important that these

424
00:36:40,663 --> 00:36:45,378
shortcomings have also been really underlined
by consortia of researchers working on

425
00:36:45,437 --> 00:36:50,364
this topic and we really recommend
to to urgently close these loopholes.

426
00:36:50,435 --> 00:36:56,095
We can go to the next slide. Here I also
won't go through all the the examples given

427
00:36:56,144 --> 00:37:01,919
here but it's important to show examples
of many particularly hazardous pesticides

428
00:37:01,974 --> 00:37:07,577
who are still on the market. For example
endocrine disrupting pesticides by law they

429
00:37:07,628 --> 00:37:12,826
actually have to be banned but in practice
they remain on the market and and banning

430
00:37:12,875 --> 00:37:18,547
is taking a really long time and these are
substances of which experts also say we

431
00:37:18,606 --> 00:37:23,139
cannot really define safe concentrations
because they can already at very low

432
00:37:23,222 --> 00:37:25,055
concentrations have important

433
00:37:25,355 --> 00:37:30,158
effects important negative effects on
health and we see for example that then the

434
00:37:30,215 --> 00:37:35,910
directive on CMRs to protect against
CMRs at work also focuses on for example

435
00:37:36,013 --> 00:37:42,269
reprotox one B substances but we have
also even some reprotoxic one B pesticides

436
00:37:42,343 --> 00:37:48,527
which are still authorized today.
We can go to the next slide.

437
00:37:48,635 --> 00:38:01,514
Then about. Protective equipment is is
really essential of course but it's important

438
00:38:01,577 --> 00:38:06,037
that there has been quite some research
on how it's definitely not a silver bullet

439
00:38:06,095 --> 00:38:10,278
and and really a miracle
solution for exposure.

440
00:38:10,415 --> 00:38:16,025
So studies show some data show also that
sometimes exposure gets even higher because

441
00:38:16,104 --> 00:38:21,160
of the field situations farmers are in.
So it's possible that in a protective

442
00:38:21,215 --> 00:38:28,030
equipment overall for example inside the
concentration gets higher than outside.

443
00:38:28,115 --> 00:38:32,260
And it's also important to not lay the
responsibility with individual farmers

444
00:38:32,315 --> 00:38:36,957
because of course we have to ensure they
are not exposed during their work to

445
00:38:37,058 --> 00:38:43,955
particularly hazardous pesticides.
We can go to the next slide.

446
00:38:44,075 --> 00:38:48,921
This I shortly want to mention because
these are other key shortcomings in

447
00:38:49,004 --> 00:38:53,685
implementation we see. For example the
implementation of the sustainable use of

448
00:38:53,756 --> 00:38:59,679
pesticides directive is lacking behind.
We also have no spatially explicit digital

449
00:38:59,757 --> 00:39:04,385
pesticide use data while this is of course
a key foundation we need otherwise we

450
00:39:04,447 --> 00:39:09,674
cannot well see what exposure can be
expected where we cannot measure the benefits

451
00:39:09,739 --> 00:39:14,365
of certain policy actions so
we really need this urgently.

452
00:39:14,435 --> 00:39:19,835
And also the common agricultural policy we
find that there's really not a clear link

453
00:39:19,895 --> 00:39:24,297
there has been not a clear link with reducing
and phasing out harmful pesticides and

454
00:39:24,345 --> 00:39:29,150
there's also a lack of adequate social
conditionality which EFAT will also further

455
00:39:29,221 --> 00:39:34,341
look into I think. We
can go to the next slide.

456
00:39:34,475 --> 00:39:39,514
There is a certainly also a lack of recognition
and support for victims of pesticide

457
00:39:39,575 --> 00:39:44,072
exposure only a few members states have
taken steps in in this regard for example

458
00:39:44,135 --> 00:39:50,731
especially France even in countries
recognition it stays difficult and for many for

459
00:39:50,855 --> 00:39:55,655
many patients to get them the
right compensations it's a

460
00:39:55,655 --> 00:40:02,248
very long process but so an important
message is it's only in three member states

461
00:40:02,316 --> 00:40:07,572
and Belgium is currently working on this
there is no not an EU wide recognition and

462
00:40:07,624 --> 00:40:12,550
also the recommended list of occupational
diseases we see that pesticides is overall

463
00:40:12,614 --> 00:40:17,196
not included there nor is a disease as
for example Parkinson's for which there's

464
00:40:17,249 --> 00:40:19,655
really a lot of evidence
of over the links.

465
00:40:19,715 --> 00:40:26,703
We can go to the next slide. Then I would
like to mention also the omnibus X as many

466
00:40:26,771 --> 00:40:34,102
of you know which would make a lot of
significant changes to the authorization

467
00:40:34,188 --> 00:40:39,208
process. We see that that there would be
really detrimental weakenings and while we

468
00:40:39,259 --> 00:40:43,646
need better protection we would move in
the opposite direction and an example is

469
00:40:43,712 --> 00:40:49,535
unlimited approvals of pesticides of course
it's it's very much needed and I think

470
00:40:49,582 --> 00:40:53,723
evident for everyone to understand that
we have to regularly look again at at

471
00:40:53,777 --> 00:40:58,877
substances which are designed to be toxic
to have toxic effects and these scientific

472
00:40:58,933 --> 00:41:04,126
evidence is continuously progressing if
we don't do that then we really turn our

473
00:41:04,176 --> 00:41:08,578
back also to farm workers because it's
actually saying we don't really care about

474
00:41:08,636 --> 00:41:14,986
new scientific evidence and this has been
met with severe critique from scientists

475
00:41:15,051 --> 00:41:20,516
civil society farmers also victims of
pesticide exposure and health organizations as

476
00:41:20,579 --> 00:41:24,995
Parkinson's Europe we
can go to the next slide.

477
00:41:25,235 --> 00:41:31,578
Then to finalize the recommendations we we
see three major lines of actions so first

478
00:41:31,659 --> 00:41:37,288
to prevent the use of an exposure to toxic
pesticides so this means addressing these

479
00:41:37,346 --> 00:41:41,387
key shortcomings in the pesticide
regulation and in the implementation of the

480
00:41:41,435 --> 00:41:47,397
pesticides use directive this it's also
key that member states ensure enough staff

481
00:41:47,454 --> 00:41:53,100
to meet these regulatory deadlines and
adequate fees we need spatial accessible

482
00:41:53,159 --> 00:41:59,269
digital pesticide use data second point
is that there is really a need for an EU

483
00:41:59,334 --> 00:42:05,776
wide framework for recognition recognition
sorry and compensations of compensation

484
00:42:05,834 --> 00:42:10,130
of victims of pesticide exposure and
here we think it's key that financial

485
00:42:10,178 --> 00:42:13,295
compensation is also carried
by manufacturers according

486
00:42:13,655 --> 00:42:19,505
to to the polluters space principle and
then a third point is that we recommend to

487
00:42:19,561 --> 00:42:24,275
reject the omnibus as we need much better
protection not less against harmful

488
00:42:24,350 --> 00:42:29,110
pesticides and we think this would be a
historical retreat of protection thank you

489
00:42:29,156 --> 00:42:30,356
very much for your time.

490
00:42:31,175 --> 00:42:33,858
Thank you very much and
next I give the floor to Mr.

491
00:42:33,935 --> 00:42:38,121
Ivan Ivanov who's a general secretary of
European Federation of Food Agriculture and

492
00:42:38,163 --> 00:42:42,533
Tourism Trade Union who will give us the
views of workers organizations in the

493
00:42:42,609 --> 00:42:46,969
agricultural sector on relevant data
collected from their member organizations as

494
00:42:47,037 --> 00:42:51,808
well as on relevant rules notably occupational
health and safety ones as well as the

495
00:42:51,850 --> 00:42:54,730
perspective on the future so please you
have the floor for the next seven to eight

496
00:42:54,759 --> 00:42:55,959
minutes.

497
00:42:57,095 --> 00:42:57,875
Thank you.

498
00:42:57,875 --> 00:43:02,392
Thank you very much chair and thank you
very much for the invitation to talk about

499
00:43:02,435 --> 00:43:07,765
this important topic maybe we go to the
next slide I mean the I think the first two

500
00:43:07,831 --> 00:43:12,280
slides are basically representing EFAT just
to say that we are the European umbrella

501
00:43:12,331 --> 00:43:17,255
organization of trade unions in the sectors
food agriculture tourism and domestic

502
00:43:17,315 --> 00:43:23,270
work we have 120 national trade unions
affiliated to our federation from 40

503
00:43:23,358 --> 00:43:29,102
different countries and I think I'm not
going to spend much of my time on presenting

504
00:43:29,195 --> 00:43:35,443
EFAT but I think the presentation you have
it already maybe we go two slides further

505
00:43:35,735 --> 00:43:41,582
and to the topic of of today's hearing
and this is exposure to pesticides of farm

506
00:43:41,654 --> 00:43:48,018
workers I would like to start start my
presentation with outlining few sector

507
00:43:48,155 --> 00:43:54,591
specificities which inter interacts with
with exposure of to pesticides among farm

508
00:43:54,670 --> 00:43:59,683
workers first of all we speak about
agricultural sector we speak about the sector

509
00:43:59,750 --> 00:44:07,989
where we still encounter over 30% of share
of undeclared work this is estimate by

510
00:44:08,075 --> 00:44:12,327
the platform for undeclared work which is
under the umbrella of the European labor

511
00:44:12,382 --> 00:44:20,036
authority and you can imagine that being
let's say in a employed in an informal

512
00:44:20,109 --> 00:44:26,420
setting I think that this also the occupation
of healthy and safe framework is is

513
00:44:26,490 --> 00:44:33,062
usually not applied so 30% of the workforce
we can we can assume does not benefit

514
00:44:33,108 --> 00:44:38,816
let's say from from the European OSH framework
which which which we have in in place

515
00:44:38,970 --> 00:44:43,775
then secondly estimate by the European
Economic and Social Committee we have a

516
00:44:43,835 --> 00:44:49,620
sector where we have a high a significant
share of migrant and seasonal workforce we

517
00:44:49,715 --> 00:44:53,466
have different estimates here but I think
the European Economic and Social Committee

518
00:44:53,505 --> 00:45:00,355
speaking of 2. 4 million seasonal workers
in the European agriculture and we know

519
00:45:00,405 --> 00:45:05,209
that seasonal and migrant workers they
are more vulnerable usually they are less

520
00:45:05,255 --> 00:45:11,975
aware of their rights as as workers and in
that respect they are also more prone to

521
00:45:12,095 --> 00:45:18,245
to non-compliance with labor provisions
and exploitation and less likely to report

522
00:45:18,315 --> 00:45:22,175
any any violations and any
disrespect of their of their of their

523
00:45:22,355 --> 00:45:27,502
rights. Then talking still about agriculture
we we spoke about very fragmented

524
00:45:27,556 --> 00:45:35,807
sector with let's say family farms
being the most predominant form and and.

525
00:45:36,095 --> 00:45:42,427
Subsequently also low frequency and
of inspections which take place in in

526
00:45:42,491 --> 00:45:46,975
agricultural sector we have a figure for
one particular member state I'm not knowing

527
00:45:47,014 --> 00:45:53,867
to disclose which one but they are we
have find out that only 0.024% of the

528
00:45:53,909 --> 00:45:58,934
companies in agricultural sector have been
expect inspected on on annual basis so we

529
00:45:59,026 --> 00:46:04,970
have also because of that many gaps when
it comes to implementation and enforcement

530
00:46:05,043 --> 00:46:12,859
of labor provisions. So when it comes to
yeah to the exposure to pesticides and the

531
00:46:12,948 --> 00:46:19,481
direct causes we don't have very reliable
data from from the European from the

532
00:46:19,538 --> 00:46:25,251
European statistics but some some
good estimates which point out to 1.

