1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:03,000
Brussels Live
Transcribed and translated by AI

2
00:03:54,872 --> 00:04:02,903
Hello, hello everybody. Good afternoon.
We start because there are five minutes

3
00:04:03,007 --> 00:04:08,301
past. But for me, because I'm
very tired, I speak in Romanian.

4
00:04:08,372 --> 00:04:12,452
Please, for to listen a.

5
00:04:15,392 --> 00:04:20,862
Have you received the agenda?
I will not read it out again.

6
00:04:20,928 --> 00:04:23,918
If you agree, we can go
straight to the agenda.

7
00:04:23,980 --> 00:04:30,170
Also, Members have been notified of the
interpretation service we are benefiting

8
00:04:30,216 --> 00:04:35,760
from and I thank the interpreters. We
have interpretation in many languages.

9
00:04:35,861 --> 00:04:44,378
I would like you to listen. If it is
easy for you in your mother tongue.

10
00:04:44,445 --> 00:04:50,177
I remind you that our sitting is
being broadcast on the internet.

11
00:04:50,268 --> 00:04:57,909
It is also available on tablet, laptop.
The voting system will be available

12
00:04:57,963 --> 00:05:02,301
tomorrow. Today, we will not be voting,
but voting will only be possible in the

13
00:05:02,365 --> 00:05:07,865
meeting room. Therefore, you
will need your voting cards.

14
00:05:08,283 --> 00:05:15,095
I could inform you that, right at the
beginning, we have a few deadlines for

15
00:05:15,164 --> 00:05:23,656
amendments, namely for 11 November we
have the deadline for the CIPSACT report.

16
00:05:23,759 --> 00:05:30,752
Would Mr Paulius Sodagar be so
kind as to give his opinion?

17
00:05:31,112 --> 00:05:32,372
I don't know it's correctly

18
00:05:32,432 --> 00:05:41,569
whether or not, and on 12 November we
also have a deadline for the multimodal

19
00:05:41,694 --> 00:05:50,002
booking and passenger protection report
on rail transport for a single ticket;

20
00:05:50,144 --> 00:05:56,346
the rapporteur for opinion is Mr
Cosma, Mr Cosma Zlotovski from the ECR.

21
00:05:56,421 --> 00:06:11,542
We have the first item on the agenda. We
have the Chair of the working group for the

22
00:06:11,661 --> 00:06:16,691
implementation of the Digital Markets
Act, Mr Andreas Schwab, who is with us.

23
00:06:16,761 --> 00:06:23,345
And of course, today, for the first item
on the agenda, we have asked the Chair of

24
00:06:23,395 --> 00:06:28,323
the group to present a report on the
meeting held on 4 November this year, in no

25
00:06:28,379 --> 00:06:30,812
more than five minutes.

26
00:06:31,352 --> 00:06:32,552
Andreas, te rog.

27
00:06:33,932 --> 00:06:42,045
Yes, thank you very much, Madam Chair. I
am also tired, which is why I am speaking

28
00:06:42,255 --> 00:06:48,275
in German. But on the matter, of course,
I am happy to also summarise the points in

29
00:06:48,311 --> 00:06:52,774
English. If I have understood you correctly,
Madam Chair, I have five minutes, and

30
00:06:52,828 --> 00:06:58,724
since I am currently the only Member
present, I take the liberty of drawing

31
00:06:58,851 --> 00:07:03,725
attention to this. Of course, I am delighted
that you, Madam Chair, are chairing

32
00:07:03,792 --> 00:07:12,562
this meeting. But also at the last meeting
of the Digital Markets Act Working Group,

33
00:07:12,625 --> 00:07:19,843
the DMA Working Group, the number of
participants was rather low despite a highly

34
00:07:19,954 --> 00:07:24,789
interesting discussion. And so we need to
think together, certainly then also with

35
00:07:24,839 --> 00:07:29,524
the Chair and the coordinators, about how
we can continue our work in the working

36
00:07:29,580 --> 00:07:30,780
groups.

37
00:07:30,872 --> 00:07:37,601
Trotzdem nonetheless, I'm very happy to
report back from the meeting that we had

38
00:07:37,660 --> 00:07:42,343
last week. The latest DMA Working
Group took place last Wednesday.

39
00:07:42,392 --> 00:07:47,981
It was focused on the comparison of how
the EU and the US approach competition in

40
00:07:48,047 --> 00:07:53,398
digital markets. In a similar direction,
but with different means and different

41
00:07:53,455 --> 00:07:58,571
tools, with a focus especially
on enforcement and on remedies.

42
00:07:58,652 --> 00:08:03,245
The two sides, so the US and the EU, because
the European Commission was present as

43
00:08:03,441 --> 00:08:12,671
well as representatives from the state
attorneys of the United States, the two sides

44
00:08:12,785 --> 00:08:19,802
share one goal and that's that market
have to stay contestable and users have to

45
00:08:19,887 --> 00:08:25,335
have a real choice. We know
that the tools are different.

46
00:08:25,412 --> 00:08:29,335
Europe combines ex-ante regulation through
the DMA with the traditional competition

47
00:08:29,384 --> 00:08:35,222
enforcement angle. The US relies mainly on
a case-by-case litigation under antitrust

48
00:08:35,297 --> 00:08:39,950
law, increasingly driven by
courts and state authorities.

49
00:08:40,052 --> 00:08:45,332
State authorities because also they
have a lot of possibilities to launch

50
00:08:45,392 --> 00:08:50,376
proceedings that in the past have also been
done at federal level, but as there is a

51
00:08:50,443 --> 00:08:55,586
bit of a Trump bottleneck at federal level
at the moment, it seems that there is

52
00:08:55,643 --> 00:08:59,747
less of activity there. So let
me come a bit to the details.

53
00:08:59,792 --> 00:09:03,588
The outcomes look different too. In Europe,
the DMA has teased and the Commission

54
00:09:03,632 --> 00:09:08,247
has started to use them. In July, it
found Google non-compliant on two counts.

55
00:09:08,312 --> 00:09:11,716
Google search favored its own
services over those of its rivals.

56
00:09:11,792 --> 00:09:17,852
Which cost it 460 million euros. Google
Playbook developers from steering users to

57
00:09:17,912 --> 00:09:22,307
better offers, which costed
it another 400, 30 million.

58
00:09:22,412 --> 00:09:28,679
That makes 809 million euros in one go and
the third DMA fine after Apple and Meta.

59
00:09:28,772 --> 00:09:32,831
And the message from that seemed to be clear
and the Commission has also defended it

60
00:09:32,874 --> 00:09:39,079
in the working group. The rules of the DMA
for open markets also in digital are not

61
00:09:39,152 --> 00:09:45,728
a pure or a mere decoration. In the US, on
the contrary, money changes hands through

62
00:09:45,807 --> 00:09:51,239
settlements. Negotiated by a state attorney
general, 700 million dollars over Google

63
00:09:51,305 --> 00:09:53,732
Play pricing and privacy and on

64
00:09:53,852 --> 00:09:58,882
privacy, 1.3 billion dollars in one
case and 391 million in another.

65
00:09:58,952 --> 00:10:03,631
So you see that the amount of money on the
other side of the Atlantic is even higher

66
00:10:03,692 --> 00:10:07,169
and the president of the United
States isn't saying anything on this.

67
00:10:07,232 --> 00:10:12,165
So maybe the European Commission can
become also a bit more courageous.

68
00:10:12,272 --> 00:10:17,783
Meanwhile, in the US, the big federal
cases on search and edtech are still in the

69
00:10:17,878 --> 00:10:23,645
courts. Remedies and appeals are pending.
So the final word is yet to come.

70
00:10:23,792 --> 00:10:27,693
In this regard, we had the pleasure of
gathering two representatives of state

71
00:10:27,747 --> 00:10:32,472
attorney generals of DG Comp and DG Connect,
as well as of Google, to have also a

72
00:10:32,542 --> 00:10:38,098
bit an open discussion of a company that
was at stake in the presentations of both

73
00:10:38,162 --> 00:10:43,249
the European Commission and the state
attorneys from Tennessee and Colorado.

74
00:10:43,352 --> 00:10:48,692
And what I can say to you, Chairwoman, is
that overall, enforcement does not happen

75
00:10:48,772 --> 00:10:53,962
in isolation. The lessons from US proceedings
and from our own should inform how we

76
00:10:54,032 --> 00:10:57,842
apply the DMA and, where
needed, improve it.

77
00:10:57,992 --> 00:11:02,921
And I just want to share with you the view
that also our American state attorneys

78
00:11:02,969 --> 00:11:08,906
were very clear that they share the basic
logics of the DMA that they share the

79
00:11:08,984 --> 00:11:13,898
fines that the Commission has been putting
out and they don't share the view that

80
00:11:13,972 --> 00:11:19,182
this is any sort of trade instrument,
but they care as we do about openness of

81
00:11:19,247 --> 00:11:24,668
markets, about fairness of competition,
and therefore the working group will keep

82
00:11:24,708 --> 00:11:29,281
following these developments further.
And we believe that we have a very strong

83
00:11:29,339 --> 00:11:34,403
cooperation also with the United States in
that case rather with the state attorneys

84
00:11:34,472 --> 00:11:39,953
and less with the federal level. But as in
politics always, things may change soon.

85
00:11:40,052 --> 00:11:44,567
Sooner or later. And therefore I'm just
grateful that the Secretariat, Chairwoman,

86
00:11:44,612 --> 00:11:48,973
is always perfectly preparing these meetings
taking into account the proposals of

87
00:11:49,031 --> 00:11:54,168
the colleagues that are participating.
There are plenty of people that complain.

88
00:11:54,212 --> 00:11:57,035
There are plenty of companies that would
like to show that the Commission is

89
00:11:57,081 --> 00:12:02,417
sometimes going too far. We are there
holding to account the European Commission to

90
00:12:02,469 --> 00:12:05,072
be sure that the enforcement
of the DMA is going

91
00:12:05,312 --> 00:12:08,093
further. And like that, I
think we should continue.

92
00:12:08,132 --> 00:12:11,636
Thank you so much. For those that have
helped, for those that have been attending

93
00:12:11,672 --> 00:12:14,492
and also for you, Chairwoman, to
give me the time to report on it.

94
00:12:18,632 --> 00:12:25,956
Thank you, Andreas. Yes, I also believe
that this working group is important and

95
00:12:26,002 --> 00:12:30,413
more people need to
participate and contribute.

96
00:12:30,558 --> 00:12:34,359
The necessary conclusions. And certainly
to share them with the European Commission,

97
00:12:34,410 --> 00:12:37,952
to see how we can improve things. That
was also the purpose of setting up the

98
00:12:37,994 --> 00:12:39,194
working group.

99
00:12:39,332 --> 00:12:40,652
Mulțumesc. Thank you, Sean.

100
00:12:42,992 --> 00:12:48,001
The next point on our agenda today I
believe is extremely important and I hope it

101
00:12:48,054 --> 00:12:55,556
will also be followed online. SMEs and the
EU’s SME test in practice – effectiveness

102
00:12:55,631 --> 00:13:01,279
and gaps. We have a study and I would like
to thank for the exchange of views and

103
00:13:01,325 --> 00:13:08,218
the presentation of the study. To those
who have taken on the responsibility and

104
00:13:08,280 --> 00:13:14,443
have come here today and are
speaking here in front of Mr.

105
00:13:14,526 --> 00:13:21,752
Timotei Iong, Research Fellow, is a
researcher associated with the Centre for

106
00:13:21,805 --> 00:13:30,701
Empirical Jurisprudence at Leuven. Also
present is the committee through Digi Grow,

107
00:13:30,913 --> 00:13:37,023
I would like to begin with a
10-minute presentation of the study.

108
00:13:37,128 --> 00:13:43,168
After that, the committee will have five
minutes to express its point of view, and

109
00:13:43,233 --> 00:13:47,248
then, of course, colleagues if they
wish to share their own points of view.

110
00:13:47,306 --> 00:13:52,892
So, I would like to thank the researcher
and give him the floor for ten minutes.

111
00:13:57,932 --> 00:13:59,132
Thank you, Chair.

112
00:13:59,672 --> 00:14:06,690
Dear Honorable Members, my name is Timothy
Iong, PhD in Economics, Research Fellow

113
00:14:06,752 --> 00:14:13,667
at SEPS. Today I represent my colleagues
and present this study on SMEs and the EU

114
00:14:13,784 --> 00:14:14,972
SME test.

115
00:14:14,972 --> 00:14:18,452
In practice, effectiveness and gaps. Next.

116
00:14:21,272 --> 00:14:29,372
Some background information. SMEs account
for more than 99% of businesses in number

117
00:14:29,512 --> 00:14:35,294
in the EU. It is therefore reasonable
to believe or assume that most of the

118
00:14:35,372 --> 00:14:44,098
legislation will affect SMEs. Indeed, in
EU law-making framework, SMEs have been

119
00:14:44,181 --> 00:14:52,427
prominent. Just to name some examples,
the 2008 Commission's Communication Think

120
00:14:52,532 --> 00:14:56,307
Small First is one of
the guiding documents.

121
00:14:56,432 --> 00:15:02,626
Within the better regulation framework,
there are SME filter, SME test, and SME

122
00:15:02,752 --> 00:15:09,883
check. The SME filter is an early step
to determine if a legislative proposal is

123
00:15:09,954 --> 00:15:19,348
relevant to SMEs. The SME test is an
assimilation of the proposal's impact on SMEs.

124
00:15:19,472 --> 00:15:25,592
And the SME check is a template for
the presentation of the SME test.

125
00:15:25,892 --> 00:15:33,872
Besides, there is a network of SME envoys
which include national representatives and

126
00:15:33,932 --> 00:15:39,188
some business associations which will be
consulted when needed especially about

127
00:15:39,268 --> 00:15:47,907
whether a proposal is relevant to SMEs.
And yet there are voices saying that SMEs

128
00:15:48,007 --> 00:15:52,592
bear significant burdens
coming from EU legislation.

129
00:15:52,712 --> 00:15:59,318
So the main policy research question of
this study is whether the better regulation

130
00:15:59,372 --> 00:16:06,092
framework has done a good job in balancing
good policy and regulatory burdens on

131
00:16:06,212 --> 00:16:12,125
SME. Next slide please.
The purposes of the study.

132
00:16:12,212 --> 00:16:19,892
We collected the impact assessment published
between 2020 and 2025 and see how they

133
00:16:19,982 --> 00:16:27,650
considered SME impacts especially when
they had a separate session or annex of SME

134
00:16:27,794 --> 00:16:33,207
test. In particular, we would like to see
if the better regulation toolbox published

135
00:16:33,272 --> 00:16:39,431
in November 2021 made any differences.
Also, we have six case studies.

136
00:16:39,512 --> 00:16:43,089
They allow us to go
deeper into the details.

137
00:16:43,172 --> 00:16:49,091
Learn the good and not so good practices
and consult six interviewees for their

138
00:16:49,195 --> 00:16:56,620
perspectives and ideas. Finally, we
summarize the findings into 10 recommendation

139
00:16:56,724 --> 00:17:02,137
ideas. Next. Next slide
please. Methodology.

140
00:17:02,252 --> 00:17:11,819
We check 224 impact assessments and
identified 172 business or SME related impact

141
00:17:11,912 --> 00:17:18,938
assessments. Then we design a data collection
template and had a team of researchers

142
00:17:19,064 --> 00:17:26,779
reading the 172 impact assessments. Besides,
we used machine to read those documents

143
00:17:26,843 --> 00:17:27,272
and

144
00:17:27,272 --> 00:17:35,912
produced some statistics. We have selected
six cases covering different policy areas

145
00:17:36,032 --> 00:17:43,198
from AI to late payments regulation.
Also, we have a case study template that

146
00:17:43,270 --> 00:17:50,172
ensures all cases are comparable.
Moreover, we conducted six interviews.

147
00:17:50,252 --> 00:17:57,353
Which involved business associations and
national representatives associated with

148
00:17:57,482 --> 00:18:07,581
the SME envoys. Next slide please. So
first, let me show you the partition of the

149
00:18:07,715 --> 00:18:16,532
224 impact assessments. As mentioned before,
there are 172 business related impact

150
00:18:16,605 --> 00:18:25,911
assessments. Among these 172 impact
assessments, 55 were published before 2022.

151
00:18:26,012 --> 00:18:33,472
Which we call the pre-2021 subsample.
Because the 2021 edition of the better

152
00:18:33,546 --> 00:18:38,556
regulation toolbox was
published in November 2021.

153
00:18:38,672 --> 00:18:44,880
So we are quite sure that these 55 impact
assessments were not under the influence

154
00:18:44,972 --> 00:18:53,775
of the 2021 better regulation toolbox.
Then we separate 95 impact assessments

155
00:18:53,848 --> 00:18:58,892
published between September
2022 and December 2025.

156
00:18:59,012 --> 00:19:07,382
We call it the post-2021 subsample. As we
are quite sure that these were draft with

157
00:19:07,511 --> 00:19:15,992
the 2021 toolbox in place. In between, we
have 22 impact assessments we call it the

158
00:19:16,082 --> 00:19:22,955
mixed or transition
subsample. Next slide please.

159
00:19:23,132 --> 00:19:30,309
A very first statistics how often SMEs
are mentioned in these impact assessments.

160
00:19:30,392 --> 00:19:38,132
We can see from this table the trend is
increasing meaning that on average SMEs are

161
00:19:38,232 --> 00:19:47,342
more frequently mentioned by impact
assessments from the pre-2021 46 times to the

162
00:19:47,492 --> 00:19:52,421
post-2021 106 times
per impact assessments.

163
00:19:52,532 --> 00:20:00,660
Next slide please. So where on the impact
assessments are SMEs are mentioned?

164
00:20:00,752 --> 00:20:06,430
We divide one impact assessment
into 10 equal portions.

165
00:20:06,512 --> 00:20:12,221
And see on average how many times SMEs
are mentioned in different positions of an

166
00:20:12,289 --> 00:20:18,706
impact assessment. Blue line represents
the pre-2021 results and the green line

167
00:20:18,791 --> 00:20:26,899
represents the post-2021 results. We can
see that everywhere the post-2021 average

168
00:20:27,032 --> 00:20:36,965
is higher than the pre-2021 average. Besides,
the first peak of the post-2021 result

169
00:20:37,060 --> 00:20:45,885
which is at 20 to 30 percent comes
earlier than the pre-2021 results.

170
00:20:45,992 --> 00:20:51,812
Meaning that on average SMEs tend to
appear earlier in an impact assessment.

171
00:20:52,592 --> 00:21:00,118
The final jump of the post-2021 result
is obviously the consequence of the

172
00:21:00,177 --> 00:21:07,664
presentation of the SME test as an annex.
So here we conclude that the 2021 better

173
00:21:07,741 --> 00:21:13,284
regulation toolbox indeed influenced
how the commission draft their impact

174
00:21:13,352 --> 00:21:20,079
assessments. And SMEs and the
commission becomes more aware of the SME

175
00:21:20,205 --> 00:21:25,909
considerations. Now I'm going to show you
some other results which may not be as

176
00:21:25,979 --> 00:21:32,135
positive as this. Next
slide. Next slide please.

177
00:21:32,312 --> 00:21:39,407
So we found that SMEs are less mentioned
in the section of why should you act.

178
00:21:39,512 --> 00:21:46,042
It suggests that the commission might fail
to relate the need for you action to the

179
00:21:46,172 --> 00:21:54,926
SMEs. Also, SMEs are seldomly mentioned
in the monitoring and evaluation section.

180
00:21:55,052 --> 00:22:00,405
So meanwhile we see that quantification
is on an increasing trend.

181
00:22:00,512 --> 00:22:08,527
But very often cost estimation does not
differentiate SMEs from larger business.

182
00:22:08,672 --> 00:22:14,906
SME contributions to public consultations
were limited but business associations

183
00:22:14,980 --> 00:22:23,418
usually replied. But what we failed to
see is if those replies were influential.

184
00:22:23,612 --> 00:22:28,452
So some other useful findings. SME
and innovation is often discussed.

185
00:22:28,532 --> 00:22:36,000
95 times out of 172. Some
more than SME competitiveness.

186
00:22:36,092 --> 00:22:43,799
But market entry and SME monitoring
measures are less discussed.

187
00:22:43,952 --> 00:22:50,985
So next slide please. So we have six
case studies but I will not go into the

188
00:22:51,032 --> 00:22:56,635
details. I picked only some of them in
the I mean some of the findings in the

189
00:22:56,698 --> 00:23:01,172
presentation. Cost, quantification
is often not matched.

190
00:23:01,292 --> 00:23:07,029
With benefits discussion. So that means
the assessment cannot tell whether the

191
00:23:07,114 --> 00:23:13,876
legislation can justify the cost. In some
proposals such as the general product

192
00:23:13,961 --> 00:23:20,618
safety regulation other principles
take precedence over economic concerns.

193
00:23:20,732 --> 00:23:25,626
And therefore the space for SME
consideration is quite limited.

194
00:23:25,712 --> 00:23:31,147
A more general observation is that the
assessment does not differentiate the

195
00:23:31,216 --> 00:23:37,985
economic roles of firms and therefore
the SME impact discussed in the impact

196
00:23:38,036 --> 00:23:42,779
assessments are too general
to apply to actual businesses.

197
00:23:42,872 --> 00:23:49,446
In other cases SME impact remain qualitative
and did not affect much the design of

198
00:23:49,553 --> 00:23:56,492
the policy options. Finally in the case of
late payment regulation while the impact

199
00:23:56,792 --> 00:24:03,067
assessment report in general positive
feedback from stakeholders business

200
00:24:03,147 --> 00:24:09,040
associations in fact ask for
the withdrawal of the proposal.

201
00:24:09,152 --> 00:24:14,557
So I would encourage you to read the cases
if you are interested in one of the cases

202
00:24:14,651 --> 00:24:22,892
in the list. Next slide please. So now let
me summarize some findings before present

203
00:24:22,952 --> 00:24:29,162
to you some recommendations. First we got
an impression that SME test is a box taken

204
00:24:29,252 --> 00:24:35,146
exercise. With little influence on
the choice of the preferred option.

205
00:24:35,252 --> 00:24:41,408
Two we sometimes found SME test and the
competitiveness check overlap and there

206
00:24:41,480 --> 00:24:46,052
might be a better way to
integrate or separate them.

207
00:24:46,172 --> 00:24:52,772
Three the condition of SMEs is not well
understood and their roles in the markets

208
00:24:52,832 --> 00:24:59,715
are not well differentiated. Four the
analytical support to the SME analysis is

209
00:24:59,792 --> 00:25:07,034
often poor without evidence. It gives an
impression that SME analysis is to justify

210
00:25:07,112 --> 00:25:12,331
the commission's choices. Five
concerning stakeholder consultations.

211
00:25:12,392 --> 00:25:16,889
The number of SMEs
consulted is usually small.

212
00:25:17,012 --> 00:25:22,864
Next slide please. Sorry that
I missed number six here.

213
00:25:22,952 --> 00:25:28,094
Stakeholders consultations are sometimes
quite detached from the rest of the

214
00:25:28,211 --> 00:25:33,531
assessments. And concerns are
not linked to the policy options.

215
00:25:33,632 --> 00:25:40,585
Seven there is a lack of monitoring and
evaluation framework for SME impacts.

216
00:25:40,712 --> 00:25:48,467
Eight the RSB is working but lacks a stronger
mandate to improve the quality of the

217
00:25:48,592 --> 00:25:56,011
impact assessments. Nine we found that SME
considerations are often lost during the

218
00:25:56,110 --> 00:26:03,850
negotiations between co-legislators. Ten
we have not found examples where the impact

219
00:26:03,927 --> 00:26:10,702
assessment considers the cumulative
effects of EU legislations on SMEs.

220
00:26:10,832 --> 00:26:18,392
Next slide please. So now I present
to you some recommendations.

221
00:26:18,452 --> 00:26:24,590
First the think small first principle
should be fully implemented.

222
00:26:24,692 --> 00:26:29,291
That means the legislation should
be designed for small entities.

