Brussels Live · EC midday briefing 2026-11-09 Transcribed and translated automatically from the original sound. Mistakes are possible. Machine translation. The original is authoritative. Independent service, not affiliated with the European Parliament or the European Commission. Source: © European Union. AI-generated: Transcripts, translations and summaries on this site are generated automatically by AI: speech recognition (Soniox), machine translation and summaries (Mistral AI). Not edited by humans before publication. EU AI Act, Article 50. [12:13:20] Speaker 2 [EN] Good afternoon. Now we're ready. Welcome to our midday briefing. We have a few announcements to share before we turn to you for your questions. And let me begin with President von der Leyen's visit to the Black Sea region, which starts today. And this year, we have been witnessing alarming increase in hybrid threats, attacks, incursions into the EU territory, and around half of these have affected Romania, Bulgaria, and the wider Black Sea region. And it is against this backdrop that President von der Leyen is traveling to Romania and Bulgaria to discuss the security situation on the ground and how Europe can strengthen its response. Today, the President is in Bucharest, where she will meet Romanian President Nicușor Dan. They will hold a joint press conference at 4:00 p. m. Brussels time. And President von der Leyen will also meet Prime Minister Luca Nicolescu. Tomorrow, the President will travel to Varna in Bulgaria, where she will meet Prime Minister Huomen Radev. And she will hold a joint press conference at 11:00 in the morning Brussels time. And you can follow both press conferences in live on EBS Plus. I would also invite you to read the statement issued by the President this morning ahead of her visit. And you will find further details on the visit in today's Daily News. Now, moving on to our second announcement. It is that time of the year: the annual renewal of media accreditations, where you are all concerned. And starting today, all journalists, accredited to the EU institutions, will receive an individual email with all the information needed to renew their, your, accreditation for 2027. And you find also further details in today's Daily News. The deadline for application, this is important, is end of January 2027. So please that you make your application for renewal on time, so that everything can go very smoothly and it's almost without notice that we continue. Our work together. And speaking of our work together, let me also use this opportunity to precisely thank all [12:16:22] Speaker 2 [EN] the accredited journalists for your cooperation throughout the year, your work as an essential part of what we do here. And we do look forward to continuing our exchanges also in the year ahead. And now, just a final reminder. [12:16:42] Speaker 2 [FR] And now, in French. The Finance Ministers, the Eurogroup and the EU's ministers are meeting today in Brussels, as part of the Eurogroup and the Economic and Financial Affairs Council (Ecofin). At the Eurogroup, the Commission is represented by Commissioners Dombrowski and Albuquerque. And the discussions focus notably on the macroeconomic and budgetary situation of the euro area, the digital euro, the banking sector and the appointments to the European Central Bank. The ministers will also address the financing of defence and the possibilities for strengthening joint procurement. At the Ecofin Council, Commissioner Hoekstra will join his colleagues Dombrowski and Albuquerque. And on the agenda are notably tobacco taxation, the Stability and Growth Pact, the economic consequences of the war waged by Russia against Ukraine, simplification of European legislation, and the implementation of the Recovery and Resilience Facility. The ministers will also take stock of the G20 outcomes and the statistical priorities of the European Union. Commissioner Dombrowski will attend the press conferences following the two meetings, so two press conferences this afternoon, one at 1.30 p.m. for the Eurogroup and around 6:45 for Ecofin. So, we invite you to save your questions on these subjects for these press conferences. That is all for our announcements. And we can move on to your questions. [12:18:37] Speaker 2 [EN] Yes, in the middle. Please. Yes. [12:18:45] Martina Sabler (Politico) [EN] Hi. Martina Sabler from Politico. I have a question on the Black Sea. Specifically about the agreements that are currently on the table for the Black Sea. So last week, Secretary of State Marco Rubio said that they were discussing an agreement of some kind. He used the word ceasefire, put on the table by Turkey. The President's statement this morning also mentioned a ceasefire, but high representative Kallas last week on the 21st said freedom of navigation deal. Not ceasefire. So they're not completely the same thing. I was wondering if we know what's the content of this proposal for agreements, what Turkey has put on the table, what India has put on the table, and if the EU is involved in negotiating those. Thank you. [12:19:33] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Well, as the [12:19:38] Speaker 2 [EN] President von der Leyen also mentioned, and you said so, very accurately, in her statement this morning, the President also said that freedom of navigation in the Black Sea must be restored and preserved. This was also part of the discussions that President von der Leyen had yesterday. In a telephone call with President Zelensky, it is a fundamental route to ensure security, security notably of food, for the EU and beyond, and hence the importance of this subject. I'm not going into the intentions of other partners, but there is a common interest in addressing any disruptions of these maritime route, which is so important for trade and for global trade in general. Yes, please. [12:20:44] Pietro Bastamacchia (Rapporteur) [EN] Good morning, Pietro Bastamacchia from Rapporteur. One question on the Black Sea. I wanted to enquire at which point are discussions on the Black Sea maritime security hub, if this will be part of the set of announcements today in Romania, in Bulgaria, if there is any news coming up on this. I think it was announced a long time ago. So if there is any update on this, thank you. [12:21:11] Speaker 2 [EN] Yes. And without prejudging or anticipating what President von der Leyen will discuss with her counterparts, both in Romania and Bulgaria, the topic of the Black Sea maritime hub should be part of the discussions. And that's also one of the reasons why it's also mentioned in the statement by the President. This morning, it was mentioned first time in the Black Sea strategy. This Black Sea maritime hub. And the visit now to both Bulgaria and Romania will provide an opportunity to take it up and further discuss it. Yes, please. [12:22:01] Xenia Polska (Deutsche Welle) [EN] Thank you very much for the floor. Xenia Polska, Deutsche Welle. My question is also based on the statement that you already mentioned, President of the Commission said in her statement this morning that the EU will be present alongside our partners in Abu Dhabi. Who will represent the EU? And will that representative take part in any session or consultations with the Russian delegation, present there? Thank you. [12:22:32] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. So correct. And again, also mentioned in President von der Leyen's communication earlier this morning, so building on the discussions which took place in Miami and most recently in Brussels last week and hosted notably by the European Commission, I can confirm that the EU will participate in meetings in Abu Dhabi. Which are part of the ongoing peace efforts alongside with other partners. And these efforts for peace will be discussed also at leaders' level. Later this week, in Dublin, in the context of the informal European Council, and also at a meeting of the Berlin Forum. It will be an opportunity to discuss the strengthening of Ukraine, including some of the funding questions, as well as the ongoing diplomatic efforts. Now, to the exact format, we have no further information to share at this point. Yes, please, in the back. Yeah. [12:23:54] Nicolas Skrzynianski (RDI Naples) [FR] Hello. Nicolas Skrzynianski, RDI Naples, Romania. My question concerns the delivery of liquefied gas from the United States to Bulgaria or to terminals. Are these deliveries not at risk? Will the European Union take any steps with the American authorities? [12:24:18] Speaker 2 [FR] Thank you. Well, that's it. This and that are part of ensuring freedom of navigation, which... the Black Sea, and as I said before, it is essential that this be for food security, but also for energy security, and this is a good example. So this is part of the efforts to ensure that there will be safe navigation to guarantee, precisely, food security and energy security. Jorge. [12:25:05] Speaker 1 [EN] Hello, Paula. I understand that you cannot give details on the specific formats in Abu Dhabi, but just to confirm, because a couple of weeks ago, from the podium, you expressed a willingness to engage with Russia directly if there's an opportunity. Do you still maintain this willingness for Abu Dhabi, and do you think the European security architecture as proposed by Jared Kushner should be on the table in Abu Dhabi? Thank you. [12:25:35] Speaker 2 [EN] Jorge, as I also had the opportunity to mention last week and on your second question, regarding any European security, framework, it's up to the European Union to decide because it's a matter of its competence and it's a matter affecting the EU's security. So hence, on such discussions, the EU needs to be present. And indeed, we are open to having the discussions with those most concerned. And hence, that's why also, once again, we will be part of the meetings taking place this week. The exact format, as said, is still to be seen. [12:26:25] Speaker 2 [FR] Yes, Stephan. [12:26:30] Speaker 1 [EN] Yes. I think you didn't answer the question of my colleague. Who will participate for the Commission? I think it's probably it's already known who will that be, as it meeting is after tomorrow. So, and secondly, I mean, how does this fit into this debate? I mean, there are some criticisms of this ununited