533
00:46:25,355 --> 00:46:32,124
6 million cases of unintentional pesticides
poisoning in Europe each year this is an

534
00:46:32,255 --> 00:46:38,811
estimate which was done by by Pan Germany
but also by Heinrich Böll Foundation in

535
00:46:38,910 --> 00:46:43,928
Germany which is a significant number and
still the authors of the study also point

536
00:46:43,991 --> 00:46:48,130
out that they assume that there'll be also
high share of underreporting also within

537
00:46:48,215 --> 00:46:54,236
this within this figure as my colleague
from Pan Europe said quite often when it

538
00:46:54,282 --> 00:46:58,243
comes about when we talk about the direct
exposure we always refer to the protective

539
00:46:58,290 --> 00:47:02,392
equipment as let's say as the most
widespread widespread protective measure but

540
00:47:02,464 --> 00:47:06,631
actually this is this the last resort when
it when we take let's say the hierarchy

541
00:47:06,683 --> 00:47:10,869
of risk controls under the occupational
safety and health framework and as my

542
00:47:10,933 --> 00:47:17,056
previous speaker said we have also evidence
there that let's say the the mitigating

543
00:47:17,195 --> 00:47:23,377
effect of personal protective equipment
might be also heavily over overestimated and

544
00:47:23,458 --> 00:47:28,842
so far we have spoken a lot about the direct
impacts the direct effect of pesticides

545
00:47:28,888 --> 00:47:36,035
exposure but what about the long term effects
like diseases like Parkinson Alzheimer

546
00:47:36,095 --> 00:47:40,415
but also cancer we also heard Parkinson
is also recognized in only three member

547
00:47:40,475 --> 00:47:46,445
states in the European in the European
country which is far from from enough so we

548
00:47:46,487 --> 00:47:48,575
go maybe to the next slide
which goes a bit to the

549
00:47:49,355 --> 00:47:53,701
what what needs to be done from our
perspective to enhance the protection of farm

550
00:47:53,758 --> 00:47:58,055
workers first of all surely we need to
improve the implementation implementation of

551
00:47:58,115 --> 00:48:01,709
both of pesticides legislation and I think
my previous speaker touch upon it but

552
00:48:01,768 --> 00:48:07,798
also of the occupational safety and health
framework and for that we have been also

553
00:48:07,895 --> 00:48:13,274
engaging also with EU OSHA and but also
with our social partner from the employers

554
00:48:13,323 --> 00:48:19,499
in developing an online risk assessment
tool to facilitate conducting a risk

555
00:48:19,544 --> 00:48:23,926
assessment in the workplace so we need to
such tools to be adapted to the national

556
00:48:23,972 --> 00:48:28,187
level but also widely promoted and I think
this is also part of our work program of

557
00:48:28,230 --> 00:48:31,835
the European sector of social dialogue
which we are having also with our social

558
00:48:31,883 --> 00:48:35,952
partners but secondly I think it's out of
question that we we can also the existing

559
00:48:36,009 --> 00:48:40,891
pesticides rules which we have at at the
moment so that's why also EFAT is firmly

560
00:48:40,955 --> 00:48:46,671
against adopting the the omnibus 10 package
and in particular the provisions which

561
00:48:46,723 --> 00:48:51,902
concern the pesticides regulation I was
referring also to the hierarchy of risk

562
00:48:51,947 --> 00:48:56,855
controls and actually as I said the
protective equipment comes as the last but

563
00:48:56,895 --> 00:49:00,772
actually the elimination of substitution
of the risk is actually the has the highest

564
00:49:00,828 --> 00:49:06,045
the highest priority even before protective
and prevention preventive measures and I

565
00:49:06,095 --> 00:49:09,695
think for that reason also EFAT has been
very active and collaborating with civil

566
00:49:09,735 --> 00:49:15,700
society organizations also from an
environmental spectrum to argue for policies for

567
00:49:15,761 --> 00:49:21,755
just transition away from
hazardous pesticides second.

568
00:49:21,935 --> 00:49:28,871
We also see and know that let's say this
preventive and protective measures they

569
00:49:28,934 --> 00:49:34,607
might come to too late for some some workers
which have been for long been exposed

570
00:49:34,669 --> 00:49:39,335
to pesticides and for that reason we need
also to better recognize and compensate

571
00:49:39,386 --> 00:49:45,351
also occupational diseases linked to
pesticides exposure that would be the case for

572
00:49:45,414 --> 00:49:49,794
instance with with with Parkinson which
needs to be also from our perspective

573
00:49:49,853 --> 00:49:54,891
recognized as occupational disease not
only three countries but in in in in entire

574
00:49:54,995 --> 00:49:57,695
Europe Germany was let's say the

575
00:49:57,755 --> 00:50:02,252
last from the three countries which
recently introduced and formalized the

576
00:50:02,305 --> 00:50:07,328
recognition of Parkinson as occupational
disease and we already have indications of

577
00:50:07,415 --> 00:50:12,899
300 potential cases in the first year
of application and I think we have an

578
00:50:12,941 --> 00:50:16,015
instrument at the European level that will
be the European semester for occupational

579
00:50:16,049 --> 00:50:20,922
diseases which needs to to be updated but
also turn into a binding instrument to

580
00:50:20,986 --> 00:50:26,512
provide for a harmonized list of occupational
diseases at European level we also

581
00:50:26,558 --> 00:50:31,055
think that we need to facilitate the
recognition of occupational diseases at the

582
00:50:31,145 --> 00:50:34,857
moment it's also also in the countries
where we have Parkinson for instance

583
00:50:34,895 --> 00:50:39,707
recognized occupational disease for workers
is particular burdensome to to prove

584
00:50:39,805 --> 00:50:44,313
this as and for that we have having also
arguing for workers for farm workers to

585
00:50:44,355 --> 00:50:48,810
have a right to a document which outlines
also the chemicals and pesticides used

586
00:50:48,855 --> 00:50:52,955
during their professional activity so that
it facilitates also the recognition of

587
00:50:53,023 --> 00:50:58,218
occupational diseases and another point
which we also believe it's essential is that

588
00:50:58,269 --> 00:51:02,620
we need to leverage the different policy
fields to enhance the protection of farm

589
00:51:02,671 --> 00:51:08,092
workers from pesticides exposure we talked
about a lot of pesticides pesticides

590
00:51:08,148 --> 00:51:12,546
regulations about occupational safety and
health regulations but I think we also

591
00:51:12,595 --> 00:51:16,489
need to leverage the common agricultural
policy and to strengthen also the social

592
00:51:16,541 --> 00:51:19,925
conditionality which we managed to
introduce in the last revision of the common

593
00:51:19,962 --> 00:51:24,695
agricultural policy as it has also an
important occupational safety and health

594
00:51:24,755 --> 00:51:30,304
pillar in it and as a last point I think
we need also to assume our responsibility

595
00:51:30,356 --> 00:51:35,770
at the global level and pesticides which
are produced here but banned in Europe we

596
00:51:35,844 --> 00:51:41,000
need yeah we should stop exporting them
also to to third countries and I end here

597
00:51:41,053 --> 00:51:48,618
and I'm at your disposal for any questions
and comments thank you very much and I

598
00:51:48,680 --> 00:51:53,651
now turn to Mrs. Claudia Melino who is
remotely connected and as the president of

599
00:51:53,692 --> 00:51:57,458
employers group of professional agricultural
organizations in the European Union she

600
00:51:57,505 --> 00:52:00,635
will give us the views of
employers organizations in the

601
00:52:00,815 --> 00:52:05,821
agriculture sector on relevant data and
relevant rules notably the occupational

602
00:52:05,864 --> 00:52:09,294
health and safety ones and also perspectives
for the future so please you have the

603
00:52:09,335 --> 00:52:19,384
floor for the next seven to eight minutes
grazie buon buon pomeriggio Claudia

604
00:52:19,457 --> 00:52:24,949
Merlino presidente Geopa il Geopa è il
gruppo europeo dei datori di lavoro delle

605
00:52:25,012 --> 00:52:31,528
organizzazioni professionali agricole e ha
l'incarico della commissione riconosciuto

606
00:52:31,575 --> 00:52:37,129
dalla commissione per il dialogo sociale
settoriale che svolgiamo ogni giorno

607
00:52:37,181 --> 00:52:43,255
praticamente con i nostri amici dell'EFAT
io vorrei iniziare questa questa audizione

608
00:52:43,355 --> 00:52:48,940
ringraziando per l'occasione con una
affermazione molto chiara da parte nostra ed è

609
00:52:49,055 --> 00:52:55,751
la seguente per i datori di lavoro agricoli
europei la salute e la sicurezza dei

610
00:52:55,820 --> 00:53:03,024
lavoratori agricoli e degli agricoltori
rappresenta una priorità assoluta è stato

611
00:53:03,099 --> 00:53:08,542
detto va detto che l'agricoltura è un
settore estremamente diversificato è un

612
00:53:08,603 --> 00:53:14,508
settore caratterizzato da presenza di
lavoratori autonomi di lavoratori familiari

613
00:53:14,596 --> 00:53:21,384
manodopera stagionale manodopera dei
paesi terzi aziende con dimensioni molto

614
00:53:21,458 --> 00:53:27,392
diverse con sistemi produttivi molto
diversi riteniamo che queste caratteristiche

615
00:53:27,455 --> 00:53:33,164
debbano essere considerate anche nella
prevenzione dell'esposizione ai pesticidi e

616
00:53:33,238 --> 00:53:39,697
ai prodotti fitosanitari ed è per questo
che vorrei concentrarmi su quattro messaggi

617
00:53:39,755 --> 00:53:46,559
principali il primo messaggio riguarda a
nostro avviso il ruolo della prevenzione

618
00:53:46,655 --> 00:53:51,412
sappiamo. Sapete come gli agricoltori
e i lavoratori agricoli affrontano

619
00:53:51,474 --> 00:53:58,770
quotidianamente tanti rischi i parassiti
le malattie delle piante le erbe infestanti

620
00:53:58,853 --> 00:54:03,981
e sono quotidianamente impegnati nella
produzione di alimenti che siano sufficienti

621
00:54:04,055 --> 00:54:09,678
e che siano sicuri ecco il primo aspetto
è questo la modalità di utilizzo dei

622
00:54:09,746 --> 00:54:16,099
prodotti fitosanitari a nostro avviso è
fondamentale il modo in cui il prodotto

623
00:54:16,175 --> 00:54:21,499
viene manipolato le attrezzature vengono
impiegate e le pratiche di lavoro adottate

624
00:54:21,564 --> 00:54:28,329
sono tutti elementi per noi rilevanti per
ridurre l'esposizione e questo è il motivo

625
00:54:28,406 --> 00:54:35,195
è stato già detto per cui abbiamo una
essenziale bisogno di formazione adeguata

626
00:54:35,435 --> 00:54:41,193
sull'applicazione sicura di questi prodotti
è altresì chiaro che noi riconosciamo in

627
00:54:41,282 --> 00:54:47,381
modo molto molto evidente il ruolo
fondamentale che ha in questa difesa la difesa

628
00:54:47,435 --> 00:54:52,825
integrata delle culture combiniamo
pratiche agricole per il controllo degli

629
00:54:52,895 --> 00:54:57,793
organismi nocivi e ci basiamo naturalmente
sul principio che il prodotto chimico

630
00:54:57,859 --> 00:55:03,287
deve venire come un come ultima soluzione
questo per noi è chiaro è stato detto

631
00:55:03,366 --> 00:55:08,697
abbiamo la possibilità di ruotare le
culture l'impiego di varietà che sono

632
00:55:08,770 --> 00:55:13,402
resistenti la gestione del suolo sono
tutti elementi che contribuiscono questo è

633
00:55:13,470 --> 00:55:19,766
indubbio a ridurre la dipendenza dai
trattamenti chimici va detto anche però che la