223
00:26:29,372 --> 00:26:35,409
The cost estimation is based on
the capabilities of small firms.

224
00:26:35,552 --> 00:26:41,260
Two the better regulation toolbox should
be designed the tools for SMEs but not to

225
00:26:41,352 --> 00:26:48,822
jam the analysis with another tools. Three
firms should not only be differentiated

226
00:26:48,893 --> 00:26:51,632
by their size but their economic roles

227
00:26:51,812 --> 00:26:57,692
so that the analysis can better study the
indirect or downstream effects along a

228
00:26:57,812 --> 00:27:05,032
value chain. Four an impact assessment
should be transparent with the supporting

229
00:27:05,132 --> 00:27:12,306
data and analytical steps made available
for verification and further studies.

230
00:27:12,392 --> 00:27:19,804
Five each public consultation should seek
an adequate SME representation on top of

231
00:27:19,910 --> 00:27:27,294
the replies from associations. Six an
impact assessment should demonstrate how SME

232
00:27:27,387 --> 00:27:34,256
consultation or the SME test influence
the policy options and choices.

233
00:27:34,352 --> 00:27:42,184
Seven a proposal should introduce SME
specific monitoring and evaluation measures.

234
00:27:42,272 --> 00:27:48,898
Eight the institutional oversight of
SME considerations and impact should be

235
00:27:48,968 --> 00:27:54,586
strengthened. The RSB should play a
bigger role and be more independent.

236
00:27:54,692 --> 00:28:01,959
Nine SME considerations should be maintained
throughout the legislative process.

237
00:28:02,072 --> 00:28:06,790
SME test should not stop being
relevant at the proposal stage.

238
00:28:06,872 --> 00:28:11,325
It should also be relevant
during the negotiation stage.

239
00:28:11,432 --> 00:28:17,301
Ten the commission should regularly
review the cumulative burdens on SMEs and

240
00:28:17,389 --> 00:28:21,566
provide more support. This
is all of my presentation.

241
00:28:21,632 --> 00:28:25,772
Thank you very much. Thank you chair.
And I welcome any comments and questions.

242
00:28:28,352 --> 00:28:33,190
Thank you very much. Even though it was
more than 10 minutes, I believe the study is

243
00:28:33,259 --> 00:28:39,294
very important. And I hope we can
have it for the entire committee.

244
00:28:39,453 --> 00:28:45,316
I am pleased that the European Commission
will speak after the presentation of the

245
00:28:45,408 --> 00:28:52,308
study, because I personally greatly
appreciate the outcome and the recommendations

246
00:28:52,356 --> 00:28:57,322
you have made, and I am very curious to see
what the Commission has to say regarding

247
00:28:57,389 --> 00:29:06,990
the results of this study. Thank you. So,
the Commission's representative will have

248
00:29:07,027 --> 00:29:11,828
five minutes. Commission, from Digi
Grău, let me see the name immediately.

249
00:29:12,002 --> 00:29:17,307
It is Mr, madam, Mr,
madam, Marie-Hélène Pradin.

250
00:29:17,433 --> 00:29:18,633
Pradin. Sorry.

251
00:29:22,172 --> 00:29:30,764
Thank you, Madam President. Thank you
and honourable Members of the Parliament.

252
00:29:30,828 --> 00:29:35,186
First of all, I would like to thank
you for commissioning this study.

253
00:29:35,235 --> 00:29:40,978
I believe we can only congratulate ourselves
on the attention paid to SMEs and the

254
00:29:41,059 --> 00:29:45,498
way in which they are taken into
account in the impact assessment.

255
00:29:45,552 --> 00:29:51,177
I will keep my remarks fairly general and
would like to make a few points and draw

256
00:29:51,241 --> 00:29:58,725
your attention to the following. First of
all, I believe it is important to point

257
00:29:58,869 --> 00:30:04,277
out that, in any case, our SME Unit and
the team responsible for the SME test

258
00:30:04,353 --> 00:30:09,174
methodology was not at all involved
or consulted for this study.

259
00:30:09,223 --> 00:30:13,964
We were not asked, we did not have the
opportunity to express our views on the

260
00:30:14,017 --> 00:30:21,127
document, and that is a bit regrettable
because from the outset we could also have

261
00:30:21,189 --> 00:30:26,402
contributed our expertise. Secondly, I
believe that in light of the presentation

262
00:30:26,470 --> 00:30:31,828
that has been made, we can only note the
progress that has been achieved over the

263
00:30:31,879 --> 00:30:36,949
period since 2021, since the Better
Regulation Toolbox of 2021 was put in place.

264
00:30:36,997 --> 00:30:40,993
SMEs are mentioned more frequently in
impact assessments, the quantification of

265
00:30:41,072 --> 00:30:46,012
costs has improved, even if it is not
yet optimal, and the SME filter has been

266
00:30:46,054 --> 00:30:50,666
applied to all proposals since 2022. I
mean, the figures speak for themselves:

267
00:30:50,725 --> 00:30:56,007
out of 224 impact assessments that have
been published, the share of those that

268
00:30:56,083 --> 00:31:03,083
include an SME test has risen from 23%
to 93% for initiatives that have been

269
00:31:03,126 --> 00:31:07,237
selected by the filter, and the mention
of SMEs in impact assessment reports has

270
00:31:07,305 --> 00:31:13,198
also more than doubled. So this demonstrates
a real progress in systematically

271
00:31:13,295 --> 00:31:19,887
taking into account the impact of proposals
on SMEs in the context of legislation

272
00:31:19,931 --> 00:31:23,033
drafting. Obviously, there are
still difficulties that remain.

273
00:31:23,102 --> 00:31:28,703
These have been highlighted by the study.
To improve the quality of these impact

274
00:31:28,810 --> 00:31:36,439
assessments in particular, the lack of
reliable data needs to be addressed by

275
00:31:36,513 --> 00:31:38,672
exploring, in particular, a more

276
00:31:38,792 --> 00:31:44,443
targeted SMEs, recourse to proxy variables
for qualitative elements where direct

277
00:31:44,501 --> 00:31:49,661
quantification is not possible, and finally
more transparent communication on data

278
00:31:49,730 --> 00:31:53,562
gaps explaining why
quantification was not possible.

279
00:31:53,612 --> 00:32:00,386
Thirdly, it is also about emphasising in
the presentation, more than in the study,

280
00:32:00,471 --> 00:32:04,128
that the SME is merely
one tool among others.

281
00:32:04,194 --> 00:32:09,588
It addresses one dimension, the SME
dimension, at a very specific stage in the

282
00:32:09,682 --> 00:32:15,835
legislative cycle. We must not forget that
this already begins before, at the very

283
00:32:15,935 --> 00:32:22,722
origin of the proposal, because as soon
as an initiative is announced, there is a

284
00:32:22,782 --> 00:32:26,669
public consultation, there is an impact
assessment, there is the drafting of the

285
00:32:26,716 --> 00:32:31,581
legal act, there are negotiations between
the European Parliament and the Council,

286
00:32:31,652 --> 00:32:36,418
and then there is the implementation. So
we try to intervene at all stages of this

287
00:32:36,521 --> 00:32:42,200
process. And that is why there is a whole
series of tools that have been put in

288
00:32:42,258 --> 00:32:46,424
place, which have already been
mentioned in the presentation:

289
00:32:46,534 --> 00:32:52,591
the filter, the test, the SME
check, which is also recent.

290
00:32:52,657 --> 00:32:58,068
And today, I am pleased to announce that
we want to go further and that there should

291
00:32:58,146 --> 00:33:04,902
be a new tool available in January 2027.
It was announced in the strategy for the

292
00:33:04,952 --> 00:33:07,517
single market to improve
the single market.

293
00:33:07,594 --> 00:33:13,361
In January 2027, we should publish a
collection of what we call SME-friendly

294
00:33:13,441 --> 00:33:19,035
provisions, which are good practices,
standard clauses that will be made available

295
00:33:19,101 --> 00:33:25,033
first to our services but also to
legislators to draft legislation that.

296
00:33:25,167 --> 00:33:30,768
will be more favourable
from the outset for SMEs.

297
00:33:30,845 --> 00:33:37,628
These are provisions that will cover key
elements of the regulation on renewing

298
00:33:37,701 --> 00:33:41,225
support for SMEs at
every stage, so to speak.

299
00:33:41,283 --> 00:33:47,517
I see that there has been feedback,
so I will conclude fairly quickly.

300
00:33:47,583 --> 00:33:50,673
We have taken good note of
the ten recommendations.

301
00:33:50,729 --> 00:33:56,332
Many of them have already been taken into
account since 2025 and since the study.

302
00:33:56,392 --> 00:33:59,192
I can go into more detail
if there are any questions.

303
00:33:59,552 --> 00:34:06,461
Finally, I would like to recall that the
simplification that is also currently being

304
00:34:06,507 --> 00:34:11,871
sought by the Commission, which is one of
its priorities, is a bit the other half of

305
00:34:11,936 --> 00:34:18,674
the picture. I will mention the 12 omnibus
packages that the Commission has already

306
00:34:18,764 --> 00:34:25,643
presented, which will bring their share of
improvements for SMEs and will also ease

307
00:34:25,742 --> 00:34:32,389
their administrative burden. This has
been estimated at €22.3 billion per year.

308
00:34:32,486 --> 00:34:35,956
Of which 7.7 billion
euros solely for SMEs.

309
00:34:36,034 --> 00:34:42,514
And you all know that there is this objective
to reduce the administrative burden on

310
00:34:42,644 --> 00:34:49,630
SMEs by 35 % by the end of this mandate.
So to conclude, we are satisfied with the

311
00:34:49,723 --> 00:34:55,916
study. It shows the efforts, sorry,
that have already been undertaken.

312
00:34:55,989 --> 00:35:01,112
Perhaps a quick reminder to say that
for this change to be truly real, all

313
00:35:01,162 --> 00:35:04,594
institutions need to move
in the same direction.

314
00:35:04,650 --> 00:35:09,100
Perhaps the best example is the regulation
on packaging and packaging waste.

315
00:35:09,160 --> 00:35:17,782
Recently, which could have been more
favourable to SMEs if it had been designed like

316
00:35:17,863 --> 00:35:22,767
this from the very
beginning. I will stop there.

317
00:35:22,821 --> 00:35:30,361
So we also count on the co-legislator
to take up this baton and improve the

318
00:35:30,424 --> 00:35:33,032
legislative provisions
for SMEs. Thank you.

319
00:35:38,012 --> 00:35:42,291
Thank you very much, and now, following
the presentation of the study and the

320
00:35:42,343 --> 00:35:48,980
committee's position, if the colleague from
Renew has a point of view, I would also

321
00:35:49,031 --> 00:35:54,294
like to speak. I invite them to ask
questions or request clarifications.

322
00:35:54,330 --> 00:35:55,530
Thank you.

323
00:35:58,952 --> 00:36:05,122
Ehm I will speak in Dutch. Well, thank you
anyway, and yes, I certainly want to say

324
00:36:05,194 --> 00:36:11,134
something in the context of SMEs because,
well, at the start of my mandate when I

325
00:36:11,190 --> 00:36:17,233
entered Parliament here, SMEs and
simplifying matters for SMEs were high on my

326
00:36:17,322 --> 00:36:25,022
agenda. And also within Renew we have fully
embraced the motto 'Think Small First'.

327
00:36:25,117 --> 00:36:28,290
So it is very important that
we have this presentation.

328
00:36:28,342 --> 00:36:32,162
Thank you also for the study
that has been carried out.

329
00:36:32,225 --> 00:36:35,867
And thank you also for the
response from the Commission.

330
00:36:35,935 --> 00:36:41,648
Ehm the study, eh, of course, shows
that there is still a lot to be done.

331
00:36:41,695 --> 00:36:47,184
Eh, but I also see the Commission, which
indeed indicates that since 2021, and the

332
00:36:47,252 --> 00:36:52,839
figures from the study also show
that, we have seen improvements.

333
00:36:52,897 --> 00:36:57,830
But not enough in my view. The eh Think
Small First principle is still not being

334
00:36:57,884 --> 00:37:01,533
applied sufficiently, and we also
see that reflected in the study.

335
00:37:01,590 --> 00:37:08,531
And I believe the importance of that
lies particularly in the fact that

336
00:37:08,623 --> 00:37:13,903
entrepreneurs, especially SMEs, are
confronted here with a piling up of rules.

337
00:37:13,975 --> 00:37:20,516
So the cumulative effect of the various
rules that we make here in this House means

338
00:37:20,625 --> 00:37:25,897
that, ultimately, certainly the small
entrepreneur does not have the capacity to

339
00:37:25,977 --> 00:37:30,796
review all those rules, to see
them and to understand them.

340
00:37:30,875 --> 00:37:34,872
So what else can we do about
this accumulation of rules?

341
00:37:34,928 --> 00:37:39,291
I see that the committee is already
working on omnibus bills, you know.

342
00:37:39,354 --> 00:37:42,265
So what we call the simplification debate.

343
00:37:42,344 --> 00:37:47,092
That is of great importance. But we can,
I think, also take further steps there.

344
00:37:47,154 --> 00:37:51,609
For the rest, it is of course important,
as also recommended, to involve SMEs at an

345
00:37:51,694 --> 00:37:56,925
earlier stage. And it is a shame that the
study notes that this is not yet happening

346
00:37:56,973 --> 00:38:03,086
sufficiently. In the effects, eh, the costs
for SMEs and, of course, also in the way

347
00:38:03,153 --> 00:38:07,197
in which, eh, SMEs are
considered in the regulations.

348
00:38:07,255 --> 00:38:13,253
And in that sense, eh, it is also important
that we involve SMEs earlier, eh, so

349
00:38:13,344 --> 00:38:18,563
that, as the example of the Packaging
Regulation was given, we do not again have to

350
00:38:18,621 --> 00:38:19,832
backtrack afterwards.

351
00:38:20,012 --> 00:38:22,715
to row. Eh because that
is double the work.

352
00:38:22,777 --> 00:38:28,648
So without wasting everyone’s time and
first plunging SMEs into a crisis and into

353
00:38:28,732 --> 00:38:32,204
the stress of whatever is now
being cooked up in Brussels.

354
00:38:32,248 --> 00:38:37,217
And that is unnecessary. Eh because I think
it is important that we take that into

355
00:38:37,271 --> 00:38:42,629
account from the outset. So I would like
to hear how we can better involve SMEs from

356
00:38:42,688 --> 00:38:49,438
the very beginning.
Thank you, Mr President.

357
00:38:49,725 --> 00:38:53,432
Okay, thank you, Commissioner.

358
00:38:53,672 --> 00:38:59,813
and the distinguished researcher can
respond to the issue because, from what I

359
00:38:59,930 --> 00:39:06,623
understand from my colleague, it seems that
SMEs are not satisfied with what we are

360
00:39:06,696 --> 00:39:10,399
doing together here to
make their lives easier.

361
00:39:10,461 --> 00:39:19,628
Who would like to open the debate or? I
believe that research, study, if you can say

362
00:39:19,694 --> 00:39:22,969
something about what has
been raised as an issue.

363
00:39:23,050 --> 00:39:29,703
How can we speed up and bring about a better
effect ultimately on simplification and

364
00:39:29,810 --> 00:39:32,252
regulation that have an impact on SMEs?

365
00:39:38,852 --> 00:39:46,946
Ъм so in my opinion or from the findings
of the study uh the think for a small first

366
00:39:47,033 --> 00:39:52,395
principle should be fully implemented in
a way that when the commission draft a

367
00:39:52,472 --> 00:39:58,402
legislation this they should say first
think about the impacts on these small

368
00:39:58,517 --> 00:40:04,200
entities for example you know in some of
the cases or in some impact assessment that

369
00:40:04,268 --> 00:40:11,331
we study the cost estimation is quite general
which applies to all the businesses in

370
00:40:11,401 --> 00:40:17,304
the economy but in fact you know the most
of the burdens would you know would be on

371
00:40:17,378 --> 00:40:23,746
the SMEs and usually they are the ones
who lack the financial means to respond to

372
00:40:23,823 --> 00:40:31,570
the cost so I think there should be a change
of the um of the way how the commission

373
00:40:31,652 --> 00:40:38,129
consider the impacts on the uh on the SMEs
um so you know trying to fully implement

374
00:40:38,192 --> 00:40:45,819
the think small first principle and
sometimes you know the SMEs are more like um

375
00:40:45,992 --> 00:40:50,972
additional analysis more like you know add
on to the main analysis which is you know

376
00:40:51,032 --> 00:40:55,261
to me the opposite of the
think small first principle.

377
00:40:55,352 --> 00:40:56,552
Thank you.

378
00:40:59,972 --> 00:41:04,652
Thank you. Commissioner, a response?

379
00:41:05,012 --> 00:41:12,539
Thank you, Madam President. Er, perhaps
a small reminder and a remark on two main

380
00:41:12,607 --> 00:41:19,900
points. Er, on the Think Small First
principle, er, so the idea of making

381
00:41:19,982 --> 00:41:27,019
legislation applicable for SMEs, er, I think
I explained that in my previous speech.

382
00:41:27,078 --> 00:41:31,535
We are really trying to take it
into account at all stages, er.

383
00:41:31,596 --> 00:41:36,494
There is first the filter. As soon as
there is the idea of the proposal, then the

384
00:41:36,545 --> 00:41:42,486
test, er, then the SME check, which
is now a mandatory annex of the impact

385
00:41:42,541 --> 00:41:48,109
assessment that goes not only to the
Commission but also to the Council and

386
00:41:48,194 --> 00:41:54,847
Parliament. And soon, we hope, the development,
in other words the provision of our

387
00:41:54,953 --> 00:42:02,193
services and the standard set of provisions
for the College, which will take account

388
00:42:02,251 --> 00:42:08,625
of SMEs that go beyond, in fact, the impact
assessment and the SMI test that we have

389
00:42:08,695 --> 00:42:14,412
in the impact analysis. So we are trying
to have this comprehensive package right

390
00:42:14,449 --> 00:42:18,166
from the start to finish for SMEs. But
perhaps I would like to make a second point.

391
00:42:18,246 --> 00:42:22,316
I mentioned this at the
conclusion of my speech earlier:

392
00:42:22,382 --> 00:42:27,585
the proposal is indeed prepared by the
Commission services, adopted by the College

393
00:42:27,646 --> 00:42:31,688
of Commissioners, but then it goes
to the Council and Parliament.

394
00:42:31,749 --> 00:42:36,038
And there, if I may, there are often
amendments and substantial amendments made.

395
00:42:36,089 --> 00:42:41,788
I am not saying whether they are justified
or not, but very often they are not

396
00:42:41,915 --> 00:42:47,540
sufficiently assessed for SMEs. This is
something we know has been acknowledged

397
00:42:47,639 --> 00:42:54,968
recently, and I believe the idea of
working towards a method to evaluate these

398
00:42:55,051 --> 00:43:01,259
impacts across the three institutions would
be a good thing to implement in a fully

399
00:43:01,310 --> 00:43:05,882
operational way. Of course, it is the
collegiate work of the institutions to discuss

400
00:43:05,934 --> 00:43:10,588
the Commission’s proposals, make
amendments and adopt them, but we would be

401
00:43:10,673 --> 00:43:17,428
available to also assess the impact that
these amendments may have on SMEs, and not

402
00:43:17,481 --> 00:43:18,812
just before the proposal.

403
00:43:19,292 --> 00:43:20,492
Thank you.

404
00:43:22,472 --> 00:43:25,004
Thank you very much. I will
also have two questions.

405
00:43:25,069 --> 00:43:32,975
One for... Those who conducted the
research, who carried out the study.

406
00:43:33,033 --> 00:43:40,078
You said in your presentation that,
first and foremost, there is too little

407
00:43:40,164 --> 00:43:45,905
consultation of SMEs when a new
legislative act is being drafted.

408
00:43:46,063 --> 00:43:55,396
And you spoke about late payments. My
question now is, and perhaps the Commission

409
00:43:55,504 --> 00:44:01,872
will respond to this, SMEs are dissatisfied
to a very high percentage in all 27

410
00:44:01,947 --> 00:44:06,966
Member States regarding the functioning
the directive on late payments, which has

411
00:44:07,034 --> 00:44:15,051
been in place since 2013 and is not
functioning properly, and we have asked – at

412
00:44:15,198 --> 00:44:20,760
least I personally have asked – for a
regulation rather than a directive to ensure

413
00:44:20,816 --> 00:44:23,905
uniform application across
all 27 Member States.

414
00:44:23,983 --> 00:44:29,504
Because if payment is delayed for a
large enterprise, the impact is smaller.

415
00:44:29,564 --> 00:44:34,217
If payment is delayed for a smaller
company, the impact is certainly greater.

416
00:44:34,297 --> 00:44:38,915
What is your view, and could you explain
what you meant by saying that companies

417
00:44:38,964 --> 00:44:44,488
should be differentiated not only by
turnover and number of employees, but also by

418
00:44:44,536 --> 00:44:49,512
the impact they have on the economy
and the sector in which they operate?

419
00:44:49,568 --> 00:44:55,004
Because I too tried in my country, in
Romania, when I was Minister, to introduce

420
00:44:55,044 --> 00:44:59,002
taxation based on CAEN codes, since the
profit rate and the ability to capitalise

421
00:44:59,061 --> 00:45:03,781
differ depending on the sector in which
I operate, in construction, textiles,

422
00:45:03,827 --> 00:45:08,141
furniture and so on. I do not know what
you meant, but perhaps you can explain.

423
00:45:08,201 --> 00:45:12,944
And to the Commission I will say frankly
that I have not felt the functioning of the

424
00:45:13,028 --> 00:45:20,320
Small Business Act. I have not felt the
functioning of ‘think small first’ and then

425
00:45:20,373 --> 00:45:26,224
we apply, and I myself say, as an SME, I
do not know how you thought, oh, I do not

426
00:45:26,284 --> 00:45:31,411
know how you consider it works, I do not
know who you consult to see whether they

427
00:45:31,463 --> 00:45:36,196
are satisfied or not. It is true that you
said we can make amendments ourselves, but

428
00:45:36,271 --> 00:45:41,078
I know that I have been at the
negotiator’s negotiation as rapporteur.

429
00:45:41,152 --> 00:45:45,932
The Commission is there in person and
often opposes when we want to make a

430
00:45:45,992 --> 00:45:50,700
change, and you know how difficult it is
to get the Council on board, which also

431
00:45:50,785 --> 00:45:55,864
opposes when we, the Parliament,
come forward with a proposal.

432
00:45:55,932 --> 00:45:59,855
But my question is, when you drew up
the Packaging Regulation and the Waste

433
00:45:59,906 --> 00:46:04,146
Regulation, I am asking you
directly, did you consult SMEs?

434
00:46:04,210 --> 00:46:08,282
I have held meetings with them many
times on these two documents, these two

435
00:46:08,356 --> 00:46:14,157
regulations, and it is extremely burdensome
for an SME to apply the Packaging

436
00:46:14,218 --> 00:46:18,461
Regulation and the Waste Regulation
because I do not see here that there is any

437
00:46:18,515 --> 00:46:21,667
difference between a large
company and a small company.

438
00:46:21,732 --> 00:46:24,932
They have to apply the same
regulations. Thank you.

439
00:46:36,212 --> 00:46:37,532
I therefore request a response.

440
00:46:42,692 --> 00:46:52,095
Right. So I I could give a short
answer to the question by by the chair.

441
00:46:52,232 --> 00:47:01,800
So when so. When we study the late payments
directive or regulation case, this is

442
00:47:01,873 --> 00:47:08,402
very interesting case because on the impact
assessments the commission said that in

443
00:47:08,485 --> 00:47:11,965
general the feedback from
stakeholder is positive.

444
00:47:12,032 --> 00:47:20,080
And what they want is more like a a unified
rule for all the sectors in the economy.

445
00:47:20,132 --> 00:47:26,557
They will follow the same the same rule
and then SMEs are only differentiated in

446
00:47:26,650 --> 00:47:32,656
terms of their size. But that actually when
we look into different comments and you

447
00:47:32,734 --> 00:47:38,687
know like opinions from
stakeholders and associations um.