or cacophonic way of dealing with Russia from especially from Italy, but others as well. How does this fit into this discussion? And why is it actually the Commission? I mean, does that Commission have the security advisor, or who would that be? Why isn't it the Council doing it? And if I'm not mistaken, in the past, the Council was also representative by his head of cabinet, but this wasn't the case recently. What is the reason behind that? Thank you. [12:27:19] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you, Stephan. And it's true, sorry, I didn't address the earlier question. So the Commission will be represented at national security advisor level. And the Council will also be represented in these meetings. And regarding your first question, we've said it several times, there are several discussions taking place on peace in Ukraine at different levels, in different formats. And we fully agree that there needs to be a united, coherent message. And we are committed to that. And that's precisely also the message sent in these various talks that are taking place. I also refer to later talks at leaders' level at the informal European Council in Dublin last week, next this week, where again the topic will also be brought up. Then at leaders' level, precisely to ensure that we speak from the same page. Good. And we move on with a different topic. Unless it's a different angle, David. Go ahead. [12:28:38] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you, Paula. It's a different angle because we are asking and you are answering on procedures. Sorry, David Carreta Radio Radicale. But I would like to ask you on substance. What is the united and coherent message that the. National security advisor of the Commission will. Bring in Abu Dhabi? Not just on Ukraine, but also on the. Security architecture of Europe since this topic could be discussed in those meetings. Apart from the. Two sentences that you mentioned on Friday, I guess, on of the European Council conclusions, what. Will be the message that you will bring to the Russians basically, which are the counterpart on this negotiation? [12:29:46] Speaker 2 [EN] Well, one of the messages David is precisely that discussions on European security framework need to take place after the conflict has ended. This is one of the messages. And we are there to present precisely the EU's stance to defend the EU's interests in talks, which obviously affect also our security. And you will understand that I will not go further into the content of the discussion, so that's as much as I can say today. And we change topic. Please. [12:30:30] Judith Hitchison (Anadolu Agency) [EN] Thank you, Paula. This is Judith Hitchison from Anadolu Agency. I have a question on Gaza. You may have also seen yourself the harshening winter conditions in Gaza. And the United Nations has warned that families and children are facing devastating conditions in makeshift tents and also with little protection. It urgently called for restrictions to aid to be lifted. The Israeli government responded to such demands somewhat mockingly, saying that it doesn't control weather conditions, but it's well documented that Tel Aviv is continuing to restrict aid and actually reconstruction attempts in the Gaza Strip. So in that sense, I'd like to know what the EU's call is to the Israeli government regarding the evolving situation in Gaza. Thank you. [12:31:19] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Ava, we'll provide us with an update of the human. Situation in Gaza, which is indeed alarming now also with the floods hitting the people there. Ava. [12:31:36] Speaker 4 [EN] Good afternoon, I am. Thank you for the question. Yeah, we are aware of the situation in Gaza and obviously if you live in the tent and the tent is full of water, the situation gets much more worse. We were already saying here many times that we use every opportunity and every level to stress to the Israeli government that we need full access to Gaza for humanitarian aid. The situation is not like that. It's changing. And not all the crossings are open for humanitarian aid. Obviously this situation makes it much more serious and people in Gaza would need aid for this. Floods. Winterization is connected to these heavy floods and it's not just because of the floods, but this can even make the situation more serious because the families living in such dire conditions can be exposed to more diseases. Pests can be there more often and so on. We know that basically a vast majority of people in Gaza needs shelter and needs also non-food item assistance. In critical conditions, it's around 60 percent of people. Let me stress that European Union is the largest humanitarian donor for Palestinian people. We have allocated since the beginning of the crisis in October 2023 more than half a billion and nearly 700 million in humanitarian aid to Palestinians. We have organized nearly 90 humanitarian air bridges that were shipping tons. Thousands of tons of help into Gaza including medicines, medical supplies, food, shelter, health items, sanitation, everything what is needed. But as I said, we need full access