634
00:55:19,844 --> 00:55:25,199
difesa integrata deve rimanere concretamente
applicabile e praticabile per i datori

635
00:55:25,263 --> 00:55:29,976
di lavoro il che significa devono essere
disponibili i prodotti devono esserci una

636
00:55:30,032 --> 00:55:35,604
sostenibilità economica degli stessi
prodotti e anche un'efficacia che va misurata

637
00:55:35,675 --> 00:55:40,928
nelle condizioni che siano reali il secondo
aspetto riguarda l'esposizione ecco noi

638
00:55:40,985 --> 00:55:46,319
riteniamo che per valutare il rischio
il rischio effettivo per i lavoratori è

639
00:55:46,403 --> 00:55:52,826
necessario considerare ovviamente la
pericolosità dei prodotti e delle sostanze ma

640
00:55:52,881 --> 00:55:57,537
anche le condizioni di esposizione e e le
misure che sono disponibili per ridurre

641
00:55:57,626 --> 00:56:03,110
questa esposizione ci sono le stesse
linee guida dell'EFSA che per esempio

642
00:56:03,167 --> 00:56:08,633
confermano l'importanza di valutare
l'esposizione dei lavoratori che rientrano nelle

643
00:56:08,700 --> 00:56:13,561
culture dopo i trattamenti e qui si
evidenzia la necessità di misure che siano

644
00:56:13,612 --> 00:56:18,816
adeguate di prevenzione ed è anche in questa
prospettiva che gli agricoltori europei

645
00:56:18,875 --> 00:56:25,537
nel l'anno scorso nel 2025 hanno chiesto
di attribuire maggiore centralità alla

646
00:56:25,629 --> 00:56:31,449
valutazione dell'esposizione poi è naturale
che occorre concentrarsi su ciò che può

647
00:56:31,531 --> 00:56:37,535
ridurre l'esposizione abbiamo tecnologie
molto utili i sistemi per esempio

648
00:56:37,615 --> 00:56:42,295
antideriva la robotica possono contribuire
in modo molto concreto a ridurre

649
00:56:42,354 --> 00:56:48,706
l'esposizione dei lavoratori e i risultati
sono misurabili vorrei citare due

650
00:56:48,769 --> 00:56:54,521
risultati importanti a nostro avviso come
un orientamento da seguire una strada da

651
00:56:54,607 --> 00:56:56,555
seguire lo studio dell'anno scorso

652
00:56:56,735 --> 00:57:01,379
dell'università di Torino ha per esempio
confrontato una irrorazione di tipo

653
00:57:01,437 --> 00:57:07,217
convenzionale con quella ottimizzata nei
vigneti e nei frutteti e si sono rilevate

654
00:57:07,295 --> 00:57:14,097
delle riduzioni di esposizione per inalazione
fino all'85% e dell'esposizione della

655
00:57:14,156 --> 00:57:21,788
pelle quindi cutanea fino al 91% un altro
esempio una ricerca europea sul sul campo

656
00:57:21,902 --> 00:57:26,387
con i sistemi di trasferimento cosiddetto
chiuso dei prodotti fitosanitari ha

657
00:57:26,441 --> 00:57:31,784
dimostrato che durante la preparazione
e il caricamento di questi prodotti è

658
00:57:31,853 --> 00:57:38,880
possibile ridurre drasticamente l'esposizione
del 90% o addirittura quasi del 100%

659
00:57:38,975 --> 00:57:43,938
utilizzando dei sistemi particolari
contenitori capovolti sistemi con estrazione

660
00:57:43,984 --> 00:57:48,535
mediante sonda ecco questi sono degli esempi
per dimostrare di come l'esposizione da

661
00:57:48,585 --> 00:57:53,124
una parte sia un fattore da considerare
determinante e dall'altra parte ci possano

662
00:57:53,170 --> 00:57:58,832
essere misure molto concrete molto pratiche
che la possono ridurre il terzo punto

663
00:57:58,955 --> 00:58:05,084
riguarda l'accesso ad alternative efficaci
vorrei citarlo sappiamo tutti bene come

664
00:58:05,140 --> 00:58:10,802
l'agricoltura europea stia oggi attraversando
una transizione molto importante verso

665
00:58:10,856 --> 00:58:16,185
cosa verso una protezione delle culture
che sia più sostenibile prodotti per il

666
00:58:16,242 --> 00:58:22,266
controllo biologico sostanze a basso
rischio tecnologie digitali ecco la nostra

667
00:58:22,323 --> 00:58:26,597
cautela è quella di essere realistici
sui tempi di questa transizione perché i

668
00:58:26,647 --> 00:58:31,292
prodotti alternativi possono richiedere
molto tempo prima di arrivare sul mercato e

669
00:58:31,349 --> 00:58:35,688
diventare delle soluzioni da una parte
competitive e dall'altra parte effettivamente

670
00:58:35,735 --> 00:58:39,947
praticabili e non è un caso che lo
stesso parlamento europeo ha adottato una

671
00:58:39,995 --> 00:58:45,160
risoluzione lo scorso anno nel quale
evidenzia per esempio per le soluzioni

672
00:58:45,213 --> 00:58:50,812
biologiche che le autorizzazioni possono
richiedere fino a 10-15 anni e questo è un

673
00:58:50,906 --> 00:58:55,824
problema sebbene l'omnibus che è stato
citato punti a semplificare l'autorizzazione

674
00:58:55,877 --> 00:59:00,875
delle sostanze a basso rischio è fondamentale
che gli agricoltori possano continuare

675
00:59:00,935 --> 00:59:05,887
a mantenere strumenti che siano efficaci
per proteggere le culture perché questo ha

676
00:59:05,950 --> 00:59:09,095
se no conseguenze sulla
produzione agricola e direi

677
00:59:09,155 --> 00:59:14,641
anche sull'occupazione l'ultimo punto
riguarda le due istanze protezione dei

678
00:59:14,699 --> 00:59:19,544
lavoratori e produttività agricola non
possono e non devono andare in conflitto

679
00:59:19,609 --> 00:59:24,315
questo avviene costantemente questa
cautela che non vadano in conflitto avviene

680
00:59:24,364 --> 00:59:28,596
costantemente nel dialogo sociale europeo
abbiamo tanti buoni esempi come il

681
00:59:28,648 --> 00:59:33,050
progetto sei fabitus a cui abbiamo
partecipato insieme ad effat ma abbiamo tanti

682
00:59:33,125 --> 00:59:37,541
esempi di dialogo sociale europeo
nazionale e contrattazione collettiva che

683
00:59:37,643 --> 00:59:43,162
funzionano cito un caso di un rischio nuovo
cosiddette le estreme temperature in cui

684
00:59:43,211 --> 00:59:47,577
a livello nazionale paesi come l'italia
la francia la spagna hanno adottato delle

685
00:59:47,626 --> 00:59:52,072
misure che sono misure concrete e misure
effettivamente spendibili ecco io vorrei

686
00:59:52,116 --> 00:59:57,481
dare con questo una testimonianza concreta
di come questa collaborazione tra datori

687
00:59:57,609 --> 01:00:03,723
di lavoro lavoratori istituzioni scientifiche
e ovviamente istituzioni sia un perno

688
01:00:03,777 --> 01:00:09,170
della nostra attività sul quale il geopa
si investe e si impegna già da subito ad

689
01:00:09,236 --> 01:00:19,778
essere disponibile e a contribuire con
proposte concrete grazie thank you very much

690
01:00:19,832 --> 01:00:27,911
we then move on to the ample coordinators
or representatives for questions and.

691
01:00:28,055 --> 01:00:32,860
Please if the questions could be two minutes
and also the answers no more than two

692
01:00:32,915 --> 01:00:37,175
minutes so you can either address it to a
specific expert or if you want everyone to

693
01:00:37,235 --> 01:00:41,540
answer then it will just take a bit more
time but let's keep it to two minutes not

694
01:00:41,615 --> 01:00:48,033
more starting with mrs. Kelemens from the
S&D merci merci madame la présidente merci

695
01:00:48,077 --> 01:00:53,604
effectivement pour les participants c'est
important hearings on l'entend voilà les

696
01:00:53,720 --> 01:01:01,010
pesticides le phytosanitaire attaque.
Lourdement la santé de celles et de ceux qui

697
01:01:01,051 --> 01:01:04,826
nous nourrissent alors qu'il soit travailleur
indépendant qu'il soit saisonnier on

698
01:01:04,882 --> 01:01:09,279
voit le risque auquel ils sont exposés tous
les jours il faut pas m'en vouloir mais

699
01:01:09,324 --> 01:01:13,841
quelque part j'ai envie de faire le lien
avec l'amiante on nous vendait aussi cette

700
01:01:13,879 --> 01:01:16,859
technologie de l'amiante comme étant
quelque chose d'incontournable comme étant

701
01:01:16,900 --> 01:01:19,355
quelque chose dont on ne
pouvait pas se passer et bien

702
01:01:19,715 --> 01:01:24,301
finalement les pesticides c'est un peu
la même chose et ici on le voit des

703
01:01:24,349 --> 01:01:28,470
travailleurs enfin moi j'entends tout
à l'heure 1,6 millions d'exposition

704
01:01:28,535 --> 01:01:33,244
problématique et de en tout cas d'accident
d'exposition avec immédiatement des

705
01:01:33,335 --> 01:01:38,357
risques directs d'irritation mais surtout
des risques à long terme c'est pour ça que

706
01:01:38,391 --> 01:01:43,304
je fais lien vraiment avec l'amiante sur
la santé avec des décès avec des maladies

707
01:01:43,355 --> 01:01:49,047
d'Alzheimer avec des problèmes neurodégénératifs
voilà mais donc à un moment donné

708
01:01:49,091 --> 01:01:53,023
l'Europe ici aujourd'hui on sait qu'elle
marche sur sa tête et qu'elle va permettre

709
01:01:53,090 --> 01:01:58,347
via ce fameux omnibus 10 de déréguler et
de permettre l'autorisation de mise sur le

710
01:01:58,391 --> 01:02:03,109
marché de ces substances nocives pour notre
santé celle des travailleurs mais aussi

711
01:02:03,155 --> 01:02:08,267
celle des enfants celle de toute la famille
de et aussi des consommateurs donc voilà

712
01:02:08,316 --> 01:02:12,755
moi j'ai envie de poser deux questions
c'est la représentante effectivement de la

713
01:02:12,815 --> 01:02:18,323
geopa copa mais aussi à celui au représentant
de eu osha sur effectivement leur

714
01:02:18,377 --> 01:02:25,062
position sur une autorisation sans plus
aucune limite de temps de pesticides qui

715
01:02:25,144 --> 01:02:29,615
risque après de se d'être extrêmement
problématique pour la santé des travailleurs

716
01:02:29,648 --> 01:02:33,106
et des travailleuses puisqu'on sait
qu'il y a l'effet cocktail il y a l'effet

717
01:02:33,155 --> 01:02:38,852
exposition chronique et le fait est
que cette autorisation sans plus aucune

718
01:02:38,908 --> 01:02:45,845
condition après d'évaluation des risques
et vous voilà voir quelle est leur position

719
01:02:45,969 --> 01:02:57,271
par rapport à ça merci thank you very
much so i open up for our experts starting

720
01:02:57,399 --> 01:03:05,195
with mr mr from eurosha thank you i do have
to say that our agency is not the entity

721
01:03:05,259 --> 01:03:09,689
that task is assessing the we're promoting
the good practices and we're doing the

722
01:03:09,728 --> 01:03:13,839
research gathering from the workplaces we're
not assessing the substances themselves

723
01:03:13,936 --> 01:03:21,661
in the ecosystem we promote the getting the
evidence on and there's no one size fits

724
01:03:21,764 --> 01:03:27,231
all approach for for this kind of thing
i will defer this question also to to the