448
00:47:38,852 --> 00:47:45,272
They said no in fact you know the late
payment situation differs significantly in

449
00:47:45,332 --> 00:47:50,254
different sectors. So there's no way that
you could have one single rule that will

450
00:47:50,320 --> 00:47:56,350
help all the SMEs in all the sectors. So
this this is you know how we've got the

451
00:47:56,407 --> 00:48:02,021
fundings that you know we fund in the
impact assessments often SMEs are not

452
00:48:02,106 --> 00:48:07,888
differentiated according to their economic
roles which is important when we try to

453
00:48:07,952 --> 00:48:16,472
understand the actual impact on the
SMEs. This is this is my short answer.

454
00:48:16,532 --> 00:48:17,252
Thank you.

455
00:48:17,252 --> 00:48:20,252
Thank you. And now the committee?

456
00:48:24,212 --> 00:48:27,604
Thank you, Madam President. Perhaps
you have asked several questions.

457
00:48:27,645 --> 00:48:30,057
I will try to address
the different points.

458
00:48:30,119 --> 00:48:37,794
Regarding the Small Business Act, in fact
it was introduced in 2009 and so it was

459
00:48:37,914 --> 00:48:43,395
before the establishment of all
the tools that we have created.

460
00:48:43,466 --> 00:48:51,236
Since then, in terms of better regulation,
before the SME filter, before the SME

461
00:48:51,304 --> 00:48:58,732
test, before the SME check, so this may
explain why SMEs had not been sufficiently

462
00:48:58,804 --> 00:49:05,734
taken into account. You are no doubt aware
that we recently adopted a communication

463
00:49:05,838 --> 00:49:13,596
last April to further improve matters,
which highlights simplicity by design right

464
00:49:13,704 --> 00:49:23,785
from the start of the proposals. I
would also like to remind you, regarding

465
00:49:23,914 --> 00:49:28,807
simplification, that as I mentioned in my
introduction, the Commission has called

466
00:49:28,877 --> 00:49:34,901
for the adoption of 12 omnibus texts to
date, but only three have been adopted.

467
00:49:34,987 --> 00:49:41,635
So we need time for the legislative
process to reach its conclusion and for the

468
00:49:41,708 --> 00:49:45,849
proposals to be implemented before
they can concretely bear fruit.

469
00:49:45,893 --> 00:49:52,773
We may regret the time it takes, but this
is the normal timeframe for legislation.

470
00:49:52,874 --> 00:49:58,372
On the issue of payment delays, I
fully understand your frustration.

471
00:49:58,453 --> 00:50:06,018
It is, moreover, shared at the level of
the committee and my unit in particular.

472
00:50:06,182 --> 00:50:12,492
Three years ago, we had proposed
a regulation to improve things.

473
00:50:12,640 --> 00:50:18,032
The Parliament was very supportive,
but the Council blocked it.

474
00:50:18,089 --> 00:50:23,308
There were quite a few discussions;
we tried to unblock the situation.

475
00:50:23,375 --> 00:50:29,063
Faced with this blockage and this inaction,
you know that the Commission chose to

476
00:50:29,166 --> 00:50:33,945
withdraw the proposal from the work
programme that was adopted last week.

477
00:50:34,011 --> 00:50:38,616
That does not mean, however, that we do
not want to do anything to improve things.

478
00:50:38,684 --> 00:50:44,408
We are currently reflecting on what we
can do to better implement the directive.

479
00:50:44,467 --> 00:50:50,641
Well, we will see how things and the
discussions can evolve subsequently.

480
00:50:50,739 --> 00:50:56,730
Regarding the consideration of the heterogeneity
of SMEs, because it is true that we

481
00:50:56,772 --> 00:50:57,992
talk about SMEs, but they are

482
00:50:58,892 --> 00:51:03,764
by nature very different in terms
of their size, their sector, between

483
00:51:03,864 --> 00:51:12,183
micro-enterprises and SMEs. In fact, in
our SME test, when a legislative proposal

484
00:51:12,291 --> 00:51:18,460
has been deemed highly relevant, we take
into account differentiation by size but

485
00:51:18,520 --> 00:51:24,015
also by sector. So this is something
that we are trying as much as possible to

486
00:51:24,132 --> 00:51:31,394
reflect. Finally, on the packaging and
packaging waste regulation, which, as we

487
00:51:31,444 --> 00:51:35,009
know, is criticised for creating additional
administrative burdens for businesses,

488
00:51:35,048 --> 00:51:40,847
and in particular for SMEs. The fact remains
that we must not forget the objective

489
00:51:40,920 --> 00:51:45,738
of the regulation, which is to improve
the functioning of the single market for

490
00:51:45,826 --> 00:51:51,984
packaging and to create economies of scale,
ultimately with a single set of rules.

491
00:51:52,038 --> 00:51:56,606
The idea is still to support a circular
economy that reduces dependence on raw

492
00:51:56,655 --> 00:51:59,951
materials and improves
the security of supply.

493
00:52:00,059 --> 00:52:06,770
The Regulation does indeed provide for
an adjustment period and exemptions with

494
00:52:06,828 --> 00:52:12,157
simplified requirements, including for small
businesses and micro-enterprises, which

495
00:52:12,215 --> 00:52:17,709
are exempted from certain reuse targets.
We have noted the difficulties in

496
00:52:17,787 --> 00:52:23,557
implementation, which is why last December
the Commission proposed an environmental

497
00:52:23,626 --> 00:52:29,601
omnibus that aimed to suspend the obligation
for Union producers to designate an

498
00:52:29,656 --> 00:52:34,441
authorised representative when they sell
directly to users in other Member States.

499
00:52:34,489 --> 00:52:40,128
This was intended to remove the significant
burden associated with designating such

500
00:52:40,224 --> 00:52:45,174
a representative, as the designation of a
representative costs a great deal for an

501
00:52:45,241 --> 00:52:51,998
individual company. The proposal is on the
table, I believe, and we are all in the

502
00:52:52,068 --> 00:52:55,615
Commission keen for it to be
adopted as quickly as possible.

503
00:52:55,665 --> 00:52:59,772
There have been quite a few discussions
and a blockage in the Council, I believe,

504
00:52:59,813 --> 00:53:05,252
but discussions have resumed, so we
can hope that this will improve things.

505
00:53:05,312 --> 00:53:11,419
things, it will go faster, and you
probably know that, as part of the Circular

506
00:53:11,489 --> 00:53:18,358
Economy Act, the Commission is preparing
a broader, more significant reform of

507
00:53:18,442 --> 00:53:25,593
mandatory representative systems. This
reform will focus on simplification,

508
00:53:25,652 --> 00:53:30,928
harmonisation and digitalisation. So we
will try to provide a more systematic

509
00:53:30,999 --> 00:53:34,652
solution to this difficulty. Thank you.

510
00:53:37,652 --> 00:53:45,048
Yes. Thank you very much. Of course, things
can always be done better, and I hope

511
00:53:45,123 --> 00:53:52,876
that we are moving in that direction
because, as I was saying, the burden – and,

512
00:53:52,944 --> 00:53:58,191
well, the expectation – of SMEs is
to regulate and simplify things.

513
00:53:58,242 --> 00:54:03,351
Certainly without deregulating, because
it is good to have a regulated market

514
00:54:03,424 --> 00:54:10,225
nonetheless. I would like to thank Mr
researcher Timothy Young and Ms representative

515
00:54:10,288 --> 00:54:19,489
of the Digi Grău committee, and I hope we
can achieve, as you, Madam, said, better

516
00:54:19,596 --> 00:54:25,094
results. I regret that the committee’s
proposal was withdrawn due to the deadlock

517
00:54:25,142 --> 00:54:30,474
created by the Council, but I hope we can
still find a solution and move forward.

518
00:54:30,584 --> 00:54:38,173
I would like to remind you that we now have
an important debate, I would say a very

519
00:54:38,229 --> 00:54:43,540
important workshop, the legislative act on
digital fairness, on how online consumers

520
00:54:43,605 --> 00:54:48,956
can be effectively protected while
ensuring coherent interaction with existing

521
00:54:49,045 --> 00:54:54,729
legislation. We also have, and I would
like to welcome here the experts, including

522
00:54:54,808 --> 00:54:58,916
those joining online, thank you
for participating in this workshop.

523
00:54:58,959 --> 00:55:03,298
The purpose of the workshop is to exchange
views on how the future legislative act

524
00:55:03,362 --> 00:55:09,300
on digital fairness can strengthen the
protection of online consumers while ensuring

525
00:55:09,358 --> 00:55:12,590
consistency and coherence
with the existing EU acquis.

526
00:55:12,654 --> 00:55:18,488
And I also want you to know that the
workshop is organised by the thematic

527
00:55:18,537 --> 00:55:23,669
department for the IMCO committee; the
workshop is divided into two discussion

528
00:55:23,718 --> 00:55:28,601
groups. The first round table, the
first debate, is on rethinking consumer

529
00:55:28,657 --> 00:55:35,258
protection in the digital age, and here
we have Professor, Doctor Emilia Miscenic,

530
00:55:35,348 --> 00:55:42,613
Professor at the Faculty of Law in Rijeka
– she is online, if she is connected,

531
00:55:42,741 --> 00:55:46,292
after 10 minutes.

532
00:55:49,112 --> 00:55:50,012
16.

533
00:55:50,012 --> 00:55:53,593
Next is Professor Doctor Peter Roth,
Professor of Commercial Civil Law and

534
00:55:53,652 --> 00:55:58,134
Information Law at the University of
Oldenburg, with a maximum of 10 minutes, after

535
00:55:58,194 --> 00:56:02,364
which, I assume, fellow Members
of Parliament can intervene.

536
00:56:02,408 --> 00:56:06,102
I understand that Professor Emilia
Miscenic, Professor at the Faculty of Law in

537
00:56:06,151 --> 00:56:08,612
Rijeka, is also connected.
I invite you, Professor.

538
00:56:13,112 --> 00:56:20,712
Uh thank you very much can you hear me
well um honorable madam chair distinguished

539
00:56:20,784 --> 00:56:25,744
members of the committee uh representatives
of the European Parliament uh of the

540
00:56:25,807 --> 00:56:30,314
European Commission ladies and gentlemen
uh it is an honor to present this briefing

541
00:56:30,359 --> 00:56:36,174
requested by IMCO committee on the horizontal
issues relevant for the forthcoming

542
00:56:36,239 --> 00:56:41,562
digital fairness act uh the title from the
average to vulnerable consumer in digital

543
00:56:41,612 --> 00:56:48,383
environments um uh captures the central
question that I intend to discuss whether

544
00:56:48,452 --> 00:56:54,977
the current uh benchmarks and definition
um of the EU consumer law such as average

545
00:56:55,052 --> 00:57:02,732
and vulnerable consumer uh remain fit for
purpose in the digital uh environments um

546
00:57:03,002 --> 00:57:11,612
next slide please. So allow me first
to shortly outline the structure of the

547
00:57:11,672 --> 00:57:17,609
presentation I shall begin very very short
overview of the policy trajectory leading

548
00:57:17,685 --> 00:57:23,034
to the digital fairness act uh then I
will turn to the core of the presentation

549
00:57:23,096 --> 00:57:27,992
where I examine the benchmarks uh in
particular in the context of the Court of

550
00:57:28,052 --> 00:57:32,756
Justice case law and in the second step
in the context of digital environments uh

551
00:57:32,817 --> 00:57:37,862
where we will discuss new emerging concepts
of digital vulnerability and digital

552
00:57:37,957 --> 00:57:43,667
asymmetry and in the end I will try to
to offer some policy recommendations and

553
00:57:43,733 --> 00:57:52,167
options regarding the possible updates
of the benchmarks um next slide please.

554
00:57:52,352 --> 00:57:59,284
So um as we all know uh the proposal for
the DFA did not emerge in vacuum uh in 2020

555
00:57:59,372 --> 00:58:05,363
new consumer agenda the commission asked
whether further legislation uh was needed

556
00:58:05,441 --> 00:58:10,884
to ensure uh equivalent level of consumer
uh protection in online and offline

557
00:58:10,952 --> 00:58:15,588
transactions and to use later the commission
launched the digital fairness fitness

558
00:58:15,632 --> 00:58:20,740
check followed by public consultation the
result came out came out in October 2024

559
00:58:20,847 --> 00:58:27,524
and then followed uh the public consultation
on the future digital fairness act in

560
00:58:27,620 --> 00:58:34,423
2025 as we can see on the slide the most
representatives uh were consumer and uh

561
00:58:34,488 --> 00:58:40,217
they agreed that and supported the new
rules on dark patterns addictive design

562
00:58:40,307 --> 00:58:46,252
personalization harmful influencer
marketing and so on however uh most of the

563
00:58:46,315 --> 00:58:47,492
respondents

564
00:58:47,492 --> 00:58:53,457
uh expressed no opinion uh on the horizontal
issues of benchmarks uh that we are

565
00:58:53,527 --> 00:59:01,589
discussing uh today so next slide please.
Uh shortly on the fitness check because

566
00:59:01,652 --> 00:59:06,255
more or less we are all familiar with
these results so on the basis of these five

567
00:59:06,323 --> 00:59:11,532
examined criteria that you can see on
the slide um unfair commercial practices

568
00:59:11,599 --> 00:59:17,292
directive uh commer uh consumer rights
directive and unfair contract terms directive

569
00:59:17,372 --> 00:59:23,112
were questioned and the general finding was
that uh the current EU legislation uh in

570
00:59:23,192 --> 00:59:30,478
consumer law is overall efficient but uh
its effectiveness is limited due to a high

571
00:59:30,536 --> 00:59:36,587
level of legal fragmentation the coherence
between directives the themselves is fine

572
00:59:36,666 --> 00:59:43,481
but the external coherence especially with
the digital key DSA DMA AI act and so on

573
00:59:43,592 --> 00:59:50,072
um there are issues um efficiency suffers
from huge discrepancy cost when it comes

574
00:59:50,142 --> 00:59:57,624
to uh businesses compliance cost and the
um online consumer harms which were at that

575
00:59:57,700 --> 01:00:05,348
time approximated um at 7. 9 billion per
year so the the overall diagnosis um is

576
01:00:05,416 --> 01:00:10,277
very clear that objectives of directive
remain highly relevant but legal

577
01:00:10,362 --> 01:00:15,960
fragmentation uh digital vulnerability
of consumers and weak enforcement um

578
01:00:16,052 --> 01:00:21,418
undermine their goals so
uh next please uh slide.

579
01:00:21,572 --> 01:00:28,530
Thank you. Uh we now turn to the core of
the briefing uh where uh first we need to

580
01:00:28,595 --> 01:00:34,467
distinguish uh consumer definition and
benchmark whereby uh the definition of the

581
01:00:34,532 --> 01:00:40,874
consumer is used to uh determine the personal
scope of the relevant act uh while the

582
01:00:40,952 --> 01:00:46,927
benchmark is used as an interpretive tool
um to help us to determine the level uh of

583
01:00:47,006 --> 01:00:52,368
protection afforded to consumer um so
uh on the one hand we have this legal

584
01:00:52,429 --> 01:00:57,681
definition of the consumer defined by
two uh cumulative criteria personal and

585
01:00:57,750 --> 01:01:03,621
functional criteria and across different
EU consumer directives uh consumer is

586
01:01:03,697 --> 01:01:10,172
always a natural person acting outside
of uh trade business or professional um

587
01:01:10,262 --> 01:01:16,573
activity and once we have um defined the
person as a consumer then we can speak

588
01:01:16,643 --> 01:01:20,967
about the benchmark and about the
position of the consumer in certain legal

589
01:01:21,012 --> 01:01:25,892
transaction and here on the slide you
can see that during 90s uh the Court of

590
01:01:26,132 --> 01:01:32,065
Justice uh established today an objective
standard of an average consumer who is

591
01:01:32,161 --> 01:01:38,612
reasonably well informed reasonably
observant and circumspect and this came by

592
01:01:38,687 --> 01:01:45,461
relying on the doctrine of um the so-called
homoeconomicus um um and information

593
01:01:45,538 --> 01:01:51,917
paradigm meaning observing the consumer
as a person who is making um rational and

594
01:01:51,996 --> 01:01:58,917
informed decisions and choices based on
available and transparent information um

595
01:01:58,989 --> 01:02:04,115
this was later codified by the UCPD unfair
commercial practices directive together

596
01:02:04,168 --> 01:02:09,306
with the subsidiary standard for particularly
vulnerable consumers and today we are

597
01:02:09,364 --> 01:02:14,103
questioning whether these benchmarks uh
which was established long ago uh still

598
01:02:14,175 --> 01:02:19,124
correspond to the needs uh of consumer in
digital environments which are shaped by

599
01:02:19,172 --> 01:02:26,654
algorithms personal recommendations data-driven
personalization and so on so um next

600
01:02:26,792 --> 01:02:35,183
slide please. Uh the Court of Justice case
law holds on strongly on these objective

601
01:02:35,238 --> 01:02:41,401
standard of an average consumer and its
applies also when interpreting other uh EU

602
01:02:41,467 --> 01:02:47,208
consumer directives such as the unfair
contract terms directive consumer crediting

603
01:02:47,266 --> 01:02:52,834
directives um consumer rights directive
however as mentioned uh the level of

604
01:02:52,889 --> 01:02:59,103
consumer protection may vary depending upon
the factual circumstances uh of the case

605
01:02:59,192 --> 01:03:07,027
and uh court uh and case law showed a
certain level of uh flexibility by bending or

606
01:03:07,104 --> 01:03:12,257
adjusting this standard
uh so next slide please.

607
01:03:12,512 --> 01:03:17,149
Uh for instance here you can see just
some excerpts from different cases in the

608
01:03:17,222 --> 01:03:22,679
famous Oceano Groupo case where there was
interpretation of unfair contract contract

609
01:03:22,772 --> 01:03:27,218
terms or there were line of cases when
it comes to interpretation of unfair

610
01:03:27,268 --> 01:03:32,379
contractual terms in credit or mortgage
uh credit agreements the Court of Justice

611
01:03:32,442 --> 01:03:39,036
concluded that this average consumer is
in a weaker position uh toward traders uh

612
01:03:39,118 --> 01:03:45,872
regarding the the both bargaining power
the level of knowledge the available

613
01:03:45,960 --> 01:03:51,475
information um here we can see for instance
Duarte Juero's Spanish case uh related

614
01:03:51,546 --> 01:03:56,430
to non-compliance of goods and the Court
of Justice considered that the consumer who

615
01:03:56,496 --> 01:04:01,652
failed to invoke one of the the rights
in the civil procedure was unaware

616
01:04:02,072 --> 01:04:07,946
uh of her rights so this basically showed
us that the benchmark is already uh

617
01:04:08,053 --> 01:04:14,576
context uh sensitive in practice and uh
that there is a possibility um to codify

618
01:04:14,648 --> 01:04:21,384
this practice of the court of justice uh
by retaining the the objectives standard

619
01:04:21,473 --> 01:04:28,472
while incorporating um the circumstances
including digital ones which may transform

620
01:04:28,552 --> 01:04:36,708
uh an average consumer into a weaker and
even vulnerable party so next next slide

621
01:04:36,859 --> 01:04:41,866
please. Uh which bring us to the benchmark
of the vulnerable consumer uh which is

622
01:04:41,935 --> 01:04:48,554
currently recognized in the UCPD consumer
rights directive AI act UK act and and

623
01:04:48,621 --> 01:04:55,840
other legislation in a similar but inconsistent
manner and is predominantly focused

624
01:04:55,919 --> 01:05:01,145
on personal characteristics as you can see
on the slide such as mental and physical

625
01:05:01,223 --> 01:05:07,518
informity age credulity uh while being
less focused on external factors which need

626
01:05:07,577 --> 01:05:12,149
special attention in particular when
we talk about challenges of of digital

627
01:05:12,212 --> 01:05:21,524
environments uh so next slide please. Uh
in this respect according to the BUC report

628
01:05:21,632 --> 01:05:27,272
2021 the digital vulnerability and uh
connected uh digital asymmetry in B2C

629
01:05:27,372 --> 01:05:33,038
relationships uh these are connected notions
and the vulnerability arises directly

630
01:05:33,092 --> 01:05:39,426
from structural architecture of digital
marketplaces and therein used uh digital

631
01:05:39,503 --> 01:05:46,223
techniques um unfair manipulative
practices which make consumer uh digitally

632
01:05:46,303 --> 01:05:52,892
vulnerable and quite very often result uh
in transactional decisions which are not

633
01:05:52,970 --> 01:05:59,337
informed uh or rational rational
ones so next slide please.

634
01:05:59,492 --> 01:06:04,727
Uh the asymmetry in the B2C relationships
and in is increasing in digital

635
01:06:04,771 --> 01:06:08,531
environments and this is of course also
recognized as you can see from again

636
01:06:08,587 --> 01:06:14,397
examples and excerpt from in the Court
of Justice case law um which is um

637
01:06:14,492 --> 01:06:21,819
recognizing um the the impact of these
techniques uh on consumer choices online um

638
01:06:21,932 --> 01:06:28,078
here we can see several cases but maybe
because of the time limit just to mention

639
01:06:28,140 --> 01:06:33,941
the previously um uh mentioned uh Compass
Banka on the previous slide where where it

640
01:06:33,985 --> 01:06:39,895
was acknowledged that the benchmark of the
average consumer uh does not exclude uh

641
01:06:39,992 --> 01:06:41,192
taking into account

642
01:06:41,432 --> 01:06:50,305
uh the influence of cognitive biases uh on
the average uh consumer um so next slide

643
01:06:50,466 --> 01:06:57,606
please. Uh so therefore in the briefing um
I recommend updating of both average and

644
01:06:57,667 --> 01:07:04,461
vulnerable uh consumer benchmarks by by
keeping the the Court of Justice uh standard

645
01:07:04,607 --> 01:07:10,488
but by adding criteria which will
reflect uh the challenges of digital uh

646
01:07:10,576 --> 01:07:16,568
environments and how to do so uh by
introducing new concepts uh on digital

647
01:07:16,652 --> 01:07:23,844
vulnerability and associated digital
asymmetry since these can obviously uh affect

648
01:07:23,912 --> 01:07:30,851
both average and vulnerable consumers in
in digital environments next slide please.

649
01:07:31,052 --> 01:07:37,230
Uh of course the way of regulating will
depend upon upon the form of the act and in

650
01:07:37,304 --> 01:07:43,862
my view the initial idea of the um avoiding
the legal fragmentation by systematic

651
01:07:43,952 --> 01:07:50,386
approach of uh updating the question
directives seems to be abandoned so whatever

652
01:07:50,448 --> 01:07:54,932
direction it goes uh the legislator
needs to be careful in achieving external

653
01:07:54,992 --> 01:07:59,381
coherence with the digital a key because
we all know that this might affect the

654
01:07:59,453 --> 01:08:05,537
enforcement next slide please. And here are
the main conclusions that I have already

655
01:08:05,587 --> 01:08:10,207
mentioned because of the time limit I
will not repeat them I thank you for your

656
01:08:10,275 --> 01:08:15,800
attention and I also thank you for for the
opportunity uh as a vulnerable consumer

657
01:08:15,861 --> 01:08:21,278
to to give me the floor online because of
my disability issues thank you so much for

658
01:08:21,355 --> 01:08:23,252
for the possibility and attention.

659
01:08:24,392 --> 01:08:25,592
Thank you for

660
01:08:25,592 --> 01:08:30,648
Thank you very much, and I hope you
will stay with us because there will be

661
01:08:30,718 --> 01:08:34,433
interventions from colleagues,
as you have observed.

662
01:08:34,507 --> 01:08:39,602
The research by Professor Emilia Mișenici
has focused on European private law,

663
01:08:39,661 --> 01:08:42,217
anti-discrimination law
and consumer rights.

664
01:08:42,269 --> 01:08:47,995
It is now my pleasure to invite Professor
Peter Rot, Professor of Civil, Commercial

665
01:08:48,085 --> 01:08:51,771
and Information Law at the
University of Oldenburg.