to be able to deliver together with our partners this essential supply. So again, we call for rapid safe and unhindered access to Gaza to be able to alleviate suffering of the people there. [12:34:30] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Other questions to Ava? [12:34:39] Gaia Niemen (EU observer) [EN] Gaia Niemen, EU observer. Thank you, Ava and Theresa. I wanted to ask on letter sent late last week from some MEPs towards commissioner El Habib. Asking for the European Commission's coordination capacity to facilitate cooperation between member states and relevant partners to get Belgium visa holders in Gaza evacuated from the territory. Due to, as you said, the pending urgency and lack of shelter. That implies that students who hold the visas and also spouses and children pending family reunifications that hold visas to Belgium are still waiting after months of unanswered questions. What has the European Commission's response been? Thank you. [12:35:28] Speaker 4 [EN] Thank you very much. Here I can be very brief. Evacuations is a responsibility of the member states and visa is also a question for the member states. If we do any evacuations from Gaza, then it's medical evacuations. We have Medevac and via Medevac we evacuate people from Gaza, but this is only about people in critical conditions who are evacuated into European hospitals. [12:35:58] Speaker 2 [EN] Thank you. Yes. [12:36:04] Tetiana Vasotska (Ukraine) [EN] Tetiana Vasotska from Ukraine. My question is about Ukraine. Today President Zelensky, after speaking with President von der Leyen, he said that the EU is going to activate special emergency mechanism to help Ukraine Ukrainian cities and communities which are now suffering without water, without electricity, without heating. Could you tell more about this emergency mechanism, when it will be activated, what it supposed to send to give to Ukraine what is the plan? Thank you. [12:36:39] Speaker 2 [EN] And Tetiana, in your right, this was a topic of the discussion yesterday between President von der Leyen and President Zelensky. The situation the humanitarian situation in Ukraine is dire and we see that Russia is deliberately targeting the infrastructure on which Ukrainians depend to survive in the winter. And our approach is very, very clear in our determination. We will not let Russia freeze Ukraine into submission. And that's why we are fully mobilized to help Ukraine maintain essential services, including electricity, heating, water supplies. So it's in this context that the issue has been raised. And also in this context that President von der Leyen offered to help. And today this afternoon the two teams on our side and on Ukrainian side are meeting to see exactly what are the immediate needs where we can help notably through the UCPM and to assess exactly how we can support the Ukrainian citizens in this very difficult situation. And we will take it from there in terms of more details. [12:38:09] Speaker 3 [EN] Other questions to Ava? [12:38:14] Speaker 2 [EN] No? Other topics? Philip? [12:38:21] Philippe Dossevine (Norwegian Media and I see your clima) [EN] Thank you, Paola. Philippe Dossevine with the Norwegian Media and I see your clima. Today both the Commission and the European Environmental Agency published their progress reports on emissions reductions. I know it's COP and climate questions might pertain to COP related matters, but I think this is for you to answer. Because the headline of the Commission's report is a quote by climate commissioner Wubke Hoekstra who says that Europe is stepping up not slowing down but if we look at the figures the emissions reduction is only of 1. 6 percent from 2024 to 2025 which is far, far less than the 5 percent needed for the EU to achieve its 2030 target. So looking at the figures it looks like Europe is indeed slowing down. What do you have to say to this perception? And secondly looking at the. Commission work program for 2027 there's not a lot of powerful measures that one can look at that would go towards or I mean commenters might note the fact that there are not enough measures to bring Europe to the 5 percent annual reduction that is needed. So will Europe be able to step up as you say? [12:40:02] Speaker 2 [EN] I take note how of your mention how you say the commentators have taken note. Of our work program that's very good that the commentators are reading it. To the report of that was published today I think here we also need to take a step back and look at the bigger picture and the longer time period as well. We are well on the trajectory. It is at the same time it is absolutely clear that we need to step up game and this is something that the next two weeks starting today in Antalya will be an opportunity also to take stock within the European Union where we are headed and how we can maintain our climate leadership globally as well. But we have a reason to do these regular reports it is very good to take stock and especially and we have this conversation I think it was last week when you were referencing another report about energy legislation. It's useful because that gives us a regular