725
01:03:27,286 --> 01:03:31,283
colleagues i think also we have colleagues
in the commission present who might

726
01:03:31,353 --> 01:03:35,097
complete here the debate but beyond that
i can say that we will be having more

727
01:03:35,135 --> 01:03:38,375
research coming out on the
specific types of cancer

728
01:03:38,435 --> 01:03:43,822
exposures on or risks we deal very much
with risks ourselves as a category not with

729
01:03:43,948 --> 01:03:55,372
individual substances thank you and then
it was from mrs melino grazie rispondo alla

730
01:03:55,475 --> 01:04:04,655
domanda in due punti veloci il primo è un
invito anche a distinguere relativamente

731
01:04:04,715 --> 01:04:09,843
al tema delle autorizzazioni il la
semplificazione delle procedure su cui credo

732
01:04:09,951 --> 01:04:17,879
tutti quanti siamo concordi nel nell'idea
di evitare almeno procedure che possano

733
01:04:17,927 --> 01:04:23,123
essere ritenute ridondanti ecco di distinguere
questo elemento della semplificazione

734
01:04:23,195 --> 01:04:28,985
dalla qualità della valutazione scientifica
e dalla qualità dei controlli effettivi

735
01:04:29,069 --> 01:04:34,280
questa è la prima diciamo considerazione
che vorrei fare rispetto alla domanda

736
01:04:34,333 --> 01:04:41,461
vorrei anche ricordare brevemente che
rispetto all'omnibus la posizione del della

737
01:04:41,555 --> 01:04:46,187
parte agricola e dei produttori agricoli
è anche più articolata rispetto a questo

738
01:04:46,235 --> 01:04:50,746
tema si parla di garantire strumenti efficaci
per la difesa delle colture accelerare

739
01:04:50,795 --> 01:04:55,582
l'accesso al biocontrollo veniva ricordato
prima quanto tempo richiedono questo tipo

740
01:04:55,698 --> 01:05:00,731
di soluzioni e garantire una soluzione
una transizione che sia praticabile ecco

741
01:05:00,793 --> 01:05:05,602
questo è un elemento che dobbiamo
considerare tutti il venir meno di soluzioni

742
01:05:05,675 --> 01:05:11,298
efficaci nell'immediato senza possibilità
di essere sostituite avrebbero delle

743
01:05:11,366 --> 01:05:16,519
ricadute sulla sostenibilità economica
delle imprese agricole ciò significa anche

744
01:05:16,590 --> 01:05:21,455
sull'occupazione ciò significa in termini
ancora più generali sulla disponibilità di

745
01:05:21,515 --> 01:05:32,727
un cibo che sia sicuro e che sia sufficiente
grazie thank you next speaker is mrs

746
01:05:32,795 --> 01:05:38,612
from the patrons oui mesdames messieurs
chers collègues merci tout d'abord à nos à

747
01:05:38,688 --> 01:05:43,612
tous nos intervenants nous sommes tous
réunis ici autour d'un objectif commun

748
01:05:43,689 --> 01:05:48,701
protéger la santé des travailleurs agricoles
mais je voudrais d'abord rappeler une

749
01:05:48,755 --> 01:05:54,443
réalité nos agriculteurs sont déjà
confrontés à un enfer réglementaire à une

750
01:05:54,515 --> 01:05:59,472
réduction constante du nombre de substances
phytodisponibles à une concurrence

751
01:05:59,527 --> 01:06:04,295
internationale qui envahit nos étals et
qui ne respecte en rien les exigences que

752
01:06:04,355 --> 01:06:08,943
nous imposons à nos propres producteurs
européens dans ce contexte comment

753
01:06:08,997 --> 01:06:12,335
pouvons-nous garantir une protection
efficace à nos travailleurs

754
01:06:12,875 --> 01:06:17,087
sans pénaliser davantage ceux qui nous
nourrissent je pense notamment à la nécessité

755
01:06:17,135 --> 01:06:23,302
de distinguer le danger intrinsèque d'une
substance à celui du risque réel lié à son

756
01:06:23,381 --> 01:06:27,566
utilisation le risque peut être maîtrisé
grâce à des équipements de protection

757
01:06:27,644 --> 01:06:32,622
adaptés à la formation et au respect de
bonnes pratiques et sur ce point j'ai

758
01:06:32,667 --> 01:06:36,598
pleinement confiance en nos agriculteurs
qui sont des gens honnêtes et amoureux de

759
01:06:36,655 --> 01:06:40,955
leur terre je pense également qu'il est
grand temps de briser certaines chaînes

760
01:06:41,015 --> 01:06:45,697
idéologiques et de redonner à nos paysans
les moyens de travailler d'innover de

761
01:06:45,762 --> 01:06:51,688
protéger efficacement leurs récoltes notre
agriculture est déjà la plus propre la

762
01:06:51,759 --> 01:06:57,257
plus performante et la plus exigeante au
monde préservons cette richesse immense car

763
01:06:57,310 --> 01:07:01,815
elle est le cœur de cette souveraineté
alimentaire alors j'ai écouté tous nos

764
01:07:01,865 --> 01:07:06,812
intervenants mais j'avoue que je reste
un peu dubitative parce que je n'ai pas

765
01:07:06,883 --> 01:07:12,728
entendu beaucoup de propositions concrètes
à part retirer les pesticides considérés

766
01:07:12,782 --> 01:07:18,047
comme les plus dangereux pas de proposition
pas d'alternative efficace rapide comme

767
01:07:18,128 --> 01:07:23,594
l'a souligné madame merlino donc je
souhaiterais m'adresser à madame christine je

768
01:07:23,643 --> 01:07:29,075
voudrais pas écorcher votre nom mais vous
qui souhaitez tout supprimer quel avenir

769
01:07:29,135 --> 01:07:33,553
envisagez-vous pour notre agriculture
quel avenir envisagez-vous pour notre

770
01:07:33,605 --> 01:07:38,704
souveraineté alimentaire si vous interdisez
tous les pesticides et que rien n'est

771
01:07:38,766 --> 01:07:43,921
proposé pour les substituer comment
tenez-vous compte des réalités économiques de

772
01:07:43,977 --> 01:07:48,205
nos exploitations face à la concurrence
internationale qui eux importent des

773
01:07:48,272 --> 01:07:54,081
produits utilisant des pesticides ultra
dangereux des ogm et là il y a un risque

774
01:07:54,155 --> 01:08:03,804
sanitaire réel pour nos consommateurs
européens je vous remercie so the question was

775
01:08:03,892 --> 01:08:12,422
for mrs please thank you very much i would
like to maybe first yeah say something

776
01:08:12,479 --> 01:08:17,730
about indeed this narrative that there's
not alternatives and we need all this these

777
01:08:17,825 --> 01:08:23,010
pesticides and i also want to to emphasize
that the omnibus is not about banning all

778
01:08:23,075 --> 01:08:28,564
pesticides the omnibus is a question of do
we regularly look at scientific evidence

779
01:08:28,625 --> 01:08:31,295
on toxic substances or not or do we tell

780
01:08:31,895 --> 01:08:38,288
farmers like yeah okay this was reviewed
we looked at the evidence 2025 years longer

781
01:08:38,375 --> 01:08:44,605
ago and it seemed fine then no and i have
to say i'm a bit surprised or we are often

782
01:08:44,675 --> 01:08:51,179
surprised that occupational health for farm
workers is not much more a priority for

783
01:08:51,275 --> 01:08:56,844
farming unions for example in in belgium
it's now been under discussion there is a

784
01:08:56,906 --> 01:09:02,203
study been done to look at potentially
recognizing neurodegenerative diseases but

785
01:09:02,268 --> 01:09:07,265
this is because of farmers in more individual
farmers civil society asking for these

786
01:09:07,322 --> 01:09:11,624
citizens asking for this to protect
farmers better but it's not a strong voice

787
01:09:11,675 --> 01:09:16,771
coming from the main farming unions
which is difficult to understand on the

788
01:09:16,850 --> 01:09:22,958
alternatives i think we lack here a correct
view on the current scientific evidence

789
01:09:23,015 --> 01:09:28,846
for example in the research institute on
agriculture in france i've been also to

790
01:09:28,911 --> 01:09:34,335
many of their events we we always read
their scientific research and they emphasize

791
01:09:34,385 --> 01:09:39,402
that what you exactly need for food security
is a paradigm shift in which pesticide

792
01:09:39,467 --> 01:09:44,552
use much more than now the case than now
is the case becomes the last alternative so

793
01:09:44,610 --> 01:09:49,344
we really have to go to systems who are
much more robust much more resilient against

794
01:09:49,402 --> 01:09:54,363
pests this is often knowledge intensive so
farmers need indeed to write support via

795
01:09:54,448 --> 01:10:00,887
cap via independent scientific advice but
this is what is needed and exactly also to

796
01:10:00,957 --> 01:10:06,924
for example address issues as pest resistance
which has exactly been caused by the

797
01:10:06,990 --> 01:10:12,842
intensive use of pesticides we've been
doing in the past so there are well

798
01:10:12,895 --> 01:10:19,009
alternatives and studies that show this
are also very varied studies that show if m

799
01:10:19,082 --> 01:10:26,192
ipm is very well implemented it it really
ensures also stable yields and decreases

800
01:10:26,247 --> 01:10:32,962
pesticide use and risk dramatically without
also undermining profitability so i i

801
01:10:33,039 --> 01:10:38,848
think the narrative of that we would go
hungry or there would be the problem for our

802
01:10:38,889 --> 01:10:46,028
farmers if we if we yeah if we reject this
omnibus is not is not correct and it's

803
01:10:46,115 --> 01:10:51,529
exactly of course in the farmers
interest to not to not allow and to ban

804
01:10:51,594 --> 01:10:54,035
particularly hazardous
pesticides and maybe

805
01:10:54,095 --> 01:10:59,988
to conclude of course we very much agree
that there should be a level playing field

806
01:11:00,077 --> 01:11:05,673
and that we should also not export pesticides
which have been banned here or import

807
01:11:05,735 --> 01:11:10,469
have residues in our food of banned
pesticides this is very clear and i think we

808
01:11:10,556 --> 01:11:16,445
fully agree on that point thank you very
much thank you and next speaker that i have

809
01:11:16,498 --> 01:11:21,112
on my list is mrs ohisala from the greens
thank you very much chair and thank you to

810
01:11:21,156 --> 01:11:27,467
the speakers experts i agriculture workers
face daily exposure to pesticides linked

811
01:11:27,524 --> 01:11:32,765
to cancer as we heard parkinson's disease
and reproductive harm and seasonal and

812
01:11:32,813 --> 01:11:37,745
migrant workers carry the heaviest burden
we've just finished the sixth revision of

813
01:11:37,810 --> 01:11:43,528
the carcinogens directive yet pesticides
and farm workers were largely absent from

814
01:11:43,605 --> 01:11:49,170
it and for us greens the hierarchy of
controls must start with substitution and

815
01:11:49,269 --> 01:11:56,774
reduce dependence on hazardous pesticides
not with ppe protection must not depend on

816
01:11:56,855 --> 01:12:03,020
your contract or your nationality and the
disease is farm workers develop much must

817
01:12:03,105 --> 01:12:10,266
be recognized as occupational diseases
everywhere in the eu and i have to comment my

818
01:12:10,337 --> 01:12:17,057
colleague here before i i heard you saying
that this is about penalizing the ones

819
01:12:17,188 --> 01:12:23,190
who feed us this is about protecting the
health and the lives of the ones who feed

820
01:12:23,255 --> 01:12:28,910
us i think this is something that we really
need to stress as a european parliament

821
01:12:28,980 --> 01:12:34,000
and my question also a bit similar than
the colleague but you were asking about the