666
01:08:51,845 --> 01:08:55,984
His contribution will
certainly enrich this debate.

667
01:08:56,045 --> 01:09:01,912
His research focuses on the effects of
digitalisation on private law, sustainability

668
01:09:01,990 --> 01:09:06,226
and ensuring compliance with
consumer protection legislation.

669
01:09:06,298 --> 01:09:08,012
You have 10 minutes, Professor.

670
01:09:14,432 --> 01:09:19,303
Thank you very much madam chair honorable
members ladies and gentlemen um my task is

671
01:09:19,368 --> 01:09:23,706
to look at some more concrete aspects
of the digital fairness act and um you

672
01:09:23,762 --> 01:09:28,062
probably all know that the digital fairness
act or the draft has been leaked to the

673
01:09:28,113 --> 01:09:33,260
best possible moment which is after we have
made our prepared our presentations and

674
01:09:33,316 --> 01:09:38,672
um I had 10 minutes to flick through it
I'll try to relate to what I've seen and

675
01:09:38,800 --> 01:09:46,246
what I have what I am proposing next
slide please so I don't uh I don't need to

676
01:09:46,343 --> 01:09:52,720
repeat all the um the the aims of the DFA
I just wanted to to mention that most of

677
01:09:52,772 --> 01:09:57,303
them increasing legal certainty reducing
legal fragmentation avoiding friction

678
01:09:57,366 --> 01:10:03,183
simplification of the legal framework is
would benefit everybody consumers as much

679
01:10:03,245 --> 01:10:08,322
as traders who would have a a clearer
framework to deal with and of course the

680
01:10:08,372 --> 01:10:14,080
internal market and uh of course all this
should happen at a high level of consumer

681
01:10:14,147 --> 01:10:19,037
protection next slide please. So what I
want to do is to look at three practices

682
01:10:19,088 --> 01:10:23,591
dark patterns influence a marketing
and personalization practices and some

683
01:10:23,664 --> 01:10:28,412
practicalities like the burden of proof and
precision of small traders and I will go

684
01:10:28,472 --> 01:10:33,678
through them by identifying gaps in legal
uncertainties um potential frictions with

685
01:10:33,732 --> 01:10:42,463
other legislation and then uh give. Some
possible solutions next uh slide please.

686
01:10:42,572 --> 01:10:46,685
So starting with dark patterns of course
we have some existing legislation but it

687
01:10:46,759 --> 01:10:52,331
only uh covers certain aspects the DSA
only covers online platforms the consumer

688
01:10:52,390 --> 01:10:57,188
rights directive only um the distance
selling of financial services and the AI act

689
01:10:57,272 --> 01:11:04,870
only dark patterns produced by artificial
intelligence whether or not the UCPD

690
01:11:05,012 --> 01:11:10,666
covers them or to what extent uh is subject
to not only academic discussion but also

691
01:11:10,720 --> 01:11:17,318
to conflicting already conflicting case
law uh in the courts uh and the same um uh

692
01:11:17,415 --> 01:11:22,978
applies to the uh to data protection law
the GDPR where of course dark patterns

693
01:11:23,022 --> 01:11:27,122
could impact on free and informed consent
but to what extent they actually do and

694
01:11:27,175 --> 01:11:30,872
what the benchmark is is again
uh discussed very controversially

695
01:11:31,652 --> 01:11:40,507
um so next slide please. Um everybody feels
a clear need to regulate dark patterns

696
01:11:40,592 --> 01:11:45,387
um in particular also the consultation
respondents and the possible solutions and

697
01:11:45,446 --> 01:11:50,998
that's the one that uh I have seen has been
chosen now by the commission is a clear

698
01:11:51,090 --> 01:11:57,010
prohibition in the UCPD an exemplary list
of dark patterns to concretize what what

699
01:11:57,077 --> 01:12:02,707
this broad notion actually means to give
guidance to um traders in particular what

700
01:12:02,776 --> 01:12:09,505
they are allowed to do and what not um and
to give the power to the commission um to

701
01:12:09,632 --> 01:12:16,887
concretize these uh these the various
forms and types of dark patterns further in

702
01:12:17,005 --> 01:12:25,108
delegated legislation what I would add um
what I haven't seen yet is um even to try

703
01:12:25,189 --> 01:12:31,488
and standardize certain legal requirements
where there is no need to give you know

704
01:12:31,595 --> 01:12:37,070
creativity to traders and my prime example
would be cookie banners where I can't see

705
01:12:37,115 --> 01:12:43,276
why everybody needs a different
one next um thank you.

706
01:12:43,412 --> 01:12:48,644
Um next point influence a marketing um
which is not explicitly covered yet at EU

707
01:12:48,712 --> 01:12:54,507
level but of course um the UCBD would
apply to influence a marketing um because

708
01:12:54,572 --> 01:13:01,412
influence is are or can be traders again
the question is in what circumstances are

709
01:13:01,484 --> 01:13:06,040
are they traders and the UCBD applies and
what exactly do they have to do to flag up

710
01:13:06,092 --> 01:13:12,134
what um that they're using commercial
communication um here we can um already see a

711
01:13:12,197 --> 01:13:16,840
lot of legal fragmentation within the
European Union and even within member states

712
01:13:16,892 --> 01:13:22,052
with uh Spanish legislation that has come
up um and implementing the audio visual

713
01:13:22,116 --> 01:13:26,643
media services directive um with the
German special rule in in the German unfair

714
01:13:26,694 --> 01:13:32,761
commercial practices law with the most
comprehensive system in France and with

715
01:13:32,809 --> 01:13:36,418
diverging national case
law next slide please.

716
01:13:36,572 --> 01:13:42,992
Again there is a clear need for regu uh for
regulation and um I've seen there is one

717
01:13:43,052 --> 01:13:50,272
in the uh in the proposal so we need a
special provision clarifying who's a trader

718
01:13:50,334 --> 01:13:56,348
and what exactly needs to be disclosed
I would also advocate standardization of

719
01:13:56,430 --> 01:14:02,997
disclosers so what what do you have to
say and um I can I've seen that the the

720
01:14:03,120 --> 01:14:04,292
proposal of

721
01:14:04,292 --> 01:14:09,325
the commission offers two um two notions
that can be used advertisement and

722
01:14:09,403 --> 01:14:15,194
commercial cooperation which I think is a
great idea and then there are aspects in

723
01:14:15,272 --> 01:14:19,537
particular from French law that deserve to
be taken over which is special protection

724
01:14:19,592 --> 01:14:28,805
of minors when it comes to um to influences
and special areas um in which influence

725
01:14:28,917 --> 01:14:34,899
so areas that are of particularly risky
it could be health uh could be financial

726
01:14:35,000 --> 01:14:40,888
services where it may not be a good
idea to um have influence a marketing.

727
01:14:40,952 --> 01:14:45,914
So there could be some prohibitions.
And there are some in the proposal.

728
01:14:45,992 --> 01:14:52,379
Um another aspect which has come up and
which I've also seen is it should be clear

729
01:14:52,454 --> 01:14:56,939
that traders that use influences to market
their product should be liable for what

730
01:14:56,984 --> 01:15:03,456
they do. So they should be um they should
have the the duty to maybe teach them what

731
01:15:03,527 --> 01:15:07,881
they are allowed to do what not and they
should be liable if they if they don't

732
01:15:07,935 --> 01:15:15,623
comply with the rules. Next slide please.
Personalized pricing my favorite one um

733
01:15:15,678 --> 01:15:21,920
there is some explicit legislation but
it is uh tend uh usually conceived to be

734
01:15:21,998 --> 01:15:27,759
insufficient um because there is only mere
information obligations in the consumer

735
01:15:27,812 --> 01:15:33,367
rights directive and the consumer credit
directive saying that personal pricing is

736
01:15:33,442 --> 01:15:38,139
applied but not how so that consumers
can't really understand what it means um

737
01:15:38,203 --> 01:15:43,970
otherwise when it comes to the UCBD there's
legal uncertainty uh some have advocated

738
01:15:44,033 --> 01:15:49,115
to to deal with um personalization of
prices as material information in terms of

739
01:15:49,206 --> 01:15:54,462
misleading omission but that has never
been tested in court so we don't know um

740
01:15:54,647 --> 01:16:01,273
there is certainly there is um there are
gaps because the CRD and the CCD don't

741
01:16:01,340 --> 01:16:07,715
cover everything and therefore a need for
regulation possible solutions next slide

742
01:16:07,790 --> 01:16:12,215
please would of course the most radical
one would of course be a total prohibition

743
01:16:12,259 --> 01:16:18,215
of personalized pricing that actually
most respondents would prefer um lesser

744
01:16:18,329 --> 01:16:23,684
solution would be an opt-in system or an
opt-out system where you could uh choose

745
01:16:23,743 --> 01:16:30,992
not to be subjected to personalization
practices um at the very least one could um

746
01:16:31,772 --> 01:16:38,866
and that's that's what I have seen in the
in the proposal um one should prohibit um

747
01:16:38,984 --> 01:16:43,897
using sensitive data for personalization
and one should not target minors with

748
01:16:43,952 --> 01:16:53,335
personalization practices. Um and of course
if one did that one should adjust the

749
01:16:53,405 --> 01:16:58,615
other uh legal acts the consumer rights
directive and the CCD accordingly

750
01:16:58,712 --> 01:17:06,148
personalized marketing next slide um. Same
issue of course there is some GDPR some

751
01:17:06,195 --> 01:17:10,532
data protection law in the background because
personalized marketing uh implies that

752
01:17:10,577 --> 01:17:16,581
someone has acquired personal data in the
first place but that is at a time long

753
01:17:16,624 --> 01:17:20,158
before the marketing and everybody knows
that nobody reads the data protection

754
01:17:20,208 --> 01:17:29,039
declarations anyway so that's not um very
helpful um um otherwise to what extent it

755
01:17:29,086 --> 01:17:34,061
may be covered under the UCBD again is
quite unclear and there could be aggressive

756
01:17:34,105 --> 01:17:39,730
practices dealing with that but we don't
uh again that hasn't been never been tested

757
01:17:39,798 --> 01:17:44,667
in court again people feel that there
is a need for regulation and to possible

758
01:17:44,722 --> 01:17:49,198
solutions next slide are pretty much the
same as when it comes to personalized

759
01:17:49,255 --> 01:17:54,032
pricing it could be an opt-in or an opt-out
system or at least the prohibition of

760
01:17:54,092 --> 01:17:58,455
the use of sensitive data and the
prohibition of personalized marketing towards

761
01:17:58,506 --> 01:18:03,766
minors the last two points are I've seen
in the proposal the first one unfortunately

762
01:18:03,812 --> 01:18:12,126
not um next slide when it comes to
practicalities um everything stands and falls in

763
01:18:12,203 --> 01:18:17,479
this black box area with the burden of
proof if you leave it to um consumer

764
01:18:17,556 --> 01:18:22,232
organizations or individual consumers to
prove that there are dark patterns in the

765
01:18:22,297 --> 01:18:26,867
web design um there will be no enforcement
no private enforcement and it's you

766
01:18:26,933 --> 01:18:31,556
you're stuck with public enforcement that
may work in some member states but not in

767
01:18:31,621 --> 01:18:37,112
others um the current rule of article
12 UCBD is clearly insufficient for many

768
01:18:37,172 --> 01:18:42,409
reasons because first of all it only relates
to fact but not to web designs and um

769
01:18:42,500 --> 01:18:49,726
it leaves the application of the rules to
the discretion of the court um apart from

770
01:18:49,805 --> 01:18:54,445
that many different standards have developed
in the member states and some are more

771
01:18:54,572 --> 01:18:57,332
friendly towards the claimant than others

772
01:18:57,992 --> 01:19:03,512
so there is surely a need uh for regulation
in particular also with regard to a

773
01:19:03,566 --> 01:19:09,337
level playing field in the different member
states next slide please poss the the

774
01:19:09,433 --> 01:19:16,080
the poss the solution that I um would see
the most convincing is for to follow the

775
01:19:16,156 --> 01:19:20,878
model of the of the the product liability
directive that has just been reformed and

776
01:19:20,940 --> 01:19:26,834
deals with the exact same problem of the
black box issue uh when it comes to smart

777
01:19:26,912 --> 01:19:32,369
products etc so there should be a right
to disclosure where for example um a dark

778
01:19:32,414 --> 01:19:36,518
pattern or price personalization is made
plausible by the claimant so it looks like

779
01:19:36,572 --> 01:19:41,368
you know you see different prices and
it can't be explained so that it's quite

780
01:19:41,416 --> 01:19:48,104
plausible that there is something in the
background um and then sanctions um if the

781
01:19:48,212 --> 01:19:55,343
web design is not disclosed by the trader
um there's also something about to say

782
01:19:55,421 --> 01:20:00,802
about the standard of proof so what to what
extent do you need to convince the court

783
01:20:00,849 --> 01:20:06,970
do you need full proof or just a probability
that uh there is a dark pattern in the

784
01:20:07,032 --> 01:20:13,218
background again different standards in the
member states next slide now we've we've

785
01:20:13,285 --> 01:20:19,409
uh just discussed SME so I have something
on small traders as well um in the sense

786
01:20:19,505 --> 01:20:24,441
that many small traders don't design
their websites themselves but they buy the

787
01:20:24,504 --> 01:20:29,546
website as it is from sellers like Shopify
and they don't necessarily know what they

788
01:20:29,594 --> 01:20:33,364
are doing they wouldn't possibly know that
there is a dark pattern in the background

789
01:20:33,415 --> 01:20:37,952
or a personalization practice and the
question is would do do we need to protect

790
01:20:38,042 --> 01:20:44,266
them in some way and um possible solution
and again I've seen that in the in the

791
01:20:44,339 --> 01:20:50,103
proposal is a redress claim against the
third party who who may have sold them or or

792
01:20:50,192 --> 01:20:55,058
designed their website uh including a
dark pattern or including a personal an

793
01:20:55,114 --> 01:20:59,633
unlawful personalization practice um it's
a system that we find in the sale of goods

794
01:20:59,672 --> 01:21:04,056
directive and also in the digital content
digital services directive and it makes

795
01:21:04,126 --> 01:21:10,705
sense to to get these third parties in to
the system you could even include them um

796
01:21:10,791 --> 01:21:17,138
more directly like in product liability law
as third persons who are responsible for

797
01:21:17,192 --> 01:21:18,992
the dark pattern in the first place and if

798
01:21:19,052 --> 01:21:24,302
you could target them directly you could
pick the problem at the root and not only

799
01:21:24,411 --> 01:21:32,166
at the many emanations but that's not in
the proposal um apart from that one could

800
01:21:32,235 --> 01:21:39,661
think of a somewhat relaxed liability
taking into account that the UCBD um is an

801
01:21:39,735 --> 01:21:46,757
objective piece of law so you only need the
breach but no negligence to be liable um

802
01:21:46,952 --> 01:21:56,192
but that's a political decision uh last one
I just uh in terms of the simplification

803
01:21:56,252 --> 01:22:02,535
agenda I just wanted to mention that um
clear prohibitions and clear standards could

804
01:22:02,602 --> 01:22:08,827
also reduce the um the the confusion
and um complexity and therefore reduce

805
01:22:08,893 --> 01:22:15,102
transaction costs would make life simpler
and it also could um bring about a more

806
01:22:15,164 --> 01:22:20,224
level playing field between big traders
and small traders because big traders can

807
01:22:20,280 --> 01:22:25,740
afford personalization practices and small
traders may not be able to do so and um

808
01:22:25,832 --> 01:22:31,439
big traders may um be able to uh create
dark patterns in their web designs which

809
01:22:31,492 --> 01:22:35,072
small traders may be unable
to thank you that was

810
01:22:35,552 --> 01:22:44,796
my presentation, thank you Mr Professor. I
have just listened to Professor Emilia, I

811
01:22:44,848 --> 01:22:47,148
hope she is with us, and to Mr Peter Ruth.

812
01:22:47,205 --> 01:22:54,557
Now, dear colleagues, according to the
principle of 'cash di', if anyone would like

813
01:22:54,656 --> 01:22:59,492
to intervene, ok.

814
01:23:00,092 --> 01:23:05,661
Dora David thank you chair um thank you
very much for the comprehensive overviews

815
01:23:05,715 --> 01:23:12,397
it's very helpful to see um the outline of
the problems and possible solutions um I

816
01:23:12,462 --> 01:23:20,517
have a question around how we can future
proof um solutions because I think we

817
01:23:20,610 --> 01:23:27,429
already have um future proof solution we
have principles based consumer laws so you

818
01:23:27,514 --> 01:23:33,927
mentioned the UCPD with regard to um dark
patterns I think uh they clearly do cover

819
01:23:34,034 --> 01:23:39,683
uh dark patterns because you know dark
patterns lead the consumer to take a

820
01:23:39,732 --> 01:23:44,438
transactional decision that they would
otherwise not have made had they been aware

821
01:23:44,497 --> 01:23:49,629
of the the design so with the expansion
of a blacklist which seems to be the

822
01:23:49,700 --> 01:23:57,577
solution proposed in the DFA in your view
how will we ensure that the law is future

823
01:23:57,630 --> 01:24:02,842
proof and doesn't need to be updated
every two minutes um you know I think

824
01:24:02,908 --> 01:24:08,318
guidelines are more flexible in this regard
um and I want to make sure that we don't

825
01:24:08,372 --> 01:24:12,872
remove the flexibility of a principles
based regime that we already have thank you

826
01:24:16,232 --> 01:24:18,932
thank you very much SND Crystal

827
01:24:20,072 --> 01:24:24,283
thank you very much first and foremost
thank you for your presentation today we're

828
01:24:24,332 --> 01:24:32,167
quite interesting and useful the upcoming
work with the DFA uh first uh to uh to the

829
01:24:32,277 --> 01:24:40,498
question about um average versus vulnerable
consumer I think uh I'm not really sure

830
01:24:40,583 --> 01:24:46,242
that uh also as you said professor I'm
not sure that that way of looking at

831
01:24:46,312 --> 01:24:52,585
consumers today makes that much sense I
would not count myself as being a vulnerable

832
01:24:52,652 --> 01:24:58,727
consumer uh I'm well educated and uh can
read and write and understand the different

833
01:24:58,793 --> 01:25:05,951
languages uh etc etc but even I fall into
uh problems sometimes when I'm online

834
01:25:06,030 --> 01:25:13,392
buying goods being kind of uh you know
tricked uh so the question is you know

835
01:25:13,502 --> 01:25:19,053
honestly I maybe we should go away from
that having average vulnerable consumers but

836
01:25:19,094 --> 01:25:24,441
just talk about consumers and make sure
that we are protected no matter what uh uh

837
01:25:24,643 --> 01:25:30,594
that that goes you know for you know could
be dark patterns but it could also be

838
01:25:30,655 --> 01:25:37,275
whether this web shop is is kind of you
know sometimes I buy and believe that I'm

839
01:25:37,326 --> 01:25:42,072
buying from a Danish web shop uh of course
I've learned the tricks now how to check

840
01:25:42,157 --> 01:25:49,919
it but uh but still I can be cheated here
as well uh so so I think I would like to

841
01:25:50,012 --> 01:25:57,492
kind of answered it but but I think that
today being a consumer being digital and

842
01:25:57,556 --> 01:26:01,698
buy online you don't have the same protection
as you have in the offline world if

843
01:26:01,764 --> 01:26:07,088
you buy good and it's broken you go down
to the shop where in the past you get down

844
01:26:07,145 --> 01:26:11,407
to the shop ask them about what you do
and they would explain your rights etc you

845
01:26:11,468 --> 01:26:17,463
had a person you could talk to today you
don't know you you cannot necessarily get

846
01:26:17,514 --> 01:26:22,524
into contact with anybody you don't get a
reply or if you get a reply it it might be

847
01:26:22,592 --> 01:26:27,282
generated by a chatbot and you can use it
for any purposes and you don't know where

848
01:26:27,328 --> 01:26:31,309
you stand if you have to uh return the
goods even though we also have good used to

849
01:26:31,371 --> 01:26:36,392
have good protection on that as well so
my question is on on average vulnerable

850
01:26:36,439 --> 01:26:42,902
whether we should keep on having this at
all and just talk about consumers uh and uh

851
01:26:43,112 --> 01:26:45,632
and on on all the good suggestions uh

852
01:26:45,752 --> 01:26:53,339
we just heard uh from the second uh
presentation uh about uh prohibition and and

853
01:26:53,411 --> 01:27:03,752
personal pricing etc etc um. Here
also I'm I'm considering uh well.

854
01:27:03,872 --> 01:27:14,462
If we put things on a list uh and and and
ban it uh isn't there a risk that uh the

855
01:27:14,672 --> 01:27:22,078
shops uh or uh the platforms will just
invent new tools that makes it even more

856
01:27:22,158 --> 01:27:29,247
difficult uh I. Have my I don't know honestly
I'm I'm really have doubt about how to

857
01:27:29,301 --> 01:27:33,324
do this I want consumers to be better
protected than they are when they're going

858
01:27:33,373 --> 01:27:40,248
online buying things but also risking
if we're too precise that it will be so

859
01:27:40,319 --> 01:27:44,837
convenient is also something that I'm a
bit scared of we have seen examples of that

860
01:27:44,882 --> 01:27:49,722
that once we come up with the idea and
they find ways to so convenient those ideas

861
01:27:49,778 --> 01:27:56,308
and that's why I hesitate a little bit about
banning things concretely um and and so

862
01:27:56,374 --> 01:28:01,013
also on the DSA when we talked about dark
patterns it was more in general because it

863
01:28:01,068 --> 01:28:04,877
is difficult to describe it in a way where
we can cover everything so it's better to

864
01:28:04,922 --> 01:28:11,123
have the term in and then you know all to
have the courts help us deciding by ruling

865
01:28:11,172 --> 01:28:14,972
on the cases so I have my doubts I would
like to hear your point of views on how you

866
01:28:15,015 --> 01:28:22,345
look at that uh but uh but just in general
I do think that we are not protecting

867
01:28:22,427 --> 01:28:26,273
consumers enough when they're online and
the thing is that it's difficult to find

868
01:28:26,310 --> 01:28:30,102
the right way to do it the right balances
where we don't want to destroy it for

869
01:28:30,164 --> 01:28:34,715
those who are the good guys but we want
to make sure that the bad guys are are uh

870
01:28:34,826 --> 01:28:40,651
stopped and then you know we also tackled
some of it in the DSA but I think in

871
01:28:40,724 --> 01:28:44,995
general we need to make sure that some that
it is possible to get into contact with

872
01:28:45,041 --> 01:28:50,458
somebody at a shop even though it's online
thank you very much thank you very much

873
01:28:50,522 --> 01:28:58,745
Crystal uh Renew yeah maybe short remark
uh thanks for the presentations um I'm

874
01:28:58,840 --> 01:29:04,103
curious to the answer also to the question
why not all consumers and not make the

875
01:29:04,159 --> 01:29:10,866
difference uh in the presentation it said
do not take a step back uh but uh I I

876
01:29:11,012 --> 01:29:16,236
think at this moment in time it's really
all consumers are at risk if if you may

877
01:29:16,273 --> 01:29:17,473
call it like that

878
01:29:17,972 --> 01:29:24,743
um and on the other hand on uh you need to
call somebody of course within the uh um

879
01:29:24,889 --> 01:29:32,399
customs uh regulation with the uh the
responsible person discussion uh what

880
01:29:32,484 --> 01:29:39,632
difficult do you see now within
the implementation Mulțumesc.