snapshot of how our member states are doing and where in particular they are facing challenges and how we can best help them. And here you will see that there are nine member states are mentioned there will be a letter sent by Commissioner Hoekstra to these member states they will have three months to get back to us with their corrective action and we will then in the kind of in the following four months give them feedback. So this is a very useful method that we have and necessary and essential method to have a close check on what is happening. But overall when we talk about progress in terms of cutting emissions or progressing with our clean energy transition goals I think it's always useful to take a step back a little bit and look at the longer trajectory and the longer and the bigger picture. On the work program it's very clear that we have very sturdy robust legislation in place both for energy both for climate to get us to the 2050 climate neutrality to 90 percent by 2040. And this is not something that work program and what's in it and what's not in it particularly for next year it is not again going to change the bigger picture and the longer kind of longer game that we [12:42:44] Speaker 2 [EN] are playing on climate action and clean transition. [12:42:49] Speaker 3 [EN] So it's rather good news. We have legislation in place. We don't need to propose it yet. To address the climate challenges that we're going through and the decrease of emissions. Yes, Nicolas. [12:43:07] Nicolas Cormier (Rapporteur) [EN] Thank you so much. It's Nicolas Cormier for Rapporteur. It's also on this. Can you tell us what happens after you give feedback on actions plans that might be shaped however? Is there does the law provide for let's say infringement procedures which the Commission has now said it wants to ramp up to boost enforcement of EU law. And the second question would be given that we're currently seeing amendments targeted amendments to key EU climate rules do you think or does the Commission estimate that this will make it less likely to achieve the 2030 climate target given that there is a need for increased action but it seems like the legislative framework is being dismantled in front of our eyes. I'm looking at delays to the MFAN regulation. I'm looking at targeted changes to the ETS. And I'm also looking at the stalled energy taxation directive which was key enabler of the 2030 climate target. Thank you. [12:44:04] Speaker 3 [EN] First of all none of the amendments or the proposed well I mean targeted amendments that we have made to our legislation none of them impact the level of ambition or the objective of any of that legislation. So that is the response to your second question. On the first one on this process so there will be Commissioner Hoekstra in this case he will soon be sending a letter to each of these nine member states that all of them were listed in the Daily News today and they this letter will inform the member states that they are required to submit a corrective action plan within three months of the date of the letter. And within four months of receiving those plans we will issue an opinion on the robustness of those corrective action plans. You asked about infringements again our objective is never to lead with infringement processes. Our kind of approach is more to make sure that our member states fully understand and they are able to implement whatever needs to be implemented but obviously all of our legislation is I mean infringement process is one of the processes and in principle yes but that is not what we will be leading on and it does not feature as the first step in this process of these corrective national plans. [12:45:32] Speaker 2 [EN] Nicolas, you have a follow-up. [12:45:37] Speaker 1 [EN] Thank you so much. So just to clarify these action plans are these supposed to be new measures from member states to address the gap or are they just going to list existing laws? And is that going to be part of the assessment and will that inform your reaction to these action plans going forward? Thank you. [12:45:53] Speaker 3 [EN] Well it is basically I mean there's a very specific reason which is outlined in the Daily News that we have. There is a reason why we are taking this action with these nine member states and what they need to provide with us with is a corrective plan of what measures they will be taking in order to get out of the situation where they find themselves in. And then we will study and analyze and in four months we will get back to them. [12:46:25] Speaker 2 [EN] Yes, David. On the topic. [12:46:30] Speaker 1 [EN] Yes, thank you. Annika you said that all the amendments and so on have no impact on the level of ambition or the objective that are fixed in the EU law. At the same time I guess that there is an impact on emission reduction. Because I mean the delays have an impact on that. So I would like to know if you have an estimate of this impact on the emission reduction year by year and in term of work program maybe not next year but later if what is missing from amendments on legislation will be covered by other efforts that you