822
01:12:34,044 --> 01:12:40,281
concrete measures so if you could once more
maybe effort and pan europe elaborate to

823
01:12:40,369 --> 01:12:46,109
one max two of the most important measures
you would now put in place in order to

824
01:12:46,175 --> 01:12:54,425
protect the workers because we already saw
huge list but where should we start thank

825
01:12:55,139 --> 01:13:10,156
you all right mr van ivanov yes thanks
thanks a lot i think let's say the most

826
01:13:10,245 --> 01:13:16,520
important measures indeed i think we need
to start with implementing legislation i

827
01:13:16,583 --> 01:13:21,526
mean we have already a good legislation osh
framework but also pesticides regulation

828
01:13:21,572 --> 01:13:28,332
but they are not effectively effectively
implemented i think we we when we look at

829
01:13:28,384 --> 01:13:29,375
the reality in the

830
01:13:29,375 --> 01:13:34,300
agricultural sector because of the sector
specificities which i mentioned in the in

831
01:13:34,453 --> 01:13:42,958
in the beginning we see that. We quite
often risk assessment are not not conducted

832
01:13:43,057 --> 01:13:49,126
at the workplace when we have migrant and
seasonal seasonal workers they are not

833
01:13:49,230 --> 01:13:56,280
properly informed and trained in in in a
language understandable to them and this is

834
01:13:56,350 --> 01:14:01,336
quite important as we see that they build
up a significant share of the workforce in

835
01:14:01,386 --> 01:14:06,824
in the sector we need to see how to ensure
also an effective labor protection also

836
01:14:06,897 --> 01:14:15,046
for the one which are not cover. Let's say
by by by a formal formal employment which

837
01:14:15,099 --> 01:14:19,775
is as i said is widespread in agricultural
in agricultural sector it's it's quite

838
01:14:19,835 --> 01:14:24,406
often that people are hired against their
will and without being let's say and

839
01:14:24,457 --> 01:14:28,191
without employment being formally formally
formally registered and recorded but

840
01:14:28,235 --> 01:14:33,446
they're still have to enjoy also the the
same workers rights as as workers who are

841
01:14:33,498 --> 01:14:37,987
let's say in a formalized in a formalized
employment and i think the same goes with

842
01:14:38,049 --> 01:14:46,168
the pesticides regulation we have let's
say a low in in place which the sustainable

843
01:14:46,235 --> 01:14:51,105
use of pesticides directly which actually
mandates that chemicals pesticides should

844
01:14:51,186 --> 01:14:56,041
be used as a last as the last alternative
but we see that the implementation when it

845
01:14:56,084 --> 01:14:59,629
comes to the implementation that this
is this is not this is not this is not

846
01:14:59,681 --> 01:15:04,372
respected and if we start let's say with
with this proper lamentation and prevent

847
01:15:04,444 --> 01:15:09,151
any weakening of the current framework
what's the case with the omnibus 10 i think

848
01:15:09,204 --> 01:15:14,906
we have already done a very important
significant step in enhancing protection of

849
01:15:15,010 --> 01:15:22,609
farm workers thank you very much and next
speaker is mr alvin it is from the left

850
01:15:22,775 --> 01:15:30,867
σας ευχαριστώ as my sorry there was also
for mrs de champelle yes sorry no problem

851
01:15:30,950 --> 01:15:38,149
thank you very much yes i i agree in many
points with with ivan from effort indeed a

852
01:15:38,222 --> 01:15:43,624
very a key point is to implement the current
legislation much better to enforce it

853
01:15:43,691 --> 01:15:49,399
also much better and for example regarding
the 1107 regulation there has been the

854
01:15:49,475 --> 01:15:50,555
best committee the

855
01:15:50,555 --> 01:15:56,792
the report of the best committee in 2019
which has a very important recommendations

856
01:15:56,855 --> 01:16:02,467
on how to to better implement and close
these loopholes in implementation and so to

857
01:16:02,530 --> 01:16:06,586
further implement these recommendations
would be an important step because my

858
01:16:06,635 --> 01:16:11,522
colleagues have done an analysis of this
and a very small percentage of these

859
01:16:11,568 --> 01:16:18,733
recommendations have been implemented then
about the recognition yes so i think this

860
01:16:18,792 --> 01:16:22,849
first point is about prevention and and
this has to do with really implementing

861
01:16:22,895 --> 01:16:27,939
regulation much better i would also want
to stress the directive as i could only do

862
01:16:27,989 --> 01:16:32,455
it shortly in my presentation the sustainable
use of pesticides directive it really

863
01:16:32,511 --> 01:16:37,639
mandates only using pesticides as a very
last resort but this is far from reality

864
01:16:37,717 --> 01:16:41,995
right now and we hear from many farmers
across across different countries in the eu

865
01:16:42,034 --> 01:16:47,015
that's what they really miss is independent
scientific advice on how they can make

866
01:16:47,060 --> 01:16:52,798
their cropping system more resilient and
really reduce the the use of pesticides and

867
01:16:52,866 --> 01:16:59,629
yeah this is key to really implement
ipm to reduce exposure as well about the

868
01:16:59,711 --> 01:17:04,065
recognition of occupational diseases
linked to pesticides i think here the

869
01:17:04,111 --> 01:17:10,043
parliament could could maybe think of an
own initiative for example to really ask

870
01:17:10,119 --> 01:17:16,160
also the eo commission to to really make
that a priority because now we have only a

871
01:17:16,221 --> 01:17:21,395
list of recommended occupational diseases
in which pesticides parkinson's disease

872
01:17:21,472 --> 01:17:26,200
are not represented as i said so i think
this could be a very important step

873
01:17:26,252 --> 01:17:32,612
concrete step the parliament could take and
then indeed about the omnibus we already

874
01:17:32,715 --> 01:17:39,792
said it definitely not weakening not.
Current authorization and risk assessment as

875
01:17:39,840 --> 01:17:44,492
has really also been stressed by many
scientists across europe but what that has to

876
01:17:44,581 --> 01:17:50,781
happen is indeed we we we we can and
should really increase accessibility and

877
01:17:50,857 --> 01:17:56,937
implementation of alternatives and this
should be among more done by by working

878
01:17:56,988 --> 01:18:02,333
through the delays by increased capacity
of size also stated that which we through

879
01:18:02,411 --> 01:18:04,955
experts extra per member
states they can actually

880
01:18:05,375 --> 01:18:12,323
in three year yeah handle the delays and
and process them so these things are very

881
01:18:12,395 --> 01:18:17,795
important and i've also been described for
example in the refit report it has also

882
01:18:17,866 --> 01:18:25,394
been described what can be done to implement
regulation 1107 much better and to and

883
01:18:25,446 --> 01:18:30,755
to ensure increased capacity and less delays
thank you very much thank you very much

884
01:18:30,815 --> 01:18:37,724
and now mr alvin it's please ευχαριστώ
χρήσιμη όμως παρέμβαση πραγματικά και για μας

885
01:18:37,775 --> 01:18:44,044
και πολύ χρήσιμη είναι και η σημερινή μας
συνάντηση και συζήτηση και ελπίζω να την

886
01:18:44,130 --> 01:18:50,821
ακούνε και οι συμπολίτες μας τα κράτη μέλη
κοιτάξτε η επαγγελματική έκθεση ορισμένα

887
01:18:50,915 --> 01:18:56,277
φυτοφάρμακα έχει συσχετιστεί με συγκεκριμένους
καρκίνους όπως ακούσαμε σήμερα και με

888
01:18:56,340 --> 01:19:01,032
τη νόσο του πάρκινσον και όπως ακούσαμε
αυτές οι συνέπειες μπορούν να εμφανιστούν

889
01:19:01,091 --> 01:19:06,260
μετά από πολλά χρόνια και από τη συλλογή
της eurostat από τις αναγνωρισμένες

890
01:19:06,328 --> 01:19:12,617
επαγγελματικές ασθένειες ορισμένα κράτη
μέλη έχουν την φοβερή τακτική του πονηρού

891
01:19:12,695 --> 01:19:17,795
στριφοκάμουλου δεν το αναγνωρίζω ότι
υπάρχει θέμα δεν υπάρχει πρόβλημα δεν την

892
01:19:17,855 --> 01:19:24,768
αναγνωρίζω την ασθένεια δεν υπάρχει ασθένεια
έξυπνο σε κάθε κράτος μέλος νομίζω ότι

893
01:19:24,829 --> 01:19:30,459
χρειαζόμαστε ουσιαστικούς ελέγχους δυνατότητα
καταγγελίας χωρίς αντίποινα πρόσβαση

894
01:19:30,536 --> 01:19:36,330
σε κατάλληλη ιατρική παρακολούθηση για όλους
όσους εργάζονται στη γεωργία εμείς στην

895
01:19:36,372 --> 01:19:40,118
ελλάδα παραδείγματος χάρη έχουμε μικρούς
κλήρους δηλαδή είναι και αγρότες και

896
01:19:40,175 --> 01:19:46,379
εργάτες ο ίδιος αλλά βεβαίως έχουμε και
εργάτες γης συμπεριλαμβανομένων λοιπόν των

897
01:19:46,444 --> 01:19:51,294
αυτοαπασχολούμενων χρειαζόμαστε αντιπροσωπευτική
καταγραφή της έκθεσης αναγνώριση

898
01:19:51,360 --> 01:19:56,195
και αποζημίωση των επαγγελματικών ασθενειών
και ο εργάτης γης πρέπει να ενημερώνεται

899
01:19:56,255 --> 01:20:02,998
στη γλώσσα που κατανοεί και γνωρίζει πότε
μπορεί να επιστρέψει με ασφάλεια στην

900
01:20:03,065 --> 01:20:07,559
καλλιέργεια τώρα θέλω να πω ακόμα ότι
η μικρή παραγωγή χρειάζονται γεωπονική

901
01:20:07,629 --> 01:20:13,934
υποστήριξη και εκπαίδευση πρόληψης όμως το
ξέρετε σε πολλά κράτη μέλη και στη δικιά

902
01:20:13,992 --> 01:20:18,823
μου έχουμε σκάνδαλα τα τα ποσά τα χρήματα
δεν πάνε σε αυτούς που πρέπει να πάνε οι

903
01:20:18,872 --> 01:20:24,290
πόροι πάνε αλλού ρωτώ ρωτώ πώς σκέφτεστε
να αντιμετωπιστεί η υποκαταγραφή των

904
01:20:24,335 --> 01:20:25,595
επαγγελματικών ασθενειών και

905
01:20:25,655 --> 01:20:31,206
ειδικά όσων εργάζονται με την έκθεση σε
φυτοφάρμακα πώς θα διασφαλιστεί η δυνατότητα

906
01:20:31,254 --> 01:20:36,995
πρόσβασης των εργατών γης στα δεδομένα τους
στα data τους μετά την αποχώρηση από το

907
01:20:37,055 --> 01:20:42,731
χώρο εργασίας τους ώστε να μπορούν
ενδεχομένως να να ανασυνθέσουν το ιστορικό

908
01:20:42,815 --> 01:20:48,792
έκθεσής τους σε επικίνδυνες ουσίες και
σε περίπτωση ασθένειας και ένα τελευταίο

909
01:20:48,875 --> 01:20:53,996
μήπως πάμε πάλι στην εοκ εδώ πάμε για
ένωση μήπως χρειαζόμαστε κοινά ευρωπαϊκά

910
01:20:54,085 --> 01:21:00,162
εργαλεία επιτέλους και τα κράτη μέλη οι
κυβερνήσεις να συμμορφώνονται ουσιαστικά και

911
01:21:00,220 --> 01:21:07,745
να μην θέτουν σε κίνδυνο εργάτες και αγρότες
θα στηρίζαμε θα υποστηρίζαμε ακόμα και