881
01:29:39,752 --> 01:29:47,228
Green thank you so much uh for your very
interesting presentations um I uh guess um

882
01:29:47,336 --> 01:29:53,550
looking at uh the DFA um from our group's
perspective or the league that we saw uh

883
01:29:53,606 --> 01:29:58,880
we can say that we're quite disappointed
uh on some of the things that we've seen um

884
01:29:58,934 --> 01:30:03,633
I think especially when it comes to dark
patterns and specifically addictive design

885
01:30:03,692 --> 01:30:07,602
um we have many times also in this committee
acknowledged that that is one of the

886
01:30:07,638 --> 01:30:12,386
biggest challenges we have for both our
health and democracy not only for kids not

887
01:30:12,452 --> 01:30:17,236
only for vulnerable consumers but every
consumer there's no one who uh can uh

888
01:30:17,294 --> 01:30:24,047
actually go against these manipulative
tricks um so uh this in my view would be

889
01:30:24,114 --> 01:30:29,582
historic mistake if it stays this way um
but now I'm very very curious actually how

890
01:30:29,650 --> 01:30:34,480
our experts uh see it because what now is
uh what we've seen now in the league is

891
01:30:34,553 --> 01:30:39,452
that uh as the tech companies wanted there
will be an opt-out instead of an opt-in

892
01:30:39,542 --> 01:30:44,671
um I don't see any other way that did
this will turn out in practice as another

893
01:30:44,732 --> 01:30:49,601
stupid cookie banner where you have to
before you enter any website or any app have

894
01:30:49,648 --> 01:30:54,055
to click which kind of addictive features
should do or do not want uh we already

895
01:30:54,092 --> 01:30:56,863
know what that's going to look like in
practice and I think it's going to be

896
01:30:56,898 --> 01:31:00,869
horrible but if you have any other ways
that you see this turning out very curious

897
01:31:00,963 --> 01:31:08,218
to hear um and also uh how do you see uh
the fact that uh probably the most extreme

898
01:31:08,272 --> 01:31:12,931
social media algorithms that are the most
addictive uh things that we are seeing are

899
01:31:13,008 --> 01:31:19,055
most probably exempted uh or at least not
covered by the latest league um and then

900
01:31:19,172 --> 01:31:26,536
when it comes to um the mention of um you
know unfair practices um it seems that the

901
01:31:26,599 --> 01:31:33,922
commission chose to go mainly for transparency
uh rather than actually um you know

902
01:31:34,009 --> 01:31:39,932
trying to uh limit uh some of these
dynamic pricing uh practices um are there

903
01:31:40,112 --> 01:31:47,459
any studies that you know of that transparency
will actually support consumers uh uh

904
01:31:47,533 --> 01:31:54,032
and whether that's uh that's a good idea
um once again I think if we if we don't uh

905
01:31:54,092 --> 01:31:59,222
take these steps right now we're making a
historical mistake as uh as Europe uh both

906
01:31:59,312 --> 01:32:04,299
in uh failing to protect our consumers but
also protecting our democracy so curious

907
01:32:04,344 --> 01:32:08,312
what will actually come out on
Wednesday thank you very much mulțumesc

908
01:32:08,912 --> 01:32:16,618
și acum dacă doamna profesor Emilia
Mișcenic este încă conectată o rog să dea

909
01:32:16,735 --> 01:32:19,892
răspuns și după aceea
domnul profesor Peter Rut

910
01:32:23,492 --> 01:32:30,485
uh thank you very much um thank you for
your questions uh which are uh not only

911
01:32:30,534 --> 01:32:36,588
interesting but they are really to the
point I actually agree with the with your uh

912
01:32:36,692 --> 01:32:42,632
statements and um maybe this was misunderstood
in the presentation because as I said

913
01:32:42,706 --> 01:32:49,227
in the briefing I I actually do recommend
that this average consumer benchmark which

914
01:32:49,310 --> 01:32:54,690
needs to be updated and which was created
by the court of justice uh needs to be

915
01:32:54,764 --> 01:33:01,832
updated in the sense of uh acknowledging
that we are as you said and explain uh all

916
01:33:01,912 --> 01:33:09,699
vulnerable uh digitally uh but when it
comes to vulnerability um and um I was of

917
01:33:09,763 --> 01:33:15,196
course thinking a lot about it reading a
lot about it this distinction as you said

918
01:33:15,288 --> 01:33:21,985
between um vulnerable and average consumer
which um exists in the from unfair

919
01:33:22,081 --> 01:33:28,336
commercial practices directive um I wrote
about it years ago that we have to make

920
01:33:28,390 --> 01:33:33,963
this distinction between digital vulnerability
and uh consumer vulnerability as um

921
01:33:34,038 --> 01:33:39,189
prescribed by the uh unfair commercial
practices directive because um under

922
01:33:39,246 --> 01:33:46,083
commercial practices directives um consumer
vulnerability is uh focused on these

923
01:33:46,172 --> 01:33:52,049
certain certain personal characteristics
uh where we look as I said informative we

924
01:33:52,138 --> 01:33:57,729
look at the age and usually what is
meant of course under consumer which are

925
01:33:57,787 --> 01:34:04,015
particularly vulnerable are children
are elderly people and there are studies

926
01:34:04,070 --> 01:34:12,700
actually studies from the European
Commission um years ago um um covering uh

927
01:34:12,872 --> 01:34:18,778
practices online and showing that um there
is actually a distinction between average

928
01:34:18,839 --> 01:34:25,307
and and vulnerable consumer and that
digital techniques unfair um commercial

929
01:34:25,369 --> 01:34:32,207
practices affect vulnerable consumer more
than than average consumer although uh

930
01:34:32,335 --> 01:34:38,850
this is very very interesting discussion
and we should really think about as you

931
01:34:38,912 --> 01:34:46,672
said whether we should change the
legislation uh to to merge to merge it all on

932
01:34:46,727 --> 01:34:52,540
Thursday I don't know whether you have
noticed there was a orcla case uh the the

933
01:34:52,623 --> 01:34:59,764
judgment came after our briefing uh where
the court of justice uh which I said said

934
01:34:59,834 --> 01:35:04,231
um explained the benchmarks came up with
the interpretation of the notion of the

935
01:35:04,272 --> 01:35:06,392
definition of the consumer and

936
01:35:06,812 --> 01:35:12,141
uh the image was again distinction there
was average consumer but then it was

937
01:35:12,196 --> 01:35:16,677
interpreted that this average consumer
can also encompass as you mentioned

938
01:35:16,739 --> 01:35:22,476
vulnerable consumers such as kids although
it was a case about design of detergent

939
01:35:22,549 --> 01:35:29,212
uh that can mislead by the packaging the
the kids uh we can by analogy use it also

940
01:35:29,292 --> 01:35:34,551
for digital vulnerabilities and say that
there are categories as as the court

941
01:35:34,627 --> 01:35:40,682
mentioned the risk of confusion in these
by these categories is heightened uh when

942
01:35:40,772 --> 01:35:46,485
it comes to to to to these categories so
I'm not sure whether I have managed to to

943
01:35:46,592 --> 01:35:53,272
to explain but I think that basically we
agree on these points uh that that as you

944
01:35:53,352 --> 01:35:59,719
said both are we are all vulnerable uh
digitally and exposed in certain cases of

945
01:35:59,772 --> 01:36:05,985
course it depends from case to case
thank you thank you very much now Mr.

946
01:36:06,092 --> 01:36:16,450
Professor Rot well yeah thank you for these
um challenging questions um let me start

947
01:36:16,560 --> 01:36:25,365
by saying um. I think I I I indicated in
my short presentation that I could have

948
01:36:25,424 --> 01:36:30,528
imagined a higher level of protection in
certain areas and the question is always do

949
01:36:30,597 --> 01:36:36,580
you want to wait for the perfect solution
or get nothing and and get nothing in the

950
01:36:36,618 --> 01:36:40,848
meantime or do you want to get some progress
I think there is some progress in the

951
01:36:40,980 --> 01:36:48,616
proposal um and I think there are some
gaps as well um transparency I'm very

952
01:36:48,711 --> 01:36:55,601
skeptical uh I have two boys of 17 and 22
and I'm very worried that they would get

953
01:36:55,665 --> 01:37:02,102
anything out of this um in particular
that generation is I think is lost for for

954
01:37:02,192 --> 01:37:09,277
transparency so I can't see that uh that
this is very helpful um as to the questions

955
01:37:09,392 --> 01:37:15,058
of future proof regulation well of course
consumer law has always been like the

956
01:37:15,110 --> 01:37:20,579
fairy tale of the hair and the hedgehog
um once once the legislator comes up with

957
01:37:20,636 --> 01:37:27,212
something the the hedgehog is has already
on the other at the end of the of the lane

958
01:37:27,467 --> 01:37:33,425
so comes up but again that cannot be a
reason to do nothing about the existing

959
01:37:33,542 --> 01:37:39,733
problems um so I think well you can tackle
what you what you have and um you need to

960
01:37:39,797 --> 01:37:45,671
remain flexible and of course nobody wants
to give up the principle based approach

961
01:37:45,752 --> 01:37:46,592
as

962
01:37:46,592 --> 01:37:52,482
a fallback option where you don't have
specific rules um you of you of course you

963
01:37:52,557 --> 01:37:58,924
need them um but otherwise I think this
layered solution of having the principle

964
01:37:59,047 --> 01:38:06,503
having um concrete examples and then even
a a description or a concretization of

965
01:38:06,565 --> 01:38:13,654
what these examples like or dark patterns
actually are is um a re and plus the

966
01:38:13,760 --> 01:38:21,429
flexibility uh that comes in with um
delegated legislation uh in that area that the

967
01:38:21,506 --> 01:38:29,323
the the draft provides for an article 103
um is sort of the best you can do at the

968
01:38:29,384 --> 01:38:34,818
moment if you instead wait for the court
system to solve the problems you wait for a

969
01:38:34,890 --> 01:38:40,918
long long time because I mean I'm from
Germany and um at least in Germany we have a

970
01:38:40,962 --> 01:38:44,988
lot of case law and if there is case case
law anywhere in the EU it's in Germany

971
01:38:45,043 --> 01:38:50,532
because we are a litigious society and
everybody wants to sue everybody um but if if

972
01:38:50,600 --> 01:38:55,961
we look at other member states you will
have nothing for the next five or 10 years

973
01:38:56,044 --> 01:39:02,668
and that that can't be the way forward so
I think um concrete examples in that in

974
01:39:02,719 --> 01:39:08,186
the legislation plus some flexibility with
delegated legislation or or if there is

975
01:39:08,237 --> 01:39:14,184
no delegated legislation at least guidelines
um but forward looking guidelines not

976
01:39:14,252 --> 01:39:18,013
guidelines that only summarize what has
already been decided by the courts because

977
01:39:18,059 --> 01:39:27,860
that that we know already um is the best
you can do at the moment um opt in opt out

978
01:39:27,932 --> 01:39:37,548
yes I totally agree I mean opt in is so um
uh opt out is so far less efficient than

979
01:39:37,674 --> 01:39:43,622
opt in um that is has always been the
preferred option of traders because they know

980
01:39:43,692 --> 01:39:47,852
nothing will happen um
it's a political decision

981
01:39:51,872 --> 01:39:57,929
thank you very much to Professor Emilia
Misenici and Professor Peter Rot and to the

982
01:39:58,017 --> 01:40:04,247
colleagues who, through the questions they
asked, supplemented the information that

983
01:40:04,333 --> 01:40:12,048
the professors provided us with, and I
hope that the committee will also take into

984
01:40:12,161 --> 01:40:17,450
account what the specialists
recommend. Thank you very much.

985
01:40:17,534 --> 01:40:23,930
We now move on to the next equally interesting
legislative act on digital fairness.

986
01:40:24,024 --> 01:40:28,870
Here we have Assistant Professor at
the Faculty of Law and Administration,

987
01:40:28,925 --> 01:40:36,381
University of Kraków, Mr. Palca – the
other name is difficult to pronounce – you

988
01:40:36,462 --> 01:40:41,132
have up to 10 minutes to make your
presentation, and we thank you for being here.

989
01:40:45,332 --> 01:40:50,197
madam chairman honorable members of the
committee ladies and gentlemen thank you

990
01:40:50,250 --> 01:40:55,518
very much it's a great honor to be here
with you next slide please in my written

991
01:40:55,572 --> 01:41:00,179
contribution I was asked to address two
questions first of all how one could

992
01:41:00,232 --> 01:41:04,314
understand addictive design in the digital
furnace act and what are the regulatory

993
01:41:04,365 --> 01:41:07,972
options on the table and second what
are the pros and cons of thinking of the

994
01:41:08,016 --> 01:41:12,396
digital furnace act as a regulation or a
directive and if a directive whether what

995
01:41:12,467 --> 01:41:17,606
are the arguments for or against minimum
or maximum harmonization this questions

996
01:41:17,672 --> 01:41:24,113
will structure also my presentation oral
presentation today next slide please we've

997
01:41:24,178 --> 01:41:29,176
been talking about addictive design in
official union documents for more than half a

998
01:41:29,235 --> 01:41:36,323
decade now it was prominently mentioned in
the UCPD 2021 interpretative guidance by

999
01:41:36,376 --> 01:41:42,705
the commission since then we have two
binding instruments DSA which only mentions

1000
01:41:42,812 --> 01:41:47,649
addictive design in its recitals but has
certain obligations directed at vlops which

1001
01:41:47,740 --> 01:41:53,905
might be used to combat addictive design
and the AI act similarly article 5 there

1002
01:41:53,956 --> 01:41:59,577
are certain ways in which one could imagine
being used against addictive design and

1003
01:41:59,623 --> 01:42:04,173
in the interpretative guidance we also here
see it mentioned there was obviously in

1004
01:42:04,231 --> 01:42:08,138
the meantime the 2023 resolution by the
European Parliament which called on the

1005
01:42:08,175 --> 01:42:11,690
commission to do something about the
addictive design and in September of this year

1006
01:42:11,739 --> 01:42:15,766
we've seen addictive
design the proposition.

1007
01:42:15,812 --> 01:42:20,686
To regulate addictive design in the proposal
for the EU Kids Act and today we have

1008
01:42:20,795 --> 01:42:27,704
seen leaked the unofficial still yet
proposal for the digital fairness act next

1009
01:42:27,788 --> 01:42:33,260
slide please in this sense one needs to
remember that there are instruments already

1010
01:42:33,332 --> 01:42:38,476
binding on the table and the DFA obviously
needs to be compatible with all those we

1011
01:42:38,531 --> 01:42:43,382
don't want this to be in any way incompatible
but at the same time one can learn

1012
01:42:43,457 --> 01:42:47,819
from the limitations of the existing
documents we have seen in the leaked proposal

1013
01:42:47,864 --> 01:42:53,549
that the idea for the DFA is to repeal the
UCPD so we will be replacing the UCPDD if

1014
01:42:53,607 --> 01:42:57,392
it gets adopted in the way that
it was proposed other than that

1015
01:42:58,892 --> 01:43:04,093
we have DSA and AI act already binding and
the EU cuts EU Kids Act being discussed

1016
01:43:04,146 --> 01:43:11,867
in the meantime next slide please when
discussing if I could please ask for the next

1017
01:43:11,959 --> 01:43:17,658
slide when. Discussing the notion of
addictive design what needs to remember that

1018
01:43:17,732 --> 01:43:23,192
the very word addictive brings into mind
the association with health unhealthy

1019
01:43:23,252 --> 01:43:28,493
lifestyles adult things that are addictive
like alcohol like tobacco like gambling

1020
01:43:28,561 --> 01:43:35,674
and in some situations when it comes to
specifically excessive use those are correct

1021
01:43:35,759 --> 01:43:40,532
intuitions however one also should
remember that from the medical from the

1022
01:43:40,584 --> 01:43:46,947
psychological perspective not every engagement
in behavior more than one would like

1023
01:43:47,003 --> 01:43:52,646
to or more than someone else thinks that
one should counts as an addiction from the

1024
01:43:52,712 --> 01:43:59,296
psychiatric perspective behavior. Addictions
are recognized very seldomly in the

1025
01:43:59,363 --> 01:44:05,343
DSM-5 which is one of the two reference
points only gambling disorder is considered

1026
01:44:05,401 --> 01:44:10,161
addiction in the psychiatric sense in
ICD-11 there's also gaming disorder however

1027
01:44:10,204 --> 01:44:14,426
all those other behaviors one engages in
more than one would like to are not really

1028
01:44:14,467 --> 01:44:18,896
recognized by the medical community yet of
course there are psychiatrists that have

1029
01:44:18,947 --> 01:44:23,964
proposed that we also recognize social
media addiction however there are certain

1030
01:44:24,032 --> 01:44:29,673
criteria that if this becomes a disorder
would need to be met in order for someone

1031
01:44:29,724 --> 01:44:34,077
to be considered addicted these criteria
include salience mood modification

1032
01:44:34,144 --> 01:44:39,341
tolerance withdrawal conflict and relapse
just like with many other addictions next

1033
01:44:39,408 --> 01:44:46,355
slide please in this sense the fact that
certain consumers believe themselves to be

1034
01:44:46,410 --> 01:44:50,858
addicted or certain consumers think
they have some type of problem does not

1035
01:44:50,950 --> 01:44:57,892
necessarily match how many people are
actually exhibiting the symptoms even if one

1036
01:44:57,992 --> 01:45:03,515
accepted the currently proposed criteria
in the literature I've cited some studies

1037
01:45:03,567 --> 01:45:08,677
in the contribution which show that it is
about 10% of people in the population that

1038
01:45:08,727 --> 01:45:13,540
can be said to suffer from those criteria
while at the same time people who claim to

1039
01:45:13,622 --> 01:45:19,883
be addicted in various studies that are
also cited the number there is much higher

1040
01:45:19,952 --> 01:45:20,552
this is

1041
01:45:20,552 --> 01:45:27,362
important because if it is health that is
being presented as the primary reason to

1042
01:45:27,512 --> 01:45:32,894
regulate addictive design this will also
be the primary way primary field in which

1043
01:45:32,945 --> 01:45:37,675
the traders will defend themselves by
saying that look not everyone using our

1044
01:45:37,734 --> 01:45:41,400
service more than they would like to is
actually addicted it's called addictive

1045
01:45:41,439 --> 01:45:45,445
design this will be one
of the possible avenues.

1046
01:45:45,512 --> 01:45:50,598
For defense one can imagine next time
next slide please of course the union

1047
01:45:50,650 --> 01:45:55,052
legislature is absolutely free to give the
notion of addictive design an autonomous

1048
01:45:55,121 --> 01:45:59,654
meaning we can define it the union
can define it in in isolation from how

1049
01:45:59,704 --> 01:46:04,873
psychiatrists psychologists think about
addiction and then one faces the question of

1050
01:46:04,930 --> 01:46:10,520
how exactly the addictive design should
be defined what we've seen in the proposal

1051
01:46:10,579 --> 01:46:14,660
the leaked proposal of the DFA is that
there is a list of certain features that

1052
01:46:14,717 --> 01:46:20,139
should be count should be counted as
examples of a trader using addictive design

1053
01:46:20,185 --> 01:46:24,954
however this is not the only possibility
one could also imagine a general clause and

1054
01:46:25,033 --> 01:46:31,447
one could also imagine some sort of
general ban on based on the general clause

1055
01:46:31,513 --> 01:46:36,763
however again all those solutions have pros
and cons what I think one should bear in

1056
01:46:36,813 --> 01:46:42,746
mind is that the root cause of the provider's
using those features is the business

1057
01:46:42,812 --> 01:46:47,607
model which is ad driven the more time
consumers spend online the more money the

1058
01:46:47,660 --> 01:46:51,763
providers make as was already mentioned
by the honorable member in the discussion

1059
01:46:51,812 --> 01:46:56,845
about the previous presentation
next slide please another.

1060
01:46:56,912 --> 01:47:00,581
Thing I would like to
point out is that it is.

1061
01:47:00,632 --> 01:47:05,024
Not necessarily the case that the problem
of addictive design needs to be addressed

1062
01:47:05,072 --> 01:47:12,247
in the DFA in one horizontal manner against
all possible traders one could imagine

1063
01:47:12,332 --> 01:47:17,795
various measures being used ranging from
flat prohibition through some type of risk

1064
01:47:17,839 --> 01:47:22,563
management like for example we have in
the DSA against vlogs or the information

1065
01:47:22,621 --> 01:47:27,622
obligations which is the least intrusive
way for traders and possibly least helpful

1066
01:47:27,675 --> 01:47:31,813
for consumers but one could imagine that
there would be certain types of services

1067
01:47:31,926 --> 01:47:36,392
that need to abide by certain
measures other types would be abiding

1068
01:47:36,752 --> 01:47:42,137
and others we could imagine a world in
which social media have different regulation

1069
01:47:42,232 --> 01:47:48,943
here than for example providers of video
streaming services or shops etc etc so

1070
01:47:49,172 --> 01:47:54,581
right now in the in in the leak draft we
have this one general article addressed at

1071
01:47:54,632 --> 01:48:00,025
all the traders that is the opt out
from the features that are listed in the

1072
01:48:00,092 --> 01:48:04,918
regulation which can be amended by the
commission however one could imagine that

1073
01:48:05,000 --> 01:48:12,543
there could be more nuance here next slide
please ultimately what choice is being

1074
01:48:12,637 --> 01:48:20,018
taken will be dictated by what exactly
is the goal that the DFA is supposed to

1075
01:48:20,097 --> 01:48:25,645
achieve a goal of better consumer protection
or easier compliance is the kind of

1076
01:48:25,692 --> 01:48:29,724
goal that everybody can agree on but it's
about the question of how exactly do we

1077
01:48:29,782 --> 01:48:34,449
operationalize better consumer protection
what exactly do we want to achieve that

1078
01:48:34,512 --> 01:48:40,062
would dictate the choices here there is
a possibility of a world in which we can

1079
01:48:40,111 --> 01:48:44,535
imagine that in certain types of services
or for certain types of consumers we don't

1080
01:48:44,592 --> 01:48:50,843
want exposure to addictive design whatever
we choose to it to mean at all in certain

1081
01:48:50,890 --> 01:48:54,566
types of services we want the consumers
to be able to switch it on and off but we

1082
01:48:54,610 --> 01:49:00,428
could also imagine that in certain types
of services or certain types of consumer.

1083
01:49:00,512 --> 01:49:04,168
We just want to inform them just like for
example we do with cigarettes no they're

1084
01:49:04,209 --> 01:49:09,505
really bad everybody knows they're really
bad but we put the sign so that the adults

1085
01:49:09,577 --> 01:49:15,078
can make that decision next slide please
when it comes to the second question of

1086
01:49:15,119 --> 01:49:18,439
whether it should be regulation or directive
we've seen that the proposal is for

1087
01:49:18,494 --> 01:49:23,374
regulation there are obvious and known
reasons to all of us why regulation provides

1088
01:49:23,444 --> 01:49:28,259
most uniformity most legal certainty at
least on paper as I think we have seen over

1089
01:49:28,309 --> 01:49:33,320
the last five years where almost all the
acts took the form of regulation however

1090
01:49:33,392 --> 01:49:38,489
there are certain problems with various
national versions of the regulations when

1091
01:49:38,534 --> 01:49:43,996
they are to be applied in practice it
is one thing to properly translate.