will ask to do through legislation. Thank you. [12:47:25] Speaker 3 [EN] That's a very good question but again when we look at the trajectory of emission reductions we need to look at the bigger picture of the direction where we are going. And the amendments that we have made for example one was on the CO2 emissions for cars and the reporting. Limited three-year flexibility. With methane same one-year limited flexibility. So in the longer term we are not touching the ambition. We are not touching the objective or the spirit of the legislation. Rather what is most important for us is that we do these surgical changes and amendments that are limited in scope and in time precisely because we want to preserve this legislation that is really really important. CO2 emissions of cars, methane emissions, etc. So that is sort of that has to be a be put a little bit in perspective. Obviously year on year emissions this is something that we do and we have this reports and we are in close contact with our member states asking them to take corrective measures where needed. But ultimately in our longer term climate policy when we're talking about 2040 2050 etc these flexibilities that are very very limited in time and scope according to our estimates and our assessment do not have an impact in the emissions in the amount of emissions in the longer run. [12:49:08] Speaker 2 [EN] So we stick to our targets in terms of greenhouse gas emissions be it for 2030 for 2040 and which eventually should lead us to climate neutrality in 2050. So that is clear. We stick to those targets. Good. Other questions to Annika? Another different question Philip. [12:49:35] Speaker 1 [EN] If I could just follow up on could you provide us with like a very short overview of which measures coming of new policy is going to take the EU from 1. 6 annual reductions like 24 to 25 to 5% in the next following five years. [12:49:56] Speaker 3 [EN] I think we would need a dedicated session for that Philip. You will understand. That's a very comprehensive. It's a very short question with a very comprehensive answer. But we may consider doing something dedicated on this given the importance of the topic. Good. Other questions to Annika? [12:50:21] Speaker 2 [EN] Let's see if Fatima Saduski? [12:50:26] Speaker 3 [EN] She. Hi. Hi. Yes. Fatima Saduski from Montaigne News. Thanks for giving me the floor. I had a question for Annika on gas talks. I'm wondering whether we could get an update on the commissions monitoring activities for gas talks. We saw that the gas level slipped to 73% just under 73% from 74 last week. So I was wondering whether you had a comment. And there's also still a big gap between some member states who met the target above 80% and others like Germany which are still below 60%. So any comments on that? Any measures? Any yeah. Comment on how such gaps and especially in terms of prices can be can be made. Thank you. [12:51:27] Speaker 2 [EN] You gave a good lay of the land there in your question already. We are as we have said before we are below the historic average in terms of gas storage but at the same time our member states are not seeing any security of supply issue for the time being. This is not to say that we are not monitoring very closely. We are. Our gas coordination group meets regularly to take stock of where our member states are. You also mentioned that there's discrepancy between the levels of storage between our member states and for this resulting from the 2022 many legislative measures that we took to ensure stability in the European gas market. We do have measures that can be put in place should the situation so require. But for the time being we do not have this kind of situation that would trigger any of these emergency measures etc. We have them in place though. And importantly with the big difference to the year 22 we do not have a supply issue for the time being but we will hopefully be able to update soon when the gas coordination groups when the gas coordination group meets the next time. Of their findings. [12:52:47] Speaker 3 [EN] Thank you. No further questions for Annika. Then we can change topic. David. [12:53:00] Speaker 1 [EN] Hi. David from Argus Media. I think it's for Matej not for Annika. It concerns last it's not about last week's well last week's beaching objection objection to the update of the European shipping recycling list. I was just wondering so. It's an objection that's but in terms of background what happens legally? Does is the commission required to change anything in that list or can the commission decide itself and progress in terms of the European list of recycling facilities? Thanks. [12:53:41] Speaker 2 [EN] It is for Annika. In fact I. It's an environmental measure. Annika. [12:53:54] Speaker 3 [EN] Yes. So we had a as you are aware there was a public consultation on this. We are now going through the results and we are working indeed on a 16th update of the European list of ship recycling facilities. And we are planning to adopt the next update to this list by the end of the year. That is the cliffhanger that you wanted right? I see your hand coming up