912
01:21:07,815 --> 01:21:13,595
αυστηρότερες κυρώσεις στα παρα στα παρανομούντα
κράτη μέλη ευχαριστώ κύριε άντερσον

913
01:21:24,515 --> 01:21:29,193
so not specified question do you all want
wish to answer then i'll start with mr

914
01:21:29,281 --> 01:21:35,068
delano thank you it's a very difficult
topic because indeed member states as you

915
01:21:35,151 --> 01:21:40,290
know follow the directives on this so
they have different criteria so it's quite

916
01:21:40,355 --> 01:21:46,891
difficult in our field to link certain
long term illnesses where especially where

917
01:21:46,976 --> 01:21:54,315
exposure is staggered where the latency
of the disease is very long term to link

918
01:21:54,385 --> 01:21:59,435
them to workplaces we have a descriptive
study in the works in yosha to understand

919
01:21:59,495 --> 01:22:05,765
already at this point we what criteria
each country uses for cancer as is member

920
01:22:05,818 --> 01:22:10,886
state has a very different approach or can
have varying degrees of approach due to

921
01:22:10,943 --> 01:22:15,263
this long latency how many years of
exposure that it takes what were the work

922
01:22:15,359 --> 01:22:19,961
conditions what do they require that the
workers meet what criteria they require

923
01:22:19,999 --> 01:22:24,573
that the workers meet so that the disease
is eventually treated as an occupational

924
01:22:24,637 --> 01:22:29,452
disease and we're aim to have this study
out by november 2027 so this is one answer

925
01:22:29,499 --> 01:22:34,961
i can give you on our side beyond indeed
acknowledging and and saying that it's a

926
01:22:35,028 --> 01:22:40,289
very difficult topic also because we're
we're looking at very varying varying

927
01:22:40,355 --> 01:22:52,775
degrees of criteria across member states
and mrs yes thank you very much yes so as i

928
01:22:52,852 --> 01:22:57,347
showed in my slides there is only three
countries up until now who have officially

929
01:22:57,395 --> 01:23:03,395
recognized it but indeed in other countries
there can sometimes be a system in place

930
01:23:03,539 --> 01:23:10,878
in which individual case per case basis
per case per case basis sorry individuals

931
01:23:10,942 --> 01:23:16,813
can try to ask for a compensation but from
what we hear this is very difficult for

932
01:23:16,889 --> 01:23:23,139
example in belgium it is also possible in
a way to to ask for compensation if you

933
01:23:23,190 --> 01:23:28,108
expect you have been exposed and your disease
has a link with pesticide exposure but

934
01:23:28,206 --> 01:23:34,111
then we hear that even doctors right now
don't necessarily make the link so why

935
01:23:34,188 --> 01:23:39,668
would then and then patients of course
themselves not even make the link neither and

936
01:23:39,733 --> 01:23:43,725
then when they have a doctor who can
really guide them it's still extremely

937
01:23:43,800 --> 01:23:47,892
difficult but then we see in the countries
where they have made steps to recognize

938
01:23:47,947 --> 01:23:50,975
parkinson's disease or
others there's still big

939
01:23:51,215 --> 01:23:56,134
differences in indeed the criteria for
example in france if i'm correct you have to

940
01:23:56,188 --> 01:24:01,377
be 10 years exposed in germany that's much
less so we really see this also as a key

941
01:24:01,436 --> 01:24:08,079
gap to work on an eu level framework and
of course to make any any person who has

942
01:24:08,156 --> 01:24:13,221
been exposed and has a disease which can
potentially be linked to to pesticides

943
01:24:13,283 --> 01:24:18,126
should be able to to get recognized and
receive compensation there was also a

944
01:24:18,217 --> 01:24:24,035
question on data and i i i want to stress
that already now so it's mandatory for

945
01:24:24,095 --> 01:24:29,469
professional users of pesticides to register
pesticide use data but it was not yet

946
01:24:29,555 --> 01:24:34,668
mandatory to do this digitally and from
next year's next year member states will

947
01:24:34,724 --> 01:24:39,295
have to gather this digitally and this
will be very important because it it's very

948
01:24:39,346 --> 01:24:44,457
important that this is a user friendly
system in which different people different

949
01:24:44,502 --> 01:24:49,321
actors can really reach these data and
certainly also for victims of pesticide

950
01:24:49,391 --> 01:24:54,133
exposure that they can easily access them
even if it's from exposure that happened

951
01:24:54,187 --> 01:25:04,122
many years ago so yeah thank you very much
thank you mr ivano yes maybe very very

952
01:25:04,163 --> 01:25:08,456
brief not to repeat also what i already
said i think it's important first of all

953
01:25:08,522 --> 01:25:13,273
that we achieve also a certain grad of
harmonization at the european level and i

954
01:25:13,319 --> 01:25:17,520
think as i said at the moment it's up to
the each member state to decide if they

955
01:25:17,567 --> 01:25:21,133
recognize particular diseases occupational
disease linked to pesticides or not and

956
01:25:21,196 --> 01:25:25,496
within the case with parkinsons we have
only three member states and i think we have

957
01:25:25,542 --> 01:25:28,587
appropriate eastern rate instrument also
the european level with the european

958
01:25:28,624 --> 01:25:32,620
semester for occupational diseases
which was also meant to be turned into a

959
01:25:32,685 --> 01:25:36,924
directive at at certain point so this this
is something which maybe can be taken up

960
01:25:36,979 --> 01:25:42,371
taken up again and at least efforts
together with if pw has been mandating and

961
01:25:42,443 --> 01:25:47,753
advocating advocating for that surely when
it comes to the criteria it's still we

962
01:25:47,793 --> 01:25:50,911
need to see what what can the european
level can do in terms of also harmonizing

963
01:25:50,949 --> 01:25:55,047
let's say the framework and the criteria
what we have been arguing from point of

964
01:25:55,125 --> 01:25:57,815
view of effort is that also let's say the

965
01:25:58,475 --> 01:26:02,984
let's say the barriers for workers to prove
this quite often disclosure link between

966
01:26:03,035 --> 01:26:07,168
the professional activity and the recognition
as occupational disease it's quite

967
01:26:07,235 --> 01:26:12,427
it's quite high in many cases and for that
for instance one of our let's say main

968
01:26:12,486 --> 01:26:17,853
demands has been to have every worker every
farm worker to have to be entitled to a

969
01:26:17,915 --> 01:26:22,448
document which proves the chemicals and
pesticides used during their professional

970
01:26:22,492 --> 01:26:27,171
activity this is something which has been
discussed within which has been taken up

971
01:26:27,224 --> 01:26:32,086
also in the draft report on the sustainable
use of pesticides regulation which was

972
01:26:32,167 --> 01:26:38,130
unfortunately not dropped voted down in in
the parliament but this is i think a very

973
01:26:38,195 --> 01:26:42,080
important practical tool which can
facilitate also the recognition of of

974
01:26:42,133 --> 01:26:47,498
occupational diseases and ensure also
access to this important information for for

975
01:26:47,555 --> 01:27:00,782
workers thank you and then mrs melino mrs
melino do you wish to take the floor si

976
01:27:00,855 --> 01:27:05,506
grazie solo per due precisazioni che mi
sono state offerte da alcuni interventi

977
01:27:05,555 --> 01:27:16,404
precedenti il primo è una diciamo un accenno
relativo alla alla all'omnibus e e al

978
01:27:16,488 --> 01:27:21,773
cosiddetto far west che si immagina come
scenario vorrei solo ricordare che la

979
01:27:21,828 --> 01:27:26,630
proposta della commissione dice
chiaramente che se emergono nuove evidenze

980
01:27:26,698 --> 01:27:31,952
scientifiche queste devono essere valutate
a discapito di ogni altra disposizione

981
01:27:32,003 --> 01:27:37,043
ecco vorrei ricordare che non siamo in un
ambito in cui tutto è possibile tutto è

982
01:27:37,102 --> 01:27:42,613
libero ma credo che sia una una un accenno
opportuno da fare il secondo riguarda

983
01:27:42,707 --> 01:27:47,178
cosa fanno cosa si fa concretamente per
la protezione dei lavoratori e per la

984
01:27:47,229 --> 01:27:51,947
protezione anche dell'agricoltori ricordiamo
che gli agricoltori non sono datori di

985
01:27:52,021 --> 01:27:59,408
lavoro che stanno nei loro uffici al
chiuso ma sono figure sono persone che

986
01:27:59,495 --> 01:28:03,268
condividono con i lavoratori ovviamente
ne hanno la responsabilità ma condividono

987
01:28:03,313 --> 01:28:07,667
gli stessi rischi la stessa esposizione
ecco vorrei ricordare non ho fatto in tempo

988
01:28:07,709 --> 01:28:12,627
nel mio intervento che l'efat il geopa
sono impegnate o c'è uno strumento

989
01:28:12,695 --> 01:28:19,251
interessante vi invito anche a consultarlo
si chiama oira online interactive risk

990
01:28:19,339 --> 01:28:21,635
assessment ed è una strumento

991
01:28:22,055 --> 01:28:28,655
interattivo che consente in modo molto
semplice molto intuitivo di fare una prima

992
01:28:28,715 --> 01:28:33,485
valutazione dei rischi professionali anche
non in presenza di diciamo conoscenze

993
01:28:33,536 --> 01:28:38,355
particolarmente approfondite ma da diciamo
degli allarmi importanti e questi sono

994
01:28:38,423 --> 01:28:43,691
degli strumenti concreti praticabili che
ovviamente non esulano dal rispetto della

995
01:28:43,736 --> 01:28:48,069
legislazione sul lavoro e della sicurezza
sul lavoro quello che noi il messaggio che

996
01:28:48,127 --> 01:28:53,035
volevamo e vorremmo che oggi passasse è
che la sicurezza non si garantisce soltanto

997
01:28:53,089 --> 01:28:56,935
rispettando le norme sulla carta è
evidente che queste vadano rispettate ed è

998
01:28:56,992 --> 01:29:01,350
evidente che gli agricoltori vogliono che
si rispettino perché si innescano fenomeni

999
01:29:01,395 --> 01:29:06,461
di concorrenza sleale a cui non vogliamo
prestarci però la sicurezza si garantisce

1000
01:29:06,505 --> 01:29:11,304
anche facendo in modo che ogni misura
di prevenzione si possa tradurre in una

1001
01:29:11,359 --> 01:29:19,235
protezione che sia reale e che sia effettiva
per chi lavora nei campi grazie thank

1002
01:29:19,283 --> 01:29:23,627
you very much we didn't move on to the
second round of questions under catch the eye

1003
01:29:23,711 --> 01:29:28,895
and as i said before if there are envisant
or agri members present please you are

1004
01:29:28,955 --> 01:29:33,010
welcome to take the floor we will take all
the questions in one block and then give

1005
01:29:33,053 --> 01:29:38,361
the floor back to the experts for answers
and for possible concluding remarks and

1006
01:29:38,437 --> 01:29:44,086
please limit for the questions please limit
them to around one minute starting with

1007
01:29:44,149 --> 01:29:51,377
mr danielson from the snd thank you also
thank you to all the speakers i think it's

1008
01:29:51,455 --> 01:29:56,951
clear from the hearing today that workers
in agriculture have a high risk of

1009
01:29:57,024 --> 01:30:03,903
exposure to cancergenic risk factors we
also know that it's a high risk sector in

1010
01:30:03,977 --> 01:30:08,864
terms of risk of labor exploitation and
today we have heard about the principles

1011
01:30:08,915 --> 01:30:15,210
such as the hierarchy of controls precautionary
principles and that exposure can be

1012
01:30:15,277 --> 01:30:21,793
limited with correct preventive measures
but let's assume that the precautionary

1013
01:30:21,851 --> 01:30:27,333
principle preventive measures and risk
assessments are less likely to occur when you