1092
01:49:44,072 --> 01:49:48,690
The regulation which our translation
service does amazingly but then those

1093
01:49:48,752 --> 01:49:50,972
regulations need to be
applied by the lawyers in the

1094
01:49:51,152 --> 01:49:55,032
member state that have been trained in a
particular member state and sometimes those

1095
01:49:55,087 --> 01:49:59,637
notions just have different meaning even
if it's properly translated there might be

1096
01:49:59,703 --> 01:50:06,729
some divergence unexpected there legislators
in the national context also see are

1097
01:50:06,812 --> 01:50:11,921
like sort of the second layer of possibly
controlling for that at the same time a

1098
01:50:11,975 --> 01:50:18,038
directive would fit the consumer a key and
that would be a solved problem next slide

1099
01:50:18,143 --> 01:50:22,607
please and. The question of whether it
should be maximum or minimum we've it's been

1100
01:50:22,656 --> 01:50:27,068
a long time since we did minimum harmonization
in consumer law and there are all the

1101
01:50:27,113 --> 01:50:31,611
known reasons why we should not do that
however I would kindly point to the fact

1102
01:50:31,673 --> 01:50:38,086
that when it comes to addictive design at
least the prime offenders are not European

1103
01:50:38,148 --> 01:50:43,180
companies they come from United States
they come from China and so the question of

1104
01:50:43,246 --> 01:50:48,864
whether the trade-off between high level
of consumer protection and easy compliance

1105
01:50:48,947 --> 01:50:54,824
is the same I think is out in the open
on the table whether we want to make it

1106
01:50:54,883 --> 01:51:00,111
cheaper for Meta or for Bidens to comply
with our laws I I don't think there is an

1107
01:51:00,173 --> 01:51:05,492
obvious answer to that moreover it's
possible that we don't really know what the

1108
01:51:05,564 --> 01:51:11,628
best way to address addictive design is and
there is some gain to be had when member

1109
01:51:11,700 --> 01:51:16,437
states can experiment you all know ladies
and gentlemen better than me how difficult

1110
01:51:16,487 --> 01:51:20,321
it is to legislate in the European Union
how long it takes for a law to be enacted

1111
01:51:20,363 --> 01:51:25,626
how long it takes for a law to be reformed
so maybe if there's a member state that

1112
01:51:25,683 --> 01:51:30,701
can master political will at home to pass
some legislation whether it's enforceable

1113
01:51:30,752 --> 01:51:35,852
or not it's another question but that could
be elaboratory in which we can sort of

1114
01:51:35,912 --> 01:51:40,261
allow other entities to come up with
solutions because it might be the case that

1115
01:51:40,314 --> 01:51:45,492
today we don't know the best the commission
leaves the door open through the through

1116
01:51:45,532 --> 01:51:49,459
through the possibility to update the list
however where the ideas will come from I

1117
01:51:49,567 --> 01:51:54,492
think is an open question this is everything
I wanted to say thank you very much for

1118
01:51:54,531 --> 01:51:56,972
your attention and I look forward
to your comments and questions

1119
01:51:59,492 --> 01:52:05,372
Mulțumesc foarte mult și acum am plăcerea
să îi invit pe șefa de unitate de la Digi

1120
01:52:05,452 --> 01:52:11,612
Just doamna Maria Mio a Canel Canelopulu

1121
01:52:12,692 --> 01:52:19,433
It's correctly that is excellent okay thank
you very much chair thank you honorable

1122
01:52:19,511 --> 01:52:23,702
members and also a big thank you from the
side of the commission to the experts who

1123
01:52:23,792 --> 01:52:31,007
intervened in today's workshop indeed you
touched upon some of the key aspects that

1124
01:52:31,056 --> 01:52:36,539
we have been examining in preparation of
our proposals for additional fairness act

1125
01:52:36,607 --> 01:52:42,210
that the commission is expected to examine
on the 11th of November so in a couple of

1126
01:52:42,272 --> 01:52:47,672
days time today's workshop for us is very
timely not only for us as commission but

1127
01:52:47,732 --> 01:52:52,959
also for the co-legislators it will it
can inform the interinstitutional process

1128
01:52:53,012 --> 01:52:58,629
that still lies ahead of us and help us
arrive collectively hopefully to a very

1129
01:52:58,704 --> 01:53:04,232
solid legal text that makes rules clear
simpler and more effectively enforceable in

1130
01:53:04,292 --> 01:53:09,606
practice this has been a key consideration
for us I'm sure you will all understand

1131
01:53:09,658 --> 01:53:14,533
that a that we are not able to comment in
detail today on the upcoming proposals I

1132
01:53:14,579 --> 01:53:19,777
would like however to reiterate three
key elements also in reaction to the

1133
01:53:19,845 --> 01:53:25,549
presentations that we heard today first
of all to remind everyone that the digital

1134
01:53:25,592 --> 01:53:30,514
fairness act is the result of a very long
journey which which started already in

1135
01:53:30,605 --> 01:53:37,511
2024 with the publication of the findings
of our digital fairness fitness check of

1136
01:53:37,591 --> 01:53:43,639
horizontal consumer protection rules we
have since consulted very broadly to prepare

1137
01:53:43,709 --> 01:53:48,277
the impact assessment for the DFA we
had a call for evidence and a public

1138
01:53:48,332 --> 01:53:54,194
consultation that received over 7,000
responses we had several surveys with targeted

1139
01:53:54,257 --> 01:54:00,706
service with consumers businesses civil
society we of course liaised with academia

1140
01:54:00,812 --> 01:54:05,070
looked into behavioral research had a youth
dialogue and implementation dialogue on

1141
01:54:05,159 --> 01:54:10,418
simplification all this is to say of
course that we have to take into account of

1142
01:54:10,491 --> 01:54:16,708
into account various elements when
formulating our proposals we paid particular

1143
01:54:16,791 --> 01:54:22,768
attention as was signaled today also to
recent case law by the court of justice and

1144
01:54:22,847 --> 01:54:28,932
I would like to thank again the European
Parliament and the IMCO committee for

1145
01:54:29,028 --> 01:54:35,794
keeping the topic of digital fairness very
high up on the agenda throughout you will

1146
01:54:35,847 --> 01:54:36,752
not be surprised

1147
01:54:36,752 --> 01:54:41,492
to see that the resolutions the debates
that this committee has had have informed

1148
01:54:41,552 --> 01:54:49,385
the proposals that the commission will
be examining on on Wednesday secondly in

1149
01:54:49,470 --> 01:54:54,436
terms of content indeed we have touched
upon and assessed the full range of issues

1150
01:54:54,475 --> 01:54:58,648
that have been highlighted today in
line with the mandate that was given to

1151
01:54:58,695 --> 01:55:03,002
Commissioner McGrath together with Vice
President Virkunen to combat unethical

1152
01:55:03,060 --> 01:55:07,875
techniques online such as dark patterns
marketing by social media influencers the

1153
01:55:07,937 --> 01:55:11,894
addictive design of digital products
and online profiling when consumer

1154
01:55:11,948 --> 01:55:17,856
vulnerabilities are exploited for commercial
purposes we also looked in indeed at

1155
01:55:17,917 --> 01:55:23,887
some horizontal questions such as the
benchmarks of average and vulnerable consumer

1156
01:55:23,972 --> 01:55:28,703
when calibrating our proposals our
objective has been to stay targeted and

1157
01:55:28,759 --> 01:55:33,531
proportionate in our intervention to
provide a meaningful digital update to EU

1158
01:55:33,595 --> 01:55:39,718
consumer production rules that already
apply horizontally to all business to

1159
01:55:39,829 --> 01:55:45,267
consumer practices to all companies that
are active in the single market and work as

1160
01:55:45,355 --> 01:55:51,061
a safety net on issues such as pricing
advertising selling contracting and other

1161
01:55:51,123 --> 01:55:56,091
commercial practices we tried to reconcile
indeed and this was a topic that was

1162
01:55:56,154 --> 01:56:01,174
highlighted I think in couple of interventions
what currently works really well with

1163
01:56:01,232 --> 01:56:06,311
our horizontal consumer protection rules
which is this flexible principle based

1164
01:56:06,415 --> 01:56:11,852
nature of the rules reconcile that with
the clarifications that we think are

1165
01:56:11,912 --> 01:56:17,315
necessary to make these rules implementable
and enforceable in the complex digital

1166
01:56:17,403 --> 01:56:22,468
environment we have also given thought
to how we can integrate elements in the

1167
01:56:22,523 --> 01:56:28,629
proposals to make these rules future proof
and able to be updated to keep pace with

1168
01:56:28,720 --> 01:56:34,990
technological developments final points
we have recent listened very carefully to

1169
01:56:35,045 --> 01:56:40,085
the strong cause for ensuring coherence
and complementarity between the digital

1170
01:56:40,166 --> 01:56:47,377
fairness act and the existing digital
rulebook which we are actively implementing

1171
01:56:47,432 --> 01:56:53,042
and enforcing in practice I'm sure you have
seen the latest the latest announcements

1172
01:56:53,106 --> 01:56:58,292
on the implementation of the
DSA the DFA will not affect the

1173
01:56:58,472 --> 01:57:02,436
current relationship between horizontal
consumer protection rules and sectoral

1174
01:57:02,501 --> 01:57:07,842
legislation our intention is not to duplicate
rules such as the DSA the audio visual

1175
01:57:07,893 --> 01:57:13,706
media services directive and the AI act but
to update indeed the baseline horizontal

1176
01:57:13,762 --> 01:57:19,223
protections in a targeted manner that
keeps them fully coherent and complementary

1177
01:57:19,292 --> 01:57:24,860
with the digital rulebook our proposals on
the DFA should of course also be read in

1178
01:57:24,914 --> 01:57:33,143
conjunction with the upcoming EU kids with
a recent proposal of for an EU kids act

1179
01:57:33,272 --> 01:57:37,905
there the commission put forward very
concrete rules for the protection of children

1180
01:57:37,967 --> 01:57:43,626
who are indeed particularly vulnerable
as online consumers for example on key

1181
01:57:43,695 --> 01:57:49,747
aspects such as addictive design on the
commission side we will continue to work

1182
01:57:49,791 --> 01:57:54,563
very closely digi just and our colleagues
in digi connect as we have done for the

1183
01:57:54,619 --> 01:57:59,552
preparation of the proposals also throughout
the negotiation process to make sure

1184
01:57:59,632 --> 01:58:06,021
that the legal text develop in a manner
that is both clear mutually reinforcing and

1185
01:58:06,077 --> 01:58:07,652
coherent thank you very much

1186
01:58:11,612 --> 01:58:17,794
Mulțumesc foarte mult iată avem și
poziția comisiei vreau să vă informez că

1187
01:58:17,912 --> 01:58:21,787
serviciul. De cercetare a Parlamentului
European a făcut un briefing foarte

1188
01:58:21,842 --> 01:58:28,109
interesant și vi l recomand legat de ceea
ce se va întâmpla peste câteva zile și

1189
01:58:28,203 --> 01:58:35,192
acum întrebări din partea
colegilor la. Te rog din partea SND

1190
01:58:38,192 --> 01:58:43,786
Thank you chair and thank you to to
the experts for this very interesting

1191
01:58:43,869 --> 01:58:49,800
presentations thank you Mithos we have been
working for the last two years and it's

1192
01:58:49,883 --> 01:58:55,200
not a surprise that from the SND IMCO we
have been calling for an ambitious and

1193
01:58:55,309 --> 01:59:03,926
strong legislation that will imply a DFA
that would tackle the vulnerabilities that

1194
01:59:04,006 --> 01:59:11,654
exploit consumers online especially those
of children the leak that we have seen now

1195
01:59:11,732 --> 01:59:16,509
it's too early to to make an assessment
from my side but obviously we consider

1196
01:59:16,555 --> 01:59:21,294
there's an opportunity to finally address
what the existing legislation has not

1197
01:59:21,357 --> 01:59:26,621
sufficiently tackled addictive design
dark patterns manipulative advertising and

1198
01:59:26,686 --> 01:59:31,872
unfair personalization but I want to make
three points first we need to move from

1199
01:59:31,928 --> 01:59:37,112
consumer responsibility to corporate
responsibility and from my point of view it's

1200
01:59:37,160 --> 01:59:43,742
not enough to allow users to switch off
addictive features with this opt out why

1201
01:59:43,812 --> 01:59:49,100
should the burden fall on the consumers
again rather than on the companies that

1202
01:59:49,165 --> 01:59:54,939
deliberately designed this mechanism safety
and fairness must be by default not an

1203
01:59:55,010 --> 01:59:59,860
option so this is to the commission
secondly obviously we consider that children

1204
01:59:59,912 --> 02:00:05,058
must be at the center of the legislation
and we need to ensure the DFA and Kids Act

1205
02:00:05,124 --> 02:00:10,205
work together without loopholes and gaps
in protection we will make sure from this

1206
02:00:10,259 --> 02:00:15,442
parliament that this is the case and finally
we must address economic manipulation

1207
02:00:15,512 --> 02:00:21,234
especially also with addictive sorry
dynamic pricing and ensure strong European

1208
02:00:21,293 --> 02:00:25,798
enforcement transparency is not enough
rights without enforcement are simply

1209
02:00:25,868 --> 02:00:30,442
promises so let me conclude with one
message Europe should not accept a digital

1210
02:00:30,497 --> 02:00:35,760
economy where profits depend on exploitation
on exploiting people's vulnerability

1211
02:00:35,807 --> 02:00:44,331
thank you so much thank you very much
now EPP Dora thank you thank you for the

1212
02:00:44,453 --> 02:00:51,218
presentations as well Note that consumers
don't read regulations they feel them or

1213
02:00:51,313 --> 02:00:56,720
they don't so once I've had a chance to
digest the leak I haven't had the chance

1214
02:00:56,776 --> 02:01:00,212
either yet I will read the
DFA with one question in mind

1215
02:01:01,412 --> 02:01:07,036
will it actually change what people
experience online the goal is of course better

1216
02:01:07,085 --> 02:01:11,739
consumer protection but I worry that more
rules will not necessarily lead to that

1217
02:01:11,814 --> 02:01:17,220
outcome so to make sure that we have or
maximize the chances of better consumer

1218
02:01:17,278 --> 02:01:22,357
protection the DFA has to be very precise
the commission's own fitness check

1219
02:01:22,407 --> 02:01:27,143
identified where the current rules fall
short and that's where the DFA should act

1220
02:01:27,212 --> 02:01:32,651
not on what the digital services act the
AI act or the unfair commercial practices

1221
02:01:32,728 --> 02:01:37,681
directive already cover because overlapping
obligations do not protect consumers

1222
02:01:37,743 --> 02:01:42,596
they only create legal uncertainty
and I worry that the complexity as

1223
02:01:42,655 --> 02:01:47,012
counterproductive and leads to higher
rates of non-compliance which is basically

1224
02:01:47,069 --> 02:01:51,632
where we are now because consumers don't
understand their rights and businesses

1225
02:01:51,672 --> 02:01:56,372
don't understand their obligations and as
the professor said the DFA is entering a

1226
02:01:56,432 --> 02:02:01,903
crowded crowded field so I I don't know how
consumers and businesses will understand

1227
02:02:01,952 --> 02:02:06,103
which rules apply to them when we already
have these obligations especially if they

1228
02:02:06,152 --> 02:02:12,433
now need to look at an additional set of
rules to have the full picture and then

1229
02:02:12,498 --> 02:02:18,335
secondly rules have to be the same
everywhere it's welcome I think that the

1230
02:02:18,385 --> 02:02:23,372
commission proposes a regulation but it
must leave no room for divergent national

1231
02:02:23,432 --> 02:02:29,537
rules because we see that's another issue
towards legal uncertainty a consumer in

1232
02:02:29,587 --> 02:02:34,104
Budapest deserves the same protection as
a consumer in Amsterdam and a business

1233
02:02:34,157 --> 02:02:39,455
should face one set of rules not 27 the
commission has committed to simplifying

1234
02:02:39,509 --> 02:02:43,879
consumer protection consumer information
requirements and I would like to see that

1235
02:02:43,928 --> 02:02:52,125
commitment in the text text and not new
reporting obligations I have a question to

1236
02:02:52,192 --> 02:02:57,985
the commission for every new obligation in
the DFA DFA will you show us which gap it

1237
02:02:58,072 --> 02:03:04,759
closes and why existing law does not yet
cover it and then final one final comment

1238
02:03:04,832 --> 02:03:10,286
like my colleague I think already mentioned
it's essential that we make sure the DFA

1239
02:03:10,339 --> 02:03:15,210
and the Kids Act work together and I find
it a bit confusing that some parts of the

1240
02:03:15,294 --> 02:03:16,494
DFA touch on

1241
02:03:17,432 --> 02:03:23,407
specifically on minors and I think wouldn't
it make more sense to keep that in the

1242
02:03:23,482 --> 02:03:31,382
Kids Act which is going to be about kids
thank you thank you very much now Renew um.

1243
02:03:31,592 --> 02:03:39,040
Yes on the the issue of well psychology or
maybe it's neurology I don't know I spoke

1244
02:03:39,127 --> 02:03:44,686
to a neurologist who also gave a lot of
information on what is happening in the

1245
02:03:44,769 --> 02:03:52,914
brain of the of youth um with all the social
media but just out of curiosity we see

1246
02:03:52,996 --> 02:04:01,516
a lot of negative negative framing. On
social media because people like to click on

1247
02:04:01,608 --> 02:04:11,035
some kind of a negative framework is this
something that with advertisement and and

1248
02:04:11,132 --> 02:04:17,163
product selling should be reckoned with
or should we frame that in another way is

1249
02:04:17,238 --> 02:04:28,522
there any from a psychology point of view
maybe an answer to that thank you Crystal

1250
02:04:28,652 --> 02:04:32,492
thank you very much first and foremost
thank you for a very soon presenting the

1251
02:04:32,552 --> 02:04:39,420
proposal of the digital fairness act I think
we really need it because we still have

1252
02:04:39,476 --> 02:04:44,234
some loopholes we need to to cover I also
think that we have been quite we have

1253
02:04:44,288 --> 02:04:49,174
learned quite a lot since for instance the
DSA and one of the things is for instance

1254
02:04:49,216 --> 02:04:53,520
about addictive designs I mean things
are developing quite fast in the digital

1255
02:04:53,579 --> 02:04:58,362
environment and and here I think it really
makes sense to to look into what we can

1256
02:04:58,438 --> 02:05:02,966
can do to to make sure that consumers
are better protected so in my opinion it

1257
02:05:03,029 --> 02:05:08,594
really makes sense to to do more but of
course also being aware of not having double

1258
02:05:08,672 --> 02:05:13,663
legislation but I I hope that the commission
is taking care of that it's your task

1259
02:05:13,751 --> 02:05:19,474
anyway so but but one thing as Laura also
said I I really think that it is extremely

1260
02:05:19,532 --> 02:05:26,176
important to remember in this environment
today when you're online most of us can be

1261
02:05:26,284 --> 02:05:31,502
cheated we are kind of vulnerable everyone
so we need to do something to reverse the

1262
02:05:31,552 --> 02:05:36,069
burden of proof or anything something that
really can help consumers I don't think

1263
02:05:36,112 --> 02:05:40,764
that people feel that they are protected
well enough today and hopefully we can use

1264
02:05:40,832 --> 02:05:47,017
the DFA and the Kids Act to to cover up
for that so not to cover up to to cover

1265
02:05:47,081 --> 02:05:50,252
those gaps so thank you very much for
that I'm looking very much forward

1266
02:05:50,432 --> 02:05:53,852
forward to the coming month on that.

1267
02:05:54,752 --> 02:06:00,549
Thank you. If there are no further interventions, I would like to ask the Commission

1268
02:06:00,627 --> 02:06:04,102
a single question: are you already
prepared to launch it in a few days?

1269
02:06:04,142 --> 02:06:06,328
Have you discussed with all
the relevant stakeholders?

1270
02:06:06,379 --> 02:06:08,539
What is the position of the Member States?

1271
02:06:08,591 --> 02:06:13,130
What are the Member States saying? Because
the professor here was telling us that it

1272
02:06:13,202 --> 02:06:18,197
is difficult, as lawyers in the 27 Member
States will interpret it differently, and

1273
02:06:18,238 --> 02:06:21,814
once again we will have fragmentation and,
once again, we will not have protection.

1274
02:06:21,859 --> 02:06:23,765
Do you have a response
from the Member States?

1275
02:06:23,806 --> 02:06:25,832
Can you tell us what their
position is? Thank you.

1276
02:06:31,832 --> 02:06:37,853
thank you very much chair and thank you
to the honorable members I can start by

1277
02:06:37,908 --> 02:06:42,832
confirming what I said also in my previous
intervention that we are indeed very

1278
02:06:42,912 --> 02:06:48,249
mindful of the interplay between our
horizontal consumer protection rules to which

1279
02:06:48,298 --> 02:06:53,657
the upcoming proposal on the digital
fairness act belongs and sectoral legislation

1280
02:06:53,728 --> 02:07:01,136
on digital services we have taken atmos
care to avoid duplication our starting point

1281
02:07:01,204 --> 02:07:06,016
indeed has been the findings of our
digital fairness fitness check but also the

1282
02:07:06,094 --> 02:07:10,616
wealth of inputs that we received through
a very broad consultation process that I

1283
02:07:10,667 --> 02:07:17,086
tried to highlight indeed with the proposals
you will see in the accompanying impact

1284
02:07:17,138 --> 02:07:24,035
assessment exactly how we tried to first
of all establish clarify the gaps and areas

1285
02:07:24,092 --> 02:07:31,781
of illegal uncertainty and how we have
calibrated the preferred policy response to

1286
02:07:31,897 --> 02:07:42,688
each of those when it comes to the
discussions with stakeholders academia and the

1287
02:07:42,812 --> 02:07:48,314
member states indeed that is something we
paid particular attention to throughout

1288
02:07:48,392 --> 02:07:53,678
the process of formulating the digital
fairness act beyond the consultation

1289
02:07:53,753 --> 02:07:59,237
activities that I enumerated we have of
course as we did with the parliament we have

1290
02:07:59,299 --> 02:08:05,252
been in I think nearly every IMCO committee
meeting in the last two years giving

1291
02:08:05,327 --> 02:08:09,856
updates on the on the preparation of the
digital fairness act we have done the same

1292
02:08:09,918 --> 02:08:16,512
for the relevant council working party
formations and we received several responses

1293
02:08:16,564 --> 02:08:22,632
from member states to the
consultation process as well as a.

1294
02:08:23,132 --> 02:08:29,913
Inputs over the past days so we have
tried to take everything into account and

1295
02:08:29,968 --> 02:08:36,816
calibrate the proposals in a balanced
manner that takes into account the various

1296
02:08:36,959 --> 02:08:45,476
points of view thank you very much domnule
profesor thank you very much for the

1297
02:08:45,521 --> 02:08:49,118
comments and the questions regarding
the one question that was addressed

1298
02:08:49,169 --> 02:08:55,012
specifically to me that is negative framing
I think this is clearly a political and

1299
02:08:55,059 --> 02:08:59,547
regulatory problem that needs to be addressed
that is we do have empirical studies

1300
02:08:59,612 --> 02:09:04,652
suggesting that negative content
toxic content content giving rise to

1301
02:09:04,772 --> 02:09:09,943
negative emotions leads to more time being
spent online to more engagement and that

1302
02:09:09,997 --> 02:09:14,898
is very much in line with the business
model of many of the social media platforms

1303
02:09:14,965 --> 02:09:19,352
when those become the main tools through
which consumers get news and information

1304
02:09:19,412 --> 02:09:26,610
about the world this starts becoming
very problematic now whether this problem

1305
02:09:26,675 --> 02:09:32,680
should be reckoned with through consumer
law or on a basis of a union act based on

1306
02:09:32,774 --> 02:09:38,404
article 114 I think the answer to that is
is not obvious right I think here there

1307
02:09:38,463 --> 02:09:43,122
are arguments to be given for and against
I could imagine a world in which it is the

1308
02:09:43,197 --> 02:09:48,212
member states that start thinking about
this problem and start regulating this

1309
02:09:48,292 --> 02:09:52,449
problem in one way or another and once
there is proof that this distorts the

1310
02:09:52,495 --> 02:09:56,873
internal market we do something about it
but as we know we are not living in that

1311
02:09:56,922 --> 02:10:02,804
world so I think it's it's it's a difficult
difficult question and other than that I

1312
02:10:02,876 --> 02:10:07,648
I think I agree with with with everything
that was said so I think we're we're we're

1313
02:10:07,712 --> 02:10:12,332
closing so I will not be taking more of
your time thank you very much Mulțumesc.

1314
02:10:13,052 --> 02:10:19,159
Thank you very much, and to the professors
and the representative of the committee,

1315
02:10:19,211 --> 02:10:24,267
please allow me to inform you that all the
PowerPoint presentations and information

1316
02:10:24,341 --> 02:10:31,087
will be published online on our committee’s
website, so you can study them in more

1317
02:10:31,151 --> 02:10:35,346
detail here. They were
presented within the time limit.