though. When is the end of the year? It is the 31st of December. [12:54:31] Speaker 2 [EN] David you have a follow up. [12:54:35] Speaker 1 [EN] Not about Christmas or the end of the year. It's just what actually happens so Parliament said no in committee right? It's fairly clear what they've said but I was just wondering technically what form of implementing decision is this if Parliament says no can the commission continue anyway? I think it concerned two Indian beaching facilities about the problems of you know beaching and the pollution that goes with it. Do you have to go back to the drawing board or can you just proceed anyway? Thanks. [12:55:10] Speaker 2 [EN] We do not have yet a date for the vote on the on the update. So I would and on the process on the specific steps and the process I would prefer to check that and get back to you. [12:55:29] Speaker 3 [EN] Good. We'll get back on that. David other questions to Annika? We had already concluded. Let's. Me see. Yes please. [12:55:47] Speaker 2 [EN] Tamara Georgia. I have two questions if I may. First next week there will be two events. One enlargement forum and the second the second ministerial meeting on security and connectivity. As I have information on first event there are isn't invited Georgian dream and on connectivity there is a lower invitation than in other countries. So can you confirm it and tell some more details and second questions question is about EU sanctions office. Within the European Commission. So will this office also address this topic through this third countries non-EU countries? I mean for example Georgia and issues related to Georgia and the this crypto platforms. Thank you. [12:56:45] Speaker 3 [EN] Thank you Tamara. So on your second question that will be for Siobhan. But your first question is for Guillaume. [12:56:54] Speaker 1 [EN] Indeed. Thank you Tamara for the question. When it comes to I would actually draw your attention to the enlargement report we published last week and when we describe in details our current position and description of the situation also when it comes to the enlargement path with Georgia. Regarding your specific questions on the different meetings you mentioning. The thing is important to recall that on our side we have always remain open and constructive for dialogue based on mutual respect to find a way out of the current crisis. However as you know the engagement with the Georgian authorities will remain downgraded. Until actually the authorities demonstrate resolute commitment to reverse the course of action again as described in the enlargement report. So when it comes to the meeting on the enlargement from the taking place next week I can confirm that Georgia was not invited to this meeting and when it comes to the second meeting the ministerial meeting on connectivity that will take place on next Monday and. As it was the case in the past the Georgia participation in those meeting is continues to be decided on a case by case basis taking into account also EU's interest. So when it comes to this specific meeting I can confirm that the Georgian authorities were invited but at a lower level. [12:58:29] Speaker 3 [EN] Let me just see before asking Siobhan to join us if we have any other questions for Guillaume today. Don't think it's the case. Then let's ask Siobhan. To address the question on the new EU sanctions office. [12:58:59] Speaker 2 [EN] Good afternoon everyone. Hi Tamara. So as we said on Friday we announced the creation of a new EU sanctions office inside the commission with the idea to bring together expertise from across the commission to work on the entire life cycle of sanctions. So from design, implementation, outreach, and anti-circumvention I'm not sure that I heard all of your question but I think that probably encapsulates what you were asking about outreach to third countries. It would of course you know include include that as well. And then on crypto we also announced on Thursday at the meeting of the high level the high level meeting of sanctions coordinators that we would set up an informal task force to work on crypto sanctions because again we see that this is a very fast moving area of circumventions. So the idea would be to bring together expertise from within the commission and member states to look at how we can better design enforce and of course tackle circumvention using using crypto. [13:00:05] Speaker 3 [EN] Thank you. Other questions. For Siobhan today. No. Other topics. Yes please. [13:00:17] Speaker 2 [EN] Viska EU observer. I have a question about last week's bomb hoaxes on multiple airports. Commissioner sorry I will butcher the name. Sorry. Said on Friday that security experts from member states will meet next week. So that will be this week in Brussels to review the situation I'm wondering if you have any details as to when they will meet at what proposals will be on the table. And secondly I would like to ask you for a comment that many reports have pointed to Russian hackers being behind those hoaxes what would be the commission's reply. Thank you. [13:00:53] Speaker 3 [EN] This confirms the breadth and width of Annika's