1014
01:30:27,404 --> 01:30:34,481
have labor exploitation at the worksite
if this is true which i hold to be quite

1015
01:30:34,552 --> 01:30:36,215
obvious isn't that the fact

1016
01:30:36,695 --> 01:30:43,862
that the taking away the social conditionality
as proposed by the agri council would

1017
01:30:43,928 --> 01:30:49,838
mean that more workers get exposed to
pesticides and other cancergenic substances at

1018
01:30:49,905 --> 01:30:57,251
the workplace and in the end we will have
more workers get in cancer and in the end

1019
01:30:57,395 --> 01:31:02,295
miss lose their life because they get
exposed at the workplace that's the question

1020
01:31:02,367 --> 01:31:06,639
thank you thank you very much i now have
mrs saharia and mr andrush on my speakers

1021
01:31:06,687 --> 01:31:14,144
list is there anyone else who is to
take the floor if not mrs saharia please

1022
01:31:14,315 --> 01:31:19,595
ευχαριστώ κυρία πρόεδρε κάθε τόσο
ερχόμαστε στην ολομέλεια και ψηφίζουμε για

1023
01:31:19,675 --> 01:31:25,124
φυτοφάρμακα και ζιζανιοκτόνα και βλέπουμε
ξανά και ξανά να προωθείται η χαλάρωση των

1024
01:31:25,202 --> 01:31:31,400
περιορισμών στο όνομα της ανταγωνιστικότητας
ποια συμφέροντα κρύβονται πίσω από

1025
01:31:31,515 --> 01:31:38,827
αυτές τις αποφάσεις τα λόμπι των χημικών
βιομηχανιών μόνο αυτοί ποιοι πίσω από αυτές

1026
01:31:38,906 --> 01:31:44,351
τις αποφάσεις είναι άνθρωποι ένας εργάτης
γης ας πούμε ένας αγρότης δουλεύει χρόνια

1027
01:31:44,405 --> 01:31:49,754
μέσα στα φυτοφάρμακα τα εισπνέει έρχεται
σε επαφή μαζί τους πολλές φορές χωρίς την

1028
01:31:49,805 --> 01:31:55,091
απαραίτητη προστασία και μετά από 10-15
χρόνια αρρωσταίνει σοβαρά πώς θα αποδείξει

1029
01:31:55,153 --> 01:32:00,261
ότι αρρώστησε από τη δουλειά του ποιος θα
αναλάβει την ευθύνη ποιο επίσημο έγγραφο

1030
01:32:00,330 --> 01:32:05,910
γράφει ότι αυτός ο άνθρωπος από αυτές τις
ουσίες που εκτέθηκε έχει αρρωστήσει είναι

1031
01:32:05,975 --> 01:32:12,044
απαίτηση των εργατών η υποχρεωτική καταγραφή
της έκθεσής τους στα χημικά η δωρεάν

1032
01:32:12,129 --> 01:32:18,494
ιατρική παρακολούθηση εφόρου ζωής και η
ουσιαστική προστασία των εργαζομένων όχι δεν

1033
01:32:18,550 --> 01:32:22,924
μπορεί η ανταγωνιστικότητα να περάσει
πάνω από τα πτώματα των εργαζομένων δεν

1034
01:32:22,974 --> 01:32:27,335
γίνεται και αυτό πρέπει να το αποφασίσουμε
πλέον και να μην χαλαρώνουμε τα μέτρα

1035
01:32:27,395 --> 01:32:38,192
ευχαριστώ πολύ and mr andrush thanks
a lot well this discussion is maybe

1036
01:32:38,269 --> 01:32:44,121
unexpectedly timely and i will follow up
johan's intervention because 10 days ago

1037
01:32:44,187 --> 01:32:48,493
agriculture ministers adopted their
position to the legislation on common

1038
01:32:48,564 --> 01:32:55,340
agriculture policy for post 28 period and
majority of european ministers refused

1039
01:32:55,415 --> 01:33:01,099
refused commissions proposal for binding
the access to agri subsidies with social

1040
01:33:01,175 --> 01:33:06,755
conditionality even weakening
compared to to current situation so

1041
01:33:07,415 --> 01:33:13,194
social conditionality covers two particular
topics working conditions as regulated

1042
01:33:13,270 --> 01:33:19,520
by national and and european legislation
and occupational and safety and health

1043
01:33:19,608 --> 01:33:25,283
rules today if national labor inspectorate
uncovers violation of ocean rules agri

1044
01:33:25,369 --> 01:33:34,879
companies are penalized by cutting zoom of
subsidies since 2028 this rule should no

1045
01:33:34,964 --> 01:33:40,286
longer be applied and access to agri
subsidies should be guaranteed also for

1046
01:33:40,402 --> 01:33:48,282
companies that demonstrably violate
ocean rules contrary colleagues ministers

1047
01:33:48,383 --> 01:33:56,881
confirmed that animal welfare and plant
health will remain as conditionalities for

1048
01:33:56,961 --> 01:34:04,495
access to agri subsidies so dear colleagues
i know that this legis this particular

1049
01:34:04,553 --> 01:34:09,778
legislation doesn't fall under competencies
of this of this committee however

1050
01:34:09,875 --> 01:34:15,011
contrary to me you are members of different
groups so i would like finally i would

1051
01:34:15,093 --> 01:34:23,915
like to to ask you to do your best to
overturning this this minister's decision in

1052
01:34:23,975 --> 01:34:29,943
the parliament once we will vote on this
legislation thank you thank you very much

1053
01:34:29,998 --> 01:34:35,347
and we then move back to our experts in
the same order so starting with mr de leon

1054
01:34:35,435 --> 01:34:40,921
thank you very much and thank you for
for the the lively debate and interesting

1055
01:34:40,983 --> 01:34:45,381
questions they're not easy questions not
the least because from you osha i do have

1056
01:34:45,425 --> 01:34:50,601
to say as you well know that this is
outside of our scope what i can tell you is

1057
01:34:50,650 --> 01:34:55,035
that there we are tripartite agency so
we have as you know the employers the

1058
01:34:55,076 --> 01:34:58,727
employees and governments on our board
and there's a consensus that the osh legal

1059
01:34:58,775 --> 01:35:05,393
framework with that we advise with our
research not influence or propose in any way

1060
01:35:05,442 --> 01:35:11,102
is generally seen as the gold standard and
at the same time we we we try to promote

1061
01:35:11,190 --> 01:35:16,196
measures and and guidelines to protect
workers and the motto for that i i i have to

1062
01:35:16,237 --> 01:35:19,755
remind everybody it's good for you good
for business so we do see that when there's

1063
01:35:19,800 --> 01:35:24,218
investment in good prevention we actually
have studies that show there's a return on

1064
01:35:24,257 --> 01:35:30,096
that investment in the in the lower cost
down the line so while the the specific

1065
01:35:30,145 --> 01:35:33,515
questions which were very directly
addressed is is outside of our

1066
01:35:33,635 --> 01:35:39,223
scope to to answer in general the wash
framework is seen as quite healthy also

1067
01:35:39,286 --> 01:35:44,108
because it's the product of long debates
and agreement between the three partite

1068
01:35:44,195 --> 01:35:49,465
partners and we hope that this dialogue
can continue again in the future hopefully

1069
01:35:49,535 --> 01:35:59,442
relying on the data that we provide thank
you and mrs champion thank you very much

1070
01:35:59,531 --> 01:36:04,417
yeah regarding the social conditionality
indeed we have been very surprised to see

1071
01:36:04,475 --> 01:36:10,115
this change in the the general approach of
the of the council of course this is key

1072
01:36:10,166 --> 01:36:16,012
it's it's difficult to believe that this
was that this was removed as were other key

1073
01:36:16,098 --> 01:36:22,947
key provisions we think for example the
that the transition payments which was we

1074
01:36:23,002 --> 01:36:27,781
think a good proposal of the commission
which made which were made voluntarily while

1075
01:36:27,822 --> 01:36:32,379
this kind of schemes are exactly what is
needed to for example support farmers in

1076
01:36:32,470 --> 01:36:39,224
phasing out harmful pesticides so and yes
i think the questions are correct it would

1077
01:36:39,275 --> 01:36:45,095
indeed lead probably to more exposure for
workers and to more risk for workers given

1078
01:36:45,155 --> 01:36:49,542
that the social conditionality is is
when this conditionality would be removed

1079
01:36:49,595 --> 01:36:55,133
because yeah this criteria would just not
be there anymore to receive public funding

1080
01:36:55,225 --> 01:37:01,002
and the cap overall should not fund and
support harmful practices but should of

1081
01:37:01,058 --> 01:37:07,041
course only support practices which are
healthy for farmers for civil society

1082
01:37:07,129 --> 01:37:13,905
overall and for the environment regarding
the question on data how can someone prove

1083
01:37:13,993 --> 01:37:18,849
i want again repeat so this is why this
digital pesticide use data are key otherwise

1084
01:37:18,904 --> 01:37:23,929
it's indeed becomes very difficult for
someone to to prove to what they have been

1085
01:37:24,008 --> 01:37:29,435
exposed or what they have been using
which might have been a factor in the

1086
01:37:29,515 --> 01:37:35,090
development of their disease i maybe if
i if i quickly want to respond to the

1087
01:37:35,137 --> 01:37:41,055
comment made on the omnibus and that it
would keep targeted revision just as it's

1088
01:37:41,155 --> 01:37:47,067
important to to to specify this there is
already now in the regulation an option to

1089
01:37:47,135 --> 01:37:53,508
ad hoc revise based on latest scientific
evidence in article 21 but in practice this

1090
01:37:53,589 --> 01:38:00,803
has proven to be very difficult and also
you transfer the burden of proof now it's

1091
01:38:00,875 --> 01:38:01,655
it's very logical

1092
01:38:01,655 --> 01:38:08,743
that producers have to every 10 15 years
again provide the dossier pay for this show

1093
01:38:08,850 --> 01:38:15,324
that as a certain pesticide is not
particularly hazardous and if you remove this

1094
01:38:15,397 --> 01:38:21,195
then all the burden comes on authorities
on civil society to try to fight for a

1095
01:38:21,277 --> 01:38:26,204
certain pesticides to be reviewed and from
experience this would in practice be very

1096
01:38:26,255 --> 01:38:32,155
difficult and really not comparable to
to periodic review we have now maybe to

1097
01:38:32,225 --> 01:38:37,580
conclude yes i would like to just emphasize
again that much better protection is

1098
01:38:37,642 --> 01:38:45,455
needed not less it's really about the major
human health crisis the numbers are are

1099
01:38:45,575 --> 01:38:51,314
very yeah alarming and the evidence that
is there also on the links with pest with

1100
01:38:51,384 --> 01:38:58,198
pesticides and certain diseases are are
very strong for certainly for a serious of

1101
01:38:58,280 --> 01:39:03,895
diseases so more than enough is needed
is known to really act and to use this to

1102
01:39:03,949 --> 01:39:09,411
apply the precautionary principle while
also really supporting farmers to phase out

1103
01:39:09,502 --> 01:39:16,088
hazardous pesticides and and implement
sound alternatives thank you very much thank

1104
01:39:16,190 --> 01:39:22,932
you and mr ivanov yes thank you thank you
very much no i cannot agree more that the

1105
01:39:22,984 --> 01:39:27,893
decision which was taken by by the agrifish
council few few weeks ago it's it stands

1106
01:39:27,945 --> 01:39:33,629
in stark contradiction to the objective to
to reduce exposure to to pesticides among

1107
01:39:33,695 --> 01:39:38,990
farm workers and from our point of view
it's a it's a very big political political

1108
01:39:39,085 --> 01:39:43,774
mistake as or has been already said the
social conditionality it's currently

1109
01:39:43,829 --> 01:39:47,987
contains three directives two on occupation
of safety and health one on predictable

1110
01:39:48,035 --> 01:39:55,212
and working conditions and let me say that
one of the directives from from the osh

1111
01:39:55,267 --> 01:39:59,521
framework it's the framework directive which
also contains the main instrument which

1112
01:39:59,574 --> 01:40:04,710
we have in the osh framework the risk
assessment which is also important to ensure

1113
01:40:04,811 --> 01:40:10,226
that the exposure to to
pesticides is is reduced given.