1318
02:10:35,437 --> 02:10:49,439
Thank you very much, and we will move
on. The last item on today’s agenda is —

1319
02:10:49,609 --> 02:10:54,924
regarding women, the last point: women as
consumers — combating gender stereotypes

1320
02:10:54,983 --> 02:11:05,562
and unfair commercial practices. I remind
you that we had Gender Equality Week in

1321
02:11:05,636 --> 02:11:11,188
Parliament, and we were pleased to
include an item in our programme:

1322
02:11:11,241 --> 02:11:16,641
women as consumers — combating gender
stereotypes and unfair commercial practices.

1323
02:11:16,758 --> 02:11:26,750
To begin with, a two-minute video message
from Ms President Roberta Metsola, which

1324
02:11:26,860 --> 02:11:32,911
will provide a good introduction
to our discussion today.

1325
02:11:33,023 --> 02:11:39,869
I would like to welcome the speakers
at this event and thank them for their

1326
02:11:39,933 --> 02:11:47,555
participation. I regret that, despite our
efforts to ensure representation from the

1327
02:11:47,603 --> 02:11:51,290
business sector, unfortunately none
were able to accept our invitation.

1328
02:11:51,338 --> 02:11:55,978
I consider myself to be from the business
world, so I have worked extensively in

1329
02:11:56,032 --> 02:12:02,089
this area, and I will certainly invite my
colleagues, after we have discussed the

1330
02:12:02,152 --> 02:12:07,472
matter, to share their views. Let us now
listen to our President, Roberta Metsola.

1331
02:12:12,512 --> 02:12:17,819
Europe moves forward when people decide to
step up and take the lead as president I

1332
02:12:17,868 --> 02:12:22,701
see this in action every day I have met
incredible women leaders throughout our

1333
02:12:22,765 --> 02:12:28,039
society and across our continent who are
blazing trails building success stories and

1334
02:12:28,095 --> 02:12:33,619
changing our societies but these brave
women are still too often held back by

1335
02:12:33,729 --> 02:12:40,712
pressures that may leaders rarely face
from pay disparities and invisible labor to

1336
02:12:40,802 --> 02:12:47,512
outdated stereotypes and online abuse in
this house we are taking steps to smash

1337
02:12:47,582 --> 02:12:52,848
these glass ceilings and make the path
to leadership more accessible including

1338
02:12:52,914 --> 02:12:58,460
making space on corporate boards and
closing employment pay and pension gaps this

1339
02:12:58,532 --> 02:13:04,102
parliament can also be proud of our electoral
reform on proxy voting rights so that

1340
02:13:04,172 --> 02:13:10,100
no member is forced to choose between hair
democratic responsibilities and starting

1341
02:13:10,184 --> 02:13:14,583
a family we will maintain the pressure for
ratification by all member states and the

1342
02:13:14,641 --> 02:13:21,026
national parliaments so that no woman is
left behind but opening doors at the top is

1343
02:13:21,092 --> 02:13:26,161
only part of the task we need to do
more to help women succeed from day one

1344
02:13:26,234 --> 02:13:32,612
leadership is cultivated throughout
childhood education and careers it needs a

1345
02:13:32,672 --> 02:13:37,772
strong role models and systems of support
that is why this house must continue to

1346
02:13:37,832 --> 02:13:42,545
build a more equal and representative
democracy that makes leadership a real

1347
02:13:42,614 --> 02:13:49,218
possibility for women in every field from
STEM to sports getting to that point takes

1348
02:13:49,288 --> 02:13:54,752
political will and sustained action this
is what gender equality week is all about

1349
02:13:54,812 --> 02:13:59,819
my thanks I'll go to my colleague vice
president Antonella Zberna and chair Lina

1350
02:13:59,912 --> 02:14:04,923
Galvez Munoz and thanks to all of you who
work tirelessly for gender equality this

1351
02:14:04,991 --> 02:14:11,058
week every week and every day keep up the
good work because when women rise all of

1352
02:14:11,132 --> 02:14:12,332
Europe rises with us

1353
02:14:15,512 --> 02:14:21,852
We must apply this beautiful message, thank
you, Roberta, even if you are not here

1354
02:14:21,908 --> 02:14:29,163
right now. We have three speakers, and now
we have the intervention from the Deputy

1355
02:14:29,232 --> 02:14:39,550
Director of the Directorate for Equality
and Non-Discrimination at Digi Just, Ms

1356
02:14:39,667 --> 02:14:44,792
Pinuccia Contino. You have
seven minutes, thank you.

1357
02:14:52,532 --> 02:14:59,008
Thank you very much honorable chair and
committee members it is a pleasure to come

1358
02:14:59,072 --> 02:15:03,743
back to this distinguished committee after
being responsible for product safety has

1359
02:15:03,821 --> 02:15:10,479
head of gender equality in Digi Just
let me first recall the fundamentals EU

1360
02:15:10,542 --> 02:15:17,303
consumer protection is enshrined in article
169 of the treaty and article 38 of the

1361
02:15:17,352 --> 02:15:22,511
chart of fundamental rights of the European
Union that protection is based on the

1362
02:15:22,590 --> 02:15:29,003
premise that consumers are in a weaker
position in relation to sellers or suppliers

1363
02:15:29,089 --> 02:15:35,360
in that they have generally less information
less economic power and less experience

1364
02:15:35,432 --> 02:15:41,302
than sellers or suppliers consumer law
aims therefore to compensate for this

1365
02:15:41,368 --> 02:15:47,663
structural imbalance for example the unfair
commercial practice directive protects

1366
02:15:47,752 --> 02:15:53,712
consumers against unfair commercial
practices including misleading actions and

1367
02:15:53,790 --> 02:16:00,372
omissions and aggressive practices gender
related advertising such as advertising

1368
02:16:00,452 --> 02:16:07,870
that exploits insecurities relating to
appearance body image aging or motherhood may

1369
02:16:07,983 --> 02:16:14,648
fall within the UCPD the unfair commercial
practices directive if they are unfair in

1370
02:16:14,744 --> 02:16:21,595
any way leading to consumers in this
specific case women to take a transactional

1371
02:16:21,692 --> 02:16:28,199
decision they would not take otherwise the
unfair commercial practice directive also

1372
02:16:28,257 --> 02:16:33,466
provides for a higher level of protection
for a clearly identifiable group of

1373
02:16:33,533 --> 02:16:39,092
consumers who are particularly vulnerable
to a commercial practice or the underlying

1374
02:16:39,152 --> 02:16:45,325
product because of mental or physical
infirmity age or credulity where the trader

1375
02:16:45,392 --> 02:16:51,058
could reasonably foresee that vulnerability
in such cases the practice is assessed

1376
02:16:51,114 --> 02:16:56,582
from the perspective of the average
member of the group gender as such here's

1377
02:16:56,652 --> 02:17:02,852
however not one of the listed vulnerability
grounds in UCPD that being said the

1378
02:17:02,906 --> 02:17:08,067
unfair commercial practices directive
requires a case by case assessment of the

1379
02:17:08,132 --> 02:17:12,699
particular practice taking into account
the circumstances surrounding the specific

1380
02:17:12,752 --> 02:17:18,368
practice or contract this makes this
directive a flexible instrument to tackle

1381
02:17:18,421 --> 02:17:24,618
different types of practices and contracts
for example a higher price for a product

1382
02:17:24,692 --> 02:17:25,892
marketed to women

1383
02:17:26,312 --> 02:17:31,664
than for a comparable product marketed
to men the so-called pink tax is not

1384
02:17:31,755 --> 02:17:38,403
automatically an infringement of the
UCPD the UCPD does not establish general

1385
02:17:38,467 --> 02:17:43,933
prohibition on price differences between
consumers or product variants it may

1386
02:17:44,016 --> 02:17:50,614
nevertheless apply where for example the
trader misleads consumers about the price

1387
02:17:50,701 --> 02:17:58,315
or its calculation omits material information
or uses an aggressive practice as many

1388
02:17:58,378 --> 02:18:04,232
of you know and we have just heard all the
discussions the commission will propose

1389
02:18:04,332 --> 02:18:10,592
the DFA in a couple of days the DFA aims
is to strengthen consumer protection online

1390
02:18:10,712 --> 02:18:17,432
and we have seen how much the DFA is
conceived to protect the interests of all

1391
02:18:17,522 --> 02:18:23,477
consumers men or women in all their
diversity its rules are intended to address

1392
02:18:23,533 --> 02:18:28,951
practices that can harm consumers generally
while taking account also of vulnerable

1393
02:18:29,012 --> 02:18:35,386
consumers for sure certain forms of influencer
marketing or personalized advertising

1394
02:18:35,457 --> 02:18:42,607
or pricing might disproportionately affect
women for example influencers promoting

1395
02:18:42,700 --> 02:18:48,922
beauty anti-aging or weight loss products
makes exploit gender specific insecurities

1396
02:18:48,992 --> 02:18:53,976
relating to appearance and body image while
failing to make sufficiently clear the

1397
02:18:54,037 --> 02:18:59,057
commercial nature of their endorsements
the DFA could strengthen protection in this

1398
02:18:59,132 --> 02:19:04,346
area including by requiring sale and
disclosures to ensure that consumers are made

1399
02:19:04,399 --> 02:19:10,066
aware of the commercial nature of such
content the work on the DFA also looked at

1400
02:19:10,133 --> 02:19:16,232
addressing unfair personalized advertising
practices for example for instance where

1401
02:19:16,325 --> 02:19:22,660
traders use consumers personal data including
sensitive information revealing health

1402
02:19:22,717 --> 02:19:29,124
conditions or other characteristics protected
under the GPDR the GDPR to target them

1403
02:19:29,179 --> 02:19:34,328
with advertising that exploits their
vulnerabilities and here we know how certain

1404
02:19:34,389 --> 02:19:39,767
health conditions only affect women as
we have stressed in the gender equality

1405
02:19:39,850 --> 02:19:44,972
strategy minors are particularly vulnerable
to influencer marketing often perceiving

1406
02:19:45,032 --> 02:19:50,813
influencers as their friends influencers
sometimes exploit minor's trust for example

1407
02:19:50,871 --> 02:19:52,071
by blurring the commercial

1408
02:19:52,292 --> 02:19:57,850
purposes of their activities or exploiting
gender stereotypes and gender specific

1409
02:19:57,919 --> 02:20:02,959
vulnerabilities pushing minor to buy
products or otherwise distorting their

1410
02:20:03,022 --> 02:20:08,103
transactional decisions there is also
evidence that girls can be particularly

1411
02:20:08,211 --> 02:20:15,212
affected online also specifically with
respect to video games because even though

1412
02:20:15,272 --> 02:20:22,805
loot boxes and problem gambling was shown
in a 2020 study to be stronger among among

1413
02:20:22,892 --> 02:20:28,079
girls than boys although boys were
considerably more likely to engage with loot

1414
02:20:28,140 --> 02:20:34,448
boxes in the first place the DFA work has
looked specifically into this matter and

1415
02:20:34,500 --> 02:20:40,183
more broadly into the matter of spending
maximizing practices if we look at

1416
02:20:40,248 --> 02:20:46,207
financial services now there is of
course a big risk of algorithmic biases

1417
02:20:46,292 --> 02:20:51,206
traditional credit scoring models for
instance often fail to account for women's

1418
02:20:51,276 --> 02:20:57,240
different career partners patterns including
breaks for caregiving to children or

1419
02:20:57,374 --> 02:21:03,694
older parents when AI systems are trained
on historical data reflecting decades of

1420
02:21:03,752 --> 02:21:10,352
gender inequality they can perpetuate and
scale these biases the revised consumer

1421
02:21:10,412 --> 02:21:17,281
credit directive which will come into
application on 20th November 26 strengthens

1422
02:21:17,343 --> 02:21:22,422
protection against discriminatory
automated decision making looking forward

1423
02:21:22,479 --> 02:21:28,048
implementation will be key to ensure that
algorithms are regularly tested for gender

1424
02:21:28,112 --> 02:21:34,211
bias and deliver fair outcomes the gender
equality strategy also explicitly covers

1425
02:21:34,277 --> 02:21:40,221
the angle of women as consumers i can go
deeper into this because i see that my

1426
02:21:40,285 --> 02:21:46,143
seven minutes are almost there and i
really hope that we can continue working

1427
02:21:46,199 --> 02:21:50,820
together with all of you to address gender
equality issues in the field of consumer

1428
02:21:50,876 --> 02:21:52,076
rights

1429
02:21:53,852 --> 02:22:01,112
Mulțumesc foarte mult da de decenii este
inegalitate să sperăm că ajungem să trăim

1430
02:22:01,184 --> 02:22:10,508
și noi egalitatea de de șanse acuma am să
invit pentru patru minute pe doamna Mary

1431
02:22:10,571 --> 02:22:15,692
Collins secretar general pentru
lobby european al femeilor please

1432
02:22:18,632 --> 02:22:23,409
Thank you very much Madam Chair and thank
you to the MCO committee it's um very

1433
02:22:23,466 --> 02:22:28,077
honored to be here on behalf of the European
Women's Lobby and I think your this is

1434
02:22:28,158 --> 02:22:34,444
very timely event as um the cost of living
is soaring and we can hear out cry and in

1435
02:22:34,509 --> 02:22:39,759
the streets I just want to first of all
reiterate that women are more than 50% of

1436
02:22:39,822 --> 02:22:45,098
the population they are not a vulnerable
group they are not a footnote they're not a

1437
02:22:45,169 --> 02:22:51,069
minority but however there are many
different characteristics that impact their

1438
02:22:51,124 --> 02:22:56,566
spending power one of them being that
there is still a persistent gender pay up

1439
02:22:56,677 --> 02:23:04,792
between 11 and 12% for decades and that
has lifelong consequences because it leads

1440
02:23:04,892 --> 02:23:10,799
to a gap in lifelong earnings and pension
gap and it means poverty in older age so

1441
02:23:10,865 --> 02:23:17,697
this obviously has a huge impact on the
capacity of women in terms of their spending

1442
02:23:17,767 --> 02:23:24,819
power also we should not overlook the
entrenched gender stereotypes that impact on

1443
02:23:24,893 --> 02:23:31,302
consumer and commercial practices there
are gender biases that are ingrained so I

1444
02:23:31,349 --> 02:23:36,237
wanted to quickly if I may in my four
minutes look at the so-called pink tax which

1445
02:23:36,298 --> 02:23:42,051
we can also call a sexist tax secondly
menstrual products and thirdly the

1446
02:23:42,117 --> 02:23:46,830
commodification of women's bodies so it was
pointed out that this so-called pink tax

1447
02:23:46,909 --> 02:23:53,698
is what we would call a sexist tax it
shows that products that are aimed at women

1448
02:23:53,775 --> 02:24:00,846
that target women are much more expensive
even if the equivalent exists for male

1449
02:24:00,916 --> 02:24:07,393
consumers so for example um healthcare and
particularly products like the deodorant

1450
02:24:07,472 --> 02:24:12,382
which is far more expensive when targeted
woman but the studies show and there are

1451
02:24:12,432 --> 02:24:19,502
not that many studies to be honest show
that um even impacts on toys children's toys

1452
02:24:19,570 --> 02:24:24,872
children's clothes the different color of
products as well so we can see that gender

1453
02:24:24,932 --> 02:24:31,092
stereotypes are ingrained and some studies
show that actually it is against um

1454
02:24:31,185 --> 02:24:37,099
gender equality laws as well in different
countries so we would like to see MCO and

1455
02:24:37,209 --> 02:24:43,467
FAM do a joint um own initiative report
to really trace the differentiation of

1456
02:24:43,555 --> 02:24:45,632
prices um with between women

1457
02:24:45,812 --> 02:24:51,082
and men in throughout the European Union
quickly move on to menstrual products and

1458
02:24:51,158 --> 02:24:55,943
it's more about a tampon tax it's often
referred to as a tampon tax but it's more

1459
02:24:56,007 --> 02:25:01,098
about that it's about inclusion it's part
of the union of equality and it's access

1460
02:25:01,145 --> 02:25:05,838
to women's sexual and reproductive health
and rights throughout Europe today girls

1461
02:25:05,920 --> 02:25:12,610
still drop out of school while they have
their periods homeless women lack access to

1462
02:25:12,692 --> 02:25:17,492
sanitary facilities and it's difficult to
manage in terms of their dignity and their

1463
02:25:17,576 --> 02:25:23,957
safety so we would again like to see more
studies done in relation to this there are

1464
02:25:24,008 --> 02:25:28,799
some good practices in different parts of
throughout the European Union these need

1465
02:25:28,865 --> 02:25:34,557
to be scaled up because this is a really
you know very important issue for girls in

1466
02:25:34,630 --> 02:25:40,072
terms of VAT just to say that the revision
of the VAT directive gave the possibility

1467
02:25:40,145 --> 02:25:46,985
of to member states to actually be more
flexible in terms of classifying sanitary

1468
02:25:47,042 --> 02:25:52,600
products from being luxury items to
ordinary items however today there are only

1469
02:25:52,656 --> 02:25:59,420
three countries in Europe um Malta Cyprus
and Ireland where there's a zero VAT on

1470
02:25:59,528 --> 02:26:05,341
sanitary products thirdly I want to the
commodification of women's bodies so women

1471
02:26:05,405 --> 02:26:11,355
are not for sale and this includes prostitution
pornography as well as accelerating

1472
02:26:11,432 --> 02:26:16,883
exploitive digital exploitation think it
was spoken about a little bit earlier they

1473
02:26:17,000 --> 02:26:24,187
aim to hurt alienate violate women and
girls bodies minds and fundamental rights so

1474
02:26:24,234 --> 02:26:28,724
it's an issue of violence against women
and needs to be addressed as such however

1475
02:26:28,786 --> 02:26:35,299
what we do see is that the so-called
mainstream media and advertising they also use

1476
02:26:35,354 --> 02:26:42,507
the sexualization of women's bodies to lure
um customers and clients into practices

1477
02:26:42,579 --> 02:26:47,866
and consumer practices so these need
to be um called out for what it is it's

1478
02:26:47,916 --> 02:26:54,736
exploitation of women so the DSA covers
some issues for example big platforms uh

1479
02:26:54,810 --> 02:27:00,274
such as porn um porn pornhub but it doesn't
go far enough so we really need to have

1480
02:27:00,332 --> 02:27:04,955
a we need really need to call out against
the um sexualization of women through

1481
02:27:05,012 --> 02:27:06,212
media through

1482
02:27:06,392 --> 02:27:11,790
advertising which have an impact in terms
of consumer preferences and choices I'll

1483
02:27:11,827 --> 02:27:13,172
leave it at that thank you very much

1484
02:27:15,992 --> 02:27:20,536
Mulțumesc foarte mult și mulțumesc și pentru
că ați fost și la celelalte prezentări

1485
02:27:20,582 --> 02:27:25,138
apreciez foarte mult că ați fost aici în
sală așa cum apreciez că domnul profesor

1486
02:27:25,189 --> 02:27:31,195
stă acum să asculte și problema noastră a
femeilor acum pentru patru minute am s o

1487
02:27:31,262 --> 02:27:37,622
rog pe doamna Silvia Maurer director
advocacy beuc patru minute să din perspectiva

1488
02:27:37,712 --> 02:27:38,912
beuc acum

1489
02:27:43,532 --> 02:27:48,396
Good afternoon uh Madam Chair honorable
members thank you very much for inviting the

1490
02:27:48,441 --> 02:27:52,522
European Consumers Organization B to this
workshop so that we can also maybe share a

1491
02:27:52,572 --> 02:27:57,652
little bit of the research of our member
organizations because indeed uh I think

1492
02:27:57,744 --> 02:28:03,310
that um very often uh women do uh continue
to face practices that undermine their

1493
02:28:03,359 --> 02:28:09,275
ability to participate in markets on equal
terms with men um we have heard about the

1494
02:28:09,327 --> 02:28:14,627
so-called pink tax and that is something
that our members have also uh confirmed uh

1495
02:28:14,695 --> 02:28:20,710
and it's not only anecdotal so our Slovak
member SOS has for example analyzed 200

1496
02:28:20,792 --> 02:28:26,317
products that were sold by online retailers
and they found that around 10% of those

1497
02:28:26,367 --> 02:28:31,367
products were more expensive in their pink
version and according to their research

1498
02:28:31,421 --> 02:28:36,203
the most significant differences appeared
in health supplements footwear and

1499
02:28:36,283 --> 02:28:41,794
sporting goods but also our UK member which
found out that one of the latest trends

1500
02:28:41,852 --> 02:28:48,212
is to relabel uh uh products for uh menopa
with menopause and to make price premiums

1501
02:28:48,272 --> 02:28:52,655
even though there's very often no added
value of these products compared to other

1502
02:28:52,725 --> 02:28:58,139
ones um I will try um not to be too
repetitive because a lot of points that have

1503
02:28:58,185 --> 02:29:03,145
already been made I would also have raised
the exact same issues um on the pricing

1504
02:29:03,194 --> 02:29:07,822
what is maybe also interesting is that uh
sometimes it's like very obvious what was

1505
02:29:07,877 --> 02:29:12,152
referred to by the pink tax meaning it is
almost the same product it's just that the

1506
02:29:12,202 --> 02:29:16,606
price is higher when it's packaged differently
or the color is different but there

1507
02:29:16,693 --> 02:29:22,258
is also more subtle uh misleading uh where
women are paying more because that can be

1508
02:29:22,306 --> 02:29:26,222
that for example the quantity is lower
and the price is the same so that's an

1509
02:29:26,284 --> 02:29:33,312
indirect way on how to mislead about the
pricing um and uh we have already also

1510
02:29:33,397 --> 02:29:40,055
heard about uh the issue about um algorithms
uh that they uh increasingly determine

1511
02:29:40,112 --> 02:29:45,217
which products we see which advertisements
reach us and uh sometimes even different

1512
02:29:45,285 --> 02:29:50,980
prices that we pay and that there uh these
systems rely very often on biased data uh

1513
02:29:51,053 --> 02:29:55,412
or reinforce existing stereotypes
so that's why discrimination can

1514
02:29:55,652 --> 02:29:59,921
occur also at the level that is very much
invisible to consumers and very difficult

1515
02:29:59,972 --> 02:30:05,951
to challenge uh I think be would agree
that we should uh pay very close attention

1516
02:30:06,008 --> 02:30:10,695
actually to influencer marketing because
women and girls are among the uh the

1517
02:30:10,763 --> 02:30:17,482
primary targets um so uh young women are
encouraged to pursue unrealistic beauty

1518
02:30:17,552 --> 02:30:22,190
standards to through endless product
recommendations and they are very often also

1519
02:30:22,238 --> 02:30:27,221
pushed towards excessive consumption for
example of fast fashion uh and that's I

1520
02:30:27,269 --> 02:30:31,266
think also where we would like to make
a link to your previous workshop on the

1521
02:30:31,312 --> 02:30:35,046
digital fairness act because obviously
we need to discuss a little bit on the

1522
02:30:35,098 --> 02:30:41,185
solutions as well what we can do um because
many of these practices are very subtle

1523
02:30:41,240 --> 02:30:46,822
and they and the market for too long um I
think that also refers to the fact uh as

1524
02:30:46,892 --> 02:30:52,788
Gigi justice some uh how pointed out before
the pink tax may be an unfair commercial

1525
02:30:52,846 --> 02:30:58,157
practices but it's also not so clear in
in the law that uh that you can uh act on

1526
02:30:58,245 --> 02:31:04,900
everything there um so on the digital
fairness act uh actually I think we have uh uh

1527
02:31:04,963 --> 02:31:11,822
here a possibility on how we can improve
the legislation um but maybe we also need

1528
02:31:11,872 --> 02:31:16,456
at the EU level to see a little bit how we
can on a on a strategic alignment better

1529
02:31:16,504 --> 02:31:20,794
align for example the implementation of
the consumer agenda together with uh the

1530
02:31:20,864 --> 02:31:25,492
strategy on gender uh maybe there are some
ideas that we can can also develop and I

1531
02:31:25,546 --> 02:31:29,847
would also say whenever there is very
practical legislation that we indeed need to

1532
02:31:29,896 --> 02:31:34,448
see if there are specific requirements
that we need to make on the general product

1533
02:31:34,494 --> 02:31:38,933
safety regulation for example in the
past there was a notion that technical

1534
02:31:38,989 --> 02:31:43,480
standards uh for safety testing very often
never look at female bodies for example

1535
02:31:43,535 --> 02:31:47,897
and it was the parliament that had made
the addition I think to the text that was

1536
02:31:47,960 --> 02:31:52,283
finally being agreed uh and it's just like
this thinking that we need to apply very

1537
02:31:52,366 --> 02:31:58,037
often on where uh improvements are possible
I think I would leave it here um I think

1538
02:31:58,112 --> 02:32:02,132
also maybe one last comment is
that on some of the practices um

1539
02:32:02,552 --> 02:32:07,027
maybe we need a good tools for European
and enforcement where we have cases of

1540
02:32:07,075 --> 02:32:11,478
common interest and if we want to advance
on the uh fairness agenda in relation to

1541
02:32:11,532 --> 02:32:15,352
women maybe there are also some projects
and and joint enforcement actions that we

1542
02:32:15,392 --> 02:32:20,935
can be looking for together also the the
evidence but also the experience on what

1543
02:32:21,024 --> 02:32:27,152
practices are really um not uh not
allowed in the market thank you

1544
02:32:28,712 --> 02:32:35,081
Thank you very much before giving the floor
to my colleagues, I regret that efforts

1545
02:32:35,152 --> 02:32:40,553
have been made and representatives of the
business sector have been invited, and

1546
02:32:40,627 --> 02:32:45,467
unfortunately they have not
accepted our invitation.