1114
01:40:10,295 --> 01:40:14,156
Let's say the sector specificities which
i mentioned also the implementation gaps i

1115
01:40:14,221 --> 01:40:20,154
think it's really important that we leverage
any possible policy fields to improve

1116
01:40:20,255 --> 01:40:23,375
and to reduce the the exposure
to pesticides and i think

1117
01:40:24,695 --> 01:40:29,615
the common agricultural policy it's it's
one policy field which needs to be needs to

1118
01:40:29,675 --> 01:40:35,352
be leveraged it's also quite disappointing
that the arguments which led also to this

1119
01:40:35,396 --> 01:40:40,467
decision by the agrifish council were
also quite quite misleading and false if

1120
01:40:40,535 --> 01:40:45,017
you're interested we have also engaged with
this arguments and try to debunk them so

1121
01:40:45,068 --> 01:40:49,774
if you if you need some some some arguments
some some additional information on that

1122
01:40:49,835 --> 01:40:54,540
we're happy happy to provide this and again
we rely very much on the parliament but

1123
01:40:54,588 --> 01:40:59,160
also on your important role as employment
committee as even if let's say it's the

1124
01:40:59,223 --> 01:41:03,655
competence lies with another committee
of of the parliament i think it's it's an

1125
01:41:03,702 --> 01:41:07,764
aspect which concerns very much also the
and interact with the competencies of this

1126
01:41:07,805 --> 01:41:11,202
committee i think it's it would be important
also to to talk to your colleagues in

1127
01:41:11,244 --> 01:41:16,901
agri committee and to reiterate again the
importance of this of this mechanism so it

1128
01:41:17,011 --> 01:41:23,091
remains preserved and and eventually also
secured in the in the in the subsequent

1129
01:41:23,145 --> 01:41:29,869
interinstitutional negotiations and secondly
on on the comment that health and lives

1130
01:41:29,911 --> 01:41:34,524
are more important than competitiveness i
cannot also agree more i mean health and

1131
01:41:34,613 --> 01:41:40,165
lives of people have has to have always
a priority and i always we always tend to

1132
01:41:40,235 --> 01:41:45,513
say from the trade union movement that
actually good health environmental standards

1133
01:41:45,575 --> 01:41:49,835
are not obstacle to the competitiveness of
the european economy they are actually an

1134
01:41:49,873 --> 01:41:53,889
essential part a trademark trademark of the
european competitiveness and this is how

1135
01:41:53,941 --> 01:42:09,020
it should be seen thank you very much
and mrs merlino grazie un accenno sulla

1136
01:42:09,077 --> 01:42:18,575
condizionalità sociale non voglio esimermi
ma solo per ecco fare un appello a non a

1137
01:42:18,635 --> 01:42:25,258
non confondere lo strumento con l'obiettivo
per noi è fondamentale la legislazione

1138
01:42:25,319 --> 01:42:30,774
europea le legislazioni nazionali europee
prevedono già sanzioni molto severe molto

1139
01:42:30,839 --> 01:42:34,923
severe per chi viola le norme sulla salute
e sulla sicurezza dei lavoratori nonché

1140
01:42:34,974 --> 01:42:39,430
tutte le altre norme relative alla
legislazione sul lavoro quindi non stiamo

1141
01:42:39,483 --> 01:42:42,215
parlando di una norma
che va ad intervenire

1142
01:42:42,395 --> 01:42:45,781
su un vuoto su una lacuna normativa ma
stiamo parlando di una norma che va a

1143
01:42:45,824 --> 01:42:51,088
intervenire su un elemento addizionale noi
siamo assolutamente convinti l'invito è

1144
01:42:51,141 --> 01:42:55,667
anche a tutti voi a ragionare su quanto
il nostro impianto legislativo rispetto a

1145
01:42:55,740 --> 01:43:01,705
paesi diversi dai nostri e a regioni del
mondo diverse dalle nostre siano tra i più

1146
01:43:01,775 --> 01:43:06,744
maturi e tra i più evoluti e a cercare
di preservare questo grado di evoluzione

1147
01:43:06,815 --> 01:43:13,604
normativa di rispetto delle norme sul
lavoro e facendosi che gli agricoltori e con

1148
01:43:13,666 --> 01:43:18,281
essi i lavoratori che sono nelle loro
aziende possano essere accompagnati in questa

1149
01:43:18,335 --> 01:43:22,483
transizione è una transizione complessa
ciò che si chiede ciò che chiedono gli

1150
01:43:22,535 --> 01:43:30,197
agricoltori non è di essere esenti da
responsabilità non è quello di attenuare le

1151
01:43:30,248 --> 01:43:35,213
loro responsabilità ne siamo perfettamente
coscienti lo viviamo tutti i giorni nelle

1152
01:43:35,288 --> 01:43:40,595
nostre vite l'invito è quello ad accompagnare
l'agricoltura in questa transizione

1153
01:43:40,655 --> 01:43:45,735
attraverso strumenti attraverso risorse
attraverso anche la collaborazione

1154
01:43:45,802 --> 01:43:50,483
interistituzionale e anche con i sindacati
agricoli dei lavoratori attraverso delle

1155
01:43:50,534 --> 01:43:56,072
misure che siano misure che pensino anche
al lato ad azioni positive io sto pensando

1156
01:43:56,135 --> 01:44:00,523
al agli investimenti in competenze agli
investimenti in tecnologie sono tutti

1157
01:44:00,575 --> 01:44:05,084
elementi che vanno da ultima istanza
a beneficio anche di un miglioramento

1158
01:44:05,135 --> 01:44:09,574
complessivo delle condizioni di salute
e di sicurezza della nostra agricoltura

1159
01:44:09,635 --> 01:44:19,680
grazie thank you very much and after all
of these questions and answers where a lot

1160
01:44:19,754 --> 01:44:24,195
of topics and points have been raised made
a short list implementation of existing

1161
01:44:24,242 --> 01:44:29,558
legislation omnibus x occupational diseases
list and recognition cmrd six the right

1162
01:44:29,604 --> 01:44:33,995
to information from the point of view of
workers the social conditionalities i will

1163
01:44:34,055 --> 01:44:40,633
also give the floor to the commission
representatives for comments mr fabio faraula

1164
01:44:40,767 --> 01:44:45,298
from from from the employment sector in the
commission please you have the floor for

1165
01:44:45,342 --> 01:44:51,460
a round three minutes thank you chair good
afternoon everybody everyone first of all

1166
01:44:51,511 --> 01:44:56,593
let me say that the commission is happy
to participate in this exchange of such an

1167
01:44:56,658 --> 01:44:57,858
important topic

1168
01:44:58,535 --> 01:45:05,007
also allow me to remind that in the eu
agricultural workers are protected from the

1169
01:45:05,075 --> 01:45:11,368
risks of exposure to pesticides through
three main paths product approval rules

1170
01:45:11,442 --> 01:45:17,681
occupational safety and health legislation
and third enforcement by member states on

1171
01:45:17,744 --> 01:45:22,802
the first point the eu legal framework
establishes that pesticides can only be

1172
01:45:22,857 --> 01:45:27,714
placed on the market and used if they
are authorized following a scientific

1173
01:45:27,767 --> 01:45:33,167
assessment of the risks to human health
and environment in addition when a product

1174
01:45:33,218 --> 01:45:38,330
is authorized specific conditions may be
imposed to reduce worker exposure such as

1175
01:45:38,407 --> 01:45:45,553
training limits to application methods
buffer zones and use of pp as specifically

1176
01:45:45,612 --> 01:45:50,933
regards the occupational safety and health
legislation allow me to underline that

1177
01:45:50,991 --> 01:45:57,651
the uwash framework directive which
applies to all activity sectors with the

1178
01:45:57,727 --> 01:46:02,695
exception of course of those sectors
that have been recalled in previous

1179
01:46:02,754 --> 01:46:10,170
interventions also covers agricultural
workers this legislation defines general

1180
01:46:10,235 --> 01:46:15,190
principles sets minimum requirements and
allows member states to adopt stricter

1181
01:46:15,264 --> 01:46:19,574
national measures importantly the commission
is focused on protecting workers from

1182
01:46:19,633 --> 01:46:24,851
the risks of exposure to hazardous chemical
substances this is mainly done through

1183
01:46:24,901 --> 01:46:30,014
supporting effective implementation and
continuous update of the relevant eu

1184
01:46:30,095 --> 01:46:35,141
regulatory framework in particular by
setting occupational exposure limit values in

1185
01:46:35,195 --> 01:46:40,175
the framework of the chemical agents
directive and the carcinogens mutagens and

1186
01:46:40,235 --> 01:46:46,063
reprotoxic substances directive the process
relies on scientific evidence and is

1187
01:46:46,124 --> 01:46:51,176
based on a well-established procedure with
the involvement of the tripartite working

1188
01:46:51,230 --> 01:46:56,680
party on chemicals of the advisory committee
on safety and health at work in this

1189
01:46:56,775 --> 01:47:01,342
context experts representing workers
employers and national authorities address

1190
01:47:01,388 --> 01:47:07,333
health concerns relating to the exposure
of workers to chemicals hazardous chemicals

1191
01:47:07,415 --> 01:47:14,845
for possible action at the eu level concrete
examples of these action include the

1192
01:47:14,942 --> 01:47:21,341
recently adopted sixth revision of the cmrd
the five updates of the chemical agents

1193
01:47:21,395 --> 01:47:26,015
directives the update of the
asbestos at work directive the

1194
01:47:26,135 --> 01:47:31,868
publication of guidelines for example the
one on asbestos and the one on hazardous

1195
01:47:31,942 --> 01:47:38,298
medicinal products as well as the establishment
of an indicative list of hazardous

1196
01:47:38,383 --> 01:47:46,297
medicinal products and finally the already
mentioned agricultural eu osha oira and

1197
01:47:46,504 --> 01:47:53,651
oshwiki to conclude let me remind that
while the eu sets the legal framework

1198
01:47:53,709 --> 01:47:58,546
national authorities are responsible for
implementation and enforcement of the rules

1199
01:47:58,611 --> 01:48:04,879
and for checking compliance and inspections
well the senior labor inspectors

1200
01:48:04,955 --> 01:48:13,812
committee supports member states in doing
that thank you thank you very much and

1201
01:48:13,853 --> 01:48:17,490
that brings us to the end of this
public hearing i think it's been a very

1202
01:48:17,546 --> 01:48:22,685
interesting hearing and discussion so also
showing that there is clearly rule for

1203
01:48:22,760 --> 01:48:27,938
room for improvement and of course we have
to ensure that workers and farmers alike

1204
01:48:27,987 --> 01:48:32,637
in agriculture are properly protected
against the risks arising from the use of

1205
01:48:32,735 --> 01:48:37,237
pesticides so i'd like to thank once again
our speakers for the insights you have

1206
01:48:37,303 --> 01:48:41,407
provided and also the other committees
and especially the agri committee for good

1207
01:48:41,450 --> 01:48:46,335
cooperation in the organization of this
hearing and as i mentioned i think we have

1208
01:48:46,381 --> 01:48:52,644
gotten a long list of topics to address
and to follow up on so this hearing really

1209
01:48:52,700 --> 01:48:58,569
provided with i think substantial food
for thought and also points for follow-up

1210
01:48:58,631 --> 01:49:03,635
work so thank you very much and to the
members we will see each other tomorrow

1211
01:52:52,055 --> 01:52:53,255
.