1547
02:32:45,531 --> 02:32:48,688
I hope that next time they
will be able to attend.

1548
02:32:48,750 --> 02:32:53,765
I just want you to know that efforts have
been made, we have invited them, and they

1549
02:32:53,819 --> 02:32:57,005
did not come to this debate,
which I believe is important.

1550
02:32:57,061 --> 02:33:00,020
As someone mentioned here,
women are not cowards;

1551
02:33:00,082 --> 02:33:06,069
we have over 51% women, and I believe that
any legislation must be considered from

1552
02:33:06,125 --> 02:33:12,812
the perspective of its
impact on women. Dora IPP

1553
02:33:18,212 --> 02:33:23,732
Yes thank you for coming today and thank
you for the presentations um indeed as you

1554
02:33:23,834 --> 02:33:29,235
and also um our colleague has just
reiterated women are more than 50% of the

1555
02:33:29,296 --> 02:33:34,764
population so we need to raise more
awareness uh of the impacts of unfair uh

1556
02:33:34,832 --> 02:33:39,811
commercial practices or that unfair commercial
practices have on them uh so I'm also

1557
02:33:39,866 --> 02:33:46,009
a bit disappointed to see uh the low
turnout today um I would like to ask you um

1558
02:33:46,107 --> 02:33:51,632
about the pink tax um because I I was looking
and I couldn't find any recent studies

1559
02:33:51,702 --> 02:33:57,076
on it so I I would be interested in whether
you have data on the prevalence of it um

1560
02:33:57,159 --> 02:34:03,645
and how big a a problem or how widespread
a problem this is and um and how you

1561
02:34:03,752 --> 02:34:07,724
propose tackling it I mean we said uh
and and I do think there is a case where

1562
02:34:07,771 --> 02:34:15,595
existing legislation covering this um as
a misleading uh practice um so I I come

1563
02:34:15,652 --> 02:34:21,512
back to enforcement and enforcement priorities
um and there that my my key question

1564
02:34:21,572 --> 02:34:26,772
is um how will we ensure that uh the
commission and the national enforcement

1565
02:34:26,847 --> 02:34:31,913
authorities actually take action and how
we can raise awareness that they they

1566
02:34:31,971 --> 02:34:39,298
should take action in in these um in these
unfair um practices situations and then

1567
02:34:39,361 --> 02:34:44,860
um just another question on on the I
know the commission has done the digital

1568
02:34:44,912 --> 02:34:51,843
fitness fairness check um and has come out
with a figure of a staggering 7.9 billion

1569
02:34:51,932 --> 02:34:57,870
per year of losses consumer losses um given
the the shortcomings of the existing a

1570
02:34:57,948 --> 02:35:03,625
key um and they break this down by age but
not by gender so I wonder whether there's

1571
02:35:03,692 --> 02:35:09,632
there are plans for the commission to
collect data uh on such breakdown thank you

1572
02:35:11,672 --> 02:35:17,132
Thank you very much
Georgia S&D. Thank you.

1573
02:35:18,272 --> 02:35:24,318
Mr President, thank you for this very
important debate, thank you to all the guests

1574
02:35:24,443 --> 02:35:30,918
who have provided us with some very
interesting insights, because digital

1575
02:35:30,998 --> 02:35:37,538
transformation has certainly opened up new
opportunities but has also given rise to

1576
02:35:37,619 --> 02:35:44,212
many critical issues that we are trying
to address, particularly with regard to

1577
02:35:44,307 --> 02:35:50,769
unfair commercial practices and
forms of consumer manipulation.

1578
02:35:50,875 --> 02:35:56,852
In this sense, the initiative on the
Digital Fairness Act represents a very

1579
02:35:56,927 --> 02:36:04,013
important opportunity that we must not let
slip away, so that the gender perspective

1580
02:36:04,098 --> 02:36:10,408
can also be integrated into the new rules
and in the assessment of their impact.

1581
02:36:10,490 --> 02:36:17,071
We are obviously thinking of algorithms
that can amplify those unrealistic beauty

1582
02:36:17,145 --> 02:36:25,497
models, those targeted advertisements that
predominantly exploit insecurities linked

1583
02:36:25,554 --> 02:36:30,928
to the body, age or those marketing
strategies that reproduce or further reinforce

1584
02:36:30,994 --> 02:36:35,413
the gender stereotypes that we
unfortunately know all too well.

1585
02:36:35,489 --> 02:36:40,034
These practices do not only
affect consumer choices;

1586
02:36:40,098 --> 02:36:45,767
they can have very concrete consequences
on economic autonomy, well-being and, above

1587
02:36:45,831 --> 02:36:52,676
all, women’s freedom of choice. We are not
simply faced with isolated instances of

1588
02:36:52,745 --> 02:36:57,778
discrimination; these are not
isolated episodes, we know this well:

1589
02:36:57,834 --> 02:37:05,349
gender stereotypes and prejudices are truly
embedded in algorithmic systems and in

1590
02:37:05,455 --> 02:37:12,779
business models. They reproduce and amplify
inequalities that already exist, and we

1591
02:37:12,846 --> 02:37:19,819
see this happening continuously. It is
clear that this is not a new concern.

1592
02:37:19,897 --> 02:37:25,199
I recall a 2023 study by the European
Parliament, which was requested by the FEM

1593
02:37:25,267 --> 02:37:30,439
Committee on the impact of the gender
gap in consumer protection data.

1594
02:37:30,550 --> 02:37:37,758
The study highlights how the lack of
disaggregated data also has an impact on women

1595
02:37:37,824 --> 02:37:42,923
as consumers in the digital market. This
is why I believe it is absolutely necessary

1596
02:37:42,976 --> 02:37:47,552
for the gender perspective not to remain
merely a general principle but to be

1597
02:37:48,512 --> 02:37:57,182
really a concrete criterion within the
European legislation on consumer protection

1598
02:37:57,295 --> 02:38:06,940
right from the GDPR. But I wonder, well,
what are the criteria that are being

1599
02:38:07,018 --> 02:38:10,352
defined in ever greater detail? Thank you.

1600
02:38:13,292 --> 02:38:19,999
Thank you very much. And now I would
like answers from all three of you.

1601
02:38:20,088 --> 02:38:25,394
Before that, I want to tell you that yes,
you are right, you said that cosmetics for

1602
02:38:25,455 --> 02:38:28,460
women are more expensive,
but so is lingerie.

1603
02:38:28,551 --> 02:38:33,672
I am the one who does the shopping in the
family and I know this, and I do not think

1604
02:38:33,748 --> 02:38:38,760
it is normal. But what is even worse,
the fact that women, who have lower pay

1605
02:38:38,804 --> 02:38:43,174
compared to men, have to pay more to
purchase cosmetics or other products.

1606
02:38:43,255 --> 02:38:48,858
What is very serious, however, is what
you said in your presentation, that young

1607
02:38:48,928 --> 02:38:54,445
girls are being misled, especially
young girls, to look good.

1608
02:38:54,513 --> 02:39:00,249
I have seen so many cases where there is
false information, fake news, where they

1609
02:39:00,301 --> 02:39:03,738
are sent to various clinics
and are simply mutilated.

1610
02:39:03,811 --> 02:39:06,873
So we really need to be very careful here.

1611
02:39:06,942 --> 02:39:11,492
Thank you, and I expect a response
and conclusions from each of you.

1612
02:39:19,892 --> 02:39:25,655
Thank you very much, uh, for this, uh,
really important debate and for all the

1613
02:39:25,709 --> 02:39:31,901
points that have been raised. Um, as we
know, when we come to gender equality,

1614
02:39:31,958 --> 02:39:39,310
unfortunately, there are no easy, uh,
responses because gender inequalities are so

1615
02:39:39,373 --> 02:39:45,818
much ingrained in every aspect of life. So
definitely I, uh, the commission can only

1616
02:39:45,860 --> 02:39:48,329
agree with all the points
that have been raised.

1617
02:39:48,392 --> 02:39:56,432
And I would maybe here, uh, first of all,
um, uh, call on hopefully, uh, gathering

1618
02:39:56,552 --> 02:40:05,435
more data in the future. We have, uh, our,
uh, agency that, uh, does a lot on this,

1619
02:40:05,543 --> 02:40:12,238
uh, on this area and definitely, uh, we
can, uh, bring also to to the attention of

1620
02:40:12,323 --> 02:40:19,594
EGE, um, the angle of women as consumers
that maybe has, um, not necessarily been

1621
02:40:19,681 --> 02:40:27,485
the most, uh, uh, addressed, um, um, aspect
because of course there is so much to do

1622
02:40:27,552 --> 02:40:31,712
on on on the side of fighting
violence against women.

1623
02:40:31,772 --> 02:40:37,774
There is so much to do on the side of
understanding better all the gaps, all all the

1624
02:40:37,841 --> 02:40:45,327
gender gaps, gender pay gap, gender work
gap, gender pension gap, and, um, uh, the,

1625
02:40:45,401 --> 02:40:50,988
and of course there is a lot, uh, to do,
uh, to fight against stereotypes that

1626
02:40:51,053 --> 02:40:57,226
unfortunately cannot change just by
law. So they really require a very, uh,

1627
02:40:57,311 --> 02:41:04,535
multifaceted and complex action that, uh,
the commission has addressed in all its

1628
02:41:04,601 --> 02:41:09,936
gender equality strategies and in
particular in the latest that the commission

1629
02:41:10,009 --> 02:41:17,955
adopted on, uh, 5th of March 2026 and that
covers until 2030 where, uh, all of the

1630
02:41:18,022 --> 02:41:25,387
problems that have been raised today, uh,
get attention and, uh, are, uh, the object

1631
02:41:25,472 --> 02:41:32,029
of many, many, many different actions,
initiatives, uh, sometimes it's studies,

1632
02:41:32,088 --> 02:41:38,035
sometimes it's, uh, legal measures,
sometimes it's initiatives or funding.

1633
02:41:38,132 --> 02:41:45,722
So, uh, what I can assure, uh, this, uh,
um, honorable, uh, committee and members is

1634
02:41:45,797 --> 02:41:52,098
that we will do all that we can to use
all the tools we have at our disposal to

1635
02:41:52,181 --> 02:41:58,577
improve the situation. But we definitely
also need you and all your work, passion,

1636
02:41:58,652 --> 02:42:01,952
and, uh, stress on this.
Thank you very much.

1637
02:42:03,032 --> 02:42:09,080
I want to reiterate that our entire debate
was broadcast online, um, and certainly

1638
02:42:09,133 --> 02:42:13,885
many more people were connected online.
Um, but I believe the quality of the

1639
02:42:13,971 --> 02:42:20,284
presentations and the quality of the
questions was, um, of a high standard, and I

1640
02:42:20,371 --> 02:42:24,596
would like to thank those who delivered
presentations, my colleagues who asked

1641
02:42:24,645 --> 02:42:28,937
questions, and those who listened online,
because it is important to discuss openly,

1642
02:42:29,008 --> 02:42:33,304
frankly, and without reservations
in order to find solutions.

1643
02:42:33,393 --> 02:42:39,751
Um, I now invite the representative of
the lobby and then BEUC to speak, each for

1644
02:42:39,793 --> 02:42:40,993
two minutes.

1645
02:42:46,952 --> 02:42:52,122
Thank you very much and thank you very
much for your questions and comments and

1646
02:42:52,187 --> 02:42:56,432
feedback as well. Um, so the first question
was asked how big is the problem in

1647
02:42:56,492 --> 02:42:59,354
terms of the pink tax? It's probably huge.

1648
02:42:59,432 --> 02:43:05,187
Uh, the problem is we don't have massive
studies but where there are studies we can

1649
02:43:05,240 --> 02:43:10,877
see that it's very high. And sometimes the
distinction is made between the basket of

1650
02:43:10,965 --> 02:43:16,886
goods so the kind of ordinary basket of
goods that everybody uses and services.

1651
02:43:16,952 --> 02:43:22,675
So when you, for example, there was a
study done in Germany in 2017 so it's going

1652
02:43:22,727 --> 02:43:27,392
back a number of years so when it came to
the basket of goods the differentiation of

1653
02:43:27,449 --> 02:43:32,337
prices weren't huge. So some of the products
that would be, you know, aimed at women

1654
02:43:32,395 --> 02:43:37,362
wasn't massive. But however when it
came to the services and particularly

1655
02:43:37,441 --> 02:43:46,237
hairdressing, dry cleaning, tailoring,
cosmetics, etc., it was 37% difference.

1656
02:43:46,292 --> 02:43:50,006
So it's massive. So we can
only imagine that it was huge.

1657
02:43:50,072 --> 02:43:55,239
It is huge. So we do need data and
absolutely join the commission by saying that

1658
02:43:55,292 --> 02:43:57,821
we're very fortunate
in the European Union.

1659
02:43:57,872 --> 02:44:03,881
We have the European Institute for Gender
Equality who collect data and on a yearly

1660
02:44:03,949 --> 02:44:09,505
basis who present, um, the gender
equality index showing where we're at.

1661
02:44:09,572 --> 02:44:14,846
Actually it'll be the the 26th one will
be launched on the end of this month.

1662
02:44:14,912 --> 02:44:19,330
So we're very fortunate to have that. And
yes this is, uh, something that the the

1663
02:44:19,404 --> 02:44:24,552
institute could do is collect the data
so that we can see, uh, visibly the

1664
02:44:24,619 --> 02:44:30,067
differentiation of, um, of prices
because there's absolutely no objective

1665
02:44:30,152 --> 02:44:35,400
justification for it. So that's why
we call it a sexist tax as well.

1666
02:44:35,552 --> 02:44:39,514
So what else can be done? Um, so
industry has to come on board.

1667
02:44:39,572 --> 02:44:47,651
That's absolutely necessary. Um, and also
in terms of representation of women in the

1668
02:44:47,732 --> 02:44:52,285
sector. We know that the representation
of women is still very low in a lot of

1669
02:44:52,352 --> 02:44:55,937
sectors. We do have the
directive on women on boards.

1670
02:44:56,072 --> 02:45:01,499
But we would like to see it going much
further and to have parity on boards.

1671
02:45:01,592 --> 02:45:06,692
Because, and parity means 50/50
representation to really strive for that

1672
02:45:06,992 --> 02:45:12,572
because we believe that that is a way of
cracking some of these, uh, issues and also

1673
02:45:12,632 --> 02:45:17,712
having a different perspective especially
when it comes to using the use of women's

1674
02:45:17,774 --> 02:45:22,456
bodies and girls' bodies. Um, that we really
need to have a very different approach

1675
02:45:22,491 --> 02:45:27,475
around that. And as the commission says
there are many, um, tools that we do have

1676
02:45:27,572 --> 02:45:30,602
and we need to make sure
they talk to each other.

1677
02:45:30,692 --> 02:45:38,305
So, um, you know, the digital services act,
uh, the DFA, the AI act, the, you know,

1678
02:45:38,357 --> 02:45:42,580
the gender equality strategy, um, they all
need to talk to each other because there

1679
02:45:42,642 --> 02:45:48,780
is no, you know, one solution. It is part
of a global, uh, set of standards in our

1680
02:45:48,872 --> 02:45:56,152
in our societies and particularly gender
stereotypes and you would imagine that

1681
02:45:56,227 --> 02:45:58,778
today in 2026 that we've gone beyond that.

1682
02:45:58,832 --> 02:46:02,541
But no, we have not. It's still
very, very much entrenched.

1683
02:46:02,612 --> 02:46:06,207
Then I would like to say something
as well about, um, funding.

1684
02:46:06,332 --> 02:46:10,991
So we do need funding. We do need resources
because we do need to tackle it on all

1685
02:46:11,046 --> 02:46:16,745
different levels. And I just really want
to point out that, um, for the next, um,

1686
02:46:16,850 --> 02:46:24,742
MFF, they proposal by the council to, uh,
reduce the Agora EU instrument which is an

1687
02:46:24,824 --> 02:46:30,407
instrument that covers, uh, fundamental
rights, gender equality, equality for all,

1688
02:46:30,482 --> 02:46:36,528
the media and culture. All of the actors
that play in it really an important role

1689
02:46:36,621 --> 02:46:40,628
in, um, bringing these issues to the
forefront and really being able to address

1690
02:46:40,683 --> 02:46:44,830
them. That that fund is
proposed to be cut by 30%, 3.

1691
02:46:45,032 --> 02:46:48,750
0, which is the highest cut
in the whole of the EU budget.

1692
02:46:48,812 --> 02:46:52,954
So I'd like to appeal to you here today
as well to really make sure that that

1693
02:46:53,012 --> 02:46:58,762
doesn't happen. And to go back to what the
commission proposed, and, uh, to actually

1694
02:46:58,832 --> 02:47:00,771
go beyond that too.
Because this is crucial.

1695
02:47:00,812 --> 02:47:05,312
This is about democracy as well.
And especially a long-term budget.

1696
02:47:05,372 --> 02:47:10,217
We're looking at the next seven years.
Even if today the situation might feel a

1697
02:47:10,285 --> 02:47:13,982
little bit grim. But in seven years'
time we would hope that we have a more

1698
02:47:14,057 --> 02:47:16,772
positive, and a more
hopeful world. Thank you.

1699
02:47:18,932 --> 02:47:23,391
Thank you very much. And I believe that
to eliminate stereotypes, we also need to

1700
02:47:23,436 --> 02:47:28,847
address education. From school, in families,
from when children are very young in

1701
02:47:28,905 --> 02:47:33,124
kindergarten, the car is only for boys,
for girls it's something else, this colour

1702
02:47:33,170 --> 02:47:37,186
is for boys, the other one is for girls.
So these things need to be tackled at the

1703
02:47:37,231 --> 02:47:41,231
grassroots level and through
education, not just when we are adults.

1704
02:47:41,284 --> 02:47:44,948
And not only through laws. So
education has a very important role.

1705
02:47:45,010 --> 02:47:47,012
Now, the representative of BEUC, please.

1706
02:47:53,132 --> 02:47:59,916
Thank you. Um, I think indeed that we might
need, uh, more evidence collection and

1707
02:47:59,972 --> 02:48:04,708
also connected very different areas of
where we want to look for the evidence.

1708
02:48:04,772 --> 02:48:10,112
Um, because I think, uh, in in principle
the problem here I think is systemic to a

1709
02:48:10,176 --> 02:48:15,028
certain extent because um, women are told
we are advertisement that they're not

1710
02:48:15,074 --> 02:48:20,522
quite good enough yet. And that, um, the
next purchase will bring them much closer

1711
02:48:20,575 --> 02:48:26,616
to an ideal. And that creates a constant
cycle of this satisfaction that drives then

1712
02:48:26,682 --> 02:48:30,907
again consumption. Not because consumers
need a product but because they have been

1713
02:48:30,950 --> 02:48:34,577
persuaded that they need to
fix something about themselves.

1714
02:48:34,652 --> 02:48:40,100
And, um, I think there are always unfortunately
new new forms on how that feeling is

1715
02:48:40,152 --> 02:48:43,784
being used for marketing techniques
and new sales channels and everything.

1716
02:48:43,832 --> 02:48:48,155
So it's a little bit of a self-repeating
cycle whenever you found out something

1717
02:48:48,212 --> 02:48:52,355
there are more subtle techniques on how
you continue the selling techniques to the

1718
02:48:52,407 --> 02:48:57,085
women. At worst terms because as we heard
before I mean uh, women first of all often

1719
02:48:57,152 --> 02:49:00,462
on average um, earn less
and then they pay more.

1720
02:49:00,512 --> 02:49:05,243
Uh, so they are punished twice to be
consumers in in a in a single market.

1721
02:49:05,312 --> 02:49:10,115
And that needs indeed our our attention.
Um, I would agree to some of the proposals

1722
02:49:10,172 --> 02:49:13,769
that have been made for the way forward
and we would also be happy to stay in a

1723
02:49:13,824 --> 02:49:17,629
discussion on the data. It's true that
we have not much but I can make available

1724
02:49:17,672 --> 02:49:21,571
maybe this one or two consumer surveys
from the members that we have uh, in case

1725
02:49:21,622 --> 02:49:22,822
those would be of interest.

1726
02:49:25,232 --> 02:49:27,996
Thank you very much.
Thank you for the answers.

1727
02:49:28,055 --> 02:49:31,619
Thank you for the questions. Thank
you to the secretariat who helped me.

1728
02:49:31,675 --> 02:49:37,319
Thank you to the interpreters because
without them, how would we have managed?

1729
02:49:37,405 --> 02:49:41,998
It’s very good. We have 24
languages. Official languages.

1730
02:49:42,051 --> 02:49:45,018
Today, almost all booths
are full. Thank you.

1731
02:49:45,096 --> 02:49:52,180
And I hope we don’t stop here. I will
discuss in the IMCO committee to continue and

1732
02:49:52,247 --> 02:49:57,268
perhaps bring here what we didn’t have
today, namely the industry side to

1733
02:49:57,345 --> 02:50:02,494
participate in the discussions. Of course,
it is very important not only to regulate

1734
02:50:02,551 --> 02:50:07,755
but also to implement. Because we can have
a very good document but apply it poorly.

1735
02:50:07,824 --> 02:50:12,566
And to apply it well, I believe all
stakeholders must get involved and report

1736
02:50:12,642 --> 02:50:18,833
issues. We must educate consumers to
complain when their rights are violated, and

1737
02:50:18,886 --> 02:50:25,273
especially women, because women are more
hesitant, let’s say, to speak up when their

1738
02:50:25,390 --> 02:50:29,629
rights are infringed upon.
We must work a lot on this.

1739
02:50:29,682 --> 02:50:33,884
Personally, I work in my country, you should
know I lead a women’s association that

1740
02:50:33,951 --> 02:50:39,965
has been active for 30 years, and I work
very well with them, and this education has

1741
02:50:40,054 --> 02:50:46,662
emerged to give them the courage to value
their qualities and not be manipulated by

1742
02:50:46,723 --> 02:50:51,637
all the false information. Thank you very
much, and let’s meet again another time.

1743
02:50:51,683 --> 02:50:52,883
Thank you.

1744
02:51:15,152 --> 02:51:21,932
Thank you very much. Congratulations.

1745
02:51:36,032 --> 02:51:37,232
Thank you very much.

1746
02:52:00,572 --> 02:52:15,692
Thank you. I have one.
Thank you. Thank you.

1747
02:52:39,632 --> 02:52:53,492
Tomorrow. Tomorrow.
Tomorrow. Yes. Thank you.

1748
02:52:55,712 --> 02:52:58,952
Good evening. Good evening. Yes, yes, but
